Latest / Deconstructing Horror / Brews, Brains & Chainsaws | A Theology Beer Camp Horror Special
Transcript
- Ryan Does: Hey friends, before we start this episode of the show, I just want to let you know that today is a best of compilation episode. So I am going to be sharing a few different clips from a few of my friends that are gonna be guests at Theology Beer Camp, which is an event I have been going to for a few years now, in October. I love each and every one of these conversations in their entirety, and you can check those out on the channel or through the podcast. But this is a few little segments here that I thought were noteworthy and enjoyable, and they also give you a bit of a forecast of the people that are going to be at Theology Beer Camp. If this is an event that interests you, I've put links in the episode description that you can follow up with more information there. please enjoy. These segments from conversations with Leah Robinson, Cutter Callaway, Christy Whaley, and Derek Weston. We're gonna be talking about Poltergeist, Texas Chainsaw Massacre, The Bride of Frankenstein, and Godzilla. I know that is a that is a fearsome four films all packed into one episode, but I hope you enjoy this best of edition of the show. Why does it seem like it gets easier and easier to do that in day-to-day life? But then also when someone says, like, hey, by the way, we shouldn't forget this thing, or we should reconcile with this thing, or we should come to grips with this piece of our history, a thing that we've done to other people, things that people have done to us, basically unpacking the the terrible. Of you know, history, why has it become easy to both ignore that or justify it? I I know that's a deeply complex question, but it feels like that happens so often, whether it's in the news in our own personal lives. It's so prevalent. And I wonder why. Yeah. I mean, I I go back to when I lived in in Ireland. There's always an anecdote in here, but it is important because I dated for a long time. this Irish guy and he had we would have a yearly thing where we would go to the to the graveyard. It's a day of the dead. It's the same day of the dead situation. And we would go and we would drink and we would sit by the graves and we would remember and we would cry and we was hard and we had to wrestle with stuff. And But it was a great celebration. You'd eat food, but you'd talk about everyone in the graveyard. Cause it was like And I think with all denominationalists, I think Protestants, we want to forget. Like when people die, it hurts. So we don't want to remember. We don't want to deal with uncomfortable things. And so this is my theology coming out. But I think with humans, especially, I'm gonna contextualize it in the US, is that we live in a culture that's very selfish. Like it is a very selfish it's not a communal culture. It is a very American dream. Yeah. It's very individualized. And so if it means that like one person gets to have the house of their dream, their dreams, but they have to pave over an entire graveyard to do that, well those people are dead. You know, and that doesn't benefit that person alive. So we'll just go ahead and do it. And I think we've done, you can use that as a metaphor too, but we've done that with I mean, from the cre I teach US religion in American history as a class to undergrads. And we start at the beginning and we say, you know, the native peoples, like you know, the the they thought it was the promised land, these pilgrims. And why did they think it was the promised land? Well, because they said God told them it was and they got there and these native people already there and they were like, well you know, we'll just kill you. Well, yeah, because we and again, if I'm paraphrasing out of out of pocket here, let me know. But it's the idea of like we are so sold on our version of this dream, this divine right to take this place, that you being here is kind of inconvenient for us. So they theologize it. They the manifest destiny is all about like it's theology. They said God You just are not a part of God's plan. Yeah, like you being here is a stepping stone to us being here. So we are going to remove stepping stones, but like in poltergeist, we're going to leave the bodies. Remove the stepping stones, leave the bodies. The nuclear family aspect of the Sawyers who are affected by this industrialization in their own way, a perversion of the nuclear family. That they're they're their perversion of it, like the dinner scenes. What like why is that like every Texas Chainsaw movie has a a scene like that? And why is that so principal? It's principal iconography for this franchise. Yeah. You know, it's like the like a black mass version of what we think about is this sort of sacred American ritual. right, the the the Norman Rockwell yes, the Rockwell that is it is and even today, right? I mean that people will talk about the nuclear family as like the thing that is propping up all of Western democracy, you know, like if If that goes down, the whole the whole thing goes down. And and so you could take it a few different ways. One, clearly, I think, the film is is doing that sort of like black mass thing, right? Like this is a a profane version of something that is held sacred. and and and it's deeply unsettling because that reveals, I think, well there's sort of two things. There's two ways to go about it if you're gonna think about it, let's say theologically. So on the one hand, what they are doing as a family is a kind of what I would call idolatry. And and idolatry from a theological perspective is essentially a a good that becomes misdirected. it's it it itself isn't misdirected. So what happens when you, you know, take something that God has created and given humans and then you distort it in a way that all of a sudden it's functioning in a way that should be reserved for God, right? So that's kind of what I mean by idolatrous. So they they've they've distorted, misdirected, because structurally all the elements are there, right? This is just a lovely nuclear family loving each other and and doing doing good by murdering people, right? so so clearly we say that's not good, even though it's it's a really close knit nuclear family. Yes, yes, they're very close. But but the other thing is the back to kind of similar to like the bodies, like our revulsion at it reveals the things that we hold sacred, right? And a question we could ask as Americans, and I actually think as American Christians then, is that if if that is so revolting and so effective and how profoundly it affects us. It reveals something about the way we really do imagine the nuclear family. We really do imagine the nuclear family as sacred. and that theologically is a problem. because Jesus very clearly says it's not biological kin that count as my family. These are not my brothers and sisters. These, those who do the will of my father, are my brothers and sisters. So he's literally saying. not he's not saying nuclear families are bad. He's just saying this isn't where the sacredness lies. Yeah. And as soon as you see it as a indispensable part of your society, you might actually be committing an idolatry. Like you you actually hold this nuclear family up in a way that it shouldn't be. When you're this revolted by the film doing something with it, it might reveal that kind of idolatry lying underneath. So Those are kind of the two ways I would think about it in terms of how at least this movie and I haven't watched all of the the various different spinoffs. Yeah. to know if it's similar but She is created in the film to placate her Adam. So, ergo, she is a reimagining of what a modern Eve would be. Now, for those of us that may not be so familiar, the creation narratives in the beginning of the the book of Genesis, they aren't really concerned with what Eve's reaction to all of this is, because she's also Created out of nothing. She's minutes old and it's like, hey, you two, maybe, huh? Huh? Sh we're not concerned with her passive acceptance of this role. Yeah. So when we see the bride as a reimagining of a modern Eve, what what does that say about her, the role she's created for, and how this version of the bride kind of assaults that idea. I think it's a really good reminder of later Eve, because if we read the creation story and are really like reading it and not placing our Sunday school memorized lesson on it, who is the only person fighting with the serpent? Who's the only one saying, I don't think we should eat that apple? 'Cause it's not Adam. It's not He's just like, sure, give me that apple. I'm gonna take a bite. Eve is the one being like, I don't think we're supposed to do this. And the serpent is like, no, no, no, you're wrong. It's fine. Adam's just sitting because he's there. We're told he's there. He's just sitting there silently and then he just eats the apple. And so, yeah, I actually see this as like reclaiming who Eve is depicted to be. Right. And again, this idea of nature and the woman or nature and the feminine being so intertwined is like, yeah, Adam, you know, is the the the one we think of or the one that we assume like God made Adam. And then he just like, you need a companion, here's Eve, right? But like, in fact, Eve becomes a far more moral, you know, and and I do I think that the bride gives her a bit of justice because again in In her rejection of the creature, she's also rejecting like what's going on. Yeah. And then the creature comes to his senses and is like, oops, yeah, actually I remember you're right. We have to go back to being dead. And I'm gonna kill Petorius because he's the evil guy here. like we're I'm gonna shut this all down literally by pulling the lever. she's the savior. She's the one who fixes things, you know. And it and it kind of it makes sense why, since Lancaster does this performance in the 30s, why she never reprises this role. Like the bride is kind of left on not the cutting room floor, but left to be this icon of a few minutes. And it's not until You know, the the the eighties and nineties and modern films like Lisa Frankenstein, Poor Things, and Maggie Gillenhall's new movie, The Bride, where the bride is given this full center stage reimagining or a more full embodying. Yeah. Is that in a way, like we get see a moment of her reject this monstrous identity that she is given? Modern recreations of her, are those just further Further like telling the story forward, how how that like my favorite without telling is Edward Scissor Hands. because like it's obviously Frankenstein being retold, right? But in that one, we get Winona Ryder who is able to see Edward, still accepts him, and is the one who basically like helps him again to come to a moral understanding of his his nature, what he needs to do, etc. And like has a love for him, like not in a partner kind of way. They don't like end up together, but at the same time, like her ability to later tell the story and stuff, you know, and all that, like go back and see him up there. And I just think like, yeah, there's an embodiment or an autonomy that she's given in that retelling that I think like the bride would have wanted to have. Like Yeah. You know, it's it is it's a lot to ask a minutes old human, Do you want to be married to this d stitched up dude? But perhaps if they had given her a life first, if they had like created her and like, okay, now we're gonna treat her better, teach her, help her grow, things like that. Perhaps then she could have also been the savior for the creature, you know. Not gonna be rejected in the same way because she is beautiful. Right. After watching Godzilla, after kind of emphasizing this spirit of lament, but also how human innovation leads to a lot of these things as well. When we talk about responsibility in response to a monster, let's be honest, a lot of the larger scale climate and environmental issues that our world struggles with today and is facing are not ones that this generation right now started being inheriting things. We are feeding a monster that we did not create. How do we, in relationship to nature, how do we accept responsibility? And what do we do with that responsibility as individuals, as people? Yeah. And I I think the the importance is like recognizing that we didn't create it doesn't free us of responsibility. It's real that's really important. Yeah. because we still we still have a responsibility to the, you know, I I always talk about, you know, Jesus' command to love our neighbor includes to love our future neighbor. That like we we we need to be thinking about our future neighbor. And our future neighbor should have breathable air. Our future neighbor should have clean water. Our future neighbor should have soil they can grow food in. So like let's let's not abdicate our responsibility to our future neighbor. Recognizing that that there's still ways that we are still feeding the monster too. But like there's there's still ways that like we are you know, we're setting up the electrical poles on this monster that seems to be getting stronger with by with electricity. If only we could weaken him, God. So like maybe we should stop firing our weapons at Godzilla. and just kind of thinking about like what are the what are the little little ways, you know, because they they are gonna be like little in the grand scheme of things. But What are the little ways that we divest from the systems that are feeding Godzilla and making the new Godzilla? Like, what are the little ways that we we you know we monitor our traveling and we we shop more ethically, we eat more ethically, we take ourselves out of of this kind of like cycle of capitalism that just produces plastics that could be easily thrown away? Like, how do we take ourselves out? out of that, every one of us doing the little bit that we can with our resources, with our capacity to like just not feed the monster. Yeah. I I think that that sense of personal responsibility is really hard for a lot of us to to reckon with. It's hard for me to reckon with. It's very easy for me to be like, well, you know, the a big corporation or a government should just stop doing what they're doing. It's like, okay, that can also be true. Yeah. That that can be walk in parallel with you also doing what you know is best, not just for yourself. Maybe it's inconvenient for you. A lot of times it is gonna be can inconvenient for you because companies have made it very convenient to do the wrong thing. And they've made it very expensive to do the right thing. Right. So they they they reverse incentivize you to make the bad choice, which is which is insanely sick and just Gross. go everybody I hope you enjoyed this best of edition of the show today And conversations here on the channel for YouTube and on the podcast feed. So I hope you enjoyed this episode. And just remember that just because the horrors persist doesn't mean we can't also