Latest / SPEAK LIKE A CEO / 263: Seth Godin: All Leadership Is, Is Communication
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to Speak Like A CEO, my name is Oliver Owls and it is my job on this podcast to help you become the top 1% communicator.
- 0:08Today's guest is none other than Seth Godin, Seth is the world's most famous marketer, a highly successful entrepreneur and the author of 21 Best Selling Books.
- 0:17In our conversation, Seth explains how all of us can drive positive change in our organizations, industries and beyond.
- 0:24He just released a brand new book on the topic entitled This Is Strategy, it is a groundbreaking guide to creating meaningful change in the complex world.
- 0:32I think the whole tide of quick fixes and short of thinking in the world enough outdated systems and ideas that no longer work, so Seth's book and our conversation are very timely.
- 0:42Of course we also discuss marketing, storytelling and communications and towards the end, Seth says how he fights climate change as part of the movement.
- 0:51Enjoy this episode with one of the world's most influential business thinkers, Seth Godin.
- 0:56Seth, thank you so much for being on the show today.
- 0:59Well thanks, Oliver, it's a pleasure.
- 1:01So why did you do something to write a book about strategy?
- 1:04You know, I often spend time giving free advice to people who are trying to make a difference and what I find is they think they have a marketing problem, but they don't have a marketing problem, they have a strategy problem.
- 1:19And the irony runs really deep here because we have trouble talking about it, but a huge part of strategy is talking about it.
- 1:28And what I needed to do is describe to people what strategy is because once you know what it is, once you see it, you're surprisingly good at it, but we can't skip that step.
- 1:42That's super interesting. You as a marketer obviously that you highlight this issue and I wonder how do you define strategy that the book is called this is strategy, so I think definitions are in order.
- 1:55It is a philosophy of becoming strategy is the work we choose to do overtime to get better overtime.
- 2:06It is not tactics tactics support strategy strategy involves games and empathy and systems and time.
- 2:16And when we weave those four things together, we have a chance to build something bigger than ourselves. That's leadership, not management. They're different.
- 2:26They're different indeed and we want to go into that a little later, but first to say the topic of strategy, you already mentioned the key elements of strategy, but imagine some readers and now some listeners think, OK, I can't quite get my head around it, so that sounds really plausible, but could you elaborate on that?
- 2:44It doesn't matter how fast you are running, if you are headed in the wrong direction, you're not going to get there. And most modern management workplace development, effort, productivity is focused on how do I run faster?
- 3:01And there is very little conversation on where are we choosing to go.
- 3:07And so how can leaders the best communicate that strategy? So let's say you go through the process, they say, OK, I said, I hear you, we need to focus more on our strategy and we actually developing that sort of strategy that you're talking about in the book.
- 3:23So how can we then communicate that as leaders? Because what I observe and you may also observe a lot of the time is that leaders struggle to communicate strategy consistently and an ongoing basis.
- 3:38There may be big announcement once in a while, but then how do you keep that going? How do you keep people involved in the strategy? Make sure they understand what the role is in strategy?
- 3:46I love that your podcast is about leadership communications. Thank you. Because all leadership is is communication that most CEOs are managers. They are not leaders. They use power and authority to get people to do what they are instructed to do.
- 4:07You don't need a lot of communication to do that. You just have to write a memo.
- 4:12Communication and strategy go together because we need people to enroll in the journey to see what we see because we can't tell them every choice they need to make.
- 4:26And so the indoctrination, the dominant model of do what I said exactly what I said undermines any work that a leader wants to do.
- 4:37What a leader can do is say, I'm going over there, over there specifically, who wants to come with me? Who will help us get there?
- 4:47That communication cannot be hidden from the agenda. In fact, it's all there is.
- 4:54Yeah. So it comes down to persuasion, to storytelling, to understanding the concerns, also off the audiences because it away strategy often implies change and change tends to worry people, right?
- 5:08Strategy always involves change and let's think about why people are worried about it.
- 5:17From an evolutionary point of view, no creature likes change because it's a threat. But in our modern world, that's not the case.
- 5:28But we know that bad things happen in organizations because leaders who are managers dump stuff downhill.
- 5:38When there's strategy doesn't work out, they blame someone who has less power and they do.
- 5:44So a key part of the communication is not lying and saying everything will be okay.
- 5:51It is instead selling people on the idea that the journey is worth the risk.
- 5:58What do you say that first of all that have to establish so that the past wasn't all bad or that maybe there's less to worry about than people think?
- 6:10Just thinking psychologically when you talk about strategy, which implies change, that what one dimension is about the company and the journey of the company, but there's also this sort of internal psychological battle that's going on.
- 6:23So let's think about surfing. Nobody goes surfing expecting the waves will be the same every day. In fact, they don't want that.
- 6:34And when people choose to surf, what they're choosing to do is engage with changing conditions.
- 6:43The challenge of leaders is to stop hiring and managing people in the mindset of a manager of saying to them everything is going to be the same.
- 6:54And I will take care of you to the minimum and you will get paid. That is the Henry Ford model. It was invented on purpose.
- 7:02But if you're working from that model, please accept the fact that the cost of that is resilience and enrollment and the positive energy you're looking for.
- 7:15The tradition has been going on for a long time right from the old industrial age to the modern age now fueled by AI, of course.
- 7:22Would you never let say there's a particular point in time that we are at maybe due to COVID, maybe due to AI where we say, OK, the old industrial model is really out of date now and we should really focus on the new model of leadership and guiding and communicating as a leader rather than command and control.
- 7:40Oh, I think it predates COVID. I think the cascade of innovation amplifies Moore's law.
- 7:52And then when you multiply that by the exposure, the internet gives innovation, that's when the two came together.
- 8:01So Chris Anderson points out that the pace of innovation in a sport like skateboarding is stunning because it used to be or snowboarding.
- 8:11If you came up with a great new snowboarding trick, you probably had two years to keep it to yourself. Now, thanks to the internet, you're about two minutes.
- 8:21And so people see what any organization does to innovate and that instantly becomes a new standard and then and then and then.
- 8:30So if you're waiting for things to go back to normal, this is normal. In fact, this is the safest and most reliable the world will ever be again today.
- 8:44I think that's a big statement. I also think that's a correct statement yet. I don't think that many organizations have digested that or implemented that internally. I think there's still this hope.
- 8:56Let's say hope hope is not a strategy, but there is a hope or an expectation even that things will go back to some sort of previous state.
- 9:06Yeah, so let's get practical here. If I had an institution with more than 10 people in it, I would divide it into two groups.
- 9:16I would say you can sign up for the first group and they follow the rule book. They are the people who keep the planes from crashing and the database from getting hacked.
- 9:29You will always have a manual and we will work as hard as we can to keep things the same.
- 9:34And then there's the second group and that group seeks innovation signs up for science and is doing experiments all the time.
- 9:43Which group do you want to be in? The people in the second group get better snacks, bigger upsides and fewer guarantees.
- 9:51The people in the first group accept that it's going to be the way it is until we shut it down and it will probably shut down slowly, but it won't be here in 10 years for sure.
- 10:01So at Kodak, they had the patents on digital photography and they willingly let it fade away because there was nobody in group two.
- 10:12Everybody at Kodak wanted to do what they did yesterday. On the other hand, when Reed Hastings and Ted Surandos were pivoting Netflix from the red envelopes with DVDs to streaming, this amazing story.
- 10:29At all the meetings they had, no one from the DVD group, including the people who ran it, were invited to the meetings.
- 10:38That's when Netflix became Netflix when they said to folks, you can't even come because we know that we will try to make you happy and that will kill.
- 10:48And I suppose that there's a quote in the book which I really like which is a strategy isn't a map, it's a compass.
- 10:54I assume this is kind of what you're referring to, right? That there is no certainty and the sense there is no map to the destination, but it's a compass.
- 11:02We directly know where we want to go and that's obviously what leaders need to communicate.
- 11:08And please don't ask me every day for step-by-step directions. I just gave you a compass.
- 11:17I trust you. Announce what you're doing and then go do it. But do not ask for permission or for me to take responsibility for every step because I don't know.
- 11:29That's the point. I don't know.
- 11:31That's a huge shift, both for employees as well as leaders, right? From the age of certainty to the age of, essentially uncertainty and from the age of the map to the age of the compass.
- 11:43What other mistakes do you see leaders make when it comes to strategy?
- 11:48Roger Martin has pointed out that strategic planning is an oxymoron.
- 11:55Companies love planning because it's about power and certainty and authority and agency. If you have a plan, you have a to-do list and you can check it off.
- 12:07We might need plans because we need them for projects, but they have nothing to do with strategy. Strategy says there's a deck of cards here. It's stacked, but I'm not sure exactly what card is going to come next.
- 12:20Time is a factor here. Probability is a factor here. We are going to outline a possible path, but the plan isn't up to us because we're engaging with the market, with partners, with uncertainty.
- 12:35Therefore, it's a mistake to call a plan because it's going to change.
- 12:41I think it's also something to do with length. Sometimes I hear leaders say that when I ask about strategy there, we have a deck, we have a strategy deck that is probably 40 slides or 20 page documents, but I can't quite recall.
- 12:55To be clear, neither of us is talking about mission statements. We are not talking about clip 40 word models that could be used by any company.
- 13:14A strategy could involve things like it's the year 2000. We are asserting that the internet will become more ubiquitous and faster.
- 13:27We are asserting that the web will become more open. Therefore, our strategy is to do x, y, and z.
- 13:37AOL had people who were talking that way, but they got drowned out by people who were defending the status quo. Yahoo had people who were talking that way, but they got drowned out by people who were defending the status quo.
- 13:49Yahoo had the chance to buy Google for $10 million and didn't do it because they didn't understand their strategy.
- 14:00You introduced the idea of an elegant strategy in the book. What makes a strategy elegant?
- 14:07Elegant strategies have the wind at your back, and they are simple to describe and difficult to stick with.
- 14:15They are difficult to stick with because the status quo in the system will keep chipping away at it, and the second that the institution has a chance to catch its breath and say, okay, we're done, it will.
- 14:28So what we're looking for is where are the waves coming from and what is our prediction as to how they will keep coming.
- 14:39If we are going in that direction, the odds are we'll do better than if we insist and try to change the way the waves are going.
- 14:49So simple to describe, but hard to stick to. That's a great definition. How often in a way would you suggest leaders communicate the strategy?
- 15:00Internally, it's not internally and then we can think about external as well.
- 15:05In my experience, it's in every single conversation.
- 15:11So if you show me the new designs for the logo, and I don't like it, but it doesn't have anything to do with our strategy, is this my personal taste?
- 15:22I'm not allowed to tell you I don't like the logo.
- 15:25If you tell me you're nonprofit that you're having a gala to raise money, I'll say, who's it for and what's it for?
- 15:33How does us spending this time and money help us with our strategy?
- 15:39Every single time we're interacting, if you're asking for my approval, I'm asking you about how it fits with our strategy.
- 15:44So all the time in any form of communication written, spoken, video, audio, everything, internal, external, so customers as well?
- 15:56Well, you know, what is the strategy of the people at ozemic?
- 16:02Well, the cultural waves of status and affiliation say that a huge number of people who have resources don't want to weigh more than is culturally appropriate.
- 16:16That statement fuels 100 decisions they're going to make in the future.
- 16:22I'm not sure they need to say to every customer, hey, you don't want to be fat, do you?
- 16:28Because they're just making an assertion internally about that.
- 16:33But I do think it's important that as they think about where they're going and how they market it, they bring empathy to the table.
- 16:42And don't do things to their patients, but with them and for them.
- 16:47And this is the mistake, the horrible, immoral mistake that Purdue and other drug companies made.
- 16:54Because their strategy was doctors hate patients who whine about pain.
- 17:00This will solve that problem and make them a bunch of money.
- 17:04And they did nothing to support the people who ultimately they were supposed to serve.
- 17:10And it's horrible when that happens.
- 17:13Sooner or later, it burns out. Sooner or later, it stops working.
- 17:17Because it lacks empathy, right? Which is one of four key tenants, as you mentioned beginning.
- 17:22Do you want to speak with confidence, inspire your team and accelerate your career?
- 17:26You can now roll in the speak like a CEO academy and work with me over the next 90 days to become a top 1% communicator.
- 17:32If listens of this podcast, we have a 15% discount in October.
- 17:37Head over to speak like CEO academy.com and use podcast 15 at checkout.
- 17:42The link and the discount code are in the description below.
- 17:46Let's think about it strategically. If you bring strategy to marketing, I'm sure you would agree that storytelling plays a key role here.
- 17:58That's all communication is, right? That we are using symbols and history to help people see what we see.
- 18:10And story is not once upon a time. Story is simply the hooks we can put with our idea into somebody else's lived experience.
- 18:22So the story of the Apollo 11 mission has a lot to do with the Vikings.
- 18:28And there's no technical reason it has anything to do with the Vikings.
- 18:33But we understand the stories of Vikings. And in my country, we understood the story of Columbus and now we re-understood the story of Columbus.
- 18:42And so you don't have to say once upon a time Neil Armstrong got into a rocket.
- 18:47But this idea is baked into us at a young and level.
- 18:53Most of the marketing organizations need to do if it's important is at that level of getting to someone's lived experience in ways that they don't even have words for.
- 19:06But thinking a lot about narrative and story recently and one point that especially Micah Margolis made on this podcast a few weeks ago was that we have to be careful with traditional storytelling and business because it tends to be more relative tale and then the question who's right and who's wrong.
- 19:23And sometimes that's useful. But we have to be mindful of this effect of storytelling because not everyone of course no one wants to be the victim but no one wants to be the villain.
- 19:33So we have to be quite careful about the drama triangle and everything that traditional storytelling implies that the once upon a time you mentioned.
- 19:41Well, I would argue there's lots of kinds of stories. There doesn't have to be a villain for there to be a story.
- 19:48There is the story of I am being left behind by my friends.
- 19:53There is the story of my family doesn't have enough to eat.
- 19:58There is a story of finally people understand I have a good heart.
- 20:05These are still stories.
- 20:07And if we look at the greatest TV commercials or we look at the products or services and we look at the billions of dollars people give the charity.
- 20:19What's the economic Milton Friedman incentive to quietly give money to charity there isn't one.
- 20:26And yet it happens because the story is my mom is proud of me and you don't need to hear or villain in that story.
- 20:36You just need to understand where your heart is.
- 20:40Nice. I love that and I totally agree that many different types of story are probably an infinite amount and it is mostly about being just very mindful of the kind of story we apply to what situation and the context and the audience.
- 20:54Now I'd love to also ask you about your previous book The Song of Significance which I loved and keep recommending and in that and I can't believe I get to get to ask you about this but you write that management runs a race to the bottom leadership offers a chance to run for the top which I said are underline three times.
- 21:13I just love this distinction between management and leadership and you make that distinction in the context of the old industrial system and the modern economy the market economy.
- 21:24And while he did it he gave everyone a huge raise.
- 21:28Henry Ford did things like you can have any color car you want as long as it's black not because black paint was cheaper but because it dries twice as fast so he could make more cars.
- 21:40That cycle of delivering enormous amount of value at a lower price established a lesson that almost no one has forgot which is if we just get more machines and turn the dials faster and lower prices we will win.
- 22:00The race to the bottom says I can cut a corner that the customer won't realize at least right now and lower my prices.
- 22:09And the problem with the race to the bottom is you could win and you have to live at the bottom or you come in second which is even worse.
- 22:18But all you're doing is repeating yesterday but faster and cheaper.
- 22:22A race to the top says there's an innovation over there that people will appreciate there's a problem to be solved it hasn't been solved yet.
- 22:31We have to do something that might not work but if we do it people will wait in line for it and they will not ask how much it costs.
- 22:40Later people will copy us that's fine then we'll go do the next thing.
- 22:44But those choices are right in front of us and now that there are computers that do so much of the brain dead work it's going to be easier than ever to race to the bottom.
- 22:57Many of my peers are starting to use AI to do their writing their posting their social.
- 23:04Okay well then what are they going to do because it's all going to become this sort of great jelly and people will tell they'll tell its average stuff for average people and you can't build something in that way.
- 23:18So what do you recommend that leaders do because I could hear almost many of them saying I hear you say that makes a lot of sense I would love to work on these intricate difficult challenging problems that that will make my day but my organization isn't there yet we still in the industry mindset.
- 23:36Well the first thing I would say is you have a choice.
- 23:40The people who listen to this podcast are some of the most leveraged smartest kindest people in the world in terms of being mindful about their power.
- 23:50I'm sure Steve Balmer is not listening and so you get a choice and if the place you are working truly will not let you do the work that needs to be done you don't get tomorrow over again you should leave.
- 24:09But I don't believe that's the case in most organizations I think the case in most organizations is you are hoping your boss will give you a blank check approval and encouragement to go do something that might not work and if it doesn't work she will take all the blame.
- 24:26That's unlikely to happen in any organization instead you have the opportunity in 10 minutes a day or 20 minutes a day or an hour a day to start modeling a new behavior and see who follows you.
- 24:40And part of the reason I go to all the trouble of making books which has cost me my vocal cords is you can share them and if you can get five people in your organization to read a book and talk to each other about it.
- 24:55Things are more likely to change and we saw this was a song of significance and I'm hoping it will happen with this strategy as well which is if you don't talk about it it's not going to get better.
- 25:07Yeah exactly and would you say I mean we focused on business so far but would you say this also applies to governments because you know governments are so central to our well being certainly from our perspective and the challenge I see is that they find it even harder to reform to modernize for various reasons and good reasons but you know there isn't even the sort of the pressure the stock market or you know they can't hire new employees or all the things that put pressure on business to.
- 25:37Modernize yeah you know I gave it a long talk yesterday to an important nonprofit they have the same issue.
- 25:46It's about the enrollment if I was the secretary of whatever in the cabinet I would start a team and I'd say this is the team that gets the good snacks I'm inviting you to be on it.
- 25:57We need to shine the non-believers the people in government or industry that want to maintain the status quo aren't evil they're not bad that's just what they signed up for they signed up for the affiliation status that comes from the status quo.
- 26:12But we've seen change happen every government agency is now powered by computers none of them were powered by computers 40 years ago change happens.
- 26:22So we're not going to get it by having a standing ovation and a unanimous vote it's going to happen because we're going to start small teams that change things.
- 26:32If you look at New York City which is 10 miles from here Mike Bloomberg put the 311 system in place now he was in charge but the number of people who worked on it at the beginning was probably a dozen.
- 26:48And finding small projects that then create visible successes creates the conditions scaffolding for the next project to work even better.
- 27:00And do you think that is also part of the solution to climate change I know that's an that's an issue that's very close to your heart.
- 27:08So a lot of the book is about systems and the most important system of all of our lives is the market right now it's been the most important system for a century.
- 27:21The market is a super powerful system that no one is in charge of it finds problems it solves them and it has enriched billions and billions of people.
- 27:33There are more than 3 billion people who have a job now than there were when I was born we invented 3 billion jobs in my lifetime.
- 27:44We're not going to solve the problem of climate by abandoning the market it's impossible.
- 27:51What we could do is let the market understand the signals that it is so good at understanding so that the market itself will change its behavior.
- 28:02And what we have done artificially separated the signals from the truth of what they're actually dealing with what do I mean by this we subsidize carbon by approximately $7 trillion a year worldwide.
- 28:20That in the United States we spent hundreds of millions of dollars subsidizing cattle that we pay unreasonably low prices for things because we ignore their effects their side effects.
- 28:33So as soon as we put the price correctly people will make new decisions they will make new decisions based on accurate data.
- 28:43And from everything I've read of the carbon dividend this reverses climate damage in a week because when you give people the choice to make a different purchase decision and then give them back cash money because other people made a different decision it doubles the kind of change that's happening.
- 29:09So the way a carbon dividend works is this right now a plastic water bottle in my country costs about a euro and it should cost three euro because there's two euros worth the side effects that aren't built into the price.
- 29:28So the carbon dividend just says let's charge the right price for a bottle of water three euro but the two euro surplus goes in a check cash transfer to every single person.
- 29:41It just gets distributed to everybody so if you stop buying plastic water bottles your cash balance is going to go up.
- 29:49And if you keep buying them your cash balance is going to stay the same.
- 29:53And the end result of this is if you want to take a private jet the London please do but it's going to cost you half a million dollars because that's what it should cost.
- 30:01And when people start getting a thousand two thousand five thousand dollar checks every month they will make new decisions then producers will make new decisions because they will see that the market is responding the way the market always responds.
- 30:15And so this isn't a government regime it's a community action that says everyone's getting a checks and the money isn't going to some bureaucratic offer it's in and it's out make new decisions based on correct information.
- 30:31That's very powerful because I think often these ideas get rejected because people think it's just another tax and I'm already paying enough and you know just the goods I need and want to buy it getting more expensive.
- 30:42Yeah, it just makes sense I totally about with this I think the you know the idea that you can disconnect climate change from the market and which is solve itself and some sort of command control way I think it's not going to work.
- 30:55But yeah, we can use the market to achieve the right outcome for sure.
- 30:59Seth, where can people find out more about you in the book?
- 31:03Well, I'm lucky that if you go to most search engines and my favorite one these days is perplexity and type Seth there you'll find me.
- 31:11If you go to Seth.blog there's 9,000 wide blog posts there for free and if you go to Seth.blog slash TIS there's everything you need to know about the new book.
- 31:21Wonderful and obviously everywhere we can get good books you will find the book.
- 31:25The final question I always ask is what's your best piece of leadership communications advice?
- 31:30There's a word that just got recently invented called Sander and Sander is the moment when we realize that everyone has a noise in their head the way we have a noise in our head and everyone else's noise is different than ours.
- 31:47In that moment you grow up and I think practical empathy is I don't know what you know I don't believe what you believe I don't see what you see and that's okay.
- 32:01My job is not to get you to become me my job is to bring you a story that resonates with you.
- 32:08Well that's powerful and novel I've heard this before Seth Gordon I appreciate you so much I appreciate the new book this is strategy out now and thank you very very much for taking the time to speak to us today.
- 32:22What a treat thanks for having me.
- 32:24Thanks for listening and if you enjoyed this episode could you do me a huge favor and leave a review.
- 32:28This allows us to help more people and to bring you bigger and bigger guests.
- 32:32Thank you.