Latest / Newcomer Pod / Trump's plan to win the AI race
Transcript
- 0:00Hello. Hello, everybody.
- 0:01It's Tom Doughton here bringing you their latest episode of the
- 0:04Newcomer podcast, joined by Eric, Newcomer of Newcomer and
- 0:08Madeline Renbarger of Newcomer. Welcome everybody.
- 0:11How you guys doing? You love that.
- 0:13I'll never stop. I asked Tom if you wanted to
- 0:15change the podcast name. He said no.
- 0:18It's a brand. It's a big giant end.
- 0:20Well, I'm just a contractor, so I'm actually a free radical here
- 0:23You guys are deep in deep in the swamp of newcomer.
- 0:25Speaking of the swamp, Madeline, you just returned from the
- 0:29swamp. I was talking to you yesterday.
- 0:31You were at a defense tech conference, Hill and Valley.
- 0:34Why is it called Hill and Valley?
- 0:36So I actually let me clarify, it was Co hosted with the Hill and
- 0:40Valley forum, but it was actually called winning the AI
- 0:43race, which was a new conference also Co hosted with the all in
- 0:46podcast. So I want to clarify for the
- 0:47brand's sake, a different event, but it's called Hill and Valley
- 0:51because it's, you know, the merger of, you know, DC, the
- 0:54Hill and the Silicon Valley coming together.
- 0:58Silicon Valley. See, I was thinking, no, I'm not
- 1:01smart in that way. And I actually I was liking my
- 1:04brain because you know, there are some like Chinese based
- 1:06private equity firms called like Hill House Capital and stuff and
- 1:10you never know what that means. I thought this was some weird
- 1:12permutation of that, but no. This podcast is supported by
- 1:16Google. Hi folks, Paige Bailey here from
- 1:18the Google DeepMind Devrel team. For our developers out there, we
- 1:21know there's a constant trade off between model intelligence,
- 1:24speed and cost. Gemini 2.5 Flash aims right at
- 1:27that challenge. It's got the speed you expect
- 1:29from Flash, but with upgraded reasoning power.
- 1:32And crucially, we've added controls like setting thinking
- 1:35budgets so you can decide how much reasoning to apply,
- 1:37optimizing for latency and costs.
- 1:39So try out Gemini 2.5 Flash at aistudio.google.com and let us
- 1:43know what you build. Tell me, tell me so and you just
- 1:46found out at some point as you were there like, ah shit, I'm at
- 1:49an all in conference. Yeah, so it was advertised as
- 1:52being Co hosted by All In. But what I did not realize
- 1:55getting into it is that the on stage programming was a 5 hour
- 1:58live all In podcast. Where the All In.
- 2:01Guys, I didn't even realize that.
- 2:03Yes, they all in guys were on stage with all of these tech
- 2:06leaders and Trump administration officials just kind of running
- 2:09through Trump's new AI policy and reacting to it and chumming
- 2:13it up and hanging out on a couch.
- 2:15That was the general vibe. There also was the classic
- 2:18networking section outside where you could talk with founders and
- 2:21investors that attended. My God.
- 2:23So we're gonna have a whole future media segment of this
- 2:26show, I guess. Man, I didn't realize that piece
- 2:29of it. Or I guess we have to make like
- 2:31Cerebral Valley a live podcast, like a 5 hour podcast now.
- 2:35Like if that's the bar, we. Just want like filibustering but
- 2:38anyway. Well, it's kind of funny to me
- 2:40that I mean, you know, not to start off with the all in guys
- 2:44because really the less about them, the better we say.
- 2:46But like, you know, they've played a huge part in, you know,
- 2:49the the Trump, the tech MAGA movement.
- 2:52And obviously David Sachs is part of the administration now.
- 2:55But this seems to be like the fullest, like the most fullest
- 2:58expression of like their Trump ties, right?
- 3:02This is like the full the first time that they've done like a
- 3:04conference around the fact that they are like deeply embedded in
- 3:07the administration. I mean, David Sachs is working
- 3:10for them at this point. Like they've had conferences.
- 3:13I don't know. If anything, I feel like some of
- 3:15the like the sex appeal and freshness of it all is going
- 3:18away. It's like they've done
- 3:20conferences. Trump's there while the Epstein
- 3:24files are dropping. It's like, it feels a little bit
- 3:27like, I don't know, state TV to me where they're like on the
- 3:31team setting it up. Did did they bring?
- 3:34I assume Epstein did not come up at all on stage, right?
- 3:37You know, Eric Epstein did not come up on stage.
- 3:40And but their media figures on some level, like what media,
- 3:44even conservative media figures, can't stop talking about Epstein
- 3:47because it's such a good story. And so I think the fact that All
- 3:50In would have a conference and not talk about like the biggest
- 3:54elephant in the room. It we learned that day that the
- 3:57attorney general had told Trump that he was in the Epstein files
- 4:00and they don't bring it up. It's just that is the smoking
- 4:03gun that all in is in no sense media.
- 4:06But they're not not just not media.
- 4:08They are not working on the behalf of their audience, right.
- 4:11If you're working on the behalf of your audience, forget.
- 4:14I don't even want to say I'm a journalist anymore.
- 4:15You know, my whole thing has been like, I'm a creator that
- 4:18wants to exceed expectations, but at least I know that I am
- 4:21working for my audience and the readers.
- 4:24And if they had an obvious question, I had someone up on
- 4:27stage, I didn't answer it. They should make fun of us, you
- 4:31know, and all in is is working for their subjects and not for
- 4:36their listeners, whether their listeners want to acknowledge
- 4:39that or not. And I think this event was sort
- 4:41of the capstone of that sort of capture.
- 4:46Well, I feel like they're listeners and their audience
- 4:49and, you know, I feel like it's kind of merging into one, right?
- 4:53Like if this is the culmination of, you know, all in post having
- 4:56Trump on the podcast, they talked a lot about how, you
- 4:58know, they saw the light after he was such a great guest on the
- 5:01show to then, you know, be parts of the administration.
- 5:04Well, Trump. Trump literally thanked even
- 5:07Jason. Even as we know, Jason
- 5:10Calacanis, I say even thank you, Jason.
- 5:16All right, in in classic fashion, we couldn't hold off on
- 5:19takes for long. So I've already given you a rant
- 5:21without even laying the groundwork.
- 5:22But Madeline, can you give it give us sort of a little bit of
- 5:25the overview of the day. Yes.
- 5:27So spearheaded by the all in guys, Trump was obviously the
- 5:30draw. You did what the quick trip to
- 5:34DC from New York, train there train back same day.
- 5:36What was what was on the ground who talked?
- 5:39Just give us sort of a couple bull points on what it was like.
- 5:42Sure. It was definitely, I think
- 5:44compared to past Hill and Valley forums, which I've covered much
- 5:47more emphasis on government officials.
- 5:49There were, you know, Chris Power from Hadrian who just
- 5:52raised a big amount of money, gave a presentation on stage
- 5:55about how they're going to, you know, build up AI factories.
- 5:57And Jensen of course, was on stage with the all in guys
- 6:00talking, you know, thanking President Trump for accelerating
- 6:02AI and talking about all of the great jobs that AI build up is
- 6:06going to create. However, most of the people on
- 6:08stage were predominantly administration officials.
- 6:11So it felt a lot more like here we are, it's DC, we're coming on
- 6:16tech friendly media to talk about all the great stuff we are
- 6:18doing for you, the tech audience.
- 6:20And this was literally like an announcement, right?
- 6:22I mean, they literally published winning the race America's AI
- 6:26Action Plan, like right around this.
- 6:28It was. The same day, about an hour
- 6:30before the event kicked off. And Davis X is the AI czar
- 6:34bringing in his in house media and basically like.
- 6:37But that's just smart event planning.
- 6:39That's just called synergistic thinking.
- 6:40Democrats need to get this shit together.
- 6:42Have friendly softball questions from in house media you know.
- 6:46Oh, I just meant like having an announcement, you know, you want
- 6:48news to break on the day of your conference, you get people
- 6:50talking. I mean, good, good on them.
- 6:53That's actually sounds like a very traditional media playbook.
- 6:55And it seems to me like they're really in the pocket of
- 6:56traditional media now. Yeah, what I heard Madeline was
- 7:01saying that all the reporters were passed off to the balcony.
- 7:04You couldn't even hear the toss A.
- 7:05Member As a member of the New Media Madeline, how how are you
- 7:08treated? As a member of the new media, I
- 7:11felt like I should have been treated a little better since
- 7:13we're, you know, not the lamestream media over here at
- 7:15Newcomer I, the press area was a little bit separated off from
- 7:19the main auditorium, up on a second level.
- 7:21They didn't really want us coming down to the main level
- 7:23to, you know, mingle with people unless we were in the lobby, you
- 7:26know, grabbing coffee and stuff. So I do feel like the the media
- 7:30was kind of in attendance, but not really participating in the
- 7:33the same way as past events that I've attended.
- 7:36You should have you should have like a flat, you know, like the
- 7:38the press, you know, flak jackets that they get like when
- 7:40they're embedded people. I feel like you could get a
- 7:42separate one that says sub stack on it and they just treat you a
- 7:45little different in these events.
- 7:46I think I should have gotten special treatment because we're
- 7:48a sub stack newsroom. I think we are the independent
- 7:51media that they want to have covering this.
- 7:53You know, we're, we're breaking the molds.
- 7:55Sub stack needs to have his own advocacy org, you know, just
- 7:59like there's like the White House Correspondents
- 8:01Association. The sub stack should have sort
- 8:03of a centralized like you can't treat our people like that.
- 8:06But OK, I know it's Trump and like it's mostly optics and says
- 8:10a bunch of insane shit. He talked about like maybe we
- 8:13should break up NVIDIA. And then somebody explained why
- 8:16that would be a terrible idea given Nvidia's like the heart of
- 8:19everything we're doing. But so there was lots of insane
- 8:21Trump shit and we can talk a little bit about like, you know,
- 8:24his demeanor, but the substance, please, just what what?
- 8:29Just just the substance, just quickly, what what actually
- 8:32happened? Like what they wield all the
- 8:34levers of power, Like all of them.
- 8:37Like what? What are they doing?
- 8:39Yeah. I mean, they had on stage the
- 8:41Vice President and the President of the United States.
- 8:44What are they doing? Like what is?
- 8:46What are they? Doing not.
- 8:48Saying like what is going to happen?
- 8:50The key thing that is going to happen per the executive orders
- 8:54is that environmental regulation is going to be pulled back so
- 8:57that this data center build up will be easier to do.
- 9:01Fuck the environment. Build AI, get energy ready.
- 9:03Let's go. Yeah.
- 9:04It was very build, baby build, you know, instead of drill, baby
- 9:08drill, there was build, baby build.
- 9:09That was the vibe inside the room.
- 9:11Clear regulation, clear cut regulation.
- 9:13So AI can like dominate and we're going to have this energy
- 9:16crisis. So we need to light every like
- 9:19dead dinosaur that we got left on the planet.
- 9:22Sure, the abundance guys are shedding a tear of joy in the
- 9:25midst of all of that so we can find.
- 9:26Some, yeah, it's pretty abundant.
- 9:28We're going to have AI abundance.
- 9:30Step 2, the second executive order really touched mostly on
- 9:34around exporting AI to make sure that American AI can be
- 9:39exported. So that's, you know, the plug to
- 9:41Jensen. We're not going to totally clamp
- 9:44you down with export controls. After all that China fear
- 9:47mongering, it's like actually, after creating tariffs and
- 9:52saying isolationism is the path to American success on AI,
- 9:56somehow they've conned Trump into saying actually America's
- 10:00AI succeeds if we can sell it everywhere.
- 10:02So it's embedded even in China. We want NVIDIA chips in China
- 10:05because otherwise it's going to be Huawei.
- 10:08We are globalists and internationalists on AI and then
- 10:12randomly on like manufacturing cars and any industry that
- 10:16doesn't have a great lobbying firm where isolation is.
- 10:18It makes zero sense. Oh, that's totally the policy.
- 10:22Well, I was going to say too, I think what was really just, you
- 10:26know, the tell of all of this was that during Trump's speech,
- 10:29you know, he bragged about all of the tariffs, making jokes
- 10:31like there's too many countries. I have to do deals with all
- 10:34these countries and, you know, touted his recent Japan deal.
- 10:37But then of course, with AI, it's like, cut it loose, let it
- 10:40go because that's, you know, American soft power ruling the
- 10:43world or else China AI will take over.
- 10:44So I feel like there were the inconsistencies in the policy
- 10:47really kind of popped off throughout the day.
- 10:50Have you just paid a little bit of attention?
- 10:52I obviously believe in some environmental regulation, but I
- 10:54think clear cutting regulation to build AI is good.
- 10:59I think for the if you buy into the like the Super growth
- 11:04mindset that we need to do this in the China race, it certainly
- 11:07is good. I do think that the extent that
- 11:09they want to cut it is definitely, you know, no gloves
- 11:13at all, just build drill. But we're going to be helping
- 11:16China now. We're selling them NVIDIA chips.
- 11:18Like, I don't think it's about like the war with China.
- 11:21Like I don't buy it at all. But we're also beating them.
- 11:24Sure. We're beating them.
- 11:26We're giving them the tools to undercut us and steal.
- 11:30Yeah, I want to cooperate with China, so I I have no problem
- 11:32with it. Godspeed.
- 11:33But the idea that it's going to help us beat China by giving
- 11:36them the chips that they need to deliver the stuff doesn't make
- 11:40sense to me. But also the export ban wasn't
- 11:42working like the the the whole thing end up being they were
- 11:46getting in there through like Indonesia and like various
- 11:48Southeast Asian countries like you saw with DeepSeek that they
- 11:51were plenty capable of building like competent high quality
- 11:55models largely on chips that had been smuggled into the country.
- 11:57So. All it was really doing was
- 11:59hurting American chip manufacturers, which is why
- 12:01Jensen was kind of pushing them to, you know, hey, don't, don't
- 12:04lock this in this way. Can I ask quickly because I, I,
- 12:08I saw the tweet, I didn't dig more into it.
- 12:11Why did he want to break up NVIDIA?
- 12:12What was the argument there? Why were they scary to him?
- 12:15I might be misremembering, but it felt like it was like an
- 12:18NVIDIA. Who are those guys?
- 12:20What are they doing? No, they're American.
- 12:22Asian guy that runs it, that's no good.
- 12:25Break that thing up, but it's like.
- 12:27You can't tell me that there wasn't at least an initial
- 12:29thought by Trump that like they're a Chinese company.
- 12:32Right. No, literally.
- 12:34On stage. He more or less implied that in
- 12:36his little NVIDIA riff he was doing in the speech.
- 12:39Like, so there there's this AI action plan, but then there were
- 12:43also executive orders about AI, the most disturbing of which to
- 12:47me was this order that says if you're a government contractor,
- 12:52you have to have unbiased AI. And they specifically talk about
- 12:57DI and transgenderism. And it's just like, yeah, I
- 13:02mean, the idea of unbiased is incoherent.
- 13:05And then in the same executive order, you're basically saying
- 13:08what you can't talk about. So it's like inserting bias.
- 13:12I, I don't know, I find that deeply troubling.
- 13:14The last thing I'll say on this, I, you know, one of my more
- 13:17viral tweets, I said, you know, no atheists in a foxhole, no
- 13:21libertarians in a bank run when David Sacks was like begging for
- 13:25SVB to, to get a bailout. And now it's like, you know,
- 13:28there are no, there are no free marketers in government.
- 13:31It's like as soon as David Sachs touches the government, they're
- 13:34putting out executive orders saying let's let's regulate AI
- 13:38so that you can't explain transgenderism to people.
- 13:42Well, it's always just the point of, you know, the free speech
- 13:45for me and not for thee. We saw this with the social
- 13:47media wars, right? Like this felt like kind of
- 13:49social media Part 2 where Zuckerberg caved and, you know,
- 13:52got rid of community notes and Meta and all of this stuff to,
- 13:55you know, get these get close to Trump and buddy buddy with the
- 13:57administration. And so by just declaring that
- 14:00for AI companies to work with the government in any way,
- 14:03especially with all these DoD contracts on the line, they have
- 14:05to, you know, remove bias just like that just means that they
- 14:09have to censor certain topics because the training data is
- 14:11already in there. Like what do they want?
- 14:12And of course, which AI company has seemed the most biased so
- 14:16far? You're talking about the one
- 14:17that has written into. It's like prompts that like.
- 14:20What would Elon say on this topic?
- 14:22Right, the one that literally talks in first person sometimes
- 14:25as the owner and searches like what's the guy who owns me think
- 14:29before I answer this. Well, I also love the idea of
- 14:33like, you know, a contractor having to explain to whatever
- 14:36the DoD or any other organization that's going to
- 14:38sign a huge, you know, trying to get like a huge RFP for the
- 14:42different language models. Like Sir, we have found the most
- 14:45unbiased of all of the chat bots that are out there.
- 14:48Side point, it is Mecca Hitler. So you you will have to work
- 14:52through that. But yes, as we ran through it,
- 14:55the most unbiased 1 happens to also give specific instructions
- 14:58on how to attack Will Stancil in the night.
- 15:00But it is the least woke. So that is the one we're going
- 15:03to have to choose based on the EO.
- 15:05Yeah, it is just the hypocrisy of, you know, bias just meaning
- 15:10different from Trump's positions on issues like that is if we're
- 15:13just classically going back to that, it's just the greatest
- 15:16hits of that. Again, we're just putting that
- 15:17in executive order. And I just, I'm curious to see
- 15:21how companies respond to it because I mean, working with the
- 15:24federal government has proven to be very lucrative for a lot of
- 15:27these companies so far. So I don't know what's gonna
- 15:30happen. Well, we, we, we also saw like
- 15:32in Trump one like vendettas being used as a way to hand out
- 15:36contracts or stop other companies from getting contracts
- 15:38was like fairly standard procedure.
- 15:40Like Amazon AWS lost their shit after the Pentagon gave a
- 15:44contract to Azure and to Google over AWS because of, you know,
- 15:48Trump's anger at Bezos and, and Amazon and the Washington Post.
- 15:53And so, yeah, no, I'm just saying like there's a real
- 15:55reason for these people to like, play up at, you know, Curry
- 15:58favor and like be as sycophantic as possible to Trump because.
- 16:01Oh my God, yeah. Didn't Jackson literally say
- 16:03America's going to win an AI because of Trump or something?
- 16:06I America's unique advantage that no country possibly have is
- 16:12President Trump. There there are a lot of
- 16:16compromises I wouldn't want to make as a public company CEO.
- 16:19Like, I don't know, but like the Oh yeah, Trump, you're a genius.
- 16:23Like everything through you. It's like it's such a low
- 16:26hanging way to Curry favor that I can see why it's so tempting.
- 16:32And Jensen smartly, you know, got his export controls
- 16:35overturned, so it's a good play. His approval ratings and Tom,
- 16:37you're making this point before the show.
- 16:39They are bad, like, somehow, like, until we have the
- 16:42midterms, I feel like the culture, you know, if this were
- 16:44like a normal president with approval ratings this bad,
- 16:47people would, like, start to not taking him seriously.
- 16:50But I think it's because the Republicans would get primaried
- 16:53anyway that they have to be so locked up.
- 16:55I don't know. Yeah.
- 16:57Tom, what's your observation on the.
- 16:58I think. We've talked about this a couple
- 17:01times on the show, like, you know, the bald faced sycophancy
- 17:04of the tech, you know MAGA, right?
- 17:06Whatever you want to call it toward Trump at one point seemed
- 17:09fairly prescient, right? If you were, I don't want to
- 17:12talk about Sean McGuire again, But if you were one of those
- 17:13people that were backing Trump during the 2024 election, you
- 17:18looked really smart, like you looked way ahead.
- 17:20Well, I would say to this point, Tom, the all the Hill and Valley
- 17:23Forum leaders who, you know, put on this summit in the 1st place
- 17:26with Jacob Helberg, you know, kind of spearheading this with
- 17:29Delia and and Christian Garrett, they have, you know, hold the
- 17:32anchors of powers in some way. And you know Helberg is going to
- 17:35be appointed in the administration.
- 17:37Republicans, if you're willing to be the one smart person
- 17:40around a Republican, you could like, fucking ascend to the top
- 17:43immediately. It's like it's a vacuum.
- 17:44It's the easiest hack. It's like so many fucking
- 17:47lawyers do that. But that's under the assumption
- 17:50that being smart helps you as a Republican, which I don't really
- 17:52think it does. I mean, but they always want.
- 17:54I don't think to dominate. I mean, you see.
- 17:56Yeah, you can. I think they can tell you the
- 18:00story that being quote UN quote smart doesn't necessarily make
- 18:02you the like the popular guy or the most powerful person in the
- 18:05party. But you know, like Sam Altman is
- 18:07an interesting case with that because he lifelong Democrat,
- 18:11you know, is as public about hating Trump as almost anyone in
- 18:14tech after he gets elected. I mean, he makes as a source
- 18:16told me like not too long ago, he made a determination like
- 18:19midway through the campaign, 24 Trump's going to win.
- 18:22I need to start getting closer to him and he starts doing that
- 18:25and then he streets out, you know, Oh, I misunderstood you,
- 18:27Trump. Everything I thought, you know,
- 18:29was, you know, intermediated by a biased media and all this
- 18:33bullshit that everyone has to say in order to make themselves
- 18:35feel, you know, close to Trump. So but that all seemed very
- 18:38smart. And now, like, I was talking
- 18:39about 37% approval ratings as low as it's ever been for him.
- 18:43It's not as low as it got during Trump won, but like, he is not a
- 18:46popular president. And and, and so when you see,
- 18:48and it's not, I don't know if it's going to get better or not,
- 18:50but it's unlikely to turn around in a major way.
- 18:53And so when you see the same rhetoric from the tech crowd
- 18:57supporting him, like Jensen saying, you know, we couldn't
- 18:59have done without you, Trump, the big advantage that we have
- 19:01is that you, we have Trump and no one else does.
- 19:04It's so blatant as to what's going on here.
- 19:06You're not tapping into a zeitgeist.
- 19:08You're just trying to get the best possible deal for your
- 19:09company. You're trying to line your
- 19:11pockets. And that's fine.
- 19:14That's business. It's it's gone like that.
- 19:15Forever they want to get rich, they want the companies to do
- 19:17well and that that's their job. But I, I do think they also want
- 19:20to see, they think AI is like a bigger force than honestly, like
- 19:24the, the US government and like the US government has a lot of
- 19:27power. But it's like we need to suck up
- 19:29the Trump and he's going to like clear cut the government and say
- 19:33we can do whatever we want to power the data centers.
- 19:35We need to build God like that's that's what they want.
- 19:40And Eric, to your point, I, I think that is what they want.
- 19:42And I feel like they've really got it.
- 19:44Like, you know, I was, you know, commenting like all this point
- 19:47about, you know, Trump being low energy and like, you know, the
- 19:49Epstein story breaking while he's on stage, Like none of that
- 19:52seems to really matter. They got the order, you know,
- 19:55like it's, it's been the the path has been cleared.
- 19:57It will matter electorally, but like they're willing to just
- 20:00like, well, yeah, we won't talk about any of that.
- 20:02Just like we'll we'll say you're awesome.
- 20:04Like give us our clear cutting and like.
- 20:06Let's go forward. Right.
- 20:08The action plan is already out. The orders are already signed
- 20:10like you know they're good to go.
- 20:12Yeah, and they don't really need a Congress to support any of
- 20:15these things anyway, so they might as well build as quickly
- 20:17as they can until Trump, you know, completely loses his
- 20:19ability to do any of the things that they want.
- 20:22Because I I guess you can always sign E OS.
- 20:25No one's really going to stop you from that.
- 20:27And I don't even know how. I mean, is it clear actually
- 20:29does you're talking to people there like whether or not these
- 20:32executive orders were going to do all that much.
- 20:34I mean, there's a lot of posturing with these things.
- 20:37You're not actually changing that many rules.
- 20:39They're not signing things into law.
- 20:40You're not getting rid of active restrictions.
- 20:42I mean, you know, this, we're poking around like a theme of
- 20:45this administration is like, who cares what appropriators said
- 20:50this money was for? Like, we'll do whatever we want.
- 20:52So there is a degree to which, if the administration is willing
- 20:56to say they want something and they're willing to bend all the
- 20:59rules about using money appropriated by Congress however
- 21:02they want, this is a time where executive orders are more
- 21:06powerful than ever if they can navigate the bureaucracy.
- 21:10What stood out to you among the EOS that you think is going to
- 21:13be the most important? Because I have some thoughts,
- 21:15but I'm curious as you were there, like what what mattered
- 21:18to you? What stood out to me, there's
- 21:19something that stood out from, you know, us as reporters
- 21:22standpoint that could shape the form of AI, which I do think
- 21:25the, you know, removing government contracts, unless
- 21:28your AI isn't woke or whatever point will have impacts on how
- 21:33this AI forms in the future. But I think from the business
- 21:36standpoint, you know, streamlining regulations and
- 21:39gutting climate rules to, you know, do this massive build up I
- 21:41think will be the most consequential for the AI
- 21:43industry. What do you think, Tom?
- 21:46Yeah, I sorry, just back on like the, you know, government
- 21:49contracts for AI. We we've seen a bunch of the big
- 21:52companies, the the big labs and model makers sign, you know,
- 21:55multi $100 million deals with the government recently.
- 21:58Like I saw XAI got a big contract, which is interesting.
- 22:02Open AI got one as well. So we're like at the beginning
- 22:05stages of like actual tangible contracts between these
- 22:09companies and and the government.
- 22:10I do want to say as a point, it does often get misreported that
- 22:14like opening, I signed a $200 million contract with the DoD.
- 22:17That's not quite right. They signed like a $5,000,000
- 22:20like basically exploratory contract with the potential of
- 22:23it getting up to $200 million. So people should not report it
- 22:27as like $200 million is going directly into open AI as like
- 22:30some sort of government enterprise contract deal.
- 22:32It's a little different than these things typically get
- 22:34reported. But the one part that stuck out
- 22:37to me, and again, I don't know how much this is going to matter
- 22:40in the large scheme of things is the fact that, you know, and I
- 22:43think Trump mentioned this in his speech, that AI model should
- 22:46be given clearance to train on copyrighted materials.
- 22:51And it's a huge issue right now that's playing out really
- 22:55literally in the courts over, you know, the when all of these
- 22:59models were built, you know, chat GPTS models, GPT 4,
- 23:02whatever anthropics models, they basically ingested the entire
- 23:06web and, you know, published materials in order to train on
- 23:09these things. And as the New York Times is
- 23:11currently suing right now, they New York Times, because it was
- 23:14trained on their content, should be compensated for the
- 23:18information that they created that was later used to create
- 23:21these models, which are obviously now hyper competitive
- 23:24with traffic to all of these new sites.
- 23:27And I also saw there was, was it like a gal or was it like a Pew
- 23:29poll or a Pew study today that showed that traffic has declined
- 23:33substantially to a lot of new sites based on the AI overviews
- 23:38that Google does. And so kind of like the doomsday
- 23:41scenario that every news organization was thinking about
- 23:44with the rise of AI and like summarization of articles may be
- 23:48upon us because people are more willing to read an AI summary of
- 23:52copyrighted material then then go to the article.
- 23:56But I got super into this topic, like over the last couple days
- 23:59and was talking to people about it.
- 24:01Because if you talk to, you know, journalists or certainly
- 24:05the lawyers who are representing The New York Times, they believe
- 24:07like a grave injustice is being it's been done here right now
- 24:11that that the fact that, you know, these models were trained
- 24:14on New York Times copyrighted materials, like fucked
- 24:16everything up for everyone. And they deserve money for it.
- 24:19And so far, the most of these lawsuits have lost like Mehta
- 24:23recently just won, you know, a case against this.
- 24:26And it's a really fascinating conversation and like discussion
- 24:29about what does it mean to consume and create material and,
- 24:35you know, the, the, the, the history of the copyright.
- 24:38And, you know, like when Google created its algorithm for its
- 24:41search engine, it was also ingesting the entirety of the
- 24:44web, creating cached pages of, of, of the Internet and creating
- 24:48some sort of content. If you want to call a search
- 24:50result content on top of that, that had specific effects on the
- 24:54websites. And we are seeing now basically
- 24:58again, this doomsday scenario play out where it is competitive
- 25:01to a degree with the original content, whether or not they
- 25:06were legally allowed to do it. And I mean, if we want to get
- 25:09into a debate about it, I'm down to but like my stance as I spend
- 25:11more time and it is like, yeah, I do believe they are legally
- 25:14allowed to do it. And it and it comes down to this
- 25:17question. And I think Trump kind of
- 25:18touched on it, you know? Well, yeah, I was going to say
- 25:22it. Can.
- 25:22Can I say it? Yeah.
- 25:23And when he was on stage, Trump kind of did a little when he
- 25:26went off script, he did a little riff about this.
- 25:29You can't be expected to have a successful AI program when every
- 25:32single article, book, or anything else that you've read
- 25:35or studied you're supposed to pay for, Gee, I read a book, I'm
- 25:39supposed to pay somebody. And you know, we, we appreciate
- 25:42that, but you just can't do it because it's not doable.
- 25:46And if you're going to try and do that, you're not going to
- 25:48have a successful program. I think most of the people in
- 25:50the room know what I mean. When a person reads a book or an
- 25:54article, you've gained great knowledge.
- 25:57That does not mean that you're violating copyright laws or have
- 26:01to make deals with every content provider.
- 26:05And that's a big thing that you're working on right now.
- 26:08I know, but you just can't do it.
- 26:09China's not doing it. And if you're going to be
- 26:11beating China, and right now we're leading China very
- 26:14substantially and AI very, very substantially.
- 26:17And nobody's seen the the amount of work that's going to be
- 26:20bursting upon the scene. But you have to be able to play
- 26:25by the same set of rules. So when you have something, when
- 26:29you read something and when it goes into this vast intelligence
- 26:35machine, we'll call it, you cannot expect to every time,
- 26:40every single time say, oh, let's pay this one that much.
- 26:43Let's pay this one just doesn't work that way.
- 26:45Of course you can't copy or plagiarize an article, but if
- 26:49you read an article and learn from it, we have to allow AI to
- 26:53use that pool of knowledge without going through the
- 26:55complexity of contract negotiations, of which there
- 26:58would be thousands for every time we use AI.
- 27:03He kind of touched on the point, you know, himself in a way that
- 27:06I felt like was honestly kind of hard to go up against.
- 27:11How do paywalls play into this? Like is there?
- 27:15Is there just how I don't actually know the particulars?
- 27:18Like how much is their argument that they're the information was
- 27:21behind a paywall? I think if you know this gets
- 27:24into like the robot dot TXT construction of websites which
- 27:29basically allows the robots to scan the pages.
- 27:33I, I'm pretty, I'm pretty sure stuff that's behind a paywall is
- 27:36still probably scannable by by the robots and so that stuff
- 27:40does like. The New York Times had set it up
- 27:43so that it was scannable because they wanted search results.
- 27:45Yeah, yeah, yeah. The same way that it can get
- 27:48scanned by, you know, the web crawler also allowed these
- 27:52models to be able to ingest the content on these pages.
- 27:54The way someone framed it to me, which I was really interested
- 27:57in, was like, the core of the question is really, do robots
- 28:00have the right to read? Like, are they allowed to go to
- 28:03these websites and read and learn things?
- 28:05And is the thing that they created by reading it
- 28:07competitive with it? Is it transformative or is it
- 28:09derivative? If it's derivative, it's
- 28:11competitive and it's in a violation of copyright.
- 28:13If it's transformative, it's something new.
- 28:16And I mean, these are the questions that are going to be
- 28:17playing out probably in front of the Supreme Court.
- 28:20But I should be allowed to say who can read read my stuff
- 28:24right? And like if I have a paywall.
- 28:26Would you be fine with your like newcomers stories not showing up
- 28:30in a Google search because you don't want it to?
- 28:32But why can't I draw a distinction and say I I'm OK
- 28:35with Google and I'm not OK with you And like you're allowed to
- 28:37do business with whoever you want.
- 28:39Like I'm OK with businesses where they're they're trying to
- 28:42link to me and get people to come to me and not OK with
- 28:45businesses where they're trying to replace me and summarize me.
- 28:49Like I don't know where to free market.
- 28:52I can do business with who I want.
- 28:54So so to me, I would sort of push more on this sort of like,
- 29:00you know, should open AI have paid?
- 29:01Yeah, paid to access the stories.
- 29:07Well, people, you know, Anthropic did it in their own
- 29:09way. You know, they bought literally
- 29:11bought physical books and scanned them and then destroyed
- 29:14the original material, which that seems like the nature of
- 29:18the. Book, I mean a book, it's like,
- 29:19yeah, you get it. You can do whatever you want.
- 29:21You can, you know, consume it. Physical media you you have the
- 29:25right to consume it once you own it.
- 29:27I don't know how it's going to play out.
- 29:28I mean, again, like every single lawsuit has has lost or or been
- 29:31thrown out thus far. I think the New York Times
- 29:34probably has the strongest 1 going right now just because
- 29:38they're the New York Times. They probably have the best
- 29:39lawyers to advocate for it. But I imagine this is going to
- 29:43reach the Supreme Court. It like hurts my heart.
- 29:46It's like a hard, like, on the one hand, you know, if AI is
- 29:51going to succeed and AI is like clearly important, our models
- 29:54need to be able to like scroll, you know, consume all this
- 29:58information and like they're going to be of national
- 30:01importance. And like China is clearly doing
- 30:03the same. So just on a pragmatic level,
- 30:05like clearly we need them to basically consume everything and
- 30:10higher quality information. But I'm certainly sympathetic to
- 30:14people who created all the valuable information saying, I,
- 30:18I created this world, historically important thing.
- 30:22Shouldn't I get money out of it? I do.
- 30:24I do think a lot of the like the value in these AAI models, the
- 30:29techniques, everybody's been able to copy the technique and
- 30:31people who came up with the technique or some random
- 30:34researcher, you know, a lot of the value in the models is the
- 30:37actual underlying knowledge that's been accumulated by, you
- 30:42know, a bunch of. Different companies.
- 30:43My worry about this though is is that if it does get to a point
- 30:46where you basically just have to compensate all the creators of
- 30:49content to in order to use their material to create a model,
- 30:54there are companies that can pay for it.
- 30:56They're just giant tech companies and we're leading
- 30:59towards a world where the only people that would be able to
- 31:02build models are ones that have the 10s of billions of dollars
- 31:05that you would maybe need to to pay off the creators to do it.
- 31:08And that's fine. We're kind of already there
- 31:10anyway, but it destroys the possibility of ever there, you
- 31:13know, of open source models and, and I think obviously they're
- 31:17not very big right now the open source community compared to the
- 31:20proprietary's. But if you believe in that, and
- 31:22I think a lot of people in the Internet world do have that as
- 31:25their core belief that open source matters, this seems to
- 31:28set an extremely high bar monetarily to build these sort
- 31:32of things. And, and I think that's a bad
- 31:33thing. Just to add on to that, in the
- 31:35open AI action plan, you know that they were touting all day
- 31:38yesterday, there was a provision around protecting open source
- 31:43and a lot of founders that I spoke to said that that was a
- 31:46really important win for little tech for them so that they could
- 31:49continue operating. So.
- 31:50Oh yeah, that that's a key thing.
- 31:52I mean, honestly, in some of what Trump is doing is what he's
- 31:55not doing, you know, it's like the Biden administration trying
- 31:58to come up with rules and savior this a model this size we're
- 32:01going to attract you. And now they're being expressly
- 32:04pro open source. You know, there there was much
- 32:07more it felt like in the bite administration, the anthropics
- 32:11and opening eyes of the world. We're trying to sidle up to the
- 32:15administration and say you can trust us part of the deep state
- 32:18liberal machine. Don't trust the sort of Wild
- 32:21West open source models. And clearly under Trump, it's
- 32:24like, OK, open source is sort of that capitalistic, let everybody
- 32:29compete spirit. And so that that's another part
- 32:33of what they announced. Yeah.
- 32:35So, so Eric, earlier you mentioned Dario's Modi, CEO, Co
- 32:38founder of of Anthropic, also Cerebral Valley guest at one
- 32:43point, all these things are and more on his LinkedIn, he
- 32:47recently sent an internal memo to the staff at Anthropic saying
- 32:51that they are planning to or in discussions to take some money
- 32:54from the Middle East. Where was it specifically?
- 32:57Was it was it Qatar or? Qatar definitely is one of the
- 33:00major sources. I forget if you called out a
- 33:02specific country. Yeah, yeah.
- 33:04And, you know, it seemed like he was a little sheepish about the
- 33:07whole thing, or at least defensively explaining it,
- 33:09saying, listen, we did not intend to take money from the
- 33:12middle. East, he literally says like,
- 33:13you can't just have good people benefit from your success if you
- 33:17want to be a big company. Yeah, yeah.
- 33:20He's teaching us about the way the world works.
- 33:21He basically gives us the Ned Betty speech in in from network
- 33:25about how the world works and how you need to kind of accept,
- 33:28you know, the, the, the primordial powers of of the
- 33:30universe. It is like capitalism sort of at
- 33:33its essence. You know, I like capitalism, but
- 33:36there is a certain like, oh man, like our job is to do this.
- 33:40You look at the trade off. You know, we're gonna we need to
- 33:43raise money. Money is money.
- 33:44Like I, I'm. I mean, this is just one of many
- 33:48compromises that Dario has had to make as the CEO of Anthropic.
- 33:52And if you remember the history of this company, he broke off
- 33:55from Open AI because he was pissed off about taking money
- 33:59from Microsoft and it kind of polluting this effective
- 34:01altruist mission of, of the original company and, and the
- 34:05nonprofit. And then he goes off and lo and
- 34:08behold, there's a shit load of money that can be made.
- 34:10And also it cost a lot of money to make these models.
- 34:12And, you know, he goes off and raises as much as almost any
- 34:15other company other than Open AI and now realizes that, like,
- 34:19when you need to keep raising this level of money, there's
- 34:21really only one place you can do it, and that's the Middle East.
- 34:24And so the guy is like pretty experienced at compromises.
- 34:27And it's funny that he's even like, trying to, you know,
- 34:30explain it away when it's like. I mean, I don't have any
- 34:33objection to him taking money in the Middle East.
- 34:35I think the sort of capitulation is interesting to interrogate.
- 34:40To me, it's interesting right now, just like thinking about
- 34:44Trump's executive order, right? If we are counting on companies
- 34:49to have backbone and say, I guess we won't sell the
- 34:51government, we're going to have to sell out our values on, you
- 34:55know, thinking about what the results the model produces.
- 35:00This is not a sign that the the companies will keep their
- 35:02backbone, right? They're like, well, our job is
- 35:05to chase the almighty dollar. And yeah, the government is an
- 35:08important contractor and this is a small capitulation about a
- 35:12topic we don't that is not central the model like whatever
- 35:15the money sort of swamps the principle.
- 35:18And so I, I do think, you know, it's the classic like you give
- 35:21up one principle and slowly you find yourself giving them all
- 35:26up. And I don't think this is
- 35:28necessarily the line that anthropic needs to hold on to.
- 35:32And I still generally trust them as a moral decision maker.
- 35:37But you know it. It's small capitulations on the
- 35:41way to to giving up your morality.
- 35:44It feels like that was kind of the long arc of open AI, right?
- 35:47Like, you know, as the an AI that is benevolent to mankind.
- 35:51And then, you know, there were moral conflicts between this,
- 35:53but. Open AI was always run by one of
- 35:56the most power hungry men alive, so I don't know that that's less
- 36:00surprise. I they yes, they became they
- 36:03started a non profit. But you know, Sam was always
- 36:05extremely ambitious. That's that's sort of the that's
- 36:08line of open AI. That's very fair.
- 36:10That's a good point. But all this just to say, I'm,
- 36:13I'm saying even the effect of altruist AI company goes the way
- 36:18of capitalist enterprise, so. Yeah.
- 36:22And listen, like if there are going to be paying customers
- 36:24that want to buy the ability to make biological weapons with
- 36:27your AI, do you want to win or not like?
- 36:31They probably pay really well. Yeah, like it's and that always
- 36:35is the thing. By the way, I've noticed that
- 36:36there's like fears about the usage of of of large language
- 36:39models to make bio weapons. And, you know, to date, Dario
- 36:43remains against using this technology to do that.
- 36:46But listen, we make one compromise.
- 36:49You make a lot of compromises. Well.
- 36:50I was going to say there's always that fear on the bio
- 36:52weapons, but the the qualms around other weapons and, you
- 36:55know, partnering with the Defense Department, those are
- 36:57gone. So yeah, it's just the bio
- 36:59weapons. I'm interested in like, you
- 37:02know, the value of a corporate morals and and strategy as to
- 37:09you know, like, is it about recruitment?
- 37:10Is it about winning over business or is it about just
- 37:12sleeping at night? Well, Anthropic has always had
- 37:16this position that on AI safety they would create a race to the
- 37:20top. And you could argue that there's
- 37:23some truth to this. Like the idea was we'll have
- 37:26scruples and therefore engineers with scruples will come here and
- 37:31that will create pressure on other companies to, to have
- 37:35scruples themselves. And I, I do think we've seen way
- 37:38fewer defections from Anthropic than we've seen at Open AI.
- 37:42On the other hand, you know, I don't think, Mike, I don't think
- 37:46Meta is shouting about its scruples.
- 37:48It's shouting about the power of the American dollar.
- 37:50And so I don't know that Anthropic's race to the top is
- 37:54necessarily trickling out to the rest of the AI industry.
- 37:58But I do think it's had this sort of view that having sort of
- 38:02principles about we're really going to test these models,
- 38:04we're going to have robust safety, would help it win
- 38:08because it would attract, you know, these AI engineers are
- 38:11getting paid more money than they could ever use.
- 38:13So to some degree, they are the type of people that will decide
- 38:17where they work based on other things besides just money.
- 38:20And you know, having sort of principles is one of them.
- 38:24I mean, that's the missionary versus mercenary, uh, breakdown.
- 38:27And it was funny for Sam to be the one that kind of put that
- 38:31into, you know, the conversation and into the discourse.
- 38:34I mean, I he's a missionary, but it feels so ambitious, you know,
- 38:38it's like, it's like I want to be the God king of, you know,
- 38:40AI. Well, if you're if you're a
- 38:42missionary surrounded by mercenaries too, like you can,
- 38:45you know, I don't know how much longer that's going to last for
- 38:48you if it's really ultimately A mercenary world about attracting
- 38:52talent. And I think everyone does really
- 38:54have a number, whatever. I don't want to go deep into
- 38:56like the talent wars again, but. I mean, you've talked to some of
- 38:59these people. Yeah.
- 39:00Well, I think they they are they everyone has a number.
- 39:06Yeah, I don't understand the psychology of the person who's
- 39:08like, I make $10 million in four years, Like now I need to make
- 39:1475 or whatever. I guess I Yeah, that that person
- 39:18is distant from me. What?
- 39:19What is the thing that they want?
- 39:21Well, I think it's just the human impulse of like, I make
- 39:23$10 million and this guy who's as talented as I am, or maybe
- 39:27even less talented I am, is making 75,000,000.
- 39:29Like, fuck you. Like, why do you get a third
- 39:31house? Like that just doesn't that
- 39:33doesn't sit well with me. So I'm going to like if that
- 39:36that fucking money's out there, I would be stupid not to take.
- 39:39I think that's a much more powerful.
- 39:40Argument and, you know, you start looking at all the
- 39:42different like marble countertops that you could get
- 39:45and you're like, well, you know, it adds up, you know.
- 39:48There's always a place to spend the money.
- 39:49That's never the issue. All right?
- 39:52Anyway, good luck, Dario, with that Middle East money.
- 39:55We'll, we'll, we'll be watching. For it, they still invest, you
- 39:58know, like they they read this memo where they're like, yeah,
- 40:01it's distasteful, but we'll do it.
- 40:04Right, we're about to take. Money from some of the most
- 40:06disgusting. People in the world.
- 40:08This is going to be the worst of both worlds.
- 40:10You know, they they make the moral capitulation, then they
- 40:13don't get the money because they stuck their nose up at it.
- 40:16Yeah, well, capitalism runs both ways too.
- 40:18Like they they want to invest in these things because they want
- 40:20to make money as well. So you're right.
- 40:22Yeah. Like they're not just.
- 40:25All. Right, that that about does it
- 40:27for us this week. Thanks so much for listening and
- 40:30we will catch you back here next week.
- 40:33Subscribe to newcomer.co and we'll see you next week.