Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Motorcycle Helmets 101: Understanding the Critical Role of Helmets in Motorcycle Accident Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Motorcycle Helmets 101, Understanding
- 0:06the Critical Role of Helmets in Motorcycle Accident
- 0:10Cases. I'm Philip Vondra, Co -Chair of the Beverly
- 0:13Hills Bar Association's Personal Injury Law Section,
- 0:17and I'm delighted to introduce today's speaker,
- 0:20Malicek Burgess Myers. Malicek began representing
- 0:24injured victims and their families immediately
- 0:27upon her admission to the California bar, and
- 0:30has done so throughout her career. Having earned
- 0:33a reputation for her fierce advocacy, Melasek
- 0:36is often entrusted with personal injury and wrongful
- 0:39death cases previously considered unwinnable
- 0:42by other attorneys. Her unwavering dedication
- 0:46to justice and her client has earned her a recognition
- 0:49as a 2020 Consumer Attorneys Association of Los
- 0:54Angeles Rising Star nominee. Prior to founding
- 0:57the law office of Melasek Burgess and then co
- 1:00-founding Burgess Meyers PLC, Melasek had the
- 1:04privilege of working as a law clerk for over
- 1:06eight years at the largest trial court in the
- 1:09U .S., gaining extensive and invaluable knowledge
- 1:12in civil litigation. And now let's get started.
- 1:17Thank you very much, Philip. Good afternoon,
- 1:19everyone. Welcome to our webinar. My name is
- 1:25Malisak Burgess, and I'm a personal injury attorney
- 1:28with Burgess Myers PLC. Today's webinar will
- 1:32focus on the crucial role that motorcycle helmets
- 1:36play, not in only saving lives, but also in shaping
- 1:40the outcome of a motorcycle personal injury case.
- 1:45Slide, please. Everything looks better from inside
- 1:50a motorcycle helmet. This anonymous quote reminds
- 1:53us that helmets aren't just a safety device.
- 1:56They're part of the motorcycle rider's experience.
- 1:59But from a legal perspective, they're also one
- 2:02of the most important factors we need to examine
- 2:05when evaluating a potential motorcycle injury
- 2:10case. Slide, please. Today we will examine California's
- 2:17current strict requirements. explore modern helmet
- 2:21safety design and technology. We're going to
- 2:23delve into the medical consequences of not wearing
- 2:26or improperly wearing a helmet. And finally,
- 2:30we're going to discuss how all of this ties into
- 2:33evaluating, handling, and potentially litigating
- 2:37personal injury cases involving motorcycle riders.
- 2:42Slide, please. Before we get started, let's take
- 2:49a quick look at the dramatic evolution of motorcycle
- 2:52helmets and helmet laws. Surprisingly, the first
- 2:56motorcycle helmet, which can be seen in the photo
- 2:59to the left, was not developed until almost 30
- 3:01years after the first petroleum -fueled motorcycle
- 3:05was invented. Even so, it was seen more as an
- 3:10optional accessory, and it was rarely used by
- 3:13riders. Slide please. It wasn't until the 1950s
- 3:21that the development of motorcycle helmets took
- 3:24a major step forward when American motorcyclists
- 3:27acknowledged the importance of better head protection
- 3:30and began advocating for effective head gear.
- 3:34So after a several actually high profile crashes,
- 3:39including fatalities involving. prominent figures
- 3:42in the motorcycle community, there was a growing
- 3:45consensus that helmets could help save lives.
- 3:49This led to the introduction of the first helmet
- 3:51standards in the United States in 1953. These
- 3:56standards were created to ensure helmets provided
- 3:58basic protection, particularly for head and skull
- 4:02injuries. As the number of motorcycle -related
- 4:05injuries and fatalities rose, in the 60s, public
- 4:08safety groups and insurance companies started
- 4:10to push for legislation requiring the use of
- 4:14helmets. As a result, the first federal law mandating
- 4:18universal helmet use by both motorcycle operators
- 4:22and passengers regardless of their age or experience,
- 4:26was put into effect in 1966. So the federal government
- 4:30required states to enact universal motorcycle
- 4:34helmet laws in order to qualify for certain highway
- 4:38safety funds. By 1975, universal helmet use laws
- 4:43were in effect in 47 states and the District
- 4:46of Columbia. But when federal penalties for states
- 4:50without a universal helmet law were eliminated
- 4:53in 1976, just a year later, a year after, sorry,
- 5:02so many, the most states there are, had a law,
- 5:07I'm not sure if that made sense, but the universal
- 5:12laws were eliminated, I'm sorry. Roughly half
- 5:15of the states got rid of their laws. So, once
- 5:19they got the funding, they were not interested
- 5:21in having these laws any longer. So next slide,
- 5:27please. California is its own creature. I mean,
- 5:30with the landscape that we have and all the different
- 5:34areas where motorcyclists can go riding, it makes
- 5:38sense that they have extremely strict laws. So
- 5:42California vehicle code section 27803, has some
- 5:49of the strictest helmet laws in the country.
- 5:53It makes it unlawful to operate a motorcycle
- 5:55or ride as a passenger without wearing a safety
- 5:58helmet. There's some states that say just the
- 6:02operator needs to wear it. In California, both
- 6:04the operator and the passenger have to be wearing
- 6:06a safety helmet. So the statute defines what
- 6:12it means to wear a safety helmet, which is, quote,
- 6:16having a safety helmet on the person's head that
- 6:18is fastened with the helmet straps and that is
- 6:21of a size that fits the wearing person's head
- 6:24securely without excessive lateral or vertical
- 6:27movement. Every part of that, in order to be
- 6:32considered a safety helmet. that complies with
- 6:37the law. Another difference with California law
- 6:42is that California doesn't care about your age
- 6:45when it comes to helmets or your experience or
- 6:48even the type of motorcycle which is being ridden.
- 6:55It all comes down to It doesn't matter if you're
- 6:58a kid, you're an adult, where you are, you need
- 7:00to be wearing the helmet. And it applies to both
- 7:03highways and local roads. Under this code section,
- 7:07safety helmets must also meet the requirements
- 7:10established pursuant to, slide please, vehicle
- 7:14code section 27802, which basically, requires
- 7:19compliance with the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety
- 7:23Standard number 218 or FMVSS number 218 for short.
- 7:30Slide please. So the National Highway Traffic
- 7:36Safety Administration, I'm sure most of you've
- 7:38heard of it, the NHTSA, which is a part of the
- 7:44US Department of Transportation, the DOT, they
- 7:47were responsible for drafting and getting FMVSS
- 7:52number 218 passed. So what's so special about
- 7:56this standard? Well, it basically sets the minimum
- 8:00level of performance that helmets in the US must
- 8:05meet to protect the head and brain in a crash.
- 8:11client helmets that are manufactured, and it's
- 8:14a very specific date, before, I'm sorry, on or
- 8:19after May 13th, 2013, are required to have a
- 8:23certification label on the back that you see
- 8:26in this photo, sorry, slide, that you see in
- 8:31this photo here. And this label is key. And so
- 8:36like the one that you see on the screen, the
- 8:40following language and information must be on
- 8:43there. So first, you need the manufacturer or
- 8:46the brand of the helmet. And then below that,
- 8:50it has to have the model of the helmet. Next
- 8:54is the letters DOT, must be on there, followed
- 8:58by the statute, which is FMVSS number 218. Finally,
- 9:04all caps certified. Every one of those needs
- 9:08to be on there for it to be considered a compliant
- 9:12motorcycle helmet. So if the helmet was made
- 9:16before May 13th, 2013, the law just requires
- 9:20that it read DOT and nothing else in order for
- 9:24it to be DOT compliant. As attorneys, it's critical
- 9:28to check the helmet yourself. So make sure you
- 9:32get the helmet. If you're going to take on a
- 9:33motorcycle accident case, make sure you get the
- 9:36helmet. Either have the client bring it or go
- 9:41pick it up. But it's a key piece of evidence
- 9:43that you need. And once you do get that helmet,
- 9:47you need to look at the sticker on the back and
- 9:50make sure all five of those things are on there.
- 9:53Now, if it's not DOT certified, then That's definitely
- 9:57something that the defense may use against your
- 10:00client. And we're going to get more into that
- 10:03in a few minutes. Here, I have a helmet. Let
- 10:09me see if you guys can see this. All right. So
- 10:15I'm not sure if you can see it. All right. As
- 10:17you see, first line is the manufacturer. Below
- 10:22that is the model. And then next you see the
- 10:29letters DOT, really big, followed by FMVSS number
- 10:34218, and the word certified. So this helmet is
- 10:41DOT compliant, and it does the trick. And you
- 10:44should feel how heavy it is if you've never felt
- 10:45a motorcycle helmet. All right. Now slide, please.
- 10:55Over the years, motorcycle helmets have undergone
- 10:58substantial improvements in terms of material,
- 11:01comfort, performance, and protection. Today's
- 11:05helmets have an outer shell, which is typically
- 11:08made from materials such as fiberglass or carbon
- 11:12fiber. And these materials provide durability
- 11:17and impact resistance. So tough that nothing
- 11:21sharp is able to penetrate the helmet. Inside
- 11:27of the helmet, it features padding made from
- 11:31a multi -density foam. And this is huge. It made
- 11:35a huge difference for the comfort of the riders.
- 11:38And this foam is designed to absorb impacts of
- 11:42varying severity and also to cushion the motorcycle
- 11:48rider's head. So The outer layer of the inside,
- 11:56I mean it's like layer after layer after layer,
- 11:58but the if we can change the slide Actually,
- 12:03sorry, can we go back on them? right So the the
- 12:09two layers inside each has its own significance
- 12:12the out outer layer is Created or is you know
- 12:18installed in there so that it can absorb the
- 12:21high energy impacts. And the inner layer of the
- 12:24inside protects against lower energy impacts.
- 12:29And this motorcycle drawing on here basically
- 12:35breaks it down like that. There's the outer shell,
- 12:39the impact absorbing liner. You have the padded
- 12:43comfort layer. the face shield or visor in California.
- 12:49It doesn't have to be attached to the helmet,
- 12:52but they do need to, riders do need to wear some
- 12:54sort of eye protection when they are riding a
- 12:57motorcycle. And then it also has the cheek pads.
- 13:02So there's the chin strap too, but we're gonna
- 13:05get to that in just a moment. So this padding
- 13:10is engineered to provide, again, maximum protection
- 13:14in the event of a high -speed crash. But comfort
- 13:17is very, very important. And you see that a lot
- 13:20that when I was doing research that comfort has
- 13:24always been one of the most important factors
- 13:25when creating these helmets. Basically, I'm assuming
- 13:30it's because if a rider is uncomfortable, they're
- 13:33less likely to wear the helmet. Again, the multi
- 13:38-density foam is considered one of the key innovations
- 13:41in modern helmet technology because it not only
- 13:46improves the overall safety of the helmet, but
- 13:49also increases the rider's chances of surviving
- 13:52a crash. But in all reality, a motorcycle helmet
- 13:57only works if it's the right fit, snug enough,
- 14:02and it is on securely. It's fast and securely.
- 14:06And these are both actually express requirements
- 14:09under California vehicle code section 27803,
- 14:14that first code section we looked at. So key,
- 14:18key, key, very important. The strap should be
- 14:21tight enough to keep the helmet in place, but
- 14:25not so tight that it causes discomfort. And so
- 14:28in addition to that, the helmet needs to sit
- 14:32level on the head. fit snugly. There can't be
- 14:36any gaps in between the head and the inside of
- 14:40the helmet. Also, no discomfort. We keep going
- 14:45back to that. And all of this is so that the
- 14:51helmet remains stable during movement. Because
- 14:54again, if there's gaps, if there's movements,
- 14:57then the protection is not 100 % there. Next
- 15:02slide, please. All right. Here's a little cartoon,
- 15:07funny, not funny, but that I found. And what
- 15:10you see here, you see there's a brain on the
- 15:13ground. And in the background, you see the ambulance,
- 15:16the motorcycle, and what appears to be the hand
- 15:19of probably the writer. And it says, you know,
- 15:23now that I'm out here thinking about it, maybe
- 15:25helmet laws are a good idea. I found that very
- 15:28amusing, and I wanted to share that with you.
- 15:31Next slide, please. I think it's pretty safe
- 15:38to say that motorcycle riders who don't wear
- 15:42helmets or who wear them incorrectly put themselves
- 15:46at a much higher risk of serious injury if they
- 15:49are in a crash. In the absence of a helmet or
- 15:53a properly worn helmet, the motorcycle rider
- 16:01is much more vulnerable to a range of injuries.
- 16:06take a genius to figure that out. So what are
- 16:08those most common injuries? Traumatic brain injury,
- 16:12first and foremost, what we normally just say
- 16:15TBI. This is one of the most common and serious
- 16:18injuries associated with motorcycle crashes.
- 16:21Just about every case that I've handled has had
- 16:25some kind of TBI, whether it's a mild TBI or
- 16:29a much more serious TBI involved. A lot of those
- 16:33patients did recover. Some, you know, some did
- 16:37not. So TBIs are, as many of you already know,
- 16:44they can change your life. I mean, personality,
- 16:47everything, because the brain functions. I mean,
- 16:49sorry, the brain is, you know, it is what we
- 16:53need for our bodies to function correctly. I'm
- 16:56sorry, for our bodies to, yeah, function correctly.
- 17:00So it's the brain. And we all get excited about
- 17:03those TBI cases when they come across our desk.
- 17:05So always look for a TBI, especially with motorcycle
- 17:09cases. So without the securely strapped and snug,
- 17:19properly fitted helmet, the percentage of injuries
- 17:25and death goes up. Unlike a vehicle accident,
- 17:31two cars, a motorcyclist doesn't have that shell,
- 17:35doesn't have that protectant, which is the car.
- 17:38Another reason why motorcycle riders need to
- 17:43be wearing helmets, they don't have that same
- 17:45protection. Research that was published by the
- 17:51NHTSA states showed that helmets reduce motorcycle
- 17:57fatalities by 22 to 40 % and death by 41 to 69%.
- 18:04So those are huge numbers. Again, remember TBIs
- 18:09can vary from a mild concussion. or a concussion,
- 18:13which we often refer to as an MTBI, all the way
- 18:16to long -term disabilities and pain. So in addition
- 18:22to head and brain injuries, motorcyclists who
- 18:25don't wear helmets, I'm skipping the skull, but
- 18:31I'm going to go to the spine injuries, there
- 18:33are much higher risk for neck and spine injuries.
- 18:38And of course, neck injuries can cause permanent
- 18:41paralysis or any other kind of long -term disability
- 18:47in pain. Back to the skull injury. The skull
- 18:53is really like an egg shell. It might feel not
- 18:56as thin, but it's as delicate. We often see fractures
- 19:01of the skull in motorcycle cases. This happens
- 19:09particularly when the rider is thrown off the
- 19:13motorcycle, which I don't think I've ever handled
- 19:15a motorcycle case where the client didn't go
- 19:17flying off their motorcycle. Where was I? Oh,
- 19:25yes. That skull, it's just as important as the
- 19:30brain because it surrounds the brain. Finally,
- 19:34we have Facial injuries and I've had quite a
- 19:39few of those the last one the client had a 17
- 19:43centimeter scar on his face and he was wearing
- 19:45the helmet the visor broke and cut his face,
- 19:49but Facial injuries can include broken bones
- 19:53nasal fractures and disfigurement again From
- 19:59any scar that they have they get as a result
- 20:01of the crash. So on top of producing, you know
- 20:05great physical pain, all of these things can
- 20:10have long -term effects on people's lives and
- 20:13their appearance and their quality of life. All
- 20:18right. Next slide, please. So what you're seeing
- 20:23in this slide here are collision photos from
- 20:26the very same case as the motorcycle helmet I
- 20:29showed you a few moments ago. We finished this
- 20:32case a couple of years ago. And there's no question,
- 20:37absolutely no question that our client's proper
- 20:40use of his helmet saved his life. I spared you
- 20:43guys the bloody photos, but what happened here
- 20:47was that our client was driving down the street.
- 20:51This Range Rover, she says that she stopped the
- 20:53stop sign, but I mean, it looks like she didn't.
- 20:58And so she just went going. She basically. was
- 21:02about to cut off our motorcyclist, but she went
- 21:05straight and he went right into her driver's
- 21:10side door. You see the shattered glass. I mean,
- 21:13you can't even tell like that's a car door if
- 21:15you take it off the car. And our client did go
- 21:19flying. In fact, you see his shoes in the photo
- 21:21in the left. He was wearing all stars. And so,
- 21:27It's I mean the first time I saw the photos I'm
- 21:29like, how is this guy alive? But he is and again
- 21:32that his motorcycle helmet Absolutely saved his
- 21:35life He did end up having among other injuries
- 21:40a MTBI a mild TBI and some fractured nasal bones,
- 21:46but At the end of the day, that's nothing compared
- 21:50to what could have happened without the helmet
- 21:52I would I doubt that he would have survived without
- 21:55the helmet but Next slide, please. All right,
- 22:04motorcycle helmets in the context of personal
- 22:06injury cases, which is why we're all here. So
- 22:11helmets, again, are not just life -saving devices
- 22:14that reduce the severity of injuries and so on,
- 22:19but they also play a critical role in personal
- 22:22injury claims that the or the personal injury
- 22:27claim that the rider is potentially going to
- 22:30file. So this is why, as plaintiff's attorneys,
- 22:35it's so, so, so important for us to understand
- 22:38the pivotal role of helmets in these kinds of
- 22:41PI cases. And whether or not there's a helmet
- 22:46really can affect whether or not you take a case.
- 22:50We'll talk about that in a second too. What we
- 22:54need to remember is that the helmet also ensures
- 22:59a much better result. You want the best compensation
- 23:06because obviously the more the client gets, the
- 23:07more you get. But it makes a huge, huge, huge,
- 23:11huge difference. And I've seen people take cases
- 23:15where there was no motorcycle, sorry, no motorcycle
- 23:19helmet and there were no other injuries other
- 23:22than a TBI, and it didn't go well for them. I
- 23:28mean, they got some money, but I saw how hard
- 23:32that attorney worked on that case. And to me,
- 23:36it wouldn't have been worth it to take the case
- 23:38and put in all that time and effort because really,
- 23:41they got peanuts. There was no motorcycle, so
- 23:44that's strike one, not good. California is a
- 23:55pure comparative vault state. So what does that
- 24:01mean? That means that if you can prove that the
- 24:06plaintiff was negligent in not wearing the helmet
- 24:09and that their negligence was a substantial factor
- 24:14in causing their harm, then their damages are
- 24:17going to be reduced. There's no doubt about that.
- 24:22I've never seen otherwise, to be honest. Next
- 24:26slide, please. Okay, so in this silly picture,
- 24:34what you see is to the left, it shows someone
- 24:38who is wearing a helmet, but obviously not. properly.
- 24:42And next to the photo, you also see a very small
- 24:47stack of $1 bills. Well, basically what that
- 24:50means is that you don't wear a helmet, you don't
- 24:52wear it correctly, then again, like I said earlier,
- 24:55you're going to get peanuts. And not wearing
- 25:02a helmet is not going to throw out the whole
- 25:05case, of course. There could be other injuries.
- 25:08to have their compensation significantly reduced,
- 25:13that's our concern here. You don't want to be
- 25:16in that position. So I want you to remember,
- 25:25I'm not saying don't take a case if there was
- 25:27no... the rider wasn't wearing a motorcycle.
- 25:30No, because they could have, you know, I've had
- 25:32a case where an arm was severed, it was basically
- 25:35hanging and that had nothing to do with the,
- 25:37with him not wearing, our client not wearing
- 25:39a helmet. So of course you had, you know, very
- 25:43good case for this partially severed arm. It's
- 25:47only in the cases where there is no helmet or
- 25:51there was an improperly worn helmet and the only
- 25:53injuries are, you know, to the brain or the face
- 25:57or the head. Next slide, please. All right. There
- 26:05are some essential helmet questions to ask at
- 26:08intake, and you wouldn't be doing yourself justice
- 26:11if you don't ask these four simple questions.
- 26:16Let's say you get a call from a potential client
- 26:18who claims that they suffered a head or brain
- 26:22injury as a result of a motorcycle accident.
- 26:26As a plaintiff's attorney though, you got to
- 26:29make sure to ask these questions before deciding
- 26:31whether or not to sign up the client. The first
- 26:33question is, you want to ask them whether they
- 26:36were wearing a helmet at the time of the crash.
- 26:39I've never had anyone lie to me and say, you
- 26:42know, they weren't wearing a helmet or they were
- 26:44wearing a helmet when they weren't. I mean, they
- 26:46I've gone lucky because there are the clients
- 26:49were like, I had an helmet. I don't know where
- 26:50it went. No, I swear up and down. I was wearing
- 26:52a helmet. But later on, someone took that case.
- 27:00And what happened? I think there was surveillance
- 27:01video, like clear surveillance video doing no
- 27:04helmet. So the client was a liar. Now, if the
- 27:09answer is no, if there was no helmet worn or
- 27:12if they admit that they didn't have the strap
- 27:14on or it was too big and it was wobbly, then
- 27:18you really need to pause for a moment. Do yourself
- 27:22a favor, pause, don't get all excited. You hear,
- 27:25oh, brain injury. And think about whether the
- 27:28case is viable. Because if the case is just limited
- 27:32to head injuries, brain injuries, facial lacerations
- 27:37or broken bones then chances are that and there's
- 27:43no other significant injuries like a broken leg
- 27:45fractured femur or you know internal trauma then
- 27:48chances are that uh you are not going to get
- 27:52the compensation the client would have gotten
- 27:54if they were wearing a helmet so but if they
- 27:58answer yes so yes there was a helmet good check
- 28:02one then you want to know if the helmet is available
- 28:07for inspection. So you got to make sure that
- 28:10after client, okay, you're wearing a helmet or
- 28:12the potential client. Where is it? Where is it
- 28:14now? And if the answer is no, it's not available
- 28:21for inspection, then there's multiple arguments
- 28:25that defense can make to either try to... not
- 28:32so much deny liability, but to lower the value
- 28:36of your claim. And so first there's the spoiliation,
- 28:39destruction of evidence argument. Here, the defense
- 28:42may claim that the missing helmet constitutes
- 28:45destruction or loss of key physical evidence.
- 28:50And they're going to say, this is stopping us
- 28:52from, now we're not able to evaluate the helmet
- 28:55to determine, for example, whether it was DOT
- 28:57certified. Because how do you prove that without
- 29:00a helmet? Sorry. And so they want to argue, they're
- 29:08going to go for that. of evidence. I've seen
- 29:13it with other cases of colleagues and they try
- 29:17to take that and run with it. If you're going
- 29:20to take a case with no helmet, you need to be
- 29:22prepared for that. Comparative fault. The defense
- 29:25may also assert that because the helmet is missing,
- 29:30then plaintiff can't prove that it was DOT certified
- 29:33or that it was even being used at the time of
- 29:38the crash. Therefore, they're going to say it
- 29:40was plaintiff's own negligence and failing to
- 29:46wear a helmet, a DOT certified helmet that contributed
- 29:51to some or all of their injuries. In such a situation,
- 29:55you need to make sure you line up testimony if
- 29:59you are going to take the case. from plaintiff,
- 30:04any witnesses to the crash and any first responders
- 30:07who first on the scene of the crash to that confirms
- 30:12that there was a helmet and it was being used.
- 30:16You know, the first responders can attest to
- 30:19the fact that there was a helmet. There was a
- 30:21helmet at the scene. We don't know what happened
- 30:23to it or that there was or that well. got to
- 30:29make sure before you call the first responder
- 30:31that there really was a helmet. But they need
- 30:35to show that you also want to get eyewitness
- 30:38testimony. Someone might have been standing on
- 30:41the corner of the street as the potential client
- 30:43got struck and they saw. the helmet. And so you
- 30:49also, another thing that's key that you want
- 30:52to line up here is you got to make sure to gather
- 30:56medical records that showing that the nature
- 30:59of the injuries is consistent with helmet use.
- 31:04You know, if the client suffers a concussion,
- 31:09then they must, and they, you know, It was very
- 31:11similar to the case I showed you, and they went
- 31:13head first, then they must have been wearing
- 31:15a helmet because without a helmet, you have much
- 31:18more than a concussion if you end up inside the
- 31:22window of the vehicle that hit you. So with those
- 31:28medical records, one thing you can do is tie
- 31:31this evidence and tie directly to your contention
- 31:39that, listen, medical records equal helmet. And
- 31:44so you've got to get those records. You've got
- 31:46to get them soon. We all lack sometimes with
- 31:49records. But I mean, obviously, we know there
- 31:51could be other damning information in there.
- 31:53But you really want to be prepared for these
- 31:57defenses. And one of them is, again, you need
- 32:00to get the records to see if, OK, all right,
- 32:03yeah, you know. First of all, there's a mention
- 32:05of a helmet, but yeah, this is consistent. This
- 32:08kind of injury is consistent with helmet use.
- 32:12Finally, you want to point to California's pure
- 32:16comparative fault rule. And so you want to emphasize
- 32:20that, okay, yes, damages are reduced, but the
- 32:26client's not barred from collecting. And that's
- 32:27the truth. No helmet doesn't mean no money. don't
- 32:31let them try to tell you that. And again, I've
- 32:35seen it with colleagues cases where the defense
- 32:37just tries to take that and run with it. But
- 32:40the truth is the law doesn't say that if you're
- 32:42not wearing a helmet, you don't get any money.
- 32:44Unlike, you know, Prop 213, you don't have auto
- 32:47insurance, then you don't get general damages.
- 32:50It just says that it's reduced. And so you want
- 32:53to focus on, if they make that argument, you
- 32:55want to focus on at the end of the day, it was
- 32:57the defendant's, you know, negligent conduct
- 33:00that put our client in a situation that caused
- 33:03the injuries. Next is the causation of injuries.
- 33:11I've seen this also. Defense experts might say
- 33:15that without the helmet, they can't verify whether
- 33:19specific injuries such as head trauma or facial
- 33:23fractures would have been prevented or mitigated,
- 33:26that these defense experts, you know, love to
- 33:28take something and just harp on it. And so, as
- 33:32a part of their evidence, they can go as far
- 33:35as, in support of their position, they can go
- 33:39as far as retaining biomechanical experts to
- 33:42speculate about, you know, alternative scenarios.
- 33:46And so, be aware, be aware, be aware if you're
- 33:50going to take that case. If they do hire an expert,
- 33:54like a biomechanical expert, to speculate or
- 33:58try to show alternative scenarios, of course
- 34:01you need to retain your own expert who's going
- 34:03to point to the medical records, point to the
- 34:06witness statements, and point to scene evidence
- 34:11consistent with helmet use and head protection.
- 34:14So you might, at the scene, No, first responders
- 34:20might not have seen a helmet, right? But there's
- 34:23the piece of glass, which is the visor, which
- 34:26is the cover that protects your eyes with the
- 34:30helmet. And so that in and of itself is an example
- 34:33of evidence at the scene that points to helmet
- 34:35use. You have to make sure that you read every
- 34:41line of that police report to see if there is
- 34:43any evidence that would help support your position.
- 34:47The client was wearing, even though we don't
- 34:49have it, the client was wearing a helmet. And
- 34:53then, of course, credibility and reliability.
- 34:56They're going to attack your client's credibility
- 35:00if they say that there's a helmet, but I don't
- 35:06know what happened to it. Here's the thing. The
- 35:08defense may argue that the plaintiff's account
- 35:13of the existence of the helmet is self -serving
- 35:17and it's unreliable and there's no reason that
- 35:19any jury should believe them and so here you
- 35:22need to make sure that you bolster the credit
- 35:25uh the plaintiff's credibility with corroborating
- 35:27again witness um statements uh and these witnesses
- 35:32these for these are the witnesses of the scene
- 35:35but there's also witnesses who can be you know
- 35:39writing partners maybe they weren't that there
- 35:41that day but you know they can testify that we
- 35:45always wear helmets. Anytime I've seen them,
- 35:48I don't remember a single time that Joshua was
- 35:51not wearing a helmet. There's also family and
- 35:56friends who can attest to this. It doesn't harm,
- 36:01it helps. But if you have a sales receipt, that
- 36:06says that, you know, like a year before, whatever,
- 36:09they bought a helmet. Again, it doesn't prove
- 36:11that they were wearing it or wearing it properly,
- 36:13but at least there's some existence, you know,
- 36:15sign of a helmet. Photos, you know, collect photos
- 36:20from When the client had gone writing in previous
- 36:26times, social media, that's big. If you have
- 36:29a client who is a avid bike rider and they like
- 36:33to post, there's going to be photos on there
- 36:35from the past that show that they always had
- 36:37their helmet on or they had their helmet with
- 36:40them. This is all trying to establish the fact
- 36:43that there was a helmet, just don't know where
- 36:45it is right now. So if your answer to the second
- 36:49question, so once again, the question was whether
- 36:51the helmet is available for inspection. If your
- 36:54answer is yes, if it's no, sorry, if it's no,
- 36:58then you need to really think about whether you
- 37:03wanna take the case. But if it's yes, okay, that's
- 37:07great. So we... have a helmet, the helmet was
- 37:14worn, it's, you know, available for, it's available
- 37:20for inspection. Next, you want to know, next
- 37:26slide, please. If the helmet was DOT certified,
- 37:34okay. We're back to that certification. That
- 37:37sticker here is key. Now, you want to make sure
- 37:43that the helmet complied with FMVSS 218. The
- 37:48best way to do this is to have the potential
- 37:51client bring you the helmet. I've gone to pick
- 37:54up the helmet myself in more cases than I've
- 37:56had the client bring the helmet because the injuries
- 37:59were so serious. But I made sure that within
- 38:0224, 48 hours, because every minute something
- 38:05can happen, I have possession of that helmet
- 38:08and I take a look at it. You need to take a look
- 38:11at it yourself. I mean, it's five different things
- 38:13that you're looking for. So this is no time to
- 38:15be lazy. You want to get your hands on that helmet
- 38:18and look for the certification. Again, if it's
- 38:26not DOT certified, you're going to have to be
- 38:28prepared again for that comparative fault argument
- 38:30that the defense is going to bring. Now, if your
- 38:34answer is Yes, then the next question is whether
- 38:39the potential client was properly wearing the
- 38:42helmet, okay? We go back to those two things
- 38:45that I've mentioned earlier. One is did they
- 38:47have the helmet strap? Fastened Helmet is no
- 38:52good if it's not fast and it's going to come
- 38:54off your head. It's kind of go flying off your
- 38:56head, you know upon impact Also, you want to
- 39:00ask the client did the helmet securely fit their
- 39:02head now? If your client is a petite woman who
- 39:08was borrowing one of her husband's helmets and
- 39:13her husband is a huge guy weighing like 250 pounds,
- 39:17that helmet is not going to be snug on her head.
- 39:19I mean, let's be real. So she was wearing a helmet,
- 39:23but it wasn't going to do its job. And it's clear
- 39:28because the helmet, you can... push it around,
- 39:32tilt it, and it needs to fit snug, for those
- 39:36of you who have never seen a helmet or seen anyone
- 39:39wear a helmet. But many of you, I'm sure, have
- 39:41noticed that when people come to take off, riders
- 39:44come to take off their helmets, they really have
- 39:46to lift that thing. Now, if the answers to those
- 39:50questions are no, then, again, do yourself a
- 39:54favor. Don't move forward on this case without
- 39:58really determining whether the case is viable
- 40:02or not. Our time is money. We work on contingency.
- 40:06Why would you take on a case where the client
- 40:10either was not wearing a helmet or was wearing
- 40:16it improperly and there's no other injuries,
- 40:22no broken arm, no... severed leg or anything.
- 40:29These are very, very, very important questions
- 40:32to ask. Are there any questions that I can answer
- 40:37right now? Not at this time. Okay, perfect. Okay,
- 40:41good. All right. Now if we can go to the next
- 40:46slide. Okay. best practices for handling a motorcycle
- 40:53injury claim. If you're going to remember anything,
- 40:55you need to, before you sign up a motorcycle
- 40:59case, just remember these four things. You got
- 41:01to confirm the helmet type. You want to make
- 41:05sure it's DOT certified and you want to do this
- 41:08early on. Don't wait to get that helmet. That's
- 41:11a huge mistake. As all of you as attorneys know,
- 41:14Evidence gets lost. Chain of custody can become
- 41:17an issue, which takes me to the next one. Preserve
- 41:20the helmet as evidence. Do yourself a favor,
- 41:24preserve the helmet. I have a few helmets here
- 41:27that after the case was over, the client didn't
- 41:29want them, but I made sure they were in my office
- 41:32because defense attorneys do want to see the
- 41:35helmet. We all know they're in the business of
- 41:38not paying, and so any excuse not to pay. You
- 41:41need to, need to, need to. uh, anticipate the
- 41:44defense, the defense's arguments on helmet use.
- 41:48Again, we said those defenses could be, you know,
- 41:52spoliation or destruction of the evidence, um,
- 41:56comparative fault, causation of injuries, and
- 41:59credibility. You need to be ready for all that.
- 42:02You need to, I mean, you all know, be 10 steps
- 42:04ahead of defense counsel. Very important here
- 42:08is the fact that you need to frame your arguments
- 42:11around causation, right? A lot of attorneys,
- 42:13you know, get all caught up in, oh, you know,
- 42:18but they were, oh, no, like, you know, there's
- 42:21no helmet or we can't find it or whatever. Listen,
- 42:24the case is not completely dead. If they argue,
- 42:27you know, comparative faults, then you need to...
- 42:31make sure that in your demand, in your phone
- 42:35calls, whatever it is in your mediation brief,
- 42:38to separate the cause of the crash from the severity
- 42:42of the injuries. Those are two completely different
- 42:44things, and they should be treated differently.
- 42:47Because you want to make it clear that while
- 42:50helmet use might have affected the extent of
- 42:53the injuries, the cause, the cause here. which
- 42:57is the defendant's negligence, remains the same.
- 43:00Not wearing a helmet doesn't change the fact
- 43:02that with the case I showed you guys, the driver
- 43:07didn't stop at the stop sign. She was still negligent.
- 43:10So don't let them dictate the narrative. You
- 43:13got to make sure that you have this distinction
- 43:15and that it's clear and that the defense knows
- 43:19that you're not going to be a pushover and you're
- 43:22going to fight this and be like, that's fine,
- 43:24yes. Some negligence by not wearing a helmet
- 43:27by the end of the day It was the defendant's
- 43:31conduct that caused the injuries Something back
- 43:36to us. So let me see. All right. Yeah back to
- 43:41comparative fault so Again, you need to remember
- 43:45that comparative pure comparative fault doesn't
- 43:48mean okay. They were at fault then no money there
- 43:54compensation, their award, um, will be reduced
- 43:58by the percent that the jury, for example, finds
- 44:04that the defendant was, I'm sorry, the plaintiff
- 44:06was negligent. So if the jury, you know, decides,
- 44:09um, that, and a great place to find information
- 44:13on this is in the, uh, Cassie, I always pronounce
- 44:18her wrong, Cass or Casey, the, the, basically
- 44:20the civil Judicial counsel jury rules that that's
- 44:25a great, great, great source to look at when
- 44:29you are trying to figure out, well, OK, you know,
- 44:33comparative faults. How much should I be afraid?
- 44:35Like what's important? What's not? That's a that's
- 44:41jury rule jury instruction, sorry, number four
- 44:45or five, and it was on on slide 13. And I understand
- 44:48that you guys all have the slides, so. All defendant
- 44:54needs to prove is that the plaintiff was negligent
- 44:56and that that negligence was a substantial factor.
- 44:58And then it goes to the jury and you don't want
- 45:01the jury to come back and say, okay, your client
- 45:04was 90 % at fault. I mean, that's really bad.
- 45:08I've never seen that. But this percentage is
- 45:14key, again. Just because they're comparative
- 45:17comparatively at fault doesn't mean that they
- 45:21get zero. It's just a reduction in their In their
- 45:26compensation. So if for example, the jury comes
- 45:29back with a million dollar verdict But they decide
- 45:33that you know, the plaintiff by not wearing a
- 45:36helmet was 30 % at fault then Three hundred thousand
- 45:42dollars gets knocked off of the hundred dollar
- 45:45um jury award excuse me hundred thousand dollars
- 45:48sorry one million dollar jury award so uh look
- 45:54at that do yourself a favor i mean you should
- 45:56always be looking at jury instructions when you
- 45:59sign up a case uh but especially when you're
- 46:01going to file the lawsuit but this is a very
- 46:03important one to keep handy uh this rule or instruction
- 46:08number 405 uh this Are there any questions? Yeah,
- 46:18we do have questions. Okay, I mean, next slide
- 46:21please. Questions, go ahead. All right, can you
- 46:28one second while I look them over? So let's see,
- 46:35given advances in helmet safety technology, do
- 46:38courts recognize the distinctions between older
- 46:40helmets, and modern designs when evaluating liability
- 46:45or damages. So at the end of the day, the helmet
- 46:50needs to be DOT certified. If I'm understanding
- 46:53the question correctly, so we have the ones that
- 46:56have all five levels of certification. That's
- 47:02for helmets that are after May of 2013 or on
- 47:06or after manufactured on or after May 2013. But
- 47:11if it's an older one, at a minimum, it needs
- 47:13to have the DOT. Am I answering the question?
- 47:16Is that what the question was? Yes. I think they
- 47:18were talking about what you said, the 2013, the
- 47:22five standards after that, but then the helmets
- 47:24prior to 2013 where it was just DOT, if there
- 47:27was a difference between how they evaluate based
- 47:31on that. No, no. It's treated just the same as
- 47:34if it was. you know on or after may 13th it still
- 47:38needs to have it just the only difference is
- 47:40that um it doesn't go one by one at the end of
- 47:45the day the old helmet needs to be dot certified
- 47:48too it needs to be on snug it needs to be strapped
- 47:52you know all those other things of course assuming
- 47:54i understand what you're saying that need to
- 47:56be there all right uh let's see let me know if
- 48:01i didn't answer the question So, let's see. What
- 48:07are the best practices for preserving and presenting
- 48:11a helmet as evidence to maximize its impact with
- 48:13the jury? So, you know, there's a specific company
- 48:17I'm on. I mean, I don't want to make it sound
- 48:19like I'm plugging. So, but there is this one
- 48:22company that our firm and other very reputable
- 48:26law firms use where they have the bike stored
- 48:30and, you know, you could have them keep the Helmet
- 48:35as well. So the best practice is to so that there's
- 48:37no chain of custody issue really is to have A
- 48:40third neutral third party in this case. It's
- 48:42the storage the bike storage facility keep the
- 48:46helmet Right and then Our juror is more persuaded
- 48:53by physical inspection of the helmet in court
- 48:56or by expert analysis such as photos and testing
- 48:59I Mean at the end of day Juries want to see things
- 49:04for themselves. I've never seen a juror who fell
- 49:08in love with an expert because their testimony
- 49:10was so fun and enjoyable. It makes a lot more
- 49:13sense to bring it in yourself, but just show
- 49:17them that it depends on what the expert's argument
- 49:19is, but do both. Don't try to replace an expert.
- 49:23Don't not hire an expert because you have the
- 49:25helmet. You need to see where the defense is
- 49:29going with their arguments and then decide. One's
- 49:33not a substitute for the other, the helmet in
- 49:36court versus the expert testimony. And then this
- 49:43is somewhat related in regards to experts. In
- 49:48your experience, do jurors understand helmet
- 49:50certifications, such as the DOT, or is expert
- 49:54simplification essential? Isn't that kind of
- 49:58the same question? It was from a different attendee.
- 50:02I figured it was. Maybe I've gotten lucky. Every
- 50:08single one of my motorcycle cases settled before
- 50:12we went to trial. A couple of them were on the
- 50:17eve of trial, but they never made it to court.
- 50:22I don't know how the juries would have reacted.
- 50:27That's a, that's a, you know, good question.
- 50:34Sorry. So to me, it sounds like the question
- 50:37from before, just like the question from before,
- 50:38because it's asking, you know, would the jury
- 50:44rather see the helmet than listen to the expert?
- 50:47And I mean, you can do both. Are you ready for
- 50:54the next question? Oh, yes. So this attendee
- 50:58is asking, what about plaintiff operating motorcycle
- 51:01without a license and let's say it's a rear end
- 51:03accident. Maybe they could elaborate on that
- 51:06question a little bit more. Do you understand
- 51:08what they were trying to ask? So I think I know
- 51:13what they're asking. Is the license just as important
- 51:17as the helmet? I mean, we've all. I've handled
- 51:20quite a few cases where my client didn't have
- 51:22a driver's license, because in all reality, the
- 51:25insurance matters more than the license. But
- 51:27I wouldn't pass on a case just because the client
- 51:29didn't have a driver's license or motorcycle
- 51:32license. And the fact that it was a rear end
- 51:34makes no difference, whether it was a T -bone
- 51:36or a rear end. Lack of a driver's license is
- 51:41not as detrimental to the case as lack of a helmet
- 51:46would be. Great. Let's see. So that about wraps
- 51:59up questions for now. Do you have any parting
- 52:00advice for our attendees? Yes, of course. All
- 52:03right. So if you've never handled a motorcycle
- 52:07case before, ask for help. Because although a
- 52:12lot of these PI cases seem to... basically be
- 52:16the same checklist. Motorcycle cases are different.
- 52:20So ask for help. I mean, at the end of, actually,
- 52:24if we could go to the final slide, you'll find
- 52:27my information. I'm more than happy to answer
- 52:29questions because do your client justice. If
- 52:34you don't know something, do the research, ask
- 52:36questions. And I know a lot of attorneys who
- 52:41would happily help, especially the younger attorneys,
- 52:45figure out if it's a good case or if it's one
- 52:48that they should pass on. So ask for help. Another
- 52:51piece of advice that I would give is these cases,
- 52:55you need to make sure every client needs to be
- 52:58credible. Credibility is big. But with these
- 53:01motorcycle cases, especially when it comes down
- 53:04to the helmet, you got to make sure that the
- 53:06client is telling the truth. Meet with them in
- 53:10person. You want to see how credible they are.
- 53:13And that should make a difference, again, with
- 53:15any case. Because the last thing you want is
- 53:17to go in front of a jury and have your client
- 53:21come across as not credible. That's hugely detrimental
- 53:25also. Some more parting advice. Let's see, with
- 53:30these cases. I can't think of anything else.
- 53:35I think I've covered everything. If we could
- 53:39talk about the medicine for a second, the four
- 53:43different kinds of medical consequences that
- 53:46I discussed earlier, with any PI case, it helps
- 53:52to understand the medicine. You got to ask the
- 53:57clients the questions like, when you were hit,
- 54:01first of all, did you go flying off the bike?
- 54:04But what part of your... Did your helmet hit
- 54:07the ground? Did it hit an object? What part of
- 54:09your head? These are all very important questions,
- 54:12especially if you're trying to establish whether
- 54:14there was a TBI injury. You got to ask these
- 54:22detailed questions about the side of your head,
- 54:26the top of your head. Again, those are important
- 54:30questions. I know we have six more minutes. So
- 54:39let me see. Let's see. Let me check and see if
- 54:50we have any additional questions as well. Can
- 54:56we take a poll or we can't do that? We could
- 55:00take a poll. What would you like? I'm just curious,
- 55:03how many people have handled a motorcycle accident
- 55:06case in the past? All right. One second, please.
- 55:32A poll is now live. Please input your answers
- 55:36into the poll. All right. I'm going to end the
- 55:51poll now. It looks like we have a 50 -50 split.
- 55:56Oh, wow. It does look like that. Okay. Well,
- 55:59that's good. And I'm not sure how many people
- 56:01are in attendance. So OK, that's great. That's
- 56:08a lot. I mean, there are amazing cases after
- 56:13wrongful death. This sounds horrible, but those
- 56:15are my favorites. But motorcycle cases are truly,
- 56:18I haven't had a single case that... wasn't fun
- 56:22because there's always different things that
- 56:23come up and that wasn't lucrative. This case
- 56:26ended up settling pre -lits. I just sent a demand,
- 56:29a very good demand, but for the limits of $2
- 56:34.5 million. They assigned defense counsel to
- 56:37the case, even though we hadn't filed, and actually
- 56:40had him call me and compliment me on my demand.
- 56:45These demands are really big too. Of course,
- 56:47as attorneys, if we have to go to trial, we'll
- 56:49go to trial. it only makes sense to if you can
- 56:54settle the case before litigation make your client
- 56:58gets more money and you know you can move on
- 57:00to the next case and so it only makes sense that
- 57:04you sorry uh that you i just totally lost my
- 57:10train of thought what was i talking about I am
- 57:16so sorry. You weren't listening either. I do
- 57:18have a question that we could end on. Do you
- 57:22anticipate any changes in helmet law or safety
- 57:25standards, such as smart helmets, influencing
- 57:29the way future cases are litigated? You cut out
- 57:34for one second. Can you say that one more time?
- 57:36Do you anticipate changes in helmet law or safety
- 57:39standards influencing the way future cases are
- 57:43litigated? No, I don't really anticipate I can't
- 57:48see how California would get even more strict
- 57:50than this but no I don't anticipate I haven't
- 57:54heard of anything. I don't anticipate anything
- 57:56Of course, you know, there's always Rules are
- 58:03changed all the time, but I don't see anything
- 58:05anything happening Well, I believe that about
- 58:10wraps up the Q &A. Thank you so much for your
- 58:13time today and presenting on this topic, and
- 58:15I hope our attendees enjoy the rest of their
- 58:16afternoon. Thank you, everyone.