Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Introducing Bitcoin for Businesses: The Supercycle Catalyst
Transcript
- 0:00All right, welcome to the world premiere, episode 1 of the
- 0:03Bitcoin for Businesses podcast. Move over cartoons because we've
- 0:07got your favorite Saturday morning show right here.
- 0:10So TuneIn each week as this amazing cast that I'm about to
- 0:12introduce covers the week's breaking news in Bitcoin and
- 0:15business. And the whole goal here is for
- 0:18us to help guide operators through bitcoins adoption as a
- 0:22core savings technology for your corporate treasury.
- 0:25So we're going to be covering breaking news best practices and
- 0:29most importantly, why this disruptive asset class presents
- 0:32an asymmetric opportunity for those of you listening to the
- 0:35podcast that are in the know. So introducing our Co host and
- 0:40then I know Michael here is going to want to say a few more
- 0:43words about the the purpose of this podcast, but Michael
- 0:46Tanguma here is the founder and CEO at Onramp, which is a
- 0:50Bitcoin asset management platform built on multi
- 0:53institution custody. He's also a partner at Early
- 0:56Riders, a Bitcoin denominated venture firm.
- 0:58Liam Neeson or sorry, not Liam Neeson, but that's kind of
- 1:02funny. Liam Nelson is also a partner at
- 1:05Early Riders and has a background in private equity and
- 1:09Matt Ball has been contributing to the Bitcoin space for years
- 1:12and recently went full time into Bitcoin, joining as head of
- 1:16design at Onramp and head of product at my company Acropolis.
- 1:20I'm your host, Chase Palmieri and I'm the Co founder and CEO
- 1:23at Acropolis, which is a sister company to Onramp and one of the
- 1:27funded portfolio companies of Early Riders.
- 1:29And Acropolis is pioneering the world's first Bitcoin treasury
- 1:33platform built on multi institution custody.
- 1:36Guys, great to have you in here for episode 1.
- 1:39And and Michael, I know you wanted to say a little bit more.
- 1:43Well, I just had first up to say mic drop because Chase, if that
- 1:47opening was indicative of your hosting skills, you're going to
- 1:50absolutely crush this and excited to be here.
- 1:52Also excited for a Saturday morning RIP.
- 1:54I used to listen to use go on with Ippolito from Blockworks
- 1:58and it was always a nice one, especially in the summers when
- 2:00it's a little quiet. But yeah, as Chase alluded to, I
- 2:03think where I'm really excited about this and I think us as a
- 2:05group really stems from 2 functions. 1 is my previous
- 2:09Royal Building Unchained. I really felt the pain and the
- 2:14gap in the market for serious businesses that were allocating
- 2:17to BTC that knew they needed to get their keys off of an
- 2:19exchange, but they ultimately couldn't get their board, their
- 2:22shareholders in a fiduciary, anybody managing other people's
- 2:25capital comfortable with private key EC phrases and everything
- 2:28under the sun. And that's really where multi
- 2:30institution really stem from the start was just the reality that
- 2:33there was a need in the market and then naturally owner have
- 2:36stepped in and then obviously Acropolis is filling the gap on
- 2:39the corporate and you know, SMB side of things.
- 2:42So that's really the excitement part, but also around the notion
- 2:46that there's a lack of, we know enterprises and businesses are
- 2:49adopting Bitcoin at a feverish pace, but around the
- 2:52implementation and best practices just aren't being
- 2:55discussed. You hear a lot of concepts
- 2:57across the board we'll be talking about week after week.
- 3:00So that's kind of like on the the genesis of a lot of this.
- 3:02But the other side of it is really rooted in pragmatism is
- 3:05businesses of all shapes and sizes are suffering from
- 3:08inflation. I'm sure Chase, you talked about
- 3:11this before, but your family, you know, working in the service
- 3:14industry and I'm sure they see it.
- 3:15You know, when you think about my wife's in the hospitality
- 3:17industry and they see the inputs and outputs of inflation, they
- 3:20really impact every business from individuals all the way to
- 3:23the biggest businesses. And every business will
- 3:26ultimately need Bitcoin if they're going to survive in this
- 3:28future world where inflation runs rampant or increases.
- 3:31And so it's just a paramount focus for the market to grow,
- 3:36but education, good services to be able to be distributed and
- 3:39discussed. And it's kind of a crazy thing
- 3:41because just how multi institutions, while that it
- 3:43didn't exist and we're the ones that, you know, really pioneer
- 3:45it very similarly. It's kind of weird that there's
- 3:47not a Bitcoin for businesses podcast.
- 3:49And so naturally, what I found in being in Bitcoin for the time
- 3:52I have is if you have a good idea, it's usually probably a
- 3:54really good idea and you should act on it.
- 3:56And so really excited for us to be here and every and everyone
- 4:00else to join from this group to commit the time, but then also
- 4:03the listeners and hopefully you can like subscribe, share and
- 4:07TuneIn. We'll do it bi weekly to start,
- 4:09but depending on how much interest there is, maybe we'll
- 4:11we'll shift to weekly and you know, extend ourselves even
- 4:14further in this whole ecosystem. Yeah, and Liam, did you want to
- 4:17say a couple words? Just say hello to everybody,
- 4:20introduce yourself, maybe a touch more.
- 4:22Yes, super excited to be here. Thanks again for having us.
- 4:24I think we're in really early stages and there are a lot of
- 4:28people who are on both sides of things who think that everybody
- 4:32needs to go 100% in on Bitcoin and you know, just try to kill
- 4:35Fiat as fast as possible. And that should be the sole
- 4:38focus of their business. As well as on the other side,
- 4:40there is the idea that people should have no I no Bitcoin
- 4:46exposure at all or not even be thinking about it from a
- 4:48business perspective. And the reality is honestly
- 4:51somewhere in the middle where people need to actually run a
- 4:55successful business. Otherwise they should just shut
- 4:57it down and, you know, buy Bitcoin with it.
- 4:59But the reality is Bitcoin is 1 tool and a massive tool kit that
- 5:04a businesses really have in order to create better outcomes
- 5:07for themselves. And that's kind of what we're
- 5:09here to talk about week in and week out.
- 5:12Yeah. And it's not an easy tool to
- 5:14know how it fits into HR versus treasury and all the different
- 5:18kind of functions in a company and that you've been working
- 5:21full time in Bitcoin now and you've been behind the scenes
- 5:24with a lot of interesting Bitcoin projects, but full time
- 5:26now for like a week. How are you doing?
- 5:29Doing well, it's a it's a blessing to be able to work with
- 5:32with this team and super excited to to be on this pod and kind of
- 5:36cut through some of the noise in the in the sort of Bitcoin for
- 5:40business space right now and kind of deliver that signal.
- 5:42So I think it's a great opportunity and really excited
- 5:44to to RIP with you guys bi weekly for the foreseeable
- 5:47future. All right, great.
- 5:49The pleasantries are out of the way.
- 5:51Let's get into the signal. I'll go ahead and kick things
- 5:54off with one of the topics that I brought to the show today,
- 5:58which is the fact that this week LED in got rid of all of their
- 6:02crypto backed loans and decided that they're going to focus on
- 6:05Bitcoin only loans to date. They're not.
- 6:09Their book was already 98% Bitcoin.
- 6:12You can imagine that as Bitcoin becomes, you know, greater
- 6:16market share in the crypto space in general, this was kind of
- 6:19always going to be the path that the asset class went down.
- 6:22It was always going to make up the majority of capital for any
- 6:25of these projects, platforms, exchanges that do crypto plus
- 6:29Bitcoin. But really interesting to see a
- 6:31company that has been dabbling in ETH backed loans and other
- 6:35crypto backed loans kind of pull back and say, no, you know what,
- 6:38our clientele wants us to be focused on Bitcoin only.
- 6:42It's a simpler business to execute on when we can focus on
- 6:44just one asset class. And and so it's 898% of our
- 6:49books anyway. And so they've gone exclusively
- 6:52to Bitcoin only. I'm curious, Michael, do you
- 6:54think that this is something that we're going to see a lot of
- 6:57other companies that have kind of dabbled in crypto more
- 7:00broadly pull back and get back to Bitcoin only roots?
- 7:03Or is this maybe a one off because of the lending space and
- 7:06the nuances there? Yeah, I think it's a it's a
- 7:09great question and kind of a symptom of time in the market
- 7:12because historically and it's still the case, it's very hard
- 7:15to raise capital from traditional venture capitalists
- 7:19and having a singular view and Bitcoin only it's still today,
- 7:22let alone you go back five years and it's kind of my journey into
- 7:26getting into venture and and really the early writers theme
- 7:29as well. But what what I think happens is
- 7:33it's actually the most pragmatic and rational thing to do.
- 7:37But whether it's the entrepreneur not really fully
- 7:40grokking that it's Bitcoin is a signal or having to offer other
- 7:44services because you have to raise capital, it brings out
- 7:48lack of focus. And that's why you see
- 7:49exchanges. There's no shortage of exchanges
- 7:51and proliferation of even like you think about.
- 7:53ETF flows are drastically disproportionate of BTC, but
- 7:56something like Bitwise focuses on everything under the sun.
- 7:59What I think ultimately happens, and we've seen this, is if you
- 8:02have that lack of focus, that means you know you're obviously
- 8:05having trade-offs in your core business.
- 8:06And the flows are in every respect denominated in BTC,
- 8:10whether it's custody, trading, revenue, clientele, interest.
- 8:14And what happens is most companies we've seen, especially
- 8:18in the lending space have blown themselves up because they
- 8:20necessarily don't even understand counterparty risk,
- 8:22the custody aspect. And then also or dealing in the
- 8:25long tail about altcoins and what you generally are seeing.
- 8:29And this is an example of once you get to the other side of it,
- 8:32you're like, why am I doing this to myself?
- 8:33Because you naturally have this attack surface, whether it's
- 8:36having to manage custodial assets on the long tail of
- 8:38crypto or you have to think about the volatility and the
- 8:42just inherent kind of like centralization and the moving
- 8:45and manipulative markets that I think if you're long enough like
- 8:48letting to stay alive, it's the rational outcome to say, well,
- 8:51like maybe I should just focus on the thing and that just makes
- 8:53you a more efficient business. So I think that's kind of like
- 8:56the trajectory with the one caveat that as a market gets
- 8:59more sophisticated, you'll just see more capital and funding for
- 9:03just Bitcoin related businesses because it's just a prudent
- 9:06thing to do if you're a business owner or a capital allocator.
- 9:09Yeah, I agree, especially I mean lettings business model is
- 9:12Bitcoin loans or crypto loans in the past.
- 9:16And you know you want to have loans on the best performing
- 9:19asset that actually has gone up over time because otherwise you
- 9:22would just sell it because and take the capital gains hit
- 9:25rather than taking a loan out against it.
- 9:28And Bitcoin is appreciated more than others.
- 9:31Not to say that many others haven't done extremely well over
- 9:35in different timeframes, but especially recently Bitcoin has
- 9:37outperformed most others other than maybe past month or two.
- 9:42So just makes sense to focus there from a only limited
- 9:46bandwidth perspective with the respective Bitcoin only
- 9:50businesses. I maybe don't necessarily agree
- 9:54that all consumer facing businesses will be Bitcoin only.
- 9:58I think Bitcoin and digital assets have been necessarily
- 10:02grouped together because the industries had to be kind of
- 10:05pirates or operate with maybe big laws around them rather than
- 10:10having clear rules of the road. And I think in the future you're
- 10:13you're more likely to see Bitcoin grouped in with like
- 10:17just typical stocks, other financial assets that people
- 10:20typically have versus Bitcoin and Etho Solana and whatever
- 10:26spark coin under the sun. It just makes more sense because
- 10:29people want a unified experience when just when they buy their
- 10:32assets, just like a Robin Hood or whatever it is, Unless with
- 10:35the caveat that I'll make unless you're providing infrastructure
- 10:39like sub custody for a bank or or something like that is when
- 10:42you can offer Bitcoin only financial services.
- 10:46Unless you want to be kind of a niche player in the market,
- 10:48which can can certainly happen and kind of be a niche player
- 10:52that continues to be profitable. But I just don't think that's
- 10:54necessarily how the majority of people want to interact with
- 10:57financial services. I guess Matt, kind of teeing it
- 11:01up for you here. We see a lot of Bitcoiners, we
- 11:03know a lot of Bitcoin Maxis. They really only want to use
- 11:05products and services that speak to that Bitcoin only use case.
- 11:09They really don't want to use a service that's meddling in these
- 11:11other things. So if you're really going to
- 11:13capture the Bitcoin market share and those hardcore Bitcoiners,
- 11:18you kind of do need to commit to not dabbling in the other stuff.
- 11:22So honestly, from maybe just a market share perspective, it's
- 11:27almost a good call to go Bitcoin only because it's only
- 11:30incremental dollars in the crypto side and it adds a a ton
- 11:33of confusion. So what do you think about this
- 11:35idea of, you know, businesses that have been doing crypto,
- 11:38doing Bitcoin only? Yeah, I think, I think this is a
- 11:41great case study here. I mean they've they came to
- 11:43market with just crypto. They were offering Ethereum
- 11:46loans and Bitcoin loans and then sort of their, their customer
- 11:50base, their users kind of informed their next pivot from
- 11:54that. So they, I mean, 98% of the
- 11:56loans were allocated were backed by Bitcoin.
- 11:59The rest were 2% Ethereum. So that's sort of was a, an
- 12:03opportunity for them to make a pivot.
- 12:05And I think it's, I think it's as a Bitcoiner, it's more when
- 12:09you have an offering that is Bitcoin only because then you
- 12:12can assume and safely assume that the the team that's
- 12:16building that product is. I was wary of the the added sort
- 12:20of security vector attacks that might arise if offering other
- 12:24crypto sort of strategies or products at themselves.
- 12:27I think I don't, I don't discount London for sort of
- 12:30coming out with the crypto first, but I love the fact that
- 12:32they've pivoted from this and that they've seen the allocation
- 12:36that they're using customers were making and decided just to
- 12:39go Bitcoin only here, which I think is a is a valiant sort of
- 12:42pivot and shift from their original introduction.
- 12:46Yeah, I think, you know, you've obviously seen a value in being
- 12:50Bitcoin only in your own career. I can see a lot of enterprises
- 12:53seeing value in being Bitcoin only for that level of focus as
- 12:57well. So next topic that Michael you
- 13:01brought to the table here, it's really an eye popping number.
- 13:04The top 100 public Bitcoin treasury companies now hold over
- 13:08a million BTC. That's quite a bag in the hands
- 13:13of Bitcoin treasury companies. Where did you want to go with
- 13:15that? Yeah, I think brought that
- 13:18mainly because of the I could have never forecast and this is
- 13:22kind of the stemming of this show and also the we'll be
- 13:26seeing you know, with some of the announcement with folks
- 13:28joining in different products launching for the enterprise
- 13:30sector of the market. The amount of air cover that has
- 13:34existed for businesses of all shapes and sizes to now figure
- 13:37out their Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 13:39Because ultimately what has effectively inhibited most
- 13:43individuals and all the way up to institutions of corporations
- 13:46is the stigma around Bitcoin. It's why Bitcoin has generally
- 13:49been adopted by individuals because they're a consensus of
- 13:51one. You don't necessarily need to
- 13:53get governance right and maybe outside of your wife to, you
- 13:55know, ape in or whatever. And but the reality is there's a
- 13:58lot of Bitcoin investors that own businesses and whether it's
- 14:03getting their board approval or just feeling, you know,
- 14:06comfortable with talking about it.
- 14:07And this notion of it's in the zeitgeist now, you know, you
- 14:10have what's happening with the digital asset treasury
- 14:13companies, but more importantly, you have not only ETFs, but the
- 14:16the notion of over the top 100 publicly traded companies hold
- 14:19over $1,000,000 a million BTC that there's error cover now for
- 14:23businesses to start adopting, you know, Bitcoin.
- 14:26And that's where I thought was like the signal through a lot of
- 14:28this is that the cat's out of the bag.
- 14:30And now we're just naturally going to slowly see companies
- 14:33not only allocate from balance sheet capital, but thinking,
- 14:36thinking about long term cash flows into BTCI.
- 14:40Don't necessarily think it's for the some are doing it for the
- 14:43reasons of like it's the the trade.
- 14:44And and there's we see a lot of, you know, natural leverage that
- 14:48wants to get inserted into the system.
- 14:49But I think that there's also just the aperture opening of,
- 14:54well, what is this thing Bitcoin?
- 14:56Oh, is this a better savings technology for my business to
- 14:58outpace what's happening from an inflation perspective?
- 15:01That is a trend that's going to continue to.
- 15:06Yeah. And I know I've looked it up and
- 15:07I think only about 10 of those hundred of public Bitcoin
- 15:11treasury companies actually have a profitable operating business.
- 15:14So we may still see some of those coins come back to market
- 15:17overtime. But Liam, I know that's
- 15:19something you're pretty passionate about is kind of
- 15:21having a profitable underlying operating business as well.
- 15:24Yeah. I think, well, to that point as
- 15:27well, I think that some of those are probably mining companies
- 15:30too that, you know, sometimes do make profit on paper and then
- 15:34the free cash flows inevitably that the business just gets more
- 15:38challenging over time. But yeah, I mean, to that point,
- 15:42you know, we saw Tesla adopt Bitcoin in 2021 and thought that
- 15:47there would be more come significantly after that just
- 15:50given, you know, how people view Elon as kind of a leader in that
- 15:55space. And it just naturally made
- 15:57sense. But I really am excited about
- 15:59Figma. And and to your point, Michael,
- 16:01it's just more so $90 million worth of Bitcoin.
- 16:05They're obviously not going nearly all in for how big the
- 16:07overall size of the business is, but they're the ETFs give them a
- 16:11significant amount of cover too, because it's essentially A
- 16:14professionalized solution for them to get into where in the
- 16:18past they didn't know which way they should go.
- 16:21If it's going to be, if they go with Coinbase or whoever else
- 16:24under the sun. If there really is going to be
- 16:26that Bitcoin at the end of the day and they can have more
- 16:30certainty signing off that their board actually did or that
- 16:34BlackRock did the due diligence on Coinbase and how everything
- 16:37is custodied and managed there. And not to say that it's a
- 16:39perfect solution at all, but it certainly brings air cover to
- 16:45the figments of the world who want to just get like a
- 16:47relatively small allocation and, you know, use that as a way in
- 16:51order to help them just diversify their treasury for
- 16:54their core operating business. The Figma thing is absolutely
- 16:58fascinating because you know, in tech when you generally hear
- 17:01this is in general business where you follow the talent and
- 17:04the talent kind of that's where the industry where people are
- 17:06going. It reminds me of where SWIB
- 17:10Wisconsin's I believe it's, is it pension?
- 17:13Was it? Yes, with their pension system
- 17:15allocated to BTC. And when you went and looked at
- 17:18their performance against all of their pensions, they were in the
- 17:21top tier. They have a very unique
- 17:22governance structure when it comes to their investment
- 17:24committee that actually generates revenue like from a
- 17:26personal perspective, if they outperform.
- 17:28So the lines incentives perfectly and it reminded me of
- 17:33that's following the talent in the same way where if you look
- 17:35at Figma's balance sheet, it's absolutely incredible from like
- 17:38there, I believe have been in the black for a while from a
- 17:40profitable profitability perspective.
- 17:42But then also like they almost, it's not really a hedge fund in
- 17:45the majority of senses run like a hedge fund in the sense like
- 17:48they're managing their balance sheet in a very productive way
- 17:51when it comes to the different cash equivalents that they store
- 17:53in the amount of BTC they've been holding.
- 17:55And it's not for playing on their stock price or a mimetic
- 17:59or marketing scheme. It's just they've been
- 18:01allocating and increasing their allocation, which is again
- 18:04following that talent. Yeah.
- 18:05And we didn't know that they had the Bitcoin until they came
- 18:08public. I mean that's how much they
- 18:09weren't using it as a marketing ploy.
- 18:11It was really just discovered quietly from people looking
- 18:14through S ones and that any take on a million Bitcoin held by
- 18:19public treasuries right now. Yeah, I think that's, I mean
- 18:21incredible, incredible opportunity as a as a Figma user
- 18:24myself, I think it's, it's cool to see that these companies in
- 18:28San Francisco and tech companies pick these up.
- 18:30I know the Figma founder specifically was a little crypto
- 18:33curious around like the 2018 time frame.
- 18:37And so obviously he kind of went down that path and decided to
- 18:40allocate to to Bitcoin, which is a very exciting, very exciting
- 18:44event. Yeah.
- 18:46And just to put a finer point on all this too, is the air cover
- 18:50of these 1,000,000 Bitcoin that all these public companies have.
- 18:53It's it couldn't really happen without the change in accounting
- 18:57rules back in 2024 as well, which is just also given
- 19:00additional air cover. And just the, the amount of
- 19:02different boxes that people need to check in order to get Bitcoin
- 19:06on their balance sheet between getting all the, everybody on
- 19:10the corporate board understanding what Bitcoin
- 19:12actually is, why they should own some how to custody it, how to
- 19:16manage it from an accounting perspective, how to get all of
- 19:19their employees on board that they're not just gambling away
- 19:21the money on the balance sheet and they'll, they won't be able
- 19:24to pay the employees at the payroll next week.
- 19:26It's, it really couldn't have happened without.
- 19:29I think that was a big impetus, the accounting change too.
- 19:31Definitely. And Liam, you had another story
- 19:33here around the New York based Inversion Labs and their plans
- 19:37to acquire low margin companies and outfit them with blockchain
- 19:41to juice efficiency and then reap the profits that follow.
- 19:45What about that story was interesting?
- 19:47Yeah. I thought that Mike would like
- 19:49that a lot. It's essentially, I mean,
- 19:52there's going to be a lot of transformative companies at this
- 19:56time that just figure out essentially marginal ways to
- 20:00really reduce the cost of the business, which will directly
- 20:04translate to profits. But at the same time, I don't
- 20:08necessarily think that. A massive overhaul with the
- 20:12having private equity focus just to essentially run stable coins
- 20:17through a business is is going to be a massive profit center
- 20:20and, and really juice the, you know, actual profit margins for
- 20:25them to outfit them and and then sell later on.
- 20:27And so I have a lot of a lot of hesitations and reservations
- 20:32around if this will actually be successful.
- 20:34But you know, just with all the noise in the market right now, I
- 20:36thought it was super relevant to share, I think.
- 20:39Yeah, maybe teeing you up, Michael.
- 20:42One thing that's interesting about inflation and how it
- 20:45affects businesses is how it shrinks their margins.
- 20:48I don't think people who just experience inflation in their
- 20:52everyday life kind of understand that that's the downstream kind
- 20:55of waterfall that results in shrinking margins.
- 20:58Can you maybe touch on that as well when you kind of touch on
- 21:01what Liam was saying? Yeah, I'll, I'll touch on Liam's
- 21:05and I think the what you're referring to kind of ties into
- 21:07the, we'll pull up the businesses, the number of
- 21:11businesses that have gone out because that that'll kind of
- 21:13like correlate to kind of the fundamentals being dislocated.
- 21:17I think the thing that Liam shared, what I want to touch on
- 21:20and I think doesn't get discussed enough is the, the
- 21:24play today for businesses is really the buy and hold.
- 21:27The market has not developed and this is objectively not
- 21:30subjectively like the market is not developed around yield
- 21:33generation and Bitcoin for 15 years, people have promised and
- 21:36tried to do it and they've blown themselves up.
- 21:39There's probably some small niche hedge funds or a market
- 21:42makers that can do it, but at a very small scale.
- 21:45It's really hard as you increase the amount of Bitcoin you're
- 21:47holding or inches dollars in general to hit the return
- 21:50profile or benchmark. Why I bring that up is because
- 21:53that's a common narrative that's coming up together.
- 21:56We it's on the most innocent side.
- 21:58If you figure out the trade, just custody it don't get, you
- 22:01know, thrown into the loop of how do you generate more, you
- 22:03know, incremental yield on the BTC.
- 22:06But it's also thrown around a lot with the version, I think
- 22:09the 2.0 version narrative of dats and and what will come is,
- 22:13well, we're going to accumulate a war chest and then we're going
- 22:15to go allocate it to get Bitcoin denominated financial services
- 22:18to generate yield. And it's a really great story
- 22:20and I would encourage anybody that listens to, you know, this
- 22:24is the kind of the difference. And I think some of the thoughts
- 22:26we'll be sharing is for 15 years nobody's been able to do this
- 22:30without blowing themselves up. And so I don't think that in a
- 22:33long enough time horizon, Bitcoin as a financial asset,
- 22:36you will be able to monetize it and do other things with it.
- 22:39But we're so early that the market actually has a coalesced
- 22:42and figured out of somewhat risk free rate of return.
- 22:45And so that's really the the call out there is I think there
- 22:48was a lot of language or marketing spin of how they're
- 22:50going to generate some incremental yield to bring that
- 22:53back. And you're going to see this
- 22:54with the digital asset treasury companies on the staking side,
- 22:58because everyone loves passive yield and income.
- 23:01And so that's how they're going to wrap around in the innovation
- 23:03and go by my, you know, dat versus the underlying.
- 23:07So that's kind of what I might take away from that was, is just
- 23:10that there's going to be no shortage of marketing schemes
- 23:12that we're going to generate more Bitcoin.
- 23:13But it's never been done, actually, not even a subjective
- 23:16thing. It's never been done, especially
- 23:18at a scale that we're talking about.
- 23:19And the last part is to go in and step in to do it is pretty
- 23:24much impossible to do because we saw this happen in 21 and 22 is
- 23:28when you first step into the market unless you're insanely
- 23:30conservative. We could talk about some of the
- 23:32practices there maybe later on the show or future shows, is
- 23:35that generally people put the mental models of traditional
- 23:38finance as they enter Bitcoin. And it's a different game
- 23:41because when you think about 24/7 markets, volatility,
- 23:46rehypothecation, there's no lender of last resort.
- 23:48So you get caught naked in this asset class and that's how you
- 23:51get blown up. And that's why so many people
- 23:52have gone away that you just got to be very careful if your
- 23:56business is going to put any of its capital at risk.
- 23:58Yeah. I mean, at early riders, we've
- 24:00seen a bunch of the stacks and etcetera that just I mean, not
- 24:04even that we would take them seriously seriously, but just
- 24:06from the amount of capital that they're able to raise.
- 24:09And it's just literally mind boggling that so many people can
- 24:13really be interested in this. It's in in Bitcoin, it's
- 24:16specifically there is you don't want to be on the cutting edge
- 24:21of your savings and putting your savings to work you, you
- 24:24actually want to there's a lot of value to being very kind of
- 24:28slow methodical, using Trident best practices that are actually
- 24:33tried and true, etcetera, rather than trying to figure out
- 24:36something new, especially when you have a significant amount of
- 24:39capital on the line. And so anytime that somebody
- 24:42pitches you something too good to be true, it it honestly
- 24:45probably is. And that should be the best
- 24:47practice of how you think about the industry as a whole.
- 24:50Yeah. I'm thinking how many of that
- 24:521,000,000 BTC that are being held by the pub co's are taking
- 24:57single counterparty risk right now.
- 24:59Probably most of it. Yeah, that's exactly right.
- 25:02Matt, any words on those topics? They're shrinking margins,
- 25:06inflation affecting businesses chasing yield with your Bitcoin
- 25:10instead of just, you know, sitting on the performance at a
- 25:13time when we're just going up the S curve of adoption.
- 25:16I think you, I think you covered it well right there.
- 25:18I think you guys highlighted the main.
- 25:21I think if we want to go to the the inflation and margin
- 25:26compression. So there was an article that
- 25:28came out, this was from Zero Hedge, but they were citing
- 25:31Newsweek, which the title was large U.S. companies are going
- 25:35bankrupt at the fastest pace since the global financial
- 25:37crisis. And it shows, according to
- 25:39Newsweek, 446 large companies filed for bankruptcy during the
- 25:43first seven months of this year. And you know, if we get
- 25:46encapsulated with the purpose of Bitcoin for businesses this show
- 25:49and in general Bitcoin is the notion of it comes at it for
- 25:54multiple facets. But I guess the the two sides of
- 25:58it is from an individual perspective to a business or a
- 26:01sovereign. When you dislocate or mess with
- 26:07the signals, the underlying economics will distort the money
- 26:10supply and the cost of it that cost the capital.
- 26:13It makes it very hard to plan in CapEx, OpEx and investments in
- 26:17your business. And so we've seen this whipsaw
- 26:19back and forth for, you know, you know, frankly 30 to 50
- 26:21years. But really just look at 20 post
- 26:242020 when 2021 everyone understands kind of that was
- 26:28like the peak craze in traditional VC and kind of
- 26:31capital dislocation. Everybody was, you know, getting
- 26:34rid the raises that the valuations, but then ultimately
- 26:38as the Fed whipsawed and started to raise interest rates,
- 26:41businesses became incredibly non the economics didn't make sense.
- 26:47And so there was another example about four weeks ago came out
- 26:51open store, which was an aggregator raised that I think
- 26:54it's peak a billion dollar valuation by really big venture
- 26:57funds founders son I believe, and Keith Ribroy was the CEO.
- 27:00They recently had to do a down round, at least I think $50
- 27:02million valuation because the business just didn't
- 27:05fundamentally make sense. That's what happens when you
- 27:07distort the cost of capital. On the other side of that is
- 27:12structurally, given the amount of debt, it is a structure, it's
- 27:16structurally impossible not to increase the number of monetary
- 27:18units because the entire system would delever.
- 27:21And once somebody understands that, well, then they understand
- 27:23that inflation only picks up at an accelerated pace.
- 27:26That's what has happened happened empirically over the
- 27:29past 10 plus years, but specifically the past five years
- 27:32post COVID. But to what Chase asked earlier,
- 27:34inflation doesn't happen in a vacuum.
- 27:36Meaning as the goods and services rise, if you're a
- 27:39business and it cost more, whether it's the cost for your
- 27:43employees or the the cost of your inputs.
- 27:46If you're, you know, whether it's you're building a house or
- 27:49if you're a hospitality group in a restaurant and everything that
- 27:53goes into to the ingredients cost more, well, now you have to
- 27:57make a decision. Do you raise your prices or do
- 27:59you keep them constant? If you keep them constant, well,
- 28:02now you're having margin compression because your
- 28:05constant prices, there's a gap between what you had to pay for
- 28:08the inputs. If you raise the prices, well
- 28:11then that naturally to keep up with inflation, well, that's
- 28:14really where two things happen. You're lowering the amount of
- 28:17revenue because it's not in a vacuum.
- 28:19Again, just because you raised the prices doesn't mean the same
- 28:21number of people are going to continue to buy the goods and
- 28:24services. And this is something everyone
- 28:26probably feels and maybe can't put a finger on it, but there's
- 28:29been a visceral degradation in the client services, the
- 28:34product. Everything we touch and feel
- 28:36feels a little off, whether it's the amount of like calling that,
- 28:39you know, air airline and you got it like, you know, just
- 28:43either if they even if you can even get them on the phone, it's
- 28:45like who are you talking to? But ultimately in goods and
- 28:49services across the board. And this is just like a cousin
- 28:52of shrinkflation, right? And so I think that's a really
- 28:55big this is where so you Add all that together and you see again,
- 28:59largest number of bankruptcy since the OA crisis.
- 29:03And this ties into what Matt Ball and we're talking about
- 29:06Sigma at the end of the day, like there's a lot of ways to
- 29:09slice this. One of them is in the same way
- 29:11it'd be crazy for a business not to adopt SAS or adopt AI.
- 29:15It's just like upgrading your tech stack.
- 29:18It's going to be looked at in the same vein as if you don't
- 29:20upgrade your savings technology where you're just going to get
- 29:23out competed away. I think it's this is indicative
- 29:25of that. We're still in the early
- 29:26innings. I don't think most Pubco's are
- 29:28actually buying Bitcoin for this reason.
- 29:30I think this happens at the traditional SMB mid market place
- 29:33where people are upgrading, you know, their big their their
- 29:35savings stack. But we're still early.
- 29:38And as inflation runs and the Bitcoin price runs in podcasts
- 29:41like this and the tools and services like multi institution
- 29:44to make it easy for a company to aggregate material amounts and
- 29:47not be worried about a single custodian or holding, you know,
- 29:50hardware devices, we will see this, you know, industry and
- 29:53specifically businesses adopting Bitcoin.
- 29:55Yeah. I mean, if you look at just my
- 29:57family restaurant, to your point, when inputs go up, you
- 30:00either have to decide are we going to put less pasta on the
- 30:03plate? Are we going to downgrade the
- 30:05quality of the ingredients or are we going to charge our
- 30:07clients more? But you can't just hold constant
- 30:10because you know, otherwise you're taking on that additional
- 30:14cost. One other thing that we're
- 30:16seeing now, we, we saw the rate hiking cycle.
- 30:18Now it looks like we're going to see the beginning of rate cuts,
- 30:22which is still a manipulation in the price of money and, and the
- 30:25cost of capital. But it's, it's somewhat
- 30:29predictable to think that the $7 trillion or so that's rough
- 30:34estimates this week of money that's sitting in money market
- 30:37funds. Once those rates drop, that they
- 30:39might start looking around for a better performing asset that
- 30:42does a better job of keeping pace with true inflation, not
- 30:45just CP. Do you think, you know, this is
- 30:49for anybody here? Do do you think that that 7
- 30:52trillion trapped in money markets today is going to start
- 30:55looking at Bitcoin or are we still too early to see it
- 30:58choosing that asset class? Yeah, I mean, you can't help but
- 31:01feel that as interest rates go, everyone's going to get further
- 31:03out on the risk curve. So I think you you will see
- 31:06that. I think your main point, this
- 31:08was a big aha moment. And during COVID there was like
- 31:11a local Mexican restaurant Taco shop and it was super innocent,
- 31:15but like they had a board with the prices of tacos and they
- 31:18were all market priced. I mean, you know, they had like
- 31:21it was like if you're going to a butcher or like a fish place,
- 31:23like it was all tape over it. This is, this is tacos, right?
- 31:26Like a Taco, you know, Texas cost $1.50 or whatever.
- 31:28And I just had this visual feeling of, oh God, like, not
- 31:31only do they need Bitcoin, but if they adopt Bitcoin and the
- 31:34Taco shop across the street doesn't it gives you, and this
- 31:37is really the crux of like adopting a Bitcoin treasury is
- 31:41it gives you optionality on well, you can not have to
- 31:45increase the price because you're, you know, your treasure,
- 31:48your savings is increasing at the rate if you're not faster
- 31:51than inflation, so you can keep pace.
- 31:53And again, inflation is having a vacuum.
- 31:55So your competitor is having to increase the prices, lower the
- 31:58quality of service while you're not having to do that.
- 32:01And that's the thing that I think happens at an independent
- 32:04level is it's all Darwinistic, right?
- 32:06It's like, if you don't protect yourself, well, then you're
- 32:08going to have less to be able to spend on what you want.
- 32:10The same way businesses are eater be eaten.
- 32:13There's a great book, Hardball. Are you playing to play?
- 32:15Are you playing to win? And the whole objective, it's a,
- 32:19it's a moral imperative for a business to to win because
- 32:22that's how productivity grows. That's how a society grows.
- 32:24And so the businesses that are playing to win are going to
- 32:27adopt BTC. They're going to have better
- 32:29goods and services and they're going to out compete and end up
- 32:31purchasing their competitors or their competitors are just going
- 32:34to go out of business. Yeah, I think that's a great
- 32:37point. And one thing that I haven't
- 32:39really thought about quite as hard as I need to.
- 32:42But it's just the idea of having all of your suppliers and
- 32:45customers adopt Bitcoin as well. Because over time, you know, if
- 32:50as long as your competitor doesn't adopt it, it's the same
- 32:52rate as you. Over time, they're going to have
- 32:55more optionality to reinvest in their manufacturing facilities,
- 32:58the product to increase the what the actual core inputs are to
- 33:03whatever you are producing. And then over time, your
- 33:06suppliers will have more time to, you know, actually buy more
- 33:10of your products and services, reinvest in you too.
- 33:12And so it's a it's a weird game where you actually don't want
- 33:15your competitor to adopt Bitcoin, but you really want
- 33:18all, you know, your customers and suppliers to adopt Bitcoin
- 33:22and as well. And so while there there is
- 33:25something to being open in the market about, you know, actually
- 33:28adopting Bitcoin even as a private business too.
- 33:31Hey guys, a quick word from early riders.
- 33:34If you like concepts like Bitcoin is a hurdle rate as well
- 33:37as following along with everything across Bitcoin
- 33:40infrastructure, Bitcoin startups today, I highly recommend you
- 33:43check out Early Riders and everything that we're doing
- 33:46there. We're putting out a ton of
- 33:47research, so please subscribe at earlyriders.com/research and
- 33:51please reach out if you're ever interested in how to get
- 33:54involved. Thanks.
- 33:55Yeah, I think we talked about Bitcoin on the balance sheet in
- 33:58a very defensive way a lot of times, like guard yourself
- 34:01against monetary debasement, protect yourself from the margin
- 34:04compression. But Michael and Liam to your
- 34:06guys points, it is an offensive strategy as well because if you
- 34:09don't have to raise your prices, you can go out and capture more
- 34:13of market share. You know, there are a limited
- 34:16supply of dollars and customers in your sector.
- 34:19And if everyone around you has to raise their prices because
- 34:21they're not sitting on Bitcoin in the treasury and you can keep
- 34:25your prices constant or even potentially start to lower
- 34:27prices over time, even if on a kind of a input to production
- 34:32cost basis, it's net negative. But you're able to capture
- 34:35market share and your treasury is, you know, outperforming.
- 34:39So you're still experiencing that enterprise growth that you
- 34:41need to show investors you're you're really able to kind of
- 34:44single handedly start to gobble up a market.
- 34:47Yeah, I mean, it goes back to the the the trope, I don't know
- 34:49who coined it, but the best defense is a good offense.
- 34:52And it just so happens to be, you know, Bitcoin is offensive
- 34:54and defensive. I think what Liam said is
- 34:58interesting in the sense like I think you want everyone to adopt
- 35:01Bitcoin. That's the beauty of Bitcoin is
- 35:03it's not a 0 sum game. And by notion of getting into
- 35:06Bitcoin, if your competitors are buying it, they're buying not
- 35:10your bags, but they're increasing the price
- 35:11theoretically. And then you just get back to
- 35:14competing on kind of just traditional business of
- 35:17fundamentals. And the thing that this is
- 35:19really, you know, we'll see Chase and Matt Ball and even
- 35:22Liam TBD and who moves to Texas first.
- 35:24I think everyone eventually ends up there, but is why the focus
- 35:27has been in Texas very heavily. And Parker Lewis has really been
- 35:30leading that way from an early stage and understanding.
- 35:33He would talk about Venezuela as an example, being one of the
- 35:36almost oil rich countries in the world.
- 35:38But when their currency collapse, they couldn't get the
- 35:40oil out of the ground because you can't coordinate economic
- 35:43activity, The truck stop running, the employment, the
- 35:45drill stop running because you don't have the ability to
- 35:48coordinate. And so there's something very
- 35:51important to what Liam was sharing about.
- 35:52You want everyone around you also to benefit from this
- 35:56because you need them to be around because this is how
- 35:59economies work. We don't, I don't, I'm not the
- 36:00cattle driver. I don't produce the cow.
- 36:02And I need my farmer to be able to accept my money and for
- 36:06something he understands in the same way a business supply
- 36:08chain. And so there's something deeply
- 36:11important about kind of that full stack managing that or
- 36:15they're gonna be kind of you're gonna you end up in a place
- 36:18where you end up exposed if you want to be able to purchase
- 36:20goods and services and things you need.
- 36:22The person went out of business A. 100% and the the core part of
- 36:26everything is the employees really make up the company and
- 36:29by adopting Bitcoin, you're going to be able to, you know,
- 36:31increase the amount of your purchasing power, which
- 36:34translates to everything just as like investing in capital
- 36:38expenses, R&D, whatever it may be under the sun.
- 36:40And if you have more capital, you have more capital to attract
- 36:44the best people in the world and the best people in the world
- 36:46want to work at companies that are growing.
- 36:48And so it becomes a self reflect like reinforcing flywheel of
- 36:53adopting Bitcoin allows you to get more money, which allows you
- 36:56to get the best people and create the best products and
- 36:59services. But I would, it's interesting.
- 37:02Yeah, you want Bitcoin for yourself, but you also want
- 37:05everybody in your industry to have it because then everybody
- 37:07in your industry is creating better products and services.
- 37:10Iron sharpens iron to Michael's point about your competitors
- 37:12adopting Bitcoin and and everybody around you too.
- 37:15And yeah, TBD on Texas. TBD on Texas, I think it
- 37:19highlights a pretty big ethos point of Bitcoin in general.
- 37:22Like the whole Bitcoin is for enemies, it's can be sort of
- 37:26extrapolated to like Bitcoin is for competitors.
- 37:28And in the business sense, I think you've both highlighted it
- 37:31well on sort of what that means. Yeah.
- 37:34One thing I want to ask Matt about this is kind of teasing
- 37:37because we didn't share on the top of the show, but part of the
- 37:40show will focus on kind of mainstream enterprise adoption
- 37:44and then a focus on some of the impacts from a business adopting
- 37:47BTC and then some of the innovation and opportunities
- 37:50that we will be developing, thinking about investing in.
- 37:53And one of them that we've talked about behind closed doors
- 37:56is the notion of restricted Bitcoin units aligning 4 O1 KS,
- 38:01right? Look, when you start thinking
- 38:02about a big part of any business and growth and winning is
- 38:06employee retention and, and keeping the best people at your
- 38:09firm. And historically, equity cash
- 38:12incentives, you know, specifically equity is very
- 38:15illiquid. And I think people are starting
- 38:16to get, you know, Privy to that and they're not necessarily
- 38:19incentivized by that. I'm curious, Matt, specifically
- 38:22on your side, seeing what you've been in Silicon Valley, the
- 38:25notion of some of the interesting ideas we've talked
- 38:28about where a company can start to incentivize employees via
- 38:32Bitcoin employment, employment programs, matching programs
- 38:36where you can keep them longer if you think that'll be an
- 38:39interesting trend in the future. Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 38:43Coming from recently coming from GE, which is a like a Fortune
- 38:47500 company now to living in the Silicon Valley area and seeing
- 38:50just a very different landscape of people.
- 38:52Like for example, at GE, we, I would reach out to, to finance
- 38:57executives pretty regularly and sort of get a pulse on their,
- 39:00their stance on Bitcoin and their general sentiment.
- 39:02And even our 401 KS and our retirement savings plan, we
- 39:06couldn't, we, we weren't allowed to self direct or sort of
- 39:09allocate to even the basic ETF offerings, which I think was a
- 39:13big, it's, it's a big sort of pulling back point for the
- 39:18employees, right? Like if you want to grant them
- 39:21that permission, that's certainly also sort of a freedom
- 39:23aspect as well when you're saving for retirement and you're
- 39:27able to sort of do with what you want with that money as you see
- 39:30fit. If there are limitations there,
- 39:32I think that can potentially be a big problem and, and it's just
- 39:37very different here. Here in Silicon Valley, I think
- 39:39there's much more appetite for that sort of self direction and
- 39:43having that freedom of allocating to those those new
- 39:47products such as ETFs and such. I think at Acropolis, we're
- 39:51trying to highlight that adding Bitcoin to your balance sheet is
- 39:54really just the first step. And that once you do, you can do
- 39:57things with that Bitcoin like RB use, you know, vesting Bitcoin
- 40:01to your employees, attracting, retaining talent.
- 40:04But another thing that I had on. Docket today that I think is
- 40:07interesting because I had on on the other pod on the Acropolis
- 40:10new foundations pod last week, the Co founder of Arch lending
- 40:14Bitcoin backed loans platform. We really dug into this idea of
- 40:18an asset backed loan versus a credit backed loan.
- 40:22And we know there's a lot of companies out there that really
- 40:24struggle to get financing a line of credit from a bank etcetera.
- 40:28Once that bitcoins on your balance sheet, you can borrow
- 40:31against it for operational needs and you don't have a gatekeeper.
- 40:35You just need to post the Bitcoin as collateral and you
- 40:38can get that liquidity, you know, sometimes in hours.
- 40:41So maybe just kicking that over to you, Michael, do you, do you
- 40:44think this idea of having this asset backed loan availability
- 40:48is a game changer for small businesses or businesses with
- 40:51bad financials or in industries that don't easily get funding?
- 40:55Yeah, I, I love that you brought this up.
- 40:58I wouldn't have had this opinion if I didn't have a conversation
- 41:01a few days ago with a client. And you know, potentially on the
- 41:05early writer's side is something that we look into from an
- 41:08investment perspective is what you just described it was
- 41:11referencing. We all have our like myopic or
- 41:14singular views and it's helpful to take a step back right from
- 41:16either where we come from or just different markets.
- 41:19And what you hit on was in Latin America, the level of lending is
- 41:23insane. Like I didn't really recognize
- 41:25that it cost anywhere between 25 to 35% like interest rate on
- 41:29like a business loan and taking out, you know, any kind of to
- 41:32run your business. And he's looking at what does it
- 41:35look like down there? He's kind of thinking about
- 41:39that's a just in general, how do you play the arbitrage?
- 41:41If you have your own Bitcoin and you can take that loan and then
- 41:44our route, which is some execution risk, right?
- 41:46Because you got to make sure the business has fundamentals to pay
- 41:48it back. But to your point, I can't speak
- 41:52directly to the US, but I I can't imagine it wouldn't apply
- 41:55to anywhere specific of Latin America.
- 41:58As a business starts to adopt and increase its savings into
- 42:02BTC, it opens them up from capital growth or the
- 42:05opportunity to lend against it at a much lower nominal rate
- 42:09than the current market rate in that country or region.
- 42:12And because of the proliferation of stable coins, you can get
- 42:15access in the dollarized world. You can be in any country,
- 42:19frankly, and get access to dollars backed by BTC.
- 42:22And so I think, yeah, it makes complete sense that you will
- 42:25have this kind of growth of a market as individuals we see it,
- 42:29but also in businesses will you'll use it for operating
- 42:32capital. So yeah, I think it's spot on.
- 42:36Every business will hold Bitcoin.
- 42:38Some already do. Others are developing a plan.
- 42:41Acropolis is how smart companies take action today.
- 42:44Built on multi Institution Custody, Acropolis delivers a
- 42:47turnkey Bitcoin treasury solution designed specifically
- 42:51for businesses. Here's why that matters.
- 42:53Multi institution custody is the breakthrough that unlocks the
- 42:56corporate adoption of Bitcoin. It eliminates the need for
- 42:59employees to hold private keys and removes reliance on any
- 43:02single custodian. Instead, Bitcoin is secured
- 43:05using A2. 3 multi signature quorum where each key is held by
- 43:09a separate regulated institution.
- 43:11No single party can move funds on their own, eliminating single
- 43:15points of failure and greatly reducing risk.
- 43:18We act as an extension of your treasury team, managing
- 43:21institutional grade custody, insurance, continuity planning
- 43:24and strategic advisory so your company can adopt Bitcoin
- 43:28confidently and securely. If your company has been sitting
- 43:31on the sidelines, unsure of how to get started or worried about
- 43:34getting it wrong, this is your signal to reach out.
- 43:37Visit acropolistreasury.com and schedule a consultation with our
- 43:40team. Bitcoin is reshaping corporate
- 43:43finance. Don't get left behind.
- 43:44And you mentioned stablecoins there, Michael, we've got some
- 43:47big news out of Tether coming to the US today.
- 43:50Should we dive into that? Yeah.
- 43:52So the headline that came out earlier today was Bo Hines is
- 43:56now taking the CEO role of a new formed NZT, which is.
- 44:01I didn't fully read the whole thing.
- 44:02I guess I should. I'm pretty confident this is
- 44:04right. It's a new entity and the new
- 44:06stablecoin is like USTA or something.
- 44:10USAT. USATUSAT wow, that's that's
- 44:14pretty apt. I think that why I call this out
- 44:18is it's very bullish for Bitcoin adoption globally, Bitcoin
- 44:24adoption in America, and then Bitcoin adoption in businesses,
- 44:27which is the topic of this podcast because of the simple
- 44:31version of there's still an inherent stigma of the
- 44:34digitization of money. We know it's digitized via
- 44:37credit card and all that, but it's still like, what's a
- 44:40digital currency? Do I really want to park my
- 44:42value in it? And Bitcoin is a big leap.
- 44:44Like if we put ourselves back into, you know, pre, you know,
- 44:48adopting Bitcoin for your own personal balance sheet, this
- 44:50notion of magic Internet beings and putting all our money is
- 44:53still a very foreign concept that I think as an industry, we
- 44:55still don't fully know how to grapple with and and
- 44:57communicate. But the notion of digital
- 44:59dollars is pretty straightforward and especially
- 45:02for businesses when you think about remittances, cross-border
- 45:06merchant and interchange fees and all of that is topic du jour
- 45:09when you talk to banks and everyone.
- 45:11So you have this notion and Bo Hines literally coming from
- 45:14directly the government to go lead.
- 45:15This is Canary in the coal mine that the market is going to
- 45:19embrace this trad fi and everyone across the board.
- 45:22Now, obviously, there's a lot of speculation, a lot of losses.
- 45:24That's part of hopefully what we can help dispel here and add
- 45:27some clarity. But it's also going to
- 45:29drastically increase the flow of dollars into Bitcoin because now
- 45:33you're one click removed. And this is effectively what
- 45:35Tether pioneered, right? Tether and it was really circle
- 45:38consortium first, but it was the notion that they needed a pair
- 45:41to trade 24/7 because wires didn't work around Bitcoin.
- 45:45And this is that extension, but the orders of magnitude greater
- 45:48when it comes to just global liquidity into BTC.
- 45:51Yeah, Jack Mahler talks a lot about the USDC or the USDT and
- 45:56Bitcoin pair, and that as the, you know, the float of stable
- 46:00coins increases, by definition, money's going to find its way
- 46:03into Bitcoin. I'm not sure I've totally
- 46:06grokked how that works, if anybody here can kind of
- 46:10explain. Yeah, as as.
- 46:12You know, people just have access to more digital money.
- 46:15They're just going to hold more and more of it in Bitcoin
- 46:18because Bitcoin just goes up over time and tethered does not.
- 46:22It goes down and over time because it's U.S. dollar backed.
- 46:25And so people are just going to want to save and something that
- 46:27makes more sense and they're just going to find more and more
- 46:30comfort with having digital dollars.
- 46:32And there's there's probably not going to be a wallet with a seed
- 46:35phrase just like we have today. It's going to be all obfuscated
- 46:38away with all the different technology.
- 46:41But yeah, I think that people will just be more used to
- 46:44interacting with money in this type of way, and so going to
- 46:47Bitcoin won't seem nearly as crazy.
- 46:50Yeah, I think, I think that's right.
- 46:52Maybe one piece missing is if you're ready, the big gap is
- 46:57getting your analog dollars in the bank account or in your
- 47:00physical like you know, cash account or under mattress into
- 47:04Coinbase or the exchange. You think about the wire and
- 47:07that's just kept a lot of people out there want to generally buy
- 47:09from their bank. And so whether it's your bank or
- 47:12Amazon, because I think stable coins will really forget across
- 47:15the world, we've seen what's happening with Stripe in Tempo.
- 47:18It's the reality that digital dollars are programmable and
- 47:22they can easily be swapped via almost any wallet in any
- 47:24infrastructure to get into Bitcoin is that big way that the
- 47:28flows happen is because you're taking out the multiple steps to
- 47:32get there. And so there's no shortage of
- 47:35ways that this could be implemented or happened.
- 47:38It'll be a confluence. But one easy example is if you
- 47:41have stable coins or BTC and different vendors like an Amazon
- 47:47or whatever has incentive to pay in BTC versus because that's
- 47:51what will happen, right? As Bitcoin grows, Companies, if
- 47:54they take the dollars have to go and buy the Bitcoin.
- 47:56So there's some nominal fee that happens there where it's more
- 47:59reasonable. And This is why stables and
- 48:01dollar and crypto working in parallel with Bitcoin is just a
- 48:07misunderstanding of, of, of money and convergent and how it
- 48:10converges to 1 because it is a form of barter where naturally
- 48:15the business is going to incentivize or only accept BTC.
- 48:19And then you have to make a decision.
- 48:20And then it's how do I get the BTC?
- 48:22And that's ultimately just a function at a time where more
- 48:25businesses will naturally incentivize you to pay in
- 48:27Bitcoin or only accept Bitcoin. And then the the individual has
- 48:31to figure out how to do that. But if it's already in a digital
- 48:33form, it's very easy to to swap into. 100% it's just like
- 48:37nobody, no businesses really accept checks nowadays because
- 48:41all of their competitors adopted better forms of money to accept
- 48:44payment left, and thus the same thing is going to necessarily
- 48:47happen with both stable coins and Bitcoin.
- 48:50Yeah, and the chargebacks is a real issue for business owners.
- 48:54The idea that they can provide a service, a product and then get
- 48:58charged back and that doesn't happen when you use a final
- 49:02settlement asset like Bitcoin. Not to mention the fact that
- 49:05obviously, you know, overtime Bitcoiners as a demographic are
- 49:09becoming wealthier and have excess Bitcoin to spend, excess
- 49:14capital to spend, and are becoming a larger and larger
- 49:16market to try to advertise to. One thing we saw this week was
- 49:20iPhone releasing the I-17 Pro in the Bitcoin orange.
- 49:26To me that feels like a little bit of a intentional pander to
- 49:30the Bitcoin community, but I don't know if anybody else
- 49:32caught that, I think. We're going to do a little
- 49:34better on referencing Bitcoin community and Bitcoiners.
- 49:38We need to discuss things like rationalist, like there's the
- 49:42old topic of servicing those individuals just going to be
- 49:44people that want to service their money because we have to
- 49:46get out of like part of this pot in general is the notion of the
- 49:50ideology and the focus on having to do things in certain ways
- 49:54kept a lot of people out. So just cognizant of that.
- 49:57The thing I will call out that's just a funny, I'm curious you
- 50:01guys take is it's never sat right with me and I think I
- 50:04stumbled on chargebacks, I think are a Fiat thing because the 2D
- 50:09response to stable coins, Bitcoin payments is how do you
- 50:11do chargebacks in some form? And I don't I'm not 100% certain
- 50:14of this. I'm just thinking out loud, but
- 50:16it reminds me very, it's like a cousin of who will build the
- 50:19roads, right? It's like, well, we'll build the
- 50:21roads because you want to live in a good society.
- 50:23And so we're going to figure that out because it's the right
- 50:24thing to do. It's from a moral perspective.
- 50:26In the same way, if you have a shitty product, you're going to
- 50:29give people the money back or you're going to go out of
- 50:31business. So if like you have a chargeback
- 50:33because the person didn't like the product or you did offer,
- 50:35you're going to figure out the right thing to do because your
- 50:38business longevity depends on it versus So like that's just in
- 50:42it. And I'm thinking through it now,
- 50:44but I'm like wondering like scammers, how do you deal with
- 50:46that? But you see where I'm going with
- 50:47like chargebacks, I think or a notion that's usually discussed
- 50:50when it comes to one way flow of they don't offer that and then
- 50:54you're going to have to build other application layers that
- 50:56will allow for it. But it feels like an inefficient
- 50:59process where theoretically it should be on the the guys of
- 51:03like the business to ultimately be able to, to figure that out.
- 51:07Because if you're a good business, you will honor and
- 51:09figure out the process for it. If you're a bad business, you're
- 51:11going to go out a business. If you're offering goods and
- 51:12services that people want their money back and you're not giving
- 51:14it to them, you know? Yeah, I take your point.
- 51:17The best businesses, the most confident in their product or
- 51:20service often offer 100% money back guarantee if you're
- 51:23dissatisfied with the product. So yeah, I think you're right.
- 51:26If you really stand behind your product chargebacks is probably
- 51:30a nominal frustration for your business.
- 51:34All right. The the there was a big aspect
- 51:38here this week of Namecheap selling $2,000,000 domain for
- 51:43for at the at this point, which was I think their biggest ever.
- 51:46They've done over $70 million in Bitcoin payments directly to the
- 51:50firm, just eliminating the cost for the business as well as
- 51:54allowing people to pay in whichever asset they would like.
- 51:57This is, it's definitely important just because or their
- 52:01demographic likes it from a privacy perspective, because not
- 52:04everybody necessarily wants their website to be known by
- 52:07other people. And so thus it's it's really
- 52:09important to actually understand your demographic and a customer
- 52:14to try to actually create what they really want rather than
- 52:18just saying here, except Bitcoin for something that's a little
- 52:22bit niche. And yeah, I thought that was
- 52:25exciting to see. I think that there will be more
- 52:28moving forward. There's just more willingness to
- 52:30use Bitcoin. It's money, but it really has to
- 52:32be for commercially viable uses. Yeah, I love that you called
- 52:35that one out because I think we lose a lot of sight in.
- 52:38We will talk about it because it's a commercial thing to do
- 52:40and it will proliferate for a long time, stable coins.
- 52:43But the real reality is they lack a lot of the fundamental
- 52:46value and reasons where Bitcoin shines.
- 52:49And one of them is what we're talking about here, this notion
- 52:53of being able to move $2,000,000 without any intermediary.
- 52:57And what was interesting, I believe they have their own BTC
- 52:59Pay servers. So they were, they, their fees
- 53:01were frankly, I think nothing because it's open source.
- 53:03I don't know if there's any charge that they associate from
- 53:06BTC Pay server, but take it into their own self custody is a
- 53:10really like insane feat when you really extrapolate that you can
- 53:13move $2,000,000 in economic value without any intermediary,
- 53:16take it directly into your custody solution with no
- 53:19counterparty risk. And given like the register, I'm
- 53:22not an expert, but the registrar and moving around domains, it's
- 53:25almost like you need a wire kind of process because you don't
- 53:28want to reverse that if somebody has a chargeback in that level.
- 53:31And so to Liam's point, it'll increasingly be at the like
- 53:34larger scale because they need that, whether it's a gold, you
- 53:36know, dealer needing to send a $2.5 million, like you need
- 53:40something that's not reversible if you're going to send the
- 53:42physical gold. It's just a very cool thing to
- 53:45see it. I think over time as more users
- 53:47understand that and then scaling layers, which will be fun to
- 53:51talk about, you know, some of the stuff light spark and
- 53:54implementations that they're doing an E cash.
- 53:56Like we're going to start to see the proliferation of, you know,
- 54:00SAT's and SAT's tied to BT dollars.
- 54:03That will really create a lot of, I think, like Renaissance on
- 54:08the Internet that historically wasn't there when it just comes
- 54:11to sending a bear asset online that isn't discussed enough.
- 54:16Yeah. And and specifically on the name
- 54:18cheap example, I mean this company is 100% privately owned
- 54:22company. They actually released this BTC
- 54:25pay server integration exactly 5 almost exactly 5 years ago
- 54:29today. And so this has just been
- 54:31something that they've offered and they've kind of been slowly
- 54:34accepting Bitcoin as a payment as a part of their domain, just
- 54:37all of their domain services. And and now we see headlines
- 54:40coming out about these big these large transactions that will be
- 54:43coming in and that that will just continue to happen.
- 54:46And Namecheap is a shout out Namecheap.
- 54:49They're a great, a great company, yeah.
- 54:51And excited to see that they're fully doing the BTC pay server
- 54:55stuff. Yeah, I think, I think we should
- 54:57go around and do final thoughts from everybody just so we can
- 55:01keep it within the hour. I'll go ahead and do mine first,
- 55:04just because it relates to this Namecheap story, which is that
- 55:07with Bitcoin, we know that it's mostly being treated as a store
- 55:11of value right now. We get a lot of people outside
- 55:13the Bitcoin community that complain, you know, when are you
- 55:15going to buy coffee with it? It's not a medium of exchange.
- 55:17It's not really a currency when Bitcoiners end up having 99% of
- 55:23their wealth in Bitcoin and that's all that they can ever
- 55:27spend if they want to spend just because Bitcoin has outperformed
- 55:30every other asset in their portfolio, you're going to start
- 55:33to see Bitcoiners have to part with Bitcoin because it's just
- 55:36the only money they have left to spend.
- 55:38So I think that that medium of exchange use case is becoming
- 55:42more and more prominent. We're going to cover the
- 55:44different ways that businesses can accept and do payments,
- 55:47cross-border payments, etcetera on future episodes.
- 55:50But I guess my closing thought would just be that it feels with
- 55:54Bitcoins performance outperformance against other
- 55:57assets in a portfolio that it's just destined to become more of
- 56:01a medium of exchange as bitcoiners still need to buy
- 56:03things in the real world. Yeah.
- 56:04Maybe I'll piggyback on that because I didn't necessarily
- 56:07have final thoughts, but I think that is a core aspect that I've
- 56:11run into a lot of conversations around like deflation and
- 56:15stagflation and like even there's just all these different
- 56:19vectors where people will reference it.
- 56:20Bitcoin goes to millions of dollars, nobody will want to
- 56:24spend it and it's just rooted in the wrong basis of economic
- 56:27coordination, where as the price goes up, that's not happening in
- 56:30a vacuum, more and more people that that's a product of people
- 56:33wanting it, adopting it. And when people want it and
- 56:36adopt it, well then they naturally produce value in the
- 56:40world. They're going to make an
- 56:41intentional effort to either say you can do pay me X or Y and
- 56:44incentivize you to pay you and why, if why is Bitcoin or they
- 56:47can go as far as saying you can only get my goods or services if
- 56:50you pay me in Bitcoin. And so now the other side, that
- 56:52market that loves their treasures, their Bitcoin, if
- 56:54they want to eat and get that cow, they're either paying
- 56:57Bitcoin or or fake, you know, not eat right.
- 57:00And so that's the last part is Bitcoins adoption is embedded is
- 57:05more and more people want it and more and more people will demand
- 57:08it for its good and goods and services and like honoring and
- 57:11multi institutions. A great example of this because
- 57:13people can pay in dollars, but a lot of people pay in BTC.
- 57:15It's like, well, why would they give up to hard earned Bitcoin?
- 57:17It's because the thing of value is helping them increase their
- 57:20Bitcoin exposure, protect it long term.
- 57:23And so they're happy to to pay in that Bitcoin.
- 57:25And if we just only accepted Bitcoin, people would still, you
- 57:29know, do that. Accepting dollars makes it easy
- 57:31and convenient because people like reoccurring and all that
- 57:33and we can easily sweep that into BTC.
- 57:35Agreed. And just piggybacking off of
- 57:37that too, employees and and people who want goods and
- 57:40services will inevitably only take that or make you pay a
- 57:44premium and Fiat just to pay for their conversion costs to BTC
- 57:48and just the other hassle that's associated with it.
- 57:50Which is going back to my earlier point about employee
- 57:53continuity and why you should adopt Bitcoin and why you should
- 57:56want your customers, suppliers and and even competitors to
- 57:59adopt it as well. Yeah, well said Liam.
- 58:01And I think, yeah, no, no real final thoughts for me.
- 58:04I think this was my first pod. So it was, it was nice doing
- 58:07this RIP with you guys and we'll work out sort of the the rest of
- 58:10the kinks as we as we continue. But yeah, super excited overall
- 58:14to kind of really guide business leaders through a Bitcoin
- 58:17adoption as a core savings technology and excited to
- 58:21excited to be a part. Yeah, when you get to go deep in
- 58:23the weeds on implementation and a lot of the things, but we'll,
- 58:25we'll cover them as they organically, organically come
- 58:29up. We got our first flip inning.
- 58:31If you notice, Liam thought Bitcoin wasn't for competitors
- 58:33and now he did. So over the course of weeks, we
- 58:36will see who who's flipping who. I would encourage anybody to
- 58:39like subscribe and also comment on what they want to see, the
- 58:43format feedback because it really helps influence kind of
- 58:47what we're going to try to deliver week after week.
- 58:50Yeah. Thanks so much guys for taking
- 58:52the time today. Yeah, like Michael said, please
- 58:54like subscribe, share it with the business owner, business
- 58:57leader, executive that you know that you want to protect.
- 58:59And please give us that feedback, especially after
- 59:02Episode 1 here in the comments, so we can know which topics you
- 59:05all are most interested in. And we'll see you either next
- 59:08week, if you guys demand it or the week after.
- 59:11Thanks, everyone. Thanks.
- 59:12Guys.