Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / Weekly Tanker Overview Week 45 of 2025
Transcript
- 0:11Welcome back to another episode of the Cycle C Trade podcast.
- 0:15I'm your host Shawnuk and executive tanker operations at
- 0:18Cycle C Trade. And today we are diving into a
- 0:21market that's been nothing short of dramatic.
- 0:23From threat rate swings to geopolitics that refused to take
- 0:27a backseat. Think sanctions, tightening
- 0:30product inventories, weather disruptions, and a few well
- 0:33timed surprises. To unpack all of this, we have
- 0:37got Trisha with us, a research analyst who has been tracking
- 0:41every ripple from the Arabian Gulf to the US Gulf.
- 0:44Trisha, pleasure to meet you. Hi Shanak, It's always great to
- 0:49be back. And yes, what a week it's been,
- 0:52not just in crude, but across the entire clean tanker complex.
- 0:57From VLCC's losing steam to LR2's quietly regaining their
- 1:02footing, the whole markets in a state of controlled turbulence.
- 1:06OK, so let's start from the top, Trisha.
- 1:09The clean tanker market's been caught in a tug of war.
- 1:12The rally stalled or stumbled, yet LRS held the line.
- 1:16What's the real story beneath these mixed signals?
- 1:20So if I had to be honest, it was a fascinating one because what
- 1:24we are really seeing is the classic November divergent,
- 1:27which means it is a cooling rally on one side and underlying
- 1:31strength building quietly on the other.
- 1:34So according to me, here's what or here's where we stand.
- 1:38So the clean tanker index, it slipped 1.4% week on week and it
- 1:43was breaking A2 week streak of gains.
- 1:46So the Mr's I would say were the main culprit here because the
- 1:50Atlantic basin, the earnings fell 10 point 1% and it was
- 1:54driven largely by the TC 14 route which plunged even more by
- 1:5917.6%. So it was spelling the tonnage
- 2:03list so far. But even as the Atlantic Mr's
- 2:07they dragged the complex down because the Pacific routes, even
- 2:10they held steady, particularly I would say the TC 17 route
- 2:14because it went up by 2.26% week on week and it was at a world
- 2:19scale 213.21, which if I were to translate it would be a TC of
- 2:26$22,134 per day. So that was the story about the
- 2:32Mrs. So if I were to talk about the LRS, they had a completely
- 2:36different story because despite the Mrs. slowdown, LR twos kept
- 2:41their footing. They were up about 4%
- 2:45collectively last week. So with TC one that is the EG
- 2:48Japan, it was hovering around world scale 136.3 and the
- 2:53earnings still a healthy 31,000 approximately dollars per day.
- 2:58So even they were slipping 4.06% week on week.
- 3:02And I think that strength it comes from structural
- 3:06dislocation which would be the US sanctions on Russian diesel
- 3:10and the NAFTA which continued to push the Asian importers to
- 3:15source from a much longer haul suppliers.
- 3:18And other reasons could be the tightening availability and
- 3:21keeping the LR utilization. So Shanak, to sum it all up, I
- 3:26would say yes the rally was indeed paused but the tone
- 3:31beneath the surface isn't bearish anymore.
- 3:33I would say just in another word, I would say it
- 3:36recalibrating because the fundamentals, they still favour
- 3:40A rebound, especially with the winter seasonality and the pre
- 3:44Thanksgiving cargo that were rushed on the horizon.
- 3:48Okay, thank you for all of that information, Trisha.
- 3:51And while we are talking about fundamentals, those inventory
- 3:54numbers have caught everyone's attention.
- 3:56Gasoline scrapping the bottom of its seasonal average Diesel
- 4:00margins holding up Now how's that shaping fret sentiment,
- 4:04especially for the Mrs. That's right.
- 4:07The inventories indeed are really driving the tone here
- 4:11because the US gasoline story is quite stark, I would say because
- 4:16the inventories, they have been falling faster than usual and
- 4:20now they are sitting near the bottom of the trailing seasonal
- 4:24average. So it's the tightest I think we
- 4:27have seen in months and I think that's giving the product
- 4:30tankers a floor. So if I were to zoom in into the
- 4:34fleet movements, there were 40 Mr. vessels which were blasting
- 4:40back east of Suez and out of those 19 are already on subjects
- 4:45or COA commitments. And I would say that that's a
- 4:50big deal because it means that we are likely heading into a
- 4:54short tonnage window that too in the Atlantic just as Asia's
- 4:58demand it starts picking up mid November.
- 5:02While on the other hand, the Persian Gulf, the in that area,
- 5:07the Mr. sentiment, it stayed firm last week and I think that
- 5:11would be thanks to the Bahari week activity and the
- 5:14precautionary chartering ahead of 2 brewing typhoons in North
- 5:19Asia. So even though the Atlantic is
- 5:21soft, the East I would say looks like it's tightening and on a
- 5:27much global scale, you could say that the Mr. markets have been
- 5:32pulled in two directions. 1 would be the because of the
- 5:35Atlantic oversupply that is dragging down the rates, but the
- 5:39Pacific and the AG regions slowly forming on repositioning
- 5:43and the weather risk. And you know, what's adding to
- 5:46all of this complexity would be the refined product margins
- 5:50because, Shawnak, they have shot higher lately.
- 5:53And that has been driven by refining capacity tightness,
- 5:58some of it due to, you know, Ukraine drone attacks on Russian
- 6:01refiners and more recently as the Trump administration's
- 6:05rejection of the Lukoil gunwar deal, which complicates several
- 6:10European refinery operations. And I think that's throttling
- 6:14European output and in a way redirecting the trade flows
- 6:18eastward. And I think all of this is
- 6:20giving LRS and the Pacific Mrs. Fresh legs.
- 6:23So yeah, it's not just freight I would say, but it's geopolitics
- 6:28baked into tonnage behaviour. Wow, that's fascinating, Tricia.
- 6:32Geopolitics really does move ships.
- 6:35But Speaking of tightness, let's not shift to the crude side.
- 6:39The VLCC's, Susemax's, Afromax's, they have all had
- 6:42quite the roller coaster. What's the pulse there this
- 6:45week? So As for the crude tanker, I
- 6:49would say the VLCC market in the Middle East Gulf, it started
- 6:54soft because the charterers they played the waiting game and you
- 6:58know they really slowed down fresh enquiries and sentiments
- 7:02as well slipped from form to neutral.
- 7:05For example, the TD2 and TD3C, they both fell down almost 20 to
- 7:1022 points and they settled around world scale 108.78 and
- 7:15world scale 103.5 respectively. So there TC's dropped by almost
- 7:21one 8.79% and two 2.23% each. But I think here's the nuance.
- 7:27By the week's end, fresh third decade loadings came out and
- 7:32that's why the tightening tonnage started again because
- 7:35the owners, they held back tonnage deliberately and they
- 7:39were in a way I think hoping to catch that rebound.
- 7:42So the XWAF VLCCS, they face the opposite though because the
- 7:47rates there fell from multi year highs as cargoes dried up with
- 7:52TD151 of the routes which was down almost 18.94 points to
- 7:57world scale 100.44 and that was a almost 20% TC drop.
- 8:04Meanwhile, on the other hand, EXUSG, it was a mixed situation
- 8:09over there because for it was firm early in the week, softer
- 8:14midweek and then it was stable because the TD221 of the roots
- 8:18it slipped almost 4.26% and the tight December positions, they
- 8:24limited this downside but the sentiments they remained
- 8:28fragile. So this was the overall scenario
- 8:30of the VLCC market. Now if I were to talk about the
- 8:34Swiss Maxis, it was a split picture there because the Meg
- 8:38market, it stayed firm and it was driven by mid November
- 8:42positions. For example, the TD8, it gained
- 8:468.93 points to world scale 202.5 with ATC which was up by almost
- 8:536.4%. So over in the West Africa TD
- 8:5620, which is one of the routes, it also held steady despite
- 9:00fewer fixtures. So owners had confidence thanks
- 9:03to the tight lists. Now finally the Afrimaxis, they
- 9:07were the stars of the week because the TD8 it surged almost
- 9:1113.57 point up to world scale 193.57 and that was a 10.9%
- 9:20increase. Whereas on the other hand the TD
- 9:2340, it also climbed by 10.69 points or to world scale 170.
- 9:29So all of this combined its tight list and strong cross
- 9:33segment support doing the trick. I think Afras are feeding off
- 9:37firm Suezmax sentiment. So to sum it all up, I think I
- 9:41would say that the VLCCS cooled a bit the mid sized segments
- 9:46which were the Suezmaxis and the Aframaxis, they remained robust.
- 9:51And you mentioned weather and repositioning earlier with
- 9:55Typhoons brewing and Bhari week just behind us, how much of this
- 9:58short term tightness can actually translate into
- 10:01sustained momentum as we had deeper into November?
- 10:05That's a really sharp question, Shanak, because right now I
- 10:09would say the market sitting at a inflection point because of
- 10:13the short term disruption versus the structural support.
- 10:16So if I had to elaborate on that, I would say in the East of
- 10:20Suez, the LR2's, they are clearly reaping the benefit of
- 10:24tight early November list because most positions have been
- 10:28taken and even though Kuwait's export program has slowed
- 10:32slightly, the demand still remains intact.
- 10:36So in a way there is a mild supply gap as well which was
- 10:39forming in mid November as several LR ones, they returned
- 10:44from shorter voyages and that was creating a potential mini
- 10:48spike. So the LR 1 market, that market
- 10:53looked quite balanced for now. But as more cargoes emerge for
- 10:57late November loadings, maybe that could flip quickly because
- 11:01remember the LR one and the LR2 earnings differential has
- 11:06narrowed very sharply. And I think that signals that
- 11:09the short term equilibrium is there, but also that the LR1S
- 11:13might soon play catch up. And now moving on to your
- 11:16second-half, the question about the typhoons.
- 11:19So the two typhoons forming in North Asia and the tonnage
- 11:23availability could, I think easily get disrupted because the
- 11:27weather related delays, especially, you know, around
- 11:31Japan and Korea, they do tend to add volatility.
- 11:35And of course, we cannot forget the Persian Gulf Bahari week
- 11:39because that was also typically when chartering spikes and we
- 11:43are already seeing that reflect in the activity.
- 11:47So yes, while these are temporary drivers, they do align
- 11:52perfectly with seasonal tightening, which are low
- 11:55inventories, higher demand and geopolitical rerouting.
- 11:59So yeah, that's why the FA curves, even with the recent
- 12:02dip, they still suggest that there's a rebound into late
- 12:06November and early December. So now let's talk LPG before we
- 12:11wrap up this segment. We have seen east of SEWS
- 12:14activity picking up Rastanura Shiba Yanmu fixtures, but also
- 12:18West of SEWS softening midweek. What's now your opinion and how
- 12:23that balance is shaping up? I would say that the LPGS had
- 12:27quite a dynamic week for sure because in the East of Suez EB
- 12:32LPG 1 route, that is the Rastanura Chiba index, it
- 12:35touched the $70 per metric ton mark midweek and one deal was
- 12:41reportedly done close to $80 per metric ton Baltic equivalent.
- 12:46And I think that's a big bounce because this rebound was helped
- 12:51by two things mainly. 1 was the easing US, China trade tensions
- 12:56and the other was of course the former Middle East propane
- 12:59prices and the average BLP G1 TC.
- 13:03It also rose around 30% week on week and that in a way signaled
- 13:08that strong returns on limited availability is there.
- 13:12But interestingly, I would say India's four week moving average
- 13:17LPG imports, it slipped almost by 12% from 6.67 metric tons to
- 13:235.89 metric ton and I think that was suggesting a short term dip
- 13:28in consumption. Now talking about the West of
- 13:32Suez BLPG 3 index, it climbed into mid $130.00 per metric ton
- 13:39before easing as more railway tonnage appeared for late
- 13:42December. So that fresh supply, it capped
- 13:46the rally, whereas the BLPG 1, BLPG 3 TC spread, it narrowed
- 13:51and I think that showed that weaker East West arbitrage
- 13:55because traders are cautious now and in a way they are waiting
- 13:59for clearer price signals before locking the new voyages.
- 14:03So yeah, overall the LPG sentiment, it still remains
- 14:07fragile in the Atlantic, but I would say it was firm in the
- 14:11East. And owners, they are still
- 14:13optimistic that late December programs or increased eastern
- 14:18demand could somehow stabilize rates and maybe help re
- 14:23establish a floor. OK, so Trisha, pulling all of
- 14:27this together from clean tankers to crude, from geopolitics to
- 14:31weather, what's your big take away for traders and ship owners
- 14:34as we move into mid November? So if I had to sum it all up, I
- 14:40would say that we are indeed entering into a high volatility
- 14:45equilibrium in the sense that the market isn't collapsing.
- 14:48It's in a way breathing, for example, clean tankers, they
- 14:53have paused after a strong rally but seasonality, sanctions and
- 14:58refining tightness. They are still favouring the
- 15:01owners and the LR2S as well. They are leading.
- 15:04The LR1S are balanced, but they are more ready to rise and the
- 15:10Mrs. as well, though they are weak in the Atlantic, but will
- 15:13likely rebound as stunage shifts in the East.
- 15:16Whereas on the crude side, VLCCS are re collaborating after multi
- 15:22year highs. While Suez, Maxx's and Aframax's
- 15:25they hold firm unlimited lists. And if we add to that the
- 15:29ongoing US, Russia sanctions, the Ukrainian refinery
- 15:33disruptions and the Middle East in supply reshuffling.
- 15:37I think all of this it's clear that volatility is the new
- 15:40normal. And for traders, I would say
- 15:42that it's about timing, it's about catching the next upswing
- 15:47in the LR and the Afromax segments.
- 15:49And for the ship owners, it's more about positioning and
- 15:53balancing the ballast runs strategically.
- 15:55And of course, at the end for the analysts, it's all about
- 15:59reading those tonnage lists, not the headlines, because the next
- 16:03three to four weeks could define the tone of quarter 1/20/26.
- 16:08Hmm, That's a sharp way to end it, Trisha.
- 16:11So volatility is the new normal. Couldn't have said it better.
- 16:14Thank you so much for joining us again on the Segal Tanker Market
- 16:18Podcast. Thank you, Shanak, it's always a
- 16:21pleasure to be on the Segal Sea Trade Podcast.
- 16:23So to our listeners, stay tuned, stay curious, and as always,
- 16:28stay ahead of the curve. We'll be back next week with
- 16:31another deeper dive into the global tanker markets.
- 16:34Until next time, navigate safely and stay informed.