Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Regulation Updates: Audits, Cyber Guidance, and Corporate Rules
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark Trekel with another episode with Flying Colors.
- 0:03NCUA went from not having a lot going on publicly to having a lot going
- 0:08on publicly and privately from what I'm hearing through the grapevine.
- 0:12And today I am recording this on December 15th.
- 0:16Of course December 18th is the Thursday into a board meeting and they've
- 0:22announced that they're going to be doing the insurance update, the quarterly
- 0:27briefing on the insurance fund, which is where they reveal where camels are at.
- 0:31So I'll be reporting on that here on the podcast down the road.
- 0:34And then they are also going to be talking about their budget.
- 0:37Lots of rumors out there about their budget.
- 0:40And whether or not they will keep the same number of regions, whether or
- 0:43not they will get rid of the Office of National Exam and Supervision,
- 0:47whether or not they will get rid of the Office of Consumer Compliance office of
- 0:51Credit Union expansion and resources, all sorts of things floating around.
- 0:56But I think we might have some clarity on that.
- 0:58On Thursday when the NCA Board of Won.
- 1:01Will be taking action relative to their budget.
- 1:03And of course, I'll have some follow ups here to the extent it's pertinent
- 1:06for you listeners and viewers.
- 1:08But on December 2nd Kyle Halman chairman testified before the house.
- 1:14And in that he talked about a hat, he gave a hat tip to some
- 1:18reg relief that was coming.
- 1:19And then on December 10th, NCUA announced that they have a project to simplify
- 1:24regulations and they drop four proposed changes to clarify some regulations
- 1:29and to provide some regulatory relief.
- 1:32I'm gonna walk through those four and then on 12 1212 excuse me.
- 1:36Yeah, 1211.
- 1:38Kaman said something similar about what had just been done
- 1:41at the FS o annual meeting and.
- 1:45He, so things are gearing up.
- 1:46He testified at the house.
- 1:47He testified or made statements at the FS o annual meeting.
- 1:51He's announced a board meeting coming later this month as opposed
- 1:55to skipping a board meeting or two.
- 1:57And then the four regulations with changes were proposed.
- 2:00So again, things are heating up as we wrap up the year here now.
- 2:05The project to simplify the regulations relate to four.
- 2:10The, so the agency's stated goals of the project are to improve
- 2:14clarity without weakening safety and soundness reduce compliance burden.
- 2:18Where possible better align in CUA regulations with in.
- 2:22Practices and statutory requirements and make future updates faster,
- 2:26especially for technology related items.
- 2:30The new initiative is similar to the modernization efforts the agency
- 2:33undertook a decade ago, but now with a renewed push driven by tech
- 2:37changes, cyber considerations, and the evolving supervisory environment.
- 2:42As part of this simplification project, NCUA issued four proposed
- 2:46rules that fit together as a package.
- 2:48I'm gonna walk through each one of these.
- 2:51The first regulation is with the proposed change is part 7 1 15 for the
- 2:56supervisory committee audits N C's.
- 3:00Main focus here is that it proposes to update part 7 1 5 to improve clarity
- 3:05around supervisory committee audits.
- 3:07Align the regulation with industry standards and give credit unions more
- 3:11flexibility in how they meet their audit.
- 3:14Requirements.
- 3:15The key points are that it clarifies expectations for the
- 3:19annual supervisory committee audit.
- 3:21It updates terminology and definitions to better match modern auditing practice.
- 3:26It simplifies the rule without changing the core statutory obligation.
- 3:31It reinforces that credit unions over $500 million.
- 3:35Are still required to have a CPA opinion audit.
- 3:37That threshold is not being touched or changed, and all the other thresholds,
- 3:42by the way, make remain the same.
- 3:44Focuses on making the rule easier to follow and reducing ambiguity
- 3:48for committees, examiners, and CPAs.
- 3:51It also supports NSU a's goal of making rules easier to understand, easier to
- 3:56comply with, and easier to examine.
- 3:59Those are the proposed, the proposals, proposed improvement areas.
- 4:04What it really means for credit unions, minimal operational
- 4:07change, but improve clarity.
- 4:09Fewer exam surprises because expectations theoretically
- 4:13are spelled out more plainly.
- 4:15And supervisory committee, of course, should review their policies to ensure
- 4:19their alignment with the updated language once the rule is finalized.
- 4:22Again, this is just a proposal has to be voted on separately, likely by notation,
- 4:28vote under the current structure.
- 4:30To be a final rule, and that's what you have to deal with
- 4:32the changes that relate to it.
- 4:34Now for corporate credit unions there's not a lot of 'em.
- 4:3711 or 12 corporate credit unions left.
- 4:39The main focus is targeting updates to corporate rules to reduce
- 4:43outdated requirements and strengthen gov governance expectations.
- 4:48The key points are it highlights and clarifies certain board
- 4:52governance provisions.
- 4:54It updates reporting requirements to reflect current practice.
- 4:57It removes outdated cross-references and cleans up legacy language
- 5:01from pre-crisis regulations.
- 5:04Pre-crisis regulations refers to the the.
- 5:07The Great Recession and the NCA having to issue the NGN Bond program back
- 5:13in the day when when all the AAA rated securities turned into junk.
- 5:17And NCA had to figure out a way to hold those so that credit unions
- 5:21losses could be normalized and.
- 5:25That's what there were regulation changes made to back then that they
- 5:29felt they could pull out to simplify.
- 5:31It also aligns more closely with standardized governance frameworks.
- 5:35For example, not requiring a board member to sit on committees.
- 5:39And it's intended as part of ongoing corporate rule maintenance, not a broad.
- 5:43Rewrite what this means for corporate credit unions, mostly
- 5:46technical and clarifying updates.
- 5:48Some governance responsibilities may be spelled out more explicitly, like those
- 5:54the change of who can be on committees and no new major operational requirements.
- 5:58But clarity improves compliance and consistency across the corporates.
- 6:04Number three, safeguarding member information.
- 6:07The main idea, appendix A to part 7 48.
- 6:10The safeguarding of member information guidelines is being removed from the
- 6:14regulation and reissued as guidance via a letter to credit union.
- 6:19It's funny that the regulation says it's a guideline, but it's a regulation.
- 6:22So this makes perfect sense.
- 6:24Guidelines or guidelines shouldn't be in a regulation.
- 6:26So it was key points appendix A was always intended as guidance under the
- 6:30Graham Leach Bliley Act, not a regulation, keeping guidance inside the CFR.
- 6:36Blurs the line between what's required and what's advisory and moving it
- 6:41to a letter to of credit unions makes updates faster and clear.
- 6:45Why is that?
- 6:45Typically it's faster to do a letter to credit unions because it doesn't go out
- 6:50for public comment and it can be sent out with the signature of the NCA Chairman.
- 6:55In this instance right now the chairman is the full board.
- 6:58So while.
- 7:00While you could argue that under a one board member scenario, it's
- 7:04not any quicker under reality.
- 7:07Guidance is much quicker.
- 7:09I had actually done podcasts and posts about why I thought that
- 7:14succession planning should be done by guidance and not regulation.
- 7:16'cause it, it bakes it in and it makes it harder to change.
- 7:19And actually, I believe that's what Todd Harper's intent was
- 7:23to make it harder to change.
- 7:24He wanted it baked in.
- 7:25And in some instances doing things by guidance makes much more sense.
- 7:29And I think in this instance, NCA has hit a home run on this proposal.
- 7:33So it also the eliminates any confusion but does not change the
- 7:39requirement for each credit union to have a written security program.
- 7:42So the still need to have a written security program and it
- 7:46eliminates confusion on whether or not that's required or not.
- 7:49What this also means for credit unions, there's really no substantive
- 7:52cybersecurity requirement.
- 7:54Being removed.
- 7:54So cybersecurity as per usual, which means you throw a lot of money at it
- 7:59and hope that you don't get hacked.
- 8:00Number two, your security program must still meet the Gram
- 8:04Leach Bliley Act expectations.
- 8:07And this move again, is just purely structural guidance belongs in letters
- 8:10and not in the regulatory code.
- 8:15Lastly response programs for unauthorized access removal from Appendix B,
- 8:20similar to Appendix A, appendix B, which outlines expectations for
- 8:24response programs to unauthorized access is also being removed from
- 8:28regulation and republished as guidance.
- 8:32Again, housekeeping.
- 8:33Aligning with the CFR with how guidance is supposed to work.
- 8:36The content's not going away.
- 8:38It's being placed in different formats in letters to credit unions.
- 8:42It's important because technology and cyber responses, expectations
- 8:46change frequently, which make it easier to put this out in a letter
- 8:49to credit unions as opposed to a regulation makes it more nimble.
- 8:54Again, you need to comply.
- 8:55You must have an incidents response program.
- 8:58You must notify NCA when there's a significant cyber incident.
- 9:02But the day-to-day expectations that have unchanged, they'll be
- 9:07put into a letter to credit unions.
- 9:09And then ultimately updates when there are changes.
- 9:11You'll see them theoretically in letters to credit unions as opposed to.
- 9:17As opposed to into a regulation.
- 9:20This is a first step towards NCUA, making some minor tweaks to their regulations.
- 9:26And I did some post on LinkedIn, did some emails to my mailing list.
- 9:30If you're not on my mailing list and you'd like to get on the mailing list
- 9:33send me a, a message on LinkedIn.
- 9:36Lot coming this week.
- 9:37N Sue's board meeting on Thursday.
- 9:39I believe that they should make some announcements about
- 9:43offices that are closing.
- 9:44I believe they will say the large credit union program and the.
- 9:48Corporate credit union will be pushed into the regions.
- 9:51I believe they may make some structural changes as to how many regions and
- 9:55or regional directors are out there.
- 9:57But that's just chatter amongst through the grapevine, if you will.
- 10:01After NSU a's board of one meets on Thursday, I will be listening
- 10:06to that via the YouTube live.
- 10:09Feed that they do, which is great, and I will have a podcast about that coming up.
- 10:13We also have a podcast with my team, Steve, Todd, and Dennis on the
- 10:18quarterly data that came out from NCOA, comparing that to some of the
- 10:22banking data and what we see that meeting potentially for credit unions.
- 10:27Also, I hope to do a.
- 10:29Summary of 2025 on the podcast episode coming up here between now and the
- 10:34end of the year, and I've got some exciting guests planned for January
- 10:38and or later this year as well as we come to a wrap here in 2025, as always.
- 10:43And as a wrap on this podcast episode, I wanna thank you for watching.
- 10:47Thank you for listening.
- 10:48This is Mark drl siding off with flying colors.