Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / Did Roanoke's Settlers Really Disappear? New Evidence Says No
Transcript
- 0:00Have you ever wondered if America's first English settlers
- 0:04didn't vanish? They had just blended into the
- 0:07shadows of history, hiding a secret that is now only coming
- 0:12to light. Stay tuned for a look into the
- 0:15Lost Colony of Roanoke. Welcome back to the Jeremy Ryan
- 0:34Slate Show. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan
- 0:37Slate, the CEO and cofounder of Command Your Brand.
- 0:41We help our clients to appear on the right podcast as guests can
- 0:45grab our free R resource over at commandyourempire.com.
- 0:50Reminder if you're brand new to this channel like this video,
- 0:53leave us a comment or smash that subscribe button.
- 0:55If you want to learn more of history's mysteries.
- 0:59Reminder to follow me on XI am at Jeremy Ryan Slate on there
- 1:03over as well as well and as every other social platform.
- 1:08And today we're diving deep into one of America's oldest unsolved
- 1:13mysteries, the lost colony of Roanoke.
- 1:18If you're like me, with a podcast background where I've
- 1:22interviewed historians and conspiracy buffs alike, you know
- 1:26how these stories hook you. It's not just dates and facts.
- 1:31It's the what ifs that keep you up at night.
- 1:35Picture this in 1587 / 100 English men, women and children
- 1:42sail across the Atlantic to build a new life in the New
- 1:46World. They vanish without a trace,
- 1:49leaving behind only cryptic carvings.
- 1:52For centuries we've wondered, were they massacred?
- 1:57Did they starve? Or did something more intriguing
- 2:01happen, like assimilation into the Native American tribes with
- 2:05a conspiratorial twist involving hidden agendas from the English
- 2:10crown? And here's why I find this
- 2:12fascinating. As someone who's always looked
- 2:15and chased the historical angles with a bit of a conspiratorial
- 2:19band, I'll admit it. Roanoke isn't just a ghost
- 2:22story, It's a blueprint for how empires rise and fall, often
- 2:28with secrets buried in the sand. Today, we'll unpack the verified
- 2:32history with names, dates, and places from sources like
- 2:36Britannica and history.com, while weaving in plausible
- 2:40theories that make you question everything.
- 2:44And we'll balance it out about 60% straight history to ground
- 2:47us, but 40% conspiracy to spark a bit of intrigue and keep me
- 2:52interested. So stick around, because recent
- 2:55discoveries might finally solve this mystery.
- 2:58And an emphasis on might. This episode's paste for a deep
- 3:02dive. And we're going to spend as much
- 3:04time as we can getting into it, really setting it up and
- 3:07learning a lot more about the colony's history and how it
- 3:12vanished. So you're really going to enjoy
- 3:14this one. We're also going to look at
- 3:16modern breakthroughs. And before wrapping up, if you
- 3:20are someone that loves a mystery, that loves a story, or
- 3:23that you're casually in the history and conspiracies, this
- 3:26is an episode for you. No pH DS required.
- 3:29I'm only in MA, not a pH D, so let's jump in and I will say on
- 3:33this story in particular and a future story I want to cover as
- 3:37well. I have not talked a lot about
- 3:40American colonization on this show.
- 3:42I want to talk about some of the, the mysteries around it as
- 3:45well. I, I've read a lot of books on
- 3:48Roanoke. There's also been a lot of great
- 3:49documentaries I've watched on Roanoke.
- 3:51There was one where they did some DNA testing, which was
- 3:54quite interesting on modern people living in the area.
- 3:58I also want to take a look in a future video, not this one, at
- 4:02the colony of Jamestown. And it's interesting how things
- 4:07get pretty bad in Jamestown. I don't think it's really
- 4:09covered in history. I read a book called Savage
- 4:13Kingdom where it basically talks about how things got so bad in
- 4:16Jamestown. At a certain point they had
- 4:18reached the level of cannibalism.
- 4:20So we're not going to talk about that here today.
- 4:22We will talk about it in a future video.
- 4:24So buckle up for this one. I think you're really going to
- 4:27enjoy it all right. To understand Roanoke, we've got
- 4:31to go back to the late 1500s in England under Queen Elizabeth
- 4:35the First. This is the Elizabethan era, a
- 4:39time of bold exploration, religious wars, and cutthroat
- 4:43competition with Spain. England was late to the colonial
- 4:47game. Spain had already claimed gold
- 4:50laden empires in South America thanks to folks like Christopher
- 4:54Columbus. In 1492.
- 4:56Queen Elizabeth wanted a piece of that pie, but secretly to
- 5:00challenge Spanish domination without a full on war.
- 5:04Enter Sir Walter Raleigh, a dashing courtier, poet and
- 5:08adventurer. Born in 1552 in Devon, England,
- 5:12Raleigh was Elizabeth's favorite.
- 5:15He funded expeditions out of his own pocket to establish English
- 5:19footholds in North America. Why not just glory?
- 5:24There was whispers of vast riches like gold and a Northwest
- 5:28Passage to Asia. But conspiratorially, some
- 5:32historians suggest Raleigh's mission had a hidden agenda to
- 5:37create pirate bases for raiding Spanish ships.
- 5:41Raleigh never set foot in America himself, but he
- 5:45orchestrated everything from London.
- 5:48The first real push came in 1584.
- 5:50Raleigh sent 2 captains, Philip Amadeus and Arthur Barlow, to
- 5:56scout the coast. They landed on the Outer Banks
- 6:00of what we now call North Carolina, a chain of barrier
- 6:04islands protecting the mainland. Specifically, they hit Roanoke
- 6:09Island, a 12 mile long strip in the Albemarle Sound.
- 6:15Barlow described it as paradise, fertile soil, friendly natives,
- 6:21and no Spanish insight. These natives were the Algonquin
- 6:26people, including the Roanoke tribe led by Chief Wengina,
- 6:32later renamed Pemissipon. After suspicions of betrayal,
- 6:38Amadeus and Barlow brought back two native men, Manteau and
- 6:44Wanches, to England as ambassadors.
- 6:48Manteo became an ally. When Chennessee, not so much.
- 6:53He grew distrustful of the English.
- 6:57In 1585, Raleigh launched the first colony attempt, about 108
- 7:02men, mostly soldiers. Under Governor Ralph Lane.
- 7:06They built Fort Raleigh on Roanoke's North End, a star
- 7:11shaped earthwork, and it's still visible today.
- 7:14But things went S fast food shortages hit hard and the
- 7:19settlers relied on natives. But tensions boiled over.
- 7:23In June 1586, Lane's men killed Chief Wengina in a pre emptive
- 7:29strike, and this is verifiable from Lane's own accounts.
- 7:33Starving and paranoid, the colonists hitched a ride home
- 7:37with Sir Francis Drake, who stopped by after raiding Spanish
- 7:42Florida. As a podcaster who's chatted
- 7:44with experts on colonial clashes, I see this as classic
- 7:49empire building hubris. The English arrived thinking
- 7:52they'd conquer, but nature and natives had other plans.
- 7:57Conspiratorially was when Gina's death a set up.
- 8:01Some theories suggest Raleigh's instructions included
- 8:04eliminating threats to secure the land.
- 8:08This is plausible given England's ruthless policies
- 8:11elsewhere. This failure set the stage for
- 8:141587 and Raleigh tried again, but with families, this time
- 8:20women and children, for a permanent settlement.
- 8:24John White, an artist who'd painted Native Life on the 1585
- 8:29expedition, was named the new governor.
- 8:33White's watercolors, preserved in the British Museum, give us
- 8:38our best glimpses of pre colonial America.
- 8:42So Fast forward to April 1587. White leads 117 souls, 91 men,
- 8:49seventeen women and nine children aboard 3 ships from
- 8:53Plymouth, England. They aim for the Chesapeake Bay
- 8:56north of Roanoke for better farmland, but their pilot,
- 9:01Simone Fernandez, a Portuguese navigator with shady loyalties,
- 9:07forced them to Roanoke Island instead.
- 9:10Why? Historical records from White's
- 9:13journals suggest Fernandez wanted a quick profit from
- 9:17privateering, not colony building.
- 9:20Conspiratorially, he was a Spanish spy sabotaging the
- 9:25mission. Spain knew about Roanoke.
- 9:28King Philip the Second had eyes elsewhere.
- 9:33They arrived July 22nd, 1587. The old Fort was overgrown, but
- 9:38they rebuilt Manteau. The loyal native was baptized,
- 9:42entitled Lord of Roanoke on August 13th, England's first
- 9:48Protestant in the New World. Then Joy.
- 9:51On August 18th, White's daughter, Eleanor Dare gave
- 9:55birth to Virginia Dare, the first English child born in
- 9:59America. Baptized on August 24th, she
- 10:03symbolized hope. But her fate, well, that's a
- 10:06mystery. Life was tough, hurricanes
- 10:10battered the coast, food was scarce, and natives were wary.
- 10:16After when Gina's murder, White noted the clashes with the
- 10:20Sicutan tribe. By late August, the settlers
- 10:25begged White to sail back for more supplies.
- 10:28He left reluctantly on August 27th, promising a quick return.
- 10:34His last sight is smoke from the native fires.
- 10:37Or was it signals? From my perspective, this
- 10:41chapter screams human resilience with a conspiratorial undercut.
- 10:46Raleigh funded it privately, but Elizabeth's court was rife with
- 10:51intrigue. Rival nobles, the Earl of
- 10:54Lynchester, might have withheld their support to undermine
- 10:59Raleigh. Is this verifiable?
- 11:01Well, court records show that Raleigh fell from favor around
- 11:05that time, so comment below. What if you were an English
- 11:09settler from 1587? Would you have stayed in Roanoke
- 11:13or would you have demanded to leave?
- 11:15Let's discuss in the comments below.
- 11:17I love hearing your takes. White's voyage home was hell.
- 11:22Storms delayed him, and in England, the Spanish Armada
- 11:27loomed. Elizabeth banned all ships from
- 11:30sailing in 1558 to fight off invasion.
- 11:33White finally departed in 1590, arriving at Roanoke on August
- 11:3818th, Virginia Dare's third birthday.
- 11:41What did he find? A ghost town, houses dismantled,
- 11:47orderly, no graves or battle signs.
- 11:50And on a palisade post, the word Croatoan carved boldly on a tree
- 11:57the letter CRO spelling Crow no cross.
- 12:02White agreed. This looked like a distress
- 12:05signal. Croatone was a nearby island,
- 12:08which is now Hatteras, home to Manteao's friendly tribe.
- 12:13White wanted to search Croatoan, but storms forced his fleet back
- 12:18and he never returned. His journal, published in 1600
- 12:23by Richard Haklut, details this as a primary source.
- 12:29It's gold. Personally this hits me pretty
- 12:32hard. It's like a cliffhanger episode
- 12:36where the guest disappears mid interview and conspiratorially.
- 12:41Did the settlers leave a code, some speculate Croato and hit an
- 12:46anagram or a map reference? It's plausible if they feared
- 12:51Spanish interception. For centuries theories have
- 12:55swirled and let's break them down. 60% rooted in history and
- 12:5940% in that conspiratorial bend I love.
- 13:03So first let's look at assimilation.
- 13:05Most historians per Britannica say they moved to Croatoan
- 13:10blending with the natives. Jamestown settlers in 16 O 7
- 13:14heard rumors from Powhatan chiefs of pale skinned people
- 13:19inland. William Strachey in 1612 wrote
- 13:23of white people with blue eyes among the tribes.
- 13:27It's a plausible conspiracy, but did the English cover this up to
- 13:32avoid admitting their failure? Raleigh was imprisoned in 16 O 3
- 13:36for treason, and maybe he knew a bit more.
- 13:40Second, a massacre. Now Hatton allegedly confessed
- 13:43to killing them to John Smith in 16 O 8, but Smith was a braggart
- 13:49and there's no real evidence. A Spanish attack?
- 13:52Well, Philip the Second sent scouts and records from Madrid
- 13:56archives show they knew of Roanoke's location but found it
- 14:00empty in 1588. Third is starvation or disease,
- 14:04drought. Data from tree rings shows that
- 14:071587 to 1589 was the worst in 800 years.
- 14:11They might have split sometime in Croatoan and others inland to
- 14:16a site called Quote Site X near the Chowan where 2015 digs found
- 14:22English pottery Conspiratorially.
- 14:26Was there cannibalism as we mentioned that is historically
- 14:30BeenVerified at the later Jamestown colony.
- 14:32It's fringe, but zombie myths arose from desperate tales.
- 14:37Or what about hidden Spanish gold?
- 14:39The motive? Raleigh sought El Dorado, Maybe
- 14:43settlers found clues and were silenced?
- 14:46What do you think about these theories?
- 14:48Massacre, assimilation or something else that we haven't
- 14:52mentioned here like a cover up? Drop your vote in the comments.
- 14:56I want to read it and maybe we'll look at it in a future
- 14:58episode. Shout it out next time.
- 15:01Fast forward to today, the first colony foundation since 2005 has
- 15:08excavated Roanoke and Hatteras. In 2023 and 2024, they found
- 15:13Algonquin pottery mixed with English styles at Elizabethan
- 15:17Gardens, suggesting cohabitation.
- 15:21And there's a big breakthrough. In just June of 2025, reports
- 15:25from archaeologists like Scott Dawson, his book and his digs on
- 15:29Hatteras uncovered Hammerscale ironworking residue from the
- 15:35English tools, plus a 16th century ring.
- 15:39Per the New York Post and history.com, this is the quote
- 15:43Smoking Gun points to the settlers moving to Croatoan and
- 15:47assimilating peacefully DNA. And this is something I talked
- 15:51about a bit in the introduction. Lumbee tribe claims descent in
- 15:552020. Study shows European markers,
- 15:58but they're quite inconclusive. Another clue, 2012 infrared
- 16:03scans of White's maps revealed a hidden Fort symbol inland as a
- 16:09possible relocation site. Is it solved well?
- 16:13Historian David Beers Quinn argued split groups in the
- 16:171970s, but now evidence backs it.
- 16:21Conspiratorial. Why the delay?
- 16:24Maybe tourism dollars keep the quote mystery alive.
- 16:28The Outer Banks thrives on it. And as I wrap this up, here's
- 16:32why I'm hooked on my different episodes.
- 16:36We look at stories like this and they remind us that history is
- 16:39not dead, it's evolving. Recent finds suggest they didn't
- 16:43vanish, but they survived, adapted, and maybe even thrived
- 16:48in secret. So thanks for joining me on the
- 16:51Jeremy Ryan Slate Show. If this episode blew your mind
- 16:55or maybe you want to hear more about the story, like share and
- 16:57comment and head over to jeremyryanslate.com.
- 17:00We're doing a total site revamp right now for more history with
- 17:03A twist, podcasts and anything else you could want.
- 17:07What do you buy as the solution? Assimilation or still a
- 17:11conspiracy? Comment below.
- 17:13I want to hear it and I'll see you next time.
- 17:16So stay curious and I'll catch you on the next episode of the
- 17:19Jeremy Ryan Slate Show. Have a good one, everybody.