Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / 2025 CAMEL Trends: What the Full-Year Data Actually Tells You
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark Kel with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03Today I'm going to be doing a camel or camels overview of the 2025.
- 0:09Camel Trends.
- 0:10Uh, this is a podcast I typically got in the rhythm of doing once every quarter.
- 0:15I kind of got away from that in 2025 'cause the numbers were
- 0:19getting better theoretically.
- 0:22Uh, I just spent a bunch of time number crunching what actually
- 0:24happened in 2025, compared it to a couple of my last podcast.
- 0:28One of which, for lack of a better term, there was a, a, an alarm sound
- 0:33by former board chairman at the time, Todd Harper, about the trends.
- 0:37So, we're gonna walk through those trends here, uh, in the podcast and on YouTube.
- 0:43I.
- 0:44I've got a PowerPoint, uh, that links to this, that I will
- 0:49kinda walk through numbers wise.
- 0:51So if you're listening to the podcast I'll try not make it so numbers
- 0:55centric that that you have that, that you have to go say, Hey, I'm
- 0:59gonna pause this and go to YouTube.
- 1:00I know some people like YouTube, some people like the podcast.
- 1:03I'll try and.
- 1:04Uh, say this in a way that works for both audiences.
- 1:08So I've titled this glass half full, glass, half empty, and the base case.
- 1:12Another way to look at that is, what do the trends mean?
- 1:15Optimistically, what do they mean?
- 1:18Uh, pessimistically and or skeptic, skeptically, and, uh, what the
- 1:23pragmatic approach would be.
- 1:24So pragmatic, skeptic, and optic optimism.
- 1:29Or said another way, glass half full, glass half empty.
- 1:32And of course the base case, which would be there in the middle.
- 1:36So again, I mentioned Chairman Harper.
- 1:39Sounded an alarm, uh, in September of 2024, which kind of sets this up
- 1:43well, since I'm looking at 2025 data.
- 1:47He sounded alarm in 2024 and said it has been a decade at that juncture since we
- 1:53saw this proportion of shares at risk.
- 1:56And during that quarter the number of code four and code fives over $500 million in
- 2:02assets tripled from three to nine, which looked like a quite alarming trend, right?
- 2:07So something triples in a quarter, uh, it means something, but code
- 2:11fours and code fives tripled.
- 2:14In the second quarter, between the second quarter of 2024 and the
- 2:19third quarter of 2024, which is what Harper, uh, was making his point of.
- 2:25And numbers wise, that was 136 credit unions that were
- 2:28code fours and code fives.
- 2:30At that juncture, there were 743 credit unions that were Camel code threes.
- 2:36And so if you take those and say that equates to being troubled in some
- 2:42way, uh, what it does mean is NCO a is gonna show up theoretically more often.
- 2:46Of course, we're gonna get into that 'cause they've got a 27% cut in staff
- 2:50making it more difficult for them to get where they think they need to go.
- 2:54And there were one in five of those credit unions that, uh, you
- 2:58could say were in distress mode in the code four, code five mode.
- 3:04So I'm gonna walk through each quarter of 2025.
- 3:07Yeah.
- 3:09And I've got a couple different ways of splicing and dicing this.
- 3:12And the chart I have in front of me shows, uh, the baseline of, of the fourth
- 3:18quarter of 2024, Q1, Q2, Q3, and Q4.
- 3:23So we have all five.
- 3:25The five last quarter ends.
- 3:27And over that time, code fours and code fives went down in total from 135 to 117.
- 3:33And uh, more importantly, from 16.3
- 3:37billion in assets to 12 billion in assets, so down 25% in assets,
- 3:46coded code fours and code fives.
- 3:49Excuse me, that was shares.
- 3:50It's essentially the same 'cause obviously you build in assets,
- 3:54builds in liabilities, and, uh, undivided earnings, et cetera.
- 3:58So assets are actually 18 point a half billion to 13.6
- 4:01billion.
- 4:02Code threes went down from 715 to 653 code three shares.
- 4:08Down from 157 billion, 158 billion to 145 billion.
- 4:14And oh, by the way, during this time period, the number of credit unions
- 4:17in existence fell from 4,467 to 4,297.
- 4:25So a drop of a hundred and rough, and again, there was an anomaly
- 4:32in, uh, the second quarter of 2020.
- 4:35Five camel, three count fill, but the dollar exposure, exposure went
- 4:40up and that would be from most likely a four being improved to a three.
- 4:47It's kind of like a, a snake eating a large rat, right?
- 4:51You're gonna see that move through the system.
- 4:53So if a code four or a five becomes a code three that's large, that's gonna
- 4:57move, uh, the numbers quite dramatically in from a four to a three bucket.
- 5:03So visualizing camel trends by institution on this chart, uh, we've got the green
- 5:10code ones and twos, the amber code threes and the black or blue, uh,
- 5:15which are code fours and code fives.
- 5:17This chart shows the, basically.
- 5:22The green code ones and twos, the orange or amber code threes
- 5:27the black code, fours and fives.
- 5:29Uh, and you can see the Camel four and five share by billions of dollars going
- 5:35from 16 to 18 to 13 to 12 to 12, and the code threes at 158 billion 146.
- 5:43Then they went back up to 1 68.
- 5:44That would be the anomaly, uh, then down to 1 54 and 1 45,
- 5:48uh, at the end of the year.
- 5:49So.
- 5:50Numbers are trending in a positive direction, but breaking that down by
- 5:55asset category reveals a little bit more.
- 5:57So this would be what are the trends for those large institutions?
- 6:03And as a reminder, NCA classifies credit unions over $500 million as complex.
- 6:12Uh, and this slide shows that data, so the number of code threes over 500 million.
- 6:20Was three of these quarters was at 69, so end of 20, 24, 69, 20 25.
- 6:26First quarter, 69 actually went up to 72.
- 6:30Second quarter, 2025 down to 69, third quarter of 2025 down to 66
- 6:36during the fourth quarter of 2025.
- 6:39And maybe that's a little bit of truth in coding.
- 6:41Maybe that's NCA saying, Hey credit unions have gotten better.
- 6:44Maybe that's NCOA saying, Hey, we've got 27% less staff.
- 6:48Staff.
- 6:49We really need to do a little bit more triage.
- 6:51And here you can also see that the, let's see, code three insured
- 6:57shares in 2024 end of twenty twenty four, a hundred twenty eight.
- 7:03Billion down to one 17, up to 1 39 the second quarter against that
- 7:08same trend of a handful of code four large credit unions becoming code
- 7:14threes if you're in that category.
- 7:17Congratulations.
- 7:18I know I had a.
- 7:19Uh, I've had some conversations with credit unions that were in
- 7:22that bucket down to 124, uh, down to 116 at the end of the year.
- 7:28And then code fives and fours from 13 to 15 to 10 to nine.
- 7:33So that trend is good.
- 7:35So the Harper Alarm tier, this is what kind of drove, uh, chairman Harper to
- 7:39say, Hey, we need to sound an alarm.
- 7:41Camel fours and fives peaked at 11 and Q1, uh, before recovering to seven.
- 7:46Uh, at year end, seven at year end, that number is different.
- 7:50Uh, let's see, 7, 7, 7.
- 7:53Below the level triggered by Harper's.
- 7:56The seven was the number.
- 7:58Oh, I'm, I'm, I'm mixing, mixing my chart up here.
- 8:02So I'm, uh, I was looking at the billion dollar shares, so, so that's accurate.
- 8:06We're down to seven large institutions as code fours and code fives.
- 8:10Camel three count was essentially flat all year, 69 down to 66.
- 8:15Uh, but shares in net bucket swung wildly down to 117 billion in Q1.
- 8:21Spiking.
- 8:22And then the composition of who was coded a three in this tier changed
- 8:25more than the count suggests.
- 8:28The glass half full Harper's specific alarm was resolved.
- 8:31The glass half empty, two of these institutions moved from three to four and
- 8:35five in Q1 before improving this tier is.
- 8:39Is a little bit wonky because there's less numbers.
- 8:42So you can see these large, dramatic dollar changes in
- 8:46the share insurance fund.
- 8:47And by the way, that goes into the calculation, you know, you
- 8:50have your Cecil calculation.
- 8:51Well, NCUA has their NCUA has their share insurance reserves that they need, and
- 8:58that's based partially by Camel Code.
- 8:59So when things go the wrong way, they need more reserves aside.
- 9:03That impacts whether or not you get a dividend or have to
- 9:05pay a premium or status quo.
- 9:08Uh, but that's a whole nother podcast and how the insurance fund works.
- 9:11We have a couple of those out there, some that compare us
- 9:14to us, compare credit unions, N-C-O-S-I-F, to the FDIC the model.
- 9:19Uh, if you find that interesting, uh, I would encourage you
- 9:22to, um, go onto our podcast.
- 9:25Area, uh, on our website or, uh, on YouTube so glass half full.
- 9:30The Harper specific, uh, alarm is resolved.
- 9:33Glass half empty.
- 9:33Two of these institutions moved from three to four at five in Q1 before improving.
- 9:39This tier is never fully stable.
- 9:42And again, that's because large numbers, the law of large numbers, you can
- 9:45see them moving because there's less in number, uh, but they're bigger.
- 9:49So you can see the swing in assets and the swing in shares.
- 9:52So the a hundred million to $500 million.
- 9:55Uh, this is the tier where 2025 made almost no progress.
- 9:59So these are not the large, but they're not the small.
- 10:02Although if you're in that category, you might consider yourself small.
- 10:06So Camel four and five count started at eight and ended at nine.
- 10:10So the s.
- 10:10So slight slightly worse.
- 10:13Camel threes went from 92 to 94.
- 10:15Also slightly worse.
- 10:17The aggregate numbers improved because small credit unions drove the gains.
- 10:22Uh, if you're a mid-size credit union, and again, this will,
- 10:24will consider this mid-size.
- 10:25Your peer group did not benefit from the trends that moved.
- 10:28The headline numbers, shares at risk in this tier were remarkably stable
- 10:34all year, hovering around 19 to 20 billion for camel's three, one.
- 10:40Three to 1.44.
- 10:42Camel four.
- 10:43Stability here means no prices, but also no resolution.
- 10:47So kind of treading water in this category, which might be what
- 10:50you're thinking as you're trying to deal with economies of scale
- 10:54as you're trying to deal with.
- 10:56Uh, administrative burden, regulatory burden, et cetera, et cetera.
- 11:00It's tough to be in this category.
- 11:01It's tough to be smaller, but it's also tough to be in this category
- 11:04'cause your members expect you to do everything and your budget might
- 11:08not allow you to do everything.
- 11:11All right?
- 11:11So less than a hundred million.
- 11:13Where the improve improvements actually happen, improvements
- 11:16with a exclamation point.
- 11:17So virtually all of the 2025 camel's improvements were concentrated here.
- 11:22Camel's four and fives dropped from 118 to 101 a reduction of 17 out of the
- 11:29total of 18 improvement across all tiers.
- 11:32So set up said, I'll say that again.
- 11:35The Camel four and code five improvements 17 of the 18 over this.
- 11:4215 month period happened in credit unions.
- 11:45Less than a hundred million Camel threes dropped from 554 to 493
- 11:5161 out of 62 of the reduction.
- 11:54So some of this is genuine improvement or rehab.
- 11:58Some is merger.
- 11:59Small credit unions are absorbed into healthier big credit unions.
- 12:03Either way, the risk exits the trouble bucket and reduces the risk
- 12:08theoretically to the insurance fund.
- 12:10So dollar exposure here is small, 1.5
- 12:12billion in four and five shares at year end.
- 12:16So the insurance fund impact is limited, but the count matters,
- 12:19uh, for their supervisory workload.
- 12:21Fewer small credit unions means NCOA stretched exam Staff has a
- 12:25more manage manageable queue of work, uh, that they need to get to.
- 12:29And again, we've had podcasts on this, but NCA.
- 12:34Dropped into their national supervision policy manual without any fanfare that
- 12:39they were stretching out their exam cycle for billion dollar plus credit unions.
- 12:44They also made it easier, easier to comply with their policies back
- 12:49when I started and for virtually forever, uh, over the last 40 years,
- 12:54if you're a code four, you had to have a follow-up exam every 120 days.
- 12:58If you're a code three, you had to have a follow-up exam every 180 days That
- 13:01went from a mandate to a goal, and they have some tracking mechanisms for that.
- 13:06But, if you are a code three, uh, they'll tell you they're
- 13:09coming back to do an exam.
- 13:11And they may or they may not.
- 13:12If you're a code four, they'll tell you they'll come back every 120 days.
- 13:16They may or may not.
- 13:17They have to do triage.
- 13:18They're doing triage, they're tweaking where they go when and
- 13:22that's creating some pressure on.
- 13:24On a lot of things, right?
- 13:26And obviously nobody there's not a lot of credit unions that say,
- 13:29Hey, I wish you had 27% more staff.
- 13:31I wish you hadn't lost all those people, because less eyes means less scrutiny
- 13:36in, in, in the short term, right?
- 13:38So, that's just the reality.
- 13:39I wanna go back to the and talk a little bit about the quarter
- 13:42the Q2, uh, 2025 anomaly.
- 13:45The dollar the count was down, but the dollar exposure was up, so they went camel
- 13:50threes went down from 6 79 to 6 67 down 12 looks like progress, but the camel three
- 13:56assets went from 172 to 198, went up 25.
- 14:00Does not look like progress.
- 14:02So smaller credit unions that exited the bucket through
- 14:05genuine improvement of mergers.
- 14:06Meanwhile, larger institutions entered it and or moved from the
- 14:09code five, four to the three bucket.
- 14:14So the, as I've called it here, the Harper Alarm alarm Complex credit
- 14:18unions code four and five is greater than 500 million in assets pre alarm.
- 14:21There were three and then nine at the alarm.
- 14:24Uh, a large alarm stage in 2024, uh, end of the end of fourth quarter
- 14:30nine, up to 11, down to eight, then to eight, then to seven.
- 14:33So as low as three pre alarm.
- 14:36Uh, the alarm when Harper, yelled it from from his podium as chair
- 14:40wars at nine, got as bad as 11.
- 14:42And now back into what I've have as the green stage, which is uh,
- 14:46seven at the end of the year.
- 14:48We'll have to see where that goes.
- 14:49I'm gonna get back on track of doing these podcast quarterly, updating this one,
- 14:53updating these slideshow as we go forward.
- 14:55So, there is three ways to read this data.
- 14:58As I mentioned, on the front end, the glass half full, the base
- 15:01case, and the glass half empty.
- 15:03What's the glass half full case?
- 15:05In summary, there's 18 fewer troubled institutions.
- 15:08The code four and five count being down from 135 to 117 over the full year,
- 15:13and it declined every single quarter.
- 15:16The dollar exposure, nearly halved.
- 15:18Shares at four and five rated credit unions went from 18 billion to 12 billion.
- 15:24The remaining institutions are smaller or on average.
- 15:28So I dollar exposure nearly Hal, that's actually, it went down, uh, 33%.
- 15:32I'm gonna have to check my math on that, how I came up with,
- 15:35uh, with that dollar exposure.
- 15:37Nearly hald.
- 15:37It wasn't halved, it came down 33%.
- 15:40Harper's alarm was answered.
- 15:41Complex credit union coded four and five, peaked at 11.
- 15:44And it backed down to seven below the nine that triggered his concern and
- 15:48the agency's concern at that time.
- 15:51And there are 62 fewer Camel three institutions from seven 15 to 6 53.
- 15:56Camel three shares at year end, 145 billion are below.
- 16:00When Harper sounded the alarm.
- 16:03The glass half empty, the quarter two anomaly camel three count
- 16:06fell, but assets jumped 25 billion.
- 16:09That just shows you that things can change quickly.
- 16:12If a few credit unions grow the wrong way the numbers can get out of whack.
- 16:16And of course, the glass half empty is these numbers are masked by mergers.
- 16:21Some improvements are credit unions that merged away.
- 16:24A substantial number of them are, and of course, if credit union
- 16:27merges, odds are their camel code.
- 16:29Wasn't as good, uh, as the credit union that they merged in.
- 16:33I'm not saying there aren't twos that merge into twos, there
- 16:36aren't ones that merged into twos.
- 16:38But a lot of these improvements, uh, in the total numbers are credit
- 16:42unions that said, Hey, you know what?
- 16:44We're tired of fighting within NCA and threes and fours, and we
- 16:47wanna do more for our members.
- 16:48And that goes into a podcast I did.
- 16:52That either, that either comes out the week before or the week after
- 16:55this one on mergers, no, excuse me.
- 16:57It already came out.
- 16:58The merger podcast came out where we talked about that 20% of of credit union
- 17:03credit unions that merged were under duress and that 80% of them did it for on.
- 17:09Expanded services.
- 17:10So the NCOA staffing wildcard, 27% of staff took buyouts.
- 17:14That's actually not the right number.
- 17:1627% staff down there were people who left from attrition that didn't take buyouts.
- 17:20The buyout was closer to 21, 22, or 23%.
- 17:24So does this mean that we're getting truth in coding or does this
- 17:27mean we don't have the resources?
- 17:28So we'll just be nicer?
- 17:31You could argue either.
- 17:32Uh, the glass half empty would be arguing that, hey, they're just, uh.
- 17:36They're just coding better 'cause they don't have the staff.
- 17:38The glass half empty also, there's still 770 credit unions
- 17:43coded at code three at year end.
- 17:45That's one outta six federally insured credit unions in that category.
- 17:48So it's not a clean bill of health.
- 17:50And if you go back to the quarterly analysis podcast I did with Todd Miller,
- 17:55Steve Farr, and Dennis Bauer of my team, uh, we talked about the fact that for
- 17:59the first time in a very, very long time.
- 18:02Delinquency in credit unions is over 1%.
- 18:05While that number isn't alarming, is not alarming, the trend
- 18:08is in the wrong direction.
- 18:10And that would play into that because NCA knows that when they
- 18:13take insurance losses, why is it?
- 18:15It's because of asset quality or economics that drive asset quality.
- 18:19So the base case.
- 18:21If you're a Camel Code one or a Camel Code two, you're gonna
- 18:24see NCAA lot less frequently.
- 18:26Use this time wisely.
- 18:28Do your internal work, stay on top of things.
- 18:32If you're, you know, I, we, we have conversations and, and clients
- 18:35that are ones and twos, and we have clients that are threes and fours.
- 18:39Fives typically don't stick around long, uh, but.
- 18:43You wanna stay there because if you slip into the three or four NCA is
- 18:47gonna come bother you more frequently.
- 18:50As I, and as I say, uh, and have said in some posts, there's
- 18:53an old country Western song.
- 18:55How can I miss you if you won't go away?
- 18:57And that song kind of says, Hey, if you're having to report monthly, if you're
- 19:01having to do monthly calls with NCOs.
- 19:04Uh, problem case officer, or if you're having to have exams every 120 days, it
- 19:11seems like you're always preparing for NCA and not caring about your members.
- 19:14So if you're in the three, four, or five bucket, you will get attention.
- 19:17Might not be as much as you got in the past.
- 19:20And your Campbell code matters more now than ever.
- 19:23As NCOA is resource constrained and they lost a lot of talented people.
- 19:27And every time I say.
- 19:29They lost a lot of talented people.
- 19:30I always wanna say that the new people and the people that are already
- 19:34there will grow into their positions.
- 19:36Uh, but it could be some growing pains if you have a less experienced examiner.
- 19:40As a result.
- 19:42So the, and then, you know, you get to the known unknown, NCA staffing, uh, cycles.
- 19:47I've mentioned that down 27%, they're, they're still a hiring freeze at
- 19:50federal government agencies, right?
- 19:52As people leave, as people retire they find their happiness elsewhere,
- 19:56as you say, uh, it's gonna get worse staffing wise before it gets better.
- 20:00And even when NCUA gets the spigot.
- 20:03Turn back on, it takes 3, 6, 9 months to actually start getting
- 20:08the job announcements out there.
- 20:09And then, oh, by the way, uh, are they gonna attract the same pool of people
- 20:12that they did before because, um, you know, people seek out government
- 20:17employment for different reasons, but, uh, safety being one of them,
- 20:21and it hasn't been necessarily the safest place to be employed right now.
- 20:25That's not.
- 20:26That's just, that's not an editorial comment, that's just the reality.
- 20:30And exam cycles are getting elongated.
- 20:32So again, some Camel Code improvements are real.
- 20:35Some of them are, are the reality of they, they don't have the people.
- 20:39So maybe they'll just be nicer.
- 20:41Uh, what to watch for in 2026.
- 20:45The quarterly board briefings now, I talk here a lot about, um, NCA needing
- 20:51to do things in the sunshine, which quite frankly, they haven't done lately.
- 20:55Uh, they've been having less board meetings.
- 20:57I am hearing rumblings that a new board member will come in as chair
- 21:01to take the place of helpmann soon.
- 21:04And when they do that, I'll do a podcast on that.
- 21:06But, uh, they need to get back to communicating better with the industry.
- 21:10Uh, they've been doing a lot of reg regulatory reductions some of which are
- 21:15real, some of which are happy to, glad I've got some podcasts coming out on that.
- 21:20Uh, the hiring free status, will it get lifted?
- 21:22When will it get lifted?
- 21:23And then I haven't said much about the economy, the eco economic headwinds.
- 21:28That's the reality of what's drives this train.
- 21:30If the economy gets worse in 2026, these numbers will get worse, and that's where N
- 21:36COAs losing 27% of their staff will really start to have impacts at the agency.
- 21:43Whatever your code is, that helps define your relationship with NCUA.
- 21:47If you're a one or two, you wanna keep that protected and guard it.
- 21:50If you're a three, four, or five.
- 21:51NCUA is stressed for resources.
- 21:54Communication is always the key to a good examination.
- 21:57It's even more important when NCUA has less staff, less experienced
- 22:00staff, that you are the consummate.
- 22:02Communicator that you take the bull by the horns in that regard.
- 22:06Alright, that's it.
- 22:07As always, I wanna thank you for watching or thank you for listening.
- 22:10If, uh, you are finding yourself needing a help on an exam, you
- 22:14know where to find us on LinkedIn, on our website, mark trico.com.
- 22:19Uh, or email me at info@marktrico.com.
- 22:24That's a wrap.
- 22:25Have a wonderful rest of your day, rest of your week, and
- 22:28again, reach out if you need help.