Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #🎙️101 | Public Inquiry Special week 22nd Sep What This Landscape Evidence Really Means Dr Amy Strecker|
Transcript
- 0:10Unknown: Welcome back. I'm Marella, your host, and I'm part of the Save Our Sperrins campaign. And this podcast is following the Curranalt public inquiry and the proposal for a gold mine in The Sperrins. If you're new to the podcast and wondering how we got here, I'd suggest going back to podcast
- 0:28number 43, the first in this public inquiry series, that will give you some of the background before joining us here. As the inquiry continues, I'll be following the evidence and the arguments, and trying to make sense of what they could ultimately mean for the people, the water, and the landscapes of
- 0:50The Sperrins. We reached the end of the landscape evidence at the public inquiry this week, and two days ago I included a short contribution from Doctor Amy Strecker. Afterwards, Amy went away and did what many of us do when we finally get out of the inquiry room. She thought about it just a little more, and she
- 1:19sent me another recording. It covers some of the ground we touched on, but it goes considerably further. And when I listened to it, I thought it deserved to be heard in full, rather than squeezed into another daily report. So this is a slightly different podcast. None of the daily proceedings
- 1:41from me, no attempts to summarise another day at the inquiry. Just Dr. Amy Streicher reflecting on what we have heard over the past week about landscape designation methodology, and ultimately, what all that means for The Sperrins. So I'll get out of the way now and hand you over to
- 2:00Amy. Hi,
- 2:02Marella. So, just some thoughts on the landscape topic after the four days. So, first of all, I was expecting the last two days to focus heavily on designations because the three subtopics scheduled for discussion under landscape were restoration methodology and designations, and I'd say we spent most of the
- 2:29time discussing restoration methodology and landscape and visual impact assessment, but less time discussing the landscape designations. In fact, the only designation that was really discussed in terms of compatibility with the project was the special countryside area. I was expecting a
- 2:50discussion on the AONB, the area of outstanding natural beauty, and whether the project proposal is actually compatible in the first instance with the AONB. And of course, AOMBs are designated by the department for their high landscape quality, wildlife importance, and rich cultural and architectural
- 3:09heritage under under the Nature Conservation and Immediately Lands Order 1985. So there are statutory duties relating to the conservation and enhancement of AOMBs, but of course the commission will be aware of that framework, and maybe they felt it wasn't necessary to go over it if it was included in some of
- 3:30the written submissions during the landscape sessions. Legal counsel for the applicant questioned my assertion that there are statutory obligations to restrict developments where they undermine the integrity of designated landscapes. First of all, I just thought that was an extraordinary thing to say when
- 3:54there are clear statutory duties to restrict development proposals when they're likely to impact the integrity of a variety of designations, not only European and international sites such as Ramsar sites, but also the integrity of national designations, including areas of special scientific interest, and
- 4:17planning permissions should only be granted for development which is not likely to result in unacceptable adverse impacts on or damage to known priority habitats and priority species in active peatland, and that comes not just from you know various provisions in law, but also from planning policy, national
- 4:38planning policies. So the SPPS, for example, the strategic planning policy statement for Northern Northern Ireland in paragraphs, well, in several paragraphs, but let's say 6.175, 6.186, 6.183, and 6.192, and there's also the precautionary. Principle as well in 6.174 in the SPPS, and the precautionary
- 5:06principle. It says the precautionary principle should be applied when considering the impacts of proposed developments on national or internationally significant landscape or natural heritage resources. So we do have statutory duties in relation to conserving and enhancing the landscape and
- 5:22restricting development that would undermine the integrity of its features if it's a nationally designated landscape, and also there's ample evidence to show that the applications are actually likely to cause significant adverse effects and demonstrable harm to designated sites, including the landscape
- 5:43designations, and I mean, this isn't just harm that's identified by third parties; it's actually acknowledged by the applicant itself and other statutory consultees at the inquiry. So, we heard during the landscape sessions that well, the applicant acknowledges that there will be significant
- 6:01adverse effects on the localised landscape, especially south of the application site. But there's also the destruction of 9.5 hectares of blanket bog, and there's other acknowledged adverse effects. So, for example, NIEA acknowledged that the lighting of the proposal will have an adverse or would
- 6:19have an adverse impact on the dark skies of this part of the Sperrin AOMB, and impact the landscape character within an extensive visual envelope around the site, and that the proposal would have an adverse impact on the tranquillity of The Sperrins landscape, which is an essential and acknowledged feature of the
- 6:37area. And these are just you know some of the acknowledged harms. We also have more, many more harms and potential harms identified by the by other statutory consultees and independent experts, including Locks Agency, the independent ecologist for FODC, independent experts for Save Our Sperrins
- 7:00Historic Environment Division in relation to Begmore ASAI, and from the several bodies in the Republic who made submissions during the Transboundary Consultation, including Antashka on and the Irish Peatland Conservation Council. But you know, aside from designations, I think there's another important
- 7:23point to make in relation to landscape.
- 7:25I mean, the landscape, the European Landscape Convention, which is renamed the Council of Europe Landscape Convention, is actually binding on the UK and Northern Ireland, since the UK is a state state party, and the convention places a lot of emphasis and and a duty on states parties to provide for
- 7:44the active participation of the public in landscape in the formulation of landscape plans and policies, so basically there's a state obligation to provide for public participation when it comes to landscape, and in essence that's what the landscape management plan from The Sperrins partnership does,
- 8:05because of course the landscape convention focuses on the principle of subsidiarity, and you know that landscapes, because it was born out of the work of the Congress and of local and regional authorities of the Council of Europe, but the plan, the the AOMB plan, management plan, it was based on
- 8:27an extensive 18 month consultation with a variety of of communities stakeholders across The Sperrins, and based on that, it produced a long term plan for the management of the AOMB, and that was, you know, based on identified values of the landscape, aspirations of the public, and objectives for
- 8:49its future. And it was a very democratic process, and a robust, a more robust assessment, and a more legitimate, and more extensive, and more representative assessment of The Sperrins A O N B for the purposes of identifying policy objectives and a management management
- 9:09plan, and I think that can be contrasted with the assessments conducted by the applicant, which are partial and relate to one particular project and are not place based or representative in any way, and it's not just me saying that. Of course, I mean this comes from the Council of Europe Landscape
- 9:26Convention, but it also comes again from National Planning Policy, the SPPS, so the Strategic Planning Policy Statement. Again, if we look at what it says in relation to areas of outstanding natural beauty, it says in paragraph 6.187, development proposals in AONBs must be sensitive to the
- 9:45distinctive special character of the area and the quality of their landscape, heritage, and wildlife, and be in accordance with the relevant plan policies. And then in the next paragraph, it says, in assessing proposals, including the cumulative impacts on such. Areas account will also be taken of the landscape
- 10:02character assessments and any other relevant guidelines, including AOMB management plans. So the management plan is actually given a footing here in national planning policy, and of course we have to consider that the plan and its vision for The Sperrins landscape is completely at odds with the proposed mining
- 10:24project. We also have to consider the public submissions that were made in relation to the application, which are in and around 50,000 at this stage. So there's really no democratic mandate for the project, and and the landscape is more than its Designations, but apart from the AOMB, I mean, okay. So apart
- 10:51from the AOMB, it is one of the most heavily designated landscapes on the whole island, and I've always said that for that reason alone, this project should never have been contemplated. We shouldn't be sitting here. It should never have got to this stage in the first place. But I do think it's
- 11:04important to mention that it's a lived-in landscape first and foremost, and it's actually this aspect-the human settlement-that gives this part of The Sperrins its identity and its essential character. And I have to say, I find it very disingenuous that the applicant is trying to use this human settlement as a
- 11:21justification for the project, so you know the applicant attempts to say, well, you know, there's human settlement here and land use here, whereas there's not as much development in the more remote parts of The Sperrins and Ergo. That's somehow makes it acceptable to have a mining project here. But
- 11:40that's a very strange logic. Logic when, in fact, the opposite is true. It's actually the human settlement, in addition to all of the designations, that warrants an outright refusal of this project. And we only have to consider the close proximity of the mine waste tailings or the
- 12:00what they're calling the dry stack facility to people's homes and the primary school, you know, which is in and around a kilometre, 1200 metres from.
- 12:09So the school is 1200 metres from the mine waste facility, and there are people's homes within a kilometre of it. In other jurisdictions, that wouldn't be lawful. So, for example, in China, you have a minimum distance between mine tailings and people's homes set to 10 kilometres, and the same
- 12:25in Brazil and other jurisdictions. So that's a minimum of 10 kilometres, and you know that that's as a result of various incidents of tailings failures with loss of life. So you know, and we've also seen recent examples of failings of tailings failures when they've been dry stack as well, and yet
- 12:52we don't even have an acknowledgement from the applicant that that's even possible, which is highly concerning when we're talking about a lived-in landscape, so, so yeah, I mean, so I suppose those are my main thoughts on the landscape sessions, and I think I think I'll leave it
- 13:14there. Thanks very much, Marella.
- 13:21And just to finish up, it's more than a little ironic that once we're discussing how best to hide it, to camouflage it, you might say, we've already accepted that this vast industrial complex should be there: the planting, the screening, the building colours, the buns, and reduced lighting,
- 13:47and that's uncomfortable. A designated landscape shouldn't simply be about finding clever ways to disguise what doesn't belong in it. The landscape itself has to be allowed to say this doesn't belong here. You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast, Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for
- 14:08joining us today. All the links you'll need, from campaign updates to our social media pages, as well as links shared by today's guests and resources mentioned in the conversation, are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares
- 14:27about protecting our land and communities. And don't forget to hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time, keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 14:47who protect them.