Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Morgan Stanley vs. BlackRock, Fannie Mae Blesses Bitcoin, & the End of DATs
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:20OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:28which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing. The role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All righty gentlemen.
- 0:52Welcome back to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:55Today is Monday, March 30th, 12:13 PM Eastern Standard Time.
- 1:02Gentlemen, how are we doing? Well, I was just wondering, how
- 1:07many weeks do we have to record this podcast at $67,000?
- 1:11Is there is, is there a time? Do we just, do we hang back?
- 1:15If, if people wouldn't mind, if they would, they wouldn't mind
- 1:18missing us for a week. Just comment, comment like and
- 1:21subscribe and then comment and be like, hey guys, don't.
- 1:23Don't kill yourself every week. Maybe there's, there's price
- 1:26thresholds where we unlock a new episode.
- 1:29So we, you know, we don't record again until we're over 70 and
- 1:32then maybe like 70. Two, there's things happening,
- 1:36but they're just less around. There's some stuff happening,
- 1:38Bitcoin and digital assets, but it's the broader world that is
- 1:42there's. We just got to be careful how
- 1:43much we cover there. Maybe people don't care.
- 1:46Yeah, beware of the algos like the It's tough to, it's always
- 1:51been tough to discern signal from noise, but I think it's
- 1:54particularly difficult over the past few weeks given everything
- 1:57going on in the world. But, you know, I think it was
- 2:01kind of a big week, Michael. We were, you know, in the group
- 2:03chat prior, prior to recording this morning really good.
- 2:05You know, it's kind of a slow week.
- 2:06Not that much happened. I kind of think some, some
- 2:08important things happened. So maybe we'll we'll jump right
- 2:11into it. This was a story from last week,
- 2:14which we've we've covered to some extent because this is sort
- 2:17of a compounding story, if you will.
- 2:20We knew about it a few months ago, but there's more and more
- 2:24information coming out. So this is Morgan Stanley
- 2:27entering the Bitcoin ETF race. And so this was announced a few
- 2:31months ago that they would be doing this.
- 2:33What we've talked about previously is effectively this
- 2:36is a departure from Morgan Stanley's typical sort of
- 2:41strategy that they're not a huge ETF provider.
- 2:43They don't do this often in terms of putting their name on a
- 2:46fund like this or product like this.
- 2:49And they are, you know, effectively going to compete
- 2:51with Ibid, Black Black Rocks Bitcoin ETF.
- 2:55And this came out late on Friday afternoon last week, that they
- 3:01would price the spot Bitcoin ETF at 14 basis points.
- 3:04So I think Ibid is 25. I think there's a few others
- 3:08that are maybe in the 20s, but basically this is now the
- 3:11cheapest Bitcoin ETF product on the market.
- 3:14So they're, they're undercut, undercutting the whole complex.
- 3:17And to me, this is a pretty strong signal that they they
- 3:21aren't playing around here. They're they're playing for
- 3:23keeps. This is this is game on in the
- 3:26sense that, you know, not only are they departing from sort of
- 3:30their typical strategy around products like this, but you
- 3:34know, they have their sort of everyone else has had a two year
- 3:38head start. So you know, I've been in
- 3:40particular is at 6070 billion in AUM as we sit here today.
- 3:45So they got some, they got some catching up to do and this is
- 3:47one way to do it just undercut them on fees.
- 3:50And this is also something we've talked about in the past around,
- 3:53you know these ETF wrappers if they're not super differentiated
- 3:56in any meaningful way, the ways you differentiate are
- 3:58effectively brand name distribution and then ultimately
- 4:02the free fee rate. And so I think that's exactly
- 4:04what we're seeing play out here. Thoughts guys?
- 4:08Yeah. I mean, I think this is
- 4:10fascinating. There's a couple things that
- 4:13come to mind. One is to your point, they're
- 4:15playing for keeps or they're they want to be a real player in
- 4:20this new digital asset world. I think we're going to have to
- 4:26have Chris Kiper on to talk about it.
- 4:28But I'd put them up with like Fidelity as the most
- 4:30sophisticated at this point. Now, I would still give the leg
- 4:32of Fidelity for being around 10 plus years building a lot of
- 4:36that platform out. But everything that we've seen
- 4:39and heard from Morgan Stanley is they're planning to play a big
- 4:42part and not only Bitcoin, Bitcoin custody, because they're
- 4:46not only just doing the ETFs, like they're fundamentally
- 4:48different than what Blackrock's doing in my view, because
- 4:51they've expressed that they plan to build custody solutions, spot
- 4:55Bitcoin buying. But the other thing that I think
- 4:58is really interesting is that they recognize, and this is part
- 5:01of why I'm saying that they're one of the most sophisticated is
- 5:04they're playing for keeps because it is the thing to play
- 5:06for keeps for that. If this asset is going to grow
- 5:08long term, you're going to monetize it way beyond just
- 5:12those 14 bits because you're bringing it into your platform,
- 5:15you bring it into your ecosystem.
- 5:17If you're going to inevitably and see that people will allow
- 5:19for delivery, well, what better way than to pull that asset at
- 5:2270 thousand $80,000, pull it away from BlackRock and then
- 5:26build other financial products, whether it's spot custody,
- 5:29because most of their significant their clients are
- 5:31sophisticated their high net worth private clients.
- 5:35They understand that they will want things above the ETFI think
- 5:38this gets lost on the market that the market may think, oh
- 5:43ETF will persist forever and it's just a Bitcoin natives that
- 5:48don't like it or doesn't make sense.
- 5:50It's like, no, no, the most sophisticated participants, the
- 5:52mortgage stands infidelities understand that their high net
- 5:56worth clients, clients that are worth hundreds of millions of
- 5:58dollars and have 10s of millions, if not hundreds of
- 6:01millions of dollars in exposure to IVIT will demand better
- 6:04products over time from assurances SM as there's a whole
- 6:06slew of reasons why they would want that outside of a wrapper.
- 6:10And the kicker is Morgan Stanley's a bank.
- 6:14And that's what obviously made this interesting, right?
- 6:16It's because it's the first bank to do it.
- 6:17But then the banking experience, when you're able to let loan to
- 6:22lending happen against that asset, mortgages just anything
- 6:27under the sun, they will be in a better place to monetize those
- 6:30assets. So it seems to make a lot of
- 6:32sense that a, you're able to undercut the market, still
- 6:34monetize it, but then ultimately bring those assets in.
- 6:37And that's, this is really probably just a cornerstone of
- 6:39their digital asset strategy. They have a lot of other things
- 6:41that they're working on. Yeah, well, sad.
- 6:45And I think the one thing that's being missed when considering
- 6:50this too is by building their own custody and house and their
- 6:53own system around digital assets as a whole, they're going to not
- 6:57have to outsource to Coinbase forever.
- 7:01Obviously they're using Coinbase for the custody and I believe
- 7:04some trade execution at the stage in the game.
- 7:07But being able to do it in house similar to I think Falcon Action
- 7:11bought Invesco and was able to bring that ECF in house.
- 7:16And so one, they obviously want to get as much assets under the
- 7:19platform as they can because that'll start to get them a lot
- 7:23more interest just with the asset holders as a whole.
- 7:29They were the first ones I believe from the very start when
- 7:32I bet started offering their ETF, they offered it to clients
- 7:36and and were able to solicit that when not all the other
- 7:39banks were being quite as digital asset forward.
- 7:42And so, yeah, I mean they also are willing to I this is
- 7:48speculation, but they, I assume that they're going to be losing
- 7:51money right at the beginning unless they are able to get a
- 7:55ton of new clients on the platform.
- 7:57And we haven't seen any firms out there that are from the
- 8:02traditional finance space take any sort of long time horizon
- 8:06view on the asset, in particular BlackRock, it was like their
- 8:09most profitable ETF year 1. And so, yeah, I mean, I think
- 8:13this is going to be a massive boom for the space and and the
- 8:17smart move by Morgan Stanley in particular and should be a a
- 8:21good catalyst for the industry that has locked one for the
- 8:23last, you know, four to six months with this launching in
- 8:27the next two weeks or so. Yeah, thanks for pointing that
- 8:32out. It does sound like this is going
- 8:33to be launching pretty pretty soon in the next few weeks,
- 8:37which is exciting. And then the only other things
- 8:39to to sort of reiterate and pull out and and muggily you
- 8:42mentioned this, but this is the first bank, real bank issuer.
- 8:45So if you think about BlackRock, Fidelity, these other Bitcoin
- 8:49needs, you have issuers, they're all sort of asset managers.
- 8:51They're not actually traditional banks.
- 8:53Morgan Stanley is the first real bank to be doing something like
- 8:56this and they have over 9 trillion in sort of client
- 9:00advised assets, which is just sort of mind boggling of a
- 9:04number. And they have 16,000 advisors.
- 9:09And previously to this announcement of this product,
- 9:12they have been they had sort of formalized a recommendation
- 9:16around crypto, Bitcoin, digital assets of sort of 0 to 4% in
- 9:21portfolios. And previously they were
- 9:24basically allowing their clients to invest in I bit or Fidelity's
- 9:29ETF within that sort of 0 to 4% band.
- 9:33And this move is effectively validation of there's real
- 9:36client demand there, but we no longer want to see those
- 9:39management fees to Black Rock infidelity.
- 9:42So we need our own product to capture those fees for
- 9:45ourselves. And so, yeah, this is this is a
- 9:48big deal. The other thing I'll point out
- 9:50is I think there's a fee waiver. So I think there's on the 1st 5
- 9:54billion, I believe it's no fee. And so another, another signal
- 10:01that they want to get strong sort of swiftly out the gate
- 10:03with this thing. Yeah, it, it sounds like this
- 10:07morning it just got approved. So I would expect it probably
- 10:09starts trading, you know, at least this week if not next.
- 10:14This is interesting from a market structure perspective of
- 10:17like demand, because I think retail buyers have historically
- 10:21chased price. And it's not to say that private
- 10:25wealth clients won't trace chase price and momentum, but they're
- 10:29a little bit more agnostic, especially if the advisors are
- 10:31able to solicit. And and it also ties into it's
- 10:36just a different buyer. Like you can imagine, you know,
- 10:39bitcoins always had this like platypus style appeal where has
- 10:42different properties and different value props.
- 10:44And they don't have to be long the dollar ending.
- 10:46They just have to be long, whether it's like tack or
- 10:50innovation or whatever, digital gold, whatever they put in front
- 10:53of them. It's just a different dynamic
- 10:55than Bitcoin needing to RIP to 110 before they step in.
- 10:58Now obviously people will step in there, but I do think it's an
- 11:00interesting component because we saw this happen with I bet and
- 11:04the demand that have been, you know, kind of latent until that
- 11:07product was released. Yeah, 100%.
- 11:10And and sort of as you mentioned, this is part of a
- 11:12broader sort of institutional infrastructure build out.
- 11:16So I wanted to switch over to this clip, Morgan Stanley's Head
- 11:20of Digital Asset strategy, Amy Oldenburg, talking about sort of
- 11:24some of the other plants. So I'll play this clip here.
- 11:28SEC. Even on the institutional
- 11:34security side, the one thing that we wanted to talk about
- 11:36today is turning on our dark pools.
- 11:39So our trajectory cross to support tokenized equities by
- 11:43the end of 2026. So this is happening this year.
- 11:46There's a lot of activity in all divisions and and we'll continue
- 11:50to power through 26 and then more to come in 27.
- 11:54Yeah, I thought this was fascinating.
- 11:55I mean, there's a couple of things.
- 11:56One is this team has been looking at this space for a very
- 12:00long time. Hopefully we get up there this
- 12:03year. But Brian and I attended the
- 12:04SALT conference. I think it was inaugural,
- 12:06inaugural 1 back in 24 and got a chance to sit down with Amy and
- 12:11really understand their level of not only sophistication, but
- 12:15just like thesis on where this market is and where value will
- 12:18accrue. And it wasn't around 1001 crypto
- 12:20currencies. It was around real
- 12:21infrastructure. And I think the after all these
- 12:25conversations, the way to distill why I find the
- 12:29tokenization aspect interesting and is like a Canary to where
- 12:34bitcoins growth will come from is that we all understand that
- 12:37the token just represents a claim on some something
- 12:40underlying somewhere else. It's the same way the dollar,
- 12:42the dollar still inflating and somebody still holding the
- 12:44treasuries. But there's a current arbitrage
- 12:47happening right now across legacy rails, right?
- 12:52Because that's all the dollar movement on stable points is, is
- 12:54like, OK, now anybody can build effectively like a neo bank and
- 12:57then it manages money movement in a more efficient way.
- 13:02In a great angle or anecdote to share is the MoneyGram CEO I
- 13:07guess was on a panel. Because this was.
- 13:10Explained from the guy was he was on a panel with during the
- 13:12DAS conference and he was saying that crypto Bitcoin tall scan
- 13:17but stablecoins are the best innovation he's ever seen
- 13:19because he was referencing that instant settlement he's had
- 13:23forever. The problem is he had to put up
- 13:24a $3 billion float to get that instant settlement and his
- 13:27stocks only trading at a couple billion dollars.
- 13:29So what he's effectively dealing is now able to leverage stable
- 13:32coins, go rebuy back his shares. But then he's starting to think
- 13:35about in the market of like, well, now if everyone can hold
- 13:38those dollars, do I give them a wallet?
- 13:40Do they generate interest? Can they spend on it, right?
- 13:42Like it just opens up these all these things that just didn't
- 13:45exist before. And so that's where I think the
- 13:47tokenization aspect will be interesting is regardless of its
- 13:50dark pools and the inefficiencies around moving
- 13:52those equities into whoever's authorized to participate there
- 13:56or if it's secondary markets or if it's private markets that
- 14:00have historically been really hard, any liquid, I'm not saying
- 14:02it's positive or negative. It is just a arbitrage on the
- 14:06inefficiency of the legacy system.
- 14:08And the problem is that the legacy system made a bunch of
- 14:10money via that bureaucracy and all of the, you know, 9 to 5
- 14:15whatever occurred where they built their moats.
- 14:17And so now because of the administration, a lot of the non
- 14:21commercial and commercial things we can say around the
- 14:22incentives, you're just going to have the firms that are willing
- 14:25to play ball and build on this new frontier.
- 14:27And it's it's kind of cool because they're doing it, but
- 14:30also anybody can do it. We talked about Alpaca as an
- 14:33example, a firm now that anybody can integrate equities into
- 14:37their market. You don't have to become a
- 14:38broker dealer. So I think it's just fascinating
- 14:40that they're looking at it. They see the market being
- 14:42disrupted and they're deciding to disrupt themselves before
- 14:45somebody else does. 100% All right, the other big story.
- 14:53Wait, wait. So before we move on to Morgan
- 14:55Stanley, so. Go.
- 14:57Go for it. Where do we think?
- 14:58William just accepted a job at Morgan Stanley.
- 15:00That's what I thought. That's what I thought he was
- 15:02going to say. Where do we think that the their
- 15:05ETF is in terms of AUM by the end of the year?
- 15:09If I bet at around just over 50 billion right now, just under
- 15:15800,000 Bitcoin held. Fidelity is just under 200,000
- 15:19Bitcoin and like 13 billion. Where do you guys think that
- 15:22Morgan Stanley's Bitcoin ETF is at the end of the year?
- 15:28I would say just shy of fidelity.
- 15:31Shy of fidelity. Yeah, I think for this year, I
- 15:35think it'll be I think the set the other part of the question
- 15:38William didn't ask, but. It's price dependent, right?
- 15:40To some extent. But is it?
- 15:43I kind of think it is like I think.
- 15:45Well, you could do it in each in Bitcoin terms then too.
- 15:50Yeah, no, I'm, I mean more like things accelerate rapidly in my
- 15:55mind if like the Bitcoin price is moving up as opposed to just
- 15:57chopping sideways for the rest of the year.
- 16:00But I guess like I, I guess maybe what Liam's asking and the
- 16:03the question is more of price stays 70 to 100K bound, how much
- 16:08demand comes from their 14,000 advisors soliciting?
- 16:11Right. Yeah.
- 16:13So I had rent some numbers last week and basically if you did.
- 16:17You ran the numbers. I, I read a few back of the
- 16:20envelope, back of the napkin numbers.
- 16:23If they, if their entire client pace allocated half a percent,
- 16:28it would basically be like half of IBET.
- 16:30So call it 3 to 400,000 BTC. If they did 1% double that.
- 16:37So basically rivaling IBET. Now their entire client base is
- 16:42not going to allocate right? Like that's, that's kind of
- 16:46probably not the way to think about it.
- 16:47But on average on sort of a look through basis, maybe they get to
- 16:53.25 to .5% because some clients are going to allocate 10/15/20
- 16:58percent and others are going to do 0.
- 17:01So I kind of think that they'll surpass Fidelity perhaps and
- 17:06start rivaling a bit towards the end of the year.
- 17:08One question on that from your experience, I mean for either of
- 17:12you guys, but mainly Brian because of being at the bank,
- 17:15what what would you say is the amount of flow like let's say
- 17:19Brown Brothers decided to launch an ETF.
- 17:22What percentage of flow that went from Brown Brothers
- 17:25accounts into I bit would move over into the native platform
- 17:32And then what percentage directionally would people not
- 17:36that get off 0 that had not because the advisor solicited?
- 17:40Yeah, great question. I think it's multifaceted and,
- 17:45and in some sense, you know, if I'm comparing it to, to what I
- 17:50saw, because it's, it's a perfect question because we had
- 17:53both external products that we brought into the platform.
- 17:56And then we also had internal products that were managed by
- 17:59Brown Brothers investment management arm that we would
- 18:03then sort of solicit to our private private banking clients.
- 18:07And the uptick on those was always greater than any of the
- 18:09external products because it was basically like, not only is this
- 18:13your best thinking from an investment perspective, but this
- 18:15is an in house product. Why would I not support what you
- 18:18guys are doing? The fees are typically lower
- 18:22than anything that we would have gotten external.
- 18:24And so all that is to say, the uptick is pretty high.
- 18:27Whether you know, it was even the external stuff that we
- 18:30recommend to clients, it was still because it was coming from
- 18:35our recommendation and we were soliciting to it like the uptake
- 18:38was call it anywhere from 50 to 75% on anything external.
- 18:44So there's, you know, maybe 1/4 of clients that would opt out of
- 18:47certain, certain funds or strategies.
- 18:50And then on the internal stuff, it was like probably closer to
- 18:5390% of like people are going to be allocated to those things.
- 18:55It's. Pretty bullish, especially like
- 18:57you got the backdrop of the fundamentals of Bitcoin.
- 19:00But then if you're saying well and it's also lower price by
- 19:04well that's about 50%. That's right.
- 19:06Well, I'll caveat all of those numbers I just threw out in the
- 19:09sense that you know what I'm talking about in terms of those
- 19:13recommendations. You know, it was all equity
- 19:15strategy. So it was things they were
- 19:16familiar with, right. It wasn't, it wasn't Bitcoin.
- 19:20So I think you could probably haircut those numbers by a
- 19:22little bit because it's Bitcoin and not something that every
- 19:25client is super familiar comfortable with.
- 19:28But yes, anything that's internal and being actively
- 19:31solicited is going to have a pretty high uptick, generally
- 19:34speaking. Yeah.
- 19:37I'm I'm going to forecast right around the Fidelity mark just
- 19:41because the new product, it sounds like some folks probably
- 19:45will immediately sell their IBET and buy MSBTC because they would
- 19:50have to lock in capital gains on that till, which is annoying for
- 19:54some folks who want to optimize for taxes.
- 19:58And then Fidelity just has all of their spot BTC too, which I
- 20:03don't know exactly how much they hold there, but I would imagine
- 20:05it's probably just about the same ish as their Bitcoin ETF
- 20:10that they cost today. So I'm going to go about where
- 20:14FBTC is like 200 to 250 KB TC. I know we've kind of been this,
- 20:20but one like other angle just to add is because it came across
- 20:25last week, but it continues to is there is a lot of holders
- 20:29like spot Bitcoin holders, self custody on ramp, whatever it
- 20:33might be. That won't put any retirement
- 20:35assets or any kind of like ETF assets into anywhere except for
- 20:39Fidelity. And they won't tell their their
- 20:42friends or family to go into anything other than Fidelity
- 20:45simply because of custody, because they look at Coinbase
- 20:47and they see a risk. And so that's just going to be
- 20:50something very interesting to watch play out because Fidelity
- 20:54again, maybe it wasn't as kind. They're probably the most if
- 20:57it's getting because they actually built out custody.
- 21:00And that is a real differentiator now.
- 21:04But then definitely in the future when risk comes out and
- 21:07you're just offloading and even Morgan Stanley had to do this to
- 21:09get to market as go through Coinbase.
- 21:12So I do think, I do think that's going to be a growing issue.
- 21:15We obviously have, you know, what we think will be the
- 21:17future, but I think that's going to be, it's going to be
- 21:21interesting also on because I've talked to ETF providers on like,
- 21:24and I don't know what the SEC response and, and pushback would
- 21:29be if they offered even in a like diversified custody
- 21:32arrangement similar to like I think Valkyrie or whoever.
- 21:35I think Valkyrie got bought, but at the time they were doing like
- 21:36Bitco and Coinbase that there's a reality like that.
- 21:40They could differ if they could to diversify because when with
- 21:45one of the firms or guys I was talking to last week, he's
- 21:48probably listening is his, he works with one of the ETF
- 21:51providers and nobody really knows about that.
- 21:53They didn't get a lot of flow. They focus somewhere else.
- 21:55But the point being is that it's a real differentiator to
- 21:58advisors. If you can be able to say like,
- 22:00oh, this is a different form of custody, like more assurances,
- 22:04but it's still early. But I expect that to pick up,
- 22:07especially when like most people forget, remember when Bitcoin
- 22:09got to like 120 people were freaking out about Coinbase
- 22:13because at the time it was Coinbase sitting on like 800
- 22:15billion in total assets. And so you have this honeypot
- 22:19and then you have, and most people don't understand the
- 22:21terms of service. There is no, there's no
- 22:23assurances, there is no insurance.
- 22:25Insurance is, you know, window dressing so well.
- 22:29It's going to be an interesting thing to follow to on custody
- 22:31and differentiation on a long enough timer. 100% and we will
- 22:35move on. Only other thing, William, to
- 22:37your point around cost basis, Morgan Stanley didn't start
- 22:41allowing their clients to invest in the other Bitcoin ETFs until
- 22:45like August 24. So it's unlikely that their
- 22:49clients have a cost basis around like 40-50 because by August, I
- 22:53think Bitcoin was well over where it is now or you know,
- 22:57607080 perhaps. So I would say depending on when
- 23:01those clients came in to the other ETFs, like I bet they
- 23:04could be underwater and it could make a lot of sense for them to
- 23:06switch into Gordon's product. OK, we are going to move on.
- 23:14The other big news item from last week we'll have a few
- 23:18Coinbase related topics, but this one is I guess somewhat of
- 23:22a +1 in the sense that they announced in tandem with Fannie
- 23:27Mae and a company called Better Coinbase Power is the first
- 23:32crypto backed conforming mortgages.
- 23:34And so basically, you know, in practical terms, what this means
- 23:37is you can now pledge your BTC for effectively a down payment
- 23:44on a home and set up a sort of Bitcoin backed mortgage, if you
- 23:48will. This is interesting from a
- 23:50number of aspects. I'm curious what you guys think
- 23:52I mean, to me the biggest take away is like, you know, why is
- 23:56this interesting? It's because it's, it's
- 23:58different than just taking out a loan and putting down a down
- 24:01payment in the sense that the terms are are sort of unaffected
- 24:06by bitcoins volatility. So there's some risk being taken
- 24:10by Fannie Mae and I guess better in some sense that, you know,
- 24:16you're not, you're basically, you're not going to get mortgage
- 24:19or you're not going to get margin called on this product
- 24:24like you would in a, in a typical Bitcoin back loan.
- 24:27So that's why it would be, you know, generally attractive to
- 24:29someone who's looking to buy a house, has a lot of Bitcoin.
- 24:33Now there's obvious draw drawbacks with this.
- 24:35It's cussed at Coinbase and so you have single counterparty
- 24:39risk with this and it's a a long, long duration product.
- 24:43So do you want to have your Bitcoin encumber that Coinbase
- 24:47for the next 30 years? Probably not, but curious what
- 24:51you guys think about this. Yeah.
- 24:56I think this is pretty fascinating and just big for the
- 24:59industry as a whole and for folks who don't want to sell
- 25:01their Bitcoin. It is pretty over
- 25:04collateralized. So I believe it's 40% Lt.
- 25:08VS. So it should be able to be able
- 25:12to handle some downturn. But I think in general, this is
- 25:18a really, yeah, what's to say, yeah, like it's Bitcoin price or
- 25:24the value of the mortgage is completely unaffected by
- 25:26Bitcoins volatility, etcetera. I think that this is big for
- 25:31folks who don't want to sell their Bitcoin and just Bitcoin
- 25:33getting cross collateralized further with other assets out
- 25:36there. It's interesting that Coinbase,
- 25:40despite, you know, posturing themselves as a everything app
- 25:45and, you know, spending a lot of time on sports gambling and and
- 25:48all Coin casino is really only pushing Bitcoin as and USTC as
- 25:54the two assets that they'll offer for collateral at this
- 25:57point, which I think just shows a little bit more on how
- 26:02different folks are underwriting the actual viability of a lot of
- 26:06these tokens long term. I think that this is a massive
- 26:10thing to see. I'm I'm just honestly surprised
- 26:13that this is such a big news through better.
- 26:15And it sounds like the rates are a good bit are higher than
- 26:20getting a traditional loan with other collateral outside of, you
- 26:25know, if you just have equities or cash or whatever.
- 26:29So I would just imagine that this market gets more and more
- 26:31competitive over time. There are more lenders who are
- 26:33willing and able to actually go out and do this as well.
- 26:39But great to see. Yeah, this is AI was working on
- 26:46a diagram to to pull up on this. I think this is huge.
- 26:51I think the net of it is we can get, we can hit the nail on the
- 26:57head in the sense of there's underlying market structure
- 27:01problems with like if you're going to trust Coinbase with a
- 27:0410 to 30 year collateral obligation.
- 27:09But the reality is we have to start somewhere And there's been
- 27:14a lot of wealth accumulated in Bitcoin.
- 27:17It's also interesting, right? It's Bitcoin is not a theory or
- 27:19Solana, but it's a lot of wealth accumulated in Bitcoin and the
- 27:24market has treated individuals with Bitcoin holding as like
- 27:28aliens. They don't want to work with
- 27:29them. I was actually just I had a lot
- 27:30of conversations. So I have a lot of anecdotes.
- 27:32I was talking to a client last week and he referenced that, you
- 27:36know, he's pretty long BTC and all different form factors,
- 27:40ETSIRAS, personal accounts, spot custody and he needed to buy a
- 27:44home and and he couldn't lend against his ETF holdings from a
- 27:50like the origination of that capital, right, because they
- 27:51want to see it in your bank account for a few months and
- 27:53then it naturally needs to come from, I think, depending on
- 27:56where the bank is. So they couldn't see it.
- 27:59They looked at I bet. So he effectively had to like
- 28:02spot sell axe hundreds of thousands of dollars to get his
- 28:05house right, because a lot of individuals listening, they
- 28:07probably know it's like it's generally a guy thing where
- 28:10you're like, look, I don't mind renting, but you know, your
- 28:12significant other wants you to buy a home.
- 28:14That's societal pressures, whatever it is.
- 28:16And so you have to really work through, you know, timing the
- 28:20market, the tax obligations, all the different things that go
- 28:24into it. And so the ability to, it's
- 28:28still relative. Like the big value props here
- 28:31are no liquidations. And then the interest rate are
- 28:35going to be, yes, higher than a standard conforming loan, but
- 28:38it's still lower than what the traditional market is the cost
- 28:42of capital for private markets when it comes to taking out just
- 28:45a Bitcoin loan. So you don't have that
- 28:47volatility risk of getting liquidated.
- 28:48You have a lower, you know, blended rate from the house
- 28:52mortgage. You have like 1 general, you
- 28:55know, mortgage or or monthly payment and you retain the
- 28:58appreciation. So you don't have to pay the cap
- 29:00gains and you retain the appreciation.
- 29:03If you're a long BTC, it's a real interesting movement.
- 29:08And then I guess the last part is that these mortgages that are
- 29:11issued by better are conforming. So Fannie Mae and the the powers
- 29:16that be, the government effectively will buy them, which
- 29:19allows for more capital to come in.
- 29:21Because if they were not conforming, then it gets more
- 29:24complex when it comes to who's going to buy those loans from a
- 29:27capital perspective. So it's very cool to see.
- 29:30I think this is just the beginning.
- 29:31We've been talking to folks that are looking to build things on
- 29:34the space, but for real sophisticated clients or people
- 29:38that understand, OK, this is great, but this is the V1.
- 29:40Do you really want long term Coinbase to hold those assets
- 29:43and you want anybody to hold those assets for 30 years.
- 29:45That's the real problem with custody is no custodians lasted
- 29:49X number of years. So to expect for a long duration
- 29:53financial instrument to be there for 20 or 30 years is, is still
- 29:56a question. You want to get that assumption
- 29:58out of the way. But either way, I think it's
- 30:01very good to see from a market structure perspective and just
- 30:03really like from, you know, triify realizing this thing is
- 30:07collateral, this thing does allow for people to buy homes
- 30:09and there's going to be a lot of banks, I think interested in a
- 30:11model like this. 100% very well said, got to start somewhere.
- 30:17This is a great V1, but there will be more.
- 30:20There will be more of this because it's a product that
- 30:22people need in a sense that to your point, there's been a lot
- 30:26of wealth created with Bitcoin and the the intuition is to not
- 30:31sell it because there's there's more upside ahead of it.
- 30:33So but people need to live their lives, they need to buy homes,
- 30:36they need to do things. So something like like this
- 30:38makes a lot of sense. OK, moving on digital asset
- 30:45roundtable, stablecoin segment of the show, Michael Stanford
- 30:47topics. We're going to talk a little
- 30:49clarity at I don't know how much new news there is here.
- 30:52It seems like we're continuing to sort of move forward in terms
- 30:55of this debate. Some people are mad, some people
- 30:57are happy. I think Coinbase with Jurid's
- 31:00support again and now save coin yield in Crypto Clarity Act is
- 31:05saying it won't allow rewards on balances.
- 31:07We've talked about this in the past.
- 31:09I think there's going to be basically a compromise, some
- 31:11sort of negotiation compromise around effectively A qualifying
- 31:16action, if you will. So they're not just going to
- 31:19allow you to have completely, you know, just stagnant balances
- 31:25doing nothing, earning these rewards.
- 31:28But if there's a qualifying action, there's going to be sort
- 31:30of workflows and, and workarounds to, to allow these
- 31:34things to, to pay quote UN quote rewards or stable coin yield.
- 31:38Maybe Michael, I'll hand it to you because I know you've been,
- 31:40you've been following this closely and, and what's the
- 31:42latest or, or how do you think this all shakes out ultimately?
- 31:46Yeah, I mean, it sounds like this has all been hanging by the
- 31:52thread of like whatever Coinbase wants to go because my
- 31:54understanding that Coinbase has been the one holding it up.
- 31:57It's, I mean there's, I haven't thought deeply about it, but
- 32:00it's kind of interesting that they are the ones holding it up.
- 32:04It sounds like from market participants, like people in
- 32:06this market, investors, builders, they just want
- 32:09something to be passed. They see the clarity as a strong
- 32:12sign for their business to move on.
- 32:14I think there's like this implied overhang of that once
- 32:19this, you know, is past, we're going to be in a better position
- 32:23for the price of digital assets or Bitcoin.
- 32:27But the the one of the learnings, and maybe this is
- 32:29obvious, but because Coinbase is the largest donator to the I
- 32:35forgot what the pact is on the political side is that the
- 32:38politicians can't afford or do not want to go or against or
- 32:43dissent to piss off Coinbase because they effectively pull
- 32:45that capital. That's my understanding of like
- 32:46why they hold so much weight. So yeah, I think everything's
- 32:50moving. And the exact same thing we
- 32:51reported on last week. I do think this probably ends up
- 32:54sooner than later simply because there's a lot of, I think,
- 32:57administration goals and incentives to get this in place
- 33:02for market forces. And so, yeah, I think my, my gut
- 33:06shot is that this is done by Q2. Yeah, I would imagine that there
- 33:13needs to get something done before the midterms later this
- 33:16year. And just because it seems like
- 33:19Republicans are projected to lose, Democrats seem to be a
- 33:23little bit less friendly to the digital asset space as a whole.
- 33:27So while this definitely isn't perfect and seems to, you know,
- 33:34not necessarily create the best outcome for consumers, is is
- 33:38typically the case they're they're likely will be something
- 33:41done and should be a catalyst for price. 2 two things just to
- 33:46to call out here 1 is I don't know why I was thinking about
- 33:50this this morning, but you know that whole term of like people
- 33:52say you don't hate the media enough.
- 33:54I don't think people hate the banks enough because if you
- 33:58think about it like the banks pay you nothing, they overdraft
- 34:02you, they charge insane interest on your credit cards.
- 34:06And this technology opens up to democratize.
- 34:10And then also further, because I don't think anybody questions
- 34:13that stablecoins will provide more efficiency and innovation
- 34:17for just like capital movement and they're against it.
- 34:21It's just so it's a pretty wild proposition.
- 34:24So there's that aspect and there's this other one where I
- 34:27don't know who this guy is. I think he's somewhere.
- 34:29I mean he has a dot E, but he has his term because WAP had
- 34:32brought something into their marketplace, which WAP is a
- 34:34standard, like, you know, technology marketplace for goods
- 34:38and services. He put what non crypto people
- 34:40don't realize is that crypto makes it a possible for every
- 34:43app and just put like dollars to become a bank and offer yield on
- 34:46balances, payments, investments and a lot more.
- 34:49Every app where people get paid, Instacart, DoorDash, Uber,
- 34:51etcetera, will become banking and brokerages.
- 34:53I think this is something that fundamentally almost everyone's
- 34:56missing. That's not really looking at
- 34:58this space because if you're Uber, DoorDash, Best Buy,
- 35:01whatever that gives gift cards, these are effectively like a
- 35:03similar mechanism where you can bring in, carry that float, pass
- 35:07it back as a customer acquisition or retain it for
- 35:10your balance sheet. And then ultimately you can
- 35:12start to build better. You know, it's a it's a newer
- 35:14design surface because now you can lend against it, move money,
- 35:17whatever it might be. And so I had this tweet above
- 35:20it, which was like, that's 100% correct.
- 35:23When value transfer doesn't have the legacy rail barriers to deal
- 35:26with, everyone that transfers value starts to look like a bank
- 35:28in fintech. And then this goes to the point
- 35:31of like, yes, it starts with stablecoins because people
- 35:33understand dollars. But if once they realize that
- 35:35the dollars is crushing them from an inflation perspective,
- 35:39then it ends with Bitcoin. And so that's why I really
- 35:43continue to like look at this innovative like surface area
- 35:47that stablecoins are bringing because ultimately, I think it's
- 35:50inevitable that it ends with Bitcoin and this is just the
- 35:53order of operations that had to take place or has to take place.
- 35:55Check out earlyriders.com for all the latest in Bitcoin
- 35:58investment research. Now back to the show.
- 36:04Very well said. OK, moving on.
- 36:09Few other headlines here. Big go quarterly earnings.
- 36:13Liam, I'm going to hand this to you.
- 36:16Any major takeaways since they IPO?
- 36:19The stock is down pretty materially.
- 36:21I think it IPO at around maybe 20 bucks a share.
- 36:24It's now at around 7. Not not too surprising given
- 36:30what the market's done since their IPO.
- 36:32But any any takeaways from from their latest earnings report?
- 36:37Not, I mean just one that's worth calling out is the
- 36:42compression of trade fees. You know, I think that they went
- 36:46from around 47 bits to 21. I think that as more and more
- 36:50folks come into the space is the ETFs just get thrown around as
- 36:54kind of high velocity. That's going to be something
- 36:57that's going to come down across the industry, especially for
- 37:01more institutional type players too.
- 37:04Outside of that, you know, they continue to grow their asset
- 37:08base. It's, you know, interesting.
- 37:11They obviously got the OCC charter and should be a massive
- 37:14boon for them just, you know, being one of the few
- 37:16institutional type players who has a banking charter.
- 37:21But yeah, I mean, they're, they're a little bit more
- 37:25resilient than some of the other players in the space who have
- 37:27gone public recently just because of the nature of being B
- 37:31to B to C having, you know, SAS like type revenues.
- 37:35But I think that just the nature of the market until there's
- 37:39something cleaned up with the the clarity and parity acts, I
- 37:43think that you know, publicly traded companies in the space
- 37:45are are going to be hit because of it.
- 37:49Yeah, I will see. The, the interesting thing to
- 37:52see play out is I think Belshi recently I saw a clip or
- 37:56something where he was like calling the IPO where we're at
- 37:59is like the V1, you know, first inning.
- 38:02And I do think that's fascinating to think about when
- 38:04we're still so early. And if you have this amount of
- 38:06assets, where do you monetize and how do you execute on them?
- 38:09It's going to be interesting to see that play out.
- 38:12You mentioned the banking charter, which obviously gives a
- 38:15lot of legal momentum and and regulatory momentum, but there's
- 38:22like an interesting dynamic on orchestration of stable coins as
- 38:25an example, where there's no shortage of people coming into
- 38:27the space and Betco's doing that.
- 38:29But I've, I was having, I forget who was having this conversation
- 38:31with, but it's like Stripe and bridge or stepping in a big way
- 38:34with tempo. And they understand that, right?
- 38:36Like they're not so old or old enough to be dangerous, but
- 38:40they're not too old to not want to touch this or be late, right?
- 38:43They did the bridge acquisition, they did the Privy acquisition.
- 38:46So you have them playing from the orchestration level and then
- 38:49you obviously have Circle and and Coinbase.
- 38:53So I don't necessarily know if Bico, where does Bico shine
- 38:56there? And they can, but there's other
- 38:57players doing it. So it's going to be interesting
- 38:59to just see where that monetization that growth comes
- 39:01from. But they have no shortage of
- 39:03different like diversified client base and then just
- 39:07treated like crypto assets in general that I, I just think
- 39:13it's going to be interesting to see where this plays out for the
- 39:15next 10 years. You can see the stock trade and
- 39:17be relatively flat and more of an infrastructure play or they
- 39:21can figure out how is it, where is the future of this stuff
- 39:23monetized? And then where are they going to
- 39:25offer direct B to C products? And then where, where are they
- 39:28going to go B to B to C? Because people stepping in to be
- 39:32that bank, to be that custodian don't want to build that out.
- 39:34And that's where they go to Betco for sure.
- 39:39Definitely agree first inning not you can't.
- 39:42You can't take too much from the stock price being down over the
- 39:46first few months when when Bitcoin price is done what it's
- 39:48done so well. She's playing a long game here.
- 39:51Obviously this one was. I'll be honest, I hadn't seen
- 39:55this next headline, but somewhat related in the sense that Gemini
- 40:01also went public recently within the past several months and
- 40:05stock price not doing too hot and they are being sued.
- 40:09So either of you, any any thoughts on this class African
- 40:14lawsuit against Gemini for basically misrepresenting the
- 40:19quality or trajectory of the business?
- 40:21I think it's what what's effectively being claimed here.
- 40:24Yeah. I think that, you know, there's
- 40:26two interesting points to pull out from this one.
- 40:29I have no idea if who's going to win or if they've said anything
- 40:33that was potentially misleading, but it sounds like they over
- 40:37like at least the lawsuit claims, yeah, they overstated
- 40:40the commitment and viability to growing to the platform post
- 40:44IPO. Financial plans were overstated
- 40:47and there was, you know, a potential risk of restructuring
- 40:52just given how loss making the businesses overall.
- 40:55I think that one thing to call is probably if if this is
- 40:59happening, there's it's definitely going to happen with
- 41:01a bunch of those dots that recently went public.
- 41:04And it's going to be interesting to see what's what ends up
- 41:07happening there, who ends up winning or losing that.
- 41:11But there was also just a shocking number of the losses
- 41:14are expected to continue to through 2029 for this business.
- 41:18The the company's been around for a while and would have
- 41:21imagined that, you know, prior to to going public, they would
- 41:24have done some, you know, getting fit.
- 41:27But just was kind of shocking that you know, if if you're just
- 41:32almost like a trading platform that we touched on earlier that
- 41:35that's not necessarily where the value is going to accrue long
- 41:39term. Yeah, I, I historically would
- 41:42not have much on equity research, but this brought up a,
- 41:46this made me think about a, a number of things.
- 41:49One of them is Gemini. It's always been understood they
- 41:51lack direction. Like if you go back to the
- 41:54genesis of that built that business, at least from my
- 41:57understanding is the Winklevi twins set it up because they
- 42:00were initially trying to launch an ETF.
- 42:01They needed a custody solution that got pushed.
- 42:04Gemini turned into a business and it's historically always
- 42:06been all over the place. It really had a lacking of
- 42:08leadership from a founding perspective and what it what it
- 42:12was ultimately. That's what happens when you
- 42:14don't fundamentally understand Bitcoin and ends up crypto and
- 42:16digital assets and and the rest. And so the question would be
- 42:21like, well, if that was the case and their books were always, you
- 42:24know, a little fragile, why would you go public?
- 42:27And this is kind of what we see in the status of the market,
- 42:30that it's not a fundamentals play, it's a momentum play.
- 42:33So the market was hot, everyone was going in and it and it's
- 42:36eerily similar to what Liam called out as the Dats because
- 42:39the Dats were all momentum and fundamentals or lacking
- 42:42fundamentals. And I expect to see more of this
- 42:46in the sense of eyeshock, like I saw without calling them out a
- 42:49dat. I don't know what had come up.
- 42:51It was something about their earnings being like completely,
- 42:53just completely missing the mark.
- 42:55And so I just put it in perplexity, I think because I
- 42:57think it has a little bit better analysis when it comes to like
- 43:00some of the research on the finance side.
- 43:02And it just chopped up everything that happened in the
- 43:05past quarter. And it was insane because they
- 43:06had all these promises on cards that were going to be delivered
- 43:09and usage and just everything the banking partners.
- 43:11And it was just like within seconds, like, no, they shit the
- 43:13bet on what they promised. And the point in sharing that is
- 43:17I think like, because those these tools are so close,
- 43:20there's going to be more people that are scrutinizing them when
- 43:22historically they'd have to go through these filings.
- 43:23You're going to have more lawsuits.
- 43:26And if anybody's just curious on any of their favorite dad, if
- 43:30you go look at it like a lot of these dads don't even hold a
- 43:33large percentage of what they went public with because when he
- 43:35went through this, it wasn't a filing.
- 43:37It was just breaking it down. It was like the lending
- 43:39mechanism to give them the Bitcoin was not really their
- 43:42Bitcoin. Then they had to puke it out
- 43:44because the debt couldn't get service.
- 43:45And it was just like this real hairy situation that nobody
- 43:48knows about. And if they knew everyone like
- 43:50that was involved would just be chastised by the industry.
- 43:53And so I just expect like this is part of that because they
- 43:57didn't necessarily have the direction it talks about in this
- 44:00dock or another one, how they had promised or generally when
- 44:03you see a growth company, you're going into emerging or external
- 44:06international markets and they're withdrawing from those
- 44:08markets like Europe and I think London or UK.
- 44:13And so, yeah, I think we're just going to see more of this.
- 44:15There was no real fundamentals. They obviously have this like
- 44:17crazy business where there's like 3 to 500 employees and
- 44:20they're not generally generating any kind of profit.
- 44:24And then the last thing I will say is I'll make a call.
- 44:26Gemini probably gets acquired by the end of the year because
- 44:29that's the thing. I was talking to a client of
- 44:31Geminis or has some Iris, some assets, I don't know what it
- 44:34was. And I was like, they're going to
- 44:36be OK. This isn't like a bucket shop in
- 44:38the sense that they're regulated by NYDFS, they're backed by
- 44:43founders that have billions of dollars.
- 44:44I believe in Bitcoin, and they do have a valuable asset in the
- 44:47sense that banks are interested in this infrastructure.
- 44:50So I don't think there's any worry on their assets.
- 44:53But from a fundamental like equity perspective, if you're
- 44:56buying them because you hope there's the stock's going to
- 44:58appreciate, it's the same thing in my mind is like buying a dat,
- 45:00like it's just tied to Bitcoin's price.
- 45:01There's no fundamental there. And if the price comes back,
- 45:03then their equity might have some left.
- 45:06But I do think they'll be acquired.
- 45:09I would be put a hard bet that in within the next two years,
- 45:14whatever that is, like 821 months.
- 45:16But but I think it'd be interesting it could see it by
- 45:19the end of this year. If the Bitcoin price doubled
- 45:21tomorrow, would you feel good about how it's being secured
- 45:23right now? Most people have not really
- 45:25pressure tested that. And I get it.
- 45:27I have talked to people who have self custody for over a decade
- 45:30and others who've stayed on exchanges because they could
- 45:32never get comfortable managing their own keys.
- 45:34Both camps have real concerns that is why we built on ramp
- 45:38multi institution custody so no single company can lose it, move
- 45:42it or use it. Lloyd's of London insurance
- 45:45inheritance planning built in and a team that can walk you
- 45:48through the entire setup. Get started in 15 minutes.
- 45:51Book a free consultation at on rampbitcoin.com on ramp secured
- 45:56by three controlled by me. Interesting.
- 46:02We shall see. Kind of in a weird way related
- 46:05to to everything we just talked about in terms of the DAP plays
- 46:10Bitcoin as a as a treasury asset.
- 46:11I thought this was kind of interesting.
- 46:13GameStop came out and reported that there was some rumors I
- 46:19guess a few months ago that they had moved some of their Bitcoin
- 46:22that they bought about a year ago to Coinbase Prime.
- 46:26People thought they were about to sell it.
- 46:27In reality, they're actually just doing a covered call
- 46:30strategy with the Bitcoin, which it's really interesting in the
- 46:35sense that like, you know, if you're trying to build a Bitcoin
- 46:39treasury and sort of do the quasi dat play, but then you're
- 46:44now capping your upside with these covered calls.
- 46:47And I believe the strike prices of the calls that they've
- 46:50written are around like 1:05 to 1:10 K for Bitcoin price.
- 46:57It kind of like defeats the purpose of like having the
- 47:00Bitcoin on the balance sheet in the 1st place because now no
- 47:04one's going to buy it for the long term sort of Bitcoin
- 47:06upside. They're just kind of doing this
- 47:08to, I guess generate some, you know, near term, quote UN quote
- 47:12yields some income on this stack, which is I guess
- 47:16interesting in its own right. But to me it kind of signals
- 47:20like they did it because there was a lot of pressure for them
- 47:23to buy Bitcoin with all the cash they had.
- 47:25And now they're kind of like questioning why they did that.
- 47:29And so they're trying to salvage it by getting some near term
- 47:31income. And then kind of giving up on
- 47:33the longer term upside for the asset.
- 47:38Yeah, I mean, the public markets are a vast man.
- 47:41Like, I don't know, we when you look at all this stuff, it's
- 47:44it's key. I was going to pull it up, but
- 47:46if you guys remember when whatever his name is, Ryan, I
- 47:50think the CEO is Ryan something came out and put put the Bitcoin
- 47:54on the balance here. Did that big $500 million buy
- 47:57and it was like during the Bitcoin conference last year and
- 48:00it was like a very not motivating like claim, right?
- 48:05And I think Parker had a tweet was like, this is not how you
- 48:08want your CEO to operate. They just bought 8 1/2 a billion
- 48:11in Bitcoin. He's like, we'll see if it,
- 48:14we'll see if it works out. It was the most tepid like
- 48:19pieces. And so, yeah, and so like, I
- 48:20mean, we were hard run enough so we don't have to go deep.
- 48:23But like these dats, everything's just grasping at
- 48:27straws that I see at because it's like we're going to put
- 48:29stretch on the balance sheet. We're going to do this.
- 48:32We have more BTC potentially per share, but we're still trading
- 48:36below. We're like everyone's down 80 to
- 48:3890%. And you know, there there is a
- 48:42real issue that doesn't get discussed enough around how many
- 48:46people are going along with it because they'll get sued to shit
- 48:51like just completely wrecked legally.
- 48:55Because like a good at mental model or just like not mental
- 48:58model, but a good thought exercise is like, how long does
- 49:05the price stay around here where these things trade below where
- 49:08they're at and people just start leaving to AI to whatever,
- 49:13right? It's like, so like what changes
- 49:16the price of Bitcoin goes up, you know, 2436 months.
- 49:21And the only thing I can think of that would keep people just
- 49:23hanging around singing about dats is that you're just going
- 49:27to get sued and you made some money.
- 49:28Maybe you didn't even make the money.
- 49:29But yeah, 'cause this GameStop deal is an exact example of it.
- 49:33To your point, they have like a fundamental thesis and they went
- 49:35completely against it. I don't even know what the
- 49:38strategy is there. It's like either puke it or
- 49:40don't. But now you're becoming like a
- 49:43like a hedge fund. Yeah, very, very strange.
- 49:46And you, you great, great transition.
- 49:49You didn't mean to do this, but people pivoting to AI.
- 49:53That's what Marathon is, is allegedly doing here.
- 49:56And we've seen this. This isn't like brand new in the
- 49:59sense that public Bitcoin miners have sort of been diversifying
- 50:04over the past couple years into AI data center infrastructure.
- 50:10And this is sort of just the latest development in that
- 50:13story, some marathon selling a bunch of Bitcoin to retire some
- 50:17debt and then really push heavier into the AI side.
- 50:22Yeah. I mean, the, the quick thing
- 50:23just to pull up here is this other tweet because I think this
- 50:26is like mining's not my Forte, but it's been largely
- 50:30understood. Yeah, this was great.
- 50:33That these guys are operating at a loss.
- 50:37I think it's a little small, but yeah, these guys are operating a
- 50:41loss. They're leveraging the public
- 50:42markets. You know, I think Fred Field
- 50:45made like $54 million last year. And this actually is really, you
- 50:52see this across the industry where people are subsidized by
- 50:55others, whether it's venture like here are the public
- 50:57markets. And it really hurts long term
- 51:01from the fundamentals like, you know, the, the right business
- 51:03will win. But short term, if you have
- 51:06people like a marathon or others being able to increase the hash
- 51:10rate, effectively making it harder for smaller miners to
- 51:14operate, it's not good. And I think our buddy, our buddy
- 51:23Boomer, what's his name from? Bob Burnett.
- 51:26Bob Burnett. Bob Burnett, he's been talking
- 51:29about this, yeah, for for a long time.
- 51:32And so anyway, the last thing to say is he goes back to just
- 51:36like, what are these firms? What do they really exist as?
- 51:39Why are they accumulating? Why are they leveraging the
- 51:41markets? I think they put on a lot of
- 51:42debt to be able to play the debt trade and have a largest
- 51:45holdings because the public markets were rewarding them for
- 51:48that. And now that that's no longer
- 51:50invoke, they're starting to keep this stuff out, which goes back
- 51:54to the main point of all of this is what goes up must come down
- 51:57if the fundamentals weren't there.
- 51:59And so if somebody deeply understands Bitcoin and wants to
- 52:01hold it, that's a completely different market structure and
- 52:05health of a market that people play in a short term game.
- 52:08Because yes, it feels good right up front, but ultimately it's
- 52:11going to end up in this just like sideways chop to down
- 52:15because people have to puke all this Bitcoin that they're not
- 52:18going to hold before we're able to, you know, go back.
- 52:21Yeah, I think the the GameStop trade is just, you know, what's
- 52:26hot at the moment. And then so becoming a dot was
- 52:29hot and then doing cover calls was hot.
- 52:32And then now they're just kind of pivoting away from that.
- 52:34And same exact thing with Marathon.
- 52:36I'm pretty sure that they, yeah, they, you know, issued a
- 52:40convertible note at 113 thousand Bitcoin in order to buy more and
- 52:44become a little bit more of a dot play then.
- 52:46And now AI is higher than Bitcoin, so they're selling some
- 52:51of their Bitcoin to return entire debt and move more into
- 52:53the AI space. I think it's unfortunately just,
- 52:56you know, what you see with this industry is a lot of, you know,
- 52:59I'm not going to say marathons kind of fly by night, but a lot
- 53:02of just kind of following the crowd and seeing what's hot
- 53:04rather than, you know, focusing on fundamentals too.
- 53:09Yeah, all well said. All right, guys, we've got maybe
- 53:1410 minutes or so left. Where do you want to go?
- 53:15We've got a few things on the list remaining.
- 53:18We could go to the latest Square Cash App moves.
- 53:22We could go to Tether audit. We could go to SpaceX, we could
- 53:27go to Coinbase gambling app. Where?
- 53:28Where do you want to go? I think we should give service
- 53:32to the square stuff. I hadn't followed as closely.
- 53:35I think my understanding is like they just basically turned it on
- 53:38for everyone now. So it sounds like Square just
- 53:41enabled Bitcoin for payment across all its different
- 53:45terminals. This went Live Today for the
- 53:48first batch of cohorts and they're turning it on in more of
- 53:51a phased approach across all of their merchants over the over
- 53:55the next month or so. And so yeah, it says on the
- 53:58screen all US sellers have been doing this automatically
- 54:03enabled, but sellers will could have been you know, because
- 54:06there was a few steps by default unless they want to turn on
- 54:08actually something that's Bitcoin and keeping it on their
- 54:11side. So it just dramatically sells
- 54:13it. I think it's just a great thing
- 54:16to see in terms of the increased knowledge of Bitcoin and having
- 54:21a get out into the wild a little bit more so than it already is.
- 54:25Unfortunately, the reality is many people just don't use
- 54:28Bitcoin for everyday payments at this stage.
- 54:31And so it's, it's a little bit early, but I like that they're
- 54:35pushing it out there. Yeah.
- 54:37I think the two big unlocks or the innovations happening here,
- 54:43the innovation, then the unlock, the innovation is that you can
- 54:48obfuscate the payment rails because this is something that
- 54:51you'll see more and more of like real category winners is just
- 54:55lightning bitcoins in the background.
- 54:57And you can provide whatever incentive, whatever process to
- 55:03effectively take in the Bitcoin sweep to dollars, bypass
- 55:09interchange, right? They're doing over lightning.
- 55:11And you can even do that in reverse.
- 55:12I don't necessarily know if that's like right off the bat,
- 55:14you probably have to turn it on. But if you can pay in dollars
- 55:17over lightning, auto convert to BTC or lightning without
- 55:21worrying about interchange, I think that that work stream and
- 55:25flow is something that will grow.
- 55:26And that's like real innovation on like technology perspective.
- 55:30The other thing is that you just have a market penetration around
- 55:34the amount of people turning it on with already within the user
- 55:37experience, meaning that there's already things like 10s of
- 55:40millions of people with Cash App and then there's 10s of
- 55:42thousands of people with the terminals.
- 55:44And so that's a big component. And then right now where the de
- 55:48minimis tax situations, you know, out there, this kind of
- 55:54like bypasses it because you're not effectively spending the
- 55:56Bitcoin, it's being transferred. No.
- 55:58I guess you're spending your Bitcoin if you're if you're
- 56:00there, but the the and the merchant doesn't have to work.
- 56:03If something happened to you tomorrow, could your family
- 56:05access your Bitcoin? Not probably not.
- 56:08They would figure it out with certainty.
- 56:11I thought about this a lot. You may feel confident managing
- 56:13your own keys, but are your loved ones?
- 56:16Billions of Bitcoin have been lost already because someone
- 56:18died without a plan. With Onramp, inheritance
- 56:22planning is built in directly into your custody setup.
- 56:25Your Bitcoin stays segregated and in your control, insured
- 56:28through Lloyd's of London and accessible to the people you
- 56:32choose when they need it. Get started in 15 minutes.
- 56:36Book a free consultation at on rampbitcoin.com On ramp secured
- 56:40by three controlled by me. Worry about it.
- 56:45Yeah, that's well said and probably going to be a stronger
- 56:49boon for, you know, getting to minimis tax exemptions on
- 56:53Bitcoin actually passed, although it's not looking like
- 56:56that's the status quo at this point.
- 57:00Do we want to touch on Tether? It sounds.
- 57:03Yeah, let's do it real quick. They they recently have signed
- 57:08up a BIG4 accounting firm to complete their first full audit.
- 57:12It is a KPMG Circle stock, I think was down 19% on the day
- 57:18that this was announced, although there was some clarity
- 57:20Action News announced on that same day.
- 57:24So wanted to turn it over to you for any thoughts on this one.
- 57:27Yeah. I don't have any broad thoughts
- 57:32because my understanding is Tethers worked or talked about
- 57:34getting an audit for a while. I mean, it makes sense that they
- 57:37need to get an audit if they're going to operate USAT in the
- 57:40United States and they're going to want some kind of
- 57:41credibility. I thought it was interesting
- 57:45that when they announced this Coinbase, it's not because of
- 57:49it, but it's just interesting timing.
- 57:50Coinbase took a a nosedive from an equity revaluation or their
- 57:54their stock I think went down 20 to 30%.
- 57:58They're they're also could be the component of the genius act
- 58:01and what does that look like from passing earn and then the
- 58:05growth of stable coins. But yeah, not much there I
- 58:07think. Yeah, I think the outside of the
- 58:11the audit is it's kind of like expected if you're going to be
- 58:13operating there. The the only other thing is I, I
- 58:16think we discount in financial services trust and brand and for
- 58:25better or worse in the traditional markets when it
- 58:28comes to USDC. And then even like Stripe and
- 58:30what they're doing with Tempo specifically with like paradigm
- 58:34that. Those are.
- 58:37The first two calls for firms building in the United States
- 58:39and we obviously know Tether has its emerging market and outside
- 58:44the US dominance, but I don't think an audit just naturally
- 58:49supports their now they have a balance sheet to establish
- 58:52liquidity and growth. But I think people just discount
- 58:56the relationships with, you know, the parties that are
- 58:59involved and the history that it just doesn't make it a foregone
- 59:02conclusion that capital markets will want to be moving around
- 59:05USAT when there's other options. Yeah, completely agreed.
- 59:11It'll be interesting to see. Obviously they've mostly seen a
- 59:14lot of demand from exchanges at this point, so we'll be
- 59:18interesting to see if you know some of the large players
- 59:21support USAT but imagine that they would go more towards
- 59:24circle, at least for AB1. Yeah.
- 59:27Do you want to pull up your? I didn't see it but I'm curious
- 59:30your thoughts. The most successful teams
- 59:32spending on AI? Yeah.
- 59:37So we can touch on this briefly, essentially.
- 59:50I can pull it up to you. Yeah.
- 59:52So this Ramp CEO or maybe CTO put out an article about just
- 59:59getting on the right side of the ice.
- 1:00:01And essentially, it's really about just how to.
- 1:00:06Leverage the latest tools that are coming out and the
- 1:00:08compounding gap that we've seen between those who are really
- 1:00:12focused on the space and, you know, doing as much as you can,
- 1:00:16doing more with less and actually adopting AI into their
- 1:00:19workflows. And the real gap was just the
- 1:00:24top 25 spenders of AI are growing their revenue over 100%
- 1:00:29since 2022 were the bottom, you know, 25% of AI spenders by
- 1:00:34company have kept pace with the US economy as a whole or
- 1:00:39slightly outperformed it and growing less than 20% of the
- 1:00:42revenue there. I just thought it was really
- 1:00:45telling. It's not necessarily, you know,
- 1:00:47a correlation that the best folks, if you spend more on AI
- 1:00:51that your revenues automatically get a grow.
- 1:00:53But I do think it's a testament to how those who are really
- 1:00:57forward link forward thinking or just operating at a different
- 1:01:01level than the traditional incumbents and how that's kind
- 1:01:04of translating into how they think about their entire
- 1:01:07company. And and the different, you know,
- 1:01:10increasing divergent between those who are, you know,
- 1:01:13outperforming and those who aren't as AI compounds things.
- 1:01:19Yeah, I think that makes a lot of sense.
- 1:01:23I mean, it's fascinating to see they have the data behind that
- 1:01:26in the growth. It's an interesting one.
- 1:01:30Like we should look at and trying to discern the the signal
- 1:01:34here because you can manipulate numbers obviously.
- 1:01:36But really looking at like the growth, the specific like
- 1:01:39anecdotes from the companies, because I don't even doubt this.
- 1:01:42I think like us being able to put, you know, let's call it
- 1:01:45five companies that were in this and then show where they're
- 1:01:49finding the growth and how they're leveraging these tools
- 1:01:52will be fascinating. I think this ties into the other
- 1:01:55tweet that was from I think he was the CEO of Stripe.
- 1:01:58And then there was a guy Carpathy or however he
- 1:02:01pronounced his name, that was, I don't know if he's a Co founder
- 1:02:04at Open AI, but it was basically the point of engineering.
- 1:02:07Like the biggest problems with engineering are generally around
- 1:02:12like DevOps, getting services, payments, databases, security,
- 1:02:15domain names. It's not actually the coding.
- 1:02:18And so when you think about agents in just this new world,
- 1:02:23you can just see how so it's not even squints anymore how you're
- 1:02:26going to need to track transfer value online.
- 1:02:30And while we've been talking to me personally about stable coins
- 1:02:32and yes, that's going to be the V1, I think that on a short
- 1:02:36enough time frame, not even long enough, you're really going to
- 1:02:38see emergence around some level of Bitcoin.
- 1:02:43Now, I don't know what it looks like.
- 1:02:44If it's lightning, you're just thinking out loud.
- 1:02:47It could even be something like Spark where you have this own
- 1:02:50like side chain that's for AI. And because a lot of these firms
- 1:02:53you're still going to have, for better or worse, embedded
- 1:02:57governance in KYC. Because you can imagine like if
- 1:03:00you need to set up a bank account for whatever reason and
- 1:03:03you have a Bitcoin, a native firm like Arab or like you still
- 1:03:06have compliance and reasons why you need to know who like that
- 1:03:09agent's tied to on the behalf If you if recourse or whatever
- 1:03:12happens. And it's a little harder, but
- 1:03:13it's just a Satoshi that's not necessarily tagged to any money.
- 1:03:16Well, the point being is that this is somebody that's deep in
- 1:03:19the domain expertise of engineering explaining that
- 1:03:22engineering has historically not been the hard part.
- 1:03:24It's the dev OPS around tying and stitching the whole thing
- 1:03:27together. And you need native value to do
- 1:03:29that, to incentivize that coordination.
- 1:03:32And I thought that's just super fascinating because we're just
- 1:03:34going to see that side of the market emerge, while Bitcoin's
- 1:03:36value or value, profit and store value will also continue.
- 1:03:42Super interesting sorry, I cut out earlier gentlemen, I'm I'm
- 1:03:46I'm confident you guys did did justice to the to square block
- 1:03:50deal, but that was that was big news.
- 1:03:53Did you see this, the second Miles tweet around actual buyers
- 1:03:58being able to toggle on Bitcoin payments as well?
- 1:04:01If someone had asked, someone had sort of replied to what was
- 1:04:03announced this morning being like, is there a reason you guys
- 1:04:06decided to make the Bitcoin payment selection on the payer
- 1:04:09side or to not do that? It would be way better you'd ask
- 1:04:13if the payer didn't have to ask the merchant to pay in Bitcoin.
- 1:04:17And Miles responded to that basically saying coming soon.
- 1:04:20So basically now both sides are going to be able to toggle on
- 1:04:24Bitcoin payments if they'd like. Yeah, that's what we kind of
- 1:04:28talked about the innovations really like the lightning
- 1:04:30working in the background to obvious gate either direction.
- 1:04:33So yeah, it's pretty, it's pretty bullish if you want to,
- 1:04:38if you're a Bitcoiner trying to accept payments or if you just
- 1:04:41understand that all of the economics on interchange get
- 1:04:45better. Because theoretically you could
- 1:04:46take the dollars and convert it to Bitcoin, then convert it back
- 1:04:49to dollars. So use those rails.
- 1:04:52I know we're coming up on time. Do you want to just do the
- 1:04:54Coinbase and the IPOI don't even know if there's a direct link.
- 1:05:00I think there was just a main theme of we're going to be in
- 1:05:05this like counterculture world of the people that are building.
- 1:05:09It's part of like discussing a lot of the fundamentals or lack
- 1:05:11of fundamentals with these companies is when we look at it
- 1:05:13from an investment perspective, what are the things delivering
- 1:05:16value to the world? Where is the unit economics that
- 1:05:18are going to persist because you can in short run, maybe make
- 1:05:21something that's shiny get, you know, investment.
- 1:05:25There was a recent one like I think it's FXF or XFFX.
- 1:05:29It was like a cross-border payments for like easy stable
- 1:05:32coins for FX, which they could build a a great business.
- 1:05:36It's just like, well, what's the Moat there?
- 1:05:38And like, what's the differentiation?
- 1:05:40And point being is that you see all these different firms and
- 1:05:44it's very heavy, heavily leaned into velocity and gambling.
- 1:05:49And so you seen Coinbase, you see all over Twitter were there
- 1:05:52across the board putting up, you know, gambling as it relates and
- 1:05:57I guess is with Kelsey, I think their relationship is for March
- 1:06:01Madness, but it's across the board, whether it's like, you
- 1:06:04know, banks not giving you interest, charging you insane
- 1:06:07amounts around on your interest or credit cards.
- 1:06:10The Robin Hood example, the IP OS that are getting pushed like
- 1:06:13the SpaceX versus what are the firms that are just helping you
- 1:06:18from a financial literacy, saving, preserving, growing your
- 1:06:21wealth. It's pretty bullish for what
- 1:06:24we're building. Because I think like when we
- 1:06:25talk to clients, they it really resonates with them.
- 1:06:27They appreciate it. They even appreciate that we
- 1:06:29talk about the Dats because I think that they suddenly know
- 1:06:33maybe that this isn't a long term thing.
- 1:06:36And so I think this is just a microcosm for what's what's
- 1:06:39happening. But I think the long term firms
- 1:06:41that persist are going to realize they have to take care
- 1:06:43of their client and not put them into these things.
- 1:06:45So it's just playing long term games and the reality is fast
- 1:06:47money, you know, creates kind of more of a higher time preference
- 1:06:52society. Yeah, 100%.
- 1:06:54The only thing that I would add to that is like, it's also a
- 1:06:58function and a reflection of broken money of the Fiat
- 1:07:02monetary system that we are in this place where people are so
- 1:07:06short term, short term oriented and financially nihilistic that
- 1:07:12they do feel the need or the expectation to go gamble to, to
- 1:07:18get ahead or, or get out from, you know, under a bunch of
- 1:07:21credit card debt or whatever it may be student loan debt.
- 1:07:24That is always that is all downstream of the money being
- 1:07:27broken to some extent. And so in that sense, it's not
- 1:07:32entirely surprising that that's where we are in terms of whether
- 1:07:36it's Coinbase or DraftKings or Robin Hood all sort of becoming
- 1:07:40the same thing, which is super short term thinking, gamble your
- 1:07:45way out of this, make it big. This is basically how you, this
- 1:07:50is your only way to escape the permanent underclass type
- 1:07:52thinking. That is unfortunate.
- 1:07:55That's where we are. And so yes, to your point, like
- 1:07:58we try to focus on being the opposite at on ramp.
- 1:08:00And, and particularly when we talk about Bitcoin and the
- 1:08:02investment thesis around it, it's savings technology, It's,
- 1:08:06it's, you know, on the other side of speculation, it's how
- 1:08:09you actually plan long term until you think long term.
- 1:08:13And so we need more of that in the market, Needless to say.
- 1:08:16100% and especially anybody who is consumer facing should be
- 1:08:21thinking about their consumer more than anything else long
- 1:08:24term. And we've talked a lot about the
- 1:08:26needs for especially like dev OPS and B to B to CAI
- 1:08:32development tools that are coming out now and marketplaces
- 1:08:34around that. We've seen a ton of nice
- 1:08:36adoptions or applications and and emails from founders to the
- 1:08:41stables kind of focusing on those sorts of things.
- 1:08:45So yeah, I just want to shamelessly plug the early
- 1:08:48riders is running an accelerator for, you know, for giving seed
- 1:08:53investments to folks who are, you know, really focused on, you
- 1:08:56know, everything that we're kind of mentioning today of helping
- 1:09:00out the consumer long term rather than pushing them into
- 1:09:02financial nihilism and making it easier for the agentic economy
- 1:09:07and businesses to create value long term.
- 1:09:09So if you if that's you and you're interested, please apply
- 1:09:13to earlyriders.com/staples. Good stuff.
- 1:09:18All right. Thank you, gentlemen.
- 1:09:20See you guys next week. Good stuff, guys.
- 1:09:23Thanks guys. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:09:27week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:09:29valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:09:32rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:09:34All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:09:36notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:09:39reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:09:41entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:09:44investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:09:47your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:09:50Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:09:54one of our private Client Advisors.