Latest / Politics with Paul / How We Can Start Fixing Political Apathy w/ Travis Taylor | Politics with Paul #108
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the politics with Paul podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Raider.
- 0:08It's another consecutive guest episode.
- 0:10And for those, I always add a disclaimer that I do not take a stance for or against the guest's
- 0:14political views or people they support, but topics are always something that anybody of any
- 0:19political view can learn something from, especially this topic.
- 0:23Because apathy about politics is always a looming threat to democracy, and that's one of
- 0:28the main themes of this whole podcast.
- 0:30Even the nation's founding fathers warned about citizen indifference to what occurs in
- 0:35government related functions, such as when Benjamin Franklin described our system of
- 0:39government as a republic if you can keep it.
- 0:43Today might be the worst that apathy has ever been.
- 0:45But why do we see so much apathy, and what can we do about it?
- 0:49Well, today's guest, doctor Travis Taylor, is here to discuss those very questions.
- 0:54Travis is a public opinion analyst, research consultant, and the author of a new book titled
- 0:59democracy in action, how citizen apathy threatens America and what we can do about it
- 1:04with in in the word inaction being in brackets.
- 1:07He is also the senior market manager for the foundation for government accountability and
- 1:11previously served in the US army as a combat medic.
- 1:14Thank you for your service.
- 1:16So Thanks for your support.
- 1:17Get his absolutely.
- 1:18So let's get his insights from his book and more about public opinion and civic involvement
- 1:23or lack thereof.
- 1:25Please welcome doctor Travis Taylor to the show.
- 1:27Travis, thanks for being here.
- 1:28How are you?
- 1:29Paul, I'm doing great.
- 1:30I appreciate the opportunity to have this conversation with you.
- 1:34Absolutely.
- 1:34I I appreciate you coming on to talk about it.
- 1:36So before you got into this work with the book and the survey research and everything, what
- 1:40got you into studying this subject of political apathy and polling?
- 1:45So it's, I took a kind of a a long circuitous route to where I am today.
- 1:52As you mentioned, I I was an army medic.
- 1:54I started in the army right out of high school, spent four years in the army, including time
- 1:59with the storied hundred and first airborne air assault division at Fort Campbell, Kentucky.
- 2:04The band of brothers, for those listeners and, watchers your in your audience who might be
- 2:12familiar with with that series, that was based on the hundred and first airborne division.
- 2:16So I spent some time there.
- 2:18I got out of the army, spent some time in law enforcement, and continued my work as a medic
- 2:23in the civilian sector.
- 2:25And it was during my time in law enforcement that I thought I wanted to go to law school,
- 2:30and so I started looking into law school and, you know, figuring out where I wanted to go,
- 2:35and what schools I I had a realistic shot of getting into.
- 2:39And, during that process of law school, I realized that you have to go to college first.
- 2:47And I my parent neither of my parents went to college.
- 2:51I'm a first generation, college graduate, and so I just didn't know this stuff.
- 2:55Right?
- 2:55And so I started attending a community college.
- 2:59I was paying for school out of pocket.
- 3:02Went to community college, ended up getting my my bachelor's degree.
- 3:06And during my undergraduate years, my pre law adviser who was an attorney, went to law
- 3:13school, clerked for a federal judge, spent some time in private practice before he got his PhD
- 3:18and and started teaching, talked me out of law school.
- 3:22And so I I heeded his advice, in steering away from law school, but then I wasn't really sure
- 3:31what I was going to do.
- 3:33And I was taking a campaigns and elections class and started volunteering for a
- 3:38congressional campaign and really fell in love with politics.
- 3:43And it was something that I'd always kind of been interested in, even back in high school,
- 3:47taking a street law class, my, like, sophomore junior year of school with coach Stan King.
- 3:56So shout out to coach King for kind of shaping my interest in in where I am today, but, you
- 4:03know, had this interest in politics and never realized that it was a a viable career path
- 4:09until I I got into college and started doing it.
- 4:11So went on to manage campaigns.
- 4:13I worked on Capitol Hill.
- 4:14I worked in a state legislature.
- 4:17I worked at a consulting firm doing direct mail and TV for congressional and gubernatorial
- 4:25candidates and state legislative candidates and a lot of outside interest groups.
- 4:30And during that time, worked on my first master's degree in political management and
- 4:37discovered that I had this passion for teaching, and so continued teaching in an
- 4:42adjunct role for a little while before deciding to pursue the PhD.
- 4:46So I went and got my PhD.
- 4:47While I was there, I I studied judicial politics and state politics and public opinion.
- 4:53And when I was finishing up my PhD, the academic job market was, and as far as I know,
- 4:59it kinda still is, a dumpster fire.
- 5:02And so ended up in, in what we call industry, right, a non academic career, working for a
- 5:10market research firm.
- 5:12Worked in traditional market research for a little while, asking people about what shampoo
- 5:17they use and why, you know, what features they would like to see in their credit card, and why
- 5:22those features are important to them, and just kind of got tired of it.
- 5:27And those were important things to understand for for the clients, but it just the passion
- 5:32wasn't there for me.
- 5:33And so, a job at FGA, the foundation for government accountability, opened up in their
- 5:39market research shop, and I applied.
- 5:42And I've been there ever since.
- 5:43I've so back into politics and public policy, just using those public opinion skills in that
- 5:49role.
- 5:50And in addition to that, doing some consulting work, for attorneys, and other trial
- 5:56consultants who are trying to understand a litigation, trying to understand their case a
- 6:03little bit better and how people view that.
- 6:05So kind of a long circuitous route to where I am today.
- 6:09Neat.
- 6:10There there is a little bit of similarity in in the to me in the sense that I actually knew
- 6:16when I went to college that I wanted to do something in politics.
- 6:19I was already studying political science.
- 6:21I didn't really know what exactly it was I wanted to do, and I figured out towards the end
- 6:25there that I really just enjoyed the educational side of things.
- 6:28Now not the more formal education where actually being a professor.
- 6:31I'm I like it more like in this kind of this kind of scenario.
- 6:36I I guess you could call it an informal way of Right.
- 6:39Describing it.
- 6:41But why write democracy in action?
- 6:44Who are you trying to reach most with the book, and why do they need to read it?
- 6:48Yeah.
- 6:48So I I've been joking with people a lot lately that I I wrote a book where the intended
- 6:54audience has no interest in reading the book, and that's a weird place to be as an author.
- 6:59But I I got the PhD, as I said a minute ago, because I love to to teach.
- 7:05And so I wrote the book for for three reasons.
- 7:07First is to educate people.
- 7:09There's a lot of educational content in there.
- 7:11You know, people may know that there are three branches of government, and they may know what
- 7:17those branches of government are, but they may not know why we have a, for example, a jury
- 7:24system that's set up the way it is.
- 7:26They may not even know that the jury system has its roots in the declaration of independence.
- 7:30We just celebrated our two hundred and fiftieth, anniversary of the declaration of
- 7:34independence, and in that declaration of independence was this long list of grievances
- 7:39against the British crown, and one of those was that he was depriving American colonists of the
- 7:44right to trial by jury.
- 7:45And so we've got this long storied history, and so there's just a lot of information in there
- 7:50that's educational.
- 7:52Because I'm no longer in the classroom, the pages of that book became my classroom.
- 7:58So rather than four walls, it's 200 pages of educational content.
- 8:05Kind of guiding people into an understanding of how our government is set up, why it's set up
- 8:11the way it is, and why their participation in it is so critically important, which leads me
- 8:17to the second point of the book, and that's just to encourage people.
- 8:21As as you said in the opening, we're we're at a point in American history where apathy has
- 8:27really taken root, and it's it's troubling for as the Franklin, whether Benjamin Franklin
- 8:37actually said that is up for a lot of debate.
- 8:40It's kind of apocryphal.
- 8:41But regardless, like, it's a great quote because that last part of it, if you can keep
- 8:47it.
- 8:47Right?
- 8:48We we are a country rooted in citizen participation from the Boston Tea Party and
- 8:56protests to a a war for independence, all the way up through, you know, we we fought this
- 9:05civil war, that was, rooted in this disagreement of government and, you know, this
- 9:11really nasty kind of, unfortunate type of citizen participation, but still, you know,
- 9:18that participatory act up through the the anti war protests of the sixties and the pro
- 9:25democracy protests of the seventies and the pro life movement starting, you know, in the late
- 9:31seventies, early eighties, the way up through the Dobbs decision a few years ago.
- 9:35So we've seen this.
- 9:36We're a country rooted in participation, and I wanna make sure that we preserve that.
- 9:43Right?
- 9:44The the Franklin quote, if we can keep it.
- 9:46The if we can keep it is really up to us, and so I just wanna encourage people to participate
- 9:51in our democracy, and not only in voting, but in a in a number of ways that that I'm sure
- 9:57we'll talk about over the next, hour or so together.
- 10:01And in that spirit, at the end of every chapter, I I have a list, kind of baby steps.
- 10:06Right?
- 10:07For people who've never been engaged or people who have been out of the game for a long time.
- 10:11They're like, I don't even know how to get back into it.
- 10:13Just some baby steps that they can take to to get engaged in small and and but but still
- 10:19significant ways.
- 10:21So to educate people, to encourage them, and the third reason, I'm a PhD, and we're we tend
- 10:26to be nerds, and sometimes we just can't help ourselves.
- 10:29So there is, some original research in there that that would appeal to more academic
- 10:33audiences, but they're not the primary target of this of this book.
- 10:38I I think that they could take some of of my learnings and apply it to future research, but
- 10:43the the book really is for the average citizen who, who doesn't understand why their
- 10:51participation is so important and doesn't know how to get engaged.
- 10:55I can empathize with all those points, and I I see I I have a lot of those same values in what
- 11:01I'm doing too is, you know, it's that how do you reach people that are oftentimes not
- 11:07invested in politics?
- 11:08And I kinda wanna give people an outlet for that, but also the people who are more invested
- 11:14in politics, try to give them a different angle to look at things.
- 11:18And like you, I wrote a book almost five years ago now, and I'm in the midst of writing
- 11:24another one, but it's about political independence.
- 11:27And it was it's definitely not aimed towards an academic audience even though I think a lot of
- 11:31academics can get something out of it because it's an area that's not very well understood.
- 11:36And even citizen apathy too.
- 11:39I mean, I mean, obviously, there's a lot of research into that as well, but, you know, it's
- 11:44it's a it's a hard code to break because, you know, most people, if they're apathetic,
- 11:50they're just generally just not gonna participate.
- 11:52But every once in a while, sometimes they do, and it's it's sometimes you gotta dig deeper
- 11:57into why that's the case.
- 11:58And then like you said, give those little baby steps at the end that people can employ in
- 12:05their lives.
- 12:06Speaking of which is a good segue into this next question because voting is the most
- 12:09obvious and perhaps the most direct way to get involved in politics and civics, but your book
- 12:15focuses on more than just that.
- 12:17And you touched on a couple of those points already.
- 12:19But can you describe a couple of these other areas where there is a concerning lack of
- 12:24public civic participation?
- 12:27Yeah.
- 12:27That's a great question.
- 12:28So each chapter in the book addresses a different a different topic, a different way
- 12:34for people to get engaged.
- 12:37One of them is contacting elected officials.
- 12:40I I used to work, as I said, on Capitol Hill as a legislative correspondent, which means that
- 12:44when the people in the member that I worked for in his district, when they would contact our
- 12:51office, I was the one seeing those.
- 12:53Right?
- 12:53I was the one sorting through the mail, reading through the emails, answering the phones.
- 12:58And so that was a way for people to let their elected official know in real time what they're
- 13:08thinking about legislation that's pending or about what's going on in Washington.
- 13:14It was much the same way when I worked in the state legislature.
- 13:16I worked in in the district office, and so, you know, I got to, talk to constituents on an
- 13:22almost daily basis, everything from, trying to help, you know, business owners figure out what
- 13:29the holdup is at the you know, at some bureaucratic, agency in the state capital, like
- 13:34what's going on with this permit or or, you know, things like that, all the way up to,
- 13:39helping them, how do I put this delicately?
- 13:42Take care of a ticket that they received from the state police.
- 13:46And so, like, there were all of these constituent services that that, that we
- 13:50performed, but it was all about the people contacting their elected official.
- 13:56And what what I find really interesting about that is in political science research, there's
- 14:03there's this long, this long lineage of of studies that shows that the best way to get
- 14:11people engaged in voting is retail politics.
- 14:15Right?
- 14:15It's shaking hands and kissing babies.
- 14:17It's knocking on doors.
- 14:19It's meeting voters where they are.
- 14:22You know, it's phone calls direct like, actual phone calls, not robocalls, actual phone calls
- 14:28from a, from the candidate him or herself or from a supporter, especially if that supporter
- 14:34knows the person they're calling.
- 14:35It's this retail politics that really drives electoral engagement.
- 14:42Once that official moves from campaign mode to governing mode into their official office,
- 14:49carrying that type of retail politics through is really important.
- 14:55But when you're a member of congress representing a district of 700,000 people, or
- 14:59you're a a US senator from Montana representing, like, you know, 1,200,000 people,
- 15:05or from Oklahoma representing 7,000,000 people, or California representing, like like,
- 15:1052,000,000 people.
- 15:11Right?
- 15:11There's only so much retail politics you can do, but those elected officials who really
- 15:18understand the representative nature of their job care about constituent services.
- 15:25They care about what people have to say when they call.
- 15:29And I saw that firsthand both at the state level and at the federal level.
- 15:33When you've got a member that cares about what people have to say, they wanna hear from them.
- 15:39And so that's that's a great way for people to get involved is to pick up the phone, go to
- 15:44their website and send an email, send them an old fashioned letter.
- 15:48Like, there are ways to to get involved.
- 15:50Another and I'm upholster, and so, you know, I have a soft spot.
- 15:56Chapter three of the chapter on responding to polls is the longest chapter because I there's
- 16:02so much misinformation and disinformation and a lot of hate on polls in the popular media right
- 16:10now.
- 16:10And so I I spend a lot of time talking about polls and and how they they're not a perfect
- 16:15science, but what they do have is a real purpose.
- 16:20And I I think in the light of of the news of the past couple of weeks, it should go without
- 16:27saying, but let's say it anyway, real polls have real respondents.
- 16:33That means that when you get that call, at dinner time and it's super inconvenient, or you
- 16:39get that text message of, we're right in the middle of a primary runoff season here that's,
- 16:45been blowing up my phone with with political polls recently.
- 16:49When you get that opportunity to, add your voice to this chorus of other Americans to let
- 16:58elected officials know what you're thinking, take that opportunity, you know, because in
- 17:04order to have a a good poll, you have to have a representative poll, which means you have to
- 17:10have a certain number of of Democrats and Republicans and independents responding.
- 17:15You have to have this right balance of men and women, and you have to have this right balance
- 17:19of working class and college educated voters.
- 17:21So you've got all of this all of these kind of cells in a grid that a pollster has to fill
- 17:26out.
- 17:27And each one of those cells isn't just a cell in a in a spreadsheet.
- 17:31It's the voice of an American that needs to go into that cell, to share their views on public
- 17:38policy and governance and politics in America.
- 17:42The the third way, getting out of jury duty has achieved mockumentary status.
- 17:49Right?
- 17:49Like, there's a there's a mockumentary on Netflix about, it's it's all about how to get
- 17:55out of jury service.
- 17:56When I when I started writing this chapter, you know, failure to appear rates are are not
- 18:03widely reported.
- 18:04Right?
- 18:05There's no master database.
- 18:06Even, the National Center for State Courts, which is a fantastic organization that has a a
- 18:12a jury, the center for jury studies, think is what it's called, doesn't have a a a big
- 18:19database of failure to appear rates, and certainly not at the individual level.
- 18:24And so, you know, I had to kind of figure out how I was going to approach this, and and some
- 18:28of the surveys that I saw were, asked people about lying, telling a falsehood, fibbing to
- 18:36get out of jury to get out of serving on a jury.
- 18:40And the number kind of surprised me.
- 18:42Seven to 10% depending on the survey, and the original survey that I did for the book, it was
- 18:48right in that same range.
- 18:50And what's what's fascinating to me as as a scholar of public opinion and somebody who
- 18:55takes my job as a public opinion researcher and analyst very seriously is that that number,
- 19:01seven to 10%, is probably low, because of, what we in social sciences call social desirability
- 19:09bias.
- 19:09Right?
- 19:09This is the idea that I'm going to tell a pollster, I'm going to tell a researcher what I
- 19:17think they wanna hear because because I wanna fit in.
- 19:21I want them to like me.
- 19:22Right?
- 19:23It's it's I want this it's social desirability.
- 19:26I I desire this person that I'm in a social contract with right now to like me.
- 19:31And so lying is not socially desirable.
- 19:35It's not something that you readily admit to someone.
- 19:37It's like, oh, yeah, I'm I lie all the time.
- 19:40Like, people just don't admit that.
- 19:42And so for seven to 10% of people to admit that tells me that there is probably a roughly equal
- 19:49number who have lied to get out of jury duty, but aren't willing to because of social
- 19:55desirability bias to admit that to another person.
- 19:59And so I I think that, you know, that that number is probably even a little low.
- 20:05So there our democracy depends not only on voting, but this whole gamut of of civic
- 20:14engagement that, and frankly, I don't even cover it all in the book.
- 20:18You know, I wrote a 200 page book to to try and convince somebody to engage in a system that's
- 20:23250 years old.
- 20:26There's just there's there's never going to be a comprehensive book on how people can get
- 20:30engaged and what different activities are important to, the if you can keep it.
- 20:38So, yeah, there are a few.
- 20:41The thing you said about polling, I think a lot about the over reporting of self reporting of
- 20:47people who go and vote where, you know, there's, like, 70 to 80% of people go, oh,
- 20:52yeah.
- 20:52I voted.
- 20:53But, really, the area is more like 50%.
- 20:57I mean, assume and that's you were talking about, you know, depending on how you calculate
- 21:01the voter turnout.
- 21:01Depends on whether you're talking about gubernatorial or presidential elections, but
- 21:06there are just so many people that don't wanna seem like, oh, I don't want people to think I'm
- 21:11not doing anything, so I'm gonna say I voted.
- 21:13But, yeah, it it's polling and that they could just you could talk about that all day as a
- 21:19totally separate thing, but I've had several episodes dedicated to polling and how people
- 21:26misunderstand them.
- 21:26A couple weeks ago, I actually had an episode where I talked about how to, you know, think
- 21:33about not assuming that the poll is a legitimate poll, how do you look into you know,
- 21:41how sincere are the respondents?
- 21:43Sorry.
- 21:43You were gonna say something?
- 21:44Yeah.
- 21:44The I I think there when it comes to self reported voting and there's, again, a long line
- 21:50of political science research on self reported behavior that shows that people are just poor
- 21:54at remembering their own behavior.
- 21:56And so there is some social desirability there.
- 22:00There there is some lying going on there, but also there there could be sampling issues
- 22:05there.
- 22:06Right?
- 22:06It's it's theoretically possible for a pollster to draw a sample where 75% really have voted.
- 22:14It's unlikely, and and we we see that, with with random sampling, it's unlikely, which is
- 22:21kind of the gold standard of of sampling in in the social sciences and in polling
- 22:25specifically.
- 22:26But, you know, like I said, there's a long line of research that shows that even with a
- 22:31verified voter file, you'll have people lying to the pollster, misremembering their own
- 22:38behavior.
- 22:39So so there is a it's kind of a confluence of issues.
- 22:43There's never never just one problem with with statistics like that.
- 22:49And so, again, you you tapped the the inner nerd in me.
- 22:54So I I I think it's important for your for your listeners and your your viewers to understand
- 22:59that it's not just social desirability bias that that can lead to issues with polling.
- 23:04There are sampling issues and and other things going on.
- 23:08Oh, yeah.
- 23:08You know, abs absolutely.
- 23:09It's just it's just something that I I just thought about, but it it just goes to show you
- 23:14just how much people misunderstand how polling works.
- 23:17And every once in while, even those of us who are involved in polling, we can make mistakes
- 23:22in in in interpreting it.
- 23:24But the thing you said about jury service, I really appreciate that you had a whole chapter
- 23:28dedicated to that.
- 23:29When I had to do jury duty, and I actually had to do it while I was still writing my my book.
- 23:36But I remember I had gotten out of it a couple of times because I was still in school, and
- 23:41then I couldn't get away from it anymore, and I was just dreading it.
- 23:44I just was like, it was all the horror stories about jury duty.
- 23:48And you know what?
- 23:49It was not that bad.
- 23:51I mean, the the actual case we had to I had to serve jury duty for was not a fun one, but I
- 23:59really came to appreciate having to do jury duty.
- 24:03And I really it was actually a very fascinating experience that I think a lot more people
- 24:09should do.
- 24:10It's really not even remotely as bad as people think it is.
- 24:13Yeah.
- 24:13I talk about that a lot in the book, and and what's really fascinating you know, there
- 24:17there's a ton of information about why a representative jury is important.
- 24:21But to to your point, like, you I mean, you are an embodiment of the research that's out there
- 24:27on jury service, and that's that when people do go and engage in it and they actually do get
- 24:34seated on a jury, and they go through a a case, and they listen to the evidence, and they they
- 24:39deliberate, and they reach a verdict, they really do enjoy the experience.
- 24:43And the other thing is, that the research shows that it's actually jury duty itself, while it
- 24:49is a civic act, is also a civic action booster.
- 24:53So people who, voted at lower levels and then served on a jury actually tended to vote more.
- 25:01People who didn't really talk about politics and then served on a jury talk about politics
- 25:06more after they've served.
- 25:07So it really is a not only a a democratic act in and of itself, it's a democratic booster.
- 25:13That's fascinating.
- 25:14I I think I've heard those statistics before, but, yeah, it just goes to show you just how
- 25:19vital it is.
- 25:21And even if you don't ultimately start participating more in politics, it's still a
- 25:26very critical civic duty for people to participate in.
- 25:30But I think that's a good way to bring up this next question.
- 25:33How much of this problem of political apathy do you think is because people want to get
- 25:38involved, but because but they're afraid to do it because they're afraid of violence or people
- 25:45yelling at them for whatever opinions they have versus simply just not caring about politics or
- 25:51thinking that it's irrelevant to their life.
- 25:55Yeah.
- 25:55So there are a couple of a couple of things to unpack there.
- 25:58The the first is, I think it's important to, to understand how we define apathy, and it's
- 26:04defined in the book as not caring.
- 26:07And so a lot of the lack of participation, and this is what I document in the book, is that
- 26:14that sense of not caring is, like, that is a driver, and and it's not the only driver.
- 26:22In in some cases, it's not even the biggest driver.
- 26:24You know, there are there's plenty of research, and and the book backs that up that a lack of
- 26:32civic knowledge is a a factor in civic participation.
- 26:41You know, there is a socioeconomic factors that that come into play, whether it's income or
- 26:51education level or employment status that that tends to play a role.
- 26:55But, apathy is is the sense of not caring about civic engagement and about, our system of
- 27:03government, not caring who wins an election, not caring about the system itself, believing
- 27:10that, it's not really your responsibility to participate.
- 27:14Another thing that I talk about gets, in the book that I measure and explore in little bit
- 27:23of detail is alienation, and that's the sense of not belonging.
- 27:27That is when somebody says, you know what?
- 27:30Like, I just my vote doesn't matter.
- 27:32I I don't feel like this system of government really prioritizes people like me.
- 27:38I just I I don't belong.
- 27:40I I thought that a sense of apathy, not caring, and a a feeling of alienation, this not
- 27:49belonging.
- 27:49I thought that those two would kind of work in tandem to drive down participation, but in some
- 27:56instances, what I saw was the opposite, that apathy would work against behavior, but
- 28:06alienation would actually increase behavior.
- 28:09And, you know, so there were a lot of interesting nuggets, coming out of of the book
- 28:17about this difference between apathy and alienation.
- 28:22And that is a very important distinction to make, and sometimes it's not necessarily made.
- 28:28And, I mean, sometimes I feel like I'm alienated.
- 28:31I feel like I'm not being represented, but it's easier for me as somebody who's actually
- 28:36involved in this stuff for a living and does believe it's my I do believe it's my civic duty
- 28:41to get involved, and I do care about the stuff, but I often feel alienated too.
- 28:46But you're talking about people who are not normally ingrained in this stuff.
- 28:50They've got other aspects of their life going on, or their their lives are not super tied to
- 28:58what goes on in politics, which to some extent is healthy.
- 29:02But it it I mean, it's it's a lot harder for somebody like that who's not otherwise normally
- 29:08engaged in politics when they're feeling alienated, they're really not going to
- 29:11participate.
- 29:12And I feel like maybe there are more people, and maybe you you have more statistics in your
- 29:17book.
- 29:17I feel like maybe more people feel that way versus just not caring about politics at all.
- 29:23Or maybe they really think like, oh, it's just irrelevant to my life anyways, but really, they
- 29:28just feel alienated, and they just don't wanna recognize it or whatever.
- 29:31But that could just be me making, you know, wild assumptions that don't turn out to be
- 29:36true.
- 29:37But let's talk about things that actually are backed up.
- 29:40What are two to three data points from your book and from a public public opinion research
- 29:46and other sources that are most concerning about civic and political participation?
- 29:50I know you brought up a couple of them, like people lying to get out of jury service, but
- 29:54what are maybe two other data points that you would point to to say, hey, we really need to
- 30:00understand how big this problem is.
- 30:03Yeah.
- 30:03So I think there are a couple here.
- 30:05Obviously, the low participation is one, and that's that's the one that I tackle primarily
- 30:10in the book.
- 30:10It's the low number of voting, the the low percentage of participation in voting, and
- 30:18quite frankly, being registered to vote.
- 30:19Right?
- 30:20Registering to vote in The US is pretty easy, and it's a very low bar to, to entry into the
- 30:27political system, and still a lot of people don't even bother doing that.
- 30:33So talk about registration, you know, low, numbers of people contacting their elected
- 30:39officials, our polling response rates are in the toilet, people lying to get out of jury
- 30:45duty.
- 30:45So it's it's the participation that I that I tackle in the book.
- 30:50But one one number that really stood out to me, as I was writing the book, and the the first
- 30:58congressional campaign that I worked on, the the the candidate slogan was be part of the
- 31:04solution.
- 31:05And former speaker, Sam Rayburn, said something very similar.
- 31:10He said, any jackass can kick down a barn, but it takes a good carpenter to build one.
- 31:18And the the point is the same.
- 31:20Like, we we can talk about problems all day long, but if you don't have a solution, then
- 31:25why are you even coming to the table?
- 31:27And if you're not willing to work toward a solution, why are you even here?
- 31:30And so that's part of a big part of the book is, you know, I've identified this problem, and
- 31:37the the solve is not only incumbent upon us as individuals, and that's a big part of it to get
- 31:44reengaged, but there's there's things that that other institutions can do.
- 31:49And one of the big things that stood out to me from an institutional perspective is that when
- 31:57I wrote the book, we were spending a thousand times more money on STEM education than we were
- 32:04on civics education.
- 32:06And that's not to discount the importance of STEM.
- 32:10These are the careers of tomorrow, and, like, we need to educate students in STEM fields.
- 32:18Authors always joke that, especially academic authors, that by the time your book is
- 32:23published, it's out of date.
- 32:25And this is this is one of those instances because the Trump the Trump administration
- 32:28recently did infuse a lot of capital into civics education nationwide.
- 32:33That's not to say that it was enough.
- 32:35That's not to say that it brings us anywhere near being on par with STEM, but the spending
- 32:41on on civics education is one thing that really stuck in my craw, to to use kind of a a country
- 32:47term.
- 32:48Right?
- 32:49So it's one thing that really bothered me, because I grew up hearing that you don't talk
- 32:55about politics and religions and polite company, whatever the heck that means.
- 32:58Right?
- 32:59It's something that you didn't talk about.
- 33:00You don't talk about politics.
- 33:02It's taboo.
- 33:04I think part of that is because my generation and the generation before me, and maybe even
- 33:11the generation before that, they just weren't taught civics in school.
- 33:15They weren't taught about the importance of democracy in and of itself.
- 33:22They weren't taught about the, the really kind of genius way, that the American federal system
- 33:34is set up.
- 33:35And that's not to say that it's perfect because, you know, we're all flawed human
- 33:40beings, and anything that a that a flawed human being makes is going to have its imperfections.
- 33:44And we've seen those imperfections come to light over the years.
- 33:48You know, the the biggest and most glaringly obvious is the institution of slavery that we
- 33:53fought a civil war over.
- 33:54So it's not to say that The United States is a perfect country, but we're a pretty darn good
- 34:01country, when you look back, at the past two hundred and fifty years, and and in comparison,
- 34:07to some of the the systems of government that have been set up, especially within that time
- 34:13frame, that have been competing.
- 34:17Winston Churchill famously said that democracy is the worst form of government except all the
- 34:21others that have been tried, and I I genuinely genuinely believe that that's true.
- 34:26And so when we're not teaching civics in the schools, we're leaving the next generation of
- 34:34citizens woefully uninformed and, just in a a place that's putting our republic in a
- 34:45desperate spot because a rightful government, the the declaration of independence tells us,
- 34:52is set up on this idea that people participate.
- 34:59Right?
- 34:59It's the consent of the governed.
- 35:01And if we're not consenting through our participation, then our system of government is
- 35:07illegitimate.
- 35:08And so we have to get to a point where we're spending an adequate amount of money on civics
- 35:16education, that it's not just a a crash course, the senior second semester, the senior year of
- 35:23high school where everybody's already checked out and, you know, they're more worried about
- 35:27class rings and and graduation apparel and regalia than they are about their coursework.
- 35:33And so we're just kind of shoving them out the door with this really inadequate understanding
- 35:38of how to be a citizen and expecting them to then be good participatory citizens.
- 35:45100% agreed on the the civics aspect of it.
- 35:48Just it's just such a sad state that civics is in this country.
- 35:54But your point about the the Winston Churchill quote about democracy, that's that's why it
- 35:59just drives me insane whenever anybody talks about their ideology or their idea for a system
- 36:06of government or economics as if, like, it has no flaws whatsoever, and it this just it's just
- 36:12not it's just not reality.
- 36:14And it kind of goes back to what you were saying about, you know, when you're coming to
- 36:17the table to have you know, try to bring solutions.
- 36:20And to add on to that, I mean, I think it's oak if if you don't have a solution, I think that's
- 36:25perfectly fine too as long as you're work wanting to work towards a solution.
- 36:28But I also not really interested in people who think they have all the answers figured out,
- 36:36and they're not going to listen to anybody else, and they're just going to try to just
- 36:41hamfist their solutions on everybody else.
- 36:45That's not something that I'm a fan of either.
- 36:48And I unfortunately, I think you do see that quite a bit in politics too.
- 36:51People who claim they want to come to the table and and solve these problems, but they wanna
- 36:56solve it their way specifically, and they think they've had it all figured out.
- 37:00But going back to the, of course, the the people who are apathetic, an attitude that is
- 37:06highly relevant to this discussion comes from those who are much more participatory in civics
- 37:12and politics.
- 37:12This is idea of if you don't vote, you don't have the right to complain.
- 37:16We don't wanna hear it.
- 37:18Does your book address this idea specifically or directly, and how much stock do you put in
- 37:23that notion?
- 37:25Yeah.
- 37:25So I I actually opened the chapter on voting with with that with that notion, not as an
- 37:32endorsement of it, but just because it is so ubiquitous.
- 37:37And the way I view it is if you don't vote, yeah, you can absolutely complain because the
- 37:44first amendment says that you can complain, and, you know, the the government can't stop
- 37:48you from doing that.
- 37:50You know, we have this this understanding in The United States that even though a private
- 37:59actor may try to get you to stop speaking your mind, that you still have this kind of
- 38:05inalienable right to do so.
- 38:09And so, yeah, absolutely, you can complain, but what good is it doing?
- 38:15And that's that's how I view it is if you wanna make a difference, if you wanna complain about
- 38:22something that's going on in government, and you wanna change it, and you want elected
- 38:28officials to do what you want instead of what they want, you have to complain in the right
- 38:33way.
- 38:34And just, you know, trying not to use inappropriate language for your listeners, but
- 38:40if you wanna gripe about it on Facebook, like, that's not gonna do any good.
- 38:44If you wanna, you know, go out and run your mouth to your neighbor, that's not gonna do any
- 38:49good.
- 38:49What's going to do some good is showing up and voting, first of all.
- 38:54If you don't wanna do that, if you think that for for whatever reason that, you know, your
- 38:58vote doesn't matter, it's not gonna tip the scales or whatever, contact your elected
- 39:02official.
- 39:03To their website, send them a letter, send them an email.
- 39:07If they don't listen, if they still don't wanna do what you want instead of what they want,
- 39:12then go volunteer for their opponent in the next election.
- 39:17There are plenty of ways that you can get out there and complain that are going to make a
- 39:20difference.
- 39:21So, you know, if you don't vote, you can't complain.
- 39:24Like, I I get it.
- 39:25I get the I get the sentiment behind that.
- 39:27It's like if you're not gonna take the the bare minimum behavior to engage in our system of
- 39:32government, when our system of government kind of runs off the rails, then you're part of the
- 39:36problem.
- 39:37And so if you're part of the problem, then stop complaining about it.
- 39:41I get the sentiment behind that.
- 39:43But I've been thinking about a lot recently about democracy as a relationship.
- 39:50And all of us, you, me, your listeners, we're all in a relationship.
- 39:55Some for some of us, it's multiple relationships.
- 39:57Right?
- 39:58We're married, or we have children, or we are children.
- 40:02For those who aren't married, you know, maybe it's a dating relationship, or just a
- 40:07friendship, or a a coworker.
- 40:10We're all in some sort of interpersonal relationship, and when those interpersonal
- 40:14relationships face rocky times, we don't just throw them away right off the bat, we we take
- 40:22steps to to figure out what's going on and try to fix those relationships.
- 40:27Right?
- 40:27We communicate with one another.
- 40:29We we show up when the other person needs us.
- 40:32And democracy, our system of government, because it is of by and for the people, it is
- 40:40another interpersonal relationship.
- 40:42Our system of government and the way we interact with it is an interpersonal
- 40:47relationship, and to just throw it away is is unconscionable.
- 40:52If, you know, if heaven forbid, my wife and I started having some sort of marital strife, we
- 40:57would take steps to fix that.
- 40:59Right?
- 40:59We would go buy a self help book, for our for our marriage, or we would go talk to our
- 41:06pastor, or we would go see a counselor.
- 41:08Like, there are steps that we can take to save our marriage before just becoming a statistic,
- 41:14a divorce statistic.
- 41:16And in the same way, our relationship with democracy requires work.
- 41:21We have to show up to make it work.
- 41:24Right?
- 41:24We have to go vote.
- 41:25We have to communicate with the other side of of the relationship.
- 41:30And so that's that to me is what's going to help sustain democracy in the long term is just
- 41:41showing up and doing the work.
- 41:42Even if it's hard, even if you feel like you don't have a voice, you have to re you you have
- 41:50to make your voice heard in order to have a voice.
- 41:53I used to be very much of that attitude of, well, if you don't vote, I don't wanna hear
- 41:59your complaints too.
- 42:00And I would not say I've done a complete one eighty on those on on that idea, but I am
- 42:07definitely a lot more understanding or empathetic to other reasons.
- 42:11Like, when people are just really feel like that they just cannot make a difference or they
- 42:17really don't know how to make a difference.
- 42:19Now to some extent, they have a responsibility to try to figure out what ways they can go
- 42:24about trying to make a difference, which isn't doesn't just include voting.
- 42:28But if you are somebody who, like, just likes to complain just because you wanna hear your
- 42:33own voice and you're just being lazy and you absolutely could make a difference or or you
- 42:38have some sort of excuse for why you don't do it.
- 42:41Like, I've I've heard there was somebody who I otherwise a cool guy, but I remember somebody I
- 42:45had a class with that basically, he didn't vote because he felt it was it was adding to a
- 42:51system that was inherently violent, which is just like, okay.
- 42:55That's that's a ridiculous reason to to not vote.
- 42:57But those kinds of people, I don't wanna hear their complaints from.
- 43:01But I do agree with the idea that you don't I don't automatically want to not hear you
- 43:07complain, but there are other ways that you can go about it besides voting.
- 43:12Like you said, like volunteering for another campaign or at least calling your local
- 43:17representative and, you know, probably gotta do a little bit more than just posting on social
- 43:23media.
- 43:23And usually posting on social media doesn't really do anything anyways.
- 43:27But, yeah, I would I would amend that attitude to some extent of the you don't vote, don't
- 43:33complain.
- 43:33I can understand some people who just feel just like they just are alienated like you talked
- 43:38about, but definitely if you're just being lazy and smug, I don't wanna hear it.
- 43:43Alright.
- 43:43So we're just about the home stretch of this interview here.
- 43:47So I know I gotta get you out of here.
- 43:48So real quick, any final thoughts that you'd like to share about the importance of civic
- 43:53participation or how to get more people involved in it?
- 43:57Yeah.
- 43:57I think there are a couple of things.
- 44:00And the the number one, it's an election year.
- 44:05And and we've talked about how engagement in civics and American government goes beyond
- 44:09elections, but it is an election year.
- 44:12And a lot of political science research shows that the the best way to make sure that you go
- 44:18vote is to have a plan.
- 44:20That means know what time of the day you're going to go vote.
- 44:22Are you gonna go before work?
- 44:23Are you going to go on your lunch break?
- 44:25Are you going to go after work?
- 44:26What are you going to do with your kids?
- 44:28Are you going while they're at school, or are they even better yet coming with you to observe
- 44:33you participating in our system of government?
- 44:37Know what's for dinner?
- 44:38Are you going to have a crock pot meal, or are you going to go grab something, at, you know,
- 44:45the local burger joint after you voted in the evening?
- 44:49Have a plan for what how election day is going to go down for you, and, and what that will do
- 44:55is just like when you when you have a plan for date night, going back to this idea of
- 45:01democracy being a relationship.
- 45:03If you're like, alright, let's have a date night on Friday, but I don't plan for my mom to
- 45:11come over and watch the kids, and I don't make a dinner reservation, and I don't buy theater
- 45:15tickets, and I don't do all of these things to get ready for date night, we're gonna end up,
- 45:19like, eating, you know, frozen pizzas and sitting on the couch, scrolling on our phones
- 45:26or reading a book and just being angry that we didn't get a date night.
- 45:29Right?
- 45:29So you can have a plan and execute the plan, or you can end up angry eating frozen pizza.
- 45:36And so make a plan to to go vote.
- 45:39And the other thing that I would say is, like I said earlier, one of the best ways to get other
- 45:44people to participate is to just ask them.
- 45:47So involve a friend in your plan.
- 45:50Whether it's your neighbor, be like, hey, you know, I'm gonna go vote after I drop the kids
- 45:56off at school.
- 45:57You wanna wanna you wanna ride with me?
- 46:00Or it's your, you know, your elderly grandmother, you know, hey, grandma, I'm gonna
- 46:05go vote.
- 46:07Can can I take you to you know, do you need a ride to the polls?
- 46:12Or a friend.
- 46:13Hey.
- 46:13Let's let's grab a quick lunch and go hop in the line to vote.
- 46:17Take somebody with you, that and so those are the two things that I would say.
- 46:22Have a plan.
- 46:23Take somebody with you.
- 46:24Both great points, and I I can't remember the exact statistics off the top of my head, but I
- 46:28do remember back in grad school seeing some or maybe it was sometime after that.
- 46:33But remember seeing that it's surprisingly effective to to include somebody else to say,
- 46:39hey.
- 46:40Do you wanna come vote with me?
- 46:41And getting them Yep.
- 46:42To participate.
- 46:43And who knows?
- 46:44You may have sparked a lifetime of civic participation in them for for doing that.
- 46:52Sometimes they just feel like they're just not being included, but if one of the people they
- 46:55know, like a friend or a family member tries to include them, maybe they will start to shift
- 47:00their opinions.
- 47:01Yeah.
- 47:01Voting is voting is habit forming, and I hate to keep saying the the lines a lot of political
- 47:06science research shows, but it it really is the truth.
- 47:09But voting is habit forming.
- 47:11When you do it once, you're more likely to go do it again, and then you're more likely to go
- 47:14do it again.
- 47:14And so when you do start that snowball rolling downhill
- 47:18Yeah.
- 47:19Absolutely.
- 47:20And so we're going to finally wrap things up here.
- 47:24Once again, Travis, thank you so much for for being here.
- 47:26The final question we're gonna use to wrap things up.
- 47:29So for those of you who are new or returning to the show, I always like to add a random
- 47:34question at the end that's not I'm kind
- 47:36of excited about this question.
- 47:38Good.
- 47:38I'm I'm glad.
- 47:39But I like to just round things out and give a different side to our guests.
- 47:43So, doctor Taylor, today's random question of the day for you is, you have the power to ban
- 47:50one kind of clickbait tactic.
- 47:52Which one do you choose to eliminate?
- 47:54Can I just be eliminating clickbait entirely?
- 47:57I wish you could, but I I I I want you I wanna just one specific one that really grinds your
- 48:03gears.
- 48:04Because I mean, yeah, clickbait in general grinds my gears, but
- 48:08Oh, man.
- 48:08Gotta make a choice.
- 48:09Yeah.
- 48:10That's I'm I'm I'm going to say it's the misleading headlines.
- 48:14You know, we talked earlier about political information and how critical political
- 48:21information and civic knowledge is for participation in government.
- 48:26And when all you're doing is just, like, rage baiting people and getting them to click on a
- 48:32story that really with a very misleading or just flat out lying headline.
- 48:39Yeah.
- 48:39It sucks them into that rabbit hole, and just they keep going further and further down.
- 48:44So if you can keep them from getting into that rabbit hole to begin with, I think that's best.
- 48:48So I'm gonna say eliminate the eliminate the misleading headlines.
- 48:55Great choice.
- 48:56I might actually answer a different time on a different day, but I gotta tell you, there's
- 49:01just something about the capitalization of specific words to, like, get a rise out of
- 49:09people that just is one of the most annoying things to see in political media.
- 49:15Like, so and so owns this person.
- 49:20An argument.
- 49:21Yeah.
- 49:21All caps or, like
- 49:23When did when did when did we get perfect.
- 49:26Yeah.
- 49:26When did we move from a a point where using all caps and yelling was or all caps in writing was
- 49:32like yelling at someone to now it's just like run of the mill writing.
- 49:36It yeah.
- 49:37I'm with you there.
- 49:38Yeah.
- 49:38Just it just drives me up a wall, and I've I've done it a couple times, and I stopped doing it.
- 49:43I was like, I I can't do the same thing that I'm I'm complaining about other people.
- 49:47And it might not even be the worst one.
- 49:48The misleading title is probably a worst one, but there's just something about the just
- 49:53because it's such a cheap way to get people's attention that Right.
- 49:56It just just really makes me annoyed.
- 49:59But, yes, like you, I wish you could just eliminate clickbait completely.
- 50:02Sadly, I don't think that's gonna be happening anytime soon.
- 50:05But in any case though, Travis, thank you very much for being on this show.
- 50:11And before we close out, any other links you want me to share?
- 50:14Obviously, I'll I'll link the book, but anything else you want me to share?
- 50:18No.
- 50:18The anybody that that wants to connect with me can do so on LinkedIn as well.
- 50:22You can feel free to share that link.
- 50:25Love to hear people's thoughts on the book.
- 50:27And so if you wanna shoot me a LinkedIn connection request and a message, just let me
- 50:33know you've read the book and let me know your thoughts.
- 50:35I'd love to hear those.
- 50:36But, Paul, this has been a great conversation.
- 50:38I really appreciate the opportunity to chat with you today about the book.
- 50:41Absolutely.
- 50:42And thank you for being on here.
- 50:43So, yes, I will put those links in the show notes for my links, my other works, including
- 50:48my book on amazon.com about political independence and why they are why they why
- 50:55independents rarely win elections and how they become more could become more competitive.
- 51:00And my medium.com profile that I write on from time to time and my five day educational email
- 51:07course about how to more effectively mitigate polarization and toxicity.
- 51:11And then my other links, my LinkedIn, my facebook.com page, and my website,
- 51:17paulraider.org, and my email, PaulRaiderWrights@Gmail.com.
- 51:21So thank you all so much for listening, and we'll see you next time.