Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Why EVs Often Outlast Their Gas-Powered Rivals
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Explainer. Today we're bringing you a truly
- 0:03epic engineering bottle. We're putting modern electric
- 0:06vehicles and traditional gas powered cars head to head
- 0:10against one of Mother Nature's absolute most destructive
- 0:13forces, deep floodwater. In this Explainer, we're going
- 0:16to break down the specific mechanics, the hidden dangers,
- 0:19and the ultimate survival guides for navigating high waters,
- 0:22pulling straight from the actual engineering specs and expert
- 0:25safety guidelines. It's a totally fascinating clash
- 0:28of modern tech and the raw elements, so let's get right
- 0:31into it. It's the ultimate question,
- 0:33right? I mean, we've all been taught
- 0:35since we were kids that water and electricity are a terrible,
- 0:37highly dangerous combination. It's a super common fear.
- 0:41So it's totally natural to wonder if you drive a massive
- 0:45rolling battery into a giant puddle, is that basically the
- 0:48same as trying to wash or toaster while it's plugged in?
- 0:51Do the rules of physics just suddenly change when you're
- 0:53behind the wheel of an EV? Well, before we pit these two
- 0:56technologies against each other, we really have to establish the
- 0:59golden rule of driving in floods.
- 1:01And this applies regardless of what's under your HUD.
- 1:03Scrap car comparison states that it can take only 6 inches of
- 1:06water for you to lose control of your car.
- 1:08Seriously. Just six inches?
- 1:10And the a A They strongly recommend staying away from even
- 1:134 inches of water. Why?
- 1:15Because if that water is moving, it takes incredibly little force
- 1:18to lift and completely sweep away even the heaviest of
- 1:20vehicles. The absolute best way to survive
- 1:22a flood is just to avoid driving into it in the first place.
- 1:25OK, let's dive into Section 1, the water and electricity myth.
- 1:31We need to clear up the biggest misconception about electric
- 1:33vehicles right out of the gate here.
- 1:35We've got to separate the Hollywood explosions from actual
- 1:38automotive engineering. There's this pervasive myth that
- 1:41an EV will just instantly spark and explode the second water
- 1:44hits a chassis. But guys, that is simply not
- 1:46true. Electric vehicles are packed
- 1:49with highly advanced safety systems.
- 1:51If the car detects that it's being submerged, built in
- 1:53circuit Breakers are designed to literally instantly trip.
- 1:56This completely cuts the power and dramatically reduces the
- 1:59likelihood of any immediate fire or explosion in the water.
- 2:02You aren't driving a fragile toaster, you were driving a
- 2:04highly regulated piece of modern technology.
- 2:07Section 2, the head to So knowing that an EV won't just
- 2:13blow up on impact, how do these two completely different vehicle
- 2:17architectures actually fare against the water?
- 2:19Well, there's a fundamental engineering difference between
- 2:22the two. Traditional internal combustion
- 2:24engine or ICE cars are essentially giant air pumps.
- 2:27They rely entirely on breathing and oxygen to mix with fuel and
- 2:31create combustion. If you block that air, or, you
- 2:34know, replace it with water, the engine simply dies.
- 2:36E VS on the other hand, don't breathe.
- 2:39They have absolutely no air intake requirements.
- 2:41Their power comes from a sealed chemical reaction which actually
- 2:44gives them a surprisingly submarine like advantage in
- 2:47deepwater. And this lack of breathing is
- 2:49exactly why traditional gas guzzlers die so quickly in
- 2:52flooded streets. It causes a catastrophic event
- 2:55called hydro locking. See, if you drive a gas car into
- 2:58water deep enough that liquid cascades into the air intake,
- 3:02the engine tries to compress that water inside the cylinders
- 3:05instead of air, but as we know, water doesn't compress.
- 3:08The results? Absolute instant engine
- 3:11destruction. You end up with bent Pistons and
- 3:13a completely ruined motor. It is literally lights out for
- 3:16the car. Now what's really interesting
- 3:18about this is a specific alphanumeric code, IP67.
- 3:22This is the strict regulatory standard that EV manufacturers
- 3:25actually use. It means that the massive
- 3:27battery packs and the high voltage components are heavily
- 3:30sealed and waterproofed against dust and temporary submerging in
- 3:33water. Because EVs lack that vulnerable
- 3:35engine air intake and have this tough IP67 shielding around
- 3:39their high voltage heart, they're actually structurally
- 3:41way better equipped to survive an immediate plunge than a gas
- 3:44car. But let's be real, EVs are not
- 3:47completely invincible here. While the gas car has fatal
- 3:50vulnerabilities like the engine intake and the alternator, the
- 3:53EV still has plenty of parts that water can absolutely
- 3:56destroy. Even though the main battery is
- 3:58sealed tight, floodwaters can wreak absolute havoc on the
- 4:01auxiliary components. We're talking about delicate
- 4:03sensors, cooling pumps, fans, and all those complex under body
- 4:07wiring connections. The heart might survive the
- 4:09plunge, but the nervous system can still get incredibly
- 4:12waterlogged and completely fail. Which brings us to Section 3,
- 4:16the real danger post flood aftermath.
- 4:20See, the EV might comfortably win the initial battle of
- 4:23driving through the puddle without stalling, but the hidden
- 4:26threat, the truly dangerous part, is delayed.
- 4:29And this is a terrifying concept we really need to talk about.
- 4:32Thermal runaway. If floodwater, and especially a
- 4:35highly corrosive saltwater, eventually eats through those
- 4:37IP67 seals and breaches the massive lithium ion battery
- 4:41pack, it causes internal short circuits.
- 4:43Now, this doesn't usually happen while you're actually in the
- 4:46water. It happens hours, days, or even
- 4:49weeks after the flood has receded.
- 4:51The battery cells start heating each other up in an
- 4:53uncontrollable chain reaction, creating a massive, extremely
- 4:56difficult to extinguish fire. Because of this delayed, sneaky
- 5:00threat, the village of Key Biscayne has actually released
- 5:03specific safety guidelines on what to look out for if your EV
- 5:06has been in a flood. You have to use your senses.
- 5:09Be incredibly alert for hissing or popping noises coming from
- 5:11the car. Watch out for inspected smoke or
- 5:14strange sweet or maybe metallic odors, and physically inspect
- 5:18the car for any bulging panels near the battery compartment.
- 5:21Underneath any of these are immediate blaring red flags that
- 5:24thermal runaway might be starting.
- 5:26So the crucial point is how we handle this Section 4 Surviving
- 5:31a flood safely. How do we practically navigate
- 5:34these situations out in the real world to protect ourselves and
- 5:37our cars? If you absolutely, positively
- 5:40cannot avoid driving through a flooded area, here are the
- 5:43strict techniques you've got to use first.
- 5:45Obviously check your owner's manual for waiting death, but
- 5:48generally speaking, never let the water exceed the wheel hubs
- 5:51or the lower edge of your doors. When you enter the water, you
- 5:54must maintain a very steady, consistent speed.
- 5:57Do not stop. If you stop, the bow wave of
- 5:59water you are pushing forward can collapse right back into
- 6:02unprotected areas of the car. And finally, be highly aware
- 6:06that the rear of an EV can become unexpectedly light and
- 6:09buoyant, causing you to lose traction entirely.
- 6:12Now, if the worst has happened and your EV was submerged, this
- 6:15is your immediate post flood action plan.
- 6:17Step one, do not drive or charge the vehicle under any
- 6:20circumstances. The car's battery management
- 6:23system, or BMS will usually isolate the high voltage if it
- 6:26detects an anomaly, but you just shouldn't risk it.
- 6:28Step 2. If it is safe to do so, move the
- 6:31car at least 50 feet away from any structures or buildings due
- 6:34to that severe fire risk we talked about.
- 6:36Step three, Do not try to dry it out yourself like a wet
- 6:39smartphone in a bag of rice. Just don't.
- 6:41And Step 4, you must have an authorized technician formally
- 6:45inspect the integrity of those high voltage seals before the
- 6:47car is ever used again. So to bring it all together, an
- 6:51electric vehicle's sealed architecture makes it vastly
- 6:54superior to a gas car. When you're crossing a flooded
- 6:56St. It simply won't choke and die on
- 6:58the water, but the incredibly corrosive nature of flood water
- 7:01means that if the moisture gets inside that battery pack later
- 7:04on, the resulting damage is completely catastrophic.
- 7:07Basically, EVs might win the battle against the puddle, but
- 7:10the water can still win the war. Before we wrap up, I just want
- 7:13to send a massive thank you to all of you, our listeners and
- 7:15viewers for tuning into The Explainer, exploring these
- 7:18intense engineering matchups, and uncovering how our everyday
- 7:21tech holds up against the extremes.
- 7:22That's what this show is all about.
- 7:24Your curiosity is exactly what drives this Explainer, and we
- 7:26truly couldn't do it without you.
- 7:28Stay safe out there on the roads.
- 7:29Keep learning. And as climate patterns shift
- 7:31and floods become more common, it leaves us with one final,
- 7:34pretty big question. Are our cities truly ready for
- 7:37an electrified future? We'll catch you in the next
- 7:39Explainer.