Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [13F] Phil Town's Rule One Fund Portfolio: Q3 2025 Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Dee dive. Today we are cutting right
- 0:03through the noise to give you a strategic shortcut into value
- 0:06investing in action. That's right.
- 0:08Our sources are all focused on one thing, the Q 32025 portfolio
- 0:13of the Rule One fund, which is managed by Philtown.
- 0:15Right. And our mission here is to
- 0:18really move beyond the textbook stuff.
- 0:21We're looking at how a highly concentrated conviction driven
- 0:24strategy, what they call rule hashtag one, investing, how it
- 0:29actually decides where to put its money.
- 0:30This isn't theory, This is real capital making some very
- 0:34calculated high stakes moves. And before we get into the
- 0:36stocks, let's just quickly define that philosophy because
- 0:39it really underpins every single trade we're about.
- 0:41Talk about rule, hashtag one. It's rooted in Graham and
- 0:43Buffett, and it uses this simple but really powerful tool, the 4M
- 0:49framework. The four M's, it's the filter,
- 0:51it's what forces the discipline. You start with meaning, do you
- 0:54deeply, and I mean deeply, understand the business, right?
- 0:56Then you've got Mote. Does it have a durable
- 0:58competitive advantage that just keeps everyone else out?
- 1:00OK, so meaning mote, what's next?
- 1:05Management Are the people in charge trustworthy?
- 1:08Are they talented? Do they care about shareholders?
- 1:10And the final M, which is I think the most critical for any
- 1:14classic value investor. It is margin of safety, the big
- 1:17one exactly. You find that wonderful
- 1:19business, you know, using the first three Ms. and then you
- 1:22wait. You wait until it's trading for
- 1:24way less than what it's actually worth.
- 1:26And that price cushion, that's your protection.
- 1:28That is your margin of safety. It protects you from mistakes,
- 1:31from volatility, from yourself sometimes.
- 1:34So when we look at the snapshot of this fund, the first thing
- 1:37that just jumps out is the sheer conviction.
- 1:39Oh, absolutely it's. Holding only 9 positions total
- 1:43market value about $217 million. Yeah.
- 1:46And the top five holdings make up almost 87% of the entire
- 1:49portfolio. I mean, that is not
- 1:51diversification, no. That is profound belief.
- 1:54It's the ultimate expression of it.
- 1:55They are betting big, and I mean big on their absolute best
- 1:58ideas. And here is the core story of Q
- 2:013/20/25. This is the real aha moment.
- 2:05The fund didn't just tread water, it executed a massive
- 2:09strategic pivot. A huge one.
- 2:11They liquidated 5 positions and these were high quality names
- 2:16like Alphabet, GOGL, PayPal, Ulta Beauty and they did it to
- 2:23fund one. One singular massive purchase,
- 2:26Yeah. 143.88% increase in their position in Lululemon Athletica
- 2:32Lulu. And that action is the perfect
- 2:34living demonstration of rule hashtag 1.
- 2:37You sell good companies that are fairly valued to go all in on a
- 2:41wonderful business that has temporarily gone on sale.
- 2:44So we're going to break this all down by strategic intent.
- 2:47Let's put things into 3 buckets. Strategic patience,
- 2:50opportunistic action, and then the core compounders in Special
- 2:53Situations. Sounds good.
- 2:54Let's start with the source of all that power, Pillar one, the
- 2:57engine of strategic patience. Right and if you want to
- 3:00understand the managers mindset, you just have to look at this 1
- 3:02#46.46%. Almost half the fund.
- 3:05Almost half over $101 million is just sitting in a government
- 3:09money market fund. It's basically cash.
- 3:11Which to a lot of investors, that looks like hesitation.
- 3:13It looks like you're sitting out of the game, especially if the
- 3:15markets running hot. And that's the classic mistake,
- 3:18right? This is actually the highest
- 3:20form of discipline. It is an active investment
- 3:22decision. This huge cash pile is the
- 3:26purest expression of M4 margin of safety.
- 3:29The rule is don't swing at every pitch.
- 3:31Exactly. Don't swing at a fair pitch when
- 3:34you know you can wait for a fat one.
- 3:36This dry powder isn't lazy, it's potential energy.
- 3:40It gives them the optionality to act decisively when a crisis
- 3:43hits. It's also a loud and clear
- 3:45statement that the manager thinks the overall market is,
- 3:48well, probably overvalued. It is.
- 3:50And if you're listening to this and you're wondering, you know,
- 3:51how can I monitor that from my own decisions, that larger
- 3:55context is so vital for applying that margin to safety ideas
- 3:58successfully. Absolutely understanding the big
- 4:01picture tells you when to hold cash and when to, well, when to
- 4:05load the Canon and to track that total market temperature and to
- 4:09get daily updates, we highly recommend checking out the iOS
- 4:12app Buffett Indicator. A Buffett indicator.
- 4:14Yeah, just search for it and download it from the Apple App
- 4:17Store. Monitoring that metric is how
- 4:19you know when it's time to act, just like the Rule One Fund did
- 4:22this quarter. OK.
- 4:23So from patients to aggression, once that cannon was loaded,
- 4:27where do they aim it? Pillar 2.
- 4:29Opportunistic action. The fat pitch.
- 4:32The massive swing at Lululemon Lulu, which is now a huge
- 4:37holding. So why?
- 4:39Why was Lululemon suddenly on the bargain rack?
- 4:41Well, the stock had just collapsed.
- 4:43It was down over 45% for the year.
- 4:45The entire narrative was broken. What happened?
- 4:48Management came out and admitted that their US lifestyle lines
- 4:51had, and I quote, become stale. And then on top of that, they
- 4:55got hit with an unexpected $240 million tariff headwind.
- 4:58Ouch. So the market saw a catastrophe.
- 5:00The impatient market saw a catastrophe and ran for the
- 5:03exits. It really sounds like a classic
- 5:04falling knife scenario. How do you justify buying a
- 5:07stock that's crashing because of management issues?
- 5:09I mean, where's the safety against just poor execution?
- 5:12That's the key question and that's where their four M
- 5:14counter thesis comes in, specifically Mote M2.
- 5:18The fund looked right past that temporary noise.
- 5:20They assessed the core quality of the business.
- 5:23Lululemon has an incredibly wide Moat based on its brand, its
- 5:27pricing power. And you see that in the numbers.
- 5:29You see it right there in the financials, 60% gross margins, a
- 5:32massive 41.3% return on invested capital or ROIC.
- 5:38OK. So for our listeners, what does
- 5:40an ROIC of over 41% really tell you about a company's
- 5:43competitive advantage? It means for every single dollar
- 5:46of capital they have in the business, they are generating an
- 5:49incredible 41 cents in profit. That is a sign of intense
- 5:53efficiency, of brand dominance. Something a generic retailer
- 5:57could never do. Never.
- 5:59And when a company has that kind of financial firepower, the fund
- 6:02can make a bet that these problems, like stale products,
- 6:05are temporary and, more importantly, fixable management
- 6:07issues. An M3 problem.
- 6:09And the international growth was still there.
- 6:11Still accelerating up 22%. So that story was completely
- 6:14intact. Which brings us to M4, the
- 6:16margin of safety. The market panic created what
- 6:19they saw as a once in a decade opportunity.
- 6:21Their own models, Their DCF models suggested an intrinsic
- 6:24value around $255. And the stock was trading where?
- 6:27At $177.00 so you had a built in 33% margin of safety.
- 6:32That Lulu trade is the perfect playbook.
- 6:35Liquidate assets you like but don't love to go all in on an
- 6:39asset you love when it's on sale.
- 6:42Patient, yet opportunistic. OK, let's shift gears now to the
- 6:45bedrock of the portfolio, the core compounders, Pillar three.
- 6:50These are the wonderful businesses they want to hold for
- 6:52the long haul. Even if they're not on deep
- 6:54discount. Exactly.
- 6:56Let's start with ASML. ASML holding a 3.16% position.
- 7:00This is the definition of a technology toll booth.
- 7:03A toll booth. I like that.
- 7:04The Moat here M2 is absolute. It's a 100% monopoly on extreme
- 7:08ultraviolet lithography machines.
- 7:10EUV. And just remind us why that
- 7:12monopoly is so powerful. Because EUV is the one
- 7:15indispensable technology you need to make the most advanced
- 7:17microchips in the world. No one else can do it, period.
- 7:20You're not getting a deep discount, but you're buying
- 7:22certain. You're buying certainty, and
- 7:24that certainty is backed by an astounding 55.5% return on
- 7:28equity. And Roe, just to clarify, that
- 7:30measures how efficiently a company uses shareholder money
- 7:32to make profit, 55% is? It's world class capital
- 7:36efficiency, so they are more than happy to pay a fair price
- 7:39for that kind of compounding. OK, then there's Netflix NFLX,
- 7:43their largest equity holding over 20% of the fund.
- 7:46A massive position. That's some serious faith in the
- 7:49content Kingdom. But wait a minute, if you look
- 7:52at the financials, traditional DCF models suggest Netflix is
- 7:57significantly overvalued at its Q3 price.
- 8:00Yeah, around $11198. Doesn't that just fly in the
- 8:03face of the whole margin of safety principle?
- 8:05That's the essential challenge with this holding and it shows
- 8:07their flexibility. It's a pure conviction play on
- 8:10the durability of the Moat. They call it the scale driven
- 8:13hit flywheel. We can blame that.
- 8:15You have 277 million paid members funding an $18 billion
- 8:20content budget. That budget creates more hits,
- 8:23which attracts more members, which funds a bigger budget.
- 8:26It's a cycle that rivals just can't break into.
- 8:28So they're betting on the value of that Moat over a cheap price
- 8:31today. Exactly, but they aren't just
- 8:33chasing it blindly. Right.
- 8:35They showed discipline earlier. They did.
- 8:37They trimmed shares back in Q2 when the price was even higher.
- 8:40So they're managing the position, They're holding a long
- 8:42term compounder, but they still know when the valuation gets a
- 8:45little too, too hot. OK, let's pivot to two companies
- 8:47that are really transformation stories, Occidental Petroleum,
- 8:51Oxy and Howard Hughes, HHH. Let's do Oxy first.
- 8:55Occidental, which is a 5.65% position, is fundamentally a
- 8:59debt repayment story. The Moat is there.
- 9:01They have Tier 1 assets in the low cost Permian Basin, but the
- 9:05real thesis is M3 management. Fined by deleveraging.
- 9:09Relentless deleveraging. They repaid $7.5 billion in debt
- 9:13in just thirteen months. That kind of kind of aggressive
- 9:16action is just pure value creation for shareholders.
- 9:19But the stock price still seems to reflect that old dead heavy
- 9:22story. Correct.
- 9:23And that's the M4 thesis. The market is pricing OXY for
- 9:26the company. It was not the deleveraged hash
- 9:28flow machine it's becoming. The numbers suggest it's about
- 9:3136 percent, 41% undervalued right now.
- 9:34And Howard Hughes Holdings HHH. This one feels like a pure
- 9:37management bet. It really is HHHA 5.66% position
- 9:42is built on the idea that it's master planned communities were
- 9:45MPCS are irreplaceable. Think of The Woodlands.
- 9:48These giant self-sustaining cities, basically.
- 9:51Right. They create this geographical
- 9:53Moat and incredibly stable, predictable cash flow.
- 9:56But the transformation, that's the M3 genius.
- 9:59This is a bet on Bill Ackman. Ackman's plan to turn it into a
- 10:02a modern day Berkshire Hathaway. That's the goal.
- 10:05He's using the MPCS as the cash flow engine.
- 10:07The float, just like Berkshire, uses insurance float to fund
- 10:10future acquisitions without having to go to the market for
- 10:13capital. So if I buy HHH today, I'm
- 10:15getting getting the existing real estate which is already
- 10:17undervalued, plus I get a free option on Ackman's future
- 10:20capital allocation skills. You just distill the entire M4
- 10:23thesis. The stock is already 17 to 19%
- 10:26undervalued based only on the real estate it currently owns.
- 10:28The whole Ackman transformation that's basically being offered
- 10:31up for free. A very compelling proposition.
- 10:33Finally, Pillar 4, the special situation the fund holds Fannie
- 10:40Mae and Freddie Mac. This is the exception that
- 10:42proves the rule right. These don't fit the four M
- 10:44framework at all. They do not.
- 10:46This is a purely event driven asymmetric bet, a high risk one.
- 10:51These companies, the GSE's, have been in federal conservatorship
- 10:54since 2008. The Treasury just sweeps all
- 10:57their profits away. So the entire investment hinges
- 10:59on one single binary event, a political catalyst.
- 11:03That's it. The thesis is that eventually
- 11:05the government will end the conservatorship and reprivatize
- 11:08these companies. And the upside could be huge.
- 11:10Immense. The current prices are
- 11:12speculative, maybe around $12.00 a share, but proponents suggest
- 11:16a reprivatization value could be 25 dollars, $34, maybe even
- 11:19higher. So why would a fund so focused
- 11:21on conviction and safety hold what's essentially a lottery
- 11:24ticket? It's a strategic allocation
- 11:26because the core portfolio is anchored by these high quality
- 11:29compounders and that massive cash reserve they can afford to
- 11:32take this calculated. Risk.
- 11:34It's noncorrelated upside. Exactly, if it pays off, the
- 11:36returns are massive. Yeah, and it uses capital that
- 11:39wasn't big enough for that fat Lululemon pitch.
- 11:42O what does this all mean? When you put the strategic cash,
- 11:44the opportunistic action, the core compounders and the special
- 11:48situation altogether, what's the final picture?
- 11:51I think the Q3 action was a definitive master class and
- 11:54strategic value investing. You had the massive patience of
- 11:57that 46% cash position providing the firepower for the conviction
- 12:01of the Lulu buy. And that conviction then angers
- 12:06the core compounders, you know, the quality businesses like
- 12:08Netflix and ASML, and it allows you to take calculated
- 12:11asymmetric bets like the Gses. They showed that selling a
- 12:15perfectly good company like Google is not just okay, it's
- 12:19necessary when a truly great opportunity comes along.
- 12:22And that strategy, it really hinges entirely on having cash
- 12:25ready when a temporary crisis hits a wonderful business. 100%.
- 12:29Which brings us to our final provocative thought for you.
- 12:32We challenge you to look at your own portfolio.
- 12:34What percentage of your capital is truly dry powder really
- 12:38waiting to capitalize on that next moment of maximum market
- 12:42pessimism, just as the Rule One Fund did with Lululemon?
- 12:45Think about the optionality that cash gives you.
- 12:48It allows you to be the rational, aggressive one when
- 12:51everyone else is panicking. Thank you for joining this deep
- 12:53dive my. Pleasure disclaimer.
- 12:56All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 12:59may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 13:03The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 13:06constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 13:10before making investment decisions.
- 13:12If you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 13:15or access more advanced contents, welcome to join Deep
- 13:18Value Club membership or subscribe us on Apple Spotify
- 13:21Podcasts channel Deep Value Investing and to track total
- 13:26market temperature. Welcome to search and download
- 13:29the iOS app Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store to go
- 13:34Star Yi pocheng cheche ETA Tuko si a Dong Jianyu Wahi Kos Diego
- 13:39Dong Kono A Camina Chu Kanye sukenjiangyu waipu.
- 13:43Kong Kong Kuhayya Choi Kufangyu Ishtechong Kong Kong Yo Kong
- 13:49Kong Kong Kong Kong Yu Shi Kong Wukong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kuye
- 13:54Shigo Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong
- 13:58Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong
- 14:03Kong Kong Kong Kong Tao Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong
- 14:11Tao Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong
- 14:22danielle.com. Kong Kong Kong Chong Kong Kong
- 14:27Hong Kong Hong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong
- 14:39Kong Kong Kong Kong Kong Shang Kong album Conga Town Hong Kong
- 14:50Town show Bang Island. I'll be in that out Sean Kong.