Latest / Stacking The Box, a Football Podcast / Is the NFL Moving Away From the Passing Game?
Transcript
- 0:02[SPEAKER_00]: Tommy Jagayov fan cited here with NFL expert Marcus Mosher and we come to you with almost no NFL news, Marcus.
- 0:10[SPEAKER_00]: Last time we were on this show, we got to talk about a miles gear at trade and just some of the buzz was happening around the NFL.
- 0:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's not that normally doesn't happen this time of year right now.
- 0:19[SPEAKER_00]: It is dead quiet as you would expect because we are entering mid-June here and it's pretty quiet around the NFL, but we're going to talk
- 0:29[SPEAKER_00]: NFL trends.
- 0:30[SPEAKER_00]: Are you buying or selling some of the latest NFL trends?
- 0:33[SPEAKER_00]: And so we're going to make it a fun show regardless.
- 0:35[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and I want to start talking with the the tight end craze that's happening in the NFL.
- 0:40[SPEAKER_01]: It really started in free agency this year.
- 0:43[SPEAKER_01]: You started to see more of these.
- 0:47[SPEAKER_01]: Let's call them like non-superstar tight ends, just to be very kind.
- 0:51[SPEAKER_01]: Starting to get paid a lot of money.
- 0:52[SPEAKER_01]: I think a perfect example was Charlie Coler of the Baltimore Ravens, kind of big con check with the chargers.
- 1:00[SPEAKER_01]: And you're starting to see more and more teams lean into having two, three, or even four tight ends set.
- 1:07[SPEAKER_01]: So I've got my theory behind why it's happening, but I'd love to hear yours.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_01]: Why do you think we're seeing an uptake in tight ends
- 1:17[UNKNOWN]: You
- 1:18[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I think there has to be more versatile for one thing.
- 1:20[SPEAKER_00]: You talk about an H-back and inline Titan and F-Tiden.
- 1:25[SPEAKER_00]: What's so interesting, Marcus, is the NFL absolutely goes in waves.
- 1:29[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that we're seeing that yet again, you go back to like the 90s, early 2000s.
- 1:34[SPEAKER_00]: It was all about smash mouth football, the running game.
- 1:37[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, you wanted the big body inline Titans.
- 1:40[SPEAKER_00]: We got away from that for a while.
- 1:41[SPEAKER_00]: And then it was the air raid passing game.
- 1:43[SPEAKER_00]: And it's everybody doing 11 personnel and trying to push the ball down the field.
- 1:48[SPEAKER_00]: There hasn't been much of that.
- 1:50[SPEAKER_00]: And with the quick passing game and the run game coming back, I think that's a big reason why we're seeing this research is at the tight end position.
- 1:58[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's very, very possible.
- 2:00[SPEAKER_01]: And honestly, that's probably the best reasoning.
- 2:03[SPEAKER_01]: I think because these tight ends can do so much.
- 2:08[SPEAKER_01]: They're really valuable to have as like that fourth and fifth weapon in your passing game.
- 2:12[SPEAKER_01]: I also think the NFL just likes to copy whatever Sean McVeigh does.
- 2:15[SPEAKER_01]: And typically they're always like a secular two behind Sean McVeigh last year.
- 2:20[SPEAKER_01]: Devontate Adams got banged up yet the hamstring injury for half the season.
- 2:25[SPEAKER_01]: So rather than putting out receivers like two to at well and some of the other.
- 2:31[SPEAKER_01]: trying to be nice bad receivers at the Rams had they opted to play more tight ends and they were really successful now they had puking a kova and they had Matt Stafford and Sean McVay right so they still had those three and you can run your offense but they were throwing the ball
- 2:46[SPEAKER_01]: out of 12 and 13 personnel.
- 2:48[SPEAKER_01]: That's two tight ends and three tight ends on the field.
- 2:51[SPEAKER_01]: And they were pretty successful.
- 2:53[SPEAKER_01]: And I think you see the rest of these GMs look at that situation on top of the bears.
- 2:58[SPEAKER_01]: Tommy, where, you know, the bears drafted Colston, Lovelin, I believe it picked 10 last year.
- 3:03[SPEAKER_01]: They also had Colcomet.
- 3:05[SPEAKER_01]: And you saw what Ben Johnson was able to do with that bears team.
- 3:08[SPEAKER_01]: And now everybody's trying to be the Rams of the Bears.
- 3:12[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's a really good theory because why would you not want to replicate Shomic Bay best coach in the business?
- 3:16[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of odd though because when you look at the Ramses like they don't have any superstar tight ends or anything that way and yet they just have a bunch of them.
- 3:24[SPEAKER_00]: They play a bunch of them.
- 3:25[SPEAKER_00]: It's the receivers that soak up all of the production in the passing game still.
- 3:29[SPEAKER_00]: So what I would ask you then, what is the purpose of playing so many tight ends if they're not necessarily going to be consistently involved in the passing game?
- 3:39[SPEAKER_01]: I think for the really good offensive minds, it's just to get different defensive looks, right?
- 3:46[SPEAKER_01]: Because if you have, let's say it's a 13 person now.
- 3:48[SPEAKER_01]: And that is one wide receiver, three tight ends and one running backs.
- 3:53[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of times you're having to either go with a base defense with three linebackers on the field, or a big nickel with three safetys on the field, or however you decide to match up against it.
- 4:03[SPEAKER_01]: And for an offensive minded coach like Sean McVe, that's awesome.
- 4:07[SPEAKER_01]: Like less defensive backs on the field, that's a lot easier to design a passing game.
- 4:11[SPEAKER_01]: I can move my number one receiver around to get advantageous situations.
- 4:16[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's part of it.
- 4:17[SPEAKER_01]: And all the numbers show throwing out of 12 and 13 personnel is incredibly valuable.
- 4:24[SPEAKER_01]: And I think a lot of times people look at, you know, having these tight ends on the field.
- 4:27[SPEAKER_01]: And you think, okay, we just want to become a better run team.
- 4:30[SPEAKER_01]: Let's put three tight ends on the field.
- 4:32[SPEAKER_01]: And that's how we're going to become a power running game.
- 4:35[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of times it doesn't work because your second and third tight ends aren't generally great blockers and usually putting that extra line back or extra safety on the field kind of negates that I really think it's because of what you can do as a past catcher.
- 4:49[SPEAKER_01]: So if you've got guys like Tyler Higby who can be you know assets as receivers, that's how you get the most value out of these sets.
- 4:57[SPEAKER_01]: But one of the things Tommy I'm fascinated by is in the NFL draft this year.
- 5:02[SPEAKER_01]: We saw I'm looking at the numbers now 12 tight ends I believe go in the first 95 picks including some guys that
- 5:10[SPEAKER_01]: We didn't think we're going to be drafted inside the top 100, but you've got guys like Max Clare going to the Rams.
- 5:17[SPEAKER_01]: Sam Roosh, who was at Stanford, he was an early third rompick from the Bears who already have two really good tight ends.
- 5:24[SPEAKER_01]: You see the same scrap Oscar delt.
- 5:26[SPEAKER_01]: You see the Patriot scrap Eli Raredon, who already have Hunter Henry.
- 5:31[SPEAKER_01]: I just think these guys, because they can do so much, they can help out on special teams.
- 5:36[SPEAKER_01]: Teams are putting more value on that position.
- 5:39[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it seems like no team can get enough tight ends right now.
- 5:42[SPEAKER_00]: You look around the league.
- 5:43[SPEAKER_00]: There are multiple teams with several high paying tight ends.
- 5:47[SPEAKER_00]: The Steelers just became the latest with Darna Washington getting 10.5 million per year.
- 5:51[SPEAKER_00]: That's on top of Pat Friday.
- 5:53[SPEAKER_00]: I'm with getting $12.1 million a year.
- 5:55[SPEAKER_00]: And you're still getting some of these teams.
- 5:56[SPEAKER_00]: investing 20 plus million dollars at the tight end position.
- 6:00[SPEAKER_00]: The Vikings are one of those teams, TJ Hawkins, and they're white head end, they're blocking tight end Josh Oliver.
- 6:05[SPEAKER_00]: You mentioned Charlie Kohler going to the chargers.
- 6:08[SPEAKER_00]: Like it does feel like it's a dramatic shift from what we saw in the past decade of football or like you had your Jimmy Graham and you didn't care of what else was on your team.
- 6:18[SPEAKER_00]: You had your Jason Whitney and you didn't really care about the rest of the group.
- 6:21[SPEAKER_00]: Now it feels like there's a much
- 6:23[SPEAKER_00]: more even split, even when it comes to playing time and snap distribution among the top tight ends.
- 6:28[SPEAKER_00]: And it's almost Marcus in a way, it kind of feels like the new running back position where it's kind of tight end by committee.
- 6:35[SPEAKER_00]: And unless you have a really good one at Pro Bowl, all pro level tight end, then you're kind of just throwing guys out there that are going to get the, you're going to get the most out of playing multiple positions.
- 6:45[SPEAKER_01]: And there's one of the team that we should mention here.
- 6:47[SPEAKER_01]: I apologize for not mentioning them earlier.
- 6:49[SPEAKER_01]: And that's the
- 6:51[SPEAKER_01]: was the number two ranked Titan in the NFL last year by PFF.
- 6:54[SPEAKER_01]: Now he missed a lot of time.
- 6:56[SPEAKER_01]: And that met Jackson Haas, who was a fifth round rookie from Georgia Tech, had to play a lot of SNAPS.
- 7:02[SPEAKER_01]: And Jackson Haas actually finished as the fourth ranked Titan in the NFL.
- 7:06[SPEAKER_01]: He played over 500 SNAPS.
- 7:08[SPEAKER_01]: They also had Dawson Knox.
- 7:09[SPEAKER_01]: So the bills were another team.
- 7:11[SPEAKER_01]: I think because they were so depleted at receiver, Khalil Shikir got banged up early in the
- 7:20[SPEAKER_01]: They just felt like the tight ends on their rosters were better players.
- 7:24[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think it was because they felt like they found this grand new idea that suddenly going to open up their offense.
- 7:31[SPEAKER_01]: I think a lot of times these offensive coaches were just figuring like, hey, Jackson Haas is a better blocker than my third receiver.
- 7:38[SPEAKER_01]: Let's put them on the field and try to figure it out.
- 7:41[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and that might be the best example of all, especially when you consider that King Kade was a first round pick.
- 7:46[SPEAKER_00]: They are willing to take him off the field and play him in essentially a part-time role because of Jackson Haas and because of Dawson Knox and the trio that they have going on for them in Buffalo.
- 7:56[SPEAKER_00]: Let's talk about the run game because we talked about the Titan Impact in that regard.
- 8:01[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, could we see more teams rely even more heavily on the run game as we move forward?
- 8:06[SPEAKER_00]: And I got to say, like,
- 8:08[SPEAKER_00]: A few years back, we're talking like three, four years ago now, like patch from home, so on for 50 touchdown type of seasons, I was wondering back then.
- 8:16[SPEAKER_00]: I'm like, why would we ever see the NFL shift back the other way?
- 8:20[SPEAKER_00]: We not offense is so high powered in the last few years.
- 8:24[SPEAKER_00]: I think that's gone down a little bit with the quick passing game, getting the ball out fast.
- 8:29[SPEAKER_00]: Are we going to see a resurgence in the run game in the NFL?
- 8:33[SPEAKER_01]: I think we've seen it a little bit over the last couple of years.
- 8:36[SPEAKER_01]: Now I don't think it's necessarily been one single running back that has done it.
- 8:42[SPEAKER_01]: I still think committees are the way to do that.
- 8:47[SPEAKER_01]: And I also think it depends on the team.
- 8:49[SPEAKER_01]: Like let me ask you this.
- 8:50[SPEAKER_01]: Do you know who led the NFL and rushing yards last year?
- 8:52[SPEAKER_01]: Just give me a guess.
- 8:54[SPEAKER_01]: Bijon Robbins.
- 8:55[SPEAKER_01]: Bijon Robbins was fourth.
- 8:57[SPEAKER_01]: It was actually James Cook.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_01]: And we don't think it's James Cook.
- 9:00[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, we don't think of James Cook as like this.
- 9:03[SPEAKER_01]: perennial all pro running back right we think of James Cook is kind of like the sidekick to Josh Allen they give them the ball whatever Josh Allen doesn't want to do something with it.
- 9:12[SPEAKER_01]: I think you're just seeing more of that and maybe those guys will become more efficient right and again the bills are one of these teams that used more tight ends but I do think you're going to see teams try to be more balanced not because
- 9:25[SPEAKER_01]: It's more effective that way, but also just it takes some of the wear and tear off your quarterback and you know, but we obviously have a 17 game season.
- 9:33[SPEAKER_01]: I think we're eventually going to get to an 18 game season.
- 9:36[SPEAKER_01]: You just don't want your quarterback to be exposed to so many hits.
- 9:40[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's where the run game is going to come back into the the focal point for these offenses.
- 9:45[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, I would tend to agree.
- 9:46[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, we've kind of had this running a motto philosophy, if you will, that running games matter and not necessarily running backs do they don't make give me wrong.
- 9:57[SPEAKER_00]: There's a few guys who at their peak.
- 10:00[SPEAKER_00]: It really hard to match their production by committee, the Christian McAfrey, what he can do, and the receiving game and the running game.
- 10:07[SPEAKER_00]: And obviously, St. Juan Barkley, the season he had two years ago, like those, those guys matter.
- 10:12[SPEAKER_00]: But in general, it's the running games that matter, not the running back.
- 10:16[SPEAKER_00]: I do think the running game matters.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think that ever went away.
- 10:19[SPEAKER_00]: It was more
- 10:20[SPEAKER_00]: the workhorse running backs kind of going by the wayside.
- 10:24[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that we're still seeing that.
- 10:25[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, we're look around most teams around the league.
- 10:28[SPEAKER_00]: Don't have just one true workhorse.
- 10:30[SPEAKER_00]: It's getting like 85, 90 percent of the teams touches.
- 10:33[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's unwise.
- 10:34[SPEAKER_00]: You're just going to wear them down, especially as the NFL season continues to get longer.
- 10:38[SPEAKER_00]: And I think teams are just being smarter about how they run the ball.
- 10:41[SPEAKER_01]: Like,
- 10:43[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't that uncommon 10 years ago to just see everybody hey it's second and 10 run the block hit yourself into third manageable right that's not really the common thinking anymore it's you goal shouldn't be to get to third manageable the goal should be to get a first down on basically every play right so.
- 10:59[SPEAKER_01]: You're seeing teams be smarter about how to run the ball, win the run to ball, trying to get formations on the field that can help you.
- 11:08[SPEAKER_01]: So if you're going to run the ball, try to run it out of three receiver sets.
- 11:11[SPEAKER_01]: That way you only have five or six guys in the box, right?
- 11:14[SPEAKER_01]: Throw the ball at a three tight end set so that way you only have so many guys in coverage.
- 11:20[SPEAKER_01]: I think offensive coordinators and play colors in general have just gotten a lot smarter and I think you're starting to see some of those I like to call them dinosaurs get faced out of the league a little bit and I think that's why you're seeing the efficiency for these running backs all go way way up.
- 11:36[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, I think that it only makes sense to lessen the workload, get guys fresh at the position and I think that it's it's obviously safe to say we're never going to see those Emmett Smiths to get in those guys who can carry the load year after year and not wear down like that, it's just wise to distribute those touches.
- 11:55[SPEAKER_00]: You are tuned into stack in the box where NFL fans come to talk, celebrate and debate for more coverage at fanscited.com, powered by the passionate fans at fanscited.
- 12:03[SPEAKER_00]: All right, Marks, let's talk about the defense here and how will the things we just talked about, the surgeons of the Titan position, more 12 and 13 personnel, the running game, how will defenses now match up against us?
- 12:17[SPEAKER_00]: What are they going to do to counteract those things?
- 12:20[SPEAKER_01]: Well, we started to see a little bit of it last year with Seattle and really Baltimore did this with Kyle Hamilton as well.
- 12:26[SPEAKER_01]: If you have a safety that can play in the slot, it just gives you more versatility.
- 12:32[SPEAKER_01]: Now you can have three safety in the field and you're still able to stop the run and if you've got a safety that can really cover, okay, now you put yourself into an advantage
- 12:42[SPEAKER_01]: The problem is there's only a handful of those guys in the league and this is what makes that position.
- 12:48[SPEAKER_01]: I think I couldn't be surprised if we see it become more valuable over the next couple years.
- 12:53[SPEAKER_01]: Kyle Hamilton can do it jail in Petrie and Houston can do it a little bit, Nick even worried with a seahawks as the example that I mentioned at the top.
- 13:00[SPEAKER_01]: They're when James with the Chargers, if you have one of these safeties that can play in the slot, that can stop the run, that can rush the pass or then that can cover a little bit.
- 13:10[SPEAKER_01]: I do think that's a trend, and you're starting to hear from more and more defensive coordinators around the league, whether it's like a Vick Fangeo, or a Christian Parker, or a advanced Joseph.
- 13:19[SPEAKER_01]: The number one goal for their slot defender has got to be able to tackle.
- 13:23[SPEAKER_01]: Like they can live with some of the coverage bus if you've got a guy that can make plays in the
- 13:29[SPEAKER_01]: And that time we kind of for us growing up, it was always these really small undersized slot corners that were really good on coverage and you gave up a little bit in terms of the tackling, I think that's changing.
- 13:41[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yeah, I mean, absolutely.
- 13:42[SPEAKER_00]: And it really has.
- 13:44[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, it used to be your boundary corners are big, your slot corners, small and shifty.
- 13:48[SPEAKER_00]: And now, where they call it these days, the star roll, where you can play some safety, you can play box, you can play in the slot.
- 13:55[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously, you can cover, you've got size length and closing speed and tackling abilities.
- 14:00[SPEAKER_00]: Why a guy like Devon Widdish who is so successful in today's NFL, like who, speaking in an, like what is the model,
- 14:09[SPEAKER_00]: for this is the guy that I want to build my defense around this star role like who is that guy that's like prototype for that position right now.
- 14:18[SPEAKER_01]: I mean Kyle Hamilton's the number one band that's that's that's so hard to find guys.
- 14:23[SPEAKER_01]: I'll give you one from this year's draft.
- 14:30[SPEAKER_01]: Caleb Downs is really that the perfect type of guy for this role right he's six foot he's a hundred and ninety five pounds he can play free safety he can play in the box he can play his slot and I think if you stick him at one position you're probably not getting the most value but his ability to play multiple spots and kind of line up wherever you need to based on the offense
- 14:51[SPEAKER_01]: that's what makes these guys so valuable and I think that's why someone like Dylan Thineman went and ran one because he can do a lot of the same things I do think you're going to see more and more of these players come out over the next five or so years
- 15:05[SPEAKER_01]: It's just really, really hard to find them.
- 15:07[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think it's worth mentioning too that a lot of the best receivers in today's game, a lot of the quick passing game, is going to this lot.
- 15:15[SPEAKER_00]: And so to have a guy that can cover there, at least match some of that, to play some inside leverage.
- 15:21[SPEAKER_00]: And obviously, some of these good corners, they will follow you and the best in the league can go outside inside and have that flexibility.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_00]: But I do think it's a really important role that's certainly gaining steam in the NFL right now.
- 15:35[SPEAKER_00]: Let's talk about playing more safeties from that, the slot position, Marcus, and will this be something that we continue to see an uptick in this trend?
- 15:47[SPEAKER_01]: I would think so.
- 15:48[SPEAKER_01]: I think because of how successful Nicki Minaj and Kyle Hamilton and Jalen Petrie have been in that role, I do think you'll see more of it.
- 15:56[SPEAKER_01]: Now, not every safety is going to be able to handle that because you still have to be able to cover at an adequate level.
- 16:03[SPEAKER_01]: And that's generally the knock for safety.
- 16:05[SPEAKER_01]: It's the reason why they're playing safety and not corners because they can't cover as well.
- 16:09[SPEAKER_01]: That corner position pays basically dumb.
- 16:11[SPEAKER_01]: I still want safety is due.
- 16:12[SPEAKER_01]: But yeah, I do expect that trend to continue at least for the next couple of years.
- 16:19[SPEAKER_00]: I think it's going to be interesting to see if there are other teams who try to follow suit.
- 16:25[SPEAKER_00]: It's a copycat league.
- 16:26[SPEAKER_00]: We talked about teams trying to replicate what Sean McVay is doing on offense and why not replicate what Mike McDonald is doing on defense like it's what works.
- 16:37[SPEAKER_00]: is what other teams are going to notice as well, and I think that this is one of those things.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_00]: And so, do you see any up-and-coming players at the position that guys, I mean, Nick, I mean, where I was obviously one of them, we saw the flashes during his rookie season.
- 16:50[SPEAKER_00]: Are there any others out there that you think could be,
- 16:53[SPEAKER_00]: primed for this role.
- 16:55[SPEAKER_01]: By the way, I think it's really funny that Mike McDonald is the one that had Kyle Hamilton playing in that role in Baltimore.
- 17:01[SPEAKER_01]: Now he's got Nicki Minaj doing it.
- 17:03[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I don't think that's a coincidence either.
- 17:04[SPEAKER_01]: He wanted one of those guys for his defenses for sure.
- 17:08[SPEAKER_01]: I think the top guy that I would keep an eye on is Evan Williams for the Green Bay Packers, who was really, really good last year.
- 17:14[SPEAKER_01]: I thought he was one of the best run defending safeties and the reason why he was so good is a lot of times they would blitz him right off the edge.
- 17:23[SPEAKER_01]: I think we're going to talk about the Packers here in a little bit, but Evan Williams is a guy if the Packers are going to get back to being a legit Super Bowl contender, he's the guy in their secondary that I think could take that step and really become a force this year.
- 17:37[SPEAKER_00]: All right, yes, I'm to keep an eye on this your team have one of these guys that slot safety defender probably not there's only few of the league right now and I think that we're getting away from that the we're getting further away from the Mike Hilton's of the world just that the undersized five foot nine slot corners we want these big guys that can cover hit run tackle chase and do it all we'll see where this ends up leading us from the highs the heart breaks every headline this is stacking the box your source for NFL talk powered by fan cited
- 18:07[SPEAKER_00]: and the voices at fancited.com.
- 18:10[SPEAKER_00]: So let's talk about this, Marcus.
- 18:11[SPEAKER_00]: Is it better to build a deep past rush unit or to have one superstar?
- 18:17[SPEAKER_00]: So we're shifting gears here from the safety talk, talking about past rush.
- 18:21[SPEAKER_00]: We've seen, for example, the Cleveland Browns and Miles Garrett.
- 18:26[SPEAKER_00]: You had one superstar always an adequate player across from him and it was remarkable.
- 18:32[SPEAKER_00]: Now, Garrett's one of ones.
- 18:33[SPEAKER_00]: So this is probably not a fair comparison to start with.
- 18:36[SPEAKER_00]: But just based on what we've seen in recent years, and again, this is NFL trends, are you buying these trends right now?
- 18:44[SPEAKER_00]: Is it better to have a deep, full rotational unit like the Seattle Seahawks, for example, or to have a superstar eddrusher, and then kind of just throw whoever next to them who's probably going to be efficient anyway, just because they're not drawing the attention.
- 18:58[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
- 18:59[SPEAKER_01]: I wish I had a better answer, but this is something that I've been thinking about a lot over the last couple of weeks, and really Brian Schott and Hymer with the Dallas Cowboys brought this up that he said all the best defenses in the league have multiple past rushers, rather than just one superstar one.
- 19:14[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's kind of coat for just not having Mike of Parsons, but also I kind of understand it and again, the C-Ox are the perfect example of it last year.
- 19:24[SPEAKER_01]: They had some really good players, including Boymuffy, Derek Hall, the Marcus Lawrence, but I don't think you would call any of those guys top 15 edge rushers.
- 19:33[SPEAKER_01]: Like I'm being conservative if you're like, there's a good chance that none of those guys are even top 20 edge rushers.
- 19:39[SPEAKER_01]: And I look at someone like
- 19:44[SPEAKER_01]: But I don't know if Nick Benito's considered a superstar pass russia or anything like that.
- 19:49[SPEAKER_01]: But they had just a bunch of guys that they could put in and they could all do different jobs and they could feel different roles compared to like Green Bay last year that had Micah Parsons and Rashad Garry.
- 20:00[SPEAKER_01]: But once Micah Parsons went down, the defense completely fell apart.
- 20:04[SPEAKER_01]: They didn't win a single game after Micah got hurt in that Denver game.
- 20:09[SPEAKER_01]: Cleveland, the same thing.
- 20:10[SPEAKER_01]: Cleveland would have Miles Garrett, who was the best pass rusher I've seen over the last 20 years.
- 20:15[SPEAKER_01]: And there were still games where they would give up the 30 points because they could triple team Miles Garrett and take him out of the equation.
- 20:22[SPEAKER_01]: I think you always want to have those superstars, but if you don't build out a good roster behind them, I don't know how much of it matters.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, I think it's a really good conversation because I think you can go either way.
- 20:33[SPEAKER_00]: In fact, can I give you just a the Pittsburgh Steelers example of this here?
- 20:38[SPEAKER_00]: Because we've seen it both ways just over the last five or six years.
- 20:41[SPEAKER_00]: Younger TJ watt from 2018 to 2021, it was superstar not much else going with them.
- 20:47[SPEAKER_00]: You had a kind of a so-so but debris.
- 20:51[SPEAKER_00]: You had a really young Alex Heismeth who hasn't broke out yet.
- 20:54[SPEAKER_00]: It was drafted in 2020.
- 20:58[SPEAKER_00]: TJ, why does not that superstar anymore, but Alex Highsmith is playing his best football and Nick Herbieg is broken out.
- 21:04[SPEAKER_00]: And it's really even for me, like it's hard to say, if one is better than the other, I would almost lean towards having the superstar that can draw a lot of attention and make the assignment easier for other players in the defense.
- 21:18[SPEAKER_00]: But so much depends on that player, so much depends on their health and whether or not they are being able to overcome their assignment.
- 21:27[SPEAKER_00]: And so I think what's more consistent is just having the better and deeper group overall.
- 21:34[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, and again, I being a cowboy fan, I saw this play out where the Cowboys had some really good defenses in 22 23.
- 21:41[SPEAKER_01]: they get to a playoff game against the packers and the packers are just dedicated to putting two guys on my comparisons wherever it goes and it just really completely nullified the past rush of Dallas they had guys like the Marcus Lawrence and Dante father who are good players but not guys that can be that can consistently win one on one and that really torpedoed their season they gave up 49 points in that game.
- 22:07[SPEAKER_01]: I think if you can build a unit that has four or five guys that are all about the same caliber, that you feel good in any, you know, situation.
- 22:15[SPEAKER_01]: That's ideal.
- 22:17[SPEAKER_01]: It's also really hard to do that.
- 22:18[SPEAKER_01]: Just like it's hard to find a superstar password.
- 22:20[SPEAKER_01]: There's just not many of those guys out there.
- 22:22[SPEAKER_01]: And that's why I think like what the chargers did last year with Jesse Minter, you know, they have a 34-year-old Cleo Mack, they had buddha pre, they had a doffy away for half the season.
- 22:33[SPEAKER_01]: Again, nobody that would be ranked as a top 12 pass rusher, and yet that was arguably the best defense in the league.
- 22:39[SPEAKER_01]: So it really depends on who's calling your defense.
- 22:45[SPEAKER_00]: I feel like I got a couple follow-up questions here, Marcus, and the first thing I would ask is, what is the right number in this edge rotation?
- 22:52[SPEAKER_00]: Is it three?
- 22:52[SPEAKER_00]: Is it four?
- 22:53[SPEAKER_00]: Is it five?
- 22:54[SPEAKER_00]: And I think if you go any further than that, I don't know if there's many teams that keep six edge pressures out there.
- 22:59[SPEAKER_00]: But you obviously, you want to have your best guys on the field, right?
- 23:02[SPEAKER_00]: But
- 23:03[SPEAKER_00]: at not at the cost, you want them to be fresh.
- 23:06[SPEAKER_00]: And so, where's the balance of keeping your most talented players fresh on the field not digging too deep into your lineup where you're going to get less production, less efficiency?
- 23:16[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think you want to have three.
- 23:17[SPEAKER_01]: Three guys that you feel really good about.
- 23:20[SPEAKER_01]: Typically, one guy is going to be better than the other two.
- 23:23[SPEAKER_01]: And that guy you want to get, I think, around 700 to 800 snaps.
- 23:26[SPEAKER_01]: And then kind of split up the snaps between the other two.
- 23:30[SPEAKER_01]: The goal here is to be good in the playoffs, right?
- 23:33[SPEAKER_01]: If you've got one guy, and this is the situation like the Raiders have run into the last couple years, they've got Max Crosby, an all-procaliver player who's playing a thousand snaps each season, but by the time we get to December in January, he's just gasped, right?
- 23:47[SPEAKER_01]: And you don't have anybody that can take any of the pressure off of him.
- 23:52[SPEAKER_01]: I think three is the right number fours would be great.
- 23:56[SPEAKER_01]: but it's also really hard to find four quality edge rushers in today's NFL.
- 24:00[SPEAKER_00]: And one more question for you here, Marcus.
- 24:02[SPEAKER_00]: Past defense, past rush.
- 24:05[SPEAKER_00]: They go hand in hand.
- 24:06[SPEAKER_00]: They work together, Cowboys fan.
- 24:08[SPEAKER_00]: You know that better than anybody.
- 24:09[SPEAKER_00]: The pressure, Mike, I got direct impact on the cornerback production and how well they were able to perform there.
- 24:16[SPEAKER_00]: What's more important in today's NFL right here and right now is it having a deep well-rounded Past defense that can aid your past rush and allow them the time to get there or is it getting really quick pressure and not Investing quite as much in your back into your defense
- 24:34[SPEAKER_01]: I still think it's a pressure up front and I think Houston's the best example of this.
- 24:37[SPEAKER_01]: No, well, yeah, maybe not because they also have really good luck.
- 24:42[SPEAKER_01]: When you can get pressure with your front for and not have to blitz, you can do so many creative things on the back end.
- 24:49[SPEAKER_01]: Whereas if you've got great coverage, but you have to send pressure to get, you know, the blitz.
- 24:54[SPEAKER_01]: This is the problem that Minnesota has run into the last couple years.
- 24:57[SPEAKER_01]: They've got, they've got the town in the secondary.
- 24:59[SPEAKER_01]: They haven't had it up front, so they have to blitz.
- 25:01[SPEAKER_01]: It just leaves you more exposed to giving up big plays.
- 25:04[SPEAKER_01]: I would rather have the consistent pressure up front.
- 25:07[SPEAKER_00]: I agree.
- 25:08[SPEAKER_00]: I think that that's still where I would lean though.
- 25:10[SPEAKER_00]: I think it is trending a little bit more towards the past defense.
- 25:13[SPEAKER_00]: We will see what happens in 2026.
- 25:15[SPEAKER_00]: All right.
- 25:17[SPEAKER_00]: This is stacking the box.
- 25:18[SPEAKER_00]: It premieres every Tuesday evening.
- 25:20[SPEAKER_00]: Be sure to check it out.
- 25:21[SPEAKER_00]: You can follow Marcus on X at Marcus underscore.
- 25:25[SPEAKER_00]: Moser.
- 25:25[SPEAKER_00]: You can follow me on X at Tommy Jagai.
- 25:28[SPEAKER_00]: You can download the stack in the box podcast wherever you get your podcast.
- 25:31[SPEAKER_00]: Also check us out on YouTube.
- 25:32[SPEAKER_00]: If you can follow my written content on stillcurtain.com Marcus is written content on the fan-sided NFL network.
- 25:39[SPEAKER_00]: Be sure to check out fan-sided.com for all your daily sports news and opinions.
- 25:43[SPEAKER_00]: And thanks again for listening to Stacking the Box.