Latest / Epic Fury: The US-Iran War Podcast / Iran War Day 71: Trump Awaits Iran Letter as US Fires on Tankers, Rubio Demands Serious Offer
Transcript
- 0:16Rubio said Friday morning the United States expects a response
- 0:20from Iran on the peace proposal. Yesterday, Trump said he is
- 0:24expecting a letter from Iran. Supposedly tonight Iran's
- 0:28Foreign Ministry called it a grotesque absurdity for the US
- 0:31to claim to seek peace while simultaneously threatening one
- 0:34big glow. Iran's Foreign Minister Arachi
- 0:37posted on X that every time a diplomatic solution is on the
- 0:40table, the US opts for a reckless military adventure and
- 0:43that Iranians never bow to pressure and diplomacy is always
- 0:47the victim. the US fired on 2 Iranian oil tankers on Friday to
- 0:51enforce the blockade. Hezbollah attacked an Israeli
- 0:55military base, the first publicly claimed cross-border
- 0:58strike since the Lebanon ceasefire extension was
- 1:00announced, and the State Department announced the second
- 1:03round of Israel Lebanon peace negotiations to be held later
- 1:07this month. It is Saturday, May 9th, 2026,
- 1:11day 71 of Operation Epic Fury. The war is 71st morning.
- 1:16The ceasefire is intact for Trump, who also fired on 2
- 1:20Iranian tankers on Friday and named the Hormuz Transit
- 1:23operation Project Freedom and announced Project Freedom Plus
- 1:26is available if a deal does not materialize.
- 1:29Iran's response is expected, according to Rubio today.
- 1:33And the distance between Iran's grotesque absurdity,
- 1:36characterization, and assigned framework agreement is precisely
- 1:39where this war currently lives. This is episode 71 of Epic Fury,
- 1:44the US Iran War podcast. Follow on Spotify and Apple
- 1:49Podcast to stay with this story as it develops.
- 1:52Let's get into it. Begin with Friday's diplomatic
- 1:55standoff. Because it contains the most
- 1:57compressed sequence of contradictory signals this
- 2:00conflict is produced in any single day, and because embedded
- 2:03within those signals is the specific question that Day 71
- 2:07exists to answer. Rubio said on Friday morning
- 2:10that the United States expected a response from Iran on the
- 2:13peace proposal that day. He said the US would see what
- 2:17the response entails and that he hoped it was a serious offer.
- 2:21Those two formulations, we will see what it entails.
- 2:24I hope it is a serious offer. Are Rubio managing American
- 2:27public expectations with deliberate care?
- 2:30He did not say a response had arrived.
- 2:32He said the US expects 1 today. He did not say the framework is
- 2:37agreed or that Iran has committed.
- 2:40He said he hopes the Iranian response is serious, meaning one
- 2:43would assume a response that rejects the framework or
- 2:46restates the grotesque absurdity position would not constitute a
- 2:50serious offer. By Friday afternoon, Trump
- 2:53confirmed from the White House that he was expecting a letter
- 2:55from Iran supposedly tonight as he was departing for the
- 2:59weekend. Asked whether he believed Iran
- 3:01was slow rolling the negotiations, Trump replied.
- 3:04We will find out soon enough that exchange, Rubio expecting a
- 3:08response, Trump expecting a letter supposedly tonight.
- 3:12Neither confirming arrival as of the afternoon press pool brings
- 3:15Day 71 to a specific and unresolved question.
- 3:19Did the letter arrive and what did it say?
- 3:21As of this Friday night recording, no public
- 3:24confirmation of the letters arrival have been reported by
- 3:27any major news organization. The 48 hour response window the
- 3:31administration described on Wednesday as the expected
- 3:34Iranian reply timeline has extended through Thursday
- 3:37afternoon, through Thursday night, through Friday morning,
- 3:40and into Friday evening without a publicly confirmed final
- 3:43Iranian answer. The extension of that window is
- 3:46itself significant. Iran's civilian diplomatic track
- 3:50is conducting an internal deliberation on the most
- 3:52significant and consequential strategic concession its
- 3:55government has been asked to make since 1979.
- 3:58The nuclear commitment. The enriched uranium stockpile
- 4:02removed from Iranian territory, potentially to the United States
- 4:06for Dow prohibited snap inspections authorized a
- 4:10framework that binds a 12 to 15 year moratorium on enrichment.
- 4:15Lebanon included in the war ending declaration.
- 4:18Each of those elements requires common A's explicit
- 4:21authorization. Each requires that the Irgc's
- 4:25hardline position that Iran does not negotiate under military
- 4:28pressure, that any concession made under duress is
- 4:31capitulation, That Arachi's grotesque absurdity formulation
- 4:35is the right characterization be overcome by the civilian tracks
- 4:38argument. That the cost of not conceding
- 4:40now under this blockade and this military posture is greater than
- 4:44the cost of conceding. That deliberation is happening
- 4:47in meetings, audio calls and internal governmental
- 4:49communications that no public reporting can see.
- 4:52In that Pakistan's mediation team may be only partially
- 4:55informed of whether the letter arrives tonight or over the
- 4:58weekend, or whether the deliberation ultimately produces
- 5:01a rejection of the framework rather than agreement to sign
- 5:04it, is the specific question around which the entire 71 day
- 5:08arc of this war is currently suspended waiting.
- 5:11Iran's Foreign ministry spokesperson's characterization
- 5:13of the situation, a grotesque absurdity, is its most emphatic
- 5:17and unambiguous public rejection of the diplomatic framing the
- 5:21administration has used for the past week.
- 5:23The specific absurdity the spokesperson identified is the
- 5:26following contradiction. The United States claims to be
- 5:29seeking peace, to be working to avoid a nuclear crisis, to be
- 5:33engaged in a sincere diplomatic process, while the same
- 5:36president is publicly offering a solution of one big glow as the
- 5:39stated alternative to a deal. Those two positions, the
- 5:42spokesperson argued, are impossible to reconcile in a
- 5:46single coherent foreign policy. You cannot simultaneously
- 5:49present yourself as a peace seeking power and threaten what
- 5:52Trump's phrasing evokes, a single catastrophic strike that
- 5:56produces a visible glow in the same Friday press availability.
- 6:00Iran's Foreign ministry is using that contradiction to
- 6:03characterize the American approach not as a genuine peace
- 6:06offer, but as a coercive ultimatum dressed in the
- 6:08language of diplomacy. The framework document in this
- 6:12framing is not an invitation to negotiate.
- 6:15It is a pressure instrument. Agree to these terms or face the
- 6:19glow. The grotesque absurdity
- 6:21formulation is Iran telling its domestic audience, its regional
- 6:25allies, and the international community that it does not
- 6:28regard the American approach as a sincere negotiation and that
- 6:31its response, whatever the letter being discussed might
- 6:34contain, is being made under duress, not in genuine
- 6:37partnership. Foreign Minister Arachi's post
- 6:40on X articulated the historical pattern that underlies the
- 6:43grotesque absurdity accusation. He wrote that every time a
- 6:47diplomatic solution is on the table, the US opts for a
- 6:50reckless military adventure. He said whatever the causes, the
- 6:54outcome is the same. Iranians never bow to pressure
- 6:57and diplomacy is always the victim.
- 7:00That is Iran's official framing of the sequential pattern of
- 7:03this entire war. The June 20, 2512 day conflict
- 7:07came after indirect talks failed and Israel struck.
- 7:11Operation Epic Fury on February 28th came after the pre war
- 7:15nuclear negotiations broke down. The May 7th CENTCOM strikes came
- 7:20while proposed framework was actively under Iranian review.
- 7:23The pattern Arachi describes is talks, then strikes.
- 7:28And the lesson he says Iran draws from that consistent
- 7:31pattern is that pressure does not produce concessions from the
- 7:33Islamic Republic. It produces defiance.
- 7:37Whether that lesson is the one Common A is applying as he
- 7:40considers the letter being drafted, or whether the economic
- 7:43cost of the blockade has finally produced a different calculation
- 7:46in the governing councils, is what the Friday letter, if it
- 7:49arrives, will reveal. That framing is Iran's official
- 7:53public diplomatic posture on Friday.
- 7:56It's private posture. What is in the letter Trump says
- 7:58he is expecting is the operative question that the grotesque
- 8:01absurdity statement does not answer.
- 8:04The public defiance and the private response have been
- 8:06different documents throughout this conflict.
- 8:09Iran's public statements have consistently been more defiant
- 8:12than its private proposals through the Pakistan channel.
- 8:15Every proposal Iran has sent through this process, the first
- 8:18Hormuz opening offer, the revised 2 stage framework, the
- 8:2214 point counter proposal was preceded and accompanied by
- 8:25public statements describing the US as untrustworthy.
- 8:29The talks is held under unacceptable conditions and any
- 8:32concession as capitulation to an aggressor.
- 8:35Whether Friday night's expected letter is more consistent with a
- 8:38grotesque absurdity framing or with a framework that Trump says
- 8:41Iran has already agreed to is the specific question the
- 8:44weekend will answer. the US fired on 2.
- 8:47Iran flagged oil tankers on Friday in separate incidents,
- 8:51preventing them from docking at Iranian ports in violation of
- 8:54the naval blockade. Both vessels were attempting to
- 8:57transit to Iranian ports. Enact the blockades.
- 9:00Rules of engagement prohibit the ceasefire Trump confirmed
- 9:04remains in effect after the tanker incidents.
- 9:07The tanker firings are the blockade performing its design
- 9:09function, intercepting and turning away ships carrying
- 9:13cargo to or from Iranian ports. They do not constitute new
- 9:17offensive strikes against Iranian military infrastructure
- 9:20in the way Thursday's CENTCOM self-defense strikes did, but
- 9:24they represent the continued and active operation of maximum
- 9:27economic pressure. On the same Friday that
- 9:29diplomatic correspondence is expected to arrive, The 48th,
- 9:3349th, and 50th ships turned away from Iranian ports since the
- 9:36blockade began on April 13th are being turned away on the same
- 9:40day. Rubio is hoping for a serious
- 9:42Iranian offer. The blockade does not pause for
- 9:45diplomacy. The economic pressure on Iran's
- 9:48fiscal position accumulates whether or not the letter
- 9:51arrives today, whether or not it arrives tomorrow, whether or not
- 9:55Rubio's hope for a serious offer is fulfilled.
- 9:58That is, of course, precisely the point.
- 10:01The blockade is the primary reason the letter is being
- 10:04written at all. Without the $500 million a day
- 10:07drain, without the 53,000,000 barrels trapped in tankers in
- 10:11the Gulf, without the 49 ships turned away, there is no letter.
- 10:16Trump named the Hormuz guided transit operation on Friday,
- 10:19revealing it was officially called Project Freedom.
- 10:22Speaking to reporters as he left the White House for the weekend,
- 10:25he said. I think Project Freedom is good,
- 10:28but I think we have other ways of doing it also.
- 10:31We may go back to Project Freedom if things do not happen,
- 10:34but it would be Project Freedom Plus, meaning Project Freedom
- 10:37plus other things. The Plus formulation is Trump's
- 10:41escalation signal delivered in real time.
- 10:44Project Freedom. The original Monday operation
- 10:47involved 15,000 service members, more than 100 aircraft and
- 10:51guided missile destroyers transiting the Strait.
- 10:54It was paused on Tuesday evening after triggering Iranian fire
- 10:58and the CENTCOM self-defense strikes that followed.
- 11:01Trump is now describing a version that builds on that
- 11:04foundation, with unspecified additions.
- 11:07Whether those other things include the Dark Eagle
- 11:09hypersonic missiles that CENTCOM formally requested for
- 11:12deployment in early May, expanded Carrier Strike Group
- 11:15operations, strikes on straight adjacent IRGC shore
- 11:19installations, or elements of a broader reinstatement of
- 11:21offensive combat operations is not specified by the Plus
- 11:25formulation alone. That deliberate vagueness is the
- 11:28point. Project Freedom Plus is a threat
- 11:31whose specific contents are not disclosed, which makes it more,
- 11:35not less, effective as a deterrent.
- 11:37Iran's military planners must plan against the full range of
- 11:41what the plus could encompass. They cannot dismiss it as
- 11:44equivalent to the original Monday operation, which the IRGC
- 11:48tested and survived at the cost of having military facilities
- 11:51struck inside Iran in self-defense on Thursday.
- 11:55The plus is Trump's signal that the next version of the straight
- 11:57operation, if diplomacy fails to produce the letter he is waiting
- 12:01for, will be something Iran has not yet experienced in the
- 12:04current conflict. Trump's Truth Social post on
- 12:07Thursday described the US military response to Iranian
- 12:11attacks on the destroyers with characteristic directness.
- 12:14He wrote that the Iranian drones and missiles dropped ever so
- 12:17beautifully down to the ocean, very much like a butterfly
- 12:20dropping to its grave. He said Iran trifle with the US
- 12:25and described the American response as blowing them away.
- 12:28He named the three destroyers the USS Rafael Peralta, the USS
- 12:33Mason, and the third vessel is all confirmed unharmed despite
- 12:36the Iranian onslaught. He separately praised the
- 12:39American military's ability to deflect the missiles, drones and
- 12:43small boat attacks simultaneously.
- 12:46Then he added what is, taken at face value, a significant
- 12:49strategic claim about Iranian nuclear intentions.
- 12:53He wrote. A normal country would have
- 12:54allowed these destroyers to pass, but Iran is not a normal
- 12:58country. They are led by lunatics and if
- 13:02they had the chance to use a nuclear weapon, they would do it
- 13:04without question. That statement, without question
- 13:08they would use it. Is Trump publicly articulating
- 13:10the strategic rationale for the nuclear constraint at the center
- 13:14of the framework being negotiated.
- 13:16The entire structure of the proposed agreement, the
- 13:19moratorium, the stockpile removal, the Furt out
- 13:22prohibition, the SNAP inspections, is premised on the
- 13:25belief that an Iran with a nuclear weapon would eventually
- 13:27use it. Trump is saying that explicit
- 13:30from the Oval Office and on Truth Social simultaneously, he
- 13:34warned that the US would knock Iran out a lot harder and a lot
- 13:38more violently in the future if Iran does not get its deal
- 13:41signed fast. The sign fast formulation is
- 13:44Trump's deadline expressed as an imperative rather than a
- 13:47specific timeline. It is directed at the Iranian
- 13:51government currently reviewing. The framework letter is also
- 13:54directed at every news organization and government
- 13:57watching to ensure that the pressure architecture's message
- 14:00is received at full force by every audience simultaneously.
- 14:04That warning sign fast is Trump's timeline pressure
- 14:07applied directly to the question of what is in Friday's expected
- 14:10letter. The CENTCOM strikes on Thursday
- 14:13are the most recent demonstration of what happens
- 14:16when Iran interferes with U.S. military vessels in the Strait.
- 14:20The tanker firings on Friday are the blockade at work.
- 14:24Project Freedom Plus? Is the escalated straight
- 14:26operation available if the letter does not produce a result
- 14:30and one big glow remains the in state threat if no deal
- 14:33materializes that architecture of escalating consequences.
- 14:38Thursday's self-defense strikes. The Friday blockade tanker
- 14:41firings, Project Freedom Plus on standby.
- 14:44One big glow as the terminal option is Trump's pressure
- 14:47ladder fully extended on the 71st day of the war.
- 14:50Hezbollah's attack on an Israeli military base on Friday is the
- 14:54first time the Lebanese organization has publicly
- 14:57claimed responsibility for a cross-border strike since the
- 14:59Lebanon ceasefire extension was announced.
- 15:02Previous ceasefire violations, and now up in hundreds on both
- 15:05sides, frequently went unattributed or were described
- 15:09through vague statements about responding to provocation.
- 15:12Hezbollah publicly claiming this strike by name is a different
- 15:15kind of communication. It is Hezbollah telling Israel,
- 15:19the US and the international community that it is operating
- 15:21under its own rules of engagement regardless of any
- 15:24ceasefire framework, That its strategic calculation has
- 15:27changed since Operation Eternal Darkness killed 92 people in
- 15:31Beirut on Tuesday, and that the Lebanon ceasefire announced
- 15:34extended shattered by Operation Eternal Darkness is not a
- 15:38constraint on its military posture.
- 15:41The State Department announced on Friday that a second round of
- 15:44Israel Lebanon peace negotiations will be held later
- 15:47this month. The first round produced the
- 15:49three-week ceasefire extension that Operation Eternal Darkness
- 15:53shattered on Tuesday after 11 days, the second round being
- 15:56announced while Hezbollah is claiming cross-border strikes
- 15:59and while Israel is conducting daily operations in southern
- 16:02Lebanon. Is the United States attempting
- 16:04to reassemble a Lebanon diplomatic architecture even as
- 16:08both sides demonstrate it has no operational reality?
- 16:11The State Department described the second round as seeking A
- 16:14framework for lasting peace, the full restoration of Lebanese
- 16:17sovereignty, and the delineation of borders.
- 16:20Those objectives, lasting peace, sovereignty, restoration, border
- 16:24delineation, are the right long term targets for a Lebanon
- 16:28settlement. They presuppose conditions that
- 16:30Operation Eternal Darkness and Hezbollah's Friday strike have
- 16:33made more rather than less distant in the immediate term,
- 16:36but which the State Department is correct to pursue as the
- 16:39eventual architecture of a Lebanon settlement whenever that
- 16:42settlement becomes achievable. The United States imposed new
- 16:45sanctions on Chinese entities on Friday for supporting Iran's
- 16:49military and defense industrial base.
- 16:52Rubio said the United States will take all necessary action
- 16:55at its disposal to target third country entities and individuals
- 16:59aiding Iran's military. Chinese entities that have been
- 17:02supplying Iran with components and materials throughout the
- 17:05war, drone parts, avionics, industrial precursors and other
- 17:09dual use materials are now formally sanctioned by
- 17:12Washington. The China sanctions are
- 17:14simultaneously A substantive pressure measure and a
- 17:17diplomatic signal. Substantively, they are designed
- 17:20to close the supply chain channels through which Iran has
- 17:23been partially offsetting the blockades economic impact.
- 17:26Diplomatically, they are Washington telling Beijing that
- 17:29supporting Iran's military and defense industrial base during
- 17:33active nuclear negotiations will be penalized regardless of US
- 17:36China trade diplomacy happening simultaneously.
- 17:40Rubio sanctioning China based entities on the same day he is
- 17:43hoping for a serious Iranian offer.
- 17:45Is the administration maintaining maximum pressure on
- 17:48every dimension simultaneously on Iran directly on the blockade
- 17:52and on the third party networks that have been cushioning Iran's
- 17:55economic position? The ASEAN summit in the
- 17:58Philippines adopted A contingency plan on Friday to
- 18:01mitigate the Iran war's impact on member economies.
- 18:05The Philippines, among the worst affected by fuel price spikes
- 18:08caused by the hormones closure, hosted the summit with President
- 18:11Ferdinand Marcos ordering it stripped of traditional ceremony
- 18:15in acknowledgement of the economic emergency facing the
- 18:18region. The contingency plan includes
- 18:20establishing a regional fuel reserve and coordinating energy
- 18:24supply alternatives. Southeast Asia's collective
- 18:27acknowledgement that the Iran war requires a formal regional
- 18:30economic contingency plan, separate from an additional to
- 18:34any diplomatic resolution, is a measure of how broadly and
- 18:37deeply the 71 day conflict has embedded itself in global
- 18:40economic planning. EU NS Food and Agriculture
- 18:43Organization separately reported Friday that global cereal
- 18:46supplies are forecast to hold through 2026, with production
- 18:50rising 6% year on year, but that the Hormuz closure is driving up
- 18:54energy and fertilizer costs significantly, adding meaningful
- 18:58uncertainty to next year's wheat output projections in importing
- 19:01countries. Day 71.
- 19:04Rubio expected Iran's response today.
- 19:07Trump expected a letter supposedly tonight.
- 19:10Iran's Foreign ministry called it a grotesque absurdity.
- 19:14Arachi said Iranians never bow to pressure and diplomacy is
- 19:18always the victim. Two tankers fired on as the
- 19:21blockade held Project Freedom Plus on standby if things do not
- 19:26happen. Hezbollah attacked an Israeli
- 19:29military base, the first publicly claimed cross-border
- 19:32strike in weeks. The State Department announced
- 19:35the second round of Israel, Lebanon peace negotiations.
- 19:38China sanctioned for supporting Iran's defense industrial base.
- 19:43ASEAN adopted a war economic contingency plan and somewhere a
- 19:47letter is either on its way to Washington through Pakistan or
- 19:51it is not 71 days of war have brought the conflict to this
- 19:55specific moment. A Friday night, a channel in
- 19:57Islamabad, and a world waiting to find out what is inside the
- 20:01envelope. If this podcast is helping you
- 20:03make sense of what's happening, take 2 seconds to leave a five
- 20:07star rating on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 20:10It makes a huge difference to how many people find the show.
- 20:13And if you want the deeper breakdown of what's really going
- 20:16on and where this is heading, you can unlock the premium
- 20:18episodes directly in Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
- 20:22This has been episode 71 of Epic Fury, the US Iran War Podcast,
- 20:27and we will be back very soon.