Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #89 🎙️|Public Inquiry Break – If the River Could Speak 12th Aug 2026 Part B|
Transcript
- 0:05First off, if you're new to this podcast, I suggest you first
- 0:11listen to podcast number 88 to get a grasp of what is going on,
- 0:16or even better, return to the start of season two podcast
- 0:20number 41, which is the beginning of this podcast series
- 0:24for the public inquiry. And if you listened to the last podcast
- 0:30and managed to stay with me through water framework
- 0:34directives, water bodies, mixing zones, natural background
- 0:37concentrations, and even the rather grandly named
- 0:40physiochemical quality elements, which apparently I managed to
- 0:44mispronounce in the last podcast, as my ever vigilant
- 0:48friends were quick to let me know and take a bow and
- 0:51congratulations. You made it, and frankly, I think we all
- 0:55deserve some sort of certificate. But having spent
- 0:58all that time trying to understand this new European
- 1:01Commission guidance, I was left wondering what I should actually
- 1:04do with it. My first instinct was that this follow-on podcast
- 1:09should be about what we, as a community, need to do in
- 1:12response. And then I realised something rather important: we
- 1:16don't actually know what we're responding to yet. We know that
- 1:20just before the inquiry broke, the applicants asked for this
- 1:23newly published European Commission guidance to be put
- 1:26before the inquiry. We know that the pack subsequently admitted
- 1:33it, but what we didn't know yet is why. We don't know which part
- 1:37of the guidance the applicant considers particularly relevant,
- 1:41and we don't know how they intend to use it when the water
- 1:44evidence eventually comes before the inquiry. And I don't think
- 1:47it would be particularly helpful for me to sit here and guess.
- 1:51Perhaps when the water evidence begins, we'll find out. But
- 1:56having now read this document several times, I do know
- 1:59something I didn't know before. I know some of the things I want
- 2:02to listen for, and that brought me back to the question I asked
- 2:05at the end of the last podcast: Who speaks for the water?
- 2:09Because everybody else certainly seems to. The applicant speaks
- 2:14about it. The experts speak about it. The statutory bodies
- 2:17speak about it. The barristers will undoubtedly have quite a
- 2:20lot to say about it, and of course we campaigners have spent
- 2:23years talking about it also. So perhaps just once, instead of
- 2:27all of us speaking for the water, we should let the water
- 2:30speak for herself. And if the rivers and burns and springs of
- 2:34these hills could speak, perhaps she might say something like
- 2:38this. Apparently, you call me Water Body. I have to confess, I
- 2:43didn't know that was my name. I've had plenty of names over
- 2:47the years: On Kalu, On Ray, Byrne, Stream, Spring, and
- 2:53River. Some of you know me as the place where you fished as a
- 2:56child. Some know me as the river at the bottom of the farm. Some
- 3:01of you cross me every morning and probably don't think about
- 3:04me at all, and that's fine. I don't require your attention; I
- 3:09just keep moving. But lately, I seem to have attracted rather a
- 3:15lot of attention. Scientists are studying me, lawyers are
- 3:20discussing me, regulators are measuring me, and mining
- 3:24companies are modelling me, and campaigners are trying to
- 3:26protect me. So perhaps after all these years of everybody talking
- 3:31about me, I might get a word in for myself. The first thing you
- 3:36should probably understand is that I am considerably bigger
- 3:40than the bit of me you can see, you look over a bridge and there
- 3:44I am, a river. But I begin much further away. I fall as rain
- 3:49onto these hills, and I sink into the peat and soil, and I
- 3:53find my way through the cracks and spaces in the rocks, and
- 3:56move underground where you cannot see me. Eventually, I
- 4:01emerge again, a spring perhaps, then becoming a tiny burn, and
- 4:08that burn meets another and another until eventually I
- 4:12become large enough for you to give me a name, and from there I
- 4:16keep travelling. And there's something else you should
- 4:19probably know about me. I have never seen the boundary of the
- 4:24proposed mine. I don't know where the red line is. I don't
- 4:28know where one town land ends and another begins, and I don't
- 4:32stop flowing because somebody has reached the edge of a
- 4:35planning map. I follow the land. So, if you really want to
- 4:40understand what happens to me.
- 4:42Perhaps you should do the same. Follow the water, because what
- 4:47begins as a spring high in the hills can eventually become part
- 4:52of somebody else's river many miles downstream. Now, while
- 4:57I've been getting on with being a river. You humans have
- 5:00apparently been busy dividing me up. You've created things called
- 5:05water bodies. I understand why. You need boundaries so you can
- 5:09measure me, classify me, and decide what condition I'm in.
- 5:13But I discovered something interesting in that new European
- 5:17guidance. It acknowledges that the size of a water body can
- 5:21affect the assessment. That's curious because I'm still just
- 5:25water, the same water. So when somebody eventually sits in the
- 5:30public inquiry and says there will be no deterioration of the
- 5:34water body, perhaps don't just nod. Listen for which water body
- 5:42they mean? Where does it begin? Where does it end? Is it at the
- 5:48watershed? And perhaps it's down in Lockfoil. What exactly is
- 5:54included? Because there is quite a difference between reassured
- 5:59that the water body will be fine, and actually understanding
- 6:04what piece of water is being talked about. And while you're
- 6:09listening, do listen carefully whenever somebody talks about my
- 6:13baseline. That's another word I've learned recently. Baseline,
- 6:17essentially, it means what am I like now before anything
- 6:20happens, as we discovered in the last podcast, certain metals
- 6:26occur naturally in rocks and soils, and the European
- 6:29Commission guidance recognises that these natural background
- 6:34concentrations can be taken into account when water is assessed,
- 6:39making perfect scientific sense. If something was naturally
- 6:44present in me before mining, you cannot simply assume afterwards
- 6:49that mining put it there. But surely the reverse is also true.
- 6:54If one day somebody is going to say, "Ah, yes, but some of that
- 6:59was already there naturally, then we need to understand what
- 7:03actually was there naturally, and remember, I'm not
- 7:08necessarily the same after three weeks of rain as I am after
- 7:12three dry weeks in the summer. I change the amount of water
- 7:17flowing through me changes. What I carry can change. What is
- 7:23happening beneath the ground may not be exactly the same as what
- 7:27you can see on the surface. So, when you hear people talking
- 7:32about base lines, listen carefully, because if we don't
- 7:36understand what before looked like, we may one day find
- 7:40ourselves having a very complicated argument about what
- 7:44"after" means, and by then I can't take you back and show
- 7:49you. And of course, you already monitor me. Every so often,
- 7:55somebody appears with a little bottle and takes a bit of me
- 7:58away. I go off to a laboratory, and eventually return as
- 8:03numbers. Those numbers become tables and spreadsheets, and
- 8:08those tables and spreadsheets become reports. And after a
- 8:12while, somebody in a hearing room somewhere says, "The
- 8:16monitoring shows. Listen carefully when you hear those
- 8:20words too, because that little bottle came from somewhere at a
- 8:23particular moment. Was I running high after a day of rain? Was I
- 8:28low after a dry spell? How often did somebody come back? What
- 8:33exactly were they looking for? If people are making decisions
- 8:38about my future, I very much hope that they monitor me, but
- 8:44do understand what the monitoring actually tells you,
- 8:48because I'm not one bottle of water taken from one place on a
- 8:52Tuesday evening. I am a moving system. Which brings me to
- 8:58something else I also recently discovered about myself,
- 9:02apparently I can have a mixing zone. Who knew? And we talked
- 9:07about these in the last podcast. It's an area around a discharge
- 9:11point where, subject to conditions, concentration of a
- 9:15pollutant may exceed the relevant environmental quality
- 9:19standards, while the water body as a whole remains compliant.
- 9:24Now I'm a river, mixing things is something I'm particularly
- 9:28good at, so I understand the principle. But if the word
- 9:32mixing zone ever comes up when the water evidence begins,
- 9:36perhaps don't leave them floating around the hearing room
- 9:39as some abstract technical concept. Understand where the
- 9:44mixing zone actually is, and what piece of river are we
- 9:47talking about? How far does it extend? What happens there when
- 9:51I'm running low? What lives there? Because saying the water
- 9:55body as a whole remains compliant sounds wonderfully
- 9:59reassuring.
- 10:00But I imagine it sounds slightly less reassuring if you happen to
- 10:04be a trout living in that particular bit where the
- 10:07environmental quality standard is being exceeded, and then
- 10:12there's another word I've been thinking about: temporary. Some
- 10:16effects upon me may, under particular circumstances and
- 10:19subject to specific legal conditions, be regarded as
- 10:23short-term. I'm not going to repeat you yesterday's European
- 10:27legislation lesson. We've all suffered enough. But if somebody
- 10:31eventually tells you that an effect upon me will be
- 10:34temporary, don't immediately assume they're wrong. Listen
- 10:38instead for something much more important. How did they know?
- 10:43What evidence sits underneath that prediction? What bespoke
- 10:47model was used? What assumptions were made? And what happens if I
- 10:52behave differently from the model? And will somebody
- 10:56actually come back afterwards and establish that I recovered
- 10:59in the way they predicted? And here we arrive once again at
- 11:03those two words from the last podcast: sufficient certainty.
- 11:08They come from the European Commission guidance itself.
- 11:12Before authorisation, the competent authority has to
- 11:16establish with sufficient certainty that a project will
- 11:20not cause deterioration or compromise the achievement of
- 11:23good status or potential unless the appropriate legal exceptions
- 11:28apply, and the guidance says that decisions should be based
- 11:33on soundly documented evidence beforehand. I like those words
- 11:37because often I hear other words such as mitigation. Whenever
- 11:43something might happen to me, mitigation seems to arrive
- 11:46shortly afterwards. There will be measures, there will be
- 11:50controls, there will be monitoring, there will be
- 11:53systems designed to stop the things everybody is concerned
- 11:56about from happening, and I sincerely hope they all work.
- 12:00Believe me, I have absolutely no desire to prove anybody wrong.
- 12:05But if my future depends upon them, perhaps there is nothing
- 12:09unreasonable in listening carefully to the evidence that
- 12:12says they will work-not simply on paper, but work here in these
- 12:18hills, in this geology, through wet winters and dry summers, and
- 12:23those days when the rain comes sideways, and I become something
- 12:26rather different from the neat blue line on your map, and
- 12:31that's really what I'm asking you to do when the water
- 12:34evidence eventually comes before the inquiry. Listen to the
- 12:37evidence underneath the conclusions. If somebody tells
- 12:40you I won't deteriorate, understand how they reach the
- 12:43conclusion. If somebody produces a model predicting what I will
- 12:48do in 10 or 20 or 30 years, understand what assumptions went
- 12:52into that model. A model isn't me; it's an attempt to predict
- 12:57how I might behave, and that is why good science matters, not
- 13:02the science that tells one side what it wants to hear. Good,
- 13:08independent science that follows the evidence wherever it leads,
- 13:14because if you're going to ask everybody else for sufficient
- 13:17certainty, surely you have to be prepared to apply exactly the
- 13:21same standard to yourselves, and there's something else I'd also
- 13:26like you to remember. You've lots of names for me by now:
- 13:30surface water, groundwater, water body, chemical status,
- 13:34ecological status, mixing zone. Oh, and I understand why. You
- 13:39need ways of describing and measuring me in order to protect
- 13:43me, but don't confuse the language you've invented to
- 13:46describe me with me. Groundwater doesn't reach the edge of a
- 13:52planning application and politely turn around, and a
- 13:55track doesn't know whether it has just swum into a mixing
- 13:58zone. You created these classifications to help protect
- 14:02water. The danger comes if protecting the classification
- 14:07ever becomes more important than protecting the water itself,
- 14:11because ultimately I don't know whether a spreadsheet says I am
- 14:15compliant. I only know whether I can still support life. So
- 14:20perhaps I can answer that question from the end of the
- 14:23last podcast. Who speaks for the water? Maybe I've been speaking
- 14:29all along, through the springs that rise where it has always
- 14:32risen, through the fish returning to spawn, through the
- 14:36little burn after three days of rain, through the chemistry
- 14:41inside that sample bottle, through the groundwater moving
- 14:45quietly beneath your feet. Perhaps the problem isn't that I
- 14:50don't have a voice. Perhaps you simply need to learn how to
- 14:53listen to it. Listen to the applicants' experts. Listen to
- 14:58the statutory bodies. Listen to. The objectors and their experts,
- 15:02and listen particularly whenever somebody tells you what will or
- 15:05will not happen to me. Ask something useful like, "How do
- 15:09they know? What evidence lies underneath that conclusion?
- 15:13And does that evidence provide the sufficient certainty that
- 15:17the European Commission itself talks about? Because when the
- 15:21experts have finished, when the barristers have packed away
- 15:24their files, when the chairs in the hearing room are empty, I
- 15:29still have to come down from these hills through the peat and
- 15:33through the rock, through the springs and the burns, into the
- 15:36own ray and the own canoe, and onwards through every community
- 15:40downstream, so I don't need you to decide my future before
- 15:45you've heard the evidence. I need you to understand the
- 15:48evidence well enough to recognise what my future might
- 15:51depend on. And when all talking finally stops, listen to me.
- 15:59You've been listening to the Save Our Sperrins podcast,
- 16:02Voices from the Frontline. Thank you for joining us today. All
- 16:07the links you need, from campaign updates to our social
- 16:10media pages and resources mentioned in the conversation,
- 16:14are available in the show notes. Please take a moment to share
- 16:17this podcast with friends, neighbours, or anyone who cares
- 16:20about protecting our land and communities, and don't forget to
- 16:24hit the follow button on your podcast platform. It really
- 16:28helps the algorithm spread these voices further. Together, our
- 16:33voices are stronger. Thanks for listening, and until next time,
- 16:37keep standing with the land, the water, the air, and the people
- 16:41who protect them.