Latest / Sinister House / Chapter IX
Transcript
- 0:00Chapter nine of Sinister House by Leland Hall. This LibriVox recording was in the
- 0:06public domain. Read by Ben Tucker. Chapter nine. It was with mixed
- 0:13feelings of fear and love that I started out with Giles early the next afternoon
- 0:16to walk over to Eric's. I had slept until nearly noon and felt,
- 0:20if not refreshed, at least calm. I realized instinctively that I had need
- 0:26to be calm. I felt that we were walking on to the conclusion of
- 0:29the drama. Annette had telephoned to doctor Gresham, Eric's line being still out
- 0:34of order. I guess the poor fellow hadn't thought to do anything about it,
- 0:38and had learned that Julia was suffering only from a heavy cold. The
- 0:42doctor wouldn't say much, but he hinted that Julia's nerves were highly wrought up
- 0:46that she ought to have a change. The sky was overcast, it was
- 0:50cold, and the wind was rising. Giles and I swung along the road
- 0:53against it, silent for a good quarter of an hour, during which,
- 0:57thanks to the healthy exercise and the buffeting wind, I straightened out my mind
- 1:00and arrived at a rational decision as to my stand and conduct in this affair.
- 1:06Believe me, there was one stark fact I could not but face.
- 1:10I had turned Eric away from my house as I would have turned a carrier
- 1:12of pestilence. I felt for Eric as keenly as I had ever felt,
- 1:17but with the difference much as I knew he was suffering. I tried to
- 1:21harden my mind to believe that it was his own fault. Yet it really
- 1:26wasn't. I mean, he was not entirely blameworthy. He was acting almost
- 1:30as an animal would act, because something in his life had beaten him down
- 1:34to just that. He was determined to shun what had wickedly maltreated him.
- 1:40But by Gemini, a man hasn't a right to his own life, not
- 1:42even to his own past. If he wishes to live wholly alone, that's
- 1:47different. But there's hardly a man who can do that. Life does not
- 1:49let him. You know that my sympathies are easily aroused. They had been
- 1:55greatly excited by the suffering, visible acutely only to me of my two friends.
- 2:00Recent events, however, had shown me that sympathy, all in the
- 2:02guise of understanding, may be absurdly and dangerously blind. I was beginning to
- 2:07understand that afternoon. What more thoughtful natures than mine understand an early manhood,
- 2:14What certain temperaments are aware of instinctively from the first. The conventions of society
- 2:20and the activities of business all point to the fact that a man is only
- 2:23a piece in a machine, really not self important, but important only in
- 2:28his relations to others. Oh, I thought many things that are probably old
- 2:32and stale to the world, no matter how new, to what Net calls
- 2:36my simple nature. It isn't worth while recounting them. But I wasn't wholly
- 2:42converted. I could not turn Eric away from my house when he was in
- 2:45trouble. I had to turn him away or my own flesh and blood,
- 2:49my son would suffer cruelly. Just the same, I resented Giles prodding into
- 2:53Eric's past life, as if Giles and I had been thinking along the same
- 2:58line. He turned to me after we had gone a mile or so and
- 3:00said, I'm sorry, Pierre, you didn't hear the story of the Snarts
- 3:05as I told it last night. Greer has been mixed up with them in
- 3:08the past. It's a remarkable Don't for Heaven's sake tell it to me.
- 3:14I cried, it's an evil sounding name, and I'm sure it was an
- 3:17evil family it was, said Giles laconically. Then it's rotten luck that Julia
- 3:24and Eric, who are the salt of the earth, should have come to
- 3:27a house they had anything to do with luck. Oh no, not luck.
- 3:32There's a queer streak in human natures. Men come back to places for
- 3:37secret reasons, for feelings they cannot resist more than men come back. I
- 3:43said, look here, Pierre, Giles began sharply. You know that,
- 3:46simple minded as you are, you indulge yourself too much in the luxury of
- 3:51the dramatic, of the melodramatic. Indeed, you'll pass for a gentle soul,
- 3:53not too fiery, content with what the French call the menus pleasure.
- 4:00You're honest and kind and trustworthy. But upon my soul, sometimes I think
- 4:03you're a good deal of a damned fool. I cannot keep from smiling,
- 4:09partly because it was so like Giles, so true to type, as he
- 4:12would say, to pitch in to me with interpretations of myself. Partly because
- 4:16to be called a damned fool on that afternoon was strangely comforting. But I
- 4:21didn't say anything. I think that perhaps it's because I held my mouth shut
- 4:26so much during these horrid days that I ever wrote the story at all.
- 4:30I used to feel ashamed, then now I don't well. Giles went on
- 4:34in regard to this affair between mister and missus Greer, They're nervous, sensitive,
- 4:39and highly strung, not the sort of people you have seen much of
- 4:42or can be expected to understand. Therefore, they take on in your mind
- 4:46and heroic shape, and trail you along into a world of myths and goblins.
- 4:51The house they live in, which I grant is not up to date,
- 4:54gives you the creeps, the figures of speech they use aszoom in your
- 4:58imagination, a grotesque reality. On such things, your simple mind loves to
- 5:01dwell, and you think them over and over until your too easily stimulated imagination
- 5:08jumps out of your control and you are no longer responsible for what you claim
- 5:11to see and hear. You must control your mind and use it. You
- 5:15must take facts for what they are. He would have gone on and on,
- 5:18but I said, Giles, you are a wiser man than I,
- 5:21and for these few remarks on myself, many thinks I suppose experience teaches us
- 5:27to know ourselves, and I am learning in this which will always remain one
- 5:30of the most horrible in my life. I know that Annette thinks my mind
- 5:33is diseased. You think that it is unexercised, uncontrolled. Strangely enough,
- 5:41I think that my wits are about me. Now let me talk a little
- 5:44more. There are what you call facts well and good. You can say
- 5:47that in French for me if you want to. I will grant that my
- 5:50keen sympathy for Julia and for Eric too may have made me a little blind,
- 5:56but they like me. There's one fact in Neither an unexercized mine nor
- 6:00a too keen sympathy can do away with the fact that Julia and I too
- 6:04have You know, I could not say it. The great fact, Giles
- 6:11broke in, is that Eric Greer has kept to himself something that, by
- 6:14praying on him, has begun to pray on his wife and on his friends.
- 6:19True crime or misadventure. And I am inclined to think there are both,
- 6:25the one perhaps palliated by the other, something in his past life which
- 6:28demands an accounting or a confession. There's my explanation, what's yours? Remember,
- 6:33I can substantiate what I claim. I preferred to keep silent, and
- 6:38we walked on without a word, tramp tramp against the wind along the flat
- 6:43highway until the hemlocks by Eric's house hove in view. Then Giles turned suddenly
- 6:47to me and said, when there's a rotten thing in a man, the
- 6:51surgeon must cut it out. Watch Eric, whatever happens this afternoon, I
- 6:56am glad Julia will not be present. That took the wind out of me.
- 7:00I could not imagine what Giles had arranged for my dear little Flivver was
- 7:04standing in the driveway by the door, and just as we came up,
- 7:06Eric stepped from the house, evidently about to drive it back to me.
- 7:11When he saw us, however, he stood waiting, a finger on his
- 7:14lips. How I whispered, is Julia, she is asleep? Just now?
- 7:20He whispered back. The doctor judges that her cold is not serious.
- 7:26But I think we will go away for a change in a day or two.
- 7:29He looked pale and haggard, and his hand, as I took it,
- 7:31felt cold. Giles had little to say. I cannot fancy that Eric
- 7:36and Giles could ever have had much to say to each other. The one
- 7:40visionary and reserved the other rather cynical and very outspoken. There was a pause
- 7:46of a minute or so, embarrassing to all of us. But though Eric
- 7:49was preoccupied, I think he did not want us to jump into the ford
- 7:53and go back at once. After a while, he collected himself enough to
- 7:56invite us to be seated on the little veranda to the left of the front
- 7:59door. There happened to be three old chairs there. Giles looked at his
- 8:03watch. It's about four. He said to me. I say, career,
- 8:09could you give us a drop of tea? I've told you that such
- 8:11bluntness was what I envied in Giles Pharaoh. Eric responded, I'm sorry.
- 8:18I think the household is a little disorganized, and since Julia's asleep now,
- 8:22perhaps we'd better stay out of doors and will have to indulge me. Anyhow,
- 8:26I've got a hundred things to do about shutting up the house. My
- 8:30mind's disturbed too, But we can sit here a little while if you like,
- 8:33though, we'd better talk quietly. Julia's right up there, and he
- 8:37pointed to the corner room. Have a cigar, then, Eric I offered,
- 8:41forgetting that he did not smoke, He declined it and tipped his chair
- 8:43back against the wall. Giles and I were both facing him from the way.
- 8:48He pulled his cap down over his eyes and rested his head against the
- 8:52wall. I thought he must be tired, and his face, what I
- 8:54could see of it, was hollow and lined. So you're going to leave
- 9:00us, I began, Where are you going? Julia will go to stay
- 9:05with her cousin in a little town up state. You are not going with
- 9:09her. No, Eric replied in a very low voice. I I it
- 9:18sounded as if he had made up his mind to say he had to go
- 9:20elsewhere for reasons of business, but he broke off. I wondered if Julia
- 9:24and he had come to an understanding. I saw Giles look at his watch
- 9:28again, and it struck me as queer, because not five minutes could have
- 9:31passed since he had looked at it before. Alongside the veranda, the dead
- 9:37leaves on the bushes were rattling in the cold wind, which tore round the
- 9:39corner of the house. I fancied I heard a sort of banging in the
- 9:43distance, as of a loosened shudder. Everything was restless, gray and chill,
- 9:48and we three men alone on the bleak Veranda must have looked forlorn,
- 9:54Eric pulling his cap yet lower over his face so that all I could see
- 9:58of it was his mouth, and Chin said to me, I suppose,
- 10:03Pierre, you don't know of anyone who would hire this house furnished. Why?
- 10:09Perhaps that depends the thought of Eric's leaving the neighborhood. Together with the
- 10:13cold, dreariness of the day, the knowledge that the sprightly Julia who used
- 10:18to enliven us so was lying sick in one of the gloomy rooms above us,
- 10:22and the premonition that something disagreeable was going to happen, made an ordinary
- 10:26business conversation strange. Indeed, Now I thought the chances very unfavorable tenants for
- 10:35that sort of house would be rare in these days, anyhow, and at
- 10:37this time of the year, et cetera, et cetera, if I felt
- 10:41like selling Pierre, Eric went on, in a dreary voice, how much
- 10:46would the place spring? How much land you own? What you see here
- 10:50within the trees, and perhaps out to the road. Well, it wouldn't
- 10:56bring very much, I'm afraid, Eric, perhaps twenty five hundred, possibly
- 11:00three thousand. So little I saw a bitter smile, twist his lips so
- 11:07little, he repeated, and the cold wind swept his words away. It
- 11:13was hardly worth it. I turned round to size up the land, to
- 11:16do anything, rather than submit to the spirit of desolation that was moaning about
- 11:22us. There it was, the short empty driveway curving from under the hemlocks
- 11:26as from a tunnel, the half moon of land within it, the little
- 11:30bit of lawn on either side, where the grass was already dead and brownish.
- 11:35Fraid not more, Eric, I sighed, and turned back to face
- 11:39him. I'm afraid not more. Though I could not see his eyes,
- 11:43I knew that he had suddenly fixed them upon something behind me, something that
- 11:46must have come into the driveway in the last second. So sure was I
- 11:50of this that out of curiosity I should have turned round again, but for
- 11:54the amazing transformation which came over him, and which held me fixed in my
- 11:58chair and powerless to move. His jaw dropped so that his mouth hung open.
- 12:03He put up a trembling hand to cover his eyes, pushing back the
- 12:07cap from his brow as he did so. Then, very slowly, as
- 12:11if at the cost of great effort, over himself, he brought that hand
- 12:16back to the arm of his chair. I saw his eyes dilated, horrified,
- 12:20starting out of their sockets, still with a slowness that to me was
- 12:26excruciating. He lowered one foot from the wrong of the chair, feeling for
- 12:30the floor of the verandah, finding it, and then he let the chair,
- 12:33which had been tilted back against the wall of the house, come forward
- 12:37on its four legs. Slowly, terribly slowly. He regained control of himself,
- 12:43closed his mouth, set his jaw behind me. I heard the crunching
- 12:48of steps on the gravel. Someone was approaching, more or less hesitatingly,
- 12:52but steadily, someone whose appearance must have been to Eric as unspeakably what shall
- 12:58I say, a blasting, as the apparition of the female specter of malice
- 13:03had been to me. Even Giles groaned, overcome by the look on Eric's
- 13:09face, that ever fine handsome features, so often a glow with ardor and
- 13:13love, could become such a mask of hateful tragedy. He was getting to
- 13:18his feet, his loose raincoat fastened by only one button, flapping and almost
- 13:22tearing in the wind. Instinctively, I put out a hand towards him.
- 13:26He did not see it, He saw nothing but what was approaching him?
- 13:31With steps that were beginning to falter under his breath, he said, come
- 13:35on, I am not afraid of you, you rotting white devil. It
- 13:41was not more than a whisper, but it was terrible. Suddenly he stiffened
- 13:43to his full height. He snatched his cap from his head and flung it
- 13:46on the floor. Nostrils dilated and quivering, eyes blazing, he stamped on
- 13:52the floor. His hair blew like a wild man's in the strong cold wind.
- 13:56He cried out, with all the power of his full voice, come
- 14:00on, I say, what do you want? There was about him at
- 14:03that moment, and nobleness of rage, a majesty of defiance, something greatly
- 14:07heroic. I was fascinated by him. I could not take my eyes from
- 14:13him, and I only heard what went on A rather lisping voice. A
- 14:16woman's answered, I want to see mister Greer. Mister Greer replied Eric,
- 14:26still in that extraordinarily resonant, trumpet like voice, is not at home.
- 14:31He has gone away, Oh, said the woman. Then I will come
- 14:37again. I heard her footsteps as she retreated, and when they had grown
- 14:41faint, in my mind told me that the woman had descended into the tunnel,
- 14:46through the hemlocks, and gone out of sight. Then I saw Eric
- 14:50lay a hand on the veranda rail, vault over it and light on the
- 14:54brown grass just beyond the bushes. He stumbled but did not fall. I
- 15:00turned to watch him, crouching like a tiger. He darted across the lawn
- 15:03to the right, paused a second on a spot. Whence he could see
- 15:07that woman, now out of my sight, pursuing her way through the gloomily
- 15:11shadowed tunnel. Darted a little farther, always to keep her in view,
- 15:15across the lawn, down the driveway, into the tunnel. Maybe he stalked
- 15:18her. Thus as far as the road, I saw no more of him
- 15:22till he returned to us. Heaven save us. I groaned, what have
- 15:28you done? Giles? But all Giles would say, and he said it
- 15:31again and again was she must have been dreadful. She must have been dreadful.
- 15:41We waited without saying anything more, chilled by the comfortless, harsh wind,
- 15:46vague to each other in the failing gray light. And then Eric came
- 15:50back to us. Think of it. He was dazed, and he mounted
- 15:54the veranda steps wearily. The force of the wind had torn the button from
- 15:58his coat, so that the body of it flapped behind him. From his
- 16:02manner, it was evident that he was quite unconscious of the staggering effect his
- 16:06dramatic lie had had upon us. And indeed our amazement might well, from
- 16:10his point of view, have been quite negligible. Our moral sensibilities had been
- 16:15stunned, perhaps, but he well. He stopped and caught up his cap
- 16:19as the wind was blowing it away. Then he half sat on the rickety
- 16:23railing of the verandah, looking down at his cap, which he still held
- 16:26in his hands, and slowly fingered. His face was relaxed, I thought,
- 16:33he said, at last, it was a woman who I know is
- 16:37dead. He dropped his cap and took hold of the railing. Hold a
- 16:44snart, Giles asked, in a low, cold tone. I was shocked.
- 16:49But the effect of that name on Eric was like that of the touch
- 16:52of red hot iron on a maddened animal. He sprang to his feet,
- 16:57wrenching the rail with such force as to tear it from its standards. It
- 17:02was rotten anyhow, but his wildness lasted only a few seconds. With what
- 17:07must have been a more than normally human effort, he calmed himself. What
- 17:11makes you think that pharaoh? He returned, speaking quite evenly. Because this
- 17:17woman who has given you such a start is her cousin, and is said
- 17:22to look astonishingly like her. There could never have been more than two such
- 17:26as they calm yourself, Greer, I am calm, said Eric. I
- 17:33took a long breath, tentatively to make sure my lungs could function. Giles's
- 17:37temerity had knocked me breathless. It was a sanctimonious family, Giles remarked,
- 17:44apparently incongruously. Was it, yes, singularly colorless before the world, like
- 17:51that blanched fungus which grows in damp cellars. There was a sort of secret
- 17:55evil name in the neighborhood, though that was colorless too. They were cold
- 18:00blooded, all abnormally blonde. I was going to tell you last night when
- 18:03you interrupted me that Morgan Snart built this house. I'm surprised you are not
- 18:08more curious about it. Who me, yes, especially you. You bought
- 18:15the house, you know, I suppose through Grimmer and Strode. Eric's reply
- 18:21was spoken quietly. But if the gale had burst into a hurricane, I
- 18:25could not have been more startled, or our mask of tranquility more wildly swept
- 18:29away. None of your business. That's what he said. For the first
- 18:34and only time I saw Giles flabbergasted. He paled with anger. He stood
- 18:40up and began speaking rapidly, the words almost tumbling over each other. I
- 18:44happen to know that Grimmer and Strode were Morgan Snart's executors. Through them,
- 18:48I know that this house was never for sale. I know that on the
- 18:49death of Morgan Snart, this house passed to his daughter, and on the
- 18:53death of a few hours later of his daughter, it passed to the name.
- 18:57If ever it was spoken, was drowned. And Eric's loud, insane
- 19:00laughter. He threw back his head and laughed at the sky peal after peal.
- 19:07It made me almost sick to hear him. I had not known laughter
- 19:11could be such a voice of anguish. All the time, the wind was
- 19:15flapping his raincoat behind him, flattening his trousers against his thin legs. His
- 19:21long black hair mixed with gray, tossed about his head and face. He
- 19:25laughed until I thought I must stuff my fingers in my ears. He lifted
- 19:30his hands high before him, and the section of the rotten railing he still
- 19:33held, fell from them with a dull noise to the floor. Then he
- 19:37went slowly into the house, crying through his laughter. Oh my wife,
- 19:41Julia, Oh, my wife, Julia. His terrible laughter still came to
- 19:47us from within. I was speechless, Giles said, damned, madman.
- 19:52Listen, Pierre, shut up. I cried not a word. You've driven
- 19:56him mad. Keep your facts to yourself. Present, and not more than
- 20:00a minute, Eric came out again. His laughter had been in our ears,
- 20:04but at the sight of us, whose presence he may have forgotten,
- 20:07he ceased laughing. Suddenly. The sudden silence was in itself unnerving. No,
- 20:15he said, eyeing us mournfully. I may not go to my wife
- 20:19Julia. I am forbidden. He looked curiously at Giles and pointed a finger
- 20:26at him in the silence before he spoke again. I heard the distant banging
- 20:30of the loosened shudder. I think you are a ghoul in a dead man's
- 20:33grave, he said, in his habitual melancholy voice. But you have not
- 20:38learned all. Even you do not know who died first. Before Giles could
- 20:45make any reply to this crazy statement, Eric stepped from the porch and walked
- 20:48out of our sight into the blackness of the hemlocks. He did not leave
- 20:53us to silence. There was always the wind and the banging of that shutter.
- 20:57And then I heard a weak voice above my head, calling Eric,
- 21:02Eric. Oh, but it sounded miles away over a wind torn sea,
- 21:07Herrick, Herik. I knew Eric was out of his head. I ran
- 21:11into the house. Darkness was falling outside. Within was already deepest gloom.
- 21:18I rushed upstairs like a wanderer in a nightmare. I knew not where or
- 21:22which door for me to find. But I paused and listened and tried,
- 21:26and at last I opened the door and walked into a chamber, where,
- 21:30almost invisible in the dusk, little Julia lay in a great bed. Julia,
- 21:34I said, going softly to the bedside. Eric is away. I
- 21:38am, Pierre, stay with me. A moment. I am frightened.
- 21:42I dreamed I heard Eric laughing like a man gone mad. What a horrid
- 21:47dream, Julia, Where is Eric? I will find him, Yes,
- 21:52find me Eric. He must not be alone with his black thoughts. I
- 21:56will find him, Julia. But is it best to bring him back to
- 21:59you? You are not strong the night is here. Though the whole house
- 22:03was trembling in the force of the wind, cheerless, dark, and full
- 22:07of drafts, yet for the time being it was empty of evil. Never
- 22:11did those sinister spirits lurk in its corners or lope along its shadowy walls.
- 22:15While the Master was away. Only the memory of dread now haunted it.
- 22:19For the present, all was actually well, though dreary and under the spell
- 22:23of a foreboding. I should have been glad to prevail upon Julia, not
- 22:27to call back Eric from wandering abroad with his black thoughts, with his malevolent
- 22:33familiars. If only he could have slipped them a mile or so away upon
- 22:37the road, and left them bobbing and fluttering against the wind, powerless to
- 22:41follow him. But that he could not do. They would come into the
- 22:45house with him. They were strong after sundown. Julia was weak this night.
- 22:49The odds would be with them. Julia, I will find Eric,
- 22:55but let me take him away with me. I am afraid to be a
- 23:00I will fetch a Nette. She will stay with you tonight. Giles is
- 23:03downstairs too, Pierre, she said, calmly, thinking for my boy.
- 23:08You cannot take Eric to your house. You know, Yes, I know,
- 23:14I repeated, shuddering. If I am to die tonight, I want
- 23:18Eric with me. You will not die tonight, Julia. Not of your
- 23:22cold. No, not of my cold, she whispered hoarsely. It was
- 23:29so dark I could hardly make out her form in the bed, but I
- 23:33knew she had relapsed into a state of exhaustion. So I went downstairs to
- 23:37the ford. Giles was sitting where I had left him. He was still
- 23:41angry, but puzzled more to know what Eric's last cryptic words had meant.
- 23:45I requested him to stay at the house at least until I returned with the
- 23:48net. Then I started off, but I did not go at once to
- 23:52my own home. I drove a mile up the highway in the other direction,
- 23:56looking for Eric. The twilight had deepened into night. If Eric had
- 24:00left the road, I could not hope to see him. But until I
- 24:03turned back towards my house, I thought my lights might pick him out ahead
- 24:07of me. Even after I turned, I rather thought I had guessed wrong
- 24:10on the direction he had taken, and that I should discover him on the
- 24:12road the other way. But I didn't, though my eyes were strained for
- 24:17the sight of him. Where was he on this wild night? I will
- 24:22say that I had never imagined him gone to the high cliffs over the river
- 24:25to make an end of himself. I apprehended nothing worse than roaming half the
- 24:30night in search of him, and passing the other half beside him, still
- 24:33tramping, perhaps, but perhaps before a fire at the Carraway club, that
- 24:37could be arranged. As I drew near my home, having missed him so
- 24:41far on the way, I put on all speed. There was a chance
- 24:45that he had set out for my house. I meant that he should not
- 24:48enter it. He wasn't there. The children were in the kitchen with a
- 24:52net, having their supper. I kissed them good night there and called Annette
- 24:56into the living room. A fire was blazing on the hearth, and the
- 25:00room was warm and cheerful. It was hard to tell my wife we must
- 25:03leave it. But I can't leave the children alone to night, she cried,
- 25:07I can't do it. You know. The telephone is out of order
- 25:11too. Yet I persuaded her to come with me. She saw that I
- 25:15dreaded what was ahead of me. That night. We hoped. I don't
- 25:19know what we hoped, but I had a premonition that the matter was going
- 25:22to be settled one way or the other. It might be settled early,
- 25:26it might be settled late. I remember one poignant detail of our departure.
- 25:33That was the sound of the bolts shot too behind us. It seemed like
- 25:37a defiance to Eric. Why Annette put the children to bed herself in our
- 25:42room. She made Felicia promise to sleep on a couch in the same room
- 25:47and to lock the room door. She insisted upon Felicia's closing the front door
- 25:51behind us, almost before we had crossed the threshold, and she would not
- 25:55leave the porch until she had heard the click of the bolt shot home,
- 25:57and sighed against Eric, who was wandering half crazed with some terrible secret grief
- 26:03through a cold, wild and friendless night. I see a Nette now making
- 26:08her way down the granelithic walk in the light of the forward lamps, holding
- 26:12her hat on her head against the wind, her wide mouthed knitting bag inflated
- 26:17and pulling at her arm, her skirts slashing like the canvas flap of a
- 26:21tent. She went first, and I followed her. So we had often
- 26:25gone to the theater, and now the curtain was about to rise on the
- 26:29last act of the strangest drama and the most terrible I have ever witnessed.
- 26:34End of Chapter nine