Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Name, Image and Likeness
Transcript
- 0:09Kentucky. Tonight I'm your host,
- 0:11Chip Polston. Well, it's almost
- 0:12college football season in
- 0:13Kentucky. Tonight we'll take a
- 0:14look at what may be considered
- 0:16the biggest transformation in
- 0:18the history of college sport.
- 0:20The shift to paying players
- 0:22through name, image and
- 0:23likeness deals or NIL tonight
- 0:25you'll hear from some of the
- 0:27biggest names in Kentucky
- 0:28collegiate sports. We'll have
- 0:30interviews with the presidents
- 0:30of the state's two flagship
- 0:32universities, Doctor Eli
- 0:34Capilouto at the University of
- 0:35Kentucky and Doctor Jerry
- 0:36Bradley at the University of
- 0:38Louisville. You'll also hear
- 0:39from Pat Kelsey, men's head
- 0:41basketball coach at the
- 0:42University of Louisville.
- 0:43Joining us live in the studio
- 0:45tonight are Jay Bat, CEO of
- 0:47Champions Blue, LLC and
- 0:49director of athletics at the
- 0:50University of Kentucky. Josh
- 0:52Hurd, director of athletics at
- 0:54the University of Louisville,
- 0:56Brooklyn. DeLay, a senior at
- 0:57the University of Kentucky and
- 0:58member of the volleyball team
- 0:59which made it to the NCAA
- 1:01tournament championship game in
- 1:032025. She is also an NIL
- 1:05participant and Kyle Tucker,
- 1:07veteran national sports
- 1:08journalist, formerly of The
- 1:10Athletic, the sports division
- 1:11of The New York Times and
- 1:13currently the director of
- 1:14college basketball content at
- 1:1624 over seven sports. Many
- 1:17thanks to all of you for being
- 1:19here with us tonight. And as
- 1:20always, we want to hear from
- 1:22you. You can send your
- 1:23questions and comments by X,
- 1:24formerly Twitter at Pub Affairs
- 1:27KET. Send an email to KY
- 1:29TONIGHT at ket.org. You can use
- 1:31the web form at ket.org/ky
- 1:34tonight, or you can call one
- 1:39(800) 494-7605. So how did we
- 1:42get here? It's hard to believe
- 1:44that it all started with a
- 1:45video game. Ed O'Bannon was a
- 1:48member of the 1995 men's NCAA
- 1:50national championship
- 1:51basketball team at UCLA,
- 1:53according to his book Court
- 1:55Justice. One afternoon in 2009,
- 1:57he saw a kid playing the EA
- 1:59sports game NCAA basketball oh
- 2:01nine on his Xbox 360. As he
- 2:04watched, he noticed a player
- 2:05for UCLA in the game who wore
- 2:07his number 31 was listed as
- 2:09being six feet, eight inches
- 2:10tall and 222 pounds, and was a
- 2:13left handed power forward. That
- 2:15was him. The only thing missing
- 2:17on the avatar was O'bannon's
- 2:19name on the back of his jersey.
- 2:20His pro basketball career had
- 2:22never turned him into a star,
- 2:23and at the time he was selling
- 2:25cars at a Toyota dealership in
- 2:26Nevada. After initially feeling
- 2:28flattered to be in the game, he
- 2:30then realized somebody was
- 2:31making money from this and it
- 2:33wasn't him that led to the
- 2:35groundbreaking O'Bannon versus
- 2:37NCAA lawsuit, the first of
- 2:39several which eventually
- 2:40resulted in the House versus
- 2:42NCAA settlement in June of last
- 2:44year, which paid 2.8 billion
- 2:47with a B $2.8 billion to
- 2:49athletes who had been denied
- 2:51Nil opportunities. And for the
- 2:52first time ever, schools were
- 2:54allowed to directly share
- 2:56revenue with athletes up to
- 2:57roughly $20.5 million per year
- 3:00per school. Coming from media
- 3:02rights, ticket sales and
- 3:04sponsorships. While schools
- 3:06cannot cross the $20.5 million
- 3:08institutional cap, athletes can
- 3:10receive unlimited additional
- 3:13funds through true third party
- 3:14Nil corporate deals and booster
- 3:17collectives, and proposed
- 3:18federal legislation could
- 3:19increase that cap significantly.
- 3:22So here we are in our sit down
- 3:24interviews with Doctor
- 3:25Capilouto, Doctor Bradley and
- 3:26Coach Kelsey. I started by
- 3:27asking all of them the same
- 3:29question. How has NIL
- 3:32complicated your job?
- 3:35>> Little did I realize 15
- 3:36months ago, stepping into this
- 3:38job, you know, I thought as
- 3:40provost, I knew kind of a lot
- 3:41of what was going on. But, you
- 3:43know, really what's happened
- 3:44over the last 15 months around
- 3:45the college athletics scene has
- 3:47just been unbelievable. I mean,
- 3:49you know, we talk about
- 3:50disruptions in higher ed, but
- 3:51right now in college athletics,
- 3:53it's it's a it's a tsunami.
- 3:57>> Not really complicated. Many
- 3:59things at the University of
- 4:01Kentucky are challenging. We
- 4:03always adapt, adjust, look for
- 4:05new ways forward. When
- 4:09compensation for student
- 4:11athletes was made permissible
- 4:13through court decisions and
- 4:17other rules and regulations, we
- 4:20did set up a new mechanism
- 4:22mechanisms to oversee and
- 4:24govern college sports give us
- 4:25some flexibility, and that is
- 4:28set up an LLC Champions Blue
- 4:32that is fully under our board
- 4:34of trustees, all state laws
- 4:37when it comes to procurement
- 4:38and open meetings. But that
- 4:41brought some new expertise
- 4:42around the table to help us at
- 4:44a time when the
- 4:48commercialization of college
- 4:49sports becomes more of a
- 4:53responsibility and opportunity.
- 4:56>> I don't know if it's
- 4:57complicated. It's obviously a
- 4:59seismic shift in our industry,
- 5:01and seismic shifts in
- 5:03industries happen all the time.
- 5:05And the important thing is if
- 5:06you want to be in the industry
- 5:08and you want to have success,
- 5:10you better adapt and you better
- 5:11run at that change versus being
- 5:13resistant.
- 5:15>> So, Jay, let me start with
- 5:16you. How has NIL complicated
- 5:18your role?
- 5:18>> Well thank you, Chip. Thanks
- 5:20for having us. I'd tell you
- 5:21that, you know, we are
- 5:22certainly tackling a
- 5:24tremendously new set of
- 5:27responsibilities each and every
- 5:28day, whether it's working
- 5:29through revenue sharing Nil
- 5:31opportunities to support our
- 5:32student athletes. But at the
- 5:34University of Kentucky, we
- 5:35choose to view this as an
- 5:38opportunity. And it's a
- 5:39changing tactic to develop and
- 5:42work through Nil opportunities.
- 5:44Rev share. But at the end of
- 5:46the day, the opportunity
- 5:47mission of college athletics
- 5:49remains the same. So while this
- 5:51tactic and being excellent
- 5:52around this tactic is important,
- 5:55remaining the opportunity
- 5:56mission of college athletics to
- 5:57provide opportunities to our
- 5:58student athletes remains the
- 6:00same.
- 6:00>> Josh how about you?
- 6:02>> It might have created 1 or 2
- 6:04more headaches, but like
- 6:06everybody said here, it's it's
- 6:07an opportunity. It's an
- 6:09opportunity for us to, to
- 6:10evolve and get better. And it's
- 6:12something that we preach at the
- 6:13University of Louisville and
- 6:14our athletic department, which
- 6:15is evolve or die. And we can
- 6:17sit here and say, we don't like
- 6:19it or it shouldn't be this way.
- 6:21It is this way. And so we've
- 6:23got to figure it out because we
- 6:24want to try to be really good
- 6:26in everything we do at the
- 6:28University of Louisville, and
- 6:29that's where we're at right now.
- 6:30So in some ways it hasn't
- 6:32changed anything. We were just
- 6:33having the conversation about
- 6:34watching a field hockey game
- 6:35Sunday at 1:00. That aspect of
- 6:37it hasn't changed at all, but
- 6:38the aspect of just trying to
- 6:40figure out the business
- 6:41functions and monetize and
- 6:42commercialize different things,
- 6:44it has drastically changed the
- 6:46day to day.
- 6:46>> So let's take a look now at
- 6:48the financial institutions
- 6:49within the schools. We'll start
- 6:50at the University of Kentucky.
- 6:52In June of last year, the
- 6:53university lent the athletic
- 6:55departments $141 million. That
- 6:59included $31 million in
- 7:00operating funds to offset
- 7:02expected deficits and $110
- 7:05million in capital investment
- 7:06loans for major facility
- 7:08projects. Here's what Doctor
- 7:09Capilouto had to say about it.
- 7:12>> Our board, which it has done
- 7:16in other circumstances, it has
- 7:18made loans to colleges, other
- 7:22units when they need to invest
- 7:25as they adjust to develop new
- 7:27revenue streams. Yes, the board
- 7:31made that loan. And let me say
- 7:33that the University of Kentucky
- 7:37Athletics Department is
- 7:39operated as a tub on its own
- 7:40bottom. It receives no
- 7:43university resources, no state
- 7:46funds, no tuition and fees. In
- 7:49fact, on in the last decade,
- 7:52when it generated positive
- 7:54revenues, it supported general
- 7:57scholarships for students. It
- 7:59paid for two thirds of $112
- 8:02million academic science
- 8:04building. It pays all its own
- 8:07expenses. So we're at a time,
- 8:10though, that expenses outpaced
- 8:13revenues. We need time to
- 8:17adjust, develop new initiatives
- 8:20so that we can generate the
- 8:22revenues it's going to take to
- 8:25cover things like student
- 8:27athlete compensation.
- 8:31>> Jay, before we talk about
- 8:32the budget in April of last
- 8:34year, UK set up the Champions
- 8:35Blue LLC. This was billed as a
- 8:38first of its kind nonprofit
- 8:39holding company created to
- 8:41manage and operate the
- 8:43athletics department. Tell us
- 8:43about what that is and how that
- 8:45works.
- 8:45>> Yeah, so we're really
- 8:47fortunate at the University of
- 8:48Kentucky that our trustees, our
- 8:49president, our leadership saw
- 8:50it fit to move forward with the
- 8:52Champions Blue LLC set up. And
- 8:54I think, you know, meshing of
- 8:55the two questions, you know, as
- 8:57we move forward in college
- 8:59athletics, commercialization is
- 9:00incredibly important. Finding
- 9:02new sources of revenue are
- 9:03incredibly important. And so
- 9:05what champions blue allows us
- 9:06to do is to find those new
- 9:09sources of revenue, be more
- 9:10efficient, be more nimble. As
- 9:13college athletics continues to
- 9:14change, being nimble, being
- 9:16well capitalized through change
- 9:18allows us to be aggressive and
- 9:20to approach all of the
- 9:22opportunities with that same
- 9:23that same lens.
- 9:24>> So let's go back and review
- 9:26that budget situation that we
- 9:27talked about a little bit
- 9:29earlier as the A D. How do you
- 9:31reconcile that $31 million
- 9:33deficit and the $110 million
- 9:35loan for infrastructure? What
- 9:36that's what's that going to be
- 9:38put toward?
- 9:38>> Yeah. So I'd say two
- 9:40different, you know, kind of
- 9:41buckets there. One certainly
- 9:42helped us and helps us adapt
- 9:44through change. I'm happy to
- 9:46report that we're ahead of
- 9:47schedule, repaying that loan to
- 9:49the university and off to a
- 9:51good a good place. With that, I
- 9:53think the 110 that we're
- 9:55looking at investments, that's
- 9:56everything from Kroger Field,
- 9:58new premium opportunities.
- 10:00Those are exactly as President
- 10:01Capilouto mentioned,
- 10:03investments that our board saw
- 10:04fit to invest in a newly
- 10:06commercial operation. Champions
- 10:08blue is the tool and the
- 10:10structure in which we'll use to
- 10:11spend those dollars
- 10:13appropriately. But in today's
- 10:14college athletics environment,
- 10:16focusing not simply on
- 10:17investing for the sake of
- 10:18spending dollars, but to invest
- 10:20to create return on that
- 10:21investment. I think that's why
- 10:23the University of Kentucky is
- 10:24incredibly well positioned
- 10:25going forward, and that we've
- 10:27targeted centered those
- 10:28investments around things that
- 10:30will return.
- 10:30>> You mentioned the work
- 10:31around Kroger Field. That's a
- 10:33pretty exciting development
- 10:33that you have coming up. Tell
- 10:35folks what's going to be
- 10:36happening there.
- 10:37>> Well, certainly for this
- 10:38season, there'll be new premium
- 10:39seating, online investments. In
- 10:40our general fan experience, the
- 10:42Big Blue Nation is the
- 10:44lifeblood of Kentucky athletics.
- 10:45I think we all know that and
- 10:47throughout the state just how
- 10:48much it matters to our fan base.
- 10:50We've done everything from
- 10:52simple inside the concourse
- 10:54improvements, working through
- 10:55technology enhancements, game
- 10:56day experience enhancements,
- 10:57but also adding premium seating
- 10:59opportunities. That return on
- 11:01that investment is pretty
- 11:03strong.
- 11:03>> Well now pivot to the
- 11:04situation at the University of
- 11:06Louisville. Here's what Doctor
- 11:07Bradley had to say.
- 11:10[MUSIC]
- 11:10Looking at what's required to
- 11:12compete in this Nil era. The
- 11:15last athletics budget was
- 11:16projected to have a $30 million
- 11:18deficit. As the chief
- 11:21administrator of the university,
- 11:22how do you reconcile that? How
- 11:23do you fix that?
- 11:24>> You can't, you can't. I mean,
- 11:26at some point, then there's
- 11:27going to come at the at the
- 11:29cost, you know, where you have
- 11:31to make hard decisions about
- 11:32what is the next season look
- 11:34like, or what are the sports
- 11:35that you can do. And I think
- 11:37always the concern is that we
- 11:38never wanted to see any of the
- 11:40scholarships that existed for,
- 11:42for other athletes, you know,
- 11:43so people forget we're talking
- 11:45about like in the case of
- 11:46University of Louisville, we
- 11:47have over 600 student athletes.
- 11:50And when you look at sort of
- 11:52nil, it really is only a small
- 11:53portion of those 600 student
- 11:56athletes. And it was all about
- 11:57getting a college education and
- 11:59getting a degree is what
- 12:00college athletics was about.
- 12:02And what we will see is that,
- 12:04you know, we will see
- 12:05universities, I think, across
- 12:06the country will have to make
- 12:08decisions around what they can
- 12:10support around sports.
- 12:12>> Josh your response to that?
- 12:15>> Yeah, I think as we talked
- 12:18about with board chair and
- 12:19president myself, when we put
- 12:21out that white paper relative
- 12:22to where college athletics
- 12:23currently sits. The $30 million
- 12:28deficit was an opportunity for
- 12:29us to say, what does this
- 12:30really cost to operate a pretty
- 12:32successful athletic department?
- 12:33And I do think athletic
- 12:35departments and universities
- 12:36have been pretty good at, as I
- 12:38say, left, left pocket, right
- 12:40pocket exchanges and accounting,
- 12:43for lack of better terms, where,
- 12:45you know, is there tuition
- 12:49vouchers for out-of-state
- 12:50students that are given to the
- 12:51athletic department and all
- 12:52these different ways? Is the
- 12:53university going to pay for
- 12:55utilities? Are they going to
- 12:56pay for this? Are they going to
- 12:58pay for that? And it just kind
- 12:59of gets shifted on the
- 13:01accounting ledger. And nobody
- 13:02is nobody's the wiser. And so
- 13:03what we did when we created
- 13:05this budget is what does this
- 13:06really cost? And, and this is
- 13:08what it's going to cost. And we
- 13:09want people to see that because
- 13:11this business model has been
- 13:12disrupted and turned on its
- 13:14head. Two, three sports real
- 13:16quick, 23 sports. Two of them
- 13:19make money.
- 13:20>> Right, right. To that point,
- 13:21you mentioned the white paper
- 13:23that you and Doctor Bradley and
- 13:24board chair Larry Benz put
- 13:26together. It was called College
- 13:27Athletics is Running Out of
- 13:28Time. You've gotten a lot of
- 13:30publicity for that. There were
- 13:31three main tenets in there as
- 13:32to how you all thought Nil
- 13:34could be fixed. Walk us through
- 13:36what you said in that paper as
- 13:37to how you believe Nil could be
- 13:39straightened out.
- 13:40>> Well, I do think that there
- 13:42has to be a hard spending cap.
- 13:44And if you look at any
- 13:46professional league that has
- 13:48gone about this, there's there
- 13:50is a cap of some sort, right.
- 13:52And people know what that is.
- 13:54There has to be clear
- 13:55enforcement around that cap,
- 13:57which I think has been very
- 13:59difficult for us to get our
- 14:00arms around at the collegiate
- 14:01level. I do think that
- 14:05restriction on movement is is
- 14:07helpful. And and that one's a
- 14:09tough one for student athletes
- 14:10of, hey, maybe I didn't have a
- 14:12good experience. Maybe what
- 14:13this coach told me or this
- 14:15school told me isn't what I got
- 14:17in my first year. So am I going
- 14:19to have the ability to go where
- 14:21I want to go and, and maybe
- 14:23change some things in my life
- 14:24for the better? Or are you
- 14:26transferring every year because
- 14:27you're trying to get to whoever
- 14:29that highest bidder is? Because
- 14:30this is a highly, highly
- 14:33competitive industry. And so I
- 14:35think we need to take a take a
- 14:37look at that. And then the
- 14:40opportunity, if if it makes
- 14:42sense to pull our meteorites,
- 14:45and I don't know the answer to
- 14:46that, because I don't think
- 14:47that there has been an
- 14:49objective study done that says
- 14:51it's right or it's wrong. And I
- 14:53guess my premise around that is
- 14:55looking at the professional
- 14:56leagues and the professional
- 14:58leagues have been able to
- 15:00increase their revenue stream
- 15:02through TV because of that.
- 15:04Will that happen in college?
- 15:05College athletics? I don't know,
- 15:06I don't know, but for us to say
- 15:09that we just shouldn't take a
- 15:10look at it, I would I would
- 15:12disagree with that. And I think
- 15:13the really interesting piece is
- 15:15this is people are going to
- 15:16have different opinions based
- 15:17on where they are in the
- 15:19collegiate landscape. And I
- 15:20would tell you, for us, I think
- 15:22that makes sense to take a look
- 15:24at.
- 15:24>> Looking at the organization
- 15:25there at U of L, your version
- 15:27of Champions Blue is called
- 15:28Cardinal Ventures that you all
- 15:29have set up. Kyle, let me ask
- 15:31you, is this the model that
- 15:32you're starting to see in other
- 15:34schools that they're adopting
- 15:35this, this LLC, nonprofit
- 15:37holding company model to be
- 15:38able to manage this?
- 15:40>> Yeah, to some extent, I
- 15:41think that we're seeing a
- 15:42trending that way. I don't
- 15:43think anyone's doing it quite
- 15:45to the full extent that
- 15:46Kentucky is doing it right now,
- 15:47moving the entire athletic
- 15:48department under that LLC. But
- 15:50the reasoning behind it, it's
- 15:51pretty simple. And he mentioned
- 15:52it earlier to be nimble, you
- 15:54know, operating within the
- 15:56normal university structure is
- 15:57not really set up for speed.
- 16:00It's intentionally slow. And,
- 16:02and we started the show talking
- 16:03about how what is nil changed
- 16:05and it's changed. The business
- 16:06model has changed the need to
- 16:08run an athletic department in
- 16:09college, like a high level
- 16:11business, to hire a CEO as your
- 16:13athletic director to operate
- 16:15that way. And this, you know,
- 16:17bringing your at least your
- 16:18revenue arm under an LLC gives
- 16:20you flexibility to go out and
- 16:22pursue different, you know,
- 16:23streams of income, lines of
- 16:26credit if you want to, you know,
- 16:27some schools are looking at
- 16:28private equity and that's
- 16:29increasingly an option in
- 16:30college sports. Everybody's
- 16:31looking for, okay, we got to
- 16:32pay these guys and we got to
- 16:34pay them handsomely. And we
- 16:35still have to keep up our our
- 16:37facilities. The arms race
- 16:38hasn't ended in facilities. And
- 16:41so how do we do that? How do we
- 16:43make those decisions quickly?
- 16:44How can we do it without
- 16:45getting tied up in a bunch of
- 16:47red tape at the university
- 16:48level? And because what Nil has
- 16:50changed is we're now nakedly
- 16:52professional sports, whether
- 16:53whether anybody really likes
- 16:55that idea or not, that is what
- 16:56it is. And you have to be run
- 16:58like a business.
- 16:59>> To that point. Let's now
- 17:00look at NIL through the eyes of
- 17:02a student athlete. Brooklyn,
- 17:03you had a great career at UK.
- 17:05You were first team all sec.
- 17:06Last year. You played for a
- 17:08national championship before
- 17:09you started as a college
- 17:11athlete. What did you think Nil
- 17:13would do and has it done what
- 17:15you thought it would?
- 17:16>> Yeah, to be honest with you,
- 17:18I had no clue what Nil was
- 17:20going into college. It wasn't
- 17:21really something that was
- 17:24popular or trending at the time.
- 17:26But honestly, I think now for
- 17:29athletes that are going into
- 17:31that recruiting process, that's
- 17:32going to be the big talk of it.
- 17:34But back in the day when I was
- 17:36doing it, it was more of
- 17:38finding the school that would
- 17:39best fit me for the next four
- 17:40years and set me up for life.
- 17:42So I was more looking at
- 17:44culture and just the coaching
- 17:45staff and people around the
- 17:46university instead of just nil
- 17:48itself.
- 17:48>> So you've kind of seen how
- 17:50this evolves as when you came
- 17:51in, this really wasn't in play.
- 17:53Now it is over that course of
- 17:54time. How does it work in the
- 17:57locker room and are players
- 17:58looking at each other
- 17:59differently because of
- 18:00different sums of money that
- 18:01may be paid? How does that work
- 18:03out?
- 18:03>> Yeah, you know, I can't
- 18:04speak for any other sports or
- 18:06institutions, but I know at
- 18:08Kentucky and the volleyball
- 18:09locker room, we don't talk
- 18:10about Nil. That's kind of just
- 18:11been a rule that's been set by
- 18:13US leaders because it could
- 18:15cause drama or it could cause
- 18:17just like a difference in, I
- 18:19don't know, people as a whole.
- 18:21So our main focus is just
- 18:23trying to win a national
- 18:24championship, trying to win
- 18:25games. And if Nil comes from
- 18:27that, that's great. But we try
- 18:28not to speak about it just
- 18:30because we don't want the extra
- 18:31drama from just trying to play
- 18:33volleyball.
- 18:33>> Our folks following that
- 18:34rule to not talk about it
- 18:36pretty well. Yeah. Okay. In
- 18:38looking at what it takes to be
- 18:39a college athlete, it takes a
- 18:41lot of time. Not only are you
- 18:43going to school, but you've got
- 18:44a lot of time to devote to your
- 18:46sport. Now, NIL is a part of
- 18:48this as well. How do you manage
- 18:50the time commitments regarding
- 18:51this?
- 18:52>> Yeah, I think it definitely
- 18:53helps with time management, but
- 18:56also just like a lot of people
- 18:57don't know, just the work that
- 18:59it takes to kind of do all the
- 19:01deliverables that are asked of
- 19:02you within deals. But I think
- 19:04it's just also such a cool
- 19:06opportunity that athletes have
- 19:08in order to make money in
- 19:10college. But yeah, it
- 19:11definitely does take some extra
- 19:13time, especially on like off
- 19:15days when you're trying to get
- 19:16those done. But I think just
- 19:18the university does a really
- 19:19good job at Kentucky to just
- 19:21set us up for success in trying
- 19:22to get those knocked out before
- 19:24the season starts, so that we
- 19:26can just truly focus on our
- 19:27sport.
- 19:28>> The importance of social
- 19:29media within NIL your your
- 19:32brand value, if you will. Is
- 19:34that really the big intangible
- 19:36that's at play here for folks
- 19:37like you?
- 19:38>> Yeah, I don't really do much
- 19:40on the social media side of
- 19:42things. I know some athletes
- 19:44are really big into that, and
- 19:45that's great because they're
- 19:46just building their brand and
- 19:48getting endorsements because of
- 19:50that. And just the following
- 19:51that they make from just
- 19:52posting videos or just their
- 19:54daily lives. But I'm not one to
- 19:57just like put my daily life on
- 19:59social media. So I don't think
- 20:00it really affects me as much as
- 20:02others.
- 20:03>> What do you hear from fans?
- 20:05Do they have this misconception
- 20:07that everybody who plays
- 20:08college sports now is a
- 20:11millionaire, or do they not
- 20:12really understand how much or
- 20:13how little you might be getting
- 20:14from this?
- 20:15>> Yeah, I think it's
- 20:16definitely a misconception. I
- 20:17feel like especially with the
- 20:19numbers that are thrown around
- 20:20on social media or just in the
- 20:22news is kind of crazy. And just
- 20:24people that don't know much
- 20:25about Nil are kind of blind to
- 20:27like the reality of it kind of
- 20:30what was mentioned before. Only
- 20:31a select few of athletes get
- 20:33the opportunity to make nil,
- 20:35and that doesn't go for
- 20:36everyone on the team or
- 20:38everyone in the athletic
- 20:39department. And I think that's
- 20:40something that people should be
- 20:42aware of, because those numbers
- 20:44are sums that are getting
- 20:45talked about aren't happening
- 20:47to majority of the athletes.
- 20:49>> Wright J. And Josh, let me
- 20:51ask you this question. What
- 20:52Brooklyn just described here,
- 20:53this sounds like an education
- 20:55in and of itself. It's almost
- 20:56like a graduate level business
- 20:58class that she's actually
- 20:59getting to live. Do you all
- 21:01provide any guidance in terms
- 21:02of things like tax liability
- 21:04and things like that, to kind
- 21:05of bring athletes up to speed
- 21:07on on creating a business while
- 21:09they're an athlete?
- 21:10>> Yeah, first and foremost,
- 21:11let me just say how incredibly
- 21:12proud I am. Of course, you know,
- 21:14this is this is a hard thing to
- 21:16to come on here and talk. And
- 21:18you make everybody at the
- 21:19University of Kentucky proud.
- 21:20So thank you for being here.
- 21:21I'm also really proud of the
- 21:23team that we put behind our
- 21:24student athletes, whether it's
- 21:25through our partner at JMI or
- 21:28also through our internal
- 21:30resources. I do think we do a
- 21:32really good job of supporting
- 21:33our student athletes, not only
- 21:35providing opportunities for
- 21:36them to go and earn, but also
- 21:38to try to help them as they
- 21:40navigate those things, whether
- 21:41it's, you know, completing
- 21:43deliverables or making great
- 21:44choices going forward.
- 21:46>> I think the only thing I
- 21:47would add there is life comes
- 21:49at you fast, right? When you're
- 21:5118 and you're transitioning
- 21:53from high school to college.
- 21:54And oh my gosh, NIL
- 21:56opportunities. And what does
- 21:57this mean from a tax liability?
- 21:58I mean, there are so many
- 22:00questions and I do have a lot
- 22:01of confidence like Jay does,
- 22:03that those resources are there.
- 22:04If our student athletes want to
- 22:06take advantage of them. I think
- 22:07that is the that is the main
- 22:10variable that.
- 22:10>> Interested in that.
- 22:11>> Exactly, exactly. And we
- 22:13have one of or had one of the
- 22:16absolute legends relative to
- 22:18making a smaller sum of money,
- 22:20not necessarily in college, but
- 22:21in the pros in Junior Bridgeman,
- 22:23who parlayed that into just an
- 22:26unbelievable, unbelievable
- 22:27business career. And so we were
- 22:30so, so fortunate to have him
- 22:31because he would come and talk
- 22:33to our student athletes about a
- 22:34lot of those things that you
- 22:36just talked about right there.
- 22:37So we have to fill that void.
- 22:39Definitely. But I think we're
- 22:40doing that.
- 22:40>> Let's look at it now from
- 22:42the eye or through the eyes
- 22:44rather of a coach. A couple
- 22:45days ago, I had the opportunity
- 22:47to sit down with UofL men's
- 22:48head basketball coach Pat
- 22:49Kelsey, to ask how he
- 22:50approaches Nil within his
- 22:51program.
- 22:54[MUSIC]
- 22:54How is it affecting or
- 22:56impacting the end product that
- 22:58we see on the court? Is there a
- 23:00direct correlation that you see
- 23:01there?
- 23:02>> I mean, there's people that
- 23:03think, and I probably subscribe
- 23:05to this theory as well, is that
- 23:08it's raise the talent level.
- 23:10You know, I mean, kids that are
- 23:13probably able to go
- 23:15professionally earlier on in
- 23:16their career or staying around
- 23:18because of the, the amount of
- 23:20money that they can make in
- 23:21college sports. So, you know, I
- 23:23think the level of play is
- 23:25probably as high or higher than
- 23:26it's ever been.
- 23:27>> Thanks to N I, l and being
- 23:29able to keep those kids that
- 23:31maybe would have gone pro.
- 23:31>> I think.
- 23:32>> So. Okay. From a recruiting
- 23:34standpoint, how has it
- 23:35complicated recruiting folks to
- 23:37come to this program? What what
- 23:39are the different layers that
- 23:40you're having to deal with now
- 23:42that maybe five, ten years ago
- 23:43you didn't have?
- 23:44>> Again, I don't know if it's
- 23:46complicated, but it's changed.
- 23:47And again, you have to adapt to
- 23:49change. Obviously, the amount
- 23:51of money and the fact that
- 23:53negotiations and, and money is
- 23:54a major factor. That hasn't
- 23:56been the case for years and
- 23:58years and years. It was it was
- 24:00it was your scholarship and it
- 24:01was your room and your board
- 24:02and your books. And then, you
- 24:04know, eventually the NCAA
- 24:07started giving, you know,
- 24:10allowing players to have
- 24:11stipends and cost of attendance
- 24:13type things. And that was kind
- 24:15of the first time the players
- 24:17received anything outside of
- 24:18scholarship. And now, you know,
- 24:19the floodgates have opened. And
- 24:21obviously you're talking lots
- 24:23and lots of money. And, you
- 24:25know, the involvement in agents
- 24:27in the the recruitment is
- 24:29important as well, just because
- 24:30of the amount of money and the
- 24:32stakes and those type of
- 24:35negotiations. I mean, players
- 24:36are smart, you know, like
- 24:37they're not professional
- 24:40negotiators and things like
- 24:40that. But agents are and
- 24:43they're, they're, they're smart
- 24:44to partner with people that
- 24:45know what they're doing and
- 24:46that in that realm. So that's
- 24:48added some layers to it as well.
- 24:50>> What are those negotiations
- 24:52like?
- 24:52>> I don't do it. Okay. So I
- 24:54don't know. I stay completely
- 24:55out of it. I'm the basketball
- 24:57coach. I want my relationship
- 24:59with the player to be player
- 25:00and coach basketball. And, and,
- 25:03you know, I let the I let the
- 25:04people that in our in our at
- 25:07our university and in our
- 25:08department in our front office,
- 25:09if you will handle those things.
- 25:11>> So you're, you're completely
- 25:12hands off when it comes to that.
- 25:14You don't want to be in that
- 25:15pool.
- 25:16>> I don't want to have I do
- 25:18not have money conversations
- 25:19with players or parents or
- 25:20agents just on principle.
- 25:21That's the way I do it. Just
- 25:23because, like I said, I don't
- 25:25want those type of things to
- 25:26affect my relationship with the
- 25:27player. I want it to be about
- 25:29mentor, player, basketball,
- 25:31coach, player and keep it at
- 25:33that.
- 25:34>> Is that typical among
- 25:35coaches or are you kind of a
- 25:36standalone there?
- 25:38>> I mean, obviously you have
- 25:39to be involved because you have
- 25:41everybody has a certain amount
- 25:43of money to spend. You got to
- 25:44figure out how to allocate your
- 25:46resources. But when you
- 25:47actually get down to the, the
- 25:49numbers part of it and you're
- 25:51negotiating and talking with, I,
- 25:52I stay completely out of it, I
- 25:54don't know.
- 25:57>> Many thanks to Coach Kelsey
- 25:58for taking the time to speak
- 26:00with us. You can catch our full
- 26:01interview with him on KET
- 26:03YouTube channel now bears
- 26:05saying we did reach out to UK
- 26:06men's basketball coach, Mark
- 26:08Pope over the last several
- 26:09weeks to get his take in. His
- 26:11communications team said they
- 26:12were. He was not able to make
- 26:13it work due to scheduling
- 26:15conflicts. Kyle, let me go to
- 26:17you with what Coach Kelsey said
- 26:18there about being hands off on
- 26:20NIL is that a norm or is that
- 26:24something that that you don't
- 26:25hear that often?
- 26:25>> Well, I think it depends on
- 26:27what hands on, you know, what
- 26:29conversations you're talking
- 26:29about behind closed doors
- 26:31conversations. I think every
- 26:32head coach in the country is
- 26:34very hands on. And it's
- 26:35probably the the final say in,
- 26:38as he alluded to there behind,
- 26:39you know, when when they're in
- 26:41their staff, as you're talking
- 26:42about, how much do we have to
- 26:44spend is what's the value?
- 26:45What's the, you know, if we
- 26:47spend this much, do we can we
- 26:49complete our roster? Right. I
- 26:51think roster management is a
- 26:53conversation that every head
- 26:54coach is heavily hands on. But
- 26:56I do think that there are there
- 26:58are several like him who
- 27:00believe it's awkward and can
- 27:02create a lot of awkwardness
- 27:03within your roster, within your
- 27:04team, within your relationships,
- 27:06to have the money conversation
- 27:08between the head coach and the
- 27:09player or the family. And it's
- 27:11interesting because we're
- 27:12talking about college sports as
- 27:13pro sports, but not it's not a
- 27:15one for one, but you you think
- 27:16about the NBA and college
- 27:18basketball. The GM position now
- 27:19in college basketball is
- 27:20popular. A college basketball
- 27:22GM is not an NBA GM. The NBA
- 27:24gym is the is the coach's boss.
- 27:26That is not the case in college
- 27:27basketball. And so a head coach
- 27:29in college basketball kind of
- 27:30has to wear a little bit of
- 27:32both hats. He he sort of is the
- 27:34final say. And so I think
- 27:36different coaches play it
- 27:37differently, but they're all
- 27:38very heavy handed in, in
- 27:40deciding is it worth it to
- 27:42spend this money on this guy.
- 27:43>> In terms of how our
- 27:45basketball coaches in Kentucky
- 27:46are responding to this and a
- 27:47conversation I had with you,
- 27:48Kyle, last week, you said that
- 27:50you think the two coaches most
- 27:52on the NIL hot seat in the
- 27:54nation right now are Mark Pope
- 27:56and Pat Kelsey. Why is that?
- 27:57>> As you put me on the hot
- 27:59seat, I think the word hot seat.
- 28:01I wouldn't use the word hot
- 28:02seat necessarily. I think what
- 28:04what money does is apply
- 28:05pressure. It applies it to the
- 28:06players we see. We could talk
- 28:08about that. The mental health
- 28:09that comes along with players.
- 28:11I've come in and people know or
- 28:13think that I'm the highest paid
- 28:14player on the team or in the
- 28:16country or in the conference,
- 28:17what pressure is on me? I think
- 28:19that's true too, of coaches
- 28:20when when you've got an
- 28:21investment and we're talking
- 28:23about running these things like
- 28:24businesses and forming LLCs and
- 28:25desperately seeking every
- 28:26revenue stream we can to pay
- 28:28these exorbitant prices, when
- 28:30you're then given huge dollars,
- 28:33you know, some of the the most
- 28:35expensive rosters in the
- 28:36country, it applies pressure.
- 28:37And I think, you know,
- 28:38certainly before the Mark
- 28:39Mitchell case today and he's
- 28:41going back to Missouri when he
- 28:43was coming to Kentucky, I think
- 28:44I would put Kentucky and
- 28:45Louisville both in the top five,
- 28:47probably in most expensive
- 28:48rosters in college basketball
- 28:49this year, maybe one, two, you
- 28:50could make a case. I think
- 28:52transparency would be great. So
- 28:53we'd actually know those things.
- 28:54But when that is the case, when
- 28:57you've when you've spent as
- 28:58much as anybody in America,
- 29:00there's pressure. And that's
- 29:01what I don't know if hot seat
- 29:02is the right word, but the
- 29:04expectation at Kentucky is to
- 29:05go to a Final Four. It's the
- 29:07same at Louisville. And these
- 29:08are two guys going into year
- 29:10three who now have been given
- 29:11rosters that are among the most
- 29:13expensive in America, and you
- 29:14got to win.
- 29:15>> Neal is something that both
- 29:16federal and state governments
- 29:17have looked at, trying to rein
- 29:19in. And two years ago, during
- 29:20an NIL hearing with officials
- 29:22from the NCAA on Capitol Hill,
- 29:24Kentucky, Representative Morgan
- 29:26McGarvey asked a pointed
- 29:27question. And now remember,
- 29:29he's directly asking this to
- 29:31staff from the NCAA. Here's
- 29:33what he said.
- 29:36>> I'm going to say this is the
- 29:38first time on our committee I
- 29:39have seen an organization come
- 29:40forward before us who doesn't
- 29:43have its act together and is so
- 29:45inept that they are actually
- 29:47asking the government to take
- 29:48over what's going on and
- 29:50regulate this. Here's my
- 29:52warning. Just like what we did
- 29:54in Kentucky, when you needed a
- 29:55change, you got to go back to
- 29:57the state legislature. When you
- 29:58all are asking the United
- 30:00States government where it will
- 30:01literally take an act of
- 30:02Congress to change something
- 30:04once we let it out. Loose in
- 30:05the wild. Is the NCAA so inept
- 30:10right now that this is
- 30:11something Congress must
- 30:12legislate?
- 30:13>> GA Josh your response to
- 30:15that?
- 30:17>> As I say, when we get asked
- 30:19this question, because I know
- 30:20Jay gets asked it a lot and I
- 30:22do too. Do we really think that
- 30:24the federal government needs to
- 30:25be involved in college
- 30:26athletics? And my answer is
- 30:28pretty simple do we need to? Do
- 30:29we think the federal government
- 30:31needs to be involved in
- 30:32anything until they actually do?
- 30:34Right? Because that's the point
- 30:35and that's the function of
- 30:36government. And I think, yes, I
- 30:38do think that we have shown and
- 30:40the NCAA has shown that they
- 30:42need help governing college
- 30:45athletics. When the NCAA was
- 30:46created, did they ever think
- 30:47that they were going to be sued
- 30:50every day of the week relative
- 30:52to eligibility? Right. It was,
- 30:54hey, here's here's the rules
- 30:55that we're going to play by.
- 30:57You get four years, sometimes
- 30:58you get five, there's an injury,
- 30:59so on and so forth. And now
- 31:01we've gotten to the point where
- 31:03it's like, you know what? I
- 31:04want to play one more year. I
- 31:06think I'm just going to sue you.
- 31:08And that's another saying that
- 31:09I say all the time in that
- 31:11college athletics was never
- 31:12intended to be a profession.
- 31:13Let's not forget why kids
- 31:15student athletes go to college.
- 31:17Yes, they have an opportunity
- 31:18to make money now, which is
- 31:20great, but getting a college
- 31:22degree is worth more than
- 31:24anything that they're ever
- 31:24going to make, because you
- 31:25can't take that away from them.
- 31:27You know, there's a lot of
- 31:28these student athletes, they're
- 31:30not going to have this money
- 31:31down the road, but you can't
- 31:32take that college degree from
- 31:34them. And so, yes, I would say
- 31:36that getting the federal
- 31:37government involved, we are at
- 31:39that point now because we need
- 31:40a framework that says, hey,
- 31:42here's some protections that
- 31:43are going to be afforded to the
- 31:45NCAA or whatever that governing
- 31:46body looks looks like, so that
- 31:48you guys can actually govern
- 31:50and move forward.
- 31:50>> Jay, your thoughts?
- 31:51>> Yeah, I think I would agree
- 31:53in in particularly as it
- 31:54relates to Protect College
- 31:55Sports act. You know, as Josh
- 31:58mentioned, having a, a
- 32:00consistent framework for all of
- 32:02these affairs across all of our
- 32:04states from a competitive
- 32:06equity perspective is
- 32:07incredibly important. I think
- 32:09secondarily, we've all talked
- 32:10about here where Nil can be a
- 32:12benefit to our student athletes
- 32:14and a lot of different ways we
- 32:15need to provide that in a
- 32:17consistent, enforceable way so
- 32:19that we get some consistency.
- 32:21We also need to provide
- 32:22protections for our student
- 32:23athletes, right? We talked a
- 32:24lot about the different
- 32:25pressures that this creates.
- 32:27Well, part of that is we need
- 32:28to provide a consistent
- 32:29framework under which we can
- 32:31help to alleviate some of those
- 32:33pressures. And I think there's
- 32:34some some consistency pieces
- 32:35there, certainly some high
- 32:37level kind of parts and pieces
- 32:40of that legislation that
- 32:41provide us that framework.
- 32:42There's still work to be done.
- 32:45There's still pieces that we
- 32:46would, you know, I think as it
- 32:49evolves, we'll see. But I think
- 32:50at the end, it would be a
- 32:51really good step forward.
- 32:53>> And you talk about that
- 32:54consistency. And Josh, I
- 32:55believe you all covered this in
- 32:56the white paper that you did.
- 32:58The problem really is the
- 32:59patchwork of state laws and
- 33:00judicial rulings by judges that
- 33:02are sometimes alumni of the
- 33:03schools that they're ruling on
- 33:04that really has has clouded the
- 33:06issue and complicated the
- 33:07factor.
- 33:08>> Well, once again, that goes
- 33:10back to think about how highly
- 33:12competitive this is, where
- 33:15literally it's like, hey, do we
- 33:16like we think this judge is
- 33:18going to rule, rule in the
- 33:19favor of this student athlete
- 33:20or that student athlete. It's
- 33:22unbelievable. You know, it's
- 33:24something that Jay and I were
- 33:25talking about before the show.
- 33:26Is there anything in the state
- 33:28of Kentucky that creates more
- 33:31emotional joy or emotional pain
- 33:34than wins and losses by the
- 33:36Wildcats and Cardinals? And so
- 33:38when you get that kind of
- 33:40emotion involved, then you need
- 33:42an objective body to come in
- 33:44and say, hey, this is how we're
- 33:46going to do things, and this is
- 33:48how we're going to make
- 33:49decisions.
- 33:49>> So let's now really look at
- 33:51another question. And all this
- 33:53really does beg the question,
- 33:54how can smaller schools in
- 33:57Kentucky who aren't the cats or
- 33:58the cards compete? Here's what
- 34:01Kentucky schools spent on Nil
- 34:02over the course of about a year.
- 34:04And this information comes to
- 34:05us courtesy of the Louisville
- 34:06Courier Journal. According to
- 34:08the CJ, UK declined to reveal
- 34:10the amount they paid out. The
- 34:12University of Louisville
- 34:13reported paying just less than
- 34:16$33 million. From there, the
- 34:17numbers drop off decisively. KU
- 34:20paid out around $2.5 million.
- 34:22EKU and NKU were in the six
- 34:24figure range, and Morehead
- 34:25State was slightly under
- 34:28$100,000. J is that Courier
- 34:29Journal reporting correct? And
- 34:31if so, what's the mindset
- 34:33behind not releasing that
- 34:34information?
- 34:34>> Yeah. You know, I think
- 34:36there's in these roles, there's
- 34:37two really good
- 34:39responsibilities. I think first
- 34:40and foremost is to our student
- 34:41athletes. And so we find it
- 34:43really important to protect
- 34:45their their individual
- 34:46information, including how that
- 34:48relates to revenue sharing in
- 34:50Nil. I think the second part of
- 34:51that goes back to a little bit
- 34:53what Josh says, which is this
- 34:54is a highly competitive
- 34:56environment. And those how
- 34:58we're arranging those Nil
- 35:01opportunities, Rev share all
- 35:02that provides a competitive
- 35:05portion of the of the program
- 35:06that we feel like is important.
- 35:08>> So looking back at those
- 35:09figures, how can smaller
- 35:11schools like EKU and NKU
- 35:14compete? In this story from
- 35:15Kentucky Edition, our Emily
- 35:16Prince traveled to Richmond and
- 35:17Highland Heights to find out.
- 35:21>> Revenue sharing. It's a
- 35:23relatively new term in college
- 35:25sports, but what does it mean
- 35:27for institutions like UK? It
- 35:29means they can share millions
- 35:30of dollars of revenue directly
- 35:32with student athletes. But
- 35:34that's not the case at
- 35:35universities like Eastern
- 35:37Kentucky and Northern Kentucky.
- 35:39>> I think we often hear the
- 35:41words revenue share, but I
- 35:42think revenue share really is
- 35:45for those institutions that
- 35:47have revenue to disperse and to
- 35:49share. That's not in our case,
- 35:51and it's not at the mid-major
- 35:53level.
- 35:53>> In KU and EKU participate in
- 35:56Division one athletics, but are
- 35:58not in a power four conference,
- 36:00meaning they don't have the
- 36:02same resources or media
- 36:04exposure as schools like UK or
- 36:07UofL.
- 36:07>> It's a little bit different,
- 36:08I think, at our level in terms
- 36:10of the revenue share, it just
- 36:13allows us maybe to do some
- 36:15things that we weren't able to
- 36:16do for our student athletes,
- 36:17but certainly not at the level
- 36:20the power force.
- 36:21>> One of the things Eastern
- 36:23Kentucky can do involves
- 36:25scholarships. They now have the
- 36:26ability to divvy up scholarship
- 36:28amounts to different players,
- 36:30rather than all players
- 36:31receiving the same amount of
- 36:33scholarship money.
- 36:34>> It just gives us a chance to
- 36:36maybe get a picture or maybe
- 36:37get a softball pitcher, a
- 36:40baseball pitcher, or a position
- 36:42player that can help us. We
- 36:43can't get a whole team, but we
- 36:45may be able to get a player or
- 36:47two that that separates us from
- 36:49our competition.
- 36:50>> For KET, I'm Emily Prince
- 36:53now.
- 36:53>> As for NKU, they're the only
- 36:55public university in the state
- 36:56to not have a football team. So
- 36:58they'll be concentrating their
- 37:00Nil funds on their basketball
- 37:02program. Kyle, let me go to you.
- 37:03Can small schools keep their
- 37:05heads above water with this and
- 37:06how is that going to play out
- 37:08for them?
- 37:09>> I think they can. But I
- 37:10think I think one of the things
- 37:12that worries a lot of people is,
- 37:14have we seen the death of
- 37:15Cinderella? And I don't think
- 37:17we've seen the end of
- 37:18individual upsets. That's
- 37:19always going to happen. You
- 37:20think about the NCAA tournament,
- 37:21but are we at the end of the
- 37:23era where a team like that can
- 37:25make a long run, win several
- 37:26games in a row? And I think
- 37:28there's a lot of questions, a
- 37:30lot of doubt that that can
- 37:31happen. I talked to a lot of
- 37:33coaches this summer. What
- 37:34worries you most about the
- 37:35sport? And Josh Schertz at
- 37:36Saint Louis said exactly that.
- 37:38Like, is Cinderella dead? And
- 37:39you know, he's not not
- 37:40discounting that somebody could
- 37:41get crazy hot and there could
- 37:43be a huge shooting variance or,
- 37:44or, you know, any number of
- 37:46things. It's not impossible.
- 37:47But the likelihood of it, I
- 37:49think has gone way, way down.
- 37:50And we're going to see, again,
- 37:52individual games, but not that
- 37:53long ago, what, three, four
- 37:55years ago we had two Mid-majors
- 37:56in the Final Four. We've seen
- 37:58VCU get to the Final Four and
- 37:59George Mason get to a Final
- 38:01Four. Can a team string
- 38:02together 5 or 6 wins when you
- 38:04know the teams they're going
- 38:05against have outspent them 5 or
- 38:076 X what's on their roster? And
- 38:09also because of the fact that
- 38:10this has led to Mid-majors
- 38:12being the farm system for the
- 38:13big boys, quite frankly. And
- 38:16every year your roster is
- 38:17getting picked over anybody who
- 38:18can play even a little bit at
- 38:20the lower level is getting
- 38:21called up to the big leagues.
- 38:23And so, you know, a lot of
- 38:25those Cinderella stories are
- 38:26built over years of teams
- 38:27staying together. And you get a,
- 38:28you know, five seniors who
- 38:30played together for their whole
- 38:31career at a mid-major level
- 38:32level. And they get hot. We're
- 38:34not going to see that anymore,
- 38:35for certain.
- 38:36>> In terms of the pool of
- 38:37talent that's out there. I had
- 38:39a chance to listen to one of
- 38:41your podcasts a couple days ago,
- 38:42and I was fascinated by
- 38:43something that you talked about
- 38:45in terms of college basketball
- 38:46recruiting, and you felt the
- 38:48preeminent college basketball
- 38:50recruiting event now in America
- 38:53wasn't a Nike five star camp
- 38:55somewhere. It was the NBA
- 38:58combine. Why is the NBA combine
- 39:00such a fertile recruiting
- 39:01ground for coaches?
- 39:02>> Well, there's two reasons
- 39:03that it's now the preeminent
- 39:05recruiting event. It's because
- 39:06high school recruiting has been
- 39:08de-emphasized. I mean, that's
- 39:09when you talk about who is
- 39:10who's who. Is it costing guys
- 39:12getting a fifth year of
- 39:13eligibility and guys sticking
- 39:14around to get their pay day is
- 39:16kids coming out of high school.
- 39:17That's one reason. And because
- 39:19every coach wants to be older,
- 39:20not younger. And and, you know,
- 39:23on the flip side of that, and
- 39:24we talk about the product
- 39:26itself is really good right now
- 39:27in college sports and college
- 39:28basketball in particular, it's
- 39:29because guys like Thomas Houck
- 39:31at Florida, who was going to be
- 39:32maybe a lottery pick, certainly
- 39:34a first round pick actually is
- 39:35incentive, has incentive to
- 39:36come back to college because
- 39:37he's going to make, you know,
- 39:39five, six, seven, eight, nine,
- 39:41$10 million in college. And and
- 39:43because you can go to the
- 39:45combine now and offer that and
- 39:46say, listen, you didn't have a
- 39:48great combine. You know, you're
- 39:49slipping in the, the mock
- 39:51drafts, I can guarantee you
- 39:52more money next year in college
- 39:53basketball than you're going to
- 39:54make in the NBA or trying to
- 39:56make it in the NBA. It's a much
- 39:58more attractive thing to those
- 39:59players now. I mean, we are
- 40:01seeing that everywhere. Guys
- 40:02that would have never, ever,
- 40:03ever come back to college in
- 40:05any other circumstance. They
- 40:06can outearn what they would
- 40:08make in the NBA.
- 40:09>> And as Coach Kelsey said, it
- 40:11really is driving up the level
- 40:12of talent that's staying in
- 40:14college and is making that a
- 40:15better product, right?
- 40:16>> It's I think it's the second
- 40:18highest paying league. And you
- 40:19could argue maybe it's the
- 40:20second best basketball league
- 40:21in the world after the NBA.
- 40:23>> Josh and J. Let me ask you
- 40:25all in looking at this overall,
- 40:27can coaches still use the pitch
- 40:30come to this school because
- 40:32it's the best place to get an
- 40:34education and develop as an
- 40:35athlete without having the
- 40:37money conversation? Or is the
- 40:39money conversation so baked in
- 40:41now that it's just going to be
- 40:42the part of any conversation
- 40:44that a recruiter has with a
- 40:45student?
- 40:46>> Yeah. I mean, I'll start
- 40:47with that and then kick it to
- 40:49Josh. I would say that much
- 40:51about college athletics hasn't
- 40:52changed, right? And all of the,
- 40:54the parts and pieces that you
- 40:56just mentioned, those are
- 40:57incredibly important is the
- 41:00student athlete package going
- 41:03to be important? Heck yeah it
- 41:04is. That's part of the the
- 41:06evolved or the evolution of
- 41:07college athletics. But I think
- 41:09tonight and just go forward, we
- 41:11shouldn't lose the opportunity
- 41:13quotient of this, this this
- 41:15discussion. And, you know, as,
- 41:17as Brooklyn said, there's a lot
- 41:19of different situations across
- 41:21the board. Student athletes
- 41:22have a lot of different
- 41:23conversations in recruiting.
- 41:25And so it is certainly not the
- 41:26only thing. It is a privilege
- 41:28and an honor to come to the
- 41:29University of Kentucky and
- 41:30compete for the Wildcats.
- 41:32There's a lot that goes into
- 41:34that is NIL or revenue share.
- 41:36Part of that for sure for some
- 41:38folks. But I am committed to
- 41:40and continue to find that the
- 41:42opportunity quotient matters.
- 41:44>> Joshua, let me ask you, as a
- 41:45differentiation of this, are
- 41:47you hearing from coaches that
- 41:49there's 18, 19 year old
- 41:50athletes who are approaching
- 41:51this in a completely
- 41:53unrealistic way? Are you are
- 41:54you hearing that there's a lot
- 41:55of these conversations where
- 41:57they're just not rooted in
- 41:59reality of what the economics
- 42:00of it looks like?
- 42:01>> I think there's there's
- 42:03obviously some of those
- 42:04conversations being had, but I
- 42:06think if you have an
- 42:07established culture around your
- 42:08program that you're going to
- 42:09say what we're going to take a
- 42:11pass on on that potential
- 42:13student athlete. And going back
- 42:14to what Jay was saying here a
- 42:15little bit, putting that offer
- 42:17out there, whatever it may be,
- 42:20I think allows you to say, hey,
- 42:22this is where we're at now.
- 42:23Let's talk about all the other
- 42:24things that in our case, the
- 42:26University of Louisville and
- 42:28this basketball program, or
- 42:29whatever program it may be, can
- 42:31do for you. And that's where I
- 42:33would put Coach Kelsey up
- 42:34against anybody in the country,
- 42:36because I've said on some of
- 42:37those recruiting phone calls
- 42:38and he he builds a plan for
- 42:41everybody that he's recruiting.
- 42:42This is how we're going to get
- 42:43you to be a first round draft
- 42:45pick. This is how we're going
- 42:47to get you to do what you, you
- 42:49know, to be your your absolute
- 42:50best while you're here at the
- 42:52University of Louisville. So
- 42:53it's a variable moneys a
- 42:54variable now, but it is not the
- 42:56it should not be why decisions
- 42:57are made. And if that's the
- 42:59only reason decisions are being
- 43:00made. Like I said, if you have
- 43:02an established culture, you say
- 43:03thanks, but no thanks. We're
- 43:04going to we're going to move on
- 43:06down the road here.
- 43:07>> Let's look. I'm sure, sure,
- 43:08sure. I mean, to his point, I
- 43:10think the money is almost
- 43:11allowed for more honesty or
- 43:13it's just upfront, what are you
- 43:14what are you getting? What do
- 43:16you want? You know, what's
- 43:17everybody else offering you?
- 43:18Can we match it or not? Can we
- 43:20get close? Okay. If we can get
- 43:22in the neighborhood, then let's
- 43:23then. Okay, we start there. The
- 43:24money's we're we're above board
- 43:26here. We know what everybody's
- 43:27dealing with. Everybody's hand
- 43:28is. And now I can sell myself
- 43:30and my program to you beyond
- 43:31the money. Because everybody,
- 43:32if you're a hot commodity,
- 43:33everybody's offering you a nice
- 43:35pay day. Not everybody's
- 43:36offering you the same coaching
- 43:37and plan and place. And I think
- 43:39it does allow for some more
- 43:40honesty.
- 43:40>> There are variables there
- 43:42that can differentiate.
- 43:43>> I think in today's
- 43:44environment, you know, all
- 43:45these discussions, you know, we
- 43:46just celebrated Craig Skinner's
- 43:48500th victory on Saturday or
- 43:50what Saturday. And I think it's
- 43:53a testament to, as you said,
- 43:54Kyle, as this is evolved,
- 43:57authentic leadership from
- 43:59coaches makes more of a
- 44:00difference today than it ever
- 44:01has, whether it's the speed of
- 44:03change, the speed of these
- 44:05decisions that have to happen.
- 44:06But the ability for our coaches,
- 44:09no matter the sport, to pour
- 44:10into our young people and
- 44:12change trajectory, outperform
- 44:14all those sorts of things that
- 44:15have always been there, even
- 44:17more important today than it's
- 44:18ever been.
- 44:19>> Let's look at the sources of
- 44:21of revenue and how that's
- 44:23playing out. And it begs the
- 44:25question to Jay and Josh,
- 44:27where's this money going to
- 44:28come from? Colleges in and of
- 44:31themselves. Academic
- 44:32departments are out trying to
- 44:33raise money. Universities are
- 44:35trying to raise money for
- 44:36scholarships and different
- 44:37areas. You all are trying to
- 44:39raise money as well. Is the
- 44:40well going to run dry, or do
- 44:43you think that that this can
- 44:44continue on as it has been?
- 44:47>> I'll start and then maybe,
- 44:48you know, I would tell you that
- 44:50I think we need to be. And we
- 44:52look at and certainly champions
- 44:53blue. This is part of our
- 44:55approach is that there are
- 44:58traditional revenue streams
- 44:59that as we move into a more
- 45:01commercially facing entity and
- 45:03enterprise, we've got to find
- 45:04ways to maximize and optimize
- 45:05those. And those are
- 45:06traditional and we've worked at
- 45:07those a long time. I also think
- 45:09part of these different setups
- 45:11allow us to approach new and
- 45:12different sources, whether it's
- 45:14external events or interesting
- 45:16setups around, you know,
- 45:18entertainment district or
- 45:19whatever it might be around our
- 45:21our assets, exploring those
- 45:23pieces. You've got to do both.
- 45:26>> I just think college
- 45:29athletics just didn't evolve
- 45:31for a very long time. Like
- 45:33traditional model. Here it is.
- 45:34We've got ticket sales, we've
- 45:36got concessions, we've got a
- 45:38few other revenue streams. And
- 45:39then it like it necessitates a
- 45:41change. And yeah, you can say
- 45:44that maybe leadership got a
- 45:46little lazy and we said, hey,
- 45:47we're going to be fine. And
- 45:49it's like, nope, we're not fine.
- 45:50And so we've got to look at
- 45:52every opportunity. And that's
- 45:53getting into what Jay was
- 45:55saying. There's opportunities
- 45:56there. We just I don't think
- 45:57we've taken advantage of them
- 45:58in the past, and we have to
- 46:00rethink how we're doing
- 46:01everything from a business
- 46:02model standpoint. And so do we
- 46:04think the well is going to run
- 46:05dry? Do we think people are
- 46:07going to stop watching college
- 46:08football or college basketball
- 46:09or volleyball or women's
- 46:10basketball? I don't think so.
- 46:11>> And in the white paper you
- 46:13all talked about, and you
- 46:14mentioned this earlier, media
- 46:16rights being something that
- 46:17really needs to be looked at.
- 46:18You all believe that there's a
- 46:19great opportunity there.
- 46:22>> Yes. I, I believe it's worth
- 46:25looking at. I absolutely
- 46:27believe it's worth looking at
- 46:28and seeing if that is another
- 46:29revenue stream that can be
- 46:32created or increased. And I've
- 46:33been very clear, the
- 46:36expectation that the Big Ten or
- 46:37the SEC is going to take a
- 46:38reduction from media rights. If
- 46:39this goes. Absolutely not. That
- 46:41would be foolish. This is this
- 46:43is still America. This is still
- 46:45capitalism at its finest. The
- 46:47idea for me is can can they get
- 46:49more money out of it and
- 46:51increasing everybody's revenue
- 46:53streams? That's that's what I
- 46:54want us to take a look at.
- 46:55>> Rising tide raises exactly.
- 46:57>> An objectively saying this
- 46:58works. Or you know what, guys?
- 46:59We don't think it does.
- 47:01>> Yeah.
- 47:01>> I have a question for you.
- 47:03If I could, for for the two
- 47:05athletic directors here, I
- 47:06always wonder, you know, as you
- 47:07talk about new revenue streams,
- 47:09Josh Pastner sort of raised
- 47:10some eyebrows out saying, you
- 47:11know, do you want to buy? Do
- 47:13you want to own a college
- 47:14basketball team? But it's an
- 47:15interesting question because
- 47:16because you need revenue and
- 47:18because you're very reliant on
- 47:19your donors and now other
- 47:20revenue streams. And if if
- 47:22private equity comes in, is
- 47:23there a concern that you that
- 47:25it's, you know, whether it's,
- 47:27you know, literal or, or more
- 47:29figurative, that you have an
- 47:30owner or a group of an
- 47:31ownership group? And do you
- 47:34lose? Is there a risk of losing
- 47:36control of your own program
- 47:37when you're sort of beholden to
- 47:39the money?
- 47:40>> I'll give that an answer,
- 47:41which I would say is, you know,
- 47:44having donors that have
- 47:45provided resources, whether
- 47:46it's tickets or other things,
- 47:48there's nothing new there that
- 47:50that's been an important part
- 47:51of our ecosystem. And we've
- 47:52been really, really fortunate
- 47:54at the University of Kentucky
- 47:55to have a lot of really
- 47:56generous folks that have
- 47:57supported and stepped up. And
- 47:58we've managed with those folks.
- 48:00And I seem to I seem to think
- 48:02of them as partners, but at the
- 48:03end of the day. I think what's
- 48:07really important is we explore
- 48:08new revenue streams. Kyle is
- 48:09it's got to make sense. It's
- 48:11got to fit right. This is a
- 48:13really important brand in the
- 48:17Commonwealth of Kentucky. And
- 48:18so any of the things we're
- 48:19going to explore, any of the
- 48:21new opportunities we might go
- 48:22after and Chase have to make
- 48:23sense and fit within our brands.
- 48:26>> I'll try to boil this down
- 48:27to how my 11 year old and nine
- 48:29year old think, because they're
- 48:30bringing home all kinds of
- 48:32squishies and trading them all
- 48:33around the neighborhood, and
- 48:34they get to determine whether
- 48:35or not they want to make a deal
- 48:37for this squishy or that
- 48:38squishy. Well, we still get to
- 48:40decide, do we think this is a
- 48:41good deal for the University of
- 48:43Louisville? And and until we
- 48:45give that up, which I don't
- 48:47expect us to do, then we have
- 48:49the ability to say, hey, it's
- 48:51you get a win in this. We get a
- 48:53win. Let's move forward with
- 48:54this deal or no, this doesn't
- 48:55make sense for the University
- 48:57of Louisville. And we're going
- 48:58to hit the pause button right
- 49:00here.
- 49:00>> Looking ahead, if I could, I
- 49:01also think at the end of the
- 49:03day, doing what's best for our
- 49:05student athletes, we can't lose
- 49:06sight of that as we as we
- 49:08continue to evolve this
- 49:09business. And you've mentioned
- 49:10a lot of different things that
- 49:11are out there and folks have
- 49:13talked about, we're still here
- 49:14for our young people. And so I
- 49:16think part of that fit, to your
- 49:17point, Josh, making those
- 49:18decisions intentionally comes
- 49:19back to, are we making the
- 49:21right choices to support our
- 49:22student athletes and and our
- 49:23institutions? It's got to be
- 49:25the right thing. It's got to be
- 49:26the right fit.
- 49:27>> And I'm going to add on to
- 49:29this really quickly. When we
- 49:30think about student athletes
- 49:31and people talk about it's
- 49:33professionalized, it's
- 49:33professionalized, you know,
- 49:34professional sports don't have,
- 49:35you know, 15 academic advisors
- 49:36just for their student athletes.
- 49:37They don't have ten mental
- 49:39health professionals just for
- 49:40their student athletes. We can
- 49:41go on. There are so many
- 49:43instances where it's like, no,
- 49:45it's not professional sports.
- 49:47And so to sit here and say it
- 49:49is would just be flat out wrong,
- 49:51because we have so many student
- 49:53athletes that rely on a lot of
- 49:54the resources that aren't
- 49:55generating a dollar anywhere.
- 49:57But we're not we're not going
- 49:58to cut those.
- 49:59>> Excellent point. And in
- 50:00terms of tapping into those new
- 50:02revenue streams, some states,
- 50:03such as North Carolina and
- 50:05Louisiana, are beginning to tap
- 50:06sports wagering proceeds to
- 50:08fund Nil programs. The latest
- 50:10data we have in Kentucky is
- 50:12from June of this year, and it
- 50:13comes from the Kentucky Horse
- 50:15Racing and Gaming Corporation
- 50:16for that month. In Kentucky,
- 50:18the sports wagering handle was
- 50:21$223 million, a 27% increase
- 50:24from the same time a year ago.
- 50:25Now, the state excise tax,
- 50:27which is collected from
- 50:28wagering revenue, was $2.8
- 50:31million. A majority of this
- 50:33excise tax funds in Kentucky
- 50:35now go to helping Kentucky's
- 50:37public pension systems. I know
- 50:39it's a hot button issue, but I
- 50:40need to ask it. Would you
- 50:42support a measure in Kentucky
- 50:43to dedicate some of sports
- 50:45wagering proceeds to fund Nil
- 50:46at Kentucky schools?
- 50:48>> I'll take this one. And yes,
- 50:50it is a hot topic based on
- 50:52where these proceeds go now.
- 50:54And sure, not trying to dodge
- 50:55the question, but I would tell
- 50:57you, we need to look at
- 50:58everything. So what are those
- 51:00opportunities? As we're seeing
- 51:01other states start to go down
- 51:02that road, not just with
- 51:04gambling revenues. Right. But
- 51:06Wisconsin appropriated $15
- 51:08million, was new Jersey
- 51:10appropriated another $5 million
- 51:12for Rutgers. You're starting to
- 51:13see it. And once again, it goes
- 51:15back to name anything else in
- 51:17this state that brings, we
- 51:18could probably argue maybe
- 51:20bourbon here in Kentucky, but
- 51:22brings more joy to the
- 51:24Commonwealth than our teams
- 51:27having success. And so what
- 51:30opportunities at the state
- 51:31level can be provided to say,
- 51:32hey, we want the University of
- 51:34Louisville, the University of
- 51:35Kentucky, Western Kentucky,
- 51:37Northern, right on down the
- 51:38line to be very successful in
- 51:40college athletics.
- 51:41>> Jay, very quickly, your
- 51:42thoughts on that?
- 51:42>> Yeah, I appreciate the
- 51:44question, Chip. I do, but I
- 51:45would say that, you know, we've
- 51:48got really great leaders at our
- 51:50state and they're certainly
- 51:51tackling a lot of really
- 51:53complex issues. And so would
- 51:55would think that they would,
- 51:56you know, look at everything
- 51:57they possibly can. But
- 51:59certainly something that I
- 51:59would leave to them.
- 52:00>> To close out tonight. We
- 52:02asked everyone we interviewed
- 52:03for this show the very same
- 52:04question at the end of our
- 52:06interviews. If for one week you
- 52:08were king of college sports and
- 52:10you could do whatever you
- 52:11wanted to fix the Nil issue,
- 52:14what would you do? Here are
- 52:15their responses.
- 52:18>> I would have myself have the
- 52:20enforceability around what the
- 52:22settlement had been. That was,
- 52:24which would be this year, 21.3
- 52:26million. I think I'd rather
- 52:27that be the cap than even a
- 52:29higher cap than that, because I
- 52:30think it creates a more level
- 52:33playing field, no pun intended.
- 52:35Across the conferences. I think
- 52:37none of us want to see a
- 52:39situation where we have a Super
- 52:41League, or we just have a few
- 52:42that come to dominate. What is
- 52:44college sports?
- 52:47>> I think I'd want a fairly
- 52:49regulated market that gave
- 52:52student athletes an opportunity
- 52:54to get a good education, have
- 52:58the benefits that we provide in
- 53:00terms of scholarships, wellness,
- 53:05academic support that are
- 53:09universities to a level
- 53:11competitive playing field would
- 53:14provide our fans memories that,
- 53:19you know, bring people together,
- 53:21build community.
- 53:24>> I just know one thing, it is
- 53:26special. I mean, it's how I
- 53:28feed my children. I love my job
- 53:29and I'm so blessed to be here.
- 53:31And when I hear and I know this
- 53:33is, you know, public television,
- 53:36I don't know if I can pump up
- 53:39another network, but when you
- 53:40hear that CBS music, you hear
- 53:42that NCAA tournament. Dun dun
- 53:44dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun
- 53:47dun dun. And just how special
- 53:49college sports is in wanting
- 53:51that to continue. Like I said,
- 53:54I'm going to leave it to the
- 53:56people that are smarter than me
- 53:58or are thinking about it 24
- 53:59over seven how to figure this
- 54:01out. I'm trying to get, you
- 54:02know, those 13 young men over
- 54:04in that other room into
- 54:06championship shape. So I'm
- 54:08controlling what I can control.
- 54:09I'm counting on those people to
- 54:10take care of what they can,
- 54:12what they can do to fix this
- 54:13thing. And then and then let's
- 54:15go.
- 54:16>> Quick answers. Josh, what
- 54:17would you do?
- 54:18>> A clearly enforceable cap
- 54:20guidelines around eligibility
- 54:23requirements and protection
- 54:24around lawsuits and state laws.
- 54:28>> Jay.
- 54:29>> I would simply add that we
- 54:30need to continue to, to develop
- 54:32two things. A clear, broad
- 54:36based system that provides a
- 54:38understandable, consistent
- 54:40framework in addition to what
- 54:41Josh shared. And then we need
- 54:42to continue to protect
- 54:43opportunities for student
- 54:44athletes.
- 54:44>> Do you think that clear
- 54:46framework does involve federal
- 54:47legislation? At this point?
- 54:48>> The Protect College Sports
- 54:49Act would move that forward,
- 54:50and I think that's a really
- 54:52good thing today.
- 54:53>> Brooklyn, what would you do?
- 54:54>> Yeah, I think I would take
- 54:56out the transactional piece,
- 54:57especially in the transfer
- 54:58portal. I think NIL is a great
- 55:00opportunity, but for athletes
- 55:02that are going into the portal
- 55:03just to find a school that
- 55:05gives them the biggest amount
- 55:07or biggest paycheck, I think
- 55:09should be taken out.
- 55:10>> So to reel that bidding war
- 55:12back in so that you don't have
- 55:14that.
- 55:14>> People are going to the
- 55:15school for the right reasons.
- 55:17>> Sure, sure. That's right.
- 55:18And Kyle, your take on.
- 55:19>> It, I think the real fix is
- 55:21a lot of we're alluded to here,
- 55:23short of congressional
- 55:24intervention, require
- 55:24collective bargaining. And that
- 55:25comes with a whole nother web.
- 55:27>> We could do another layer on
- 55:28that.
- 55:29>> I don't I don't see us
- 55:30getting there with any speed.
- 55:31And so if you're saying one
- 55:33change that could make a
- 55:34difference, again, I pulled a
- 55:35lot of coaches this summer and
- 55:37many of them said one time
- 55:38transfer, with the exception of
- 55:40because the argument is my
- 55:41coach leaves, well, then you
- 55:42get an exception. If your coach
- 55:44leaves, you can also move.
- 55:45Maybe if you graduate early and
- 55:47you have that extra year.
- 55:48That's one other exception, but
- 55:49very few exceptions because
- 55:50player movement and being able
- 55:51to transfer every year really
- 55:52leads to most of the problems.
- 55:54It leads to tampering, rampant
- 55:55tampering. Because if I know
- 55:56every player in college
- 55:57basketball is available to me,
- 55:59I'm going to start talking to
- 56:00him in December and floating
- 56:02the number. I think it would
- 56:03lead to athletes taking time to
- 56:05make a better decision about
- 56:06their long term future. That's
- 56:07not just dollars and cents.
- 56:08>> Well, it's been a
- 56:09fascinating topic. Many thanks
- 56:11to our panelists tonight, and
- 56:12we hope we've been able to
- 56:13provide you some background on
- 56:15how all this works for sports
- 56:16that are so near and dear to
- 56:18all of us in Kentucky. We
- 56:19appreciate you watching. Be
- 56:21sure to join us Each weeknight
- 56:22for Kentucky edition at 630
- 56:23eastern, 530 central. And I'll
- 56:25see you again right here on
- 56:26Saturday night at 8:00 eastern,
- 56:287:00 central on Kentucky Life.
- 56:29Have a good week.