Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Scarce Assets E007: Alex Gladstein - Bitcoin is a Global Life Raft
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that this
- 0:02podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10If you are enjoying On RAMP media content, please like
- 0:13subscribe and share as it goes a long way in helping others find
- 0:17the signal through the noise. Now for a word from on RAMP.
- 0:20On RAMP is a Bitcoin asset management platform built on
- 0:23multi institution custody leveraging our partnership with
- 0:26Bit Go and their 10 plus year track record in securing assets
- 0:29and Coincover, the premier digital asset risk mitigation
- 0:32company on ramps. Multi institution custody is a
- 0:35segregated institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:39institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:43unique permissions have been met at on RAMP we understand that
- 0:47your Bitcoin journey is a multi generational pursuit catalyzed
- 0:50by the ideals of perseverance, aspiration and legacy.
- 0:54That's why we're proud to introduce on RAMP Heritage, a
- 0:57suite of private client services dedicated to ensuring your
- 1:00Bitcoin legacy is preserved and passed on, embodying the true
- 1:04essence of wealth that goes beyond mere numbers.
- 1:07If you would like to learn more, please schedule a consultation.
- 1:10As we prepare for the Bitcoin having and the next wave of
- 1:13global adoption of this nascent and growing asset class, we are
- 1:17halving all annual maintenance fees for clients that secure
- 1:20their wealth before the next Bitcoin epoch.
- 1:23Let's be clear, Bitcoin is an international asset.
- 1:27We are spending like drunken sailors.
- 1:31Bitcoin is the only economic entity where the supply is
- 1:35unaffected by the demand. If you want to preserve your
- 1:39wealth, you have to. Convert that.
- 1:41Currency into an asset that's scarce, desirable, portable,
- 1:46durable, and maintainable. Hello, my name is Andy Edstrom
- 1:56and I'm excited to welcome you to the 7th episode of Scarce
- 1:59Assets, a show that examines scarcity, the most fundamental
- 2:03driver of economics and markets, and the scarcest asset of all,
- 2:06which is Bitcoin. Today, I'm very happy to be here
- 2:09with my friend and Co host Jesse Myers and our guest, the
- 2:12prolific Alex Gladstein. Now I have the pleasure of
- 2:16saying a few things about Alex. I think Alex is simply the best
- 2:19person in the world at articulating how Bitcoin
- 2:22advances and protects human rights.
- 2:24His views have been published by the Atlantic, the BBC, The New
- 2:28York Times, The Wall Street Journal, the Guardian, and lots
- 2:32of other places. His he is the author of the book
- 2:36called Check Your Financial Privilege, which is the best
- 2:39summary I've found on how Bitcoin is making a direct
- 2:42positive impact on people and especially the poorest and most
- 2:45disempowered people all over the world.
- 2:48And I just finished it and I highly recommend it.
- 2:51And lastly, I'm just going to say Alex is a very nice guy and
- 2:55I'm absolutely delighted to have him here with us today.
- 2:58So, Alex, how are you? I'm great.
- 3:01I'm. I'm happy that I qualify as a
- 3:03nice guy. Yep, more so.
- 3:05More so than the other stuff, but yeah.
- 3:08Well, you got to keep, you know, you got to keep it up though,
- 3:11you know, it's a it's an ongoing test.
- 3:14I really appreciate you coming on today.
- 3:16Let's dive in. Let's dive into.
- 3:18Some of the. The content from Check Your
- 3:21Financial Privilege So So while we live in the US and most of us
- 3:25use the dollar day-to-day and most people in the world aren't
- 3:28so lucky, some live in places like Egypt or Argentina which
- 3:32just experienced major devaluations.
- 3:35My question for you is why do you think that otherwise well
- 3:39meaning people in rich countries like the US don't talk about the
- 3:43damage caused to the lives of poor people by bad currency
- 3:46management? It's a great question, and I
- 3:51think that there's actually 2 dimensions.
- 3:55There's a financial privilege which talk about in my book and
- 4:00that relates to the monetary technology people use.
- 4:04You know, about a billion people have the benefit of living in a
- 4:07country that has proper private property rights protections
- 4:10under a Liberal Democratic government that is restrained by
- 4:14the population as well as having what's known as a reserve
- 4:18currency. So, you know, a Fiat that's
- 4:20relatively attractive so that other central banks will save in
- 4:24it. The other 7 billion people
- 4:26either live under authoritarianism or, you know, a
- 4:30really shitty currency. But there's also energy
- 4:33privilege, and they're actually really connected.
- 4:36So if you look at like a chart of like, per capita income
- 4:39versus basically per capita energy usage, like America's up
- 4:43in the upper right, and that's where you want to be.
- 4:46And then there's like 4 billion people in the bottom, lower left
- 4:49who, you know, don't have a lot of economic capital and who use
- 4:57very little energy. And they are, you know, in some
- 5:04way essentially enslaved, you know, to a degree, right.
- 5:10They, they don't have the full freedom of their time, of their,
- 5:15of their occupation, of their future.
- 5:19And and we have a lot more of that freedom right in the upper
- 5:23right. So sound money and access to
- 5:28energy I think are the two building blocks for for freedom
- 5:31actually. And what's interesting is to
- 5:35look at Bitcoin as a tool that can actually address both of
- 5:37these things is is where my work has been recently going back to
- 5:43check your financial privilege. And all the stories I was
- 5:46researching and interviewing for about five years ago, 2019-2020
- 5:50that went into that book are all profoundly important.
- 5:54I think in terms of understanding our role in the
- 5:56world as American, at least of me as an American understanding.
- 5:59You know, the dollar is very unique and most people don't
- 6:03live with the dollar. You know, they live under some
- 6:05currency that's that's basically collapsing, going to zero
- 6:09against the dollar. And that's only part of the
- 6:14story though like the the the electricity, energy, power part
- 6:17is is really key too. And it's so fascinating that
- 6:20Bitcoin is this. Technology that can, actually.
- 6:23Do both like it. It gives people sound money and
- 6:26it can allow them to access and expand and turn the energy
- 6:33that's around them that's otherwise untappable into
- 6:38capital or power. That's just very profound I
- 6:42think and and the the coming. Century is going to see the
- 6:46impact of that, I think, especially in places like
- 6:49Africa, Latin America, Asia, yeah.
- 6:52Yeah, it it feels, it feels funny that, you know, when folks
- 6:58in the top right of that energy graph you're describing, there's
- 7:03almost like this psychology of scarcity that comes in of like
- 7:08almost crabs in a bucket. Where like I feel like in the
- 7:12West, we tend not to think about the people in the bottom left
- 7:15because we have this scarce mindset of like we're going to
- 7:19take more kind of knowing that we're feeling that like it's at
- 7:24the expense of other people that we're getting more than our fair
- 7:26share a scarcity. Yeah, that we're using too much
- 7:29when the answer is abundance. Not in this case is abundance,
- 7:34not scarcity. Like the the when you're in
- 7:36Malawi and there's only 11% of people who have electricity but
- 7:40you're surrounded by energy resources, you realize it's not
- 7:45about scarcity. I mean in in in terms of energy
- 7:48at least it's about what can help us transform all of the
- 7:58energy around us into either capital or electricity in a
- 8:05market with a market based solution like you know because
- 8:08right now that's all being done with aid and with concessional
- 8:11financing basically with gifts, it's not sustainable and that's
- 8:15why people languish so much. Bitcoin is like this piece of
- 8:20technology that comes in and provides a market based
- 8:25framework for people to make money and do do business and do
- 8:29well by harnessing all of that otherwise wasted or stranded or
- 8:36orphaned or or just untapped unrealized energy.
- 8:42And that's that's, I think, again, amazing, especially when
- 8:46they're going to get paid and sound money.
- 8:48Which? Is a lot better than the
- 8:50Milanian Kwacha, which is like the sort of the if you're to do
- 8:55a vignette about financial privilege.
- 8:56I mean, these people are the 6th poorest country in the world.
- 9:00They make about $300.00 a year. That's the median.
- 9:04So of course, outside the cities it's probably closer to $100 a
- 9:07year. They save only in Fiat.
- 9:11I know that Saylor was getting skewered the other day for his
- 9:14line where he said that, you know, people who save in Fiat
- 9:19currency, we call them poor. But it was taken out of context
- 9:23of actually a really good point that he was making about rich
- 9:26people don't save in Fiat currency.
- 9:28Rich people save in assets, real estate like like, but poor
- 9:31people do save in Fiat currency and they save in Fiat currency
- 9:33in Malawi, right. So all these people, they don't
- 9:36have real estate or stock market or bonds or they're not
- 9:41investing in companies. I mean, if they're lucky,
- 9:46they're using paper money or, you know, they don't have bank
- 9:50accounts, but like, you know, if they're lucky they have cash,
- 9:53otherwise it's cows in sheet metal.
- 9:55I mean, that's what people save in.
- 9:56That's what most of the world saves in, cows in sheet metal.
- 9:59So most people save, if they're lucky, in Fiat.
- 10:05And it's not like in the United States where we have pretty
- 10:11strong currency that's accepted around the world and isn't going
- 10:13to like, you know, lose all its value overnight like that.
- 10:16That's highly unlikely, right? That is exactly what happens in
- 10:20Malawi, right? So not only is it not acceptable
- 10:22anywhere, not convertible anywhere, can't buy anything
- 10:26with it, whether it be the citizens or the state.
- 10:28State cannot print quacha to buy planes from Boeing or oil from
- 10:32Saudi Arabia or fertilizer from France.
- 10:36No, no. They have to go get dollars
- 10:37first. And and at the micro level
- 10:41people are like basically trapped into like international
- 10:44commerce and then they get devalued.
- 10:50So in November they had a 44% overnight unannounced currency
- 10:53devaluation. So these people who are all
- 10:56saving in Fiat money, they are poor and and they're the
- 11:04dictionary definition, I mean we're, we're, we're talking
- 11:06about radically poor here. I mean, again, $300.00 a year,
- 11:10poor. And all of a sudden they're
- 11:14being told, oh, by the way, you know, the fruit of your labor's
- 11:19only going to buy 54% as much as it as it did 56 as much as
- 11:25percent as much as it did the other day.
- 11:27You know, that's insane. And you know I I kind of argue
- 11:31that it's a crime against humanity because they weren't
- 11:33consulted. They didn't like no one asked
- 11:35them and it hurts everybody in the whole country and that
- 11:39that's that's what financial privilege is.
- 11:41Financial privilege is not even need needing to think about that
- 11:43financial privilege is not even needing to know about that
- 11:46financial privilege is not even like being concerned with that
- 11:50at all. Financial privilege is just
- 11:52being comfortable with money and being able to use it around the
- 11:55world relatively easily and and not really having ever to think
- 11:58about a frozen bank account or an overnight devaluation or
- 12:01hyperinflation or to to to a black.
- 12:06Market price for your currency in your country.
- 12:09And financial privilege is not knowing that the overwhelming
- 12:12majority of the world deals with everything, all of those things,
- 12:14every day. So that's that's really what
- 12:16financial privilege is. Ignorance is bliss in that
- 12:19regard, but I really appreciate you bringing these stories to
- 12:22the fore. That's actually one of my
- 12:24favorite things about your book. Check.
- 12:25Your financial privilege is the case studies.
- 12:27So we just went through one. There are several others and
- 12:31they're all unique and different that you talk about.
- 12:35I though would like to go back to your comment about energy.
- 12:39And I'm wondering, I'm wondering if there's a case study that is
- 12:43top of mind for you with respect to what's going on with people
- 12:48being able to harness energy, you know, rather than just the
- 12:52pure financial access and devaluation stories?
- 12:58Yeah, well. Ever since I publicly check your
- 13:03financial privilege, I wrote another book called Hidden
- 13:05Repression that explores kind of the structure behind financial
- 13:12privilege. And it looks at the dollar
- 13:15hegemonic system and how, whether intentionally or not,
- 13:21like we we basically created a debt, colonial debt,
- 13:24colonialism. And we replaced the old school
- 13:26way of exploiting the world's resources by great powers, which
- 13:29used to be done with violence, pretty much traditional
- 13:32imperialism. And we've replaced that with
- 13:36debt colonialism and that that that book describes how that
- 13:40works and and the vast implications of that and how
- 13:43it's totally hidden from most mainstream people don't know
- 13:48that poor countries send rich countries trillions of dollars
- 13:52net per year in value. But that is not known by people.
- 13:56People just have no idea. They just, they have they, they
- 13:58assume, including me before I did the research like that rich
- 14:02countries, you know, give money to poor countries and we give
- 14:05them aid and stuff. No, no, no.
- 14:06That's what I assumed too. I learned it from I learned it
- 14:09from you. Yeah.
- 14:10We take, we take and it's wild and and it's not like and
- 14:16everything's marginal, right. So it is important, but it it
- 14:19it's, it's, it's. Cruel.
- 14:21Because the amount we take isn't even a huge percentage of our
- 14:25GDP. You know, it's like, but we take
- 14:27anyway. It's like, it's like super,
- 14:29super. Cruel.
- 14:30But anyway, the point is explored That and then my my
- 14:34newest piece that is, you know, at that level came out recently.
- 14:40It's called Stranded and it explores stories and case
- 14:44studies of Bitcoin being used as a technology to expand
- 14:48electricity. Access both both as a social
- 14:51enterprise and and as a capitalistic system.
- 14:55Yeah, awesome. Is there?
- 14:57Yeah, I'm thinking of cases. I guess I've sort of heard of
- 15:00one or two case studies perhaps in Africa.
- 15:02Is that where these, where these stories are are centered?
- 15:06Anything you want to preview with us from the piece?
- 15:12Yeah, sure. So in Malawi we visited a town
- 15:18called Bondo which is a village and it's a place where only 11%
- 15:24of people have electricity in this country.
- 15:29And before 2016 nobody in this village had ever had power
- 15:31before. And through the gift of the
- 15:34Scottish Government an 8 year project took place where finally
- 15:38they were able to get some power to people.
- 15:39And a small company was created by a local conservationist
- 15:43called Mega which was which is the power company and it
- 15:45provides the power so it takes the micro hydro power and
- 15:48distributes it to villagers. The problem is this concessional
- 15:51financing model doesn't cover OpEx or expansion.
- 15:56So what you have is a situation where you know, people kind of
- 16:01stuck. I mean there's like so many
- 16:03people who have electricity and then there's no like capital to
- 16:07to do more, to to hook up more homes or to build more power.
- 16:10It's, it's the they just make enough to scrape by and barely.
- 16:13I mean they're not making, it's not profitable like they're
- 16:16they're paying out of their pocket.
- 16:17The power companies subsidized the energy, so it's not $0.90
- 16:20per kWh, so it's more like $0.20.
- 16:23So it's. So it's not five times as much
- 16:25as what Americans pay, but like 2 times.
- 16:27What Americans pay and. And that's all subsidy.
- 16:29So this is no, no, no market anything here.
- 16:31It's just social enterprise. It's a charity basically and
- 16:35they're running it so that these people can have power.
- 16:38OK, so then enter Bitcoin mining.
- 16:39So now, ever since about a year and a half ago or whatever, the
- 16:43Bitcoin network is now buying 100% of the power that the hydro
- 16:48station can't sell to the village, which is obviously at
- 16:52night pretty much all its power during storms, all its power and
- 16:58and and you just start to realize is that base load, power
- 17:03generation and all, all power generation, like even even even
- 17:08wind with which is just sort of base load sometimes and not
- 17:11others, right? It's like it turns on and off.
- 17:14You can't. You don't really control that,
- 17:15right. All these sites waste a
- 17:18tremendous amount of power because especially in rural
- 17:20areas and places without grids like which is most of the world,
- 17:23you know, not not advanced economies, but out there there's
- 17:26no, like sophisticated grid. So it's not like the village of
- 17:28Bondo can sell it's excess power to someone else.
- 17:31No, there's no one around and there's no grid, so.
- 17:33So it just goes back. It just gets, it gets put back
- 17:36into the ground with like a machine.
- 17:37It's literally crazy. So, so now they don't do that
- 17:40anymore. Now the Bitcoin network through
- 17:42a company called Grid List and there's other companies doing
- 17:44this. There's a whole alliance of
- 17:45companies. Doing this but.
- 17:48They come in, they set up the little Hut, they they they mine.
- 17:53They buy the power that is not used and they mine Bitcoin with
- 17:58it and they pay a fee to the power company for the service.
- 18:02They're doing that and they make money.
- 18:04Everybody makes money. Everybody does.
- 18:05Well now the power company Mega no longer has to subsidize out
- 18:10of its own pocket. The Bitcoin network subsidizes
- 18:12that power brings brings the cost down for everybody and it's
- 18:16just it's pretty extraordinary and that that's the social
- 18:19enterprise piece and now the power company has enough capital
- 18:22now finally to connect more homes to build more power.
- 18:26And and you know Gridlist thinks this is going to basically
- 18:29electrify all of Malawi by the end of 2530 years from now where
- 18:34whereas like no World Bank or Red Cross or IMF or UN
- 18:39initiative would ever get that done.
- 18:41No Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, none of that stuff
- 18:44there. None of them.
- 18:45No, no, none of those people are going to electrify Malawi
- 18:47Bitcoin will. And then that that was pretty
- 18:50incredible to realize. Yeah, that I I love this topic
- 18:55in particular that what grid list is doing because it's
- 19:00amazing that it it bootstraps capitalism it bootstraps
- 19:03infrastructure. It solves half of the two sided
- 19:07market problem of like to have energy infrastructure you need
- 19:11you need to be creating it but you also need to have a buyer
- 19:13for it. It's a two sided problem and it
- 19:15solves half of that problem makes it so there's demand
- 19:19there's always demand for energy.
- 19:20So good, you know, if you can justify the business case based
- 19:24on the knowledge that there's always going to be demand for
- 19:27from Bitcoin for energy, then boom, you you have.
- 19:31Solved. Yeah, the other half and and
- 19:33that's a charity case. So this is like, OK, so bacon
- 19:36can come in and help social enterprise.
- 19:38Now the business case, so then we went to Kenya and we went to
- 19:44a lake and we saw what is very dominant in Kenya, which is the
- 19:50use of. Power to move water because the
- 19:53country's the world's largest exporter of cut flowers in the
- 19:56world, which was crazy, but basically if you're in Europe
- 19:58and you're buying flowers, probably.
- 19:59Came from Kenya. So you've got a lake and we're
- 20:04sitting outside of the lake and there's a water pump and it's
- 20:07being fed by geothermal base load power, clean, you know,
- 20:13carbon neutral green power that is going to be the same for the
- 20:16next 40 years, every day. It's going to deliver the same
- 20:18amount again, no grid, no buyers, middle of nowhere.
- 20:24Whatever the water pump doesn't use gets wasted.
- 20:26And the water pump, it's not on all the time.
- 20:29It's like variable demand, consumer energy.
- 20:33OK, so normally you're like, you're first of all, you're
- 20:36like, wow, OK now I'm starting to understand how much power is
- 20:39wasted in the world. And then on your left there's a
- 20:41little Hut again, little starlink on top, bunch of neatly
- 20:45stacked what's a miners inside? And it's the Bitcoin arc again.
- 20:49And it's buying all of the power that's otherwise wasted.
- 20:53And the economics are pretty amazing because you know
- 20:56whatever probably cost about 100 grand to buy the miners at the
- 20:59time 20 grand to set up the Shack.
- 21:02So that's your initial upfront for this company that comes in
- 21:07the things going to make like 1/4 a quarter, $1,000,000 a
- 21:09year, OK. So you know they have to pay a
- 21:13fee, so think about 30%. So they'll end up making some
- 21:21money in the first year and then they'll start making a lot of
- 21:23money year 2345. And then this is just assuming
- 21:27like this is looking at a backwards looking five year plan
- 21:32that that that has ranked you know that is that has told them
- 21:35that they're going to make between 7:00 and 9:00 cents from
- 21:37the Bitcoin network by selling it energy.
- 21:39It could be more than that, could be less, but that's like
- 21:42the meat that's the middle of the hump here.
- 21:44So this is what it's all based on.
- 21:45And you start to realize this is going to be incredibly
- 21:47profitable and it's going to be good for the Bitcoin network
- 21:51because if America starts taxing or electricity gets expensive
- 21:56here, dude, people are going to move there.
- 21:58And what that means is you're moving the hash rate from a
- 22:01centralized, controlled area to an area that's off grid.
- 22:05And this is just really, really bullish for Bitcoin.
- 22:08Yeah. So what I find so interesting
- 22:10about about all that is taking back to what you were saying,
- 22:13Alex, about charity. This is not charity what you're
- 22:16laying out right there. That's a strong business case
- 22:18that creates the incentive for the profit incentive for people
- 22:22to develop energy infrastructure in Africa and and do what the
- 22:26Economist has been lamenting for the last 25 years as I've been a
- 22:32subscriber over the past, like, they love this trip of like, why
- 22:35is Africa not developing. It's they had something back on
- 22:39like 2000 calling it the Dark continent.
- 22:41Like everybody's scratching their heads, Why is Africa not
- 22:43developing? And here's Bitcoin presenting a
- 22:46a bootstrapping mechanism for energy infrastructure through
- 22:49the profit incentive. Yeah, it's.
- 22:51Crazy. It is really crazy and I don't
- 22:55think it it's anything Satoshi could have possibly foresaw.
- 22:59Yeah. Do you think, do you think when
- 23:02you. Yeah.
- 23:03But when you create something that ties together incentives in
- 23:07this way, I mean, it creates some unpredictable outcomes.
- 23:12Absolutely does. Do you think, Alex, do you think
- 23:15the narrative around energy usage, let's just say, I mean,
- 23:19you could say in the developing world, but also just globally is
- 23:22the narrative around energy usage and the scarcity mindset
- 23:27and oh, there's only so much energy to go around.
- 23:31Obviously Bitcoin is helping, one would assume, to shift that
- 23:34narrative, but do you think it's actually making an impact yet in
- 23:37terms of average mind share and how the average sort of
- 23:40concerned? Citizen things starting to I
- 23:43mean there was a piece the last week in the Economist which is I
- 23:52think we would agree mainstream. And it's pretty based.
- 23:58I mean, I mean I'll just read you the the the opening line is
- 24:02pretty wild. It says Bitcoin mining is like
- 24:05pouring water on an even floor. It will always go to the lowest
- 24:10point. Later on it says basically that
- 24:19the worldwide search for cheap power is on If you don't get
- 24:22cheap power you won't survive the halving.
- 24:25And later, they say about Africa's renewable energy
- 24:28projects that a lot of them are stalled because there's not
- 24:32enough local consumers who are able to buy electricity to make
- 24:35them financially viable. By offering themselves as a
- 24:38buyers of last resort, miners can help stabilize demand for
- 24:41power and ensure utilities turn a profit.
- 24:44They also might incentivize the investment needed to provide
- 24:47electricity to the 600 million people in Africa, roughly half
- 24:50its population, who do not have access to power from the grid.
- 24:54So I mean, I think it's starting to soak in for people.
- 24:58It takes time. I think it's going to take many
- 25:00years, many, many years for this to properly.
- 25:04Yeah, that sounds like somebody at the Economist gets it right
- 25:08now and that's that's unbelievable actually to hear
- 25:10that at this point. What a turn in the last couple
- 25:14years. Yeah, no, I agree.
- 25:16I mean, the article's not entirely positive, but the point
- 25:19is that they're they're recognizing this.
- 25:24And once you actually just go and see it for yourself, it's
- 25:28you know it's life changing. I had, I wrote three or four
- 25:34years ago about how Bitcoin mining and we can help bootstrap
- 25:39renewable energy in in Africa and elsewhere.
- 25:42I mean that was kind of something I picked up on from
- 25:47Ross Stevens 2020 letter where he talks about this.
- 25:51And I really thought it was very insightful and I started to
- 25:53actually talk to miners working there and it's I started to
- 25:56realize it was happening. But I I had no idea to what
- 25:59scale this was going to change the world until.
- 26:01Until I actually went out there and visited these power sites
- 26:03and started to realize the scope of what's happening now in terms
- 26:08of wasted power and how Bitcoin says this, the technology that
- 26:12was invented to save wasted energy.
- 26:14And that's actually an incredible technology if that's
- 26:16the only thing it did. It would be a top 10
- 26:20civilizational innovation if that's the only thing it did was
- 26:25save wasted energy. But that is not even top 10 of
- 26:30what most people in Bitcoin think it does like.
- 26:32I think if you surveyed, like people who listen to Bitcoin
- 26:36podcasts or something like that and said what are the top 10
- 26:39things that Bitcoin does? I don't think they would
- 26:42actually say that. But, you know, I think they will
- 26:47in 10 years. I think is this will be more
- 26:48known and like look I'm like freedom human rights guy you
- 26:52know but I've always thought mining and bitcoin's
- 26:55relationship with energy was equally as interesting and and
- 26:59the impact that it will have on our relationship with energy is
- 27:02equally as profound as the impact it will have on our on
- 27:05our freedom. And that Bitcoin the money is is
- 27:10amazing but but not any more important necessarily than than
- 27:14Bitcoin these sort of energy buyer.
- 27:18So, so that that's that's been underlined recently.
- 27:20So I've started to make these little stickers.
- 27:24Let's say not mining Bitcoin wastes energy.
- 27:27I love it, you know, 'cause like at first you're like, oh, it
- 27:31says mining Bitcoin wastes energy.
- 27:32And then you see the not right. And it's like, it really flips
- 27:37the mainstream Meredith on its head.
- 27:39I mean it really literally they tell you the government has told
- 27:43us for years for decade plus, mainstream media has told us
- 27:48that Bitcoin mining is a waste of energy.
- 27:50Yeah. And it's kind of crazy to
- 27:52realize that the virtual, the literal opposite is true.
- 27:56The diametrically opposed opposite is true.
- 27:59And and yet we continue to like trust these sources of
- 28:03information. And and you know, look, you have
- 28:06to be able to sense make, right. Like a lot of what is written in
- 28:11those newspapers is, is good, is good information.
- 28:13It's helpful or interesting, but some of it is just complete
- 28:18nonsense, and just because it's written in a reputable
- 28:21organization's paper does not mean it's true.
- 28:23It's sort of the point that that the world could be united around
- 28:27telling you that Bitcoin mining wastes energy for so long, when
- 28:29the reality is literally the opposite is pretty wild.
- 28:33Yeah, well, it's partly, you know, due to your work and your
- 28:35efforts. I think that the that the
- 28:37narrative is shifting. I I put out a piece, I can't
- 28:39remember, it was two or three years ago on the same topic,
- 28:41'cause I saw, I recognize that the narrative, the environmental
- 28:44narrative on Bitcoin was quite bad at that time.
- 28:47And I was thinking to myself, you know, I think this is wrong.
- 28:50I don't think I had, you know, 100% confidence or the
- 28:54conviction at that at that level.
- 28:56I just didn't have the information.
- 28:57But I I tried to apply the logic and it seemed wrong and it is
- 29:02very, very refreshing to see more people coming to terms with
- 29:07this. And yeah, it's not in small part
- 29:10I would say due to the due to your efforts IE it's in
- 29:14substantial part. So let's so let's talk about you
- 29:17know that shifting framework 'cause I I also would have said
- 29:21you know you were telling the story of say like Roy Maboob,
- 29:24right. You know and that was about
- 29:26financial that was really about financial access I think at
- 29:28freedom. And now you're proposing, oh,
- 29:31actually the energy thing is every bit is big.
- 29:34Maybe it's even bigger is this. Do you expect as we learn about
- 29:40this thing that you know, they'll be even additional
- 29:44concepts and benefits that we don't understand up to this
- 29:47point? I mean, we're whatever, 15 years
- 29:49into the existence of this thing, are we still just
- 29:53scratching the surface or do you feel like we've finally started
- 29:56to get our arms around the benefits here?
- 30:00Yeah, I think we're just scratching the surface.
- 30:01I mean, when you actually model it out, it's kind of incredible.
- 30:05It's like Bitcoin is this thing that like attacks
- 30:08inefficiencies. It like attacks corruption.
- 30:11It attacks exploitation and then it it like fixes it.
- 30:17It's kind of incredible. Well, when you you look at for
- 30:19example the way that the world harvests the resources of poor
- 30:26countries and brings them to the economic center and abuses labor
- 30:35and devalues currency and living standards and wages in these
- 30:39other countries so that we can get stuff cheaper, that that's
- 30:43really evil in many ways but but it's but it's but no one would
- 30:48ever say it's that because it's the way we live you know and
- 30:53it's so deep seated that it could never be changed until
- 30:58Bitcoin, right and now Bitcoin steps in and it's offering one
- 31:03neutral currency for all people. So we can't do that anymore.
- 31:08You can't just be like, oh, we're just going to like,
- 31:09squeeze these people over here. I'm going to squeeze these
- 31:11people over here. No, we're all making the same
- 31:14money. Like, you know, we're making
- 31:16different amounts of it. But, like, you can't.
- 31:18It's not like Bitcoin is going to be you.
- 31:20You can't just overhear Malawi decide that Bitcoin's going to
- 31:23be worth less rice than tomorrow.
- 31:28No, it's just going to be the same as in anywhere else.
- 31:32And that's crazy. And that's going to do profound
- 31:35things to World Trade and international relations.
- 31:39But what's really interesting is that it like like it's going to
- 31:43force the people who do the exploiting to to tear down the
- 31:46wall themselves like they they're gonna they're gonna
- 31:49popularize and adopt Bitcoin unknowingly almost.
- 31:53It's like the way it's like the slide roundabout way.
- 31:55It's really really cool. So that's that's kind of, I
- 31:58think what we're seeing now is it's going to spread like a
- 32:02freedom virus and it's going to get into these little nooks and
- 32:04crannies and it's going to like, ignorance will make it stronger.
- 32:14Like, OK, so if the US government is ignorant and wants
- 32:16to tax Bitcoin miners, 'cause they're more morons and they run
- 32:22bad policy and have high electricity costs, 'cause they
- 32:25don't know what they're doing, great.
- 32:28Bitcoin will get stronger. Bitcoin will migrate elsewhere
- 32:31and it will feed off energy from other places and it actually
- 32:34will literally evolve from there, meaning it will, it will
- 32:37become less centralized, it'll become more decentralized in
- 32:40doing so. So it's this kind of crazy
- 32:43insane incentive structure that just I mean it it it it changes
- 32:50us, we we we we contribute to it knowingly but without knowing
- 32:55like knowing that we want Bitcoin or we want to earn
- 32:58money. We we we we contribute to it
- 33:00short in a short sighted way but it it is very farsighted and
- 33:05what it's going to do to the world.
- 33:06So I I don't even think we've even begun to scratch the
- 33:08surface. Yeah, it shines sunshine, shines
- 33:13a light. Where previously there's been
- 33:15darkness, it's this uncompromising capitalism.
- 33:18Totally. That that is incorruptible and
- 33:21that comes into into contact and conflict with the existing
- 33:25system that is corruptible. It has had hundreds of years of
- 33:30corruption. It's creeping into its corners
- 33:33and it's the very fabric of how it works.
- 33:36And here comes this thing that is completely uncompromising and
- 33:40is here to take over, not take part.
- 33:43Thanks for tuning in. If you're interested in
- 33:45exploring any of these topics further, or want to learn more
- 33:48about how we can help you secure a new or existing Bitcoin
- 33:51allocation, get in touch with our team at on rampbitcoin.com.
- 33:55We look forward to supporting you on your Bitcoin journey.
- 33:59Let's let's talk tactics. You know, I still get questions
- 34:02from friends, family, clients, and it's, you know, I'm
- 34:08interested in this Bitcoin thing, but I'm concerned about
- 34:11X, right? Or I'm concerned about Y.
- 34:14And sometimes I just say go, go read Gladstein.
- 34:19But I'm curious what you find resonates at this point with
- 34:23respect to getting people to at least be a little bit open
- 34:26minded with respect to the benefits of Bitcoin.
- 34:31You know, other than obviously storing wealth and accumulating
- 34:34wealth, is it, is it really the case studies that that that
- 34:38resonate the most? Yeah, I think one of the stories
- 34:46that's most powerful is my friend Roya from Afghanistan,
- 34:50and she was one of the first people who taught me about
- 34:53Bitcoin. And you know, she was using it,
- 34:57'cause she had to. There was no other option.
- 35:02There was no other way to pay women in 2013 in Afghanistan in
- 35:07a safe manner. Cash would get taken by the male
- 35:13relatives. Bank account was not an option.
- 35:16They didn't. A lot of the fintech was
- 35:18sanctioned so she paid, she paid the people that worked for her
- 35:22software company over there and in by the way which was called
- 35:26Citadel software, which is kind of funny but but she paid for
- 35:31for for their services in Bitcoin and it's quite profound.
- 35:35I mean they had ups and downs obviously that year but big
- 35:40ones, but I mean similarly to to you know to going from basically
- 35:48like 10K TO120K back down to 20 Ki mean that's that's
- 35:55essentially what you went through like in relative terms
- 35:59which made it. Price wise dollar price of
- 36:00Bitcoin. Yeah, yeah, which.
- 36:01Which made it hard to become a Bitcoin native company at the
- 36:06time. It's just Bitcoin, you know,
- 36:07which wasn't ready, you know, wasn't ready yet, but it was
- 36:10really impossible to forget was this idea that that This is
- 36:12Money that they could control. So she baked it into her
- 36:15philanthropy and charity efforts and and trained all these girls,
- 36:18thousands of girls over all these years, how to use Bitcoin.
- 36:21So cool. So.
- 36:23And now that's how that's how. That's that's how you fund
- 36:26education in Afghanistan for women today.
- 36:28With Bitcoin, you can't use dollars.
- 36:30It is physically impossible to use a dollar to fund underground
- 36:34education for girls in Afghanistan.
- 36:36Physically, technologically impossible.
- 36:40But you can do with Bitcoin. So people who are like, oh,
- 36:43there's no use case or whatever this is, this is the one, you
- 36:46just explain this to them and that they they basically have to
- 36:49start thinking a little differently, but that there's a
- 36:52million different use cases. But that one is that one I think
- 36:55is particularly important. Yeah.
- 36:57So let's talk lessons for policy there.
- 36:59I mean, you know, at the moment where we sit here in 2024, there
- 37:04are a number of countries that are under US sanction financial
- 37:07sanctions. One of the implications is loss
- 37:11of access to the dollar and arguably the dollar's, you know,
- 37:14at least the the best Fiat currency around, you know, loses
- 37:19less of its value over time. Do you have thoughts, sort of
- 37:24big picture on sanctions policy, you know, whether it's US-led or
- 37:29otherwise, and you know what it means basically for the average
- 37:33human on earth. I mean, are there good
- 37:35sanctions? Are there bad sanctions in terms
- 37:38of the general populace? What are your What are your
- 37:41thoughts? Well, I think that collective
- 37:47punishment is wrong. And whether it be, you know,
- 37:55embargoing an entire country like Cuba or Iran or or Gaza or
- 38:01whatever, I just think that's bad because so many of those
- 38:03people aren't responsible for what the rulers are doing.
- 38:06In fact, none of those countries are a democracy.
- 38:08So why would you punish them? It makes no sense.
- 38:13I I do think that smart sanctions can be quite
- 38:17effective, and I don't think they even need to be monetary.
- 38:23I mean, it could be as simple as the president of Harvard saying,
- 38:26you know what, No, the dictator of China who's currently waging
- 38:30A genocide. No, they're not gonna.
- 38:32They're not. They're we're not gonna admit
- 38:33their daughter to Harvard. It could be as simple as, like
- 38:39the, you know, New York's New York, NY, you know, real estate
- 38:48community saying, you know, no, we're not gonna like let them
- 38:52buy property here or whatever. Like, it doesn't necessarily
- 38:54have to be a frozen bank account, which which, which
- 38:56which could be, you know, which might become not a practical way
- 39:01to deal with people in the future, but there's a lot of
- 39:06different ways to to shame and and and and to oppose people who
- 39:10are doing bad things. I mean, if you look at like, how
- 39:12we as a world finally, after decades opposed apartheid South
- 39:16Africa, like, you know, that that wasn't necessarily all
- 39:20business stuff. I mean, a lot of it was
- 39:22cultural. It was like athletes coming out
- 39:25and speaking against what they were doing.
- 39:27It was, you know, kind of cultural boycott type stuff.
- 39:31So again, like, I think that there are many ways to to to
- 39:36shame and isolate countries without even touching money.
- 39:40I mean, arguably, even when you try to do it with money, even
- 39:44today it doesn't work at all. I mean, look at Russia.
- 39:47I mean, everything just goes through Kazakhstan or or
- 39:51Azerbaijan. Oh, that country's got like 10
- 39:54times as much trade as it has last year.
- 39:56I wonder why. Or they they they, they continue
- 39:59to sell gas to Europe to create. This is crazy.
- 40:01That's true. And for the first year they were
- 40:03selling tons of it throughout the invasion as they were raping
- 40:06and murdering all these people. They were Germany was buying
- 40:09tons of gas. So it's like, I don't know, like
- 40:14I think the sanctions stuff is just pretty sort of
- 40:17sanctimonious, hypocritical in many ways.
- 40:21I think smart sanctions could be OK.
- 40:25But everything's so subjective. It's hard.
- 40:27You know, I, I, I, I don't really love being in that
- 40:33mindset or industry. I I don't ever want to be
- 40:35involved in that. I don't really love the idea of
- 40:38sanctioning people. I really want to devote my time
- 40:39and energy to to to positive positivity and to liberating
- 40:44people and to creating permissionless technology and
- 40:47supporting it and and you know, asking for forgiveness later.
- 40:51I think this is the cipher punk way.
- 40:55Is that a trend you're seeing in, I don't want to say the
- 40:59industry, but let's say the area of human rights advocacy or
- 41:03human rights policy. No, no, I think like we're
- 41:05reaching the high watermark of the using the dollar as a
- 41:08weapon. Every, every, every activist
- 41:10group wants to get the US government to do acts, you know,
- 41:13please sanction my government. Please do this, please do that.
- 41:17That's really where activism has has gone to today.
- 41:20It's it's become lobbying. And that's why I'm so deeply
- 41:24distressed about it. I don't want to ever have to ask
- 41:27the US government to do anything in my activism.
- 41:30I don't care. I'm just we're we're just going
- 41:33to go out and do stuff that's totally irrelevant to the US
- 41:35government. I don't ever want to work on
- 41:37something that's like trying to beg some government to do
- 41:40something. A, they're not going to give a
- 41:43shit about you in reality. B, they're probably not going to
- 41:45do it. C They might do it and then
- 41:47betray you. I mean, these governments, no
- 41:52government. The governments are not human
- 41:53rights organizations. They're they're nation states
- 41:58that have different incentives. Like maybe once in a while
- 42:02you'll get an externality where a particular leader or a
- 42:05particular policy benefits some other population.
- 42:08But that that's that's not an incentive.
- 42:11That is a, you know, a one off that is that is not not an
- 42:15incentive. So one of the things I wanted to
- 42:17talk about was was aid, government aid and you mentioned
- 42:20it earlier. Based on that statement I'm
- 42:23guessing you're not super keen on on government based aid.
- 42:28Any thoughts? I mean.
- 42:29It could. It could be OK.
- 42:31I mean, it depends. I mean, I think there's some
- 42:34interesting. I mean, look, if you have a
- 42:36bunch of starving people. Air dropping, food aid short
- 42:41notice. There's not too many people that
- 42:42can do that, right? I mean, aid can be helpful
- 42:45certainly in natural disasters and catastrophes, but long term,
- 42:50yeah, it's bad. I mean it creates dependency and
- 42:52especially because if you understand the majority of all
- 42:55assistance is loans, not aid, So overwhelmingly.
- 43:00So yeah, which means we're, which means the lenders are
- 43:04profit. Like, you know, it's just like
- 43:06let's dispense with this idea that it's charitable.
- 43:09But no, I mean, look, I mean, like in Gaza right now, people
- 43:12are starving. And, you know, I think it's fair
- 43:14to point out that it it, it's, oh, well, like they should just
- 43:17open up ports or whatever. Well, then Hamas controls
- 43:20everything. So I think this idea of air
- 43:22dropping stuff's really interesting because it
- 43:23randomizes who gets it, and it actually can get food into the
- 43:28hands of people who are starving.
- 43:30Now, putting aside the question of why are they starving?
- 43:34Every 12 hours matters, right? So, you know, given the history
- 43:38of the Middle East, it is unlikely that the issue of why
- 43:40are they starving is going to get figured out in the next 12
- 43:42hours. That's not going to happen.
- 43:44But what could happen is an AirDrop.
- 43:46And I think it's kind of interesting.
- 43:47Aid can be done intelligently in that way, right?
- 43:50Like you could have people in a very oppressive environment
- 43:54where traditionally aid might be not a good idea because it
- 43:57basically goes to the government and then it gets controlled,
- 44:00seized, corrupted, and then whatever, maybe to give some
- 44:02leftovers, the population. This is the North Korea example.
- 44:05Like aid groups working with the North Korean government are are
- 44:08mostly a sham because they just give the money to the North
- 44:12Korean government. And you know, you could probably
- 44:14have the same criticisms against aid groups that work as Ramos,
- 44:17right? Or or or any other authoritarian
- 44:20regime around the world, the Chinese government, whatever.
- 44:25It is interesting to think about the choke point, you know, being
- 44:27the existing power structure and therefore randomizing the
- 44:31receipt. Yeah, but this is.
- 44:32Why aid is a? Benedictine, We decided to
- 44:36randomize it. So we don't, we don't send any
- 44:39official anything. We like float information into
- 44:41North Korea and like let it drop or we like send it in the black
- 44:45markets. OK.
- 44:47So this is, this is how you actually reach people.
- 44:49If you send a bunch of USB sticks and computers to the
- 44:51North Korean government, they're not going to, they're not going
- 44:54to give it to who needs. They're not going to give it to
- 44:55who needs it. Right.
- 44:57So but in general, I mean aid has been profoundly damaging.
- 45:00I mean it creates a a patronage system.
- 45:06It creates A subservient, you know, a subjugation system.
- 45:09It creates A subservience, it creates a a caste type system.
- 45:13It creates a power and a powerless.
- 45:16It it it creates dependence. I think it can be OK in limited
- 45:21doses. Certainly charity can be very
- 45:25powerful, but I don't think that it's done a very good job
- 45:31helping people climb out of the colonial legacy of Africa, let's
- 45:36put it that way. Yep, so is the lesson here.
- 45:41You know, introducing a market usually is the best thing,
- 45:45letting individuals with the knowledge they have about their
- 45:48own facts and circumstances. You know, is that sort of the
- 45:52default, default way to go with respect to helping people
- 45:57improve their, you know, their situations in life, including
- 46:01with respect to rights and freedom?
- 46:03Or is it a tricky sort of a mixed bag?
- 46:07Yeah, I don't know. I think it's black.
- 46:08It's not black and white. But the point is I think that
- 46:12what? What, what?
- 46:13What's really needed? If you're going to do charity,
- 46:16well, how about let's go upgrade the monetary technology of all
- 46:20these people who are who are vulnerable and marginalized.
- 46:23No one ever has said that ever, because that's not the game
- 46:27they're playing. But guess what?
- 46:31Bitcoin's doing that, like Bitcoin, is getting into the
- 46:33nooks and crannies of the world, and it's giving people sound
- 46:35money. And it's just remarkable.
- 46:41So agreed. I'll I'll say something I I got
- 46:44it. Of course I got it in a little
- 46:47bit of trouble in in my friend group.
- 46:51I was falling down the Bitcoin rabbit hole, like when I was in
- 46:54my my most zealous right around Black Lives Matter.
- 46:59And you know, I'm so I'm going deep down the Bitcoin rabbit
- 47:02hole and Black Lives Matter is happening.
- 47:05And it just struck me as like, you know, it's it's a shame that
- 47:12Bitcoin for black America isn't like a major talking point and
- 47:16how this could really help create a positive uplift for a
- 47:21historically disenfranchised community.
- 47:24And it, you know, even tiptoeing that out there among my friends
- 47:29was controversial and, you know, politically incorrect and
- 47:34unpalatable to them. And it was just frustrating and
- 47:38exercise and frustration that like, here's this thing that can
- 47:41actually help and does actually help because of because of
- 47:43capitalism. At the end of the day, like it
- 47:45this is has capitalism behind it.
- 47:50Yeah, I mean, look, I think there's a fine line.
- 47:56I think open source Bitcoin education is the way to focus,
- 48:02let people tweak, let people modify, support them if they
- 48:04want. You know, having just watched
- 48:07Dune in the theater, you know, you don't, you don't necessarily
- 48:11want to be the the Lisan Al Gaib or whatever.
- 48:15You don't want to be the voice from the outer world.
- 48:18It it, it doesn't end well usually as that story TLDR is
- 48:26that the savior turns into a crazy jihadist right.
- 48:29So the the the idea of someone coming in to save everybody
- 48:37rarely works out. Game of Thrones also gave us
- 48:40another version of that one with with Daenerys turning into a
- 48:43tyrant. But the the the idea is that
- 48:45that this is a, this is, this is usually not the greatest way but
- 48:50but but if we can find people locally, they're doing awesome
- 48:53work and they want the support. Absolutely.
- 48:55You know, so I think there's like a fine line between like,
- 48:59you know some of this Bitcoin evangelical evangelism stuff I'm
- 49:02uncomfortable with. Like I I don't love the idea of
- 49:05like some dude from Europe going to Guatemala and like going
- 49:08store to store trying to convert people to use Bitcoin.
- 49:10Like I think that that is not a good taste.
- 49:14You think it necessarily needs to be like grassroots and and
- 49:19organic discovered by people? Yeah, like he should focus on
- 49:23his own country. Like what?
- 49:25What is going on there? I think that you, you can look,
- 49:31I just think Bitcoin's consensual.
- 49:33So like what we try to do is be open, listen people express an
- 49:39interest, they can apply for funding from from us or we can
- 49:41partner with them. But really it's on it's going to
- 49:43be on their terms. But like you can't force Bitcoin
- 49:47on people. I mean I try to gently orange
- 49:51pill people that I think could could could use it in in my
- 49:54industry right. Because I think that's very
- 49:56important for for getting policy and aid people at high levels to
- 50:00understand this. And I feel less bad about
- 50:03imposing on them because they're kind of you know in my
- 50:06environment, right. It's OK.
- 50:09But yeah, I I don't know about the door to door stuff.
- 50:12I, I, I, I think that you know, some people who are from those
- 50:16places will start amazing circular economies and then we
- 50:19can support them, right, Which is, which is what we like to do.
- 50:24But there's a little bit of a fine line.
- 50:26Here is the point. There definitely is a fine line.
- 50:29I have also learned the hard way that the hard sell generally
- 50:33does not work. If you heard someone, guess
- 50:37what, They're going to lose the fucking Bitcoin.
- 50:38They're not going to. They're not going to pay
- 50:40attention to it if they don't think it's valuable or important
- 50:43or they don't understand it like you're not.
- 50:45So that's why you really gotta just, you know, we're working on
- 50:48the education piece for human rights activists.
- 50:50This is a different, totally different one thing is like, oh,
- 50:54you run like a corner store, You should use Bitcoin.
- 51:01I don't know about that. But I have no problem being a
- 51:05little more firm with human rights activists in in just in
- 51:09as much as my approach. I'll be like, hey, have you ever
- 51:11had a frozen bank account? They're gonna be like, Yep.
- 51:13They're like, hey, would you be interested in a technology that
- 51:16allows you to escape from that. Yes.
- 51:19Like you just it's just different because it's a smaller
- 51:22niche group. But they're like broad sale like
- 51:26broad broad brush. Let's just convert everybody to
- 51:30Bitcoin. Like, I don't know.
- 51:31I know it's good intentions. I know it is.
- 51:34So that's what makes it tough. But and and yes if the if the
- 51:37person running the store listens and they plan carefully they
- 51:42will benefit. So it's not.
- 51:45I don't want to be. It's not it's it's you know when
- 51:48I say evangelism just I'm just describing kind of the like I'm
- 51:52I'm certainly a Bitcoin evangelist but like the it's not
- 51:54like spreading Christianity which which in my view is
- 51:58arguably destructive. I know some people be offended
- 52:01by that but like that's not this is different like you know you
- 52:04adopt this thing it's gonna actually it it will benefit you
- 52:07so but I just want to be careful.
- 52:10I think we should be mindful and careful about how we spread it
- 52:12is all like just remember you can't force it on people and
- 52:15better better that it be like locally grassroots.
- 52:18Grassroots is just the way to go.
- 52:20So you know, grassroots approach is the best approach.
- 52:23It's a great distinction and and of course I fall into this trap
- 52:27of you know, there's push and there's pull and and one of
- 52:32those makes sense for Bitcoin and the other gets you nowhere.
- 52:35And it's hard to remember that there's that line there between
- 52:38the two. I mean it even, I mean, even in
- 52:40the industry trying to get these exchanges to adopt Lightning,
- 52:44they're not going to do it unless they want to, unless they
- 52:46have an incentive. They're just like Binance all of
- 52:49a sudden realized it could, it could actually really
- 52:51meaningfully improve its product in P2P if they added Lightning.
- 52:55And they did. And it works.
- 52:57And it's just like very popular just in Kenya and people use it
- 53:01all the time. And now with like the mining
- 53:04pools, lighting, payouts, yeah, they're not doing that because
- 53:07they, like, love lightning. No, they're going to do it
- 53:09because it's, they have an incentive.
- 53:11So, you know, we even see it here, right?
- 53:15The incentives have to align. In that So when I when I was in
- 53:19Business School a decade ago, M Pesa was one of the big like
- 53:23case studies of you know what was going on in Kenya with cell
- 53:28phone technology allowing them to kind of leapfrog ahead in
- 53:32terms of development. Do you feel like that narrative
- 53:35is coming for Bitcoin and banking in in Kenya and other
- 53:39places? Where are the where are the B
- 53:45school cases on on what Bitcoin banking can do for for everyone?
- 53:54Yeah. I mean, look, it is a superior
- 53:57monetary technology to the US dollar, period.
- 54:00So the sooner you learn about it and grok it and understand it
- 54:04and learn how to integrate it, the better you'll be.
- 54:06For a lot of people listening, you're probably somewhat
- 54:08privileged like me and you have a pretty solid Fiat income
- 54:12stream and you can choose to convert some of that to Bitcoin
- 54:17for future generations. I mean that's that's that's like
- 54:20the middle class, upper class position on this, which is
- 54:25obviously a huge privilege to be able to do that.
- 54:29You can also regardless of how much income you have, you can
- 54:34earn Bitcoin, which is awesome and way better than buying
- 54:37Bitcoin in many ways meaningfully better mining
- 54:42obviously is going to be for a smaller group of people who have
- 54:44a particular skill set. But you know, I think mining
- 54:46will be will grow into something that's it already is.
- 54:50But you know, hopefully one day as popular as like people who
- 54:54like to mess around with cars or ham radios or whatever, there's
- 54:57going to be a massive community of like home miners, which is,
- 54:59which is really critical and great.
- 55:01We should support that. But you know, a lot of people
- 55:07around the world are not in the position that the majority of
- 55:10people who listen to like produce and listen to Bitcoin
- 55:13podcasts in the West are. They don't have like a steady
- 55:16Fiat stream of high quality Fiat that they can just decide to,
- 55:21oh, I'll just save some Bitcoin. No, they're like living hand to
- 55:25mouth week to week, day-to-day. Their money sucks.
- 55:29They're dealing with inflation. They use Bitcoin very
- 55:32differently. They have very different use
- 55:33cases for Bitcoin. They use Bitcoin to pay for
- 55:35their electricity bill. They use Bitcoin to buy
- 55:38groceries. They use Bitcoin to send money
- 55:40to someone around the world. I understand that like
- 55:44influencers here are like don't spend your Bitcoin and and you
- 55:47know obviously if you can afford yes, if yes, in theory, if you
- 55:51can afford to don't, yes, OK, obviously you should try to
- 55:53spend the Fiat. But that's just not the case for
- 55:59like so many millions of Bitcoin users.
- 56:01That's that's that's not really the boat they're in and they're
- 56:05not They may never be in a position where they can earn in
- 56:09a decent Fiat and then save in Bitcoin.
- 56:13That is a really interesting historical moment that that's
- 56:16not going to last forever. Like eventually all the fiats
- 56:19will collapse and that's just not going to be like an option.
- 56:22We're living in a time when we can speculatively attack the
- 56:25dollar and and the the pound and the yen and the R&B and the the
- 56:29ruble and all these currencies with the Bitcoin.
- 56:32But that's it that's that's that's that's ephemeral there'll
- 56:35those things will die right. So we're in this moment where
- 56:37like if you're yes, you're uniquely generation,
- 56:41generationally well positioned. If you can start saving and
- 56:45stacking Bitcoin for your future, like man, that's that's
- 56:48a once in a freaking Millennium situation there for you.
- 56:52Because most people will be born outside of that window.
- 56:55They'll have either been born too early or they'll be born too
- 56:59late. Like it's a, it's a.
- 57:03It's a amazing. Time.
- 57:05Yeah, it won't be like bad. They'll just earn denominated in
- 57:08Bitcoin. But like, the idea that you can
- 57:11earn or borrow, even really borrowing, right, is the real
- 57:16thing. The idea that you can borrow in
- 57:19dollars and then buy Bitcoin is just the craziest idea.
- 57:24And obviously Sailor is just executing this like,
- 57:27relentlessly. He's just borrowing in dollars
- 57:30and buying Bitcoin. I mean this is, I mean this will
- 57:33be, I don't even know if there will be business schools in the
- 57:35future, But if there are, I mean there's going to be a big
- 57:37freaking book written about what he's doing, that's for sure.
- 57:41But the point is not everybody, not everybody can do that,
- 57:44right. So, you know.
- 57:48Yeah, exactly. I guess he did 800 and then 500
- 57:52more. But like the the the point is, I
- 57:55mean and and the and the value of the the IO US that he minted
- 57:59are now up 40% from 5 days ago. So crazy.
- 58:02But anyway, I mean there's so much demand to gamble on this
- 58:04thing that like that there's just so much demand for that
- 58:06stuff. But 10s of millions of people
- 58:08are just in a completely different world and they're not,
- 58:12this is not, they're not going to be like borrowing in their
- 58:14local currency till that. No, no, no, this, this is like
- 58:16sort of a day-to-day tool that they use to get by.
- 58:20So I just think we should be mindful of that.
- 58:23Yeah. And it's you know I think it's
- 58:25helpful messaging for people, you know for those who are
- 58:27living in a position of financial privilege, they have
- 58:30savings, they have capital. I think it's useful for them to
- 58:33know that their storage of capital in the system is having
- 58:39positive externalities for people that they never
- 58:42encounter, they never see day-to-day.
- 58:44They're different countries. People should feel so good about
- 58:47investing in Bitcoin, being involved in Bitcoin.
- 58:49I've been giving a bunch of talks to Wall Street recently
- 58:51just to just to, like, help them understand the human rights side
- 58:53of things. But like, I mean, they should
- 58:56feel good. Really good.
- 58:58I mean, right now people are feeling nixed.
- 59:01They want to buy Bitcoin. They want to get involved in the
- 59:04ETF or whatever, but they feel, but they're not so sure.
- 59:08They've heard bad things about Bitcoin in the media.
- 59:10They don't, They don't think it's good for the environment.
- 59:11They're not so sure they, you know, criminals.
- 59:14So, so like, my point to them is like, this is the single best
- 59:18ESG investment ever in history. So that's it.
- 59:23Like if you're actually going to take the words at their face
- 59:25value, like this thing is. Incredible.
- 59:27It expands green power. It eliminates waste of the
- 59:33energy. It expands financial inclusion.
- 59:36It, it promotes human rights. It's incorruptible, like each of
- 59:40the ESG things. It's like it's just, it should
- 59:43be the gold standard for all of them.
- 59:45And the word, you know, we have, we live in a world of
- 59:49information asymmetry. So, you know, we are very far
- 59:54away from the average person understanding that.
- 59:57I mean, and maybe it's gradually and suddenly, but like I'm
- 1:00:02thinking a decade at least. So I think we're still early.
- 1:00:05I mean, I think that's actually the mark of are we, is it still
- 1:00:08early Bitcoin adoption? Well, you know what if the
- 1:00:12average person on the street in Berlin or Tokyo or Kinshasa or
- 1:00:18Sao Paulo, and you ask them about Bitcoin and the impact on
- 1:00:21the world, And if they're not so sure, if they don't know what
- 1:00:25Bitcoin is? Or they they've heard bad things
- 1:00:27about it or they don't quite understand it, then we're still
- 1:00:30early. So it's going to be early until
- 1:00:33the average person in the world knows what Bitcoin is and and
- 1:00:36the impact it's going to have on the world.
- 1:00:38The the the positive impact it's going to have.
- 1:00:40Once they can like regularly answer that question, the
- 1:00:44average person, then we're not early anymore, but we are very
- 1:00:48far from that, very far from. That I do wonder if, yeah, I I
- 1:00:54sort of my mental model of the future is that a small subset of
- 1:01:00people ever really understand Bitcoin, and that for the vast
- 1:01:04majority of people, it's just something that happens to them,
- 1:01:08to their life, to the world around them.
- 1:01:10And it's and from their point of view, it'll be almost a joke.
- 1:01:14Like who would have thought that Bitcoin would become the the
- 1:01:18currency of the world? We live in the funniest
- 1:01:21timeline. You know, that'll be the
- 1:01:22experience that people have because because I think it it, I
- 1:01:27think it's hard to dig into the 2nd, 3rd order effects of
- 1:01:31Bitcoin on the world and understand it.
- 1:01:35And I think a lot of people just live their lives and use the
- 1:01:39currency that other people want to give them and and want to
- 1:01:42receive from them. But that's OK.
- 1:01:45You know, if if only 10% of people in the world really
- 1:01:48understand that Bitcoin's a positive force for the world, it
- 1:01:51can still be the positive force that it is.
- 1:01:54That's it. Of course.
- 1:01:55I mean, look dude, I mean like 10 years ago, if you knew what
- 1:01:58encryption was, didn't matter, 90% of the world didn't.
- 1:02:01It was huge. Same thing with Bitcoin.
- 1:02:04Like it it it it, it will be this niche phenomenon for a
- 1:02:07while. But I don't.
- 1:02:09I'm not someone who believes that it it's possible for it to
- 1:02:12be limited to being niche. Like, just due to its incentive
- 1:02:15mechanism and what it is it. We can't have it both ways.
- 1:02:19It's not going to just be this little like, oh cool, like we
- 1:02:22have some freedom money over here and we're just going to
- 1:02:24keep printing Petro dollars over here.
- 1:02:26No, it's actually built to destroy the Petro dollar.
- 1:02:29So like, we can live in this little world where we have them
- 1:02:33kind of side by side for a while, but it won't, it won't be
- 1:02:36satisfied. Not until it, it completes its
- 1:02:39quest to just destroy central banking.
- 1:02:42Like, that's just what it's going to do.
- 1:02:44Agreed and and it'll do that. And most people won't realize
- 1:02:47what it did or how it did it, but they'll just be like, oh, I
- 1:02:49guess we use Bitcoin. It's just.
- 1:02:51Freaking relentless. And it's not going to stop and
- 1:02:53it's like there's just nothing working.
- 1:02:57Ultimately the incentives are not, there's nothing really
- 1:03:01working against it. Like like every asset manager
- 1:03:04eventually is going to already is being propositioned to have
- 1:03:08oh, just a little bit. Oh probably have a little more
- 1:03:11and then more and more and more and more and then you'll, I
- 1:03:14don't know what the end, end amount will be but like it's
- 1:03:18just like that's what reserves are going to be in the future,
- 1:03:20risk free reserve rates going to be Bitcoin.
- 1:03:22So it's going to make up whatever percentage of the
- 1:03:25financial crust of the infrastructure then everything
- 1:03:29else will go on top. And those people denominating
- 1:03:30Bitcoin like of course like people are still going to issue
- 1:03:33bonds and notes and they're going to invest and write checks
- 1:03:38and of course that'll all happen and and and if you're smart
- 1:03:41you'll you'll you'll outperform Bitcoin.
- 1:03:44But like your returns will be denominated in Bitcoin is the
- 1:03:47point like it'll just be like the yardstick like once you get
- 1:03:50to that level but we're very far from that level Like like
- 1:03:54Bitcoin will continue to outperform most things for a
- 1:03:56long time and then eventually as it evens out and it it reaches
- 1:04:00it's like risk free rate like you know yes OK at that point
- 1:04:04yeah you'll you can hostile to to outperform regularly and
- 1:04:07reliably but the we're just that's that's that's in the
- 1:04:11world where most people know what it is and and and really
- 1:04:15know what it is and what it does.
- 1:04:17Yeah, just to under score that we're.
- 1:04:19Far away from that. We're still in the monetary
- 1:04:22premium stored in cattle and sheet metal as you as you
- 1:04:25pointed out early in earlier in the conversation.
- 1:04:28Well, some of the other technology has to catch up and
- 1:04:30like obviously people have invented ways to to use Bitcoin
- 1:04:32without the Internet in Africa, which is incredible.
- 1:04:36But you know some of these countries, you know you still
- 1:04:39have huge swaths of the population with very little
- 1:04:41access to anything. So technology has to, continues
- 1:04:45to has to have to go. But you know, from everything
- 1:04:47I've seen, by the end, by by 20-30, almost everyone on Earth
- 1:04:51will be either in direct control of a mobile device or one step
- 1:05:00away. And that's like, you know, six
- 1:05:04years from now. So, So we'll see.
- 1:05:07That's it. It's years away, but maybe not
- 1:05:09decades away exactly. Well, this is, this has been a
- 1:05:14tremendous conversation, Alex. I learned a lot.
- 1:05:17As always, before we let you go, where do you want to send people
- 1:05:21to learn more about your work? Sure.
- 1:05:25Well, you can look up the Bitcoin Development Fund if
- 1:05:27you're interested in what we do in terms of supporting open
- 1:05:30source. If you're interested in how we
- 1:05:35support communities and people giving getting together around
- 1:05:37the world, you can look up the Oslo Freedom Forum that's gonna
- 1:05:40take place in Norway in June, June, June, 3:00 to 5:00.
- 1:05:44So check that out. We'll have a pretty robust
- 1:05:47financial freedom track. And yeah, we'll be at the
- 1:05:51Bitcoin Conference in July, so come say hi.
- 1:05:56Sounds good. I'll see you there for sure.
- 1:05:59Well, thanks again and this has been scarce assets.