Latest / Becker’s Healthcare Podcast / Healthcare’s Supply-Demand Crisis: AI, Concierge Care and the Future of Access with Dr. Sam Patel
Transcript
- 0:02- The strategic agenda facing hospital and health system
- 0:04- leaders right now is not a short list.
- 0:07- Growth in a consolidating market, sustainable margins in
- 0:09- a reimbursement environment that rarely moves in your
- 0:12- favor,
- 0:12- a tech investment cycle that demands both urgency
- 0:15- and discipline,
- 0:16- and a workforce story that is still being
- 0:19- written.
- 0:20- Eker's fourteenth annual CEO CFO roundtable brings together
- 0:23- more than 1,500 executive level attendees and nearly
- 0:27- 400 speakers across four days of sessions that
- 0:30- are designed to help c suite leaders benchmark,
- 0:32- pressure test, and sharpen their priorities.
- 0:35- Not in the abstract, but against the real
- 0:37- decisions they'll face heading into the next year.
- 0:39- It's the kind of event you leave with
- 0:40- a clear sense of where you stand and
- 0:42- what comes next.
- 0:44- So join us November second through the fifth
- 0:46- at the Hyatt Regency in Chicago,
- 0:48- and come ready to do the hard thinking.
- 0:50- Register on our events page at beckershospitalreview.com
- 0:54- by clicking on the events tab in the
- 0:56- upper right.
- 0:58- This is Scott Becker with the Beckers HealthCare
- 1:02- podcast. I'm thrilled today to be joined by
- 1:04- doctor Sam Patel.
- 1:06- Doctor Patel is not just a doctor.
- 1:09- He's also an MBA,
- 1:12- health tech innovator, and a lot more.
- 1:15- Doctor Patel, can you take a moment
- 1:18- and tell us about you and your background
- 1:20- and and what you what you do?
- 1:22- Sure. Absolutely. Well, Scott, I appreciate having the
- 1:24- opportunity to be on here. And, of course,
- 1:26- when it comes to health care, I think
- 1:28- we can all agree that it's evolving every
- 1:30- single day. And sort of my background has
- 1:32- always been in
- 1:33- building my own practices over the number of
- 1:35- years. I've had the opportunity of building 12
- 1:37- medical practices that have kind of branched into
- 1:40- regenerative medicine and wellness and all of the
- 1:43- greatness that we see with GLP ones and
- 1:45- hormones today. And through that journey, we quickly
- 1:48- realized that
- 1:49- health care deserved more. You know, the typical
- 1:51- insurance based conversations need to become more robust.
- 1:54- We are now seeing clients and patients that
- 1:56- business
- 2:05- owners and
- 2:09- the
- 2:10- business owners and clinic owners to even needing
- 2:12- to evolve. And that evolution requires,
- 2:16- some proper knowledge on how to run a
- 2:18- business, how to run a clinic. It's not
- 2:21- the days of the hospital or the days
- 2:23- of insurance where you could slide a glass
- 2:26- window and slap a clipboard and ask for
- 2:28- someone's insurance, and you can have a subpar
- 2:30- experience.
- 2:31- Today, everyone is dialed into having good patient
- 2:34- care,
- 2:34- and alongside of that, having a good experience.
- 2:37- So my focus now has shifted from being
- 2:39- an owner and operator of 12 clinics once
- 2:41- upon a time
- 2:42- to building a consulting firm and also building
- 2:45- a health care tech company
- 2:46- that focuses on that very pain point. The
- 2:49- pain point of how do we not just
- 2:51- give good quality care, help people feel the
- 2:54- best versions of themselves and live a long
- 2:56- life, but how do we have them enjoy
- 2:59- health care with a good patient experience? And
- 3:01- that's exactly what I focus on today.
- 3:04- And talk about building that. What led you
- 3:07- to build this consulting firm?
- 3:09- How is it going? Tell us about it.
- 3:13- Give us the background on on
- 3:15- what you're doing, and and what are you
- 3:17- loving about it? Sure. Well, Scott, it actually
- 3:19- happened by mistake. I realized that after we
- 3:21- were building those clinics, a lot of other
- 3:24- colleagues around the nation that I would meet
- 3:26- at either speaking events or I would meet
- 3:28- on conferences or I would be learning from,
- 3:30- they would ask me, hey, Sam. What are
- 3:32- you doing that's different that you're having such
- 3:34- great reviews or that your clinics are scaling?
- 3:36- What is it that you're doing differently? And
- 3:38- I said, hey. Listen. We're treating it like
- 3:39- a hospitality,
- 3:41- industry. We're treating it like a hotel. We're
- 3:42- treating it like a five star fine dining
- 3:44- establishment.
- 3:45- We're giving them way more. And so as
- 3:48- advice became more given to other people as
- 3:52- we were giving sort of free consulting, let's
- 3:54- call it, we realized, wow. Well, it seems
- 3:56- like people are honing in on what we're
- 3:58- doing. It seems to be that media is
- 4:01- picking it up. So why don't we actually
- 4:03- do this for a living?
- 4:04- So what was a hobby? What was sort
- 4:07- of a freelance
- 4:08- agency
- 4:09- became an actual full renowned business,
- 4:13- Chicago based consulting firm
- 4:15- that now has become a full time job.
- 4:17- It is now something that we realize is
- 4:19- not just a hobby. It is very much
- 4:21- a need. And so now our mindset has
- 4:24- shifted from, of course, the usual seeing patients'
- 4:27- clinical care that once upon a time was,
- 4:30- now to once upon a time is, which
- 4:32- is helping other clinics
- 4:34- focus in on good quality care, but the
- 4:36- patient experience. We call it the patient life
- 4:38- cycle. The patient life cycle is what's every
- 4:40- step
- 4:41- of the journey that they, of course, encounter
- 4:44- from the moments they find you on a
- 4:45- website or Google
- 4:47- to the moment they call
- 4:48- and ask questions, which the receptionist is one
- 4:51- of the most critical features of this patient
- 4:53- life cycle, to the moment they do a
- 4:55- consultation, to the moment they receive treatment, to
- 4:57- the moment they come back. That whole life
- 4:59- cycle in a nutshell
- 5:00- is what we focus on immensely
- 5:02- in our consulting firm. So now 3,000 practices
- 5:06- later across 15 countries,
- 5:08- multispecialty
- 5:09- when it comes
- 5:11- to internal medicine, to surgeons, to,
- 5:14- you know, of course, physical therapist, to chiropractic,
- 5:16- to dental. Let's just call it health care.
- 5:19- Health care in a nutshell has this life
- 5:21- cycle, but very much so has a compromised
- 5:24- one because they've always focused on quality care,
- 5:26- but not the actual life cycle and the
- 5:28- different touch points, which is exactly what our
- 5:30- consulting firm now does. So what was a
- 5:32- hobby has now become a full time full
- 5:34- fledged consulting firm because we realized that all
- 5:37- health care arenas
- 5:39- are now needing to focus on this very
- 5:41- attribute, which is called the patient life cycle.
- 5:45- Fantastic. And and we're watching in health care
- 5:47- this vast
- 5:49- increase in patient visits, in screenings,
- 5:53- in just need given 350,000,000
- 5:56- people in our country
- 5:57- and only about 900,000
- 5:59- practicing doctors?
- 6:01- How do we solve some of that supply
- 6:04- demand imbalance? Any thoughts there?
- 6:06- You know, this is a very intriguing question.
- 6:08- I think it's a very factual concept that
- 6:10- we need to start discussing more out loud
- 6:12- as what is the future of health care
- 6:13- looking like? And to your point, the volume
- 6:15- is increasing. The knowledge is increasing. People are
- 6:17- not becoming healthier. In fact, they're becoming more
- 6:20- ill. And so the need of just weight
- 6:22- loss, the need of
- 6:24- pain management, the need of just normal care
- 6:27- is combated with not just the high demand,
- 6:31- but also the supply. The physicians are burnt
- 6:34- out. They're tired. Clinics are over
- 6:36- capacitated.
- 6:38- And so I think now it's about,
- 6:40- you know, as we develop health care, how
- 6:42- do we continue to provide good health? But
- 6:45- also, we're starting to see a rise of
- 6:46- cash based clinics. We're seeing a rise of
- 6:48- concierge clinics. People that are kind of going
- 6:51- against the grain. We call them the, you
- 6:52- know, the black sheep or the unicorns of
- 6:54- the industry.
- 6:55- They're saying we need to provide health care
- 6:58- more intimately.
- 6:59- There is a growing rise of people wanting
- 7:01- help, but people have mistrust.
- 7:05- That's also equally rising because now it's becoming
- 7:08- sort of a health kill a health care
- 7:10- mill. People are having to see their provider
- 7:12- for seven minutes, and then they're on to
- 7:14- the next, you know, nurse, and then they're
- 7:16- spat outside the door. And it's very
- 7:19- unfortunate what we're seeing,
- 7:21- but it's a reality. And I think for
- 7:23- that reason, this
- 7:24- health care experience, the touch points, how we
- 7:27- make people feel when they come in to
- 7:29- when we talk to them to when we,
- 7:31- you know, do retention, this patient life cycle
- 7:33- concept,
- 7:34- is now the little inches that we can
- 7:36- improve on because there's a high level of
- 7:38- mistrust. There's a high level of demand.
- 7:41- Care is not being provided as it used
- 7:43- to be. We have good technology on our
- 7:45- side. We have more knowledge on our side,
- 7:47- but we don't have the providers to facilitate
- 7:49- the demand. And as a result,
- 7:51- we are now not focusing on the patient
- 7:53- experience. In fact, we're compromising it. So we
- 7:56- have this sort of convergence or this crossroad
- 7:59- that we're dealing with. People are expecting more.
- 8:02- They have more knowledge. They are coming in
- 8:05- with preconceived ideas of care, and then we
- 8:07- only spend a few minutes with them. So
- 8:09- you can see here that we're both going
- 8:11- in opposite directions,
- 8:12- and this is a problem. And so for
- 8:14- that very much reason,
- 8:15- it's important that all clinics, all physicians, all
- 8:18- health care providers all around the world now
- 8:20- have to figure out how do I meet
- 8:22- the demand of knowledge that patients come in
- 8:25- with? How do I give them a good
- 8:26- experience?
- 8:27- And I give them what they want with
- 8:29- intimacy, but also not burn myself out. And
- 8:31- that's sort of the the problem that we're
- 8:33- all trying to solve. And that's also why
- 8:35- the rise of cash based medicine. What I
- 8:38- say by that is concierge clinics direct primary
- 8:40- clinic. Let's just call it membership based health
- 8:43- care. It's on the rise because people want
- 8:45- that providers, clinicians
- 8:47- want to do that because it's not gonna
- 8:49- burn them out. And now I think if
- 8:51- we fast forward five years from now, there's
- 8:52- gonna be a big demand for concierge based
- 8:55- clinics in the health care arena.
- 8:59- Thank you. And let me ask you a
- 9:00- question about this. One of the common thoughts
- 9:03- is that if we have a,
- 9:06- a a nationalized health system,
- 9:09- that there won't be the need for this
- 9:10- concierge
- 9:11- and so forth care.
- 9:14- But what I tend to see in these
- 9:15- other countries is that
- 9:18- wherever they have nationalized health systems, there seems
- 9:21- to be a percentage of the population
- 9:23- wealthy or politically connected.
- 9:25- They're getting care in some sort of private
- 9:27- clinic, concierge type service in other ways.
- 9:30- Any thoughts on that? What what do you
- 9:32- see out there? Sure. So our biggest portfolio
- 9:35- outside The United States when it comes to
- 9:37- consulting health care practices and is in Canada
- 9:39- and then Europe. And so I think based
- 9:41- off this question, I can certainly kinda tell
- 9:43- you what I see in from a data
- 9:45- perspective is that,
- 9:46- you know, if we are leaning towards sort
- 9:48- of organizing that system, I think, yes, certainly,
- 9:51- maybe the
- 9:52- access to care perhaps may be improved.
- 9:55- Maybe the quality of giving people what they
- 9:58- deserve perhaps, but they debatably
- 10:00- improves. But I do think it creates a
- 10:03- greater divide. I do think that the rise
- 10:06- of, hey, people that can afford because they're
- 10:08- not gonna wait multiple months to be seen.
- 10:11- They're gonna want care today. They have the
- 10:14- means, financial means to get it. So the
- 10:16- demand for those types of clinics, as I
- 10:18- mentioned, concierge or DPC or cash based practice
- 10:21- or membership model clinics will rise. Let's use
- 10:23- Canada as an example. My biggest portfolio outside
- 10:26- The United States is all across Canada.
- 10:28- We consult a little over 500 practices there.
- 10:31- And the biggest challenge that they face is
- 10:33- that to see a specialist,
- 10:34- let's just use a physical therapist or let's
- 10:37- see, say, a psychiatrist,
- 10:39- a huge demand field right now.
- 10:41- It takes at least thirteen to upwards of
- 10:44- eighteen months to schedule a visit with that
- 10:46- specialist.
- 10:47- Now a nationalized health care system certainly may
- 10:49- be okay. Great. I will deal with that
- 10:50- because the government's paying for it. But
- 10:53- do you think that a person of, you
- 10:55- know, wealth or an individual that has the
- 10:57- means will wait? No. They want
- 11:00- for them, it's a loss of opportunity.
- 11:02- They see I'm my job is being impacted.
- 11:05- My family is being impacted. I have the
- 11:06- financial means. Is there a clinic that will
- 11:09- give me access to care now? What does
- 11:11- this ultimately relate to? This means concierge cash
- 11:14- based TPC type style practices
- 11:16- will have a higher likelihood of success.
- 11:19- But that's what I mean by create create
- 11:21- a bigger divide because we see it with
- 11:22- Canada. We see it with Europe. But we
- 11:25- see that it's only gonna create a larger
- 11:27- bottleneck, a larger time frame of specialist,
- 11:31- are being seen by a specialist. And that's
- 11:33- the fear that I have.
- 11:35- And that is really how I view it,
- 11:37- but there's a sort of common misconception
- 11:40- that we have
- 11:41- we we all want coverage for all,
- 11:44- but coverage for all without supply for all
- 11:48- is is quite frankly meaningless. It's a it's
- 11:51- a political platitude.
- 11:53- What are the most interesting issues you're watching
- 11:55- in health care currently, doctor Patel?
- 11:58- So I think that,
- 11:59- when we see
- 12:01- sort of the frustration,
- 12:03- you know, we have a growing population of
- 12:05- educated people. We have a growing population of
- 12:07- individuals
- 12:08- having access to information.
- 12:10- So as a result, people are now becoming
- 12:12- more proactive. That is the good thing that
- 12:14- we're seeing in health care. People are actually
- 12:16- saying, you know what? I can prevent disease.
- 12:18- I can prevent cancer. I can at least
- 12:20- slow down the likelihood of developing chronic diseases.
- 12:23- Let me go see my provider sooner than
- 12:25- later. We are now developing a more proactive
- 12:29- society of health care. It's still, of course,
- 12:31- growing,
- 12:32- but it is moving in that realm. What
- 12:35- does this ultimately mean? This ultimately means that
- 12:38- we now have to supply that demand because
- 12:40- before people were being reacted with their health.
- 12:43- They were only seen when they needed to
- 12:44- be seen. If something was wrong, then they
- 12:46- went to go get it fixed. Now we
- 12:48- see it with other companies. I have no
- 12:51- affiliation with these companies, but they're good examples
- 12:53- for this use case. We have companies such
- 12:55- as PerNuvo,
- 12:56- Full Body MRI. We have companies like Function
- 12:58- Health.
- 12:59- Why do these companies have good amount of
- 13:01- success? Why are they having traction?
- 13:03- Because they supply
- 13:04- knowledge. They give people access to information,
- 13:08- and, hence, they are growing in the likelihood
- 13:10- of how they're growing today. We see that
- 13:12- with
- 13:13- wearables like aura rings and all the different
- 13:16- things that are coming into the horizon. What
- 13:18- this tells us is that the demand is
- 13:20- only going to increase because the access to
- 13:23- information
- 13:24- is now increasing. People are wanting to be
- 13:25- preventative. People don't wanna go through what their
- 13:27- grandparents or their generations ahead of them have
- 13:30- gone through, like diabetes, high cholesterol, heart disease,
- 13:33- depression. We can start to actually prevent a
- 13:36- lot of this.
- 13:37- Hence, the demand is extensively high. That is
- 13:40- creating a large amount of burden and friction
- 13:43- on the health care system.
- 13:45- And for that reason,
- 13:46- I think as exciting as this is because
- 13:49- we see regenerative medicine, preventative medicine, GLP ones,
- 13:52- hormones,
- 13:53- stem cells, NAD, all this stuff is so
- 13:55- popular. It's growing in popularity.
- 13:58- But
- 13:59- to that degree, the devil's advocacy here is
- 14:02- that there are not enough people.
- 14:04- And
- 14:05- the burden is going to be very much
- 14:07- on the health care. I mean, The US
- 14:08- health care system is gonna
- 14:10- deal with a lot of pressure here. And,
- 14:11- of course, now big pharma getting involved. You
- 14:14- know, it's it's interesting what we're gonna see
- 14:16- in the next three to five years, and
- 14:17- I don't I hope that it improves.
- 14:19- What I can be helpful for is that
- 14:21- people are wanting to address their health.
- 14:24- The negative is we don't have enough people
- 14:26- to help them do that, which is what's
- 14:27- gonna be interesting over the next few years.
- 14:30- Thank you. No. I think that's exactly right.
- 14:33- And and and and talk about where you're
- 14:35- most focused and excited this next six months
- 14:38- and going into next year.
- 14:40- So my biggest focus is how do we
- 14:42- deal with this inevitability?
- 14:44- I mean, we can all sit here and
- 14:45- talk, and we could talk for days on
- 14:47- what's actually happening and sort of the let's
- 14:49- just call it the projections of where we
- 14:51- see this going. So instead, just like we're
- 14:54- treating medicine, which is being more proactive, why
- 14:56- don't we be proactive in the patient demand?
- 14:59- And that proactiveness
- 15:00- could be encouraging people to either
- 15:03- go into continuously go into medicine. I mean,
- 15:06- the residency
- 15:07- rates are changing. The med school acceptance and
- 15:10- applications are changing, not for the better. So
- 15:13- what do we do to actually have physicians
- 15:15- motivated again? And that's sort of what intrigues
- 15:17- me the most, and that's what I love
- 15:19- what I do with our consulting firm. We
- 15:21- figure out how to give the tools
- 15:23- for this demand, whether it's how do you
- 15:25- hire people? How do we increase the bandwidth
- 15:29- of the amount of patient rooms you have?
- 15:31- How do we bring in these preventative treatment
- 15:34- services like weight loss, like hormones, like regenerative
- 15:37- medicine? How do we now have a good
- 15:39- balance? We see dentists doing this. They're bringing
- 15:42- in wellness services. We see chiropractors bring in
- 15:45- wellness services. We see internal medicine that are
- 15:47- entirely Medicare or Medicaid clinics traditionally,
- 15:50- bringing in regenerative services that are cash based.
- 15:53- So I think it's how do we use
- 15:55- the amazing providers out there and help them
- 15:59- be taught on how to meet this demand
- 16:02- and inspire them to develop, or I should
- 16:04- say, evolve their clinical setting
- 16:07- to accommodate to this proactive mindset.
- 16:10- That I feel is happening now. I know
- 16:12- that because those are the clients that I
- 16:13- deal with every day, and I think that
- 16:15- that demand is gonna increase. People are burnt
- 16:17- out by the health care system.
- 16:19- They're tired. I have internal medicine physicians seeing
- 16:22- 60 patients a day, but they love what
- 16:24- they do. They love medicine. They don't love
- 16:26- the politics behind it. The reimbursement drops,
- 16:28- decline, reimbursement rates declining.
- 16:31- So they are now the ones that are
- 16:32- creating a hybrid model. Hey. I'm gonna continue
- 16:35- to do my medicine,
- 16:37- but I wanna have a proactive health
- 16:39- care adjunct
- 16:40- built to my business. I want a department
- 16:42- that does wellness, that does preventative, that does
- 16:44- pain management.
- 16:45- And I think that is gonna be the
- 16:47- future of how we balance both. It's not
- 16:49- burning out and retiring our physicians.
- 16:51- It's giving them the ability to have balance
- 16:54- to meet this demand. And that's sort of
- 16:56- what excites me because I am able to
- 16:58- help them do that, create that business model,
- 17:00- do the training behind that. And so I'm
- 17:02- excited because I think that the the demand
- 17:04- is increasing.
- 17:05- It's not about how do we get more
- 17:07- doctors trained. It's about how do we help
- 17:09- the current doctors
- 17:11- love what they do and
- 17:13- mold around this inevitable evolution that we're saying
- 17:16- rather than resist against it.
- 17:18- And let me ask you this question. I
- 17:19- think the latest number I saw was that
- 17:21- one to 2% of doctors are working concierge
- 17:26- and generally in primary care. But in our
- 17:29- area of the Greater Chicago area, there's a
- 17:31- cardiology practice that charges an access fee. There's
- 17:34- a dermatology practice that charges an access fee,
- 17:37- sort of concierge light, but but a type
- 17:40- of concierge.
- 17:42- From primary care doctors' perspective,
- 17:44- they've moved from
- 17:46- grinding away patients 30 and a 30 a
- 17:48- day to whatever
- 17:50- to now doing similar things, but having 200
- 17:53- patients that pay them a few thousand dollars
- 17:55- a year.
- 17:56- And this is a complete change in their
- 17:57- business model and quite frankly gives them a
- 17:59- lot more freedom and flexibility and probably a
- 18:02- better way to practice.
- 18:03- Are we gonna see is there at some
- 18:06- point
- 18:06- where you're gonna see an acceleration
- 18:09- towards people doing concierge
- 18:11- just because
- 18:12- it it just seems like an easier, better
- 18:14- way to make a living and run a
- 18:16- practice as a physician
- 18:18- than
- 18:19- having to schedule
- 18:20- hundreds and hundreds of patients and and seeing
- 18:22- hundreds of 100 patients and then having to
- 18:24- deal with the insurance companies. I mean, you're
- 18:26- still dealing with the insurance companies, but you're
- 18:27- getting a base that seems to be better
- 18:30- than what you were making from your insurance
- 18:31- companies before. So now you're doubling your income.
- 18:33- What what is the
- 18:36- are we gonna see more and more of
- 18:37- it?
- 18:38- I do believe so. Because over the last
- 18:40- eighteen months, the highest amount of clients that
- 18:43- we have coming to us are people that
- 18:44- are in current traditional insurance based practice.
- 18:47- And they aren't jumping to the deep end,
- 18:50- meaning they're not going straight into
- 18:52- leaving that world and going into concierge medicine.
- 18:54- I kind of kind of call it the
- 18:55- hybrid model. The hybrid model is their business
- 18:58- or their practice or their clinic has the
- 19:00- insurance model. Maybe they hired nurse practitioner, mid
- 19:03- level, or someone depending on their state regulation,
- 19:06- someone that can run that side and see
- 19:08- the high demand patients. And the physician who's
- 19:10- tired and burnt out kind of goes between
- 19:13- both worlds. They cut their patient load in
- 19:15- half on the insurance side, and then they
- 19:16- follow their passion on the cash based side
- 19:18- or the concierge side. That's what as a
- 19:20- hybrid, they're doing both. They have both different
- 19:23- practices running at the same time. Maybe it's
- 19:25- one different roof or rather one roof and
- 19:27- it's different sort of personality or two different
- 19:29- business models. But I do think to your
- 19:31- point, reimbursement rates are declining. There is nothing
- 19:35- to debate around that. We're seeing it year
- 19:36- after year, and that is having
- 19:39- that means that if someone that's in their
- 19:41- mid or maybe their peak of their career,
- 19:43- they're in their fifties, they're going into their
- 19:45- sixties or doing very well financially,
- 19:48- they're having to see
- 19:49- 30%
- 19:51- more patients just to maintain the same level
- 19:53- of financial income, not just financial income for
- 19:56- themselves, but operational costs for the business. Billers,
- 19:59- nurses,
- 20:00- all of the different team members we have
- 20:02- to have, all the technology we have to
- 20:04- invest in. Those costs are rising.
- 20:07- People are demanding more pay. Finding good quality
- 20:10- people in today's workforce is near impossible.
- 20:13- So that means we have to pay them
- 20:14- more. And on top of that, reimbursements are
- 20:16- declining. That's a recipe
- 20:18- for frustration.
- 20:19- So for that reason, there's only so much
- 20:22- a clinician or a physician is gonna take
- 20:24- to where they then see their colleague down
- 20:26- the road or in another city or someone
- 20:27- that their respect
- 20:29- convert over to the concierge model, and they
- 20:31- have their life back. They don't have to
- 20:33- deal with the inconsistency
- 20:35- or in, unpredictability,
- 20:37- which is exactly what is causing this demand.
- 20:40- Insurance agents,
- 20:41- reimbursements,
- 20:42- all of these are unpredictable.
- 20:45- And scaling a business with an unpredictable landscape
- 20:48- of income
- 20:49- is not gonna be
- 20:50- anything that's exciting for somebody.
- 20:52- Where if it's a membership model and to
- 20:54- your point,
- 20:55- you have a standard income that's coming in.
- 20:57- It's predictable. You have your members.
- 20:59- Then that provides stability. And what the aging
- 21:02- physician or physician that's getting into the later
- 21:05- stages of their career,
- 21:07- they want predictability.
- 21:08- They want stability.
- 21:10- They do not want what's currently happening, which
- 21:12- is unpredictability,
- 21:13- which is what reimbursements are. So you can
- 21:15- kinda see now why this is a recipe
- 21:17- for the convergence or rise
- 21:20- of concierge style medicine.
- 21:23- Thank you. And where do you see artificial
- 21:26- intelligence
- 21:27- evolving into all this? We're still very much
- 21:30- in a person to person business.
- 21:32- Where does AI help? Where does that become
- 21:34- part of the solution in technology?
- 21:36- Yeah. That's a great question. I think AI
- 21:38- sort of has two ways of looking at
- 21:41- it. There's operational
- 21:42- advantages, and then there's clinical advantages.
- 21:45- I think the clinical advantages is where a
- 21:47- lot of the debate, I should say, or
- 21:50- the,
- 21:50- you know, a lot of the discussions are
- 21:52- around. Should AI be
- 21:54- conducting clinical diagnostic care? Should it be creating
- 21:57- treatment plans? There's a lot of debate there.
- 22:00- So let's focus our attention on the operational
- 22:02- side because that one has a lot more,
- 22:05- at least, confidence behind it. There's not so
- 22:07- much debate. So the efficiency or operation side
- 22:10- of it is
- 22:11- AI helping with doing a lot of the
- 22:13- billing, helping with analyzing notes, or rewriting
- 22:17- a note, making it more efficient, doing the
- 22:19- dictation
- 22:20- because once again saving time. It could even
- 22:23- do a lot of the front desk receptionist
- 22:25- work, having to answer calls. Some of the
- 22:27- things I've heard now with AI agents, it
- 22:30- sounds so realistic. You would never know that
- 22:32- it's not an actual human booking appointments,
- 22:35- following up with patients, checking in on them,
- 22:37- doing patient reminders, scheduling reminders, appointment reminders.
- 22:41- These
- 22:41- efficiencies
- 22:42- now don't require us to have to have
- 22:45- them doing man doing being done manually by
- 22:47- a human. So I think AI in the
- 22:49- health care arena will make physicians
- 22:52- and businesses and practices and clinics more efficient.
- 22:56- It's gonna allow them to be saving hours
- 22:59- and hours a day, whereas typically, a lot
- 23:01- of that work was manual. On the clinical
- 23:03- side, as I mentioned, two sides of this,
- 23:05- I think there's a lot to be developed
- 23:07- there. We're seeing it with radiology. It's still
- 23:09- in the works. We're seeing it with, you
- 23:11- know, other countries, like, certain countries in Asia
- 23:14- are already vetting this model of seeing, can
- 23:16- we have AI doctors? I think we have
- 23:18- a ways to come around that. I do
- 23:20- think it helps us
- 23:22- in many ways. I don't think that the
- 23:24- world is ready for an AI doctor. I
- 23:26- do think that the world is seeing benefit
- 23:29- from AI operations management of clinics, making it
- 23:33- more efficient, giving us data, showing us how
- 23:35- we can improve our room rates, our room
- 23:38- to time ratio.
- 23:39- Yes. I think AI is brilliant there, and
- 23:41- that's where I do think that is gonna
- 23:43- be the success of AI, at least in
- 23:45- the immediate future until the world is ready
- 23:48- for AI to be involved in health care
- 23:49- management, which who knows when that time will
- 23:51- come.
- 23:52- And then in terms of health care management,
- 23:55- it seems that we're likely to be for
- 23:57- a very long time
- 23:59- in this very combined world of technology
- 24:01- and human in the loop. Like, even with
- 24:04- radiology where AI is so pervasive,
- 24:08- you absolutely have radiologists
- 24:09- reviewing
- 24:10- screenings, any AI results, and everything else. And
- 24:13- maybe it's helping them get there a little
- 24:15- quicker, a little bit better, but you still
- 24:17- we still have a shortage of radiologists.
- 24:20- Do you see this mix of human talent
- 24:22- with technology talent
- 24:24- being a long term pathway?
- 24:27- I I hope so. My fear is that
- 24:30- it's creating a lot of, worry amongst these
- 24:33- sort of specialty providers. As you mentioned, radiologists,
- 24:36- I know a lot of them. And what
- 24:37- I've noticed with them is that they're starting
- 24:39- to plan for the next five years. And
- 24:40- I asked them, I'm like, hey. Why are
- 24:42- you building a wellness practice? Or why are
- 24:44- you doing, you know,
- 24:46- injury,
- 24:47- and and and sort of legal work now?
- 24:49- It's because they're scared that they're gonna get
- 24:51- replaced.
- 24:52- Now I think that that's that's the fear
- 24:54- I have is, are is there gonna be
- 24:56- a beautiful harmony between the two? And then
- 24:58- on a global scale, or I should say
- 24:59- a more higher upscale, our hospital systems are
- 25:02- more corporatized health care systems
- 25:04- gonna say, hey. Well, this is cheaper. Because
- 25:07- at the end of the day, yes, we
- 25:08- wanna provide quality care. But from sort of
- 25:10- their standpoint, the corporate level or the health
- 25:12- health big big health care system, it's all
- 25:14- about dollars.
- 25:16- And how do we balance both?
- 25:18- And so if it's good enough, then, yeah,
- 25:20- my fear is that they'll become obsolete.
- 25:23- And I don't know if that's gonna happen
- 25:25- soon. I do think that that is the
- 25:26- fear. I see that right now. I see
- 25:29- that specifically in radiologist worlds.
- 25:31- I see that they're fearful of being replaced.
- 25:34- Now, yes, the very specialized, like, neuroradiologist
- 25:37- or the very specialized yeah. That's gonna take
- 25:39- some time. But to your point, I do
- 25:41- think that there is a fear of the
- 25:43- need of them
- 25:44- not being,
- 25:45- needed is gonna be there. But, also, I
- 25:47- think that's also why AI is on the
- 25:49- rise.
- 25:50- I think that the health care system's smart.
- 25:52- I think the developers of these platforms
- 25:55- are seeing that there's not as many specialists
- 25:57- coming into the workforce. Not as many people
- 25:59- are going into school residency.
- 26:02- So they are trying to proactively figure out
- 26:04- what to do. And the cheapest and most
- 26:07- predictable way is to create an AI that
- 26:09- replaces that person.
- 26:10- So I think they're gonna Talk about that
- 26:12- for a second. Yeah. Because one of the
- 26:13- great problems, you've almost got this vicious cycle.
- 26:16- We don't have nearly enough specialists.
- 26:19- We already saw this in primary care.
- 26:22- We're we're almost past the era of everybody
- 26:24- having their own primary care physician,
- 26:26- and by necessity and and the numbers can't
- 26:29- catch up to themselves. We're getting ten, fifteen
- 26:31- thousand primary care doctors a year, ten, fifteen
- 26:33- thousand are retiring a year. We've got this
- 26:35- growing population.
- 26:37- And so by necessity, so much of primary
- 26:39- care has moved to technologies,
- 26:41- nurse practitioners,
- 26:43- PAs, and so forth. And not that we
- 26:45- don't love our own primary care doctor. I've
- 26:47- got one, but I don't know what I'm
- 26:48- gonna do when he retires.
- 26:49- But by necessity, we've changed the model.
- 26:52- Is that what's gonna happen by specialists by
- 26:54- necessity, not because it's better health care.
- 26:57- I mean, there's obviously parts of it, but
- 26:59- we're just gonna be so short specialists. Like,
- 27:01- on oncology, there's 27,000
- 27:03- oncologists in this country,
- 27:04- 2,000,000 dot new diagnosis a year. Every oncologist
- 27:08- I talk to is overwhelmed,
- 27:10- exhausted, and information overloaded.
- 27:13- Is there no way around the fact that
- 27:14- we're gonna end up with so much care
- 27:16- provided in other ways because there's just not
- 27:17- enough doctors? So systems have to find ways
- 27:20- around it.
- 27:21- I do. I do think that we're gonna
- 27:23- see a lot of creative ways. I think,
- 27:25- as I mentioned earlier, we're already seeing that
- 27:26- now. We see a lot of these private
- 27:28- entities, like, with big health care leaders, big
- 27:31- doctors with big names,
- 27:32- creating other ways of getting labs done, of
- 27:35- getting blood work done, precancer screening done, getting
- 27:37- a full body MRI done. And I think
- 27:40- that that's sort of the next outlet because
- 27:43- politically and with big health care systems,
- 27:46- we don't know what's gonna happen. We don't
- 27:48- know what the agenda is. We don't know
- 27:49- where that's heading. We can
- 27:51- stereotypically say or traditionally, by history, it shows
- 27:55- that it's not going in the right direction.
- 27:57- And so based off of that, I mean,
- 27:58- yes, the specialties
- 28:00- are gonna be more scarce. As you mentioned,
- 28:02- we have the highest
- 28:03- population of retirees in the health care arena,
- 28:06- our baby boomers. We have the biggest population
- 28:09- of experts that are retiring right now, and
- 28:11- we're not having the influx.
- 28:12- So that is gonna be either people going
- 28:15- into medical tourism. We see that now. People
- 28:17- are going overseas to be seen by a
- 28:19- specialist, whether it's to,
- 28:20- an adjacent country, whether it's overseas. I see
- 28:22- that right now. People are going to get
- 28:24- their LASIK surgery over in Europe because not
- 28:27- only is it cheaper, they can be seen
- 28:29- right away.
- 28:30- So I think that
- 28:32- we're gonna see a lot of,
- 28:34- fatigue and a lot of reliance or dependency
- 28:37- on other avenues, whether it's privatized care, whether
- 28:40- it's these private equity firms investing immense amounts
- 28:44- of money to create private health care, like,
- 28:46- systems. You see the Amazons in the world
- 28:49- creating one medical or whatever that is. There's
- 28:52- a lot of different big, big, big groups
- 28:54- that are saying, well, hey. Why don't we
- 28:55- just do this ourselves? Telehealth
- 28:58- is back on the rise. We saw it
- 29:00- be essentially created during COVID, and now it
- 29:03- kinda it took a dip after COVID, and
- 29:05- now it's back up because once again, it's
- 29:07- easy to access. It's cheap. It's super simple.
- 29:09- It's convenient, and there's a mid level on
- 29:11- the other end that can execute at a
- 29:12- high level.
- 29:13- So, yes, I do think that the specialty
- 29:16- is gonna be an issue. Overseas market is
- 29:19- gonna rise. That's why you see The Middle
- 29:20- East and Dubai and The UAE
- 29:22- putting a lot of infrastructure
- 29:24- with specialty cares because they're gonna attract people
- 29:26- from The US who have money. And so
- 29:28- I do think that we're gonna see a
- 29:29- very interesting evolution,
- 29:31- and
- 29:32- the hospital systems are gonna struggle. I think
- 29:36- the hospital it's all we're already seeing that.
- 29:38- I mean, we have one neurosurgeon
- 29:40- in a 25 mile radius.
- 29:42- How is that one neurosurgeon gonna do neurosurgery
- 29:45- for a population size of, you know, half
- 29:47- a million people? It's not gonna happen. And
- 29:49- so disaster. I mean, it's really just asking.
- 29:51- We see it in neurology too where there's
- 29:52- this Yep.
- 29:53- Aging, dementia, Alzheimer's population,
- 29:56- and there's just there's one neurologist for 500,000
- 29:58- people. We see it in North Minnesota with
- 30:00- the dermatologist,
- 30:01- one dermatologist
- 30:02- in a population with lots of skin cancer
- 30:04- for five hundred thousand people. These numbers are
- 30:06- just getting daunting, and so we're gonna try
- 30:08- our best to use technology which is to
- 30:10- build them. It seems like there's zero political
- 30:12- will.
- 30:13- And, also, the specialty societies are very concerned
- 30:15- about increasing the number of residents if not
- 30:17- in their specialties
- 30:18- if they're needed because they worry about in
- 30:20- the long term
- 30:22- there being surpluses. But but what you're gonna
- 30:24- end up with is
- 30:25- all kinds of physicians getting run out of
- 30:27- business, so it's just not enough for them
- 30:29- for us to rely on them. I mean,
- 30:30- it's really sort of a debacle.
- 30:32- The the the telehealth thing is fast because
- 30:34- I've I've watched this with the GLP one
- 30:36- thing. It's only 30,000,000
- 30:38- plus people a year on GLP ones now.
- 30:40- Most of them are getting them through telehealth.
- 30:42- It used to be they're getting through hospitals
- 30:44- and health systems, they're getting through doctors' offices.
- 30:46- Now that entire stream has moved away from
- 30:49- that
- 30:50- with great benefit, it's
- 30:52- stopped sort of clogging up the hospital systems
- 30:54- and the primary care offices,
- 30:57- and the prices have gone down significantly. I
- 30:59- mean, it's sort of a fascinating evolution.
- 31:01- You know, there are more opportunities like that
- 31:03- in health care to try and solve the
- 31:06- the demand supply imbalance.
- 31:09- Yes. I mean, we see GLP ones themselves
- 31:10- have evolved over the last three, four years.
- 31:13- You know, you had semaglutide, then you had
- 31:14- trezepatide, and then you have RETA that's coming
- 31:16- out now and getting popularity.
- 31:18- So I think the medications and the the
- 31:20- technology behind pharma is gonna continue to increase.
- 31:23- As a result,
- 31:24- people are gonna want it. You know, there's
- 31:26- gonna be other things that solve other big
- 31:28- chronic problems. Weight, of course, is our number
- 31:30- one,
- 31:31- consideration, and I think the mental health arena
- 31:34- is starting to get a lot of attention.
- 31:35- Is there other alternatives? You see ketamine on
- 31:38- the rise. You see TMS, transcranial magnetic stimulation,
- 31:41- back on the rise. You see these other
- 31:43- alternatives
- 31:44- because to your to your point, I mean,
- 31:46- what is the other traditional way is you
- 31:48- get to see a traditional physician, you have
- 31:49- to wait months to see a specialist. And
- 31:51- by then, whether you qualify with a, you
- 31:53- know, CBT or ICD 10 code, then you
- 31:56- may get therapy. Whereas now, it's I can
- 31:58- access something quickly online virtually have it mailed
- 32:01- to my house.
- 32:02- I have worries about these things as well.
- 32:04- Is that how what's the limitation here? You
- 32:07- know, medicine has always been an intimate process.
- 32:10- We we do a physical, we see the
- 32:12- patient, We have a conversation with them. We
- 32:14- we analyze
- 32:15- their different data points, whether it's weight, whether
- 32:18- it's body composition, muscle composition, whether it's a
- 32:20- lab workup, vital signs.
- 32:23- And when we kind of turn into this
- 32:24- dependent model of online care, although, yes, it
- 32:27- gives us better access. It allows people to
- 32:29- have better quick care.
- 32:31- It's cheaper as we mentioned. It's more affordable.
- 32:34- What is the long term ramification that we
- 32:36- may see is
- 32:38- the side effects.
- 32:39- What is is this sort of the style
- 32:41- in which new medicine's gonna be? You don't
- 32:43- see a human anymore. Is it gonna be
- 32:45- robotic now? What about all the physicals and
- 32:47- other different things, other traditional when you go
- 32:50- back twenty years ago, your physician did a
- 32:52- full physical on you. They would check a
- 32:54- spot or a skin cancer that could be
- 32:57- a concern, and then they would I biopsy
- 32:59- it right in the office. They would send
- 33:00- it off. You would other you would get
- 33:02- other things analyzed. But if I'm a weight
- 33:04- loss patient, well, that weight loss patient, most
- 33:07- likely, statistically has other things going on, whether
- 33:11- it's joint degenerative disease, whether it's back pain,
- 33:14- whether it's,
- 33:15- hormone deficits.
- 33:16- But those conversations are no longer happening through
- 33:19- an online telehealth system just to get quick
- 33:21- GLP ones. That's my long term fear of
- 33:24- the online dependency that we are creating. Is
- 33:27- is it gonna turn medicine into a transactional
- 33:30- one, which it is? Or is it gonna
- 33:32- turn medicine into a more intimate one because
- 33:34- they have easy access virtually?
- 33:36- I think there's a debate for both realms.
- 33:38- And my fear is that it turns into
- 33:40- the transactional one, and we start losing medicine
- 33:43- as a whole, which is that intimacy that
- 33:45- we know from ten, twenty years ago, which
- 33:47- is analyzing your entire health, not through a
- 33:49- telehealth visit. And many of them are not
- 33:50- even telehealth. You're just texting, which is absolutely
- 33:52- obscene.
- 33:54- So although it's great for access and we
- 33:56- see the access with GOP ones,
- 33:58- where is the limitation gonna be? Where are
- 34:00- we gonna draw the line? And when does
- 34:02- it become a problem? And I think that
- 34:05- that question will be answered soon enough.
- 34:07- No. I think that's right on. I I
- 34:09- see it with my parents who are aging.
- 34:12- When they do a telehealth visit,
- 34:14- so much is lost
- 34:16- compared to doing an in person visit. Just
- 34:18- so much is lost. There's a really seeing
- 34:20- the whole patient or seeing what's going on
- 34:21- with the whole patient. You know, one time
- 34:23- we had to take my mom to the
- 34:24- emergency room to tell her the visit just
- 34:25- completely missed what was really going on with
- 34:27- my mother and just see so much of
- 34:28- that. That's anecdotal, but I think a lot
- 34:30- of things translate to lots of other people.
- 34:32- And I and I do think the same
- 34:33- concern with the GLP ones,
- 34:35- a person prescribes,
- 34:36- you don't know if you're really any real
- 34:38- doctor looking over it or not. Right. And
- 34:40- for ninety percent of people, that might be
- 34:42- fine.
- 34:43- For ten percent of people, they might be
- 34:45- avoiding what might be a real issue someplace
- 34:47- else. I think there's just a lot of
- 34:49- that. Absolutely.
- 34:50- The lifestyle modification, I mean, we can do
- 34:52- a quick fix or something. But what what
- 34:54- if that weight loss is, you know, emotional
- 34:57- and consideration? What if it's depression that's causing
- 35:00- it? What if it's a thyroid problem? What
- 35:01- if it's a there's so many there's a
- 35:03- laundry list as we know. And so it's
- 35:05- a band aid. Are we influencing this quick
- 35:08- fix band aid behavior?
- 35:10- And, you know or are we practicing good
- 35:12- root cause medicine? Which is why, once again,
- 35:14- going back to our earlier point, concierge medicine
- 35:16- kind
- 35:17- of basically
- 35:18- disrupts that concept. It says, hey. No. We're
- 35:20- gonna actually talk about your whole body. We're
- 35:22- gonna actually go through every ounce of aspect
- 35:26- of your blood in terms of the different
- 35:28- markers, the different,
- 35:30- you know, levels of hormones you have, the
- 35:32- different different electrolyte, everything. It's a full panel
- 35:35- of blood, and it tells us the whole
- 35:36- story, which is not that's why I that's
- 35:38- why I mentioned we're gonna see a massive
- 35:40- divide, a divide of access to care being
- 35:42- very easy, cheap, and affordable,
- 35:45- and
- 35:46- in many cases,
- 35:47- debatably negligent.
- 35:48- And then on the other spectrum, you have
- 35:50- amazing care, but it costs a lot of
- 35:52- money. So there's gonna be a economical,
- 35:55- division between, you know, people that have the
- 35:58- access financially versus the people who don't.
- 36:00- No. I think that's right on.
- 36:03- I I I wanna thank you, doctor Patel,
- 36:04- for joining us. What a great conversation. What
- 36:06- a brilliant mind. Thank you so much for
- 36:08- joining us today on the Bechsus Healthcare podcast.
- 36:10- A total pleasure to visit with you. Thank
- 36:11- you very much. The time. Pleasure meeting you.
- 36:13- Thank you. Thank you.