Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / EV Reliability and Safety: A Global Comparison
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. This is where we take the source
- 0:12materials. You send us all the articles,
- 0:14the research, the tech reports, and we sharpen our analysis to
- 0:18give you what you absolutely need to know without the
- 0:20overload. And today we are diving deep
- 0:23into the electric vehicle revolution.
- 0:25It's a transition that I think everyone agrees is happening,
- 0:29but the reality on the ground, especially when you look at
- 0:31vehicle reliability. It's it's.
- 0:34Causing some serious. Whiplash the.
- 0:36Reports you sent us paint a completely contradictory
- 0:38picture. Exactly.
- 0:40Our listeners curious about the future, of course, but they're
- 0:42focused on what's a painful and frankly a very confusing
- 0:46present. So our mission today is to try
- 0:48and reconcile these two wildly opposing views on EV
- 0:52dependability. And in doing that, maybe we can
- 0:54get a handle on the true state of the global EV market.
- 0:58Right. How can 2 equally reputable
- 1:00organizations look at pretty similar data and come away with
- 1:03conclusions that are just polar opposites?
- 1:06That's. The core of it isn't it.
- 1:08On one side you have consumer levels or CR.
- 1:11In the US, their data finds that EVs and plug in hybrids PHE VS
- 1:16have 80% more issues than conventional gas cars. 80% that
- 1:20sounds, I mean it sounds like a disaster.
- 1:22It does, but then you flip over to the data from Germany, ADAC,
- 1:25which is the largest roadside assistance service in the
- 1:28country. Huge.
- 1:30Huge They analyzed millions of breakdowns and found the
- 1:33complete opposite. They found that EVs have
- 1:35significantly fewer issues. For models from 2020 to 2022,
- 1:40they're logging what, 4.2 breakdowns per thousand EVs?
- 1:44Compared to 10.4 for internal combustion engines.
- 1:47That's more than double the failure rate for a gas.
- 1:49Car the difference is staggering.
- 1:51Analysts book like. Jake Fisher and Steven E like
- 2:07looked at their data. They create these EV issues as
- 2:11growing pains. What do they actually mean by
- 2:13that? They mean that reliability
- 2:15issues almost always pop up when an automaker introduces a brand
- 2:19new platform. For really.
- 2:20Aggressively designed. You're moving away from a a
- 2:24fully amortized ICE engine that they've been perfecting for
- 2:27decades. Right, something they know
- 2:28inside now. Exactly.
- 2:30Can you switch to a new, a ton of new variables that just
- 2:37haven't been protested for five or ten years?
- 2:39That initial friction, those design kinks, that's what CR was
- 2:43capturing. That makes a lot of sense,
- 2:45especially when you look at this specific group that did the
- 2:48worst in their study. You mentioned that the absolute
- 2:50lowest score went to plug in hybrids, the PHEVS.
- 2:53Oh, they were the worst offenders, I mean.
- 2:56A huge margin. A huge.
- 3:07If the gap is that dramatic, chemical simplicity.
- 3:19A PHUV is a bridge, it's for drivers who you need electric
- 3:24range here shortly commute who wants the security of a gas
- 3:27engine for a long trip and your charging is unreliable.
- 3:30The best of both worlds in theory.
- 3:31In theory, for mechanical fluids and Pistons and gearbox of an
- 3:38ICE vehicle, you're adding an entire high voltage battery
- 3:42system, the special chair drains and all the complex.
- 3:45Where to manage the handover between the two?
- 3:47So you double the complexity, you more than double the failure
- 3:50points. That's the new tech teething
- 3:53this CR data is seeing. Precisely.
- 3:55Now you. Contrast that.
- 3:56With what the ADAC data in Germany is capturing, they look
- 3:57a very clear mechanical advantage.
- 4:00The argument is just. So simple.
- 4:08Fewer moving parts means less can go wrong.
- 4:10No engine, no transmission, no oil systems, no exhaust.
- 4:13OK. That is, sheer reduction in
- 4:19mechanical complexity translates directly into dependability.
- 4:23So we. Synthesize this.
- 4:25The key take away is that the contradiction isn't really CR is
- 4:28capturing. The pain of recent second Gen.
- 4:35AV designs and these overly complex PHUVS while ADZ is
- 4:39showing us the long term reliability that kicks in once
- 4:41those initial kinks get looked down.
- 4:43OK, that. Gives us the context we need.
- 4:45Let's drill down now into some specific faults, because some
- 4:48problems seem to pop up no matter the powertrain.
- 4:51And the biggest irony here is it's in the most.
- 4:54Humble component in the car. We have to talk about the 12.
- 5:15And 45% of IC tell outs. So why can't the massive battery
- 5:19just take over if the little one dies?
- 5:21That seems like such an obvious, but the 12.
- 5:29Volt system is essential for the let's call it the initial boot
- 5:33sequence. It powers the low voltage
- 5:36computers in the relays that literally tell the massive
- 5:38battery pack it's safe to turn on.
- 5:41If that little 12 Volt battery is dead, the car can't wait up.
- 5:45It doesn't matter how much charge you have in the main
- 5:47pack. The weakest link.
- 5:49That is a potent irony. A century of innovation and
- 5:52we're still stalled by the same $100 part.
- 5:55So beyond the 12 Volt, what other EV specific issues?
- 5:59With your members reporting. Well, looking at the new
- 6:01architecture, people reporting the process of just putting
- 6:17these cards together. Efficiently is still in the
- 6:19sharing. And there was also a slight
- 6:21mechanical issue that the direct result of the EV architecture
- 6:24wasn't there. Tired.
- 6:26Yes, it's the ADC. It showed EVs had about 45 or
- 6:29two things. One, the extra weight from those
- 6:36heavy battery packs and two, the incredible instant points that
- 6:40EVs deliver. They just.
- 6:42Ran in. The rubber it was immense.
- 6:43Stressor makers and engineers are adapting.
- 6:50OK, before we move on to the geopolitical race, let's just
- 6:53quickly revisit the hybrid success story.
- 6:55We slam PHEVS for being too complex, but CR found standard
- 6:59non plug in hybrids are a. Huge win.
- 7:11Two decades to perfect that system refinement in the.
- 7:19CR Brand Reliability Scorecard The brand's known for globe
- 7:23steady interest have improvement they.
- 7:34Actually made the top 10 for the first time. 10 place, right,
- 7:3710th place, which is known as trivial.
- 7:39Senior analysts said it's because of improved build
- 7:42quality and reliability in their established models, the updated
- 7:45Model 3 and Model Y. The brand is starting to escape
- 7:48that old reputation. The Model Y, despite all that
- 7:53history, was ranked as the most reliable EV in its segment.
- 7:58Huge endorsement for maturation. It is, but let's look at the
- 8:01flip side, which is the Rivian paradox.
- 8:03This is fascinating. The Rivian R1T ranked lowest in
- 8:06the EV segment for reliability. OK, lowest.
- 8:09Yet Rivian scored. Highest on owner satisfaction.
- 8:12Wait, wait. The performance, the image of
- 8:29the phone information manufacturing clause of that
- 8:38panel, Yeah, because the overall experience is so exceeding the
- 8:43advantage. That's not, you know, your
- 8:45typical mass market consumer yet.
- 8:47That really helps put the data into perspective.
- 8:50OK, so knowing these technical weaknesses and the immense
- 8:53pressure to fix them, because this is where it gets really
- 8:57interesting, we need to look at the global wave for EV
- 9:00dominance. Yes, specifically the intense
- 9:03pressure. Europe is facing from China.
- 9:05The competitive challenge seems enormous.
- 9:08The sources we looked at suggest that despite Europe investing,
- 9:11what, €250 billion? A massive number still consider.
- 9:15Years behind China in the EV race.
- 9:17Why is that happening? You have the engineering slower
- 9:20more. Delivery transition to protect
- 9:30the big traditional automakers, and many of them still rely on
- 9:34their highly profitable ACE Protection lines for their cash
- 9:38flow. They need the transition to be
- 9:40gradual to maximize those legacy profits.
- 9:43So they're prioritizing a smooth idle transition over a rapid and
- 9:49revolutionary 1. Exactly, and the sources are
- 9:51very critical of this. Many European legacy makers were
- 9:54too slow to develop dedicated EV platforms and instead they opted
- 9:58to shield form. Electric power systems into
- 10:01existing. Ice.
- 10:02Platforms. Can you explain what shoehorning
- 10:04means in this context and why it's so bad?
- 10:06When you shoehorn, you're cramming a new system into a
- 10:09structure that was designed for a combustion engine.
- 10:11This compromises everything. You get more battery packaging
- 10:14because the hole wasn't designed to be clapped, which means
- 10:16strange. You get more management and
- 10:19you're often carrying extra structural way that you just
- 10:21don't need. If the design compromises,
- 10:23sacrifices efficiency just to get the market faster.
- 10:29They started with a clean sheet of paper and their.
- 10:35Primary strength now is vertical integration.
- 10:40Full vertical integration. They don't just control the
- 10:42problem, they control the. Refining.
- 10:45The production of hard electronics, anatomy,
- 10:47chemistries that is end to end control gives them unmatched
- 10:51speed, flexibility and most importantly price control.
- 10:54And that price disparity is staggering.
- 10:57We saw examples of major European brands filling their
- 11:00EVs so much less in China. Look at the BWID .3 and ID. .4
- 11:06In China with subsidies you could get one for around twenty
- 11:08$25,000. In Europe, a similar spec was
- 11:12closer to €45,000. Nearly double that kind of
- 11:16pressure. From cheaper Chinese rivals
- 11:17threatens the entire profitability model from there's
- 11:20a big technology. You're made.
- 11:32Too, Either China is a technology university or is it a
- 11:34bit more nuanced than that? Oh, it's definitely complex.
- 11:38Some sources claim Chinese, pointing out that high end
- 11:41models often include advanced Premier like Lidar as a
- 11:44standard. They do premium European brands,
- 11:51especially your. BMWs.
- 11:52Porsches. Mercedes they argue your latest
- 11:55models are superior in areas that are critical to the driver,
- 11:59like overall efficiency and real world range.
- 12:02So the trade off in advanced code, world versus refinement
- 12:05and established. Quality.
- 12:06Precisely. And we should also recognize the
- 12:09brands that are succeeding quietly outside of this big
- 12:12Europe, China conflict, Korean brands like Hyundai and Kia and
- 12:16certain European models. Like they know that they have
- 12:19500 E and two. To 4000 vehicles, right?
- 12:25Incredibly low numbers and they pack it up with strong
- 12:27warranties, typically eight years or 160,000 kilometers on
- 12:31the battery, which is a huge confidence and.
- 12:33What about safety that they don't come out for everyone?
- 12:36The scores are very strong possible, which is great to see
- 12:39in the latest euro and the AP test the Tesla model why LED the
- 12:42pack is especially in driver systems, but significantly many
- 12:47Chinese brands like the BID seal and Dolphin are also getting
- 12:50taught by this by meetings. They're absolutely matching the
- 12:53established players on safety. This has.
- 12:56Been a really comprehensive deep dive.
- 12:58So reliability in the EV world is, well, it's not a simple yes
- 13:02or no question. It's a really complex picture.
- 13:05It's influenced by it. Seems three things.
- 13:08Vehicle maturity. That's the CR versus ADC
- 13:11conflict. Component choice.
- 13:13The humble 12 Volt battery being the biggest.
- 13:14Headache in manufacturing approach, yeah.
- 13:16Legacy compromise This is a dedicated the long term game.
- 13:24Changer EVs will without a delegate more dependable as the
- 13:27tech materials. Tesla's client in the rankings
- 13:30proves that. But the competitive question,
- 13:32driven by China's integrated approach, forces every other
- 13:35automaker to constantly rethink everything.
- 13:38If. It fundamentally changes what an
- 13:39engineering success story even is in transportation.
- 13:42I mean, think about it, the simplicity of the EV
- 13:55fundamentally shifts the competitive edge.
- 13:57It moves away from those who mastered the key rocks and
- 14:00towards those who can master the battery.
- 14:02The supply chain to mean for the.
- 14:10Billy Idea of a premium car. When new players dominate the
- 14:14software and the traditional signs of engineering perfection
- 14:18like a silky smooth V8 are just gone, what's the new definition
- 14:22of luxury or. Performance is all the value now
- 14:25just in the. We'll do that.