Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP228: The Mysterious Murder of Lisa Au
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Hi, everybody, Welcome to this week's
- 0:38episode of Crimes and Consequences. I am Talia. This is my lovely co
- 0:42host, Tanya. We are excited to have you back here with us this
- 0:48week, and we want to thank True Crime Daily for hosting us on oir
- 0:52YouTube channel, and for all those listening, whatever their favorite podcast is,
- 0:58we want to thank you for listening. And if you feel entitled or want
- 1:04to or just have pity on us, that you can hit the like or
- 1:08subscribe button and write something nice or you can write something nasty, but we
- 1:14don't care. It doesn't bother us. Whatever you prefer. So, how
- 1:19are you I'm doing great? Are you? No? No, you're not.
- 1:23No, we just talked. No, I'm a half hour late,
- 1:26and she's not doing great. But I have a really interesting true crime story
- 1:32that I never heard before. Yes, I don't know this one. Yeah,
- 1:36because I was talking about it, right, so I might pronounce some
- 1:40things wrong because that's what we do. Yes, we do. And for
- 1:44those that don't know, Tany and I are lawyers and we like true crime
- 1:49exactly and food, yes, and we sometimes combine the two, but not
- 1:53here. And I like vodka but not right now. Yeah. So this
- 2:01is again a really interesting story. This story takes place in the island of
- 2:07Oahu. It's in Hawaii. Yeah you knew that. Yes, okay.
- 2:13It's the third largest island there and is dubbed the Heart of Hawaii. I've
- 2:19always wanted to go. I had a chance to go, and I don't
- 2:22want to go. Why it was nine hour flight ooh and five hour time
- 2:27difference. Oh, I still would have went lazy, Yeah, I know.
- 2:31Okay. Anyway, this island is home at to golden beaches. I
- 2:37mean, it's Hawaii, miles of untamed waters and plenty to do and see.
- 2:43The story takes place in nineteen eighty two, and there's this illusion of
- 2:49safety on the island, but this was shattered when nineteen year old Lisa Ao
- 2:55mysteriously disappeared. And this story has continued to haunt Hawaii for almost forty years.
- 3:05So I'm gonna give you a little background, okay, okay. On
- 3:07July twenty fifth of nineteen sixty two, sixty two, Chester and Patrise Patrise
- 3:15sorry Ao welcome their daughter Lisa into the world. Chester was a mechanic and
- 3:21Patrise was a waitress. They raised Lisa and she had ended up having two
- 3:28other younger siblings in a multi cultural home. Chester was Chinese and her mother,
- 3:36Lisa's mother, Patrise, was Hawaiian. But this story actually takes place
- 3:40in nineteen eighty two, and this is when Lisa is nineteen years old and
- 3:46she's, you know, transitioning from being a child into adulthood. Except now
- 3:52it's like twenty nine. Yeah, and when you do that, yeah,
- 3:54back then you could say that. But and her life came to a tragic
- 4:00again. In nineteen eighty Lisa graduated from a Catholic school called mary Knolls.
- 4:06She then, after the summer, spent eight months getting a certificate as a
- 4:14hairdresser for the Trendsetter Beauty College. She ended up getting a job as a
- 4:19hairdresser and she worked at a place called Susan Beer's Salant, and eventually there
- 4:29she met a coworker named Candy Mainz, and she decided, you know what,
- 4:35I want to move out. Oh, move out of mom and Dan's
- 4:39house. Yes, okay, I want to be on my own. So
- 4:42she moves in with Candy Mainz in kaalua oahou. I think that's right.
- 4:48At the time, she was dating a man named Doug Holmes. Now,
- 4:54Doug was a student. He was twenty three years old and he went to
- 4:58the university why. He was studying to be an engineer. He lived in
- 5:03the dorms there, which ended up being about thirty minutes away from Lisa's apartment.
- 5:11They met at a restaurant when he was a server. Oh, they
- 5:15hit it off. That's cute. It's cute. On January eighteenth, Lisa
- 5:23got her driver's license. She just got it. Just got her driver's license,
- 5:28and her father helped her buy her first car. It was in nineteen
- 5:31seventy six brown Toyota. I don't know what make it was, but it
- 5:36was a It was a Brown Toyota. So she's got she'd only been working
- 5:44at the salon for five weeks. Just moved in with Candy, just got
- 5:47her license, just got a car, and she is ready to take on
- 5:54the world. Thank you, you're welcome. It's January twenty first and this
- 6:00nineteen eighty two, and it started like any other day for Lisa. She
- 6:03woke up, got herself ready, drove to the Susan Beer salon. Her
- 6:10shift ended at nine pm, but she had to like clean up the station
- 6:15around her, and so it was roughly about nine forty five pm when she
- 6:21was done cleaning up everything and ready to go outside and leave, ready to
- 6:28go, but there was torrential rains. So on the part of the island
- 6:32that they're at, it's it's kind of like there's I don't know if it's
- 6:38a mountain or a hill, forgive me, but one side gets like a
- 6:43little bit of like gets blasted, and the other side doesn't get as much
- 6:47rain. So she's on the side that she's getting there getting blasted and it's
- 6:53not like a normal storm. It's bad. She calls her mom and she
- 6:59says, you know, I'm gonna leave. I'm gonna go visit my boyfriend
- 7:01Dog and his sister, Kristen. I'm gonna go to Kristen's house and that
- 7:09is in my Kiki. It's about a thirty minute drive and she's gonna go
- 7:15have dinner with them, and her mom is like he's out in the storm.
- 7:18You just gotta let your license. Yeah, two days ago, Like,
- 7:21no, she's gonna take on the storm. And back then in Hawaii
- 7:28that like the roads are winding and they didn't have a lot of barriers,
- 7:31so there's a lot of mud slides and rocks falling. Yeah, and it's
- 7:39I mean torrential rain. But Lisa's gotta see, you know, she's determined.
- 7:44I'm gonna see her boyfriend. Right, So her mom says, don't
- 7:48do it, but she went anyway. Before she met her boyfriend dog at
- 7:54his sister's apartment, Kristen's, Lisa stopped to a grocery store and she got
- 7:59a Pokey bar Oh yeah, Pokey bowls mm hmm, yeah, this is
- 8:03a eighty two. Well I only saw my first Pokey bowl like four years
- 8:07ago. Finally made its way over here, right, and she got it
- 8:11to share with Kristin and Doug. She's at the store. She wrote a
- 8:16check for two dollars and eighty cents for the poke bowl and made her way
- 8:20to Kristen's apartment. She drove down what's called Poll Highway to get there,
- 8:28and it's considered a very dangerous highway because I told you there are rocks falling
- 8:33and mud slides, and they didn't have the rail guards at the time.
- 8:39That would be terris. I don't like driving. I didn't even drive.
- 8:41I can't even drive in Michigan at night, in my own town without being
- 8:48nervous, let alone that. So she reached Kristen's Christen's apartment and kristin,
- 8:56Doug, and Lisa. They all ate anteladas that Kristen had made. Oh
- 9:01yeah, we've loved food, love food, and the poke bowl that Lisa
- 9:07bought. It was around midnight and Lisa called a roommate, Candy, to
- 9:15let her know she was leaving soon, both her and dog. This is
- 9:20where it gets a little like of her different reports on exactly how it went
- 9:24done. But both her and dog ended up leaving around the same time.
- 9:30Doug got into his car and we're talking. It's about twelve forty five am,
- 9:37and he's gonna head back to the dorm. But we know that Lisa
- 9:39left first. I don't know if it was thirty seconds earlier, one minute,
- 9:46but I know that she left first. Unfortunately, only one of them
- 9:52would make it, and it would take ten days for the truth to be
- 9:58discovered what happened to the other one, which is obviously Lisa. The next
- 10:07day, her roommate Candy wakes up and there's no Lisa, and Lisa has
- 10:11called her remember right, yeah, I'm coming home. And they worked together
- 10:16and Lisa didn't show up for work. So by mid afternoon, Candy calls
- 10:22Lisa's mom and dad and tells them I don't know where Lisa is. In
- 10:30they start panicking, of course, right. The first person they call is
- 10:35Doug, and Doug tells them I saw Lisa like twelve forty five am.
- 10:41She was on her way home. I haven't heard from her. And then
- 10:48like they they're just freaking out because there was that massive storm, right,
- 10:56And Doug offers to go and onto the roads and look for Lisa and her
- 11:01car. Maybe she got in an accident, and I believe her parents were
- 11:05calling the hospitals, but I'm not one hundred percent sure, Doug. They're
- 11:11all thinking she had car problems or an accident, like I said, because
- 11:16of the storm, and she's just such a new driver. So Doug leaves
- 11:22the University of Hawaii and he starts searching the roads. He knows the path
- 11:28that she's probably gonna take because it's an island, so there's only so many,
- 11:33so many roads roads, and this is so cheap. He knows that
- 11:37she's probably taking the Holly Highway. He's driving and he sees her car on
- 11:48Polly Highway, on the side of the road in mana mana wheela, mana
- 11:52WHEELI mana WHEELI mona WHEELI. It's near the Khalua. So sorry, I
- 12:00know it's not klukay. I studied these I tried these words so hard and
- 12:05I had it. But it's near driving and he notices it's abandoned. It's
- 12:11on the side of the road and there's this nineteen seventy six Toyota and it's
- 12:15the same car that Lisa had just bought. It's only three miles from her
- 12:20apartment, and it's ten miles from Kristen's apartment where he last saw her.
- 12:28When Doug got to the car, there's no Lisa. But there are some
- 12:33really bizarre things at that in that car, like some clues her lights were
- 12:39still on, her windshield, wipers were still going. Oh, that's kind
- 12:45of that's weird. That's right, weird. Yeah, Like this has been
- 12:48now twelve hours. The driver's side window was rolled down halfway and the floor
- 12:56of her car because of the rain, had two to three inches of water
- 13:01in it. But it's the driver's side is drenched because that's where the window
- 13:07was down. But what's weird is on top of the driver's side seat was
- 13:15her purse and it was dry. It was dry. It was dry.
- 13:20There's no water in it. There's two to three inches of water on the
- 13:24floor of her car, her seat is soaked, but her purse is dry.
- 13:31That's right. Her keys and her wallet were still in the car.
- 13:37Obviously, Doug is freaking out and he goes to the nearest phone booth or
- 13:45phone, and he calls the Honolulu Police Department. Within minutes, the area
- 13:50is surrounded by officers and they start taking a deeper look into Lisa's car.
- 13:56This is really interesting. Her car was wiped clean of all forensic evidence.
- 14:03No fingerprints, not hers, nobody's fingerprints, nothing. Hmmm, it is
- 14:13completely wipe clean. They found they found a couple like partial fingerprints, but
- 14:22not even enough to even be partial. Like this car had been totally totally
- 14:28someone tried to clean it on all of it its evidence. There were no
- 14:35fibers. They couldn't find any fibers at the scene. They couldn't find anything
- 14:39that would lead them, like forensically to who did this or where lisas.
- 14:46But then it's nineteen eighty two. So what's interesting is two police officers separately
- 14:52had driven by that her abandoned car during the storm, but they never bothered
- 14:58to like check and see if the driver needed help. That look, that's
- 15:07her, that's her, like old lady, not your naughty look. Doug
- 15:15told them everything about what happened the night before and how Lisa had never made
- 15:22it home. It was at this point that Lisa Ou was officially reported missing,
- 15:28and within hours missing person posters were posted everywhere her family and her friends
- 15:35and the whole community. I believe they put together like one hundred thousand flyers,
- 15:41and I'm not making it up. I read that someplace. I read
- 15:45some place it was one hundred. I read another place there was one hundred
- 15:46thousand, But it was a lot. It's a big difference, right too.
- 15:50But it was a lot, and they were spread around the island.
- 15:56The analysis of Lisa's car showed all those you know, kind of bizarre clues,
- 16:03and the question becomes why was her window partially down? Right, And
- 16:12why was her purse is dry? Why her keys are still in it?
- 16:18So if her car, like her car physically worked, but so like even
- 16:26if it for some reason stopped, why would she leave her purse behind?
- 16:30Yeah, that wouldn't make any sound like if you're gonna go out on foot,
- 16:33like stop, you're gonna, well, you're gonna it's a crucial rain,
- 16:37you're gonna sit there and we are not going out in a storm.
- 16:41No, so they found but they so they found that very interesting. And
- 16:48another thing they noticed is that Lisa's driver's license was missing. Oh that's weird
- 16:52too, like why why is her driver's license missing? And her windows rolled
- 16:59down? Partly yes, it appeared to the investigators that her purse had been
- 17:07put back into the car after the rain had stopped. Oh that would make
- 17:12sense, right, but who? Right? Why? Why? Important question?
- 17:18Why'd they take it to begin with? They didn't take anything from it?
- 17:22Maybe her license right right? The rolldown of the window, you know,
- 17:30makes it appear as if she rolled it down to talk to somebody,
- 17:33right, right? Okay, there were so many questions and no answers.
- 17:37These investigators they knew they had to act fast. It's it's an you know,
- 17:44it's an island, and people are freaking out. So her missing person
- 17:48posters are posted all over Oahu and the news picks us up. This's a
- 17:53big story. I mean it's it's a very big story. And as I
- 17:59told you, the local community came together. There were hundreds of volunteers that
- 18:04they closed their shops to go look for her and look on all the land
- 18:11around. But days past and days past and days past, and all these
- 18:19searches with hundreds of people grew fruitless. They there was no Lisa, and
- 18:27obviously it's looking bleaker and bleaker as every day goes by. Yeah, I
- 18:33mean it's you know, her poor parents, they loved her so much,
- 18:40and her siblings, her mother and father. They did an interview with the
- 18:44media and they said, quote, thank you, not enough. Everyone wants
- 18:48to help so much. The support has just been great end quote. And
- 18:52they're bawling during it. They're just well, wouldn't you of course I would
- 18:56be, And you could just tell they're exhausted, drained. It was just
- 19:04it was horrible. But then on January thirty first, nineteen eighty two,
- 19:11the search for Lisa was called off because her body was found this man was
- 19:19walking his dog on Tannilis Drive and it's it's you'll see a picture. We're
- 19:30posting a picture. He noticed a foul smell. He traced the smell to
- 19:34an embankment, and he walked about ten feet down the embankment, and about
- 19:41twenty five feet thirty feet from there he saw there was tall grass and there
- 19:47was a nude woman. And it's like a ravine, okay, and there
- 19:52she is. Lisa, faced down, naked, spent ten days in Hawaii
- 20:03in the grass. She was nude, and witnesses reported that it looked like
- 20:08she'd just been like dumped, okay, over the side of the road,
- 20:14down the ravine, like haphazardly like anything, and then fell because it's it's
- 20:21an embankment, okay, so she's just like moving. Lisa had been officially
- 20:29missing for ten days and her body was in an advanced state of decomposition due
- 20:36to being out in the elements for so long, and the Honolulu Police Department
- 20:41immediately transferred her case from a missing person from the Missing Person's Unit to the
- 20:47Homicide Division. Lisa's body was found roughly three miles from Kristen's place and ten
- 20:56miles from her car. And if you're remember, her car was about three
- 21:02miles from her place, yeah, right, right, so it was like
- 21:07in the opposite direct direction, so it was all switched. She wasn't yah
- 21:14found near where her car was. She was found closer to Kristen's place.
- 21:19Her body was taken away by the medical examiner, and of course, you
- 21:25know, it was prepared for an autopsy, and her family's given the news,
- 21:27and her boyfriend and they're all upset. Of course, she was just
- 21:33nineteen years old, I know, and as you as you heard me,
- 21:37she just started like her path of sighting party, you're like fifty years old
- 21:45and looking for nursing home. Soon, due to the level of decomposition,
- 21:52the Honolulu Medical Examiner was unable to determine the cause of death. Lisa had
- 21:59to be identified through dental records and they found her class ring on her finger.
- 22:08The medical examiner ruled out suicide, which seems pretty obvious when you're naked
- 22:12in an by in a ravine, right, I mean, come on right.
- 22:19Hysteria basically ripped through the community like wildfire, and there was so much
- 22:25pressure on the Honolulu Police Department to catch whoever did this. One of the
- 22:33key elements in Lisa's case was a missing driver's license, and that's when rumors
- 22:38began swirling that a police officer or someone posing as a police officer had pulled
- 22:48Lisa over that night. Oh, like maybe she was speeding or something,
- 22:52and then they asked for her. She wasn't doing anything wrong and they just
- 22:57pulled her over because the creek. That's right, right, yes, So
- 23:03that would be make sense why she would lower her window and give somebody a
- 23:10license, right. A witness reported seeing Lisa's car on the side of the
- 23:15road at about one forty five am. That's about an hour after she left
- 23:22Kristen's apartment and said goodbye to Doug. Well, all these rumors are just
- 23:29rumors, they did end up having some weight to them. The rumors brought
- 23:37something very dark and disturbing to light. In the months before Lisa disappeared and
- 23:44was killed, young women had reported that a man in an unmarked police car
- 23:49posing it as an officer, would pull him over on the highway and this
- 23:55man will try to assault these women before leaving them in the car. Now,
- 24:00so this is what's interesting. At the time. In Hawaii, a
- 24:07lot of police officers had unmarked cars, so they look like regular cars.
- 24:12They weren't, you know, didn't say Honolulu Police or whatever. And they
- 24:18would put these blue lights and they're grill of a car, and we have
- 24:22a picture of this, and the blue lights would flash to like indicate that
- 24:30you need to pull over, but it's a normal car. Yeah, hmm,
- 24:36this seems really unsafe. Well they changed that policy. Yeah, but
- 24:40I can't imagine because people can purchase these blue flashing right at the time,
- 24:45could purchase blue flashing lights. So a lot of officers wouldn't use the regular
- 24:49patrol cars. They if they're off duty, they would put them in their
- 24:53own cars and then just I don't know, decide to go ahead and pull
- 24:57somebody over for shifts and giggles. No, I'm just kidding. I don't
- 25:03know, because they were committing cracks. Yes, of course. Yes,
- 25:07you're always a police officer, of course, just like you're always a lawyer.
- 25:10Hm. Unfortunately, many people believe this is what happened to Lisa.
- 25:17I mean, given the number of reports that occurred about from women saying somebody,
- 25:22you know, somebody posing as a police officer or being a police officer,
- 25:26had tried to moless them, and the fact her window was down and
- 25:30her license was gone. Okay, the police are thinking, hmmm, maybe
- 25:37maybe it's one of one of us. Their first suspect person of interest,
- 25:45they focused on a man, an officer named Thomas Byrne. Two years prior,
- 25:51in nineteen eighty he'd been charged with he had a fourteen year old in
- 25:56his car and he was doing police ride along, okay, and he sexually
- 26:04molested her carrying the police ride along. He ended up being convicted in nineteen
- 26:12eighty one for something and he got probation and he was suspended for five days,
- 26:18for five days, for five days. Yeah, yeah, that was
- 26:22a hell of a punishment for fourteen year old girl. Wow. And then
- 26:26he was allowed to go back. I mean, is that fucked up?
- 26:29That's fucked up? Yeah? Oh, extremely, extremely, like we really
- 26:33had to do therapy though, oh okay, had to do therapy. Was
- 26:37on probation. He was questioned first and he admitted that that night he had
- 26:45pulled over a woman on Polly Highway, which is the same highway that Lisa
- 26:49was driving down. And then he said he went to a party and then
- 26:57he went help. Okay. A woman came forward and said she'd been pulled
- 27:03over by him. And she said she'd been pulled over, and then they
- 27:10showed her a lineup of people that had pulled her over because he wasn't supposed
- 27:15to be working and he's going to like a party. Yeah, Like what
- 27:18are you doing, dude? Like what are you just being weird? Just
- 27:21being weird? And she identified him as the person that pulled her over.
- 27:26And they actually brought in some dogs to sniff for evidence. But these dogs
- 27:34weren't really trained for exactly what I mean. They weren't looking for cadavers.
- 27:41I don't if maybe the scent of Lisa or something I can't remember, but
- 27:45they did focus on his car, but I don't remember exactly if it was
- 27:52a sense of Lisa, but they didn't maybe if she had been in his
- 27:55car or something like that, but they weren't when I was doing research on
- 27:59that. They weren't really trained for that, So they don't know. If
- 28:03it's a coincidence, they don't know it, they don't know. It doesn't
- 28:07matter because in the end they decided he didn't have anything to do with it.
- 28:12In January of nineteen eighty two, Bert Corneille was assigned to the criminal
- 28:18investigations. He was assigned to the Criminal Investigations Division of the Honolulu Police Department,
- 28:25and he was assigned to Lisa's case. From the start, he did
- 28:29not believe the cop theory. He just something it just his gut told him
- 28:36no. And this man ends up being in the case for forty years.
- 28:40Wow. And in the months that follow he he is looking through everything because
- 28:49he believes that the Honolulu Police Department didn't do a really good job. As
- 28:56a matter of fact, he thinks they did a shit job of just being
- 28:59honest. That's you know. He decides to retrace all of Lisa's steps.
- 29:03Okay, He first visits the Susan Beers salon where Lisa worked, and made
- 29:10his way to the grocery store where she went and got the Pokey bowl.
- 29:14You know what he found out there? What he found out that when Lisa
- 29:18got the poke bowl, she wrote a check, remember I told you,
- 29:22yeah, two dollars and eighty cents, and they asked her for her license
- 29:27and she was in such a hurry she didn't get it back. She didn't
- 29:30get it back. Oh that's where her license was. Oh no, this
- 29:36just puts a wrench in all the theories right, right, So that months
- 29:41later is where he found Lisa's license. The grocery store still had it.
- 29:48He's like, hmm, I mean, he was just shocked that the police
- 29:52went there, went there, hadn't gone there. Yeah, she was just
- 29:56in a rush. And so now he really believed this is not the police.
- 30:03Thanks to his diligent work and is his determination, he was able to
- 30:10uncover more clues and talk to more witnesses, all missed by the Honolulu Police
- 30:18Department. And because of this, that's the whole reason that her case probably
- 30:25wasn't solved, because they just did such a crappy job. So Bert is
- 30:30talking to locals and he's put in touch with Charlotte Kamaka. She delivered newspapers
- 30:38and this is according to the Hawaii News Now well she Charlotte later testified before
- 30:45grand jury about what she saw on Tannalists drive in the hours after Lisa went
- 30:51missing. She said she was on her regular route at about two thirty am.
- 30:56In the police records, she said a man drove past her in a
- 31:02blue car with a female passenger who appeared to be asleep or unconscious. Charlotte
- 31:11would also tell the grand jury. What alerted me was her head fell when
- 31:18the car made a turn. Her head just fell. Later, she said
- 31:23that she got a look at the driver as he turned and drove out,
- 31:30but it just wasn't enough for her to actually be able to identify who it
- 31:34was, and the female passenger was just gone. So I think when the
- 31:44driver turned she maybe slumped over. Yeah, she just slumped over exactly.
- 31:52So Charlotte was never able to identify the man, and she would also state
- 31:56to detect a state that detectives did ask her for her number to talk to
- 32:04her about what she saw, but they never followed up with her. They
- 32:07only talked to her one time, and she felt like what she had to
- 32:10say was pretty important. It wasn't until Bert began digging further that he got
- 32:19the full story. So it was Charlotte that actually reached out to the police
- 32:23and they never really interviewed her. It was only until when Burt saw her
- 32:29name like in the notes, that he got all the sexual information. And
- 32:35this wasn't the only witness account that Bert was able to obtain along with speaking
- 32:39to Charlotte or Charlotte, I don't know, Charlotte. I think the part
- 32:45called her both names, but no, he said Charlotte. Oh. Good
- 32:49Bert also spoke to Thomas Thornberg. He was a security guard at the apartments
- 32:54where Lisa was last seen alive, and that was Kristen's apartment. Now,
- 33:00according to the security guard, mister Thomas, he heard a couple arguing around
- 33:05eleven pm, and then he saw Lisa leaving the apartment complex in her car,
- 33:12and then minutes later he saw Doug following after her. Now this account
- 33:20messes with the timeline that Doug gates, right, because Doug stated that the
- 33:23two left at twelve about twelve forty five, And I don't know if Kristen
- 33:30was asleep by then, right, That's why I was like, why don't
- 33:32we ask Kristen. Yeah, I never found anything that talked about Kristen's version
- 33:37of the timeline. So maybe, I mean, yeah, it's it's a
- 33:42weekday and it's late, so I would have been asleep probably probably maybe unless
- 33:49I was in my twenties. Yeah, that'll probably be away. Yeah,
- 33:52anyway, from the start, Doug was a suspect obviously, right, I
- 33:59mean, serious crimes are committed by someone close to the victim. We all
- 34:02know that. But if Doug was responsible, what would be his motive?
- 34:08Right, I'm not trying to be insensitive, but if you want to kill
- 34:15your girlfriend, why are you going to go out follow her in the torrential
- 34:20rain, have her pulled over inside of the road, or even that's the
- 34:23day you picked to kill her in the torrential rain. Like, I'm not
- 34:27not trying to be insensitive. I mean they just had dinner and she wasn't
- 34:31pregnant. You know, they don't, They didn't have a history of domestic
- 34:37violence. There was no money, no money. He's just a student and
- 34:40she's a hairdresser, right, so why follower and go through all that?
- 34:46That's a lot of trouble to get her out of the car? Driver like
- 34:51ten miles bring a purse back during a storm? Right, Yeah, that
- 34:55doesn't make a lot of sense. And usually the heat of passion is during
- 35:00the heat of passion and not so anyway, I'm just saying I don't know,
- 35:07but Doug would later fail to detect test dog, no dog, come
- 35:15on, nervous, Yeah, well I would be nervous. Nervous would be
- 35:22like no, I yes, my name is Selene, would be like fail,
- 35:27It's not I know I would have been nervous as hell. Doug told
- 35:30investigators that the reason why he failed is because he felt responsible for her murder,
- 35:39because he should have never let somebody that he loved who only had been
- 35:44driving for two days, drive in that storm. Yeah, he can't do
- 35:50that though, I mean, you can't do that, but you would feel
- 35:52guilty. Of course. That's why he's saying. In his mind, he
- 35:58feels responsible, and that's why he failed the tests. I mean, they
- 36:02pressed him further, and they thought that he was on the brink of confessing
- 36:07because he kept saying, I feel so guilty, I feel so guilty.
- 36:10But he just later on said I shouldn't let her drive home in those conditions.
- 36:17But he did admit to officers that he was trying to end the relationship.
- 36:22He said, I'm going to college, I'm getting educated, because he
- 36:27was going to be an engineer, while Lisa was more or less staying still
- 36:31with her education, and in his mind, she's just going to be a
- 36:36hairdresser, and that wasn't wasn't good enough, wasn't good enough for him.
- 36:40A few sources also mentioned that when Doug found Lisa's car abandoned, attending officers
- 36:47did not scratch marks on his face. H but nothing ever came of that
- 36:58without any evidence or confession. Doug was never formally charged in Lisa's case,
- 37:05but many people still believe that he's a prime suspect he did it. But
- 37:13it it's kind of weak. It just I mean, there's no indication,
- 37:17like, Okay, so you break up with her. I mean people break
- 37:21up every day, right, They don't have to kill somebody. They don't
- 37:22have to kill somebody to break up with them. Them on the road,
- 37:24have them pull out, and so let's just let's just talk this out.
- 37:30Lisa's driving. We all know she left first and then he left. There's
- 37:36pouring rain. What made her pull over to the side of the road.
- 37:39How would she know that it was dog flashing? Right? They didn't have
- 37:45cell phones, so she wouldn't. No, that's true. See my point,
- 37:51Right, Lisa was buried with her family not knowing what happened. But
- 37:59this case is not I mean, they are a heartbroken. A year after
- 38:04Lisa was buried, her remains were exhumed and sent to a corner in Los
- 38:09Angeles. Wow. It was believed by her family and other people that the
- 38:16Honolulu Medical Examiner had missed vital clues and pieces of evidence in their autopsy,
- 38:23and they hold his second opinion. Her family basically could provide them with more
- 38:29answers. While the exhumation is how you say it, I think so sounds
- 38:35good. M was taking place for colonel He left the Honolulu Police Department and
- 38:42Lisa's family hired him to be a private detective. Oh, he like left
- 38:45the police left. I'm out of whatever the hell is going on here.
- 38:52The result of the second autopsy came in, but they weren't what people were
- 38:55expecting. According to the Hawaiian us Now, which ran a really long article
- 39:02on Lisa's case, when they exhumed the body, this is so messed up.
- 39:10It was still she'd been buried in a casket, in the body bag
- 39:15the corner. Yeah, in a body bag. It was a close casket
- 39:20and they just never took her out of the body bag, and she the
- 39:22corner hadn't washed her body and there was they found dirt, twigs and leaves
- 39:30in the body bag. So basically how she got picked up was wow,
- 39:36how she was this is terrible, But she was picked up like basically putting
- 39:39a body bag and buried. I mean you have dirt, twigs and leaves
- 39:45in the body bag. I've never heard of something like this Like that to
- 39:50me is so disrespectful, Like can you imagine it? And then what kind
- 39:53of job did they do, right, Like did they even pick any of
- 39:57it out to like did they even highly examined her rights? That's what I'm
- 40:00wondering, Like they're just it doesn't sound like it right, right, they
- 40:06got to take her out of the body bag to examiner, I think you
- 40:08were you just put her right back in, so I mean then maybe the
- 40:13I mean maybe I'm sure the examiner. But there's her right back in with
- 40:16all the I am and irritated right now. This is such a shitty job.
- 40:22I was her parents would be so fucking pissed, right they Yeah,
- 40:25I'd be beside myself. Well, and part of the Honolulu Police Department was
- 40:32upset too. I mean you have to remember this was the medical examiner that
- 40:36did that. Wasn't pleased, and everybody was appalled. They're just furious.
- 40:40I mean, that just shows the incompetence, right. So, the Los
- 40:45Angeles Corner did not make the report public after the second autopsy, but they
- 40:52did release to the media that due to the advanced state of decomposition. It
- 40:58meant that making an incan collusions were difficult, so they couldn't figure out how
- 41:04she died either. But that does tell you a few things. There's no
- 41:08bullet holes, right, There's no cut yeah from being stabbed, no broken
- 41:17bones from being strangled. Hmm. But I mean that doesn't mean she wasn't.
- 41:25But she could have done, could have been smothered, mothered, or
- 41:30she could have been strangled. I mean, but she you know, nothing,
- 41:35nothing that broke her bones, nothing, No bullets, no bullet wounds,
- 41:38things like that. But I hate this horrible. The incompetence does not
- 41:46stop there. There's more. Over the years, many people wanted to help
- 41:54the family out, and they wanted to do other autopsies, and they wanted
- 42:01at least access to Lisa's remains to conduct independent exams because technology is advancing.
- 42:08That's true, right, There's one problem now, I knows where half of
- 42:15her her remains are are all. I write a couple of articles. Some
- 42:19said all of the remains, some said her skull and what yeah, vertebrae,
- 42:23They're just gone. There's pieces missing, missing. I believe it's her
- 42:28whole body. Missing from when they exhumed her. Are you kidding me?
- 42:32No, I'm not fucking kidding you, Ilu. The Honolulu Police Department says
- 42:38that it remains. It's his school and jawbone are with so that's that's what's
- 42:44missing. But I did read other parts I said more or other articles that
- 42:49said more. They said they're at the Honolulu Medical Examiner's office, while the
- 42:52Medical Examiner's Office is admit that they were put in Lisa's coffin, but there
- 42:58weren't Lisa's coffin, so nobody else. Oh my god, this is terrible.
- 43:05Isn't that horrible? Like I feel so bad for her family, Like
- 43:10it's not she wasn't ideal, right, like like nobody gives a ship trash
- 43:16or whatever. You just put at someplace whatever, whatever. The chain of
- 43:20costy paperwork and other vital procedures weren't carried out properly. Well, the only
- 43:28way to find her remains was to dig up the grave once again. Yeah,
- 43:34and it wasn't there. Her skull wasn't found there. There's one Well,
- 43:40I'm sorry I shouldn't say that. They didn't end up doing it a
- 43:44second time? My bad, they didn't they didn't. They did not.
- 43:49There's one less clue in Lisa's case, and it involves an officer who was
- 43:55told to lie before grand jury because they did have a grand jury to try
- 44:00to see if there was enough evidence against that one police officer. I told
- 44:06you so, the happy one. Yes, yeah, yes, Thomas Byrne.
- 44:13Yes, who, by the way, did sue media outlets and stuff
- 44:19for defamation. Oh whoops. But they ended up dropping it. It didn't
- 44:23go anywhere. That's all I know is it didn't go anywhere. My opinion,
- 44:28Well, yeah, he was charged, convicted. Yes, I'm just
- 44:30saying it's not defamation if it's my opinion. No, it's just her opinion.
- 44:36Allegedly it was allegedly he was creepy, Yes, but he was convicted.
- 44:40And this is in nineteen eighty two. I don't even think that he
- 44:44is. It might not even be alive anymore. According to Hawaiian News Now,
- 44:49on the night Lisa disappeared in nineteen eighty two, officer Michael Rathfeld,
- 44:53I believe that's how you pronounce it. Raffled was directing traffic in Mana Weeli
- 45:00on a wheelie and the reason why he was directing traffic is because there was
- 45:06a month's light, so he was helping people go by. And he said
- 45:12he didn't see Lisa's car, okay, because that he testified to I'll get
- 45:20to that. So that's that's the according to him, he was asked to
- 45:25lie to the grand jury, telling them that he did in fact see Lisa's
- 45:31car and then he saw a patrol officers standing at the car. But he
- 45:37never went through his testimony and he was hypnotized, and during hypnosis he did
- 45:43not confirm that he saw Lisa's car with a police officer by it. It's
- 45:50never been revealed exactly who told him to lie or why they wanted to lie.
- 45:57Why would you want to lie and say it was right police officer?
- 46:00But it does bring like a whole lot of questions. And I read an
- 46:06article he is still alive and he said that if there was any new information
- 46:10that came out, he would be willing to say exactly the same thing that
- 46:15he was told to lie. And I don't know why. We don't know
- 46:19who he was lying for. Yeah, but I think this time he would
- 46:23come out and say it if there is a like if he was sub peanut,
- 46:29right, So why would a Honolulu police officer be told to lie to
- 46:37your injury. What's the motive? Why point the finger at a patrol officer?
- 46:43I don't know. Doing a cover up, it's a conspiracy. It
- 46:47is something, it's something messed up. So there's so many more, there
- 46:52more questions and answers in this case. And I hate doing these cases where
- 46:57I don't have the answers for you. The investigation was pretty much doomed from
- 47:00the start because of just how slappy. Yeah, I mean, it was
- 47:05just sloppy. Lisa's parents, Chester and Patrise. They ended up getting divorced
- 47:09in nineteen ninety because the murder of Lisa just for them apart. Oh that's
- 47:15heartbreaking, Yeah, and just never knowing happened to their daughter. It just
- 47:21they could never be the family they once were. And many of the key
- 47:25witnesses have passed away since then, I mean a lot of them. Doug
- 47:31Holmes, he moved to Australia. In twenty eighteen. The Honolulu Police Department
- 47:39created a cold case unit and Lisa's case has been more than ever since.
- 47:45In a statement by them police chief, her name is Susan, but Ballard
- 47:50stated in twenty nineteen, well cold case detectives are looking for anything that may
- 47:55have been overlooked at the time, or whether new technology can provide information.
- 48:01Relationships shift over the years, and it's not uncommon for people to want to
- 48:06clear their conscience. One individual, yeah, so anyway, that's the end
- 48:13of that quote. The only individual that we know for sure that knows what
- 48:22happened, she stated, was miss Lisa Au. But there's one other person
- 48:28there is, yeah, the person that did it. Oh yeah, of
- 48:30course, yeah, you're right. There's two people who know. Yeah.
- 48:37So Bert Corneil, the one that was originally worked for the police and then
- 48:43was hired as a private detective. He not lives in Florida, but he
- 48:45continues to investigate Lisa's case and he's like, I'm ready for action if anything
- 48:51comes up. He's older now, obviously, but he's ready to go.
- 48:54He said. The case has haunted him throughout his entire career and he vows
- 49:00to see it through to the very end. While Lisa's boyfriend Doug has been
- 49:07a potential suspect, there's never been any evidence brought to light to show that
- 49:13he did it, so is it him. He moved to Australia by the
- 49:19way he lives in Australia. Was it somebody impersonating a police officer. Some
- 49:24people suspect that Lisa was perhaps a victim of the Honolulu strangler, who they
- 49:32know operated from nineteen eighty five to nineteen eighty six, but maybe it was
- 49:38a little bit earlier, right right, I mean, that's just when they
- 49:42know that he did. And so I started going down a rabbit hole about
- 49:47so that might be another story that we going to do soon. Yeah,
- 49:52he strangled women, and the first one they know of is nineteen eighty five,
- 49:57but that doesn't mean that's the first one. First order he committed.
- 50:04Again, experts aren't able even when the technology they have now to because they
- 50:08didn't have give any evidence. They don't have anything. They don't have anything.
- 50:13There was nothing, probably even collected fingerprints, and they don't even have
- 50:17her skull and job bone. I hate this. I hate unsolved cases.
- 50:22They're just heartbreaking. Lisa's younger sister, she was twelve years younger than Lisa.
- 50:28She was seven at the time, but she loved her big sister.
- 50:31Her name was may Lee. She told the Hawaii News now quote, my
- 50:37parents are gone and they now know what happened now, just the living want
- 50:43to know. A lot of our family and friends close to us still want
- 50:46to know. So anybody that has any information can contact the Honolulu Police Department
- 50:53and their number is eight eight five two nine three one one one. Even
- 51:00if you think it's insignificant, I mean they're desperate for a break in this
- 51:06case, they need a break. Oh this is just isn't crazy? Yes,
- 51:12you know, statistically when it's raining or there's storms, there's less crimes
- 51:16committed because it sucks outside, right right. We just did a Patreon episode
- 51:22last month about a couple who was murdered during a storm in Florida. Yeah,
- 51:28yeah, like that's all I remember. It was during a wasn't it
- 51:34wasn't It wasn't a hurricane, but it was it was tropical storm. Yeah,
- 51:36it was a tropical storm in Florida. They were in the keys.
- 51:38So I think somebody would come out. Yeah, so you think like,
- 51:45yeah, you think everybody's going to stay home and stay out of the storm.
- 51:49But oh, I wonder what happened to Lisa. No, I feel
- 51:53like I mean somebody because I don't know why she would pull over otherwise and
- 51:58roll down or if it was her boyfriend. Wouldn't she rolled down her window
- 52:00all the way or wouldn't you just get out or not get out and have
- 52:05them get in? Have them get in? Yeah? Right? Why would
- 52:07you just roll down your window a little bit for your boyfriend? Right?
- 52:10Or if you're mad, you're like, fuck, you go leave me alone
- 52:14and drive off like you wouldn't even stop, right, I I am?
- 52:17And then there's no signs of a struggle in the car. And why was
- 52:22her purse dry? Why was her purse somebody came back and put it back
- 52:27when the rain stops. I don't know. They risked bringing her purse back.
- 52:31That doesn't make any sense. Why would they do that? I don't
- 52:34know. I'm I'm my mind is going one hundred miles a minute, and
- 52:37I have maybe it happened, right, I don't know. I don't have
- 52:42the answer. I wish we did. I know, poor Lisa, poor
- 52:45Lisa and her family. I know her parents are respect to them. Yeah,
- 52:50that's just I know. My heart goes out to her whole family.
- 52:53Having an unsolved murder in your family, someone you know, I can't imagine,
- 53:00and you ever get over it? Right? I mean, no matter
- 53:02what I think, any kind of crime like that. I don't know Doug
- 53:07have scratches on its face, but then I don't know they could have.
- 53:10That's true. I don't know they shaving. I don't know who knows.
- 53:15But anyway, okay, I want to think True Crime Daily for hosting us,
- 53:20and I want to thank all of you guys for watching us. We
- 53:22appreciate you, every single one of you. And you guys can go to
- 53:27our website, Crimesoconsequences dot com if you want to see our merchandise that we
- 53:31have ought. You're gonna wear a shirt, Yeah, I wore it this
- 53:36past weekend, so I or this past week so I haven't done the laundry
- 53:38yet. Next, and we have a Patreon that you can follow. We
- 53:45had a trial in the past two weeks, so we have not been able
- 53:47to put stuff on Patreon, but usually every week we release an episode that's
- 53:52exclusive to our patrons that subscribe to Patreon dot com slash T and T Crimes.
- 53:58You can also get these same episode ad free and also this episode ad
- 54:05free in an early release if you go to Apple Podcast and you subscribe there.
- 54:12And what else. We haven't Instagram but we haven't done that a long
- 54:15time, right. We have Instagram a Facebook, but it's not a lot.
- 54:20We're pretty busy, you know, we're busy gals. I mean bratzy
- 54:24lawyers slash pod Yes or so, we'll get it. We'll get it caught
- 54:29up one day and it'll be fabulous. Yeah. Absolutely, I think that's
- 54:32it until our next episode. Don't kill each other, Bye bye