Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The United States Proves God! (and other listener calls)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking, feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. I must confess
- 0:58I don't have a lot prepared today. Mostly I just wanted to spend time
- 1:03with you, which sounds really cornball when I say it that way, but
- 1:08it's how I feel. I was here, I was editing, I was
- 1:11working, I was getting everything updated and taking care of the website and looking
- 1:15at the tour schedule, and I thought, I missed you, so without
- 1:21a whole lot to talk about, hoping that you will fill in the blank,
- 1:25so I thought maybe we could share time and fellowship together. This is
- 1:29the religious part of me coming out, because we would call it fellowship,
- 1:33which usually involved food. I wish we had something here. Speaking of food,
- 1:38I have a confession, and this is how lazy or pathetic I have
- 1:42become. I was just tired, right tired. Natalie's got us doing yoga,
- 1:49which is really hard, ninety six degrees. My legs are tired,
- 1:55my back is tired. I was just walking around the house like a newborn
- 1:59jury trying to get up the stairs after an hour of intense resistance training.
- 2:06Really is what it is. And We've been playing tennis quite a bit and
- 2:09I'm not getting any younger. And I just had one of those days where
- 2:13I didn't want to leave the house. Have you ever had those days?
- 2:15I don't feel like leaving today. I just want to stay home, be
- 2:20a homebody. But I was craving. I was craving a Chocolate's milkshank.
- 2:29There's the car. I could probably get down to the ice cream spot in
- 2:34ten minutes, five bucks in a drive through window, and I'm set,
- 2:38But damn it, I didn't want to leave. I'm a homebody. I'm
- 2:43want to stay home. I'm sore, and I'm tired, and I'm whining
- 2:46and I'm cranking blah blah blah. So I pulled out my phone and opened
- 2:53the door dash app. There's the restaurant that serves the milkshake. Oh goody.
- 3:01I scroll down chocolate milkshake with whipped cream, no cherry, add to
- 3:10kart and then I look down and I see five ninety five and there is
- 3:17a three dollars order fee or something, and then there is a two dollars
- 3:25delivery fee. And would you like to tip your dasher? Now, for
- 3:34a few who may not know what door dash is, I'm guessing most people
- 3:38do, but I know we do have an international audience. For just a
- 3:40second, give me just a second to explain. Imagine the replicator in Star
- 3:46Trek, the next generation. Jean Luke Picard goes up and he says tea
- 3:52earl gray hot, and he says it into the little machine. The door
- 3:55opens up. It's magic. There's the tea Earl gray hot. Right,
- 4:00it appears right there in front of them. That's what door dash is.
- 4:05You just go and you find the food that you want, and you click
- 4:09little buttons and you wait usually thirty forty five minutes, and miraculously, some
- 4:15angel, some good samaritan, brings the food and lays it at your feet,
- 4:23or at least on your front porch and you open the door and awe,
- 4:28there's the food from the restaurant that you didn't have to go to the
- 4:31restaurant for. You take it in and eat it without any inconvenience. It's
- 4:38beautiful and it's expensive. Five ninety five for the milkshake, two dollars convenience
- 4:47fee, three dollars delivery fee. Would you like to tip your dash hair?
- 4:53Okay? Fine? Fourteen dollars fourteen or fifteen dollars for a milkshake?
- 4:59And I just shared at my phone. I'm just staring in my social conscience
- 5:03is kicking it? What the hell is wrong with you? Get in the
- 5:09car and drive down, get a milk, pay one third of what it
- 5:13costs, and get yourself some ice cream. And I have done neither.
- 5:18If the app is right here, I have yet to click final or buy
- 5:24or whatever the button is, and I've yet to leave to go down and
- 5:30get it for myself. You caught me at a weird moment. You ever
- 5:32crave something? I went through a thing a few weeks ago, pancakes every
- 5:39day morning, midday evening. I told Natalie, I'm craving pancakes. She's
- 5:44like, really, of course, it's got to be one of the worst
- 5:46things for you, because if you do the real syrup, I think real
- 5:50sugary syrup, that's not the half cowl or low col or diet or sugar
- 5:56free or whatever. I think you're looking at one hundred and twenty coaleries for
- 6:00two table spoons of syrup. And if you have seen my pancake plate,
- 6:06it's swimming in syrup. The syrup is just dancing all around the pancakes.
- 6:13I can't have two tablespoons, so now I'm doing them at okay, at
- 6:18least a half a coppa syrup. How many tablespoons is that? Plus the
- 6:24calorie counter of the pankins? Is this a twelve hundred calorie pancake? Uh?
- 6:31Okay, what was zaya? What else was I talking about. I've
- 6:35got a monitor here in my office with cameras that are mounted on the front
- 6:42side of my house, and I find myself looking up a lot more here,
- 6:46and in fact I'm doing it as I'm recording. We've had a series
- 6:49of break ins in the neighborhood, most of them at night. Most of
- 6:56them have been with vehicles that have been parked out in driveways, are on
- 7:00the street. I was walking Linus around the block and there's a white pickup
- 7:05truck driver's side window totally smashed out. Who knows what was stolen out of
- 7:13the car. Some people have lost tools. Someone left their cell phone in
- 7:18a car. They lost the phone. There was a construction company that was
- 7:23building a house not far from here. Somebody showed up in the middle of
- 7:26the night with a flatbed trailer and they put about ten thousand dollars worth of
- 7:33lumber and building materials that had been laying there. They were about to frame
- 7:39the house. They showed up the next day those materials had all been stolen.
- 7:44They just installed a street camera near the front of the addition. But
- 7:48I find myself thinking, okay, cars in the garage, even if I
- 7:54have to take all the cramp in the garage and mash it up against the
- 7:57walls. I don't want my cars out there. And now I'm all paranoid.
- 8:03And then you get mad because you think, go get your own,
- 8:07Go build your own, go earn your own. Why aren't you taking from
- 8:15other people? Why are you stealing? Why are you breaking the law?
- 8:18Why are you complicating the lives? You know? I always tell Natalie when
- 8:22we talk about those who do horrible things in this world, how hard is
- 8:26it really to do the right thing? If everybody would just do right by
- 8:33each other, imagine the world we would live in. And I know that
- 8:37sounds like kum bay y'ah. But why? Why is it kumb by y'ah?
- 8:41Why have we become so cynical that we think, wow, whatever?
- 8:46Why can't people do right by each other? Why can't people be kind to
- 8:54each other? Why does there have to be so much cruelty and parasitic behavior,
- 9:00sadism and predation, corruption? Why why would you smash your way into
- 9:07someone else's life to take something that is not yours and cause fear and anger
- 9:15and strife and stress and cheat someone else out of something that is theirs?
- 9:22What does that produce for you? What if you were to take all of
- 9:26the energy, the time, the will, the commitment that you spent taking
- 9:31from other people and you were to build something, If you were to develop
- 9:37yourself, your character, your skill set. It's been a hell of a
- 9:41lot harder apparently to build than it is to steal. Around here, so
- 9:46I'm watching closely, hoping I don't come home to a broken window or something
- 9:54someday. What else is going on? Oh, in fact, I'm going
- 10:00to wait right here. I'm going to actually hold on as you do me
- 10:05a solid and you open up your podcast app and you subscribe to my second
- 10:13show, True Stories with Seth Andrews. The website is True Stories podcast dot
- 10:22com. The show comes out three times a week, roughly five to seven
- 10:30minutes. It can be true crime, celebrity trivia, weird news, stupid
- 10:35criminals. You just never know what you're going to get. But I take
- 10:41a lot of time and care to make sure I vet the stories. But
- 10:46I really would like to see more people notice it and enjoy it, spread
- 10:48the word about it. So right now, and I'm just going to hang
- 10:52here while you pull up your podcast app and subscribe. Do True Stories with
- 11:00Seth Andrews. Just do it. I'm just gonna sit here and scroll my
- 11:05phone for just a second. Here, all right, I'm gonna check the
- 11:07weather because we've got storms on the horizon. So are you logging on?
- 11:11Are you subscribing? I hope you are. Chance of showers seventy one,
- 11:16maybe some severe weather in a company days, Wendy, so tennis is probably
- 11:22out. But I can do yoga. That's been good exercise, doing that
- 11:26a couple of times. Okay, have you done it? It's free and
- 11:31I appreciate the support. Podcasting has been a weird thing. We've seen adjustments
- 11:37going on in the industry and certain platforms like Apple are paying less or they
- 11:46are they've changed the model for what they record as listens, which has made
- 11:50it harder for those of us who do this full time. What else?
- 11:56Was there anything else on my I see the switchboard is populating? Oh.
- 12:03I have been invited to be the occasional post on the Line, which is
- 12:11a YouTube show. Jimmy Snow and Matt Delahunty and Forrest Valcai and Shannon Q
- 12:16and a bunch of others. They all jump in and they host and there's
- 12:20sort of a mix of hosts throughout the month. And so apparently I'm a
- 12:26regular. I'm going to be coming in while still focusing on my work here,
- 12:31and I'm going to be on shows wherever I'm invited. There are no
- 12:33restrictions. But they said, look, would you like to come and host
- 12:37for us a couple of times a month or whenever needed? And I said,
- 12:41if schedule allows, I would be honored. So we'll take calls.
- 12:46I guess we'll take a lot of theist calls. They have some odd ones
- 12:50on the line. I tend to handle calls a little bit differently, and
- 12:56I told Jimmy this, I want to make sure I'm I'm doing doing what
- 13:01they need done the way they want it done. But we'll see. We'll
- 13:05see if my tempo, my pacing serves the show. If the way I
- 13:09host and occasionally go off on a tangent and monologue will be welcome, or
- 13:15it'll drive everybody crazy and there will be complaint letters, and then they will
- 13:18wish me in a good day. Thanks for stopping by, Seth. Appreciate
- 13:24your boom. This was very temporary, very temporary. Well, we'll call
- 13:28you, pal, We'll call you. I don't know that starts in the
- 13:31month of May. But of course our work here will continue uninterrupted, and
- 13:37you have my word on that. Let's talk to you, Linda from Buffalo,
- 13:45New York. What's on your mind? What's on my mind is if
- 13:50we were to take out the whole religious aspect of what's going on in the
- 13:56world today, what would things look like? I mean, what would the
- 14:01Israelis and the Palestinians be fighting over I just had this conversation recently. If
- 14:09Hamas wasn't saying that they had a divine right, if they were not on
- 14:13a kind of holy war jihad against the Infidel, etc. If they didn't
- 14:18have a religiously excused or rationalized hatred of the Jews, if people weren't saying
- 14:26that Israel can do whatever it wants because it is Zion, and Israel is
- 14:31God sovereign with God's chosen people, and the establishment of the Jewish state is
- 14:35a precursor to the apocalypse or the end times or Christ returning, which is
- 14:41supposed to be an amazing that people weren't using religious excuses to do what they
- 14:46do. Imagine what a world you and I would live in. I've had
- 14:50that very thought. Do you feel like if religion was removed from the equation,
- 14:56from your opinion, do you feel like the conflict would go away?
- 15:01Or do you think tribalism remains a problem. We are tribalistic. We do
- 15:05get weird about our in groups and out groups and vilifying the others. Yeah,
- 15:09we do, and we'll find any excuse to dominate. Personally, I
- 15:16think we're a parasite on this planet. I don't think we belong here.
- 15:20We don't belong on planet Earth. Well, the human species is not exactly
- 15:26helping much to preserve the planet, you know. And when we say we're
- 15:31going to save Mother Earth, no, we're going to save our own asses.
- 15:37That's what we're out to do. I do get cynical about our mismanagement
- 15:41of resources, what we are guilty of doing and not doing it is frustrating,
- 15:46but I don't go that far. This is our home, right,
- 15:50Carl Sagan said, the only home we've ever known. So I just think
- 15:56we need to be better stewards of that home. That's fair, isn't it.
- 15:58Yeah, that's fair. And I want to thank you for last year
- 16:03when you gave me a very nice birthday greeting when I turned seventy six.
- 16:08I'm now seventy seven. You are most welcome, And I was always nice
- 16:14to be asked to participate in somebody's special occasion so you'd be safe up there
- 16:18in New York. Okay, okay, and you take care of yourself and
- 16:22don't do anything I wouldn't do. You got it all right? Take care?
- 16:26I guess that means no door dashing milkshakes because it's irresponsible to do so
- 16:33stand by. I got a guy who says he's got proof we're a Christian
- 16:37nation. Plus whatever else you want to talk about. We continue next on
- 16:51my speaking roster. May nineteenth, I will be at c FI West,
- 16:56Los Angeles. Would love to see you there. The Secular Student Alliance has
- 17:00invited me to go out and present. That's Little Rock, Arkansas mid June.
- 17:04Then Denver, Saint Louis, Fort Worth, Houston, Sarnia, Ontario,
- 17:10Toronto, Lexington, Bentonville, and it looks like Knoxville, Tennessee wants
- 17:15to have me out later this year. Seth Andrews dot com slash events as
- 17:22the schedule links and all you need to know James at six one zero.
- 17:30Are you there? Yeah? You hear me? I can, James,
- 17:33What is on your mind? My friend? Yeah? So, like I
- 17:37guess, my atheist journey starts a long time ago actually, probably in college
- 17:41and everything, and you're one of the first people that, like I looked
- 17:45up after because I was still going to Bible study and everything, or in
- 17:48college and stuff like that coming right out because I was in like those youth
- 17:51groups I was part of some Christian like summer camp thing where I was a
- 17:56camp counselor been going there for like years. Then I just became disillusioned with
- 18:00everything. What's interesting is that I like that you had like man Lisa Thomas
- 18:06on and everything like that, right, And I don't know if I found
- 18:08out about Mandsa Thomas through you or just doing some searching. But when I
- 18:14started my atheist journey and I'm I'm African American, what's interesting is that I
- 18:18didn't find a lot of people that look like me that were doing it,
- 18:22and I ended up in this kind of weird community called the consciousness community.
- 18:30Now me personally, I find this as like is it my entertainment now?
- 18:33And they push a lot of like kind of weird things cause they say that
- 18:38they are atheists, but they believe in a lot of weird like conspiracy theories
- 18:44or like some other stuff like that spiritualism. That's where I found out about
- 18:48people like because I know you had a conversation with someone who used to be
- 18:52part of the Nwopians, and I learned about those people like through that community.
- 18:56James, tell me what the name of the organization is again, I'm
- 19:00gonna look it up. Real quick. What's it called. Oh, it's
- 19:02not an organization. The term is called conscious community. It's a whole bunch
- 19:07of different people. Okay, so it doesn't even just include atheists. This
- 19:10is just like it's a type of community. Yeah, it's mainly online.
- 19:17Though, this is not anything that's really like I don't want to use this
- 19:21term, but if you ever heard the term whole tephi just kind of derogatory.
- 19:26But if you ever heard the term whotep that's kind of what they kind
- 19:30of fall under in a sense. But I guess I was tracted this community
- 19:34before I met people like you know, Mendecent Thomas and everything like that.
- 19:37But I wanted to see, like your opinion on like how the atheist community
- 19:44in general, because a lot of the arguments is that what they will say
- 19:48is that like, well, atheist is mainly a white thing, and atheism
- 19:51is a white idea and it's a white religion, and that this is something
- 19:56that's not of African people, of people African descent, and it's unnatur for
- 20:00you to be atheist if you're black. What are your thoughts on that?
- 20:03I actually had a conversation. I've had many conversations with people in the black
- 20:08non believers community. Mandisa and I spoke about it. It is very true
- 20:15that the atheist activist movement, I hate the word movement, but you get
- 20:21me, has looked a lot like me. White cis male, hetero male.
- 20:27But we are seeing slowly a greater diversification. We're seeing more color and
- 20:36culture as part of these conversations with black atheists. According to people like Mandisa
- 20:44Is, I understand it. When it comes to black non believers, it's
- 20:48a double whammy because the church is so integrated into the civil rights movement.
- 20:55Martin Luther King Junior being a reverend, we saw churches which or hubs for
- 21:02civil rights and racial equality discussions throughout the mid twentieth century, and the church
- 21:07played a big role. And so we're seeing this embedding in African American cultures
- 21:14and communities where the church has become part of the cultural identity. So now
- 21:19if you become an atheist as an African American, they say, not only
- 21:23have you betrayed God, but you betrayed your race. And that's a reality
- 21:29that makes the journey out of religions, out of the church more difficult for
- 21:33people of color. And it's a very real thing, but we are seeing
- 21:40more and more of them. I think it's going to be a slow climb.
- 21:42I think it's going to take a long long time to see a true
- 21:47representation of non believers who are not white males like me. But it's slowly
- 21:52beginning to change. Have you seen a shift at all in your own life?
- 21:57Are you meeting anybody who says I don't buy it. Yes, there's
- 22:02a couple of people that atheistic that are black and everything like that, even
- 22:06online, even within that community. So the first person I found with somebody
- 22:08named Uncle wes or as the God Killer, and he used to be I
- 22:14don't want to say he was ever a part of the Newabina, but he
- 22:17believed in some of the beliefs long time ago that he rejected him and he's
- 22:19like pure science and they kind of go against him because he's strictly on scientific
- 22:26literacy and everything like that, and he called himself an Athey he does not
- 22:30believe in God or anything like that. So people like him that actually pushed
- 22:33scientific literacy. I feel like that is a step forward, at least within
- 22:40the black community, so we can get away from religiosity in our community.
- 22:44Yeah, It is interesting. We talk all the time about Martin Luther King
- 22:48Junior, and Malcolm X, but few people talk about a Philip Randolph and
- 22:52so many of the other secular activists during the Civil War and then through the
- 22:59twentieth century the civil rights movement. I think educating people about those secular activists
- 23:04is certainly something we could all do a better job. That's a really good
- 23:08point. Yeah, thank you so much for calling I myself. I want
- 23:14to see a movement that doesn't look as much like me, and it looks
- 23:18a lot more like all of us. Thanks for Colin. I appreciate you
- 23:22being a part of the conversation. Okay, Yeah, thank you. So
- 23:25all right? Six one three? Is it? John? Hi? How
- 23:30are you? I'm well, what's on your mind? Okay? I was
- 23:33doing to speak to the previous caller, and I got the impression that you
- 23:38believed that black are being oppressed. But it was Catholic church, and I
- 23:44want to tell you that nothing could be further from the truth. Okay.
- 23:47I didn't say anything, whoa, whoa, whoa. I didn't say anything
- 23:49about the Catholic Church. In fact, I was speaking about how churches were
- 23:56hubs during the Civil rights movement, and that has caused religious institutions to become
- 24:03more and more embedded in African American culture. But there was no mention made
- 24:07of the Catholic Church in relation to black people. So where'd you get that?
- 24:15Well, I apologize, I apologize if I misrepresented your position. However,
- 24:19I will it to say that Black people believing in the faith is the
- 24:22best thing that ever happened to us because under faith we had businesses, we
- 24:26had schools, we had families who were prospects. It was only until we
- 24:30became atheists that things fall apart from us. When you speak about liberation,
- 24:37you speak about equality, family, community, charity, prosperity, not just
- 24:44in black communities but across the human spectrum. What about that is religious?
- 24:51Couldn't you do all of that without the church? It was done with the
- 24:56Church's the point. That's not my question. Couldn't you do it without the
- 25:00church? It's all human action reaction, right, I mean, this is
- 25:03something that requires no God belief, does it? Well, you can do
- 25:08with other church, but it's bear with it. Because we humans, we
- 25:11need, we need to believe in something higher than ourselves. Well well,
- 25:15well, wait a minute, where do you get that claim. Can you
- 25:18demonstrate that there is something higher, some greater intelligence, prime mover, a
- 25:23heavenly father. Can you prove that to me? Yes, I can,
- 25:29I can. I can really invest the example right now you're living it.
- 25:33It's called the United States of America. The Final Powers were all questions and
- 25:37they believed in the faith, and they use the tank commands to start the
- 25:41Western civilization, the vat civilization to the natives, and they ended human sacrifice,
- 25:48chield sacrifice and it's slavery, and gave you the very thing what you
- 25:51have. Now, let's speak on the very show to me to denounce it.
- 25:56Can I ask you where you where you got the information about the founding
- 26:00Fathers and the Ten Commandments and the liberation of their slaves. Can you tell
- 26:04me what the educational model was? Where did you learn this? I went
- 26:10to school? Thank you? What school did you go to? What type
- 26:14of school? Well, not to answer that question, but I do know
- 26:18that I got from there. You don't have to answer the question of how
- 26:22you learned it, but you want to make the claim that it's true.
- 26:29So if I was to come to you, and I was to say that
- 26:32I was a devout Muslim And it was Allah that the Founders be leaved in,
- 26:37and it was Kuranic truth that liberated the people, established the United States
- 26:42and set the captives free. I learned it in school, but I won't
- 26:47tell you what school that is. You would accept that at face value?
- 26:53I said to an educated man, mister Andrews, it wasn't the Muslims,
- 26:59historianist, how do you explain that the Christianities was proper religion? And how
- 27:03do you how do I explain the popularity? Well, actually, there are
- 27:10a great many explanations for the ubiquity of beliefs. It doesn't mean that those
- 27:15beliefs are true. The argument from popularity is popular, but mass illusion is
- 27:22still the illusion. We still have to go back to the original question is
- 27:26it true? And then the next question is how do you know that?
- 27:30And I could educate you about the Founders. I could talk about Benjamin Franklin,
- 27:36who often ridiculed the Puritans, Thomas Paine writing The Age of Reason,
- 27:41Thomas Jefferson slicing these supernatural verses how to the New Testament? With the Jefferson
- 27:48Bible currently on display at the Smithsonian. George Washington not taking his presidential Oath
- 27:55on the Bible and so on. We could talk about the Treaty of Tripoli,
- 28:00which was signed by John Adams bearing the words the United States of America
- 28:07is not in any sense founded on the Christian religion. We could get into
- 28:10the Danbury Baptists and the Congregationalists, as Jefferson referenced, the wall of separation
- 28:17between church and state. I could read the Constitution, the governing document of
- 28:22the United States for you. Would it make any difference. I'm not convinced
- 28:27that it would, because I sense you have made an emotional connection. You
- 28:33feel deeply we are a Christian nation and all good things came from your religion.
- 28:37But that doesn't really make it true, does it. Because you show
- 28:42me all that I'll look at, I'll pay attention, and it's food and
- 28:48correct. I would shair the mind. That's fair. I would very much
- 28:52encourage you. Just check it out. You can Google, search, Verify.
- 28:56Don't take my word for it. You want to check out the Treaty
- 29:00of Tripoli, check out the Jefferson Bible. You'll want to hopefully purchase and
- 29:06read Thomas Paines The Age of Reason. Check out the establishment clause in the
- 29:12United States Constitution. And also while you are there, search for the word
- 29:18God anywhere anywhere in the Constitution, God, Jesus, Yahweh, whatever,
- 29:23just search it. Are you telling me that's not there? I am telling
- 29:29you the word God appears nowhere in the United States Constitution. Okay, So
- 29:41I have I wronged to believe that Jane Parters were Christians, that some were
- 29:47some were Deists like Jefferson. But honestly, that's probably the wrong question to
- 29:52be asking. Because when they establish the United States, despite whatever personal religious
- 29:59belief they may or may not have had, their desire was to set up
- 30:03a secular government which protected the private expression of religious belief. But we were
- 30:10not a theocracy. We were not a church state. This would be a
- 30:14pluralistic society where all are equal people who are Christians, Muslims, Hindu seeks
- 30:21people of all faiths and none. That was the intent. So whether or
- 30:26not George Washington believed in Jesus or quoted Jesus at some time in his life,
- 30:32he and the other founders set the Constitution in place so that we were
- 30:37not a religious nation. So it was meant to be secular. Yes,
- 30:44the American experiment was something unique in our history, a country set up to
- 30:49represent everyone equally. Granted, that's not how it has played out, but
- 30:55that was the desire of the founders. Well quickly if I'm wrong. But
- 31:00was there a time in course that it is to say in godbage trust?
- 31:04Well, actually, I haven't know if that's the case. How come on,
- 31:07you I state money that says in God we trust. You can't explain
- 31:11that for me? I can I Since you may already know the answers to
- 31:15these, have you done your homework on this and you just you know you're
- 31:19trying to stir the pot on the show. I want to give you the
- 31:22benefit of the doubt. I have some education, but I'm not American,
- 31:26Okay. God was not originally on our currency. The original motto for the
- 31:33United States was e pluribus unum out of many one, again referencing a pluralistic,
- 31:41equal diverse democracy. In God We Trust was added to the money in
- 31:47coins right after the Civil War and on paper money during the Communist Scare and
- 31:55the Satanic Panic of the nineteen fifties. It was Congress who added it nearly
- 32:00two hundred years after the Declaration of Independence was signed under God didn't originally appear
- 32:07in the Pledge of Allegiance written by Francis Bellamy, who by the way,
- 32:13was a socialist. That was added in the mid twentieth century. As well.
- 32:19God was not woven into the fabric of the United States originally. It
- 32:25was added in later by Christian activists. And why would we want this to
- 32:32be a Christian nation anyway? Why would God need a state church? I
- 32:37thought it was all about a personal relationship, an omnipotent, omniscient, omni
- 32:43benevolent Jesus God whoever, would not need to institutionalize religion because it's all about
- 32:51the heart, isn't it? It is? But I want to ask you
- 32:54a question. I never heard you. Y are a person who's on the
- 33:00front of money or on a pledge of allegiance pledge allegiance to the name of
- 33:04God that person was a socialist. Is to say, yeah, Francis Bellamy
- 33:07was a democratic socialist. He actually wrote the pledge, not for the United
- 33:13States government. It was published in a local paper for I think a youth
- 33:20organization, and it was picked up. It just sort of caught fire.
- 33:24Francis Bellamy never intended for us to have a national pledge. He may have
- 33:30been delighted at the idea that his work went national, But it was not
- 33:36contracted by the Congress, it was not asked for by the people. It
- 33:39was created as kind of a one off and through a series of circumstances sort
- 33:45of became the Pledge. But Bellamy himself, he was a democratic socialist.
- 33:52He didn't think Jesus would support a class system because we would all be of
- 33:58the same class. And that's surprise as a lot of people who are defenders
- 34:01of under God in the Pledge. Oh, I see, okay, I
- 34:07see. So that's another question, was that I stays based on capitalism.
- 34:14Well that I can't say. I'm not an economist. I don't think Jesus
- 34:16would be a las a fair capitalist. Jesus wouldn't worship billionaires, the hoarders
- 34:23of wealth, with so much suffering in this world. I think Jesus would
- 34:29reward hard work, would appreciate and lawd success, even prosperity. But do
- 34:37I think unfettered, uncheckedsted I'm talking about Jesus in the theoretical sense, is
- 34:45based in the Bible. Whether or not there was an actual Jesus is a
- 34:49totally different question. I mean, does Jesus in the Bible and the New
- 34:52Testament talk about capitalism. As I recall, he went into uh, tear
- 34:58things up with the money changer because they had all become greedy because they were
- 35:02hoarders of wealth when there was so much suffering. But whether or not there
- 35:07was an actual Jesus to Caesar, what is Caesar gavant to God? What
- 35:12is God's? What's your point? That was one of his quotes. Well,
- 35:20who determines what belongs to Caesar and what belongs to God? And which
- 35:23God? And then can you prove that God existed? You and I could
- 35:28probably chit chat for a long long time. Ultimately, let me say this
- 35:32because I wanted to spend plenty of time with you, but I also want
- 35:36to make sure I'm doing my due diligence with the rest of the switchboard.
- 35:40Take this with you. The founding fathers were not all Christians. The Constitution
- 35:46has no mention of God. The inclusion of God language on our money and
- 35:52in our pledge came long decades, even hundreds of years after the founding of
- 35:59this country. And honestly, why would God need a state church if it's
- 36:06all about a relationship with individuals in their hearts. Just take that with you
- 36:10chew want it, and if you get a chance, pick up Andrew Seidel's
- 36:15book called The Founding Myth because it dismantles this claim that we are a Christian
- 36:22nation. Okay, ask your one wild questions there quickly. Let's say you
- 36:30have your way and Christianity goes away. What would you do then? What
- 36:35would your job be? What would my job be? Yeah, because let's
- 36:40assume that all of a sudden you succeed and Christianity disappears and everyone becomes atheist.
- 36:45What would you do? Actually, if Christianity disappears, we still have
- 36:50thousands of other religions, including the second most powerful religion on the planet,
- 36:55which is Islam, a religion I consider to be the most It's dangerous right
- 37:00now. If religion overall was to go away, I would still be a
- 37:07humanist activist. I would still be trying to promote humanist values, trying to
- 37:13create opportunities where we root ourselves in the real world. We'd have community both
- 37:17here and in the local, regional, and national level. I would still
- 37:22be speaking to my values as a crusader, because that's kind of my temperaments.
- 37:29We all want to make a difference out there using our gifts. This
- 37:31is kind of what I know how to do. I would hope you would
- 37:35feel the same. Okay, Okay, well all right, see you.
- 37:39It's hard because I have these conversations a lot, and I do make the
- 37:45mistake of thinking that other people already know these things. We've talked about the
- 37:52Christian Nation claim so often, especially with Christian nationalism. I've got whole videos
- 37:57and podcasts out there dismantling the Christian Nation claim. There's also another angle to
- 38:04this. People, especially in the Christian faith in this country, deify the
- 38:09Founders. They assumed they were all Sunday go to meet in Jesus Love and
- 38:15Bible literalist Christians, and they treat them like gods. The Founders wanted this.
- 38:24The Founders wrote that the Founders said, we see the Second Amendment warriors
- 38:30doing this. You can't change the Second Amendment because the Founders, the Founders,
- 38:35the Founders. There's an authoritarianism going on. There's a kind of sacrosancts
- 38:44portrait of perfection that some people have about these men. And I'm like,
- 38:50well, they were men, often problematic men. Yes, The American Experiment
- 38:57was, and in many ways a remarkable and wonderful thing. But these were
- 39:04the same people who didn't allow women to serve in government to kept women subservient,
- 39:12many owned slaves. George Washington had dentures with slaves teeth in them.
- 39:20These people were ignorant about so much they didn't even know what germs were back
- 39:24then. If you were to go back and show them Wi Fi, they
- 39:30would have thought it was witchcraft. This idea that because they said it hundreds
- 39:37of years ago, that it's got literally gospel is crazy. Stand by more
- 39:45of your calls on Whatever's on your Mind next. Thanks for your support on
- 39:58Patreon. You get the show early and commercial free Patreon dot com. Slash
- 40:05Seth Andrews. I've got Richie at six' one nine. Are you there,
- 40:13Hey, Sam? Can you hear me? I can. What's on
- 40:15your mind? Well, first, I want to say my I understand you're
- 40:17coming too La on May, and I'll actually be there to see your lecture.
- 40:21So I'm really excited about that, looking forward to shaking your hand.
- 40:23It's going to be fun. Well, I'll make this quick. So of
- 40:25course I'm a non believer and I just wanted to your opinion, I kind
- 40:30of set up having to argue about my non belief in my atheism. You
- 40:36know, I have a lot of people who are non believers in my family,
- 40:37friends who insist that I explain to them why, you know, I'm
- 40:42a non believer and give them a good reason for it. And I'm kind
- 40:45of just at this point where I'm like, you know, if that's what
- 40:46you want to believe, that's totally cool. I'm not convinced. I don't
- 40:50think I ever will be, and that's completely fine. And I guess my
- 40:53question is, do you think that's a cop out? What do you think
- 40:57about that? I'd be really interested to hear your grants and thank you for
- 41:00your time. Oh would you like me to answer off the air? Then?
- 41:04Is that it? Or off the call? Off the call? That
- 41:06way? I don't keep your time too long, don't belongs to you,
- 41:10all right, thanks for calling, ms celin. If I walk into a
- 41:15room and let's say it's a Christian, okay, and they fold their arms
- 41:22and set their jaw and stomp their feet and they say, I demand to
- 41:27know. I demand to know. I expect you to tell me why you
- 41:31reject God, why you reject the Bible. Why you don't believe in my
- 41:37Jesus? I demand to know right now. If that's the attitude, my
- 41:45first thought is, good luck with that. I don't really care what you
- 41:50expect or demand. You don't get to expect or demand anything of me.
- 41:58That I walk in here and demand and that you explain or prove your religion
- 42:04or did I just walk in the room. Am I the one trespassing?
- 42:07Looks like you're the one trespassing. This is totally different than a good faith
- 42:13interlocutor who says I don't understand, I'm curious. Can you help me?
- 42:20Can you explain why you don't believe? You can hear that intent in their
- 42:24voice, you can see it on their face. You know this is a
- 42:27good faith agent. That's different. I'm all over those conversations. Let's talk,
- 42:32right But those people who walk in with that huff of expectation, looking
- 42:39down the nose of superiority to say, well, explain yourself, man,
- 42:46I'm like, well, you can expect an explanation, but I don't owe
- 42:52you. At the time of day, life is short. The truth is,
- 42:55we often have a desire, we get caught in the trap. Here
- 43:02forgive me I'm going to just go off for a second. But I walk
- 43:06into a room and someone says, well, why don't you believe the Bible
- 43:08is true? My first inclination, because I'm relatively tooled up, is to
- 43:15go bullet point by bullet point to lay it out. I'm gonna plead my
- 43:20case. Fine, you put me on the stand, or wanted to put
- 43:22me on the stand. Okay, Well, no one knows who wrote the
- 43:24Book of Genesis. Cosmology has disproved that we live on a young earth.
- 43:30Genesis one and two disagree with each other on the order of creation. Plus
- 43:35you've got donkeys that speak Hebrew and snakes whispering in the ears of a rib
- 43:42woman who was the wife of a dirt man who wandered an enchanted garden.
- 43:46Then you've got no proof of the exodus that that ever happened the Israelites coming
- 43:52out of Egypt. Noah's flood has been totally debunked by geologic science. People
- 43:58never lived to be a thousand years old. Then we've got flying chariots of
- 44:01fire, slavery unfulfilled prophecy, Bible heroes who flew up into the sky on
- 44:08flying chariots. A man who survived underwater for three days as he was trapped
- 44:14in a giant prison fish supermen who gained power based on the length of their
- 44:20hair. Right, we're not even out of the first part of the Old
- 44:22Testament, but you and I are laying it out contradiction, wild mythology,
- 44:28slavery, misogyny, genocide, infanticide, human sacrifice, spinning into the New
- 44:36Testament. No proof of Jesus. I mean, we are going full tilt.
- 44:39Right, we are in our element, hoping that they will see that
- 44:45it's contradictory, it's unsupported, it's ridiculous and often offensive. But what happens
- 44:51Do they look at us and say, Wow, good point, that's interesting.
- 44:54I'm going to go and dig further to make sure I'm believing true two
- 45:00things. I am going to do some homework and read beyond the Bible and
- 45:04the theologians thank you so much for opening this door of potential for me.
- 45:08And then they walk off into Reasonville. Does that ever happen? No,
- 45:13not with those people, not with the agents of expectation, Because the goal
- 45:19was never to find out what's true or to understand you and me in good
- 45:22faith. The goal was to try to fix us. We're broken, we
- 45:27have to be repaired. We're doomed, we have to be rescued. We're
- 45:30lost, we have to be found. We're damned, we must be saved.
- 45:34They are not listening. They are a radio tower that is sending but
- 45:38not receiving any signal. Add to that the arrogance of demanding that I justify
- 45:47myself. No, no, I just smile and say you expect that's nice,
- 45:54have a good day, and I go get on with the rest of
- 45:59my life. So that's the difference. Good faith interlocutter who wants to know
- 46:04superior apologist who wants to condescend and overstep. Those are two different scenarios.
- 46:14I've got David, David, are you with me? My friend? I
- 46:19am, thank you so much for taking my calls. Set very kind.
- 46:22What's on your mind? Well, I'm gay, I'm an atheist, and
- 46:25I'm also a nurse. For some strange reason, nursing is a profession where
- 46:30there are a lot of religious people. I've never been able to figure this
- 46:34out because we all go to school and study science to get this job.
- 46:38But nonetheless, there is a hydrogradelar thegiosity in this profession in order to keep
- 46:45my job oftentimes after remain closeted both about being an atheist and about being gay.
- 46:51This makes the workplace very difficult to navigate, hard to be in a
- 46:53science based profession with superstition all around you. Yeah, it's really weird because
- 47:01you know, I mean, we don't think that, you know, I
- 47:05don't know somebody got sick because they walked under a ladder or acrossed the paths
- 47:09of the black cat. But people really are into the little God trip,
- 47:15and I don't know why. We've actually had some conversations about why smart people
- 47:22believe dumb things. There's a book by that title. What's the line.
- 47:25Smart people are the best at rationalizing opinions or beliefs that they came to for
- 47:32non smart reasons. Sometimes smart people are able to outsmart themselves. I also
- 47:39think that many of these people are influenced by family and culture. They came
- 47:45out of a religious home, they have a religious community, and so the
- 47:50cultural aspect of it, it's there normal and the brain's modular. We can
- 47:54compartmentalize irrational from rational. But it's weird, isn't it. Whenever somebody's in
- 48:01there and they're getting science based medical treatment. And then another person walks in
- 48:07with their hands clasped and begins to pray for healing. And I'm thinking,
- 48:12if prayer worked, there would be no hospital. Have you had that thought,
- 48:16David? Yeah, oh, many times. Many times. It's not
- 48:19just bad, it's like a whole new age thing. Is also a big
- 48:22thing up where I live too, So people are into like reiki and stuff
- 48:27like that, you know, and I mean it's all clearly bunk, you
- 48:30know. I mean, just waving your hands over somebody isn't going to cure
- 48:34a cancer, no matter what you think it's going to do. But for
- 48:37whatever reason, that's sort of the default you know, that people go to.
- 48:44Sometimes I wonder if it isn't added desperation, because there are limits as
- 48:47to what medicine can do. And if somebody has just been told some other
- 48:52horrific news, like you have this horrible condition and you're going to die from
- 48:57it and no one can help you, perhaps they're reaching out in desperation.
- 49:02But what I don't get is the practitioners, you know, people like myself,
- 49:07doctors, other medical staff, who play into this. I think you
- 49:12and you are spot on when it comes to people reaching out in moments of
- 49:16desperation, and I think this is why some of the prayer conversation deserves our
- 49:22compassion. You get the worst of news, you don't know what the future
- 49:25holds. Am I going to lose the person I care about? I'm scared?
- 49:31I feel helpless. This is often when people pray. There is a
- 49:37placebo effect, a calming effect that comes with praying and prayer rituals. You've
- 49:44got people together praying, holding hands, physical touch, demonstrations of human support.
- 49:51All of this makes prayer in that way understandable. I think that explains
- 49:57why many people lean into prayer for even when they are really relying on science
- 50:02based solutions. But I remember there was a doctor I had years and years
- 50:07and years ago, David, and I would go in he was my primary
- 50:10care physician. I would get I'd get a cold of the flu or strap
- 50:15and I would go in and he would examine me and I would get my
- 50:20medication. But after the visit he would insist on praying for me. Wow,
- 50:24I'm getting a prescription medication developed by scientists, and then he prays that
- 50:32God will help the medicine to work. And even when I was a believer,
- 50:37I thought this makes no sense. The medicine's going to do what it
- 50:40does the same way, whether we prayed over it or not. Did we
- 50:45magically enchant the medicine. So I totally understand your frustration in that way.
- 50:50It doesn't make any sense, does it. In a lot of ways,
- 50:52it's a lot like otioid medications, you know, like oxycon and things like
- 50:57that. It'll temporarily adult the pain, but people become addicted to it,
- 51:06and some people take it to such an extent that it ruins their lives or
- 51:08they even die from it. So I rather like the analogy you were using
- 51:13about comparing it to the painkiller, because in a lot of ways that's exactly
- 51:16what it is. It's also a cheat, though, because some people rely
- 51:22on prayer and ignore science based solutions. There are those who name and claim
- 51:28their good health because God has promised that they will be healthy, wealthy,
- 51:31and wise. They say, I don't need a doctor, Jesus is my
- 51:36physician. And then those people go off and die. So, you know,
- 51:40there are so many problems. There's such a minefield with the prayer issue.
- 51:46But I think we can approach people who are leaning into prayer in moments
- 51:51of desperation. We have to do that with compassion as fellow human beings,
- 51:55and then after that the harder discussions can come. But I feel you,
- 52:00David, and I'm so glad that you are part of science based solutions out
- 52:04there. You keep doing what you do, Okay, thank you. You
- 52:07keep doing what you do too. So I got to tell you it's silver
- 52:10refresh and being able to listen in on your programs and you know, it's
- 52:15like a light of reason and a sea of insanity. Thank you so much
- 52:19for all the work that you've done. Thanks so much, Dave. All
- 52:22Right, be safe, A light of reason and the sea of insanity.
- 52:25That's a T shirt. Make that into a T shirt like that. There
- 52:30was a study that was done about the power of prayer. Can prayers effectiveness
- 52:37be scientifically measured? I study was done. I forget how many years ago.
- 52:43I want to say it was fifteen twenty years ago. They took people
- 52:47who were going in for heart surgery and they had three groups. There was
- 52:53a group they were getting the surgery and they were prayed for and they were
- 52:59told there's a group that's praying for your healing or quick recovery. There was
- 53:05another group they were not prayed for, they were informed as such, and
- 53:10I think the third group wasn't told either way. And they measured the recuperation
- 53:19time and the complication rate of all of these groups. And did you know
- 53:24that those who were prayed for and knew about it actually had more complications in
- 53:31their recovery? They got worse in some cases, or they recovered more slowly.
- 53:38Now why is that? I don't know. Did they feel pressure knowing
- 53:44that there was a group that was praying for them, You know, I've
- 53:46got to get better. So now their body is stressed, their mind is
- 53:51racing. Maybe they they're just not dealing. They're not in the moment.
- 53:54Trying to rest themselves as the body recovers was another thing going on. But
- 54:00at the very least, it was revealed that being prayed for after your surgery
- 54:07does not produce faster results, greater healing, and a better recovery. Sometimes
- 54:15prayer makes things worse, and I find that extremely interesting. I will leave
- 54:24more of these discussions about science and medicine versus superstition, about Christian nations,
- 54:31the founding fathers, and whether or not one should door dash desserts. I
- 54:37will leave all of this to you with a final request to go and subscribe
- 54:43to my second show, True Stories with Seth Andrews. Be safe and well,
- 54:49and we will do this again quite soon. Follow The Thanking Atheist on
- 54:52Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs
- 54:59and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources,
- 55:04and details on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website,
- 55:08The Thinkingatheist dot com.