Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 157: Anne Hidalgo’s Paris Legacy & the 2026 Vote with Phineas Rueckert
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Linda Tremuta. We are, if you can believe it,
- 0:14nearing the end of an era. And Hidalgo, mayor since 2014,
- 0:20will soon be leaving office. And this month, we vote on her
- 0:24replacement. In fact, there are elections all
- 0:26over the country, but in Paris there are some changes to how
- 0:30that's going to go down and also who is likely to take over.
- 0:34I know many of the people who listen to the show are
- 0:36interested in local politics and curious about how Paris is
- 0:39changing, and some of them are actually going to be voting for
- 0:42the first time. So I felt this deserved a
- 0:44special focus. I'm joined by Phineas Rooker to
- 0:48Paris based journalist who covers politics and social
- 0:51issues for The Nation, Jacobin and New Lines magazine to help
- 0:55me unpack what's at stake, who's running, why this election is so
- 1:00important and also what Legacy and Hidalgo leaves behind.
- 1:07Phineas, welcome to the show. Thank you.
- 1:10We've got a big month ahead. A lot is changing.
- 1:14Our dear or not so dear Hidalgo is leaving or will be leaving.
- 1:19It's kind of wild because she's been mayor since 2014.
- 1:23Before that she was then. I know he's adjunct mayor.
- 1:27She's been in the Parisian consciousness and landscape for
- 1:31so long that it's going to feel a bit odd.
- 1:34But so many people seem to be thrilled that her terms are
- 1:37coming to an end. And just as an anecdote, I was
- 1:40with a bunch of journalists, French journalists last week,
- 1:44many of whom are would call themselves quite left wing.
- 1:47And they expressed a level of vitriol toward her that I just
- 1:52simply do not understand. To the point where, you know,
- 1:56anytime she opens her mouth to speak, they, you know, they feel
- 1:58this rage building in them. That is not, I think, the
- 2:03experience of a lot of foreigners who look up to Paris
- 2:07and see this mayor who has radically transformed in a lot
- 2:10of positive ways our city and who shepherded in the Olympics.
- 2:15And you could argue that, you know, the foreigners who don't
- 2:19live here don't have to deal with the pain points along the
- 2:21way of some of these changes. But you and I live here.
- 2:24We do. So I wanted to start here.
- 2:26I wanted to get a sense of what you think the biggest
- 2:29accomplishments have been in her years as mayor and where some of
- 2:33this hate comes from. And, and really, are Parisians
- 2:36just bound to hate whoever's in charge?
- 2:38Yeah. Well, so it's funny that you you
- 2:40bring up the story of sort of you talking to these
- 2:42journalists. It sort of reminds me of like
- 2:43when I first moved to France. It would have been around 2018.
- 2:47And I was trying to understand, like, why Hollande, the former
- 2:51Socialist president, was also so hated.
- 2:54I do think it's one of these things where it's like, like,
- 2:56not quite left enough for the left, but not quite right enough
- 3:00for the right or the center and just sort of like, manages to
- 3:04rub everyone the wrong way. And I do think there's a certain
- 3:07amount of that going on with Hidalgo.
- 3:08Like, she's definitely not, you know, shepherding in this sort
- 3:12of like, very militant sort of left wing agenda that maybe
- 3:16someone from, like, La France Muse would want to have or want
- 3:19to see. But she's also not necessarily,
- 3:21you know, going to appeal to centrists.
- 3:24You know, there's obviously a lot of people who are very upset
- 3:26about her in terms of like, oh, I can't drive around Paris as
- 3:29easily. So yeah, So I, I don't, I, I do
- 3:32think that there, there's one of these things where it's kind of
- 3:34hard to understand. And hopefully we can unpack this
- 3:36in, in the in the chat, But to answer your question, to go to
- 3:39back to what you're actually asking.
- 3:40So Hidalgo in a lot of ways has been pretty successful at
- 3:45reshaping Paris. She has laid out 1000 kilometers
- 3:51of of bike lanes, which in a city the size of Paris is is,
- 3:56that is incredibly impressive. To give a little bit of a
- 3:59comparison point, New York City has about 2500 kilometers of
- 4:04bike lanes. Paris is tiny, a fraction of the
- 4:08size of New York and many of the bike lanes in New York are just
- 4:12basically like lines on the street.
- 4:14Whereas in in Paris it's much more often protected bike lanes,
- 4:17often two way bike lanes, these sort of almost bike highways
- 4:21through the city like you'd see in a place more like Amsterdam
- 4:24or or or Copenhagen. So, you know, in terms of the,
- 4:28the physical transformation of Paris, it's not just bike lanes.
- 4:31It's also if you go in front of any school in, in any only small
- 4:35in Paris now, you'll see that the whole sort of St. in front
- 4:41of the entrance is blocked off to traffic.
- 4:44There's, you know, greenery everywhere in those areas.
- 4:48The amount of traffic circles that have been pedestrianized
- 4:53where like, you know, plus Lebesti when I first moved here
- 4:56was a mess. And now you can actually get
- 4:58around their own bike. I mean, it's not perfect, but.
- 5:00It's no. And also, so the big argument
- 5:02and this is, I mean, I don't know if we're going to be able
- 5:05to have the the explanation for this, but many of the changes
- 5:09including Bestie as one such example seem to have well
- 5:14haven't quite curbed the car traffic that she made it seem
- 5:20like we would see. Often it seems, probably worse.
- 5:24Right, it seems worse. However, we have these results
- 5:27of 50% less air pollution according to a number of
- 5:32measures so that, you know, it's like there are these things that
- 5:34are coexisting and the Hidalgo detractors all speak to, you
- 5:39know, the traffic at some of these big circles, the traffic
- 5:43that can't go along. And this has been more than 10
- 5:46years anyway. But the third, you know, the on
- 5:48the banks of the river, the thoroughfare, one person I was
- 5:51speaking to last week was like, I bike everywhere in the city
- 5:53and the bike lanes that go against traffic on some streets
- 5:57are extremely dangerous. You never should have done that.
- 6:01I mean, isn't the whole point to try things and then if you have
- 6:04to scale back you scale back, But these people just seem like
- 6:08every measure is something to pick apart.
- 6:11Yeah. And I, I just also think that,
- 6:14you know, the world has gotten more chaotic too.
- 6:16Like there's just more people like I know that like, and, and
- 6:19Paris has become, you know, each year there's more and more
- 6:21tourists. There was a whole sort of
- 6:23controversy around the dockless by what do you call those in it?
- 6:28Oh, lime, lime the. Dockless scooters.
- 6:31Oh, the scooters, Yeah. Where where there was a
- 6:33referendum actually on the the dockless scooters and and
- 6:36Parisians voted largely to ban them from from Paris, but there.
- 6:41Weren't that many people who voted?
- 6:43That was the other thing that got everyone a.
- 6:44Low turn out vote, which kind of makes sense on any sort of like
- 6:48local proposition, but it just like that.
- 6:51There's just a lot going on and like, and if you if you don't
- 6:54necessarily live here and you didn't see what it was like
- 6:57before, it could be shocking. I think it could be a very, very
- 7:00hard, hard to like navigate, especially in like, I think
- 7:03especially like older Parisians, older people in general.
- 7:06I can imagine being in their in their shoes and being like, I
- 7:09don't know which way to look anymore like how to cross the
- 7:11street. Like there's just like people
- 7:13like going the wrong way on a, on a lime scooter and then, you
- 7:17know, there's bikes crossing very fast.
- 7:20There's obviously some some issues about how people cycle in
- 7:22in Paris and. Enforcement, I guess at that
- 7:25point that's like the next step. Yeah, and once in a while you'll
- 7:27see a few like municipal cops, like, you know, ticketing
- 7:30cyclists or ticketing motorcycles who've gone through
- 7:33the bike lane. But but for the most part, it's
- 7:35it is just sort of like this, this kind of free for all.
- 7:39And I think people get that impression and they think, oh,
- 7:41this failed, but they don't necessarily see what was just a
- 7:45free for all in the past for cars.
- 7:47Right. Well, there seems to be a real
- 7:49attachment still to cars, as though somehow they are endemic
- 7:54to a city which a city like Paris, which they weren't, you
- 7:59know, it really ramped up after World War 2.
- 8:02And so to hear also young people that are like, it's impossible
- 8:04to get around Paris. Even the buses can't go fast
- 8:08enough. Is this a Hedalgo problem or is
- 8:11this something bigger, a social issue, a change issue, or a
- 8:16resistance to change that people have?
- 8:18Or is it a little bit of everything?
- 8:20It's a good question. I think people are certainly
- 8:23resistant to to change and sort of to come back to, you know,
- 8:26why Hidalgo is is quite unpopular is I think a lot of
- 8:29people feel like she was sort of authoritarian in her roll out of
- 8:33this. There wasn't necessarily for
- 8:35every bike lane in a citizen, you know, meeting in which like
- 8:40the pros and the cons were weighed out and and a decision
- 8:43was made collectively, which to be fair, often does happen in
- 8:46other cities, but which drastically slows down the
- 8:50amount of in this case, bike lanes that are being built out
- 8:53because, you know, there's opposition from like local
- 8:55commerce's because they say it's going to, you know, the work
- 8:58needed to put those into place. It's going to mess their mess up
- 9:00their, you know, their businesses.
- 9:02People are concerned about the sort of the way it was done.
- 9:06But then again, and like you have to, you know, also look at
- 9:10what Paris looks like now and and compare it to 10 years ago.
- 9:13And there are many things that have gotten better.
- 9:17I mean also noise, to be honest, like noise was another source of
- 9:21pollution that has improved. Maybe not in every area, right?
- 9:25But even even where we're recording, parts of the 1111
- 9:29thousand D small were full of loud car traffic honking.
- 9:33Motorcycles. And, you know, some streets have
- 9:36been blocked off to non resident traffic and some people still
- 9:40you sort of drive on roads they're not supposed to.
- 9:42But for the most part, that does do a lot to curb some of that
- 9:45noise. And so the reality is, is if
- 9:47you're driving and you don't have to be driving, that's why
- 9:50you hate it here, right? If you watch old videos of what
- 9:53the the kids send so that you know, the send the send what is
- 9:56now a walkway used to sound like it's it's it's just horrible.
- 10:00It's this constant drum this, this, you know, whooshing of, of
- 10:04cars over, you know, and then the traffic backed up like way
- 10:07all the way out to the Paris. It was not better.
- 10:10And that space was totally dead, which is one of the nicest
- 10:13spaces, I think, in Paris now. What is concerning is that given
- 10:17that she is going to be leaving and we don't know who will
- 10:21really be taking over. I mean, we have our our hopes
- 10:25perhaps and our fears. But if it is someone like she
- 10:30did that he who we're going to talk about.
- 10:32At one point she was campaigning on undoing some of these
- 10:37changes. Now she claims that she won't
- 10:39touch a lot of it. She is now claiming that she's
- 10:42going to not follow through with the changes at the Louvre to
- 10:46make, you know, navigation better and more secure.
- 10:50Are we at risk, do you think, of seeing a lot of these wonderful
- 10:53changes uproot it? I think, like you said, probably
- 10:59she did that T if she were to be elected as the, as the Paris
- 11:03mayor has realized that something like, you know,
- 11:08bringing cars back to the to the kid, kid Sen is a very unpopular
- 11:12measure. I think the only current
- 11:14candidate who is sticking by their guns on that issue is
- 11:18Salak Nefu. So the the far right of the far
- 11:20right from the Hulk Hong Kent party, which we can definitely
- 11:23also talk about, But I think it's it's much harder to undo a
- 11:27bike lane than to redo one or than to than to do one in the
- 11:30first place. And that would also necessitate
- 11:34a large amount of construction, which is the whole part, you
- 11:37know, one of the whole things that people were upset about vis
- 11:40A vis the bike lanes being implemented.
- 11:42So I don't see a world in which stuff like that gets rolled
- 11:46back. I just think it would
- 11:48drastically slow down like because there are parts like
- 11:50Paris is very much divided, not north-south, as has often been
- 11:55kind of the case, but more east, West.
- 11:58And, you know, the other day I was cycling in, in the 16th
- 12:03Arondismo, so like far, far West of Paris.
- 12:06And there's almost, you know, there's almost no cycling
- 12:08infrastructure. It's, it's, it's you're, you're
- 12:10there with the buses and the motorcycles on cobblestones.
- 12:13It's, it's very unpleasant actually.
- 12:15So we could just imagine that that would just sort of stay
- 12:17that way. We might just kind of stagnate,
- 12:19but not necessarily rolling it back because that would be both,
- 12:22I think, unpopular and also just complicated, you know, right,
- 12:27Very, very difficult to actually implement.
- 12:29And also most of these center right wing candidates are
- 12:34unsurprisingly campaigning on law and order, which is sort of
- 12:37their obvious beat to go on. But the the left is where and
- 12:42this is maybe where we should get into sort of what this is
- 12:44going to look like and why it is so uncertain.
- 12:47So a few things. This is your first time or
- 12:50second time voting next month. This is my second time voting in
- 12:55a French election of any type. The first time was during the
- 12:58snap legislative election two years ago.
- 13:01Yeah. Is it two years ago already?
- 13:022024, yeah, yeah, almost two years ago.
- 13:05Almost two years ago in In which case I was voting in a
- 13:08ridiculous election in Montreal between a candidate backed by
- 13:13LFES with the left wing party and then a candidate who had
- 13:15left LFE but was, you know, basically campaigning on the
- 13:19same platform but just under a different name.
- 13:21It was, it was, it was messy and unnecessary.
- 13:24But so this is my first, This will be my first time voting in
- 13:26a in a mayoral election. And what is different this time,
- 13:29which we were discussing before we started recording is that
- 13:33there are some changes to how this will go down.
- 13:35Usually the presidential election is a two round vote.
- 13:38And actually that is what will happen in March previously, and
- 13:41I completely forgot that this is how it went the last time I
- 13:44voted it for mayor was it's one it's one vote and you're voting
- 13:49for your local council. So in each element is small.
- 13:52And then that according to the number of seats ends up sort of
- 13:54informing who takes over Paris. This time though, we've got 2
- 13:59rounds. SO2 Sundays in a row are the
- 14:01first again local council and then Paris council who also then
- 14:07determines who becomes becomes mayor.
- 14:10Do you think that's that's a positive thing does that?
- 14:12Is that giving us a little bit more reason to take interest in
- 14:16this election? Do you think it will get people
- 14:19motivated? Well, this is one thing to look
- 14:21up. I'm not sure if it's that you
- 14:24vote first for your local council and then for the the the
- 14:29Paris council. I think you vote twice for both.
- 14:33We have to check this. So maybe, maybe you can put this
- 14:35in like the extra notes at the end or whatever.
- 14:37I don't know how you do things, but I think it's you vote for at
- 14:40the same time a councillor from your Ajon Dismal and you vote
- 14:44for the the Paris mayor and then you do that twice and it's it's
- 14:47a battle Taj sort of system. So I think you are right.
- 14:50Yeah. And then in the second, in the
- 14:52second Sunday of voting, any candidate both in your Ajon
- 14:56dismal and in the Paris mayoral race more more broadly, will
- 15:01advance to the second round if they get 10% or more.
- 15:04Right. So if let's say someone in the
- 15:0611th that would be small already sort of it's a clear win right
- 15:10from the beginning. They might not necessarily be on
- 15:13the value. In this situation where the
- 15:15first Sunday you'll vote for your, your local, you know, your
- 15:19local arrondissement list, council list and and the Paris
- 15:23council list, your local arrondissement list, maybe one
- 15:27candidate gets more of than 50% and then it's just automatically
- 15:30elected. Whereas you'll still have to go
- 15:32back the following Sunday to vote in the second round of the
- 15:34Paris one, which 100% is not going to end with someone
- 15:38getting 50% in the first round. And so to answer to your
- 15:42question, I think what is quite interesting about this new
- 15:44framework, which is also only the new framework in Paris,
- 15:48Marseille, Leon, it's not the case in other cities.
- 15:51Yeah, it's basically, I won't get into the weeds, but it's
- 15:53like a 1980s law that was then changed or that was that, that
- 15:57is now being changed and brought back to, I guess what was the
- 16:00case before. But all that to say, what this
- 16:03does is it actually opens up a space for candidates who
- 16:11otherwise probably wouldn't have made it to the second round, who
- 16:15can kind of skate by on name recognition.
- 16:17So like we talked about a little bit about Zach Nafo.
- 16:19So the whole concat candidate. She's for those who might don't
- 16:24recognize her, they might recognize Eric Zemwa, who is the
- 16:27head of that ridiculous party. Exactly.
- 16:30And so currently, and I'm actually working on a story for
- 16:33this for the nation, which I'm plugging now.
- 16:36Currently Saak Nafu is is pulling over 10%, which would
- 16:40mean she would actually make it to the second round of the
- 16:42election. But locally, in terms of Aron
- 16:45Dismo, she has no ground ground presence at all.
- 16:49But because now you're voting sort of for the the mayor as as,
- 16:55as its own thing, people like her are able to actually make it
- 16:58to the second round. Same goes for Shikiru, who's the
- 17:02candidate for LFE, who's about 1012% as well.
- 17:06So, you know, La France and Sumi's does have some very good
- 17:09implantation on sort of local level and like the in basically
- 17:12in the northeast of Paris. But, you know, much less
- 17:15traction in Paris as a whole, But because of this sort of new
- 17:19system, it's actually possible. And this would be crazy, but
- 17:22it's not, you know, implausible that there would be 5 candidates
- 17:26in the Barutage second round on the second Sunday.
- 17:29So it would be Emmanuel Gregoire who represents a sort of
- 17:33coalition, a large coalition of the Socialist Party, the Greens,
- 17:37the Communists, a few other parties.
- 17:40There would be Shikiro from La France and Sumis Nafu from
- 17:45Proconqueta. There's a Mooch party and then
- 17:48Hashida Dati, who's the sort of traditional right slash hard
- 17:53right candidate, currently the culture minister of Macron and
- 17:56the mayor of the 7th Onismo. And then the last candidate who
- 18:02is currently pulling above 10% is Jean Yves Bornezel, who is
- 18:07sort of a center of the road three time.
- 18:12This is his third time running for for Paris mayor.
- 18:15And yet he has almost no name recognition.
- 18:17Almost no name recognition, but about 15% polling.
- 18:20Interesting he is associated with the Horizons or or his own
- 18:24party, which was founded by Edward Philippe, our former
- 18:27Prime Minister during COVID. Actually in the beginning of
- 18:29COVID, he was the one taking, taking a beating almost with
- 18:33his, you know, semi regular nightly broadcasts.
- 18:38Anyway, he is. He's not unliked by centrists is
- 18:43what I'll say so. Yeah.
- 18:44And so Bon Azel is sort of this weird situation where he's like,
- 18:47he basically represents the Macron vote, but he's not
- 18:52necessarily running for the Macron, for Macron's party.
- 18:54Right, OK, so you you think he reflects that more than Datit
- 18:58does? Well, so Macron has, has, has
- 19:02basically endorsed, so to speak, that tea, which makes sense
- 19:06because she's, you know, a government minister of his.
- 19:08She's a member of the electrical party, which is the the right,
- 19:11the traditional right. So he has sort of, you know,
- 19:13supported her yet you know, his party support, you know, in
- 19:19terms of policies, in terms of like approach would more align
- 19:23with with Bonneville. So it is a weird sort of
- 19:26situation for the Macron East. So people who are going to be
- 19:29voting for the first time, they have a lot of individuals to
- 19:31potentially look into and what their programs are.
- 19:34And I didn't do a a deep dive on everyone who's center right, but
- 19:39they all seem to share this kind of, like I said, order security,
- 19:45cleanliness, because they assume Paris is just, you know, like a
- 19:49trash bin. And to that I want to say,
- 19:51really, have you ever been to New York City?
- 19:53But on the left, we have our own issues because there's a lot of
- 19:56infighting. And this happens every time we
- 19:59have an election. La France and Sumi's which has
- 20:01been wrongly labeled by the government by the current
- 20:05administration. The extreme left, which
- 20:07technically it is not. And the social coalition you
- 20:11mentioned, but led by the Socialist Party.
- 20:14And there's all this infighting. No one wants to agree.
- 20:17And there was this thought, or at least I, I, I assumed that
- 20:21maybe someone would finally learn from their mistakes of
- 20:24allowing these fights to go on. Because when you have the far
- 20:28right that is basically storming up the hill ready to take over
- 20:32the show and they can't get their act together and be like,
- 20:35you know why? We need to figure out a way to
- 20:37compromise or else we lose the whole operation.
- 20:40They're still not getting it together.
- 20:43What do you think might happen with regards to people who are
- 20:48only going to consider voting for the left?
- 20:52So, yeah, it's it's very, it's very much a mess on the left.
- 20:57What is historic and what is, is unique in this, in this election
- 21:01is that actually the left is more united than it has been in
- 21:06past Paris mayoral races. So in the past, you know, the
- 21:10Greens party, the communists, they have run their own
- 21:14candidate in the first round. And then when their own
- 21:17candidate either, you know, doesn't pull high enough or
- 21:19whatever, or, or, or, you know, decides that there's too much of
- 21:23A threat on the right, then they'll join the, the party that
- 21:26has the most votes, which has traditionally been the
- 21:27socialists. But actually what happened this
- 21:29year is that they all came together beforehand before the
- 21:33first round. And even with that, so that,
- 21:36that list that that electoral coalition is pulling around
- 21:403032%. The right wing coalition or the
- 21:44right wing under that T is around 2426%.
- 21:48The centrist around 15%. And then basically different
- 21:52variations because I we didn't mention actually that the, the
- 21:55air hand. So the national rally also is
- 21:57fielding a candidate in Paris. And so the between that
- 22:01candidate and the the the the sack Nepho, the concat candidate
- 22:06there about 17% for the far right.
- 22:09All of that to say, in general, you could say that Paris is 40%
- 22:15left between the two left parties and 60% right between
- 22:19the center right and far right, sort of or, you know, bad
- 22:25groups, which means that the only chance for the left to win
- 22:31election is either that there are no coalitions that take
- 22:33place between the two rounds and so they'll just kind of continue
- 22:36being 30% and winning. Or that the lost left hand
- 22:40social means. So that the the further left,
- 22:42but definitely not extreme left group would either, you know,
- 22:48take take out their candidate, withdraw their candidate to then
- 22:51have those votes go towards the the the more center left
- 22:55coalition. But neither want that to happen,
- 22:57do they? Exactly.
- 22:59And so so basically the SO socialists who are sort of in
- 23:02charge of this left wing group have said we will not do any
- 23:06type of allegiance with La France and Sumise.
- 23:09And and for people who don't know why is that because people
- 23:12listeners have heard me talk about Menel Sean on the show.
- 23:16It's been a while since we've had to talk about him, but he
- 23:19seems to be the pariah of the group that you know, where
- 23:23people who would would consider actually voting for the party as
- 23:26long as he's involved, They won't what I I think you have
- 23:30more of an eloquent way of of describing.
- 23:32No, I think, I think you know, pariah is not, is not untrue.
- 23:36You know, Medal Shaw is a very polemic figure.
- 23:39He's quite authoritarian. He, you know, has a very black
- 23:43and white sort of view of the world.
- 23:46Recently, he even went as far as, I don't know if you followed
- 23:49this, but he went as far as to ban certain journalists from
- 23:52attending a press conference that he held, including
- 23:56Liberation, which is like a left wing newspaper that, yes, has
- 24:00been critical of Melon Sean, But that's, you know.
- 24:02Part. That's part of the game, part
- 24:04of. What journalism is and that part
- 24:05of you know what, you know, the left can't just be like, oh, you
- 24:08know, all, all left wing politicians are great.
- 24:10So, you know, he's he's this sort of authoritarian figure who
- 24:15who has not been afraid to like make pretty strong statements
- 24:21about, you know, international geopolitics.
- 24:24Often he's, you know, been accused and sometimes rightly,
- 24:27sometimes not rightly, of anti-Semitism and.
- 24:31Pro Russian. Pro Russian kind of sentiments.
- 24:35Yeah. He's like a chavista.
- 24:38So he's like very close to like the Venezuelan regime.
- 24:43And so, you know, so all of those sort of like
- 24:45international. I think issues come into this,
- 24:48this general distrust of of Menel from a lot of people on
- 24:52the left, which is too bad because his party actually does
- 24:55have a lot of very progressive ideas that would advance cities
- 24:59or local races. They have been part of left wing
- 25:02coalitions before the NFA or the new best.
- 25:06And when they were, you know, they were always dragging
- 25:10certain policy issues for their to the left, you know, whether
- 25:13that's about, you know, social housing, dealing with unhoused
- 25:16populations. Major issues.
- 25:18That are important. They they've been sort of like
- 25:21bringing the ship back to the left, whereas now just because
- 25:26what you know, their, their leadership is so negatively
- 25:30viewed, you know, those things are sort of swept under the rug.
- 25:33And then obviously, we have to talk about what's currently
- 25:36going on in France, which maybe you've talked on a previous
- 25:39podcast about Compton de Hong. No, I haven't actually, because,
- 25:43oh God, yeah. Well, let's let's get into it.
- 25:46Because honestly, this is also part of the vilification of
- 25:49these of the LA France and Sumis, but also a striking
- 25:54example of how divided France is.
- 25:57And so when you think about could France follow in the
- 26:01footsteps of the United States or other nationalistic
- 26:06countries? I mean, there are some
- 26:08parallels. I'm not saying they're
- 26:09identical, but France has its own very serious issues that are
- 26:12also very different from what Italy has gone through.
- 26:15And I've heard so many people talk about, you know, oh, but
- 26:18Georgia Maloney is not as not as severe as she campaigned on.
- 26:23And whether that is true or not, the point is that you can't
- 26:28successfully or, or fairly compare Italy and France because
- 26:32their stories are so different. And we also have a very
- 26:34militarized police here, which I think plays a very big role in
- 26:39what could happen should we move to the right, you know, and how
- 26:42they can be weaponized and, and, and used.
- 26:45So all that to say, what happened with this guy who is
- 26:50sort of like, not exactly, but kind of like a Charlie Kirk of
- 26:54France? So my partner, who's also a
- 26:56journalist, Tien de Vinimo, and I are talking a lot about about
- 26:58sort of like the Charlie Kirk aspects of this and might at
- 27:02some point write a story on that.
- 27:03But you know, essentially, to make a very a very long and
- 27:06complicated story short, what happened is at basically a there
- 27:12was a talk by politician on the left from the last left, Hans
- 27:17Ansumi's party, Naima Hassan in Lyon at Science PO, a very, you
- 27:21know, venerated university. She is a very polemic figure.
- 27:25Again, you know, she's very, very vocal about Palestine.
- 27:29Palestine. She's been, you know, sort of
- 27:30the bugbear of the right and the far right and even the center.
- 27:34So, you know, the fact that she's giving this speech is
- 27:36already sort of creating some sort of tensions.
- 27:40Leon, you have to know is like there's a very weird city where
- 27:45there's like like a very strong like nationalist sort of
- 27:49movement. So it's like sort of the cradle
- 27:52of these like ultra nationalist groups in France.
- 27:55So Kim Hassan, far left politician giving a talk in
- 28:00Lyon. Obviously this didn't, this is
- 28:02very displeasing to the to the right and the far right.
- 28:04A number of groups from the far right went to protests this
- 28:09talk, which is legitimate. You know, the left protests all
- 28:13sorts of talks by far right people.
- 28:15And that's that's how this works.
- 28:17But what essentially happened is during that after sort of on the
- 28:22sidelines of that conference that she gave, there was, you
- 28:26know, protests by the far right. And then a group called Jean
- 28:29Gald, which is like a a left wing anti fascist group just
- 28:36confronted the far right activists.
- 28:39There were some sort of like it, Basically it sort of devolved
- 28:41into St. Battles between the two groups
- 28:45and sort of a little bit later, one of the members of the far
- 28:52right groups got sort of isolated from the pack, so to
- 28:55speak. Who himself?
- 28:56He's well known, though, among this group, right Contana.
- 29:00Yeah. So he, he, you know, he's, he's
- 29:02not, he's not known. He's not just some, some random,
- 29:04some random person. He's an active sort of far right
- 29:07identitarian nationalist. Christian also like sort of
- 29:11Christian nationalist. Yeah, a white man about 20-3
- 29:15years old, 24. He gets sort of isolated from
- 29:17the group. The rest of the the sort of far
- 29:20right group who was there to protest Remasan leaves.
- 29:25He ends up getting basically beaten by by legend guard, the
- 29:31anti fascist group, and about a day later he dies.
- 29:36This was about like the worst possible thing to happen for the
- 29:39left. Yeah, in you know, and, and and
- 29:42it sort of gave credence to everything that the the right
- 29:47and the far right we're saying about the left and specifically
- 29:49about La Franco Sumis, sort of, you know, creating a demon out
- 29:53of them. And what's and the reason I
- 29:56should say that that La Franco Sumis comes back into this story
- 29:59is because legend Gald was Co founded by Rafael Arno, who is
- 30:06an, you know, a left wing anti fascist activist initially and
- 30:11became actually an elected official for La France and
- 30:14Sumise. And one of the people who were
- 30:17later arrested for beating up and eventually killing this far
- 30:22right activist was a parliamentary assistant of
- 30:26Rafael Arno. So the narrative becomes very
- 30:29quickly, La France and Sumise is the biggest danger for France.
- 30:36You know, they're violent, they're going after, you know,
- 30:39white Christian French people and killing them on the streets
- 30:43in broad daylight. Filmed like there were several
- 30:46films, several angles of this were filmed, which of course is
- 30:50not actually the case. The number of people killed by
- 30:54far right groups since the end of World War 2 is around 50 /
- 31:0050. This was the 4th person killed
- 31:04by a fire left group. But that is not the framing that
- 31:09we've seen in the last 10 days. We've seen actually.
- 31:12And by the time this comes out, it will have been already.
- 31:15Three weeks or so. But there were there was a
- 31:18moment of silence required by what was it, the astronaut.
- 31:22Yeah. You know, did they do that for
- 31:25any of The Who had been killed by the right?
- 31:28Just one, Oh, just one. And it took a while for it to
- 31:30to. Happen and then so you know, and
- 31:32the media has followed. Along all of the basically non
- 31:35independent titles, essentially sort of, I don't want to say
- 31:39glorified him because it wasn't quite like what happened with
- 31:42Kirk, but there was a little bit of a relaxed take on these
- 31:48accusations toward the the La France and Sumise and it really
- 31:52wasn't equitable. And a lot of this was taken, you
- 31:54know. Out of context, like nobody
- 31:55talked about the street fighting that led up to this, like the,
- 31:58the, the far right activists who were, you know, who were there
- 32:02to protest in the 1st place. They said that they surrounded
- 32:04themselves with people who were protecting them, which was
- 32:07another far right group. But that other far right group,
- 32:10like there's some photos that way, like you see them, like one
- 32:12of them has a flamethrower and one of them has like a like, you
- 32:15know, like a crutch that's clearly not actually for
- 32:17walking, but like to be used to beat people.
- 32:20Plus a March that happened. In the days following his death,
- 32:24there were neo Nazis on the street.
- 32:26So all of this though, when it's you put this in the context of
- 32:30even the election in Paris and people are going into it
- 32:33thinking, ah, la France and Sumise is this.
- 32:36And this isn't the first time that this has happened right up
- 32:39before an election. There is some thought that also
- 32:42the US is interfering. I saw headlines about this,
- 32:46perhaps because you've got people in the administration.
- 32:50I think even Kushner said something right about the
- 32:52current ambassador. To France, Charles Kushner,
- 32:56Charles Kushner was basically made a few comments about like
- 33:00the dangerousness of Elfi. And then after those comments,
- 33:06which, you know, completely, you know, go past his his role as as
- 33:10ambassador to France, he was asked to I I don't remember if
- 33:16it was that as somebody in astronaut or a different
- 33:18institution, but he was basically asked by the French
- 33:19government. Like we you need to clarify your
- 33:21comments to us, like you need to to tell us why you said that,
- 33:24like why you took that position and he just didn't show up.
- 33:27Yeah, he didn't show up to the meeting and so.
- 33:28Now he's barred from speaking with.
- 33:30Exactly. Yeah.
- 33:31So, yeah, so all of this, yeah, just to come back to the mayoral
- 33:34elections, like all of this is all happening in the past two
- 33:36weeks. This is a very bad look on that
- 33:40house, on Sumi's, regardless of, you know, the context,
- 33:43regardless of what you think about the party, regardless of
- 33:45their platform. Like it's it's gone way beyond
- 33:47that. Because within that sort of left
- 33:49wing coalition group, there were like some who were more
- 33:52favorable to some sort of second round coalition with LFE, the
- 33:56Greens and the Communist Party more so than the Socialist
- 33:59Party, which also mirrors national level dynamics.
- 34:03There was a possibility, you know, that maybe if the the
- 34:06voting, you know, intentions suggested a coalition across the
- 34:12left, maybe that would have happened.
- 34:13Now that is completely dead in the water.
- 34:15Yeah. So the question is, will
- 34:17actually La France and Sumi's, which is currently voting about
- 34:21polling about 10 to 12%, will they actually hit the 10% number
- 34:26for the mayoral council to make it to the second round?
- 34:30And if they don't, what do their voters do?
- 34:32That's a big question. Well, I'm seeing if we can.
- 34:35Take social media for anything. At least it provides some sort
- 34:39of insight. But many LFE supporters are
- 34:42saying they won't vote. And I think.
- 34:45It's going to there's going to be a high extension rate to
- 34:49begin with. I think a lot of people are
- 34:51feeling just like no party really represents their
- 34:55interests from the left and the right.
- 34:58Jesus, sounds familiar? Yeah, Americans who have dual
- 35:03nationality, we really get pulled through the wringer in
- 35:05some ways. We have to do this twice.
- 35:07Yeah, it's, it's it's brutal. It's been a it's been a rough
- 35:10couple of years as a bi national.
- 35:12So the one. Thing I want to make sure we can
- 35:15we can address for for listeners also is why is this election?
- 35:21I mean, we know that local elections are so important
- 35:24wherever you live in the US, We know this is true here.
- 35:27It's, it's especially true because they essentially decide
- 35:30on things that impact your, your day-to-day life in your island
- 35:34small, right? So we know that, but it also is
- 35:38an indication of how things could go next year because we
- 35:41have the presidential elections and, you know, we don't start
- 35:44campaigning. We don't have the same unlimited
- 35:48fundraising ceilings as we do in the US.
- 35:50So the election, that election really won't sort of become
- 35:54palpable for, you know, many, many months to come.
- 35:57But so this is what we've got now.
- 35:59Why are the stakes of this election so important, and why
- 36:02should people keep it in mind given what's around the corner?
- 36:06Yeah. Well, I think this kind of.
- 36:07Comes back to what we were discussing earlier and like it
- 36:09does sound sort of technical, the whole like Paris, Leon,
- 36:12Marseille, like they changed the rules and now you vote for your
- 36:14local person and you're like national person.
- 36:17But I do think that actually gives us more sort of
- 36:19information about what 2027 presidential elections might
- 36:23look like in the sense that, and then this is what again, what my
- 36:28nation piece is about is like 17% of Paris, the capital of
- 36:33France is currently polling for the far right, not the right,
- 36:38not like the, you know, that's he, but the far right and in
- 36:41which island is small. Mostly in the West of.
- 36:43Paris so like the 16th, the 17th, the the 8th, the 7th.
- 36:48Well, yeah, the 7th definitely, even though the 7th is sort of
- 36:51that T's island is small. And so I think, you know, Paris,
- 36:56you can get a little bit more of a sense of where the country is
- 37:00going than if you were to look at like, you know, a local race
- 37:02and some other place. Because usually mayoral
- 37:05elections are about those issues that affect you on your
- 37:08day-to-day life. Like, you know, housing or
- 37:11ecology or, you know, education or what have you some
- 37:15healthcare. But you know, these sort of
- 37:19national level dynamics have been sort of grafted onto the
- 37:22Paris race. And so I think that you can say
- 37:25like you can see a little bit more about sort of where things
- 37:27are headed and you know, Paris I think in 2022 voted about 4% for
- 37:35for Marine Le Pen 4% and now we're.
- 37:38At 17 polling at least, and again it's between two
- 37:41different. Far right parties.
- 37:42There was also Zemmul who also had, you know, some polling in
- 37:45Paris, but it there has been, you know, the far right has
- 37:47progressed, that's for sure. And if the far right is
- 37:50progressed in Paris, it's it's progressing probably even faster
- 37:53elsewhere. And yeah, the the the broken
- 37:58left is also the case in almost every other city in France.
- 38:00There's almost no city. The only city I can think of
- 38:04where the left la France and Sumi's and the sort of
- 38:08communists green socialists have created One unique list is an
- 38:12owl in the South of France. But otherwise.
- 38:15It's you know you have. LFI and they're doing their
- 38:17thing and then you have the left and they're doing their thing.
- 38:20There's been two moments in recent French history where
- 38:23those, all of those left wing groups came together.
- 38:27And I really, you know, I, I struggled to see that happening.
- 38:30And, and going back to the content, the young thing that,
- 38:33you know, just kind of like, what's the expression?
- 38:36It's it, you know, sealed the, the tomb of the, of the, of the
- 38:41broad left coalition with, with LFE.
- 38:43It seems that you know almost impossible at this point.
- 38:48So given this. Is there any ray of hope for you
- 38:51in your mind? You're doing a lot of reporting
- 38:53about this. You've spoken to people on the
- 38:56ground. You know, I'm assuming you've
- 38:58heard people say they just won't vote because it's too much, it's
- 39:00too complicated. It's no one sort of reflects
- 39:04their their needs or their wishes.
- 39:06What do you? What is the best case scenario?
- 39:10I suppose as a journalist I should probably.
- 39:11Say I'm, you know, impartial and whatever and don't have an
- 39:15opinion. But of course I live here.
- 39:16I'm also a Parisian resident. And you know what, what what
- 39:21happens in Paris affects me on a personal level.
- 39:25So I recently had a conversation with Jan Brosa as part of my
- 39:30reporting. He is one of the members of the,
- 39:35the, the Socialist Broad Coalition list for, for Paris.
- 39:40And he said something that I thought was quite interesting.
- 39:42He basically said, and what happens in Paris is all about,
- 39:48you know, voter turn out are like working class populations
- 39:53going to come out. And he basically said, I don't
- 39:55know if I get the exact numbers right, but he said, you know, if
- 39:58there's 10% more people who vote in the 16th.
- 40:02So you know, the West of Paris, the bourgeois and small people
- 40:05who are supporting the far right, if 10% of people vote
- 40:09there compared to the 20th. So you know the the top.
- 40:13Left corner of Paris, you know, very working class, very
- 40:16immigrant heavy. If, if that if they'd vote 10%
- 40:20less than than in the 16th, almost certainly the left is
- 40:24going to lose the election. And So what he was saying and
- 40:27you know, and I think he actually has a much better sense
- 40:29of this because he's doing door knocking, he's doing lots of
- 40:31things. He was saying that, you know,
- 40:33his biggest concern is that the stakes aren't necessarily, you
- 40:38know, well, express to press to people.
- 40:41And so, you know, I think. And there is a sort of like
- 40:43Paris, like Paris has been run by the left for 25 years.
- 40:48And so people just assume, yeah, the Loft is going to win.
- 40:50Paris will continue to be a sort of socialist.
- 40:52The continuity candidate is Emmanuel Craig, who was like,
- 40:56you know, involved with Hidalgo's government.
- 41:01Most people just sort. Of assume that's what's going.
- 41:02To happen and and it's not necessarily the case.
- 41:05Obviously it's going to because it's this two round system.
- 41:09It's the most you know what to watch for is what you know how
- 41:13many candidates get that 10% and how what the turn out is even.
- 41:17In the first round, right? I mean at the very.
- 41:19Least you have one. Week to try to rally people who
- 41:22were on the fence or who weren't planning on voting assuming
- 41:25they're already signed up to vote right like because that's
- 41:28another issue but yeah it's it's really disheartening because you
- 41:31know as long as I've been a voter I've I've learned about
- 41:35and I don't mean just here I mean in the US as well about the
- 41:38importance of local elections and I just you can't sleep on
- 41:41this one you just can't and I mean like.
- 41:43Like we talked a little bit about this earlier, but it is
- 41:46kind of hard to know what the right would do if they got into
- 41:49power. Like Paris has been led by right
- 41:52wing politicians before, most notably Jacques Chirac, who then
- 41:57went on to become president. But it was a very different
- 41:59world. I was just going to say the
- 42:00right didn't look quite. The same didn't look the same.
- 42:04Obviously that T has said that she would never make a coalition
- 42:06with the far right of Saak Nefu, but will she take some of Saak
- 42:10Nefu's ideas? You know, Saak Canafo's idea of,
- 42:14of creating some sort of crazy like 2 tiered system where
- 42:17there's cars under, you know, that go along the water and then
- 42:19above ridiculous above the water, it's ridiculous
- 42:23pedestrians. Whether she would, you know,
- 42:25take some of that on and and actually, you know, try to, you
- 42:28know, try to placate the the the far right voters is, is to me
- 42:33definitely up in the air. You know, like their whole thing
- 42:36is like security. What does that mean?
- 42:37Are they going to hire a bunch more municipal police officers?
- 42:40Probably. And what hiring a lot more
- 42:43municipal police officers, even in left wing places like Sandini
- 42:47leads to is often a lot of, you know, racial profiling, you
- 42:51know, violence against minority communities.
- 42:56And we can imagine that, you know, would be exported to to
- 42:59Paris. You know, they talk a lot about
- 43:01cleanliness. What is, you know what, what
- 43:05does that actually look like? It's they haven't really
- 43:08necessarily proposed anything very clear on that.
- 43:11What does that mean for, You know, there's like 3500 homeless
- 43:14people living. It's getting worse and worse.
- 43:17Yeah, at any. Given moment.
- 43:19You know, what is their policy? Are they just going to like, you
- 43:21know, get everyone in buses and ship them out to other cities?
- 43:24Like, you know, there's not a lot of clarity on what that
- 43:26would actually look like. But then again, you know, and
- 43:29this is part of what the left has done wrong is that there's
- 43:31not enough, enough clarity, I think, coming from the left
- 43:35about, OK, you know, what are we going to do differently?
- 43:38Like, how do, how do we differentiate ourselves from
- 43:42Hidalgo, who again, like we said, the beginning is highly
- 43:44unpopular. What's our, what's our plan to
- 43:47go forward Like? Yes, we talked about the sort of
- 43:49transformation of Paris. How do you, how do you, you
- 43:53know, take that to the next level?
- 43:54What does that look like? So this has all been very.
- 43:56Serious. And I, and I want to just add in
- 44:00something for those who didn't know anything about Sarah
- 44:03Knapfo. You have to at least look at how
- 44:08she has copied Zorn Mamdani's campaign colors and fonts and
- 44:14mirrored some of his videos for social media, including, you
- 44:20know, next stop, Hotel de Villa. It lacks so much originality
- 44:24that it's it's quite humorous. But given everything you've
- 44:26said, I don't want to suggest that we should just blow her off
- 44:29entirely because who knows, right?
- 44:32So I do want to leave people with something, something
- 44:34actionable. For those who are about to vote
- 44:37for the first time, they obviously have a lot of context
- 44:40because of this conversation. But you know, the city sends out
- 44:44brochures and everyone's mailbox with the platforms of all the
- 44:48candidates. If you think that they don't
- 44:51actually express enough of what the their measures would
- 44:55actually look like, how do you think people should evaluate
- 44:59their choices? That's a good question, and
- 45:02it's. Yeah.
- 45:02It's it's very funny that I mean, it's funny and also
- 45:05concerning the, the sort of Canafo, like she uses the same
- 45:08font, you know, like her whole thing has been like this sort of
- 45:12like Mumdani esque positivity, which is really weird actually
- 45:16to see from the far right. Like, oh, like her slogan is a
- 45:18happy city. And I, I this is not an original
- 45:21thought of mine. This is from Le Monde has a
- 45:23podcast called Le Monde. And recently they did a podcast
- 45:25on the Paris municipal elections and they actually mentioned that
- 45:30this sort of the kenafo effect, what she's trying to go for is,
- 45:34is this sort of nostalgia effect of like, you know, sort of bring
- 45:38bringing Paris back to what it looked like in like the 1950s,
- 45:41which also should ring alarm bells, you know, like by getting
- 45:45rid of immigrants and like, you know, bringing the cars back and
- 45:50all of this stuff. So, so sorry, that was just a
- 45:53bit of a tangent, but to answer your question, So what to what
- 45:56to look for? I mean, for me, what I'm looking
- 45:59for, I, I do think that actually the situation for unhoused
- 46:04people in Paris is untenable. It's getting worse every year.
- 46:07I would like to see a candidate who comes up with a very
- 46:13concrete and actual plan for housing those folks, for giving
- 46:17them access to, you know, mental health services, for giving them
- 46:21access to physical health services as well.
- 46:24There's a really interesting activist group called the
- 46:28Collective Lore. It actually started it as
- 46:31activists who are trying to use the Olympics as a way to draw
- 46:35shed a light on the situation for people living on the streets
- 46:39of Paris. And they've sent sort of re
- 46:41worked their their platform to Orient towards the municipal
- 46:46elections and they've been contacting all of the different
- 46:49candidates with a very concrete plan.
- 46:51Here is what we as people who are on the ground say, you know,
- 46:54have seen and what we want to see from you as politicians.
- 46:57And, and actually, they organized an event a couple
- 47:01weeks ago where everyone but the far right, all of the
- 47:05candidates, but the far right or representative of those
- 47:07candidates were on stage together talking about though
- 47:11that proposal and, and basically being questioned, You know, what
- 47:15will you know, this element of our, of our proposal?
- 47:18Will you do this, Will you do this?
- 47:20And it was, it was really interesting.
- 47:21I was at that event. It was really interesting to see
- 47:23that. So, you know, that's one thing
- 47:24that I'm looking at and just because you know.
- 47:27People are going to wonder, did anybody have any, anything
- 47:31convincing to say? So you.
- 47:34Know, I think the, the, the, the, the two different left
- 47:39parties, you know, both pretty much support all of the
- 47:43different elements of this. But what was a bit too bad was
- 47:46just like they sort of use that, that moment as an opportunity to
- 47:49just bash on one another about previous things.
- 47:53You know, like you didn't do enough on this issue when you
- 47:55were, you know, you were in Paris, you were in, you know,
- 47:58leading Paris for 25 years. Why don't you do that?
- 48:00Which is valid Like, you know, it's a valid thing, but you
- 48:03know, there wasn't this sort of like there's a common threat
- 48:06sort of we need to get get together and, and, and sort of,
- 48:10you know, align on this. And then the the sort of the,
- 48:13the different right wing groups sort of said, well, we mostly
- 48:17want to adapt most of this, but here's our little sort of right
- 48:19wing spin on it. What's interesting about that is
- 48:22this sort of not deference to NGO's, but this this sort of
- 48:26inclusion of NGO's of people who are on the ground to actually
- 48:29make policy, which is something that I think, you know, might
- 48:33give a little bit more hope to people about the way politics is
- 48:36run. If you can know that the people
- 48:39who are actually on the ground who are actually working with,
- 48:42you know, in this case it's unhoused people.
- 48:43But you know, the same thing could be said for like anything
- 48:46from, you know, education to healthcare, you know, this
- 48:49having more sort of citizen input, I think would be would be
- 48:53something, you know, very positive.
- 48:54And this does seem to be starting a little bit.
- 48:56And groups like that are really important in making that happen.
- 48:59Otherwise, people should just look at.
- 49:01What, what the candidates are saying about the issue that
- 49:04feels most important to them? Exactly.
- 49:06Yeah. And like that.
- 49:07Is a thing that's nice about France is that everyone sends
- 49:10you their program and you can look at through their through
- 49:13the program. Actually, a lot of people don't
- 49:15necessarily even vote until they or you know, think, you know,
- 49:18decide what they're who they're going to vote for until they've
- 49:20read through all of the physical brochures.
- 49:24Yes, there are websites. But people often wait for the
- 49:27mailings. Yeah, for me, I think.
- 49:30You know, homelessness is a very important issue.
- 49:32I've written a lot on this, reported a lot on this.
- 49:34For the next person, it might be, you know, education.
- 49:38You know, there has been some sort of like, you know, some
- 49:40scandals linked to education in Paris, which we definitely don't
- 49:44have time to get into. That's a whole other topic.
- 49:46But you know, I've, you know, I think for, you know, parents,
- 49:49you know, people with young children like that could be a
- 49:52crucial and and so they want to see, you know, concrete sort of
- 49:55promises on that. So maybe we're going to need.
- 49:59To do a follow up after the election results are in in the
- 50:03first round. TBD.
- 50:06Send me a message TBD. But at the very.
- 50:08Least it will be interesting to follow what happens after the,
- 50:12what, the 22nd of March? And we're going to cross our
- 50:15fingers, I guess. Yeah, first, first round March.
- 50:1815th second round March 22nd. Both are Sundays.
- 50:23Well, those will be very interesting days also just, and
- 50:26that's what I'm planning on doing, just walk around Paris
- 50:28and sort of talk to people and see how they're feeling.
- 50:32See, you know, whether there's any protests or whether there's
- 50:35any types of like public, I don't know, manifestations.
- 50:39Yeah, Yeah. It's going to, it's going to be,
- 50:41it's going to be interesting and just in time for spring, just.
- 50:44In time for spring, hopefully. The sun level will have gone
- 50:47down far enough that we can actually like, you know, go and
- 50:49talk to people also along the the riverbanks because currently
- 50:52that's not very possible. No it isn't.
- 50:54Phineas, thank you for this explainer and for the reporting
- 50:58you do which I will link to in the show notes.
- 51:02Thank you for having me. That's the show for today.
- 51:06If you're listening on Spotify, be sure to check out the poll
- 51:09related to this episode by scrolling down in your app.
- 51:12There are more exciting conversations to come this
- 51:14season, so I hope you'll subscribe or share the show with
- 51:17a friend if you've been enjoying what you've heard so far.
- 51:20As always, you can find more from me at lindsaytremuta.com
- 51:24and at the New Paris Dispatch on Sub Stack at Treinto.