Latest / Surrounded / 1 Vegan vs 20 Meat Eaters (ft. Jack Symes)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey listeners,
- 0:00just want to remind you we have episodes of the pod coming out
- 0:03every Sunday,
- 0:04so please consider subscribing
- 0:06wherever you get your podcasts.
- 0:08Thank you for your support.
- 0:09Do you think we should reduce the amount of pain that plants are experiencing?
- 0:12Yes,
- 0:12we should.
- 0:13Plants matter.
- 0:14# plants matter.
- 0:16You're not addressing my points.
- 0:17You are not addressing my points.
- 0:18You're deflecting because I literally backed you into a corner.
- 0:21You can have sex
- 0:22and it was unethical,
- 0:23non-consensual,
- 0:24but it was great,
- 0:25or you can have the consensual sex and it's not quite as good.
- 0:27Which one did you pick?
- 0:28Probably a cheeseburger.
- 0:30Is eating meat unethical,
- 0:32or has the conversation around veganism and ethical dieting become too rigid
- 0:36and moralized?
- 0:37I'm John Regalado,
- 0:38and from Jubilee Media this is Surrounded,
- 0:40where one brave soul faces a room full of disagreers.
- 0:43Today we're diving head first into veganism,
- 0:46factory farming,
- 0:47and what it means to eat ethically.
- 0:49I'm here in the center with our featured guest,
- 0:52Doctor Jack Symes.
- 0:53Welcome to the show.
- 0:54Hey,
- 0:54thanks for having me.
- 0:55Are you ready to debate the circle?
- 0:57Sure am.
- 0:57I'm looking forward to hearing what reasons
- 0:59they've brought for their unethical lifestyles.
- 1:01Are you all ready to bring your best arguments?
- 1:05Holy.
- 1:06All right,
- 1:06let's get into it.
- 1:11My first surrounded claim is
- 1:13extreme suffering for trivial pleasure is morally indefensible.
- 1:17If you'd like to be the first debater,
- 1:19get to the chair
- 1:20in 321.
- 1:24Easy lads.
- 1:25Doctor Jack,
- 1:26nice to meet you.
- 1:27What's your name?
- 1:27I'm Doctor Pete,
- 1:28nice to meet you.
- 1:29Hey,
- 1:29Doctor Pete.
- 1:30So I am,
- 1:30uh,
- 1:31very excited about this topic.
- 1:32I think it's
- 1:33super interesting that it touches on so much in all sorts of food.
- 1:37So I'm an emergency medicine physician.
- 1:38Do you,
- 1:39do you wanna,
- 1:39on the,
- 1:39on the claim I made first of all,
- 1:40do you wanna,
- 1:41do you disagree with that?
- 1:42I do,
- 1:43I do.
- 1:43You disagree extreme suffering for trivial pleasures morally indefensible.
- 1:46Can I give you the reason then you can disagree?
- 1:48Yeah,
- 1:48yeah,
- 1:48absolutely.
- 1:48So I think this principle comes from many of the major world philosophies,
- 1:51so you could be religious or non-religious,
- 1:53or you could be a Christian,
- 1:54a Jew,
- 1:55a Muslim,
- 1:55you could be a Hindu,
- 1:56a Sikh,
- 1:56you could be a Buddhist,
- 1:57or you could have one of the secular.
- 1:58Moral philosophies of well,
- 1:59you could be an Aristelian,
- 2:00a utilitarian,
- 2:01an existentialist,
- 2:02but the easiest way to understand it is just being a utilitarian,
- 2:05right?
- 2:05A good action is one way you create lots of
- 2:06happiness and pleasure and very little pain and suffering.
- 2:09But unfortunately,
- 2:09when it comes to factory farming,
- 2:10it's the other way around in our treatment of non-human animals in general.
- 2:13Quick example,
- 2:14and I'll let you jump in.
- 2:15A broiler chicken exists for 6 weeks.
- 2:17As soon as it's born,
- 2:18it has its beak clipped off with a guillotine.
- 2:20It's put in a cage so small it can't move,
- 2:21it's pumped full of food for 6 weeks straight,
- 2:24so fast that its organs fail,
- 2:25its legs break under its own weight,
- 2:26it goes blind because of the toxins in its own feces,
- 2:29and then it has its throat slit alongside 10,000 or so of its brothers and sisters.
- 2:32I think that's an extreme amount of pain and suffering for what is trivial pleasure,
- 2:36which is the taste on your lips.
- 2:37Would you agree?
- 2:38Well,
- 2:38I'll say that all of civilization is about chasing triviality.
- 2:42And at the same time I think that suffering,
- 2:44do you think that's too much suffering for the I would
- 2:45definitely also say that suffering is inevitable and it's essential.
- 2:48It's inevitable,
- 2:49but you can minimize it,
- 2:50right?
- 2:50Is there too much there?
- 2:51So as an emergency medicine doc who takes care of suffering all the time,
- 2:54I'm happy to talk about that,
- 2:55but if you can just say,
- 2:56is that too much suffering imparted onto the chicken.
- 2:58That particular example,
- 2:59yeah,
- 3:00whatever it takes.
- 3:01Whatever it takes to sustain 8 billion people across the world,
- 3:03I would say is,
- 3:04is not it's easier to sustain 8
- 3:06billion people without uh having animal agriculture.
- 3:08It's possible.
- 3:09I'd like to hear the mechanistic argument for that,
- 3:11but I will say as a philosophy,
- 3:13you're a philosopher,
- 3:14I'm an ER doctor.
- 3:14Well,
- 3:14there are 30 to 60 million children that are dying every year from starvation.
- 3:18UNICEF put it at 30 million.
- 3:19Uh,
- 3:20Doctor Richard Opperlander puts it at 60 million,
- 3:22and so every year you've got 30 to 60 million.
- 3:24In 82% of those cases,
- 3:26the children are dying in places where the majority of the meat
- 3:29has been given to cattle and sold to more affluent countries.
- 3:32That's Ethiopia,
- 3:33that's Sudan.
- 3:34Sudan is the hungriest country,
- 3:35major in the world,
- 3:36and it has one of the biggest livestocks in all of Africa.
- 3:39So you can feed
- 3:40these people if you go to plant-based.
- 3:42You need 75% less land,
- 3:44and the,
- 3:45the amount of agriculture which is used towards.
- 3:47Supporting these
- 3:48non-human animals to slaughter them,
- 3:49it's that,
- 3:50that's one of the biggest causes of not being able to.
- 3:53You're talking about a massive problem across
- 3:55billions of people across many geographies,
- 3:57and I,
- 3:57I think what you bring up is probably true.
- 3:59But at the same time,
- 4:00I don't think the solution to it is just
- 4:02either you're vegan or you're not.
- 4:03And what I mean to say is this about suffering,
- 4:05is that
- 4:06when you take care of people with strokes,
- 4:08heart attacks,
- 4:09domestic abuse,
- 4:10bear attacks,
- 4:11they're also violent predators
- 4:13that eat all sorts of things in addition to us.
- 4:15You know,
- 4:15you start to understand that there's 2 types of suffering,
- 4:18and I think that's the most important part,
- 4:202 types of suffering.
- 4:21There's senseless suffering
- 4:22and there's meaningful suffering.
- 4:24And I think what you have to understand is
- 4:25that when you can create meaning behind suffering,
- 4:28there's gratuitous suffering,
- 4:29that's the,
- 4:30there's unnecessary suffering,
- 4:32and that's the vegan claim
- 4:33that I take veganism to be
- 4:35the practical ethical rule
- 4:37to avoid products and practices that cause unnecessary suffering.
- 4:41So,
- 4:41would you agree that if you can do something
- 4:43without
- 4:43the suffering,
- 4:44you ought to do it without the suffering,
- 4:45yes or no?
- 4:46Are you against domestication.
- 4:48That I'm happy to respond.
- 4:49If you think you can do something without suffering,
- 4:51or you do that.
- 4:52I don't think avoiding suffering is the highest good.
- 4:54What is the highest good?
- 4:56I've just told you that every major world philosophy,
- 4:58I've just told you every single major world religion,
- 5:00every secular philosophy religion thinks that extreme suffering for all
- 5:04human beings that that does not justify trivial pleasure.
- 5:07Can you name one world philosophy that thinks
- 5:09that extreme suffering can justify trivial pleasure?
- 5:12I don't need to name a philosophy.
- 5:14I think what it is is that in the ER,
- 5:16in reality,
- 5:17in reality,
- 5:18when I'm taking care of people recently diagnosed with
- 5:19cancer or they have a child that died,
- 5:21etc.
- 5:22that significant,
- 5:23look,
- 5:23there are two big studies on overall general health outcomes.
- 5:26The Epic survey at the University of Oxford looked
- 5:28at 50 million people over the last 30 years,
- 5:30and the Christian Adventist Study in the United
- 5:32States of America that looked at 75,000 people.
- 5:35In both these studies,
- 5:36it's found that you're like.
- 5:37To live significantly longer,
- 5:38less risk of heart disease,
- 5:39less risk of cancer,
- 5:40less risk of diabetes,
- 5:41less risk of obesity
- 5:43if you're vegan rather than eating meat.
- 5:44This is the most obese
- 5:46most obese country on the face of the planet in terms of the global
- 5:49and in terms of being a major country.
- 5:5175% of people in this country are overweight and obese.
- 5:54I know,
- 5:55I know it very keenly.
- 5:56I'm responsible for their health as well.
- 5:58Pause,
- 5:58you've been voted out by the majority.
- 6:00Please go back to us.
- 6:00Thank you.
- 6:01Hey,
- 6:01nice to meet you.
- 6:07How's it going,
- 6:07buds.
- 6:08Nice to meet you.
- 6:09What's your name,
- 6:09sorry?
- 6:09My name is Brian.
- 6:10Nice to meet you,
- 6:11Brian.
- 6:11You have a PhD in philosophy?
- 6:12I do,
- 6:12yeah.
- 6:13That was my first major.
- 6:14Oh,
- 6:14cool,
- 6:14nice.
- 6:14What'd you study?
- 6:15Uh,
- 6:16philosophy.
- 6:17Yeah.
- 6:17Oh,
- 6:17what do you mean?
- 6:18Where did you study?
- 6:18Oh,
- 6:19University of Texas,
- 6:19San Antonio.
- 6:20Yeah,
- 6:21I actually went to the,
- 6:22um,
- 6:23National Ethics Bowl,
- 6:24um,
- 6:24and competed.
- 6:25Awesome.
- 6:25So that's,
- 6:26uh,
- 6:26yeah,
- 6:27so what do you think of the claim?
- 6:28I,
- 6:28I made the claim earlier to one of your,
- 6:30uh,
- 6:30one of your peers that there's no major world
- 6:32philosophy that thinks that extreme suffering justifies trivial pleasure.
- 6:34Would you agree with that?
- 6:35So,
- 6:36um,
- 6:36can we just stick like point by point rather than bouncing around?
- 6:38I just wanna,
- 6:39yeah,
- 6:39OK,
- 6:39yeah,
- 6:40so just that claim.
- 6:41So what I heard from you is that you believe in the,
- 6:43in minimalizing suffering.
- 6:45I think all of the major world philosophies hold some version of that to be true,
- 6:48yeah,
- 6:48so I will not defend factory farming.
- 6:51Um,
- 6:51there is another way of producing meat,
- 6:54and it is regenerative agriculture,
- 6:56and regenerative agriculture reduces all of the harm.
- 6:59OK.
- 7:00It doesn't reduce all of the harm.
- 7:01The,
- 7:01the first,
- 7:01well,
- 7:01the,
- 7:01the majority of the harm,
- 7:02they,
- 7:03they live beautiful lives on regenerative ranches,
- 7:06bad day,
- 7:06right?
- 7:07They,
- 7:07right,
- 7:08absolutely I've had bad days.
- 7:09They don't know that it's coming,
- 7:10but,
- 7:10but they're serving one's ever.
- 7:12They're serving their purpose,
- 7:13but they're,
- 7:14OK,
- 7:14but here's the deal.
- 7:14Would they even exist in the first place if they weren't being harvested for me?
- 7:17No,
- 7:17no,
- 7:17no,
- 7:17let me just,
- 7:18let me just ask you a question.
- 7:19Do they have the right to exist?
- 7:21Yeah,
- 7:21because you're cutting me off.
- 7:22Do they have the right to exist?
- 7:24Because here's the deal,
- 7:25if you're saying that we should not harvest them,
- 7:27then those animals are never going to exist.
- 7:30So I guarantee if they had consciousness and you put them down and you said,
- 7:33here are the scenarios,
- 7:34you can either exist and you can have one bad day and you can serve.
- 7:38A purpose and you can have a beautiful life.
- 7:40You can make a positive contribution to the environment.
- 7:43You can make a,
- 7:43can I finish?
- 7:44Can I finish?
- 7:45You,
- 7:45you're taking the poll.
- 7:46Absolutely.
- 7:47I've heard the case.
- 7:47So,
- 7:48so,
- 7:48so when I die,
- 7:49I want to be buried in the soil and I want to
- 7:51decompose so that my carbon returns to grass is a myth.
- 7:53The conscientious farming is a myth because you're,
- 7:55you're not addressing my points.
- 7:56You are not addressing my points.
- 7:58You are deflecting because I literally backed you into a corner.
- 8:00Conscientious farming.
- 8:01What about all of the mice?
- 8:03What about all of the rabbits that die?
- 8:05Have you ever spent time on a farm?
- 8:07Have you,
- 8:08have you ever talked farm to farmers?
- 8:09OK,
- 8:09and how many mice,
- 8:10how many rabbits are murdered to produce vegetables of all of how many are
- 8:14murdered to produce 80% of all of them are fed to factory farms.
- 8:18I've just told you,
- 8:1980% of all of soy is given to non-human animals.
- 8:23Only 7%.
- 8:24I'm gonna stop right there.
- 8:25The soy is grown for the oil,
- 8:27the soy is grown for the oil,
- 8:28it is literally extracted.
- 8:29The leftover product is then fed to cattle.
- 8:32That is a manipulative statistic.
- 8:33I am here for discussion.
- 8:34You won't address the point.
- 8:36I've let me respond.
- 8:37Go back to the soy,
- 8:38go back to the soy.
- 8:39Go back to the soy.
- 8:40Go back to the soy.
- 8:4175% reduction according to Hannah Ritchie in 2022.
- 8:44She says that's our world in data,
- 8:46you get a 75% reduction in all agricultural land.
- 8:4930% of all your agricultural land is given to cattle.
- 8:52We've got 80 to 90% species not addressing the soy've got 80 to 90% species.
- 8:57You're not addressing the soy.
- 8:5985%,
- 9:01it is literally the byproduct.
- 9:02They grow the soy for the oil,
- 9:04even if it wasn't being fed to the animals,
- 9:05they would still grow the soy.
- 9:07That
- 9:07is true.
- 9:08That is true.
- 9:09I'm a reference right here.
- 9:10Yeah,
- 9:10and you don't understand the statistic.
- 9:12If you go and actually look at the statistic,
- 9:13all of the soy is taken,
- 9:15the oil is suppressed,
- 9:16and then the byproduct is what is fed to the animal,
- 9:19and it is 85% of it is left over,
- 9:21and that's what's fed to the animal.
- 9:2280 to 90% according to the WWF and the UN.
- 9:26Why you are deflecting.
- 9:27You are deflecting.
- 9:28You,
- 9:28so you brought up a statistic and you said that 85% of soy is fed to cattle,
- 9:3380%,
- 9:33whatever,
- 9:33whatever you said,
- 9:34you said the majority of soy is fed to cattle,
- 9:36did you not?
- 9:37I said 80%.
- 9:37Yeah,
- 9:38OK,
- 9:3880%.
- 9:38So really,
- 9:39now,
- 9:39now you're gonna argue about 5%.
- 9:40You understand the intent.
- 9:41So you're saying that the majority of soy is fed to cattle,
- 9:44and I'm telling you that that is inaccurate.
- 9:46It's not as if the soy bean in it,
- 9:48listen to me,
- 9:49listen to me.
- 9:49It's,
- 9:50it's the nuance.
- 9:50It is the nuance.
- 9:51That you were trying to deflect with.
- 9:52It is not as if 80% of all soy is fed to cattle in its natural state.
- 9:58The oil is extracted and then the byproduct is fed
- 10:01being used because of factory farming for the raising cattle.
- 10:03I'm not defending factory farming 90% of all your wildlife extinction.
- 10:06You argue against regenerative agriculture,
- 10:08for having cows,
- 10:09pigs,
- 10:09chickens,
- 10:10turkegenerative agriculture.
- 10:11Argue against regenerative agriculture
- 10:13because it destroys the wildlife,
- 10:15because it destroys the climate.
- 10:17According to the UN,
- 10:1891% of all deforestation is caused by animal agriculture.
- 10:21According to the WWF and the UN,
- 10:2480 to 90% of all wildlife extinction is caused by animal agriculture.
- 10:28Just because you're using that land.
- 10:29hunting leases,
- 10:3035%.
- 10:31Listen,
- 10:31ranchers who have hunting leases,
- 10:33meaning that they have a ranch,
- 10:34they have land,
- 10:35they don't allow animals on there,
- 10:36they will literally have ranchers bring their cattle in there
- 10:39and flash graze the grass because guess what,
- 10:42it improves.
- 10:42The entire ecosystem and it provides no energy.
- 10:45What do you think the Amazon?
- 10:47What's the leading cause of what happened?
- 10:48What happened in Yellowstone when they reintroduced
- 10:50wolves the leading cause of deforestation?
- 10:51What happened the leading cause of what happened in
- 10:54Yellowstone when they reintroduced wolves having a conversation,
- 10:57are you?
- 10:57You answer my question.
- 10:58They're doing it for soy.
- 11:00OK,
- 11:00but here's the deal you one question.
- 11:02The deforestation is related to factory farming.
- 11:04You can get rid of the deforestation.
- 11:06You think you've got factory farms in the Amazon.
- 11:08Sorry,
- 11:09have you been to,
- 11:09they're doing it for soy,
- 11:11they're doing it for soy.
- 11:12You've been voted out by the majority.
- 11:14Please return to your seat.
- 11:21How's it going?
- 11:21What was your name,
- 11:22sorry?
- 11:23Nice to meet you.
- 11:23Girl on carnivore actually.
- 11:24You're,
- 11:25you're a carnivore.
- 11:25I am Carnivore,
- 11:26full carnivore.
- 11:28So this will be fun.
- 11:29OK,
- 11:29yeah,
- 11:29you do.
- 11:31I do it
- 11:32mainly because I can't survive without meat.
- 11:35I can't survive.
- 11:35I cannot survive without an island scenario for you every day.
- 11:38It is.
- 11:38It truly is.
- 11:38What condition do you have,
- 11:39if you don't mind me asking?
- 11:40Sure,
- 11:40I have gastroesophagus reflux disease,
- 11:43and so I cannot eat a vegetarian or vegan diet.
- 11:47I will literally get very,
- 11:48very sick,
- 11:49and I was actually
- 11:50vegan vegetarian when I was 16 years old,
- 11:52and that's when I got diagnosed.
- 11:54I've been on a journey.
- 11:55Thank you.
- 11:56You've seen dietitians.
- 11:57You've spoken to GPs.
- 11:58You've seen doctors.
- 11:59I've seen doctors.
- 11:59I've seen GPs.
- 12:00They've all put me on medications,
- 12:01and I was on medication for over 10 years
- 12:04that actually ended up depleting my vitamin D levels
- 12:07and put me in great amounts of depression.
- 12:09And I was also told by doctors that I would never be able to powerlift again.
- 12:13I am now lifting 315 pounds with a deadlift.
- 12:16And you couldn't find any of the,
- 12:17like all of the amino acids,
- 12:19all of the nutrients you needed in a plant-based diet.
- 12:21Unfortunately,
- 12:21I couldn't.
- 12:22What was it you were missing?
- 12:23Um,
- 12:24mainly protein.
- 12:25I cannot consume enough protein from vegetation that I need to
- 12:30get it from meat.
- 12:31There's a study by Miguel Lopez,
- 12:33a,
- 12:33a big one last year in 2025 Journal of,
- 12:36um,
- 12:37of,
- 12:37of sport medicine
- 12:38that looks at
- 12:39over 8000 papers across,
- 12:41um,
- 12:42you know,
- 12:42protein intake
- 12:43and found there was no difference in terms of protein intake and
- 12:46upper body strength,
- 12:47lower body strength,
- 12:48and overall body strength.
- 12:49So
- 12:50I'm always surprised to meet somebody who says that,
- 12:52you know,
- 12:52this just doesn't work,
- 12:54um.
- 12:54You know,
- 12:55the obviously great athletes who take on a lot of protein,
- 12:58um,
- 12:58as well.
- 12:58And when you look at basic things like,
- 13:00you know,
- 13:00your tofu per portion's going to have more protein than your eggs,
- 13:04uh,
- 13:04your seitan's gonna have nearly twice as much protein as your,
- 13:07as your lean meat,
- 13:08your sirloin steak,
- 13:09and your soy milk's gonna have more protein than your whole or semi-skimmed milk.
- 13:12So I'm always surprised to hear people can't get the protein.
- 13:15I,
- 13:15I wonder like,
- 13:16you know,
- 13:16did you do.
- 13:16Those things were you,
- 13:17did you,
- 13:18you carefully picked all of those?
- 13:19It's an inflammation issue really when it comes down to it.
- 13:21So anytime I eat any other foods that are not
- 13:24meat,
- 13:24I get tons of inflammation.
- 13:27And so I can't physically lift.
- 13:29I can't physically really move.
- 13:31I feel very ill.
- 13:32And so meat actually makes it where I can
- 13:35live and then strive.
- 13:37Do you want to be vegan?
- 13:38I do not want to be vegan.
- 13:40Why?
- 13:41I do not want to be vegan because it makes me sick,
- 13:44but like if,
- 13:44if,
- 13:45if you were,
- 13:45you know,
- 13:45you didn't have these health conditions,
- 13:47if I didn't have these health conditions and I could eat whatever I wanted,
- 13:50it's possible,
- 13:52but I,
- 13:53I,
- 13:53you know,
- 13:53it's a really good question.
- 13:55Um,
- 13:55I really feel like
- 13:58maybe,
- 13:59yeah,
- 13:59you probably would,
- 14:00maybe,
- 14:00I mean,
- 14:01right,
- 14:01if I,
- 14:01if I had no adverse,
- 14:02if I had no adverse effects to.
- 14:05Uh,
- 14:06the,
- 14:06the vegan foods,
- 14:07OK,
- 14:07then maybe.
- 14:08So,
- 14:08so do you try,
- 14:09I think,
- 14:09I think conscientious farming is,
- 14:11is,
- 14:11is a myth,
- 14:12but do you try and get the,
- 14:13the meat-based and animal-based products that you get from,
- 14:16uh,
- 14:16as ethically as possible?
- 14:18I,
- 14:18I have.
- 14:19I'm not going to say that I do it all the time because I'm not going to lie to you,
- 14:22um,
- 14:22but my brother's actually a farmer out in Texas,
- 14:24and I try the best that I can to get my meat from my brother because I find that that's
- 14:30the best way to do it.
- 14:31I've actually went out to Texas and processed a cow with him,
- 14:33so I was actually there.
- 14:35Um,
- 14:35he shot the cow,
- 14:36and then,
- 14:37um,
- 14:37we processed it,
- 14:38and it was
- 14:39an experience for me because I actually got to see where my meat comes from
- 14:42as opposed to just being
- 14:44blindly eating.
- 14:46Yeah,
- 14:47I'm not sure,
- 14:47I'm not sure I'd enjoy it more if I got to see the creatures.
- 14:51Well,
- 14:51my family's,
- 14:51you know,
- 14:52they were butchers and,
- 14:53and so I like to,
- 14:54um.
- 14:55You know,
- 14:56just kind of continue that in,
- 14:58in my family,
- 14:58but I was a vegan vegetarian like I said,
- 15:00and when I was younger,
- 15:01and I,
- 15:02I do see where you were coming from as far
- 15:04as like where it could be ethically more sound,
- 15:06but unfortunately I've looked everywhere because I've,
- 15:09I've sort of met a bunch of people like you.
- 15:11Um,
- 15:12and I'm always,
- 15:12like I say,
- 15:13I'm always skeptical because the stuff that I
- 15:14read seems to go in the opposite direction.
- 15:16The only study I found said it was about 0.1
- 15:18to 0.2% of people have a condition like yours where they
- 15:21actually need
- 15:22the meat,
- 15:23but it seems like,
- 15:24you know,
- 15:24when I meet people,
- 15:25it's normally like 10% of people.
- 15:26Uh,
- 15:27so I,
- 15:27I do find it hard to,
- 15:28you know,
- 15:29I just to be honest,
- 15:29I find it hard to believe just in general because I meet so many people
- 15:33that say
- 15:33things like this.
- 15:35Um,
- 15:35and I'd just encourage you to,
- 15:37you know,
- 15:37to
- 15:38go as far towards vegan,
- 15:39veganism as possible,
- 15:41right?
- 15:42OK,
- 15:42but all right,
- 15:43pause pause.
- 15:44You,
- 15:45you've been voted out by the majority.
- 15:46Please return to your seat.
- 15:47We didn't really have that thing,
- 15:48but I appreciate it.
- 15:49Thank you.
- 15:49Hopefully speak to you in a moment.
- 15:51Thank you.
- 15:56Hey,
- 15:57hello,
- 15:57nice to meet you.
- 15:58What's your name,
- 15:58sorry?
- 15:59Daniella.
- 15:59Nice to meet you,
- 16:00Daniella,
- 16:00Jack.
- 16:01Yeah,
- 16:01so I first became vegetarian at 8 years old.
- 16:05I had seen PETA videos online and I told my mum 8 years old.
- 16:08Yes,
- 16:08that's bad parenting right there.
- 16:09That's horrific stuff.
- 16:10Yeah,
- 16:10I decided I didn't want to do it and.
- 16:12And then at 16,
- 16:13I went vegan
- 16:15and all Whole Foods plant-based vegan.
- 16:16So I wasn't having
- 16:18seed oils or were you taking supplements?
- 16:20No,
- 16:20I was not.
- 16:21Yeah,
- 16:22and I subsequently developed
- 16:24PCOS symptoms as well as gout.
- 16:26So eating,
- 16:27so you are.
- 16:29Yeah,
- 16:30you were against Whole Foods plant-based.
- 16:31Yeah,
- 16:32I think,
- 16:32uh,
- 16:32I think any sensible nutritionist will say that you
- 16:35need to make sure you're doing it properly,
- 16:36you need to be doing it carefully,
- 16:37and that means for a start,
- 16:38taking a B12 tablet.
- 16:40I don't think there's anything wrong with that.
- 16:41I think we do lots of unnatural things,
- 16:42flying on planes,
- 16:43watching television.
- 16:44I think going straight to the source and just having a B12 tablet's absolutely fine.
- 16:48I think when you put those two diets in front of someone,
- 16:50like if we're not in this debate and someone said to you,
- 16:52right.
- 16:52Here's one diet where you take a B12 tablet,
- 16:54and here's another one where you've got an increased risk of heart disease,
- 16:57more likely to be obese,
- 16:58more likely to,
- 16:59um,
- 17:00you know,
- 17:00develop all kinds of cancers,
- 17:02and you're gonna live 15 to 20% longer according to
- 17:04the Christian Adventist Study here in the United States then.
- 17:07I think most people would go for that one.
- 17:09I think we need better information of
- 17:10let's not go for just a whole foods diet without that nutrition.
- 17:13Yeah,
- 17:13I will say,
- 17:14since I'm responding to your claim,
- 17:15I do agree with your claim.
- 17:16That was the biggest thing that bothered me about being a vegan or vegetarian and
- 17:21people would always go and they'd say,
- 17:22oh,
- 17:22but what about bacon?
- 17:23Come back,
- 17:23you know,
- 17:24come back to the,
- 17:24come back to the light.
- 17:26Well just take,
- 17:26take the B12 tablet and become vegan.
- 17:28But I'm not.
- 17:29op ath ic medicine.
- 17:30I don't think that these supplements are really beneficial.
- 17:33Of course they are.
- 17:33These big health studies show that 500,000 people,
- 17:36University of Oxford,
- 17:3775,000 people,
- 17:38the Christian Adventist Study.
- 17:40How is there a way to
- 17:42have veganism though without cities?
- 17:44I'm not pro cities.
- 17:46Yeah,
- 17:46I'm not pro cities.
- 17:47I think,
- 17:47you know,
- 17:47you talk later about
- 17:48factory farming,
- 17:49which is a product of the industrial revolution.
- 17:51You know,
- 17:52that's not something I'm
- 17:53for in any regard.
- 17:54I think that's been very disastrous veganism's linked to cities.
- 17:58Well,
- 17:58why wouldn't it be if you need to have all of these
- 18:00supplements and you need to have all of this mass production,
- 18:03supplement,
- 18:03it's just a B12 supplement.
- 18:05Yeah,
- 18:05but you'd also need to nuts and pause.
- 18:07Pause.
- 18:08You've been voted out by the majority.
- 18:09Please return to your seat.
- 18:10Yeah,
- 18:11well,
- 18:11welcome back to veganism.
- 18:12OK.
- 18:21It's meant to be.
- 18:23Alright,
- 18:24hi,
- 18:24nice to meet you.
- 18:26How's it going?
- 18:26What's your name,
- 18:27sorry?
- 18:27My name is Nicole Ashley.
- 18:28Nice to meet you,
- 18:29Nicole Ashley.
- 18:29Jack,
- 18:30how are you doing?
- 18:30I am great.
- 18:31I think plants,
- 18:32killing plants is murder though.
- 18:34Oh dude,
- 18:35don't do this.
- 18:37Come on,
- 18:37you're joking.
- 18:38You're ripping it from the ground,
- 18:39you're ripping it from its mother.
- 18:41It's murder,
- 18:43and I enjoy the trivial pleasure of doing what the lions,
- 18:46what the hyenas,
- 18:48what the tigers have done for history.
- 18:50So you think plants can feel pain?
- 18:52Yes,
- 18:52they can.
- 18:53So you want to reduce that pain.
- 18:54You know why?
- 18:55Because I have an azalea,
- 18:57and when I don't give it enough light,
- 18:58that thing dies,
- 18:59so it feels it.
- 19:01I think plants have feelings too,
- 19:03right?
- 19:03Do you think we should reduce.
- 19:04The amount of pain that plants are experiencing.
- 19:06Yes,
- 19:06we should.
- 19:07Plants matter.
- 19:08# plants matter.
- 19:10OK,
- 19:10so according to Hannah Ritchie 2022,
- 19:12you get a 75% reduction
- 19:15in all of the land that you need for farming.
- 19:17So if,
- 19:18given the fact you're getting 40 to 1 in your calories
- 19:20and 30 to 1 in your protein from plants to animals then slaughtered,
- 19:24you get a 75% decrease in the plants that you're
- 19:26going to kill if you go vegan for history,
- 19:29and I have to say this,
- 19:31when I go and don't give.
- 19:32I burn enough light,
- 19:33it feels.
- 19:35OK.
- 19:35When I don't give it any water,
- 19:37it feels.
- 19:38Right.
- 19:38Two things.
- 19:39I'll,
- 19:39I'll let you
- 19:40do whatever that was,
- 19:41so you'll,
- 19:41you'll hear me out.
- 19:42Um,
- 19:43the first thing to say is that we don't want to,
- 19:46in philosophy we call it the principle of parsimy,
- 19:48that just basically means we don't
- 19:49want to attribute a necessary attribute something
- 19:52if we can explain it without positing it.
- 19:54What does that mean?
- 19:55Plants don't have central nervous systems and their
- 19:58behavior can be explained without positing that they have minds.
- 20:00That can experience pain,
- 20:01pleasure,
- 20:02happiness and stuff,
- 20:03no,
- 20:03they don't,
- 20:03there's no reason to.
- 20:05No,
- 20:05they don't.
- 20:05They do.
- 20:06They don't.
- 20:07They do.
- 20:07The second thing,
- 20:08just quickly,
- 20:10no,
- 20:10cause I don't want to do the natural argument as well,
- 20:12and I want to get this one out of the way really quickly.
- 20:13I'll see if I can do it in 30 seconds,
- 20:14and I promise it'll be really quick.
- 20:16The argument they gave from nature is one of the biggest,
- 20:18uh,
- 20:19one of the worst arguments for being an anti-vegan.
- 20:21And why?
- 20:22Because there are lots of things that are predisposed
- 20:24through our natures that we shouldn't follow,
- 20:26right?
- 20:26Um,
- 20:26we're naturally predisposed towards war.
- 20:28cheating,
- 20:29stealing,
- 20:29that's part of the Christian tradition.
- 20:31They think Saint Augustine the Fifth,
- 20:32but what about to the caveman times?
- 20:35The caveman times,
- 20:36the caveman lived,
- 20:37they lived off of eating meat.
- 20:39So what is the big deal?
- 20:41I love me a juicy burger,
- 20:43and why should I be denied that when you guys are murderers too,
- 20:47ripping a poor plant from its mama,
- 20:49from the Mother Earth.
- 20:51Y'all should be ashamed of y'allselves,
- 20:53and we're out of time,
- 20:54baby.
- 20:55Let's do it.
- 20:57I'm glad you got your quick.
- 21:00Thank you.
- 21:01It's tax season,
- 21:02so people are thinking about money.
- 21:04Here's something most people don't think about until it's too late.
- 21:07Getting your credit over 600 could save you about
- 21:10$2000 the next time you finance a car.
- 21:12With Kickoff,
- 21:13users with credit under 600 grow an average of 86 points,
- 21:17just by paying on time.
- 21:19Transparent,
- 21:20affordable plans start at just $5 per month.
- 21:22What I like about it is how it prioritizes building consistency.
- 21:26No credit check required,
- 21:27no hidden fees,
- 21:28and zero% interest.
- 21:30You can sign up from your phone in just minutes.
- 21:33Start building credit with Kickoff now and get your first month for as little as $1.
- 21:38That's 80% off the normal price when you go to getkickoff.com/surrounded today.
- 21:44That's kickoff without the C.
- 21:46Get KIKOFF.com/surrounded.
- 21:50You must sign up via get kickoff.com/surrounded to activate offer.
- 21:52Offer applies to new Kickoff customers first month only,
- 21:53subject to approval,
- 21:54offer subject to change.
- 21:54New car financing based on 2025 Chevrolet Silverado MSRP with $10,000 down
- 21:57payment and 5-year financing for subprime borrowers versus those over 600.
- 21:59Nationwide APR average for new cars.
- 22:00Actual savings and financing factors may vary.
- 22:01Experian,
- 22:01April 2025.
- 22:02Average first year credit score impact of plus
- 22:0386 points between August 2024 and August 2025.
- 22:05The Kickoff credit account users who started with a score below 600 are paid on
- 22:06time and had no delinquencies or collections added
- 22:07to their credit profile during that period.
- 22:08Late payments may negatively impact your credit score.
- 22:09Individual results may vary.
- 22:10Thank you to Kickoff for sponsoring this episode.
- 22:12Let's get back to surrounded.
- 22:14My next surrounded claim is that everyone should aim to be vegan.
- 22:18Alright,
- 22:18if you would like to be the first debater for this claim,
- 22:21get to the chair in +321.
- 22:26Hi,
- 22:26hey,
- 22:27what's your name?
- 22:27Nathan.
- 22:28Nice to meet you,
- 22:28Nathan.
- 22:29Nice.
- 22:29It goes pretty good,
- 22:31yeah.
- 22:31So the claim everyone should aim to be vegan,
- 22:33you happy with it?
- 22:34No,
- 22:34and here's why.
- 22:36So
- 22:37I am a 3rd year med student,
- 22:38and so I'm going to be a physician,
- 22:40Lord willing,
- 22:41next year,
- 22:41so.
- 22:42My goal is to take care of my patients,
- 22:45and I'll actually come out and say that
- 22:48the vegan diet tends to be healthier.
- 22:50Absolutely.
- 22:51I don't think there's much dispute over that.
- 22:53You can look at the evidence.
- 22:53It is,
- 22:54it is healthier.
- 22:56However,
- 22:57however.
- 22:59However,
- 23:00the biggest thing with the vegan diet from a
- 23:01physician's perspective you have to think about is,
- 23:03and it's been mentioned a couple of times,
- 23:05is the micronutrient deficiencies that you can have.
- 23:08B12 is one of them.
- 23:10So B12,
- 23:11just taking the tablet.
- 23:13No,
- 23:13but first,
- 23:14let me just,
- 23:14let me just talk for a second.
- 23:16So for B12,
- 23:17it is a DNA precursor that helps synthesize red blood cells.
- 23:21When you don't have that,
- 23:21they become big and become what we call microcytic,
- 23:24sorry,
- 23:24macrocytic anemia.
- 23:26And eventually if you don't treat it long enough,
- 23:28you will have nerve damage,
- 23:29and we've seen that time and time again.
- 23:30Early onset Alzheimer's,
- 23:31all that stuff.
- 23:32What your,
- 23:33your girl earlier on was,
- 23:34uh,
- 23:34she did the Whole Foods diet,
- 23:36and,
- 23:36and,
- 23:37and as I said then,
- 23:38you need to take that B12 supplement.
- 23:39So that's not the only thing though,
- 23:41that's the problem,
- 23:41is that we also have calcium.
- 23:43Calcium's very important for um bone density.
- 23:46About 30%,
- 23:47um,
- 23:47if you're vegan diets exclusively,
- 23:49you are.
- 23:4930% likelier to have um a fracture and you believe you can,
- 23:53you can fact check me on that.
- 23:54Um
- 23:56but these,
- 23:56these,
- 23:57these are good,
- 23:57right?
- 23:58So so the the nutrition game we can,
- 24:00we can pick out all these other things,
- 24:01but the overall health outcomes for the vegan are significantly better,
- 24:04aren't they?
- 24:05So it depends.
- 24:06So as a physician,
- 24:07the,
- 24:07the epic study at the University of Oxford,
- 24:09you'll be familiar,
- 24:09the Christian Adventist Study here at the United States.
- 24:11OK.
- 24:12That's,
- 24:12you know,
- 24:12700,000 people
- 24:14over 30 years who have been tracked.
- 24:1620% less likely,
- 24:17you know,
- 24:18you're gonna have a longer life by about 20%,
- 24:20less likely to get cancer,
- 24:21less likely to get diabetes.
- 24:23Here,
- 24:23here's what.
- 24:23Let me ask,
- 24:24can I ask you one question,
- 24:24because this is what I'm really interested.
- 24:26So the United States,
- 24:27you know,
- 24:27you've got a lot of fat people,
- 24:29a lot of obese people,
- 24:29a lot of overweight people.
- 24:31The Christian Adventist study here in the US is interesting because they look at,
- 24:35uh,
- 24:35people who have got a similar religious background,
- 24:37similar alcohol and smoking intake,
- 24:39which is very,
- 24:39very little.
- 24:41And it found that the vegans had 4 to 5 lower BMI points than the meat eaters,
- 24:45which would literally take you from obese to perfect.
- 24:48I am not in favor of the current American diet.
- 24:50I want to make that very clear.
- 24:51The the diet that I'm in favor of,
- 24:53and that I will mention to all my patients
- 24:54who are struggling with BMI is the Mediterranean diet,
- 24:57which I'm sure you are very aware of.
- 24:58It's actually very similar to the vegan diet in that it has um whole grains,
- 25:01legumes,
- 25:02seeds,
- 25:02fruits and vegetables,
- 25:03which are all super important.
- 25:04Why wouldn't you take the supplements.
- 25:06Why would I take supplements when I could just have lean meats like chicken
- 25:09and fish and turkey and things that I study by Junie Wang in 2019
- 25:14where she found
- 25:15the fortifieds and the supplements were more easily absorbed by the body
- 25:19because they're already taken away from the fibers.
- 25:22So that's why you.
- 25:22So I actually disagree with that because,
- 25:24so for instance,
- 25:24omega 3s,
- 25:26fish
- 25:26have omega 3s.
- 25:28They get it for nuts as well.
- 25:29So here's the thing,
- 25:29you can get it for nuts,
- 25:30it's actually.
- 25:31Your body has to convert it to what it needs omega 3.
- 25:35No,
- 25:35no,
- 25:35no,
- 25:35so omega 3 tablet,
- 25:37you need,
- 25:37so that's another tablet thing.
- 25:39Why would you do that when you could just take fish or something similar
- 25:42and just be able to eat that.
- 25:44a bunch of reasons.
- 25:44The,
- 25:45the one is the moral reason,
- 25:46which is significant.
- 25:47Our oceans are being destroyed,
- 25:483 to 10 trillion fish being taken out of the ocean.
- 25:51People complain about shark fin soup and they don't want whales being killed.
- 25:55The.
- 25:55is absolutely enormous.
- 25:57And when you're talking about the suffering for the non-human animals as well,
- 25:59when you talk about the cost,
- 26:00the University of Oxford study in 2021 found it's 30% cheaper
- 26:04to have a vegan or vegetarian diet than it is to have a meat-based diet,
- 26:07and the fish pescatarian diet was the most expensive out of all of them.
- 26:11So it's more affordable.
- 26:12If you're spending $10,000 on groceries to house each year,
- 26:16you're gonna save $3000 by going vegan.
- 26:18That's a very strong argument.
- 26:19Argument
- 26:20for not going for the fish,
- 26:21when,
- 26:21so yeah,
- 26:22you,
- 26:22you could eat pescatarian,
- 26:23but then you've got all of the
- 26:25destruction of the wildlife and you've got the killing of
- 26:27the animals and you've got the cost as well.
- 26:29Or you could just take that omega 3 and B12 tablet
- 26:31and you're gonna significantly reduce your.
- 26:33You also need to take calcium,
- 26:34you need to take vitamin D.
- 26:35You have to take selenium,
- 26:37you have to take 95% of people in the 95% of people in the US
- 26:41are
- 26:42vitamin D deficient.
- 26:43Yes,
- 26:44that is fair,
- 26:44and you some we do uh prescribe that,
- 26:47but the thing is unique to
- 26:48as I've seen patients as I've been rotating through different things,
- 26:50you rank the diets in terms of healthiest,
- 26:52would you go pescatarian,
- 26:53vegan?
- 26:53I'd go Mediterranean first and then pescatarian and then vegan.
- 26:57OK,
- 26:58so here's the important thing for me too far away from each other.
- 27:00We're not too far away,
- 27:01but here's the thing is that I think about my patients and I think about
- 27:04what is it achievable for them.
- 27:06And the problem with,
- 27:07and I think a lot of people agree with them,
- 27:09what's so affordable,
- 27:10but also,
- 27:11but listen,
- 27:12can I,
- 27:12can I.
- 27:13The other thing is
- 27:15I've seen
- 27:17medication non-compliance.
- 27:18Like
- 27:18I myself take a medication for blood pressure and I suck at it.
- 27:22And a lot of other people,
- 27:24one of the,
- 27:24one of the biggest things in America is that some people,
- 27:27just,
- 27:27a lot of people actually
- 27:28are just not compliant with their medications,
- 27:30so they don't take it,
- 27:31they don't take it.
- 27:32So
- 27:33it's either.
- 27:34We have them
- 27:35high BMI,
- 27:35take a bunch of medications.
- 27:37We do a vegan diet.
- 27:38We give them a lot of supplements,
- 27:39like 5 or 6 actually that you would need,
- 27:41or you can have the you have the Mediterranean diet
- 27:45where you can just have a good diet without those supplements or added things in it.
- 27:49Yeah,
- 27:49you know,
- 27:49you don't need those 5 or 6.
- 27:51You need,
- 27:51you need the B12 tablet.
- 27:53You need omega 3 calcium as well.
- 27:55And the hard thing is that like you have to be super,
- 27:56super careful about how much of the macronutrients you're.
- 28:00So as a vegan,
- 28:01you have to make sure,
- 28:01OK,
- 28:02I'm having this many of this kind of food group,
- 28:04this many of this kind of food group,
- 28:05because you want to make sure that you're
- 28:06getting those vitamins and those micronutrients in,
- 28:09whereas a Mediterranean diet,
- 28:11you wouldn't need to do that as much.
- 28:12Like you have to do it some,
- 28:13for sure,
- 28:14because you want to make sure that you're not eating too much as well.
- 28:16Because I think with the Mediterranean diet studies,
- 28:17I've seen so many studies where they just let people eat.
- 28:20Can I ask how do you,
- 28:20how do you explain
- 28:21that 600,
- 28:22700,000 people in the,
- 28:24in the overall health outcome?
- 28:26Work,
- 28:27University of Oxford and the and the Christian Adventist Study,
- 28:29which I've mentioned a few times.
- 28:31If people are struggling to take those supplements,
- 28:33and if people aren't doing veganism properly,
- 28:35you'd expect their life expectancies to be significantly reduced or not 20% more.
- 28:41They beat the pescatarians on life expectancy significantly.
- 28:44They've got better health outcomes in terms of their risk of cancers,
- 28:47diabetes,
- 28:47obesity.
- 28:48So in practice,
- 28:49you say people are bad.
- 28:50They're doing this,
- 28:51and yeah,
- 28:51of course they are,
- 28:51that rings true for us
- 28:53intuitively,
- 28:54but when you look at nearly a million people
- 28:56and you look at what they're actually doing,
- 28:57the vegan significantly has the better health outcome,
- 29:00and I want a car that's gonna
- 29:02go far.
- 29:02It,
- 29:02it doesn't,
- 29:02it has fewer trips to the garage,
- 29:04that it goes faster and longer.
- 29:06That's what I want,
- 29:07the good health outcomes.
- 29:08So the same should be true of my body as well.
- 29:10But the thing is,
- 29:10is that
- 29:11there are,
- 29:11there are truths to that,
- 29:12that,
- 29:12that definitely cancer is a thing where it's decreased in veganism.
- 29:15However,
- 29:15the Mediterranean diet does have those decreased things.
- 29:19Like,
- 29:19how do you explain the I don't know,
- 29:20I'm still a student,
- 29:20I'm still learning,
- 29:21and maybe I will find that study and I'm maybe I'll
- 29:23be able to answer that better for you at some point.
- 29:25But
- 29:25as I see it,
- 29:26we'll check it out.
- 29:27Take my,
- 29:27take,
- 29:27take my email or something after.
- 29:29I'll genuinely read it and I genuinely,
- 29:31I'm genuinely be interested to hear what you think of it,
- 29:32cause,
- 29:33cause I read it,
- 29:33I,
- 29:34it just like the difference is huge.
- 29:36But I think when it comes to the Mediterranean diet versus the vegan diet,
- 29:38the vegan diet might be better.
- 29:40In some ways,
- 29:40but only just by a little bit.
- 29:42With the Mediterranean diet,
- 29:42you still have decreased cancer rates,
- 29:44you still have decreased cardiovascular risk,
- 29:46you still have decreased risk of diabetes
- 29:48if you're doing those things properly.
- 29:50And so,
- 29:50and one of the things we learned,
- 29:51I've
- 29:52never in my medical school career been told to
- 29:56recommend the vegan diet is like the first diet to go to.
- 29:58It's always been the Mediterranean diet
- 30:00or the DASH diet,
- 30:00which is something where it's like less processed food,
- 30:02less salt,
- 30:04um.
- 30:04And I will say,
- 30:05I will admit there are red meats out there that are probably not as good for you,
- 30:08and I won't,
- 30:09yes,
- 30:09exactly.
- 30:10But when it comes to like the processed foods,
- 30:12but when you're comparing a beef burger to a regular burger,
- 30:14recent studies are showing that you,
- 30:16you're way less likely to develop heart
- 30:17disease by having the ultra processed vegan burger
- 30:20over the beef burger.
- 30:21We're not surprised by this either,
- 30:22are we?
- 30:22ultra processed vegan burger is better.
- 30:24Yeah,
- 30:24the,
- 30:25the Beyond Meat one significantly.
- 30:26Pause,
- 30:26you've been voted out by the majority.
- 30:28Please return to your seats.
- 30:29That was a pleasure.
- 30:29Thank you.
- 30:30I really appreciate that.
- 30:30That was a good conversation.
- 30:31Thank you.
- 30:39How's it going,
- 30:39dude?
- 30:40What's your name,
- 30:40sir?
- 30:41Hey,
- 30:41my name is Fode Sela.
- 30:44I am a Fode Sela.
- 30:45Uh,
- 30:46yes sir.
- 30:46I'm a Sierra Leonean professional boxer.
- 30:50Um,
- 30:50I simply just,
- 30:52I just want to have a conversation.
- 30:54are vegans,
- 30:54aren't they?
- 30:55Oh,
- 30:55no,
- 30:55they're not.
- 30:56David Lay,
- 30:57Brian Jennings,
- 30:59um,
- 31:01yeah,
- 31:01Ali,
- 31:01Akali,
- 31:01that's 3.
- 31:02OK,
- 31:03Ali,
- 31:04Frazier.
- 31:04I can name you an entire bunch of.
- 31:08Population of vegans.
- 31:09What's your point?
- 31:10That those three either won world championships or competed for them.
- 31:13First of all,
- 31:14David Hay is a bum,
- 31:16OK.
- 31:17Most current fighters that everybody knows here,
- 31:19who,
- 31:20who here knows David Hay?
- 31:21Anybody?
- 31:22Who knows Mike Tyson?
- 31:25There you go.
- 31:26That's the point,
- 31:27continue.
- 31:28No,
- 31:28I'm saying given the proportion of the amount of people that are vegans,
- 31:31and given the,
- 31:32given how these people were vegan in the 2010s,
- 31:35I think it's phenomenal that these three were some of the best.
- 31:37Boxers in the world.
- 31:38Novak Djokovic,
- 31:39the best tennis player in the world,
- 31:40is vegan.
- 31:41Lewis Hamilton,
- 31:41the best Formula One driver,
- 31:42is vegan.
- 31:43In my view,
- 31:43the best drummer,
- 31:44Travis Barker is vegan.
- 31:45All these people are vegan,
- 31:47they're the very best
- 31:48in the sport in athleticism,
- 31:49are they not?
- 31:50Also,
- 31:51it sort of ignores it,
- 31:52right?
- 31:52So
- 31:53I,
- 31:53I'm not interested in sort of going tit for tat and going who's the best boxer
- 31:57in the world.
- 31:57I think some of the best boxers in the world are vegan.
- 31:59I think those three people would,
- 32:01you know,
- 32:01take you on any day if you don't mind me saying so.
- 32:03You're sleeping on me a bit there,
- 32:05doc,
- 32:05but here's um.
- 32:06Here's,
- 32:07here's the main thing,
- 32:07right?
- 32:08We think that dog fighting is bad,
- 32:10don't we?
- 32:10Yes,
- 32:10we do.
- 32:11So what happens when we kill the dog,
- 32:12we eat its flesh and then we fight,
- 32:13is that wrong as well?
- 32:14What do you mean we?
- 32:15I don't speak French,
- 32:16I've never done that.
- 32:17So I've never seen anybody that does that either.
- 32:20A chicken?
- 32:21A pig,
- 32:21a cow,
- 32:22a chicken,
- 32:22but you're saying that in such a Western terms.
- 32:25What's the difference?
- 32:26The difference is one,
- 32:27we raised as a companion and the other one we raise as food.
- 32:31And that makes.
- 32:31The moral difference.
- 32:32Why?
- 32:32It makes a moral difference because I need to feed my kids.
- 32:36Again,
- 32:37do you think cockfighting's bad,
- 32:38having two chickens with razor blades on their legs?
- 32:40That's not what you ask.
- 32:41You ask,
- 32:42is it a problem to raise one as?
- 32:45So we agree that our companion,
- 32:47we agree that harming animals for sport is bad
- 32:50and therefore if we think that it would translate
- 32:52to us harming animals for our own sporting excellence,
- 32:54wouldn't it?
- 32:55No,
- 32:55it would not.
- 32:56Why?
- 32:57It would not because of
- 32:59the feeling.
- 33:00You're coming in from a very emotional point of view.
- 33:03I'm not emotional at all.
- 33:04You're very emotional.
- 33:05You keep a very stoic face,
- 33:07but you're very emotional on the inside.
- 33:09There's nothing wrong with emotions.
- 33:09Emotions are evaluative things,
- 33:11aren't there?
- 33:11Oh,
- 33:12I guess if you see the world you're,
- 33:13you're ignoring the main point.
- 33:15We both agree that harming animals to sport is bad,
- 33:17but you're happy to do it.
- 33:19Did I say I was happy to do it,
- 33:20or you're on the meat eating side,
- 33:21aren't you?
- 33:22Of course I'm on the meat eating side,
- 33:23OK,
- 33:24because I come from a world that's realistic.
- 33:26I come from a continent that needs meat of it to
- 33:30Brian Jennings and David Haye are all living on the moon.
- 33:32Oh great,
- 33:33there's one or two people you can name out of a,
- 33:35I'm,
- 33:35I'm not even into boxing.
- 33:36I know the names,
- 33:373 of them.
- 33:38Anybody here knows those people's names?
- 33:40No,
- 33:41just because you know something does not mean the whole world.
- 33:44They're one world champion Djokovic.
- 33:48Of course I have.
- 33:49OK,
- 33:49that's interesting,
- 33:50he's probably the best tennis player in the world,
- 33:51isn't he?
- 33:52Oh,
- 33:52he was one of the best tennis players in the world.
- 33:54Have you heard of Mike Tyson,
- 33:55Muhammad Ali,
- 33:56Imagine if he had a stake,
- 33:57he'd probably stay the best tennis player in the world,
- 33:59wouldn't.
- 33:59Why not?
- 34:00But let's get back to the actual,
- 34:02the actual thing is we,
- 34:03we,
- 34:03we think that the vegans compete at the highest level alongside the non-vegans,
- 34:07but the non-vegans,
- 34:08they engage in something which we think is morally.
- 34:10Wrong,
- 34:11which is harming animals for sport.
- 34:13Agreed?
- 34:13Uh,
- 34:14no,
- 34:14not at all.
- 34:15I love the way you put things together.
- 34:17Your accent makes it even better,
- 34:19but
- 34:19the plain fact,
- 34:21plain fact,
- 34:22plain fact is I,
- 34:23I find it quite,
- 34:24are we,
- 34:24are we flirting?
- 34:25Is it
- 34:26Almost.
- 34:27Maybe you should get a drink after this,
- 34:29you know.
- 34:29Oh,
- 34:29right,
- 34:30but
- 34:31it's quite concerning,
- 34:33and I had to get a bit serious about this.
- 34:35You come from a place.
- 34:36I believe you're British,
- 34:37correct?
- 34:38A place that's very greenery,
- 34:39and I come from a country,
- 34:41yes,
- 34:41meaning there's a lot of,
- 34:43uh,
- 34:44plant space
- 34:45in that region.
- 34:46Isn't there a bunch of trees,
- 34:47so on and so forth?
- 34:48I might be wrong,
- 34:49just as much as the US,
- 34:51True,
- 34:52but again,
- 34:52let me finish my point.
- 34:53Let me,
- 34:55come on,
- 34:56I come from a continent that has a place called the
- 34:59Sahara Desert that a lot of people depend on me.
- 35:02And you're saying that everybody should aim to be,
- 35:06aim to be,
- 35:06that's important.
- 35:07Yes,
- 35:08yes,
- 35:08again,
- 35:09let me finish my guy,
- 35:10aim to be
- 35:12vegan,
- 35:12I think it's very unrealistic.
- 35:15In a sense,
- 35:16that's the realistic part,
- 35:17should aim to be,
- 35:18not that everyone has to be.
- 35:19Vegan and there is no circumstances when you can't kill an animal,
- 35:22it's the most sensible claim you can hear.
- 35:23Everyone should aim to be.
- 35:24Yes,
- 35:25but they can.
- 35:25There's something called somebody just reading a book continuously
- 35:28and having fantasies and the world we live in.
- 35:30Are you saying I just read a book and have fantasies.
- 35:32You come off as that.
- 35:34Why,
- 35:34I've worked on farms.
- 35:37Great,
- 35:37but have you lived in a place that people depend on meat?
- 35:41Have I lived in a place where people depend on meat?
- 35:43Yes,
- 35:44have you seen a lot,
- 35:45that's my point.
- 35:46But the reason a lot of these people depend on meat,
- 35:48again as I mentioned earlier,
- 35:49is because in 82% of the countries where they're starving,
- 35:51the main produce,
- 35:52which is the plant-based agriculture is fed to the animals
- 35:55and prices out the local population.
- 35:56Countries like Sudan,
- 35:58countries like um Ethiopia,
- 36:00those countries have some of the highest is Sudan located?
- 36:03In Africa,
- 36:04what part of Africa?
- 36:05On the east coast of Africa,
- 36:07Sub-Saharan,
- 36:08right?
- 36:08Yeah,
- 36:09what happened to the majority of those countries that cannot grow plants,
- 36:14they,
- 36:14you would leave them
- 36:15to depend
- 36:16heavily,
- 36:17heavily.
- 36:18What do you think they're eating?
- 36:19They're eating camels,
- 36:20are they not?
- 36:21Sorry.
- 36:22Sudan,
- 36:23one of,
- 36:23has the one of the biggest livestocks in the whole of Africa,
- 36:26and that,
- 36:27and the animals there are eating camels.
- 36:29Did you hear me say that?
- 36:30I'm trying to understand what you're on about.
- 36:31OK,
- 36:32let me,
- 36:32let me say it very slowly.
- 36:34Maybe my American English is not going so well for you on this date.
- 36:38OK,
- 36:38come on,
- 36:38we have to,
- 36:39it's such a great chemistry.
- 36:41What I said was a place like
- 36:45sub-Saharan Africa and Sahara Africa itself
- 36:48depend heavily on certain
- 36:51meats,
- 36:52correct?
- 36:53Yeah.
- 36:53And you cannot grow plants in those areas.
- 36:56If you force those areas to depend on plants,
- 37:00we agree.
- 37:01I don't understand what the difference is.
- 37:02If you live in in
- 37:03fricking Greenland or on the North Pole,
- 37:06you can grow plants there either.
- 37:08But my claim is that veganism is the practical
- 37:10rule to avoid the unnecessary suffering wherever possible,
- 37:12and my claim now
- 37:13is that everyone should aim to be vegan.
- 37:15But the reason why the overwhelming number of people can't go
- 37:18vegan is because of factory farming and because of animal agriculture.
- 37:22We're not living there now,
- 37:23none of you are living there.
- 37:24It's not an excuse for anybody in this room.
- 37:27You keep saying we.
- 37:27First of all,
- 37:28you don't know any
- 37:29anything about these people around us.
- 37:31They're all me.
- 37:32So what's wrong with that?
- 37:33First of all,
- 37:33the judgmental side of you is crazy,
- 37:35so we can't go on this date at all,
- 37:38alright.
- 37:39Secondly.
- 37:42I know they're all meat eaters,
- 37:43I know they're all,
- 37:44um,
- 37:44some of the people have flew in,
- 37:45some people have managed to get here,
- 37:47and
- 37:48they have access
- 37:50to
- 37:51plant-based products,
- 37:51yet they choose to eat meat.
- 37:53OK,
- 37:53pause.
- 37:54You've been voted out by the majority,
- 37:55please return to your seat.
- 37:57Yeah,
- 37:57I got you now.
- 37:59You just say I got you there.
- 38:01Yeah,
- 38:01I'm breaking protocol.
- 38:02This is real quick.
- 38:05Just go with it,
- 38:05just go with it.
- 38:07I don't want to waste all their time,
- 38:08but I've,
- 38:09you say everybody should be vegan.
- 38:10Aim to be.
- 38:11Everybody should aim to be vegan.
- 38:13OK,
- 38:13I,
- 38:13I can't hide from the fact I'm a carnivore,
- 38:15um,
- 38:16but there's carnivore.
- 38:17Uh,
- 38:17carnivore.
- 38:18There's two groups of people though,
- 38:20that I want to challenge your claim on.
- 38:22The first is hunters.
- 38:23So I have a good friend.
- 38:24I grew up in Colorado.
- 38:25I have a good friend,
- 38:26he's a hunter.
- 38:27Probably one of the most ethical people I know.
- 38:29I could make the argument that people like him actually do
- 38:32quite a bit to minimize animal suffering
- 38:35because he doesn't participate in industrial farming.
- 38:38He
- 38:40kills his own meat,
- 38:41and
- 38:42He has
- 38:43made the argument to me that,
- 38:44you know,
- 38:45taking an animal's life in the wild.
- 38:48You,
- 38:48you're,
- 38:48you're sparing that animal from
- 38:51the worst death,
- 38:52a worse death that it will experience,
- 38:54because when an animal dies in the wild,
- 38:56it's usually pretty ugly.
- 38:57It suffers a lot more.
- 38:59So
- 38:59he's reducing the suffering of animals.
- 39:01So I think you might be actually more aligned with hunters
- 39:04than you realize.
- 39:05I'm,
- 39:05I'm more aligned with hunters than the person who's engaging in
- 39:08factory farming or what they think is conscientious farming for sure.
- 39:11Um,
- 39:12what I will say is,
- 39:12first of all,
- 39:13the hunters typically aren't honest about why they do it.
- 39:15I think they do it because it's fun.
- 39:16I think they do it because it taps into
- 39:18that evolutionary feeling like having sex feels good,
- 39:20being warm feels good,
- 39:21hunting feels good.
- 39:22I don't think it's sensible to deny those things.
- 39:25When you look at when the hunting elk and deer,
- 39:26for example,
- 39:27in Wyoming in the national park there,
- 39:29the state actually fund the feeding of deers and elks
- 39:31during the winter to make sure the population's up,
- 39:34and then the hunter goes,
- 39:34I'm just there for population control.
- 39:36And in Texas too,
- 39:37you've got these automatic feeders,
- 39:38and so they're keeping the population up just to go hunting.
- 39:41Um,
- 39:42Maggie Ellis did a research paper on this and found that 65% of all the des,
- 39:46deer and elks that are killed
- 39:47are male.
- 39:48So if you want to keep the population down,
- 39:50what you do is you kill females.
- 39:51You don't kill
- 39:5265% males
- 39:53because one male can impregnate 5 females and so can two,
- 39:56right?
- 39:57So it's not that,
- 39:57that's not the reason why they're doing it,
- 39:58and they're doing it to catch the,
- 40:00the,
- 40:00with the animals.
- 40:01But on the terms of optimal system,
- 40:03agreed.
- 40:03Yeah,
- 40:03yeah.
- 40:04Um,
- 40:04so here's,
- 40:06here's the problem
- 40:06with the argument that we're relieving the suffering.
- 40:09Say for example,
- 40:10I really liked having puppies.
- 40:12I love puppies,
- 40:13I'm a big dog lover myself,
- 40:14but you know,
- 40:15having a dog,
- 40:15it's a handful.
- 40:16So at 11 months old,
- 40:18I sneak up behind my puppy and I slit its throat.
- 40:21Right,
- 40:21kill it quickly.
- 40:22That'd be terrible.
- 40:23Death is bad,
- 40:23right,
- 40:24in and of itself.
- 40:25It would be wrong to do that,
- 40:26even if it was painless,
- 40:27if I had 50 puppies over my life and I just killed them
- 40:30painlessly.
- 40:31So when you deprive
- 40:32the elk or the deer or the pig.
- 40:33Of life when you're hunting,
- 40:35you're taking away the life in the same way as you might do a puppy.
- 40:38Now,
- 40:38there is an argument to say,
- 40:39and this is perhaps where we can find some agreement,
- 40:42that the deaths are going to be typically worse
- 40:44from predators,
- 40:46natural predators,
- 40:46uh,
- 40:47wolves,
- 40:47um,
- 40:48you know,
- 40:48big cats
- 40:49than they are going to be for hunters.
- 40:51Uh
- 40:51there are bad hunters too,
- 40:52but on the whole,
- 40:53you know,
- 40:53you can probably expect to,
- 40:55to bleed out 30 seconds to 1 minute,
- 40:57um,
- 40:57average hunter when you.
- 40:58You take a shot with a rifle,
- 41:00and that can typically range 8 to 10 minutes if you've got a
- 41:03predator that's crushing a skull or bleeding out of the neck.
- 41:05So you have to ask yourself honestly,
- 41:07the average elk or deer's been killed at about 4 to 6 years old,
- 41:09but they could live twice that length.
- 41:11So you're depriving them of 2 minutes of pain and suffering,
- 41:15yeah,
- 41:15but you're also depriving them of 6 years of life.
- 41:17Right.
- 41:17But I'm,
- 41:18I,
- 41:18I think a hunter would argue that not,
- 41:20they're not killing all the elk,
- 41:22you know,
- 41:22there's.
- 41:24It's a,
- 41:24unfortunate fate for a select elk,
- 41:27but then they're killing the elk
- 41:28for me.
- 41:29So I guess
- 41:30my only argument is,
- 41:31it seems like maybe rejecting hunting might be too myopic or idealistic
- 41:37for your mission because they seem like they're kind of a,
- 41:39a good ally for your cause,
- 41:41which is
- 41:41to reduce the suffering.
- 41:43Frivolous suffering.
- 41:44Yeah,
- 41:44I don't think reducing suffering's all that's important.
- 41:47You could blow up the whole world right now and that would end all suffering,
- 41:49but I don't think that's something we should aspire towards.
- 41:51I agree with that.
- 41:52Another question I have,
- 41:54should children be vegan?
- 41:55Yeah.
- 41:56Why?
- 41:57Doesn't that feel like a bit of a risk?
- 41:58I'd,
- 41:58I'd say the biggest risks on health outcomes,
- 42:01we're talking overall health outcomes,
- 42:02so we're trying to avoid.
- 42:03The nutrition game,
- 42:04not to dodge the argument,
- 42:05but to go,
- 42:06when you're looking at nearly a million people and their health outcomes,
- 42:09I get,
- 42:09the kids are going to be like child obesity in this country,
- 42:11right?
- 42:12Huge problem.
- 42:12They're going to have lower BMI if they're vegan.
- 42:14Uh they can get all the nutrients that they need
- 42:16on the vegan diet,
- 42:17they're less likely to develop these cancers and,
- 42:19you know,
- 42:20well,
- 42:20it seems obvious that that's something they should be doing.
- 42:22You're saying I should take the.
- 42:24away from my daughter.
- 42:24Yeah,
- 42:25definitely.
- 42:26But even with the ultra processed foods,
- 42:27I think we've been speaking about earlier,
- 42:29you have an ultra processed Beyond Burger or something.
- 42:31There's been studies that show that they're way better
- 42:33than having the beef burgers or the bacon.
- 42:35So you know,
- 42:35if you want,
- 42:36if you want your kid not to be
- 42:37fat,
- 42:38cancer riddled and have heart problems,
- 42:40then yeah,
- 42:40it's probably best to make them,
- 42:41make them a good old fashioned vegan.
- 42:43OK.
- 42:44I'm off.
- 42:45Nice to meet you.
- 42:46Thanks.
- 42:52Hey,
- 42:53we meet again.
- 42:54Hey,
- 42:54hey,
- 42:54Doctor Jack,
- 42:55good to see you again.
- 42:55Sorry,
- 42:55we didn't get a chance to,
- 42:57uh,
- 42:57let me hear some of your views a bit more.
- 42:58Thank you very much,
- 42:59thank you.
- 42:59So I'm a Greek Orthodox Christian.
- 43:01Nice.
- 43:01We spend 2/3 of the year as vegans.
- 43:04Nice.
- 43:04But I have no issues with anything that you're describing,
- 43:07but I'm also not motivated by the same sort of like singular motivations.
- 43:11So like I'm not doing it to save the animals,
- 43:13I'm doing it for fasting.
- 43:14I'm doing it for restraint.
- 43:16I'm doing it for virtue,
- 43:17you know,
- 43:17virtue development.
- 43:18And so in a certain sense,
- 43:20I wanted to ask you this.
- 43:21If I told you there was a population of Greek Orthodox monks,
- 43:25they all look like Gandalf,
- 43:26in Mount Athos.
- 43:28And they've been outliving society for 1200 years,
- 43:31and they actually are vegetarians throughout the year,
- 43:33and then vegans sort of spliced in.
- 43:35We actually mimic the same patterns.
- 43:37But,
- 43:38you know,
- 43:38it's just so,
- 43:39it's so ironic to me that their goal is to,
- 43:42is to pursue virtue and as a result of the 2nd,
- 43:443rd,
- 43:454th order effects of that.
- 43:47They save a lot of life around them.
- 43:49And what I've also noticed a lot of vegans who seem to put and
- 43:52elevate the animal at the top seem to get everything sort of off balance.
- 43:56Like,
- 43:57for instance,
- 43:57Christ's Spiracy,
- 43:58you ever heard of the documentary?
- 43:59The guy basically claims that Jesus came to save animals.
- 44:01Now,
- 44:02that might have been a 3rd,
- 44:034th order effect.
- 44:03Humans are animals.
- 44:05Well,
- 44:06beasts of burden,
- 44:07OK,
- 44:07um,
- 44:08however,
- 44:08however you want to describe it,
- 44:10you'd say they're animals though,
- 44:11right?
- 44:11I would,
- 44:11I would,
- 44:11so are we,
- 44:12um,
- 44:12but the apex predator,
- 44:14the apex creation,
- 44:15you know,
- 44:16my,
- 44:16my colleagues here were talking about Genesis.
- 44:18There were only 3 promises when we left.
- 44:20The Garden of Eden,
- 44:21it was pain,
- 44:22it was work and it was death.
- 44:23Death enters the world so that sin would not live forever,
- 44:25and I thought what was interesting is that when Noah's flood occurs,
- 44:28you know,
- 44:28whether it's literal or not,
- 44:30the,
- 44:30the directive was eat meat so that sin wouldn't live as long.
- 44:33And God says like I demand a sacrifice or
- 44:35repentance for all the meat that's eaten as well.
- 44:37He didn't just go.
- 44:39The hell with it,
- 44:39just eat meat.
- 44:40He goes,
- 44:40I want blood for,
- 44:41like,
- 44:42essentially blood for blood.
- 44:43Yes,
- 44:43but then Solomon ends up killing enough animals that
- 44:45he couldn't even count them all at some point.
- 44:46So there's a little bit of a
- 44:48confusion there.
- 44:48He's not too happy,
- 44:49is he?
- 44:49But I'm just saying though is that I,
- 44:51I agree that there's this aiming,
- 44:53but I also think you have to be careful as to what you're aiming for.
- 44:56Yeah.
- 44:56And so I don't think we're aiming for macronutrients,
- 44:59we're aiming for a better world.
- 45:00Yeah,
- 45:01can I ask you.
- 45:02About Saint Augustine of Hippo,
- 45:03I assume you're familiar with his work,
- 45:046th Century.
- 45:05Uh,
- 45:05the,
- 45:06you know,
- 45:06the guy who tells us it's original sin and really makes it a thing in the.
- 45:09He's more of a Latin group of poor people,
- 45:11but that's fine.
- 45:12You know,
- 45:12he says we're naturally predisposed towards lying,
- 45:14cheating,
- 45:15stealing.
- 45:15In the atheistic tradition as well,
- 45:17Thomas Hobbes,
- 45:18English philosopher,
- 45:1817th century,
- 45:20he says our fundamental nature is a war of every man against every man and life will.
- 45:24Nasty bruises and short.
- 45:25That's our nature's,
- 45:26right?
- 45:26It's the apex predator.
- 45:27But we know that we shouldn't lie,
- 45:29cheat,
- 45:29steal,
- 45:29and we shouldn't just engage in wars,
- 45:31even though that's in our nature.
- 45:32We've been doing it for a long time.
- 45:34So the Christian view,
- 45:34we should transcend that.
- 45:36But the main thing is,
- 45:37even if you didn't buy these like vegan Christian arguments and you thought,
- 45:41again,
- 45:41we spoke earlier,
- 45:42God creates the world perfectly,
- 45:43vegetarian,
- 45:43it'll be vegetarian at the end of time.
- 45:44So I think that's a really strong argument.
- 45:46I also think that angels mistreating humans is bad,
- 45:49and I'm sure you'd agree,
- 45:49so it would translate there.
- 45:51I think those are two really strong arguments,
- 45:52but even with those,
- 45:54you'd go,
- 45:54OK,
- 45:55it doesn't seem like the,
- 45:56the naturalistar argument gets you there either.
- 45:58Could I just argue though that there's kind of a false dichotomy,
- 46:00it's like unless you're a billionaire,
- 46:02you're impoverished,
- 46:02and what I'm saying is that I think people are sort
- 46:04of on a spectrum of that sort of wellness virtue,
- 46:07um,
- 46:08sort of line.
- 46:09And so,
- 46:09you know,
- 46:10I think we're still winning the,
- 46:11the,
- 46:11the war here against
- 46:13let's say unnecessary suffering
- 46:15or triviality.
- 46:16I think it's,
- 46:16I think pretty much
- 46:18it's unnecessary,
- 46:19not just,
- 46:19not just for the animals as well,
- 46:21right,
- 46:21we're stewards of the earth.
- 46:22So when you've got 91% of all deforestation because of,
- 46:25uh,
- 46:26because of the cattle industry or because of animal agriculture,
- 46:28when 80 to 90% of all species are going extinct because of animal agriculture,
- 46:32that's WWF
- 46:33and the UN,
- 46:34but 99% of all species have.
- 46:36Already gone extinct to this point in human history,
- 46:39history,
- 46:39right?
- 46:40And the main driver being the consumption of animals,
- 46:42the destructions of the ocean.
- 46:43I think the Christian has a huge responsibility to be a good steward
- 46:46and not do those things.
- 46:47Would you agree?
- 46:48Well,
- 46:48I would say that,
- 46:49you know,
- 46:49rain can cause floods or it can be essential for life,
- 46:52and I wouldn't fight floods and get rid of rain.
- 46:55You know,
- 46:56I,
- 46:56we still need the rain,
- 46:57so what I'm trying to say is you don't I still feel
- 46:58like the suffering argument from before is kind of still applicable now,
- 47:02which is that it's,
- 47:02it's inevitable and it's essential.
- 47:04It's not
- 47:05inevitable and it's not essential.
- 47:06I don't know if that's true.
- 47:07They come to my ER.
- 47:08Well,
- 47:08I've,
- 47:09I,
- 47:09I mentioned a second ago,
- 47:10the Christian Advert,
- 47:11I've mentioned this a bunch of times,
- 47:13the University of Oxford City,
- 47:14500,000 people.
- 47:15I think that's really strong evidence to say you don't need it.
- 47:17I,
- 47:17I wrote a book on the topic,
- 47:18I think you're right.
- 47:20The point is,
- 47:20the difference is,
- 47:22the difference is,
- 47:22is that the aim,
- 47:23the aim has to be right.
- 47:25The aim has to be right.
- 47:25Hey,
- 47:26Doctor Jack,
- 47:26pause,
- 47:27you've been voted out by the majority.
- 47:32My next surrounded claim is that factory farming is one of
- 47:36the worst moral atrocities in history.
- 47:38Alright,
- 47:39if you would like to debate this claim,
- 47:40get to the chair in 321.
- 47:46Hey bud,
- 47:47how's it going?
- 47:48Hey.
- 47:49Alright,
- 47:49what was your name,
- 47:49sorry?
- 47:50Gerard.
- 47:50Nice to meet you,
- 47:50Gerard.
- 47:51OK,
- 47:51so you said one of,
- 47:52so I just wanna get the ranking system down here.
- 47:54OK,
- 47:55so we're gonna have Holocaust up here.
- 47:56Is factory farming better or worse than the Holocaust?
- 47:59I don't wanna play top trumps with the worst thing that's happened.
- 48:01I'm saying one of the worst thing that's happened.
- 48:02Well,
- 48:02I'd like to know though,
- 48:03like where,
- 48:04because you clearly have some metric.
- 48:05Do you wanna hear the,
- 48:05do you wanna hear the reason?
- 48:07Do you wanna hear the reason and then you can respond?
- 48:08Well,
- 48:08I wanna know the rankings.
- 48:09So we have Armenia.
- 48:09I'll give you the reason we've got need to hear the argument.
- 48:12I'll give you the argument.
- 48:12I'll be quick and you can come straight back.
- 48:15So there are around 80 billion cows,
- 48:16pigs,
- 48:17chickens,
- 48:17turkeys that are slaughtered every year for human consumption.
- 48:19When it comes to fish,
- 48:20it's in between 3 and 10 trillion.
- 48:22The difficulty in getting the fish is for every 1 pound of fish you catch,
- 48:26you get about 3 to 5 pounds of biki.
- 48:28So we're talking trillions and tens of billions.
- 48:30But it's not just the non-human animal suffering,
- 48:32which is bad.
- 48:33Obviously,
- 48:34factory farming has huge impacts on people.
- 48:36Earlier on,
- 48:36we were speaking about how 30 to 60 million children die of starvation each year.
- 48:4182% living in countries where the majority of
- 48:43the produce is fed to non-human animals.
- 48:45It's also true,
- 48:46and I'll just give you one more example,
- 48:47of diseases too.
- 48:49According to the World Health Organization,
- 48:5075% of all emerging diseases are zoonotic.
- 48:53Zoonotic diseases such as Ebola,
- 48:55swine flu,
- 48:56uh,
- 48:56arguably COVID-19 on the fence.
- 48:59Um,
- 48:59let me go through bird flu as well.
- 49:00So you've got tens of millions of deaths,
- 49:02hundreds of millions of deaths of human beings,
- 49:04and the climate destruction too.
- 49:05first you started with the numbers of deaths of animals.
- 49:07Right,
- 49:07like that's a relevant metric for you.
- 49:09How many deaths of cows is equal to the death of one Jewish person in Auschwitz?
- 49:13Give me the number.
- 49:14How many cows for one,
- 49:15because you said,
- 49:16I asked you why it was bad,
- 49:17and you said because the number of cows that are slaughtered every year.
- 49:19So I'm asking you,
- 49:20what's your ratio?
- 49:21Like how many cows dying is as bad as someone getting gassed in Auschwitz.
- 49:25Well,
- 49:25can we,
- 49:26can we extract
- 49:27the Jewish version in Auschwitz?
- 49:29I'm just using,
- 49:29I'm using the word I like to I can think of.
- 49:31Well,
- 49:31I don't like to play into the anti-Semitic.
- 49:33How about the Armenian genocide,
- 49:34can we talk about that one?
- 49:35How many cows are worth a human being?
- 49:37I think,
- 49:37I think a,
- 49:38I think a human being is significantly more valuable than a cow.
- 49:41How much?
- 49:42Why?
- 49:42Because a cow will live for 20 years
- 49:44and a human being will live for 70 or 80 years.
- 49:46So 4,
- 49:47so a cow is 4 cows is roughly a human.
- 49:49I'll give you a number,
- 49:50I'll say 1000 cows.
- 49:511000 cows is the worth of a human being,
- 49:53is all human beings.
- 49:53It's just arbitrary number.
- 49:55What,
- 49:55so you're being arbitrary,
- 49:56you're not like,
- 49:57you're not locked into some sort of like metric for I don't know how many cows.
- 49:59Cows,
- 50:00no.
- 50:00Well,
- 50:00but you seem to be very confident that factory farming is bad because of the numbers,
- 50:03right?
- 50:03That's the very first thing you of human beings as well.
- 50:06I'm saying,
- 50:06yeah,
- 50:06but I'm saying if you but here's,
- 50:08no,
- 50:08hold on,
- 50:09you're being disingenuous on the human beings.
- 50:10So imagine right now a number.
- 50:12No,
- 50:12no,
- 50:13imagine a world where I can create factory farming where no humans die,
- 50:16but the animals are still gonna die.
- 50:18You're not gonna be OK with that,
- 50:19right?
- 50:19I'm not gonna be OK,
- 50:20right,
- 50:20because it's not about being unnecessary because it's not about the human beings,
- 50:23right?
- 50:23So let's focus on your actual objection,
- 50:24the number of animals.
- 50:25That are dying.
- 50:26Did you hear my definition of veganism earlier?
- 50:28No.
- 50:29Well,
- 50:29I was,
- 50:29you should have gave several,
- 50:30but anyways,
- 50:31I gave you one definition
- 50:32and I said that veganism is an ethical rule to avoid products and practices
- 50:36that cause unnecessary suffering to animals.
- 50:38Human beings are animals,
- 50:39so I do care about human beings.
- 50:40Right,
- 50:41but you don't care about human beings above and
- 50:43beyond cows I guess you do a 100s ratio.
- 50:45Why wouldn't I put human beings in there?
- 50:46Well,
- 50:46human beings are animals,
- 50:47but I,
- 50:48they're OK,
- 50:48good,
- 50:48they're the only ones,
- 50:49so I do care about human beings.
- 50:50Well,
- 50:50you care about some animals.
- 50:52No,
- 50:52I care about human beings cause that includes
- 50:55animals,
- 50:55and I point out that there are non-human animals.
- 50:58But now I'm asking you if,
- 50:59let's say there are 2 boats and one of them is going,
- 51:01no,
- 51:01no,
- 51:02there are hundreds.
- 51:02I'm gonna give you a hypothetical and I'd like you to answer it,
- 51:04please,
- 51:05just briefly,
- 51:05I'll be very brief.
- 51:06There are 2 boats,
- 51:07one has 3000 cows,
- 51:08one has a human being on it.
- 51:10One of the boats will sink.
- 51:11Which boat will you sink,
- 51:123000 cows or will you kill a human being?
- 51:14I'll kill a human being.
- 51:15Over 3000 cows.
- 51:172000 cows,
- 51:17you'll kill a human being to save 2000 cows.
- 51:19Yeah,
- 51:19what about you?
- 51:19How about chickens?
- 51:20What about you?
- 51:20I'm saving the human every time.
- 51:22infinite,
- 51:23an infinite number of cows?
- 51:25Oh,
- 51:25an infinite number of cows would have the problem of then the world
- 51:27would be out of cows and I wouldn't want that to happen,
- 51:29but that's ultimately because of my commitment.
- 51:31Any animal would you put on there,
- 51:32cause we're talking about veganism.
- 51:33Any animal you put on there.
- 51:34Any non-human,
- 51:34no,
- 51:35human animals are the only animals I have moral agency for.
- 51:37OK,
- 51:37so how about
- 51:38Neanderthals
- 51:39who were our ancestors 40,000 years ago,
- 51:42who your ancestors would be having sex with,
- 51:44who would look just like a,
- 51:45well they were.
- 51:46Well,
- 51:46I don't really have any moral relationship with the Neanderthals.
- 51:48If you change the.
- 51:49Hypothetical,
- 51:49so I do that.
- 51:50So are humans more valuable than the Neanderthals?
- 51:52Because morality stems from our relationships with others.
- 51:54It doesn't stem from some weird trait like,
- 51:56do they feel pain just from the relationships,
- 51:57right,
- 51:58because what you think,
- 51:58you think it stems from feeling pain,
- 52:00right?
- 52:00You think it stems from feeling pain.
- 52:01That's silly.
- 52:02No,
- 52:02yes,
- 52:03it does.
- 52:03Morality comes from it comes from pain.
- 52:04I said any of the major world philosophies would agree with me,
- 52:06which is a great appeal to authority,
- 52:07and I'm very happy for an appeal to authority.
- 52:09I said yes,
- 52:10it's true because all the major philosophies say that.
- 52:12So Platonism wouldn't agree with you on there.
- 52:13So
- 52:14that's Platonism wouldn't agree with what that.
- 52:16Feeling pain,
- 52:16that feeling pain is like the end all be all of like what morality is based.
- 52:19I didn't say it was the end all be all.
- 52:20I said but it's what you're using your mouth morals.
- 52:22So if tomorrow scientists came out and they said it actually treats
- 52:26Plato's form of the good coincides with unnecessary suffering and pain.
- 52:29It coincides with eating you think once you,
- 52:31once you're brought together with the form of the vegan,
- 52:33then you're gonna be harmed forever.
- 52:35No,
- 52:35if you're brought together with the form of the good,
- 52:37you have no problem killing animals for food.
- 52:38That's why the people who studied Platonism,
- 52:40Plato,
- 52:41Aristotle,
- 52:41Socrates ate meat.
- 52:43You think the form of the good involves unnecessary pain.
- 52:45Yeah,
- 52:45I think we're getting a little in the weeds,
- 52:47but it can involve unnecessary pain on things
- 52:48that are not part of your moral community.
- 52:50Yeah,
- 52:50it's not relevant.
- 52:51So you anyway,
- 52:51Platonist would allow extreme suffering for trivial pleasure.
- 52:54Not for no good reason.
- 52:56No,
- 52:56that's going back to your first claim that it's trivial.
- 52:58Meding is not a trivial pleasure,
- 52:59but I'm gonna try to stick to trivial.
- 53:00I'm gonna stick to.
- 53:01How is it not a trivial pleasure,
- 53:02how is it not?
- 53:03Cats could feel harm.
- 53:04How is it not?
- 53:04Hold on.
- 53:04You can't just interrupt me to keep the conversation.
- 53:06I've answered all of your questions.
- 53:07You have not.
- 53:08I'm actually trying to ask you one.
- 53:09If tomorrow it came out that no,
- 53:11you've asked me several.
- 53:11If it came out tomorrow that trees could feel pain 5 times as strongly as animals,
- 53:16would you say we can't eat trees?
- 53:17Pause.
- 53:18You've been voted out by the majority.
- 53:20Please return to your seat.
- 53:20I would.
- 53:21OK,
- 53:22thank you,
- 53:22thank you.
- 53:22Appreciate it.
- 53:29How's it going buddy?
- 53:30What's your name?
- 53:31I'm David.
- 53:32Nice to meet you,
- 53:32David,
- 53:32Jack,
- 53:33right?
- 53:33How are you doing?
- 53:33I'm good.
- 53:34So um you mentioned that you see
- 53:37killing animals and meat eating as trivial pleasures,
- 53:39correct?
- 53:39Yeah.
- 53:40So I just wanted to ask you,
- 53:41are you religious in any way?
- 53:42Uh,
- 53:43the religious would say I'm not and the atheists would say I'm not an atheist either.
- 53:46I'm what you call a pantheist.
- 53:48I believe God and the world are identical.
- 53:50And obviously the Christians,
- 53:51the Jews,
- 53:52the Muslims have told us that that not,
- 53:53that's not Abrahamic,
- 53:54and the atheists would say it's ridiculous to call the world God,
- 53:57so I'm sort of
- 53:58religiously homeless,
- 53:59but I,
- 53:59I consider myself to be a pantheist and a religious believer.
- 54:02OK,
- 54:02no problem.
- 54:03Um,
- 54:03OK.
- 54:05I'm personally Christian,
- 54:06so cool.
- 54:07Yeah,
- 54:07so I wanted to say that um killing animals,
- 54:09it's not something that's
- 54:11binary,
- 54:12it's not something that's a trivial pleasure,
- 54:13um,
- 54:14that's something that you keep mentioning that.
- 54:15Do you believe in the Bible?
- 54:16Yes,
- 54:17in the Bible,
- 54:18in the Bible,
- 54:19in Genesis.
- 54:19It mentions that animals,
- 54:21they were created for humans to consume.
- 54:23Genesis 1:29,
- 54:25the first teaching on it.
- 54:26God gives human beings a strictly vegetarian diet.
- 54:29God also says in the Bible,
- 54:31in Genesis
- 54:32that animals are meant to be consumed and killed by people we sin.
- 54:35So God creates the world.
- 54:37Genesis 1:29,
- 54:38he says we're allowed to eat fruits and trees
- 54:40that bear seeds.
- 54:41Then the original sin,
- 54:42i.e. evil,
- 54:43enters the world,
- 54:44and at the end of time,
- 54:45Isaiah,
- 54:45at the end of time,
- 54:46I say that has nothing to do with at the end of time,
- 54:48Isaiah 11.
- 54:49The the lion will eat straw with the ox.
- 54:52So it's almost as if on the Christian tradition.
- 54:54The whole world is sandwiched together in veganism.
- 54:56God creates the world perfectly.
- 54:58We sin and live in sin,
- 55:00and at the end of time we're brought together with God in vegetarianism again.
- 55:04OK,
- 55:04um,
- 55:05like I was saying,
- 55:06I,
- 55:06so you should be a vegetarian exclusively,
- 55:08it's not exclusively vegan.
- 55:09I'm not,
- 55:09I'm not gonna be a vegetarian.
- 55:10It's lots of,
- 55:11it's lots exclusively vegan.
- 55:12Genesis 1:29 is vegan.
- 55:14Noah,
- 55:14Noah's ark was made for a purpose,
- 55:16correct?
- 55:16Right,
- 55:16so Noah,
- 55:17he was brought to Earth,
- 55:18he was brought to punishing human beings for their sin,
- 55:20and he punishes the animals.
- 55:21He was brought to earth and he was creating a ship.
- 55:23And he made all these animals come on the ship
- 55:25for them to survive and carry out their life,
- 55:27receiving all those nutrients from the animals,
- 55:29receiving all the
- 55:30the benefits,
- 55:31you know,
- 55:31they have side products too,
- 55:32they have byproducts,
- 55:33right?
- 55:33Animals that create all these,
- 55:35as you say,
- 55:35it's meant for trivial pleasures,
- 55:37um,
- 55:37they create a lot of byproducts that are helping with medicine,
- 55:40that are helping with clothing,
- 55:41because you keep mentioning that all these people
- 55:44are dying because people are eating meat,
- 55:45correct?
- 55:46But people are also surviving because people are eating meat.
- 55:48I think the trade-offs for eating meat and killing these animals that way,
- 55:51I don't have all the answers.
- 55:52I'm not.
- 55:53I'm not God.
- 55:53I'm not.
- 55:54I'm not God.
- 55:55That's not the basis of my argument either.
- 55:57I'm just saying that
- 55:58animals have a lot more benefits as opposed to negative.
- 56:01I'm telling you right now,
- 56:03I'm on your side.
- 56:04I'm Animals have a lot more benefits as opposed to negatives,
- 56:06and you're talking about it,
- 56:08it's not trivial,
- 56:09that's,
- 56:09that's from a very like binary sense of thinking.
- 56:11If God creates the world perfectly and then we sin,
- 56:13definitionally
- 56:14it's worse to eat meat than not tweet meat,
- 56:16but there's a separate argument as well.
- 56:17You,
- 56:17you spoke yourself about utilitarianism,
- 56:19correct?
- 56:20Is it not benefiting a greater number of.
- 56:21People to eat meat,
- 56:23to consume meat,
- 56:23and to have all those byproducts of meat to help many people with medicine,
- 56:27with clothing,
- 56:28with it destroys different types of food,
- 56:29destroys wildlife they're not,
- 56:31we're supposed to have all those to have all those products
- 56:33as opposed to not supposed to be stewards of the earth.
- 56:35According to Robert Goodman,
- 56:3751% of all human cause of all climate
- 56:39change is caused by the animal agriculture industry.
- 56:41There is no way
- 56:43that on a Christian worldview you can justify factory farming.
- 56:4551%.
- 56:46The last,
- 56:46the last two popes have both condemned factory farming in their own words.
- 56:50This is.
- 56:51It is not a Christian worldview.
- 56:53David Clough,
- 56:54the,
- 56:54the Christian theologian,
- 56:55the evangelist he calls himself,
- 56:57has made this case very strongly.
- 56:59But there's a separate argument as well,
- 57:00very briefly.
- 57:02In Revelation 20
- 57:02God cast down Satan to hell for all of eternity for the things that Satan did.
- 57:06There is a great chain of being on Christianity.
- 57:08God,
- 57:09angels,
- 57:09humans,
- 57:10non-human animals,
- 57:11plants.
- 57:11When the angels sin
- 57:13and
- 57:14exploit the people below them,
- 57:15such as Satan leading humanity astray in the Garden of Eden the people below them,
- 57:18yeah,
- 57:19leads them astray creates.
- 57:20Then
- 57:21God punishes them.
- 57:22So he punishes the angels even though they're more rational,
- 57:25more have more free will,
- 57:26have more powers,
- 57:27and they're closer to God in the great chain of being.
- 57:29He punishes them for hurting humans.
- 57:31He will punish humans too for hurting animals.
- 57:34God loves even the sparrows,
- 57:35Matthew 10,
- 57:36Matthew 12.
- 57:37What do you mean you don't believe it's the Bible,
- 57:38it's your scripture.
- 57:39Genesis.
- 57:40You don't believe the Bible then.
- 57:41That's not what I'm saying.
- 57:42Genesis 1:29 does say that.
- 57:44Pause,
- 57:44that we.
- 57:45Pick it,
- 57:46pick it out,
- 57:46return to your seat.
- 57:47Hey,
- 57:48pleasure,
- 57:48thank you,
- 57:48cheers dude.
- 57:56Yeah.
- 57:57You've been making a lot of movement back there,
- 57:58you seem a little bit
- 58:00excited.
- 58:00What's your name,
- 58:01sorry?
- 58:01Sinjan.
- 58:01Sinjan,
- 58:02that's an interesting name.
- 58:03You know,
- 58:04you were talking about how,
- 58:04you know,
- 58:05God made the whole,
- 58:06the idea of making it a vegetarian diet.
- 58:08The what introduced the world to sin was was Eve eating
- 58:12a fruit.
- 58:13Classic women.
- 58:14Yep,
- 58:15oh.
- 58:16OK,
- 58:17I wasn't going to,
- 58:17no,
- 58:18I'm just kidding,
- 58:18sorry,
- 58:18it's a joke.
- 58:19English humor.
- 58:20OK,
- 58:20fair enough.
- 58:20But yeah,
- 58:21so it was an apple,
- 58:23or at least that's what we biblically say.
- 58:25It was a fruit,
- 58:26it could have been watermelon,
- 58:27it could have been a pineapple,
- 58:28we're not told.
- 58:28Yeah,
- 58:28but as far as we know it was a fruit that,
- 58:30you know,
- 58:31when Eve ate it,
- 58:32introduced sin into the world.
- 58:33So like,
- 58:34you could
- 58:35say that,
- 58:36oh yeah,
- 58:36God didn't want the whole
- 58:38just to only eat me,
- 58:40but
- 58:41it's a
- 58:42one of the fruits is one of the reasons that sin was introduced into it,
- 58:45temptation,
- 58:45fruit and sin.
- 58:46Yeah,
- 58:47it's a metaphor though,
- 58:47isn't it?
- 58:48It's an,
- 58:48it's an allegory,
- 58:49it's not actually a real,
- 58:50it wasn't Adam and Eve and they didn't eat a real fruit.
- 58:52If you think that they did.
- 58:54You know,
- 58:54the point of God picking out that fruit was to say,
- 58:57you know,
- 58:57don't rebel against me like Lucifer did,
- 58:59right?
- 58:59He's saying
- 59:00you will do better,
- 59:01you're made in my image,
- 59:02I Margot Day here on Earth reflects my goodness.
- 59:06OK.
- 59:06So yeah,
- 59:06but what I,
- 59:07as I was saying a moment ago,
- 59:08Genesis 1:29,
- 59:10he creates the world vegan.
- 59:11God's perfect.
- 59:11God,
- 59:12God is the greatest.
- 59:13All conceivable beings.
- 59:14And so definitionally,
- 59:15if you think God is perfect and create the world perfectly,
- 59:18then being vegan or vegetarian
- 59:19is morally superior on the Abrahamic worldview,
- 59:22while excluding Muslims because they have a different creation story.
- 59:24If you're Jewish or if you're Christian,
- 59:26then that would hold.
- 59:26I also want to ask,
- 59:27you have been
- 59:29a
- 59:30philosopher for how many years now by chance?
- 59:32I've lost count,
- 59:33maybe 1617 years.
- 59:35OK.
- 59:36And I believe that a majority of the ancient philosophers,
- 59:40they
- 59:41look at it through a human perspective,
- 59:43not an animal perspective,
- 59:45and they are not necessarily thinking about the animals.
- 59:47It's not because they don't care about the animals,
- 59:49obviously,
- 59:50life is important,
- 59:50but at the end of the day,
- 59:51at the social hierarchy,
- 59:53the more superior and more
- 59:56capable being,
- 59:57you know,
- 59:57trumps over,
- 59:58say,
- 59:58a cow and a chicken.
- 59:59Like,
- 1:00:00yes,
- 1:00:00you know,
- 1:00:01cows and chickens are cute and all.
- 1:00:03There you go,
- 1:00:03but yeah,
- 1:00:04it's the humans
- 1:00:05are the dominant species,
- 1:00:06top of the food chain dominate,
- 1:00:08and there's also the philosophy,
- 1:00:09I don't,
- 1:00:09I don't remember the exact name of it,
- 1:00:10but that
- 1:00:11life consumes life.
- 1:00:13And it's not through anything malice,
- 1:00:14but it's rather just
- 1:00:16to help,
- 1:00:16you know,
- 1:00:17sustain us because there's a lot of,
- 1:00:18so this,
- 1:00:19this commits,
- 1:00:20and we heard a version of it earlier on,
- 1:00:22but your girl was just,
- 1:00:23you know,
- 1:00:23I don't know what what she was doing.
- 1:00:24Plants matter.
- 1:00:24So,
- 1:00:25so then it was the naturalistic fallacy.
- 1:00:27David Hume in the 18th century says explanation and observation.
- 1:00:30Aren't the same thing as justification.
- 1:00:32For example,
- 1:00:32evolution by natural selection dictates that we have
- 1:00:35a biological drive towards having sex and reproducing,
- 1:00:37but what it doesn't do is give us
- 1:00:39a drive towards consensual sex and non-consensual sex.
- 1:00:42But we'd both agree that consensual sex
- 1:00:44is more moral than non-consensual sex,
- 1:00:46so therefore we should take that drive and do otherwise.
- 1:00:48If you want to go the evolution route,
- 1:00:49then there's a lot of
- 1:00:50animals that have also evolved over time to be better hunters.
- 1:00:53You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:00:55I'm sorry.
- 1:00:55That was fast.
- 1:00:56All right,
- 1:00:56you're all good.
- 1:01:04Hey,
- 1:01:05nice to meet you.
- 1:01:05Nice to meet you.
- 1:01:06What's your name,
- 1:01:06sorry?
- 1:01:06Dara.
- 1:01:07Dara?
- 1:01:08Yes.
- 1:01:08Nice to meet you,
- 1:01:08Dara,
- 1:01:09I'm Jack.
- 1:01:09Nice to meet you.
- 1:01:10How goes it?
- 1:01:11what's going on?
- 1:01:11It's going well.
- 1:01:12So Emma,
- 1:01:13hm sorry for starting again with like the Christian argument.
- 1:01:17I thought,
- 1:01:17I thought,
- 1:01:18um,
- 1:01:18yes,
- 1:01:19I thought,
- 1:01:19um Jesus fed people fish.
- 1:01:21Uh,
- 1:01:21there's nothing of Jesus feeding people,
- 1:01:24well,
- 1:01:24if Jesus was to feed people,
- 1:01:26he would have fed people fish,
- 1:01:27yeah.
- 1:01:27Yeah,
- 1:01:28so
- 1:01:28what,
- 1:01:29what,
- 1:01:29how is it like not?
- 1:01:30It's probably the best,
- 1:01:31it's.
- 1:01:31Probably the best objection to all Christians should be vegan for sure.
- 1:01:35Uh,
- 1:01:35the only thing which we can say
- 1:01:36accurately from the scriptures that he probably did eat fish.
- 1:01:39He obviously
- 1:01:40comparably also says,
- 1:01:42uh,
- 1:01:42God loves even the sparrows,
- 1:01:43Matthew 10.
- 1:01:44He also says,
- 1:01:45Matthew 12,
- 1:01:46when there's a lamb down a hole,
- 1:01:48he's speaking to the Pharisees,
- 1:01:49he goes,
- 1:01:49even on your day off,
- 1:01:50boys,
- 1:01:51you're gonna help that lamb out of there,
- 1:01:52aren't you?
- 1:01:52And they go,
- 1:01:53why would we do that?
- 1:01:54And they go,
- 1:01:54because humans are more valuable,
- 1:01:56but it's got comparable value.
- 1:01:58Um,
- 1:01:58it depends whether you read it allegorically or not,
- 1:02:00it depends whether you want to separate
- 1:02:01the historical Jesus from the regular Jesus.
- 1:02:03Historically in Palestine,
- 1:02:05Jesus would have had slaves,
- 1:02:06Jesus would have been married,
- 1:02:07it's not typically what people think Jesus is gonna be.
- 1:02:09Right,
- 1:02:09like that's why using the Old Testament,
- 1:02:11it's,
- 1:02:11it's like really
- 1:02:12out date.
- 1:02:13It when you're talking to a Christian because in the Old Testament
- 1:02:15they tell you about how to manage your slaves and you can
- 1:02:18we all agree that slavery is not a right.
- 1:02:20So if you use the Old Testament,
- 1:02:22it's really like not a valid argument for a Christian.
- 1:02:24Do you think it was relevant that Jesus was a man?
- 1:02:27No.
- 1:02:27Palestinian.
- 1:02:29No.
- 1:02:30Human.
- 1:02:32Yes.
- 1:02:33Why?
- 1:02:33Um,
- 1:02:34because he came for humans.
- 1:02:36Just for humans,
- 1:02:37not for the whole world.
- 1:02:37I thought it made it pretty clear that it was
- 1:02:39for to unite God with the whole of his creation.
- 1:02:41That like I,
- 1:02:42I don't think he ever spoke about salvation of cows.
- 1:02:45No,
- 1:02:45not salvation of cows,
- 1:02:46but the whole world.
- 1:02:47He made it clear that he was here for the.
- 1:02:49And he spoke to humans.
- 1:02:51I don't think he ever like evangelized cows or like butterflies and birds
- 1:02:55and talked to them about repentance and
- 1:02:58right?
- 1:02:58So,
- 1:02:58so Jesus doesn't value the non-human animals.
- 1:03:00He didn't come here to evangelize cows and birds,
- 1:03:05because they don't speak.
- 1:03:06Right,
- 1:03:07so it is relevant that he's a human and not a cow
- 1:03:09because he came to evangelize and to solve like for the salvation of humans.
- 1:03:13Yeah,
- 1:03:14but he also came.
- 1:03:15My my argument was that that he also came in
- 1:03:16that time and place for Palestinians in the first century,
- 1:03:19but he came for all people even though we weren't there at that time and place.
- 1:03:23And even though he was a man and a Palestinian,
- 1:03:24he's still here for you and I right now according to the Christian tradition.
- 1:03:27And again,
- 1:03:28the,
- 1:03:28the,
- 1:03:28the Christian doesn't,
- 1:03:29the Christian doesn't go the whole of the Old Testament is
- 1:03:32a load of rubbish and we shouldn't take it seriously.
- 1:03:34Yeah,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34no,
- 1:03:34no at all.
- 1:03:35And,
- 1:03:35and so when God did create the world
- 1:03:39and made it vegan and vegetarian.
- 1:03:40And at the end of time
- 1:03:41when the lion eats straw with the ox,
- 1:03:43it seems like that is better for the Christian to do.
- 1:03:45OK,
- 1:03:45OK,
- 1:03:46that's OK.
- 1:03:46Let's leave it there.
- 1:03:48Let's leave it there because this is not a history class.
- 1:03:50So,
- 1:03:51how can you evaluate suffering?
- 1:03:53How can I evaluate it?
- 1:03:54Yeah,
- 1:03:54how can you say that something suffers more than something else,
- 1:03:57right?
- 1:03:57You evaluate,
- 1:03:58you value like the lives of all animals equally,
- 1:04:00right?
- 1:04:01The mistake I think people make about veganism is
- 1:04:03that we think that all animals are equal.
- 1:04:05There's a.
- 1:04:06Level playing field
- 1:04:07and that they're all,
- 1:04:08you know,
- 1:04:08so you do have a hierarchy for your suffering,
- 1:04:11a hierarchy for animals,
- 1:04:12and where do you get that information from,
- 1:04:14it's not scientifical,
- 1:04:14right?
- 1:04:15Yeah,
- 1:04:15it's,
- 1:04:15it's a
- 1:04:16blend of
- 1:04:17um neuroscience,
- 1:04:18it's a blend of animal behavior and and information we can get from
- 1:04:22zoologists.
- 1:04:24Um,
- 1:04:24so you're arguing that because there are like this amount of cows
- 1:04:27and they have this amount of nervous terminal then that equates to.
- 1:04:31Like this amount of cubes,
- 1:04:33yeah,
- 1:04:33if you look at the neck of a chicken,
- 1:04:34a cow or a pig,
- 1:04:35you'll find that it's got very similar nerve endings and bones.
- 1:04:37OK,
- 1:04:37so you did all the mathematics to decide that it was more.
- 1:04:41That's like if you've got the same nerve endings on your neck
- 1:04:43and you've got a developed brain and mathematics to create that hierarchy,
- 1:04:47and I'm not saying that it's,
- 1:04:48it's,
- 1:04:48I'm not saying that
- 1:04:49it's not a strategy.
- 1:04:51I can't do maths.
- 1:04:52I'm saying if you slit my throat and you slit a cow's throat,
- 1:04:55you're gonna feel a very similar amount of pain.
- 1:04:57OK,
- 1:04:58I,
- 1:04:58I,
- 1:04:59it's a sensible inference.
- 1:05:00OK,
- 1:05:00how many like nervous systems,
- 1:05:02how many what?
- 1:05:02How many like nervous systems,
- 1:05:04like how,
- 1:05:04how,
- 1:05:04how many nervous,
- 1:05:05like why,
- 1:05:06like nervous terminal,
- 1:05:07nervous terminals.
- 1:05:08Well,
- 1:05:08how are you comparing that?
- 1:05:09How do you know?
- 1:05:10How do I know that the cow and the chicken and the I don't know about you either.
- 1:05:15But you have to make a sensual inference.
- 1:05:16This is Descartes' problem of other minds,
- 1:05:17but there are sensible inferences that you can draw
- 1:05:20on the base of it,
- 1:05:20so it's how I do.
- 1:05:24Well,
- 1:05:25if I slit your throat now,
- 1:05:26would that be bad?
- 1:05:27I don't know whether you can suffer or not.
- 1:05:28You've been that sounded really threatening at the end.
- 1:05:30I didn't want to end on that note.
- 1:05:32Hey,
- 1:05:32you're good,
- 1:05:33you're an animal as well,
- 1:05:34so I wouldn't slit your throat.
- 1:05:35We're,
- 1:05:35we're good,
- 1:05:36we're good.
- 1:05:36Nice to meet you too.
- 1:05:44Hey dude,
- 1:05:44nice to meet you.
- 1:05:45What's your name?
- 1:05:45Vidor.
- 1:05:46Vidor,
- 1:05:46I like your shirt.
- 1:05:47Thank you.
- 1:05:48I like yours too.
- 1:05:49It's very cool.
- 1:05:50Um,
- 1:05:50I,
- 1:05:51I,
- 1:05:51I agree,
- 1:05:52uh,
- 1:05:52your uh points about veganism and your definitions are very correct,
- 1:05:55but I disagree with the claim that you just made about
- 1:05:57it being the uh biggest uh atrocity
- 1:06:00in the world
- 1:06:01because I think the biggest atrocity would be people dying and starving.
- 1:06:04The biggest atrocity is one of the biggest atrocities,
- 1:06:06but I,
- 1:06:07I think one of the biggest atrocities would be
- 1:06:08people dying and starving in places like Mongolia or
- 1:06:12in places like Antarctica.
- 1:06:13Where,
- 1:06:13um,
- 1:06:14growing plants is maybe,
- 1:06:15you know,
- 1:06:15harder
- 1:06:16and,
- 1:06:17um,
- 1:06:17you know,
- 1:06:18where major consumption of food is through meat and
- 1:06:21I,
- 1:06:21I agree with you completely,
- 1:06:22and that's why I said veganism is a practical rule
- 1:06:25to do it as far as possible.
- 1:06:26And also as I mentioned earlier,
- 1:06:27justify the majority of these children are starving in countries where
- 1:06:30the produce is fed to the fed to the animals,
- 1:06:33and I think zoonotic diseases taking tens of millions of lives is bad.
- 1:06:36So even if
- 1:06:37you don't care about non-human animals,
- 1:06:38you should be vegan for the sake of human beings as well.
- 1:06:41I,
- 1:06:41I,
- 1:06:41I join me.
- 1:06:43Convert.
- 1:06:44Are you there?
- 1:06:45Vegan?
- 1:06:46Oh yeah,
- 1:06:46you can take my seat.
- 1:06:47I was,
- 1:06:47I was vegetarian for like 6 months,
- 1:06:49but you know.
- 1:06:50Come back.
- 1:06:51Yeah,
- 1:06:51but uh I think I was,
- 1:06:52I,
- 1:06:53I feel more,
- 1:06:53more like myself and can we have you back in the chair later,
- 1:06:55can we have him back?
- 1:06:56The time has gone.
- 1:06:57Oh yeah,
- 1:06:57you definitely can choose someone later.
- 1:06:59Oh cool,
- 1:07:00yeah,
- 1:07:00nice one,
- 1:07:01great,
- 1:07:01I might see you later.
- 1:07:02I,
- 1:07:02I don't wanna
- 1:07:03shoo everyone down just yet.
- 1:07:05Thanks everyone.
- 1:07:07My final surrounded claim is that veganism's good for the world
- 1:07:11and humanity.
- 1:07:12If you would like to debate this claim,
- 1:07:13get to the chair in 321.
- 1:07:16Nope.
- 1:07:18Hey Jack,
- 1:07:19nice to meet you.
- 1:07:19Nice to meet you,
- 1:07:20Alex.
- 1:07:20Good to meet you.
- 1:07:21OK,
- 1:07:21so two things.
- 1:07:22First,
- 1:07:23speak up a little bit.
- 1:07:25I have selective hearing.
- 1:07:26And don't do religion because I'll just.
- 1:07:28Yeah,
- 1:07:28I ignore it.
- 1:07:29Do you wanna hear just,
- 1:07:30I'll be brief.
- 1:07:30I'll give you the reasons.
- 1:07:31You can tell me where it goes wrong.
- 1:07:33Uh,
- 1:07:33so it's good for the world more generally because
- 1:07:36it's one of the leading causes of climate change.
- 1:07:38It's good for humanity as well.
- 1:07:39Let's just take zoonotic diseases as an example.
- 1:07:42So 75% of all zoonotic diseases that
- 1:07:44are emerging according to the World Health Organization
- 1:07:47are those that come from
- 1:07:48non-human animals.
- 1:07:49That's really dangerous because we haven't built them naturally.
- 1:07:51Immunity to them.
- 1:07:52One of the leading theories according to the World Health Organization,
- 1:07:55or what they think is the leading cause of COVID,
- 1:07:57was the wet market in Munyang,
- 1:07:58killed 8 million people.
- 1:08:00Again,
- 1:08:00I'm not interested in like debating the cause of COVID,
- 1:08:02so let's just go Ebola,
- 1:08:03swine flu,
- 1:08:04and bird flu obviously coming from births.
- 1:08:06So I think that if you don't want vaccinations,
- 1:08:07we don't want mandatory lockdowns,
- 1:08:09we don't want forced masks,
- 1:08:10and we don't want tens of millions of people dying in the future.
- 1:08:12One of the biggest risks to humanity is going to be zoonotic diseases.
- 1:08:15So I think that's a really strong reason.
- 1:08:17And,
- 1:08:17and then the refugees and all of the climate destruction
- 1:08:20and the deaths that are going to come from climate change.
- 1:08:22So I think those are two really good reasons.
- 1:08:23OK,
- 1:08:24so I've got two really important things that I want to ask you.
- 1:08:27So,
- 1:08:27animal testing
- 1:08:29for all of the devices,
- 1:08:31uh,
- 1:08:32immunizations,
- 1:08:33they need to,
- 1:08:35per the FDA
- 1:08:36do animal testing first
- 1:08:38so that they get approved for human use.
- 1:08:40So
- 1:08:41are you saying
- 1:08:43that shouldn't be a thing?
- 1:08:44Yeah,
- 1:08:45there's a researcher at Cornell University,
- 1:08:47a biochemical engineer,
- 1:08:48that thinks only 6% of all of the experiments done on
- 1:08:51non-human animals transfer.
- 1:08:52Uh,
- 1:08:52Harry Harlow was the chief editor of one of the biggest
- 1:08:56journals in this area.
- 1:08:57He looked at 2000.
- 1:08:58Where's the research?
- 1:08:59So he looked at 2005.
- 1:09:00Where's the research?
- 1:09:01I'm giving it to you now.
- 1:09:02No,
- 1:09:02no,
- 1:09:02no,
- 1:09:02no,
- 1:09:02I want to know who wrote the paper.
- 1:09:04Oh,
- 1:09:05Harry,
- 1:09:05Harry.
- 1:09:05Harlowe,
- 1:09:06the editor of the Journal of Comparative and Physiological Psychology.
- 1:09:09Really,
- 1:09:09and you think that's enough to prove your point?
- 1:09:11He looked at 2500 articles and he said,
- 1:09:14quote,
- 1:09:14Most of the observations,
- 1:09:17most of the data is not worth publishing and
- 1:09:18not most of the experiments are not worth doing.
- 1:09:22So he's,
- 1:09:22he's straight from the horse mouth.
- 1:09:23No,
- 1:09:23no,
- 1:09:23no,
- 1:09:24hold on.
- 1:09:24So you're basing
- 1:09:26what.
- 1:09:26You just said
- 1:09:28on one person's opinion.
- 1:09:29No,
- 1:09:29I just told you 6% of his opinion on what a whole bunch of other people.
- 1:09:33He's one of the experts in the area,
- 1:09:34yeah,
- 1:09:34yeah.
- 1:09:35And I also said that the biochemical engineer at Cornell said the same.
- 1:09:38So you'd be comfortable with like Michael Shula.
- 1:09:41OK,
- 1:09:41so anyway,
- 1:09:42can I finish?
- 1:09:42No,
- 1:09:43can I finish?
- 1:09:44Thank you.
- 1:09:45Um,
- 1:09:45excuse me,
- 1:09:46I,
- 1:09:47I grew up in New York.
- 1:09:48Um,
- 1:09:49would you have just
- 1:09:51wiped out animal testing altogether
- 1:09:53from the beginning?
- 1:09:54Um I've never done it.
- 1:09:55I think,
- 1:09:56well,
- 1:09:56we wouldn't have had,
- 1:09:57uh,
- 1:09:57several vaccinations if we,
- 1:09:59if we tested them on animals first.
- 1:10:01Um,
- 1:10:01I think that
- 1:10:02the argument most often given here is for cancer research
- 1:10:05and it's shown to have virtually no effect whatsoever.
- 1:10:08So I think that's
- 1:10:09one reason that if you're gonna test it,
- 1:10:11you test it on human beings.
- 1:10:12Alright,
- 1:10:13well,
- 1:10:13I,
- 1:10:14I
- 1:10:14politely disagree with you.
- 1:10:15I wouldn't say it was polite,
- 1:10:16but thank you.
- 1:10:17I didn't say
- 1:10:18pause.
- 1:10:19You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:10:20Please return to your seat.
- 1:10:21Hey,
- 1:10:21we're good,
- 1:10:22we're good.
- 1:10:23Hey,
- 1:10:23nice to meet you,
- 1:10:23Alex,
- 1:10:24thank you.
- 1:10:24Appreciate it.
- 1:10:30Hey bud,
- 1:10:30Brighton.
- 1:10:31Hey,
- 1:10:31nice to meet you,
- 1:10:31Brighton,
- 1:10:32nice to meet you.
- 1:10:32So I would say
- 1:10:34veganism is not good for the world,
- 1:10:36and my number one point is burgers.
- 1:10:40Have you ever had
- 1:10:41a burger
- 1:10:43with cheese on it?
- 1:10:44Yeah.
- 1:10:44Have you had a burger and what do you think?
- 1:10:46Uh,
- 1:10:47I think that people aren't the experts,
- 1:10:49they think about their own mind.
- 1:10:50Giovanni Savanni did a study in 2023 where he looked at 175 people
- 1:10:55and give them.
- 1:10:56Blind taste tests and informed taste tests.
- 1:10:59The majority
- 1:11:00couldn't figure out which one was the beef burger and the plant-based burger,
- 1:11:03and when on the informed taste test,
- 1:11:04they all preferred the plant-based burger over the beef burger.
- 1:11:07So no,
- 1:11:08I don't buy it.
- 1:11:09When we look at what people do when they're not in this debate setting,
- 1:11:11it's not clear that they prefer it.
- 1:11:13But I would say that I prefer
- 1:11:15like cheeseburgers,
- 1:11:16like real cheeseburgers,
- 1:11:18and I could tell the difference.
- 1:11:19I have like really good taste buds.
- 1:11:22So I really like when it's not like fake cheeseburgers.
- 1:11:25Yeah,
- 1:11:25go for it.
- 1:11:25I prefer it like they taste like you understand there's,
- 1:11:28there are gonna be limits to this,
- 1:11:29right?
- 1:11:29You like doing lots of things,
- 1:11:30I assume you like having sex as well,
- 1:11:32but you certainly,
- 1:11:33you certainly wanna.
- 1:11:35I imagine that you want to get it in an ethical way.
- 1:11:37Yeah,
- 1:11:38obviously,
- 1:11:38but I,
- 1:11:39I think I can get,
- 1:11:40I mean if I just go to like the store and buy a,
- 1:11:42a burger,
- 1:11:43that's pretty ethical to me.
- 1:11:44But my other argument,
- 1:11:45you,
- 1:11:45you mentioned,
- 1:11:46let me give you this question.
- 1:11:47You can have sex
- 1:11:48and it was unethical,
- 1:11:49non-consensual,
- 1:11:50but it was great,
- 1:11:51or you can have the consensual sex and it's not quite as good,
- 1:11:53which one do you pick?
- 1:11:54Probably a cheeseburger.
- 1:11:56I think um
- 1:11:58which one do you pick out of the two of them?
- 1:11:59Which one do you pick out of the two of them?
- 1:12:00Just pick one.
- 1:12:02The ethical,
- 1:12:03the ethical,
- 1:12:04don't.
- 1:12:04Well,
- 1:12:04the ethical one,
- 1:12:05but I would choose a cheeseburger over sex any day.
- 1:12:07So the analogy,
- 1:12:08OK,
- 1:12:09can I,
- 1:12:09can I make another point?
- 1:12:10Of course.
- 1:12:10OK,
- 1:12:11thank you.
- 1:12:11I'm glad we agree on that though.
- 1:12:12Absolutely.
- 1:12:13Uh,
- 1:12:13my other point would be,
- 1:12:14uh,
- 1:12:14you mentioned a lot of athletes,
- 1:12:16right?
- 1:12:16You were talking about athletes,
- 1:12:17boxers.
- 1:12:18I don't know boxers too well,
- 1:12:19but I know basketball players,
- 1:12:21and the best basketball player in the world,
- 1:12:23LeBron James,
- 1:12:24he eats all the meat.
- 1:12:26So I'm gonna,
- 1:12:27I'm gonna eat the meat and I'm gonna become like a really good
- 1:12:30athlete.
- 1:12:30That's how I feel like,
- 1:12:31like all the best athletes in the world
- 1:12:33are eating so much meat.
- 1:12:34And not all the best athletes in the world.
- 1:12:36I gave you some examples.
- 1:12:37LeBron James,
- 1:12:38he's the best pause,
- 1:12:39pause.
- 1:12:40You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:12:42Awesome.
- 1:12:43Hey,
- 1:12:43get yourself a Beyond Burger,
- 1:12:44dude.
- 1:12:49Hey,
- 1:12:49go ahead,
- 1:12:50that was a big jump.
- 1:12:50Frank,
- 1:12:51well,
- 1:12:51I am Mario.
- 1:12:53Is that your name,
- 1:12:54Mario?
- 1:12:54Hey,
- 1:12:55nice to meet you,
- 1:12:55Mario.
- 1:12:56All right,
- 1:12:56so,
- 1:12:57uh,
- 1:12:57bad for the world,
- 1:12:58you say.
- 1:12:59Um,
- 1:13:00see these two here?
- 1:13:01These are opposable thumbs.
- 1:13:02We evolved these in order to hunt better.
- 1:13:05These two pair of legs,
- 1:13:06bipedal.
- 1:13:07We are bipedal to become better hunters.
- 1:13:09Even communicating with each other,
- 1:13:11we've evolved to become better hunters.
- 1:13:13Our entire existence
- 1:13:15as a,
- 1:13:15as human species
- 1:13:17has been.
- 1:13:18eating meats and for you to just say all of a sudden
- 1:13:21with
- 1:13:21to be like,
- 1:13:22oh you shouldn't do that anymore is kind of asinine.
- 1:13:25Asinine,
- 1:13:25um sorry,
- 1:13:26I didn't know that word.
- 1:13:27It's,
- 1:13:27it's just it's the auda the audacity to just like assume that it's audacious,
- 1:13:32audacious.
- 1:13:33I didn't say everyone said everyone should aim to be for a start.
- 1:13:35Aim to be.
- 1:13:35And your argument makes the naturalistic fallacy,
- 1:13:37we've spoken about it a bunch of times.
- 1:13:38There are loads of things that evolution
- 1:13:40by natural selection dictates that we should do
- 1:13:42that says descriptively,
- 1:13:44we can give an explanation for it,
- 1:13:45that doesn't mean we should
- 1:13:46do that thing.
- 1:13:47OK,
- 1:13:48well,
- 1:13:48here's another question.
- 1:13:49We evolved,
- 1:13:49we,
- 1:13:49we,
- 1:13:50we've engaged in how many wars?
- 1:13:52True,
- 1:13:52and we shouldn't keep doing that.
- 1:13:53We shouldn't,
- 1:13:54we shouldn't.
- 1:13:55Why shouldn't we,
- 1:13:56and why shouldn't we do that?
- 1:13:57I don't know if you should bring this one up right now.
- 1:13:59But
- 1:14:00answer,
- 1:14:00well,
- 1:14:00why,
- 1:14:01why shouldn't we do that?
- 1:14:01Why shouldn't we engage in war?
- 1:14:02Because it's,
- 1:14:03it's killing
- 1:14:04our own people,
- 1:14:05people,
- 1:14:06but only humans count.
- 1:14:08Yes,
- 1:14:08I don't think that's ethical to say because we are human.
- 1:14:11News flashes,
- 1:14:11we're both human.
- 1:14:12So it's circular.
- 1:14:13Humans matter because they're humans,
- 1:14:14and why do humans matter because they're humans?
- 1:14:16Yes.
- 1:14:17So it's a circular argument.
- 1:14:18I would,
- 1:14:18I would,
- 1:14:19you know what,
- 1:14:19you can't ground it in anything else.
- 1:14:21I can.
- 1:14:21Well let me ask you this,
- 1:14:22if the human was dead and one was alive,
- 1:14:23which one would you give the better treatment?
- 1:14:25Uh,
- 1:14:25the one that is already,
- 1:14:27that's the one that's alive,
- 1:14:28yeah,
- 1:14:28so it's not just about being human,
- 1:14:29it's about being a living human.
- 1:14:30The conscious human or the non-conscious human.
- 1:14:32The one that can feel pain,
- 1:14:34the.
- 1:14:34Pleasure,
- 1:14:35the one that's got freedom of the will,
- 1:14:36the one that's got projects,
- 1:14:37long life to live,
- 1:14:38it's not just the fact they're human.
- 1:14:39There are lots of intrinsic values to being a
- 1:14:41human being that are comparable to other non-human animals.
- 1:14:43So,
- 1:14:44OK,
- 1:14:44absolutely,
- 1:14:44that's great.
- 1:14:45So it's not just because,
- 1:14:46here's the thing,
- 1:14:47and it's comparable to other animals.
- 1:14:48Would you agree with that then?
- 1:14:49See,
- 1:14:49you've changed,
- 1:14:50I wouldn't say it's comparable to animals because even earlier,
- 1:14:53even earlier you just said,
- 1:14:54even you just said like just to someone,
- 1:14:57I don't wanna I don't want a new argument.
- 1:14:59I want the thing we're talking about.
- 1:15:00I don't want to move the goalposts.
- 1:15:01You said
- 1:15:02being human is valuable because it's human,
- 1:15:04and then you've listed a bunch of things that are valuable
- 1:15:06about being human and they count for non-human animals as well.
- 1:15:09No,
- 1:15:09they don't because animals animals aren't conscious.
- 1:15:12They do not have.
- 1:15:13Animals aren't conscious.
- 1:15:14They are not alive.
- 1:15:16They are alive.
- 1:15:17They are plants,
- 1:15:18but they get,
- 1:15:19yeah,
- 1:15:19but the plants are alive.
- 1:15:20OK,
- 1:15:21so animals don't have the level of consciousness
- 1:15:23that humans What does level of consciousness mean?
- 1:15:24So they don't feel they don't feel as much empathy.
- 1:15:28Elephant when it comes across another dead elephant
- 1:15:29will cry even if it doesn't know it.
- 1:15:31Is that empathy,
- 1:15:31the gorilla cried when its kitten died.
- 1:15:34That's empathy.
- 1:15:35Regardless of what he said was wrong.
- 1:15:36I would also say that you think you're doing so much to help these animals,
- 1:15:40but let's,
- 1:15:40let's put an example here.
- 1:15:42We have 2 baskets in a grocery cart.
- 1:15:44One is 1 pound of carrots,
- 1:15:46and the other is 1 pound of rotisserie chickens.
- 1:15:49Let's say 3 of them,
- 1:15:493 rotisserie chickens versus 1 pound of carrots.
- 1:15:52It's some bad shopping right there,
- 1:15:53dude.
- 1:15:53I think.
- 1:15:54Well,
- 1:15:54yeah,
- 1:15:54obviously.
- 1:15:55But it's just an example,
- 1:15:56but it's just the meat said,
- 1:15:57said,
- 1:15:58said carrots
- 1:15:59had just
- 1:16:01arguably more death involved in getting those
- 1:16:03carrots to the grocery store than those
- 1:16:05three chickens because of all the pests and rats and rabbits over this.
- 1:16:0980% of the soy is given to non-human animals,
- 1:16:12factory farming,
- 1:16:1240 to 1 in your calories.
- 1:16:13I'm not,
- 1:16:14I'm not defending.
- 1:16:15So if you wanna reduce,
- 1:16:16if you wanna reduce crop deaths by 75% voted out by the majority,
- 1:16:19please return to your cheers,
- 1:16:20thank you.
- 1:16:20Mario,
- 1:16:21you take care.
- 1:16:26Hey,
- 1:16:27how's it going?
- 1:16:27Sorry,
- 1:16:28remind me of your name.
- 1:16:28It's B.
- 1:16:29How are you doing,
- 1:16:29Bee?
- 1:16:30Good,
- 1:16:30good,
- 1:16:30good,
- 1:16:30good.
- 1:16:31OK,
- 1:16:31so let me ask you something.
- 1:16:32Do you eat
- 1:16:32corn?
- 1:16:33Not really.
- 1:16:33You don't eat it.
- 1:16:34It's not for me,
- 1:16:35no.
- 1:16:35OK,
- 1:16:35but vegans do eat corn.
- 1:16:37It is you would consider corn vegan,
- 1:16:38I think I'd consider corn vegan.
- 1:16:40OK,
- 1:16:40so I mean if you're saying that everybody should strive,
- 1:16:42or,
- 1:16:42you know,
- 1:16:43the best they can to become vegan,
- 1:16:45then,
- 1:16:45uh,
- 1:16:45some vegans are gonna choose to eat corn.
- 1:16:47OK.
- 1:16:48How is corn grown?
- 1:16:49Uh,
- 1:16:50you'd put it in the ground,
- 1:16:51you put water on it,
- 1:16:52you put sunlight on it,
- 1:16:52OK,
- 1:16:53but it grows in soil.
- 1:16:54And how does soil grow?
- 1:16:56How does soil grow?
- 1:16:57Well,
- 1:16:57how does soil grow plants?
- 1:16:59No,
- 1:16:59how does soil grow the plants?
- 1:17:01What,
- 1:17:01what does soil mean?
- 1:17:01Nutrients in the soil and what are the nutrients from?
- 1:17:03Come on,
- 1:17:03dude.
- 1:17:04What is it?
- 1:17:04Where,
- 1:17:04where do the nutrients come from?
- 1:17:05The sunlight and the water,
- 1:17:07not the sunlight anymore.
- 1:17:08We don't have enough sunlight just get
- 1:17:10from the animals that are grazing on the fossil fuels.
- 1:17:13Fossil fuels are used.
- 1:17:15To grow
- 1:17:16corn.
- 1:17:17So what's the problem?
- 1:17:18Just jump to it,
- 1:17:18we haven't got too long.
- 1:17:19I want to know the property contradiction.
- 1:17:20So,
- 1:17:20so the point is
- 1:17:22you're saying that we want to do better for the environment.
- 1:17:24Of course.
- 1:17:24Would you say that fossil fuels are good for the environment?
- 1:17:27Um,
- 1:17:28I would say using fossil fuels should be avoided.
- 1:17:30However,
- 1:17:31the whole of the animal agricultural industry,
- 1:17:33according to the UN and one of the most conservative figures,
- 1:17:36is the animal agricultural industry,
- 1:17:38all of transport combined,
- 1:17:39every plane,
- 1:17:40train,
- 1:17:40and car.
- 1:17:41Put that next to factory farming and the animal agriculture industry.
- 1:17:44Animal agriculture is more,
- 1:17:45and when you,
- 1:17:46once you account for deforestation,
- 1:17:48deadlands,
- 1:17:49and the emissions from the animals,
- 1:17:50just very quickly,
- 1:17:51I'm,
- 1:17:51I'm literally gonna finish,
- 1:17:52and once you account for all the side effects of it too and all the waste,
- 1:17:54then it becomes about 3 or 4 times as much.
- 1:17:57Cows don't need to eat corn.
- 1:17:58What do cows normally eat?
- 1:17:59Uh,
- 1:18:00they can eat grass.
- 1:18:01They can eat exactly grass.
- 1:18:03So if we just fed cows grass,
- 1:18:05their natural diet,
- 1:18:06which is actually healthier for them,
- 1:18:07which would actually prohibit
- 1:18:11and overgrazing creates dead zones.
- 1:18:13Yeah,
- 1:18:1435% of all the US mainland is used for growing cattle.
- 1:18:19If we,
- 1:18:19if we went back to a hunting gathering society,
- 1:18:21and,
- 1:18:21and I know that's very,
- 1:18:22very,
- 1:18:23very,
- 1:18:23very,
- 1:18:23uh,
- 1:18:24because for 10,000 years we've been doing.
- 1:18:27Well,
- 1:18:27it would sustain the people that live within that area.
- 1:18:29What has happened,
- 1:18:30but it's a phantom capa it's phantom capacity right now
- 1:18:34because of
- 1:18:35the growth of grains.
- 1:18:37The growth of grains and corn have caused overproduction.
- 1:18:40Which
- 1:18:41now people are more dependent on it.
- 1:18:43It's a,
- 1:18:44so I'm saying if we taught people how to actually get food
- 1:18:47within the areas that they are in and you do regenerative,
- 1:18:50regenerative farming,
- 1:18:52which is actually very benefiers,
- 1:18:54well,
- 1:18:55we can do,
- 1:18:55we can do a hybrid
- 1:18:57because we're at this point,
- 1:18:58you're not gonna have we've got 8 billion people,
- 1:19:01we could 17 million and it's not how do we get,
- 1:19:03how do we get 8 billion people
- 1:19:05reproducing,
- 1:19:05having sex.
- 1:19:07But how?
- 1:19:08Uh,
- 1:19:08I'm not gonna give you that lesson here on camera.
- 1:19:11Come on.
- 1:19:12I'm being dead serious.
- 1:19:13So
- 1:19:13we have taken our food production,
- 1:19:16right?
- 1:19:17Dispersed it
- 1:19:18throughout the world,
- 1:19:19we have made people dependent on us as opposed
- 1:19:21to being dependent on the land that they live in
- 1:19:23and teaching them how to actually survive in their own areas.
- 1:19:26The current animal agricultural industry is
- 1:19:27destroying the planet and destroying wildlife.
- 1:19:29I think the current
- 1:19:31production of
- 1:19:32feeding them corn and and diets,
- 1:19:34they are not agricultural industries destroying the planet.
- 1:19:37I think factory farming,
- 1:19:38of course,
- 1:19:38and I disagree,
- 1:19:39I disagree with just factory farming,
- 1:19:41not just factory current animal agricultural practices.
- 1:19:43No,
- 1:19:43I don't,
- 1:19:44I don't,
- 1:19:44I,
- 1:19:44I can't.
- 1:19:45Do you have do you have,
- 1:19:46yeah,
- 1:19:47but if you want
- 1:19:48cattle raised on grass,
- 1:19:49you have to
- 1:19:51engage in deforestation or what about buffalo?
- 1:19:53What if we bring buffalo back because a lot of this area's had buffalo.
- 1:19:56It's not necessary.
- 1:19:57Why are you trying to,
- 1:19:58why,
- 1:19:58why would it be?
- 1:19:59Because I would eat,
- 1:20:01I would eat buffalo.
- 1:20:02It's a natural animal that that has survived in North America
- 1:20:05that we wiped out when the Europeans came over here,
- 1:20:08right?
- 1:20:08We wiped it out.
- 1:20:09Out,
- 1:20:09we put agriculture into our country,
- 1:20:12right?
- 1:20:13And now
- 1:20:13we are stuck
- 1:20:15in this
- 1:20:16what has been created from 10,000 years ago.
- 1:20:19So either go catch yourself a buffalo or get a plant-based diet.
- 1:20:22No,
- 1:20:22well,
- 1:20:23maybe I will,
- 1:20:23I will,
- 1:20:23I will.
- 1:20:24So you're gonna catch a buffalo pause here.
- 1:20:26I will.
- 1:20:26You're gonna be a vegan?
- 1:20:27No,
- 1:20:28voted out by the majority.
- 1:20:28Well,
- 1:20:29let me know when you do.
- 1:20:30I,
- 1:20:30I've got a strong bet against you.
- 1:20:32OK.
- 1:20:33Please return to your seat.
- 1:20:35Thank you.
- 1:20:42Good to see you again.
- 1:20:45Uh,
- 1:20:46OK,
- 1:20:46this is my first time.
- 1:20:47Oh,
- 1:20:47sorry,
- 1:20:47apologies.
- 1:20:48I actually do have a,
- 1:20:49a,
- 1:20:49a general question for you.
- 1:20:50I do think you can make a lot of valid points,
- 1:20:52and I'm learning a lot there.
- 1:20:53What would be the,
- 1:20:54which one,
- 1:20:54which ones do you think were valid?
- 1:20:56Well,
- 1:20:56I don't agree with factory farming,
- 1:20:57so yeah,
- 1:20:58we're,
- 1:20:58yeah,
- 1:20:58that's where we have common ground and the conscientious farming.
- 1:21:01Yeah,
- 1:21:02slitting an animal's throat,
- 1:21:04deep beak in it.
- 1:21:05Then yeah,
- 1:21:05we,
- 1:21:05we,
- 1:21:06we're on the same page there.
- 1:21:07OK,
- 1:21:07so no,
- 1:21:08so that,
- 1:21:08that's basically all farming.
- 1:21:09No,
- 1:21:09that's not all farming.
- 1:21:10Well,
- 1:21:11998
- 1:21:12for 1000 chickens are factory farmed,
- 1:21:13and the other two are probably conscientiously farmed,
- 1:21:15so you've got no chickens now.
- 1:21:16OK,
- 1:21:17so the question,
- 1:21:18sorry,
- 1:21:19but we agree on so much though.
- 1:21:20Because
- 1:21:21I think,
- 1:21:21I think if you're gonna go
- 1:21:2399.9% of all animal consumption is bad and I don't think I
- 1:21:27should do it and I'm gonna take the steps to do it,
- 1:21:29then that's,
- 1:21:29you know,
- 1:21:30as far as I'm concerned,
- 1:21:30that's fine.
- 1:21:31I'm happy with that.
- 1:21:32Desert island scenarios where it's force chick,
- 1:21:35you have to pick between you
- 1:21:36and the pig,
- 1:21:37that's never gonna happen to you,
- 1:21:38so I don't think you need to worry about it.
- 1:21:40So
- 1:21:40like if you agree with me that far,
- 1:21:41then we're basically on the same page,
- 1:21:43we're,
- 1:21:43we're doing the trivial stuff now,
- 1:21:44do you know what I mean?
- 1:21:49OK,
- 1:21:49so yeah,
- 1:21:49and this,
- 1:21:49this is what would be the economic impact
- 1:21:49of us not having an agricultural farm based.
- 1:21:52So given the fact that it's one of,
- 1:21:54if not the leading cause of climate change,
- 1:21:56the World Bank think you're gonna lose about
- 1:21:5710 to $20 trillion of net GDP by 2100.
- 1:22:02Uh,
- 1:22:02that's,
- 1:22:03you know,
- 1:22:03if we've got $100 trillion in global GDP at the moment,
- 1:22:06taking 20% out of it,
- 1:22:07it's gonna have huge effects for the whole world.
- 1:22:09What about the job market?
- 1:22:11Well,
- 1:22:11it's take $20 trillion out,
- 1:22:12it's a really bad.
- 1:22:13How would you replace that?
- 1:22:13I,
- 1:22:14I,
- 1:22:14I don't see how that in some
- 1:22:16economies.
- 1:22:16means this is a big export
- 1:22:18and a very,
- 1:22:18very big thing.
- 1:22:18So how would you replace it?
- 1:22:19Yeah,
- 1:22:19it's a big export in places where the people are starving,
- 1:22:22especially.
- 1:22:23So if you switch to plant-based agriculture,
- 1:22:25for a start,
- 1:22:25you're not gonna lose that 10 to 20 trillion if
- 1:22:27we do take the necessary steps on climate change.
- 1:22:30And the people who are engaging in animal agriculture at the moment,
- 1:22:33they switch to,
- 1:22:34uh,
- 1:22:34plant-based agriculture.
- 1:22:35Are there any supply chain issues?
- 1:22:37Uh,
- 1:22:38I imagine,
- 1:22:39do you have any ideas about any?
- 1:22:40No,
- 1:22:40I'm,
- 1:22:40I'm.
- 1:22:41I don't think so.
- 1:22:42I'm asking Switch the plants for the animals,
- 1:22:43yeah.
- 1:22:44So there would be,
- 1:22:45you'd think there'd be no supply chain issues,
- 1:22:46there'd be no issues for us switching from a,
- 1:22:49in an ideal world,
- 1:22:49right?
- 1:22:50So in your ideal world where we're 100%.
- 1:22:51I think,
- 1:22:52I think the cost of not doing it is just,
- 1:22:53it's monumental.
- 1:22:54Uh,
- 1:22:55when you look at,
- 1:22:55um,
- 1:22:56250 million excess deaths,
- 1:22:58I expect we're talking about climate again.
- 1:22:59And some of the crazy ones like Robert Pierce
- 1:23:01think it goes to about a billion excess deaths.
- 1:23:03Like these numbers are astronomical.
- 1:23:05Right,
- 1:23:06and there's no recovering from going to 2 or 3 degrees over,
- 1:23:09and the zoonotic deaths as well because of the,
- 1:23:11the crossover in diseases.
- 1:23:12And so
- 1:23:13the cost that it's gonna have to the global economy because of the excess deaths,
- 1:23:17like the 70,000 extra people being displaced every year again,
- 1:23:20leading cause being.
- 1:23:21Animal agriculture and um
- 1:23:23and being the
- 1:23:24uh
- 1:23:25the the global emergency in terms of climate change.
- 1:23:27So
- 1:23:28you know you've got a lot of people moving around as well and
- 1:23:31these things are awful for the economy.
- 1:23:32OK,
- 1:23:33pause here.
- 1:23:33You've been voted out by the majority.
- 1:23:35Please return to your seat.
- 1:23:36Cheers.
- 1:23:36Thank you.
- 1:23:44Good to see you again.
- 1:23:45Good to see you again.
- 1:23:47Alright,
- 1:23:47what you've been thinking about?
- 1:23:48So I've been thinking about specifically the humanity part,
- 1:23:51you know,
- 1:23:52being vegan,
- 1:23:53good for humanity,
- 1:23:53humans like you and me.
- 1:23:55You won't like this.
- 1:23:56I'm a chef,
- 1:23:57so I cook with a lot of
- 1:23:59food all the time.
- 1:24:00I do cook vegan dishes,
- 1:24:01but a lot of
- 1:24:02animal products I use
- 1:24:04products do you make?
- 1:24:05What's your best vegan dish?
- 1:24:06From what I remember,
- 1:24:07arugula andai bowl.
- 1:24:08I've got arugula,
- 1:24:09anda figs.
- 1:24:10Actually,
- 1:24:10never mind,
- 1:24:11there's goat cheese in that.
- 1:24:12Sorry,
- 1:24:12forget that.
- 1:24:13But
- 1:24:14that's,
- 1:24:15from my experience
- 1:24:16and the research I've done,
- 1:24:18you need at least
- 1:24:20some
- 1:24:20animal
- 1:24:21product to survive,
- 1:24:22because like,
- 1:24:23a lot of the vegan diet is good.
- 1:24:25A lot of it's good,
- 1:24:26the fruits and veggies and everything.
- 1:24:27But what makes you think that though?
- 1:24:29What makes me think the vegan meat is good because what makes
- 1:24:32you think that you need to eat meat to survive and thrive?
- 1:24:35Because I found out recently,
- 1:24:36I've been doing a lot more of a health to get in better shape,
- 1:24:38and I found that the more protein I eat from meat,
- 1:24:41chicken,
- 1:24:41steak,
- 1:24:42it gets me more bulk,
- 1:24:44it helps me get the vitamins and nutrient minerals I need,
- 1:24:46and I know what you might say,
- 1:24:47hey,
- 1:24:47what about the B12 vitamin,
- 1:24:49that's good.
- 1:24:49I feel like you talk about B12 so much,
- 1:24:51you sound like my sister trying to convince me that her Friend's so great,
- 1:24:54like,
- 1:24:54oh,
- 1:24:54you gotta try B12,
- 1:24:55she's great.
- 1:24:56B12 is
- 1:24:57good.
- 1:24:57Well,
- 1:24:58let me,
- 1:24:58B12 is good.
- 1:24:59You should hang out with your,
- 1:25:00your sister's friend.
- 1:25:00That seemed like a good idea.
- 1:25:02I was gonna say.
- 1:25:03May I finish this first?
- 1:25:05If I do,
- 1:25:06yeah,
- 1:25:06let's say I strict strictly do the B12 vitamins.
- 1:25:09Oh yeah,
- 1:25:09I get the minerals I need.
- 1:25:11What are you gonna do about the calories?
- 1:25:12Because,
- 1:25:13you know,
- 1:25:13you get rid of the
- 1:25:14mineral,
- 1:25:15the meats,
- 1:25:16and you,
- 1:25:16you cut out that calorie,
- 1:25:17but you also cut out a lot of the
- 1:25:20calories that you need to survive,
- 1:25:21because if we become too
- 1:25:23Malnutrition and neuro division,
- 1:25:24we will die
- 1:25:25because I recently
- 1:25:26discovered,
- 1:25:27but again I,
- 1:25:28I gave,
- 1:25:28I gave the studies a bunch of times,
- 1:25:29the overall health outcomes
- 1:25:31are what matters.
- 1:25:32So when you've got,
- 1:25:33you're less likely to die on veganism because of
- 1:25:36health concerns than you are on eating meat.
- 1:25:38Have you heard you're less likely to,
- 1:25:39I'll just let you finish and I'll be brief.
- 1:25:41I'll I'll make sure you've got time.
- 1:25:42I'm aware that you haven't got much.
- 1:25:43Um,
- 1:25:44you're less likely to develop cancer,
- 1:25:45you're less likely to have the heart disease,
- 1:25:46you're less likely to have diabetes,
- 1:25:47be obese,
- 1:25:48yes.
- 1:25:48Can you replace those things in terms of you want calories.
- 1:25:51You wanna bulk up,
- 1:25:52yeah,
- 1:25:52like
- 1:25:53in protein you mentioned,
- 1:25:54Seitan
- 1:25:55has 80 to 100% more protein per calorie than than a sirloin steak.
- 1:26:00That's significant.
- 1:26:01Tofu more than eggs,
- 1:26:02soy milk over whole milk and semi-skimmed milk.
- 1:26:05Alright,
- 1:26:05let me ask you,
- 1:26:05so you
- 1:26:07obviously we wanna not die,
- 1:26:08obviously.
- 1:26:09So have you heard of,
- 1:26:09I'm gonna mess up her name,
- 1:26:10I'm gonna butcher it,
- 1:26:11Johanna
- 1:26:12Somosonova.
- 1:26:14She is,
- 1:26:15she was a Russian
- 1:26:17vegan influencer.
- 1:26:19That died at the age of 39,
- 1:26:21and what did she die of?
- 1:26:22You haven't got long.
- 1:26:23Her own family members say that she died of malnourishment and low energy.
- 1:26:27She did not have enough calories
- 1:26:29to sustain her body,
- 1:26:30and because of that,
- 1:26:31she died before she was the age of 50.
- 1:26:33So versus the 600,000.
- 1:26:35But that's a good example like.
- 1:26:36You,
- 1:26:37if we try anecdotes aren't the same as 600.
- 1:26:401 person,
- 1:26:41yeah,
- 1:26:41you're gonna have anomalies,
- 1:26:42right?
- 1:26:42I,
- 1:26:43I,
- 1:26:43I met somebody earlier who said they can't
- 1:26:45survive and not eat meat.
- 1:26:46Yeah,
- 1:26:46right,
- 1:26:47so,
- 1:26:47so yeah,
- 1:26:47I'm not denying that.
- 1:26:49I think that the number is so slim that it's very impossible to become full vegan.
- 1:26:53There is nothing,
- 1:26:54there is nothing really in this impossible to be.
- 1:26:56What are you wearing by chance?
- 1:26:58Are you wearing Doc Martens by chance?
- 1:26:59Yep.
- 1:27:00Aren't those,
- 1:27:01are those vegan?
- 1:27:02Yep.
- 1:27:03Are you sure about that?
- 1:27:03Yeah,
- 1:27:04they're made of rubber.
- 1:27:05And rubber is made of
- 1:27:07rubber's not made of animals.
- 1:27:09But there's a lot of
- 1:27:10vegan products,
- 1:27:11there's a lot of animal products and things that you don't you think
- 1:27:13I'll turn up to one vegan versus 20 meat eaters wearing leather shoes.
- 1:27:17You think,
- 1:27:17you think I'm,
- 1:27:18I mean,
- 1:27:19a lot of people don't know a lot of stuff's in there.
- 1:27:21Oh my days,
- 1:27:22man.
- 1:27:22She's,
- 1:27:23to be honest,
- 1:27:23it crossed my mind too,
- 1:27:24it crossed my mind too.
- 1:27:25Thank you.
- 1:27:26He crossed his mind too.
- 1:27:27I rest my case and my time is up.
- 1:27:29Great demeaning.
- 1:27:30Pick up some vegans.
- 1:27:32Thank you.
- 1:27:34Alright,
- 1:27:34that's the end of our claim portion from Doctor Jack,
- 1:27:37snaps to you,
- 1:27:38great job.
- 1:27:39Uh,
- 1:27:39I'm gonna ask you to look around the circle and choose somebody
- 1:27:42who you wanna bring back to the center for one more debate.
- 1:27:45I'm gonna pick my guy in the red shirt.
- 1:27:47And what's your reasoning?
- 1:27:48We started having an interesting conversation earlier,
- 1:27:50we didn't really get into it,
- 1:27:51so yeah,
- 1:27:52interested to hear more,
- 1:27:53hear what your claim is.
- 1:27:54Alright.
- 1:27:57How's it going?
- 1:27:58Uh,
- 1:27:58my surrounded claim is that,
- 1:27:59uh,
- 1:28:00going completely vegan is,
- 1:28:02uh,
- 1:28:02for the entire world at once is impossible.
- 1:28:06I would not reject that claim.
- 1:28:07I think going all at once to veganism would be,
- 1:28:10it's an absolute claim.
- 1:28:12It,
- 1:28:12it would be possible.
- 1:28:13I do.
- 1:28:14What's your reason for it?
- 1:28:14I do want to have a conversation,
- 1:28:16uh,
- 1:28:16with you about something.
- 1:28:17Um,
- 1:28:18I,
- 1:28:18when I make,
- 1:28:19uh,
- 1:28:19food for my vegetarian friends and have uh cook dinner for them.
- 1:28:23It feels more expensive for me to go to Ralph's or Trader Joe's and buy.
- 1:28:28You know,
- 1:28:28a,
- 1:28:29a fancy dinner for them,
- 1:28:30uh,
- 1:28:30a fancy groceries for them,
- 1:28:32compared to
- 1:28:33when I would make food for my,
- 1:28:35uh,
- 1:28:35uh,
- 1:28:35meat eaters,
- 1:28:36friends,
- 1:28:36and I knew you have great stats to support it,
- 1:28:38and I'm often left with just making chana masala or something,
- 1:28:41and I don't want to serve them vitamin B12 on a plate or,
- 1:28:44you know,
- 1:28:45a protein shake on the side.
- 1:28:46Yeah,
- 1:28:47and uh yeah,
- 1:28:48I just want to have a conversation about that.
- 1:28:49Yeah,
- 1:28:49I feel it,
- 1:28:50I think one of the most common objections to the vegan is that,
- 1:28:53you know,
- 1:28:53it's some,
- 1:28:54some left woke person who has,
- 1:28:56Excess money has the time to sit around thinking about moral philosophy
- 1:28:59and then makes the change to go vegan,
- 1:29:01whereas other people don't have the privilege,
- 1:29:03they're trying to put food on the table,
- 1:29:05they don't have the time or even the resources to go out and buy
- 1:29:08vegan food,
- 1:29:09and therefore it's a privileged position.
- 1:29:11Um,
- 1:29:11I don't think that's true.
- 1:29:13I think we've got lots of intuitions.
- 1:29:14Give you an example,
- 1:29:15um,
- 1:29:16how many animals of each kind did Moses take on the ark?
- 1:29:19I'm not Christian,
- 1:29:20so I'm not.
- 1:29:20How many,
- 1:29:21how many on the ark,
- 1:29:21you should know.
- 1:29:22I do not know.
- 1:29:23You don't know how many are on the ark.
- 1:29:24Anyone know?
- 1:29:2640.
- 1:29:26Not 2,
- 1:29:27John,
- 1:29:27why?
- 1:29:282 of each.
- 1:29:29No,
- 1:29:29I said Moses in the question,
- 1:29:30not Noah,
- 1:29:31right?
- 1:29:32And so,
- 1:29:32sorry,
- 1:29:32you,
- 1:29:33why would you,
- 1:29:33you didn't even need to fall for that got you,
- 1:29:35I don't know what you're doing over there.
- 1:29:36Um,
- 1:29:37the,
- 1:29:37the point is that
- 1:29:38like our intuitions about things like that,
- 1:29:40immediately we think too,
- 1:29:41but if we slow down,
- 1:29:42we think about these things,
- 1:29:43we do the research,
- 1:29:44then we'll find that actually it's again this University of
- 1:29:46Oxford study found it's 30% cheaper to go vegan.
- 1:29:49And that the people in third world countries such as Ethiopia and Sudan,
- 1:29:52the the people who are worst off
- 1:29:54across the world,
- 1:29:55they're more likely to be,
- 1:29:57uh,
- 1:29:57to be eating meat.
- 1:29:58Um,
- 1:29:58so,
- 1:29:59so I take that to be true.
- 1:29:59When it comes to cooking for your friends,
- 1:30:01you know,
- 1:30:02like
- 1:30:02I've only been a vegetarian vegan.
- 1:30:04Vegan since I was 21,
- 1:30:05you know,
- 1:30:0612 good years,
- 1:30:07and
- 1:30:08before it'd just be beef burgers and chips and a bit of veg on the side,
- 1:30:11very common dish for a lot of people,
- 1:30:12right?
- 1:30:12Not very healthy,
- 1:30:13but yeah.
- 1:30:13And since I've went vegan,
- 1:30:15you know,
- 1:30:15I've started enjoying loads of different foods,
- 1:30:17Indian curries,
- 1:30:18Mexican spicy food.
- 1:30:20Um,
- 1:30:20and it sort of opens up a new world,
- 1:30:21yeah.
- 1:30:22Yeah,
- 1:30:22I think,
- 1:30:23um,
- 1:30:23I,
- 1:30:24I definitely agree with all your points about being,
- 1:30:26you know,
- 1:30:26going vegan and like a lot of people should aim
- 1:30:28to be vegan,
- 1:30:29and which is,
- 1:30:30which is,
- 1:30:30you think you could go vegan.
- 1:30:31I,
- 1:30:31and this is as a man,
- 1:30:33uh,
- 1:30:33of like my word,
- 1:30:34I know that
- 1:30:35it will be very difficult and I think I won't be
- 1:30:38completely able to go,
- 1:30:39um.
- 1:30:41Go completely vegan because I,
- 1:30:43I do,
- 1:30:43and I know there are moral obligations to it,
- 1:30:45but I do enjoy the taste of,
- 1:30:47you know,
- 1:30:47eating chicken or
- 1:30:48would you consider just trying
- 1:30:51a plant-based alternative instead,
- 1:30:53because I,
- 1:30:53I cited that study earlier.
- 1:30:54Right,
- 1:30:54right.
- 1:30:54175 people.
- 1:30:56I think that's so interesting when you give people a blind taste test.
- 1:30:58Right,
- 1:30:58and it tastes pretty similar,
- 1:30:59yes,
- 1:31:00and that that has happened to me.
- 1:31:01As well,
- 1:31:01but to me it feels way easier to,
- 1:31:03you know,
- 1:31:03run to the grocery store down the street and get a,
- 1:31:06a thing of chicken breast and cook it and eat it for the night.
- 1:31:08You feel the moral obligation.
- 1:31:10You,
- 1:31:10you want in theory to go vegan,
- 1:31:12but it's merely just your habit.
- 1:31:14I do not want to go vegan,
- 1:31:16but I do want to take certain steps,
- 1:31:17and I think there's a middle ground that,
- 1:31:19um,
- 1:31:19you know,
- 1:31:19because we both have the same interests to.
- 1:31:21Um,
- 1:31:22the moral argument,
- 1:31:23right?
- 1:31:23You said you feel like there's a moral obligation.
- 1:31:26Obligation means you ought to do it,
- 1:31:27so you should do it.
- 1:31:28Well,
- 1:31:28moral,
- 1:31:29um,
- 1:31:29maybe that's a,
- 1:31:30that's a,
- 1:31:31a wrong term that I use,
- 1:31:32but I think it's a,
- 1:31:33er,
- 1:31:33I do feel morally,
- 1:31:34you know,
- 1:31:35weird about
- 1:31:36cos I,
- 1:31:36if I wouldn't kill an animal,
- 1:31:37why.
- 1:31:38Would I let someone else kill an element and eat animal and eat it,
- 1:31:40right?
- 1:31:40I mean,
- 1:31:41I wouldn't say it was much better if you went out and killed it yourself.
- 1:31:43Right,
- 1:31:44um,
- 1:31:44but I think you and I will both want
- 1:31:46somewhat similar to,
- 1:31:47you know,
- 1:31:47go and preserve that the animals are protected and well
- 1:31:51taken care of and not killed in industrial farming.
- 1:31:54Yeah,
- 1:31:54but being the killing more generally as well.
- 1:31:56Another,
- 1:31:57another myth is that you're having humane slaughters.
- 1:32:00There's no such thing as a yes,
- 1:32:01but I think,
- 1:32:02and this is a thing that uh the country of India practices a lot,
- 1:32:06um,
- 1:32:06and I don't
- 1:32:07see this could be a middle
- 1:32:09this uh.
- 1:32:10Hinduism and the country of India practices,
- 1:32:14right,
- 1:32:14that we practice a thing of uh not eating meat uh on Tuesdays,
- 1:32:18which,
- 1:32:19you know,
- 1:32:19I,
- 1:32:19I,
- 1:32:20I think it's just a,
- 1:32:21it's just a step forward in the direction of,
- 1:32:23as you know,
- 1:32:24the Hindu tradition,
- 1:32:24the Buddhist tradition,
- 1:32:25the Sikh tradition.
- 1:32:26Um,
- 1:32:27the Jain tradition vegetarian.
- 1:32:28Yeah,
- 1:32:28they should practice the principle of ahimsa,
- 1:32:30non-suffering.
- 1:32:31The reincarnation depends on it.
- 1:32:34And the same is true,
- 1:32:34I think,
- 1:32:35of the,
- 1:32:35the Jewish and the Muslim traditions as well.
- 1:32:37The Muslim tradition
- 1:32:38in the Hadith 2365.
- 1:32:40You've got an example of a woman who
- 1:32:42is condemned to hell according to Muslim teachings.
- 1:32:45She's condemned to hell
- 1:32:47for putting a cat in a cage so small the cat can't move in and not feeding it properly.
- 1:32:51Yet the overwhelming amount of produce that Muslims are eating under the label of
- 1:32:55halal is factory farms,
- 1:32:57and so is the kosher meat as well.
- 1:32:59So
- 1:33:00it seems like
- 1:33:01the Abrahamic salvation is dependent on it.
- 1:33:04The,
- 1:33:04the Hindu,
- 1:33:05the Buddhists,
- 1:33:05and this is right back to the start of the conversation,
- 1:33:07all of their,
- 1:33:08their reincarnations are dependent on it too.
- 1:33:11And
- 1:33:11I,
- 1:33:11I totally agree with you,
- 1:33:12you have a religious belief yourself?
- 1:33:14I,
- 1:33:15I am uh very similar to you in terms of religion.
- 1:33:17I'm a
- 1:33:18pantheistic,
- 1:33:19uh,
- 1:33:19pantheist,
- 1:33:20um,
- 1:33:21but yes,
- 1:33:21I,
- 1:33:21I do believe that,
- 1:33:22you know,
- 1:33:23um,
- 1:33:24if you are
- 1:33:24making someone suffer,
- 1:33:25the karma is gonna catch you back
- 1:33:27and you know,
- 1:33:28um it seems like you agree with the moral obligation though,
- 1:33:30and it doesn't seem like just because of you do,
- 1:33:32and just because of the habit.
- 1:33:33But it doesn't seem to be obligation is the wrong word,
- 1:33:36but yes.
- 1:33:36And it,
- 1:33:37it seems to me like the reason is habit.
- 1:33:39Would you say that's fair?
- 1:33:40I don't think it's habit because I,
- 1:33:42I did in fact turn vegetarian.
- 1:33:44What is the reason?
- 1:33:45I can't just be what you're cooking for people.
- 1:33:47I,
- 1:33:47I think the,
- 1:33:48how easy it is for me
- 1:33:50to,
- 1:33:50uh,
- 1:33:51consume meat
- 1:33:52and how,
- 1:33:53how easy it is for me to,
- 1:33:54you know,
- 1:33:54go to a restaurant and there are two options for.
- 1:33:57Vegan or 3 and
- 1:33:5910 options for me to enjoy a nice dinner,
- 1:34:01right?
- 1:34:01And you agree that ease doesn't override the moral law though,
- 1:34:05right?
- 1:34:06Uh,
- 1:34:06say that again please.
- 1:34:07The ease of it doesn't override the moral law.
- 1:34:10It's easy to have slaves,
- 1:34:11right?
- 1:34:12But we shouldn't have slaves.
- 1:34:13We shouldn't talk about that,
- 1:34:14I think.
- 1:34:14It's a different,
- 1:34:14different kinds of topic.
- 1:34:16I mean,
- 1:34:16no,
- 1:34:16it's an analogy,
- 1:34:17I can change the analogy if it makes you feel,
- 1:34:18you know,
- 1:34:19if you,
- 1:34:19if you want to avoid that completely,
- 1:34:21um,
- 1:34:21it's easy to,
- 1:34:22I don't know if,
- 1:34:23uh,
- 1:34:23for if you're very rich,
- 1:34:24it's easy to fly a private jet wherever you.
- 1:34:26You go,
- 1:34:27right,
- 1:34:27but you think you have a moral obligation towards the environment more generally,
- 1:34:30not to use private jets all the time.
- 1:34:31I don't understand the analogy,
- 1:34:32um,
- 1:34:33it's just easy to eat meat,
- 1:34:35it doesn't justify the harm inflicted on that,
- 1:34:37that is totally fair,
- 1:34:38and it doesn't justify,
- 1:34:39yes.
- 1:34:40It's like it's picking up a Beyond Meat burger rather than the beef burger.
- 1:34:43That's not really,
- 1:34:44it's not really ease,
- 1:34:45it takes a second.
- 1:34:46I do think that there needs to be a middle ground where,
- 1:34:48you know,
- 1:34:49um,
- 1:34:49the meat eaters and the vegans or vegetarian choice,
- 1:34:52uh uh people meet because
- 1:34:54I can't just snap a finger and say.
- 1:34:56OK,
- 1:34:56we're stopping all the,
- 1:34:58uh,
- 1:34:58farming,
- 1:34:59uh,
- 1:34:59industrial farming in terms of animals.
- 1:35:01Um,
- 1:35:01so I think there needs to be like a step,
- 1:35:03it could be a step-based process.
- 1:35:05You can take that step right now.
- 1:35:06Yes,
- 1:35:06I,
- 1:35:06I,
- 1:35:07I could,
- 1:35:07I do in fact intend after this,
- 1:35:09uh,
- 1:35:10if,
- 1:35:10uh,
- 1:35:10you know,
- 1:35:10thing
- 1:35:11to maybe
- 1:35:12not eat meat one day a week
- 1:35:14or why not more though,
- 1:35:15because that is still 3 meals 3 meals a day that I'm not eating meat,
- 1:35:19you know,
- 1:35:19and,
- 1:35:19and I do intend when I
- 1:35:21do cook for other people.
- 1:35:22But I do eats like saying,
- 1:35:23you know,
- 1:35:24I,
- 1:35:24I,
- 1:35:24I love getting in pub brawls,
- 1:35:26but I only beat people up on Fridays,
- 1:35:27Saturdays and Sundays.
- 1:35:29I,
- 1:35:29I don't,
- 1:35:30I
- 1:35:31disagree with that,
- 1:35:31but
- 1:35:32then,
- 1:35:32then go the whole way.
- 1:35:33Just,
- 1:35:34just say you'll try it,
- 1:35:35you'll try going vegan.
- 1:35:36I know I won't succeed in that cos I have tried it.
- 1:35:39I'm not asking you to do,
- 1:35:40I'm asking you to try.
- 1:35:41I said everyone should aim to be vegan.
- 1:35:43That was one of my.
- 1:35:44I,
- 1:35:44as a person,
- 1:35:45I,
- 1:35:45I know myself and I don't think I would be able to do it cos I have tried.
- 1:35:49Dude,
- 1:35:49it's,
- 1:35:50it's,
- 1:35:50it baffles me that people sort of go like,
- 1:35:53hey,
- 1:35:53like it's so difficult to do,
- 1:35:55like it's so it's so not just about being difficult,
- 1:35:57but I,
- 1:35:58I do depend on it.
- 1:35:59I do depend on my.
- 1:36:01I just I could just do it.
- 1:36:02I do depend on my protein and my and my vitamins and a lot of things on me.
- 1:36:06Just say you'll try and you'll do it,
- 1:36:08you'll give it your best.
- 1:36:09I,
- 1:36:09let's end on that,
- 1:36:10just say that you'll,
- 1:36:11you'll give it your best.
- 1:36:12If you fail,
- 1:36:13you fail,
- 1:36:13but you should try.
- 1:36:15I don't think,
- 1:36:16give it a try.
- 1:36:17I
- 1:36:17I'll buy your first vegan burger.
- 1:36:18I will shake your hand only because I'm nice,
- 1:36:20but I'm not gonna go.
- 1:36:22I'm not gonna go vegan,
- 1:36:23but I don't wanna leave you hanging.
- 1:36:24Come on,
- 1:36:25you can't leave me hanging.
- 1:36:25You'll try to go vegan.
- 1:36:27I just don't want to say that I'll turn vegan in front of you and
- 1:36:30then not do it because I'm not a hypocrite asking you to turn vegan,
- 1:36:32I'm asking you to try.
- 1:36:33I,
- 1:36:34I have tried in the past,
- 1:36:35and I am,
- 1:36:35I'm promising you that I will be trying to reduce.
- 1:36:39Conversation like you,
- 1:36:40you accept all of the reasons
- 1:36:42and you think that you should do it.
- 1:36:43Yeah,
- 1:36:43Doctor Jack,
- 1:36:44I will,
- 1:36:45I promise you that I will try to limit the amount of meat I eat,
- 1:36:48but I can't promise you that I will be vegan right,
- 1:36:50like right away.
- 1:36:51Try it for a week.
- 1:36:52Give me,
- 1:36:52me me a week,
- 1:36:53Mimi a week.
- 1:36:54I don't think I'll be able to do that.
- 1:36:55Try,
- 1:36:56try me a week.
- 1:36:56I don't think I would be able to do that.
- 1:36:58I apologize,
- 1:36:59I'm a weaker man than you,
- 1:37:00but I won't be able to do that.
- 1:37:01Disappointed me,
- 1:37:02dude.
- 1:37:04Hey,
- 1:37:04it's lovely to speak to you though.
- 1:37:05Thank you to speak to you.
- 1:37:06Appreciate it.
- 1:37:09Uh,
- 1:37:09I think on the whole,
- 1:37:10like everyone's sort of like a,
- 1:37:11an animal lover anyway,
- 1:37:12just like vegans take it a bit further,
- 1:37:14so everyone feels like the pull of it.
- 1:37:16There's probably 3 or 4 people who were thought,
- 1:37:18you know,
- 1:37:18might be tempted to at least reduce,
- 1:37:20if not go vegan.
- 1:37:21I'm gonna eat twice as many meat just on the off chance that
- 1:37:24that one guy at the end does go vegan one day a week,
- 1:37:27I'm gonna offset it.
- 1:37:28I'm a big proponent of.
- 1:37:30Doing whatever feels right for you.
- 1:37:32So if they decided to become vegan after this,
- 1:37:35I guess if they feel like it's right for them,
- 1:37:37I think when you actually see somebody living a carnivore lifestyle,
- 1:37:40you might
- 1:37:41be more inclined to
- 1:37:43check it out because it's just more real.
- 1:37:45It's relatable.
- 1:37:46Numbers and stats aren't relatable.
- 1:37:48I don't think he was very relatable
- 1:37:50to most people.
- 1:37:51He's.
- 1:37:51Dairy,
- 1:37:52numbers,
- 1:37:53doctor,
- 1:37:54you know,
- 1:37:54how many people live like that?
- 1:37:56If you decided to become vegan after watching this video,
- 1:37:59let us know in the comments.
- 1:38:00If you are a vegan and you've converted back to being a carnivore,
- 1:38:03also let us know.
- 1:38:04That would be kind of strange.
- 1:38:05Uh,
- 1:38:06thanks for watching.
- 1:38:06We'll see you next time.
- 1:38:07Don't forget to subscribe to Surrounded wherever you get
- 1:38:10your podcasts so that you don't miss an episode.
- 1:38:12And if you want to watch the video version of Surrounded,
- 1:38:14subscribe to Jubilee on YouTube.