Latest / The New Paris Podcast / 156: On Paris vs London in the arts with Maïa Morgensztern
Transcript
- 0:07You're listening to the new Paris.
- 0:09I'm your host, Lindsay Trermuda. Almost two years ago I met
- 0:13today's guest on an Art Deco journalist jaunt around greater
- 0:17Paris and have followed her work ever since.
- 0:20Maya Morgenstern is a French art historian and culture journalist
- 0:23living in London, but returns to Paris monthly, usually for an
- 0:26exhibition. Given how much has changed in
- 0:29the art world in the last year, I wanted to get her take on
- 0:32Paris versus London, the historical contexts of both
- 0:35cities and their approaches to culture, and the impact of
- 0:38Brexit on the art world. We'll talk about government and
- 0:41private funding in the arts, access to cultural institutions,
- 0:44and the class divides that influence who engages with art.
- 0:48You'll also hear where she likes to go every time she's in town.
- 0:54Maya, welcome to the show. Hi, Lizzy, I'm very excited to
- 0:59thank you to be on the show. You're dialing in.
- 1:02You're calling in. What do we say?
- 1:03You're you're joining me from London.
- 1:05But yesterday you were in Paris and last week you were in Paris
- 1:08and the week before you were in Paris.
- 1:10But what were you doing yesterday?
- 1:13I said it was a very long day, but I think it's typical of
- 1:16seeing the differences between Paris and London.
- 1:18I started the day at Notre Dame de Paris because I wanted to see
- 1:23the cathedral, which I hadn't seen in a long time, and the
- 1:26Viola Logic stained glass windows that are going to be
- 1:28swapped for Clare Taboure. So I started there at Notre
- 1:33Dame. Then I went to see the
- 1:35exhibition of Clare Taboure, you know, upcoming stained glass
- 1:37windows at the Grand Palais. Fantastic, fantastic show.
- 1:40Very interesting with the Tu de Simo Marc.
- 1:43And then what did I do? I saw Evajo Spa, uh, and then a
- 1:47few other exhibitions and ended up in London and went straight
- 1:51into this Soho club for drag Queens.
- 1:55Uh, birthday party? Yes, birthday party, but again,
- 1:58like seeing the Paris in London are so close yet so far apart.
- 2:01That's what I love about it. I mean, they couldn't be more
- 2:05different in terms of the way people dress, the way people
- 2:08behave. I mean, it really is like night
- 2:10and day and you being a, a French woman who used to live in
- 2:14Paris and you know, has, has been living in London now for
- 2:17quite a long time, right? Yes, I moved to London 2008 and
- 2:21I arrived from New York City. So I think for me it's the
- 2:26experience of having lived in the US seven years and
- 2:29experienced the arts there and how it works and being trained
- 2:32as an art historian in Paris, very classically trained there.
- 2:35And moving to London, I feel like I've seen all end of the
- 2:38spectrum and the middle ground, which is the UK in London.
- 2:42Well, that's an interesting point because as I explained in
- 2:45the introduction, I haven't done an art related or art focused
- 2:49episode in about a year. And that was when the couture
- 2:52show came out at the Louvre. And there's been so much change
- 2:55since then. There's been a lot of movement,
- 2:57a lot of exciting developments. You have the opening of the
- 3:00fundes from Cartier, which moved to the first.
- 3:03You just mentioned the Grand Parade exhibitions that are
- 3:06really special that are on right now.
- 3:07But you also have Bant Vey that just closed at the Orange re
- 3:11Michelin Thomas, an American artist at the Grand Parade.
- 3:14So there's so much to see right now in Paris.
- 3:19And you, as someone who goes between who reports on art, who
- 3:22reports on cultural happenings, and as a trained art historian,
- 3:26what do you think is most interesting in this particular
- 3:30moment about what we're seeing happen in Paris, especially
- 3:34compared to London? Well, I mean, you, you said it
- 3:38yourself, it's like the list goes on and on.
- 3:40And again, both the Commerce is also very new.
- 3:43We feel like it's been there forever, but it hasn't.
- 3:46Sotheby's also open a new headquarters next to an old
- 3:49headquarters, which is massive white cube.
- 3:51Hauser and Worth also open outpost moving, you know, a lot
- 3:56of their businesses from London to Paris or just adding new
- 4:00businesses, as they like to say. But Dumplawn just closed the
- 4:03Gallery in London and just to stay in Paris.
- 4:06So that what we're witnessing right now seems major, but we
- 4:11have to remember that it's nothing new.
- 4:13These things are cyclical. And yes, it can be attributed to
- 4:17a lot of factors, but maybe I think the best way to explain it
- 4:21is that Paris and London are a little bit of vas communicant,
- 4:24you know, like vessels, like interconnected vessels. 1 is
- 4:29always trying to be like, hey, I'm there.
- 4:31And then the other one's like, yeah, I'm there too.
- 4:33And it's pushing the art world. Let's just go back a little bit.
- 4:37Like Exposition Universal, You know, like the major.
- 4:40You want to go back like a long time?
- 4:42I want to go back a long time. We could go back even further,
- 4:45but I think that will explain really what's at play here.
- 4:49Like 1855, explosive Universal opens in France, in Paris to
- 4:54showcase the best of the world, Napoleon the Third.
- 4:58Why is it doing this? Because London opened in 1851,
- 5:01the Great Exhibition. So you don't, you don't only
- 5:05want to show what's best in the world, you want to show it in
- 5:08your own home because that's of power.
- 5:11That's how you develop your ideas and spread your ideas
- 5:14somewhere else. So it's a competition within the
- 5:16competition and even the artist are participating in that.
- 5:20You think of like a Claude Monet painting gas and Lazar.
- 5:23It's not just pretty, it's showing you.
- 5:25This is what we have. We have a train station, we have
- 5:28the locomotive, the Eiffel Tower.
- 5:30It's not just for Instagram. It was made in 1889 for the
- 5:35Exposition Universal. It was a pure self power look
- 5:38right here. So this is the going back of the
- 5:41cyclical, like push and pull happening between Paris and
- 5:46London. And I mean, we could go back
- 5:48again, like, we'll go through history and say there were a few
- 5:50dips and why and when, like the Second World War, for obvious
- 5:53reasons, lost its shine a little bit to New York and then to
- 5:58Berlin. When was that?
- 6:01So we're looking at the after the end of the Second World War,
- 6:04you know, like a lot of people were either killed, sent to war,
- 6:07sent to the front, had to hide or run away.
- 6:10And all of a sudden America, great vectors of that of that
- 6:14war are offering a new way of life, a new way of seeing.
- 6:17And you have the abstract expressionists that are on the
- 6:19rise, which is vibrant and exciting.
- 6:23And again, if one day you want to do an episode on self power,
- 6:26I mean, the rise of abstract expressionist is a due a lot in
- 6:30part to the CIA. That's a kind of fairly recent
- 6:34discovery. OK, I know this this would be a
- 6:38tangent, but like can you just give like a little nugget?
- 6:41About that because. I'm you've piqued my interest.
- 6:44Well, you're not to go too deep into it, but basically you have
- 6:48a Cold War. So we're like 45 and 50s and
- 6:51like all this era between America and Russia.
- 6:55And there's two ways of life that are competing, two ways of
- 6:58seeing the world. And the reason why the CIA got
- 7:01involved in, you know, like trying to push this artist
- 7:05because abstract expressionism was just showing that new way of
- 7:09life, the freedom and capitalism.
- 7:10And it was not intrinsic to the artist and what they were
- 7:14talking about, but it's it was the freedom of expression as
- 7:18opposed to, you know, if you look at the Soviet Union of the
- 7:21beginning of the 20th century and the official art.
- 7:24So they were just trying to combat ideas of stereotypes of
- 7:28what art should be and what artists should be doing.
- 7:32But that's why they pushed it to the forefront.
- 7:34When you say push, was it financially or was it OK?
- 7:38They weren't. Initially backed.
- 7:39OK, OK. And and again, there's so many
- 7:43ways of doing soft power. You named.
- 7:45I mean, look, we're looking at it every day you rename.
- 7:47It literally. Yeah, literally.
- 7:50You name a curator, you name the director of a museum.
- 7:55I mean, if you decide, if you know who's going to decide
- 7:58what's good for the future, that's power right there.
- 8:01You're changing the conversation already, so sorry.
- 8:04That's the tangent. But that's no, but it was a it
- 8:06was a worthy one, But so, OK, so, so Paris really sort of
- 8:09dipped at that moment and there was interesting things happening
- 8:13in Berlin. I mean, there's still
- 8:16interesting things happening in Berlin, very much still the
- 8:19underground city, right? But I it's funny because while
- 8:22it there's some interesting art, I associate it more with
- 8:25clubbing and nightlife and not actually with like
- 8:28groundbreaking exhibitions in the way that we see them over
- 8:32here. Well, because our idea of ground
- 8:35breaking exhibition has become what we call a blockbuster.
- 8:40And for that you need a lot of money.
- 8:42And that's a different way of setting up art and showing art.
- 8:45Berlin was more about the Avon gout.
- 8:48And again, remember like 1889, like the fall of the wall where
- 8:52we're in the 90s. So you have East and West
- 8:55reuniting and the conversation and the rebuilding of the idea
- 9:00of a nation, what it is to have an identity.
- 9:02We're talking about intellectual art, not throwing like Jeff
- 9:06Goons on a bag. So it's it's a very different
- 9:10approach. So it's we're talking what is a
- 9:14successful exhibition, basically trying to answer your question.
- 9:16Is it one that has many people, a famous artist, or that's going
- 9:21to be intellectually challenging and we'll find out.
- 9:23It was so important, but like 50 years later when everybody's
- 9:26dead. It's a very, very good point.
- 9:28And so there is no answer, because it really depends on who
- 9:31you're asking. Exactly.
- 9:33And it's always the same story. Exactly.
- 9:35And the audience and what do you value?
- 9:37So in that sense, Berlin has always been very important for
- 9:41different reasons. And again, Harrison Berlin were
- 9:44collaborating a lot in London as well.
- 9:46I mean, it's always the same, the rivalries for a good reason
- 9:50at the end of the day, as just artists go where the
- 9:53conversation is going to be the most interesting.
- 9:55That's that's a very good point. And we see that constantly
- 9:59happening. And perhaps what's going on in
- 10:01the US right now is going to fuel all sorts of artist
- 10:04commentary in the days to come, Hopefully, freely, hopefully and
- 10:11freely. So, OK.
- 10:12If we jump ahead, though, Paris has gotten a new opportunity in
- 10:16recent years because of Brexit. I mean, I would say that, you
- 10:19know, I had done this story and I know you report on the arts a
- 10:22lot, that you can look at the data in terms of galleries
- 10:26opening. You mentioned Templon closing in
- 10:30in London and staying here. We've had other galleries that
- 10:33choose to open here. And that's really because of the
- 10:36cost of, you know, moving art and, and the UK deciding to be
- 10:43on its own. And so it's given Paris a real
- 10:45opportunity. How does that play out in your
- 10:49mind? Is it, is it sustainable?
- 10:50Is it going to keep lasting or will people sort of get tired of
- 10:54what Paris has done? Well, no, again, we're it's
- 10:57cyclical. And again, I think Paris had
- 11:00like was shining for so many years and centuries and we're so
- 11:02proud of it. London, think of the YBAS in the
- 11:0590s, you know, it was bright and new and Tracy Emin and Damien
- 11:09Hirst and putting like a cow in formaldehyde.
- 11:12Like it's, it's, it was all this like brand new vision that we
- 11:16thought Paris was a little bit tired.
- 11:18And you had this kind of like riffraff in England that were,
- 11:21you know, going for make Britain great again in that sense.
- 11:25So London had its time then when Saatchi was pushing this artist
- 11:30again financially backing them up.
- 11:32A guy in advertising pushing the riff raff is kind of also a fun
- 11:36way to look at it. So it's, it's I don't know how
- 11:39long this is going to last, but for sure at the moment, because
- 11:43London is in a such difficult spot, it is, as you said, so
- 11:47expensive to put on an exhibition.
- 11:49Artists are having a hard time, you know, just getting a visa.
- 11:53Or if you think of Pad, the Pavilion of Art and Design,
- 11:56which is the same fare, French fare originally happening in
- 12:00London and Paris, it costs so much more to buy the same
- 12:04artwork in London as in Paris. Well, guess where you're going
- 12:07to buy it. If, especially if you're a
- 12:09European collector, it doesn't make any sense to buy it in
- 12:12London. Art Basel, where is that?
- 12:15Where did they go? Not London.
- 12:17They went to Paris, kicked out Fiat, bye bye.
- 12:19And then now it's like since 2022, massive opportunity.
- 12:25So there's a big influx of money, creative minds going to
- 12:30Paris. Is that sustainable?
- 12:32I don't know. But London as and England has
- 12:35definitely isolated itself. So that's going to help a lot on
- 12:39the other side of the Channel. And what do you see in terms of
- 12:43how Paris has consolidated maybe some of its artistic power, the
- 12:48Fondaciones, Cartier moving to the center of the city after
- 12:51being in the 14 thousands small for so long since the 90s,
- 12:55right? Yeah, it's a much bigger
- 12:58structure. It's a block from the Louvre.
- 13:01It's close to the Paris Royale. It's close to, I mean, it's
- 13:04technically not far from the Musee d'orsay.
- 13:06I mean, it's really in the center of cultural power in the
- 13:09city. And of course, there's a private
- 13:11foundation that's behind it, right?
- 13:13The brand Cartier, It's not for nothing that it's called that.
- 13:17How does that fit into all of this?
- 13:20How does that opening change or or illustrate what's happening
- 13:24in the city artistically? I think what it's mostly
- 13:28illustrating is in a change in a way culture is viewed and
- 13:32consumed in France. And mostly again, I'm sorry, I
- 13:36like to go back in Easter because it's fun.
- 13:38But you know, art. Art was originally the problem
- 13:43of the government, the kings first like Francois, Premier
- 13:47Louis the 14 again, we're going back to soft power.
- 13:49Look what we can do. Look how amazing it is.
- 13:51And it was subsidized by the government at play.
- 13:54And for as long as I can remember, when we chopped
- 13:58people's head off the kings, which, you know, people didn't
- 14:01do in English, yes, in France, off with their heads, You know,
- 14:04the, the royal palace that was there was called the Muse
- 14:08Central Desert, where in 1793, that's the ancestor of the
- 14:12Louvre. So we took what was royalty and
- 14:16decided, no, that would be for the people.
- 14:18So in France, it was always the government's task, or it was
- 14:22seen as the government's task to give the people art and culture,
- 14:26which in America is not the same.
- 14:28And London is like, well, they still have their heads and their
- 14:31crowns on. So it's a different system.
- 14:34But I think that's why, like what's at play is who is
- 14:38responsible for giving people the culture.
- 14:42And in France, the major shift comes from funding like cut
- 14:45fundings. The government cannot afford to
- 14:48subsidize the art forever. There's no money.
- 14:51We know that we love to live on credit, you know, and how to
- 14:55pockets. That's what we do.
- 14:57But we don't have credit cards. At least, no, we don't.
- 15:01Because. Not like in the US.
- 15:02It's too capitalist, like it's I think for French system.
- 15:06But again, you're living, you're the French people consider it's
- 15:10the government's problem to provide the arts.
- 15:13But as money is running out, then we're looking to the
- 15:17American way of doing it, bring the private money.
- 15:20Cartier, the brand is at arm's length with the Cartier
- 15:23Foundation, even though it was started the same way.
- 15:26But it's private money behind it.
- 15:28So that's why that shift is happening right now.
- 15:31It's because the the box, the bank is empty.
- 15:34The French government does not have the money, so people need
- 15:37to find alternative ways. And it's not enough to raise
- 15:41ticket prices, right? Like the Louvre is doing it now
- 15:44again. But it's not sufficient, no.
- 15:46Because look, the windows are bright open.
- 15:48Help yourself, because this is not even enough money for
- 15:52security. I went to Paris, I wanted to see
- 15:55them the last day for the show, for Jacques Louis, David and I
- 15:59showed up so proud of myself for not missing that show.
- 16:01And they were on strike. So Oh, yes, of course, yeah.
- 16:05So it's you're, you're running into issues that's that is that
- 16:09model is not sustainable. So either you give up or you
- 16:15just open the door to a more capitalistic view, which is very
- 16:20American. And it comes with amazing
- 16:23things, being able to pay for things that could have never
- 16:26happened, not having to ask the government what they think.
- 16:30Because the second the government changes, that gets,
- 16:32you know, into the bin. And the problem is that, well,
- 16:35you get the Sackler money. It's amazing what what what the
- 16:38sacks have done huge in the States.
- 16:42But it was a little bit bloody, that money.
- 16:44Yes, this, this, this was the for for those listening who
- 16:47don't maybe remember this because it was now many years
- 16:50ago. But the Sackler family, they're
- 16:51the pharmaceutical company, the it's Purdue Pharma, right?
- 16:57Isn't that what they right? And they helped basically fund
- 17:00the opioid crisis. And their name was taken off
- 17:03what, the Guggenheim? Everywhere, basically.
- 17:06No. They created the opioid crisis,
- 17:08let's make it very clear, because they were producing the
- 17:13medicine that was prescribed to people knowing it would be
- 17:16addictive. And then again, there's a
- 17:19different system. The healthcare system in the US,
- 17:21as you know, is fabulous. So people were prescribed these
- 17:25things, getting hooked and dying from it.
- 17:28And but the pharmaceutical companies were making huge
- 17:31amount of money because they were addicted.
- 17:33So they kind of creating the created sorry, the problem
- 17:37instead of curing it and all that money was also I believe
- 17:42for some people generally given towards the arts to create open
- 17:47storage. The Smithsonian had one when I
- 17:49always had the Smithsonian many years ago and you could see
- 17:52people work on masterpieces in front of your eyes.
- 17:54The public had access to things they could have never seen an
- 18:00founding research. And I mean it was amazing.
- 18:03But the problem again, is that you get money and you don't get
- 18:07to ask. At the time, you didn't get to
- 18:09ask what that money it was for and right where you came from,
- 18:12sorry. So France is going to be a
- 18:15little bit more careful, but it's the same with BP in London.
- 18:19I don't know if you remember the turbine hole.
- 18:21No. So turbine hole in at the Tate
- 18:25was sponsored for many, many years by BP, the oil company.
- 18:30So but again, I'm I don't want to be a judge here.
- 18:33It's a long, long debate. But do you take the money and
- 18:36then artists can create and they can survive and they make
- 18:38something meaningful. If the company says, I just give
- 18:41you the money, I stay out of your process.
- 18:44Is that good enough? Because at the end of the day,
- 18:46is it still greenwashing? Are they're buying their way out
- 18:50by founding the arts BPS name got removed after too many oil
- 18:55spills and then, you know, rooting the planet.
- 18:57So it's, again, it's, it's a debate.
- 19:00I'm not here, I'm not a judge. I don't know enough about
- 19:03everything to tell you it's completely right, completely
- 19:05wrong, right. But it's, it's, you have some
- 19:08really, really bad on one side and some really, really good on
- 19:11the other side. And friends knows that and still
- 19:16has to open its doors to private funding because it's not all
- 19:20evil. He has a purpose.
- 19:22But it is also a big tax credit for the LVMHS and Pinos and
- 19:29well, I should say Bernardo, but to the LVMH Foundation
- 19:33essentially is the the conglomerate that's involved,
- 19:37not just him personally. So it's it's also a way for them
- 19:40to lower their taxes, no? Of course it's a way to lower
- 19:44tax, but there's two different things here.
- 19:47I have a problem with tax evasion and and being very very
- 19:51rich. That's good.
- 19:52Yes, we do. Well, not everybody does,
- 19:55obviously, but I the the line is when you're so rich that you can
- 20:00afford not to pay anything and contribute to the community that
- 20:03should just go to jail and be punished and no discussion and
- 20:07tax evasion is punished by law. But probably it's too easy to go
- 20:11around when you're that wealthy. On the other hand.
- 20:15I know, and maybe I'm not very French.
- 20:17What is wrong with making money if you've earned it?
- 20:21This is why you left France right here.
- 20:24Just thinking I know. If I was super rich bigger
- 20:27journalist we would both know, but I.
- 20:29Know this is true, but no, you bring up an excellent point.
- 20:32I mean, obviously the French have a, you know, genetic
- 20:35suspicion toward toward wealth, but it's it's not so much that
- 20:42there's a problem with those people being wealthy and having
- 20:45done well for themselves and then contributing by giving
- 20:47back. It's more that is it, I guess
- 20:49it's that question that we also can't answer is, is it a genuine
- 20:53appreciation for the arts or is it merely just a way to sort of
- 20:59clean up their image? I'm going to do something
- 21:01horrible. Who cares?
- 21:04Who cares? Like basically I've, I've done a
- 21:07lot of charity work for many, many years.
- 21:09I sit on the board of the some charities and I'm really excited
- 21:13to do it. And I used to feel uncomfortable
- 21:15that people, for example, would not know where the country like
- 21:20like a Rwanda, like Building Schools in Rwanda.
- 21:22We can't place it on the map. And because they're famous
- 21:25people and they're established and they're superstars coming to
- 21:27the gala. And I felt, oh, this is wrong.
- 21:31And I was like, at the end of the day, who cares if they're
- 21:34here using their, some of them celebrity to bring people to the
- 21:39cause. And I know where that money
- 21:40goes. And it really makes a
- 21:42difference. That would not have happened
- 21:43otherwise. I'll take that.
- 21:46And not everything is perfect. The Caribbear world doesn't
- 21:49exist. You draw the line wherever you
- 21:51can. But I think I'm OK.
- 21:53I don't think in the Pinot. No, it's not just tax money.
- 21:56I mean, they have fantastic collections.
- 21:58I think they care. Of course, there's a line with
- 22:01the tax credit and what you get back from it, but I think yes,
- 22:06do it. There's no reason why you just
- 22:08should be very wealthy and an Angel.
- 22:11I mean, does it mean that everybody who's poor or mighty
- 22:15wealthy is donating all their money to charity?
- 22:17I don't think so. So I would not point a finger at
- 22:20those who are doing it unless in my moral whatever compass I
- 22:25think they're crossing a line by not contributing to the
- 22:28community enough in proportion to what they're getting for it.
- 22:32It's a fine balance, but I'm totally OK with brands
- 22:37supporting project as long as the project is not a branded
- 22:43like a public communicate that has no value.
- 22:45At the end of the day, is the show good, right?
- 22:48Is it if if it's terrible, point a finger as much as you want,
- 22:52but if it created something what you would not have gotten
- 22:55otherwise, We need the money. It's not going to grow on trees
- 23:00and it's to come from somewhere. I don't want the arts to die.
- 23:03Yeah. No, absolutely not.
- 23:05No, I'm, I'm posing this question as a sort of as an
- 23:09instigator, as a, as a devil's advocate.
- 23:11I'm not suggesting that there are really any other
- 23:13alternatives, right? Like, and, and that's how the
- 23:15system has, as you said, works in the US.
- 23:18What about in London where the arts have seemed more
- 23:21affordable? I guess when we're talking about
- 23:23the cost of going to see museums there, there are some museums in
- 23:26Paris that are still free, you know, the Cal Navede being the
- 23:30city of Paris museum. And then the exhibitions are
- 23:33have a ticket cost, the private, I mean the temporary exhibitions
- 23:38and, and there are, you know, various price discounts for
- 23:41various categories at, at different museums.
- 23:44But I get the sense that it's cheaper to go to the Museum in
- 23:47London. Is that true?
- 23:49It's completely true and it's interestingly actually, museums
- 23:52are free here in London. So unless you're going to see a
- 23:56temporary exhibition, going to the VNA is completely free.
- 24:00Going to the British Museum book in advance now because too many
- 24:03people blah blah, completely free.
- 24:05The Science Museum. So it doesn't have to be like
- 24:08high art. Some of the some of these
- 24:10museums have a ticket price, like Tate is not free for
- 24:12example, but you can access art every day.
- 24:17You can go to the National Gallery every day and stay there
- 24:21and only look at one paintings for five hours or for 5 minutes.
- 24:24It's the same price. It's free.
- 24:27The temporary exhibitions cannot do that because you have the
- 24:29loans and I mean, you have to pay the people that worked on
- 24:31it. But it is subsidized.
- 24:33And actually, in England, it's subsidized by the lottery, which
- 24:36is fun. I mean, like, you know, lottery
- 24:39tickets. Yeah.
- 24:40So the lottery funds are started by, you know, people are going
- 24:44to want to be billionaires or millionaires.
- 24:47So those tickets, this is how the money is called the lottery
- 24:51fund in England. And part of the money made from
- 24:54people not winning the lottery was put directly into the arts.
- 24:57And usually when you see those little cross fingers, like
- 25:00wishing, they're going to become very rich.
- 25:02That's the logo and you'll see that on exhibitions.
- 25:05Next time you go to London, look at it and it says lottery fund.
- 25:08That's where the money. So it's it's going back into the
- 25:11pot, which makes it possible for exhibitions to not exhibitions,
- 25:15sorry, museum collections to be free.
- 25:18I mean, Can you imagine going to the VNA every day and just
- 25:22deciding just to look at things? No pressure to learn.
- 25:25Learn because you pay €15 or you know, 15 lbs your entrance.
- 25:30It's, it's, it's a pretty amazing thing that I, I hope
- 25:34it's going to stay that way, even though again, the arts are
- 25:36struggling here too. But yeah, museums are free in
- 25:40London. So it's, they're trying to
- 25:42strike the balance, I guess between the French and the
- 25:44American system. Not intentionally.
- 25:46That's just like how I see because I grocery system and,
- 25:49and it's everybody's struggling. There's no money anywhere.
- 25:54So, but what's interesting about this is that it definitely means
- 25:57that, you know, for young people to access the arts, it's perhaps
- 26:02a lower barrier to entry given how free it is now here, you
- 26:07know, I always see groups of school students and little kids
- 26:10and high schoolers. And obviously there's like a
- 26:12package deal that schools can get.
- 26:14So I'm not saying that they're all paying, you know, full price
- 26:17as students to go to the museum in Paris.
- 26:19But it does seem like, at least in terms of, and maybe it's a
- 26:23class issue if students are coming from, you know, the
- 26:27greater Paris and that is not the world that they navigate in,
- 26:31that there might be an emotional barrier to entry or a
- 26:34psychological barrier to entry with the arts.
- 26:36Do you find that that is true in London?
- 26:40Yeah, I think and again, London is so divided just to put a
- 26:44little addendum, for example, the lure is free if you're under
- 26:4718. So, so I mean youth, youth you
- 26:52still have access completely free and then you have some
- 26:56rebate and like and cards and the city of Paris is subsidizing
- 27:00quite a lot the pass cultural. I am not quite sure if there's
- 27:06such a pass here. That's something I don't really
- 27:09look at, but you have many that are free if you're younger.
- 27:13I mean, there's one thing that France has done really well, I
- 27:17guess that is in the culture that London doesn't have.
- 27:21Is the exception cultural The cultural exception exactly.
- 27:26You know that you live in Paris 1993 under Mitterrand, but over
- 27:32the ideas of Marlowe, like the idea that again, it, it was a
- 27:37tax rebate idea at the beginning, but it doesn't matter
- 27:40Like it's, it's, it's again, it doesn't matter the idea that art
- 27:43should be consumed and accessible to everyone And the
- 27:46fact do you dare or not dare under a museum?
- 27:50Do you think it's for you? That has nothing to do with the
- 27:52ticket price. It has to do with how you view
- 27:55yourself and how you think you're viewed in society.
- 27:58And, and I think, I mean, look, in England, museums are part of
- 28:03the everyday life. Again, it's, it's more about
- 28:07like it was more about about big shows.
- 28:10I know it's free, but I think it's still always the same
- 28:13population that comes through the door.
- 28:16And there's a lot of efforts to bring the schools.
- 28:19And I know, I know they're trying, but it's such a, a
- 28:22divided. And again, London is not the
- 28:25rest of the country, as Paris is not the rest of the country, but
- 28:28worse, worse, seriously, London, I think is way more diverse and
- 28:35in Paris in so many ways, but it's maybe for that reason a lot
- 28:39more cut off from the rest of the country.
- 28:43The cultural offering in London is extremely strong.
- 28:46And other cities, a lot of other cities are completely lagging
- 28:50behind. They're trying like Tracy Amin
- 28:53and Margate and like there's a lot of artists that are trying
- 28:55to push this forward. Yorkshire Sculpture Park up
- 28:57north, there's lots of places or Vienna and Tate opening outpost.
- 29:02You know, the same like Pompidou is opening in different cities
- 29:06and like a central Pompidou mess or Louvre Lance.
- 29:09I mean, it's it happens, but I feel like London is a little
- 29:14island within an island. And still it seems a little bit
- 29:19hard beyond tourist to bring people, everyday people to the
- 29:24museum. That that's that's my feeling.
- 29:27Well, and I would think that, you know, class has something to
- 29:30do with that. The the the class issues in
- 29:33London or in England writ large are are so much more prominent
- 29:38than than the issues we talked about in in France.
- 29:41In any case, class definitely, you know, class definitely plays
- 29:44a role, but you have this almost like a caste system in England.
- 29:49Guess what? Guess whose heads are still on
- 29:51their shoulders? OK, no, but come on.
- 29:54It is like they're, they're I, I, I mean them no harm to make
- 29:59sure this is clear. But we still, there's still a
- 30:02royalty here. The class system was never
- 30:05abolished in England. It was in France.
- 30:07So of course it's still there. Of course you're either blue
- 30:10blood or you're not. And this is extremely, extremely
- 30:14strong here. And don't ask me how many royal
- 30:17I have. I have none.
- 30:18And I I, and I don't think it's because it's mean.
- 30:23It's because again, the good and the bad is that you can have
- 30:26your own community and it's OK to be different and show sign of
- 30:30your different culture and wear headscarf or a cross or like a
- 30:35keeper, whatever. Here it's accepted because
- 30:38you're you are within your community and you're you can
- 30:42nurture your differences. Friends took a different
- 30:45approach liberty, egality, fraternity, everybody the same
- 30:48everybody like at the same level, which means you have to
- 30:51little bit erase exterior signs of you being different if you
- 30:55are different. So again, it's it.
- 30:58We're going back to the French Revolution.
- 31:00It it was a revolution the name comes for.
- 31:03A reason? Yeah, it's for a reason.
- 31:05England didn't do that. So the caste system is still
- 31:09very strong, which means the differences between people who
- 31:12have access to culture or refine things or your place in society
- 31:18is extremely marked. Like it's, it's your accent.
- 31:22You you your accent can tell me where you went to school.
- 31:25Of course, of course. Yeah, it's it's it really is
- 31:28wild. So as much as you were talking
- 31:30about, I mean, we've just come full circle.
- 31:33In the beginning you were talking about how we're so
- 31:35close, the the countries are so close, and yet they couldn't be
- 31:38more different. And this is another example.
- 31:40Yes, and and the fact that there's like a sea in between is
- 31:43is very like the image is very, very clear the borders it is an
- 31:47island and and it protected itself for good and for bad.
- 31:52And I think access to culture. Yeah, we're we're going back to
- 31:56circle, which is my favorite question is that who that should
- 32:00be preserved as you know, the art of the now, which means the
- 32:04commentary of today's society because that's I think the
- 32:07artist what they're doing, commenting and pointing the
- 32:10finger or just creating and who has the right to decide what
- 32:16value it has and what's valuable and what's not and and and
- 32:19nothing. That's the difference when you
- 32:20start asking these questions, you have to look at politics and
- 32:24what's at play and where the where the money comes from or,
- 32:29or are you allowed to be a dissident?
- 32:31Do you die for being a dissident or not?
- 32:33And well, England and France are both very good.
- 32:35It's, those are democracies. You don't die for saying you
- 32:38disagree. It's it's it's it's a.
- 32:42Tough. That continues.
- 32:44I think again, like we can be as negative as we want, but when I
- 32:49hear people say, oh, I hate Francis this and that or
- 32:52England, yes, you should fight. But but remember, like you can
- 32:56never call a dictatorship for something that's not.
- 32:58If you can say that and you're still alive, tomorrow probably
- 33:01isn't 1. So I think we need to fight for
- 33:05what's right, but we need to remember we have so many
- 33:08privileges that should be enjoyed before we lose them all.
- 33:13Well, and that's a good segue into the kinds of privileges I
- 33:17want every listener to be able to take advantage of.
- 33:20And that's some of the most interesting to you, the most
- 33:25interesting museums or galleries or exhibition spaces that you
- 33:30yourself find yourself drawn to every time you come to Paris,
- 33:33because you're here quite often. Yeah, I am here quite a lot.
- 33:37It's true. I mean, it's it's, it's very,
- 33:39it's interesting. I would go, I always check
- 33:41what's going on at the Grand Palais just because since it's
- 33:44being reopened, completely refurbished, they have access to
- 33:48amazing exhibitions. And again, it's, it's a
- 33:52government, you know, museums. So they get loans from all
- 33:55different kinds of other airmen. Reynalde Museum, as you know,
- 33:59museums, I always look at it I of a bit like flat to say that,
- 34:05but the Louvre, I go there maybe not for the temporary
- 34:07exhibitions, but just as a reminder that this is all there
- 34:11and I can stroll through it and, and just have like a nice look
- 34:15around. I it's funny, I haven't found my
- 34:19it used to be Palais de Tokyo many, many years ago and maybe I
- 34:24don't know, I in recent years I've gone there less.
- 34:28I wish I could give you one exact answer.
- 34:31What about the small? What about the smaller museums?
- 34:34Because, you know, Paris? I don't know if London has this,
- 34:36but we have so many house museums and small, small, small,
- 34:40privately owned little little places that you know, if you
- 34:43didn't look at a whole list of all the things that exist, you
- 34:45wouldn't even necessarily stumble upon them.
- 34:48Yes, you know what I my favorite used to be the Maison de Gustav
- 34:52Moro and it was just so quirky and weird and looking at his
- 34:59paintings with Salome like condemning, I think it was Sanjo
- 35:01Batiste to his death. I thought it was just so funny
- 35:03and violent. But it's it's you know, it's I
- 35:07think it's more about me than about the place, but it's the
- 35:10idea. I don't know of being in
- 35:12somebody's home and then looking at how they lived and, and work
- 35:17like the Giacometti as well. I mean, there's, there's a lot,
- 35:24but I'm, I'm happy. I'm happy moving around.
- 35:28Maybe that's why I do the job that I do.
- 35:30It's that I'm not a creature of habit so much.
- 35:33I will always go to Paris, go see a show, go to Comedy
- 35:36Francaise and see theater there, obviously, because that's a
- 35:40must. If you go to, that's a must.
- 35:41And also because your brother is a big deal there.
- 35:46Yes, I think maybe it's like the sisterly proud that's a bit
- 35:49stupid because as you know, I'm just very proud for nothing
- 35:53because I've I have no part in his achievements.
- 35:56But yes, it's. But you're, you're very happy.
- 35:59Yeah. No, I mean, of course.
- 36:01They are amazing. I I would go see a show if and
- 36:05if if it. Wasn't fair if you feel like you
- 36:07need to say that, that's OK. I love it.
- 36:10I I've, I mean, that was one of the first places I went as a
- 36:13student here with, you know, to see Cyrano de Bergerac, which,
- 36:18you know, has been performed there 7 billion times.
- 36:22And, and it's, and it's true that when you're, when you're
- 36:24learning French, especially it's, it's a challenging, it can
- 36:28be a challenging place because everything, I mean it is
- 36:30upholding French literature in to a tee.
- 36:34I. Would not learn French there.
- 36:35It's a little bit rough. It's not Duolingo, you know.
- 36:39So I wasn't suggesting I was learning there, but just that I
- 36:42was it was an it was an outing. It was an excursion with class,
- 36:46you know, and I did love it though.
- 36:48And so I've since been back and I got to see your brother in
- 36:51something recently and I just thought that was AI did it like
- 36:54all the dance. And I found that it's so
- 36:57interesting that you and I also met on something art related
- 37:01completely by chance. And and anyway, I just think
- 37:06that the arts are very fortuitous.
- 37:08And so whether that's theater or museums or, you know, a gallery
- 37:11space. Sure, architecture, architecture
- 37:14of the city. It's it's, I'm not just talking
- 37:16Osman like I'm and and or look or busy, but sometimes like
- 37:20little quick things. You run into something from the
- 37:2317th century, you know, like Maison, Maison de para Maison de
- 37:28Duke, whatever. And then you turn around.
- 37:29It's something completely different.
- 37:31I think Paris is very rich culturally.
- 37:34We know that. I'm not like telling you
- 37:36anything you don't know already. But what I like is not always
- 37:40going to the same thing is coming back and always being
- 37:43surprised that I didn't know this thing existed.
- 37:46It's very humbling. And it's not such a big city
- 37:49square foot like Paris en Camiros.
- 37:52And I feel so humbled every time.
- 37:54I'm like, I had no idea. And I think that's my go to is
- 37:58surprise me. What a perfect way to end Maya.
- 38:03You are a wealth of information. You will have to come back next
- 38:07time. There's some controversial or
- 38:09very talk about exhibition here in Paris so that we can dissect
- 38:14it and analyze it. But until then, this has been
- 38:18fantastic. Where can people find what
- 38:20you're writing? If people can remember all the
- 38:24letters in my last name, they can type it.
- 38:27It will be. Written.
- 38:28It will be written in the show, don't worry.
- 38:31No, basically, I mean, I, I write.
- 38:33So I write for a lot of different publications, French
- 38:37ones. I'll start with that because I'm
- 38:38very happy to collaborate with them.
- 38:40Is I'm the arts correspondent for The Good Life.
- 38:43And I think the name is all you need to know.
- 38:45It's about the things that makes us happy and it's lifestyle and
- 38:48it's a rather luxury lifestyle, but it can be aspirational as
- 38:52much as consumer driven. It's you decide or idiot, which
- 38:57is like, you know, like a deco magazine, EasyJet.
- 39:02I also do the art section for them.
- 39:04Very different. Yeah, Metropolitan Eurostar.
- 39:08Look, I try to make sure I'm like sneaking in your head
- 39:12wherever you go. Art Basel for things more in
- 39:16depth about art. I must be forgetting some.
- 39:18I mean, it's a mix. I I try to update Instagram now
- 39:22that I'm not banned anymore. I think we should do some
- 39:26because I posted an artwork. I think this is the one showed
- 39:29and I would I've been banned for almost two months for posting an
- 39:34artwork that was at the Hayward Gilbert and George and AI
- 39:39triggered me being banned and I could not appeal.
- 39:43There was nothing I could do because it said looking for a
- 39:47male escort and then it had a phone number but it was a
- 39:51collage and it was clearly clearly a network and the
- 39:55following stories had a video of Gilbert and George explaining
- 39:59and talking about the art and AI banned me.
- 40:04Oddly, a week after the stories that vanished, we're.
- 40:08Yeah, but I was labeled as a sex trafficker.
- 40:11A lawyer looked into it and said I cannot do anything for you
- 40:15because you're labeled as a trafficker and somebody who's
- 40:19offering services for money. Oh my God, it was a depiction of
- 40:24of an artwork. So how did it eventually get
- 40:26unblocked? It's, it's awful because I could
- 40:29not do anything. I try, of course, to appeal to
- 40:32an AI which goes nowhere. I try to meet people working
- 40:35there, use the connections. I thought I knew the whole
- 40:38world. I know nobody.
- 40:39I couldn't do anything. And it ended up very luckily
- 40:44with an art collector who actually has an amazing
- 40:49collection, used to be the Zablutevich collection in
- 40:51London. They closed down, but they still
- 40:53have a collection and they loan a lot of artwork.
- 40:55And I talked talked about it and I said, look, I know you have an
- 41:00art collection. You must have run into this.
- 41:02And then he said live it with me.
- 41:05And he said that's not right. 24 hours later, it was it was my my
- 41:10account was like miraculously back on.
- 41:12So I'm sure it's because they had insurance that I didn't
- 41:16have. But I read about it and I spoke
- 41:19to some activist and again for another topic another day.
- 41:24But a lot of artists are being silenced.
- 41:27They did not even censored to just disappear.
- 41:30This is what happened to me. No Facebook, no Instagram, no
- 41:33more connections. And from one day to the next, I
- 41:36just disappeared. I no longer like erased from,
- 41:39you know, the pictures of the Russian era.
- 41:41I was erased from the photo like that's it.
- 41:43I never existed. It was very shocking, not
- 41:47because people missed my stupid post about like what I add for
- 41:50dinner, but the just the idea of disappearing so quickly without
- 41:55a trace, without any noise was extremely scary.
- 41:59I mean that that gives me chills.
- 42:01And given what's happening now and who controls these platforms
- 42:05and and who they're in cahoots with, it doesn't bode well.
- 42:09That's why it happened. That's exactly why it happened.
- 42:12There was a crackdown on trafficking, but I still receive
- 42:15messages from people that want to sell me something, you know,
- 42:19obviously, and those don't get banned.
- 42:22But posting an artwork or an artist having an opinion
- 42:26disappears without living a trace.
- 42:30Well, this conversation took a big turn, but I hope it leaves
- 42:33people. No, I think it I think it, it
- 42:36leaves people with a with a warning.
- 42:39What can they do to prevent that?
- 42:40Who knows? You shouldn't just get walked on
- 42:43and and not share things, but it is a it is a timely.
- 42:49It is a warning. It is a warning.
- 42:52And so to end on a positive note, let's go back to that idea
- 42:56of surprise. Everyone should keep coming back
- 42:58to Paris to feel surprised and to check out some other gallery
- 43:03or exhibition space that they may not have seen before.
- 43:05Maya, I will link to all of your publications and, and where
- 43:09people can find you. And otherwise they will just
- 43:12need to go to London and maybe they'll find you at the museum.
- 43:16High chances. Yes.
- 43:17Thank you so much, Lucy. Thank you, Maya.
- 43:21That's the show for. Today, if you're listening.
- 43:23On Spotify, be sure to check out the poll related to this episode
- 43:26by scrolling down in your app. There are more exciting
- 43:29conversations to come this season, so I hope you'll
- 43:31subscribe or share the show with a friend if you've been enjoying
- 43:34what you've heard so far. As always, you can find more
- 43:38from me at lindsaytremuta.com and at the New Paris Dispatch on
- 43:42Substack Atreliento.