Latest / Consumerpedia / 63 - The Car Show 2024
Transcript
- 0:01Finally, some good news for car buyers.
- 0:03The market is basically back to normal.
- 0:06Dealers have a good supply of both new and used vehicles, and
- 0:09that's pushing down prices. According to Kelley Blue Book,
- 0:13the average new car buyer in March paid $47,000.
- 0:17That's a two year low, but still nearly 16% higher than in March
- 0:21of 2021. With more cars on the lot, some
- 0:24dealers and manufacturers are offering bigger incentives.
- 0:27But because Toyota, Lexus, Honda, Land Rover and Kia
- 0:30dealers are a little under stock right now, you're not as likely
- 0:34to get a deal from them, KBB says.
- 0:36I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer man, a contributing editor at
- 0:39checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia.
- 0:43At checkbook.org, we're the nonprofit that helps consumers
- 0:46select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:49Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:52any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:56completely independent and objective.
- 0:58Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's consumer
- 1:02expert, the summer Man, Herb Wise Bomb.
- 1:05In this episode, the latest reliability ratings from
- 1:08Consumer Reports, the right way to take a test drive, how to get
- 1:12the best deal on that new car, and should you consider using
- 1:16Costcos auto buying program? We've got a lot of ground to
- 1:19cover, so let's get going up. First.
- 1:22My good friend Mike Quincy, who helped me buy my last car.
- 1:25Mike is an auto writer and auto tester with Consumer Reports
- 1:28Autos. How's it going today?
- 1:30So let's talk about the sticker shock of how much it costs to
- 1:33buy a new car. Do we really need to pay 4050
- 1:36sixty $1000 or more to get a good set of wheels?
- 1:40Absolutely not. I think that's the best news
- 1:42about Consumer Reports Top Picks is we have a number of models
- 1:46that are priced around $30,000 or less.
- 1:49So you definitely don't have to spend an arm and a leg to get a
- 1:52good car that's reliable, fuel efficient, and in some cases
- 1:56even a lot of fun to drive. Give us a few examples of ones
- 1:58you have in mind and the price point we're talking about.
- 2:00The Super Cross Check, for example, which starts about
- 2:03$25,000, it's reliable. It's comfortable as lots of
- 2:07safety features. If you really want to go the
- 2:09extra mile for extra fuel economy, we highly recommend the
- 2:13Toyota Prius and Prius Prime. And the regular Prius is sort of
- 2:17the hybrid model that we've been knowing and loving for over 20
- 2:21years now. But the prime version is the
- 2:23plug in hybrid, which gets you about 39 miles of all electric
- 2:27range and then it converts to a regular hybrid.
- 2:30So these are super reliable, they're fun to drive.
- 2:33Believe it or not, Toyota put a lot of enthusiasm into this
- 2:35redesign and deservedly one of Consumer Reports.
- 2:39Top picks. So after housing, buying and
- 2:41maintaining a car is the biggest expense for most Americans.
- 2:44So buying a reliable vehicle is a really smart way to reduce the
- 2:47cost of owning that vehicle, which is why CR publishes the
- 2:50annual Auto Reliability Report. This year's ratings based on
- 2:53responses from 330,000 members for model years 2000 to 2023,
- 2:58with a few early 2024 vehicles thrown in the mix.
- 3:01Based on all this data, it's really clear to me looking at
- 3:05this as it has been in the past, that there's a great difference
- 3:08between brand to brand as far as how reliable their vehicles are.
- 3:11No question. And sort of on the same idea
- 3:14that you don't have to spend a lot of money to get a good car,
- 3:17you'd also don't have to spend a lot of money to get a reliable
- 3:20car. For example, the brands that are
- 3:22in Consumer Reports top 10 most reliable brands include Toyota,
- 3:26Honda, Subaru and Mazda and Kia. So these are not high end
- 3:30brands. Now you know the other hand,
- 3:32Lexus is the most reliable brand.
- 3:34You're definitely paying a lot for that.
- 3:36But on the other end of the spectrum, the brands that wound
- 3:39up lowest in reliability, some of them include Mercedes-Benz,
- 3:44Rivian, Volvo, Lincoln, Audi. These are some of the more
- 3:48expensive brands, so you don't always get what you pay for.
- 3:51Again, this year, the Asian automakers seem to top the list,
- 3:53right? Absolutely.
- 3:55And you know, one of the little surprises, and I do mean little
- 3:58figuratively, is Mini Cooper, which is owned by BMW, which
- 4:02also made the top 10. BMW came in #9, but Mini Cooper
- 4:05came in at #3, and that's a pretty strong showing.
- 4:08Now granted, their product line is a lot smaller than most of
- 4:12the other brands that are in the top ten, but BMW is clearly
- 4:16putting some time and energy into improving the reliability
- 4:19of their models. Mike, looking at how the brand
- 4:21stack up with #1 being Lexus 79 out of 100 points and #30 being
- 4:25Chrysler with only 18 out of 100 points, The first domestic
- 4:29manufacturer to make the list is Buick at #12.
- 4:33What is the problem American manufacturers continue to have
- 4:36with making reliable vehicles? The executives in Detroit don't
- 4:39seem to be able to figure out or unlock the keys to regularly
- 4:43consistently good reliability. They have moments where they
- 4:47kind of breakthrough and interestingly enough, throughout
- 4:50the years Buick has usually been among the best domestic
- 4:54automakers. They don't have a huge product
- 4:56line and and a lot of the designs that they have have been
- 4:58around for a while. So the company has has figured
- 5:01out how to work out of the bugs. But you know, you got to hand it
- 5:03to General Motors for always finding a way to have Buick
- 5:07really come out on top if you're looking to get a vehicle from
- 5:09Detroit. So you gave us some of the best.
- 5:11Can you give us some of the worst?
- 5:13Oh, sure. I mean, as we mentioned before,
- 5:15some of the more expensive brands are kind of bringing up
- 5:18the bottom. But there's also mainstream
- 5:20brands like Volkswagen, which came in 27th out of 30 brands.
- 5:24GMC, which is supposed to be the upscale version of basic
- 5:28Chevrolet trucks, they came in 24th.
- 5:30Lincoln isn't much above that at 23rd.
- 5:32Ford ranks in at 22 overall. So a lot of the the lower ranked
- 5:37brands are definitely coming from Detroit and also coming
- 5:40from brands that extract a lot of money from their customers.
- 5:43You know, a lot of people want the newest and flashiest models.
- 5:46I understand that. But I know we've spoken before
- 5:48and your surveys consistently show that when it comes to
- 5:51reliability, vehicles that have been around for a while tend to
- 5:54need fewer repairs. Oh, you're 100% right.
- 5:57In fact, the vehicle that is most reliable in Consumer
- 5:59Reports Reliability survey is the Toyota 4 Runner.
- 6:03And this is a design that's been around for, I don't know, maybe
- 6:0515 years, it's just about to come out with a new one.
- 6:08But but it certainly shows that if you pick a design that's been
- 6:12around a while, the the manufacturers work the bugs out.
- 6:15The advice here is don't be an early adopter.
- 6:18You know one of the hot electric vehicles is a company called
- 6:20Rivian and they are ranked really, really low for
- 6:24reliability. It's because they are a
- 6:26relatively new company. They're not used to mass
- 6:28production. So instead of being the first
- 6:30person on your block to get the latest and greatest vehicle, why
- 6:34don't you wait a year or two for the bugs to be worked out?
- 6:37So as part of your annual survey, you ask members about
- 6:40the cost of repairs and maintenance, and American models
- 6:43did the best, right? Yeah, I mean that that is also
- 6:45kind of some of the good news if you're rooting for the home
- 6:48team. Models from Buick and Lincoln
- 6:51and Ford and Chevrolet did really well for a, you know,
- 6:54relatively low out of pocket cost of maintenance once the
- 6:57warranty and the free maintenance period is over.
- 7:00But it may be The most surprising brand on this list is
- 7:03Tesla, which also is an American brand.
- 7:06Most of the time, electric cars don't have lots of moving parts,
- 7:11there's no oil changes to deal with, and Tesla's entire product
- 7:15line is electric. So that's one of the reasons
- 7:17that Tesla has the lowest cost of ownership and maintenance
- 7:21compared to the rest of the Automotive World.
- 7:24Is there a way to figure out before you buy the vehicle how
- 7:26much it's going to cost me more or less in maintenance?
- 7:29Is there a place you can go to get that information?
- 7:31Kindly go to consumerreports.org and look up our latest
- 7:35automotive survey that includes out of pocket expenses for
- 7:39brands. One of the reasons that you buy
- 7:40a car like an Accord or a Camry or Civic or something like that
- 7:43is the replacement tire cost will be a lot less than if you
- 7:47buy replacement tires for an Audi, ABMW, Mercedes or a
- 7:50Porsche. Not only do the European brands
- 7:53come with a high sticker price, but the amount of money it costs
- 7:57for parts replacements for tire replacement and a lot of these
- 8:00vehicles. When it comes to oil, oil
- 8:02changes require synthetic oil. So if you go in to get your oil
- 8:05changed in your Porsche, you might have to fork over a ton of
- 8:08money for some mobile one. So that's also in kind of the
- 8:11the buying decision process. Mike, it is always a pleasure
- 8:14talking to you. You're loaded with so much
- 8:16information. Mike Quincy, He's an auto writer
- 8:18and tester at Consumer Reports. Autos.
- 8:21Take care of my friend and drive safely.
- 8:22Thanks so much for having me on. Coming up next, we're going to
- 8:25talk about things you need to know when you head to the
- 8:27dealership and some of the tricks the salesperson may play
- 8:30on you. I'm her Weisbaum, and this is
- 8:32Consumerpedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 8:36If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 8:38consumer PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the
- 8:42show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 8:45This is Consumer Pedia. If you haven't shopped for a car
- 8:49in a while, you're going to be amazed at the choices.
- 8:51All the different models, all the different trim lines, the
- 8:54engine options and all the new safety features.
- 8:56Not to mention the Gee Whiz Bells and Whistles.
- 8:59Consumer Reports says there are now more than 260 models to
- 9:03choose from, so you really need to do some serious homework to
- 9:06decide which ones might be right for you and your budget.
- 9:09Here. To help with that, Keith Berry,
- 9:11a veteran auto reporter at Consumer Reports.
- 9:13Hey Herb, thanks for having me here.
- 9:15What should we? Be doing There are things we
- 9:17should be doing even before we head to the showroom.
- 9:19We need to do some homework. Absolutely.
- 9:21I think some of the most important things to look at are
- 9:25safety systems. You know, you should look to see
- 9:27which safety systems are included in a new vehicle.
- 9:31And some manufacturers do a really great job putting things
- 9:33standard across all of the trims, even the base models.
- 9:37Even the least expensive cars come with blind spot warning.
- 9:40Most cars come with AEB, most new cars.
- 9:42But if you're buying a used car or if you're buying from a brand
- 9:45that isn't that nice, you're going to want to actually take a
- 9:48look and make sure that the car that you're buying has the
- 9:50safety features that you want. And we hear all the time from
- 9:53our members that safety features are important to them.
- 9:56Things like that blind spot warning, things like automatic
- 9:59emergency braking, you know, don't just take the
- 10:01salesperson's word for it. Those features have to be listed
- 10:04on the window sticker, and if and if it's not on the window
- 10:06sticker, it's not on the car. And just to emphasize that
- 10:09point, because I bought a car a couple of years ago and is a
- 10:11Toyota Camry, which you guys highly recommended the hybrid.
- 10:14The different trim lines had different safety features and I
- 10:17could look in the guide and see what it was.
- 10:19Then I made sure it was on the sticker, but I wanted
- 10:21everything. So I had to go with a higher
- 10:22model, but I got what I wanted. You may not get all that with a
- 10:25lower level trim line. Exactly 2025 Toyota's put blind
- 10:29spot warning across the board for the Camry, but if you're
- 10:31looking at a used one, absolutely the two cars might
- 10:34look identical, but it might not have.
- 10:36That feature. You know Keith, many of us feel
- 10:38really comfortable these days buying things sight unseen on
- 10:40the Internet. Clothing, big screen, TV sets,
- 10:42laptops. But when it comes to a car, you
- 10:45really do need to test drive it. You can't just buy by looking at
- 10:48something and reading the specs or even the reviews from
- 10:50Consumer Reports. You've got to get behind the
- 10:52wheel and check it out. Yeah, I mean, we hear all the
- 10:54time when we talk about the cars that we buy for our test
- 10:57program, you know, we'll have conversations.
- 10:59Oh, I'm not I I hate driving that because it cuts into my leg
- 11:02or I can't see the speedometer the way that I sit or I can't
- 11:05see the dashboard. Right.
- 11:07You know, or or something's just out of reach or it's
- 11:09uncomfortable. And then another person who also
- 11:12is a Co worker will say, Oh yeah, I love that car.
- 11:14It's so comfortable. It's the best driving position.
- 11:17So absolutely you're going to want to spend some time with it.
- 11:20Something, you know as vehicles get bigger and bigger and
- 11:22bigger, we're we're hearing sometimes some folks are finding
- 11:24the cars don't fit in their garages.
- 11:28You have to actually measure the car and make sure it fits.
- 11:30So absolutely spend some time with the vehicle, even if
- 11:33you're, you know, you buying from one of those newer startup
- 11:36brands that you can order online, go to the showroom and
- 11:39spend some time with the car. And don't just sit in the car.
- 11:42Drive the car the way you would drive it where you would drive
- 11:44it. Yeah.
- 11:45And we say, you know, bring your phone.
- 11:47That's so important. Bring your phone.
- 11:49Find out how easy it is to pair your phone with the car.
- 11:52You know, take your time. You know, even if the sales
- 11:54person's, you know, looking at his watch, you're the one who
- 11:57spent 10s of thousands of dollars on this car.
- 11:59So spend some time with the vehicle to find out how easy it
- 12:02is to use. Another thing is if you got
- 12:04kids, bring the car seat with you.
- 12:07You know, if you have a mobility issue, show up with anything
- 12:09that you need to bring to the vehicle and see how comfortable
- 12:12it is for you. If it's easy for you to get an
- 12:14in and out all of those things with the vehicle.
- 12:17To emphasize that point, when we bought that Toyota Camry, it was
- 12:19between the Camry and the Avalon, drove both and my wife
- 12:22said it was got shorter legs than I do.
- 12:24I can't see over the dashboard. We went with the Camry because
- 12:27she felt much more comfortable that she could say it was a
- 12:29different design and I could see what she was talking about.
- 12:31She never would have noticed that without driving the vehicle
- 12:34and seeing that there was a problem seeing over the hood my.
- 12:37Parents had the exact opposite and they ended up with an
- 12:39Avalon. It's so individual.
- 12:41It's so absolutely individual. Obviously your.
- 12:43Parents have long legs, You know.
- 12:46In recent years, CR reviews have focused a lot on the difficulty
- 12:49of using some of the controls, especially the navigation
- 12:52system. It sounds like it'd be a really
- 12:54good idea to get the salesperson to explain all the bells and
- 12:57whistles on the dashboard, how they work, and see how easy it
- 13:00is to use all those navigation controls.
- 13:02Definitely, if there's something that's specifically important to
- 13:06you, especially on newer cars. If there's a a CD that you love
- 13:10to listen to, a newer car might not have ACD player.
- 13:13If you enjoy listening to AM radio, a lot of new cars don't
- 13:16have AM radio tuners, so these are some things to you know to
- 13:19keep in mind. Also, if you don't like the way
- 13:22the navigation works or if you don't like the way some of the
- 13:25systems work in the car, the nice thing is that most cars
- 13:28these days will allow you to let your phone take over.
- 13:31So that's that Apple CarPlay, that's that Android Auto.
- 13:34And we find when we ask about satisfaction with people who own
- 13:37cars, people tend to have a little higher satisfaction with
- 13:40those than with the built in systems.
- 13:41But, you know, don't freak out if you can't figure out the car
- 13:46immediately. None of these do have a little
- 13:48bit of learning curve. And, you know, we know it's CR.
- 13:50We're hopping from car to car to car.
- 13:52And sometimes it takes a little longer than a day or an hour or
- 13:55a few minutes to figure out a vehicle.
- 13:57So, you know, sit there, try it out, but spend a little time
- 14:01with it. Because increasingly, that's
- 14:02what's differentiating cars, is the controls, the software, you
- 14:06know, the interior of the vehicle.
- 14:08Two things that I would suggest while you're taking a test drive
- 14:11is #1 find out about the lane assist.
- 14:13You know, some give you a little beep, some jerk the wheel and
- 14:15that might be disconcerting to you.
- 14:17And the other one would be, and I don't know what it's called,
- 14:19but some cars get better mileage by they shut off when you come
- 14:21to a traffic light and start on again.
- 14:23If you haven't bought a car in a while, that is.
- 14:24That's really disconcerting to some people.
- 14:26Yeah, the auto Start Stop, Some of those allow you to turn it
- 14:30off, some require you to turn it off every time you get into the
- 14:33vehicle. You know, that's one nice thing
- 14:34now these days about hybrids is that they shut off and you don't
- 14:38notice it. You know, you don't hear the
- 14:39car, the ignition turning and cranking in the car starting up.
- 14:42So that's actually a benefit of a hybrid vehicle these days, but
- 14:45absolutely that's something to keep in mind.
- 14:47And the lane assist is different with different manufacturers.
- 14:49Entirely. That is something we test to
- 14:51Consumer Reports, and you can read that in the road test we
- 14:54have a whole new test track where we test these specific
- 14:57features. And even within the same brand,
- 15:00we find that there's variation from vehicle to vehicle.
- 15:04You know, will it nudge you in your lane?
- 15:06Will it basically steer for you? Or is it going to ping pong you
- 15:09back and forth? Is it going to yell at you?
- 15:12Is it only going to intervene if something's about to go wrong?
- 15:14And depending upon what you like, sometimes some cars allow
- 15:18you to change how that's set up and that's that's great, you
- 15:21know, to be able to change those things.
- 15:23But other cars, it is the way it is.
- 15:25So definitely try that out. You know, you can read all about
- 15:28it, but it isn't until you experience it yourself that you
- 15:30really get that sense of whether or not it's it's going to work
- 15:33for you. So narrow it down by reading and
- 15:35learning about it and watching the videos etcetera, but you
- 15:37really have to go in there and see.
- 15:39So buying a car is never a fun experience, even if you think
- 15:42you're a fabulous negotiator or a consumer reporter with a lot
- 15:45of experience. I've been quoted as saying I'd
- 15:47rather root canal than go buy a car.
- 15:49Even if you've done it before, even if you think you're doing
- 15:51it great. You always wonder what tricks
- 15:53the salesperson is going to use on you.
- 15:55What kind of thing should we be watching out for, Keith?
- 15:57The first thing you should look out for is that kind of lowball
- 16:00offer, because car dealerships want to get you in the door.
- 16:04That's the most important thing that they can do is is get you
- 16:07there, because if you're there then they can kind of work their
- 16:10tricks on you. So when we buy cars at CR, you
- 16:13know, we always start by e-mail and we think you should do the
- 16:16same thing, E-mail the dealership, ask them for, you
- 16:19know, say I'm interested in this car, What's your best out the
- 16:21door price and can you itemize it?
- 16:23Show exactly you know what I'm going to be paying, what extra
- 16:27taxes, fees, whatever. Itemize those and give me what
- 16:30that number is because I'm going to come in with a check for that
- 16:32number. And that will give you a sense
- 16:34of whether the dealer is serious.
- 16:35If they respond and say, I can't do that, come in or can I have
- 16:38your phone number. They're trying to get their foot
- 16:41in the door and to get you in the door.
- 16:43So absolutely start that conversation and if you see a
- 16:47price that seems too good to be true, there's a chance that it
- 16:50might be that they're going to try and make that up on the back
- 16:53end by adding accessories or kind of getting you to strong
- 16:56arming you into a warranty or even increasing the interest
- 16:59rate. And they can do that.
- 17:00They can increase the interest rate that they're offering you
- 17:03and keep the difference. So absolutely they're going to
- 17:05make some money as a car dealer who I knew once said when he
- 17:10bought a car, he'd say, listen, I want you to make some money,
- 17:12but not a lot and not off of me. That's good, Checkbook always
- 17:18advises. Don't let the dealer get you to
- 17:19say how much you have to spend or how much you can afford for
- 17:22that monthly payment. Could you explain to everybody
- 17:24why? Yeah, I mean, that's negotiating
- 17:26one O 1. You let the other person set the
- 17:28floor and the ceiling of the negotiation.
- 17:30Once dealers have that information, once the
- 17:32salesperson, if they're good, if they have that information,
- 17:35they'll try to build a deal around those numbers and they'll
- 17:38try and say, you know, if you say, hey, I have $30,000 to
- 17:43spend, they might say, well, OK, we have some good cars in the
- 17:453233 range and just try and just push you a little bit everywhere
- 17:50they can. And if you push a little a lot
- 17:52of times that's a lot of profit. So absolutely keep that to
- 17:55yourself, ask what's the best they can do, but keep your sort
- 17:59of bottom line number to yourself and the monthly payment
- 18:02too. It can hide a lot of sins.
- 18:04With a monthly payment, you really want to negotiate on the
- 18:07actual price of the vehicle because of the monthly payment.
- 18:10They can change how long the loan is.
- 18:12They can add things into the cost of the vehicle.
- 18:16They can change again the interest rate.
- 18:18You want to negotiate every individual part of that.
- 18:21And what I like to do is have my phone open with a an interest
- 18:24rate calculator. There's a great one, actually, I
- 18:26like one that the Dallas Fed has one that's really easy.
- 18:29It works on your phone, and you can just punch in those numbers
- 18:32and double check, you know, OK, if this is the interest rate, if
- 18:35this is the price, what your monthly payment's going to be.
- 18:38There's a lot of numbers moving around.
- 18:39I've had dealerships make honest mistakes, and I've had
- 18:42dealerships make some dishonest mistakes, but you want to be
- 18:45checking that math the whole time.
- 18:46So after investing hours and hours at the dealership and
- 18:49you're in there with a finance person, they give you this
- 18:51paperwork and you just tend to put your initials wherever they
- 18:53need to be. You really need to check that
- 18:55final paperwork. The FTC's warned that you know
- 18:58those sneak a lot of things on there.
- 18:59Sometimes they had cases where people were charged for oil
- 19:02changes for electric vehicles that don't have an oil change.
- 19:05You just can't Willy nilly sign on the dotted line.
- 19:07You got to see what you're signing.
- 19:08Yeah, and. You know, a couple of dollars
- 19:09here and there over the course of a 6072 month car loan, that
- 19:14adds up to a lot. I think that's important advice
- 19:17in general. Slow down.
- 19:19Take any opportunity you can to slow down.
- 19:21I know that. You know, it's a long process.
- 19:24It takes hours, It's painful. You have people who want to move
- 19:28things along. You want to get out of there.
- 19:30No one wants to be in it. The dealers don't even want to
- 19:32be there. They want to be home with their
- 19:34families. Spending all that money they
- 19:35just made on you. Exactly.
- 19:37So slow it down. If anything feels like it's
- 19:39moving too fast, just take a breath, you know, say, you know,
- 19:43I got to, I got to step outside, you know.
- 19:45Oh, I got to take a phone call. Just have something in mind to
- 19:48say, oh, you know, I have a hard stop at this time.
- 19:51Take a break, Come back, Don't get worn out.
- 19:54That's why I will never buy a car alone.
- 19:57I always have someone there who's not emotionally involved.
- 19:59As you become during the process, I want that blue
- 20:02whatever and can say to you whoa, time out.
- 20:04We got to go outside and talk about this for a minute.
- 20:06Somebody. Playing games with the year.
- 20:07I think that's great advice. I haven't heard that one myself,
- 20:10but I think that's great advice. Anything that's sort of
- 20:13something to slow down the process, take a breath because
- 20:17it isn't the end of the world. I I mean, I know that we're all
- 20:20absolutely in a rush, but take that breath and it could save
- 20:22you hundreds or thousands of dollars on a vehicle.
- 20:26And salespeople are they're counting on you to get caught up
- 20:29in the sort of emotion and the timing and and being worn down
- 20:33to let your guard down and spend more than you want to.
- 20:37And bottom line, if you don't feel comfortable, it's your
- 20:39money, it's your decision, Walk out the door.
- 20:42Because if you sign the contract, you can't go off the
- 20:44lot and then come back 24 hours later and say, sorry, I don't
- 20:46like this car. Take it back.
- 20:48It's yours. Walk out the door if you don't
- 20:50feel comfortable. That is absolutely true.
- 20:51There's always going to be another car.
- 20:53There's always going to be another dealership and you know
- 20:56you're in the ultimate power position when you are buying a
- 20:58car because they need you to buy that car from them more than you
- 21:02need to buy that car from them. Keith Berry is a Senior Auto
- 21:04Reporter with Consumer Reports. He has written a bunch of
- 21:07articles about shopping for a car and you'll find them all
- 21:09listed links in the show notes for this podcast.
- 21:12Keith, it was a pleasure talking to you.
- 21:13Thank you so much for spending time with us.
- 21:15Thank you and drive safe. O Maybe you want some help
- 21:18buying that New car. Services like TrueCar promise to
- 21:21help make the process quick and easy by letting you get offers
- 21:24from multiple dealerships. Checkbook cautions that most of
- 21:27these companies don't deliver good deals.
- 21:30We'll have more on that with executive editor Kevin Rassler
- 21:33straight ahead, plus his take on Costco's auto buying program.
- 21:37I'm Herb Weissbaum, the consumer man, and this is Consumerpedia,
- 21:40powered by checkbook.org. Consumerpedia Fast Facts Each
- 21:46year Consumer Reports names the best cars of the year based on
- 21:49road test performance, predicted reliability, owner satisfaction
- 21:53and safety. Here are the editors Top 10
- 21:55picks for 2024 Sub compact SUV, Subaru Crosstrek compact SUV,
- 22:02Subaru Forester midsize SUV, Toyota Highlander hybrid luxury
- 22:08SUV BM WX5 and BM WX5. Plug in hybrid, plug in hybrid
- 22:14SUV, Toyota Rav 4 Prime, small car, Mazda 3 midsize car, Toyota
- 22:21Camry hybrid, electric vehicle, Tesla Model Y hybrid and plug in
- 22:26hybrid Toyota Prius and Prius Prime and small pickup, Ford
- 22:31Maverick and Maverick hybrid. Buying a car is a complicated
- 22:37transaction. You'll find detailed
- 22:38instructions on how to get the best deal when you buy or lease
- 22:41a car on checkbook.org. Those stories were written by
- 22:44Checkbook's executive editor, Kevin Rassler, who joins us now.
- 22:47Hello, Herb. So some people want to skip all
- 22:49the hassles involved with buying a car themselves.
- 22:52So they turn to one of a number of websites that claim to make
- 22:55the process quick and simple. But as you warn, buyers need to
- 22:58tread carefully. Yeah, There are lots of websites
- 23:00out there that claim to provide buyers with easy to obtain
- 23:04offers from multiple dealerships, Say, you know,
- 23:06obtain upfront pricing about this car you're interested in.
- 23:09But we find that most of those websites don't deliver good
- 23:11deals at all. Instead, really what they do is
- 23:13say this, sell your info is a sales lead to dealerships and
- 23:17then you just get inundated with calls and emails and texts from
- 23:21salespeople who are eager to put you through the usual kind of,
- 23:24you know, hard sell and negotiations ringer.
- 23:26So TrueCar is a good example of this.
- 23:28It promises to provide low upfront vehicle pricing, and it
- 23:32partners with lots of big companies like Allstate and
- 23:34American Express and GEICO, and even some consumer groups like
- 23:38AARP and Consumer Reports. TrueCar makes most of its money
- 23:42by collecting a fee from dealers.
- 23:44Every time a dealer closes the sale and TrueCar help facilitate
- 23:47that sale, it has to pay TrueCar.
- 23:50It's cut. So TrueCar, you know it's real.
- 23:52Clients are dealerships, Not car buyers, not consumers.
- 23:56Even though consumers are often led to TrueCar from consumer
- 24:00groups, from insurance companies that are promising to help their
- 24:03members or customers obtain good deals, we find really that
- 24:06TrueCar doesn't usually serve up the best pricing.
- 24:09When we got competitive bidding for lots of different cars over
- 24:13many years and compared to what the best price we could get from
- 24:15TrueCar, we often found that we could save $1500 or more other
- 24:20than what we could get on our own.
- 24:21And in some cases, we found that the best prices we could get
- 24:24through competitive bidding were more than $3000 less than what
- 24:28we could get through TrueCar. Really, the big issue with
- 24:31TrueCar and most other sites like it is that they offer
- 24:35horrid buying experiences. I mean, I have it several times
- 24:39in the last 10 years, requested pricing from TrueCar and I was
- 24:42just immediately swamped with dozens of calls and texts and
- 24:46emails. The last time I did this, even
- 24:48after six months, I was still getting emails and texts and
- 24:51none of these sales people sent me detailed pricing up front in
- 24:55advance, which is what TrueCar says it will do.
- 24:58I mean, it is really a joke. As we spoke earlier in the
- 25:01podcast, the only way to get the best possible price on a new
- 25:04vehicle is by collecting competitive bids.
- 25:06But for those who want to save time and avoid the hassles of
- 25:09haggling, Costco offers a way to get a lower than average price.
- 25:12And you did a deep dive into Costco's auto buying program.
- 25:15He called it well conceived and well managed and I've used it
- 25:19and I was very happy with it. Yeah, I think it's worth, you
- 25:21know, saying and once again, the best way to get the lowest
- 25:24possible price is to initiate this competitive bidding
- 25:27process. I mean you have to be
- 25:28persistent, but it works. But if you just can't deal with
- 25:32that, and I completely understand why, I think Costco
- 25:35is a decent alternative. What it does is it offers a car
- 25:39pricing service as a free member benefit.
- 25:42It's no haggle pricing. And when we've tested it, we
- 25:45found it provided better than usual pricing.
- 25:47It's not as good as getting bids, but it's still pretty
- 25:50good. What Costco does to make sure
- 25:52its members are paying, you know, well below market rates.
- 25:55It conducts price surveys of dealerships that analyzes
- 25:58transaction and inventory data, and it shops for the best deals.
- 26:02It has its own secret shoppers that go in and negotiate with
- 26:06dealers and, you know, see what the pricing they can obtain on
- 26:08their own, how that compares to the commitments Costco is asking
- 26:12its dealerships to make. What it does is it asks
- 26:14dealerships in various geographical areas to commit to
- 26:17a price that Costco thinks is a good one for that specific year,
- 26:21make and model of car. It will send you, the
- 26:23participating dealer in its network in its area near you to
- 26:27the dealer that is agreed to hold that lower pricing that
- 26:30Costco has set. It also sometimes works out
- 26:34members only discounts with manufacturers.
- 26:36So for example, you know Audi or Volvo, they might offer Costco
- 26:40members a rebate of $1000 or something like that.
- 26:43If you identify yourself as coming in as a Costco member,
- 26:46it's something you have to ask for.
- 26:48It comes right off the top of the sale.
- 26:50Is that something you'd have to negotiate with the dealer?
- 26:53One drawback to Costco's program is it doesn't offer special
- 26:56pricing on every make and model. You got to remember that.
- 26:58And just because you use the program, you're still doing all
- 27:01the final paperwork and all the wheel and a deal.
- 27:03And at the end, except for price with the dealership and I had an
- 27:07experience, ones where they try to play some tricks on me, You
- 27:09got to be careful. You got to read the paperwork,
- 27:11you got to know what you're getting.
- 27:12Just because you're going through Costco does not
- 27:13guarantee this is going to be a satisfactory purchase.
- 27:15Yeah, it's just as if you were getting bids.
- 27:18You really have to make sure they don't pull a switcheroo on
- 27:20you, right? That they don't try to, you
- 27:22know, send you toward a more expensive car or payless for the
- 27:25trade in than what your car is really worth.
- 27:28Or try to set you up with some weird financing offer or try to
- 27:31sneak in a lease, which is what we often hear that a lot of
- 27:33dealerships try to do. Another thing is Costco.
- 27:36It doesn't necessarily have every make and model in its
- 27:39database. It doesn't have Tesla's, for
- 27:41example, because Tesla follows a retail model and it doesn't have
- 27:44other cars because you know they may be in high demand or just
- 27:47can't get dealers in that in your area to commit to a certain
- 27:50price. The other thing Costco does is
- 27:52if it can't find a dealer in that area to commit to its price
- 27:55what Costco has decided is good price, then it just doesn't list
- 27:58the car and it also doesn't list cars if you can't get a dealer
- 28:02to charge MSRP or less. I mean it knows at that point.
- 28:05Look, if we can't get a dealer to even stick to the
- 28:07manufacturer suggested pricing, we know we really can't supply
- 28:12our members with good advanced pricing.
- 28:13Well, important information, Kevin, as always, and we're
- 28:16going to let you ease on down the road.
- 28:18Thank you. We have a lot of information
- 28:20about buying a car, auto insurance and auto mechanics on
- 28:23checkbook.org. You'll find the links listed in
- 28:26the show notes. Well, that's it for this edition
- 28:28of Consumerpedia. We hope you'll rate the podcast
- 28:31and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 28:34to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 28:37episodes every other Thursday. Here's another way you can
- 28:40support this show. Follow us on Consumerpedia at
- 28:43Facebook and Instagram. At my Consumerpedia on X,
- 28:47formerly Twitter. I'm Herb Weissbaum.
- 28:50Thank you for listening. Consumerpedia is a public
- 28:53service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 28:56helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 28:59You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 29:02and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 29:05unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 29:08seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 29:11Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 29:16Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC To get your free
- 29:2030 day subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumerpedia.
- 29:24If you like what you've heard, we hope you'll become a
- 29:26supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show Notes to
- 29:29make a small contribution each month.
- 29:31Consumerpedia Empowering consumers to save money and make
- 29:35smarter choices.