Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / A Tennant Windfall, Dismissal for Cause, and Future Earnings
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for a regular segment with Barrister and Solicitor with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:04Adam Stirling: It's Michael Mulligan and Legally Speaking on CFAQ.
- 0:07Adam Stirling: Morning, michael.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: How are we doing?
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Hey, good morning, I'm doing great.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Always good to be here.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Some interesting items on the agenda this week, including an interesting case, reasonably local, that has to do with landlords, tenants and procedural fairness.
- 0:22Michael Mulligan: That's exactly right, and I should start by saying this right.
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: The reason why only a vanishingly small percentage of contracts that people enter into ever wind up in court is that the basic nature of a contract is a free agreement between two people to do something they both want to do, right, hey, do you want to buy my bike?
- 0:42Michael Mulligan: Yes, great, right, you're happy to get the bike, I'm happy to get your money.
- 0:46Michael Mulligan: But we've moved provincially further and further away from that sort of free agreement between two people in the case of residential tenancy, and when you see the changes over the years and read these decisions that come out, it's become very apparent that for political reasons, the provincial government has modified sort of what people can agree to to the point where often these agreements are not free agreements between two people entered into where they both think there's some mutual benefit, but they're something else, right, designed to achieve a social aim.
- 1:28Michael Mulligan: And then, as often the landlord tries to escape that reality, the provincial government comes along and plugs various things into the the dike of you know water coming out the other side.
- 1:40Michael Mulligan: And so that's the broad background to this case that just came out that originated in Duncan, and the background of it is that landlord who owned a home in Duncan wanted to move into the home and so gave notice, as they are permitted to do under the Residential Tenancy Act, and the those provisions in terms of when somebody can make use themselves of a home that they own, that they previously been renting, require a number of things.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: They require there to be a longer notice period.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: They now require there to be one month's free rent given to the tenant, and then the part which is sort of the only way I could describe it would be sort of gamified.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: The situation is that if the landlord who gives notice doesn't move into the unit themselves within a reasonable period of time, the tenant former tenant can seek 12 months rent from the landlord, and so it's produced a circumstance where it reading these decisions.
- 2:40Michael Mulligan: So, parent, you know, you've got former tenants trying to sneak by and knock on the door and see is the person there?
- 2:46Michael Mulligan: How long do they take to move in?
- 2:47Michael Mulligan: Because there's a potential big payday If the person didn't move.
- 2:52Michael Mulligan: The landlord didn't get into the house at a reasonable period of time, and so this case, the landlord gave notice to the tenant, tenant moved out after a couple of months and then the landlord was doing some repair work on the house before moving into it.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: They took out the carpet and realized there had been water leaks in the house that required them to remove drywall, replace appliances, repair structural damage, plumbing and electrical work get permits to do these things, and so that delayed them moving into the house.
- 3:23Michael Mulligan: Now it got a little fuzzy because the landlord, in addition to fixing the problems that became apparent when the carpet got removed, decided to do other things like replacing windows and ordering appliances and, I think, doing another upgrade or two to the property, and that delayed them moving into it.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: And so the former tenants brought an application to try to get 12 months rent, which produced a hearing under the Residential Tendency Act.
- 3:52Michael Mulligan: And that's where things started to go a little haywire here and how it eventually wound up in court.
- 3:57Michael Mulligan: And the challenges and this would be something that would have been entrenched over the period of COVID is that these hearings are now conducted by routinely and presumptively telephone.
- 4:09Michael Mulligan: Now, that's okay, I guess, so far as it goes, it's a 20-minute hearing by telephone.
- 4:15Michael Mulligan: But one of the requirements under the Residential Tendency Act and this would be a requirement of procedural fairness is that the parties need to if they're going to be relying on documents during the hearing, they need to give them to the other person, right?
- 4:31Michael Mulligan: That sort of fairness kind of dictates that right.
- 4:33Michael Mulligan: You don't say, just like in court, you can't sort of pass something secretly up to the judge without letting the other person see it.
- 4:39Michael Mulligan: That's not right.
- 4:40Michael Mulligan: No, so here there's a requirement to do that.
- 4:45Michael Mulligan: The problem is that when the hearing is conducted by telephone it may not be apparent well what exactly is being referred to here.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: And after the decision was made.
- 4:57Michael Mulligan: And the decision by the adjudicator was that the additional work that the landlord did, apart from replacing the drywall and the structural damage and the electrical work and so on from the water leaks, amounted to not just addressing a deficiency but doing an upgrade on the property.
- 5:17Michael Mulligan: And so the language in the Residential Tendency Act, when somebody hasn't moved in in a reasonable period of time, is that there has to be an exigent circumstance which prevented them from moving in.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: And so, in any case, the adjudicator here said well, I don't think this was an exigent circumstance.
- 5:37Michael Mulligan: I guess the adjudicator was interpreting it in a way to say you have to live through your renovations, you have to be in there yourself Tough enough Interesting In any case it became.
- 5:48Michael Mulligan: After the decision where the adjudicator awarded the tenant $16,200, the 12 months rent, it became apparent that the former tenants had provided more material to the adjudicator that the adjudicator was looking at in making their decision.
- 6:04Michael Mulligan: That was not provided to the former landlord and it wasn't the parent during the hearing, it was on the phone.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: So you've got the adjudicator looking at various things and making a decision about the repairs the tenants talking about.
- 6:18Michael Mulligan: They were suggesting oh, we don't think that the mold damage was that bad and we didn't notice it in the kitchen, this kind of thing.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: And the adjudicator was going along looking at a bundle of documents that turned out only later.
- 6:30Michael Mulligan: The landlord was never given, and so that's the fact pattern that wound up in court by way of a judicial review.
- 6:39Michael Mulligan: And I should say this these cases are becoming now relatively common, whereas in the past it would be very rare for a residential tenancy decision to wind up in the Supreme Court for things like a judicial review, because it would be uneconomic.
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: Right If people are fighting over a month's rent or what about this or that, it's not worth doing that.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: But when the Act is out and amended, trying to close off a way in which a tenancy could possibly be ended by a landlord by producing this sort of gamified, large possible award, the cases are winding up in Supreme Court.
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: And so here the judge, who had to review all of this, concluded that, well, it's perfectly acceptable that residential tenancy decisions be made in a summary fashion.
- 7:29Michael Mulligan: Right, we, we, you want to have process, the kind of accords with how much people are fighting over, right, and so doing them by telephone makes sense.
- 7:36Michael Mulligan: Or, if you're fighting over a few hundred dollars, you probably shouldn't make everyone take the day off work and go to court and hire a lawyer.
- 7:42Michael Mulligan: That's just not going to work.
- 7:43Michael Mulligan: Right, that's fine, but there has to be a high degree of procedural fairness, and that's going to be even more carefully scrutinized when there's a large amount of money involved, which is part of what's happening here.
- 7:57Michael Mulligan: You've got the government creating what amounts to sort of penalty provisions payable to the tenant If a landlord tries to end a tenancy.
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: Right?
- 8:06Michael Mulligan: So, bear in mind, ordinarily, with a contract, people are would be able to write up a contract that would say hey, I'm going to rent my house to you for two years, is that okay?
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: Yeah, you agree, I agree.
- 8:16Michael Mulligan: Great, we agree, right, um, but those kinds of things are just not permitted any longer.
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Like, once somebody gets in as a tenant, they're in right, unless the landlord can somehow find some provision that would allow the thing to end.
- 8:29Michael Mulligan: And then they also restrict, uh, of course, uh how much rent can be charged.
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: And so you wind up with circumstances where, in many cases, there's no longer some meeting of the minds where the two people agree, for a mutual benefit, that they want to exchange something for money.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: Yeah, it's a circumstance where the government is sort of effectively tried to sort of expropriate part of the value of people's property to redistribute to a certain group of people, those being current tenants.
- 8:55Michael Mulligan: Right, and I guess that's a philosophical thing.
- 8:59Michael Mulligan: Generally, with the sort of rent control uh efforts, whether that's appropriate or not, I suppose I would say we'd be better off as a public policy if we want to subsidize rent for existing tenants, tax everyone uh and give them a subsidy, rather than trying to extract that value from people that happened to be existing landlords.
- 9:19Michael Mulligan: Otherwise, of course, you're going to wind up with all kinds of arguments about, you know, whether the person can possibly get out of some unwilling uh uh agreement, which is what people have been forced into.
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: And then you wind up with provisions like this trying to plug uh holes yeah, people are doing things improperly.
- 9:37Michael Mulligan: And then even where nobody seems to like, in this case, have been doing anything untoward, you wind up with this kind of a decision and reviews and court cases and so on.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: And so it's just an example of that.
- 9:48Michael Mulligan: Um, there'll be a new hearing in this case where the landlord will get all of the material and get to go back and have another telephone hearing uh, and we'll have to wait the outcome here, but I think it's worth people knowing about both in terms of that reality.
- 10:02Michael Mulligan: Uh, and I'm no doubt this would fact this kind of a case and this kind of a circumstance is going to factor into people's decisions about do you ever want to be a landlord?
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: Because you are now subject to potentially very large uh awards.
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: Uh, you know, if it takes too long to uh fix up the rotten floorboards or whatever, get the appliances into the house, if, uh, if you ever want to move back into it, so that's the uh.
- 10:28Michael Mulligan: That's the case of the Duncan, legally, speaking.
- 10:29Adam Stirling: We'll continue in just a moment.
- 10:30Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, from Mulligan defense lawyers.
- 10:32Adam Stirling: After this, legally speaking on C facts 1070, michael Moulton, from Mulligan defense lawyers.
- 10:36Adam Stirling: As we continue our segment today, what's next on the agenda?
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: Michael Uh next on the agenda is a case we spoke about uh back at the trial stage.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: There's now had an appeal uh, and it's got a local element to it as well.
- 10:50Michael Mulligan: Uh, it's a case that involves a former manager of galaxy boaters, which is a chain of?
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: Uh several used card dealerships Uh or lots on Baker Rylan Uh, and it was a wrongful dismissal claim brought by a former manager of Galaxy Motors.
- 11:10Michael Mulligan: And the first thing that was notable about it I think both the trial decision and the court of appeal decision is that's a pretty good line of work to be in, it would seem, as the fellow's income in the year that he was terminated was between $750,000 and $1 million.
- 11:25Michael Mulligan: So don't feel bad if you're leaning into the used car dealership for a bit of a discount on the truck you're buying.
- 11:32Michael Mulligan: It would seem that they're doing pretty well Uh.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: So the background of it was that this fellow, the manager, well paid manager uh went on a business trip up to Parksville and brought his wife and, according to the judge, they found that uh, while staying in Parksville, uh the manager had dinner with his wife but wrote the name of two employees on the dinner receipt and the next morning had breakfast at the same restaurant and wrote another employee's name on the receipt and submitted them for reimbursement.
- 12:01Michael Mulligan: Uh, that got spotted on an audit.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: He was confronted with it and denied doing it.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: Uh, and as a result of that he was fired.
- 12:10Michael Mulligan: Uh, he sued for wrongful dismissal and that case went to trial, unsuccessfully, uh for the former manager, and so he appealed that uh, and one of the grounds of appeal was arguing that uh, the uh, what the judge found to be dishonesty surrounding the restaurant expenses should not have, standing alone, been sufficient to provide just cause for dismissal.
- 12:34Michael Mulligan: Is the way it works is that if an employer has just cause to fire somebody, they can do exactly that.
- 12:40Michael Mulligan: Right, yes, you're fired and they're not.
- 12:42Michael Mulligan: You're not entitled to any compensation, but if you're fired without just cause, a person could be uh entitled to it would presently be entitled to either notice or pay in lieu of notice, depending on.
- 12:55Michael Mulligan: You know how long did they work there for and how specialized was the job?
- 12:58Michael Mulligan: Did the person find other employment?
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: And so the central issue in wrongful dismissal cases, as can often be, was something just cause for firing.
- 13:07Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the former manager argued that uh, the?
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: Uh.
- 13:11Michael Mulligan: The single instance of uh, the writing the employee's names on the receipt for the two meals with the wife um should not have amounted to just cause, because the car dealership uh had uh alleged other things as well, a broader pattern of misconduct, uh, and the court of appeal found that that was not uh a ground of appeal, found that the uh fact that the fellow had uh submitted the receipts improperly and then not acknowledged it when confronted with it, uh found that the act relied upon by the judge, those things, according to the court of appeal, went to the heart of the employer employee relationship and that it was sufficient uh cause for dismissal.
- 13:53Michael Mulligan: Hmm, uh.
- 13:54Michael Mulligan: And so that's one takeaway there, sort of how, uh, you know, dishonesty in that regard can be the end of employment without any compensation.
- 14:01Michael Mulligan: Then the other thing which was, I think, worth noting the unsuccessful former manager submitted an affidavit on the appeal setting out that, hey, he had other expenses that he could have claimed that he didn't claim, arguing that, well, I haven't really profited from this because I had other legitimate expenses that I didn't claim for.
- 14:22Michael Mulligan: So I was reimbursed for less than really what I was entitled to, even if those two meals shouldn't have been paid for by the car dealership.
- 14:32Michael Mulligan: And that raised the first issue which people should know about, which is a test for fresh evidence on an appeal, and the idea there is that you can't just sort of argue your case at trial, not succeed, and then come along later and say, well, look at this evidence, it's all very compelling.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: And so there's a four-part test you need to satisfy If you want, on an appeal, the Court of Appeal to look at something new.
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: And the first part of it is you have to show that, if that, you could not, if you were duly diligent have found whatever it is you're trying to rely upon at the time of your trial right.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: Next you have to show that it would be relevant.
- 15:09Michael Mulligan: Next, you have to show that it's potentially credible or reasonably capable of belief, and then, finally, you have to show that it could have reasonably be expected to have affected the outcome of the trial.
- 15:21Michael Mulligan: It's got to be important, not just some minor point.
- 15:24Michael Mulligan: And so, looking at that, the Court of Appeal found it doesn't even get past the first test.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: If you had some receipts you didn't claim for, you could easily have found those at time of the trial.
- 15:34Michael Mulligan: You didn't, and so this is not something fresh or new that you couldn't have found without, if you exercise due diligence.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: So it doesn't even get past the first hurdle.
- 15:43Michael Mulligan: And then, moreover, the Court of Appeal found that the evidence, not only that, but it was not relevant and could not have affected the result.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: Right, because the basis for finding that there was just cause to fire the fellow was that this conduct and his response to it sort of undermined the trust relationship with the senior employee, and so the fact that he may not have claimed other things that he could have claimed, that just would not have affected the outcome of the case, and so that ground of appeal was dismissed as well, and so the outcome from the Court of Appeal is no compensation.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: The restaurant receipts with the employee's name and then the response to it, those things together amounted to just cause for the dismissal, and so that's the life lesson from Galaxy Motors.
- 16:31Adam Stirling: All right, we have five and a half minutes left.
- 16:33Adam Stirling: I see a couple of stories on the agenda.
- 16:34Adam Stirling: Which would we prefer?
- 16:36Michael Mulligan: Sure, well, why don't we talk about the Court of Appeal decision involving the person who wanted to be a doctor?
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: Sure, interesting one, all right.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: And so the background of that?
- 16:46Michael Mulligan: This is also a local case.
- 16:47Michael Mulligan: It was a woman who was going to university of Victoria doing a bachelor's degree in science, and she was very unfortunate.
- 16:57Michael Mulligan: That would appear from the decision.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: She wound up in a total of four car accidents between 2014 and 2020.
- 17:03Michael Mulligan: Wow, and not all the details are set out here, but at least one of them wasn't her fault.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: She was a passenger in a car that got rear-ended, so, fair enough, she was very unfortunate in terms of car accidents.
- 17:15Michael Mulligan: Now, this case predates no fault, which is important to know, and that's important to know because, prior to no fault, one of the things that could be considered in a case where somebody was injured and it affected their ability to work in the future is that a court could need to consider like well, what were your future prospects, how are things likely to work out for you, and how did the accident impact that Right?
- 17:40Michael Mulligan: Did the accident make it less likely you would have pursued your career as a I don't know ballet dancer or, in this case, doctor?
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: And the woman's argument was that she was wanting to go to medical school and the effect of these, all these car accidents which had did appear to have a significant effect on her physically and psychologically she had, I think, mild traumatic brain injury flowing from these things affected her ability to become a doctor, and so she wanted to think she was asking for, in terms of compensation, was the difference between how much she would make as a nurse, which is, she went through nursing school and how much she would have made if she'd become a doctor.
- 18:23Michael Mulligan: And her argument was well, my ability to become a doctor was impaired by these car accidents.
- 18:27Michael Mulligan: And so that's what the trial judge had to wrestle with and what, ultimately, the court of appeal had to sort out, and that's complicated.
- 18:35Michael Mulligan: Even the court of appeal judges couldn't agree on the proper result here.
- 18:39Michael Mulligan: It was a split decision, it was two to one court of appeal, and the background of it is the trial judge concluded, based on the evidence that she had, was that they?
- 18:50Michael Mulligan: She concluded that there was a 75% chance that this woman would have gotten into medical school and then looked at how much money she would be making Working for the rest of her life as a registered nurse and how much money she would have made had she succeeded in getting into medical school and then awarded her the difference.
- 19:10Michael Mulligan: Right, it's been some contingencies.
- 19:13Michael Mulligan: The majority of the court of appeal interestingly didn't agree with the trial judge and part of the analysis was looking at what is her person's actual chances of getting into medical school.
- 19:24Michael Mulligan: Yeah, yeah, saying I want to go to medical school doesn't mean you're going to medical school.
- 19:29Michael Mulligan: And so they were right into the weeds looking at things like well, what were her transcripts like?
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: What were her marks?
- 19:35Michael Mulligan: How many people get into medical school?
- 19:37Michael Mulligan: What's the acceptance rate?
- 19:38Michael Mulligan: How many spots are there all across the country?
- 19:40Michael Mulligan: Yeah, and one of the very interesting tidbits there and this maybe, is a comment on grade inflation.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: She, apparently the woman had not that great grades for the first few years of university but then really buckled down, was doing very well.
- 19:53Michael Mulligan: Yes, and in fact in her nursing program which she had transferred over to, I think you, yeah, you BC, she was in the a to a plus range, although this was an odd point.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: The her transcripts indicated that was the average in her class.
- 20:07Michael Mulligan: So I'm not sure what that looks like, but apparently the nursing program's got a pretty high, pretty high grading scheme.
- 20:15Michael Mulligan: Now the other caught the other factor which was not in her favor.
- 20:18Michael Mulligan: It's so found the majority of the court of appeal is that she had not written the MCAT.
- 20:24Michael Mulligan: The MCAT is like the Please into whether you're gonna get into medical school.
- 20:30Michael Mulligan: Yes, and so the majority of the court of appeal said look, I appreciate she's done very well in her last.
- 20:35Michael Mulligan: You know her nursing program and she's keen and wants to go to medical school, but you haven't written the MCAT.
- 20:42Michael Mulligan: The very few people get into medical school.
- 20:44Michael Mulligan: The acceptance rate is really low.
- 20:47Michael Mulligan: And so, effectively, what the majority did was to find that the accidents Diminished her chances of getting into medical school by 10% Not that she was a 75% probability of getting in and look what the income would have been and just subtract one from the other and Calculated in the amount, the majority found that no, they did have an effect.
- 21:09Michael Mulligan: Right, you, your chances of getting in may have been better, but for these various car accidents.
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: But concluded that rather than there being a 75% chance she would have gotten in, concluded there was only a 20% probability she actually would have been admitted.
- 21:22Michael Mulligan: And then we found that the accidents reduced that and so the proper amount would be.
- 21:28Michael Mulligan: You had a 20% chance.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: Your accidents reduced that and then this is the amount that you would get and the difference at the end of the day was $450,000, but it's a really interesting insight into how that works.
- 21:39Michael Mulligan: Yeah, the other thing to note is that, under no fault, none of this occurs.
- 21:44Michael Mulligan: What happens is you get a percentage of the income you're making at the time You're disabled in the accident and so if you're a medical student, say in your last year, of course part time, you work part time at the coffee shop.
- 21:56Michael Mulligan: Yeah, you will resend your disabled completely.
- 21:59Michael Mulligan: You cannot work for the rest of your life.
- 22:00Michael Mulligan: You get a portion of what you make at the coffee shop and that's it.
- 22:04Michael Mulligan: Consideration is given to what was almost certain to happen next year.
- 22:07Michael Mulligan: As soon as you graduated, you're just considered part-time coffee shop employee for the rest of your life.
- 22:12Michael Mulligan: That's awful and so really interesting case.
- 22:15Michael Mulligan: But we know, wow, it's imagine that outcome now.
- 22:19Michael Mulligan: So, yeah, that's a local case for the woman who wanted to be a doctor important example.
- 22:24Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan, appreciate your time as always, until next week.
- 22:27Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 22:28Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 22:28Adam Stirling: That's a Michael Mulligan Mulligan defense lawyers, legally speaking during the second half of our second hour on the program every Thursday.
- 22:34Adam Stirling: News is next.