Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Next Station London-Matthew Dunstan
Transcript
- 0:00So it's the Spielder's Yarus on Sunday, and so I thought, as a
- 0:05build up to the award that I would interview the designers that are nominated this
- 0:10year and so we can get an insight into the games that have been nominated.
- 0:14And so the first one is Matthew Dunstan talking about next Station London.
- 0:19I hope you enjoy it. So I'm massively excited on the Spields Yara Special
- 0:25to speak to one of the nominees. This is Matthew Dunstan. Matthew,
- 0:30all the way from Newcastle and not the way I won, but the good
- 0:35day one. Welcome to the show, thanks for having me on. Then,
- 0:38nice to talk to you from yes a very far away away. So
- 0:42first Lee, how annoyed are you that you get nominated for the Spielders Jarus
- 0:47six months after moving back to Australia. I think my pleasant surprise and joy
- 0:54of being nominated far outway any kind of inconvenience. So no, I've overall
- 1:00sort of emotion, I would say. So let's talk about that then,
- 1:03because the nomination, as we're recallding, the nominations have been announced for a
- 1:07couple of days, so two things. Firstly, did you have an inkling
- 1:11that you were going to get nominated? And secondly, how did you find
- 1:17out and what was your reaction. I think I should say that, like
- 1:22every year, you sort of like, as long as you have a game
- 1:26that you could fit the criteria, you sort of have this thing, oh
- 1:29like maybe, but I've sort of learned over the years that you just never
- 1:32know. And also you also really don't know about the kind of especially like
- 1:36the German distribution side of things, because as I'm sure are you saying,
- 1:40you show your games have to be available and widely available in German distribution to
- 1:44be considered, and I just don't know about that. So you know,
- 1:46you could be hoping for something, but you know it could not be a
- 1:49chance anyway because of these sort of restrictions. All that being said, with
- 1:53Next Station in London, I actually really hadn't thought it at all. There
- 1:59was another one of my games which I thought maybe it was a chance,
- 2:02but I heard a couple of German friends talk about it and say, oh
- 2:09it could you know, they think it could fit the spiel or something other.
- 2:13So I was actually really only from hearing it from those that I thought,
- 2:15oh, okay, maybe you know, I thought it was just a
- 2:19I don't know, you never know what fits are not and I had in
- 2:22my head that I thought it wouldn't fit. So when I heard, I
- 2:25was because the announcement was because the time difference, it's like one am here,
- 2:30and I wasn't gonna I wasn't gonna stay up for that. But of
- 2:34course then I couldn't really I was a bit excited, so I ended up.
- 2:38I think, I don't know. I woke up at two o'clock in
- 2:39the morning. I just checked my phone and I saw it, although it
- 2:44was like a little bit confusing because I couldn't work out like the long list
- 2:46and the shortlist and everything. So and probably I was half asleep at the
- 2:51time as well, so I kind of like went back to sleep and then
- 2:54checked it properly in the morning, and of course by then, you know,
- 2:58I had very nice messages for folks, you know, saying like,
- 3:01oh, there will be a nice surprise when he wakes up kind of thing,
- 3:04which it definitely was. So yeah, And so how do you see
- 3:08your reputation in Germany? Do you have any any sort of notion of that?
- 3:14Because you also have your escape room games that seem to be quite popular
- 3:17here. Are you sort of Are you sort of known in the German gaming
- 3:22scene? You think, well, I don't know really specifically Germany. I'd
- 3:29say it's equivalent to my sort of wider I don't think I have much reputation.
- 3:34I mean, you know, for bad or good. Really, I
- 3:37think I make a lot of different styles of games, and with lots of
- 3:42different publishers, So I think it, you know, for better or worse,
- 3:46it makes it hard for me to be kind of associated with my designs
- 3:50in a way because you you know, and especially for example, with these
- 3:54adventure games or narrative games, I mean, they're even less on the kind
- 3:58of designer game style. So I think, you know, I don't think
- 4:02people people even think about them in the same way as being designed. Of
- 4:05course they are. But um so I yeah, I don't. I don't
- 4:10know what I guess. I know much more about my ownership with publishers,
- 4:13but that's much more of a kind of professional thing than than you know,
- 4:15at the public at large. So no, I suspect that nobody really knows
- 4:19who I am. But that's perfectly fine. I don't mind. So let's
- 4:24let's get onto next station London. Then. So so firstly, you mostly
- 4:30if I'm correct, design games with other people. You know, Brent is
- 4:33your most sort of established partner, but you know you have the unfortunate,
- 4:39unfortunate, um privilege of designing a game with Tony Boydell at the moment.
- 4:44And but this one is designed alone. Why I mean, I guess it's
- 4:50actually was the first game I designed really during the pandemic, which probably had
- 4:56contributed to it. And I think I do make game. I think I
- 5:00had left Cambridge at the time, and I wasn't really seeing you know,
- 5:04I wasn't a lot of collaborations usually start with some initial physical meet up,
- 5:09even though they can continue virtually afterwards. And I think I was just at
- 5:12a point in my life and career that I wasn't doing much of that.
- 5:15And I had a really clear idea for this game, even though the original
- 5:19prototype there were sort of I remember there was one very specific point in the
- 5:24middle where it changed and became what it was. But I kind of always
- 5:27knew this kind of idea about the pencils, you know, being the lines
- 5:30and changing as as you went around. And so I think because I sort
- 5:35of had that idea, I didn't really feel the need to collaborate. And
- 5:39also because the game, I knew the game was going to be a bit
- 5:42generally simpler, it wasn't going to be particularly complex game. So I think,
- 5:46yeah, I just sort of got on with it, I guess,
- 5:47and no kind of worked out well. But yeah, there was this.
- 5:55Really it's not always the case with game design. You don't sometimes think that
- 5:59the progression of a design it's not particularly momentous, or you don't really remember
- 6:05milestones, or you know, there's just like thousands of different changes. But
- 6:10with Next Station in London, I really clearly remember before it was a much
- 6:14more Originally it was my full kind of procedural. You know, you had
- 6:16these different actions and you could you know, you could do a certain number
- 6:19of track, or you would have two lines of track or three lines,
- 6:23or you could make one turn, or you could do all of this sort
- 6:25of thing. And there was just a point where it kind of like flipped
- 6:28in my mind. Instead of being about kind of like the the extent of
- 6:31what you could do in your turn, it became about where were you going,
- 6:33what you're connecting to At the moment I had, you know, made
- 6:38that change. Everything just really came together, you know, in a and
- 6:44it not only sort of made the game better, but it just simplified everything.
- 6:46And those those are the moments I think I love most about game designs,
- 6:49where you somehow you come across this one thing that kind of solves everything
- 6:54at once. So yeah, that's kind of my memories of that kind of
- 6:58process, I guess by myself and without wanting to be crude. Obviously,
- 7:04if you're designing alone, you don't have to share not just credit but also
- 7:12money with your design partner. Is it preferable now you're a full time professional
- 7:17game designer, is it preferable for you to design alone? Do you sort
- 7:21of try and do that more or are you happy designing in partnerships. I'm
- 7:29still really happy designing partnerships in my view for a long time, I think,
- 7:31even before I went full time, But I think it persists now that
- 7:34I am full time. Is that I think I'm going to always be able
- 7:40to produce more than double the amount of work of games then I would designing
- 7:48singly. So even though I kind of have to split it halfway, you
- 7:53know, I'll make say I'll make three games in partnership for every one game
- 7:57I would make by myself in terms of the time it would take, and
- 8:00I honestly also say the quality generally would be better. And I think in
- 8:03collaboration you you gained so much, not just in terms of efficiency, but
- 8:07in terms of like you make better games, I think in my opinion,
- 8:11So no, I I and games after this I haven't, you know,
- 8:15like I've made still continue to make games in collaboration. This is sort of
- 8:18like the really the aberration in a way, So no, I, it
- 8:24does. It is a part of a thing you think about, but there's
- 8:28so many other variables than than just like the royalty percentage, you know,
- 8:33and whether that's halved or not. You know, it's it's what publish you're
- 8:35working with, you know, the print sizes, the number of different international
- 8:41partners, how it's released, et cetera. Extentations. So I'm still have
- 8:45the opinion of a I'm going to make more games that are better with with
- 8:48collaborating and be that you just have to take as many shots as you can
- 8:52that that that's the way, at least in my way, to be sort
- 8:54of financially viable industry. I don't have one game that makes me, you
- 8:58know, millions of euros or something like that. I had many games that
- 9:01kind of I pieced together, and so that's kind of been my approach and
- 9:05I'll continue to try it, I guess, for as long as I can.
- 9:09And so what was the process of getting Next Station London published? I
- 9:13mean, was was it difficult? Or was this one? Did you specifically
- 9:18think, oh, Blue Orange, this is going to be slap bang in
- 9:20the middle of their catalog, all pitched to them. How did that process
- 9:24go? Yeah? It was well also because it was during the pandemic.
- 9:28It was you know, over that time was the time of virtual pitching,
- 9:33which I you know, I don't think anybody did it my choice, right,
- 9:37I didn't particularly like it. I always I mean, I had the
- 9:39huge privilege of being able to pitch in person at essence for you know,
- 9:43ten years or whatever because I was living close enough, and you know,
- 9:48it was a huge privilege. But you know, it was a great experience
- 9:50to be able to do that. I had already signed a game with Blue
- 9:54Orange before Bubble Stories. Fact, yeah, that's that's the only one,
- 9:58I think, um, And I think they just asked did I have anything
- 10:03else? And It was sort of interesting because it just happened to be I
- 10:07had finished, like, I had kind of finished the game relatively reci or
- 10:11I was kind of happy with it, and it just came up the date
- 10:13that they were you know, they were like, oh, let's have a
- 10:15meeting and you know, show me whatever. It wasn't that I thought of
- 10:18this games for Blue Orange. Obviously, when they contacted me, then I
- 10:20thought, oh, yes, it could fit fit what they're doing. But
- 10:24and they liked it so quickly that I didn't show it to anybody else just
- 10:28because they they they signed it very quickly, which you know, it's not
- 10:31necessary, you know, it's a bit unusual in a way, but maybe
- 10:35in retrospect, you know it, you know, it was it was a
- 10:39good fit for them, and obviously the game had they saw saw quality in
- 10:43it. Yeah. So actually it was surprisingly a surprisingly smooth process signing the
- 10:48game. And also I was also kind of unusually because I had had this
- 10:52other game signed around the same time and there was a developer as working with
- 10:56on that game. He became the developer on this as well, so you
- 11:00know, I already had a good working relationship with the developer as well,
- 11:01and we we we fell into, you know, working on these two projects
- 11:05sort of at the same time. And his name is Brian Lefevre, and
- 11:09I'm sorry, Brian that I've puchered your last name, I think, but
- 11:13he you know, the quality of the game is as much about my design
- 11:18as his, about his editorial and development skills and Maxim Moron's illustrations. It's
- 11:26I really think it's one of those cases where you've had each of the kind
- 11:28of contributors. Really it's, you know, come together so well and a
- 11:33really nice skillhesive packet, and you can kind of see everybody's talents coming out
- 11:39at Brian. People call him sort of eagle eyed. He has this this
- 11:43eye for detail, and especially with Next Station London, you have these maps
- 11:48and you might not know by looking at them, but there's a lot of
- 11:50kind of rules that you have to sort of follow, and there's lots of
- 11:54ways that you can do something where it's not a mistake, but it can
- 12:00lead to problems with how the map will play. And you know, if
- 12:03you try and move one thing to fix something, then it introduces all these
- 12:05other problems because everything's kind of intertwined because it's this network and so his ability
- 12:11to kind of spot that and solve those or at least you know, alert
- 12:15me to that was incredibly important, and also in the rules as well.
- 12:20So it's been a very smooth process actually, and so on that then development
- 12:26is pretty murky for most people. Most people aren't privy to the sort of
- 12:33development process. I mean, how different was the game you initially pitched a
- 12:37blue orange to the final one in the box. It's exactly the same.
- 12:41It actually hasn't changed really much at all. The only thing that really has
- 12:46changed is like some the map itself, some things have kind of moved around,
- 12:52but the rules are the same, and it was more about just optimizing
- 12:58a few yeah, like placements of things. As I said, there can
- 13:01be some errors in which, for example, each starting station, you know
- 13:07you have to have two there are four shapes in the game, and you
- 13:09know you're going to draw one from the deck to connect to. And we
- 13:11made sure that each of the starting stations has exactly two of each of the
- 13:15four shapes that are available around it, and and things like this, you
- 13:18know, And so the development was mainly around optimizing that map and making sure
- 13:22you know that it was it was kind of correct in that way, But
- 13:26in terms of the rules, they're kind of said because the game itself is
- 13:30it's really simple in its core mechanisms and there's not much room to to sort
- 13:35of wiggle. You know, either it works or it doesn't, So that
- 13:39that that worked well. And the other I guess the other kind of development
- 13:41thing was in the the additional kind of modules. There are these two kind
- 13:48of bonus modules that can you can add And definitely the pencil powers were part
- 13:52were kind of added in development. I designed them, but they were they
- 13:56weren't originally get in the game. I can't remember actually if I think the
- 13:58goals were in the game before, but they were probably also developed and changed
- 14:03a bit, and maybe they were a bit easier too hard and changing numbers
- 14:07and that sort of thing. But no, I would say it was a
- 14:09fairly kind of light amount of development in overall in my experiences across different games.
- 14:18But that kind of matches again the kind of late lighter nature of the
- 14:20game itself. So you are not a stranger to spield a CRUs ceremonies.
- 14:28You've been nominated before, and I don't want to. I don't want to
- 14:33dredge up terrible memories here. But how does it feel to go to the
- 14:37ceremony and not win? Well, I should say they're not. It's not
- 14:41a terrible with every I think. Look, I mean you can't, you
- 14:46know, as much as you try and kind of fool yourself and kind of
- 14:48prepare yourself for you know, the likely you know, you're excited, you're
- 14:52you know, there's an out of trepidation. I still remember definitely not really
- 14:56being able to sleep very well and just being very tense, you know,
- 15:01thank God for me, thankfully it was for the Kenish bill, which is
- 15:05the one they announced first, so like at least you get it out of
- 15:07the way. But yeah, and like once once you hear it, you
- 15:11know, you kind of like like a lot of that tension goes away,
- 15:16you know, for better or worse, whether you win or not. Like
- 15:18that, and that's that's a good thing. And I think just actually in
- 15:22a way, I mean, I hope I'll be able to go this time.
- 15:26I think I might appreciate it even more for the kind of just the
- 15:28experience that it is because it and I actually don't know whether they've changed things
- 15:33around. I know previously they had a dinner at the night before where you
- 15:37got to meet other people and the other nominees and the other jury members and
- 15:41things like that. And I think it was actually a really early point for
- 15:46me in the industry, you know, very fortunate to be nominated, but
- 15:50Elysium was only basically my third or fourth release game, I think, Whereas
- 15:56now, you know, I've been around for a while, so I hope
- 15:58that I'll I'll be able to kind of savor that that event because it is
- 16:03it is something kind of yeah, you just don't really get to experience it
- 16:06very much. And yeah, of course you're disappointed, but I think I
- 16:11think I actually knew the last time. I think I knew it more deep
- 16:17down that like it was going to be a bit of quite unusual if we'd
- 16:22won. Like Elysium wasn't a very kind of quote unquote German game, especially
- 16:26when you look at kind of the Kennish bills they do, I think they
- 16:29actually are are more predictable than the spiel is nowadays. I think they seem
- 16:34to really just sort of see it. And and yeah, we kind of
- 16:38knew that it was actually that that was kind of joy of being nominated was
- 16:41the kind of great already the achievement, and I think the feeling right now
- 16:45for me is a little bit different, not that I think it's still I
- 16:49feel like this should a bit of a still a bit of an outsider,
- 16:52but it's just harder to kind of predict the spiel. So, um,
- 16:56you sort of don't you don't know. But anyway, it's so we'll see.
- 17:00I mean, I'll be excited of course either way, whether I'm there
- 17:03or not, whether I'm staying up at one am to watch the or not,
- 17:07or if I'm there in person. And so what is the process?
- 17:11Have so the spielders jars people just deal with the publisher or have I contacted
- 17:17you personally? How how is that works? I don't I haven't been contacted.
- 17:22I can't really remember how it worked last time. If we'd had this
- 17:26interview in a week or two, it might just be a question of time.
- 17:27I mean that the announ's been only happened, you know, like two
- 17:30or three days ago. So I'm sure that they're kind of processing things.
- 17:34And maybe in this particular case, because the publisher that the German publisher or
- 17:41distributor is different from there's not blue Orange itself. It's a sorry HTM Kinsell,
- 17:48I think you know you can. So perhaps they've already been in contact
- 17:52with the Spielder Jarras people and maybe there's just a delay in that following on
- 17:56to Blue Orangel to me. So I'm sure here something, but I haven't
- 18:00heard anything yet. And so we talk about the Spielders as being life changing
- 18:11if you win it. What what do you anticipate Do you anticipate this changing
- 18:19your profile as a designer? Do you do you anticipate as a professional designer
- 18:23this this making this year exceptionally good? I mean, what do you anticipate
- 18:29from from just the nomination? Good question. I think the main thing,
- 18:34honestly is just more people knowing about the game, and whether that track,
- 18:37I mean that probably does translate into more sales, and you already see it.
- 18:42Sometimes the folks say, oh, you know, I see the dominations.
- 18:45I haven't heard of these games. I've gone out and bought them,
- 18:48or in the case of Next Station, London actually has a really great board
- 18:51game arena adaptation which I actually recommend anybody listening though. It really has a
- 18:56really good kind of solo challenge as well, so a lot of people and
- 19:00A would try it out, and I think honestly, that's the main thing.
- 19:03You know, the board gaming being a very global hobby, it's tricky
- 19:08that you know, Blue Orange is a French publisher, and I think they're
- 19:11quite strong in Europe, but maybe they don't quite have the same reach in
- 19:15North America or it's just a different market. And so that's the kind of
- 19:19the power of the Spielder Jars is that people feel like, just as it
- 19:23happens in Germany, but also in other places that they're like, oh,
- 19:26I may as well, even if it doesn't win. It's like, this
- 19:29is something I should A certain percentage would be go, I should try this
- 19:32out. So you just get to reach more people. And I think my
- 19:34hope is that we're releasing, you know, in a stroke of luck,
- 19:40we're releasing the second installment in the series next day in Tokyo, probably around
- 19:44the time when Spiel is on, which you know, it wasn't planned that
- 19:47way, but of course it's good to be ready for that, and we're
- 19:51already work for the third third City. So my hope is that it might
- 19:55also allow the series to have maybe more longevity than it would have had other
- 20:00have had otherwise, because it is a kind of system which you know is
- 20:03sort of I think, very flexible, and I love making thing systems a
- 20:10little bit like Elysium. Actually, you know that these systems which can support
- 20:12variation and innovation and can kind of live, and of course Elysium didn't quite
- 20:17have that unfortunately in the end, but that would kind of be my hope
- 20:21that maybe it as a side effect of the nomination. And you've taken my
- 20:25last question, which which was going to be is there going to be a
- 20:29next Station Tokyo, a Next Station Berlin? And so this this game is
- 20:33going to have multiple different versions. I guess they won't be expansions that we
- 20:38sort of stand alone games, right, yeah, exactly, So they'll just
- 20:41have their own pad and their own modules. And I think that we've made
- 20:47for Tokyo, for example, we've been able to you know, there are
- 20:49goals which are Tokyo and then there's a new module of kind of powers,
- 20:53but you can even mix that module with London, so there's a little bit
- 20:57of you know, for folks who already got it before. Actually, Tokyo
- 21:00is already available on Board Game Arena in beta, so if anybody wants to
- 21:03check it out, it's it's already up there, and yeah, I think
- 21:07it's it's I love being able to once you know a system and how it
- 21:11works. I love ben tinkering with it and how how can you give people
- 21:15a different experience but without radically changing the rules. And actually the third installment
- 21:21is actually going to be without saying they specifics, it's it's going to be
- 21:25in collaboration with an actual, real company that runs a transport system, and
- 21:32so it's it's going to be a chance also to reach even put potentially a
- 21:34wider audience. So we're making it even kind of a simpler version for the
- 21:37third one to kind of match that. But yeah, hopefully I'd love to
- 21:41be able to go into more cities and kind of explore that. I mean,
- 21:45I love I'm a bit of a transport nerd anyway, So it's it's
- 21:48a joy to be able to kind of, you know, do a bit
- 21:51of research. I was reading all up about the Tokyo Metro and all the
- 21:55kind of different quirks and things and seeing what we could bring into the game
- 21:57for that. So that was a lot of fun, brilliant. Well,
- 22:00Matthew Dunston, thank you very much and best luck. Thank you very much
- 22:04Ben, and yeah, thank you very much having me on