Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / What Credit Unions Need to Know About the 100 Year Report on FHLB System with Ryan Donovan
Transcript
- 0:35Markoverdub: Hey everyone, this is Mark Treichel with another
- 0:37episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:39This morning I'm with Ryan Donovan, the CEO of the Council
- 0:43of Federal Home Loan Banks.
- 0:44Ryan, how are you doing today?
- 0:46Doing great, Mark.
- 0:47How are you?
- 0:47I'm doing great.
- 0:48My, my listeners may recall that you formerly were the number two at CUNA.
- 0:53And I know that we did an earlier podcast when you transitioned over to
- 0:58your new role and you, you picked an interesting time to go do that with the
- 1:03FHFA 100 year report on federal home loan banks, which, I know you, you had
- 1:09a lot of listening sessions and things tied to that but the report's out, right?
- 1:15The big reveal of the report was I think just last week.
- 1:19And so I reached out, I was very happy that you could get on and share
- 1:22your takeaways from this report.
- 1:25At first blush, I'm sure you've read it a few times.
- 1:28I read it at least once and scanned it before the call here.
- 1:30But so the report's out and from where you sit what's your take?
- 1:35Ryan: Listen, the FHFA went through, and first of all, Mark, thanks
- 1:38for having me back on the show.
- 1:40I have a repeat guest.
- 1:41I'm honored.
- 1:42I, when we think about the report, I think it's important to take a step
- 1:45back and remember the process that FHFA.
- 1:49Went through to develop the report.
- 1:52They heard from about 800 stakeholders over the course of 6 or 7 months.
- 1:59They had their listening sessions 3 days at the beginning of the process.
- 2:033 days at the end of the process.
- 2:05They held 19 regional.
- 2:09Or virtual roundtables focused on different aspects of the report,
- 2:15and they had to comment periods.
- 2:18I believe both of which I know they were both more than 30 days.
- 2:21I think that they were both 45 day comment period.
- 2:24So they took in a considerable amount of feedback from stakeholders.
- 2:29And I think that is more or less reflected in the report.
- 2:34Thank you.
- 2:34Most of what they heard.
- 2:37In fact, I'd say in excess of 80 percent of what they heard during that process
- 2:43was positive and supportive of the role that the home loan banks play in providing
- 2:51liquidity for their members and the role that they play in supporting affordable
- 2:56housing and community development.
- 2:58In fact, if you were going to have a, if you were going to try to draw a
- 3:01theme From the stakeholder feedback, it's that stakeholders want more
- 3:09from the home loan bank system.
- 3:11And I think that's a good position to be in.
- 3:13And when you consider that feedback, and then you look at the report,
- 3:17there, it certainly plots a a path provides a direction of travel to a
- 3:26place where In some respects, the home loan bank system could do more but,
- 3:32the devil's always in the details.
- 3:34What we have at this moment is we have a report coming at the
- 3:39conclusion of a very long process.
- 3:41It provides about 50 recommendations and in total, the thing that
- 3:48I would tell credit unions.
- 3:50As we've told other groups is none of the recommendations are inevitable.
- 3:54In fact, most of the recommendations are quite big.
- 3:58There's a lot of clarity.
- 3:59That is yet to come.
- 4:01But we will be engaging in the rulemaking process because there's
- 4:05a number of potential new rules coming out of this will, of course,
- 4:10be engaged in a legislative process.
- 4:13If that develops, there were statutory recommendations in this.
- 4:17And of course, the agency telegraphs in.
- 4:21In its report areas where they will use the supervisory process to change policy
- 4:26and try to achieve their their objectives.
- 4:29So we've got to stay engaged in all of this.
- 4:31But I, but.
- 4:32At a very high level, I think the report is largely additive
- 4:37to the system with however, the potential to limit or disrupt.
- 4:43Access to reliable liquidity.
- 4:48Markoverdub: Got it.
- 4:49Got it.
- 4:49So you framed up the three.
- 4:51So there's legislative, there's rulemaking, and there's
- 4:53the supervisory process.
- 4:54So putting my old NCOA hat on.
- 4:57Legislative would be for the corollary for credit unions would be a change
- 5:01to the federal credit union act.
- 5:03That's a heavy lift.
- 5:04That's a long lift.
- 5:05That's a lift that might never quite frankly happen.
- 5:08Because you want to change doesn't mean it necessarily will.
- 5:11So that's the what 5, 10 year.
- 5:14Ryan: Yeah, and I'd say, when you look at the things that are the statutory
- 5:20requirements in this report they recommend they're going to recommend to Congress to
- 5:24increase the affordable housing program.
- 5:27Minimum contribution.
- 5:29It's currently 10 percent of net earnings.
- 5:31They want to take it up to 20%.
- 5:34The homeown bank system is already moving in that direction, right?
- 5:37During this process, responding to the feedback that we heard,
- 5:42each of the banks agreed to go to 15 percent of net earnings, and
- 5:47they're working to implement it.
- 5:48That right now, so we're moving in that direction.
- 5:52Yeah, a statutory change is a heavy lift, but I think a benefit of the
- 5:58review was that we're already moving towards, towards more to HP and to
- 6:05voluntary programs, another statutory recommendation that I think was
- 6:11reflective of feedback that they heard.
- 6:15Had to do with expanding the community financial institution definition,
- 6:20and this is something that will be important to credit unions because
- 6:25right now, that definition doesn't include credit unions, but the agency
- 6:29and its report is recommending.
- 6:31To expand that definition.
- 6:33And what that means for credit unions is that if Congress makes that change,
- 6:37they will be able to pledge as collateral small business loans, agriculture loans.
- 6:43It just expands the option of collateral for credit unions.
- 6:47Then there were some other.
- 6:49Recommendations for statutory change that, frankly, weren't reflective of things
- 6:52that they heard in in the process, like giving the FHFA more power to consolidate
- 6:59home loan banks or giving them more powers around executive compensation.
- 7:03This wasn't reflective of the feedback that stakeholders gave.
- 7:08And it's hard to see Congress having much of an appetite for that in the near term.
- 7:15Got it.
- 7:15Got it.
- 7:16Markoverdub: Yeah, I remember last time we chatted that, the low housing
- 7:19initiatives and how great of a job that the federal home loan banks did.
- 7:24I wasn't aware at that juncture because again, from where I've sat in my
- 7:27history has been on liquidity side.
- 7:28But
- 7:29Ryan: Yeah, and the really the untold story is that the home loan bank system is
- 7:34the largest private sector contributor to affordable housing efforts in the country.
- 7:39It's a, Okay.
- 7:40Our contributions are a function of our earnings.
- 7:44And so when we have high earning years, like we are in right now, and as we were
- 7:50last year we're contributing even more.
- 7:53So we're contributing a lot.
- 7:55And we've committed to doing more as a function of our earnings.
- 8:00And I think that, the thing that I would take away is not only do we have a
- 8:03commitment to do more, but we heard what stakeholders were saying in this process.
- 8:08And even before FHFA put out their report, we were out there making changes to
- 8:14address the needs of our stakeholders.
- 8:17Right,
- 8:18Markoverdub: and what 15 percent is roughly one out of every 6 and 20 percent
- 8:23would be roughly one out of every 5.
- 8:25So if you take that extra dollar out of the, you give that extra dollar
- 8:29out of that equation, it's good for.
- 8:32The housing needs, but it also then the other side of that is as you're
- 8:36trying to make the federal home loan bank safe and sound, that's something
- 8:40they can't put into their reserves.
- 8:42So it's a balancing act.
- 8:43It's good if you can give it, but if, but become statutory,
- 8:47it's not a, you can, it's, you
- 8:49Ryan: must.
- 8:49That's right.
- 8:50And I think the balance and credit unions know this well, is making
- 8:54sure that you maintain the value proposition of the cooperative, right?
- 8:57Home loan banks are cooperative financial institutions, just like credit unions.
- 9:02And so it is a constant balance of how do you make sure that there is incentive for
- 9:08participation in the cooperative, while also making sure that you're meeting.
- 9:13This important aspect of the dual mission of the home loan bank system.
- 9:18So it's, we've got a part of our mission is to provide a reliable
- 9:22source of liquidity for our members.
- 9:24Another part is to support affordable housing and community development.
- 9:27It very much is a balancing act.
- 9:29Markoverdub: Got it.
- 9:29Got it.
- 9:30And then so below the legislative level, the rulemaking level what
- 9:34type of recommendations, yeah, got on your radar relative to that.
- 9:38Ryan: This is probably the.
- 9:41The biggest area of recommendations if you're bucketing them into
- 9:45these 3 categories and, what.
- 9:49I think the agency has made clear through this process and certainly in the report
- 9:55is that mission is very important.
- 9:58Clarification of the home loan bank's mission is very important and I think
- 10:06they do a relatively good job of emphasizing the, the important role
- 10:11that we play on the liquidity side for our members and as well as the
- 10:15affordable housing role that we have.
- 10:17But if you ask me, what are they going to try to tackle?
- 10:211st?
- 10:22I wouldn't be surprised if out of the gate.
- 10:25They issued a proposed rule that clarifies their regulatory mission statement.
- 10:31And that will that, I think, will provide some opportunity for additional
- 10:35feedback to the agency and perhaps some direction in that regard.
- 10:40Another issue that.
- 10:43They, I hope will try to tackle early on is simplification of
- 10:48the affordable housing program.
- 10:50So we've been talking about how we're putting more resources into, but 1 of
- 10:56the things that we heard during the process was, it's really complicated.
- 11:00To get AHP dollars that there's a lot of regulatory burden.
- 11:05There's duplicative requirements.
- 11:07And so I and the agencies acknowledge this.
- 11:10They in their report they indicate that they're gonna work on simplifying that
- 11:14program, and I think that will help make those dollars have a greater impact.
- 11:19When they're when they're given out.
- 11:21So that's another area of rulemaking that we're paying attention to.
- 11:26There is there are some things I think to be concerned with, though,
- 11:31from from the report, the agency has indicated that they're going to
- 11:35pursue rulemaking that would provide a Ongoing mortgage asset test.
- 11:41So Mark, you are probably aware in order to join the home loan bank system, a
- 11:45member has to have 10 percent of their assets and mortgage related assets.
- 11:50What they have said in the report is that they want to have some sort of
- 11:55ongoing mortgage asset test for members.
- 11:58I think that what this does.
- 12:01Along with some of the other changes that they're proposing is it really
- 12:05starts to add questions about whether or not the home loan bank will be
- 12:10there when a member needs liquidity.
- 12:12If I, if you're a home loan bank member, you've got to check to see if you're, if
- 12:16you've got enough mortgage assets before a loan if you're the home loan bank, you
- 12:22may have to set up a process where you're checking on that before you give the loan.
- 12:26If.
- 12:27Nothing else.
- 12:28It slows down that process.
- 12:31Another concern that we've got is the recommendation around.
- 12:35Changing the definition of a long term advance right now, if you
- 12:39take an advance out that's longer than five years in duration that is
- 12:44considered a long term advance, and those proceeds of the advance have to
- 12:49go for additional mortgage activity.
- 12:53The report contemplates reducing that to one year.
- 12:58What impact will that have on our members?
- 13:00How they use the home loan bank.
- 13:03Whether they see us as a, a strong value proposition remains to be seen.
- 13:08We will be, we would be, we'll be concerned about that rulemaking and
- 13:13we'll be doing some analysis on the potential impact on it, on that.
- 13:17There's a whole host of regulatory changes.
- 13:19Now, the thing about it is, as Mark, the regulatory process.
- 13:23Takes a great deal of time from the proposal of an A.
- 13:28M.
- 13:28P.
- 13:28R.
- 13:29to the effective date of a final rule.
- 13:32That can be years.
- 13:33And so there will be opportunity for stakeholders to weigh in
- 13:38through the comment process.
- 13:40I anticipate that there will be some congressional interest.
- 13:44In some of these some of these rules.
- 13:46And so we're gonna need credit unions and other home loan
- 13:49bank members to be engaged.
- 13:51And we're working closely with una and Nafq America's credit unions,
- 13:55America's credit unions to exactly to and the state leagues, of course, to
- 13:59make sure that we've got information for credit unions and when the time
- 14:02comes, they'll be ready to engage.
- 14:04Markoverdub: Yeah, as you're talking through that creating additional
- 14:07regulatory burden where you're slowing down the institution, having to
- 14:10check a bucket a and bucket B before they can get the funds in your.
- 14:15And you're slowing down the federal, the individual federal home loan bank,
- 14:17where they having to do X, Y, and Z.
- 14:20It reminded me of one of my favorite books, which is atomic habits.
- 14:23And one of the things about having good, one of the concepts in the books
- 14:27is friction creating, your good habits, you want to remove friction and your
- 14:31bad habits, you want to create friction.
- 14:34The.
- 14:35It's counter, it's counter to the philosophies of that book from the
- 14:39perspective of if you're creating friction on the most important, or one of the most
- 14:45important elements of what an institution gets out of it and you're making it
- 14:49harder You're putting a burden in there that might lessen the ability to assist.
- 14:55And going back to Signature Bank and SVB and all that.
- 14:59The ability to move quickly is one of the biggest strengths of the system.
- 15:04Ryan: Absolutely.
- 15:05And, first of all Atomic Habits, great book, highly endorse it.
- 15:09I don't know what it says about me that multiple people have
- 15:12given me that book as a gift.
- 15:14But I've given it to my kids.
- 15:16So it's a really, it's a really good book.
- 15:18But to your point, Mark, when we think about March, 2023, a lot of
- 15:23the focus is on SVB and Signature and First Republic and Silvergate.
- 15:28And certainly they were members of the home loan bank system.
- 15:30There was activity, but in March, 2023, the most important thing that
- 15:37the home loan banks did was the access to liquidity they provided
- 15:42to the 6,500 members of the system.
- 15:44So that there was, they were a stabilizing force during a time of turmoil.
- 15:49And that's lost in a lot of the, a lot of the reporting,
- 15:53but it shouldn't be because.
- 15:55For us to be there, our members have to have confidence that we'll
- 15:59be able to meet their needs, right?
- 16:01So that anything that.
- 16:05Is put into place, whether it's through the regulatory process or the supervisory
- 16:09process that undermines their confidence in us, undermines their ability to
- 16:16receive that on demand liquidity really creates that friction that will, I think,
- 16:22create some instability in the future.
- 16:25Yeah,
- 16:25Markoverdub: And that's going to be, that's going to be.
- 16:27Really, as you're getting your members thoughts and CUNA and NAFCU, America's
- 16:32Credit Unions are getting those member thoughts, it's going to be very important
- 16:35for the stakeholders to make the FHFA and Congress aware of that as you, it's
- 16:42almost like you're entering the playoffs now, the report coming out it's great
- 16:46it's out, but but now you've got to double down on the efforts to make sure
- 16:49that the recommendations are handled
- 16:51appropriately.
- 16:52Ryan: That, no, you're exactly right.
- 16:56I'm going to put a timeline out there.
- 16:58It's just more of a big long number.
- 17:00But this report probably creates about a decade's worth of work, right?
- 17:04If the agency was going to go through and try to get everything
- 17:08done, it probably take 10 years.
- 17:11Now the thing about it is not everything's going to be done.
- 17:14Not, you can't have 50 priorities.
- 17:16So they're going to focus on.
- 17:18The ones they think are most impactful, and I think stakeholders are going to come
- 17:23to the table with their thoughts on FHFA's proposed rules or the statutory changes.
- 17:30And there, there is, there's still a lot of process ahead of us.
- 17:34Markoverdub: That's right.
- 17:35That's right.
- 17:35Yeah, if everything's a priority, nothing's a priority.
- 17:37So that's right.
- 17:39Great point.
- 17:40That leaves the supervisory process.
- 17:43There's things that may fall down to that level.
- 17:46I'm guessing there's things that the that you and the federal home loan
- 17:49banks might prefer that if you're going to do it, you should regulate
- 17:52it because we can get more comment.
- 17:53But if that process plays out well, and, again, putting my head
- 17:57on a letter to credit unions.
- 18:00That doesn't go through the public process can put burdens on the credit
- 18:03unions and then NCUA always dovetails into the, the safety and soundness
- 18:08arena to try and give it a little bit of a hook to quasi enforce it.
- 18:13Is there, are there similar issues and concerns as it relates
- 18:17to how this might play out?
- 18:19Ryan: Yeah, there's a lot of commentary in the report about the efforts
- 18:23that they're going to undertake to strengthen member risk management
- 18:26to limit large debt issuances.
- 18:29The the definition of a stressed member the process for, handing members off to
- 18:37the Fed when they're troubled, a lot of things that the terms, are vague enough
- 18:44that they probably deserve more sunlight on them as the policies are developed.
- 18:50And you're going through, you're up HFA, you're going through this huge process.
- 18:55You're trying to get it right for the centennial of the system in 9 years.
- 19:01It just seems like it makes a lot of sense to keep as much
- 19:04out in the sunlight as possible.
- 19:07Particularly when the changes could have an impact.
- 19:12On the members, the value proposition and the impact of the home loan bank system.
- 19:17As Mark, the supervisory processes is really there's really a cloak over it.
- 19:23But when you're making policy through the supervisory process, there shouldn't be.
- 19:29And we're going to, I think, encourage the agency to do as much out in the open.
- 19:37As possible so that our members know what to expect when they come to
- 19:40the home loan bank for liquidity.
- 19:43Markoverdub: Now, that all makes sense.
- 19:44That all makes sense.
- 19:45This I know a lot more about the report now that we've chatted about it.
- 19:49Is there anything Ryan that else you'd like to say about it?
- 19:52Or is there a question?
- 19:53I should have asked you here this morning that I didn't.
- 19:58Ryan: tHe one thing that I would just emphasize for credit unions
- 20:00and frankly, for all home loan bank members is that nothing's changed
- 20:04because of this report, right?
- 20:06Today, while we're talking, these are just recommendations.
- 20:10They're in a nice, glossy document.
- 20:13There hasn't been a proposed rule issued.
- 20:16There hasn't been a bill written.
- 20:18Credit unions that are members of their home loan bank should Thank Approach
- 20:22their home loan bank just like they would for liquidity and should expect to get
- 20:26the service that they've always that they've always received and enjoyed.
- 20:31We are going to enter a policymaking process now, and it's going to be
- 20:35critical just like when credit unions engage on interchange, on a tax
- 20:40status, all of the credit union issues that I worked on for so many years.
- 20:45It's going to be critical for them to engage on this because
- 20:47they're stakeholders in this.
- 20:48They are, they're members of.
- 20:51This financial cooperative.
- 20:53And as I told credit unions for years, if the folks that are most invested in the
- 20:58cooperative aren't speaking up for the cooperative, who will we need members to
- 21:02engage and we'll be working with America's credit unions and the state credit
- 21:06union leagues to ensure that they've got the information that they need in
- 21:11order to be engaged in these processes.
- 21:13Markoverdub: Well said.
- 21:14Yeah, that's a good rap.
- 21:15They don't, if they enjoy what the federal home loan banks are doing for them and
- 21:19they want to keep it, they need to stay engaged and they need to be available.
- 21:23And give a little bit of time to the system and make their thoughts known.
- 21:26So that's fabulous, Brian.
- 21:28So if someone listening wants to do that, and obviously you can do it
- 21:32through the leagues, through QNUC through NAVQ, is there, if there's
- 21:36something here that they, that triggered their mind that they'd like to reach
- 21:39out to you or your organization, what would be the best way for them,
- 21:43Ryan: To do that?
- 21:44Let me offer a couple of suggestions.
- 21:45One, I am very active on LinkedIn.
- 21:48And the council is as well.
- 21:49So seek me out on LinkedIn.
- 21:51I will I'll connect with you and follow you or whatever the term is
- 21:55on LinkedIn, but that's a really good way of reach me as, Mark, because
- 21:58that's how you reached out to me.
- 22:00The council also has a a LinkedIn page too, that is good to follow.
- 22:04And then my email address is our Donovan at C F H L B.
- 22:09org.
- 22:10So that's also a good way to reach
- 22:11Markoverdub: me.
- 22:12Okay, great.
- 22:12And I'll put in the show notes, your link to your LinkedIn and a LinkedIn
- 22:16to the council's LinkedIn page.
- 22:18So if someone pulls it up, they can connect with you via the podcast.
- 22:23Notes.
- 22:23So Ryan, thanks so much.
- 22:25I know you're real busy right now with this just having coming out.
- 22:27I really appreciate you giving me some time this morning to highlight.
- 22:31No,
- 22:31Ryan: happy to anytime,
- 22:32Markoverdub: Mark.
- 22:33Thanks.
- 22:33You got it.
- 22:33All right.
- 22:34Thanks so much.
- 22:35And listeners, I want to thank you for listening.
- 22:37Hope you'll listen again soon.
- 22:38This is Mark Treichel signing off.
- 22:40With flying colors