Latest / Newcomer Pod / Talking Threads With the Facebook Whistleblower Frances Haugen
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, it's Eric Newcomer. Welcome to the Newcomer Podcast.
- 0:04A really exciting episode this week.
- 0:07We're talking to a whistleblower, Francis Haugett,
- 0:10the Facebook whistleblower is on the show.
- 0:12I feel like we've been building to this for a literal years.
- 0:15I've been talking about Facebook's content moderation,
- 0:18the implications of her release to the Wall Street Journal of
- 0:21the Facebook Files, and her decision to go public.
- 0:24And we really got into the substance of it.
- 0:26I feel like so much of the discussion around social media.
- 0:29Moderation is sort of built for a simplistic public consumption,
- 0:34and I really tried to get into the meat of these issues and
- 0:37what potential policy solutions there are.
- 0:42So give it a list. Francis Alga and Facebook
- 0:45whistleblower, Welcome to the Newcomer podcast, author of The
- 0:48Power of 1. Thanks for joining me.
- 0:51Thank you for inviting. Happy to be here.
- 0:53I have followed your story, the Wall Street Journal reporting
- 0:56now the book super closely. So really excited to have the
- 1:00conversation. You know, the Facebook Files
- 1:04series and sort of the complaints about Facebook can be
- 1:08so sprawling, like there's so much to it.
- 1:12So I just wanted to start off the conversation.
- 1:14If you had to sum up the top Facebook sin or you're like main
- 1:19core objection, what is your top?
- 1:22Facebook objection. So I would say the through line
- 1:25that goes through all of the different kind of shocking, you
- 1:28know, headline, exclamation mark type things that came out of the
- 1:31Facebook files. And to remind people who maybe
- 1:34don't remember exactly what happened about two years ago,
- 1:36you know, it ranged everything from Facebook.
- 1:38We knew they were human traffickers on the platform and
- 1:41worried more about offending the buyers than the people being
- 1:45sold. Or Facebook had lots of research
- 1:48on their products, making kids unhappy, making them depressed.
- 1:51Facilitating eating disorders, refused to hand it over to the
- 1:54Senate when asked. You know what On and on and on.
- 1:57But the thing that was the common through line, I would say
- 2:00through all those things is we live in a world where Facebook
- 2:04has to report publicly it's profit and loss numbers, It's
- 2:08expenses like how it got to that profit and loss, but it doesn't
- 2:12have to report a social balance sheet, you know, like what's the
- 2:16social costs of making those dollars and for most other
- 2:19industries. Those public costs, those
- 2:22externalities are very obvious. You know, it's pollution in a
- 2:25river, it's pollution in the air, it's forced labor.
- 2:28You know, we can see what's going on with digital products.
- 2:33You can take from the social side of the balance sheet and
- 2:36make your economic balance sheet look a lot better.
- 2:39And that's the core problem that is repeated over and over again
- 2:42across all of these, all these harms.
- 2:44Yeah. And I mean, that really sort of
- 2:46comes through in the book. I mean, you make the point that
- 2:48like, you know, Apple, it would be sort of visible with a
- 2:51hardware device, whereas with this social media company like
- 2:54Facebook, it's less visible. Is it a matter of the fact that
- 2:59Facebook is customizing feeds from person to person or is it
- 3:04more than that, what makes Facebook's products so much,
- 3:07like, less visible than something more tangible?
- 3:11The point I make in the book is if you go search for Apple
- 3:14whistleblower, you don't find a lot.
- 3:17Like, there are occasionally Apple whistleblowers, but
- 3:19they're not like Facebook whistleblowers.
- 3:21Like I I always kind of bristle when people describe me as the
- 3:24Facebook whistleblower because there's a new Facebook
- 3:26whistleblower every two weeks, you know, often with really big
- 3:30revelations. It's not like there's one person
- 3:32in the company that's feeding all that out there.
- 3:34It's like a whole range of conscientious people who know
- 3:37the public need to be brought in.
- 3:39So you can ask the question, like, why is that?
- 3:41Like, why is it Apple isn't producing the same volume or
- 3:44intensity of whistleblowers, But I think it's that when Apple
- 3:48launches a new iPhone, you know, within a couple of hours of that
- 3:52iPhone going on store shelves. Don't be YouTube videos live
- 3:57like already live where people have taken apart those phones
- 4:00and confirmed like yes that processor is in there.
- 4:03Right. They'll be like, oh, they added
- 4:04a hard drive and now the hard drive slightly slower because of
- 4:08it. Yeah, exactly.
- 4:10It's very visible to people. But when it comes to what I call
- 4:13opaque systems. And more and more of our economy
- 4:17is going to be run by opaque systems.
- 4:19So that's things like a large language model that lives on a
- 4:23data center and all you see is the outputs, you don't see the
- 4:26inputs, you don't see out there manipulated.
- 4:28It could be a social media site. So like you said before is the
- 4:31problem because we all see something slightly different.
- 4:35That's definitely a huge part of it.
- 4:37So if we were talking about Google, have you ever programmed
- 4:40before? No, I'm not a programmer.
- 4:42I know you're not going to believe me when I say this, but
- 4:44if you and I sat down for three weeks, I could teach you enough
- 4:48programming that you could ask real, meaningful questions about
- 4:52how Google works. You know, what's getting
- 4:54distributed? What's not getting distributed?
- 4:56How prominent are different kinds of things?
- 4:58What kinds of answers does Google give if we want to do the
- 5:02same kind of accountability? 101 for Facebook?
- 5:06Free Instagram. Don't even mention tick tock,
- 5:09tick tock. It's way harder because it's
- 5:10video. Right.
- 5:11It's bandwidth intensive. You know how much hard it is to
- 5:14a video podcast than an audio podcast?
- 5:17We'd have to recruit 20,000 volunteers and convince them to
- 5:21install software on their phones that would send back what they
- 5:25saw on these platforms. It's a an entirely different
- 5:30order of magnitude in terms of difficulty, and Facebook knows
- 5:34that. With TikTok, sort of.
- 5:36I really understand it right where it feels so tailored to
- 5:39the human being. And it's.
- 5:41Sort of machine learning driven where it feels like is there
- 5:44even someone over at TikTok who really gets exactly why I'm
- 5:48getting what I am? I mean but Facebook at least in
- 5:50the beginning was supposed to be more like network based and like
- 5:54friend based. Which?
- 5:55Felt like, yeah, easier to trace.
- 5:58Do you think it's totally moved away from that or why?
- 6:02Why is Facebook so much harder to follow than at Google?
- 6:07So by the time I got to Facebook in 2019. 60% of everything
- 6:12people in the United States viewed came from a Facebook
- 6:16group. It wasn't content from your
- 6:18family and friends anymore. It's one of these things where
- 6:21one of the projects my nonprofit is going to work on, let's go
- 6:24beyond the screen because we help people see beyond their
- 6:28screens, is doing a simulated social network.
- 6:31Because, you know, it's like you brought up before a lot of
- 6:34people if you were to stop them on the street and say, what is
- 6:37Facebook for? And they would say it's about
- 6:39connecting with my family and friends.
- 6:41But if you were to actually go and look under the hood that
- 6:46products, you know, that product where the only things you saw in
- 6:49your feed were things that your family and friends posted, that
- 6:52world is long gone. And the reason why it changed
- 6:55was Facebook is an advertising supported business.
- 6:59You know, as you scroll, you see an ad, they make money, you
- 7:03click on that ad, they get money.
- 7:05They have a motivation to get you to conceal more and more
- 7:09higher value ads every single month.
- 7:11You know, the more time you spend on the platform, the more
- 7:14content you view, the more ad dollars come in.
- 7:18They had a huge motivation to figure out how can they make
- 7:21sure your feed is always full of really stimulating content.
- 7:25What's interesting about TikTok is TikTok said.
- 7:27Hey, we don't want to wait to get critical mass.
- 7:32You know, in the case of Facebook or like creating a
- 7:34Facebook competitor, when the expectation from the user is the
- 7:38things that I see come from my family and friends, you have the
- 7:42like a chicken and egg problem where you need to get all of the
- 7:46person's friends before the person wants to join, right?
- 7:49Like how do you make that happen with something like TikTok or
- 7:52now Threads? Threads has a very similar
- 7:55model. And that's Facebook's new
- 7:56Twitter competitor. There's much less of a user
- 8:00promise of what you're going to see.
- 8:02So when you show up, they don't have to wait for critical mass.
- 8:06They just need to entertain you. But at the same time, now you're
- 8:09putting yourself in the hands of an algorithm you know, You
- 8:13better understand what the biases are in that algorithm,
- 8:16what it shows you and doesn't show you, because now the
- 8:18algorithm is in control, not your friends and family.
- 8:21You brought up threads and I I too see the similarity with
- 8:25TikTok where it's, you know, it's bite size.
- 8:27You know, it's not as tied to even like a follower network as
- 8:31Twitter because they needed it to work right away.
- 8:34So it feels like, oh man, this is going to be really powered by
- 8:37machine learning pretty quickly. Like as you know a reporter.
- 8:41It's funny to see sort of the reporter class sort of embracing
- 8:45threads at the moment when I feel like.
- 8:47You know two years ago or more than that, they would have been
- 8:50so negative and apprehensive about trusting Facebook.
- 8:55I'm just curious like watching the sort of pretty upbeat
- 8:59response to threads, what do you take from that?
- 9:02And like, are you surprised that there seems to be some Media
- 9:07Trust of Facebook right now? I.
- 9:09Think that's probably a sense where the trauma the Twitter
- 9:13community has faced in the last year?
- 9:16It's pretty intense. You know, it's one of the things
- 9:18where, you know, Twitter never really went down that often, now
- 9:21goes down regularly. It used to be, you know, as Jack
- 9:24Dorsey, the former CEO, has pointed out recently, you know,
- 9:27it used to be basically when you posted, things went live
- 9:30instantaneously. And now they're, you know, he
- 9:32flagged that they were now, you know, a minute or two delays
- 9:35between when you posted and when it went out to people.
- 9:38I think Elon Musk really gave himself an incredibly hard hill
- 9:42to climb when he bought the company using so much debt.
- 9:46Because when that happened, it meant that he put a clock on
- 9:49himself. You know, he has to make a
- 9:51billion dollars of profit a year and a product that was maybe
- 9:55breaking even before he bought it, It was really hard.
- 9:59And he's had lots of advertisers flee.
- 10:01So I think there's further the positive reporting on threads is
- 10:05that people really liked having a space to discuss ideas, to
- 10:10discuss issues and the idea that they could have a space again.
- 10:15Feels really good. Just to say another way, it's
- 10:17like people were so frustrated with Twitter that give them some
- 10:21openness to trust Facebook again.
- 10:23Or Meadow, whatever we're calling it these days anyway.
- 10:26Continue. It's interesting, like this is
- 10:28still true, but people were reporting the, you know, the
- 10:31first day to of threads. You weren't even given the
- 10:34option to just receive content from people you chose.
- 10:38Like it really is like talking that way where you have to put
- 10:42yourselves in the hand of the algorithm.
- 10:44And be like algorithm. May I please?
- 10:45Yeah, there's no follower feed. Does that mean you haven't
- 10:48downloaded it? Are you personally?
- 10:49I have not. I have not.
- 10:51Isn't that I'm unwilling to download it.
- 10:52I just haven't got around to download it yet.
- 10:54And I as someone who worked on Google Plus.
- 10:57So for your listeners who may not remember, you know tech 12
- 11:00years ago. Yeah, Google said, hey, there
- 11:04are flaws with Facebook, like we should make a version of
- 11:06Facebook that doesn't have those issues.
- 11:09And in reality, you know, they were trying to go after the
- 11:11personal social media market that's like you can actually
- 11:14with people, you know, but they because they wanted to grow so
- 11:17fast, they basically made something very similar to
- 11:19Twitter. And you know, growing too fast
- 11:22is actually a problem because it means that when people go and
- 11:26take that chance on you, they don't land in a functioning
- 11:31community. They land in chaos.
- 11:32And they don't really understand what the point is.
- 11:34They don't understand what the point of this place is, doesn't
- 11:37feel like a place and they move on.
- 11:39And at least some of the initial data around engagement, It seems
- 11:42like that's a very similar problem to what Facebook is
- 11:44facing right now. People were willing to download
- 11:46it with threats, yeah. I mean, one thing Facebook did
- 11:50differently is they, like, prepopulated it with all these
- 11:53celebrities. Yeah.
- 11:54So they had that. And they had obviously the
- 11:57Instagram sort of connection to flow people in.
- 12:00But I agree there's a lot of similarity, especially and, you
- 12:02know, I mean, what's is it Google Plus, man, I can't even
- 12:05remember the name. You just said it.
- 12:07Google Plus. Yeah.
- 12:09They like, I mean they got a ton of users in the beginning I, you
- 12:12know, I was on it for a second and then it sort of faded.
- 12:15So it's very possible. I mean Threads takes that same
- 12:19arc, I don't think that's my personal view.
- 12:21I mean is that a prediction or do you think this will be like a
- 12:25Google Plus situation? I think one of the things that's
- 12:27interesting about Twitter is the way Einstein's like to frame
- 12:31Twitter is. Twitter is fueled by content
- 12:35from a relatively small fraction of its users.
- 12:38Who are most interested in the thoughts of that other small
- 12:42fraction of users? So I talked to a law professor
- 12:46who is regularly cited in tech discussions and she was like I
- 12:50use Twitter to hear from 300 other people and just happens to
- 12:54be that those people talking to each other and caring about what
- 12:58each other says everyone else gets to kind of be a fly on the
- 13:01wall and follow along for the conversation.
- 13:03There are people like Elon Musk who love like raising up their
- 13:06followers and like having direct conversations with a wide spot
- 13:09that people. But I'd say the fuel, the real
- 13:12core of Twitter is those, you know, communities of connection
- 13:18and it'll be really interesting to see if threads can maintain
- 13:21that. Like is it just going to end up
- 13:23kind of a brand safe By brand safe, I mean for, you know even
- 13:27sell Tide, Washington, GA. And Clorox, you know, bleach
- 13:31one. Yeah, they're very programs,
- 13:33definitely. Really.
- 13:34Is it going to be just a space that is, like innocuous?
- 13:37Or is it going to be a space that really does cultivate
- 13:39community the way Twitter did? I mean it also, you know, it
- 13:43feels like you could have one community on threads and one on
- 13:48Twitter, especially with the part, you know, like I mean
- 13:51you're seeing Elon right now, he's like making these payments
- 13:54out to. Twitter personalities, it feels
- 13:57like extremely conservative. I mean you could just see sort
- 13:59of more left wing liberal, sort of, you know, people on threads
- 14:04and sort of a right wing Twitter world.
- 14:07It's very possible. I can totally imagine that
- 14:09happening. It makes me nervous because like
- 14:11when we do move into a space where we are entirely dependent
- 14:15on an algorithm like, I have no idea if I post on threads like,
- 14:20will my posts even get distributed?
- 14:22You know, like my publisher couldn't even tag it to sell the
- 14:25book, right? So it's things like that.
- 14:28Wait, you think Facebook is like actively suppressing your book
- 14:33on their platforms or? I know that for events I've
- 14:36done, they couldn't use the word Facebook to describe the event.
- 14:40So I can't be the Facebook whistleblower.
- 14:42I can be a whistleblower. Like, you know, they'll have to
- 14:44sit there and try a bunch of different variation of ads to
- 14:47run an ad I was told by my publisher was, you know.
- 14:51They sell lots of books. They post about lots of books on
- 14:54Instagram. They went through and tried to
- 14:57tag my book and they got back an e-mail saying that it violated
- 15:00the commerce policy for Instagram.
- 15:03And they paint their like, concierge because they spent
- 15:07enough money on ads that they get, you know, a human shot to.
- 15:10And the person was like, I don't know why this would violate the
- 15:13commerce policy. I mean, there's not white
- 15:15community. There's no violence, you know,
- 15:17whatever. And yeah, so they they don't
- 15:20know why. I mean, do you think Facebook
- 15:23just has a blanket ban on people using the word Facebook?
- 15:26Ooh, I don't know. I've had other experiences, like
- 15:29the Nobel Peace Center had an event that I spoke at, and they
- 15:34had never had an ad blocked for being a political ad until they
- 15:39advertised my event. So think about that.
- 15:41Like, do you think the events at the Nobel Peace Center are
- 15:43political? I think most of all are.
- 15:46Right. So.
- 15:48It is what it is. Have you interacted much with
- 15:50Facebook otherwise or like? Have you had any direct
- 15:53engagement since you left? I think if I was more of a
- 15:57troll, you know I have a little bit of troll, not like a huge
- 16:00amount of troll in my heart. I have like a enough troll for
- 16:03spark, right. I would totally promote them
- 16:06more because they so aggressively will not
- 16:10acknowledge that I exist. So if like for example, if you
- 16:13ever get to be in a Q&A session with a Facebook executive like
- 16:17at a conference. Ask them about me because they
- 16:20will not use my name. So that's the kind of thing
- 16:22we're like. If I was a bigger troll I would
- 16:24see more questions at their events, but you know, I have
- 16:27other things to do so. Back to sort of the core
- 16:31disclosures, you know, in the book and I mean clearly you talk
- 16:35about sort of them lying and I'm just curious like what you think
- 16:40sort of the core or like great examples of like Facebook's
- 16:44deceit? Have been because I mean there's
- 16:46obviously they have such an information advantage where it's
- 16:49like, yeah, they can just run circles around anybody trying to
- 16:52scrutinize them because they understand the platform so much
- 16:55more. But the cases where they were,
- 16:57you know, lying. Flagrant so I'll give you an
- 17:00example. This is one of the core parts,
- 17:03and I complain. Back in 2018, Facebook faced a
- 17:06business problem. You know, they could see over
- 17:09time people were making less and less content.
- 17:12This is a normal phenomenon on social networks like some people
- 17:15get really into it. Most people slowly start to self
- 17:18edit self censor and they tried a bunch of experiments on you
- 17:23and I to see could they induce us to produce more content.
- 17:29And one of the things I know, it's like guess what your
- 17:31experiments are on every day every time you're on one of
- 17:33these platforms. So it turns out if they
- 17:36artificially. Get you twice as many likes and
- 17:40the way they do this is they just keep showing your your post
- 17:43to more and more people until you get to that number of likes.
- 17:46If they can get you up to you know twice as many likes you
- 17:50produce more content. You know it's a very clear like
- 17:54dose response that if you feel more social rewards more little
- 17:58hits of dopamine you make no. So they came out and said we
- 18:03don't want people mindlessly scrolling.
- 18:06You know, mindlessly scrolling, that's bad for people.
- 18:09So we're no longer going to prioritize content on Facebook.
- 18:13They start how much time you're going to spend on the platform.
- 18:16That's like, you know, it could be a prophecy for like how much
- 18:19you enjoy consuming things. Instead, we're going to reward
- 18:24meaningful social interactions. So I think about a phrase like
- 18:28that, it's like, what is a like to you?
- 18:29What is a meaningful social interaction?
- 18:32Something that, you know, like a day later I'd reflect on and
- 18:35say, oh, that was like a good thing.
- 18:37And I'm like glad it happened you.
- 18:39Know. Or maybe like your friends
- 18:40shared something really revealing and you wrote a
- 18:43comment saying, you know, that's hard.
- 18:44I'm really glad you shared that. You like that sounds like a
- 18:47meaningful social interaction. In reality it was just was there
- 18:51any social interaction, right? So you could put bullying or
- 18:56hate speech in a comment and that would be considered
- 18:59meaningful social interaction. And within six months of this,
- 19:04researchers across Europe on the left and the right, local
- 19:07parties, local parties on the left and the right were telling
- 19:11Facebook researchers, we know you changed the algorithm.
- 19:15It used to be we could post like a white paper on our
- 19:18agricultural policy and we get it.
- 19:20It's like, not the most thrilling thing in the world.
- 19:22Didn't get a lot of comments. Well, we could see from the
- 19:25stats that people spend time with it.
- 19:27They read it. Now if we post that same kind
- 19:31of, you know, bread and butter content, nothing.
- 19:33It's crickets. Like, we're being forced to run
- 19:36positions that are so extreme that we know our constituents
- 19:39don't support them. But like, our job is to run
- 19:42social media. Like we have to, like, put stuff
- 19:44out there and it has to work or we'll lose our jobs.
- 19:47And what's kind of crazy about this is in some ways Facebook
- 19:50acknowledged implicitly they had a problem.
- 19:53Because they put out, excuse me, Mark Zuckerberg put out a white
- 19:56paper, probably one of his employees.
- 19:59It's like 5000 words long. I really doubt Mark wrote it.
- 20:02It said, hey, this engagement based ranking thing we just
- 20:06launched, there's a problem, which is people are drawn to
- 20:10engage with extreme content. But don't worry, don't worry.
- 20:14And you know, we ask people afterwards, did you like it?
- 20:16They say, no, we're going to protect you from the lowest
- 20:19extreme content by taking it down.
- 20:20We're going to have these magical a I systems.
- 20:23And even their solution to their first lie was another lie,
- 20:28because those systems that they claimed we take down all the bad
- 20:31stuff, they were only successfully removing 3 to 5% of
- 20:34things like hate speech were less than 1% of violence, right?
- 20:39It's kind of crazy when you think about it, but they told
- 20:41everyone from Congress to, you know, the, you know, teachers
- 20:45unions, like we're protecting people, But in fact, it was all
- 20:49kind of smoke and mirrors. I think this is the policy
- 20:51solution you want, or at least the one that would seem to sort
- 20:54of come from what you're saying is like okay, some sort of
- 20:57disclosure where, you know, outsiders can sort of track how
- 21:01this is all happening. I mean, how possible is that?
- 21:05I mean, every social media network is so different.
- 21:08You know, I'm a capitalist. I want companies to be able to
- 21:10change and react and like, you don't want a bunch of laws that
- 21:14like, say, oh, you need to disclose things this way and so.
- 21:17Now you're forced with a certain type of the same network you've
- 21:20had, Instead of evolving, how would you see a disclosure
- 21:24regime working that still allows companies like Facebook to be
- 21:28flexible and to change? Let's actually unpack for a
- 21:31second something you just said, which was, I think a lot of
- 21:34people don't sit and think about what's the menu of options when
- 21:38it comes to intervening in a problem as complicated as this,
- 21:41right? I'm really glad that you brought
- 21:43up the idea that these companies grow a change.
- 21:46Where that, well, you know the next one to come along might not
- 21:48fit the exact same walls of this one.
- 21:50One of the ways the European Union handles that flexibility
- 21:54and and to be really clear like this kind of way of doing
- 21:58regulation of saying disclosure and transparency is in instead
- 22:02of something like what's happening in say Utah, where
- 22:05Utah is coming in and saying this is how you will write your
- 22:08company. If people are under 18, they
- 22:09have to have parent supervision no privacy for kids.
- 22:12Their parents can see everything.
- 22:13We're like Montana coming out and just flat out banning
- 22:16Tiktok. Those are kind of we'll call
- 22:18them building fences, type rules where we're like, oh, this is
- 22:21the fence you can't cross. And the thing about technology
- 22:24is they it moves and changes and they're very good at running
- 22:26around fences. So the alternative is something
- 22:30like what the European Union passed last year, which is
- 22:33called the Digital Services Act. And the Digital Services Act
- 22:36says, hey, if the core problem, you know we started at the
- 22:39beginning of this conversation, if the core problem.
- 22:42Is a power imbalance, right, Like the fact that you can know
- 22:46what's going on and I can't know.
- 22:49Let's address that core problem because a lot of other things
- 22:52will flow downstream from it. So they say, hey, if you know
- 22:56there's a risk of your product, you need to tell us about it.
- 23:00You know, if you discover one, if you can, you know, imagine
- 23:04one, you need to tell us about it.
- 23:05You need to tell us your plan for mitigating it, because it's
- 23:07going to be different for every platform.
- 23:09We want to unleash innovation. And you need to give us enough
- 23:13data that we could see that there was progress going on to
- 23:16meet that goal. And if we ask you a question, we
- 23:20deserve to get an answer, which sounds really basic but is not
- 23:23true today. You know, I've been asked
- 23:25questions by governments around the world that are very basic,
- 23:28like how many moderators speak German.
- 23:32I've gotten that question but for different languages all
- 23:34around the world. And it's because Facebook
- 23:36doesn't have to answer. They don't even have to answer
- 23:38things like how many users are there in your country?
- 23:41Which is extremely frustrating given that Facebook stance has
- 23:44always been where their move has been like, regulate us.
- 23:47Like, you know, not all these decisions should be made by a
- 23:50private company, like. And then it's like, oh, well,
- 23:53then why don't you give at least the governments around the world
- 23:56or the information they would need to write good regulations?
- 23:59So, I mean, obviously you're talking to a journalist, so
- 24:02disclosure is always gonna be something I'm gonna cheer for,
- 24:04but certainly a frustrating situation.
- 24:06To provide a road map, though, so my nonprofit, it's called
- 24:09Beyond the Screen. One of our core projects is
- 24:12called Standard of Care where we are working to build out a wiki
- 24:16that people can contribute to around identifying the problems
- 24:20of social media. What are the surface areas or
- 24:23what we call the levers for preventing or mitigating harm
- 24:27and then what are the strategies for pulling those levers.
- 24:30So just to give context on that, you know a lot of the problems
- 24:34around kids. A lever that is common across
- 24:37them is let's keep under 13 year olds off these systems.
- 24:41But when the kids advocates talk about technology, they often
- 24:46don't know what's possible and so they'll settle on solutions
- 24:49that might seem obvious but have problems.
- 24:51So for example, in the case of the lever of keeping under 13
- 24:54year olds off the platform, they'll say let's check ID's,
- 24:57which I don't think you want, I don't think I want.
- 24:59It also just doesn't work. But if you've gone to a
- 25:02technologist and said, hey, I have this lever.
- 25:06Let's keep under 13 year olds off the platform.
- 25:09That technologist could come back and say here's 10 or 15
- 25:11different ways to find under 13 year olds.
- 25:14You know, some of it's really basic, like kids will say I'm a
- 25:16fourth grader or things like I learned this one from my
- 25:18principal. Kids report each other, like to
- 25:21punish each other. So like you're mean to me on the
- 25:24playground and I'll report your Instagram account and as soon as
- 25:27you find 10,000 kids, you can find all the other ones.
- 25:32And so the way I think this could tie into transparency.
- 25:35Is once we have a menu saying these are the harms, these are
- 25:39the surface areas, the levers for addressing each of those
- 25:43harms. You can come in and say okay.
- 25:45Then we at a minimum like I think there should be raw data
- 25:48assets for researchers. But if you don't want to go that
- 25:50far, at a minimum you can say we need data on how bad each of
- 25:54those harms are and how hard you're pulling the levers to try
- 25:59to reduce those problems. You can figure out lots of
- 26:02different strategies to pull those levers.
- 26:04But you need to show U.S. data on things like under 13 year
- 26:07olds, how late are they on the platforms at night, that kind of
- 26:10thing. I mean, a core response that
- 26:14Facebook would give in this situation would just be, they
- 26:17might not say this outright because it's probably not
- 26:19political, but like some of these problems that you've
- 26:22identified are just human problems, right?
- 26:24If you talk about sort of the Instagram critique with it
- 26:27potentially making sort of. Young teenage women, sort of,
- 26:32some segment of them unhappy. I mean, you could say, like, was
- 26:36that so different from Vogue? Is this really an algorithmic
- 26:39problem, or is this just like how humans are?
- 26:42I mean, and I would probably attach more on the a lot of the
- 26:46sort of Democratic liberal sort of anger at Facebook was about
- 26:51just what Trump supporters are like and like their views and
- 26:54the fact that there's like an audience for them.
- 26:56And not always the fact that Facebook would give them
- 26:59distribution. So I guess across a lot of these
- 27:02categories and we can get into the particulars of totally I
- 27:04mentioned. But yeah, what would you say
- 27:06about the just like some of these things people are mad
- 27:08about are just things that human beings do that happen to happen
- 27:11on Facebook. But it's not necessarily their
- 27:13levers that are moving people to do those things.
- 27:17So I think one way to think about this is technology can
- 27:20either. Amplify and bring out the
- 27:22worstness. Or it can act as a bridge that
- 27:25helps us seek our best and happiest selves.
- 27:28So I totally agree with you that you know there are always been
- 27:31teen girls that were unhappy about their bodies or how nice
- 27:35their clothes were, but there are a limited number of pages of
- 27:39Vogue every month. You know, the second time you
- 27:41read Vogue, you're going to have a different impact on you than
- 27:44the third time you read Vogue, or you're going to get bored of
- 27:46it. And in the case of something
- 27:48like Instagram, you know, Instagram progressively pushes
- 27:52you towards more and more extreme content.
- 27:54So I'll give an example. I had a journalist reach out to
- 27:57me for an interview and he explained to me that he had just
- 28:00had a new baby. So this is a healthy, happy baby
- 28:03boy. He's a modern father.
- 28:06He made an Instagram account for the baby.
- 28:09That baby had maybe five or six baby friends.
- 28:12Everyone here is healthy, happy, cute baby.
- 28:16He's only ever clicked on or commented on happy, cute,
- 28:19healthy babies and yet about 10% of his feed with children who
- 28:24were visibly suffering. So kids who had gone horrible
- 28:27accidents and were just figured disabilities and deformities
- 28:31that looked really painful. Kids died of cancer in hospital
- 28:34beds with tubes coming out of them.
- 28:36And he was like, Francis, how did we get from healthy, happy
- 28:40babies to this? Like, what happened?
- 28:43I've only ever clicked on the Happy Fun tent.
- 28:46And I was like, well, the A I knows very clearly you like
- 28:50babies. You know you've made this whole
- 28:51little baby centric world. So it's showing you content and
- 28:55knows that people who like babies have trouble not engaging
- 28:58with. And I want to be honest, even if
- 29:00you're not clicking like on that content or sad or whatever you
- 29:04probably are lingering and a lot of these A I's have dwell you're
- 29:09just you're the fact that you paused is a single signal that
- 29:12you like that content. And so, you know, he's old
- 29:15enough and, you know, cognitively mature enough to see
- 29:19something weird is happening with a 13 year old girl.
- 29:23You know, she might start out by looking for something like
- 29:25healthy recipes and just by clicking all the content get
- 29:29pushed over time towards more and more extreme materials.
- 29:33And we see these reports from things like child psychologists
- 29:36who say I have these kids in my practice.
- 29:39They come into their appointments and say I'm trying
- 29:41to make better choices. Like I'm trying to follow the
- 29:44program, but it follows me around Instagram.
- 29:48And right now we live in a world where we don't have consumer
- 29:51rights to really basic things like should you be allowed to
- 29:55reset an algorithm without losing all your past.
- 29:59So like, those kids are being forced to choose from their
- 30:01past. You know, all their memories,
- 30:03their friends and their futures. Because an algorithm wants to
- 30:06keep them from moving away from something that was hurting them.
- 30:10I'm sure you saw. You know if you want to delete
- 30:12threads, they say. You delete.
- 30:13Instagram too, which is just like insanity.
- 30:17I mean, it's like, oh, we know you love this other thing.
- 30:19I'm much more supportive of the we should regulate tech through
- 30:24laws that, like correct it rather than the sort of huge
- 30:26antitrust push. I mean to me like things as
- 30:29simple as just like then push notification hacking.
- 30:32Like we need to escape a world where like.
- 30:35Tech companies are allowed to use sort of little badges that
- 30:38psychologically drive us crazy that don't show, like actual
- 30:42alerts. But the problem is you write
- 30:44that rule, you know, like I'm sitting here like I'm frustrated
- 30:47with like Facebook. And I'm like, why is Facebook
- 30:49showing me this group that I never use?
- 30:51But it knows I love to clear algorithms.
- 30:53We should ban it. But then, you know, for the next
- 30:57startup that's trying to build and doesn't know anything about,
- 31:01you know, it's just like, it creates a huge regulatory
- 31:03burden. They could end up helping
- 31:06Facebook. So this is part of why we want
- 31:09to do our standard of care project, right.
- 31:11Like right now Facebook has a really huge advantage in that
- 31:15they have done research in this space for decades and decades.
- 31:1915 years, 17 years somewhere in there I guess they are coming up
- 31:23on 20 years cuz it's 2023 and they were founded in 2004.
- 31:28But you want to talk about real deep cuts.
- 31:30Do you remember Friendster or you not quite old enough?
- 31:33Yeah, that's. So Facebook was my first real
- 31:37social media I graduated. You weren't a life spacer.
- 31:39In 2009 so, but I'm aware of sort of the history.
- 31:42Of yeah, the first web crawler. So that's a thing for
- 31:47downloading data off the Internet so you can analyze it
- 31:50that I ever wrote. I wrote Friendster because I was
- 31:53using really early graph mapping algorithms because I guess I've
- 31:55always loved graph based problems.
- 31:58But yeah, part of why we're doing standard of care is we
- 32:01know we want to make sure that the next generation of social
- 32:04platforms and you know, social platforms take lots and lots of
- 32:07different forms, things like roadblocks.
- 32:10Roadblocks is a social network. You know, we're going to always
- 32:13have new social platforms. How can we make sure that people
- 32:16have the best head start, you know, the best platform to build
- 32:20off of to be like, oh interesting, we can get a very
- 32:23robust education on what we should be worrying about.
- 32:26Very quickly and an understanding of like what
- 32:28options exist for being able to afford all those problems.
- 32:33Is privacy a big part of your advocacy?
- 32:36Or like how optimistic are to me, I'm sort of like, oh man,
- 32:40privacy sort of lost in this world once you're on them.
- 32:43Like, I'm just not like a privacy that's I'm much more
- 32:48aligned on this sort of like, oh man, them hacking our brains and
- 32:51like, using actual, like, psychological tricks to get us
- 32:53to engage with them. That's really troubling.
- 32:56But like, yeah, I don't know how much time are you spending on
- 32:59sort of privacy advocacy and what's your sort of view on on
- 33:03that part of? It so privacy is not what I
- 33:05would say, one of my tentpole issues, I'm very open to it as a
- 33:08technique in terms of, you know, people emotionally connect with
- 33:12privacy as an issue and it is a way of decreasing the ability of
- 33:17algorithms to be able to act towards you.
- 33:19Like if they're not allowed to record information about you,
- 33:22it's harder to manipulate you. At the same time, like, you
- 33:25know, we're developing AIS that are getting better and better at
- 33:28doing implicit inferences. And so it's this question of,
- 33:31you know, how little data do you need in order to actually still
- 33:34see a lot of these phenomena. And also, I think it's only
- 33:37things where it's like, I don't think you can write privacy laws
- 33:40that are going to strip enough data to actually neutralize the
- 33:44problems that we're talking about.
- 33:45Here. I'll give you a really basic
- 33:46example. One of the big ways you reduce
- 33:50misinformation on something like WhatsApp, which is end to end
- 33:53encrypted, it's private chat is he's saying, hey you know, as
- 33:58something gets reshared, so there's a chain of reshares.
- 34:01So I got it, I reshared it. My friend reasshared it on and
- 34:04on. One is a chain of reshares.
- 34:07Once it gets 5 hops away from the person who created it, say
- 34:11to them, hey, you can totally spread this further, but you
- 34:15have to copy and paste it. You have to make an affirmative
- 34:17action to continue forward. That kind of change doesn't, you
- 34:22know, you know, allowing that, not allowing.
- 34:26That's not really a privacy topic, but it's one of the most
- 34:28impactful things for safety. So I'm very pro privacy
- 34:32legislation. If people want to push it, I
- 34:34think it can have a really positive impact on a lot of the
- 34:37problems I talk about. But it's not being trinsically
- 34:39solve all the things that we're talking about here.
- 34:42No, that makes a lot of sense. I sort of alluded to the
- 34:45political piece of this sort of digging into that section.
- 34:49I mean the political asymmetry in the United States and like
- 34:55how that affects conversations about Facebook.
- 34:58Like to me it's like pretty obvious that like Trump
- 35:02supporters, Republicans like are behaving in sort of different
- 35:05ways than Democrats and spreading generally more false
- 35:09information. And like, it's very awkward.
- 35:12For Facebook, certainly. And for politicians or, well, I
- 35:16don't know, journalists can sometimes sort of have trouble
- 35:19sort of highlighting that asymmetry.
- 35:22I don't know. What's your view on it?
- 35:23Do you agree with me that there's like a sort of partisan
- 35:26asymmetry there and that that is sort of creating some of the
- 35:30problems about how Facebook is able.
- 35:32Facebook doesn't want to target Republicans because then they're
- 35:35going to get a lot of heat from Republicans.
- 35:37And so then they're not willing to do sort of things that would
- 35:41have. Asymmetric outcome, I guess.
- 35:44Do you agree with that is sort of the question.
- 35:46Facebook has spent a lot of money trying to frame the issue
- 35:49of what can be done about any of these online safety bras in
- 35:53terms of freedom of speech versus safety.
- 35:56And they get up there, and this is a real quote.
- 35:59Mark Zuckerberg went on a podcast and he was like, you
- 36:03know, I've really grown a lot in the last year.
- 36:06This was like, I don't know, a year after I came out nine
- 36:09months. I know I've really grown a lot
- 36:11in the last year because I've realized sometimes if you stand
- 36:15up for what you believe in, you're going to be unpopular.
- 36:19And I'm a defender of freedom of speech.
- 36:22And what I found so aggravating about this is like, you know,
- 36:25that thing we just talked about with WhatsApp, You know, when
- 36:27you cut the research chain at 5, You know, if you do that same
- 36:31thing on Facebook when you cut the research chain at 2:00.
- 36:34And has the same impact on misinformation as the entire
- 36:37third party fact checking organization.
- 36:39And you're not picking and choosing what are the good ideas
- 36:42and the bad ideas. And I think right now, you know,
- 36:45a pattern we see across the world is if you are a political
- 36:50party that is not in power, you have more of a motivation to
- 36:54figure out new technologies, new ways of reaching people because
- 36:58you're the party that's out of power.
- 37:00You know you don't have the advantages of being an
- 37:02incumbent. And so if we were to roll back
- 37:04in time to say, the Obama presidency, like the first one,
- 37:08you know, when Obama got elected, he did a lot of
- 37:11techniques with technology that no one else was doing.
- 37:15You know, they were monitoring, you know, what's not as a, B,
- 37:18testing emails. So they would say, you know, if
- 37:21Obama holds a puppy, how much money do we make?
- 37:23If Obama is their first wife, how much money do we make?
- 37:25You know, do people sign up for the XYZ thing?
- 37:29He had a a motivation to do that because he was the scrappy
- 37:32incumbent. And so I think when we think
- 37:34about these things as like there is a partisan lean that you know
- 37:37one side is maybe playing the game a little harder than the
- 37:41other side. I think when I think of it is
- 37:43that it's just a question of like who it is or isn't in
- 37:45power. And So what I always try to say
- 37:48when I speak with right leaning voters or right leaning
- 37:51podcasters, if you have any suggestions for ones I should go
- 37:54on, I'm always trying to reach out to a more and more diverse
- 37:57audience. If your listeners can think of
- 37:59great ones for me to go on, e-mail me at
- 38:01francis@francishogan.com. What I would say is, if you care
- 38:06about freedom of speech, you should be demanding transparency
- 38:10about these censorship systems. You know, when I talk to women's
- 38:14rights advocates around the world, all of the have been
- 38:18kicked off Facebook because these A I systems are so crude
- 38:22that if you talk about violence against women, the A I thinks
- 38:26you're committing violence against women.
- 38:29Like, if you really care about for no space, you should be
- 38:31marching on the streets for transparency.
- 38:34And I think that's a space that we should all be willing to work
- 38:36at. I totally get sort of the
- 38:39messaging there and that you want everyone to be sort of on
- 38:42board with these issues. I mean, you look at even the
- 38:44threads roll out when they launched it, they had some, I
- 38:48think, tools in there early on that said, oh, you know, this
- 38:52person, I forget what the exact language was, it was like.
- 38:56Oh, you know, they, I forget if it was the past false things or
- 38:59I'm not going to get it totally right.
- 39:00But there were warnings before people reshared them, which then
- 39:05like can have sort of a perceived sort of partisan
- 39:08focus. And obviously, I mean, Elon
- 39:10Musk, whole campaign on Twitter was the idea that Twitter was
- 39:15sort of shadow banning, you know, people and the replies and
- 39:19all that. Yeah, yeah, I don't know.
- 39:22I guess the question there is like.
- 39:24Clearly what we're seeing is there is some sort of right wing
- 39:27backlash to cases where social media companies try to do what
- 39:31you're saying, which is sort of either flag or not sort of a
- 39:35size things that violate their policies.
- 39:37I think this again, it's funny since I actually worry about
- 39:40this a lot for AI safety. If you already feel distressed,
- 39:44you know you feel like you have been left behind or you're a
- 39:47marginalist. And, you know, I grew up in
- 39:50Iowa. Like, I have a lot of empathy
- 39:52for Republican voters today. You know, Iowa has been left
- 39:56behind economically in a pretty dramatic way.
- 39:59That if you already are feeling a little that anxiety about the
- 40:03idea that people with power don't really care about you,
- 40:06it's very easy to read into when a moderation system takes an
- 40:11impact that you're being singled out.
- 40:13And I think this is also true for, say, African American or
- 40:16less affluent people who participate, only that you have
- 40:20very similar things where like African Americans will get
- 40:23sanctioned for hate speech because these systems are not
- 40:26very well done. And so I think there's a fear,
- 40:29and this is a fear that could be addressed by being more
- 40:32transparent of saying, hey, we're going to actually let you
- 40:34see what we're doing because you know the case of a I safety,
- 40:38you're already seeing people come out with calls of saying I
- 40:41don't want. Systems that have been aligned
- 40:45with the public good. I want true or real AI.
- 40:48And I think that in both cases, either what conservatives are
- 40:52saying about content, moderation on threats, or AI safety, you
- 40:56know, when people feel like it's out of their control, when they
- 40:59feel like something's being done behind the scenes, they object
- 41:02to it. So giving the user control
- 41:06basically. Or having enough transparency
- 41:09that you can build trust on these things.
- 41:12Right. Like it should be possible for
- 41:13researchers to come out and say, like, hey, actually, or if you
- 41:16yourself. So right now, if your content
- 41:18gets taken down on Facebook, the only people you can appeal to or
- 41:22you can send your thing off to is the oversight board.
- 41:25Imagine if you would say, I'd like to be put in a public
- 41:28research data set. Like, I would like reporters to
- 41:31be able to look at this and say, oh, interesting, you know, this
- 41:34whole political candidate is getting taken down at a much
- 41:36higher rate than this other one. Like that would be a very
- 41:39different world. Facebook would have to work
- 41:41harder to make sure that its systems were objective and
- 41:44effective. In the book Power One which
- 41:48everyone should go read and you talk about like the rise of
- 41:51COVID and like I mean COVID sort of is a great way to get into
- 41:55the misinformation question and I think like how misinformation
- 42:00like the view on sort of that word and sort of the ideas
- 42:03there. What is your view on like how
- 42:06Facebook. Handled COVID, like, are you
- 42:10supportive of, you know, tamping down on people who were like,
- 42:16you know, skeptical about the origins of the vaccine or
- 42:19skeptical about the vaccine? Because that fits right into
- 42:21this sort of partisan thing where in there end up being sort
- 42:24of sides that align with parties that fit onto these.
- 42:28So yeah, how do you score Facebook's handling of COVID
- 42:32misinformation? Oh, great question, God.
- 42:36It's interesting. My criticisms on Facebook are
- 42:38much more like the part of the book that I I think you're
- 42:42alluding to is, you know, when they went and divided up the
- 42:46United States into 600 communities.
- 42:50So think of a community as you enjoy the same kind of groups,
- 42:53You follow the same kind of pages, you post on the same
- 42:56kinds of topics, you click on the same kinds of topics.
- 42:58You know, imagine you put people into communities that were
- 43:01between 500,000 people and 3 million people.
- 43:04If you went and said, you know how many of these communities
- 43:09make up 80% of all the received COVID misinformation, it turned
- 43:14out that 4% of the US population fell into communities that got
- 43:1980% of the COVID misinformation, right?
- 43:22So you and me, average person gets maybe one piece of COVID
- 43:27misinformation every couple days, once a week.
- 43:31For a small fraction of people, they were getting whole streams
- 43:34of it. That's what happened with the
- 43:35January 6th people, but for different groups, different
- 43:38ideas. And and part of that was because
- 43:41the way Facebook was designed was if you have a post that is
- 43:45really controversial, you know has a big fight in the comments,
- 43:49Every new comment makes that post new and can show up at the
- 43:54top of your home feed again. And so there were a few
- 43:57communities where, you know, COVID had a really intense
- 44:00emotional balance. Those communities actively
- 44:04censored out voices that said anything different and they
- 44:08became these kind of echo chambers.
- 44:10And so I think there's interesting conversations to be
- 44:12had around, like how do phenomena like that occur and
- 44:16like what other contexts are they happening in?
- 44:18And so like, let's imagine you're seeing something like
- 44:21that where you know, the algorithm and the product design
- 44:24are pushing people towards. These kind of parallel
- 44:27realities. And like, that's why you had
- 44:29people showing up and like, you know, threatening teachers with
- 44:32guns or like people showing up at school board meetings
- 44:35screaming because literally when they looked at their Facebook
- 44:37feeds, all they saw was stuff about how teachers were trying
- 44:41to kill their kids, Right? So that's kind of the
- 44:44environment we're entering into when we have to say, like, what
- 44:47is Facebook's role or what should Facebook's policy be?
- 44:51And I think it's really complicated.
- 44:53Like, I think they did a bad job.
- 44:56In that they had, you know, these blacklists, they had the
- 44:59concepts that you couldn't talk about, but they never told
- 45:02anyone, you know, They never let us see how well these systems
- 45:06performed. And it meant that you had people
- 45:08feel like they weren't, like it was a hidden truth and hidden
- 45:12truths are very alluring. And so, you know, effective
- 45:16social software should be designed such that if I write a
- 45:20thoughtful reply, if I go do research, if I come back to your
- 45:24allegation with. Something meaningful for a
- 45:26conversation. I should get similar amounts of
- 45:29distribution to your inflammatory statement, and that
- 45:32just doesn't happen today. Like, the systems aren't
- 45:34designed to reward extreme ideas.
- 45:36They're not designed to reward thoughtful, moderate ideas.
- 45:39So. Your solution there would be
- 45:41just to. To give more distribution to
- 45:45sort of counter messaging basically.
- 45:48So like, they've done research inside of Facebook, and one
- 45:50thing that's kind of exciting about the next few months is
- 45:53like Harvard has an archive of most of the Facebook files and
- 45:57they're starting to make access for those documents to academic
- 46:00researchers. One of the papers in there talks
- 46:04about how, if you are good at writing such that people diverse
- 46:10from you different from you. Can engage with that content.
- 46:13Are those ideas You're doing a very complicated thing, right?
- 46:18You know, if I can write a political post that Republicans
- 46:21and Democrats can like instructively have a
- 46:23conversation in the comments, you know, people are thumbs up
- 46:26and each other. It's like a positive
- 46:28conversational template. I should be rewarded for that
- 46:32because it's not obvious. Like I might not get the most
- 46:35comments, I might not get the most likes.
- 46:38But if I can get a diverse community of people, a diverse
- 46:41audience to engage with it, that should be rewarded.
- 46:44If you come in there and say, hey, we're going to boost
- 46:47content from people who can successfully reach across the
- 46:50aisle, you end up getting less hate speech, less violence for
- 46:54free, less misinformation. So it's a lot of these things
- 46:58where if you start making transparent, what is distributed
- 47:02versus what is created on these platforms.
- 47:06And you start saying, hey, like right now what you're giving
- 47:09distribution to is very different than what's being
- 47:11created. Can we get those a little bit
- 47:13more in line? I have a feeling what would end
- 47:16up happening as you'd start finding more techniques like
- 47:18that where you could come in and say, hey, people who are fear
- 47:22mongering, you know, they shouldn't be the only ones who
- 47:26get to stand on the stage. And that's kind of what's
- 47:28happening today. So it's still a world where like
- 47:32there's like sort of? A hand on the till in terms of
- 47:36what's getting reach and like it's just sort of in some ways
- 47:40just doing things that are less oriented around sort of their
- 47:43business interests necessarily, which are Max engagement, right.
- 47:46I mean it's certainly not saying like don't sort of weigh certain
- 47:51things differently than others, right, Because if you just tried
- 47:54to create this sort of like neutral algorithm, you would
- 47:57just then be deferring to sort of.
- 48:00Negative aspects of humanity potentially.
- 48:02Am I understanding that correctly?
- 48:04Yeah, algorithms can only capture the level of complexity
- 48:07that you put in the algorithm. So if you come in there and say,
- 48:11hey, people developing compulsive behaviors, right?
- 48:16So in the case of kids, you know, something like 8% of kids
- 48:20say that they take control of usage and it's hurting either
- 48:23their employment, school or their health, right?
- 48:26Think about that 8%. How selfaware are 14 year olds
- 48:30like, not super selfaware. How honest are they with
- 48:32themselves? Not super honest.
- 48:34It's probably a lot more than 8%, right?
- 48:36They're suffering like that. You know, if you don't have a
- 48:39system that says, hey, sleep deprived kids are a longterm
- 48:44harm to society, you know, they do worse in school.
- 48:47They are at higher risk for developing mental health issues
- 48:49that will last so long throughout their life or put
- 48:51them at higher risk of recurrence.
- 48:53They're more likely to use drugs, both uppers because
- 48:55they're tired, Downers because they're depressed.
- 48:58You know, if you have an algorithm that just is like, how
- 49:00many clicks can we get? Like how much ad revenue can we
- 49:02get? You don't capture those kinds of
- 49:05social costs. And so I think there's a huge
- 49:09opportunity where if you just come in and say like, hey, with
- 49:12cars, if you have a car accident, everyone gets to see
- 49:16the car accident. You know, everyone gets to see
- 49:19the body on the ground and see that your, you know, your seat
- 49:21belt didn't work. We don't have a similar feedback
- 49:25cycle. On these social platforms, and
- 49:28they can keep kind of having their problems and they don't
- 49:31have anything that brings them back to center.
- 49:33For the last part of the conversation, just talk about,
- 49:36you know, the decision to release information and to go to
- 49:41the Wall Street Journal. And, yeah, the reporter, it's
- 49:44Jeff Horowitz, right? He reached out to you on
- 49:46LinkedIn. Or tell the story a little bit
- 49:48about how this happened. Like, did you see yourself?
- 49:51Sure, like as a whistleblower before you heard from him?
- 49:56I had been contemplating for quite a while.
- 50:00Like, would I have to go forward at some point?
- 50:03Like, I had a chance to talk to my parents about it a large
- 50:05number of times, just because, like, what I was seeing on a
- 50:08daytoday basis while I lived with them during COVID was just
- 50:12so different than what the Facebook public narrative was on
- 50:14these issues. But the moment where I was like,
- 50:17OKI have no other options was right after the 2020 election.
- 50:21So this is in December. It's like less than 30 days
- 50:24after the election. They pulled us all together on
- 50:27Zoom, and they said, hey, you know how for the last four
- 50:31years, the only part of Facebook that was growing was the civic
- 50:35integrity team. So it's the team that was for
- 50:39facebook.com, at least. So civic Integrity's job was to
- 50:42make sure that Facebook was a positive force in the world,
- 50:45like a positive social force in the world.
- 50:47You know, it wasn't going to disrupt elections.
- 50:49It wasn't going to cause any more genocides, because by that
- 50:52point there'd been 2. You know, it was going to be a
- 50:54positive force. And they said, hey, you are so
- 50:58important, we're going to dissolve your team and integrate
- 51:01it into the rest of Facebook. And when they did that, that was
- 51:06kind of the moment where I realized Facebook had given up,
- 51:09that the only way Facebook was going to save itself was if the
- 51:12public got involved, that the public had to come and save
- 51:15Facebook. And so by chance, so that day I
- 51:19went and opened up LinkedIn because, you know, I was kind
- 51:22of. When you have instability at
- 51:24work, that's what you do. You know, you open up LinkedIn.
- 51:27And I saw that I had a message from this guy, Jeff Horwitz, and
- 51:33he did a lot of reporting for the Wall Street Journal about
- 51:35the violence that Facebook had facilitated in India,
- 51:38particularly like Muslim Hindu violence.
- 51:41And, you know, he said, do you want to talk?
- 51:47And I was like, oh, interesting, like of all the places that I
- 51:51would want to work with. I wanted to work with the Wall
- 51:53Street Journal because I really view all of these topics as
- 51:57bipartisan. You know, they're not left,
- 51:59they're not right. They're like basic rules of the
- 52:02road. And I knew that if the reporting
- 52:04had come from the New York Times that there would be a large
- 52:08swath of right leaning voters that would never be able to
- 52:10trust it. But if it came from the Wall
- 52:12Street Journal, it was likely that they would be able to at
- 52:16least consider it. And I think that's part of why
- 52:19the Senate hearing was so bipartisan because.
- 52:22It was something that came out of, you know, it was trusted
- 52:25like that. A lot of the things that were
- 52:27said in those articles sounded crazy.
- 52:29They sounded super. There's like, no way, there's no
- 52:32way the company could be this bad, like the human trafficking
- 52:34thing of the Facebook employees being worried about offending
- 52:38buyers over the people being trafficked.
- 52:41But because it came from a very, you know, center of the road,
- 52:45cautious publication, people were like, oh, maybe this is
- 52:48actually true. And yeah, I mean, I think this
- 52:52journal is so credible and sort of careful and how they present
- 52:56things. Initially, you were not going to
- 53:00come out, right? Like what motivated your
- 53:02decision to go public? So wondering why the disclosures
- 53:06are so large. So I want them to be able to
- 53:07stand on their own like I always expected to do.
- 53:10Like closed door briefings but like governments to be able to
- 53:13explain them. But I never intended to be like
- 53:16part of the story. And right before I came out, so
- 53:20maybe a couple months before, my lawyers started really putting
- 53:24pressure on me where they were saying, you know, Facebook knows
- 53:27it's and they can look at all the different documents, right?
- 53:30They know it's you. You know, the report is going to
- 53:32get started. They're going to figure out real
- 53:33fast or as soon as they start going to ask for comment,
- 53:35they're going to figure out real fast.
- 53:37And the Wall Street Journal, they said here's the deal.
- 53:43Like either you can wait for the rest of your life for Facebook
- 53:47to present you to the public. You know, every day you're like
- 53:51open, you know Google News. You're going to open your
- 53:53newspaper and be like, is today the day that Facebook is going
- 53:56to introduce me in the worst possible way?
- 53:58Or you can take responsibility for what you did.
- 54:01You know, I know that you don't want to be out.
- 54:03You don't want people looking at you.
- 54:04You don't want to be out there. Like, you know, go and take
- 54:07responsibility because if you do, close door briefings.
- 54:11Every single briefing you do will expand the circle of trust,
- 54:15and you're going to be like the juiciest story for some reporter
- 54:19to break. Like if they can.
- 54:20Find post or somebody would have just.
- 54:23And one of my friends joked, like, after I came out, they
- 54:26were like, I don't understand how this story stayed quiet for
- 54:29so long. I thought, everyone in San
- 54:31Francisco, I knew Francis was doing this.
- 54:33And I was like, everyone in our circle of friends knew I was
- 54:35doing this. Not everyone in San Francisco.
- 54:37But still, it's one of those things, like, someone brags to
- 54:40their friend about how I know where the Facebook whistleblower
- 54:42is and, you know, I just goes. And so I decided to step out
- 54:48into the light. And it's actually been a really
- 54:50transformative experience. You know, it's one of these
- 54:53things where I spent a lot of my life, like, really trying to
- 54:57avoid being seen. You know, like, I've gotten
- 54:59married twice. I eloped both times.
- 55:02The idea of standing in front of a crowd, having them just, like,
- 55:05stare at me for my wedding sounds very stressful.
- 55:07You know, I've had two birthday parties in the last, like, 20
- 55:09years. Like, it's just not my jail.
- 55:11But it's been really interesting having to, like, stand up and
- 55:14try to educate people on these issues.
- 55:17Because, you know, I really believe in democracy and the way
- 55:21the world changes is we change it.
- 55:24You know, we get out there and we say, hey, you know, I'm going
- 55:27to keep repeating this until I see something different in the
- 55:29world. And having to show up in my own
- 55:31life has been a huge blessing. And I, something I never
- 55:35expected to be one of the things that I would walk away, you
- 55:37know, two years later and say I'm so grateful for this.
- 55:41Awesome. That is a great ending to the
- 55:43podcast. Thank you so much for coming on
- 55:45and I really appreciate talking to.
- 55:47You. My pleasure.
- 55:49The honest thing I leave people with is if you think all these
- 55:52things are too complicated, you know, like these are, you know I
- 55:55couldn't understand a technical book.
- 55:57The whole point of power of 1 is that democracy requires an
- 56:01informed population. So it is written so that if you
- 56:04could follow along today, I guarantee you'll be entertained
- 56:08and follow along the power of 1. And there's lots of fun stories
- 56:11and, you know, crazy hijinks along the way.
- 56:13Because I've always got into trouble.
- 56:15You know what? I didn't mean to.
- 56:16And so I hope you come along on this journey too.
- 56:19Thank you so much. That's our episode.
- 56:21Thanks so much to Tommy Herron, our audio editor.
- 56:23I want to shout out. Annie Wen, our intern for the
- 56:26summer, has been helping me prep for the podcast and working on
- 56:30punching up the show. Shout out to Riley Kinsella, my
- 56:33chief of staff, and young Chomsky for the theme music.
- 56:37This has been the newcomer podcast.
- 56:39Please like comments, subscribe on YouTube, give us a review on
- 56:43Apple Podcasts, and most importantly, most important,
- 56:46subscribe to the Sub Stack newcomer.co Become a paid
- 56:50subscriber today. It makes this all possible.
- 56:53Thank you so much. See you next week.
- 56:56Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:57Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:58Goodbye. Goodbye.
- 56:59Goodbye, Goodbye, Goodbye.