Latest / Becoming Financially Confident / The Truth About Annuities: Guaranteed Income or Scam?
Transcript
- 0:00Ralph: What if I told you there is an investment out there that promises guaranteed.
- 0:04Lifetime income.
- 0:06But it's been called a scam that only benefits the person selling it.
- 0:10Would you be interested or would you run the other way?
- 0:14Well today, we're going to break down annuities.
- 0:16and I'll provide you with the facts so you can make a more informed decision.
- 0:22Intro: Welcome to the Ask Ralph Podcast, where listening to an experienced financial professional with over 30 years of experience can help you make sense of confusing questions, current headlines, and industry trends about taxes, small business, financial decision making, investment strategies, and even the art of proper budgeting.
- 0:42Ask Ralph makes the complex simple by sharing his real world knowledge from a Christian perspective with all things financial.
- 0:49Now here's your host, Ralph Estep, Jr.
- 0:52Ralph: Welcome to our financial Friday show.
- 0:54I'm so glad you chose to join us.
- 0:56I just want to thank you for listening and more importantly, supporting the program.
- 1:00It's a beautiful Friday here on the farm.
- 1:02And I'm coming to you from the Saggio accounting studio.
- 1:06Let me put on my podcaster hat and put down those overalls.
- 1:09And yes, I do actually wear overalls when I'm out working on the farm.
- 1:13And let's move that adding machine to the side.
- 1:16Let's get to some financial wisdom from a Christian perspective.
- 1:20Today, we're tackling the complex world of annuities.
- 1:23Annuities seem to have the bit of a mixed reputation out there.
- 1:26Some tout them as an excellent way to receive guaranteed income for life, but all there's called them exorbitant scams that only make them money for the insurance agents who sell them.
- 1:37So what's the real truth on annuities.
- 1:39Can they have a place in a wise Christian investor's portfolio?
- 1:42Or our annuities just trouble.
- 1:44That should be avoided.
- 1:46By the end of today's episode.
- 1:47If I do my job.
- 1:49You'll understand exactly what an annuity is, the pros and cons of investing in them.
- 1:54Who can benefit the most from them and whether some of the criticisms about annuities are really valid.
- 2:01Get out your notebooks folks classes in session.
- 2:04Don't forget to subscribe to the show and join our email list.
- 2:07You do that at askralphpodcast.com . So you don't miss tomorrow show.
- 2:11We have the great Dave Jackson hall of fame, podcaster, and Dean of the school podcasting.
- 2:18And we're going to discuss how you start a podcast for your business.
- 2:21Or let's say you're one of those people that has a passion for something.
- 2:24He's going to talk about how to create that.
- 2:27And make a podcast out of it's a great interview and one you don't want to miss.
- 2:31We also just launched an insiders group on Facebook.
- 2:34And I encourage each of our listeners to join the group, to continue the conversation from the show.
- 2:39It's a great place to share your ideas for the show.
- 2:42We're going to have some.
- 2:43Episodes coming up where we got those directly from that group, it's a place to discuss your triumphs and also talk about your challenges.
- 2:49I have a link to the Facebook group in the show notes today.
- 2:53Let's ground ourselves today in the Bible verse, it comes from Proverbs chapter 13, verse 11, and says this dishonest money dwindles away.
- 3:01But whoever gathers money, little by little makes it grow.
- 3:05As we discuss annuities, which can be complex financial products.
- 3:09These are not simple.
- 3:10Folks we'll explore whether they are wise investments to gather money over time or dishonest schemes that dwindle savings away.
- 3:18Let's start with a simple question, Ralph, what is an annuity?
- 3:22Well simply put an annuity as an insurance contract that provides guaranteed payouts either immediately or in the future.
- 3:29There are really two main types of annuities.
- 3:31That's an immediate annuity and a deferred annuity.
- 3:34Immediate annuity start paying out quickly after you invest your lump sum.
- 3:38You give an insurance company say a hundred thousand dollars.
- 3:41And every month they send you guaranteed payments based on that amount, your age and other factors.
- 3:47These payouts usually lasts for life.
- 3:50Deferred annuities.
- 3:51On the other hand, lets you invest money for years before the payments start, they operate in an accumulation phase where you contribute funds at grow tax deferred.
- 4:01that means, you're not paying tax on those monies as you put them in there.
- 4:04Then at some point you switched to a payout phase where you receive routine income.
- 4:09Deferred annuities have surrender charges.
- 4:11If you try cashing out too soon, this is something you have to understand and watch out for.
- 4:15We'll talk about that a little later in the show.
- 4:17Now, within these broad categories of immediate and deferred annuities, there are many other more specific types of, we're not going to go down that rabbit hole today.
- 4:25Or we'll be here all day and you will definitely zone out.
- 4:29Just know the world of annuities is complex with lots of variations out there.
- 4:33Okay.
- 4:34So now we've got a general idea of what an annuity is.
- 4:37Let's dive in this.
- 4:37Some of the benefits they offer, the number one advertised pro is providing reliable, guaranteed income for as long as you live folks, that's the true selling point of what an annuity may do for you.
- 4:50This appeals to our human desire for certainty in an uncertain world.
- 4:54And boy, we are in uncertain times.
- 4:56You don't have to worry about outliving your money in retirement.
- 4:59If you have an immediate annuity sending you checks every month.
- 5:03Especially if your annuity has cost of living adjustments that increase the payouts to keep pace with inflation.
- 5:08So, yes, there are annuities that will adjust the amount of payout you receive based on inflation.
- 5:14Another advantage is that death benefit, many annuities offer, but so you pass away after only receiving annuity payments for five years out of a potential 30 year payout horizon, some annuity contracts will pay your heirs, the remainder of those payments.
- 5:28You never got to collect.
- 5:30It's almost like life insurance in reverse.
- 5:32And if you have health issues already, you can qualify for certain annuities.
- 5:36Even if your insurance company won't give you traditional life insurance.
- 5:40So that's something to consider.
- 5:41For deferred annuities, a benefit.
- 5:43Is there tax deferred growth potential while you're in the savings accumulation phase, just like a 401k or IRA, you'll avoid paying annual taxes on any gains.
- 5:53Your annuity, investment earns.
- 5:55They are deferred.
- 5:56This gives your funds more room and time to potentially go faster to give you larger future payouts.
- 6:02Now there is a wide range of investment options within deferred annuities as well from conservative bonds to aggressive stocks.
- 6:09So in theory, they can align them well with most investors, risk tolerances.
- 6:13However annuities definitely have their downsides.
- 6:16Number one is they're notoriously high expenses through surrender charges.
- 6:20mortality fees, expense ratios and their management fees.
- 6:25Agents selling annuities make big commissions.
- 6:29And those costs are passed on directly to the consumer.
- 6:31Unfortunately, some annuities come with 10 to 12 year surrender charge periods.
- 6:36So if you need your money during that initial decade, you'll face stiff penalties, potentially eating up 10% or more.
- 6:43Of your original investment.
- 6:46Payout rates can also seem very low for what you put in.
- 6:49Here's an example, a 200,000 immediate annuity for a 60 year old may only spit out a thousand dollars per month.
- 6:56And due to low interest rates, the past decade, even rates on fixed annuities, aren't so attractive anymore.
- 7:02You may lock into just 3% annual returns.
- 7:05Another con is complexity.
- 7:08Annuity contracts come loaded with all sorts of conditions, all sorts of clauses and exceptions and moving parts.
- 7:15It's easy to get lost in how exactly they work.
- 7:18And shady agents often exploit that confusion to oversell inappropriate annuity products to buyers, just looking for guaranteed returns.
- 7:26Okay.
- 7:27So who can actually benefit from owning an annuity, given these pros and cons?
- 7:32Well, annuities can serve a role primarily for two groups of people.
- 7:36Newly retired folks looking for reliable retirement income and investors who desire, downside protection.
- 7:42If you've recently stopped working and need to map out cashflow streams to replace your employment earnings.
- 7:48An immediate annuity could make sense.
- 7:50Just don't put a hundred percent of your nest egg in one, maybe 25 to 50% tops to cover fixed expenses.
- 7:56And combine it with social security.
- 7:59With your pensions.
- 8:00If you have them and withdraw some other investments, you ideally want multiple income sources to give you flexibility.
- 8:06And that's true, whether this be a discussion of annuities or any other type of investment
- 8:10for deferred annuities, someone that dislikes wild investments swings also could be a candidate.
- 8:16If, and this is a big if.
- 8:18The products benefits outweigh cost Within your timeline.
- 8:22These products do provide solutions for principal protection, not always available in the stock market, but here's the truth.
- 8:29Folks.
- 8:29You may sacrifice some gains for that added security.
- 8:33So you've got to know exactly what you're getting into and how surrender periods or penalties limit making changes down the road.
- 8:39Finally let's tackle this question floating around out.
- 8:42There are all annuities, essentially scams benefiting only the insurance agents.
- 8:47I hear this.
- 8:48All the time in my practice.
- 8:50The short answer is no.
- 8:52But with some caveats.
- 8:54Annuities themselves are legitimate products approved in all 50 states that can absolutely help certain buyers achieve financial goals, like low risk retirement income.
- 9:03But, and this is a big one.
- 9:06Shady agents absolutely do take advantage of unwitting seniors.
- 9:10Over promising benefits while hiding costly traps in the fine print.
- 9:14These people earn sky high commissions and face, little accountability.
- 9:18When the products fail expectations, years later.
- 9:22Annuities aren't inherently bad, but complex contracts combined with conflicting agents incentives.
- 9:28Absolutely lead billions lost by consumers due to inappropriate recommendations.
- 9:33So wisdom is vital.
- 9:35When considering these vehicles, you got to know the pros and cons study all the fees charged and how they eat into returns, longterm.
- 9:43And here's the truth folks vet any agent thoroughly before moving forward, taking time up front could spare you major disappointment later.
- 9:52All right.
- 9:52My friends let's do a quick recap today.
- 9:54We've covered what an annuity actually is.
- 9:56As we said, it's an insurance contract for guaranteed future payments.
- 10:00We talked about benefits like lifelong income, death benefits and tax deferred growth.
- 10:05We talked about those downsides, like high costs, low payout rates and confusing complexity.
- 10:11We also discussed the best target buyers being recent retirees, and those who are conservative for protection of their investments And whether all annuities are scams.
- 10:21No, but abuses absolutely do happen.
- 10:24If you're considering an annuity weigh carefully, whether guaranteed income is truly worth reduced investment performance in the long run.
- 10:31You've got to thoroughly analyze all fine print and fees and talk to an advisor, not being compensated for selling you that product.
- 10:39annuities can be appropriate tools.
- 10:41Sometimes I am truly not a big fan of these.
- 10:44And I'll tell you that's my bias ahead of time.
- 10:47But they require a much diligence given intricate trade-offs
- 10:50As always, I appreciate you tuning into gain financial wisdom and discernment as faithful stewards, please visit askralphpodcast.com for more back episodes and handy resources.
- 11:01Also share this show.
- 11:03On social media and other areas so that we, as Christians can make wise financial decisions and align money matters with our faith.
- 11:11And as I always say, stay savvy out there, my friends and saints.
- 11:15And God bless you.
- 11:18Outro: Thank you for joining us on the AskRalph podcast.
- 11:21And with a simple click to subscribe, we'll invite you back to our next episode.
- 11:25And remember, financial issues don't have to be complicated.
- 11:28Just AskRalph.
- 11:29The information contained in this episode of AskRalph is based on data available as of the date of its release.
- 11:35Sagio Accounting Plus and AskRalph Media Inc.
- 11:38is under no obligation to update this content if changes occur.
- 11:42Applying this information to your specific situation requires careful consideration of all facts and circumstances, and any information provided is not to be considered as financial, tax, or legal advice.
- 11:52Please consult your tax advisor or attorney before acting on any material covered.