Latest / Murder Files Unsealed / The 2009 Disappearance and Murder of Eridania Rodriguez

Transcript

The 2009 Disappearance and Murder of Eridania Rodriguez · Murder Files Unsealed

0:00
Speaker 1: So I want you to just take a second and
0:01
imagine a twenty six story Manhattan.
0:04
Speaker 2: Skyscraper, Okay, setting the scene.
0:06
Speaker 1: Yeah, and this place. It's surrounded by three hundred and
0:09
sixty degree surveillance cameras. It has electronic keycard turnstiles right
0:15
there in.
0:16
Speaker 2: The lobby, right highly secure, exactly.
0:18
Speaker 1: It's got twenty four to seven security guards actively monitoring
0:22
every single point of entry. But now imagine a woman
0:27
walking into that exact building, waving to those cameras, and
0:30
then just well, she simply vanishes into thin air.
0:33
Speaker 2: It sounds like a magic trick, but it's an absolute nightmare.
0:36
Speaker 1: It really is. Today we are taking a deep dive
0:39
into excerpts from the night Cleaner of Rector Street, and
0:41
the mission here for you listening is to really look
0:44
beyond those, you know, the standard true crime headlines.
0:47
Speaker 2: We want to dig into the architecture of the event itself.
0:50
Speaker 1: Right, We are going to explore this profound, deeply disturbing
0:53
paradox like how the safest, most hyper surveilled buildings in
0:57
the entire world are actually designed these massive fatal blind spots.
1:02
Speaker 2: Yeah, and it forces a complete re evaluation of what
1:04
the word security actually means right, because we tend to
1:08
view safety through this highly binary lens.
1:11
Speaker 1: Like good guys inside, bad guys outside.
1:13
Speaker 2: Exactly, we assume the thread is always external, you know,
1:16
the invading force, the unauthorized intruder. Our entire modern security
1:22
infrastructure is built around hardening the perimeter just to keep
1:26
the outside world out right. But I mean, when you
1:29
only focus on the perimeter, you completely ignore the internal ecosystem.
1:34
You ignore the vulnerabilities of the invisible workforce that literally
1:38
keeps those fortresses functioning after all the executives go home.
1:41
Speaker 1: Okay, let's unpack this because I want you the listener,
1:44
to really picture your own office building after hours.
1:47
Speaker 2: It's a completely different world it is.
1:49
Speaker 1: Think about the quarters you walk down every single day.
1:52
Imagine them at like two.
1:53
Speaker 2: In the morning, just total silence.
1:55
Speaker 1: Completely empty, just the hum of the fluorescent lights, the
1:58
absolute silence of the cubicles, and the people who arrive
2:02
with their carts to clean up the mess after the
2:03
powerful have gone to sleep. That is the world we
2:06
are stepping into today. And our setting here is to Rector.
2:10
Speaker 2: Street right down to the Financial District.
2:12
Speaker 1: YEP. It's this massive, gleaming commercial tower in the Financial
2:17
district of New York City.
2:18
Speaker 2: And you know the context of time and place is
2:21
basically the foundation of this entire situation. The year is
2:24
two thousand and nine, and to Rector Street is located
2:27
just a few blocks from the World Trade Center reconstruction site.
2:30
Speaker 1: So I mean, you literally cannot get a more hypervigilant
2:34
location on the entire map of the United States.
2:36
Speaker 2: No, you really can't. And that geographic reality it dictated
2:40
everything about how this building operated. Lower Manhattan in two
2:44
thousand and nine was still deeply psychologically scarred by the
2:47
attacks of September eleventh. Of course, the architectural and operational
2:52
mindset of the entire districts was just fiercely defensive. Threat
2:56
modeling was focused almost entirely on mass casualty.
2:59
Speaker 1: Terrorism, looking for bombs, not interpersonal islands.
3:02
Speaker 2: Exactly. So two Rector Street implemented layers of what security
3:06
professionals actually call access control. They had physical guard stationed
3:10
around the clock. They possessed this incredibly dense network of
3:15
high definition cameras monitoring the lobby, the loading docks, and
3:20
every single exterior door.
3:22
Speaker 1: They even use electronically programmed RFID keys, right, the ones
3:26
that restricted people from just wandering around. Yeah, the key cards,
3:29
Like you couldn't just get in an elevator and push
3:30
a button. Your badge only let you onto the specific
3:33
floor where you actually worked.
3:35
Speaker 2: And that network of access control creates a massive digital footprint.
3:39
Speaker 1: Oh, because it tracks you.
3:41
Speaker 2: Right, every time a card swipes, a server logs the identity,
3:44
the timestamp, and the location. It is designed to create
3:48
an absolutely impenetrable digital and physical wall.
3:51
Speaker 1: And the building had the tenant list to justify it.
3:54
I mean we're talking about high profile occupants here, like
3:56
the architect Daniel Libskin. Yeah, he was the man literally
4:00
developing the master plan for the reconstruction of the New
4:02
World Trade Center, and his offices were right there into
4:06
Rector Street. So the environment was actively projecting this aura
4:10
of total, unshakable authority.
4:13
Speaker 2: But if we connect this to the bigger picture, if
4:15
we examine the mechanics of that security, we find a
4:18
classic tragic example of security theater. Security theater, Now, that
4:24
term usually implies the security as fake or just for show,
4:27
but in this case it was very real and highly
4:30
functional against its intended target, which was unauthorized external intruders.
4:35
But when you funnel millions of dollars into preventing an
4:38
outside attack, you generate a catastrophic blind spot regarding internal
4:42
interpersonal violence because.
4:44
Speaker 1: You aren't looking inside exactly.
4:45
Speaker 2: The system is designed to ask does this person have
4:48
a badge? It completely fails to ask is the person
4:51
holding the badge a danger to the people around them?
4:54
Speaker 1: I see this compared all the time to building a
4:57
moat around a castle, But that analogy for flawed to me, Well,
5:01
it's not just about building a moat and forgetting to
5:03
check the guards. It's way more insidious than that. By
5:07
sealing the building so tightly, by ensuring that nobody can
5:10
enter or exit without being recorded in log you weren't
5:13
just keeping the bad.
5:14
Speaker 2: Guys out right.
5:15
Speaker 1: If a predator happens to be legally employed inside that building,
5:19
you have basically engineered a hermetically sealed trap. You have
5:22
locked the predator inside with the prey, and you've guaranteed
5:25
the prey has absolutely no unmonitored avenue of escape.
5:29
Speaker 2: That is the chilling reality of modern corporate architecture. The
5:32
perimeter security ensure that whatever happened inside that shell would
5:37
remain contained entirely within it. It's a total inversion of safety.
5:41
The fortress literally becomes a cage.
5:43
Speaker 1: And that beautifully designed, heavily guarded cage is exactly what
5:47
a forty six year old woman named Aridania Rodriguez walked
5:50
into on the evening of July seven, two thousand and nine.
5:53
Speaker 2: Right, and to comprehend the gravity of the events that followed,
5:57
we really have to look closely at who Aerdania was
5:59
and this pacific sociological space she occupied in that building.
6:02
Speaker 1: Let's talk about her background.
6:04
Speaker 2: So she was born in San Francisco de Machorus, a
6:06
city in the Dominican Republic. It's a region known for
6:10
deep agricultural roots and a very very tight knit communal culture.
6:14
Speaker 1: And like so many people, she emigrated to the United
6:17
States in the nineteen eighties or nineties looking to build
6:19
a different kind of future exactly, and she succeeded in
6:23
building this deeply rooted, really vibrant life in New York.
6:27
She was married to Geronimo Figueroa. She was a mother
6:30
to three children, two daughters, Denise and yon Niras and
6:34
a son. By two thousand and nine, she had even
6:37
become a devoted grandmother.
6:39
Speaker 2: And the sources for this deep dive, including all these
6:41
interviews with her family and neighbors, they paint a remarkably
6:45
consistent picture of her personality.
6:47
Speaker 1: Yeah, she sounded incredible.
6:48
Speaker 2: She was described as just relentlessly peaceful. Her daughter Denise
6:52
noted she was someone full of positive thoughts. She really
6:56
embodies the archetype of the immigrant matriarch.
6:58
Speaker 1: Oh totally.
6:59
Speaker 2: You know, someone who absorbed the friction of a difficult
7:01
life just to ensure the upward mobility and stability of
7:04
her children.
7:05
Speaker 1: But she wasn't just existing in a vacuum either. She
7:07
had a sprawling, extended family network that was heavily involved
7:11
in her life, including her siblings, her brothers Caesar and Victor,
7:15
and her sister Denise.
7:16
Speaker 2: And her brother is a huge part of this narrative context.
7:19
Speaker 1: Yes, here's where it gets really interesting, because there is
7:23
a staggering, almost cinematic dichotomy within this family structure. Her brother,
7:28
Victor Martinez, was not just some casual fitness enthusiasts.
7:32
Speaker 2: No, he was world class.
7:33
Speaker 1: He was one of the most famous professional bodybuilders on
7:36
the entire planet. He won the Arnold Classic, which is
7:39
an event promoted by Arnold Schwarzenegger, and he was a
7:41
top contender on the mister Olympia stage.
7:44
Speaker 2: The contrast in their daily realities is profound. I mean,
7:48
consider the mechanics of Victor's life. He exists in a
7:51
state of extreme literal visibility. Right, he stands on brightly
7:56
lit elevated stages. His body is scrutinized, judged, celebrated by
8:00
thousands of people in arenas and by millions more through
8:03
international media. His physical presence is his entire currency.
8:07
Speaker 1: Right, he is hyper visible. Meanwhile, his sister Aridania is
8:13
experiencing the exact opposite extreme of the socioeconomic.
8:17
Speaker 2: Spectrum, the ultimate invisibility.
8:19
Speaker 1: Exactly. For about a year leading up to that July,
8:22
she worked as a night cleaner at two Rector Street.
8:25
She was a member of the SEIU Local thirty two
8:27
Bjay union. She made around twenty one dollars.
8:30
Speaker 2: An hour, which was solid for that era.
8:32
Speaker 1: Yeah, for the commercial cleaning industry at that time. That
8:34
was a decent union protected wage that came with benefits.
8:39
But the fundamental nature of the job itself is total invisibility.
8:43
Speaker 2: It is the literal physical erasure of the daytime world's mess.
8:48
We really have to examine this stark contrast within that
8:51
single building.
8:52
Speaker 1: The day versus night shift.
8:53
Speaker 2: Exactly during daylight hours, you have elite architectural firms designing
8:57
the skyline of the twenty first century. It's a space
8:59
of power, negotiation, and visibility. Then the sun sets, the executives.
9:04
Speaker 1: Leave, and the building flips right, and the immigrant.
9:08
Speaker 2: Women of the night shift arrived to quietly reset the stage.
9:11
The mechanics of the job require vacuuming miles of empty corridors,
9:16
wiping down massive conference tables, and hauling industrial trash bags
9:20
in absolute solitude.
9:22
Speaker 1: I honestly can't even imagine the psychological toll of that
9:25
kind of isolation. It's not just quiet, it's a heavy,
9:27
oppressive kind of quiet. Absolutely, and the sources point out
9:32
that Aridania was really feeling the weight of it. She
9:34
had been losing weight. She had explicitly told her family
9:38
and her coworkers that she felt deeply uneasy about working
9:41
alone at night in that massive, empty skyscraper.
9:44
Speaker 2: She knew something was off.
9:45
Speaker 1: She was even actively considering quitting the job, which is.
9:48
Speaker 2: A crucial detail because it tells us her situational awareness
9:51
was functioning perfectly. She intuitively understood the vulnerability of her
9:56
environment right. The isolation of night work in a commercial
9:59
high rise isn't a matter of feeling lonely, you know,
10:02
it is structurally dangerous. You are entirely cut off from
10:06
the herd. You are navigating vast dead zones in a
10:09
concrete labyrinth where a scream simply will not be heard.
10:13
Speaker 1: But she pushed through that fear because of her family.
10:16
That heavy burden of being invisible was just the price
10:19
of admission to provide for her kids and grandkids. Yeah,
10:22
but the tragedy is that her invisibility, the very thing
10:25
the corporate world demanded of her, was about to be
10:28
weaponized against her. The timeline of July seven, two thousand
10:32
and nine, starts off completely normally.
10:34
Speaker 2: Though right the early evening just establishes her standard routine.
10:38
At five zero pm, Aridinia arrives at two Rector Street
10:42
for her shift. The lobby surveillance cameras capture her walking
10:46
through the turnstiles wearing her standard blue custodial uniform right
10:50
on time. By seven zero zero pm, the digital access
10:54
logs and lobby cameras show her stepping into a passenger elevator.
10:58
Her specific assignment for that evening was to clean the
11:00
offices on floors five through eight.
11:03
Speaker 1: So she goes up, the elevator, doors closed, and she
11:05
begins her solitary routine. But there is another person working
11:09
off hours in the building that night, a twenty five
11:11
year old man named Joseph Pabon.
11:13
Speaker 2: And he's a very different kind of employee.
11:15
Speaker 1: Yeah, he's from the New Springville neighborhood over in Staten Island.
11:18
The case files describe him as a husky, heavily tattooed guy.
11:22
He is employed by the building as an elevator.
11:25
Speaker 2: Operator, specifically the freight elevator.
11:27
Speaker 1: Yes, yeah, And on this specific Tuesday, he is working
11:30
an overtime shift running the freight elevator to assist a
11:34
moving company that is clearing out of vacated office space.
11:37
Speaker 2: Now we need to look at the unique power dynamic
11:41
of a freight elevator operator in a skyscraper. It's a
11:44
lot of power, it really is. Bobin had worked at
11:47
two Rector Street long enough to possess dangerous institutional knowledge.
11:51
He didn't just know where the bathrooms were. He knew
11:54
the internal anatomy of the twenty six story tower, the
11:57
hidden parts exactly. He understood the fire stairwells, the blind corners,
12:01
the utility corridors. Most importantly, he knew the exact boundaries
12:05
of the camera network, and this is.
12:06
Speaker 1: Where the narrative shifts from just a quiet night shift
12:09
into something incredibly sinister. Because the timeline is driven by
12:13
intentional predatory movements. According to testimony from his coworkers, Pabon
12:18
actively seeks out information. He asks another employee where the
12:23
cleaning woman Aridania is assigned to work that night he's hunting.
12:27
Exactly shortly after getting that information, he tells the moving
12:31
crew he has a stomach issue and needs to use
12:33
the bathroom. He hands off the manual controls of the
12:36
freight elevator, he walks away, and for the next forty
12:39
two minutes, Joseph Pabon completely disappears from the building's massive
12:44
surveillance grid.
12:46
Speaker 2: That forty two minute gap is the defining anomaly of
12:48
this entire case.
12:49
Speaker 1: It's terrifying.
12:50
Speaker 2: In a post nine to eleven fortress equipped with continuous surveillance,
12:54
generating forty two minutes of unrecorded time is not an accident.
12:58
It requires a deliberate exploitation of the system's blind spots
13:02
by someone who literally holds the keys to the infrastructure.
13:05
Speaker 1: I keep trying to visualize how that is even physically possible.
13:08
Like we established earlier that the perimeter is sealed, you
13:11
can't leave without the cameras catching you. So how does
13:14
a grown man vanish inside a lock box?
13:17
Speaker 2: Right?
13:17
Speaker 1: It makes me think of an old arcade game like
13:19
pac Man.
13:20
Speaker 2: Oh, that's an interesting way to look at it.
13:22
Speaker 1: Yeah, Like the cameras are only watching the main maze,
13:25
the lobby, the front doors. But Paban knew how to
13:28
use the warp tunnels. He knew how to step off
13:30
the edge of the monitored board and travel through the
13:32
unseen arteries of the building to pop out exactly where
13:35
he wanted to be.
13:36
Speaker 2: That is an incredibly accurate way to model his movement.
13:41
The surveillance budget in these buildings is heavily concentrated on
13:44
the perimeter, you know, to prevent unauctwised entry. But once
13:48
an individual is credentialed them inside the shell, the internal
13:52
transit systems, the freight shafts, the emergency egress stairwells, the
13:57
mechanical rooms, they are often completely unmonitored. They are the
14:01
warp tunnels.
14:02
Speaker 1: So the clock is ticking, Paban is off the grid
14:05
and then we hit ten thirty PM. One of Aridania's
14:08
coworkers realizes that nobody has seen her.
14:11
Speaker 2: For hours, which is highly unusual.
14:13
Speaker 1: Yeah, in a building that empty, usually cross paths or
14:16
at least hear a vacuum. They go looking for her.
14:18
They take the elevator up to the eighth floor, which
14:20
was mostly deserted that night, and sitting right there in
14:23
the middle of the hallway is her cleaning cart. It's
14:25
just abandoned. The vacuum is off, the supplies are sitting there.
14:29
It is the universal terrifying sign that some external force
14:33
has violently interrupted her.
14:35
Speaker 2: Routine, absolutely chilling.
14:37
Speaker 1: The coworker immediately alerts security. They call her daughter, and
14:40
the family races down to the financial district, but Aridania
14:44
is gone. She entered the cameras at five zero pm,
14:47
but she never crossed the lobby threshold to leave.
14:49
Speaker 2: And what's fascinating here is that the reconstruction of what
14:53
occurred during those unrecorded forty two minutes relies entirely on
14:57
the forensic evidence.
14:58
Speaker 1: Left behind her, because there's no video.
15:00
Speaker 2: Right, no video, and what that evidence reveals is a
15:03
staggering level of brutality. But simultaneously an awe inspiring display
15:09
of physical resilience by the victim.
15:11
Speaker 1: I really want to make sure we honor that resilience,
15:13
because Eridania didn't just freeze when Pibun used his knowledge
15:16
of the building to track her down to an isolated
15:18
section of the eighth floor and attacker, she fought back.
15:21
Speaker 2: She fought hard.
15:22
Speaker 1: We are talking about a forty six year old grandmother
15:25
fighting off a husky twenty five year old man who
15:28
does heavy lifting for a living, and she fought him
15:31
so ferociously that she gouged his neck, his torso, and
15:35
his head.
15:35
Speaker 2: The forensic reality of that struggle is profound. In the
15:39
midst of fighting for her life, she was actively securing
15:43
the biological evidence required to solve her own murder aaw
15:47
By clawing at him, she forced his skin cells and
15:50
his DNA deep beneath her fingernails.
15:52
Speaker 1: She made sure he couldn't just walk away clean. But
15:55
the mechanics of how he finally overpowered her are just
15:58
gut wrenching. He didn't just hit her. He systematically restrained her.
16:02
He bound her hands tightly behind her back, he bound
16:04
her feet, and then he used heavy duty industrial construction
16:07
tape to wrap her face and mouth.
16:09
Speaker 2: We really have to analyze the use of that specific material.
16:13
Industrial construction tape has incredibly aggressive adhesive properties. It is
16:18
designed to bind heavy materials together and resist moisture.
16:21
Speaker 1: It's not like regular masking tape, not at all.
16:24
Speaker 2: It does not stretch or yield like standard household tape.
16:28
When applied tightly over the lower half of the face,
16:31
it ceases to be a mere gag. It actually becomes
16:34
a mechanism of asphyxiation.
16:36
Speaker 1: Ah, that's horrific.
16:37
Speaker 2: It restricts the airways so severely that it acts as
16:40
the murder weapon, and the crime scene photos noted a
16:44
particularly cruel detail. Her gold crucifix necklace became caught in
16:49
the adhesive, left dangling near her mouth as she was suffocated.
16:53
Speaker 1: It's one of those visceral details that just burns into
16:55
your memory. So he commits this horrific act on the
16:58
eighth floor. But now he has a massive problem, right
17:01
he has a body. Yeah, he has a body in
17:03
a building that is about to be heavily searched. But
17:05
because he is the freight elevator operator, he controls the
17:08
ultimate transport mechanism.
17:10
Speaker 2: A commercial freight elevator is essentially a mobile room that
17:13
operates entirely behind the scenes, doesn't stop at lobby levels
17:16
unless summoned. Pabun loaded her body into that freight car
17:20
completely bypassing the passenger corridors and took her up to
17:23
the twelfth floor.
17:24
Speaker 1: And the twelve floor wasn't just a random choice.
17:26
Speaker 2: Was it not? At all? Yeah, the twelve floor was
17:29
actively under renovation. In commercial real estate, a floor under
17:33
renovation is a chaotic environment. The internal walls are often
17:37
torn down, the drop ceilings are removed, and the structural
17:41
guts of the building, the wires, the pipes, the massive
17:45
steel ventilation ducts. They are completely exposed.
17:48
Speaker 1: Which provides the perfect physical cover for concealment.
17:52
Speaker 2: Exactly.
17:52
Speaker 1: He drags her into an obscure utility room, and he
17:55
doesn't just leave her on the floor. He physically stuffs
17:58
her body into an air conditioning duct, a massive metal
18:03
ventilation shaft wedged in the space between the twelfth and
18:06
thirteenth floors.
18:07
Speaker 2: It's incredibly tightened there.
18:08
Speaker 1: He takes her shoes off and throws them further down
18:11
the duct system to make her profile even smaller. It
18:13
is an incredibly tight, dark, mechanically complex hiding spot, and
18:17
once she is hidden, he just well, it just goes.
18:20
Speaker 2: Back to work. He re enters the camera network exactly
18:23
forty two minutes after he left it. The surveillance footage
18:26
shows him walking down a back hallway, but now he
18:28
has a shirt draped over his shoulders and around his neck.
18:31
Speaker 1: Oh to hide the scratches.
18:32
Speaker 2: It is a highly deliberate adjustment to his uniform, designed
18:36
specifically to hide the severe defensive scratches Aridamia just inflicted
18:40
on him. He approaches his supervisor, claims his stomach virus
18:44
has flared up severely, clocks out early, and takes the
18:47
ferry back home to Staten Island.
18:49
Speaker 1: He goes to sleep that night, believing he just pulled
18:52
off the perfect locked room murder. He basically weaponized the
18:57
building's own life support systems, the hvac U, to erase
19:01
a human being, and for four agonizing days, as the
19:05
city woke up and the executives came back to work,
19:08
it looked like he was going to get away with it.
19:10
Speaker 2: What followed the official missing person's report the next morning
19:13
was a logistical nightmare for the New York Police Department.
19:17
Searching a commercial high rise is not like executing a
19:19
search warrant on a residential home.
19:21
Speaker 1: I honestly can't even fathom where you begin searching a
19:24
twenty six story skyscripper. You just start opening doors.
19:28
Speaker 2: You begin with the blueprints, but in a building that
19:30
old blueprints often lie. Buildings are retrofitted over decades. You
19:35
were dealing with hundreds of thousands of square feet. But
19:37
the real challenge is what architects call interstitial space or
19:41
punum space.
19:42
Speaker 1: What does that mean?
19:43
Speaker 2: This is the void between the structural concrete floor of
19:46
one level and the suspended drop ceiling of the level
19:49
below it. It could be several feet deep. It houses
19:52
all the telecommunications cabling, the plumbing, and the massive sheet
19:56
metal HVAC returns.
19:58
Speaker 1: So a twenty six story building actually has miles of
20:01
hidden secondary tunnels built right into the ceiling exactly.
20:05
Speaker 2: It is a three dimensional vertical labyrinth. The NYPD brought
20:08
in bloodhounds. They had hundreds of officers going floor by floor,
20:12
popping ceiling tiles, shining flashlights into elevator shafts, and opening
20:17
locked mechanical closets.
20:18
Speaker 1: It's like looking for a needle in a haystack, but
20:20
the haystack is made of concrete and steel.
20:22
Speaker 2: And simultaneously, detectives were commandeering the security office, sitting through
20:26
thousands of hours of digital camera footage from every conceivable angle,
20:30
just trying to spot a single mistake.
20:32
Speaker 1: And the search wasn't even contained to the building. Because
20:36
Aridania was a cleaner and she disappeared near her trash cart,
20:39
the police had to account for the horrifying possibility that
20:41
she had been thrown down a trash chute and hauled
20:44
away by the sanitation trucks before.
20:46
Speaker 2: Gone, which meant searching the trash.
20:48
Speaker 1: Yes, they literally trace the building's waste manifest and the logistics.
20:53
Speaker 2: Of that specific avenue of the investigation are just staggering.
20:57
A modern commercial landfill isn't just a random pile of garbage.
21:01
It is a highly organized, layered grid. I didn't know that.
21:05
Oh yeah, the trucks are weighed, their origins are logged,
21:08
and they dump in specific geographic cells. The NYPD had
21:13
to identify the exact trucks that service to rector street
21:16
track them to a massive landfill in Pennsylvania, bring in
21:19
heavy excavators to peel back the newer layers of trash,
21:23
and put officers in hazmat suits to manually rake through
21:26
tons of rotting debris.
21:28
Speaker 1: All while Aridania's family is standing on the sidewalk outside
21:31
to Rector Street, completely paralyzed by panic.
21:34
Speaker 2: It's agonizing for them.
21:35
Speaker 1: They know she went into the building, they know she
21:37
never came out. Her brother, Victor Martinez, is at the
21:41
absolute peak of his bodybuilding career, and the sources note
21:44
he is completely derailed. The gym, the training, the discipline,
21:48
it all vanishes.
21:49
Speaker 2: The human toll is immediate.
21:50
Speaker 1: He is too distraught to even prepare for his upcoming
21:53
international competitions. The family is trapped outside this impenetrable fortress,
21:58
waiting for answers.
21:59
Speaker 2: The art chitecture of the building, the sleek, minimalist design
22:03
that corporations pay millions for, is specifically intended to hide
22:07
its ugly mechanical guts. Paban exploited that design to hinder
22:11
the rescue operation. He used the building's desire to look
22:14
clean against the people searching it.
22:16
Speaker 1: But on July eleventh, four days after the cart was found,
22:19
the illusion of the perfect crime finally cracks. An NYPD
22:22
detective is conducting yet another sweep of that chaotic twelfth floor,
22:26
the renovation floor exactly. He is inspecting the exposed infrastructure,
22:31
and he notices something that shouldn't be there. He spots
22:34
a dark liquid, a biological fluid, leaking from the seams
22:38
of a large sheet metal ventilation.
22:40
Speaker 2: Shaft, and that visual discovery is the exact moment the
22:44
operation violently pivots. It is no longer a rescue mission.
22:48
It instantly becomes a homicide investigation and a man hunt.
22:52
Speaker 1: The tone shifts entirely.
22:54
Speaker 2: The crime scene unit is called in. They literally have
22:56
to dismantle the.
22:57
Speaker 1: Heavy duct work, and in inside that tight, claustrophobic metal box,
23:01
they find Aridania. She is face down, still wearing her
23:05
blue custodial uniform. Her shoes are missing, her hands and
23:09
feet are bound with the industrial tape, and the tape
23:11
is wrapped tightly around her face brutal. The medical examiner
23:15
is brought in and the official cause of death is
23:17
ruled as asphyxiation.
23:19
Speaker 2: The detectives on the scene were stunned by the mechanical
23:22
complexity of the concealment. They'd swept that exact floor multiple
23:26
times with dogs and flashlights and missed her simply because
23:30
the duct was so deeply embedded in the interstitial space
23:33
and the airflow of the HVAC system completely disrupted the
23:36
scent profile.
23:37
Speaker 1: The building was basically protecting.
23:38
Speaker 2: His secret, But the moment they recovered her body, the
23:42
investigative focus snapped away from the physical building and zeroed
23:45
in on the human beings who possessed the keys to
23:48
that infrastructure.
23:49
Speaker 1: And it didn't take long for the spotlight to hit
23:51
Joseph Pebbun because remember, during those four days of searching,
23:55
the police were actively interviewing every single person who swiped
23:59
a badge in that building. On July seventh, when detectives
24:03
first pulled Paban into the precinct for a routine interview,
24:06
they didn't need a microscope to see he was involved.
24:09
The physical evidence was practically screaming at.
24:11
Speaker 2: Them because the visual presentation of a suspect shortly after
24:14
a violent struggle is highly informative. When Paban sat down
24:19
in the interview room, he was covered in fresh healing injuries.
24:23
He had deep visible scratch marks traversing his nick, his hands,
24:27
his torso, and his scalp, and.
24:29
Speaker 1: He also had these very specific fingerprint shaped bruises on
24:33
his forearms and viceps yes.
24:35
Speaker 2: In forensic pathology, those are classified as classic defensive wounds.
24:39
They occur when a victim is violently grabbing the attacker's arms,
24:42
desperately trying to peel them away from their body or
24:45
their throat.
24:46
Speaker 1: So the bruises literally matched the grip of a human
24:49
hand precisely. The detectives know exactly what they're looking at,
24:52
so they start pressing him. They lean into the emotional angle.
24:56
They talk about Aridanius family standing outside the building, crying,
25:00
just wanting to find their mother to give her a
25:01
proper patholic burial up behind the pressure, and under that pressure,
25:06
Peban actually breaks down. He starts crying in the interrogation room.
25:10
But here is the critical thing. A guilty conscience doesn't
25:13
automatically mean.
25:14
Speaker 2: A confession, No, it rarely does.
25:16
Speaker 1: Despite the tears, he sticks to an alibi that makes
25:20
absolutely no logical sense. He claims the scratches are from
25:24
hauling heavy boxes and that his strange behavior and disappearance
25:28
were just the stomach.
25:30
Speaker 2: Virus, and the investigators knew he was the perpetrator. But
25:33
standard police procedure requires crossing the threshold from suspicion to
25:37
evidentiary proof.
25:38
Speaker 1: Right, you can't just arrest on a hunch.
25:40
Speaker 2: You cannot arrest someone purely on the existence of fresh
25:43
scratches and a weak alibi. They needed the biological science
25:47
to catch up to their instincts. So they release him,
25:50
but they place him under heavy, continuous surveillance while the
25:53
lab processes the evidence from the duct.
25:56
Speaker 1: So what does this all mean. While the surveillance teams
25:59
are tailor Pibon around Staten Island, the background investigators are
26:03
pulling his files. And this is the part of the
26:06
story that I think will make any listener incredibly angry.
26:09
Speaker 2: It's a massive failure.
26:10
Speaker 1: Because we find out that Pebon isn't just a guy
26:13
with a clean record who suddenly snapped. He had a
26:16
deeply disturbing, highly violent, and incredibly recent criminal history. Just
26:21
three months prior to Aridinia's murder, in April of two
26:24
thousand and nine, he was arrested for a terrifying domestic
26:27
violence incident in Sunnyside, Queens and.
26:30
Speaker 2: The mechanics of that prior arrest are essential to understanding
26:32
the systemic corporate failure to Rector Street. According to the
26:35
police reports, Peban had physically attacked his girlfriend, Lisa Marie Blumenberg.
26:40
He placed his hands around her neck and choked her.
26:42
Speaker 1: He choked her.
26:43
Speaker 2: Yes, Then, in a state of uncontrolled rage in the
26:47
middle of a public intersection, he grabbed a heavy bowling
26:51
ball and violently smashed the windshield of her car. When
26:55
the NYPD arrived to intervene, he actively resisted arrest.
27:00
Speaker 1: Wa wait, I don't understand If he was arrested for
27:02
choking a woman and attacking a car with a bowling
27:05
ball in April, how is he operating a freight elevator
27:08
in a highly secure Manhattan skyscraper in July.
27:12
Speaker 2: Well, it comes down to the mechanics of the municipal
27:14
justice system and the gaps in corporate background checks. Payband
27:18
plead guilty to a charge of criminal mischief, just criminal mischief. Yes,
27:22
he was granted a conditional discharge, which essentially means the
27:25
court releases you without incarceration provided you meet certain conditions
27:29
like staying out of trouble for a specified period. But
27:32
a conditional discharge in Queen's Criminal Court does not automatically
27:36
trigger an alert to the human resources department of a
27:39
private real estate firm in Manhattan.
27:41
Speaker 1: That is just an unfathomable failure of duty of care.
27:45
We pour millions of dollars into RFID key cards and
27:48
biometric scanners to make sure unauthorized people don't steal corporate laptops.
27:52
But the guy who literally choked his girlfriend in the
27:54
street three months ago is handed the master keys to
27:57
the building. He is given unmonited structural access to an isolated, vulnerable,
28:03
night shift workforce consisting almost entirely of women.
28:07
Speaker 2: It highlights how dangerously disjointed our definitions of a security
28:12
risk truly are. Corporate security models excel at protecting data,
28:17
intellectual property, and physical assets, but they consistently ignore the
28:21
behavioral red flags of the human beings operating within the perimeter.
28:25
Speaker 1: They weren't looking for a violent threat exactly.
28:28
Speaker 2: The system flagged him as a violent threat to women
28:30
in April, but because the corporate security apparatus wasn't looking
28:34
for that specific type of data, they allowed him to
28:36
command the freight elevators in July.
28:38
Speaker 1: Finally, on July seventeenth, the science delivers the knockout blow.
28:42
The lab results come back from the Medical Examiner's office
28:45
and the DNA profile is undeniable.
28:47
Speaker 2: The science is objective.
28:48
Speaker 1: They analyze the cellular material recovered from deep beneath Aradania's fingernails,
28:54
they find a mixed DNA profile. The major contributor is
28:57
Aridania herself, but the a minor contributor. The foreign genetic
29:02
material is a perfect statistical match to Joseph Pabon a
29:07
direct link. Furthermore, investigators found a workman's glove left behind
29:11
in the utility area near the duct, and that glove
29:14
contained a mixture of both of their DNA. A police
29:17
source speaking to the press at the time called the
29:19
DNA match one hundred percent solid.
29:22
Speaker 2: And that forensic anchor is the legal threshold required for action.
29:27
Once the lab certifies that match, the surveillance teams are
29:30
given the green light to execute the arrest. Warrant and
29:33
the logistical execution of that arrest provides a stark look
29:36
at the reality of Peban's daily life.
29:38
Speaker 1: They don't just knock on his apartment door at dawn.
29:40
The apprehension is incredibly dramatic. Peyban is driving his sedan.
29:44
He comes to a stop at a red light at
29:46
the intersection of Clove Road and Victory Boulevard and Staten
29:49
Island middle of the day. He is actually sitting in
29:51
the backseat of the car. His girlfriend is driving, and
29:53
they had just left a children's party.
29:55
Speaker 2: The juxtaposition is striking. He is participating in the mundane,
30:00
joyful rituals of family life, while simultaneously knowing a massive
30:05
homicide investigation is circling him.
30:08
Speaker 1: Suddenly, unmarked cars block the intersection. Eight plane clothes NYPD
30:13
officers swarm the sedan. They draw their service weapons, They
30:16
surround the vehicle, They rip the doors open, and they
30:19
physically yank him.
30:20
Speaker 2: Out of the backseat.
30:21
Speaker 1: A total takedown, and the only thing Pebon does is
30:23
yell ah and threw his hands up in the air.
30:26
He didn't ask why he was being arrested. He knew
30:28
exactly why the guns were drawn.
30:30
Speaker 2: He is transported to Central Booking and formally indicted on
30:33
charges of second degree murder and kidnapping. But any prosecutor
30:37
will tell you that in arrest, even one backed by
30:39
a mountain of DNA evidence in a perfect timeline, is
30:42
merely the beginning of the battle.
30:44
Speaker 1: The trial is a whole different beast.
30:46
Speaker 2: An indictment is just an accusation. You still have to
30:48
step into a court room and prove it to twelve
30:50
ordinary citizens beyond a reasonable doubt.
30:53
Speaker 1: And the trial, which finally begins in early twenty twelve
30:56
in Manhattan Supreme Court. Is an absolute master class in
31:00
the friction of the justice system. It shows how difficult
31:03
it is to secure a conviction when a defense attorney
31:06
is willing to throw an avalanche of alternative theories at
31:09
the jury just to see if a single seat of
31:11
doubt takes root.
31:12
Speaker 2: The state's case was presented by Assistant District Attorney Christine Keenan.
31:16
Legal analysts observing the trial described her presentation as mathematically crushing.
31:21
Speaker 1: She elaid it all out.
31:22
Speaker 2: She didn't rely on a motion. She relied on logistics.
31:25
She built a massive chronological chart. She showed the jury
31:29
the exact forty two minute gap on the digital surveillance logs.
31:32
She brought in blueprints to map out his exclusive access
31:35
to the freight elevator, his intimate knowledge of the twelve
31:38
floor renovation space, and the testimony from his coworkers regarding
31:42
his specific questions about Eridania's location eighty eight.
31:45
Speaker 1: Keenan's argument is basically, look at the board, he had,
31:49
the opportunity, he possessed, the unique means to move her
31:52
through the building unseen, and the victim literally captured his
31:55
genetic identity under her fingernails. It seems insurmountable.
31:58
Speaker 2: It does.
31:59
Speaker 1: But then the defense attorney, Mario Galucci stands up to
32:02
give his opening statement, and he has the unenviable task
32:06
of explaining away the unexplainable. His opening stance is incredibly blunt.
32:11
He points to his client and says, he didn't do
32:14
a thing, nothing.
32:15
Speaker 2: Gluccy's strategy is a textbook example of generating reasonable doubt
32:19
through environmental contamination and coincidence. He cannot deny the timeline,
32:23
so he attacks the interpretation of the timeline.
32:26
Speaker 1: How does he explain the scratches?
32:28
Speaker 2: He argues that the severe scratch marks all over Pabon's
32:30
body were simply occupational hazards, the result of hauling heavy
32:34
abrace of boxes into the freight elevator all night. He
32:38
leans heavily into the verified alibi that Pebon had complained
32:41
of a stomach virus, arguing that the virus explains why
32:44
he disappeared to the bathroom, why he was sweating profusely,
32:47
and why he abruptly left his shift.
32:49
Speaker 1: Okay, I can almost understand a jury buying the stomach
32:51
bug excuse for the timeline. But the DNA. How on
32:55
Earth does a defense attorney stand in front of a
32:57
jury and explain away the suspect's cellular tissue deeply embedded
33:00
beneath the victim's fingernails.
33:02
Speaker 2: This is where we have to dive deeply into the
33:04
forensic science. Because the defense attempted to leverage a concept
33:08
known as transfer DNA. Galucci presented what was dubbed the
33:13
garbage transfer theory.
33:14
Speaker 1: The garbage transfer.
33:15
Speaker 2: Yeah, the core of the argument is that Pabon's job
33:18
involved manually handling the building's massive trash bags. Eridania's job
33:23
also involved handling and consolidating those exact same trash bags. Therefore,
33:28
the defense suggested their DNA simply carningled on the surface
33:32
of the plastic bags in the basement, and through casual contact,
33:36
his DNA is seriously migrated onto her hands and under
33:39
her nails.
33:40
Speaker 1: I'm sorry, but that theory feels almost insulting to basic biology.
33:43
Let's break down the science of why that is absurd.
33:45
I understand touch DNA. If I touch a coffee cup,
33:48
I leave a few microscopic epithelial cells on the ceramic.
33:51
If you touch the cup, maybe you pick up a
33:52
few of myself right, primary and secondary transfer, But we
33:56
are talking about subungle DNA, the material trap under a fingernail.
34:01
The mechanics required to extract skin tissue from another human
34:04
being and pack it tightly beneath the hard keratin of
34:07
your nail bed requires profound, forceful, aggressive friction, have to
34:12
literally shear the skin off their body. Handling the same
34:16
smooth plastic trash bag does not forcefully pack cellular material
34:20
deep into your nail bed.
34:21
Speaker 2: Your analysis of the biomechanics is entirely correct, and it
34:23
is exactly what the prosecution's forensic experts testified to. Secondary
34:28
transfer of microscopic touch DNA as a recognized phenomenon, but
34:31
transferring a major biological profile deep into a recessed anatomical
34:35
space like a nail bed via a secondary object is
34:38
practically impossible without direct violent friction. However, the defense's goal
34:43
wasn't to prove the garbage theory was a scientific certainty.
34:47
They only needed to convince one single juror that was
34:50
a possibility. Furthermore, Galucci muddied the waters by pointing out
34:55
that the lab found trace amounts of unidentified male DNA
34:58
on other pieces of evidence near the duct, and he
35:01
heavily emphasized reports that vagrants occasionally managed to bypass security
35:05
to sleep in the unmonitored emergency stairwells.
35:08
Speaker 1: So they are throwing everything at the wall. They are
35:11
trying to conjure a nameless, faceless boogieman from the stairwell
35:14
to take the blame, hoping the jury gets confused by
35:17
the noise. The prosecution, to their credit, doesn't even attempt
35:21
to establish a definitive motive. They don't need to. They
35:24
argue the mechanics of the crime prove it was a
35:26
crime of opportunity fueled by rage and control. After a grueling,
35:30
emotionally exhausting trial, the jury is sent out to deliberate.
35:34
They argue behind closed doors for two full days, and
35:37
on April six, twenty twelve, they return to the courtroom
35:40
with a verdict that contains a massive amount of legal nuance.
35:43
Speaker 2: This is perhaps the most legally complex aspect of the
35:46
entire story, and is vital to unpack it clearly. The
35:49
jury convicted Joseph Pabon of felony murder in the second
35:53
degree as well as first degree kidnapping. However, they formally
35:58
acquitted him on the charges of intent murder and reckless murder.
36:01
Speaker 1: Okay, I need to stop you right there, because as
36:04
a layperson, that sounds like a massive contradiction.
36:06
Speaker 2: It does sound contradictory.
36:08
Speaker 1: How can a jury look at a man who bound
36:10
a woman's hands, taped her mouth shut with industrial adhesive,
36:13
and shoved her into a metal ventilation shaft and say
36:17
we acquit you of intentional murder? Were they just cutting
36:20
a deal in the deliberation room.
36:22
Speaker 2: It often looks like a compromise from the outside, but
36:24
it is actually a demonstration of a jury adhering strictly
36:28
to the letter of the penal code regarding men's rea
36:30
or the state of mind. Okay, explain that the jury
36:33
clearly believed, beyond any shadow of a doubt that Pabone
36:37
was the individual who attacked her, bound her, and hid
36:40
her body. That is why they secured the conviction for
36:42
first degree kidnapping. Now, under New York state law, the
36:46
felony murder rule dictates that if a death occurs during
36:49
the commission of a specified severe felony like kidnapping, robbery,
36:53
or arson, the perpetrator is automatically guilty of secondary murder,
36:57
regardless of whether they explicitly planned the death.
37:00
Speaker 1: Oh I see. So the jury is saying, we know
37:02
you kidnapped her. We know she died as a direct
37:04
result of the actions you took while kidnapping her. Therefore,
37:08
the law says you are fully responsible for murdering her.
37:11
Speaker 2: Precisely, the acquittal on the specific charge of intentional murder
37:16
suggests that the jury felt the prosecution did not definitively
37:19
prove that Pabun's primary premeditated goal when he applied the
37:23
tape was to kill her.
37:24
Speaker 1: They thought maybe he just wanted to keep her quiet, right.
37:27
Speaker 2: They may have theorized that his intent was simply to
37:29
silence her screams or incapacitate her so he could move
37:32
her body, and that the fatal asphyxiation was a secondary,
37:35
albeit horrific consequence of the kidnapping. It's an incredibly technical
37:41
legal distinction regarding his internal thought process, but practically speaking,
37:45
a felony murder conviction carries the exact same weight of
37:48
accountability in the exact same sentencing guidelines as an intentional
37:51
murder conviction.
37:52
Speaker 1: The gavel finally falls, the jury has spoken, and the
37:56
sentencing phases where all the clinical legal terminology fades away
38:00
and the raw, unfiltered agony of this three year nightmare
38:04
spills out into the courtroom. Yeah On June five, twenty twelve,
38:07
Judge Maxwell Wiley presides over the sentencing. He hands down
38:11
the absolute maximum penalty allowed under the law, twenty five
38:14
years to life in state prison. Paban will not even
38:16
be eligible for a parole hearing until the year twenty
38:18
thirty four, and throughout the entire sentencing, as his fate
38:21
is sealed, Pabon remains completely silent.
38:23
Speaker 2: The Manhattan District Attorney at the time, Cyrus Arvans Junior,
38:27
released a formal statement emphasizing the profound brutality of taking
38:31
a mother away from her three children, but he also
38:34
made a point to highlight Erdania's physical courage, noting that
38:38
her desperate struggle to secure the DNA evidence was the
38:41
lynchpin of the conviction. He expressed hope that the maximum
38:45
sentence would bring a small measure of peace to the.
38:47
Speaker 1: Family, but the word piece feels incredibly hollow when you
38:51
actually listen to the family speak. Erdania's daughter, Denise Figueroa,
38:55
who is twenty nine years old at the time of
38:57
the sentencing, stood outside the courthouse on Center street and
39:01
delivered this incredibly raw, visceral statement to the press.
39:05
Speaker 2: It was heartbreaking.
39:06
Speaker 1: She was shaking with anger. She said, he's an animal.
39:08
You don't call that person a human being. All that
39:10
my mother suffered, now it's time for Joseph Pabben to suffer.
39:14
He will never now see the sun anymore.
39:16
Speaker 2: You are hearing the searing, permanent trauma of a child
39:20
who has been forced to vividly imagine her mother's final moments,
39:24
bound to the dark, suffocating alone inside a metal ventilation shaft.
39:29
Eridania was eventually transported back to her hometown in the
39:32
Dominican Republic to be buried. She made her final journey
39:35
home and her brother. Her brother, Victor Martinez, eventually channeled
39:39
his immense grief back into the discipline of bodybuilding, finding
39:42
some solace in the rigid structure of his sport. But
39:45
the void left in the center of that family is
39:47
permanent and unfillable.
39:49
Speaker 1: And as for Paban, he is currently sitting in a
39:52
cell at the sing Sing Correctional Facility, a maximum security
39:55
state prison in Austining, New York. He continues to maintain
39:59
his absolute inn His various legal appeals have been systematically
40:03
denied by.
40:03
Speaker 2: The higher courts because the evidence holds up.
40:05
Speaker 1: The fundamental pillars of the case. The digital timeline, the
40:09
biological DNA match, and his exclusive operational access to the
40:14
building's infrastructure remain absolute. Recently, the case even re entered
40:19
the global cultural footprint. It was prominently featured in a
40:22
twenty twenty four Netflix documentary series called Homicide New York,
40:26
which brought the story of the night Cleaner to an
40:28
entirely new generation of viewers.
40:30
Speaker 2: And this raises an important question beyond the true crime fascination,
40:34
beyond the television documentaries, We have to ask what actually
40:38
changed in the physical world.
40:40
Speaker 1: Did the buildings get safer?
40:41
Speaker 2: The case generated a lot of immediate corporate lick service
40:44
about reviewing night cleaner security protocols and improving safety. But
40:49
for the thousands of immigrant women who will swipe their
40:51
Metro cards this afternoon, take the subway into Manhattan, walk
40:55
into those massive empty towers at five zero zero PM tonight,
40:58
where any sweeping mandated structural changes implemented. Aridania's death exposed
41:04
massive fatal cracks in the architecture of corporate security. But
41:07
there's very little empirical evidence that the industry actually filled.
41:10
Speaker 1: Those cracks, and that brings us right back to you,
41:13
the listener. The next time you walk into your pristine
41:16
office building at eight am, the coffee is brewing in
41:19
the breakroom, The trash cans are lined with fresh plastic,
41:22
the carpets are perfectly vacuumed. I want you to stop and.
41:25
Speaker 2: Look around, realize what it takes.
41:27
Speaker 1: I want you to remember that that cleanliness is not magic.
41:30
It doesn't just happen. It is the direct result of intense,
41:34
physical human labor. It is the result of isolated, vulnerable
41:39
people navigating immense spaces that were designed to protect assets,
41:43
not to protect the people maintaining them.
41:45
Speaker 2: We spend billions of dollars globally engineering fortresses to protect
41:49
intellectual property, server farms, and executive suites from outside forces.
41:53
But the mechanics of Aridanias story reveal a terrifying, undeniable
41:57
truth about modern architecture is only as secure as the
42:01
most vulnerable person working inside it.
42:04
Speaker 1: If we continue to design systems that treat the people
42:06
maintaining them as invisible parts of the machinery. If we
42:10
build massive, impenetrable castles but refuse to run background checks
42:15
on the guards holding the keys to the dungeons. We
42:18
are inadvertently designing the perfect shadows for monsters to hide in. Absolutely,
42:23
we give them the blueprint, the isolation, and the timeline
42:26
to erase the very people we rely on to keep
42:28
the lights on. Thank you for joining us on this
42:30
deep dive. Stay curious, look much closer at the invisible
42:33
systems humming around you every day, and always remember to
42:36
question who exactly the fortress was built to protect.