Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Trends in Motion Picture and Television Financial Litigation
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Trends in Motion Picture and Television
- 0:07Financial Litigation. My name is Ilan Haimov.
- 0:10I'm a partner and entertainment practice leader
- 0:13at the accounting firm of GHA, where I focus
- 0:17on film and television, profit participation,
- 0:20audits, and forensics. I am pleased and honored
- 0:23to moderate today's panel. Today's program is
- 0:26sponsored by the Entertainment Law Section. The
- 0:29Entertainment Law Section itself is sponsored
- 0:31by the Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company. For
- 0:35five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance Company
- 0:37has been the only California -based company to
- 0:40continuously provide lawyers throughout the state
- 0:42with professional liability insurance coverage.
- 0:45Their experience and expertise are complemented
- 0:49by the fact that LMIC is directed by a group
- 0:53of dedicated lawyers. They offer special rates
- 0:56with competitive premiums for wide range of area
- 1:01of practice, including entertainment law, learn
- 1:03more at lawyersneutral .com. And with that, I'm
- 1:10delighted to introduce our speakers. We have
- 1:12with us today, Ashley Jurgen, partner and co
- 1:16-chair of the entertainment and media group at
- 1:18Russ, August, and Cabot. We also have Bobby Schwartz,
- 1:23partner and co -chair of the Media and Entertainment
- 1:25Industry Practice at Quinn Emmanuel's Los Angeles
- 1:28office. And last but not least, we have Chatfish
- 1:31Gerald, partner with Focus on Entertainment Litigation
- 1:34at the Kinsella Law Firm. Welcome. Thank you
- 1:39for having us, Alon. Thank you. Yeah, it's my
- 1:43honor. And really, really quickly from a logistical
- 1:45perspective, We have lots and lots of people
- 1:49joining today. If you do have any questions,
- 1:53please, as in the past has been done, please
- 1:55put those questions in the Q &A box and if time
- 1:58permits, we'll consider them. However, we only
- 2:00have an hour. And if we are unable to respond
- 2:03to them, we've asked the Beverly's Bar Association
- 2:06to send those to us and then we'll do our best
- 2:09to get back to you via email. So with that, let's
- 2:12get into it. All right. The first area we wanted
- 2:18to cover today is general industry trends. So
- 2:22we're gonna kind of start at the higher level.
- 2:24And what I wanted the panel to cover first is
- 2:29let's just talk about what trends each of us
- 2:32see in terms of type, significance and appetite
- 2:35for litigation. And we're going to go into following
- 2:37order. We're gonna have Bobby start, Chad will
- 2:40follow, and then Ashley. will close. And again,
- 2:43what trends do you see in terms of type, significance,
- 2:47appetite for litigation right now? Right. And
- 2:50obviously, we're confining this to litigation
- 2:53pertaining to financial arrangements, participations,
- 2:57investments, backends, that and not all the other
- 3:00kinds of disputes that we all get involved in.
- 3:02And I was joking. I think that the pithy comment
- 3:07is the more things change, the more they stay
- 3:09the same. The driver in a lot of disputes now
- 3:15is something that's been happening for 25 plus
- 3:18years, something that Larry Stein coined, actually
- 3:24more than 25 years ago, vertical integration
- 3:26with challenging related party transactions within
- 3:30a vertically integrated company. And he was suing
- 3:33at the time Fox, which the allegation was they
- 3:37were licensing, X files and other content to
- 3:43their affiliate, the FX cable basic cable service
- 3:46below market. And it was depriving the participants
- 3:49of money to which they were entitled. The result
- 3:52of that was a wave of contract provisions that
- 3:56dealt with how and the terms and the basis on
- 3:59which a studio could deal with licensed content
- 4:03to an affiliate, and there would be benchmarks.
- 4:07And over time, those benchmarks have become more
- 4:09and more favorable to the studios. Nonetheless,
- 4:12we are still seeing a lot of litigation. And
- 4:16we will go back to COVID. Warner Brothers then
- 4:20owned by AT &T announced Project Popcorn. Jason
- 4:23Collar took a lot of heat for that. The notion
- 4:25was that in the following year, that would be
- 4:30Calgary or 2022, I think, all of the Warner Brothers
- 4:33theatrical releases would debut day and date
- 4:36on HBO Max because there was a lot of pressure
- 4:39to drive viewers to HBO Max. And I represented
- 4:43a lot of clients that had theatrical deals with
- 4:45Warner Brothers who were not happy about that,
- 4:47particularly not just because it was undermining
- 4:49the theatrical revenue source, but it wasn't
- 4:52being made up on the... license fees that the
- 4:56affiliate was paying. And I think at the time,
- 5:00Warner took the position that, well, we're really
- 5:02sorry, but it turns out our output deal with
- 5:04HBO doesn't obligate them to pay additional monies
- 5:08for streaming the content because they obtained
- 5:11streaming rights under the original output deal
- 5:14with the linear channel. And so that's what it
- 5:17is. has not stopped. And at least I'm seeing
- 5:23situations where to build the audience or to
- 5:29make the economics of the affiliated distribution
- 5:33entity, which at this point is a streaming service,
- 5:35look better. The content acquisition costs are
- 5:39depressed or suppressed by paying less than what
- 5:44the studio would get from an independent streaming
- 5:47entity. So just to dig into this a little bit
- 5:51deeper, I've seen situations where a studio or
- 5:55TV network would create content with a client,
- 5:59co -finance, co -produce television series. And
- 6:03for a non -exclusive license to a Netflix or
- 6:07an Amazon or a Hulu, they might get $30 ,000
- 6:09to $50 ,000 an episode. The same episode of the
- 6:13same season, could be it was being made available
- 6:17on the affiliated streaming service at the same
- 6:20time. And we discovered that the payment was
- 6:24around $800 an episode. Very hard to justify
- 6:27that. And so I spend a fair amount of my time
- 6:35dealing with these situations. And I think there
- 6:38is less and less of a resistance on the part
- 6:41of the potential plaintiff. to file a lawsuit.
- 6:46And we'll get into that a little bit later. I
- 6:48don't want to monopolize this. So let me stop
- 6:50and tell you that's what I'm seeing. I think
- 6:59Chad, you're going to go next. OK. Yeah, thank
- 7:01you, Lon. Yeah, I have to echo everything that
- 7:06Bobby said. I mean, I'm primarily a talent litigator
- 7:10or present, you know, everything from individuals
- 7:12to smaller production companies against the studios.
- 7:16I do a lot of profit participation audits. And
- 7:19like Bobby said, you know, what is old is new.
- 7:21Again, it's the same thing we were dealing with
- 7:25in the in the inception of this vertical integration
- 7:28kind of litigation. The only difference is that
- 7:32now, instead of questioning the value of a license
- 7:36in syndication to a terrestrial cable network
- 7:40or internationally. Now the bulk of the money
- 7:43that the audits turn up is on streaming. Of course,
- 7:47streaming has changed and sort of upended the
- 7:50industry. But upended is probably the wrong word
- 7:53because it's the exact same claims like Bobby
- 7:55just said. It's, you know, instead of selling
- 7:57the show to your affiliated cable network in
- 8:01Germany or on basic cable in the U .S., they're
- 8:05licensing it for below market costs to their
- 8:07affiliated streaming platform. And the streaming
- 8:11wars, they seem to be kind of over or nearing
- 8:14an end now, but for a while, a few years ago,
- 8:1710 years ago to more recently, every major studio,
- 8:22with a couple notable exceptions, was in this
- 8:24arms race to establish their own in -house streaming
- 8:27service. And that is just a recipe for the price
- 8:32depression suppression that Bobby was talking
- 8:34about when they licensed their own content to
- 8:36their own streaming platform. So it's just a
- 8:38new vehicle, a new package for the same old problem.
- 8:42And I'm seeing, I agree with Bobby that there's
- 8:46certainly a lesser resistance for my clients
- 8:49to at least do an audit, right? To see if the
- 8:53show has made money, it's worth. however much
- 8:56a firm like yours would charge to do the audit.
- 8:59The audits often or almost always are gonna uncover
- 9:03some money, some potential shady accounting or
- 9:07whatever. And then it's also usually, I mean,
- 9:11I don't have a lot of cases that are going all
- 9:13the way to filing a complaint, but I certainly
- 9:16threatened that. And ideally we negotiate a resolution,
- 9:20but litigators are a part of that negotiation.
- 9:24And the only other thing I would add to on what
- 9:27Bobby said is that, you know, in the way that
- 9:30studios got smarter and smarter with these benchmarks,
- 9:33these affiliated transaction provisions that
- 9:36they would put into their contracts to say, oh,
- 9:38you know, it's okay that we do this as long as
- 9:40we meet some sort of nebulous standard. They
- 9:44also got very smart about putting mandatory arbitration
- 9:48clauses in there. So, I mean, the amount of court
- 9:51cases I get to file is very very tiny compared
- 9:54to it's all in arbitration and therefore it's
- 9:57you know confidential and we can't really we
- 9:59can talk about generalities but not specifics
- 10:02unless it's in court. I think Bobby and Chad
- 10:07pretty much covered everything that I'm seeing.
- 10:10I would just say that even preparing for this
- 10:11panel in terms of pulling materials was difficult
- 10:14for the reason that Chad just articulated, which
- 10:16is that most, if not all, of these cases right
- 10:19now are in arbitration. There are a few over
- 10:22big, huge issues that we've seen that impact
- 10:25participants like the Scarlett Johansson filing
- 10:27on the Black Widow thing a couple of years ago,
- 10:30the Village Roadshow WB started in court, so
- 10:33we sort of saw what some of those allegations
- 10:35were, which included an allegation about day
- 10:38and date exploitation of the matrix when it should
- 10:41have been theatrical only. And then you kind
- 10:44of had the CBS Sony fight over distribution and
- 10:49participation on those big series of Jeopardy
- 10:51and Wheel of Fortune. For the most part, though,
- 10:55everything else is sort of hidden, which is why
- 10:56it's important for these kinds of panels to happen
- 10:59so that we can kind of talk about what we're
- 11:01seeing in generalities to know what the claims
- 11:04are and what we should be looking out for. Elon,
- 11:07can I add something to what they were talking
- 11:08about? So I think arbitration, I mean, that is
- 11:12a fixture in virtually every contract I see now,
- 11:16and it may be 90 % plus, so that's whatever that
- 11:20translates to rhetorically. And I think the impetus
- 11:23for that was a desire to take these fights out
- 11:28of the public arena and avoid the press chiming
- 11:34in about what horrible people the studios are
- 11:37or whatever. And the assumption was it would
- 11:42be there'd be less adverse PR, it'd be faster
- 11:45and cheaper, and you could better contain the
- 11:49possibility of a runaway outcome. Maybe it has
- 11:54in some respects, but I think it has also caused
- 11:57disputes that might be on the bubble to be litigated
- 12:02where people would say, hey, you know what? No
- 12:05one else is going to know about this. Other companies
- 12:08that might hire me or that I might do deals with
- 12:10to co -finance things, won't know. Maybe that's
- 12:13wishful thinking. But I think there probably
- 12:17are more of these cases litigated because of
- 12:20arbitration provisions. And I'm not sure, frankly,
- 12:23that they're faster or cheaper. And as Fox found
- 12:25out in the Bones case, I don't know that there's
- 12:29insulation against getting hammered. I mean,
- 12:33obviously, when that arbitration ruling came
- 12:35before the Superior Court judge, he tossed out
- 12:37the punitive damage portion of it, but the underlying
- 12:43actual damage award was massive. So arbitration
- 12:50mixed bag. And the other thing is I've encountered
- 12:54a lot of people who, yeah, they know their client
- 12:57is subject to an arbitration provision, but they
- 12:59want to make a public statement. And so they'll
- 13:01file a lawsuit anyway, knowing that you're going
- 13:03to move to compel arbitration. and just sort
- 13:06of look sheepishly and whatever. But they got
- 13:10their shiv in your back with the PR they wanted.
- 13:16Thank you for that. Yeah, Bobby, I appreciate
- 13:18it. And thanks for the overview from everyone.
- 13:21So what I want to do now is, obviously, the big
- 13:25transaction that everybody is thinking about
- 13:29is the pending. sale of Warner Brothers, at least
- 13:33a portion of Warner Brothers, to Netflix and
- 13:37the ongoing battle between Paramount and Netflix
- 13:42in pursuit of those assets. And there is so much
- 13:46that will go on over the next maybe two years
- 13:49before we'll see who the ultimate buyer and how
- 13:52the transaction will look like. For the purpose
- 13:55of our webinar though, and again it's very difficult
- 13:59to predict, but wanted to see if you can comment
- 14:03on the potential impact of a significant transaction
- 14:07like this on the potential of litigation risk.
- 14:13And again, it could be a general comment or it
- 14:15could be more specific, but just hearing from
- 14:17you as to your thoughts as to how this transaction
- 14:22could potentially affect future litigation. And
- 14:26what I wanted to do here, sorry, just be more
- 14:28specific. Bobby, if you don't mind, maybe be
- 14:30the first to kick it off and then see if Chad
- 14:34and Ashley have anything. I'm happy to defer
- 14:36to them and then fill in. I don't want to be
- 14:38doing too much talking here. So why don't we
- 14:40let, unless whatever they want to do. Ashley,
- 14:43do you want to? Sure, I mean, I think it's going
- 14:45to be interesting to see if we assume Netflix
- 14:48is the one that takes all. Are they going to
- 14:52import the Netflix model on future WB property,
- 14:56or are they going to let WB continue the way
- 14:59that it's been? If it is the Netflix model, then
- 15:04over time you're going to see probably no back
- 15:07end in some of these deals, which will obviously
- 15:11lead to fewer profit participation cases, although
- 15:13they will be assuming a library that will have
- 15:15participations that go on for a period of time.
- 15:19So that's kind of one question. I think the theatrical,
- 15:22non -theatrical aspect of it is really interesting
- 15:25one. Ted has clarified his position on that recently.
- 15:29And I think people that are in production now
- 15:31on Warner's projects may have commitments that
- 15:35their projects is going to be released on 5 ,000
- 15:37screens or what have you. So one would hope as
- 15:41a participant or talent lawyer that those are
- 15:45going to be honored when Netflix comes to be
- 15:48the distributor of those works. If not, I think
- 15:50you'll see a lot of claims specifically arising
- 15:53in that area. Yeah, I mean that's exactly what
- 15:58I was gonna say and I just want to add on to
- 16:00it that the the talent community that least that
- 16:04I've heard from the talent reps and also talent
- 16:06themselves Are kind of justly freaking out about
- 16:10this because there's there's really no Good outcome
- 16:14or there are sort of there are problems with
- 16:17either outcome whether Netflix ends up owning
- 16:19one of others or paramount does if Netflix ends
- 16:23up warning owning them, it's everything that
- 16:25Ashley was just saying. It's the fear that back
- 16:28end will go away, that theatrical release windows
- 16:31will shrink to nothing. But conversely, it's
- 16:36not a bed of roses if Warner Brothers ends up,
- 16:40I mean, if Paramount ends up buying Warner Brothers,
- 16:43because then there's one less major studio, there's
- 16:46one less buyer for content out there. And how
- 16:49that affects negotiation, pricing, I mean, from
- 16:53my vantage point, selfishly, if Paramount ended
- 16:57up becoming the owner, you know, Paramount is
- 17:01a studio, they know how to do back end deals,
- 17:04they know how to put movies in theaters. So that
- 17:08might be great for my ongoing litigation work.
- 17:11But the fact that it's just more consolidation.
- 17:16Instead of a tech company, which Netflix essentially
- 17:19is, coming and buying a studio, it's another
- 17:21studio coming and buying a legacy studio. So
- 17:24there's one less buyer in the market. I have
- 17:27friends who work at Warner Brothers who remain
- 17:31nameless, but they're sort of looking at it from
- 17:36like... they might have a better chance of keeping
- 17:38their job longer if Netflix comes in, as opposed
- 17:43to a studio which will have redundancies and
- 17:46have legal departments and business affairs departments,
- 17:49there may be massive layoffs. So it's really
- 17:53not great on either side, from what I'm hearing.
- 17:59Uh -oh, it's gonna be unanimous. Netflix announced
- 18:06the bid. I'm not alone in having the reaction
- 18:10I had, which was why do they want Warner Brothers?
- 18:13Why do they think they need Warner Brothers?
- 18:15Are they buying it to keep it away from other
- 18:18competitors? How big of a competitor was Paramount
- 18:23at that point anyway? Did it matter? What did
- 18:26they really want? I don't think they bought Warner
- 18:28Brothers or hoped to buy Warner Brothers because
- 18:31They like being in the exact same business that
- 18:33Warner Brothers is currently in. I mean, that's
- 18:36a roller coaster ride. So you have to assume
- 18:39they bought Warner Brothers. At least I'm making
- 18:43the assumption they bought Warner Brothers to
- 18:45keep HBO Max from eating too far into their market
- 18:49share. And because they view Warner Brothers,
- 18:52especially the TV unit, but also the feature
- 18:55film unit, as a pipeline for content. and a whole
- 18:58group of people that have creative relationships
- 19:01and so on and so forth, and a great library that
- 19:04they can maximize. But it is not to maintain
- 19:07the status quo of Warner Brothers. And the status
- 19:09quo of Warner Brothers, at least historically,
- 19:11depended a lot on a theatrical release window.
- 19:15So there's gotta be, you have to assume there
- 19:16are gonna be big changes there. Will Netflix,
- 19:19if they acquire, if they are the winner, honor
- 19:22contracts, I think they're not going to set out
- 19:26to just... wholesale breach agreements. I think
- 19:30they've built into their models that there will
- 19:33be a period of time in which they have to honor
- 19:36certain obligations like Ashley was talking about
- 19:39for theatrical release commitments. But that
- 19:43phase will last as long as it has to last. And
- 19:46then Warner Brothers will be a different proposition
- 19:52than it is today. And if you and it's going to
- 19:57lead to more disputes. And I think what Ashley,
- 19:59I think you had a very good point about legacy
- 20:01content where there are ongoing obligations and
- 20:04there may be content that isn't subject to agreements
- 20:09that have affiliate provisions. And we saw a
- 20:14wave of class action lawsuits a couple of years
- 20:16ago involving older movies where classes were
- 20:20formed against each of the studios for distributing
- 20:22movies that predated home video provisions and
- 20:27royalty provisions and said what are you doing
- 20:29i never agreed to a royalty. Those got settled
- 20:32and and lately they dealt also with est which
- 20:36nobody really thinks about as a as a form of
- 20:39distribution now so anyway that's gonna happen
- 20:41and it's gonna have to just work its way through
- 20:43the system like that. rodent through a Python.
- 20:46If Paramount wins, I don't see it being that
- 20:49different. Again, I don't think Ellison is looking
- 20:54for scale. I think he's looking for content and
- 20:57wants to have a preeminent streaming platform.
- 21:01He may be a newer entrant, but the consolidation
- 21:08and the emphasis on streaming is inevitably going
- 21:11to change deal making. opportunities and drive
- 21:14more disputes. Everybody, all of your comments
- 21:20are appreciated, and I would agree with all the
- 21:24comments. I was just going to add that emphasizing
- 21:27something that I think both Ashley and Bobby
- 21:29mentioned more specifically, and it's a question.
- 21:33Will the ultimates potentially shrink in the
- 21:36future for existing IP that is being distributed
- 21:40by Warner. And with the combination of related
- 21:45parties coming together, I think there is that
- 21:47risk of valuation. There's that risk of arms
- 21:51length transactions and the ensuring that the
- 21:54valuation is reasonable. So there's, I'm sure
- 21:58more to come. Again, it's all hypothetical. We're
- 22:01all watching and seeing where we're going and
- 22:04more I'm sure we'll hear about in the coming
- 22:07year. All right, so we're going to jump into
- 22:09our next major area, which is just focusing on
- 22:15litigation in the area of contingent compensation.
- 22:18And here, I wanted you, Chad, to maybe kick it
- 22:22off. And again, this ties into what Ashley says.
- 22:25We rarely ever hear about those cases because
- 22:28they are subject to confidentiality within, obviously,
- 22:31the confines of an arbitration process. So we're
- 22:36going to talk. this in general, but I do want
- 22:38to see if we can dive into the kinds of issues
- 22:42that we're dealing with right now in connection
- 22:45with contingent comps. So we'll have Chad maybe
- 22:47kick it off and then Ashley and Bobby to add,
- 22:50obviously, as well. Well, I was noticing, and
- 22:55I'm not trying to jump ahead to the Q &A portion,
- 22:58but Greg Ramer had a good question about imputed
- 23:02license fees. and those making sort of becoming
- 23:05a thing again, as he said, and making a comeback.
- 23:08And I am seeing that not so much a litigation
- 23:12as in sort of pre -litigation, negotiating deals,
- 23:16negotiating settlements, but impute license fee
- 23:20just very briefly for anyone on this. panel who
- 23:23doesn't know or not in the panel on the audience
- 23:25who doesn't know is when there's a related party
- 23:28transaction and a check doesn't actually have
- 23:31to be cut and money moved from one arm of the
- 23:34company to the other, but they will literally
- 23:37impute sort of a bookkeeping entry for the value
- 23:40of the license of the transaction. It's an internal
- 23:42bookkeeping mechanism that actually does ascribe
- 23:47value for a license to the license fee and therefore
- 23:51that value filters down hopefully to the participants.
- 23:56That was a big deal a few years ago. There was
- 24:01the Walking Dead litigation that I was involved
- 24:03in, the first Walking Dead litigation with Frank
- 24:07Darabont and Crip CAA against AMC. There was
- 24:11an imputed license fee in that and we argued
- 24:14for many years over whether that was fair market
- 24:18value or approximated the contractual affiliate
- 24:21transaction language. Studios and content creators
- 24:26seem to have gotten away from a few license fees
- 24:28a little bit after that and actually would try
- 24:33to ascribe and pay an actual license fee in some,
- 24:37I mean, I would argue as a talent lawyer to make
- 24:39it look more above board. But it's the same issues.
- 24:44Whether it's real money or imputed money, it
- 24:46still isn't enough money. But now, in the streaming
- 24:51context, I'm seeing studios that have their own
- 24:56streamers, again, they will remain nameless,
- 25:00trying to put in imputed licensees into their
- 25:02deals for when they sell the content to their
- 25:05own streaming platform. And so the same like
- 25:10Bobby was saying the very beginning, you know,
- 25:12what's it what goes around comes around. It's
- 25:14the same old thing. It's is and deal lawyers
- 25:17have to be particularly Cognizant of that and
- 25:20pay close attention to it because at least the
- 25:23ones I've seen trying to be put into, you know,
- 25:26overall deals renegotiations of overall deals
- 25:29is sort of established relationships. The studios
- 25:31are now saying, oh, by the way, we have a streamer.
- 25:34And if we're going to sell your show, we're all
- 25:36the next shows you make to our streamer. And
- 25:39by the way, here's what we're going to impute
- 25:41the license fee. And it's too low. It's not market
- 25:44rate. It's not what an unaffiliated Netflix or
- 25:47Amazon would pay. So it's moving that discussion
- 25:54up to the deal making phase. But I have no reason
- 25:57to believe that the studios are going to up their
- 26:01imputed license fee. So then in the deal making
- 26:04phase. So then it will eventually, sooner rather
- 26:07than later, filter down to litigators like us.
- 26:09And we'll have to argue that, yes, here's the
- 26:13imputed license fee. Yes, we signed the deal,
- 26:15but it still doesn't. And if we can make those
- 26:19arguments, it still doesn't comply with company
- 26:21good faith and fair dealing. It doesn't comply
- 26:23with these other obligations elsewhere in the
- 26:26contract to make all transactions. substantially
- 26:30equivalent to an arm's length basis or whatever
- 26:31the wording is. So it is coming around again.
- 26:35It is coming back into the four, I think. Yeah,
- 26:45I think this highlights an asymmetry in the warfare
- 26:49between a distributor slash studio on the one
- 26:53hand and a co -financer, co -producer, or talent
- 26:57on the other hand, which is if you have an imputed
- 27:00license fee that is a dollar amount, that's one
- 27:04thing. If you have an imputed license fee that's
- 27:06based on a formula or a concept, that's a recipe
- 27:10for a lot of mischief. Often there would be ones
- 27:14that you talk about fair market value, but That's
- 27:18not a popular concept and so it's you get wording
- 27:22that's like you know what the. It sort of gets
- 27:27inverted either what the studio is is receiving
- 27:32for comparable content that it licenses to an
- 27:36unaffiliated entity. Or what the. call it in
- 27:42this way, the streaming entity is paying to acquire
- 27:44comparable content from an unaffiliated licensor.
- 27:50Actually, those are very different standards
- 27:52in practice. Let's acknowledge, at this point
- 27:56in the deal, the talent is usually so happy to
- 28:00have a deal, they don't want to risk cratering
- 28:03the deal over the definition of the backend,
- 28:05much less the imputed license fee for affiliated
- 28:08transactions. And so, A lot of things just kind
- 28:12of get swept under the rug and people just don't
- 28:15have the leverage or the inclination to try and
- 28:17focus on the language. But when you end up getting
- 28:19a dispute over this, where there's enough at
- 28:21stake to hire lawyers to present and even litigate
- 28:25the case and you're stuck with this language,
- 28:28then you try and litigate it and you say, well,
- 28:30I want some discovery here. I want to see what
- 28:33deals you did for, and you realize, well, these
- 28:38definitions or these principles don't apply very
- 28:41well in practice. It's like, well, there are
- 28:43no other deals to look at. I have no other contracts
- 28:45I can give you. Sorry. And since you're the plane
- 28:48comparable content, like how do you compare these
- 28:52kinds of shows to each other? Yeah. And so studios
- 28:56are a couple of content is what we say it is.
- 28:58Yeah. And you know, you may have very limited
- 29:01discovery rights. You may be in an arbitration
- 29:04subject to provisions where your right to any
- 29:06discovery like this is going to be up to the
- 29:08good graces of the arbitrator and whether they
- 29:10think you've shown good cause or maybe it's further
- 29:13constrained by the rules. And nobody I'm not
- 29:18saying anybody's not doing their job. It's just
- 29:20at the time you're negotiating the contract,
- 29:24this isn't where you're focusing your energy.
- 29:27You're focusing your energy, especially if you're
- 29:29doing a deal directly with a streamer. It's like,
- 29:30look, I have the back end. Come on. What's it
- 29:32really ever going to be worth? Elon, when you're
- 29:37doing an audit and you want to get access to
- 29:39some of these things to check these things and
- 29:41the door gets slammed in your face, you have
- 29:43no recourse. And often, historically, we would
- 29:46have conversations where we'd say, don't worry
- 29:48about it. When we file a lawsuit, we'll have
- 29:50discovery, and the judge isn't going to let them
- 29:52get away with this. Well, no, because you're
- 29:54now in an arbitration, and you may have different
- 29:56discovery rules. And so you may never be able
- 29:59to prove your case. You may never be able to
- 30:02adduce evidence that would benchmark provide
- 30:05benchmarks for what these fees are to deal with
- 30:09the fact that the party on the other side is
- 30:13doing deals with its affiliate. So it's a serious
- 30:16problem and it doesn't lend itself to an obvious
- 30:20solution, but people should have their eyes open
- 30:22when they're negotiating these deals as to how
- 30:27they're going to be enforced, if they're going
- 30:28to be enforced. Well said, no, I appreciate it.
- 30:35I think this is a topic that I think we'll be
- 30:40monitoring over time, and it has to do with what
- 30:45information do we have to value... the distribution,
- 30:49the value of the licensing, I think, or challenge
- 30:53the imputed license fee, I think the chat I think
- 30:55kicked off the conversation with. We as a firm,
- 30:59we try our best to keep ourselves aware of trends,
- 31:05trying to maintain key performance indicators
- 31:08and work with our clients to try and assess the
- 31:12reasonableness of those valuations. But I think
- 31:14it's an area that will stay with us for some
- 31:17time. So let's move forward. I actually wanted
- 31:20to jump to an area that is something that is
- 31:26at the forefront of our business, which is artificial
- 31:29intelligence. I actually want to get into that
- 31:31topic next. And the one particular deal that
- 31:37I hope, Bobby, you can talk a little bit about
- 31:39is the Disney OpenAI investment deal that is
- 31:44publicly available. Everybody knows. In general,
- 31:47we don't have all the details, but that deal
- 31:49was struck not that long ago. And OpenAI is having,
- 31:54I think, other discussions with other IP owners.
- 31:58But before we get into that, I wanted to see
- 32:00if maybe, Ashley, you can kick off the conversation
- 32:02about the types of AI -related disputes we're
- 32:06seeing right now. And then I'm going to see,
- 32:12Chad, maybe you can add if you're seeing as well.
- 32:14But then I want to maybe Bobby will be the last
- 32:16to get into that Disney AI investment with OpenAI.
- 32:22So Ashley, maybe you get that conversation going.
- 32:25So I think we're seeing kind of three lines of
- 32:29cases or how I would describe them. There's the
- 32:33input cases, the output cases, and then kind
- 32:35of what individual talent are doing to protect
- 32:38their name and likeness from AI infringement
- 32:41and deepfakes. The input cases are looking at
- 32:44What content is being used and how is it being
- 32:47copied and stored to train AI models? The early
- 32:52cases in that area were not particular to the
- 32:55entertainment industry. The first ruling that
- 32:58came down was actually a Thomson Reuters decision
- 33:00that had to do with Westlaw Headnotes and a company
- 33:04that was trying to create a direct competitor
- 33:06to Westlaw. That decision actually rejected a
- 33:10fair use defense. on the grounds, I think that
- 33:13was heavily driven by the fact that the defendant
- 33:18was trying to create a competitive tool to Westlaw
- 33:22that was basically a mirror image of that. The
- 33:25other two cases that have come down came out
- 33:27the opposite way. So you have Barts versus Anthropic
- 33:30and Kadri versus Metta. And those both found
- 33:34fair use. So it basically said, if you're scanning
- 33:36books to train the AI and the AI's output is
- 33:42not going to be substantially similar, because
- 33:44keep in mind what we're worried about here is
- 33:45copyright infringement. Does the product of whatever
- 33:49you're doing look substantially similar to what
- 33:52the input was? So if you're just scanning books
- 33:55to train an AI model, then the AI model is just
- 33:59learning language. Whatever it outputs is not
- 34:02going to be substantially similar to someone's
- 34:04novel. So I think that's what really influenced
- 34:07the courts there. Interestingly, in Barts though,
- 34:09the court actually said that storing all of the
- 34:12pirated content on the database for the purposes
- 34:15of training is not a fair use. So they got caught
- 34:18there. So people are going to have to be careful
- 34:20about how and where they do their copying and
- 34:23where they store things, which will translate
- 34:26as time goes on, obviously, to entertainment
- 34:29works, which we'll get into. And then the output
- 34:33cases are more looking at, okay, if you want
- 34:36to create a work that, say, is Mickey at the
- 34:40beach playing volleyball, and you want to give
- 34:43that prompt to something, the output is going
- 34:45to look substantially similar. It is going to
- 34:47be Mickey. And that is what prompted the Mid
- 34:50Journey cases. So you had Disney and Universal
- 34:53last year filing for copyright infringement against
- 34:56Mid Journey. Warner Brothers filed its own case
- 34:59several months later. The cases have been consolidated,
- 35:02interestingly, set for mediation. They already
- 35:05have a mediator. Judge Suzanne Siegel from the
- 35:08federal bench with a mediation completion of
- 35:12the summer of 26. And so the question is, are
- 35:17these cases going to go on? I mean, if you look
- 35:19at the complaints, they're very compelling. All
- 35:22of the characters look exactly like Disney characters.
- 35:25You cannot differentiate them. So at the same
- 35:28time that Disney... was suing Mid Journey. It
- 35:31sent a cease and desist to Google for basically
- 35:34the same conduct on Google Gemini. And then it
- 35:37did a deal with OpenAI. And it said to OpenAI,
- 35:40we'll actually do a license that has some limitations,
- 35:44but of content that Disney fully owns. And so
- 35:48they're starting with... that I think because
- 35:51then they don't have to deal with the possibility
- 35:53of participants and other people wanting to know
- 35:56where their share is of some of this some of
- 35:58this deal but you will basically now be able
- 36:02to go on open AI and create your own content
- 36:05using Disney characters and through a bizarre
- 36:09part of the deal even have the opportunity for
- 36:12your work to then appear on Disney plus. And
- 36:16I don't know if the economics of that have been
- 36:18worked out and how they intend to pay people.
- 36:21But that is a critical component of the Disney
- 36:24open AI deal. Thank you, Ashley. Chad, I don't
- 36:31know if you wanted to add any comments. I know
- 36:33there's some questions, by the way, about AI,
- 36:35which I want to hold off on. But Chad, anything
- 36:37else you wanted to add? I mean, I don't. I don't
- 36:40have a lot to add to what Ashley said. In my
- 36:42practice, I'm seeing more of, I think it was
- 36:45her third bucket, where it's talent having concerns
- 36:52about not only fakes, but the use of their name,
- 36:56image, and likeness, their speech, and how they're
- 37:00going to be compensated for that, which is also
- 37:02a very thorny issue. But I haven't delved into
- 37:07the copyright aspects of AI, it's more about,
- 37:11you know, talent seeking compensation for the
- 37:14use of AI. And a lot of that is, I mean, it's
- 37:18the I was gonna say it's theoretical, it's coming
- 37:20very quickly on the horizon, but it's all sort
- 37:23of like, kind of unfocused rule right now. What
- 37:27you just said is actually tying perfectly into
- 37:29what I'm hoping Bobby can speak to. And that's
- 37:31the how does that partnership between Disney
- 37:35and OpenAI ultimately affect the co -finance
- 37:37partners and the talent. And we have limited
- 37:40information, so it's hard to gauge this. But
- 37:44Chad, your point is, how do we actually see the
- 37:48value ultimately coming out of these partnerships?
- 37:51So I don't know, Bobby, if you'd like to say
- 37:52a little bit. I gotta tell you, it's strange.
- 37:54Yeah, and there's a fair amount of speculation
- 37:57in this on my part, which I hate, because I...
- 38:01You know, these are very sophisticated business
- 38:03people and I have to presume they know very well
- 38:08what they're doing. And I also have to be careful
- 38:12because we represent a lot of AI platforms in
- 38:16IP matters. But speaking not for them or for
- 38:22the firm, but just for myself, I'll tell you
- 38:24the Disney transaction with open AI is strange
- 38:29for a couple of reasons. One, Sounds like it's
- 38:32a tremendous amount of money, a billion dollars,
- 38:34you know, and I feel like we're going to do something
- 38:36from Austin Powers, where it's like one billion
- 38:41dollars sounds like a lot of money. But to open
- 38:42AI, I mean, my God, you know, that that I don't
- 38:45it's not as big as it seems. And yet a couple
- 38:49thoughts. One, what it's strange that open AI
- 38:54is not paying Disney. for the right to use its
- 38:58content. And maybe there is some aspect of the
- 39:00transaction where they are, but instead Disney
- 39:03is writing a check to open AI in return for a
- 39:07billion dollars worth of equity. It's not an
- 39:09equity grant from open AI, it's a purchase of
- 39:12equity. So what's justifying that? And is this,
- 39:18I mean, a cynical person could look at this and
- 39:21say, well, for one thing, There's no grant of
- 39:26rights to use the Disney IP for training. That's
- 39:30carved out. So what it really is, is we Disney
- 39:35won't sue you, OpenAI, if it turns out that your
- 39:38users are creating outputs that we think are
- 39:41substantially similar in appearance to the appearance
- 39:46of copyrighted content we own. But you can't
- 39:50get a leg up. In training your model on using
- 39:53our content, even the content that we put in
- 39:55this narrow bucket or smaller bucket of of and
- 39:58also we're not granting you any name, image,
- 40:00or likeness rights. And so what's the value proposition
- 40:07here? And one thing you could say as well. Disney,
- 40:12it's very important to Disney to enforce its
- 40:14IP rights against AI platforms that are doing
- 40:17things that violate Disney's or infringe Disney's
- 40:19rights. And Disney obviously has every right
- 40:21to do that. But when you look at fair use, which
- 40:25factors prominently in all of these cases, and
- 40:28you look at the fourth fair use factor, which
- 40:30looks at the potential impact or the impact on
- 40:33the potential or actual market for the content,
- 40:37Originally, everyone was saying, well, nobody's
- 40:39licensing this to any AI platform. What's the
- 40:42harm to Disney if somebody's using OpenAI to
- 40:45create a five -second video? I mean, it's like,
- 40:47well, now, no, there is a market now. Disney
- 40:49has done a deal with OpenAI, and this may undermine
- 40:53the value of that transaction or other transactions.
- 40:55And so you could cynically say, no, this is part
- 40:57of a broader litigation strategy to protect the
- 41:00IP. by being able to defeat the defense or some
- 41:03of the arguments associated with fair use. Is
- 41:06that what anybody's thinking over there out on
- 41:09Mickey way or whatever it is? No idea. But it
- 41:13is certainly possible. And if you assume they're
- 41:16as intelligent as they really are, maybe that's
- 41:19part of part of it. The other thing is I don't
- 41:24think Disney wants to feel like it's being run
- 41:26over by the tech community. And so this makes
- 41:30them look like, hey, you know what? We're dipping
- 41:33our toe in the water here. We're trying to make
- 41:35sure we stay relevant and we have AI capabilities
- 41:39in our product offerings. And this is a way of
- 41:42doing it for low cost. And so those are some
- 41:47reactions to that transaction. I think there's
- 41:49a lot more to be learned. The other thing, again,
- 41:53is, OK, well, if you assume Disney is getting
- 41:55some value for this, they're obviously getting
- 41:59value from content that's created by people to
- 42:03whom they may have ongoing financial obligations.
- 42:06Is there any obligation on the part of Disney
- 42:08to compensate them or share some portion of the
- 42:11value Disney's getting for this as gross revenue
- 42:16or gross receipts on those television shows or
- 42:20motion pictures? And we've seen that it happens.
- 42:24It happened was it 20 or 30 years ago with when
- 42:27there were competing disc platforms coming out.
- 42:32And I remember it was at Toshiba, forgetting
- 42:35as somebody wrote a check for a hundred million
- 42:38dollars to DreamWorks to be the exclusive. So
- 42:44the DreamWorks would not release its content
- 42:46only on that type of disc. It wasn't the Sony
- 42:50or I can't, I apologize for not recollecting
- 42:54the exact parties. I think it was Paramount.
- 42:58Is it Divix? I remember correctly. What's that?
- 43:00I think it may have been Paramount. Oh, all right,
- 43:02whoever it was, but I remember having conversations
- 43:04with some of your colleagues at the time saying,
- 43:08you know, why isn't some of that money, it's,
- 43:10you know, there's no, the only reason they're
- 43:11paying that money is because they want the DreamWorks
- 43:15animation content or the Paramount, whatever
- 43:17it was. Why shouldn't that some of that be apportioned?
- 43:22And so as we see these deals, that issue is going
- 43:25to come back again. Again, as we say, the more
- 43:28things change, et cetera. Well, it's going to
- 43:31be hard to parse. You know, there's certain Disney
- 43:33works where the character. Might be a live human
- 43:36to Chad's point where this is an actor and so
- 43:39how do you parse the character versus using the
- 43:42actors likeness or their voice or things like
- 43:44that and if that person has a participation shouldn't
- 43:46they then participate in some fashion. I think
- 43:49this initial round maybe they've limited some
- 43:51of the content so that there's less likelihood
- 43:54of that argument being made but but that is certainly
- 43:57a question I also kind of wonder how they put
- 44:00guardrails on. what types of works are being
- 44:03created, because there's going to be things that
- 44:05are going to be done to Disney content that is
- 44:07not the Disney family brand. And also, you know,
- 44:11what if people have certain rights to create
- 44:13sequels or derivative works of Disney properties,
- 44:16and now they're not the first one to do that,
- 44:19because some guy on Mid Journey made a sequel
- 44:21to some Disney film. I mean, I don't know how
- 44:23much they're going to be able to do on Mid Journey,
- 44:25but to me, that seems like a possibility. And
- 44:28then you violated some director's you know, write
- 44:30that they had to make the sequel. Interesting.
- 44:35Yeah, right now the technology is is is at least
- 44:39in text to video or image to video. The outputs
- 44:44are pretty short in duration. They don't they
- 44:48don't usually don't have audio. You have to that's
- 44:52a whole separate process to be added on. So,
- 44:56you know, is that yes, technically speaking,
- 44:59that that's the preparation of a derivative work.
- 45:03But is it really undermining the market for Zootopia
- 45:063? Probably not. But that's for someone else
- 45:10to fight about. Right. All right. This is a topic
- 45:14that will also, I think, continue into the future.
- 45:18And we'll have to monitor. I think there's a
- 45:21couple of comments I was going to make. OpenAI,
- 45:23I believe, if I'm not mistaken, is looking to
- 45:27go public and it's becoming a fairly important
- 45:33part of the future of AI we'll have to watch
- 45:35and see. The other thing is what makes it so
- 45:39difficult I'm sure as litigators is it's hard
- 45:42to predict how new technology will ultimately
- 45:45affect their relationships and ultimately have
- 45:49a need for litigation but this is certainly an
- 45:51area that we'll have to continue to monitor and
- 45:53see which leads me to the final question before
- 45:56we take We'll take a look at some of the Q &A
- 45:59questions. And I'm going to summarize, really,
- 46:03and I call that lessons learned. From your experience,
- 46:06especially in the past year, as you look to the
- 46:08future, what would be the advice or what would
- 46:13you recommend to a general counsel or a talent
- 46:21or even just transactional attorney to keep in
- 46:24mind for the coming year? the potential for litigation
- 46:31areas should they be keeping an eye on it as
- 46:34they go to the coming, for the rest of this year?
- 46:37So maybe the way we'll do this is, I think Ashley,
- 46:40if you don't mind maybe kicking that off, and
- 46:43then we'll have Chad and then Bobby will close.
- 46:47Just to get your, what would be your recommendation
- 46:49of what they should be thinking about for the
- 46:51coming year? Well, I think Chad made a good point
- 46:54about looking at the deals as much as you can
- 46:57and at the deal stage to the extent that you
- 46:59can try to anticipate some of these things that
- 47:01we're seeing and address them if possible at
- 47:05the deal stage. That goes to both what we were
- 47:08talking about on the imputed license fee, but
- 47:10also the issue of name and likeness. SAG certainly
- 47:15addressed the issue as far as what can be done
- 47:17with actor's content that's filmed. But for people
- 47:22that aren't part of SAG, there are ways to build
- 47:24in those protections. And you may just want to
- 47:26do that anyway. I think also just keeping an
- 47:30eye on having your clients do audits. We've had
- 47:34several clients recently that just were resistant
- 47:36to the cost of an audit. And I just think there's
- 47:38too much going on right now that It really does
- 47:41justify the cost of an audit. Whether or not
- 47:45you take it to the next step. I mean, among our
- 47:47clients, I think we are seeing some reticence
- 47:50to litigate as both the costs and time of arbitration
- 47:54are increasing. And so if there is a reticence
- 47:59there. But I do think that the ability to negotiate
- 48:03and threaten it is very important. And so we've
- 48:05been stressing that even if you're not going
- 48:07to go that step and you know today that you're
- 48:09not going to go to that step, still do the audit
- 48:11and then see what happens. But I also think the
- 48:16contraction of buyers is going to be something
- 48:18that some of our clients are really going to
- 48:20weigh in terms of whether or not they're actually
- 48:21going to pursue litigation. Yeah, I mean. Ashley
- 48:27said it exactly right. It's funny. What guidance
- 48:31would I give someone who may consider pursuing
- 48:32litigation? Do it. And not to be glib, but Ashley's
- 48:37point is right. And this is not just a pitch
- 48:38for business because I'm a talent litigator,
- 48:41although it may be also that. But I think people
- 48:44have a misconception that you only need to call
- 48:47or you only should call a litigator when you
- 48:50are ready to, at the courthouse steps, file the
- 48:52complaint. And that is let me disabuse you of
- 48:55that. 90 % of what I do and what Ashley does,
- 49:01and maybe a little less, but I'm sure a lot of
- 49:04what Bobby does, is not actually litigating,
- 49:08arguing in front of a judge or an arbitrator
- 49:09in the courtroom. The amount of audits we see,
- 49:14and I echo Ashley's point, I think I made it
- 49:16earlier, that if you are a participant on a piece
- 49:20of content that has generated some significant
- 49:23amount of money, maybe not even enough to have
- 49:26it go break even into the black, but getting
- 49:28close to it, it makes sense to do the audit.
- 49:31Pay the money, do the audit because Alon and
- 49:34his colleagues are very good at their job. They
- 49:36are going to find money that you didn't know
- 49:39about. And once you have that audit, I would
- 49:44recommend calling a litigator during that process
- 49:47because - Agreed. We are very good, Ashley and
- 49:50I and Bobby are all very good at working with
- 49:53Alon and his team to craft the audit report.
- 49:57Our reports are not pleadings, they're not complaints,
- 50:00but you can say things in a way that will make
- 50:03a potential complaint a lot more airtight and
- 50:06a lot better, and we can help with that process.
- 50:08You know, we can't dig through the numbers and
- 50:11the paper and the receipts the way Alon does,
- 50:13but we can guide that process to a place where
- 50:18if litigation becomes necessary, or to Ashley's
- 50:22point, before that, if a negotiation with the
- 50:25studio about, hey, this all report says you owe
- 50:27me $5 million. litigators are I think uniquely
- 50:32entertainment litigators like us on this call
- 50:35are uniquely situated to help that process and
- 50:38litigation is not the end goal. In fact, it's
- 50:41to be avoided, I think it because it is very
- 50:43expensive. It is very time consuming. It is a
- 50:46real pain for all parties involved. And the old
- 50:50joke, the only people who get rich off litigation
- 50:52are the litigators, right? But, but the idea
- 50:56of resolving this dispute short of litigation,
- 50:59whether that's drafting a complaint and saying,
- 51:02hey, if you don't get serious, studio, this is
- 51:05where this is going to go. But even before that,
- 51:07just crafting the arguments, I think that you
- 51:11are well served as a talent or a talent lawyer
- 51:14to a transactional lawyer to involve litigators
- 51:17early in that process. I know it sounds like
- 51:19a pitch for business. And so take it with a grain
- 51:22of salt. But I think that we do provide a lot
- 51:25of service short of just arguing and handling
- 51:28the table in the courtroom. Here, here. If I
- 51:35were giving advice, I guess you're asking me
- 51:37to give advice. So I think over the next 12 months
- 51:41and even beyond, I'm going to show how facile
- 51:43lawyers and litigators in particular can be by
- 51:46saying, even though I started out saying the
- 51:48more things stay the same, the change, the more
- 51:49they stay the same, I'm going to say, I'm starting
- 51:52to notice some really weird dynamics, and I'll
- 51:56give an example of one of them and suggest that
- 51:59everyone needs to be on the lookout for the possibility
- 52:02that things we assume may not hold true, and
- 52:06you have to step back from the paperwork of the
- 52:08transaction and ask yourself, am I protected?
- 52:12Is there anything I can do about this? Right
- 52:16as we speak, advising a client that is not a
- 52:22studio, it's a producer, financier, self -financier
- 52:26of movies that has deals with different studios
- 52:28for distribution. And they have a deal for one
- 52:32of their properties and it's with a studio that
- 52:36has an affiliated streaming service. And they're
- 52:40making a movie and they're also working with
- 52:45the streaming service on a series based on the
- 52:49underlying IP or some version of it. Conflicts
- 52:54have arisen. I'm just going to be very general
- 52:56about this over release patterns and Windows
- 53:00and what have you. The streaming service is over
- 53:04here and our client and the studio are over here.
- 53:11and the studio is unable to control its affiliated,
- 53:15wholly owned streaming service from doing what
- 53:16it wants to do. I've never encountered that before.
- 53:20I've seen rivalries where people are, you know,
- 53:23they're publicly dissing one another, but I've
- 53:26not seen a situation, and the studio is saying,
- 53:27sorry, you know, we're not happy about it either.
- 53:30And that sounds like a lot of bull crap, but
- 53:33it's a very significant problem. It creates,
- 53:36it's creating ruptures in a lot of important
- 53:39things, planning and, well, just leave it at
- 53:43that. Keep it at a very high level. So if I'm
- 53:45looking at a transaction and I would say to myself,
- 53:48look, am I counting on the fact that every party,
- 53:53that the studio is going to be aligned with the
- 53:54streaming service or what have you? It's like,
- 53:58don't assume anything. The only thing you can
- 54:01assume is that human nature is not going to change
- 54:03over the next year. It's probably not going to
- 54:05change in our lifetimes. and money talks and
- 54:08participant rights walk. And so you've got to
- 54:13be looking for every form of chump insurance
- 54:16you can within the confines of the bargaining
- 54:19power that you have and the realities of wanting
- 54:21to close and all that sort of thing. But you
- 54:25really got to step back. And this is just not
- 54:27limited to affiliate related transactions. It's
- 54:30everything. And the other thing is I don't know
- 54:33that the, I mean, you've got to assume the theatrical
- 54:36window, theatrical release concept of theatrical
- 54:40release. It's going to change. It's going to
- 54:42keep changing. Everything's going to change.
- 54:44And it's going to put pressures on people to
- 54:46make decisions that maybe they don't want to
- 54:48make, but they're going to make because it's
- 54:50the lesser of evils and it's going to F your
- 54:53client. If you, you know, in the process, that's
- 54:56the advice I give people is that that's, it's
- 54:57not very specific, but if, you know, if I'm looking
- 55:00at the agreement, you'll see things and you'll,
- 55:02you'll talk about them and, and see what you
- 55:04can do. But this is a very chaotic period. So
- 55:08there. Wow. Thank you. Chaotic is a powerful
- 55:14word, but it is probably reflective of where
- 55:17we are. What I wanted to do is we have a couple
- 55:21of minutes. I'm going to see if we can at least
- 55:23address a couple of the questions, and I'm going
- 55:26to just go in order. One question I think we've
- 55:30already addressed regarding the computer license
- 55:32fee. Another one. Chad, maybe you can speak to
- 55:36that or any one of you. I don't believe that
- 55:39there have been any litigation or challenges
- 55:43to what we call alternative backend exhibits
- 55:48being suggested by some of the studios to follow
- 55:54a model that's consistent with streamers. I don't
- 55:56believe that is something we've seen yet. This
- 56:00is David Shraga's question. Yeah. Yeah. As you
- 56:06probably know, the litigation tends to lag behind
- 56:10deal making by a good five to 10 years. I mean,
- 56:14the deals that I'm litigating over were made
- 56:19a while ago, up to a decade or more ago. So no,
- 56:23I haven't seen litigation about these new sort
- 56:25of alternative streaming back end. things yet,
- 56:31because they're not being audited yet. But as
- 56:33soon as or I mean, I don't know, or the audits
- 56:35haven't come across my desk yet. But it's coming
- 56:37and it's coming soon. And I mean, if there's
- 56:40any vehicle by which a distributor is paying
- 56:44money to participants based on success, that's
- 56:49exactly what we do. And that's, you know, their
- 56:52vertical integration issues come into play there,
- 56:54if it's a self dealing transaction, evaluation,
- 56:57whenever there's something to value, but as for
- 57:00my practice, you know, I haven't seen, I haven't
- 57:03dealt with those deals yet. And Netflix has been
- 57:06talking about it for years and they still haven't
- 57:08done it. And now, you know, recently Bella Bajaria
- 57:11said they're not going to do it. So I know other
- 57:14studios are starting to do some sort of payment
- 57:17for in success on streaming, but I haven't really,
- 57:20so it's coming down, it's coming down the pike,
- 57:22it's on the horizon, but I haven't really had
- 57:24a lot of experience with it yet. To your point
- 57:28about Netflix, you're talking about doing it.
- 57:31One of the things I've noticed in some of their
- 57:34deal conversations lately is that they actually
- 57:37are asking for rights, off platform rights. So
- 57:41just to flag that for some of the dealmakers
- 57:43out there, that obviously if they're going to
- 57:46do that, they are at some time figuring that
- 57:48there could be a sub license from Netflix and
- 57:51they are not. presently offering any compensation
- 57:54back end or otherwise in exchange for that? Well,
- 57:59or I've seen I'm seeing something right now like
- 58:02that with one of the key streaming platforms
- 58:04where they're paying a very substantial upfront
- 58:07fee. It's a rights acquisition. And but they're
- 58:11reserving and there's a back end and we're talking
- 58:15about the value of the back end. And there's
- 58:17this reservation of off platform distribution.
- 58:24And, but there's no real, there's no clarity
- 58:26beyond that. As to what it means, what it could
- 58:28be, and because the deal's in perpetuity, you're
- 58:31potentially giving away something very valuable
- 58:33that, you know, arises in 20 years. So can I
- 58:37throw out a crazy idea? I haven't really bedded
- 58:39this, so people are probably going to go, oh
- 58:40my God, but having stuck my foot in it. quite
- 58:45often when we're litigating issues and we get
- 58:47to provisions and contracts and we say like,
- 58:49wow, that's an unusual provision or whatever.
- 58:52And you want to say like, well, was there any
- 58:53discussion? Did you have any conversations? Because
- 58:55lawyers and judges are looking to interpret contracts
- 58:58and understand what do the parties intend? What
- 59:00did they communicate to each other? Your undisclosed
- 59:04intent, subjective is irrelevant. And we all
- 59:08live through email now, and so we're just firing
- 59:11markups back and forth. It would be so nice.
- 59:15It's dangerous, but think about it. It would
- 59:17be so nice if there was email that says, look,
- 59:19I've redrafted this because I know our goal here
- 59:22is blank. And the nice thing about that is if
- 59:26the other side buys into it, then it makes it
- 59:29very hard for them to walk away from that language
- 59:31saying that's not what the party's intended.
- 59:33The risk is Don't. You've now locked yourself
- 59:37into something, and something may come up that
- 59:39nobody anticipated. And that's going to make
- 59:42it very hard for the lawyers to argue that it
- 59:44should be expanded to include that. Because no,
- 59:46no, the parties talked about it. It was only
- 59:48intended to cover this. And so double -edged
- 59:51sword. But sometimes people draft things so badly.
- 59:55And we just look at it and think, well, if that's
- 59:57what they meant, it would have been so much easier
- 59:58to say this, this, this. And judges don't know
- 1:00:00what to do with that. And so you end up getting
- 1:00:04nothing. So anyway, crazy idea. There it is.
- 1:00:08Well said. I know we've run out of time. There's
- 1:00:11a few more questions which our team together
- 1:00:14will look to address after the close of our webinar.
- 1:00:19But I really wanted to thank my three colleagues
- 1:00:22for taking time away from their schedule to be
- 1:00:24with me and really walk through some of these
- 1:00:27issues with everybody. Thank you, Ashley. Thank
- 1:00:30you, Chad. And thank you, Bobby. Appreciate it.
- 1:00:32Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for having us.
- 1:00:35Thanks, everybody, for joining.