Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / She Done Him Wrong (1933)
Transcript
- 0:12Hello, everyone, and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:17every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:20I'm Kyle. And I'm Ryan. You nailed it. Yeah,
- 0:22no more 1827 for me. The show that takes you
- 0:25from Best Picture. Sometimes it feels that way.
- 0:28Yeah, a little bit. Last episode was definitely
- 0:30the one. I think we were both not looking forward
- 0:34to having to cover an episode like that. So maybe
- 0:37that's where my hesitation with the year was.
- 0:39Sending us back in time. I'm very, well, that
- 0:41was fitting for that. I'm very grateful to be
- 0:44moving on. And we're talking about something
- 0:46different this week. We're talking about She
- 0:48Done Him Wrong. Yeah, we are. Very excited about
- 0:51this one. So we're continuing the trend of you
- 0:54not having seen any of these movies. That's correct.
- 0:57So this is your first time with She Done Him
- 0:58Wrong. Yes. Is this your first Mae West film?
- 1:00Yes. Yeah, it was. Mine too. Cool. That's awesome,
- 1:04man. Cool. Good talk. So let's talk about the
- 1:08nomination. Just take a seat here. I'm going
- 1:12to take care of this for you. It was one. Outstanding
- 1:15production on behalf of Paramount Picture. Man,
- 1:17you are killing it. We are. Thank you. We are
- 1:20in an interesting time where I feel like these
- 1:23movies either have one nomination and it's only
- 1:26for Best Picture or like seven. Yeah. And it's
- 1:30like all around. And it's funny. We've reached
- 1:32the point now where because of last year's winner,
- 1:36Grand Hotel, it only won one Oscar. Correct.
- 1:41And that's like the record, right? For Best Picture
- 1:44winner. It was the fact that it was only nominated
- 1:46for Best Picture and won. There was no other
- 1:50Best Picture winner that was only nominated for
- 1:53Best Picture. Gotcha. That kind of spoils the
- 1:57rest of our podcast in the sense that. When she
- 1:59done them wrong shows up and there's one nominee,
- 2:02you know this isn't it. Yeah. Which I guess we
- 2:05also spoiled that in the last episode about the
- 2:07cavalcade. But I think that's us doing, you know,
- 2:10our duty. Yeah. Our research. Yeah. Because people
- 2:13don't listen to the ceremony episode wanting
- 2:14to hear it won. They want to know who was speaking
- 2:18while Jackie Cooper fell asleep. Yep. And which
- 2:21U .S. president was attending. Or wasn't attending,
- 2:25but was president. Or sent their VP. Yeah. That
- 2:28happened last year. Right? Like, in real life?
- 2:30No. Sorry. The last year we covered. Oh, okay.
- 2:33The fifth Academy Awards. Probably. I don't know.
- 2:35That's fine. But let's talk about Mae West. Deal.
- 2:37So, this is, like, a big deal. Last week, we
- 2:42talked about Cavalcade, and that was, like, the
- 2:43most pacified, just... There was no spice. It
- 2:49was white rice. Just... No spice. White rice.
- 2:53That's the one. This is, like, the production
- 2:58code. This is your Mexican rice in comparison.
- 3:02This is you walk into the Mexican restaurant
- 3:04and you say, listen, I can't have spicy food.
- 3:08And they said, no, I blame this. And then you
- 3:11get rocked. This is the equivalent of my dad
- 3:15going to a Jinya ramen bar. And he's like, I'll
- 3:18have a number seven or I'll have this ramen level
- 3:21seven spice. And both myself and the server were
- 3:24like, what? Yeah. He's like, I could do it. Yeah,
- 3:28no, this is a spicy one. This is it. It didn't
- 3:31fare well for him. It fared well for me. So,
- 3:33spoiler alert there. So, yeah, this is directed
- 3:38by Lau Sherman or Mae West. You really can look
- 3:44at it that way. Yeah. Starring Mae West as Lady
- 3:47Lou, Cary Grant as Captain Cummings, Owen Moore
- 3:52as Chick Clark. And a big shout out here, Luis
- 3:56Beavers as Pearl. That's a big call out for me
- 3:59that I want to talk about later in the episode.
- 4:01I wanted to talk a bit about Noah Beery as Gus
- 4:03Jordan, but we'll get there. Well, of course
- 4:05you do. Yeah. You're a Beery boy. Well, unfortunately
- 4:08that's going to stick. I also want to point out
- 4:11that while you talk about, you mentioned that
- 4:13directed by, could also be from Mae West, written
- 4:16by. Also pretty clearly by Mae West. Also Harvey
- 4:20F. Few and John Bright. Yeah. Mae West has her
- 4:23hands all over this movie. This is her movie
- 4:2510 ,000%. To a point where my double feature
- 4:28was pretty much locked down until I was like,
- 4:30oh man, we can't pick Oscar nominated films.
- 4:33Right. Or Best Picture. We'll get there too.
- 4:35But there's a pretty clear, I think you'll be
- 4:37able to pinpoint exactly what I'm talking about
- 4:39as we talk about this movie. Because it does
- 4:42feel very much like a Mae West show. Gotcha.
- 4:44Yeah. So this. Was a Broadway play in 1928 created
- 4:50and starring Mae West. That was called Diamond
- 4:54Lil. So right off the bat, I want to say that
- 4:57the production code had this on a you cannot
- 5:01make this movie list. Yeah. A lot of drama behind
- 5:05this, too. So much. I mean, before we even get
- 5:07to the movie, like. What ended up happening here
- 5:10was that this adaptation itself, again, you mentioned
- 5:13it's called Diamond Lil. It ended up being changed
- 5:16to She Done Him Wrong. And they changed her name
- 5:19from Lil to Lou. That's kind of the only variances
- 5:21we see. But this adaptation in general resulted
- 5:24in the head of Paramount's production board,
- 5:26which was James Wingate, leaving. And he was
- 5:30replaced. He just straight up quit. He was like,
- 5:33I can't do this. There's too much going on. I'm
- 5:35out of here. And he was replaced by Joseph Breen.
- 5:38And Joseph Breen had such like a stringent and
- 5:41like moral code that it brought on like a slightly
- 5:44watered down, like this movie ended up being
- 5:47the slightly watered down version. And it was
- 5:51still pretty spicy. Like this is essentially
- 5:53a movie about like a brothel slash burlesque
- 5:56slash club. Yeah. Like this is. This is very
- 6:01spicy. And that's the thing. Even if you remove
- 6:03all of the criminal activity in this, if you
- 6:06will, Mae West's presence in this movie is that
- 6:10level seven at the Jinya Ramen Bar. Yes. She
- 6:14is a sex icon, like, full stop. Full stop. I
- 6:18mean, she is a commanding presence on screen,
- 6:22too. You know, there's a phrase that's said in
- 6:25this movie multiple times. And it's by Mae West,
- 6:28her character, Lady Lou. And she's standing on
- 6:31a staircase most times that she says it. And
- 6:33pretty much any man in her life that isn't like
- 6:36Gus Jordan, she's like, oh, hey there, big, tall,
- 6:39and handsome. But she says, why don't you come
- 6:42up and see me sometime? And when she first said
- 6:45that, I was like, oh, yeah, that old trope. I've
- 6:48heard plenty of cartoons and movies reference
- 6:50that. They're referencing this. Right. This is
- 6:54that moment. This is the moment where that was
- 6:56birthed and that idea came out. And it's such
- 6:58a genius idea back then because it's alluding
- 7:01to the obvious. But she's not saying anything
- 7:04wrong. Right. And that's the thing. In order
- 7:07to get this made, Mae West was like, okay, well,
- 7:10I know what I need to do. Tons of innuendos.
- 7:13Tons of double entendres. Like, she is rewriting
- 7:17this entire play so that it can be made into
- 7:20a film. And it is just, the lines in this are
- 7:24so incredible. I had so much fun with everything
- 7:27that she said. Yeah, I mean, this is, honestly,
- 7:31this is one of the more engaged, one of the most,
- 7:34sorry, one of the experiences where I've been
- 7:37most engaged with these movies. Because this
- 7:40is almost like a thrill ride of a movie. And
- 7:42I think ultimately it's maybe a comedy, maybe
- 7:45a drama. It's not a thriller by any means. But
- 7:48I was so engaged with everything happening here.
- 7:50One big highlight to this, we talked about how
- 7:52it was a play and it was adapted. I love whenever
- 7:57adaptations happen, sometimes people take liberties
- 7:59and they're like, yeah, I mean, it was a 90 -page
- 8:03book, but we turned it into a three -trilogy
- 8:06epic. Right. Sure. In this, 66 minutes. Yes.
- 8:11Wow. This is the shortest nominated Best Picture
- 8:14film in history. Yeah. To this day, still the
- 8:17case. And I loved that because it felt like it
- 8:21wasn't too short. It wasn't too long. It was
- 8:23just the perfect length for this kind of movie.
- 8:25But let's get into the movie itself. The thing
- 8:29we're introduced to, you mentioned on a previous
- 8:31episode, an organ grinder. A grinder monkey.
- 8:34Yes. There's a couple of scenes that almost reminded
- 8:37me of City Lights in this, where it's kind of
- 8:40more interested in showing the outside world
- 8:42than it is the club at first. Yeah. So you want
- 8:45to get to know the time and where we are and
- 8:47the comedic side of things. The grinder monkey
- 8:49was one. There's another scenario where a guy
- 8:52is about to, I think, is he about to drink something
- 8:56or steal something right in front of a cop? And
- 8:58the cop makes a face like, ooh, you better not.
- 9:00Yeah. It's something like that. It's definitely
- 9:03alcohol related. Yeah. There's also a man like
- 9:06cleaning up the streets, like a horse behind
- 9:08a horse. And he looks so sad. Yeah. He's just
- 9:11absolutely miserable. So it's just showing not
- 9:14to be sad or anything, but like to kind of like
- 9:18bring up the, it shows how comedic of the movie
- 9:20it is. Yeah. And then we're introduced to the
- 9:22actual club itself. Yeah. And this does take
- 9:26place in the 90s. 1890s. You killed my joke.
- 9:32Yeah. The 1890s. I was about to go off. It was
- 9:36going to be great. I was going to talk about
- 9:38Pizza Hut. I mean, I would love a ye olde Pizza
- 9:42Hut. Right. Do you think they had Book It in
- 9:451890? Yeah, probably. Cool. How does it feel
- 9:49to have your joke destroyed? Yeah, well, okay,
- 9:51we're fair game there then. So it does open up
- 9:54saying, like, this is the gay 90s. Yes. Yeah,
- 9:57and we're introduced to this nightclub. And my
- 10:01favorite part about this is right from the get
- 10:04-go, the second somebody opens their mouth, they
- 10:07are talking about Lady Lou. And I think the first
- 10:1010 minutes of this movie is going around being
- 10:14introduced to all of these employees and patrons
- 10:16of this nightclub. And you see what kind of club
- 10:20this is. There's a heavy focus on alcohol in
- 10:23the club, which I think is a huge deal for when
- 10:27this movie is released. We're still in the prohibition
- 10:29era. But you're also seeing, like, these are
- 10:32men who are coming here specifically to see the
- 10:36women and for the beer. But there's kind of like
- 10:39a gangster element to the people who work here.
- 10:41But everybody in this nightclub is whispering
- 10:45about Lady Lou. And it's so cool the way it builds
- 10:50up to this. Yeah, I mean, it builds on the lore
- 10:53of this character. And you're kind of waiting
- 10:55for this powerhouse performance. Which sometimes
- 10:57is a detriment to the character. Because they,
- 11:00well, not in this case. But it's a detriment
- 11:02because you're like, oh, I'm building this person
- 11:04up. And then they show up and you're like, okay,
- 11:05sure. But with Mae West, she lives up to this
- 11:09hype and this build. Yeah, and before you ever
- 11:12get a glimpse of Mae West. In this movie, you're
- 11:15introduced to Cary Grant, who is part of kind
- 11:19of like an unnamed religious organization. Temperance
- 11:23League. Gotcha. Temperance League. He runs it.
- 11:26And essentially, I did some research on this
- 11:28because about halfway through, I was like. What
- 11:29does he do? So he runs a temperance league, which
- 11:33is to help people who are dealing with addiction,
- 11:35specifically alcohol. Anyone who's an alcoholic,
- 11:38he helps them feel comfortable, which lends him
- 11:41to also be this individual that whenever crime
- 11:43is happening, they know they can kind of rely
- 11:45on him to help them out a little bit. Even to
- 11:49the point where the police know his character,
- 11:52Captain Cummings, as... Someone who protects
- 11:55and has a safe haven for these criminals. Yeah.
- 11:58And this Temperance League is kind of just a
- 12:01replacement for the Salvation Army. That was
- 12:03originally the point. But of course, Mae West
- 12:06was like, well, we can't do that. Right. That's
- 12:08a big no -no. There's something about that real
- 12:11quick that I want to dive into at the Temperance
- 12:12League. So the National Legion of Decency, which
- 12:15I like to think if we were a comic book group,
- 12:19you and I, our Justice League would be called
- 12:21the National Legion of Decency. The National
- 12:24Legion of Decency was formed in October of 1933,
- 12:27which is about six months after this film's release.
- 12:29And the Legion specifically cites and officially
- 12:33cites this movie and Mae West as a major reason
- 12:36for the League's necessity. So them introducing
- 12:39the Temperance League and Captain Cummings' character
- 12:42led itself to this Legion of Decency, which again,
- 12:47insane name, hard name that I rock with, actually
- 12:50being formed. So it's cool to see how she was
- 12:54like, well, we can't do that. Let's do this.
- 12:55The influence in this movie, and we haven't even
- 12:57gotten to Mae West's appearance on screen, is
- 13:00so present. Yeah. Man, she should have trademarked
- 13:04it and just been like, you're going to have to
- 13:06pay royalties on that one. You have to come up
- 13:10and pay me royalties sometime. Yeah. So when
- 13:12you first see Cary Grant, though, he kind of
- 13:14is like the good guy in this movie who's going
- 13:17around and he's trying to help any individual
- 13:19he can. And this is one of his first big pictures.
- 13:241933 was his first year doing film roles. How
- 13:28did you feel about seeing Cary Grant for the
- 13:31first time on the big screen? Well, I mean, this
- 13:33was, it was almost shocking. Yeah. Because you
- 13:36almost expect him to be the lead in something
- 13:39like that when you hear Cary Grant. And he is
- 13:43a big part of the movie, but he's certainly not
- 13:44like, I think, second most important character.
- 13:47Right, right. He's up there, but you would almost
- 13:50expect, like, oh, cool, she's going to fall for
- 13:53him, and this is going to be the relationship,
- 13:55right? Yeah. It doesn't go that way. No. Like,
- 13:57ultimately, things happen, but you're right.
- 14:00They do have interactions, and there's moments
- 14:02they have together, but ultimately, it's not
- 14:05like he is the cover of the poster with her.
- 14:07This is Mae West's movie. Yes. So it was kind
- 14:10of shocking in that sense, but, I mean, he's
- 14:12really good. You know, stop the presses. We think
- 14:15Cary Grant's really good, but you didn't like
- 14:18him in this movie? So I think that this is such
- 14:20an early Cary Grant movie that he has not formed
- 14:24his persona. And I think when you pair him with
- 14:27someone who is always on, she has her persona
- 14:33and her character and her act just down to a
- 14:37science. So when you have Cary Grant up against
- 14:40her or just on screen with her, he almost feels...
- 14:43awkward and clunky and a little silly at times
- 14:47yeah you know what it might be for me it might
- 14:50be the wow it's so nice to talk about characters
- 14:53and how they're like actually fleshed out yeah
- 14:55after talking about cavalcade um it might be
- 14:58how he is running this league reading about what
- 15:01the league actually does and you know his involvement
- 15:04in that and then watching him protect people
- 15:06as they come in they're like well the cops are
- 15:08after me i really need some help To me, it seems
- 15:11like the perfect, I don't want to say foil, but
- 15:12the perfect pairing to Mae West's character.
- 15:15Sure. Because she does the same thing, but she
- 15:18has a little bit more of like lore built around
- 15:20her. Oh, 100. Yeah. She has a harder like surface
- 15:23than he does. And I really liked the pairing
- 15:26of those two. Yeah. So I liked them together
- 15:28a lot, which made me really like his performance.
- 15:31That's fair. I think for me, the— But what's
- 15:34to come? Yeah, you're right. I mean, he just,
- 15:36like, evolves. Right, yeah. He's so much more,
- 15:39obviously, as his career goes on. In here, I
- 15:41think he is kind of just like, look at this handsome
- 15:43man and his performances. In a uniform. Exactly,
- 15:47exactly. So it was exciting to see Cary Grant.
- 15:49I don't think this is going to be anybody's favorite
- 15:52Cary Grant movie. Can't imagine it's on Mount
- 15:54Rushmore. Right. But after we're introduced to
- 15:58him— That's kind of the most important person
- 16:00before Mae West shows up. Yes. We're interested
- 16:04in a few other people. Gus Jordan being one of
- 16:06them. A moment for Gus Jordan. Played by Noah
- 16:10Beery. For anyone who has not guessed yet, this
- 16:12is the older brother to Wallace Beery. Yeah.
- 16:14Unfortunately did pass in 1946, just about 10
- 16:18plus years after this came out. But you know
- 16:21what's so funny? I wasn't familiar with Noah
- 16:23Beery going into this. Yeah. And when it said
- 16:25Noah Beery, I didn't think anything of it. Like
- 16:28in the credits. And as soon as Gus Jordan speaks,
- 16:30and he's just like, I'm trying to think of something
- 16:32specifically he says, but he's like, do we know
- 16:35when Lady Lou is going to be here? I was like,
- 16:37Wallace Beery? You're right. Is Wallace Beery
- 16:39in this movie? And looking at him, I was like,
- 16:42well, he looks like a Beery. And I was like,
- 16:44oh, cool. Noah Beery. So great. Unsurprising
- 16:48to anyone listening to the podcast and unsurprising
- 16:49to you, I took a major liking to Gus Jordan pretty
- 16:52quickly. Also great presence. I think he has
- 16:55a little bit of like the comedic. Not gangster,
- 16:58but like he's the heavy on the side of the club.
- 17:02He's the muscle. I mean, technically Spider is.
- 17:06Okay, I take that back. Gus Jordan is the brains.
- 17:09Right. Or at least the brains when Lady Lou isn't
- 17:13around. And Spider is the muscle. Right. Which,
- 17:16gotta love a bouncer being named Spider. Oh,
- 17:19it's so good. It's so good. Gus is kind of the
- 17:22love interest of Lady Lou. Am I right in saying
- 17:26that? Like, he is the one who owns this club.
- 17:28Yes. And he provides Lady Lou with diamonds and
- 17:33jewelry and all of the materialistic things that
- 17:36she just completely, like, that's her drive.
- 17:39To me, it almost was like a keeping her happy
- 17:42type thing than it is like we're in love. Yeah,
- 17:44yeah. But yes. Like, certainly, you know, he
- 17:47hands her a diamond and she kind of cozies up
- 17:50to him. Yes. That's... Kind of her entire motivation
- 17:55is diamonds and jewels and things like that and
- 17:59riches. Right. Covered in them. That being said,
- 18:02you're introduced to all of these characters.
- 18:04And I love that we've almost built up just as
- 18:07much as the movie has because that's all it is.
- 18:09Everyone is like, is Lady Lou going to be on
- 18:11tonight? Oh, I was with Lady Lou last night.
- 18:14No, you weren't. Punched. Like, it's so much
- 18:17fun. It's not my double feature, but you know
- 18:19what it reminds me of is Hamilton. When everyone's
- 18:22just like, who's this guy? Who is this guy? Do
- 18:25you know about this guy? And then he just appears
- 18:27with the spotlight of just like, I'm Alexander
- 18:28Hamilton. That's almost what Mae West does in
- 18:31this. The way that her character is introduced,
- 18:34correct me if I'm wrong, is it when? No, it's
- 18:36not when Captain Cummings is talking with a police
- 18:38officer. No. She appears on the staircase. She
- 18:40rides up in the carriage. That's it. Yeah. And
- 18:43this is a great introduction, too. You see her
- 18:46in a horse and buggy driving to the nightclub.
- 18:50And you get to see everybody on town looking
- 18:54at her and reacting to just her presence. So
- 18:57you have kind of the high fashion women look
- 18:59over and just turn their noses at her. And she
- 19:03almost rolls her eyes and she's like, whatever,
- 19:06you know, why does the lion waste their time
- 19:10with the opinion of sheep kind of thing? And
- 19:12then you have the men who are just like. just
- 19:15immediately infatuated with her dying to be in
- 19:17her eyeline yes and she makes her way to the
- 19:20club and the second she opens her mouth i was
- 19:23like oh okay this is her i get it it's a commanding
- 19:27performance by may west her her accent and her
- 19:30voice she has that like uh the man's wanted for
- 19:35moida like yeah it's so good and it's it's a
- 19:39cliche now for sure it's very much the dame in
- 19:42like a noir Yeah, it's been replicated. It's
- 19:44been done. Her outfits are like huge and boisterous.
- 19:48She's got these massive hats that look like she
- 19:51should be captain of the Black Pearl or something.
- 19:54And all of her dresses are like skin tight and
- 19:59bedazzled and immediately like she's iconic.
- 20:03More so maybe than any other woman we've covered
- 20:07on the show. The only other one I can think of
- 20:09is Marlene Dietrich. In Shanghai Express. True.
- 20:12And even then, I feel like there's less of a,
- 20:14the presence is there. But I feel like there's
- 20:18more of a commanding level from Mae West in this
- 20:20than there was from Marlene Dietrich. Right.
- 20:22In Shanghai Express. And the way that I've heard
- 20:25it described is Marlene Dietrich was kind of
- 20:28shaped by the studio and Joseph von Sternberg.
- 20:33Whereas Mae West, like this is who she is. This
- 20:37is her creation. Yeah. So she really is domineering
- 20:41and just so, so huge on screen. And this is the
- 20:46whole movie is Mae West to me. Yeah. You know,
- 20:50the thing that I wanted to point out here, the
- 20:52double feature that I originally had in mind,
- 20:54this is we're going to talk out of both sides
- 20:57of our mouth on this one. This is Disraeli. This
- 21:01is Disraeli. Oh, yeah. Yes. This is a gender
- 21:04swapped Disraeli. But this is. The right way
- 21:07to do it. Right. Because the movie is Mae West.
- 21:10Mae West is the movie. And everything is following
- 21:13Lady Lou. You cannot have this movie without
- 21:15Lady Lou. And she is pushing the story forward
- 21:18with all the characters. However, she is letting
- 21:21things breathe with the other characters and
- 21:23having them have their personalities, their character
- 21:27traits that kind of lend to the conversation.
- 21:29Yeah. So it doesn't feel like she is acting circles
- 21:31around people while she is giving the best performance
- 21:34of any of them. Hands down. It doesn't feel like
- 21:37she is neglecting their performances in favor
- 21:39of her own. That's how Disraeli felt. Right.
- 21:42This is what I wanted Disraeli to be. Yes, absolutely.
- 21:45Also in terms of length. Yeah, there's that too.
- 21:48A prime example of that and kind of the type
- 21:51of person Mae West was, we're introduced to her
- 21:55servant, Pearl. Yes. Played by Louise Beavers.
- 21:58And she is, she is, quote unquote, the... mammy
- 22:03character the stereotype sure she's kind of like
- 22:07a heavyset black woman who has that the accent
- 22:10and kind of the vernacular yes yeah thank you
- 22:13the vernacular that eventually we get to a point
- 22:17where like okay well we're just serving stereotypes
- 22:19and like harmful stereotypes right however may
- 22:23west was well known when she did like her broadway
- 22:26productions for hiring black actors and actresses
- 22:30even though They weren't meant to be on stage,
- 22:34like they weren't allowed to be on stage. So
- 22:36much so that she was arrested at times for having
- 22:39black actors appear in her musicals. She was
- 22:43a huge fighter for black actors being billed
- 22:47in her films. So while it is still a negative
- 22:52stereotype at this point, Pearl gets a lot to
- 22:55do here. And she's not treated like a servant.
- 22:57No. Right? She's treated almost like a confidant.
- 23:00Right. For Lady Lou. So I did like that aspect.
- 23:03You're right. I mean, there is still the servant
- 23:05aspect that makes this a little, you know. Yeah.
- 23:08Like you're kind of pulling on your collar a
- 23:10little bit. But you're right. I mean, she's creating
- 23:12opportunities that didn't exist back then. Yeah.
- 23:14And, you know, movies like Aerosmith, I'd love
- 23:16to see more of the involvement in that kind of
- 23:19degree. But if she's standing up for like, you
- 23:22know, any kind of group of people for them to
- 23:24have involvement in movies, like that's a -okay
- 23:26with me. Yeah, yeah. And, you know. Not to defend
- 23:30the stereotype, but the movie also takes place
- 23:32in 1890. Sure. So like, you know, it fits the
- 23:35setting in a way. And I think, again, when you
- 23:38pair that with her being a defendant of people
- 23:42of color during the time period, like this is
- 23:45this is cool to see Louise Beavers have such
- 23:48a large role in this movie. And really plays
- 23:52such a huge part in like serving as a confidant,
- 23:55as you said, you know, and kind of guiding Lady
- 23:58Lou a little bit in her endeavors. Right. Yeah,
- 24:01it's a great performance. And it's one that doesn't
- 24:05that actually is a really great segue for what
- 24:07I was talking about with Disraeli to where it
- 24:09feels like she's not just stepping over that
- 24:11character. She's letting that character be in
- 24:13the scene with her. And then that brings out
- 24:16her character work as well. So, yeah, big fan.
- 24:19And, you know. to praise Mae West a little more.
- 24:22We talk about Cary Grant being in this movie.
- 24:24That was her decision. And she has gone on to
- 24:27claim like, Oh, I'm, I'm the one who brought
- 24:30him into the pictures and like made him a star,
- 24:33which he was in a picture with Marlene Dietrich,
- 24:36I think earlier this year, even so like he's,
- 24:40he's already doing it, but this certainly helped
- 24:42his career. Yeah, definitely. It's very funny
- 24:44that Mae West is like, that's because of me.
- 24:46Yeah. I want to point out that Mae West, obviously
- 24:49a controversial figure for what you have described
- 24:51here, but also just this was not like a chance
- 24:54for her. This was not like something that she
- 24:56went out of her way and made this kind of movie,
- 24:59this kind of character. She's known for this.
- 25:00Yeah. And this is what she goes on to continue
- 25:02to do. Unfortunately, this is the only Mae West
- 25:05film to be nominated at the Academy. So whether
- 25:08it be the controversy off screen or the controversy
- 25:10on screen of the characters she portrays and
- 25:12the story she likes to tell, this doesn't show
- 25:14up very often. Makes sense with what ends up
- 25:17happening next year, 1934. Yeah. With the code
- 25:20and just not having an opportunity to, you know,
- 25:22ruffle some feathers further. But I definitely
- 25:25think in terms of what's depicted here, even
- 25:28though it is a comedy, it's not like a tragedy
- 25:29by any sense. The controversy around this movie,
- 25:32you have to believe 100 % leads. To The Code
- 25:36next year. Oh, yeah. Like, this has got to be
- 25:39one of the top 10 movies that they watched in
- 25:421933. And they were like, something has to be
- 25:45done. I mean, you have this huge scene where
- 25:49I think Lou, she's either speaking to Gus or
- 25:51Spider, but she's in her dressing room and she's
- 25:54behind one of those screens. Gus. Oh, she's talking
- 25:58with Gus. I thought you meant Gus was behind
- 26:00the screen. I was like, you know how badly I
- 26:02wish Noah Beery was like, let me slip into something
- 26:04more comfortable. Yeah. And you see like him
- 26:07tighten the corset behind the screen. But she's
- 26:09changing behind this screen while she has this
- 26:11whole conversation with him. Yes. And you're
- 26:13seeing like shoulders and like just above the
- 26:16collarbone. It's very risque. And like that,
- 26:20again, that's the whole movie. You're seeing
- 26:22a lot of neckline from Mae West. A lot of her
- 26:27figure. So, and then, you know, we haven't even
- 26:32gotten into like the double. Entendres? No, the,
- 26:36like the dual purpose of this nightclub. Yes.
- 26:40So she is just a performer at this nightclub.
- 26:43She's the headliner. And even though she alludes
- 26:48to being very, very close to. a lot of men it's
- 26:52it's never hinted at it being prostitution or
- 26:55anything for her no it's more out of self -interest
- 26:57yeah she just she enjoys it like literally men
- 27:01will just be brought into the club and they're
- 27:02like hey this is my assistant and she's like
- 27:04oh who are you yeah but she calls him is it tall
- 27:08dark and handsome or is it something else yes
- 27:11it's something like tall dark and handsome sounds
- 27:13right yeah i forget his name but this is the
- 27:15assistant for her colleague That also works at
- 27:18the club. Yeah, the Frenchman. Yeah, and when
- 27:20I say assistant, I believe it's also implied
- 27:22that they're romantically involved, too. So then
- 27:24there's a little bit of a, you know, not controversy,
- 27:26but scandal between this flirtation that they
- 27:29have. But this flirtation that she has is kind
- 27:32of with, like, the majority of men that are,
- 27:34like, attractive. So you take Spider and Gus
- 27:36out of it. Pretty much any other man that shows
- 27:38up, she's like, well, hello. Yeah, including
- 27:40Cary Grant's character, who is not interested.
- 27:44He's there to do a job. and find out that she
- 27:47is romantically entangled with someone who is
- 27:50in prison. And this is Chick Clark portrayed
- 27:54by Owen Moore. Right. And this is a great moment
- 27:58for so many reasons. She goes down to the prison
- 28:01to meet with Chick. She's almost reminded, I
- 28:05think, by Spider or Gus. Yeah, they're like,
- 28:07you should probably go check on him. She's like,
- 28:09I should go down there and see him sometime.
- 28:13But she goes to the prison. And it's such a great
- 28:16moment. She's walking by these jail cells. And
- 28:18in every single cell, there are men who know
- 28:22her. Yep. And she's got something just so smart
- 28:27to say about each one. And one of the biggest
- 28:29standouts here for me was she walks by a cell
- 28:32with two individuals in the cell. And they say
- 28:35something to her. And as she's passing, she makes
- 28:39a comment, the Cherry Sisters or something like
- 28:42that. And this was... A brief little hint that
- 28:46they were a gay couple. Interesting. I did not
- 28:50pick up on that. Yeah. And this was a huge deal
- 28:53as well, because obviously gay relationships
- 28:56or gay partners or anything like this is not
- 28:59depicted on the screen. But Mae West had no problem
- 29:03showcasing these types of things. You know, it's
- 29:06interesting. I'm thinking back now to our conversation
- 29:07about Cavalcade. We didn't even get to talk about
- 29:09there's a sequence that kind of alludes to this
- 29:11as well. in cavalcade is there yeah there's um
- 29:14it's towards the end where it shows like the
- 29:16result of all the war and everything in between
- 29:19the politicians and the pastor like speaking
- 29:21there's a clip of like one of the clubs that
- 29:23um fanny is singing at and there's like two women
- 29:26that are talking to each other and they're like
- 29:28fairly close but it's not a big deal But then
- 29:30it cuts to two men, and they're sharing a cigarette.
- 29:33And the way they look at each other is very romantically
- 29:35involved. So there's a scene that hints at that,
- 29:38too. So it's interesting that we're two movies
- 29:40back -to -back in our conversations about them
- 29:43alluding to this. I think there's more of an
- 29:45on -screen flirtation with cavalcade. But to
- 29:49even include this in something like She Done
- 29:51Him Wrong, this is something that they're pushing
- 29:52the boundaries on more often. Yeah, yeah. And
- 29:54again, this is like a Mae West. decision right
- 29:58here so i i thought that was wild to see and
- 30:02just all of her little snide remarks to everybody
- 30:04is she doesn't have a single line in this movie
- 30:06that doesn't hit hard no i mean she is again
- 30:11commanding the screen you you'd worry that it's
- 30:13going to get exhausting sometimes because you're
- 30:15right she has something to say about everyone
- 30:16and she passes the cell you're a little worried
- 30:18that this is going to be like you have a little
- 30:19too many like one too many one -liners right
- 30:21but no she's she's crashing it she's on a hundred
- 30:24percent the other aspect of this with chick clark
- 30:26and all the men that she's involved with is that
- 30:29we're gonna choose to a character named sally
- 30:31Sally comes into the club very silently, minding
- 30:35her own business, and then attempts to take her
- 30:37own life. We had a conversation off pod about
- 30:39what she actually is doing to take her own life.
- 30:42Yeah. We assume it's some kind of pill that she's
- 30:44going to take. Very bold of the bouncer spider
- 30:47to then be like, she's going to off herself and
- 30:49knock her out. Right. But to prevent her from
- 30:53hurting herself, they knock her out and then
- 30:55bring her to Lady Lou to make sure she can take
- 30:58care of her. And then she brings her in. And
- 31:01says, hey, if you need a place here, if you're
- 31:03escaping something, let me know. And she opens
- 31:05up and says, well, technically I'm kind of on
- 31:08the run from my husband or partner. His husband,
- 31:10right? Yeah. Where he did her wrong. Yes. So
- 31:14to speak. And she's on the run from, not on the
- 31:17run, but she's on the outs of that. And she's
- 31:19looking for a place to belong. And they're like,
- 31:21you can stay here as long as you want. And they
- 31:22end up like bringing her in kind of as like a
- 31:24performer or, you know. potentially prostitute
- 31:27in that sense, but to be at the club and they
- 31:30give her like clothes and a makeover and everything.
- 31:32I want, I bring up Sally, uh, not just to mention
- 31:34her, uh, involvement with the club, but also
- 31:37did you read who originally was supposed to play
- 31:39Sally? I did not. So Marion Marsh originally
- 31:43was supposed to portray Sally. She was Jenny
- 31:45Townsend in five star final. Oh yeah. The daughter.
- 31:49Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh, she originally was going
- 31:51to be, uh, playing Sally. Uh, but then Rochelle
- 31:54Hudson. Took over and portrays her in the movie.
- 31:57Nice. I like the aspect of Sally, although it
- 31:59was a little comedic. Obviously, I have some
- 32:02questions about how they knew that she was going
- 32:05to offer herself. But this is something that,
- 32:07and that's their words, there's a line that they
- 32:09say where they're like, you know, people keep
- 32:11trying to come in here and kill themselves. Yeah.
- 32:14So this happens. Mae West has this great line
- 32:16where she's like, hey, Gus. tell the girls stop
- 32:19trying to make this place a morgue or something
- 32:21like that. Yeah. Again, it's those lines that
- 32:23kind of like deal with very serious subjects
- 32:26in a very lighthearted way. Yeah. So I really
- 32:29appreciated that. But that was an interesting
- 32:31aspect for Sally, where, again, it kind of shows,
- 32:33while she might be rough around the edges, that
- 32:36Lady Lou is similar to Captain Cummings in a
- 32:38way where she is bringing in anyone who needs
- 32:42this place and helping them have a role. Right.
- 32:45And to be clear, up to this point, like you mentioned,
- 32:47she's brought in to serve as a performer and
- 32:51also maybe a prostitute. Server, perhaps, maybe.
- 32:54Right. Up to this point, we don't know. the other
- 32:59purpose of this club right and lady lou she's
- 33:03not part of of whatever salacious activities
- 33:05exist in this club so when sally's brought in
- 33:09they're like can you sing or dance no okay well
- 33:12you won't be a performer tell you what we're
- 33:13gonna send you somewhere uh for another job and
- 33:17ultimately we find out that she's going to be
- 33:19trained to be a pickpocket so this The owner
- 33:22of this club, Gus, and then Rita as well, the
- 33:25other woman at the club, they run this prostitution
- 33:30ring, a counterfeit ring, and they're sending
- 33:32girls who come in looking for really just a place
- 33:36to end it. And inevitably a second chance. Yes.
- 33:41I love that Lady Lou isn't a part of any of this.
- 33:44She really is trying to just be helpful and look
- 33:46out for people, and she lives this life in like...
- 33:51Her own terms. I'm hyping her up a lot. I think
- 33:54she's just such a cool character. She is. And
- 33:57I really like where this ends up going. There
- 33:59is another individual who comes in. I'm forgetting
- 34:02his name, but he's trying to buy the club from
- 34:05Gus Jordan, or at least take over ownership from
- 34:08Gus Jordan. Right. Yes. I don't remember his
- 34:11name either. No, I can't remember. So he ends
- 34:14up kind of plotting against Lou and Gus to kind
- 34:18of get the... club itself and then in by proxy
- 34:22lady lou and get access to her so she feels kind
- 34:25of cornered between chick clark could potentially
- 34:28get out of prison and now he's kind of coming
- 34:30back for her in that sense this guy really wants
- 34:34the club itself and is going to take it from
- 34:35gus jordan there's the police involvement and
- 34:38she feels kind of like cornered and backed into
- 34:41a corner so to speak yeah i think this is where
- 34:43the movie turns a little bit for me is where
- 34:45the movie feels like it's out of lady lou's control
- 34:48And she tries to make some like, you know, plans.
- 34:52It's funny. The way that she kind of like talks
- 34:54with Gus Jordan and Spider and a couple of people
- 34:56of like, well, I think we're going to try this.
- 34:58And maybe if we do this and we do it the right
- 35:00way, we can get out of this. You're like, cool.
- 35:02So like, are they going to frame Chick Clark
- 35:05for something and have the police like pick him
- 35:07back up or tell the police where Chick's going
- 35:08to be so then he can like arrest them? No, what
- 35:11ends up happening is they have Chick Clark murdered.
- 35:15Is that right? No, no, no. He doesn't get murdered.
- 35:17Who gets shot? Because remember, she's performing.
- 35:20She's performing. She done him wrong. And they
- 35:22plan some kind of trap upstairs, and you can
- 35:25see multiple people involved and looking at her
- 35:27eyeline. Yeah, she sends people up to go get
- 35:31Chick Clark, who's waiting in this room for her.
- 35:34Yes. And he shoots just one of the bouncers,
- 35:37basically. Is it not that they shoot Chick Clark?
- 35:40No. Chick Clark, he's alive until the very end.
- 35:44With the twist with Cary Grant. Because then
- 35:46Chick Clark has Lady Lou by the throat or whatever.
- 35:50And he's like, I'm going to take you with me
- 35:52kind of thing. Yes. Okay. You're right. So. While
- 35:56she's performing, and I did like this sequence
- 35:57at least, while she's performing, she's looking
- 36:00into the audience and above and behind the audience
- 36:02is the upstairs area where we see her room, where
- 36:06Gus Jordan is sitting, like there's another group
- 36:09of individuals sitting to the left. So she's
- 36:11kind of like making eye contact with them and
- 36:13planning this while she's singing. And then ultimately
- 36:15the shooting ends up happening. That interrupts
- 36:18the performance. And just one of the most quick,
- 36:21like, hey guys, don't worry, there's a shooting.
- 36:24services will be back in like 30 seconds and
- 36:26music will be back on i was like i'm not staying
- 36:29if someone just got shot upstairs and died no
- 36:32i'm not staying thank you but i mean lady lou's
- 36:34still there so right there you know you gotta
- 36:36stick around until she leaves that's true a valid
- 36:38point but yeah with the shooting like as soon
- 36:40as it happens the cops show up and We skipped
- 36:44over a little bit with Cary Grant, but ultimately,
- 36:46like, he tries to convert her, if you will, save
- 36:50her, put her on the right path, and she gets
- 36:53very flirtatious. And at one point, he does kind
- 36:55of make a move on her, and I love that she denies
- 36:59him. Again, just a movie with a strong female
- 37:02lead that is calling the shots here. It's so
- 37:07cool. It's also very funny that Mae West can
- 37:09now say, like, she has a movie with Cary Grant
- 37:11where she's, like, denying his advances. Right.
- 37:13Yes. But the big twist at the end of this movie
- 37:17is Cary Grant shows back up, Captain Cummings,
- 37:20and you see that he is, in fact, a police officer.
- 37:24And this whole thing was like an undercover job
- 37:26trying to take down this crime ring. So he makes
- 37:31his way inside. Lady Lou is upstairs with Chick
- 37:34Clark, and he is threatening. Her life, Captain
- 37:38Cummings shows up. And I guess, I don't, he like
- 37:41shoots Chick Clark, but doesn't hit him, but
- 37:44stops him. Like a warning shot? Yeah. I don't
- 37:46know what happens, but he arrests Chick Clark.
- 37:49And there's, this is, this is my favorite scene
- 37:52of the movie is when he is approaching Lady Lou
- 37:55and he's like, all right, this is it. Like basically
- 37:59we're taking you down with, with everybody else.
- 38:01Right. And she is just so snarky with him. And
- 38:06he's coming up to her with handcuffs. And she's
- 38:09like, well, I don't need those. Hands aren't
- 38:11everything. Blah, blah, blah. Just, you know,
- 38:13she's got a zinger for everything. Yeah. My favorite
- 38:15part is he puts like her mink coat on and then
- 38:21grabs her by the arm to walk her out. And she
- 38:23goes, if you want to help me, pick up my train.
- 38:26So he like picks up her train and hands it to
- 38:28her and then like just walks out with her. She's
- 38:30still in control, even as she's being let out
- 38:33by the police. And ultimately, this ends with
- 38:37all of the criminals getting loaded up into the
- 38:40paddy wagon, if you will. And Captain Cummings
- 38:44puts her into his private vehicle and reveals
- 38:47that he is going to keep her around and he is
- 38:50going to be the one to provide her with diamonds
- 38:53and jewels and everything she wants. And she's
- 38:55really hesitant at first. But the second he whips
- 38:58out a diamond ring and places it on her finger,
- 39:00she's like. okay well yes i'm listening yeah
- 39:04and the final line of this movie carrie grant
- 39:08leans over it and this is where i thought it
- 39:10was a little cheesy because carrie grant just
- 39:12seems like such a little nice boy yeah but he's
- 39:15like you bad girl and she says you'll find out
- 39:20yep end credits you know i one thing that i really
- 39:24liked about that specifically is that it it's
- 39:26a uh and a book End cap? Book cap? Whatever.
- 39:29Book ends. That's the word. It bookends the beginning
- 39:32and the end of Mae West's Lady Lou in this with
- 39:36that arrival and departure. Yeah. So it kind
- 39:39of feels like that play aspect of like, here's
- 39:41the entrance and here's the exit. Yeah. Everything
- 39:43takes place at this club. And I liked that a
- 39:45lot. That felt great. I can't say that I loved
- 39:48the last portion of this because it just kind
- 39:50of felt like we just got to wrap this up and
- 39:52get this over somehow. Yeah. And it was a little
- 39:55confusing of like whose side is on who and what's
- 39:59actually going on and what does this last scene
- 40:01mean? And this ultimately feels like a dark ending
- 40:04of her being like arrested. But then I guess
- 40:07the twist in that, and it feels a little Billy
- 40:08Wilder, or not Billy Wilder, Ernst Lubitsch in
- 40:11this regard, is he has this line that a police
- 40:15officer would be saying to a prostitute at that
- 40:17point is like, you're with me now? Or like...
- 40:21I'm going to like I'm going to take care of you.
- 40:23We're going to take care of you. But taking that
- 40:26ring out like you belong to me is kind of like
- 40:28the idea here, which makes sense with like a
- 40:30prisoner and like a cop. Yeah. But in this sense,
- 40:34he kind of like flips that a little bit. And
- 40:36it's like you belong to me now and hands her
- 40:38that ring. Right. And flips it on her finger.
- 40:40So then he's kind of alluding to the fact of
- 40:42like I've arrested you, but like you're probably
- 40:44not going to be arrested if you just spend the
- 40:46rest of your life with me. And in reality, that's
- 40:48probably not going to happen. She's going to
- 40:49get out of it somehow, but she's more than happy
- 40:51to oblige this. And that just felt a little tacked
- 40:56on for me to where I wasn't like super as engaged
- 40:59with that. Like I was for the first like 75 %
- 41:01of this movie. Yeah. But I mean, still good.
- 41:04Just it didn't resonate with me a ton. So the
- 41:06ending was actually tacked on. This was a studio
- 41:09decision. Sure. This was not the original ending
- 41:12of the play Diamond Lil. Do you know the original
- 41:15ending? don't um i know that it is more in line
- 41:20with like the rest of the story um this was tacked
- 41:23on so there there was some kind of all of these
- 41:26movies include marriage and i think the the diamond
- 41:30ring going on her finger that's supposed to be
- 41:33the okay well now even if we are going to be
- 41:36like have this taboo relationship The symbolism
- 41:41is still there of like, okay, well, we are exclusive
- 41:44or whatever. So, yeah, it doesn't hit as hard,
- 41:47but that's the reason. Like, it wasn't a Mae
- 41:51West ending, really. Right. Which otherwise it
- 41:54feels like a very Mae West movie. Right. Yeah.
- 41:57I do like that, you know, the final line, the
- 42:00bad girl, and you'll find out. That's great.
- 42:03I think that is a good closing line from her.
- 42:06But it is kind of a little bit silly, the ending.
- 42:10And I really feel like it's Cary Grant that makes
- 42:12it silly to me. Yeah. I think it's because he
- 42:16has so many like turns in his character. And
- 42:18you see him as like this very sweet individual
- 42:20leaning up to this reveal. Yeah. And then he
- 42:22has to kind of turn on a dime and not be sweet.
- 42:25The second he has to be like bad boy Cary Grant,
- 42:28I'm like, I don't know if you're there yet, my
- 42:30dude. He'll get there. Yeah. But he's not quite
- 42:33there. Little, little. silly but a little silly
- 42:37you know it's it's funny to think about with
- 42:39this runtime length of this movie being 66 minutes
- 42:42it's funny thing about this episode being just
- 42:44as long as the movie yeah yeah that is pretty
- 42:46silly so it's it's difficult to do that but you
- 42:49know we've kind of talked about the majority
- 42:50of the movie itself we've talked about like the
- 42:53behind the scenes here it's a shame that we don't
- 42:55see something like this happen again with may
- 42:57west because i i really enjoyed this it almost
- 43:00makes you wonder if this came out like 1931 Like
- 43:03we would have undoubtedly had something like
- 43:04this in 1933. Yeah. But in its time frame now,
- 43:07it didn't have enough time to be another movie
- 43:10to be produced with the code that's incoming.
- 43:12Right. And this is just her first or this is
- 43:16her second appearance on screen. So like this
- 43:18is very early in her film career. And she does
- 43:22go on to make a lot of quote unquote Mae West.
- 43:26Right. But I do think that the code itself did
- 43:29kind of pacify her career a little bit. But I
- 43:33mean, this this is the character that she became
- 43:36from this point on. Like in every movie, she's
- 43:40doing some variation of this like Diamond Lil
- 43:43Lady Lou character. Yeah. And she she is great
- 43:47in it. And obviously, to your point, huge icon
- 43:49of what was to come to a point where even this
- 43:53year. And this is a tee up for you. There's an
- 43:55animated short made about this, right? Yeah,
- 43:58yeah. I didn't write it down. She Done Him Right,
- 44:00I believe is what it's called. Yeah, it's a cartoon.
- 44:02It's a universal cartoon. Same creator of Oswald
- 44:06the Lucky Rabbit. And I forget his name. It's
- 44:08like Pup the Pooch or something. But it's this
- 44:11little Mickey Mouse -esque dog who is excited
- 44:16to go see Puddles, I think her name is. Okay.
- 44:20Puddles, the Mae West character. I thought that
- 44:23was their name. I was like, that's a... A little
- 44:25on the nose, but okay. It really is just kind
- 44:29of like your standard early Mickey Mouse, early
- 44:31like Oswald the Lucky Rabbit cartoon. All of
- 44:36these animals are like thirsting over Puddles
- 44:39the dog who gets to sing a little bit on stage.
- 44:44It's kind of silly. It's like this poodle, this
- 44:47very curvy poodle. And yeah, I mean, there's
- 44:50really not much to tell. It has that kind of
- 44:53zany. early cartoon vibe to it. Yeah, with a
- 44:57wolf shows up and it's kind of like Pete in a
- 45:00Mickey Mouse cartoon. Yeah. I don't know. There's
- 45:01not a whole lot to say other than it is a fun
- 45:05little nod to She Done Him Wrong and Mae West's
- 45:09character. You're correct in the names Pooch
- 45:11the Pup. Pooch the Pup, not Pup the Pooch. So
- 45:15close. And Poodles. Poodles. Yeah. So close.
- 45:19Almost had it. Almost had it. Almost had it.
- 45:21I love when there's like cartoon versions of
- 45:24movies. And I think that goes to show, I mean,
- 45:26look, it's nominated for Best Picture. It's not
- 45:28like this is the only example of that. But love
- 45:31whenever they show the iconography of these movies
- 45:34and how it affects the outside world. Totally.
- 45:37And the way that I got to watch it, we'll talk
- 45:39a little bit about physical media. This movie
- 45:41is available. In like a Cary Grant collection
- 45:45or a Mae West collection. But also Kino Lorber
- 45:49put out a disc. I want to pull up my reviews
- 45:54because this led me to, I rented this from Videodrome.
- 45:58Love Videodrome. DVD or Blu -ray? Blu -ray. So
- 46:02excited. Yes. So I watched it once, right? The
- 46:05all 60, what is it? 67 minutes of it? 66. 66
- 46:09minutes of it. Then there was a commentary track
- 46:12by film historian David DiValli. I watched that
- 46:15a second time. Then there was another commentary
- 46:18track with film historian Kat Ellinger. So yesterday
- 46:22I watched this movie three times, back to back
- 46:25to back, because I wanted to absorb as much of
- 46:28this bonus material that I could. And it was
- 46:31great. It was great, especially the David Ellinger.
- 46:34Or no, David Davali. His commentary track, there's
- 46:37so much information about Mae West and just how
- 46:40iconic she is and how this persona, like, this
- 46:45was always her. When she showed up, there's this
- 46:47whole rumor of, like, nobody really knew Mae
- 46:50West because anytime anybody spoke with her,
- 46:53she was playing this character for the rest of
- 46:56her life. Right. And I think that's such a huge
- 46:59testament to just... the legacy that she created
- 47:03with this character, and how it went on for years
- 47:06to be replicated and mimicked by so many other
- 47:11movies and actors and actresses like Madonna
- 47:14and her Material Girl era. Oh, for sure. Like,
- 47:16that's Mae West. Just in the visuals alone. Yeah.
- 47:20So it's really cool. I had a great time. with
- 47:23this movie. Yeah, I did too. I also want to point
- 47:26out that in the time frame that you mentioned
- 47:28that there is a physical release for this, I
- 47:31was able to go on Amazon, find it for $7 on Blu
- 47:35-ray, the Kino Lorber release you're talking
- 47:37about, and order it. Excellent. So it is on its
- 47:39way to me now. In real time. In real time. uh
- 47:42purchasing visit which for me i was like yeah
- 47:44i wonder if i could find that collection found
- 47:46the single disc for seven dollars on blu -ray
- 47:49.com it's like done beautiful purchased it really
- 47:52is cool the the commentary i think you'll like
- 47:54it a lot and you'll get a lot out of that was
- 47:56on the kena lorber disc yes perfect yeah yeah
- 47:58i can't wait to watch it you know i feel like
- 48:00i'll go back and check my ratings on this but
- 48:02i feel like my ratings are going to be a little
- 48:03bit lower On this than what it sounds like? Yeah.
- 48:06Oh, wow. Yeah, your reading is much higher than
- 48:08I thought it was going to be. After three times.
- 48:11That's true. After three times, there's going
- 48:12to be a difference in viewing. But you can't
- 48:16deny the iconography of something like this.
- 48:18I mean, she just absolutely crushes this role.
- 48:21I don't think it's the best. I don't think that
- 48:24it's like the most enjoyable, not enjoyable,
- 48:26but the most accurate representation of like
- 48:28where we were at this time. I love that something
- 48:31like this was nominated for Best Picture because
- 48:33it's such a breath of fresh air compared to something
- 48:36like Cavalcade. I mean, I watched Cavalcade and
- 48:38then watched this. And this was such like, oh,
- 48:41wow, this feels so different. There's a moment
- 48:44on one of the commentary tracks where I think
- 48:46David DiValle says. This is another prime example
- 48:49of a movie being nominated for Best Picture that
- 48:52shouldn't have been. And I think that's so wild
- 48:55because, again, in a year where Cavalcade takes
- 48:59home the Best Picture win, and that's such, like
- 49:03I said earlier, like white rice, no spice movie.
- 49:07This is so littered with everything the production
- 49:10code despises. So much so that, again, Diamond
- 49:14Lil was on basically a ban list. This is not
- 49:17Lady Lou, though. Yeah, it's so much fun. And
- 49:21just this is the exciting part of watching pre
- 49:24-code. You sit down to watch this and you're
- 49:26like, wait a minute. They can do this? Yeah.
- 49:28They can look like Mae West? Wild. In language,
- 49:32in sex, in violence. even a crime, it's all in
- 49:38this movie. It is. But it doesn't feel too overstuffed
- 49:41with ideas like that. Yeah. If anything, Bryce
- 49:43says in his review, and I agree with him, the
- 49:46movie can feel dull at some times because it's
- 49:48just happening around you. And I think that's
- 49:51more the back third of the movie. I think leading
- 49:55up to it, thrilling. Getting to know everyone,
- 49:57seeing their interactions, the introduction of
- 50:00Lady Lou, and how she's running this club, essentially.
- 50:04I thought it was fantastic, and I loved. And
- 50:06it being 66 minutes, it's like even if it does
- 50:09drag at any point, which for me it didn't, but
- 50:13if it does, it's over. It's snappy. Yeah. Yeah,
- 50:16it keeps going. So we can get into ratings. I
- 50:20gave it four stars. You did. I had a blast. I
- 50:23will watch more Mae West because I think she
- 50:26is iconic. I would love to point out your review
- 50:29on Litterboxd. which is simply commentary by
- 50:33Kat Hillinger. So I have three loggings of it.
- 50:37So I have one for each commentary. The first
- 50:40one doesn't have a review. But if I had to give
- 50:42it a review. Oh, I see. Your review of it was
- 50:45how you watched it a second and third time. Yeah.
- 50:47Copy. I thought that was a review. My review
- 50:50would be, wow, wowie, wow, wow. Great. Yeah.
- 50:54That's pretty much everyone's reaction whenever
- 50:55they see Lady Lou on screen. Nailed it. I'm at
- 50:59three stars. Okay. Not bad by any stretch of
- 51:03the imagination. And I think I was pretty easy
- 51:05at two and a half. And then just looking back,
- 51:07I'm like, no, I had way better of a time of this
- 51:09than I thought I did. It's that dull nature of
- 51:12like the last third of the movie that just kind
- 51:14of kept me from really engaging with this as
- 51:16much. Yeah. But I mean, literally the word undeniable
- 51:20doesn't do it justice for what Mae West does
- 51:23with this role, with this movie. It's ultimately
- 51:25what we want something like Disraeli to be. So
- 51:28it didn't land as heavily with me. But when it
- 51:32comes to just appreciating the art, if I can
- 51:34take myself out of it, it's probably four or
- 51:36five stars easily. Yeah. Or maybe four and a
- 51:38half. But exceptional. Really, really fun to
- 51:41watch. Yeah. A blast. Had a really good time.
- 51:43How about a double feature? Double feature for
- 51:46me, I went right down the middle. I picked a
- 51:48movie that also touched on far, far from controversial,
- 51:53at least as much as something like She Done Him
- 51:56Wrong in the 1930s. But in 2010, the director
- 52:00Steve Anton did Burlesque. This stars Christina
- 52:05Aguilera and Cher, where Christina Aguilera becomes
- 52:08a waitress, bartender, and then ultimately performer
- 52:11at a burlesque club ran by Cher and Stanley Tucci.
- 52:17There's not near as many crimes, allegations,
- 52:21scandals that are happening in this club, but
- 52:23the idea of Sally and her presence under Mae
- 52:28West's tutelage felt very similar to something
- 52:30like Cher and Christina Aguilera and Burlesque.
- 52:33This is a movie that, it's so funny. I feel like
- 52:36when people see me and get to know me, well,
- 52:39when they see me, they're like, oh, yeah, okay,
- 52:40this guy likes movies. Well, he's probably like
- 52:42film bro. And then when Taylor's like, hey, do
- 52:44you want to share a movie with me? Like, yeah,
- 52:45I do. She's like, cool. What do you want to share?
- 52:47I'm like, let's watch 2010's Burlesque. Yeah.
- 52:50She's like, what? And then we watch it and she's
- 52:52like, well, I loved that. I'm like, I know you
- 52:53do because you like Coyote Ugly and you love
- 52:56all these movies from the 2000s, like the, you
- 52:58know, the Bring It On, Legally Blonde, like the
- 53:01way that it like tackles female stories in a
- 53:04really interesting way. Yeah. And Burlesque is
- 53:06that. I think Burlesque is a movie that's criminally
- 53:08slept on. It also gives us the viral Cher wagon
- 53:12wheel with Tusi that people talk. Okay, we're
- 53:15on different sides of TikTok. It's a viral thing.
- 53:17Burlesque is a lot of fun. And I had a really
- 53:19good time with it. And I think that it is not
- 53:21as successful as something like She Done Him
- 53:23Wrong and not nearly as iconic as that. But it's
- 53:27a nice show of like how even before or what we
- 53:32were able to do before the code and then what
- 53:33we're able to do after the code. I think it's
- 53:35a nice little litmus test of how different things
- 53:38are. Yeah. Nice. I've not seen Burlesque. I need
- 53:41to check it out. It's cool. It's been on my list
- 53:43for a long time. Had a good time. It's always
- 53:45fun to do a Cher impression whenever you're watching
- 53:47it. She has so many things that she says and
- 53:49you're like, I can't wait to try and say that.
- 53:50And Stanley Tucci in the news with Devil Wears
- 53:52Prada, too. Oh, there you go. So it's relevant.
- 53:55Stanley Tucci. Love him. I worked on a movie
- 53:58one time and Stanley Tucci was on set and I was
- 53:59so excited to... be placed for the scene alongside
- 54:03him. And they ended up using an ant farm instead
- 54:07of the backgrounders that day. So I got replaced
- 54:10by ants. I mean, it's a spinning image right
- 54:13now. I'm trying to determine if you're, you were
- 54:15an ant right now. You'll never know. Your figure
- 54:17is incredible. I mean, you and an ant are just
- 54:19like. I lift six times my body weight or something
- 54:23like that. Wow. Yeah, you know. Okay. There's
- 54:25also something to be said about, like, I think
- 54:28around some celebrities, I would be very, like,
- 54:30chill. I'm just kind of like, okay, how are you?
- 54:32Stanley Tucci, I do think would be my, like,
- 54:34hi, Kevin moment from SpongeBob. Yeah. I'm like,
- 54:36hi, Stanley. Like, I just don't know how to talk.
- 54:40I'd be very nervous. Yeah. Well. What about your
- 54:42double feature? Because you're not an ant. That's
- 54:43true. So my double feature, one of the most interesting
- 54:47things on these commentary tracks is how they
- 54:49talked about Mae West becoming kind of a queer
- 54:53icon. Yeah. Speaking of Cher. She is more heavyset
- 54:58than most of the women in Hollywood during this
- 55:00time. Sure. And I think that that kind of lends
- 55:04itself to like the drag community kind of adopting
- 55:08her. So I think the impact that even if it wasn't
- 55:12purposefully. The impact that this has had over
- 55:15time on the queer community has led me to choose
- 55:19the Rocky Horror Picture Show. Oh, great. As
- 55:22that is also a major, major high point in the
- 55:27queer community. Obviously, you have Tim Curry
- 55:29doing one of the best drag performances ever
- 55:32put onto film. I've not seen all of Rocky Horror
- 55:35Picture Show, but I have seen that scene, his
- 55:39introduction. And it's undeniably incredible.
- 55:42Well, he's almost doing like a version of a Mae
- 55:44West thing. Yeah. In like the big hair and the
- 55:46way that he's like presenting himself and especially
- 55:48de -escalating doesn't sound right, but like
- 55:51scaling down the stairs feels very Mae West.
- 55:55And it's so funny because, you know, I talk about
- 55:57Mae West's size and Tim Curry is like scrawny
- 56:00in that. So it's almost like a contradiction
- 56:03right there. But yeah, I just think that. I don't
- 56:07know. Acceptance is a big part of it, right?
- 56:09With like the plus size and the queer nature
- 56:12of it. Like Tim Curry goes a very long way in
- 56:14the evolved nature of what Mae West was doing.
- 56:17So I follow. Yeah, yeah. I just think that like
- 56:20she, from what I've learned, she's an incredible
- 56:22woman who really, if it didn't hurt her, she
- 56:27spoke out. Well, even, I mean, she got arrested.
- 56:30So even if it does hurt her, I think that she
- 56:33spoke out and she may not have like actively
- 56:36fought for things, but she was like, yeah, whatever.
- 56:38Come on. I support this. So making space for
- 56:41people. Exactly. Exactly. And I think that that's
- 56:44why I'm going with Rocky Horror Picture Show.
- 56:47I love it. And I think in both examples of what
- 56:49we've. what we've chosen here is double features
- 56:51it speaks to how far we've come in terms of like
- 56:55accepting or not accepting but making space for
- 56:59everyone yeah uh and and i love that all aspects
- 57:02that we can of that whether it be when it comes
- 57:04to like uh the sex work side of it um the what
- 57:08was the character that you said was um her pearl
- 57:12yeah pearl her involvement may west's um Work
- 57:15to make sure that she and others are involved
- 57:18in movies like that. And also just the queer
- 57:21nature of it, too. Like, especially the drag
- 57:23and scene of what it's become since then. It's
- 57:26really cool to see the inclusion that can come
- 57:30out of something like this. Yeah, the impact
- 57:31and all of that. Even with the code looming overhead.
- 57:34Yes. Man, this coming right after Cavalcade and
- 57:38just being like, oh, this is what we. Could have
- 57:41if this continues and this is what might happen
- 57:44after the code. I get chills thinking about it,
- 57:48Ryan. It stresses me out. They're multiplying.
- 57:52It's true. It's true. A different musical. Would
- 57:54you give it three stars? I gave it three stars
- 57:56and that feels unfair. I might come back to it
- 57:58at a later date. But I don't like that face you
- 58:00made. The face is definitely, I'm better than
- 58:02you. Like, yeah, it's okay. You're not there
- 58:04yet. Yeah, I'm sure that'll change over time.
- 58:06And if I watch it again, I mean, look, for what
- 58:08it's worth, I said three stars. And as soon as
- 58:10you said there's a Blu -ray and I saw it was
- 58:11$7, immediate purchase. Right. Didn't happen
- 58:14with Cavalcade. No. Nope. You were like, hey,
- 58:17there's maybe a DVD and it's $50. I'm like, okay.
- 58:20That's cool. Cool. I'll see it in a museum one
- 58:23day. But very cool to have something like this
- 58:25in your collection. And I'm very excited to add
- 58:28it to it. So it probably is more than three stars.
- 58:30But also, you know, we just saw, we, I just saw
- 58:33Devil Wears Prada and I gave it three and a half
- 58:35stars. And someone was like, yeah, it's really
- 58:37low. And I was like, is it? I don't, it's not.
- 58:41It's above the halfway mark, which shows like
- 58:43positive. Yeah. So we got to like. we meaning
- 58:46myself too, we got to chill and we got to find
- 58:48like the balance of what this means. Yeah. Cause
- 58:50I could just drop a heart and be like, I can't
- 58:52rate it, but I liked it. Yeah. So we'll keep
- 58:54that alive. It was a weird popping clip. Yeah.
- 58:57What was that? I don't know what that was. That
- 58:58was, um, that was your, uh, system telling you
- 59:02when you're, uh, you're done. Yeah, maybe that's
- 59:04what it was. Anyway, that's She Done Him Wrong.
- 59:06If you have thoughts about me... Did we do it
- 59:08wrong? Yeah. Let us know. Exactly. Shoot us an
- 59:11email at outaopodcast at gmail .com. And if you
- 59:15want to support the show financially, check out
- 59:17patreon .com slash outaopodcast. I'm going to
- 59:21leave it at that. Rate and review the show, I
- 59:23guess. Please. Beyond that, next episode, we
- 59:26will be covering The Return. janet gainer we're
- 59:29going to the state fair we are i'm excited i'm
- 59:32excited i love here we come iowa yippee i love
- 59:36corn good yeah that's all i got as always i'm
- 59:41kyle i'm ryan and we'll see you at the movies