Latest / The So What? / Project Vulindlela
Transcript
- 0:05Hello and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:27This podcast goes with J .P.'s newsletter, dated
- 0:31the 14th of October 2025. And the title is Project
- 0:36Wollendlela. But before we come to that, JP,
- 0:41it's been a while. Why the silence since, what
- 0:44is it, July? Yes, we must apologize to our readers
- 0:47and regular listeners for the long period of
- 0:50silence. Basically two reasons. I fell ill with
- 0:53pneumonia and couldn't shake it. That dragged
- 0:55on and dragged on. And then I've been... very
- 0:58busy and between those two impediments I can't
- 1:02do couldn't do the kind of deep research that
- 1:05I like to do when I do the compile the notes
- 1:08so that's what happened my apologies but we're
- 1:11all healthy now and happy and going on and here
- 1:14we are with the next episode talking about Willem
- 1:17Lela Well, there was also food poisoning while
- 1:21you were on the road, poor thing. Yes, yes. I
- 1:23was doing a roadshow and developed food poisoning
- 1:26and that was extremely uncomfortable. So, yes,
- 1:29all these things contributed. But fortunately,
- 1:31that's now behind us. So, why Project Fullendlela?
- 1:35It's been going for a while. Why do you want
- 1:37to focus on it now? In one of the roadshows I
- 1:41did in the last couple of weeks, we went around
- 1:43the country and spoke to about nine or ten business
- 1:46audiences. And I underlined the fact that they
- 1:49were business audiences. And in each of those
- 1:52meetings, I asked the audience members, do you
- 1:55know about Project Will and Leila? Do you know
- 1:57what it is? And to my shock and horror and amazement.
- 2:03Very, very few people knew about it. In fact,
- 2:05there were two of the towns and cities in which
- 2:08we were, where nobody in the audience have heard
- 2:11about Burundlela. And that made me realize that
- 2:16it is such an important program. And that made
- 2:19me realize that the ordinary business people
- 2:22out there do not have, shall I say, sufficient
- 2:25knowledge of what's going on. Why is Burundlela
- 2:28important? It is the most meaningful economic
- 2:32program by the government, economic policy program
- 2:35by the government since 1996 when the GEER program
- 2:38was launched. Since then, we've had many economic
- 2:42programs. We've had ASGISA. We had the new economy
- 2:46plan. In Zuma's time, there was the nine -point
- 2:48plan. Then there was the National Development
- 2:51Plan. And lately, in the last few weeks, the
- 2:54ANC has released the 10 -point economic plan.
- 2:56None of them are as comprehensive and as focused
- 3:00on implementation. That's really the point, as
- 3:03focused on implementation as the Volendela project.
- 3:07And I thought it's important that we talk about
- 3:10it. You go back to 2019 to find the origin. Absolutely.
- 3:15In 2019, October 2019, it's now six years ago,
- 3:19The then Minister of Finance, Titimo Bueni, released
- 3:22an innocent -looking document from the National
- 3:24Treasury, about 62, 63 pages, outlining changes
- 3:29that have to happen in the economy, structural
- 3:34change that must come in various areas. There
- 3:37was a huge hullabaloo. The document was condemned
- 3:41by some people as a sop. to new liberalism. It
- 3:45was condemned by others as a rogue document.
- 3:48Somebody said treasury has gone rogue. And yeah,
- 3:53there was a huge reaction. A month later, Tito
- 3:57Mubuweni went to the National Executive Committee
- 3:59of the ANC. And he apologized that he released
- 4:02this document before it was discussed internally
- 4:05by the ANC. So clearly, he believed that it's
- 4:09better to ask forgiveness later than to ask permission
- 4:13up front. So that's the background. That was
- 4:17in 2019. Sorry, but why? Why were people so shocked?
- 4:21What was in the document that was so different?
- 4:24As you will see when we go through the detail,
- 4:26what it basically entailed is that room must
- 4:30be made for the private sector. That's the big
- 4:32organizing principle if you pull it through.
- 4:36Room must be made for the private sector to come
- 4:39into areas where traditionally there has been
- 4:41government monopolies, like energy, for example,
- 4:44like logistics, like water. And with that, the
- 4:47private sector must also bring in capital and
- 4:49management expertise. And that was quite an important
- 4:52rubric online for many people in the ANC. Hard
- 4:55for the ANC to make that shift. For some of them,
- 4:59yes, absolutely. Clearly not for Mbueni and also
- 5:02not for the government, because what happened
- 5:04in 2020, we got COVID, the country went into
- 5:08a lockdown. But then in October 2020, a year
- 5:11after this rogue document was released, Government
- 5:15released an economic reform and recovery program
- 5:17to recover from COVID. And that program was basically
- 5:22premised on the document released by Titimo Bovene
- 5:27on the road document. And from then on, that
- 5:30became official government policy, basically
- 5:32from October 2020. And it was in the sonar, presidential
- 5:38sonar of February 21, where Ramaphosa just slipped
- 5:42in a little sentence in the speech to say that
- 5:45this document is now official government policy.
- 5:48And from there on, we had Willem Lela. What are
- 5:51the focus areas? There are five of them. It is
- 5:53electricity, spectrum release and digital communication.
- 5:59Water, freight transport, that is railways and
- 6:02ports, and number five, visa and skilled migration.
- 6:05Now, you must remember this, we now talk about
- 6:072021, 2020, 2021. These issues then were very
- 6:13prominent and paramount. Some of them still are.
- 6:17And the point about Project Will and Leila was
- 6:19it was a combined team of the presidency and
- 6:22national treasury that worked together to drive
- 6:25changes in these five areas through the government
- 6:28bureaucracy. The word Will and Leila means make
- 6:31way or open up. You know, it was get out of the
- 6:33way. remove the constraint, remove the obstacle.
- 6:36That's basically what the word means. Well, my
- 6:39little bit of Zulu says, open the road, the way.
- 6:44Well, there you are. There you are. That's a
- 6:45very good description of what it is about. Point
- 6:48number one was electricity. And that is probably
- 6:53the one area that people know about. But summarize,
- 6:57where were we with load shedding in 2021? It's
- 7:01very important to remember that load shedding
- 7:03was the big story. That was the big thing. We
- 7:05had stage six load shedding in 2020. We had load
- 7:09shedding virtually every day. So the first thing
- 7:12that we worked on was to try and fix load shedding.
- 7:15And the number of things were done. And today,
- 7:17it's now 2025, we look back and the issue of
- 7:21generating too little power. That is what load
- 7:24shedding is. You generate too little power for
- 7:27the need. That has been resolved. There may be
- 7:30individual areas in the country where municipalities
- 7:33have failed and there's load shedding or load
- 7:36reduction, as it's now called, in those areas.
- 7:39But the national problem of not producing enough
- 7:41electricity has been resolved. But something
- 7:45else happened in the process, and that is that
- 7:48the electricity industry was completely deregulated.
- 7:52Electricity used to be a state -run monopoly,
- 7:54run by ESCOM. It's a system that developed over
- 7:57many, many decades. It served the country well
- 7:59until about 10, 15 years ago. And the rest of
- 8:03the world has moved on to deregulated electricity
- 8:05markets in one way or another. And with this
- 8:09crisis of load shedding that we had in South
- 8:11Africa, we've taken the gap to not just solve
- 8:16the load shedding problem, but to reorganize,
- 8:18deregulate electricity. And I think it's important
- 8:21to do that just to understand how far this has
- 8:23gone. We have the example of Richards Bay Minerals
- 8:27in Richards Bay on the eastern side of the country.
- 8:30They are now, it's a smelter. A smelter uses
- 8:34a lot of electricity constantly. They now buy
- 8:3770 % of the electricity from solar and wind producers
- 8:42in the Western Cape. And then the electrons are
- 8:46sent across the country to the eastern part of
- 8:48Richards Bay. And they run a smelter on it. Not
- 8:51exclusively, as I've said, 70 % of their power.
- 8:54But, and this is the other important point, they
- 8:57buy that power, they say, at about 70 % of the
- 9:00tariff that ESCOM charges. So that's how far
- 9:03this thing has developed. Just in the last two
- 9:06weeks or so, we heard about Glencore, an international
- 9:09mining company. who run coal mines in South Africa.
- 9:13They have now signed an agreement to buy renewable
- 9:16energy from solar and wind to run a coal mine.
- 9:20Just think of the irony of that. Now, these things
- 9:24were completely impossible three years ago, four
- 9:26years ago. Couldn't happen. The law was against
- 9:28it. The law has been changed. The regulations
- 9:31have been changed. And a completely new dispensation
- 9:34is evolving. Now, obviously... vested interest
- 9:38in the old dispensation like ESCOM are not keen
- 9:42and they're trying to resist and they're trying
- 9:44to protect their position everybody will do that
- 9:47but it's quite clear which way the trend is going
- 9:50and the trend is away from from certainly a government
- 9:54monopoly to private sector private enterprise
- 9:57producing and selling electricity and the subsequent
- 10:00trend is away from coal to produce electricity
- 10:05to other sources of energy, like solar and wind
- 10:10and so on. It's quite a magnificent change that's
- 10:13happening in our country. And electricity is
- 10:16such an important basic network industry. If
- 10:20things go wrong there, it really circles out.
- 10:23If things go right there, you have the opposite
- 10:26kind of positive consequences. It also strikes
- 10:29me that there's been a mind shift. almost a national
- 10:33mind shift, that we no longer think that this
- 10:37is weird. That's a very important point that
- 10:39you're picking up on. Because we grew up, you
- 10:42and me and our generation, we grew up with state
- 10:45monopolies in certain areas. Electricity was
- 10:47one, but also in logistics. You call it a state
- 10:51monopoly, but from the recipient's point of view,
- 10:54it was simply the state provides. Yes. Yes, exactly.
- 10:58And that has now been broken and is being broken.
- 11:01Look, it's a journey. We must accept that. It's
- 11:04not happening overnight, but there's no question
- 11:06about the change. There's no question about the
- 11:09direction. There's no question about where we're
- 11:11going. And that is Project Ruland Lela. Number
- 11:15two on their list was Spectrum Release. And I
- 11:19think we as the users don't really notice what
- 11:24happened there. No, absolutely. Spectrum release
- 11:26was on the agenda, was supposed to be done, and
- 11:31was delayed for 10 years. Why was it delayed?
- 11:34Well, first, there were lots of political wranglings,
- 11:36particularly in a time of the Zuma administration.
- 11:40And then when Ramaphosa took over and the politics
- 11:42were sorted out, there were core challenges.
- 11:45And so we had this ironical thing that... Virtually
- 11:49everybody, three, four companies went to the
- 11:51High Court to say that the conditions of spectrum
- 11:54release, you know, are not fair to them. And
- 11:58that was all resolved. And after the delay of
- 12:0110 years, a spectrum auction took place in, I
- 12:05think it was in March 2022, yes. And that spectrum
- 12:09auction realized 14 and a half billion rand.
- 12:12for the government fiscus, money which is obviously
- 12:15welcome now for the fiscus. But the real point
- 12:18for you and me is now that spectrum that was
- 12:21released could now be used to introduce 4G and
- 12:255G. And if you now go across the country, you
- 12:28know, 5G is very available, certainly 4G is,
- 12:33and we've moved on from 2 and 3G where we were.
- 12:37In fact, I think there's an effort going on by
- 12:39the telcos to close down. 2G and 3G stations,
- 12:44the public has moved on. So all this is possible.
- 12:484G and 5G, which will be of us for forever, has
- 12:53been made possible because of digital spectrum
- 12:56release. And that was one of the first wins or
- 12:59victories that Volendela registered. And we've
- 13:02now forgotten about it. But spectrum release
- 13:04was certainly a big story. Number three on their
- 13:08list is water. Has anything shifted? Because
- 13:12once again, from the point of the consumer, it
- 13:15looks a bit dire. Absolutely. And yes, to answer
- 13:17your question, yes, things have shifted. Number
- 13:19one, the Zuma administration in its time abolished
- 13:23or suspended a water and sanitation measuring
- 13:26system known as blue drop, green drop or no drop.
- 13:30The logic was probably if you don't know about
- 13:33a problem, the problem doesn't exist. This was
- 13:35brought back by the Ramaphosa administration.
- 13:39Those reports, we've now had the first versions
- 13:41of those reports and obviously they make for
- 13:43dire reading because the water and sanitation
- 13:46and loss problem, as we know, drop comes in.
- 13:49Losses are quite high and we know there's a problem,
- 13:52but now at least we know it. And what you measure,
- 13:56what you know, you can manage. That's the first
- 13:59one. The second thing is we now have 11 projects
- 14:01going on countrywide. to a tune of about 156
- 14:05billion rand to have bigger bulk water supply.
- 14:10So you start at the top, you aggregate water,
- 14:14you have bulk water supply, and now you must
- 14:16distribute it to various municipalities and so
- 14:18on. So our problem now lies with distribution
- 14:21by municipalities. They will say, we didn't know
- 14:24what was going on, so you started measuring.
- 14:27Then you worked on bulk water that is now in
- 14:29process and being fixed. Now you've got distribution
- 14:32by municipalities, which is currently the big
- 14:34problem. And there are two interesting initiatives
- 14:37going on. The first one is to ring fence water,
- 14:41also electricity, but let's talk about water,
- 14:43to ring fence water activities inside municipalities
- 14:46as a separate utility, so that the money that
- 14:50comes in from water is put back into water, into
- 14:54maintenance, into infrastructure, into proper
- 14:56billing, that sort of thing. So this is what
- 14:59Will and Leila is now working on, is the ring
- 15:02fencing of water supply. Because previously that
- 15:05money has been used to pay other salaries. Absolutely.
- 15:09It went into the general income of a municipality
- 15:11and it was spent on general expenses. And we
- 15:14know that municipalities overspend on things
- 15:17like salaries, obviously patronage, that sort
- 15:20of thing. And this will help to curb that. The
- 15:23second change that is taking place, and I think
- 15:25it's a big one, again, it will take time, is
- 15:27to distinguish in a municipality between the
- 15:31constitutional obligations of a municipality
- 15:33to be a water service authority. What is a water
- 15:37service authority? They must make sure that the
- 15:40citizens in their area are serviced, that they
- 15:43are not overcharged, that the poor gets their
- 15:45proper share, and so on and so forth. But you
- 15:48separate those obligations from being a water
- 15:51service provider. The provider is the one that
- 15:54must lay the pipes, make sure they work, issue
- 15:57bills, collect the money, and so on. Do the actual
- 15:59work. Do the actual work. Now, in South Africa,
- 16:02the 250 -odd municipalities we have do both.
- 16:06They're the water service authority, but they're
- 16:08also a water service provider. There are only
- 16:11two exceptions to that. And the one is the Dolphin
- 16:13Coast, on the Dolphin Coast in KwaZulu -Natal.
- 16:16And the other one is in Mpumalanga. There, they've
- 16:20already separated the delivery of water from
- 16:23the responsibility for water. One is a political
- 16:26function, the other one is a management function.
- 16:28So the idea is to bring that across the whole
- 16:31country. Now, obviously, municipalities don't
- 16:33like this. Obviously, they will resist it. But
- 16:37obviously, they will have to come along. because
- 16:40there's a fiscal crisis developing around municipalities
- 16:43not paying for water. And again, it's quite clear
- 16:47in which way the direction is. And that's an
- 16:50important follow -up work that Wurundjela is
- 16:53doing now. Now, obviously, you can't tackle 250
- 16:56-odd municipalities simultaneously. So Wurundjela
- 16:59is now focusing on six of the country's eight
- 17:02metros to help them to get their water function
- 17:06re -established, ring -fenced with proper management
- 17:10and running it. It also, with the separation
- 17:13of water authorities and water providers, there's
- 17:17also a licensing regime that is brought in with
- 17:20standards that must be met by the provider. And
- 17:23if the provider doesn't meet those standards,
- 17:26the license can get cancelled and can be given
- 17:29to somebody else. So you can take the license
- 17:32away from a municipality as a water provider
- 17:35and give it to a private company or a not -for
- 17:38-profit NGO or a community -based organization.
- 17:41These changes are now possible. The Water Act
- 17:44is being amended to make that possible. Point
- 17:47number four on the Wollendlella list, freight
- 17:50transport, rail and ports. We hear quite a lot
- 17:53about that, but how far is the process? Let's
- 17:57separate railways from ports. Again, the organizing
- 18:00principle is that you want to bring in private
- 18:03companies on running certain railway lines, railway
- 18:06sectors, and also private companies to run ports.
- 18:10On the railway side, after a long period of delay
- 18:14and preparatory work that had to be done, you
- 18:17must remember, Ruda, we've had the government
- 18:19run rail services for the best part of 150 years.
- 18:24So you now have to change that whole system.
- 18:26And you have to take out the inherent conflicts
- 18:29of interest. You cannot expect a private sector
- 18:32to come in and run a particular railway line
- 18:35if they are not sufficiently protected and independent
- 18:38from transnet unfair competition. So you had
- 18:43to establish a railway regulator. You had to
- 18:45break transnet railways up between an asset manager
- 18:48and an operating company. These kinds of preparatory
- 18:53works take time. They require legislative changes,
- 18:56accounting changes and so on. But that has now
- 18:59progressed to the point where 11 sectors have
- 19:03been put up for bidding by the private sector.
- 19:05More than 50 companies applied. Some 25 were
- 19:09selected. And those 25 are now negotiating with
- 19:14Transnet, with the infrastructure manager. to
- 19:16lease these railway lines, what the conditions
- 19:19will be, who will take what responsibility, where
- 19:22the risk will lie and so on. And what will happen,
- 19:25which is busy happening, these companies interested
- 19:28in doing the business will either rent railway
- 19:32stock from Transnet or they will bring in new
- 19:36stock from overseas. Apparently a contract has
- 19:38been signed to bring rolling stock in from Australia.
- 19:42So the companies will bring their rolling stock,
- 19:44they will pay a fee, the fee will go into infrastructure
- 19:48investment, and that way you want to resuscitate
- 19:51the railway system. With that, a second tender
- 19:56has been put out by Transnet for railway sidings
- 19:59to be taken over by private operators, private
- 20:02people, to run the sidings. Now, you know, if
- 20:05you go through the country, we see a sorry sight
- 20:08of a lot of sidings that have been... just dilapidated
- 20:11and neglected. So it's an effort to turn that
- 20:13around. Because efficient sidings mean you can
- 20:16park trains, let other trains park, you can offload
- 20:20cargo. It makes for more flexibility in the system.
- 20:24That's why you have them in the first place.
- 20:26And the fact that they went to wreck and ruin
- 20:28actually undermines the operation of the entire
- 20:32system. How many little blocks that go into building
- 20:36this tower? And I think that's a very important
- 20:38point. It is not... You can't just do a big bang.
- 20:42It's not like just abolishing prices or abolishing
- 20:47exchange control. That's a big bang. You can
- 20:49do it one night, government gazette, done. Here
- 20:52you have to move a lot of small parts and bring
- 20:55them all aligned. And that's happening. So some
- 20:58people say it's happening too slow. That may
- 21:00be. But, you know, you must work with what you
- 21:04have. Just before we leave the railway lines,
- 21:06this is not part of Volendela, but Praza is also
- 21:10recording some interesting progress. And I think
- 21:13our listeners must just take note of that. In
- 21:15a future research piece, we may deal with that.
- 21:19So those are the railway lines. What's happening
- 21:21on ports is similar logic. Bring the private
- 21:24sector in. Now, the big one was Durban, Durban
- 21:27Pier 2. That's South Africa's largest harbour.
- 21:31Transnet has given a concession to a Philippine
- 21:34company to run it. Well, first there was a bidding
- 21:38process. It was given to a Philippine company,
- 21:41one of the biggest port operators in the world.
- 21:44One of the companies that lost, I think, a mask,
- 21:48then took the case to the High Court. And that's
- 21:50caused a two -year delay. Now, you know, in the
- 21:54ideal world, you don't want such a delay. quick
- 21:57decisions, if possible, no court decisions. But
- 22:01that's how it is. And we're now through it. The
- 22:04High Court has ruled in favor of Transnet. The
- 22:06Philippine company can now take control of Durban
- 22:09Harbor and do the investment and train the people.
- 22:13So that has already progressed. But then similar
- 22:16outsourcing tenders have been released for Richards
- 22:19Bay, for the Cougar Harbor in the Eastern Cape.
- 22:23And now also for some activities in the Cape
- 22:26Town Harbour for LNG facilities. We will have
- 22:29to import gas in the near future to supplement
- 22:32our energy supply. The more you do renewables,
- 22:35the more you need gas to even out the intermittency
- 22:41of renewables. But for that you need gas. And
- 22:45so we will build LNG terminals and bids for that
- 22:50has gone out. So you can see it's the same story.
- 22:53Open up where Transnet used to do everything.
- 22:55Open up, let private companies come in. They
- 22:58must bid competitively and they must bring capital.
- 23:01And I think this is important. Nothing is being
- 23:03privatized. It's the misconception that these
- 23:06things means privatization. What is privatization?
- 23:09It's a change in ownership. There's no change
- 23:12in ownership. Transnet remains the owner of the
- 23:15property. Think of it as a house that you own.
- 23:18You get a new tenant. The tenant comes in and
- 23:21fixes your house. He uses his money to fix your
- 23:23house. And then he still pays rent as well. I
- 23:27mean, how is that not a good deal for the homeowner?
- 23:30But it's also a good deal for the guy who wants
- 23:32accommodation and wants to, maybe a house is
- 23:35not the right example. Well, maybe he rents out
- 23:38the rooms to students. Maybe he rents out the
- 23:40rooms to students. Absolutely. So he can use
- 23:42it to make money. And that's what's happening
- 23:44here. And then the fifth one on the list, visas
- 23:48and skilled migration. Yeah, we all know about
- 23:52the progress that has been made there. The new
- 23:54Minister of Home Affairs has really rattled the
- 23:56cage. I think a lot of that is work that was
- 23:59done by his predecessor and he was happy, he
- 24:01was lucky enough to reap the rewards. I think
- 24:04one must say that. But the fact is it's happening
- 24:07and it's changing the way we're dealing with
- 24:10visas. It's changing the way in which we can
- 24:12accommodate tourists. The work is not completed
- 24:14yet. It will carry on. But the big thing, the
- 24:18big aim is to make it easier for skilled people
- 24:21to come here, make it easier for remote workers
- 24:23to come and work here and service their clients
- 24:27in the US or Europe or wherever. And the third
- 24:30one, of course, is tourism. And if we can get
- 24:32those things right, you can unlock a huge number
- 24:35of jobs and economic growth. So you summarize
- 24:38this actually under the heading from a developmental
- 24:41state to a partnership state. Yeah. And what
- 24:44my thinking was there, and you would notice there's
- 24:46a question mark because I think it's not definite,
- 24:50but my thinking is as follows. Since it has come
- 24:53into power, the ANC has worked with the concept
- 24:55of a developmental state. And they basically
- 24:58got it from Southeast Asia, from South Korea,
- 25:00Taiwan, and, of course, China, who are the prime
- 25:05examples of a developmental state. And the ANC
- 25:08tried to copy that here. I think it's safe to
- 25:11say that we know it didn't work. The idea of
- 25:14a developmental state is that you take an SOE,
- 25:16a government company, a government enterprise,
- 25:18and they must drive developmental work. How much
- 25:21developmental work has come out of ESCOM? How
- 25:24much has come out of Transnet? How much has come
- 25:26out of our water authorities? How much has come
- 25:29out of our very dysfunctional municipalities?
- 25:32So I think what we're seeing here is a collapse,
- 25:35if I may use that word, of the notion of a developmental
- 25:38state and a move over to a partnership state
- 25:41where you bring people into traditional state
- 25:44functions. You don't privatize, you concession
- 25:47and you liberalize. I think liberalize is a much
- 25:50better word than privatization. And they now
- 25:53coming, private sector players are now coming
- 25:55into areas where the state used to be. And to
- 25:58do that, they have to work together. They have
- 26:00to develop a common understanding of where's
- 26:02risk, where's reward. Who's taking responsibility
- 26:05for what? It is a coexistence. It's not a single
- 26:09existence. So I think politically speaking, what
- 26:13we're seeing is a move from developmental state
- 26:15to a partnership state. And that's a very new
- 26:18direction in our politics. We have a completely
- 26:21new dispensation since last year's election.
- 26:25Did that upset the apple cart? No, not at all.
- 26:29It reinforced the apple cart. The program that
- 26:34we've discussed in this podcast so far was started
- 26:37by the previous administration, the sixth administration.
- 26:39They launched Wallenlela. They launched the five
- 26:42areas. And that was basically the ANC. They had
- 26:44a majority. They were governing. Correct. And
- 26:48so they must get the credit for it and where
- 26:50people want to blame, they blame. The government
- 26:52of National Unity, first of all, endorsed that.
- 26:55The DA in particular was quite keen on Wollendlela.
- 26:59And the government of National Unity has now
- 27:01launched Wollendlela 2. What is Wollendlela 2?
- 27:04It is a continuation of the work that is not
- 27:07finished yet from Wollendlela 1, like water,
- 27:10for example, and electricity, the development
- 27:13of electricity market and so on. But the Government
- 27:16of National Unity has added three items to Wurundlela
- 27:19II. The first one is municipalities, local government.
- 27:22How you fix that, I don't know. That's going
- 27:24to be a very hard nut to crack. But it's there,
- 27:27it's the priority, and they've started working
- 27:29on that. The second one is what is called spatial
- 27:31inequality. The fact that we still have the legacy
- 27:35of group areas, and we have a lot of particularly
- 27:37working class people living very far away from
- 27:41the places of work, which is the opposite of
- 27:43what you find in a... normal city, if I can put
- 27:46it that way. So there are concrete things that
- 27:49can be done there. And most important is suburban
- 27:54transport. In other words, railway lines and
- 27:56bus lines. And in these, these things are part
- 27:59of the Villanueva program under the item of spatial
- 28:02inequality. Also release land where it's possible
- 28:06for access by poor people. And then the third
- 28:09one added by the government of national unity,
- 28:12is a transformation to a digital governance.
- 28:14And the idea is that every citizen must have
- 28:16a digital ID and all interactions with the government
- 28:20is via that digital portal. There are countries
- 28:23using that and the roadmap must now be developed
- 28:27for South Africa to do that. That's detailed.
- 28:30The point is those three areas. Local government.
- 28:34digital and spatial inequality have been added
- 28:37by the Government of National Unity to Wollonglela.
- 28:40Wollonglela is now housed in the presidency and
- 28:43a project team in the presidency is driving the
- 28:47implementation. Can this make a difference to
- 28:51our dismal growth rate? Well, that's the whole
- 28:54reason why we're doing it, is to try and improve
- 28:57growth and with that, jobs. And the Bureau for
- 29:00Economic Research at Stellenbosch released last
- 29:03year a very important research paper in which
- 29:07they modeled the impact of these changes that
- 29:11Willem Lela is striving for. And the impact is
- 29:14that over a period of two, three years, growth
- 29:17can move from 1 % now to 3 .5 % in two or three
- 29:22years' time. They have since updated their work
- 29:25and they're more or less sticking with that timeline.
- 29:29take a year or so longer. Trump's tariffs of
- 29:31course will cause a delay and other things may
- 29:36cause a delay but there's no doubt about it that
- 29:40the dividend will come through and that ties
- 29:42up with what we know. You look around the world
- 29:45when governments embark on structural reform
- 29:48you get a productivity improvement and then growth
- 29:51and a classic example is India. India for many,
- 29:55many years after independence had a very low
- 29:58growth rate, 1 % thereabouts. Then Mohammed Singh
- 30:02became Minister of Finance and India ran into
- 30:05a big foreign currency crisis and a budget crisis.
- 30:09And he said, well, we can't carry on like this.
- 30:11We've done it now for a couple of decades. And
- 30:14he launched big economic reforms. He then became
- 30:19Prime Minister, Mr. Singh, and carried on with
- 30:22the reforms. He passed away the other day. His
- 30:25government was replaced by the current Modi government.
- 30:28Modi is pursuing it further and India's growth
- 30:31rates now are spectacular. So I don't think India
- 30:34ever used the word Project Villain Leela. You
- 30:37know, that was not there. But it's the same kind
- 30:39of thing. You open up the economy. What was called
- 30:43a Raj economy was transformed by Mohammed Singh
- 30:46through structural reform. And that's what's
- 30:49happening here. in South Africa now. So yes,
- 30:52you look at India, you look at other countries,
- 30:54when you do structural reform, there's a productivity
- 30:56increase and there's a growth dividend. And that's
- 30:59the way I think this one will play out. In summary,
- 31:02so what? The key point about Volunt Leela is
- 31:05it's not another policy paper. It's about implementation.
- 31:08And there's a huge difference. So we've had,
- 31:12as I've said in the beginning, several policy
- 31:14papers. This one is about implementation, and
- 31:17we can see from the record that there are actual
- 31:20practical results coming out. So that's one.
- 31:24I think it's important for business people in
- 31:26particular to take note of what's happening with
- 31:28Will and Leila. The fact that in nine cities
- 31:32and towns across the country, very few people
- 31:34knew about it, I think is perturbing. And taking
- 31:38the trouble to understand more about what's happening.
- 31:41will be good for confidence. And let's face it,
- 31:44the smart money is already there. Those entrepreneurs
- 31:46who are tendering for railway lines, tendering
- 31:49for contracts in the harbors, in the ports, the
- 31:53people who are investing in 4G and 5G, the smart
- 31:56entrepreneurs are out there. Smart money is out
- 31:59there. Don't be left behind. I think the third
- 32:04so what, as you put it, there's lots of small
- 32:07pieces that must be put together. It's a journey.
- 32:10It's not a big bang. It's not a one -eyed stand,
- 32:14if I can put it that way. This is a long -term
- 32:15marriage that you have to work through. And we
- 32:19must have the patience with that. Then there's
- 32:21the point that I think we are moving from a developmental
- 32:24state to a partnership state. I really think
- 32:26that's in progress. Now, of course, the politicos
- 32:29will argue about this and so on. ANC stalwarts
- 32:33will say no no no the state must remain in control
- 32:35and on the other side right wingers will say
- 32:38everything must be privatized leave that aside
- 32:41for the big majority of people in the middle
- 32:44I think this shift from developmental to partnership
- 32:47is a shift that fits in with the mood in the
- 32:50country It fits in with the GNU. And I think
- 32:55that's the way the country is moving from developmental
- 32:57to partnership. Thank you very much. Most interesting.
- 33:01Thank you. Thank you for listening to the So
- 33:05What Podcast. If you enjoy this content, please
- 33:08don't forget to leave a review and a rating,
- 33:10and please consider subscribing so you don't
- 33:13miss any future episodes. Also, tell your friends.
- 33:17Remember, you can find a written version of all
- 33:19JP's content at jplandman .co .za.