Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Car Strategy: Buy City Car or Premium?
Transcript
- 0:09If you're looking at electric vehicles right now, you've
- 0:11probably seen this split happening in the market.
- 0:15It feels like two different worlds almost.
- 0:17Yeah, it really does. You've got these, you know,
- 0:19small agile city EVs, the urban Warriors, and then the big range
- 0:25feature heavy premium cars. Exactly 2 distinct philosophies.
- 0:29And look, our mission today is really to help you figure out
- 0:31which approach makes more sense for you.
- 0:34Is it better to go all in on maximum capability?
- 0:37Right. Buy the car that can do
- 0:38everything, even if you only need everything a few times a
- 0:41year. Or is the smarter play actually
- 0:44about flexibility? You know, buy the smaller
- 0:47cheaper City car and just rent the bigger one when you need
- 0:50that extra range or space that. Capability versus flexibility
- 0:53question, that's the core of it, isn't it?
- 0:55It's not about the best EV overall, but the right EV for
- 0:59your life. And what we found digging
- 1:01through the data is it pretty much boils down to one key
- 1:04thing. It is your usage, specifically
- 1:07how many miles or kilometers you actually drive per year.
- 1:11OK. Annual mileage makes sense.
- 1:13Yeah. We've looked at a whole load of
- 1:15sources, detailed financial models, some using those
- 1:18European metrics like kilometers per euro, but the principle
- 1:21holds everywhere. We looked at performance
- 1:23charging and really importantly, depreciation data.
- 1:27And you found a kind of tipping point.
- 1:29A very clear one, actually. The economics really flip around
- 1:32the 10,000 kilometer mark. That's roughly 6000 miles a
- 1:36year. OK, 6000 miles.
- 1:37That gives us a solid number to work with.
- 1:39So let's start with the City side, then the urban warrior.
- 1:42What makes a good city EV? What are the must haves?
- 1:46Well, three things really stand out.
- 1:48First, and this is non negotiable, it has to be compact
- 1:51parking, tight streets, congestion.
- 1:53You need something small. Makes total sense.
- 1:55What's #2. Quick acceleration, not
- 1:57necessarily top speed, but that instant torque E VS are known
- 2:01for. You need it to zip away from
- 2:02lights, merge safely. It's that immediate response
- 2:05that makes them great in town. OK, small size, quick off the
- 2:08line. And the third thing you
- 2:10mentioned charging optimization. Right.
- 2:12And this is where people sometimes get it wrong.
- 2:14They focus only on the maximum charge rate, the peak kilobou.
- 2:18But for a City car, the small battery itself is the advantage.
- 2:21Because it's smaller capacity. You can often do those really
- 2:25useful 20% to 80% charges incredibly quickly.
- 2:29Even if the peak rate isn't super high.
- 2:31Exactly, you might get that crucial top up maybe under 20
- 2:34minutes just because you're filling a smaller tank, so to
- 2:37speak. That's a great point focusing on
- 2:38the practical top up speed, not just the Max number.
- 2:41So like the Fiat 500 E that seems to fit this perfectly.
- 2:45It's a classic example. Tiny, super easy to park.
- 2:48The official EPA range is 149 miles and that 20 to 80 charge
- 2:5319 minutes. It nails the City car brief.
- 2:55OK, but 149 miles? Yeah, that brings us to the big
- 2:58caveat, right? The climate issue.
- 3:00Ah. Yes, the snowman in the driveway
- 3:02problem, as we call it, I. Kind of like that.
- 3:04Explain what you mean. It means you need to think about
- 3:06the absolute worst weather conditions you face because our
- 3:09sources consistently show extreme cold or extreme heat can
- 3:13slash your usable range by up to 40%. 40% Wow, that's huge for a
- 3:18smaller battery. It's massive.
- 3:20Suddenly that 100 and 49 mile Fiat might only give you, what,
- 3:24less than 90 miles on a really freezing or boiling day?
- 3:28You absolutely have to factor that in.
- 3:30So you need to calculate your worst case scenario need like if
- 3:33my winter commute is 50 miles round trip.
- 3:35Exactly, with a 40% hit you'd actually need a car with a
- 3:38stated range of around 85 miles just to cover that comfortably,
- 3:43never mind any extra stops. It's a critical stress test.
- 3:46OK, so it's less about the sticker range and more about
- 3:49that guaranteed minimum in your climate.
- 3:51Good point. What about city cars that offer
- 3:53maybe a bit more practicality but are still fairly compact?
- 3:56Yeah, there are some strong contenders.
- 3:58The Hyundai Cone Electric often gets mentioned.
- 4:00Starts under $33,000 roughly. It's big.
- 4:03Plus is cargo space. Really good for its size, Budget
- 4:06friendly practicality. OK, Kona and the Kia Nero EV bit
- 4:11more expensive, around $39,600, Yeah.
- 4:14And the Nero has a really interesting feature V2L vehicle
- 4:17to load. Where the car can power other
- 4:19things. Exactly.
- 4:20Laptops, tools, camping gear, you name it.
- 4:23It turns the car into a sort of mobile power bank.
- 4:26Adds a layer of utility you don't often see in this class.
- 4:28That's genuinely useful. And then of course there are
- 4:30cars that are compact but definitely premium, like the
- 4:33Volvo EX30. Right starts hire $46,000 plus.
- 4:37Small enough for the city but it's packing premium stuff.
- 4:40Performance version does 0 sixty in like 3.4 seconds.
- 4:44Wow. And fast charging to 2080% in 16
- 4:47minutes. So it's kind of a blend city
- 4:49size, but with some Road Warrior DNA.
- 4:51That speed is nice, but if we're talking premium tech, that
- 4:54really changes the game for long distance driving.
- 4:57The reason someone might pay premium for a road machine.
- 5:00We need to talk about 800 Volt architecture right?
- 5:02Like in the Genesis GV 60. Oh absolutely.
- 5:04The 800 Volt system versus the standard 400 Volt, it's a huge
- 5:08deal for people doing serious mileage.
- 5:10So it's not just double the voltage.
- 5:11What does it mean practically? Think of it like widening the
- 5:14pipe the electricity flows through means the car can accept
- 5:17energy much, much faster at those high power chargers.
- 5:20The GV 60, for instance, can go from 20% to 80% in about 11
- 5:24minutes. 11 minutes. Seriously.
- 5:26Seriously. And it manages heat better too,
- 5:29so it can often sustain that high charge rate for longer than
- 5:31a 400 Volt car might. That heat management is key.
- 5:35OK, 11 minutes, that barely a coffee break.
- 5:38That's not just convenience, that's fundamentally changing
- 5:41the road trip experience. Yeah, that feels like something
- 5:43worth paying extra for if you travel a lot.
- 5:45It absolutely is for the high mileage driver.
- 5:47It's about minimizing downtime and stress, and they also need
- 5:51the range itself, of course. Right cars like the Tesla Model
- 5:543 Long range, 358 miles, EPA. Where the Hyundai Ionix six 361
- 6:00miles, even the Mercedes EQS pushing up towards 450 miles.
- 6:04That kind of range just melts away anxiety on long.
- 6:07Hauls and the charging network itself matters too.
- 6:10Faster charging is great, but you need reliable stations.
- 6:13Access to something like the Tesla Supercharger network is a
- 6:16big part of that premium value. Prof.
- 6:18Definitely. Network reliability is crucial
- 6:21when you're doing long trips frequently.
- 6:22Saving even 15 minutes per charging stop adds up incredibly
- 6:26quickly over a year. It's time, it's reduced stress
- 6:29that justifies the cost for the right user.
- 6:31Which brings us right back to that financial threshold.
- 6:34When does paying for all that premium capability make sense,
- 6:37and when is it, well, overkill? It all comes back to the annual
- 6:42mileage. Let's look at scenario A low to
- 6:45moderate usage. OK, this is our city driver.
- 6:48Maybe 5006 thousand miles a year Max.
- 6:51Lots of short trips. Exactly up to about that 8000 to
- 6:5510,000 kilometers or 6000 mile mark for this group, the data is
- 7:00really clear. The City car Plus rental model
- 7:03wins financially. By the cheaper city EV, rent
- 7:07something bigger for the few long trips.
- 7:09Precisely, the numbers show the total annual cost, including
- 7:12those rentals lands somewhere around 5000 to 6.
- 7:15OK. And compared to owning the
- 7:17premium car outright? You could be saving 2000 and
- 7:20maybe even 3000 a year. That's significant, but hang on,
- 7:23what about the hassle factor of renting?
- 7:24You know, booking, picking up, dropping off, making sure the
- 7:27rentals charge, Does the saving really outweigh that friction?
- 7:30That's a fair question. The friction is real, but the
- 7:33financial gap is just so wide it tends to make the hassle
- 7:36worthwhile for many in this usage bracket.
- 7:38Where do those savings mainly come from?
- 7:40The biggest chunk is capital allocation.
- 7:42You're just not tying up say 40,000 dollars, 60,000 dollars,
- 7:45$80,000 in a car that sits parked most of the time or just
- 7:49does short hops. That money can work for you
- 7:50elsewhere. Right opportunity costs.
- 7:52Plus insurance is way cheaper, think 350 euro €450 for the Citi
- 7:56car versus maybe 800 to €1200 for the premium one.
- 8:00Lower maintenance too, and potentially some regional tax
- 8:04benefits depending on where you live.
- 8:05OK, strong case for the City car plus rental if you're under that
- 8:096000 mile threshold. So let's flip it.
- 8:11Scenario B High usage driving over say seven, 509,000 miles a
- 8:17year. Yeah, consistently over 12,000
- 8:20to 15,000 kilometers. For these drivers, the premium
- 8:23purchase starts to make solid financial and practical sense.
- 8:26Why? What's the justification?
- 8:282 main things. First, capability.
- 8:30If you're driving that much, you need the longer range, the extra
- 8:32comfort, and critically, those superfast charging stops.
- 8:36Those 11 to 18 minute turnarounds, they translate
- 8:38directly into hours saved over the year.
- 8:40It's a quality of life thing. OK.
- 8:42So you're actually using the capability you paid for
- 8:44regularly and the second justification?
- 8:47Long term value. When you spread that higher
- 8:49upfront cost over say 7 or 8 years of ownership and you
- 8:53factor in maybe permanent local incentives like tax exemptions
- 8:56that high mileage drivers benefit from constantly, the
- 8:59numbers start to balance out. And depreciation plays a role
- 9:02here too, right? You mentioned EVs hold value
- 9:04reasonably well. Generally yes, around 48% value
- 9:08retention after three years on average, which is better than
- 9:11many older petrol or diesel cars, but the premium medium EVs
- 9:15often do significantly better than that average.
- 9:18Like which ones? Well, the data showed the
- 9:19Polestar 2 losing only about 42% in three years, Tesla Model X
- 9:23around 43%. The real stand out was the
- 9:26Porsche Tican losing only 37%. OK. 37% loss on a Tican.
- 9:31It's still a lot of cash though, isn't it?
- 9:33I mean, compare that to losing maybe 57% on a much cheaper Citi
- 9:36car like a Smart EQ. Is that lower percentage loss
- 9:39really a compelling cushion given the huge initial price
- 9:41difference? That's a really important
- 9:43distinction for listeners to grasp.
- 9:45Yes, the absolute cash amount lost is higher on the expensive
- 9:48car, no doubt. But the rate of loss relative to
- 9:51what you paid initially is much lower for something like a
- 9:54Tican, 37% versus 57% for the Smart.
- 9:58So the premium card holds its value better proportionally.
- 10:02Exactly. It means that while you spent
- 10:04more upfront, you get a larger chunk of that back relative to
- 10:07the initial price when you sell or trade it in.
- 10:09For the high mileage driver who needs the capability anyway,
- 10:12this stronger resale value helps offset that initial investment.
- 10:15It acts as a better financial hedge over time, assuming you
- 10:18have the capital initially. Got it.
- 10:20So the high mileage user gets the needed features and better
- 10:23depreciation protection relative to the purchase price.
- 10:27Okay, this paints a pretty clear picture then.
- 10:29Yeah, I think the deep dive really confirms it.
- 10:31It's about matching the tool to the job.
- 10:34Your job, your driving pattern. So to summarize, driving less
- 10:38than around 10,000 kilometers or 6000 miles a year.
- 10:40Maximize flexibility. Go for the City car plus rental
- 10:43strategy. Save capital, lower running
- 10:46costs. Driving more than, say, 15,000
- 10:49kilometers or 9000 miles a year. The premium EV investment is
- 10:52likely justified. You're paying for capability
- 10:55you'll actually use frequently, plus better comfort, faster
- 10:58charging, and that stronger residual value.
- 11:00The bottom line seems to be don't pay a premium for battery
- 11:04range and features you simply won't use regularly.
- 11:07Be honest about your needs. Absolutely, but there's one
- 11:12final check everyone needs to do, especially if leaning
- 11:15towards the City car, which is circle back to that snowman in
- 11:18the driveway, that 40% potential range reduction in extreme
- 11:22weather. Before you commit, verify that
- 11:25even with that worst case hit, the car still meets your
- 11:28absolute minimum required range for essential trips.
- 11:31Use those online calculators that factor in temperature.
- 11:33Exactly double check that your chosen car, especially a smaller
- 11:36battery 1, won't leave you stranded or stressed on the
- 11:39coldest or hottest day of the year.
- 11:41It's crucial final sanity check. That is invaluable advice.
- 11:45A practical last step. Well, this has been fantastic,
- 11:49really breaking down the strategy and the financials
- 11:51behind choosing between a City EV and a premium one.
- 11:56Hopefully this gives you, the listener, a clear road map.
- 11:59Yeah, it's been great digging into the numbers and trying to
- 12:01build something genuinely useful.
- 12:02We really appreciate you joining us for this analysis.
- 12:05And if you did find this deep dive helpful, please do consider
- 12:09following the channel. We try to bring these kinds of
- 12:12curated knowledge shortcuts regularly.
- 12:14And, you know, we hear from some listeners that tuning into these
- 12:17discussions can also be a pretty good way to brush up on English,
- 12:20especially if it's not your first language, while getting
- 12:23informed. That's true.
- 12:25So multiple benefits perhaps. Again, thank you so much for
- 12:27your time and attention today. Thanks everyone.
- 12:30Until next time, drive safe and make informed choices.