Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Robinhood’s Transformation From Casino to SuperApp
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. It is Tuesday, February 10th,
- 0:032026. Hard to believe we are already
- 0:06what, almost through the first quarter of the year?
- 0:08It really is time just flies when the markets are moving this
- 0:11fast. It absolutely does.
- 0:13And today we are doing something a little bit.
- 0:16We are essentially stepping into a time machine.
- 0:20Well, not really, but we're dissecting a company that feels
- 0:23like it has gone through, I don't know, a decade of
- 0:25evolution in just a few short years.
- 0:27You're talking about Robin Hood. We are talking about Robin.
- 0:29Yeah, it has been quite the journey for them.
- 0:31I mean, if you look at the entire timeline of modern
- 0:35fintech Robin Hood's story, it's arc is probably the most
- 0:38dramatic one out there. Absolutely.
- 0:40From the, you know, the Sheriff of Nottingham accusations back
- 0:44during the meme stock era. Oh yeah, where they fit today.
- 0:46It's just it's night and day. Completely.
- 0:49And I think for a lot of people, that name Robin Hood still
- 0:52brings up those very specific, almost chaotic images from 2021.
- 0:57It does you think of GameStop, AMC, Dogecoin.
- 1:01The digital confetti falling on your screen when you made a
- 1:03trade. Exactly.
- 1:05It felt less like a sophisticated brokerage and, I
- 1:08don't know, more like a casino you could carry around in your
- 1:10pocket. Right, it was all about
- 1:11gamification. But looking at the stack of
- 1:14research on my desk today, the 10 KS the analyst notes, the
- 1:18deep value reports, that whole narrative, like entire story,
- 1:22just feels ancient. It does.
- 1:24It feels like a lifetime ago in financial years.
- 1:27The company we're looking at today bears almost no
- 1:30resemblance to that 2021 startup.
- 1:33I mean, the DNA is still there, sure, but the maturity level is
- 1:37it's a completely different Organism.
- 1:38Exactly. Because today, in early 2026, we
- 1:41are not looking at some scrappy startup fighting for its life or
- 1:44answering to Congress about gamification.
- 1:46We're looking at a profitable $77 billion fintech giant.
- 1:51But here's the tension. And this is really the core
- 1:53conflict we're going to unpack today.
- 1:55This is the big question. Is this new Robin Hood, the
- 1:57Apple of finance, you know, a tech platform that deserves a
- 2:00massive premium valuation because it is solve the user
- 2:03experience puzzle? Or is it just a cyclical
- 2:06brokerage in disguise that is, for now, renting A Moat through
- 2:11some pretty unsustainable subsidies?
- 2:13That is the multi billion dollar question, isn't it?
- 2:17And it's fascinating because the market itself seems really,
- 2:20really torn right now. How so?
- 2:22Well, you have growth investors on one side who see a super app
- 2:26that's going to dominate the next 20 years.
- 2:28And then on the other side, you have value investors who are
- 2:31just screaming that it's priced for perfection.
- 2:34Trading in multiples that make no sense for a financial stock.
- 2:37Exactly. They're looking at it saying
- 2:38this is a bank, why is it priced like a software company?
- 2:42And before we get into the weeds of the numbers, and we have some
- 2:44really wild numbers to cover today from the 20, 2025 earnings
- 2:48report to the death cross that just formed on the charts, I
- 2:52want to mention a tool. It can really help you track the
- 2:55temperature of the broader market if you're trying to
- 2:58understand valuations like the one we're discussing today.
- 3:01Or I just want a sense of whether the market is, you know,
- 3:03overheating. Which is always a good thing to
- 3:05know. It is.
- 3:07You should search for and download the iOS App Buffett
- 3:10Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 3:12It's a great resource, simple but very powerful.
- 3:15It really is. It gives you that 10,000 foot
- 3:17view of where the total market stands relative to GDP.
- 3:21You really can't analyze a stock like Robin Hood in a vacuum.
- 3:25You have to know if the tide is high or low.
- 3:27Context is everything, absolutely.
- 3:29OK, so let's set the scene today.
- 3:31Robin Hood stock ticker HOOD is trading right around $85.60.
- 3:38And it's been a rough couple of weeks for them, very volatile.
- 3:40It has. We've got some technical signals
- 3:42flashing red, which we will absolutely get to later in our
- 3:45deep dive. But the mission right now is to
- 3:47strip away the story, strip away the narrative, and just look at
- 3:49the cold, hard facts from the fiscal year 2025 earnings.
- 3:53And those facts, they tell a very, very specific story of of
- 3:57metamorphosis. Start right there.
- 3:59Section 1. The Metamorphosis, if you just
- 4:02look at a chart of their profitability, it looks like a
- 4:05hockey stick. It just goes straight up.
- 4:08But explain to me and to our listeners who might just see
- 4:11that headline, how real is this turn around?
- 4:14Because, you know, accounting can be creative sometimes.
- 4:17It's very real and to appreciate the magnitude, you really have
- 4:20to remember the hole they were crawling out of.
- 4:22In 2021, Robin Hood posted a net loss of $3.7 billion. 3.7
- 4:31billion, yeah, that is a staggering amount of money to
- 4:33lose. That's more than the GDP of some
- 4:36small countries. It was a black hole.
- 4:38They were bleeding cash. It was the absolute definition
- 4:40of growth at all costs, fueled by massive stock based
- 4:44compensation and just a chaotic market environment.
- 4:47Right. They were hiring thousands of
- 4:48support staff just to answer tickets about why people
- 4:50couldn't buy GameStop. Exactly.
- 4:52Now Fast forward to the fiscal year we just closed, 2025, they
- 4:55posted a net income of $1.9 billion.
- 4:58So that's what, a swing of over $5 billion to the bottom line.
- 5:03It's a 5 1/2 billion dollar swing.
- 5:06It's not just an improvement, it is a complete structural
- 5:09overhaul of the entire business model.
- 5:11That is massive, yeah. And the top line, the revenue
- 5:13that jumped too, right? Oh yeah.
- 5:15Total net revenue for 2025 hit 4 1/2 billion.
- 5:18That's up 52% year over year. 52%.
- 5:21And that's not small scale growth.
- 5:24That is massive scaling for a company this size.
- 5:27When you see 50% growth on a base of, you know, $3 billion,
- 5:31that tells you something fundamental has shifted in the
- 5:34demand for your product. OK, so I I have to play the
- 5:36skeptic here from you. They're making money hand over
- 5:38fist now, but how? I mean did everyone just start
- 5:41day trading five times as much? Did the meme frenzy come back
- 5:45and we all just missed it? No, because usually for a
- 5:48brokerage profit comes when people are over trading.
- 5:51And that's the key misunderstanding.
- 5:53If you think Robin Hood's profit comes from people trading
- 5:57Dogecoin, you're looking at the 2021 model, the pivot.
- 6:00The real genius here was toward net interest income, or Nii.
- 6:04That combined with just extreme cost discipline.
- 6:08Nii, let's define that for everyone, because it sounds like
- 6:12some sort of banker jargon, but it's actually the secret sauce
- 6:14here, isn't it? It is the secret sauce, but it's
- 6:17actually pretty simple. Nii is just the difference
- 6:20between the interest a company earns on its assets, like cash
- 6:24it holds at the Fed, and the interest it pays out to its
- 6:27customers on their deposits. So Robin Hood is sitting on
- 6:30billions and billions of dollars of user cash in their accounts.
- 6:34Exactly. And when interest rates are high
- 6:36like they have been, Robin Hood takes all that uninvested cash.
- 6:39They park it in safe government securities or overnight
- 6:41facilities, and they earn, let's say, 5%.
- 6:45And what do they pay the user? Well, they might pay the user
- 6:484%, maybe less, or in some cases nothing at all.
- 6:52If they aren't a gold member and they just they keep the
- 6:55difference, that spread is almost pure profit.
- 6:57So they basically became a bank. Essentially, yes.
- 6:59They diversified their revenue streams so now they aren't just
- 7:02making money when you click buy or sell, they are making money
- 7:0624/7 on the cash just sitting in your account, on margin loans,
- 7:10on securities lending. And that's where the cost
- 7:13discipline comes in. That's the other half of the
- 7:14equation. They managed to get their
- 7:17Adjusted EBITDA margins up to around 75%. 75% that.
- 7:22That's unheard of in traditional finance.
- 7:24That sounds like a software company margin.
- 7:26Exactly. Goldman Sachs or JP Morgan, they
- 7:28don't have margins like that. They can't.
- 7:31They have physical branches, thousands of employees, legacy
- 7:36mainframe computers from the 1980s, you know, layers and
- 7:40layers of middle management. Whereas Robin Hood is just code.
- 7:44Robin Hood is code. They are running incredibly
- 7:46lean. They replaced a lot of their
- 7:48support staff with AI chat bots. They automated compliance
- 7:51checks. They're operating with the
- 7:53efficiency of a sauce company, but they have the revenue model
- 7:56of the bank. It's a potent combination.
- 7:58So they've got the margins of a tech company and the revenue
- 8:01streams of a bank. I guess that explains the
- 8:03massive cash pile. I see the phrase fortress
- 8:05balance sheet here in our notes. Yeah, that's a term Jamie Dimon
- 8:08usually reserves for JP Morgan. But you know what?
- 8:10Robin Hood has kind of earned it.
- 8:11They are sitting on $5.4 billion in corporate cash. 5.4 billion.
- 8:17And here's the kicker, their debt to equity ratio is just
- 8:210.088. That's that is basically zero
- 8:25debt. For a company of this size, it
- 8:27is incredibly low. Most fintechs, most growth
- 8:29companies, they leverage up. They take on debt to fuel their
- 8:33expansion. But Robin Hood didn't.
- 8:34They didn't, and this matters so much because it gives them
- 8:38options. It gives them flexibility.
- 8:40When you have that much cash on hand and no debt service
- 8:42weighing you down, you can survive any market downturn.
- 8:46You can weather a crypto winter where trading volumes just dry
- 8:50up. But more importantly.
- 8:51More importantly, you can fund incredibly aggressive incentives
- 8:55to go out and steal customers from your competitors.
- 8:57Steal is a strong word, but in finance it really is a 0 sum
- 9:01game isn't it? If I move my account to Robin
- 9:03Hood, Charles Schwab loses an account.
- 9:05It's a war for assets and right now cash is the ammunition
- 9:09we're. Definitely going to talk about
- 9:10those incentives or bribes, as the bears might call them in a
- 9:14little bit. But I want to touch on the users
- 9:16first. Back in the day, the big knock
- 9:18on Robin Hood was that it was just kids with, you know, $50
- 9:23accounts trying to get rich quick on meme stocks, right?
- 9:27Has that actually changed or is that just marketing spin from
- 9:30the company? The data says it has changed and
- 9:33changed drastically. We really need to stop looking
- 9:36at just active users, which can be a vanity metric, and start
- 9:40looking at wallet share. OK.
- 9:42So what's the key metric there? The metric to watch is ARPU,
- 9:46average revenue per user. In 2021, at the peak of the
- 9:50mania, that number was around $65. 65 OK.
- 9:54In the fourth quarter of 2025, it hit 191 dollars.
- 9:58Wow. OK, so the users they have today
- 10:00are nearly three times more valuable than the users they had
- 10:02back then. Exactly.
- 10:03And the average account size is now around $12,000.
- 10:07That's up from 4000. Now, 12 grand might not sound
- 10:10like a lot compared to a private banking client at Morgan
- 10:13Stanley, but for a mass market retail brokerage, that is a
- 10:17very, very healthy number. It shows they're shedding those
- 10:21tiny inactive accounts. In fact, in 2025 they went
- 10:26through a process called a sheet meant.
- 10:28A sheet meant That sounds like a medieval torture device.
- 10:30Yeah. What is that in plain English?
- 10:32It's a regulatory term. Basically, if an account sits
- 10:36dormant for a certain number of years, usually three to five,
- 10:39the state can claim it as abandoned property.
- 10:42So. Robin Hood just hands over the
- 10:44account. They turned over about 460,000
- 10:47inactive low balance accounts to various state governments.
- 10:50That's a lot of users. To lose half a million people,
- 10:53the headline must have looked terrible.
- 10:55The headline number looks bad, yeah, losing half a million
- 10:57users. But strategically it was
- 10:59brilliant. It was pruning the dead weight.
- 11:01How so? Think about it.
- 11:03A user with $5 in their account who hasn't logged in since the
- 11:07Dogecoin crash of 2021 still cost you money.
- 11:10You have to pay for server space for compliance checks, you have
- 11:13to send them tax documents. You have to handle support
- 11:16tickets if they ever do login. They're a cost center, not a
- 11:19profit center. Exactly.
- 11:21By is sheeting those accounts, they just cleaned up the entire
- 11:24user base. They got rid of the liabilities.
- 11:26Now they can focus on the people who are actually bringing in six
- 11:29or seven figures. So they're actively trading
- 11:31quantity for quality. Precisely.
- 11:33And it's working. They're successful, successfully
- 11:35attracting serious money. Now this isn't just for play
- 11:37money anymore. For a growing number of people,
- 11:40it's becoming their primary financial home.
- 11:43The person who opened an account to buy one share of AMC is now
- 11:46using Robin Hood for their IRA, their credit card and their high
- 11:50yield savings. OK, so that's the financial
- 11:52foundation. They're profitable, they are
- 11:54cash rich, and their users are richer.
- 11:57Now let's get into the bulk case.
- 11:59This is the argument that Robin Hood isn't just a better
- 12:01brokerage, it's becoming the Apple of finance.
- 12:04This is the Super app thesis. The whole idea is that you have
- 12:07one single app on your phone for everything.
- 12:11Banking, trading, crypto, spending, retirement, you name
- 12:14it. And the engine driving all of
- 12:16this is their subscription model, Robin Hood Gold.
- 12:19I see they have 4.2 million members on gold now that's a
- 12:23that's a lot of recurring revenue.
- 12:24It is, and think about what that means.
- 12:26These are people paying a monthly fee just to be part of
- 12:29the ecosystem that creates recurring revenue, which Wall
- 12:33Street absolutely loves because it's predictable.
- 12:35Unlike trading fees. Exactly.
- 12:38Trading fees go up and down with market volatility.
- 12:41Subscription fees are steady. If the market crashes tomorrow,
- 12:44those 4.2 million people are very likely still going to pay
- 12:48their subscription fee next month.
- 12:50But the real genius, or the real danger, depending on your point
- 12:54of view, is how sticky they've made it.
- 12:56That's the key, the sticky factor.
- 12:58So what keeps people paying that subscription?
- 13:01Why don't they just leave and go to Fidelity or Vanguard where
- 13:04there are no monthly fees for basic accounts?
- 13:06There are two main anchors holding people in right now.
- 13:09First, the Gold card. They have 3,000,000 active users
- 13:13on their credit card. The one with the metal design.
- 13:14That's the one and it's really disrupting the industry because
- 13:17it offers a flat rate cash back 3% across the board in some
- 13:21categories. That is just it's very, very
- 13:23hard for traditional banks like Chase or Amex to compete with
- 13:28without destroying their own margins.
- 13:30Everyone loves flat rate cash back.
- 13:32It's simple. You don't have to think about
- 13:34calculating points or these rotating categories like gas
- 13:38stations in July or drug stores in October.
- 13:41It is simple and simplicity is Robin Hood's entire brand.
- 13:45But the second factor, Yeah, this is the real golden
- 13:48handcuffs, the retirement match. Yes, the famous 3% match.
- 13:54This has been all over their ads.
- 13:56It has. So if you transfer your IRA,
- 13:58your individual retirement count to Robin Hood and you're a gold
- 14:01member, they give you a 3% match on that money.
- 14:04But, and this is a big crucial bet, there's a catch.
- 14:07You have to keep the money there for five years.
- 14:09Five years, so if I move $100,000 over they just give me
- 14:12$3000 for free, but I'm essentially locked in for half a
- 14:15decade. Essentially, yes.
- 14:17It's a brilliant retention tool. It's why their assets under
- 14:20custody or AUC just hit $324 billion.
- 14:24Wow. They are literally paying people
- 14:26to bring their life savings over.
- 14:28And think about the friction involved.
- 14:30Moving a retirement account is a headache.
- 14:31There's paperwork, transfer fees, waiting periods.
- 14:34It's a. It's a huge pain.
- 14:37Once that money is there and you've got that 3% bonus
- 14:40vesting, you are not going to move it out again for a small
- 14:43reason. It creates incredible
- 14:45stickiness. It transforms A transactional
- 14:48relationship into a long term marriage.
- 14:50So they're locking people in, but they're also launching new
- 14:53stuff constantly. I feel like every week I see a
- 14:57headline about a new Robin Hood feature.
- 14:59Is this just feature creep or is there a real strategy here?
- 15:02It's product velocity and it's a huge part of the bull case.
- 15:06They are strategically trying to shed that image that they're
- 15:09only for newbies. They launched Robin Hood Legend,
- 15:12for example, which is a high-powered desktop platform.
- 15:15The desktop users have been begging for that for years.
- 15:18Yeah, I mean, the mobile app is great for checking a price, but
- 15:21if you're doing serious technical analysis, you need a
- 15:23keyboard and mouse. You need screen real estate.
- 15:25Of course, serious traders want multiple screens.
- 15:28They want dense charts. They want data.
- 15:30Robin Hood Legend gives them that, and it stops the advanced
- 15:33traders from graduating to a platform like Interactive
- 15:35Brokers or Thingja Swim. So they used to lose their best
- 15:38customers once those customers got too good for the app.
- 15:41Exactly. Now they have a place for them
- 15:43to stay. And then there's Cortex, their
- 15:46AI research assistant. Is that actually useful or is it
- 15:49just another gimmick? I feel like everyone is just
- 15:52slapping AI on their product and calling it a revolution.
- 15:55Here's your AI toaster. It's a fair skepticism, but from
- 15:58what I've seen, Cortex is designed to democratize the kind
- 16:02of analysis that hedge funds have been using for years.
- 16:05It's not just buy the sell that, it's more like summarize the
- 16:09sentiment on the stock from the last 50 news articles or find me
- 16:13companies with this specific growth profile file and low
- 16:16debt. So it keeps users on the
- 16:17platform. That's the goal.
- 16:19If you have to leave the Robin Hood app to go to Google or
- 16:21Yahoo Finance, they lose your attention.
- 16:23Cortex is designed to keep the entire research workflow inside
- 16:27their walled garden. And then there are the
- 16:29prediction markets. I've been seeing a lot about
- 16:31this, the partnership with Calci, right?
- 16:33Yes, this is fascinating. In 2025, Robin Hood users traded
- 16:378.5 billion event contracts. 8.5 billion that's that's wild.
- 16:45It is massive volume and you have to remember prediction
- 16:48markets are uncorrelated with the stock market.
- 16:50You can bet on election outcomes, sports results,
- 16:53economic indicators. So even if the S&P 500 is flat
- 16:57or crashing, people will still want to bet on who wins the
- 17:00Super Bowl or what the feds next move is.
- 17:02Precisely, It opens up a completely new revenue stream
- 17:05that doesn't care if we're in a bull or bear market for stocks.
- 17:09It's almost recession proof entertainment and it's another
- 17:11reason to open the app everyday. OK.
- 17:13So they have the subscription model, the retirement lock in
- 17:16the pro level tools and now these betting markets.
- 17:19If you look at this through the lens of a growth investor like a
- 17:22Peter Lynch or a Stan Druckenmiller type, how do they
- 17:26see Hood? They classify it as a classic
- 17:29fast grower and the key metric they'd point to is the PEG ratio
- 17:32price earnings to growth, which is under one point O.
- 17:35Let's pause on the PEG ratio for a second to find that for us.
- 17:38Sure. The PE ratio price to earnings
- 17:40tells you how expensive a stock is relative to its current
- 17:43earnings, but that doesn't account for how fast those
- 17:45earnings are growing. So a company with a high PE
- 17:48might actually be cheap if its earnings are doubling every
- 17:51year. Exactly.
- 17:53The PEG ratio divides the PE by the earnings growth rate, and
- 17:56typically anything under one point O is considered cheap for
- 18:00a growth stock. It means the growth rate is
- 18:03actually outpacing the premium you're paying for the stock.
- 18:06So despite the stock price going up so much, the underlying
- 18:09growth is rising even faster. Correct.
- 18:12And they have this massive demographic tailwind behind
- 18:15them, the great wealth transfer. We hear this term a lot.
- 18:18Break it down. Trillions of dollars are set to
- 18:20move from the baby boomer generation to millennials and
- 18:23Gen. Z over the next decade as
- 18:25inheritances are paid out. And guess who the number one
- 18:28brokerage choices for Gen. Z and Millennials?
- 18:31Robin Hood. It's Robin Hood by a landslide.
- 18:34So the bull case logic is you don't even need to acquire new
- 18:37customers, you just need to wait for your existing customers to
- 18:40inherit money. They're sitting in the front row
- 18:43for the biggest movement of capital in modern history.
- 18:45That's the thesis. When Grandma leaves her
- 18:48portfolio to her grandson, he isn't going to keep it at the
- 18:51dusty old bank she used. He's going to move it to the app
- 18:54he already uses everyday. Plus, they're going global now.
- 18:57Right. The Bit STEM acquisition, the
- 18:59expansion into the UK and the EU, over 15% of their revenue is
- 19:03now international. Their stated goal is 50%.
- 19:07So the growth story is pretty clear.
- 19:10We have the young people, we have the best tech and we're
- 19:13taking this model to the rest of the world.
- 19:15It sounds perfect. It sounds like a slam dunk.
- 19:18Why wouldn't everyone just buy this stock at $85?
- 19:20Well, hold your horses, because now we have to flip the coin and
- 19:24look at the bear case, and the bears have some very, very sharp
- 19:28claws. OK, so let's play devil's
- 19:29advocate. If it's growing this fast, if
- 19:30everything looks this good, why the hesitation?
- 19:34What's the problem? One word valuation.
- 19:37But you just said the PEG ratio is good.
- 19:39The PEG ratio is good if you believe that 50% growth will
- 19:42last forever. But if you look at a different
- 19:44metric, the price to book ratio, it's sitting at roughly 9 point
- 19:48O. 9 times book value. OK.
- 19:51For context, what do traditional banks and brokerages trade at?
- 19:55Charles Schwab, JP Morgan, Morgan Stanley.
- 20:00They usually trade at one to two times book value, maybe three
- 20:03times if they're really crushing it and growing fast.
- 20:05So Robin Hood is trading at four or five times the valuation of
- 20:08its more established peers. Correct.
- 20:10The market is pricing H hood like it's a software monopoly,
- 20:14like a fails force or a Microsoft, not like a financial
- 20:18firm. And the Bears would argue.
- 20:19The bears argue that money is a commodity.
- 20:21A dollar at Robin Hood is the same as a dollar at Fidelity.
- 20:25You shouldn't be paying a nine times premium for a checking
- 20:27account just because the app has a nicer user interface.
- 20:30If that growth slows down even a little bit, that multiple of 9
- 20:34has a long, long way to fall. That brings us to this rent a
- 20:37mote theory. I love this phrase, but it's
- 20:40also, it's kind of damning. It's the most critical analysis
- 20:43of their whole strategy. We talked about that 3% IRA
- 20:46match as a brilliant retention tool from the bull perspective,
- 20:49right? The bears look at that exact
- 20:51same thing and say that's not a brand advantage, that's a bribe.
- 20:54Meaning people are only there because you are actively paying
- 20:58them to be. There exactly.
- 20:59There's a great quote from one of the bear analyst reports.
- 21:02Mercenary capital moves for the highest bidder.
- 21:06That's good. It is.
- 21:07The question is if Robin Hood stocks paying that 3% match or
- 21:12if a competitor like Weeble or Sofi comes out and offers 3.5%,
- 21:16do those customers stay loyal to the Robin Hood brand or do they
- 21:20leave? If they leave for an extra half
- 21:22a percent then you never really had a Moat in the 1st place, you
- 21:26were just renting those customers with your shareholders
- 21:28capital. Precisely.
- 21:29You are buying loyalty, not earning it, and that gets very
- 21:32expensive very fast. It forces you into a race to the
- 21:35bottom where you have to keep spending more and more just to
- 21:38stand still. That is a scary thought because
- 21:41of the loyalty is purely transactional.
- 21:44Then those amazing 75% margins we celebrated earlier might just
- 21:48be temporary. And that links directly to the
- 21:50Goldilocks earnings risk. We mentioned that a huge chunk
- 21:54of their profit now comes from net interest income, interest on
- 21:57customer cash. Right now, interest rates are
- 22:00around 3 1/2 to 3.75%. That's a perfect Goldilocks zone
- 22:05for them. It's high enough to make really
- 22:07good money on cash, but not so high that it crashes the
- 22:10economy. But the Fed is always a wild
- 22:12card. Always, if the economy slows
- 22:15down and the Fed has to cut rates significantly, say back
- 22:18down to 2% or even 1%, that free money profit from Nii.
- 22:23Just just it evaporates. And it falls straight off the
- 22:27bottom. Line immediately and if your
- 22:29earnings drop because rates drop, that PE multiple of 36
- 22:32could skyrocket or the stock price could crash to adjust.
- 22:36They are incredibly sensitive to macro factors that are
- 22:40completely outside of their control.
- 22:42They are effectively a big bet on interest rates staying
- 22:44relatively high and. Then there's the governance
- 22:46stuff. This always seems to pop up with
- 22:48these big tech founder companies.
- 22:50It does. For one, they have a dual class
- 22:52share structure, which means it means some shares have more
- 22:55voting power than others. The founders, Vlad Tenev and
- 22:59Baiju Pot, they control the vote.
- 23:02As a common shareholder, you're just along for the ride.
- 23:04You don't really have a say in major corporate decisions.
- 23:07If you don't like the direction the company is going, your only
- 23:10real option is to sell your shares.
- 23:12And Speaking of selling, the insiders themselves are getting
- 23:17out. That's a Mazer concern for the
- 23:19bears. The Co founder by UPOT has sold
- 23:2398% of his holdings. 98% that's practically a full exit.
- 23:28It is, and the CEO, Vlad Tenev and other executives have been
- 23:32consistently selling under what are called 10B51 plans.
- 23:35OK, explain A10B51 plan so we're all clear on what that is.
- 23:39It's basically a prearranged plan to sell stock.
- 23:41It's a legal way for insiders to sell shares without being
- 23:44accused of trading on nonpublic information.
- 23:47They set it up months in advance saying I will sell X number of
- 23:50shares On this date. Now, to be fair, founders sell
- 23:53stock all the time to diversify their wealth.
- 23:56It's normal. It is normal they can't buy a
- 23:58house with stock certificates but when you see that level of
- 24:01selling 98% from a Co founder combined with a nine times book
- 24:05value valuation it makes investors very nervous.
- 24:10It begs the question, if they really believe the stock is
- 24:13going to $200 a share, why are they selling so much at 85?
- 24:18It is a very valid question. If the captain of the ship is
- 24:21quietly lowering the lifeboats, you start to worry about the
- 24:24voyage, even if the band is still playing on deck.
- 24:27And on top of that, there's the issue of stock based
- 24:29compensation or SBC. Right.
- 24:32To attract top engineering and product talent, they pay a lot
- 24:35of it in stock. That creates dilution.
- 24:37They're constantly issuing new shares which makes every
- 24:40existing share you own worth a trainee bit less.
- 24:43But they have a buyback program, don't they?
- 24:45I thought I saw something about a billion dollars.
- 24:47They do, but the Bears argue that the buyback is just
- 24:50treading water. They're basically buying back
- 24:52stock just to offset the new stock they're printing to pay
- 24:55their employees. It isn't actually reducing the
- 24:57overall share count as much as you'd hope.
- 24:59So it's just stopping the dilution from getting worse.
- 25:02It's like running in place on an escalator that's going down.
- 25:06You're working hard just to stay where you are.
- 25:08OK, so the bull says future of finance and the bear says
- 25:12overvalued casino that's renting its customers.
- 25:15Let's look at what they're doing to try and fix that.
- 25:17Casino image Section 4, the pivot to institutional and
- 25:21global markets. This is their big attempt to
- 25:24escape the retail trap. They know they can't just rely
- 25:28on individual day traders forever.
- 25:30Their stated goal is to have 50% of their business come from
- 25:34institutions. That seems ambitious for an app
- 25:37that started with a wait list for college kids.
- 25:39How are they even going to do that?
- 25:40Bitstamp was the big move here, the acquisition of Bitstamp.
- 25:43The crypto exchange, right? Yes, but this wasn't just about
- 25:46buying an exchange to get more coins listed on their platform.
- 25:49This was about buying infrastructure, licenses and
- 25:52relationships. Bitstamp has deep institutional
- 25:55roots in Europe. How deep?
- 25:57In the third quarter of 2025 alone, Bitstamp did $48 billion
- 26:03in crypto volume. 48 billion, OK, that is serious volume.
- 26:07That's not just retail traders buying $50.00 of Bitcoin.
- 26:11No, that is institutional flow. That's hedge funds, family
- 26:14offices, large crypto funds, and allows Robin Hood to serve that
- 26:19market. It helps them move away from the
- 26:21volatility of meme coins like DOGE and Shiba Inu towards
- 26:25structural 24/7 crypto revenue. That happens regardless of
- 26:29whether a meme is trending on Twitter.
- 26:31So it makes the revenue quality higher, more predictable.
- 26:34Exactly. And then what about trade PMR?
- 26:37I saw that acquisition mentioned.
- 26:39It's the other side of the coin. Trade PMR is a custodian for
- 26:42registered investment advisors, Rias.
- 26:45Financial advisors, exactly. Look, most really wealthy
- 26:48people, people with five million, $10 million, they often
- 26:51want a human to help manage their money.
- 26:53They aren't sitting around picking stocks on their phone
- 26:55while they're waiting for a coffee.
- 26:57By buying a trade PMR, Robin Hood is basically saying to
- 26:59those advisors, hey we can provide the back end technology
- 27:03and custody for your clients. It allows them to touch the
- 27:07money of older, wealthier clients who would probably never
- 27:10download the Robin Hood app themselves.
- 27:13That's smart. It's like a back door into the
- 27:15high net worth market. It's a huge maturity play.
- 27:18It diversifies them away from the fickle retail trader.
- 27:22And Speaking of maturity, they've largely cleaned up their
- 27:24regulatory headaches. They finally settled with the
- 27:27SEC regarding their legacy crypto operations so that.
- 27:30Wells notice overhang is gone now.
- 27:32It is, and that removes a huge cloud of uncertainty that was is
- 27:36hanging over the stock. Plus they're now piloting
- 27:39tokenization in the EU stock tokens.
- 27:41Stock tokens. So like a crypto token that
- 27:44represents a share of Apple stock?
- 27:45Exactly. It allows for a 24/7 trading and
- 27:48instant settlement on the blockchain.
- 27:50It's really the future of market structure and they're testing it
- 27:52out in Europe where the regulations are a bit friendlier
- 27:55right now. It positions them as a
- 27:57technology leader, not just another brokerage.
- 28:00They're helping build the rails of the next generation of
- 28:02finance. OK.
- 28:03So fundamentally, it seems like they're making all the right
- 28:06move to mature the business. But we have to talk about the
- 28:10chart Section 5 technical analysis, because right now the
- 28:14chart it looks a bit. Ugly.
- 28:16It's a battleground, no doubt about it.
- 28:18If you're a trader. Just looking at the charts, the
- 28:20trend right now is clearly bearish.
- 28:23The price is trading below both the 50 day and the 200 day
- 28:26moving averages. And we mentioned the Death Cross
- 28:28earlier, just like a heavy metal band, but what does it actually
- 28:32mean for the stock? It's a well known technical
- 28:34pattern. It happens when when the short
- 28:36term average, the 50 day moving average, crosses below the long
- 28:40term average, the 200 day moving average, it signals that the
- 28:43momentum has shifted downward and that the long term uptrend
- 28:46might be breaking. Is it reliable or is it just,
- 28:50you know, astrology for traders? Well, it works because people
- 28:53believe it works. It's a signal that trading
- 28:56algorithms and institutional traders watch very closely, so
- 28:59it often becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 29:02When the algos see a death cross, they sell, which pushes
- 29:05the price down even further. It usually means there's more
- 29:07selling pressure ahead. But at the same time, looking at
- 29:10the RSI, the relative strength index, it's at 14.
- 29:13Which is extremely low. The RSI measures the speed and
- 29:17change of price movements. Anything below 30 is generally
- 29:21considered oversold. An RSI down at 14 implies that
- 29:24there's been some panic selling. It means the selling has been so
- 29:27intense and so fast that it might be overdone.
- 29:30So is this a huge buying opportunity or is it a don't try
- 29:34to catch a falling knife situation?
- 29:36That is the $1,000,000 question, isn't it?
- 29:38An RSI of 14 often triggers a bounce, a dead cat bounce, or at
- 29:42least a short term snapback. If you believe the fundamental
- 29:45thesis that this is $100 billion company in the making, then this
- 29:49could be a generational. Entry point You're buying when
- 29:52there's blood in the streets. The technicals are screaming
- 29:54fear, and value investors often like to buy fear.
- 29:58As Warren Buffett famously says, Be greedy when others are
- 30:01fearful. So who is buying these this fear
- 30:04right now? Arc Invest Kathy Wood Her funds
- 30:08bought about $36 million worth of the stock just recently.
- 30:11She's famously a buyer of the dip on her high conviction
- 30:15names. She loves her disruption place.
- 30:16She certainly does. And don't forget, another huge
- 30:20technical factor is that Robin Hood was included in the S&P 500
- 30:23index back in September of 2025. Right, I forgot about that.
- 30:27That's a big deal. It's huge because it forces all
- 30:30the passive index funds to hold the stock.
- 30:32Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street.
- 30:35If they run an S&P 500 fund, they have to buy Robin Hood to
- 30:38match the index. That creates a permanent floor
- 30:41of demand that just didn't exist a few years.
- 30:44Ago, it stabilizes the shareholder base.
- 30:46It does. It means Robin Hood is no longer
- 30:48just a speculative asset held by individuals.
- 30:51It's a core part of the retirement portfolios of
- 30:53millions of Americans, whether they know it or not.
- 30:56And what about the sentiment on the street, or rather on the
- 30:59Internet forums? It's really shifted if you go to
- 31:02Reddit now on the investing forums it's less about Yolo
- 31:05calls and rocket emojis and to the moon, it's more about yield
- 31:10harvesting. Yield harvesting.
- 31:11People are discussing the APY on their cash, the best strategies
- 31:14for the IRA match. It's more boring, but for a
- 31:17company trying to be a bank, boring is good.
- 31:20Boring is stable. Boring is good.
- 31:23I never thought I'd hear that said about Robin Hood.
- 31:26OK, So let's wrap this all up. Section 6.
- 31:30The verdict. Advocate versus avoid.
- 31:33Let's synthesize this, put it all together.
- 31:35OK the advocate stance why do I buy this stock today at 85
- 31:40bucks? You buy this if you believe in
- 31:42that super app vision. You look at the growth metrics,
- 31:44revenue up 52%, EPS positive, ARPU tripling.
- 31:49You look at that $5.4 billion cash pile protecting the
- 31:53downside, you see a company that is capturing the next generation
- 31:57of wealth. If you run a discounted cash
- 31:59flow analysis with even decent growth assumptions, you can get
- 32:02a target price right around $90.00.
- 32:04So at 85 it's pretty much fair value for a great company with
- 32:08massive upside if they execute. Exactly.
- 32:10You're betting on the management team to continue this incredible
- 32:13pivot they've built off. And now the other side, the
- 32:16avoid stance. Why do I stay away?
- 32:18You avoid if you are a strict value investor.
- 32:20You look at 9 times book value and you just say there's
- 32:23absolutely no margin of safety here.
- 32:25You are paying for perfection. So if anything goes wrong.
- 32:27If growth slows, if a new regulation hits, if the Fed cuts
- 32:31rates and their Nii drops, this stock could get cut in half and
- 32:35still not be cheap by traditional metrics.
- 32:38You argue that a brokerage is a commodity business and it
- 32:41shouldn't trade like a tech monopoly.
- 32:43You wait for a much lower price, maybe around 40 or $50, where
- 32:46the valuation starts to make sense as a financial firm, not a
- 32:50software firm. So it really, really depends on
- 32:52what lens you're wearing when you look at.
- 32:54It it absolutely does. My final thought on it is this
- 32:58Robin Hood has graduated. It went from being the bad boy
- 33:00of finance to a very promising professional, but the current
- 33:04price tag assumes they've already won the championship.
- 33:07What's the one thing you were watching most closely?
- 33:10The key metric. The churn rate on gold members
- 33:14specifically, if they ever reduce that 3% IRA match or if
- 33:18the market turns and that free money from high interest rates
- 33:21dries up, do the users stay? That is the true test of the
- 33:24business. Is it a community or is it just
- 33:27a transaction? That's the key question.
- 33:29Is it a cult or is it a coupon? Exactly.
- 33:31If it's a cult, the stock is probably cheap right now.
- 33:33If it's just a coupon, the stock is probably very expensive.
- 33:37Well said. Well, here is my final
- 33:39provocative thought to leave you with As AI, like their new
- 33:42Cortex tool, takes over more and more trading and research
- 33:46decisions, does the individual investor eventually become
- 33:49obsolete on their own platform? Are we moving toward a future
- 33:54where Robin Hood is the traitor and the user is just a capital
- 33:57source? If the AI is doing all the
- 34:00thinking, does it even matter if the interface is fun to use
- 34:03anymore? That is a deep philosophical
- 34:05question for the future of all of Fintech.
- 34:07It changes the whole relationship between the user
- 34:10and the app, from being active participant to more of a passive
- 34:13limited partner. It really challenges the very
- 34:16mission of democratizing finance if the machine is the one doing
- 34:19all the work. Something to Mull over.
- 34:22Just a reminder for everyone listening.
- 34:25Full deep value research reports can be found in the description
- 34:28links. All the analysis we discussed is
- 34:30based on publicly available sources and may be subject to
- 34:33revisions or differing interpretations.
- 34:35This content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 34:38constitute investment advice. Always, always conduct your own
- 34:42due diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 34:45If you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 34:48or access more advanced contents, you are welcome to
- 34:51join the Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to us on
- 34:54Deep values dot AI. And don't forget to like this
- 34:57video. It is much appreciated.
- 34:58Thanks for listening and we will see you in the next deep dive.
- 35:01Goodbye everyone.