Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Bill Ackman's Bet on Old Tech Giants Explained
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine, like, the stock market is just completely melting up,
- 0:02right? Everyone is throwing billions at
- 0:05the newest, flashiest artificial intelligence startups.
- 0:08Oh yeah. The entire financial world is
- 0:10basically obsessed with, you know, next Gen. semiconductors,
- 0:14chip designers getting any piece of the AI revolution.
- 0:17Exactly. And in the middle of this
- 0:19absolute frenzy, one of the world's most famous top tier
- 0:22billionaire investors decides his absolute best move is to
- 0:26place these massive bets on, get this, a recently bankrupt rental
- 0:31car company, some sleepy real estate and businesses that
- 0:35people are essentially writing off as old tech.
- 0:38Right, which sounds totally counterintuitive it.
- 0:40Really does. So today for this deep dive, we
- 0:43are figuring out exactly why. And honestly, it almost sounds
- 0:47like a punchline, but it's actually this incredible master
- 0:49class in market psychology. We are looking at the strategy
- 0:53of Bill Ackman and his highly concentrated portfolio at
- 0:56Pershing Square. He is actively betting against
- 0:59the current hype cycle, and the framework he uses to do it is
- 1:02just, well, it's fascinating. I am so glad we're unpacking
- 1:05this because, you know, it challenges everything you're
- 1:08taught about chasing growth. Oh.
- 1:09Absolutely. It feels like, OK, let's unpack
- 1:12this. It feels like we're watching
- 1:14everyone scramble to get a reservation at, like, the
- 1:18trendiest new molecular gastronomy restaurant in town,
- 1:22the one where dinner is, I don't know, a foam that tastes like a
- 1:25campfire and costs a fortune, Right?
- 1:27Yeah, and meanwhile this investor is just quietly walking
- 1:30around town, totally ignoring the trendy foam and buying up
- 1:33the absolute best classic cash producing diners while they just
- 1:38happen to be on sale. That is such a brilliant way to
- 1:40visualize it. I mean, understanding that
- 1:43mindset is incredibly valuable for you listening.
- 1:46We all live in a world of constant information overload,
- 1:49right? Every single day there is a new
- 1:51trend, a new must buy stock or some panic dominating your
- 1:55newsfeed. Understanding how a top tier
- 1:58investor actually filters out that deafening noise to identify
- 2:02durable long term compounder's it can fundamentally shift how
- 2:06you evaluate opportunities. And that applies whether you're,
- 2:10you know, managing A brokerage account, deciding which job
- 2:13offer to take, or just figuring out how to allocate your own
- 2:16time. Right, so to understand the
- 2:19diner versus the foam, we really first have to talk about how
- 2:22this strategy actually defines the word value exactly.
- 2:25Because when I hear value investing, my brain immediately
- 2:28goes to the old school bargain bin approach like buying a
- 2:32struggling or maybe even dying company just because the stock
- 2:35is creating for pennies. Yeah, the classic Warren Buffett
- 2:38cigar butt investing. You look for a discarded company
- 2:41on the street that has, you know, one good free puff left in
- 2:43it. But this strategy explicitly
- 2:46rejects that model. To him, true value has literally
- 2:50nothing to do with buying a bad business just because the price
- 2:53to earnings ratio is low or it's trading at a discount to book
- 2:56value. True value is simply the
- 2:58mathematically calculated present value of the cash a
- 3:02business is going to generate over its entire lifespan.
- 3:04The present value of future cash, so you aren't hunting for
- 3:08cheap junk. No.
- 3:09Not at all. You're hunting for a global
- 3:11dominance that just happens to be on a temporary discount.
- 3:13Exact the the distinction and that philosophy really explains
- 3:17the massive pivot into what the market was.
- 3:20Frankly punishing his old tech, right?
- 3:23Specifically, we're talking about Microsoft, Meta, and
- 3:26Amazon. Which is wild to think about
- 3:29now, but like, look back at the market dynamics just a short
- 3:31time ago. The obsession with the new AI
- 3:34race, the scramble for NVIDIA chips, the data center energy
- 3:38plays, things like SpaceX. It just sucked all the oxygen
- 3:42out of the room. Oh, completely.
- 3:43And to fund those shiny new bets, institutional money was
- 3:47selling off established tech giants.
- 3:48They really threw the baby out with the bathwater there.
- 3:51Take Microsoft for example. OK, at one point during that
- 3:53sell off, Microsoft was down 40% from its peak.
- 3:57Wow, 40%. Right.
- 3:59Just think about the mechanics of that one of the most
- 4:01entrenched rofitable software monopolies in human history lost
- 4:06nearly half its market value, and not because its business
- 4:09model broke, but simply because investors were distracted by the
- 4:13new shiny object. Wow, That massive drop brought
- 4:17Microsoft down to evaluation that finally made mathematical
- 4:21sense for a value investor. And the competitive advantages,
- 4:24the moats these companies presents are just staggering
- 4:27when you actually look under the hood.
- 4:29Take Meta. Oh yeah, Meta is a great
- 4:31example. The market was punishing Meta
- 4:33because Apple had changed its privacy settings, making it way
- 4:36harder to track users and target ads.
- 4:38People literally thought Meta was dead in the water but their
- 4:42growth actually accelerated. Because they used AI to rebuild
- 4:45their target engine from the ground up.
- 4:47Yes. I mean, instead of relying on
- 4:49Apple's tracking data, Meta built internal algorithms that
- 4:53drastically improved ad performance using their own
- 4:56localized data. Advertisers started getting way
- 4:59higher returns on their ad specs, which is crazy.
- 5:01And simultaneously, users were just spending unprecedented
- 5:05amounts of time scrolling through Instagram Reels and.
- 5:08WhatsApp. Then you look at Amazon, which
- 5:10is honestly the perfect example of a hidden mode.
- 5:12People still think of it as an online retailer.
- 5:14Right, the everything store. But the real magic is the
- 5:18logistics network. They've expanded so aggressively
- 5:21into rural areas, offering a massive basket of goods
- 5:24delivered in a couple of hours. And their philosophy is
- 5:27brilliant. They almost never use their
- 5:29monopoly power to push prices up on the consumer.
- 5:32No, they don't. They use it to push for faster
- 5:34delivery and lower internal costs.
- 5:37Competitors simply cannot replicate that physical
- 5:40infrastructure. It is an impenetrable real world
- 5:43fortress, but of course retail is really only half the story
- 5:46with Amazon. Right, the other half is AWS,
- 5:49their cloud computing business. I mean there is near infinite
- 5:52demand right now because every single company trying to build
- 5:55an AI product needs massive computing power.
- 5:59But no startup is going to spend billions building their own
- 6:02server farms. They just rent the servers from
- 6:04Amazon. Which actually makes me want to
- 6:06push back on this whole premise for a second.
- 6:09Wait, isn't calling Microsoft and Amazon old tech?
- 6:12Completely missing the point. If Amazon is the number one
- 6:15player in cloud and Microsoft owns a massive chunk of open AI,
- 6:20they are legacy companies. Aren't they actually the
- 6:23landlords of the entire AI revolution?
- 6:26Well, what's fascinating here is you are hitting on the exact
- 6:29thesis that drove the investment.
- 6:31OK. The broader market completely
- 6:33miscategorized them. The market narrative said, you
- 6:36know, these are yesterday's winners, time to move on, right?
- 6:38Right. But a true value investor looks
- 6:40at the mechanics and says, no, these are the foundational
- 6:42infrastructure companies. For tomorrow.
- 6:44I see the sector doesn't matter. A tech company is a value play
- 6:48if there's a highly defensible monopolistic position and a
- 6:52temporarily depressed stock price.
- 6:54Business quality over business sector always.
- 6:57That makes perfect sense. Buying durable monopolies when
- 6:59the market gets distracted is a really clean, logical strategy.
- 7:04But then you look at the next major play in this portfolio and
- 7:08it just shatters that entire framework.
- 7:10It is the complete opposite of a stable tech monopoly.
- 7:13Oh, you're talking about Hertz? It's Hertz, a car rental company
- 7:17that had essentially crashed into a brick wall.
- 7:20How on earth does a near bankrupt rental fleet fit into a
- 7:23strategy obsessed with durable cash flow?
- 7:27Well, this is where we transition from the safety of
- 7:30durable compounders to the high wire active asymmetric upside,
- 7:34OK. And the origin story of this
- 7:36particular trade is completely unexpected.
- 7:38It began purely as a macroeconomic hedge.
- 7:41A hedge against the potential of new Trump trade tariffs, right?
- 7:45Yeah. And we should clarify for
- 7:46everyone listening, we are looking at this purely through
- 7:48the lens of economic mechanics, entirely stripped of any
- 7:52political stance, just as it was laid out in the source.
- 7:55Exactly. The underlying economic logic is
- 7:57what matters here. So if broad tariffs are placed
- 7:59on imported goods, the supply chain gets squeezed and brand
- 8:03new cars become significantly more expensive to manufacture
- 8:06and buy, right? If new cars become prohibitively
- 8:09expensive, consumers are forced into the secondary market.
- 8:13Suddenly the existing pool of used cars becomes much, much
- 8:17more valuable. And if you are looking for a
- 8:19company sitting on a massive physical mountain of used cars,
- 8:24you look at Hertz. But there was a massive problem.
- 8:26Hertz was in the middle of a totally self-inflicted
- 8:29catastrophe. A car rental company is
- 8:32essentially 2 businesses stitched together.
- 8:35There's the operating side, the desk at the airport where you
- 8:38rent a sedan for the weekend. And there's the asset side, the
- 8:42massive balance sheet required to finance and own hundreds of
- 8:45thousands of vehicles. And the management team at the
- 8:48time made a highly publicized fatal error on that asset side.
- 8:52They basically went long Teslas. They bought a massive fleet of
- 8:56electric vehicles, and the timing couldn't have been worse
- 8:59because shortly after, Elon Musk drastically cut the retail price
- 9:03of brand new Teslas to spur demand.
- 9:05Which sounds great for consumers, but if you own a
- 9:07rental fleet, that is a death sentence.
- 9:09It absolutely crushes you because a rental car company's
- 9:12survival relies heavily on what's called residual value,
- 9:15which is what those cars are worth when they retire them from
- 9:17the fleet and sell them on the used market.
- 9:20Let's say you buy a fleet of cars at $50,000 each, expecting
- 9:23to sell them for 30,000 in a few years.
- 9:25OK, if the manufacturer suddenly drops the price of a brand new
- 9:29car to 40,000, your used cars are instantly worth a fraction
- 9:33of what you projected. Hertz had enormous value wiped
- 9:36off its balance sheet almost overnight.
- 9:38It was a disaster. The stock plummeted down to
- 9:41around $3 a share. Most institutional investors
- 9:44just ran for the hills. But this is where the concept of
- 9:47a levered bet comes in, isn't it?
- 9:49Yes. A levered bet means using debt
- 9:53to amplify your potential returns.
- 9:55Hertz had a massive amount of debt, right?
- 9:58When a company is heavily indebted, the stock price
- 10:00becomes incredibly volatile. If things go slightly wrong, the
- 10:04equity goes to 0, but if things go right, the equity can
- 10:07multiply incredibly quickly. Yeah, Ackman saw a classic
- 10:11asymmetric opportunity. The downside was capped at $3 a
- 10:14share, but the upside was explosive.
- 10:17Because a new, highly credible management team stepped in to
- 10:20clean up the Tesla mess. And the math was simple.
- 10:23If used car prices go up due to macroeconomic factors and the
- 10:27new CEO fixes the airport rental operations, the stock rockets
- 10:32upwards. Which it did.
- 10:33Yeah, and nearly doubled from that initial entry point.
- 10:36But the trade isn't just a short term turn around.
- 10:39There is a massive long term unpriced variable hidden in
- 10:43Hertz business model. It involves the blue sky upside
- 10:47of autonomous vehicles like Waymo, OH.
- 10:49This is the part that completely changed how I view this
- 10:52industry. Right now.
- 10:53Autonomous vehicle companies are brilliant at software, Lidar,
- 10:56sensors, all of that. Yeah, but as they try to scale
- 10:58from a few 100 test cars to hundreds of thousands of robo
- 11:01taxis across the country, they hit a very gritty physical
- 11:05bottleneck. They really do.
- 11:07Who is? Vacuuming the back seats.
- 11:08Who is rotating the tires, charging the batteries, and
- 11:11parking these massive distributed fleets every single
- 11:14night? Waymo and Tesla do not have the
- 11:16physical infrastructure to maintain massive fleets across
- 11:19thousands of cities. Right.
- 11:20But Hertz does they already. We have the real estate, the
- 11:23mechanics and the institutional knowledge to manage vehicles at
- 11:27a global scale. This sounds a lot like the
- 11:29classic picks and shovels strategy from the Gold Rush.
- 11:32Is this investor basically betting that Hertz will become
- 11:35the janitor for the autonomous vehicle revolution?
- 11:38Janitor is a humble term, but strategically it is the perfect
- 11:42analogy. It is a Ure infrastructure play.
- 11:45You buy a distressed asset for its immediate turn around
- 11:48otential, but you hold onto it because it owns the real world
- 11:51infrastructure that the software giants desperately need.
- 11:54So OK, we have tech monopolies bought on a temporary dip and a
- 11:58rental car company bought out of the bargain bin for its
- 12:01infrastructure, but the ultimate question is what do you do with
- 12:04the massive amounts of cash these investments generate?
- 12:07Yes, and this brings us to the most patient, ambitious move in
- 12:11the entire portfolio. They are attempting to build an
- 12:14exact replica of Warren Buffett's wealth generating
- 12:17machine. The Holy Grail of finance?
- 12:19Recreating the Berkshire Hathaway architecture.
- 12:22Let's walk through the mechanics of this, because it is just
- 12:24brilliant. Decades ago, Warren Buffett
- 12:27famously took control of a struggling textile mill called
- 12:31Berkshire Hathaway. Right, A dying business in a
- 12:33dying American industry. But it was incredibly cheap
- 12:36relative to its assets. Buffett realized quickly he
- 12:41couldn't save the textile business, so he engaged in
- 12:44masterful capital allocation. He slowly wound down the mills,
- 12:48liquidated the physical assets and took all that cash and
- 12:52bought an insurance company. And the reason he bought an
- 12:54insurance company is a concept called float.
- 12:57Float is the secret sauce of billionaires.
- 13:00When you buy car insurance, you pay your premium today.
- 13:03But the insurance company might not have to pay out a claim for
- 13:06an accident until, say, three years from now.
- 13:09That massive pool of cash sitting there in the middle
- 13:13waiting to be paid out is the float.
- 13:15It is essentially a multi billion dollar zero interest
- 13:19loan from your own customers. Exactly.
- 13:22Buffett took that free float and invested it into high return
- 13:25businesses, compounding the gains tax free over decades.
- 13:29And Ackman is building the exact same engine right now using a
- 13:33real estate company called Howard Hughes.
- 13:35Howard Hughes owns vast tracts of residential land and master
- 13:39planned communities. As they build and sell those
- 13:42condominiums and properties, the business throws off a mountain
- 13:45of cash, right? Historically, a real estate
- 13:47developer just takes that cash and buys more land.
- 13:50But right now, commercial real estate is a tough low return
- 13:54environment. So instead of throwing good
- 13:56money after bad, they took that real estate cash and used it to
- 14:00acquire a specialty insurer and reinsurer called Vantage.
- 14:03They successfully built the Berkshire Engine.
- 14:05But owning an insurance company is only half the battle, right?
- 14:08You have to invest the float correctly.
- 14:10Which is where the major operational shift happened.
- 14:13Before this acquisition, Vantage was doing what most insurers do.
- 14:17They outsource their investment management to Wall Street giants
- 14:20like BlackRock and Goldman Sachs.
- 14:22Who just parked the money in safe low yield bonds?
- 14:25Probably. Precisely.
- 14:27But Ackman's team is pulling that money back in house.
- 14:30They are going to use that insurance float to buy the high
- 14:33quality, durable tech monopolies and asymmetric turn around plays
- 14:37we've been discussing. Their stated goal is to compound
- 14:40equity at 20% per year for the next 60 years.
- 14:44Wow. But building a 60 year
- 14:46compounding engine requires an almost inhuman level of
- 14:49discipline regarding what you choose not to invest in.
- 14:52And the best example of this discipline was their attempt to
- 14:55buy Universal Music Group. Yeah, Universal Music is an
- 14:59incredible business. It owns the rights to a massive
- 15:02chunk of global music. It has a completely dominant
- 15:04Moat. Pershing Square tried to buy it,
- 15:06but the deal structure was incredibly complex.
- 15:09How so it? Required navigating A
- 15:11controlling shareholder, the Bowler, a group led by French
- 15:13billionaire Vincent Bowler. A and European corporate
- 15:16governance is vastly different from the US Controlling families
- 15:19often have different incentives than typical shareholders.
- 15:22Plus, executing a change of control in this specific case
- 15:25required securing a 2/3 majority vote in Amsterdam.
- 15:29The Bulla Ray Group ultimately rejected the bid.
- 15:32Now, if you look at the history of Wall Street, when a
- 15:35billionaire activist investor gets rejected, their ego usually
- 15:39takes over. Always.
- 15:40They launch a hostile takeover. They start a proxy war.
- 15:44They buy full page ads in the Wall Street Journal.
- 15:46They spend millions on lawyers to force the deal through.
- 15:49But Ackman just walked away. They sold their stake and moved
- 15:53on, and the framework they used to make that decision is
- 15:56arguably the most valuable take away from this entire strategy.
- 16:00They measure opportunities using an internal metric called the
- 16:03Return on Invested Brain Damage. Return on invested brain damage.
- 16:07That is the greatest financial metric I have ever.
- 16:09Heard it forces you to quantify the mental toll of an
- 16:12investment. They look at Universal Music and
- 16:15realized, you know, finding a controlling billionaire family
- 16:17in a foreign legal jurisdiction was going to consume an
- 16:20unfathomable amount of mental energy, time, and legal fees.
- 16:24Meanwhile, Microsoft and Amazon were sitting right there,
- 16:27heavily discounted, requiring 0 proxy wars to acquire.
- 16:32The return on invested brain damage for Universal Music was
- 16:35simply too low to justify the effort.
- 16:37Capital and mental bandwidth could be deployed vastly more
- 16:41efficiently elsewhere. That is profound, but let me
- 16:44challenge this entire 60 year Berkshire comparison.
- 16:48Here's where it gets really interesting, but also
- 16:50questionable. Buffett's 20% compounding took
- 16:5260 years. We live in a totally different
- 16:55era now. We are in a hyper fast
- 16:57algorithmic high frequency trading environment where
- 17:01investors measure success in 90 day earning cycles.
- 17:04Is it even realistic to try and replicate A6 decades slow burn
- 17:08strategy when the market demands immediate gratification?
- 17:11You are pointing directly to the psychological cost of this
- 17:14strategy. Taking a 60 year view guarantees
- 17:17that you will endure agonizing periods of short term
- 17:19underperformance, and right now, Pershing Square is living
- 17:22through exactly that. Yeah, let's look at the actual
- 17:24numbers because it highlights how painful this is.
- 17:27Recently, the S&P 500 was up around 7 or 8% for the year.
- 17:31Over that same time frame, this concentrated portfolio was down
- 17:35about 10%. That is an 18 percentage point
- 17:38swing in the wrong direction in the modern finance industry.
- 17:43Trailing the index by that much usually results in clients
- 17:46pulling their money and the financial press writing your
- 17:49obituary. So how does a fund manager
- 17:51justify that to their investors? By clearly explaining the
- 17:54structural mechanics of the S&P 500 right now, the index is
- 17:57market cap weighted, meaning the biggest companies dictate the
- 18:01direction of the entire market. Right now, the S&P 500 is
- 18:04heavily distorted by a handful of massive tech and chip stocks.
- 18:07The Magnificent 7 Buying the index right now is essentially
- 18:11making a massive, concentrated bet on the AI hardware hype
- 18:14cycle. Ackman's underperformance is
- 18:16entirely intentional. He's deliberately refusing to
- 18:19buy those wildly overvalued semiconductor and energy stocks
- 18:23just to keep up with the index. So what does this all mean for
- 18:26you? Listening.
- 18:27It's like going to the gym. The days you feel the weakest
- 18:29are actually the days you're building the most muscle.
- 18:32But psychologically, how hard is it to hold on to your old tech
- 18:36when your neighbor is getting rich on speculative chip stocks?
- 18:39You feel like an idiot in the short term.
- 18:41But the pitch to clients is completely counterintuitive.
- 18:45These periods of painful underperformance are
- 18:47mathematically the best times to invest more capital because it
- 18:52means their portfolio of durable compounders is trading at a
- 18:55massive unjustified discount relative to the broader hype
- 18:59driven market. And they have the historical
- 19:01track record to back up that swagger.
- 19:03If you zoom out and look at the last 8 to 9 years, this specific
- 19:07strategy has compounded at roughly 22% annually.
- 19:10Well, the S&P 500 compounded at about 14% over the same period.
- 19:14That eight percentage point difference might sound small,
- 19:17but over a decade, the compounding effect of that
- 19:19outperformance creates a staggering difference in total
- 19:21wealth. But capturing those long term
- 19:24gains requires a titanium stomach.
- 19:27You have to be willing to look foolish while the rest of the
- 19:29world is chasing the newest trend.
- 19:31It demands an unshakable conviction in your own
- 19:34definition of value. If we synthesize the entire
- 19:37framework we've explored today, true value is never just buying
- 19:41cheap, dying companies. It is identifying durable,
- 19:44monopolistic cash flows that the market is temporarily mispriced
- 19:49due to distraction. It is finding infrastructure
- 19:52turnarounds like Hertz that offer heavily skewed asymmetric
- 19:56upside. And above all, compounding
- 19:59wealth over a lifetime requires the cold, calculated discipline
- 20:02to walk away from situations with a terrible return on
- 20:05invested brain damage. So you have the emotional
- 20:07fortitude to whether the inevitable cycles of
- 20:10underperformance. It is about building an
- 20:12intellectual framework that survives the hype.
- 20:15And Speaking of building intelligent frameworks, we want
- 20:17to share something with you to access more advanced researches,
- 20:20applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 20:23multi agent Deep value intelligence.
- 20:26Welcome to explore and join deep values dot AI community track
- 20:31total market temperature. Welcome to Search and download
- 20:34iOS App Buffett Indicator from Apple App Store.
- 20:37And of course, our required disclaimer.
- 20:39All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 20:42may be subject to revisions or different interpretations.
- 20:45All contents from this channel is for research and
- 20:47entertainment purposes only and does not constitute any
- 20:50investment or financial advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 20:53before making investment financial decisions.
- 20:55Don't forget to like this video. Much appreciated.
- 20:58We talked a lot today about the return on invested brain damage
- 21:02metric for multi billion dollar buyouts.
- 21:05But look at your own life, whether it's a relationship, a
- 21:08job, or an argument on social media.
- 21:10What are you currently holding on to that has a terrible return
- 21:12on invested brain damage? Maybe it's time to sell your
- 21:15stake and reinvest that energy somewhere else.
- 21:18Catch you on the next deep dive.