Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Deep] Microsoft, What's Wrong?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to your deep dive. We are tackling a Titan today, a
- 0:03company so fundamental to the global economy that its
- 0:06performance really dictates the direction of the entire tech
- 0:09sector. Microsoft ticker MSFT.
- 0:13And this isn't just a company synonymous with personal
- 0:15computing anymore. It's arguably the foundational
- 0:18digital infrastructure utility provider for the modern world.
- 0:21But here is the critical question we are here to answer
- 0:24for you today. Is it a great investment right
- 0:27now? That is the mission and it's a
- 0:30complicated 1. You are really asking if the
- 0:31market's pricing reflects reality or just, you know,
- 0:34enthusiasm. Our approach is rigorous.
- 0:37We are taking a decade of MSFT financial data, their very
- 0:40latest quarterly report that's Q1 fiscal year 2026 and running
- 0:44it all through a really demanding deep value checklist.
- 0:46So the standards inspired by Benjamin Graham and Warren
- 0:49Buffett. Exactly.
- 0:50We're applying those time tested high standards to see if the
- 0:54company's undeniable high quality justifies its current
- 0:58price tag, which is significant. We need to move beyond the
- 1:01headlines and examine if there's any true bargain opportunity
- 1:04left or if you know every successful future outcome is
- 1:08only priced into the stock. And as always, we are relying on
- 1:12detailed financial research and cross validated data to give you
- 1:16the most granular view possible of Microsoft's shift that shift
- 1:20from a legacy software giant to what we might call the AI
- 1:24infrastructure utility of the future.
- 1:26This is your shortcut to understanding the biggest
- 1:28financial pivot of the decade. Exactly.
- 1:31And before we unpack those absolutely monumental numbers, a
- 1:34crucial point of context in a disclaimer derived directly from
- 1:37the source material. All analysis is based on
- 1:39publicly available sources and maybe subject to revisions or
- 1:42differing interpretations. The content you are about to
- 1:44hear is for educational and informational purposes only and
- 1:48does not constitute investment advice.
- 1:50Please conduct your own due diligence with a licensed
- 1:53financial advisor before making any investment decisions.
- 1:55That's absolutely critical. And on a related note, if you're
- 1:58looking to track the overall market temperature and sort of
- 2:00gauge exuberance, we welcome you to search and download the iOS
- 2:03app Buffett Indicator for the Apple App Store.
- 2:07It's a great tool for, you know, getting a feel for market
- 2:09sentiment. A superb tool for understanding
- 2:12the broader environment. Now let's jump right into the
- 2:15latest performance report. OK, let's unpack this Q1 FY20 26
- 2:20report Microsoft delivered with the sources unanimously describe
- 2:24as a resounding beat. This quarter was the litmus test
- 2:28right? The quarter that had to prove
- 2:30definitively that their AI first strategy wasn't just talk, but
- 2:33actual monetization. The headlines scream success.
- 2:38What were the absolute headline numbers that signaled the
- 2:40strategic pivot is delivering? Well, the top line figures were
- 2:43genuinely staggering, even for Microsoft's massive scale.
- 2:46We're talking about a multi trillion dollar company
- 2:48achieving growth rates typically reserved for, you know, much
- 2:51smaller nimbler startups. Revenue hit $77.7 billion for
- 2:57the quarter. 77.7 billion. Yes.
- 3:00To put that in perspective, that's an 18% increase year over
- 3:03year or 17% in constant currency.
- 3:06High growth at a colossal scale is an extremely difficult feat
- 3:10to sustain, yet they are doing it.
- 3:12And crucially, the profitability metrics demonstrated that they
- 3:15still possess that classic software operating leverage.
- 3:18It wasn't just top line growth fueled by excessive spending.
- 3:23Absolutely not. The oerating income surged even
- 3:26faster than revenue, rising by a owerful 24.
- 3:30This is the critical sign of quality for a software giant.
- 3:34It's operating leverage. It means that once their
- 3:36infrastructure is built out, every incremental dollar of
- 3:39revenue is extremely profitable because the cost of delivery for
- 3:42another software license or cloud seat is near 0.
- 3:45So they're adding revenue far faster than they are adding
- 3:48fixed costs. That's what drives the margin.
- 3:50Expansion. That's the hallmark of a high
- 3:52quality, scalable business. And the bottom line, the
- 3:54earnings per share, the EPS. Diluted EPS came in at $3.73.
- 4:00That is a massive bottom line for a single quarter.
- 4:03However, the sources flag a specific, highly relevant
- 4:06financial detail hidden within that EPS figure.
- 4:09A drag on profitability, even that robust EPS figure included
- 4:13a negative impact of $0.41 per share.
- 4:16And that 41 cent hit was strategic, wasn't it?
- 4:19Wasn't an operational mistake. Precisely that negative impact
- 4:22was driven primarily by equity losses attributed to the
- 4:25company's deepening strategic investment in open AI.
- 4:28They're essentially betting aggressively on the future AI
- 4:30ecosystem. This detail shows you just how
- 4:33crucial the AI pivot is. Microsoft is willing to take a
- 4:37significant quantifiable hit on the profit and loss statement
- 4:40today, accepting volatility in their net income to ensure a
- 4:43future dominance. It's a calculated long term
- 4:46sacrifice. It really is.
- 4:47This perfectly transitions us to the core identity of the
- 4:50Business Today. The financial researchers
- 4:52describe Microsoft as functioning as a diversified
- 4:55technology conglomerate, positioning itself effectively
- 4:58as a tax on global corporate productivity.
- 5:03Can you unpack that analogy and breakdown this critical triple
- 5:05threat business model for us? That tax on productivity analogy
- 5:09is incredibly accurate because virtually every employee in the
- 5:13corporate world, from the biggest multinational bank to
- 5:16the smallest startup, uses Microsoft software to do their
- 5:19job, and they pay a recurring fee for that privilege.
- 5:22Their business is fundamentally split into three major segments,
- 5:26and understanding their proportional revenue is key to
- 5:29grasping the scale of their transformation.
- 5:31Let's look at the breakdown. What defines these three
- 5:33pillars? OK, First you have intelligent
- 5:35Cloud, which is now the dominant segment.
- 5:37It brings in the largest piece of the pie, about 32% of the
- 5:40total revenue. This segment is the future,
- 5:43includes Azure, Windows Server, SQL Server, GitHub.
- 5:47This is infrastructure, data and developer tools.
- 5:49OK. The engine, right?
- 5:512nd productivity and business processes that accounts for
- 5:54roughly 34% of revenue. This is the classic cash cow
- 5:58that turned into a compounding machine.
- 6:00Office 365. LinkedIn and Dynamics 365.
- 6:04South, those two segments alone account for roughly 3/4 of the
- 6:07revenue representing that cloud first subscription based future.
- 6:11Exactly. And finally, the legacy
- 6:13division, more personal computing is about 24%.
- 6:16This covers Windows license fees, Xbox gaming, Surface
- 6:20hardware and their search advertising revenue.
- 6:22While it's still massive, it is now the smallest and slowest
- 6:25growing segment. The intelligent plow, the Azure
- 6:27story is clearly the engine we need to focus on.
- 6:30What kind of growth momentum did that show in Q1?
- 6:32It remains the growth engine. It grew 20% in the quarter, but
- 6:37the long term scale is the real story here.
- 6:40The report show that Azure revenue surpassed $75 billion in
- 6:44fiscal year 2025 alone. That demonstrates an astonishing
- 6:4834% annual growth rate over the prior year.
- 6:52This is where the AI monetization truly lives, when
- 6:55an enterprise signs up for a Copilot subscription or begins
- 6:58building AI models that scales directly with their consumption
- 7:02of Azure. Azure is their pipeline into the
- 7:04future corporate. Wallet.
- 7:05That's a perfect way to put it. Now we have to talk about
- 7:08customer scale. The penetration into the
- 7:10corporate world is what makes this recurring revenue so sticky
- 7:13and predictable. It provides incredible financial
- 7:16stability. How wide is their reach?
- 7:18The reach is what makes Microsoft structurally different
- 7:21from almost any other company. Let's start with the knowledge
- 7:23worker. Microsoft boasts over 400
- 7:26million paid commercial seats for Microsoft 365. 400 million.
- 7:30That's not a rounding error. No, it's a vast majority of the
- 7:34global white collar workforce paying Microsoft a recurring
- 7:38sticky subscription fee simply to do their day-to-day jobs.
- 7:43To e-mail, to spreadsheet, to communicate.
- 7:45That's the baseline, the immense foundation.
- 7:47What about the heavy hitters? The foundational enterprise
- 7:50clients. Azure is utilized by a stunning
- 7:5385% of the Fortune 500, and we're not talking about casual
- 7:57trial usage here. Azure serves as the actual
- 7:59digital backbone, the infrastructure, data storage and
- 8:02compute power for the world's largest, most demanding
- 8:05corporations. When you consider this kind of
- 8:08deep integration, it leads directly into the critical point
- 8:11about their competitive advantage, or what Buffett calls
- 8:14the economic Moat. The Moat analysis.
- 8:16If we're judging this company by high quality value standards, a
- 8:19wide economic Moat is non negotiable.
- 8:22Microsoft appears to have built a fortress, not just a ditch.
- 8:25What are the three primary pillars of that defensibility?
- 8:28There are three interlink strategies that create an almost
- 8:31insurmountable barrier for competitors.
- 8:34The first is high switching costs.
- 8:37Think about an enterprise that is deep into the Microsoft
- 8:40walled garden. They run Windows on all their
- 8:43devices, use Azure for infrastructure to use for
- 8:45communication, Office for documentation, trying to switch
- 8:49that entire ecosystem. It's operationally and
- 8:52financially prohibitive. The friction is just too high.
- 8:55The risk of downtime or integration failure is too
- 8:58great. It effectively locks customers
- 9:00in it's inertia weaponized. Once they have that deep
- 9:03integration, the customer is essentially permanent unless
- 9:06something dramatically disruptive happens.
- 9:08What's the second pillar? The second pillar is the classic
- 9:11network effect. This applies particularly
- 9:13strongly to their own platforms like LinkedIn and GitHub.
- 9:16These platforms gain intrinsic value with every new user who
- 9:19joins. More developers on GitHub make
- 9:22it a better tool for the developers already there.
- 9:24More professionals on LinkedIn make it more valuable for
- 9:27recruiters. So the utility of the platform
- 9:29increases exponentially with scale, making it self
- 9:32reinforcing. And the third Moat pillar is the
- 9:35most relevant to the new AI era, and perhaps the most aggressive
- 9:38one they are currently building. This is the cost advantage
- 9:41derived from scale, which really means a capital expenditure
- 9:44mode. The barrier to entry in the
- 9:46frontier AI infrastructure space is just astronomical capital
- 9:51investment. Microsoft is using it's immense
- 9:54cash flow to pour billions into infrastructure data centers
- 9:57specialized in video GPU's, custom silicon.
- 10:00This massive capital spend or CapEx, which we will detail in a
- 10:03moment, acts as a financial fortress.
- 10:06By spending so much so fast, they prevent smaller
- 10:08challengers, even well funded ones, from competing.
- 10:12The growth is undeniable. The Moat is formidable.
- 10:15We've established Microsoft is a wonderful business in structural
- 10:17terms. However, here's where the
- 10:19investment thesis gets truly complicated and where we move
- 10:22from quality analysis to risk assessment.
- 10:24The cost structure is changing fundamentally.
- 10:27The sources highlight a major new, almost existential
- 10:30financial risk, the AI CapEx wall.
- 10:33What exactly is this financial dynamic and why is it currently
- 10:36creating so much investor anxiety?
- 10:38The AI CapEx wall is the physical financial manifestation
- 10:41of the AI, the arms race between the hyperscalers Microsoft,
- 10:45Amazon, and Google. It refers to the massive,
- 10:49unprecedented surge in capital expenditures, the spending on
- 10:52physical infrastructure like data centers and specialized
- 10:55chips that is required not just to compete but to maintain
- 10:58leadership. It's a high stakes bet that
- 11:00forces companies to rapidly consume capital.
- 11:03We need to put a number on this massive spending.
- 11:05How big was the scale of this capital expenditure surge in the
- 11:08latest quarter Q1 FY20 26? The number is astounding.
- 11:12Capital expenditures hit a staggering 34.9 billion.
- 11:16Dollars 34.9 billion in a single quarter.
- 11:19In a single quarter, this is an amount that would make the
- 11:22entire GDP of some small countries blush.
- 11:24To give you the context required to understand the pivot, annual
- 11:27CapEx was 44.5 billion for the entire fiscal year 2024.
- 11:31Just a decade ago in 2015, their annual CapEx was only 5.9
- 11:35billion. This surge reflects an
- 11:37unprecedented scale pivot. Microsoft is effectively
- 11:41investing almost a quarter's worth of revenue into
- 11:43infrastructure in just three months.
- 11:45That comparison going from 5.9 billion annually to almost 35
- 11:50billion in 1/4 fundamentally alters the financial DNA of the
- 11:54company. It transforms them, at least
- 11:56temporarily, from an asset light software business into a heavy
- 12:00utility infrastructure builder. Why does this scale create such
- 12:04anxiety around return on invested capital or ROIC for
- 12:08long term investors? The anxiety stems from the
- 12:11immense pressure on the return on investment.
- 12:14When you spend 35 billion, the market demands rapid, high
- 12:18margin revenue growth immediately to justify that
- 12:21spending. If this infrastructure spending
- 12:23these billions in depreciating data center assets is merely A
- 12:27sustaining innovation. Thinking it just helps them keep
- 12:29existing customers and stops them from migrating to
- 12:32competitors. Right, rather than generating
- 12:34entirely new high margin revenue streams.
- 12:36Then the math gets ugly. The depreciation cost from all
- 12:39these assets could weigh heavily on earnings for a decade,
- 12:42suppressing profitability. This sounds like a financial
- 12:45cycle we've seen before, where capital deployment outpaces a
- 12:47media revenue realization. The source material draws a very
- 12:51powerful historical analogy here, doesn't it?
- 12:53It does, and it's a terrifying analogy for cautious investors.
- 12:57The late 1990s telecom fiber boom.
- 13:00During that era, telecom companies poured massive capital
- 13:03into building fiber networks globally, convinced that the
- 13:06Internet explosion meant immediate, limitless returns.
- 13:10But what actually happened? What happened was massive
- 13:13overcapacity. They build infrastructure faster
- 13:15than demand materialized. The result was huge asset write
- 13:18downs, years of delayed profitability, and a decade
- 13:22where those depreciation costs dragged heavily on earnings and
- 13:25suppressed stock prices. Investors are concerned that the
- 13:27mass of AI CapEx could potentially create a similar
- 13:30scenario. So the company is spending this
- 13:32money based on projections of what future AI consumption will
- 13:35look like, but the market is demanding results based on
- 13:37current consumption. What's the short term paradox
- 13:40arising from this investment frenzy?
- 13:43The paradox is fascinating. Ironically, the immediate growth
- 13:46of Azure AI is not demand constrained, it is fundamentally
- 13:49supply constrained. Microsoft literally cannot build
- 13:53data centers fast enough or acquire enough NVIDIA GPU's to
- 13:56meet all customer requests for AI compute power.
- 13:59That's a bizarre but important bottleneck.
- 14:02It means the CapEx wall ironically is a temporary
- 14:05ceiling on short term revenue upside.
- 14:08They are having to turn away or defer potential immediate
- 14:10business because they don't have the physical capacity yet.
- 14:13Exactly this incapacity to fulfill immediate red hot demand
- 14:17is what likely contributed to earlier reports about
- 14:20recalibrating aggressive AI sales targets.
- 14:23It's not a lack of interest from customers, it's a lack of
- 14:25physical supply. The 35 billion is going towards
- 14:28solving the supply problem, but until that capacity comes fully
- 14:32online, this high CapEx spending will be visible on the balance
- 14:35sheet before the corresponding high margin revenue appears on
- 14:38the income statement. Now let's look beyond these
- 14:41financial dynamics. What are the other long term
- 14:43risks, the external non financial factors that could
- 14:46permanently impact the business model?
- 14:48We identified 3 major external long term risks that need
- 14:51detailed consideration. The 1st and most familiar is
- 14:55regulatory and antitrust risk. Microsoft's sheer size and
- 14:58market dominance put it squarely in the sights of every major
- 15:01global regulator the FTC in the US, the EU Commission and the
- 15:05CMA in the UK. What are the specific pressure
- 15:08points today that regulators are focused on?
- 15:10The scrutiny is intense across the board.
- 15:13They are looking at the forced integration of Teams into the
- 15:15Office 365 bundle, which some argue is anti competitive.
- 15:19They are scrutinizing the massive acquisition of
- 15:21Activision Blizzard and of course the incredibly close
- 15:24strategic partnership with Open AIA.
- 15:27Forced remedy from any of these bodies could dismantle the core
- 15:30integration strategies that make the Microsoft ecosystem so
- 15:33sticky and profitable. The second major long term risk
- 15:37relates directly to the AI core business and it is a massive
- 15:41unknown legal liability. That is new legal liabilities
- 15:44concerning data sovereignty and copyright.
- 15:47The entire legal foundation of generative AI is being
- 15:50challenged globally, particularly over the practice
- 15:52of training large language models on copyrighted data
- 15:55scraped from the Internet. This is a crucial, unsettled
- 15:58legal question. Is this just a theoretical risk
- 16:01that lawyers are discussing, or is it manifesting in the real
- 16:03world? It is absolutely manifesting.
- 16:06We are seeing major lawsuits from authors, artists, news
- 16:09organizations. Crucially, the source material
- 16:11notes that shareholder proposals are demanding AI data sourcing
- 16:15accountability. This indicates that
- 16:18institutional investors are already wary of unquantified,
- 16:20otentially massive legal risks. If courts rule against current
- 16:24training methods, Microsoft could face billions in legal
- 16:27liabilities and damages. And finally, the third risk
- 16:30brings us back to profitability, but this time it is structural
- 16:33margin pressure. This is a direct structural
- 16:36challenge arising from the CapEx wall.
- 16:38AI queries and services are structurally lower margin
- 16:41activities than selling traditional sauce software.
- 16:43Why? Because of the immense
- 16:45computational load and the higher energy costs, this means
- 16:48that as AI revenue grows as a proportion of total revenue, the
- 16:51consolidated gross margin percentage is dipping.
- 16:53Q1 FY20 26 showed a slight but measurable dip in gross margin
- 16:58to 68%. This compression is a tangible
- 17:01sign that the shift to AI is more capital and energy
- 17:04intensive. That is the core conflict.
- 17:06Then the company is spending like a utility to ensure future
- 17:10dominance, but in doing so it is structurally altering the hyper
- 17:14profitable capital light business model that gave it such
- 17:17high margins in the first place. Precisely they are trading peak
- 17:20margin for maximum scale. The risks, the CapEx wall, the
- 17:24regulatory scrutiny, the copyright liability are real,
- 17:27but we cannot ignore the decade of financial success that earned
- 17:30Microsoft this premium valuation in the 1st place.
- 17:34We need to look at the historical table, the decade of
- 17:36transformation from fiscal year 2015 through the trailing 12
- 17:40months of 2025, to truly understand why the market is
- 17:44willing to pay such a high premium today.
- 17:46This historical table tells the definitive story of the Nadella
- 17:49era transformation, and it is a study in financial excellence.
- 17:53The core insight here is the dramatic decoupling of revenue
- 17:56growth from profit growth. Walk us through that stunning
- 17:58margin expansion story. From 2015 to 2024, revenue grew
- 18:03approximately 2.6 times, from around 94 billion to 245
- 18:08billion. That translates to about a 13%
- 18:11compound annual growth rate, which is solid.
- 18:13But net income, the actual bottom line profit, grew a
- 18:17staggering 7.2 times over the same period, soaring from 12
- 18:21billion to 88 billion. Seven times the net income
- 18:24growth on only 2 1/2 times the revenue growth.
- 18:26This margin expansion is the entire investment thesis for the
- 18:30last decade, summed up in 2 numbers.
- 18:32It absolutely is. It demonstrates the immense
- 18:34power of the strategic pivot towards recurring high margin
- 18:37cloud and subscription services like Office 365 and Asher.
- 18:41This focus on margins saw operating margins expand from
- 18:4419.4% in 2015 to a stellar 44.6% in 2024.
- 18:49And their ability to convert revenue into profit is
- 18:52outstanding. The Net margin is truly
- 18:54exceptional. It is Net margin currently sits
- 18:57at a remarkable 35 to 36%. Think about that number.
- 19:01In FY20 24, Microsoft earned 36 cents of pure profit on every
- 19:06single dollar of sales it generated.
- 19:08That level of margin excellence is almost unmatched.
- 19:12Margins are crucial, but the true sign of a quality business
- 19:15is its ability to generate cold, hard, unrestricted cash.
- 19:20How does the free cash flow story look over the decade?
- 19:23The free cash flow machine is perhaps the single most
- 19:25impressive metric. FCF grew from 23.7 billion in
- 19:292015 to 74.1 billion in 2024 and reached 78 billion on a trailing
- 19:3512 month basis. Crucially, the FCF margin, the
- 19:39percentage of revenue converted directly into free cash flow, is
- 19:42consistently outstanding, averaging 30% in recent years.
- 19:46This easily beats the traditional deep value threshold
- 19:49of 5%. When a company generates that
- 19:51much excess cash, 10s of billions a year, management's
- 19:54capital allocation strategy becomes paramount.
- 19:56What does Microsoft management do with all that cash, and how
- 19:59friendly are they to shareholders?
- 20:01Microsoft is highly shareholder friendly, operating a twin
- 20:04engine for returning capital First the dividend.
- 20:08They have demonstrated immense consistency by increasing their
- 20:11dividend for 19 consecutive years.
- 20:14They paid out 24.1 billion in the last 12 months alone.
- 20:18And then there's the buyback program, which is arguably even
- 20:21more impactful than the dividend.
- 20:22Absolutely. They maintain one of the S&P
- 20:24500's most aggressive share buyback programs with a current
- 20:28standing authorization of $60 billion.
- 20:31Critically, these buybacks have tangibly reduced the share count
- 20:34over the decade, shrinking the outstanding shares from about 8
- 20:37billion in 2015 to 7.4 billion in 2024.
- 20:42The systematic reduction is a powerful financial engineering
- 20:44tool that significantly boosts earnings per share.
- 20:47Let's shift our focus to the leadership team.
- 20:50The sources universally praised the management team led by Satya
- 20:53Nadella. How much of this radical success
- 20:55is attributed to the cultural and strategic transformation led
- 20:58by Nadella and CFO Amy Hood? Nearly all of Satya Nadella, CEO
- 21:03since 2014, is credited not just with identifying the cloud
- 21:07opportunity, but executing the profoundly difficult cultural
- 21:10and strategic pivot. He fostered a cloud first AI
- 21:14focus culture, embracing open source and breaking down the
- 21:17internal silos that once played Microsoft.
- 21:20CFO Amy Hood is the financial architect responsible for the
- 21:23discipline, cost management and the aggressive capital return
- 21:26policies. And how aligned are they with
- 21:28shareholder interests? Do they truly have skin in the
- 21:31game when it comes to the long term stock performance?
- 21:34They do, and their compensation structure ensures alignment.
- 21:38The Dell's total compensation for 2025 was nearly 96.5
- 21:41million, heavily weighted toward performance based stock awards.
- 21:45This means his compensation hinges on the stock continuing
- 21:48its upward trajectory. While he and Hood are noted as
- 21:51net sellers of stock received his grants, which is a common
- 21:53practice, their personal wealth remains heavily tethered to
- 21:56MSFT's long term performance. Speaking of long term holders,
- 22:00the source material contained A fascinating and perhaps worrying
- 22:03nugget of data regarding the activity of certain smart money
- 22:07investors in the recent past, the activity of the product
- 22:10takers. This is a critical data point
- 22:12that requires serious reflection for any potential investor.
- 22:16Today. The Q32025 data shows a
- 22:19noticeable cooling among some prominent long term holders, the
- 22:23kind of investors who rode the stock up for years and now feel
- 22:26evaluation may be overheated. The most significant action was
- 22:30taken by the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
- 22:32How massive was that reduction? They sold 17,000,000 shares.
- 22:36That's nearly 65% of its entire stake in Microsoft. 65%.
- 22:40Yes, think about that. This foundation, which is
- 22:43intimately familiar with the company, decided to sell almost
- 22:462/3 of its position after the stocks massive run up.
- 22:49Selling 2/3 of a multi decade holding suggests that these long
- 22:53term institutional investors believe the reward no longer
- 22:56justifies the risk at the current valuation, regardless of
- 22:59the company's quality. That is the most likely
- 23:01interpretation. They are sitting on massive,
- 23:03unrealized gains, and they are rationally taking profits and
- 23:07managing concentration risk. It is not an indictment of
- 23:10Microsoft's operational quality, but it is absolutely a flashing
- 23:14red warning sign about the stock's current price.
- 23:17We have established beyond a doubt that Microsoft is a
- 23:19compounding machine, an absolute powerhouse of quality.
- 23:24Now we apply the final rigorous test, the Buffett style filter,
- 23:28separating company quality where Microsoft excels from the stock
- 23:32valuation where the investment decision is made.
- 23:35This is the moment of truth where we see if the quality is
- 23:37available at a reasonable price. And this checklist is designed
- 23:40to find companies that are both high quality and cheap enough to
- 23:43offer a margin of safety. As we go through this, you'll
- 23:46see a stark division. The company achieves near
- 23:49perfect quality scores, but the valuation metrics fail
- 23:52spectacularly. It's the classic, wonderful
- 23:54company at a terrible price dilemma.
- 23:56Let's start with profitability and efficiency, the quality
- 23:59check first. Gross margin greater than 40%.
- 24:01Pass consistently hovers around 69% elite.
- 24:05OK. Net margin greater than 20%.
- 24:07Pass currently sitting high at 35 to 36%.
- 24:11Superb efficiency. Return on equity the 10 year
- 24:14average greater than 15%. Pass Microsoft's Roe has
- 24:18consistently averaged over 30% in recent years.
- 24:21Exceptionally efficient use of shareholder capital.
- 24:23Return on invested capital ROIC 10 year average greater than
- 24:2712%. This is the big one.
- 24:29Pass Their ROIC consistently ranges between 24 and 30%.
- 24:34A benchmark of 12% is excellent 30% signals and almost
- 24:38impregnable competitive mode. Now here's the metric that
- 24:42reflects the changing business model.
- 24:44Depreciation divided by gross profit less than 10%.
- 24:47Minor miss This is where the AI CapEx wall first appears.
- 24:51Depreciation is currently running around 11.7% of gross
- 24:55profit. A decade ago this was an easy
- 24:57pass. This slight miss today reflects
- 24:59the high capital intensity required for the massive cloud
- 25:02and AI infrastructure build out. So 4 clear passes and one minor
- 25:06miss due to the AI pivot. Let's move to balance sheet
- 25:09safety. Debt to equity less than 0.5.
- 25:12This is an exemplary pass. The ratio is exceptionally low,
- 25:15around 0.12. This is a fortress balance sheet
- 25:19with minimal reliance on debt. Interest coverage greater than
- 25:23three times. Pass coverage is not just
- 25:25greater than three, it is astronomically high, sitting
- 25:27around 37 times in FY20. 24 No practical debt servicing issues.
- 25:32Now here's a metric that often trips up hyper efficient tech
- 25:35companies. Current ratio greater than 1.5.
- 25:39Fail. But this is an instructive
- 25:41failure. The current ratio is around
- 25:421.35. While still fundamentally
- 25:45healthy, it falls short of the conservative value benchmark of
- 25:481.5. Wait, you're saying a company
- 25:51with 78 billion in free cash flow is technically failing a
- 25:54safety test? Isn't that just pedantic?
- 25:56That's a great question. Is a technical failure not a
- 25:59sign of financial weakness? The reason is simple.
- 26:02Microsoft doesn't hoard cash. Instead of keeping a huge buffer
- 26:05on the balance sheet, they immediately return excess cash
- 26:08to shareholders through his aggressive buybacks and
- 26:10dividends. So technical fail, but
- 26:13contextually it is an extremely safe balance sheet.
- 26:17Noted 2 passes and 1 technical strategic failure.
- 26:21Next up, growth and predictability.
- 26:24Free cash flow positive every year and FCF margin greater than
- 26:275%. Pass.
- 26:28We already established FCF margin is 24 to 33% annually
- 26:32beyond outstanding. Return on retained earnings
- 26:35greater than 12%. Pass.
- 26:37The estimated return on the capital they retain and reinvest
- 26:39largely into Azure is well over 45%.
- 26:42They are superb capital allocators.
- 26:45And earnings per share rising every year for 10 years mostly.
- 26:48Pass. The overall trend is powerfully
- 26:50upward. EPS roughly quadrupled.
- 26:53However, there were minor non operational dips in 2018 due to
- 26:56a tax charge and 2023 due to write downs.
- 27:00Excluding those one time events, the underlying earnings power
- 27:02has risen consistently. OK, on quality, safety and
- 27:05operational excellence, Microsoft is a blue chip
- 27:08champion. It passes 9 out of 11 rigorous
- 27:10tests. But now we reach the section
- 27:12that defines the investment decision, valuation discipline,
- 27:15the price check. Prepare yourself.
- 27:18We are looking for clear quantitative margins of safety
- 27:21and we find none first price to earnings or PE ratio less than
- 27:26or equal to 15. Fail.
- 27:28The current PE is approximately 33.7.
- 27:31This is well over the traditional standard and near
- 27:34the high end of Microsoft's own historical range.
- 27:36You are paying more than double the standard price for every
- 27:39dollar of current earnings. Next price to book PB less than
- 27:43or equal to 1.5. Fail PB is approximately 12.
- 27:49Now context is important here. This high ratio is common for
- 27:52asset light software giants, but strictly applied it fails the
- 27:56deep value test. You are paying 12 times what the
- 27:58tangible assets are worth. Finally, the PEG ratio PE
- 28:01divided by the expected growth rate less than one.
- 28:04Fail. This is the crucial valuation
- 28:06metric. Microsoft's PIG ratio is
- 28:08estimated between 2:00 and 3:00. Any figure far above 1 means the
- 28:11stock is highly expensive relative to its current and
- 28:14projected growth rate. The market is not just pricing
- 28:16and growth, it is pricing and accelerated growth for a very
- 28:19long period. The final score is decisive.
- 28:22Microsoft is a wonderful company by every measure of quality, but
- 28:26it fails every single quantitative deep value pricing
- 28:30metric. The take away is absolutely
- 28:32clear, the market has fully priced in the quality, the Moat
- 28:35and the expected success of the AI pivot.
- 28:38It's a gold plated company, but it is not available at a bargain
- 28:41price. So what does this all mean for
- 28:43the potential investor? The stock is not cheap.
- 28:46When a stock fails all the valuation tests, we need the
- 28:48discounted cash flow, or DCF analysis to quantify exactly
- 28:53what kind of future cash flow the market is currently
- 28:55expecting. This allows us to find the
- 28:57theoretical fair price and understand the margin of safety,
- 29:00or lack thereof. The DCF analysis is vital
- 29:03because it strips away emotion and reveals the high stakes
- 29:06gamble investors are taking on future growth.
- 29:09We start with the trailing 12 month free cash flow of around
- 29:117078 billion as our base and we run three highly sensitive
- 29:16scenarios to test how dramatically the perceived
- 29:19intrinsic value changes based on future growth assumptions.
- 29:22Let's start with the absolute financial floor scenario one,
- 29:26the no growth or stagnation case.
- 29:29This is assuming the company stops growing FCF entirely from
- 29:32today. Right.
- 29:33This assumption helps us determine the underlying value
- 29:36of the company's established cash flows.
- 29:39Assuming 0% growth indefinitely and using our 10% discount rate,
- 29:44Microsoft's intrinsic value per share would be between 105 and
- 29:48111 dollars. And the necessary margin of
- 29:51safety buy price 30% below that. That would put the buy price
- 29:54between 73 and $78 per share. The insight here is chilling.
- 29:59If MSFT were to stop growing tomorrow, the stock would be
- 30:02dramatically overpriced by about 75%.
- 30:05This confirms mathematically that the market's current
- 30:07valuation of $470 is based entirely on the expectation of
- 30:11significant multi year future growth.
- 30:14Next, let's move to the conservative scenario, or slow
- 30:17growth. This assumes the AI pivot fails
- 30:19to accelerate growth and the company reverts to its
- 30:22historical lowest sustained FCF growth rate.
- 30:25Historically, the weakest sustained FCF growth was around
- 30:283% annually. If we assume FCF grows slowly,
- 30:32at this 3% rate for the next decade, the intrinsic value per
- 30:36share lands around $144. 144 that is still more than 2/3
- 30:42below the current trading price. This means even a modest
- 30:45deceleration implies a massive overvaluation if you require a
- 30:4910% annual return. Exactly.
- 30:52If we use a slightly more generous historical low growth
- 30:55rate, say 10%, the intrinsic value jumps to about $340.
- 31:00Even then, the margin of safety buy price still lands you around
- 31:03$238. In short, based on conservative
- 31:06historical growth, the stock would need to be in the low 2
- 31:09hundreds just to be a fair value.
- 31:11This makes the risk very clear. Now for the final most crucial
- 31:15test Scenario 3, the nominal growth or AI success case.
- 31:19This is where we attempt to quantify the market's current
- 31:21optimism. What does the company have to
- 31:23achieve to justify today's price?
- 31:25We model 2 optimistic versions here.
- 31:27The first assumes a simple continuation of the 10 year
- 31:30historical average FCF growth of 13% that yields an intrinsic
- 31:35value per share of approximately 308 dollars. 308 That's a huge
- 31:40intrinsic value, but still $160 below the current market price
- 31:43of 470. So even the long term average
- 31:46growth rate isn't enough. Correct.
- 31:48Therefore the market must be pricing in accelerated growth
- 31:52driven by AI. So we modeled the most
- 31:55aggressive front loaded AI success case we could justify
- 31:58from the research. We assume free cash flow grows
- 32:01at an accelerating rate of 15% for the next 5 years, then fades
- 32:06only modestly to 10% for the remaining 5.
- 32:08That is a highly aggressive, optimistic forecast that
- 32:12requires the AI CapEx wall to pay off immediately and generate
- 32:15massive sustained cash flow growth.
- 32:17What is the intrinsic value per share under this ideal scenario?
- 32:21Under this most optimistic aggressive AI success case, the
- 32:25intrinsic value per share rises to $479.13.
- 32:29Wait, let me repeat that figure, because it's the linchpin of
- 32:32this entire Dick dive, $479.13 and the stock is currently
- 32:39trading right around 470 to 474. This is the critical defining
- 32:44take away. The current market price aligns
- 32:46almost perfectly within a few dollars with the most
- 32:49aggressive, optimistic DCF scenario.
- 32:53This model assumes the AI transition is a complete,
- 32:55sustained success and generates double digit FCF growth for a
- 33:00full decade. That means the market has priced
- 33:02in perfection. There is no room for error.
- 33:04Exactly. When the theoretical fair value
- 33:07based on the most aggressive growth assumptions perfectly
- 33:09matches the current trading price, it signals that the stock
- 33:12offers literally 0 margin of safety.
- 33:15If anything goes wrong, if regulatory risk materializes, if
- 33:18the CapEx wall takes longer to pay off, the stock is instantly
- 33:22overpriced. And investor buying today is
- 33:24simply betting that Microsoft will execute its most optimistic
- 33:27forecast perfectly for 10 years. Which is a high stakes
- 33:29proposition indeed. It is.
- 33:31Remember that Buffett himself famously said it's far better to
- 33:34buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company
- 33:37at a wonderful price. Microsoft is a wonderful
- 33:41company, but today's price is not merely fair, it is demanding
- 33:44absolute perfection. To summarize our comprehensive
- 33:48findings, we established that Microsoft is an elite quality
- 33:51business. It passes virtually all the
- 33:53rigorous tests for margins, debt, safety, and compounding
- 33:56capital. It is, by all measures, an
- 33:58unquestionable wonderful business.
- 34:01However, it fails every single quantitative value test.
- 34:04The market is paying a hefty premium assuming a high teens
- 34:07growth rate for many years to come.
- 34:09At the current price, near $470 per share, the stock offers 0
- 34:13margin of safety for the prudent conservative investor.
- 34:16For you, the learner, this deep dive provides the classic
- 34:19essential distinction between a great company and a great stock.
- 34:22Microsoft is a compounding machine, a foundational digital
- 34:25utility. But today's analysis shows you
- 34:28are paying full exuberant AI success driven price for that
- 34:32machine. This leaves little room for
- 34:34error if the AI CapEx wall anxite the fear of massive
- 34:37spending not translating immediately into massive high
- 34:39margin revenue turns into a growth reality check.
- 34:42You are buying high certainty, but at a very high price.
- 34:45And that leads to our final provocative thought for you to
- 34:47consider the question that will define the next decade for MSFT.
- 34:52Microsoft is currently investing 1/4's worth of revenue into
- 34:55capital expenditure, 35 billion and one quarter to maintain its
- 34:59leadership. If the market's assumption is
- 35:02correct, it will be the utility provider of the next economic
- 35:04cycle printing cash. But if the massive
- 35:08infrastructure spending required for AI becomes a permanent
- 35:10structural cost of doing business, can Microsoft's
- 35:13profitability ever return to the capital light 40% plus operating
- 35:17margin structure that fueled its historic margin expansion?
- 35:21Or is the new reality one of lower margins but higher scale?
- 35:25That is the multi trillion dollar question the market has
- 35:27seemingly already answered, but which remains untested by
- 35:30reality. And finally, a crucial reminder,
- 35:34all analysis presented is based on publicly available sources
- 35:37and may be subject to revisions or different interpretations.
- 35:40Remember, this content is for educational and informational
- 35:43purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 35:47Please conduct your own due diligence with a licensed
- 35:49financial advisor before making any investment decisions.
- 35:52And once again, if you want to track the total market
- 35:54temperature, we welcome you to search and download the iOS app
- 35:57Buffett Indicator from the Apple App Store.
- 35:59It is a fantastic resource for assessing overall market
- 36:02valuation.