Latest / Bloomberg Law / Weekend Law: SBF Convicted, 'Trump Too Small' & Social Media
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: It was a spectacular fall from grace. Just last year,
- 0:14Speaker 2: Sam Bankman Fried was running a crypto empire estimated to
- 0:18Speaker 2: be worth tens of billions of dollars, with the lifestyle
- 0:21Speaker 2: of a celebrity. Now he's a convicted felon for what
- 0:25Speaker 2: federal prosecutors described as one of the biggest financial frauds
- 0:29Speaker 2: in American history. A jury found him guilty on Thursday
- 0:33Speaker 2: night of all seven criminal charges against him. Bloomberg Legal
- 0:37Speaker 2: reporter Ava Benny Morrison says Bankman freed was stoic as
- 0:41Speaker 2: the verdicts were read out, them very still.
- 0:44Speaker 3: He had his eyes cast down. The jury walked in,
- 0:47Speaker 3: took their places in the jury box. The judge asked
- 0:50Speaker 3: Sam to stand up and face the jury. He had
- 0:52Speaker 3: his hands clasped in front of him, kept these eyes
- 0:55Speaker 3: towards the floor or the desk in front of him.
- 0:57Speaker 3: As the guilty verdicts were read out. He was very
- 1:00Speaker 3: feel emotionless that his parents looked like they were quite
- 1:03Speaker 3: overwhelmed that was sitting in the public gallery. He made
- 1:06Speaker 3: his way from Sam, date held each other. He fathered
- 1:09Speaker 3: almost doubled over as his mother put a company hand
- 1:13Speaker 3: on his back.
- 1:14Speaker 2: Manhattan US attorney Damian Williams called the verdict a warning.
- 1:18Speaker 4: This is what relentless looks like. This case moved at
- 1:22Speaker 4: lightning speed. That was not a coincidence, that was a choice.
- 1:28Speaker 4: And it's also a message. It's a warning this case
- 1:32Speaker 4: to every single fraudster out there who thinks that they're untouchable.
- 1:36Speaker 2: My guest is former federal prosecutor Michael Weinstein of Coal Shots. Michael,
- 1:42Speaker 2: the jury deliberated for only about four hours. What's your
- 1:45Speaker 2: reaction to such a quick verdict?
- 1:48Speaker 5: Not surprised? The evidence was insurmountable for the defense, and
- 1:52Speaker 5: the jury obviously agreed. The government made this case almost simplistic.
- 1:57Speaker 5: They did not get into the issue of cryptocurrency and
- 2:01Speaker 5: all the nuances of cryptocurrency. They brought it as a simplified,
- 2:05Speaker 5: straight out broadcase, and that's pretty easily digestible for a jury,
- 2:11Speaker 5: and their witnesses were prepped to foster that kind of
- 2:15Speaker 5: criminal activity. And so when it goes to the jury
- 2:18Speaker 5: and there's overwhelming documentary evidence, there's overwhelming testimony, and the
- 2:23Speaker 5: defense takes the stand and he's just not credible, or
- 2:26Speaker 5: if he is, it's pretty watered down. That leads to
- 2:29Speaker 5: a quick verdict.
- 2:30Speaker 2: When the defendant takes the stand, it's all about his credibility,
- 2:34Speaker 2: and we've talked about how risky it is, but I
- 2:37Speaker 2: don't see that he had much choice here but to
- 2:39Speaker 2: take the stand. Do you think, looking back, the defense
- 2:43Speaker 2: is regretting that now.
- 2:45Speaker 5: I don't think so. I think, as you said, they
- 2:47Speaker 5: had very little, if any choice. If he did not
- 2:50Speaker 5: take the stand, his narrative, his story would never have
- 2:53Speaker 5: come out, and his perspective and his denials would never
- 2:57Speaker 5: have been entered into evidence. It didn't work. I still
- 3:00Speaker 5: think the defense had no choice.
- 3:02Speaker 2: The three witnesses who flipped were the heart of the
- 3:05Speaker 2: prosecution's case, the star witnesses, and the defense tried to
- 3:08Speaker 2: cast doubt on their credibility, But prosecutors make their cases
- 3:12Speaker 2: on these kinds of witnesses, and it seemed that the
- 3:15Speaker 2: jurors believe them. Was there anything the defense could have
- 3:19Speaker 2: done to hurt their credibility?
- 3:21Speaker 5: Certainly the defense could have been more aggressive with them
- 3:24Speaker 5: and tried to chip away, if not take them out
- 3:27Speaker 5: in some ways and articulate perhaps that they were doing
- 3:30Speaker 5: this in order to get a better sentence, or they
- 3:32Speaker 5: were doing this because they were vindictive, or they were
- 3:34Speaker 5: a jilted lover in miss Ellison's case, things of that nature.
- 3:38Speaker 5: But the downside of doing that is, you know, the
- 3:40Speaker 5: jury turns on you as the defendant, and so the
- 3:43Speaker 5: defense has a delicate balance. You know, they want to
- 3:45Speaker 5: be aggressive, they want to make sure they undermine the
- 3:47Speaker 5: testimony of the cooperating witnesses, but they don't want to
- 3:50Speaker 5: go so much overboard that the jury turns off to that.
- 3:52Speaker 2: Do you see anything else that the defense could have
- 3:55Speaker 2: done in this case?
- 3:57Speaker 5: I think they were in a very, very uphill battle.
- 4:00Speaker 5: It was kind of doomed from the start. Could they
- 4:02Speaker 5: have been more aggressive, perhaps, Could they have prepared their
- 4:04Speaker 5: client a little bit longer and a little bit more precisely, perhaps,
- 4:09Speaker 5: But you know, he had said a lot of things
- 4:10Speaker 5: for months and years prior, so it didn't really matter
- 4:13Speaker 5: how much they prepped him because he had already said
- 4:15Speaker 5: things on the record and through spack messages and through
- 4:18Speaker 5: emails and through congressional testimony which came back and haunted him.
- 4:22Speaker 5: So there really was not much more they could have
- 4:24Speaker 5: done other than try to get some of the witnesses
- 4:28Speaker 5: in that were rejected by the judge, and that might
- 4:31Speaker 5: have changed the dynamics of the case.
- 4:33Speaker 2: And Michael, if you add up all the possible sentence
- 4:36Speaker 2: as it comes to something like a one hundred and
- 4:38Speaker 2: ten years or more, what's a more likely sentence for
- 4:41Speaker 2: Sam Bankman.
- 4:42Speaker 5: Freed, He's looking at decades in prison, no doubt he
- 4:45Speaker 5: will not see the light of day, whether it's the
- 4:48Speaker 5: Bahamian light of day or the US light of day.
- 4:50Speaker 5: For well, when he's an older man.
- 4:53Speaker 2: That seems like a lot of time for a white
- 4:55Speaker 2: collar crime. Elizabeth Holmes only got eleven years time.
- 5:00Speaker 5: But you know this is the generation X, you know
- 5:02Speaker 5: madeoff and you have to really look at the cryptocurrency
- 5:07Speaker 5: space and it's the wild left. And you know, in
- 5:10Speaker 5: almost no scenario is it ever appropriate to use customer
- 5:15Speaker 5: funds for your own benefit. And that's simply what happened,
- 5:18Speaker 5: and there was just no justification for that.
- 5:21Speaker 2: And what about the three witnesses who turned on him
- 5:23Speaker 2: and flipped. I mean, cooperators often get good deals. My
- 5:29Speaker 2: mind always goes to Sammy the Bull Gravano, who got
- 5:32Speaker 2: only five years in prison despite confessing to nineteen murders,
- 5:36Speaker 2: and Gary Wang said on the stand he's hoping for
- 5:40Speaker 2: ideally no time in prison.
- 5:42Speaker 5: Right, he may hope that, but that may not be realistic.
- 5:45Speaker 5: I'm not so sure that they're going to get no
- 5:46Speaker 5: time in prison. I think their involvement and the types
- 5:50Speaker 5: of charge that they pled guilty to larrence, specifically jail time. Yes,
- 5:54Speaker 5: they were cooperating witnesses, and yes, they gave testimony which
- 5:57Speaker 5: ultimately was a huge, tremendous fact or in the defendant's conviction.
- 6:01Speaker 5: And that's something that their defense attorneys will draw out
- 6:04Speaker 5: before the judge and will argue with the government that
- 6:07Speaker 5: they should warrant a downward departure and they should warrant
- 6:10Speaker 5: a variance in any kind of potential sentence. I think
- 6:13Speaker 5: the three of them were really the three nails in
- 6:16Speaker 5: the coffin for dam Bankman free, and at the end
- 6:19Speaker 5: of the day, their testimony was just too insurmountable. Do
- 6:22Speaker 5: I think they're going to go to jail?
- 6:23Speaker 2: Yes? And is the government likely to try to force
- 6:26Speaker 2: the three cooperators to pay restitution.
- 6:30Speaker 5: I believe so. The government's going to look and see
- 6:32Speaker 5: how they benefited from their criminal activity, and often is
- 6:35Speaker 5: any condition of a criminal sentence, the government will require
- 6:39Speaker 5: restitution back to the victims. So if the three cooperating
- 6:42Speaker 5: defendants benefited from the criminal activity, the government will try
- 6:47Speaker 5: to recoup some of that money that's from other fights.
- 6:49Speaker 5: You know, what is the extent of the money that
- 6:51Speaker 5: the government wants paid back? The defense lawyers are going
- 6:54Speaker 5: to say, well, there's very little money or no money.
- 6:56Speaker 5: They didn't benefit and look at you know how much
- 6:58Speaker 5: they cooperated with the trial and the benefits that the
- 7:00Speaker 5: government received from them providing testimony. The government's going to say,
- 7:04Speaker 5: all that is true, and yes they did cooperate, and
- 7:06Speaker 5: yes they provided helpful testimony, but that still doesn't mean
- 7:09Speaker 5: that they shouldn't pay back the money that came from
- 7:11Speaker 5: the criminal activity.
- 7:13Speaker 2: These cooperators made a lot of money. Caroline Ellison testified
- 7:16Speaker 2: that one year she made twenty million dollars as a bonus.
- 7:19Speaker 2: Nisad Singh has already agreed to surrender a three point
- 7:23Speaker 2: seven million dollar house he bought and shares in an
- 7:27Speaker 2: artificial intelligence startup that he paid forty million dollars for.
- 7:31Speaker 2: Does the government know where the money is to be
- 7:34Speaker 2: able to force restitution?
- 7:36Speaker 5: Yeah, and that's a lot of money. And that's excessive.
- 7:38Speaker 5: But again, that is just monopoly money for these three
- 7:42Speaker 5: or four people running the business at the time. It's
- 7:45Speaker 5: no different if they were twenty years old and out
- 7:47Speaker 5: of college or in college, didn't around drinking beers on
- 7:49Speaker 5: a Friday night playing monopoly. To them, twenty million dollars
- 7:53Speaker 5: was just a Friday night. And so do I think
- 7:55Speaker 5: the government has tracked that money? Yes? Do I think
- 7:58Speaker 5: the government knows where the money went? I think a
- 8:00Speaker 5: majority of it. And that's the problem that the defendants
- 8:03Speaker 5: that played guilty that are going to have, is that
- 8:05Speaker 5: the government knows how much they had at their disposal,
- 8:07Speaker 5: how much was given or taken by them, and the
- 8:10Speaker 5: government's going to go after it and try to take it.
- 8:12Speaker 2: Let's talk about the possibilities on appeal. For example, the
- 8:15Speaker 2: judge ruled against bankman freed on several pretrial motions, holding
- 8:20Speaker 2: he couldn't call seven I think it was expert witnesses
- 8:23Speaker 2: to testify, and then during the trial he held that
- 8:26Speaker 2: mini testimony and decide he couldn't use the advice of
- 8:30Speaker 2: council defense. Do any of those seem like winning appellate arguments?
- 8:35Speaker 5: I think they're interesting. Do I think that they're going
- 8:38Speaker 5: to carry the day on appeal at the Second Circuit.
- 8:41Speaker 5: I think the answer is no. Certainly, his defense lawyers
- 8:44Speaker 5: are going to make a robust attempt, but you know
- 8:46Speaker 5: the government's going to have arguments and opposition. The judge's
- 8:49Speaker 5: given some latitude and discretion under the federal rules of
- 8:52Speaker 5: evidence to make a decision based on those types of issues.
- 8:56Speaker 5: So I do not foresee the Second Circuit overturning the conviction.
- 9:00Speaker 2: The US Attorney Damian Williams gave a little press conference
- 9:03Speaker 2: last night and said that the case was a warning
- 9:07Speaker 2: to fraudsters. We've heard similar warnings from other US attorneys.
- 9:11Speaker 2: Do these kinds of statements have any impact on white
- 9:14Speaker 2: collar crime?
- 9:15Speaker 5: No, it sounds great, it's wonderful before the media. It's
- 9:18Speaker 5: something that a federal prosecutor, especially leading the US Attorney's
- 9:21Speaker 5: Office for the Southern District of New York, should say
- 9:24Speaker 5: and must say. He has to let it be known
- 9:26Speaker 5: that there's a sheriff in town and he's going to
- 9:28Speaker 5: patrol and make sure that the public's protected. But if
- 9:31Speaker 5: you look back on the history of you know, frauds
- 9:33Speaker 5: in the last forty years, starting with Michael Milkin, going
- 9:36Speaker 5: to the Enron scandal, then going to Bertie Madoff, and
- 9:40Speaker 5: now ending up with Sam Bankment freed. There's a pattern
- 9:43Speaker 5: here in every ten or twelve years, you know, there's
- 9:45Speaker 5: another big prosecution that's brought by the US Attorney's officers,
- 9:49Speaker 5: and it re emphasizes the point that there's fraud and
- 9:52Speaker 5: there's people that commit crimes, and the government is there
- 9:54Speaker 5: to regulate and to be the sheriff and to say no,
- 9:57Speaker 5: that's not appropriate.
- 9:58Speaker 2: And the judge will sentence Sam Bankman freed in March.
- 10:01Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Michael. That's Michael Weinstein of Coal Shots.
- 10:05Speaker 2: Coming up next. Should public officials be allowed to block
- 10:09Speaker 2: you on social media? I'm June Grosso and you're listening
- 10:12Speaker 2: to Bloomberg.
- 10:13Speaker 6: That's what makes these cases hard is that they are
- 10:15Speaker 6: First Amendment interests all over the place.
- 10:17Speaker 2: And not only are their First Amendment issues all over
- 10:20Speaker 2: the place, as Justice Elena Kagan put it, but the
- 10:23Speaker 2: justices questions seemed to be all over the place as well.
- 10:27Speaker 2: As they considered whether two school board members in San
- 10:31Speaker 2: Diego and a city manager in Michigan could block followers
- 10:35Speaker 2: who are criticizing them from their social media accounts. The
- 10:39Speaker 2: central question is whether the social media activity constitutes state action,
- 10:44Speaker 2: making it subject to the First Amendment, and the Justices
- 10:48Speaker 2: presented a host of scenarios to the attorneys. Here are
- 10:52Speaker 2: Justices Sonya Sotomayor and Brett Kavanaugh.
- 10:55Speaker 7: So let's assume a mayor says I'm setting up a
- 10:59Speaker 7: hotline for emergencies on my Facebook or Twitter, and if
- 11:06Speaker 7: you have an emergency, call that hotline and I will
- 11:10Speaker 7: use the power of my office to set in motion
- 11:15Speaker 7: government response for your emergency. Seems to me that that's
- 11:21Speaker 7: government faction, isn't it.
- 11:23Speaker 8: But suppose the city manager on the personal site says,
- 11:27Speaker 8: we have new recycling rules. You have to use a
- 11:30Speaker 8: blue bin, has to be at the curb, will be
- 11:33Speaker 8: picked up on Wednesdays. If you have any questions, contact me.
- 11:37Speaker 8: That's only on the personal site, not on the official site.
- 11:41Speaker 8: That's state action.
- 11:42Speaker 2: Joining me is Professor Eric Golman, co director of the
- 11:45Speaker 2: High Tech Law Institute at Santa Clara University Law School.
- 11:49Speaker 2: Eric explained the main issue in these cases.
- 11:53Speaker 9: The quir issue is what should happen when government officials
- 11:57Speaker 9: maintain social media accounts. Can they treat it as if
- 12:01Speaker 9: they're ordinary citizens or are they governed by the rules
- 12:05Speaker 9: that apply to government generally, and are the issues in
- 12:08Speaker 9: the two cases before the court basically the same. They're
- 12:12Speaker 9: basically the same. There are little details about exactly how
- 12:16Speaker 9: the particular government officials were using their social medi accounts
- 12:20Speaker 9: that might matter to the final conclusion, but the core
- 12:23Speaker 9: questions the court's asking and the legal test it's likely
- 12:26Speaker 9: to adopt are probably going to be the same.
- 12:28Speaker 2: So let's talk about the concerns of some of the justices,
- 12:32Speaker 2: and Justice Elena Kagan said there are First Amendment interests
- 12:36Speaker 2: all over the place.
- 12:37Speaker 9: I thought that was a really great line, honestly, just
- 12:40Speaker 9: as Kaigan has just such a great way of turning phrases,
- 12:43Speaker 9: and she's absolutely right their First Amendment considerations on all sides.
- 12:47Speaker 9: It's not like there's an easy path forward that balances
- 12:51Speaker 9: all the respective interests. On the one hand, people who
- 12:54Speaker 9: work for the government should be free to engage their
- 12:57Speaker 9: communities and express themselves publicly as private citizens. That's the
- 13:01Speaker 9: constitutionally protected right. They don't give up that right by
- 13:04Speaker 9: going to work for the government. On the other hand,
- 13:07Speaker 9: when the government controls online discourse spaces where people are
- 13:12Speaker 9: talking to each other, there's a really real and significant
- 13:17Speaker 9: risk of censorship. And so the concern is that if
- 13:21Speaker 9: the government officials can act like private individuals, they can
- 13:24Speaker 9: functionally censor conversations. Now, if they're acting in the private
- 13:28Speaker 9: individual they're allowed to do that, but it's acting the government,
- 13:31Speaker 9: they're not. And so, either we're going to circumscribe the
- 13:34Speaker 9: free speech rights of government employees, or we're going to
- 13:38Speaker 9: allow government eployees to circumvent the free speech rights of
- 13:41Speaker 9: the people who want to engage with them. Somebody is
- 13:44Speaker 9: going to lose something here.
- 13:45Speaker 2: So to me, it seems like, you know, if you're
- 13:48Speaker 2: posting public information on a website, on a Facebook page,
- 13:54Speaker 2: that that should be open to the public and the
- 13:56Speaker 2: public able to comment, and if you want not to
- 13:59Speaker 2: do that, then have a private page as well.
- 14:02Speaker 9: Certainly those ideas came out. In fact, there are three
- 14:04Speaker 9: different categories of pages that a government official might have.
- 14:08Speaker 9: They may have an official government page, they may have
- 14:12Speaker 9: a campaign page, which is not part of their official
- 14:15Speaker 9: government duties but still is an important place for them
- 14:18Speaker 9: to evangelize the work they're doing. And they may have
- 14:21Speaker 9: a personal page that has nothing to do with their
- 14:24Speaker 9: role in government and figuring out which account is in
- 14:27Speaker 9: which category is something that is baffling to us as
- 14:31Speaker 9: citizens when we see our government officials online. And it's
- 14:34Speaker 9: also vexxing to the government officials because so often they
- 14:38Speaker 9: want to take their victory labs, they want to tout
- 14:40Speaker 9: their successes, and we aren't sure are they telling them
- 14:43Speaker 9: as official government policy, as a campaign promise, or just
- 14:47Speaker 9: because they're touting their own work as a private individual.
- 14:50Speaker 9: And the court didn't know how to approach that issue.
- 14:53Speaker 9: They understood the trade offs, but there was no clear
- 14:56Speaker 9: way to move forward that was going to satisfy everybody.
- 14:59Speaker 2: Do you think that they can come up with a
- 15:01Speaker 2: clear legal test here?
- 15:02Speaker 9: Honestly, no, there is no clear legal test. And I
- 15:06Speaker 9: think we can be a little bit more emphatic that
- 15:08Speaker 9: the different considerations include things like what's the employee's job
- 15:14Speaker 9: and what tools are available in social media to be
- 15:17Speaker 9: able to cold control conversations and which of those tools
- 15:20Speaker 9: was wielded, and how did the person describe or characterize
- 15:24Speaker 9: their account, and how much of the account was used
- 15:27Speaker 9: with official related postings versus personal postings, Like we need
- 15:31Speaker 9: a multi dimensional matrix to try to figure out where
- 15:34Speaker 9: to place all the different nodes in those questions. And
- 15:38Speaker 9: that's why, even with two cases in front of the
- 15:40Speaker 9: Supreme Court that they can use to compare and contrast,
- 15:43Speaker 9: they still don't have enough cases to cover the full
- 15:45Speaker 9: range of facts that are going to be implicated by
- 15:48Speaker 9: their ruling.
- 15:49Speaker 2: There were three hours, I believe, of oral arguments. Did
- 15:52Speaker 2: you see blocks of justices sort of coming to some
- 15:57Speaker 2: conclusions or.
- 15:59Speaker 9: Did you see any pad The short answer is no, Really,
- 16:02Speaker 9: the oral arguments were quite opaque about where the judges
- 16:05Speaker 9: are likely to end up, which is unusual. One would
- 16:08Speaker 9: have hoped that we would have been able to get
- 16:10Speaker 9: a clearer line from the oral arguments. Having said that,
- 16:12Speaker 9: there are two things that stood out to me. First
- 16:15Speaker 9: is that some justices seem to be gravittained around the test.
- 16:18Speaker 9: It was advocated by the Department of Justice and was
- 16:22Speaker 9: endorsed by the lawyers for the government employees about looking
- 16:26Speaker 9: at the duties of the government official and their authority
- 16:29Speaker 9: to speak on behalf of the government. And so Justice
- 16:31Speaker 9: Gore Such for example, at one point said it sounds
- 16:34Speaker 9: like we got consensus that's the right test. I don't
- 16:37Speaker 9: know if there was consensus, but it wouldn't surprise me
- 16:40Speaker 9: if the test looked something like that. At the end
- 16:43Speaker 9: of the oral arguments, Justice Kagan once again had a
- 16:46Speaker 9: really powerful turn of the phrase. She came and basically
- 16:49Speaker 9: blasted the government lawyers, saying that the government lawyers proposed
- 16:53Speaker 9: test was really out of sync with the importance of
- 16:57Speaker 9: social media to the government function and would limit the
- 17:01Speaker 9: ability of us as constituents or to be able to
- 17:04Speaker 9: defend our own interests when the government keeps embracing social media.
- 17:08Speaker 9: So I saw kind of two opposite approaches there, Justine
- 17:11Speaker 9: score Such saying, you know, sounds good to me, let's
- 17:13Speaker 9: go with the test that you proposed, and Justine Keagen
- 17:15Speaker 9: saying that test is actually really harmful to the future.
- 17:19Speaker 2: At times when we've had these oral arguments at the
- 17:22Speaker 2: Supreme Court involving you know, the Internet, texting, social media,
- 17:27Speaker 2: the justices have seemed to be a step behind, maybe
- 17:31Speaker 2: more than one step. Did they get all the social
- 17:33Speaker 2: media implications in these cases?
- 17:36Speaker 9: They really didn't. This was yet another example of how
- 17:39Speaker 9: the Internet baffles Supreme Court justices. And just to be clear,
- 17:43Speaker 9: we don't know how many Supreme Court justices spend time
- 17:46Speaker 9: on social media, but it's not like they do it publicly.
- 17:50Speaker 9: So they're just not familiar with social media at the
- 17:53Speaker 9: same degree that most of us, as everyday users are,
- 17:56Speaker 9: so it's not surprising that it's a little bit baffling
- 17:59Speaker 9: to them that they're not immersed in that is part
- 18:01Speaker 9: of their daily functions. There was a really awkward line
- 18:04Speaker 9: that came from Chief Justice Roberts where he talked about
- 18:07Speaker 9: social media described it as the gathering of protons, and
- 18:12Speaker 9: it was such a reductionist approach that social media is
- 18:15Speaker 9: just about the movement of electronic pulses on the Internet.
- 18:18Speaker 9: That's all it is. And it's kind of like saying
- 18:20Speaker 9: that Supreme Court opinions are just inc on a piece
- 18:24Speaker 9: of paper. It's a reductionist conclusion that isn't inherently wrong,
- 18:28Speaker 9: but it completely misunderstands the scope and the stakes at
- 18:32Speaker 9: issue in this case.
- 18:34Speaker 2: And this is the first of several social media clashes
- 18:39Speaker 2: that coming up this term involving the First Amendment and
- 18:42Speaker 2: how it applies to social media companies.
- 18:44Speaker 9: So, just to be clear, there's going to be a
- 18:47Speaker 9: steady stream of internet law cases going to the Supreme
- 18:50Speaker 9: Court and likely to be decided by the Supreme Court
- 18:53Speaker 9: over the next few years. We've had just this upswell
- 18:57Speaker 9: of legislation trying to regulate the Internet. Many of those
- 19:01Speaker 9: laws are going to end up before the Supreme Court.
- 19:03Speaker 9: So we're just kind of at the beginning of the
- 19:06Speaker 9: multi year cycle where the Supreme Court is going to
- 19:09Speaker 9: be regularly deciding the future of the Internet.
- 19:11Speaker 2: They might have to actually get on social media. Thanks Eric,
- 19:15Speaker 2: that's Eric Goleman, a professor at Santa Clara University School
- 19:18Speaker 2: of Law. Coming up, The Justices considered Trump too small
- 19:23Speaker 2: as a trademark.
- 19:24Speaker 10: This is Bloomberg, which hands hit my hands?
- 19:37Speaker 7: I've never heard of this one.
- 19:38Speaker 8: Look at those hands?
- 19:39Speaker 5: Are they small hands?
- 19:41Speaker 2: You may remember seven years ago when Donald Trump and
- 19:44Speaker 2: Senator Marco Rubio were engaged in locker room talk over
- 19:48Speaker 2: the size of Trump's hands. Now it's part of the
- 19:51Speaker 2: case before the Supreme Court. Attorney Steve Elster says he
- 19:55Speaker 2: has a free speech right to trademark the phrase Trump
- 19:59Speaker 2: too small to use on T shirts. The US Patent
- 20:02Speaker 2: and Trademark Office disagreed, and it appears that the Supreme
- 20:06Speaker 2: Court also disagrees. At oral arguments on Wednesday, Justice is
- 20:11Speaker 2: across the ideological divide suggested that denying Elster a trademark
- 20:15Speaker 2: for the phrase does not violate his free speech rights
- 20:19Speaker 2: for a host of reasons. Justice Katanji Brown Jackson discussed
- 20:23Speaker 2: the point of trademark.
- 20:24Speaker 6: Law and trademark is not about expression. Trademark is not
- 20:29Speaker 6: about the First Amendment in your and people's ability to speak.
- 20:32Speaker 6: Trademark is about source identifying and preventing consumer confusion.
- 20:38Speaker 2: Justice Sonya Sotomayor said that not getting a trademark does
- 20:42Speaker 2: not infringe on his speech.
- 20:44Speaker 7: As you're not talking about stopping the speech. You're talking
- 20:48Speaker 7: about not receiving government protection for activity that you would
- 20:53Speaker 7: like to heighten protection for. Doesn't stop you from selling.
- 20:57Speaker 7: It doesn't stop you from selling anywhere as much as
- 20:59Speaker 7: you want.
- 21:01Speaker 2: Justice Neil Gorsich pointed to history.
- 21:03Speaker 11: But at the end of the day, it's pretty hard
- 21:07Speaker 11: to argue that a tradition that's been around a long
- 21:11Speaker 11: long time since the founding, you know, common law type stuff,
- 21:16Speaker 11: is inconsistent with the First Amendment.
- 21:18Speaker 2: And the Chief Justice said that giving him a trademark
- 21:22Speaker 2: would have the effect of restricting the speech of other people.
- 21:25Speaker 8: Because the whole point of the trademark, of course, is
- 21:27Speaker 8: to prevent other people from doing the same thing.
- 21:30Speaker 10: So if you win the slogan trump too small or whatever.
- 21:34Speaker 11: Other people can't.
- 21:35Speaker 5: Use it right.
- 21:36Speaker 2: The case revolves around a section of the LANIMAC that
- 21:39Speaker 2: requires written consent to use the name of a living
- 21:42Speaker 2: person in a trademark. Joining me to help explain it
- 21:45Speaker 2: all is intellectual property. Litigator Terrence Ross, a partner at
- 21:49Speaker 2: Katon Mutchen Rosenmann Terry tell us about the procedural background
- 21:54Speaker 2: of this case.
- 21:55Speaker 12: Mister Elsert thought trademark registration from the United States Trademark Office,
- 22:01Speaker 12: and the trademark examiner handling the application denied it as
- 22:06Speaker 12: a violation of the landam Act, which is the trademark laws.
- 22:10Speaker 12: Mister Elster then appealed within the Trademark Office, which confirmed
- 22:15Speaker 12: the denial, and mister Elster took it to the United
- 22:18Speaker 12: States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit here in DC.
- 22:20Speaker 12: The Federal Circuit unanimously reversed the decision of the Trademark
- 22:26Speaker 12: Office on constitutional grounds, had found that, at least as
- 22:29Speaker 12: applied in this case, section ten point fifty two SEA
- 22:34Speaker 12: of the Landham Act was unconstitutional in light of the
- 22:37Speaker 12: First Amendment, and the Trademark Office decided that this was
- 22:42Speaker 12: important enough to appeal to the Supreme Court of United States.
- 22:45Speaker 2: Elster's lawyer told the court that the government's sole interest
- 22:49Speaker 2: in denying the trademark is protecting the feelings of famous people,
- 22:53Speaker 2: but that's not a legitimate reason to burden protected speech.
- 22:57Speaker 2: How did his arguments strike you of me as being weak?
- 23:01Speaker 2: In many ways?
- 23:02Speaker 12: I thought it was extraordinarily weak. My reaction was that
- 23:07Speaker 12: mister Alistair's counsel did not do a very good job.
- 23:10Speaker 12: It was pointed out in the press that this was
- 23:13Speaker 12: his very first argument to the Supreme Court, but quite frankly,
- 23:16Speaker 12: he came across as as a first a pallot argument
- 23:18Speaker 12: in a sword. And indeed his response to this question
- 23:22Speaker 12: was really a hail mary, because he was unable to
- 23:26Speaker 12: answer a previous question from Justice Kagan. Justice Kagan had
- 23:31Speaker 12: asked him for any case that he could think of
- 23:35Speaker 12: in which the conveying of a government benefit in a
- 23:39Speaker 12: position neutral viewpoint had been held to be unconstitutional. You know,
- 23:44Speaker 12: it was crickets in the room.
- 23:45Speaker 2: He had nothing, nothing except maybe a sinking feeling.
- 23:49Speaker 12: Yeah, when just so might work asked this, he went
- 23:51Speaker 12: for his press conference SoundBite, which was, Oh, we can't
- 23:55Speaker 12: be protecting the feelings of famous people. Oh, you know,
- 23:58Speaker 12: that's actually not what the stat is about. And it
- 24:01Speaker 12: helps sometimes to read the actual wording of a statute
- 24:06Speaker 12: here fifteen Usc. Ten fifty two to see essentially bars
- 24:10Speaker 12: registration of a trademark. That quote consists of, or comprises
- 24:14Speaker 12: a name, portrait, or signature identifying a particular living individual
- 24:19Speaker 12: except by his written consent. This applies to everybody, applies
- 24:22Speaker 12: to you, applies to me, applies to listeners. A living
- 24:25Speaker 12: person's name and lateness can't be used to promote another product,
- 24:30Speaker 12: and this is fundamental to trademark lok. Going back into
- 24:33Speaker 12: the common law is known as passing off. You know,
- 24:36Speaker 12: it's claiming that some famous person had blessed this product
- 24:39Speaker 12: or was associated with it. And so it was very
- 24:42Speaker 12: much sort of an absurd response to Justice so too,
- 24:45Speaker 12: my org and really reflected a core problem with their argument,
- 24:51Speaker 12: which Justice Thomas identified quickly. He asked just straight out
- 24:56Speaker 12: what's the burden on free speech here, and really didn't
- 25:00Speaker 12: get an answer because simple fact that, as you said,
- 25:04Speaker 12: people are already using this slogan everywhere. The fact that
- 25:07Speaker 12: you don't get registration does not mean you can't use
- 25:10Speaker 12: the slogan. And mister Elster himself has already been using it.
- 25:14Speaker 12: All it means is that he's been denied the benefit
- 25:16Speaker 12: of registration, which is the ability to exclude, in certain circumstances,
- 25:20Speaker 12: third parties from using his slogan.
- 25:22Speaker 2: And the Chief Justice John Roberts pointed out that giving
- 25:26Speaker 2: him a trademark would have the effect of restricting speech
- 25:31Speaker 2: by other people who want to use that slogan.
- 25:34Speaker 12: And I think it's a fair point to make that.
- 25:37Speaker 12: In effect, by granting the trademark registration here, because of
- 25:42Speaker 12: the unique category in which it fought, it really does
- 25:47Speaker 12: limit other people's free speech because this slogan Trump too
- 25:52Speaker 12: Small is apparently commonly used by folks who are opposing
- 25:56Speaker 12: former President Trump's candidacy.
- 25:58Speaker 10: So, Jerry, we.
- 25:59Speaker 2: Always say you can't tell from their oral arguments how
- 26:02Speaker 2: the Court is going to rule, but it seemed to
- 26:04Speaker 2: me that justices across the ideological spectrum we're against giving
- 26:10Speaker 2: this phrase trademark protection.
- 26:13Speaker 12: I agree with that. My count was that there was
- 26:16Speaker 12: a clear majority skeptical of granting registration, and I agree
- 26:20Speaker 12: with your comment. It's hard to always read or arguments,
- 26:23Speaker 12: but in this case, particularly, the tonalities of the justice's
- 26:29Speaker 12: questions really reflect it pretty hardened positions antagonistic to any
- 26:35Speaker 12: type of register this my count had Justice Thomas, Justice
- 26:39Speaker 12: Sodomi or Justice Kagan, and Chief Justice roberts As all skeptical,
- 26:45Speaker 12: if not outright saying they were opposed to registration here.
- 26:49Speaker 12: In addition, I had Justice Gorsich and Alito disagreeing with
- 26:53Speaker 12: mister Elster's council on different grounds. They historically are opposed
- 26:58Speaker 12: to this notion that trademark confers a government benefit. So
- 27:02Speaker 12: by my account, that's six justices who seem pretty firmly
- 27:06Speaker 12: opposed to registration of this trademark. And I really couldn't
- 27:10Speaker 12: count that maybe the other justices as being in favor.
- 27:13Speaker 12: They just seem to not express an opinion one way
- 27:15Speaker 12: or the other. So sick zippy is a pretty good
- 27:18Speaker 12: starting point for the government here.
- 27:20Speaker 2: So that leads me to the question, how did a
- 27:24Speaker 2: unanimous panel of the Federal Circuit allow this trademark?
- 27:28Speaker 12: Jude, We could spend a lot of time on decisions
- 27:32Speaker 12: by the Federal Circuit where I practice a lot, by
- 27:35Speaker 12: the way, and the level of disrespect according to those
- 27:38Speaker 12: decisions by the Spring Court in the United States, true,
- 27:40Speaker 12: I mean the mere fact that this decision came out
- 27:43Speaker 12: of the Federal Circuit probably starts off with, you know,
- 27:47Speaker 12: points in the government's favor here, because the Supreme Court
- 27:50Speaker 12: just doesn't respect decisions, most significant decisions coming out of
- 27:55Speaker 12: Federal Circuit. The history of reversal is just phenomenal. And
- 27:59Speaker 12: so those of us who priss the Federal Circuit regular
- 28:01Speaker 12: basis say, Okay, you get granted search the ri out
- 28:05Speaker 12: of the Federal Circuit, you got a good chance of winning.
- 28:08Speaker 12: This is another great example. But the Federal Circuit was
- 28:11Speaker 12: three zero in favor of mister Elster, and their views
- 28:16Speaker 12: were in large part based on an attempt to accord
- 28:21Speaker 12: their decision with what they perceived the Supreme Court wanted
- 28:24Speaker 12: based on prior cases involving the First Amendment trademark. And
- 28:28Speaker 12: it looks like once again they just plane got it wrong.
- 28:31Speaker 2: And in two of those prior cases, the court struck
- 28:34Speaker 2: down parts of the trademark law in favor of free speech,
- 28:39Speaker 2: one trademark involving an Asian rock band called the Slants
- 28:42Speaker 2: and another involving a clothing brand called fuct.
- 28:47Speaker 12: So if you look at those two cases, you would
- 28:49Speaker 12: have come away, as the Federal Circuit did, thinking that
- 28:52Speaker 12: the Supreme Court dislikes limits on trademark relating to some
- 28:57Speaker 12: form of speech, even if that's speed, which is really distasteful,
- 29:01Speaker 12: and in both those cases it was very distasteful. And
- 29:04Speaker 12: yet the Federal Circuit clearly misread what had happened before
- 29:09Speaker 12: and they just plane got it wrong. Here.
- 29:11Speaker 2: We'll see just how wrong when the decision comes out.
- 29:14Speaker 2: Thanks so much, Terry. That's Terence Ross of Catain Euchen
- 29:17Speaker 2: Rosenmann coming up. Jet Blue goes to trial with the government.
- 29:21Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg.
- 29:22Speaker 1: If not blocked, the merger of Jet Blue and Spirit
- 29:25Speaker 1: would result in higher fares and fewer choices for tens
- 29:29Speaker 1: of millions of travelers across the country. The Justice Department
- 29:34Speaker 1: is suing to prevent that from happening.
- 29:37Speaker 2: Attorney General Merrick Garland announced in March that the government
- 29:41Speaker 2: was suing to stop Jet Blue's three point eight billion
- 29:44Speaker 2: dollar takeover of Spirit Airlines, and on Tuesday, the trial
- 29:49Speaker 2: began before a federal judge in Boston. It will be
- 29:52Speaker 2: a test of the crackdown on airline consolidation at a
- 29:56Speaker 2: critical time for the industry, when domestic low cost care
- 30:00Speaker 2: have cut services as fair slide and travel slows joining
- 30:05Speaker 2: me from Boston is Bloomberg Intelligence senior litigation analyst Jenniferree,
- 30:09Speaker 2: who's covering the trial. Jen this isn't Jet Blue's first
- 30:13Speaker 2: run in with antitrust regulators. Why is the government trying
- 30:17Speaker 2: to stop this merger?
- 30:18Speaker 13: Well, you know, the government really sees this as reducing
- 30:22Speaker 13: output and increasing prices, or at least a deal that
- 30:24Speaker 13: would have the potential to do that in the industry
- 30:27Speaker 13: because Spirit is what's considered an ultra low cost airline
- 30:31Speaker 13: that offers a la carte options, and so if a
- 30:34Speaker 13: consumer wants to fly and really get the very lowest
- 30:36Speaker 13: price they can, they have the option of doing that
- 30:39Speaker 13: on Spirit and not buying the extras, the food or
- 30:41Speaker 13: the infight entertainment. Whereas Jet Blue has a different kind
- 30:44Speaker 13: of a model, and so jet Blue, if it takes
- 30:47Speaker 13: over Spirit, intends to change everything over to its own model.
- 30:51Speaker 13: All the airplanes would be retrofitted, so there'd be fewer seats,
- 30:55Speaker 13: so that means reduced output, and it would likely mean
- 30:57Speaker 13: increase fairs because Jet Blue's average tend to be over Spirits.
- 31:01Speaker 13: So overall, the Department of Justice is concerned about the
- 31:05Speaker 13: removal of this a la carte ultra low cost option.
- 31:08Speaker 2: Jet Blues lawyers said the companies account for just eight
- 31:12Speaker 2: percent of industry revenue. Even after the merger, Jet Blues
- 31:16Speaker 2: market share would rise to just seven percent from five percent.
- 31:21Speaker 2: I mean, is the government going after them because of
- 31:23Speaker 2: the decades of lax enforcement that have left four airlines
- 31:28Speaker 2: with eighty percent of the market.
- 31:29Speaker 13: Look, that's a good argument by Jet Blue, but I
- 31:32Speaker 13: think it's sort of a red herring because at the
- 31:34Speaker 13: end of the day, that national competition, that combined national
- 31:38Speaker 13: share isn't really relevant to the anti trust inquiry because
- 31:42Speaker 13: the anti trust inquiry looks at options for consumers, and
- 31:46Speaker 13: consumers that are trying to fly from let's say Boston
- 31:49Speaker 13: to Santa Fe don't care about the fact that combine
- 31:52Speaker 13: they're small nationally. If when they're shopping for their flights
- 31:55Speaker 13: they have fewer options and now the prices have gone up,
- 31:58Speaker 13: those consumers care about. So really, with airline deals, they
- 32:03Speaker 13: have to be looked at from city to city and
- 32:05Speaker 13: which airlines are competing on each of those routes. So
- 32:08Speaker 13: it's kind of like a lot of mini mergers.
- 32:10Speaker 2: Well what do you think Jet Blue's best argument was
- 32:14Speaker 2: in the openings?
- 32:15Speaker 13: Well, I think that their best argument is, and they've
- 32:17Speaker 13: done a good job with it that Look, at the
- 32:19Speaker 13: end of the day, we are going to increase competition
- 32:22Speaker 13: because we have a really tough time fighting against the
- 32:25Speaker 13: big legacy carriers Delta America and United and you can
- 32:29Speaker 13: throw Southwest in there too, that actually combined account for
- 32:33Speaker 13: about eighty percent of air travel and cost a lot
- 32:35Speaker 13: of money. We have lower fares than they do. And
- 32:38Speaker 13: by increasing Jet Blue, by making Jet Blue a bigger,
- 32:40Speaker 13: more viable competitor, we can exert more competitive pressure on
- 32:43Speaker 13: those legacy airlines and it pulls down their prices. It's
- 32:47Speaker 13: something that the Department of Justice has acknowledged called the
- 32:49Speaker 13: Jet Blue effect, and I think that the lawyers have
- 32:52Speaker 13: so far we're just at the beginning, effectively laid that
- 32:55Speaker 13: out and made that argument. And I think it's a
- 32:57Speaker 13: good argument because what it does is forces the judge
- 33:00Speaker 13: to kind of say, which is the better side, you know,
- 33:03Speaker 13: which is the bigger harm or the lesser harm? Is
- 33:05Speaker 13: it better to remove this ultra low cost option for
- 33:08Speaker 13: some real bargain conscious consumers, but end up, you know,
- 33:12Speaker 13: exerting more of a competitive influence on the legacy carriers.
- 33:15Speaker 13: Which side is stronger.
- 33:17Speaker 2: So if an airline could have a persecution complex, it
- 33:20Speaker 2: seems like Jet Blue would have one. It's the second
- 33:24Speaker 2: time that antitrust enforcers have stepped into a Jet Blue deal.
- 33:28Speaker 12: You know.
- 33:29Speaker 13: I think that it's the types of deals essentially that
- 33:32Speaker 13: Jet Blue has entered into. So, you know, if you
- 33:35Speaker 13: looked at the deal with American, I think that the
- 33:38Speaker 13: partnership went a little bit too far. They were also
- 33:41Speaker 13: collaborating on capacity, and they were collaborating on revenue rather
- 33:45Speaker 13: than just code sharing, and I think that that was
- 33:48Speaker 13: kind of what.
- 33:48Speaker 2: Doomed that, And the judge will decide whether this merger
- 33:51Speaker 2: is doomed as well. Thanks so much, Jen. That's Bloomberg
- 33:55Speaker 2: Intelligence Senior Litigation analyst Jenniferree. And that's it for this
- 33:59Speaker 2: edition of The Bloomberger. Remember you can always get the
- 34:02Speaker 2: latest legal news on our Bloomberg Law podcasts. You can
- 34:05Speaker 2: find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot
- 34:09Speaker 2: Bloomberg dot com, Slash podcast Slash Law, And remember to
- 34:13Speaker 2: tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten
- 34:16Speaker 2: pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso, and you're listening
- 34:20Speaker 2: to Bloomberg