Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Medicaid Reform
Transcript
- 0:09Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:10Shaw and we thank you so much
- 0:11for joining us this evening.
- 0:13Tonight we're discussing
- 0:15reforming Kentucky's Medicaid
- 0:16program. Proponents for
- 0:18transforming the program say
- 0:19the Medicaid budget has more
- 0:20than doubled over the last five
- 0:22years without a significant
- 0:24turnaround in health outcomes
- 0:25of the program's enrollees.
- 0:28House Bill two implements new
- 0:30federal community engagement or
- 0:31work requirements for certain
- 0:33low income beneficiaries,
- 0:35imposes co-pays and tighter
- 0:37eligibility redeterminations,
- 0:39which some of which causes
- 0:40concern for many health care
- 0:41access advocates. So here with
- 0:43us tonight in Lexington to
- 0:45tease out this complicated
- 0:46issue are state Senator Stephen
- 0:48Meredith, a Leitchfield
- 0:49Republican chair of the Senate
- 0:51Health Services Committee and
- 0:52member of the Medicaid
- 0:54Oversight and Advisory Board.
- 0:55Emily Beauregard, executive
- 0:57director for Kentucky Voices
- 0:59for health and State
- 1:01representative. Ken Fleming, a
- 1:02Louisville Republican and
- 1:03co-chair of the Medicaid
- 1:04Oversight and Advisory Board.
- 1:06Joining us from our Louisville
- 1:08studio is state Senator Karen
- 1:10Berg, a Louisville Democrat
- 1:12physician and member of the
- 1:13Senate Health Services
- 1:14Committee and Medicaid
- 1:16Oversight and Advisory Board.
- 1:17We certainly want to hear from
- 1:18you tonight. You can send your
- 1:20questions and comments by X,
- 1:22formerly Twitter, at Pub
- 1:23Affairs KET, or send an email
- 1:25to KY Tonight at KET dot o r g,
- 1:28or use the web form at KET dot
- 1:31Johnny Nash KY tonight. Or you
- 1:32can simply give us a call at
- 1:34one 800 494 7605. Well, welcome
- 1:38to all of our guests here in
- 1:39the studio and Senator Burke
- 1:41there in Louisville. We're so
- 1:42glad to have you talking about
- 1:43this very important issue.
- 1:45House Bill two. But before we
- 1:46talk about the issue itself, I
- 1:49just want to give our audience
- 1:51some perspective on what
- 1:53Medicaid looks like now. And
- 1:55I'll go to you first, Miss
- 1:56Emily Beauregard, about the
- 1:58folks. How many Kentuckians are
- 2:00on Medicaid, both expanded
- 2:03population and why we say
- 2:04expanded versus traditional and
- 2:06the services that they're
- 2:07receiving. And what would
- 2:09happen if there's some reform
- 2:10of the system, as we currently
- 2:12have before us now?
- 2:14>> So Medicaid has really
- 2:15become the cornerstone of our
- 2:16health care system in so many
- 2:19ways, not only because it
- 2:21covers 1 in 3 Kentuckians at
- 2:23any given time, but also
- 2:25because it's an economic driver.
- 2:26It covers many of the services
- 2:29that we all rely on here in
- 2:31Kentucky, keeping our hospital
- 2:33doors open. And it makes sure
- 2:36that we have a safety net for
- 2:37those moments when we least
- 2:39expect that we're going to need
- 2:40it. Accidents, injuries,
- 2:43tornadoes, flooding, those
- 2:44things that just pull the rug
- 2:45out from under your feet and
- 2:47leave you without the basics.
- 2:51So Medicaid is there when we
- 2:52need it most. At any given
- 2:55moment in someone's life. It's
- 2:58covering people cradle to grave.
- 3:01It's not a static number one
- 3:02and three Kentuckians use
- 3:04Medicaid at different points in
- 3:05their life. So about half of
- 3:07the babies born in Kentucky are
- 3:09born covered with Medicaid.
- 3:12Three and seven people with
- 3:14disabilities have Medicaid
- 3:15coverage, and about 70% of our
- 3:18loved ones in nursing homes are
- 3:20covered by Medicaid. So when we
- 3:23say cradle to grave, we don't
- 3:24mean that someone has Medicaid
- 3:26coverage for their entire lives.
- 3:28If you do, but it's that it's
- 3:30there for us when we need it.
- 3:32>> But of those 1 in 3. So
- 3:34you're saying it's not always
- 3:35the same people, but it's a
- 3:37hefty portion of the population?
- 3:38>> That's right. We have a lot
- 3:40of low wage workers in Kentucky
- 3:41and Medicaid. Is there
- 3:43providing coverage that their
- 3:44employers aren't and helping
- 3:46them to stay healthy enough to
- 3:48work?
- 3:48>> So I want to go to this side,
- 3:50representative Fleming, the
- 3:51value of Medicaid and the
- 3:53reform effort that you're
- 3:54putting forward in House Bill
- 3:56two, is it to cut people off of
- 3:59a public service that you think
- 4:01perhaps they may have abused,
- 4:03or what is the overall goal of
- 4:05House Bill two?
- 4:06>> Well, first of all, thank
- 4:07you very much for having us
- 4:09here. This is a really very
- 4:10important issue we've got to
- 4:11address when it comes to
- 4:13Medicaid. You have to think of
- 4:15Medicaid. This the state is in
- 4:17the business of insurance
- 4:19company. We are insurance
- 4:20company. And so we need to take
- 4:22care of those folks, those
- 4:24individuals on the on the
- 4:25program. And what we're trying
- 4:26to do is to know we're not
- 4:28trying to cut any cut anybody
- 4:30off. We're trying to to
- 4:33maximize the services that are
- 4:34delivered to those who are
- 4:35least among us. And to do that,
- 4:37we need to look at an internal
- 4:39internally and what we're
- 4:40trying to accomplish, what
- 4:41we're trying to do. And there's
- 4:42a lot of challenges we have
- 4:44from the from the program
- 4:46itself when it comes to
- 4:47oversight, oversight, and
- 4:48making sure the program is
- 4:49delivered effectively and
- 4:51efficiently. And as you
- 4:52mentioned earlier, the cost is
- 4:53doubled. We know some of the
- 4:56reasons why. That's why this
- 4:57Medicaid board was was
- 4:59established last year in order
- 5:01to take a very deep dive
- 5:03approach, in order to make sure
- 5:04that the services that we have
- 5:06is being delivered in an
- 5:07efficient and effective way to
- 5:09help those least among us. And
- 5:11yes, there are many folks that
- 5:13do not have any income or they
- 5:15have very low income. And so we
- 5:17need to make sure that as our
- 5:19quote unquote, customer, but
- 5:21our, our citizens, they're our
- 5:22next door neighbors that we
- 5:23need to take care of and help
- 5:25them out to make sure that
- 5:26their health is maintained and
- 5:28the quality of services is
- 5:30delivered in the best way
- 5:31possible.
- 5:32>> But you have said in
- 5:33meetings and public hearings
- 5:35about this particular issue
- 5:36that and I even said it in the
- 5:38introduction about how the
- 5:40amount of money that's being
- 5:42invested into this program, the
- 5:45return in terms of health
- 5:46outcomes and improvement
- 5:47thereof, there's not very much
- 5:49evidence of that. You still
- 5:50stand by that?
- 5:52>> I do. When you look at where
- 5:54we are in ratings, well, we
- 5:55have not moved hardly at all in
- 5:58terms of overall ratings over
- 5:59the past 15 years. So the state
- 6:02has has opted we can do it
- 6:04internally or we can basically
- 6:06have another organization or
- 6:08organization to do that. That's
- 6:09the managed care organizations.
- 6:10And so we have put a lot of
- 6:12money into that process, and we
- 6:14have not seen the returns that
- 6:16we need to we need to achieve.
- 6:18That's why on House Bill two
- 6:19takes a really serious look at
- 6:23transparency, to look at some
- 6:24dashboard, to look at MCO
- 6:26contracts, you know, to look at
- 6:28other items in there to make
- 6:30sure that what are what are we
- 6:32doing? How are we going about
- 6:33doing this? And then basically
- 6:35make some changes in order to,
- 6:37you know, to help folks out.
- 6:39>> So Senator Berg and
- 6:40Louisville want to come to you
- 6:41now to get your overall view
- 6:43about House Bill two, that is
- 6:44in the possession of the Senate
- 6:46at this particular juncture.
- 6:48There's not been a hearing
- 6:49there yet, but we know we
- 6:51anticipate that to be coming.
- 6:52What are your overall thoughts
- 6:54based on what you understand
- 6:55about this measure?
- 7:01>> You know, overall, excuse me,
- 7:04House Bill two is is actually
- 7:07really a fairly aggressive
- 7:10attempt to. Hart. I don't want
- 7:18to say controlling to start
- 7:22impacting the number of people
- 7:27eligible for Medicaid in our
- 7:29state and how services are, how
- 7:35people will be able to stay in
- 7:36the program, what type of
- 7:37services they will be eligible
- 7:39for. And, you know, it's really.
- 7:49You can you can applaud Senator
- 7:52or Representative Fleming for
- 7:55really trying to take a big,
- 7:59big bite out of a very, very
- 8:04difficult problem.
- 8:07Unfortunately, it's it's too
- 8:09much too soon. And we need, I
- 8:14think, here in Kentucky to take
- 8:16two steps back, find out what
- 8:20we have to do according to the
- 8:22one big, beautiful bill at this
- 8:24point, what we need to do down
- 8:26the road, but we need to make
- 8:29sure that we maintain
- 8:32eligibility for people and that
- 8:34we do not have co-pays and
- 8:38community engagement
- 8:39requirements that basically
- 8:42keep people from accessing
- 8:44health care, because that's
- 8:46contrary to the purpose of
- 8:49Medicaid.
- 8:50>> And so just to clarify,
- 8:52because of the one big,
- 8:53beautiful bill, the HR one, the
- 8:56federal act that was passed by
- 8:59Congress, doesn't Kentucky have
- 9:01to comply with the work
- 9:04requirement and community
- 9:05engagement requirements.
- 9:07>> Yeah. You know, the one big,
- 9:10beautiful bill is, is a very
- 9:14large, very comprehensive piece
- 9:16of legislation that honestly,
- 9:18ideally should have been broken
- 9:20down into multiple smaller
- 9:22pieces and done with a little
- 9:24more attention to the impact of
- 9:30these requirements. What we've
- 9:33decided to do in Kentucky or
- 9:35what what HB two at this point
- 9:38does, I'm not sure that we're
- 9:40going to decide to do this by
- 9:41the end of the session. It it
- 9:44speeds up the requirements here
- 9:47in the state and actually goes
- 9:49way beyond a lot of what. House
- 9:55Bill one or the big, beautiful
- 9:57bill actually requires of us.
- 10:00So, for example, we are going
- 10:02to be instituting what some
- 10:05people want to call cost
- 10:07sharing, what other people want
- 10:08to call co-pays 21 months
- 10:13earlier than the federal
- 10:15government is going to require
- 10:17us to do that instead of
- 10:20meeting community engagement
- 10:22requirements within a three
- 10:23month period, we've decided,
- 10:25you know, you have to do it
- 10:26within a month, which is not
- 10:28feasible because people don't
- 10:29even know when they're going to
- 10:31get injured or sick. So you
- 10:33can't predict those dates.
- 10:38We're talking about a bill at
- 10:39this point, guys, that the
- 10:43estimates are it is going to
- 10:45cost us $141 million just to
- 10:52institute the changes that this
- 10:55bill is going to require us as
- 10:58a state to do. And, you know,
- 11:01most of this money comes from
- 11:02the federal government. The
- 11:04vast majority of Medicaid money
- 11:06is not state money, it's
- 11:09federal money. But still, we're
- 11:11talking about almost $40
- 11:13million in state money alone,
- 11:16just to start trying to
- 11:18institute the requirements of
- 11:19this bill when we don't even
- 11:21know that the federal
- 11:23government is going to continue
- 11:25these requirements. There is a
- 11:27lot of discussion that these
- 11:29parts of the bill are not going
- 11:32to achieve their goals and need
- 11:36to be readdressed. And when I
- 11:39say going to achieve their
- 11:40goals, when you talk about a
- 11:43$20 co-pay for somebody talking
- 11:46about a family of three with
- 11:50$27,000 annual income and a $20
- 11:53co-pay every time, every time
- 11:57you need to see a specialist.
- 11:58So for people in cancer
- 12:00treatment, for people in
- 12:02dialysis, you're you're talking
- 12:05about a large percentage of an
- 12:08income that is not adequate
- 12:11already to feed and house.
- 12:14>> So yeah, yeah, yeah. Well,
- 12:17I'm going to come back to you
- 12:19because I want to get our
- 12:20audience up. Yeah. There's a
- 12:22lot to dissect here. And before
- 12:23we kind of break down some of
- 12:25these provisions one by one,
- 12:26Chairman Meredith, I do want to
- 12:28come to you and ask you about
- 12:29your overall opinion about if
- 12:31Medicaid needs to be reformed.
- 12:32And is this the right direction,
- 12:34or do you agree with your
- 12:36Democratic counterpart that it
- 12:38goes too far, too fast?
- 12:40>> Well, we certainly need to
- 12:41address the issue with Medicaid.
- 12:42And I think H.R. one either
- 12:45gets too much credit or too
- 12:46much blame for the
- 12:47transformation we're seeing
- 12:48right now, because even if that
- 12:50bill had not been passed, I'm
- 12:52confident we would be doing
- 12:53similar things. Now that we're
- 12:56trying to accomplish. As is
- 12:57noted earlier, when I came to
- 12:59the Senate in 2017, our
- 13:01Medicaid budget was $10 billion.
- 13:03And I said then it's as large
- 13:05as it ever should be. If we're
- 13:07improving the health of the
- 13:08population, if we're getting
- 13:09people back to gainful
- 13:10employment and reducing the
- 13:11bureaucracy, there's enough
- 13:12money there. Roll it forward
- 13:13nine years. Now we're at $20
- 13:16billion, and it's just not
- 13:17Medicaid. Medicaid is kind of a
- 13:19microcosm of the health care
- 13:20delivery system. In total. It
- 13:22can't sustain itself. It's now
- 13:2420% of our state budget, and
- 13:27we're shifting funds away from
- 13:28other needed services, trying
- 13:29to meet the needs of the people.
- 13:31We're not getting the results
- 13:32that we need. So again, H.R.
- 13:35one, we had to make some
- 13:37federal mandates, but I don't
- 13:38think that's going to make the
- 13:40substantive changes to the
- 13:41program that are needed to let
- 13:42Medicaid survive.
- 13:44>> So let's break this down a
- 13:45little bit, chairman Fleming,
- 13:47about what's in the bill. Right.
- 13:50And let's talk about the cost
- 13:51sharing or co-pays. It's $20
- 13:54for each visit.
- 13:56>> Well, let's, let's, let's
- 13:57put things in a, in a more of a
- 14:00perspective. First of all, the
- 14:02bill has been broken into two
- 14:04components. One is a is address
- 14:05that what's coming down the
- 14:06feds on H11 in terms of
- 14:09adjusting that. The other one
- 14:10is program interrogate
- 14:11integrity. So we need to go
- 14:12through and look at those two
- 14:14items in a very expeditious but
- 14:15thorough way. Now, when it was
- 14:19mentioned by, you know, the
- 14:21Senator Berg about the $20 and
- 14:22you just mentioned, that
- 14:23doesn't take effect until
- 14:25October 1st of 2028, we've got
- 14:28several a lot of time to go
- 14:30through and digest this, get
- 14:31more information, get a get an
- 14:34understanding of the data in
- 14:35terms of what's the impact and
- 14:37towards what that is. So right
- 14:39now, you know, it's a proposed
- 14:41at $20, but that's not gonna
- 14:42happen until October 1st of
- 14:442028. Now, when you look at the
- 14:46copays, there's only two items
- 14:48in the copays. One is $35 for
- 14:53in hospital services. The other
- 14:55one is $8 for individuals that
- 14:58are visiting emergency rooms
- 15:00for non-emergency services. So
- 15:01when you break that down, we're
- 15:04trying to change the mindset to
- 15:06get people to go see their
- 15:07primary care physician, because
- 15:10going that path, there is no
- 15:12co-pay. And so we're trying to
- 15:14trying to change that. So when
- 15:16you look at the cost of that
- 15:17right there, that's around $90
- 15:19million. We're trying we're
- 15:20we're looking at and trying to
- 15:21adjust address.
- 15:22>> So you're saying instead of
- 15:24folks using the emergency room
- 15:26for non-emergency issues, that
- 15:28you want them to establish a
- 15:30medical home by which they're
- 15:31seeing on a regular basis, a
- 15:33primary care general physician,
- 15:35right?
- 15:35>> Because because of the, the
- 15:36er doctors are they've got,
- 15:38they've got to handle a lot of
- 15:40things that are coming through
- 15:41the room. And so I would hate
- 15:43to see them see individuals sit
- 15:45there for hours on end where
- 15:47they can go and see a primary
- 15:48care physician. So that's,
- 15:49that's what we want to get to
- 15:51more of a holistic approach to
- 15:52really take care of the of the
- 15:54individual and try to figure
- 15:55out what their issue is.
- 15:56>> Okay, so let's put a pin
- 15:58there. Miss Bogut, what do you
- 16:00think of that? Well.
- 16:01>> I agree completely that we
- 16:02want everyone to have a medical
- 16:04home. And primary care is
- 16:06essential. It really should be
- 16:07foundational to our health care
- 16:08system. And we don't have
- 16:10nearly enough right now. And so
- 16:11when I think about how we
- 16:13incentivize people to get the
- 16:15right care at the right place
- 16:16at the right time and primary
- 16:18care before emergency care, we
- 16:21have to make that access easier
- 16:23for people. It has to be easier
- 16:25to go to your primary care
- 16:27doctor than to go to the E.R.
- 16:29And right now, it's faster for
- 16:31most people to get into the
- 16:33E.R. that's not the way our
- 16:34health care system should work.
- 16:36So that's one reason that I
- 16:38think we need to be careful
- 16:40about these copays, because
- 16:42while I appreciate the
- 16:44incentive to go to primary care,
- 16:45and I think the big, beautiful
- 16:47bill got that right, making
- 16:48sure to exempt primary care and
- 16:50behavioral health services was
- 16:51a good decision. What the big,
- 16:54beautiful bill didn't do is
- 16:56exempt people based on their
- 16:58health status. And so I think
- 17:00to Senator Berg's point a
- 17:02little bit earlier, someone who
- 17:03needs specialty care for really
- 17:05serious health conditions like
- 17:07cancer, for something like
- 17:09dialysis, they'll be paying
- 17:11copays for every service that
- 17:13they need. And that adds up
- 17:15very quickly. Now it is capped
- 17:17at 5% of your annual income.
- 17:20But for a family of four making
- 17:23$33,000 a year, that adds up to
- 17:27$1,650. And if people don't
- 17:29have that money at the point of
- 17:31service, they can be turned
- 17:32away. There are a lot of good
- 17:34providers out there who don't
- 17:35want to turn their patients
- 17:37away, but for $20 over and over
- 17:40and over again, they're going
- 17:41to be faced with a tough
- 17:43decision because a lot of our
- 17:45providers, hospitals especially,
- 17:46are going to see reduced
- 17:48reimbursements because of the
- 17:49big, beautiful bill. And I
- 17:51think that they're going to be
- 17:52in a hard position to take on
- 17:54more of that uncompensated care.
- 17:55>> Renee let me respond to that.
- 17:58I was a I was a provider. I ran
- 18:00a mental health center, and we
- 18:03took on the responsibility that
- 18:04we could waive that so
- 18:06providers can waive those,
- 18:07those co-pays, in addition to
- 18:09the Mcos can also waive that.
- 18:11You can set.
- 18:12>> Up what's the likelihood
- 18:13that many providers would do
- 18:14that.
- 18:15>> With the likelihood. You
- 18:16know, what I've I've talked to
- 18:18several that they're willing to
- 18:19do that. So, you know, so we're
- 18:21there to serve the individual
- 18:23and making sure that they're
- 18:24they get, you know, they're
- 18:26getting the service and or to
- 18:27do that. In addition to that,
- 18:29the, there are provisions that
- 18:31will provide the Secretary to
- 18:33waive those in case there are
- 18:35hardships and so forth, so they
- 18:36can go through and have those
- 18:38those those waived.
- 18:40>> So but there is a process by
- 18:42which they'd have to almost
- 18:43appeal that. Right. And how
- 18:44long would that take for and
- 18:46how long would that delay their
- 18:47their contact of care?
- 18:49>> Well, nobody's going to go
- 18:50to those extremes. I'm going to
- 18:51tell you quite candidly,
- 18:52particularly in the rural
- 18:53health care environment, copay
- 18:55equals no pay. And when we talk
- 18:58about it's great to go to your
- 18:59primary care physician. Super.
- 19:01Where are they in rural
- 19:03Kentucky, where we have 41%
- 19:05population, only 17% of our
- 19:07primary care physicians are
- 19:08there. And what drives them to
- 19:10E.R. more than anything, is a
- 19:11lack of primary care physicians.
- 19:136,070% of visits are primary
- 19:15care because of lack of access
- 19:17to primary care physicians. So
- 19:19this burden and I understand we
- 19:21have to do with the federal
- 19:23government. This burden is
- 19:24going to fall proportionately
- 19:25against rural health care
- 19:27providers who can stand the
- 19:29cuts the least. As you know,
- 19:31they already have their back up
- 19:32against the wall with
- 19:33projections. As many as 50% of
- 19:35our rural hospitals could close
- 19:37as a result of some of these
- 19:38changes. So that's not going to
- 19:40address that situation at all.
- 19:42I understand we have to comply,
- 19:44but I think we have to make it
- 19:46as minimal as we possibly can.
- 19:47>> Senator Berg, I think you
- 19:49wanted to jump in here.
- 19:54>> Well, just real quickly, I
- 19:57wanted to point out that in
- 19:592021, we passed a bill, Senate
- 20:01Bill 55, that eliminated cost
- 20:04sharing in the Medicaid program
- 20:06specifically because it wasn't
- 20:09cost effective. By the time you
- 20:12try to collect these co-pays,
- 20:16you spend more money trying to
- 20:18collect them than you actually
- 20:19end up collecting. So doctors
- 20:22lose, you know, the $20, they
- 20:25just lose that. So for them,
- 20:28it's just another decrease in
- 20:33reimbursements and patients
- 20:35lose access because if they
- 20:37don't have the money, they
- 20:38don't feel like they can go.
- 20:40Now. Yes, there are nice
- 20:42doctors out there. They will
- 20:44waive these co-pays. There are
- 20:46clinics that will see people
- 20:47without any money, but that is
- 20:49the exception. That is not the
- 20:52rule. And when we're talking
- 20:53about a program, guys, 50% of
- 20:56the children in this state are
- 20:59covered by Medicaid. 70% of our
- 21:03nursing home residents are
- 21:05covered by Medicaid. We have to
- 21:08have really rules that are
- 21:11going to actually work that we
- 21:13can we can put into place, and
- 21:16that will move the system in a
- 21:20positive financial way, not
- 21:24spending tons of time and tons
- 21:27of money trying to comply with
- 21:33regulations that aren't
- 21:35necessary and aren't needed at
- 21:38this point.
- 21:38>> So I do want to get a point
- 21:40of clarification.
- 21:42>> Needs.
- 21:44>> Yeah, let me if you don't
- 21:45mind. Senator Berg, I just want
- 21:47to really quick clarify. When
- 21:48we talk about half of the kids
- 21:52and most of the residents in
- 21:54nursing homes, Representative
- 21:56Fleming, would this measure
- 21:57apply to them?
- 21:58>> No. And there's there's
- 21:59quite a few exemptions that
- 22:01that that apply. Like kids
- 22:03don't, children don't get get
- 22:05charged. The, the medically
- 22:08frail. Pregnant women, pregnant
- 22:10women, people that are in
- 22:13behavioral, you know, substance
- 22:14abuse. So there is a quite a
- 22:16few different exemptions that
- 22:19that is included in that. So
- 22:20we're looking at a very small
- 22:22segment of society that might,
- 22:24may or may not get charged. And
- 22:26once again, there's, there's
- 22:27some provisions in there to
- 22:29provide individuals to for
- 22:30those things to be waived.
- 22:32>> So that's right. These
- 22:34Medicaid copays are for a
- 22:36subset of the population,
- 22:37Medicaid expansion members,
- 22:39making between 100 and 138% of
- 22:42the federal poverty level. The
- 22:43cabinet for Health and Family
- 22:45Services estimates that that's
- 22:46about 377,000 Kentuckians. So
- 22:49not a small number. And of
- 22:50course, many of those are
- 22:53families. Those are parents,
- 22:55caregivers, people who live
- 22:56with someone who has
- 22:57traditional Medicaid, a child,
- 22:59maybe they're caring for an
- 23:00adult with a waiver. So it
- 23:03still takes away from the
- 23:05household income and what
- 23:06they're able to spend for rent,
- 23:08for utilities, for other basic
- 23:11needs. So I do think we need to
- 23:13consider that as an indirect
- 23:14impact of these copays. But
- 23:16something else that I wanted to
- 23:18mention, the big beautiful bill
- 23:20has these different
- 23:21requirements, right? Primarily
- 23:23for the Medicaid expansion
- 23:25population. One is community
- 23:26engagement or work reporting
- 23:28requirements that has
- 23:30exemptions based on your health
- 23:31status. So for somebody with a
- 23:33substance use disorder or a
- 23:35serious mental illness for a
- 23:38condition like cancer, you're
- 23:40probably going to be able to
- 23:41get an exemption from having to
- 23:43report your community
- 23:45engagement hours. That doesn't
- 23:47apply to copays. And I think
- 23:50that's where there's some
- 23:51confusion because unfortunately,
- 23:53the big, beautiful bill just
- 23:54didn't make a consideration for
- 23:57that. And the the one thing
- 23:59that I think we should be
- 24:01thinking about, and maybe for
- 24:03our policymakers who have
- 24:05relationships with Washington,
- 24:07with our leaders at CMS, is
- 24:09what is the the final rules?
- 24:11What are the final rules going
- 24:13to look like? What is that
- 24:14federal guidance going to be?
- 24:16Will it allow us some State
- 24:18flexibility that we don't we're
- 24:19not aware of right now? Maybe
- 24:22if we gave it some time and
- 24:23waited until the next
- 24:24legislative session, which I
- 24:25think we could do because like
- 24:28Representative Fleming said, we
- 24:29don't have to comply with this
- 24:30until October of 2028. Then we
- 24:32would have time to look at
- 24:33whether we could create some
- 24:35exemptions for people based on
- 24:36their health conditions. And
- 24:37then one other thing I wanted
- 24:39to mention about the big
- 24:40beautiful Bill. It actually has
- 24:42a very wide range that states
- 24:45are allowed to charge for
- 24:47copays. So yes, Kentucky is
- 24:48required to charge something,
- 24:50but it can be anywhere from a
- 24:51penny, which is a little bit of
- 24:53a joke at this point because we
- 24:55know it's no longer in
- 24:56circulation, but it could
- 24:57certainly be a dollar up to $35.
- 25:00That's a that's a big
- 25:02difference for somebody who's
- 25:03on a fixed income. And that's a
- 25:05big difference for a provider
- 25:06who may end up not being able
- 25:08to collect that co-pay. So, you
- 25:09know, $20 over and over, you're
- 25:12going to see a huge impact.
- 25:13That's going to mean rationing
- 25:15care. That's going to mean
- 25:16providers having to make that
- 25:17decision about whether they eat
- 25:19that cost or turn someone away.
- 25:21You charge people a dollar and
- 25:23you're really reducing that
- 25:25barrier.
- 25:25>> So how did you settle on 20?
- 25:28Representative Fleming.
- 25:29>> That was settled on looking
- 25:32at individuals who come in and
- 25:35apply for. We had a scholarship
- 25:37in our in our in the agency
- 25:39that I'm involved with, and we
- 25:42came up with $20 based on what
- 25:45we look at on bank statements
- 25:47and how they spend their money,
- 25:49have been looking at this for
- 25:50about ten years and capable of
- 25:52$20. There seem to be. That was
- 25:54pretty much of a balance. In
- 25:55order to do that. Now, I'll be
- 25:57the first to admit, and I know
- 25:59the chairman, I you know,
- 26:00sometimes we agree, most times
- 26:02sometimes we disagree. But
- 26:03that's okay. I respect him
- 26:06highly. You know, once again,
- 26:08this this is not stuck in stone
- 26:10because we're not we're not
- 26:12there. It's not October 1st of
- 26:142028. So I want to try to get
- 26:16some information in order to
- 26:18see exactly what is that number?
- 26:20Is it $1 or is it $10 or
- 26:23whatever it is? We do have to
- 26:24charge something because to put.
- 26:26>> It in statute that it's 20,
- 26:28you'd have to go back and amend
- 26:30this particular if this passes.
- 26:32Right. So why why not wait
- 26:35until that data informs what
- 26:36the number should be.
- 26:37>> Change statutes all the time?
- 26:39All the time.
- 26:40>> Well, there was a question
- 26:41then. I want to go to Senator
- 26:43Burr because I know she wants
- 26:44to weigh in here. A question
- 26:46from a viewer named Adam that
- 26:47asked, do the new community
- 26:49engagement requirements apply
- 26:51to all Medicaid recipients,
- 26:53regardless of age or disability?
- 26:55And you mentioned that phrase,
- 26:56the expansion group. And so for
- 26:58those folks who don't know what
- 27:00is Medicaid expansion from the
- 27:01Affordable Care Act enacted in
- 27:032010, of course, Medicaid
- 27:05expansion came under then
- 27:07Governor Steve Beshear for
- 27:09adults that were, what, 138% of
- 27:11the Medicaid poverty level. So
- 27:13that's known as the expansion
- 27:15population. But I want to go to
- 27:17you before I go to Senator Berg.
- 27:19Senator, I want to ask you
- 27:20about the copays. And you kind
- 27:22of talked about this, how this
- 27:24could really possibly hurt
- 27:25rural providers and maybe even
- 27:28hasten the closure of rural
- 27:30hospitals. Although we heard
- 27:31debate in your Senate Chamber
- 27:33that that's kind of alarmist
- 27:36thinking that rural hospitals
- 27:38are on the verge of shutting
- 27:39down. Straighten that out for
- 27:41us.
- 27:41>> Well, the threat is real.
- 27:43And when you look at the co-pay,
- 27:45it's just not the co-pay itself.
- 27:48There's administrative costs
- 27:49associated with that. And
- 27:51really a $20 co-pay when you
- 27:53add in administrative costs,
- 27:55really the cost of the provider
- 27:56is more like $40 because they
- 27:59had to make some attempt to try
- 28:01to collect it. And this is
- 28:02going to make the decision to
- 28:04write that off. But any
- 28:05additional money that's taken
- 28:06away from rural providers, it's
- 28:07just going to hasten their
- 28:08demise. It's that critical
- 28:09right now. And the real sad
- 28:11part about this is are we
- 28:12trying to comply with federal
- 28:14regulations, or are we trying
- 28:15to fundamentally change the
- 28:16Medicaid program, which we need
- 28:17to do? And this will not
- 28:20fundamentally change the
- 28:21program. It doesn't address the
- 28:22drivers of health care costs to
- 28:23begin with. It's not that
- 28:25people are over utilizing, it's
- 28:27that we have too much
- 28:28bureaucracy. We have not
- 28:29improved the health of the
- 28:31population, and we haven't got
- 28:32people back to gainful
- 28:33employment. If we can do those
- 28:35three things in combination, we
- 28:36can save the Medicaid program
- 28:38and reduce health care
- 28:39expenditures dramatically in
- 28:41Kentucky. And I would hope to
- 28:42be a model for the nation that
- 28:44we can reduce health care costs
- 28:45at least 20, 30%.
- 28:47>> Senator Berg.
- 28:53>> Senator Meredith and I
- 28:54actually agree on this. If we
- 28:58if we approach this with a
- 29:03smarter way of looking at
- 29:06health care utilization, you
- 29:08know, one of the things that
- 29:10this bill is supposed to end up
- 29:13doing is dis enrolling about
- 29:1820,000 people in the state for
- 29:21Medicaid, making them no longer
- 29:24eligible. And it's not really
- 29:25that they won't be eligible.
- 29:27It's that they won't have been
- 29:28able to jump through the hoops
- 29:30to prove that they are eligible.
- 29:34And this bill requires us, you
- 29:39know, that they disenroll you
- 29:41and then you have to reapply.
- 29:44So even if you did meet
- 29:47eligibility, you're still not
- 29:48going to be eligible. And
- 29:51that's that's the real problem.
- 29:52The problem with Medicaid is
- 29:55not that we have people seeing
- 29:59doctors, people seeing health
- 30:02care professionals is actually
- 30:04what we want because in the
- 30:07long term that is more cost
- 30:08effective. If you can keep
- 30:10somebody on blood pressure
- 30:12medicine before their kidneys
- 30:15and before their multiple
- 30:17strokes, you can actually
- 30:20improve both the quality of
- 30:21their life and decrease the
- 30:25cost of caring for that person
- 30:28over the long term. So trying
- 30:29to get people not to have
- 30:32health care is, is, is the
- 30:34exact opposite of what you
- 30:36really want to do. What you
- 30:38want to do is you want people
- 30:40to have access to good quality,
- 30:44cost effective health care. And,
- 30:47you know, part of that is the
- 30:49social determinants of health,
- 30:51housing, education, food. Part
- 30:55of that is, is your social
- 30:57network of providers, which
- 30:59right now in this state is very,
- 31:03very weak. We do not have
- 31:06enough health care providers.
- 31:08So it's a complicated process
- 31:11of you have to pay providers or
- 31:14you're not going to have them.
- 31:16You want patients to get health
- 31:18care, but then the whole thing
- 31:20ends up costing a lot of money.
- 31:22And part of the reason that
- 31:23we've had such an expansion of
- 31:26costs in, in this world
- 31:29recently is it's multifaceted,
- 31:31but but one is we started
- 31:33covering mental health care. We
- 31:35want covering mental health
- 31:38care. So just the fact that we
- 31:41now cover this type of care, of
- 31:44course, increased our costs,
- 31:47you know, significantly. We
- 31:49also honestly, in this. State.
- 31:51War. War allowing people to
- 31:54bill for some services at a
- 31:57rate that was really
- 31:59unacceptable. And I think we're
- 32:00going to fix that this session.
- 32:01That's supposed to save us $300
- 32:04million. Just fixing one CPT
- 32:08code in this state. There's a
- 32:10lot of things that we can do,
- 32:13but taking a sledgehammer to
- 32:15the system and just saying, now
- 32:18the legislature is in charge,
- 32:21we are going to do this, this,
- 32:22this and this. We expect you to
- 32:24do this, this, this and this.
- 32:25Even though people are telling
- 32:27us it's going to cost $141
- 32:30million, just institute the
- 32:32changes in this bill guys you
- 32:36got to take a step back.
- 32:37>> You got.
- 32:38>> To. Look at the system as a
- 32:40whole. You have to have people
- 32:42who understand the system
- 32:43better. Then we go.
- 32:44>> From brought up the cost. A
- 32:46couple a couple of components.
- 32:47Let me let me give you a
- 32:49perspective. The General
- 32:50Assembly, frankly, is concerned
- 32:53about the information that
- 32:54comes from the administration.
- 32:56I'll give you an example. It
- 32:58was it was it was first
- 33:00announced that 200,000 people
- 33:01were going to be disenrolled
- 33:04for eligibility and work
- 33:06requirements. Then it went down
- 33:08to 70 from the from the
- 33:10technical Medicaid technical.
- 33:11Then it went down to 32,000.
- 33:13Then it went down to 28,000. So
- 33:15we don't know what the we don't
- 33:18understand what's going on in
- 33:19terms of how they're going in
- 33:21analyzing the data information.
- 33:22You're looking at a spread of
- 33:27400 million to $2.8 billion in
- 33:28order to do that. And
- 33:29apparently, there's not a
- 33:30really good understanding of
- 33:32that. In addition to that, when
- 33:33we got the the budget requests
- 33:36from the agency, it was $37
- 33:39million in order to look at or
- 33:4035, $35 million to look at
- 33:42technical changes. Well, two
- 33:45contractors that's on the list
- 33:47from the CMS said, well, you
- 33:49know, we can help you out from
- 33:50a technology software around $2
- 33:52million. So why are we going
- 33:53through with $37 million in
- 33:55order? We can use the current
- 33:57contractors for $2 million. In
- 33:59addition to that, we have not
- 34:01heard anything, not one iota,
- 34:02when it comes to community
- 34:04engagement and what they're
- 34:05trying to do, but yet there's
- 34:07$35 million to, to look at,
- 34:09quote unquote, we need to
- 34:10assess the situation. Well,
- 34:12we've been doing this since,
- 34:13you know, July of the bill came
- 34:15in July of last year. Where,
- 34:19where's the where's the
- 34:20communication? What are we
- 34:21trying to do? We just want to
- 34:23get some answers and try to
- 34:25work with the administration in
- 34:26order to help solve this so we
- 34:28can get a good cost analysis
- 34:29assessment. So we can go
- 34:30through and do some budgeting
- 34:32of that.
- 34:32>> You know, I think
- 34:34Representative Fleming makes a
- 34:35really good point. The numbers
- 34:36have, you know, how many people
- 34:38may be Disenrolled have really
- 34:40bounced around and there's a
- 34:41lot of uncertainty and for good
- 34:44reason, because these policies
- 34:46are only as good as they're
- 34:48implemented. And some states
- 34:49are going to do a better job of
- 34:52helping people understand what
- 34:53the requirements are, helping
- 34:55people to complete the new
- 34:57reporting requirements and not
- 34:59fall through the cracks. Other
- 35:01states are going to really
- 35:02struggle with that, and I think
- 35:05Kentucky will struggle if we
- 35:06don't have a good system, a
- 35:07good IT system with connect,
- 35:09our integrated eligibility
- 35:10system in place that really
- 35:12makes this seamless. And we're
- 35:13going to struggle if we don't
- 35:15have more State caseworkers to
- 35:17do these additional reporting
- 35:19requirements and
- 35:20redeterminations just all of
- 35:22the work that goes along with
- 35:24that. But I think that our
- 35:27state has every intention of
- 35:28doing it right. And that's and
- 35:30on both sides, both from the
- 35:34legislative branch to the
- 35:35executive branch, I think
- 35:36everyone wants to get this
- 35:38right as far as making sure
- 35:39that people who are eligible
- 35:40for Medicaid don't lose it. It
- 35:42is a real balancing act. And
- 35:44some of those early estimates,
- 35:46whenever the bill, the big,
- 35:47beautiful bill was still being
- 35:49debated in Congress, those came
- 35:51from the Congressional Budget
- 35:52Office. Those came from some of
- 35:54the national groups like Kaiser
- 35:55Family Foundation, you know, as
- 35:58Kentucky. And our Department
- 35:59for Medicaid Services is
- 36:01drilling down and really
- 36:02looking into, you know, who are
- 36:04our Medicaid members right now.
- 36:05Here are some things that we
- 36:07know. We know that the majority
- 36:08are working, or they're in a
- 36:10household where at least one
- 36:11individual is working. 96% of
- 36:14Kentuckians should already be
- 36:17satisfying the community
- 36:18engagement requirements, but
- 36:20some will do that automatically
- 36:21because they have income data
- 36:23that, you know, can be accessed
- 36:27automatically by the state.
- 36:28Others are going to have to
- 36:29report, and that's where people
- 36:31fall through the cracks. The
- 36:32other reason that people will
- 36:33be satisfying this is because
- 36:34their caregivers, they're in
- 36:37school, they have a disability
- 36:39or some other illness that will
- 36:41exempt them. And another 2% of
- 36:44Kentuckians are actively
- 36:45looking for work. We only have
- 36:472% of Kentuckians with Medicaid
- 36:49coverage who fall into that
- 36:51category of Medicaid expansion,
- 36:53who we're not sure why they're
- 36:54not working. So that's where we
- 36:57should really be focusing our
- 36:59time. And I think we'd be
- 37:01better spending our dollars if
- 37:02we were providing more
- 37:05employment training
- 37:06opportunities to these
- 37:07individuals, because Medicaid,
- 37:08at the end of the day, is a
- 37:09work support, having good
- 37:12health coverage, being able to
- 37:13go see the doctor, get your
- 37:15preventive care, you know, take
- 37:17care of any chronic conditions
- 37:18that you may have is actually
- 37:20going to make you more
- 37:21employable, more productive at
- 37:22work, and people have an easier
- 37:24time getting better paying jobs
- 37:26and really climbing the
- 37:27economic ladder. So we need to
- 37:28think about Medicaid as one of
- 37:30the tools that helps us with
- 37:34our workforce and build on that.
- 37:36>> Well, that kind of satisfies
- 37:38this question from Deborah and
- 37:39Jefferson County, who asks, is
- 37:41there a process to determine
- 37:42who really needs Medicare or
- 37:45Medicaid? Excuse me, will there
- 37:46be consideration of new rules
- 37:47to ensure people who actually
- 37:49need it have it? Very basic
- 37:52question there. Representative
- 37:54Fleming.
- 37:54>> Well, I guess part of the my
- 37:57thoughts is like, you have to
- 37:58go through an eligibility to
- 37:59make sure that they are they,
- 38:01they meet the criteria that
- 38:03they are actually need the
- 38:05Medicaid services. So there's,
- 38:07there's an eligibility process.
- 38:09And then we basically, from a
- 38:10technology standpoint, we on
- 38:12the bill basically has that the
- 38:15information that's submitted is
- 38:18checked against a numerous
- 38:19number of data sources to make
- 38:21sure that that it's there and
- 38:23making sure that the person is
- 38:26saying, saying what the, you
- 38:28know, that, that, that they
- 38:30don't have any, whether it's
- 38:31low income or, or their, where
- 38:33their situation is, you know,
- 38:35part of what I, what I've seen,
- 38:38Renee. And that is there is a
- 38:42several folks that have come to
- 38:44me that said that I've got 2 or
- 38:463 businesses and I just
- 38:48basically push all my expenses
- 38:51out to the business and I only
- 38:52claim $20,000. I've heard that
- 38:54more than one time. I hear
- 38:58individuals that actually see
- 38:59and watch Social Security of
- 39:02these, these items being, I
- 39:05guess, being above the minimums
- 39:07that that you need to that you
- 39:10need to, you know, be qualified.
- 39:12So when it comes to those sorts
- 39:13of things, we're there is a
- 39:15system that will go through and
- 39:17try to validate and so forth.
- 39:18Now, you know, if somebody
- 39:20found that they, they are not
- 39:23part, they, they, one of the,
- 39:25one of the data sources
- 39:26basically shows that, that they
- 39:28did not, you know, qualify or
- 39:31something shows up that that
- 39:32sort of puts them in and say,
- 39:34oh, you may not qualify, then
- 39:36the administration, you know,
- 39:38can help them go through that
- 39:40process and go through the
- 39:42appeals process in order to do
- 39:44that.
- 39:44>> But they don't have coverage
- 39:46in the meantime while they're
- 39:47going through that appeals
- 39:48process.
- 39:48>> Well, if they're if. Well,
- 39:50you've got two things going on.
- 39:51You. One, you have the
- 39:53redetermination. So they will
- 39:54they will still be on there.
- 39:56But if you're applying new.
- 39:59Yeah. I mean, right now you
- 40:00still you're still on Medicaid.
- 40:01You still have to go through
- 40:03and get qualified.
- 40:04>> So this person has a very
- 40:05specific question, and I hope,
- 40:07Mr. Gill, that it can be
- 40:08answered for you from Jefferson
- 40:10County. He asked, how many
- 40:11hours does Medicaid pay for
- 40:12in-home care for a quadriplegic
- 40:14patient for the 160 hours, 24
- 40:17over seven care during the week?
- 40:18Very specific. I'm not sure if
- 40:20you all have information about
- 40:21that or if Senator Burr does.
- 40:23We appreciate the question, but
- 40:25unfortunately, there's not
- 40:26someone here from centers for
- 40:27Medicaid Services to help
- 40:29answer that. But perhaps you
- 40:30can get that answer for you and
- 40:31get back to you. We appreciate
- 40:33the question. A lot of
- 40:35questions about eligibility.
- 40:36And there's so much more. And I
- 40:38do want just for a moment,
- 40:40because during one of the
- 40:41hearings and I think it was the
- 40:43the House a n r committee, we
- 40:45heard from a woman named Maggie
- 40:47Chisolm, whose daughter had
- 40:48died, and she was on the list
- 40:50or waiting to receive a heart
- 40:52transplant. And she shared some
- 40:54pretty emotional testimony a
- 40:55couple of weeks back. And
- 40:57here's her story.
- 40:59>> Evie was born on September
- 41:017th of 2016 with hypoplastic
- 41:03left heart syndrome. Basically,
- 41:06only half of her heart was
- 41:08functional, and by the time she
- 41:09was four years old, she had
- 41:11already undergone three major
- 41:13open heart surgeries. Evie was
- 41:16also on a Medicaid waiver for
- 41:18the majority of her life, due
- 41:19to her complex medical needs
- 41:22and compromised immune system.
- 41:25Despite her extensive medical
- 41:28history. I had to fight every
- 41:29year just to get her waiver
- 41:31renewed. It was exhausting and
- 41:33time consuming, and the amount
- 41:35of paperwork required was
- 41:37overwhelming. But I did it. I
- 41:40did it because there was no
- 41:42room for inaction. On August
- 41:4626th of 2024, at seven years
- 41:49old, Evie was hospitalized for
- 41:51heart failure and placed on the
- 41:53heart transplant list. In
- 41:56September of 2024. While she
- 41:58was fighting to survive, I was
- 42:00notified that she was going to
- 42:02be removed from her Medicaid
- 42:04waiver because she was not,
- 42:05quote, utilizing services. Let
- 42:08that sink in. My child was
- 42:12dying, waiting for a heart that
- 42:14never came. And I was told her
- 42:17coverage might be terminated
- 42:19because she was too sick to use
- 42:21it. The very condition that
- 42:24qualified her for care was
- 42:26being used to justify taking it
- 42:28away. In that moment, resting
- 42:31was not an option. Waiting was
- 42:33not a luxury I could afford.
- 42:36Advocacy was not a choice for
- 42:37me. It was survival. It was a
- 42:41battle I fought while being
- 42:43swallowed by fear and despair,
- 42:45because doing nothing would
- 42:46have meant losing everything. I
- 42:49fought because my child's life
- 42:51depended on it. In my family's
- 42:54case, Evie passed away on
- 42:58November 13th, 2024, before her
- 43:01coverage could be taken away
- 43:03from her. And yet, to add
- 43:06insult to injury, 13 days later,
- 43:10on November 26th, just five
- 43:13days after I buried my daughter,
- 43:15I received a text message
- 43:18reminding me that her coverage
- 43:19would be canceled on December
- 43:211st. I had to explain through
- 43:24my grief that she had already
- 43:26died and they could remove her
- 43:28from their lists. Mine is not
- 43:31an isolated story. There are
- 43:33countless stories of children,
- 43:35of parents, of individuals who
- 43:37do not have the privilege of
- 43:40waiting for systems to improve,
- 43:42people whose lives are measured
- 43:43in days and decisions, not
- 43:45fiscal years. The system is
- 43:48already failing Kentucky
- 43:50families, and its most
- 43:51fundamental promise to protect
- 43:53those in need to protect our
- 43:55most vulnerable populations.
- 44:00>> Miss Beauregard, your
- 44:01response?
- 44:02>> Well, I've gotten to know
- 44:03Maggie. She is such an amazing
- 44:05advocate, and there are many
- 44:08families who are advocating for
- 44:10their loved ones, you know,
- 44:12children, grown family members
- 44:14with Medicaid. And and it is a
- 44:16lifeline for them. And so we
- 44:19have hundreds of caseworkers at
- 44:22the cabinet for Health and
- 44:23Family Services processing this
- 44:26paperwork, all of these
- 44:27eligibility requirements. We
- 44:28have 1.3 million Kentuckians
- 44:30who need this coverage. And the
- 44:34process can feel callous until
- 44:36you walk in someone's shoes and
- 44:38really experience what Maggie
- 44:39just described with the
- 44:41paperwork. It may seem like
- 44:43it's easy to get Medicaid
- 44:45coverage, but there's a lot
- 44:46that you have to document in
- 44:48terms of your income, in terms
- 44:49of your residency, in terms of
- 44:52your household size, to make
- 44:55sure your citizenship status,
- 44:56to make sure that you are
- 44:59approved for Medicaid coverage.
- 45:00And when you have a waiver,
- 45:02there's even more that you have
- 45:03to document. And so anything
- 45:06that increases that paperwork
- 45:08burden on families is something
- 45:09that we want to really take a
- 45:11close look at and make sure
- 45:12that it's absolutely essential,
- 45:14because otherwise we are just
- 45:16adding additional paperwork to
- 45:19something that's already kind
- 45:20of a fraught situation and can
- 45:22be really challenging for folks.
- 45:24And the prospect of losing
- 45:25health insurance for someone
- 45:27who absolutely needs it to
- 45:29survive, or just to a person
- 45:30who wants that security. We all
- 45:32do. To know that when you get
- 45:35sick, you're not going to be in
- 45:36medical debt. You know that
- 45:38that's something that really
- 45:40weighs on people. I think
- 45:41there's a lot of anxiety around
- 45:43this paperwork. And so when we
- 45:45look at some of the eligibility
- 45:47verification, the program
- 45:49integrity in the bill, that's
- 45:51where I think, again, we really
- 45:52have to find that balance
- 45:54because there are two sides to
- 45:56this coin. Kentucky actually
- 45:57has a very low error rate. It's
- 46:00less than 1%. We are among the
- 46:03states.
- 46:03>> And what do you mean by
- 46:05error rate.
- 46:06>> So when you're looking at
- 46:07eligibility determination
- 46:09errors where you're essentially
- 46:10determining somebody eligible
- 46:11who is not eligible because
- 46:13they do audits. So they look at
- 46:15that paperwork, they dig into
- 46:16it more. And, you know, through
- 46:18those audits, CMS, the federal
- 46:20government determines an error
- 46:23rate. Ours is 0.8%. And that's
- 46:28very low. That's great. That
- 46:30means we're doing a good job.
- 46:31We have a good system in place.
- 46:33It can always be improved. But
- 46:35generally speaking, I think
- 46:36that we're handling that pretty
- 46:37well. The other side of that
- 46:39coin is, and this is not
- 46:41measured by the error rate. How
- 46:43many people are we denying
- 46:45Medicaid who are actually
- 46:47eligible? We need to be
- 46:48thinking about that when we
- 46:49make these decisions about
- 46:51paperwork, because for every
- 46:53additional measure you put in,
- 46:55you may be incorrectly,
- 46:59unfairly denying somebody their
- 47:01coverage.
- 47:01>> Mr. chairman, was that a
- 47:02consideration.
- 47:02>> That we can talk about
- 47:04something that's a success,
- 47:05such as an error rate, but yet
- 47:07the health measures were seen
- 47:09on the bottom of the nation
- 47:11from any of those things. We
- 47:12talked time and time again
- 47:13about the bureaucracy around
- 47:15health care, but we never
- 47:16address the fundamental problem.
- 47:17We know that we're spending
- 47:19$0.30 of every health care
- 47:20dollar on the administration of
- 47:21the program, double y the
- 47:23industrialized nations are
- 47:24doing, but yet we don't take
- 47:26that leadership position to
- 47:28address that. And we have to we
- 47:30have to come from a fundamental
- 47:31belief that there's enough
- 47:32money in the system already to
- 47:34take care of everyone. We just
- 47:35spend it the right way and
- 47:37measure the right things. And
- 47:38we're not doing that.
- 47:39>> And I mean, a chairman.
- 47:43Meredith, is that right? And
- 47:44Emily brought up some some good
- 47:45points as well. So when I first
- 47:48started talking about this, I
- 47:49come to realize if we're not a
- 47:51funding problem, it's a
- 47:52management problem. And there
- 47:54are some there are some
- 47:55concerns about paperwork and
- 47:57trying not to burden some folks.
- 48:00That's why I think coming from
- 48:01a, I guess an insurance
- 48:04insurance company perspective,
- 48:06even though I'm not an
- 48:07insurance taking a business
- 48:09approach to this to say, what
- 48:10can we do to be more creative,
- 48:12to cut the paperwork down, to
- 48:14serve our clients and the
- 48:15administration needs to do a
- 48:16whole lot more. Now what the
- 48:18General Assembly has done with
- 48:19this House bill, we've looked
- 48:20at on the waiver program, we're
- 48:22looking at basically having a
- 48:23doctor assess at the very
- 48:25beginning to make sure that,
- 48:26okay, this person needs this
- 48:28information or this person
- 48:29needs these services. In
- 48:30addition to that, we're going
- 48:31to have the administration go
- 48:33through and assess the acuity
- 48:35of that of that individual to
- 48:37make sure to do that. So right
- 48:38now it's duplicated. There's
- 48:40there's two processes going on,
- 48:42but not doing that. And so
- 48:43we're trying to combine that,
- 48:44reduce the paperwork in order
- 48:45to provide a better
- 48:47understanding of, of that
- 48:48individual and what they need
- 48:50so we can deliver services. So
- 48:51we are, we are looking at this
- 48:53from an operational standpoint.
- 48:54>> You know, something else
- 48:55that House Bill two does, and I
- 48:57think it's Wright is more data
- 48:59checks that are automated built
- 49:01into the system, state and
- 49:03federal data sources. There are
- 49:04more than a dozen that are used
- 49:06to determine eligibility or to
- 49:08check eligibility to verify.
- 49:10And I think that's a good way
- 49:12of reducing the paperwork
- 49:13burden on the individual, the
- 49:15household, the family, and
- 49:17putting it in the hands of the
- 49:18caseworkers and using any data
- 49:20that we have at our disposal
- 49:21before we have to request
- 49:23something that the state
- 49:24probably already has access to.
- 49:27Now, what concerns me about the
- 49:29bill is some language around,
- 49:31you know, what happens if
- 49:33there's inconsistent data, if
- 49:35there's a state or federal data
- 49:37source that flags, you know,
- 49:38something a little bit
- 49:39different than this other data
- 49:40source. And there are lots of
- 49:42reasons why they could be
- 49:43inconsistent. They're coming
- 49:44from different, you know,
- 49:45places, maybe different time
- 49:46periods. But when that happens,
- 49:49it will trigger a
- 49:50redetermination period that
- 49:51could happen at any time
- 49:53throughout the year. And
- 49:54someone could lose their
- 49:55coverage before they're given
- 49:56the opportunity to submit
- 49:57additional documentation to
- 49:59reconcile what that conflict
- 50:01might be. And that, I think, is
- 50:02a relatively simple fix that we
- 50:04could make to just make sure
- 50:06that people always have the
- 50:08opportunity to reconcile
- 50:10something. Now they may not be
- 50:11able to, and then they would
- 50:13lose their coverage, but people
- 50:15should at least have that
- 50:16chance.
- 50:17>> Right?
- 50:17>> Any my frustrations always
- 50:18been when we discuss data is we
- 50:20don't act on the data that we
- 50:22do have. And we get to, I think
- 50:24micro and macro, it's great
- 50:25that somebody may have
- 50:27eligibility for coverage, but
- 50:28if they can't access health
- 50:30care provider, what good does
- 50:31that coverage do them? And I
- 50:32think one of the biggest
- 50:33challenges we have going
- 50:34forward is building a strong
- 50:36primary case or primary care
- 50:39base across Kentucky. If we're
- 50:41really going to improve the
- 50:42health of the population. I
- 50:43think that's where the most
- 50:44significant savings come from
- 50:45by improving the health. But if
- 50:47we don't address those health
- 50:48Health manpower shortage areas,
- 50:49we're not going to make any
- 50:51significant headway. I don't
- 50:52care how much eligibility
- 50:53people have.
- 50:55>> We're under MCO model
- 50:58Chairman Meredith has been
- 51:00advocating for several years to
- 51:01look at a different model in
- 51:02terms of providing care. We're
- 51:04also in the bill, we're looking
- 51:06at dentists and we're looking
- 51:07at carving them out. That will
- 51:09not only give them a little
- 51:11more understanding and control
- 51:12of how the process and the
- 51:14claims work from administrative
- 51:15services organization, that's
- 51:16what it's called. But we're
- 51:17also we're taking a really
- 51:19serious look. And I've talked
- 51:20to our at least a House A and R
- 51:22to look at reimbursement
- 51:23because right now, Dennis, it's
- 51:25dismal. They're they're leaving
- 51:26in particular when it comes to.
- 51:27Eastern. Kentucky. And so we've
- 51:29so that's a workforce issue as
- 51:31well. So we need to do a whole
- 51:32lot more. And I don't know if
- 51:34Chairman Meredith would want to
- 51:35comment on that, but but it's a
- 51:37different unique thing that we
- 51:38need to flush out to see.
- 51:40Exactly. Is this a is this a
- 51:42good alternative?
- 51:43>> It's a foundational problem
- 51:44with Medicaid. Managed care
- 51:45does not work. It cannot work
- 51:46if we're going to focus on
- 51:48reducing the cost of health
- 51:49care, because the managed care
- 51:51organizations are not
- 51:52incentivized by spending less
- 51:53dollars, they're incentivized
- 51:54by spending more dollars.
- 51:56That's why we haven't seen
- 51:57significant improvements. And
- 51:58there's a better way to do this.
- 52:00And we can't ignore those
- 52:01social determinants of health.
- 52:02We say we don't have enough
- 52:03money to address those things.
- 52:05Yes we do. We have $20 billion
- 52:06Medicaid budget. It's spending
- 52:08the dollars in the right place
- 52:09at the right time to get the
- 52:11best outcomes. And we don't
- 52:12have a system that's focused on
- 52:13doing that. So I'm proposing
- 52:15that we go with accountable
- 52:16care organization that's
- 52:17community based, owned by local
- 52:19communities, owned by providers,
- 52:20and put them at risk for
- 52:21managing the health of their
- 52:23population in whatever savings
- 52:24we achieve. I think potentially
- 52:25there could be 20, 30% that
- 52:27stays within that community to
- 52:29help. For those social
- 52:30determinants of health and
- 52:31build the infrastructure they
- 52:32need to be successful, like job
- 52:34creation.
- 52:34>> One of the goals of your HB
- 52:36two House Bill two is to get at
- 52:38fraud, right, and encourage
- 52:40more transparency. Well, this
- 52:42comment and question from Tyler
- 52:44Glick, and it's directed to
- 52:46Chairman Meredith, but I think
- 52:47Chairman Fleming, you can also
- 52:48chime in a recent story by Joe
- 52:50Zanca of the Louisville Public
- 52:51Media detailed the massive
- 52:53fraud allegedly perpetuated by
- 52:54addiction recovery care. The
- 52:56Department of Medicaid Services
- 52:57did not heed warnings from Mcos
- 52:59about red flags. The General
- 53:01Assembly actually took the side
- 53:02of AAC and attacked Mcos for
- 53:04making cuts to reimbursements
- 53:06to questionable providers. Was
- 53:07this a systemic failure of both
- 53:10branches?
- 53:12>> I think that's a fair
- 53:14indictment. I think maybe on
- 53:15the legislative side, it's
- 53:17because we saw a problem, news
- 53:19of crisis, and we try to
- 53:21address it in the best manner
- 53:22that we knew how to at the time.
- 53:25We're recognizing now that it's
- 53:26probably not the best situation.
- 53:28We're still struggling with.
- 53:30Substance abuse disorders, is
- 53:31the best model to use to get
- 53:33the most effective outcomes. So
- 53:34that's ever evolving. But at
- 53:36that time, I think that's the
- 53:38best thing we have available to
- 53:39us, the best tool we have at
- 53:41hand. But obviously it was
- 53:43abused, not the first instance
- 53:44in the medical health care
- 53:46delivery system of that. You
- 53:48can look at the pharmaceutical
- 53:49companies, the prices are
- 53:50charging for medications, and
- 53:52that's another major abuse.
- 53:53That's the fleecing of America,
- 53:55such as Ozempic, which we have
- 53:57talked about. It costs us
- 53:58almost $1,000 a dose to do that.
- 54:01The manufacturer has decided
- 54:03they're going to reward us by
- 54:04reducing that the $250 per dose.
- 54:07But ask the question in
- 54:09committee, why can't we get the
- 54:11same price as Australia, which
- 54:12is $100 a dose, and the cost of
- 54:14producing that drug is like $5.
- 54:17You can charge $10 and get 100%
- 54:19profit on that. So there's
- 54:20abuse throughout the system.
- 54:21And I think maybe this is going
- 54:23to be a wake up call for
- 54:24America, that if we don't
- 54:26control health care delivery
- 54:27costs, it's going to collapse
- 54:28our economy quite literally.
- 54:30>> Representative Fleming, I
- 54:32just I mean, I look at this as
- 54:34our budget at home or even when
- 54:37I was running a business Allen
- 54:39expenses usually usually have,
- 54:41you know, put a mark on there,
- 54:435 or 10% of a fluctuation in
- 54:45your expense item. And so when
- 54:47you have a particular, I think
- 54:49Mr. Glick was referring to one
- 54:52particular code. And that was,
- 54:53I mean, a couple of years ago
- 54:55is around, I don't know, like
- 54:571.4, $1.5 million. Then it
- 54:59skyrocketed up to like 15, $16
- 55:02million. And that was over a
- 55:03year and a half. So where was
- 55:05the where was the control
- 55:06measures? Where's where is the
- 55:08quality? Where's the oversight?
- 55:09Where is the leadership in
- 55:10order to, to do all that? So
- 55:12that that that's happened in
- 55:13that particular situation, but
- 55:14it's happened in other, other
- 55:16areas within Medicaid.
- 55:17>> Right. Senator Berg, I'll
- 55:18give you about 30s.
- 55:23>> Well, I just, you know,
- 55:24where's the leadership? Where's
- 55:25the oversight? It was the
- 55:28legislature legislator that
- 55:30made the decision in that case
- 55:33to cover this particular code.
- 55:36And then, I mean, anybody could
- 55:38have told honestly, pretty
- 55:39early on that there was a big,
- 55:42big, big problem because all of
- 55:44a sudden, Kentucky had more
- 55:47recovery beds than any other
- 55:49state in the country, which
- 55:51means, guys, something's wrong.
- 55:55That's what we need to be
- 55:56worrying about because that's
- 55:58where the fraud in Medicaid
- 56:00actually happens.
- 56:01>> Yeah. Senator Berg, thank
- 56:02you so much. I hate to cut you
- 56:04off, but our time is is nigh
- 56:06and at the end, and I
- 56:08appreciate you so much for
- 56:09joining us from Louisville. And
- 56:10I appreciate our panelists here
- 56:11in Lexington. We'll have more
- 56:13coverage of the 2026 Kentucky
- 56:14General Assembly next week. On
- 56:16Kentucky night, we'll talk
- 56:16about the budget. Cross our
- 56:18fingers. That will be on at
- 56:198:00, and then you can keep on
- 56:21track of what's happening in
- 56:22Frankfort each week. Night at
- 56:23630 eastern, 530 central on
- 56:25Kentucky edition. I'll see you
- 56:26tomorrow night. And thanks for
- 56:27being with us tonight.
- 56:28[MUSIC]
- 56:29Talk to you soon.