Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / FSR Brief EP10: Naming firms under investigation in "exceptional circumstances" put to the test in Judicial Review
Transcript
- 0:12SPEAKER_01: Hello all and welcome to episode 10 of the FSR Brief.
- 0:16SPEAKER_01: I'm John Ford, a partner in the contentious financial services regulatory team here at HSF Kramer, and today we're going to be talking about the judicial review by the Claims Protection Agency of the FCA and the FCA's decision to publicly announce its investigation into them.
- 0:33SPEAKER_01: Obviously, now we know that it's the Claims Protection Agency, but for a number of months their name was anonymised.
- 0:40SPEAKER_01: We had a first part of the judgment published in November last year, and then earlier this month, the second part of the judgment has been published once the Court of Appeal refused the Claims Protection Agency permission to appeal.
- 0:55SPEAKER_01: And the case brings out a number of interesting factors, both from a regulatory perspective but also from a public law perspective.
- 1:03SPEAKER_01: So today I am joined by Michael Tan, a senior associate in the FSL practice.
- 1:08SPEAKER_02: And James Wood, a disputes partner specialising in public law and regulatory disputes.
- 1:13SPEAKER_01: Excellent.
- 1:13SPEAKER_01: So we've got all the experts in the room to talk through this issue.
- 1:17SPEAKER_01: And Michael, can you kick us off by giving us some of the background and context in relation to the FCA investigating this and then their decision about publicly announcing and what happened about that?
- 1:30SPEAKER_00: Sure, John.
- 1:31SPEAKER_00: So since the uh Hopcraft decision, this is an area that the FCA has been looking into with particular interest.
- 1:40SPEAKER_00: The Claims Protection Agency, which was the claimant in this case, is a claims management company that's active in the motorfinance claims space.
- 1:51SPEAKER_00: It's been taking on uh a significant number of customers, a point which we'll come back to later in the pod, no doubt.
- 1:59SPEAKER_00: Um and on the 12th of August 2025, the FCA notified CPA that it was opening an investigation into it relating to potential breaches of uh the advertisements that it had been giving and whether they had been making misleading statements on the potential value of claims, quoting, for example, that customers could receive up to four to four and a half thousand pounds per vehicle, failing to adequately describe the free-to-claim alternatives for customers if they decided not to use a CMC to bring their claim, and using high-pressure selling tactics and making excessive contact with potential customers.
- 2:52SPEAKER_00: So, early doors, the FCA case team were thinking about whether to make a public announcement in relation to this investigation, and we understand from the judgment that the FCA case team produced a memo setting out considerations of whether to announce the investigation.
- 3:11SPEAKER_00: And that first uh memo set out a recommendation that there should be an announcement, but it should be on an anonymized basis.
- 3:22SPEAKER_00: That memo was put forward to the senior decision maker in this case, which was Therese Chambers.
- 3:28SPEAKER_00: She considered the memo, and we understand that she sent back a two-page email asking them to reconsider that first recommendation, which she did not necessarily agree with, and calling out particular points that they may have underplayed or not taken into sufficient consideration.
- 3:47SPEAKER_00: Indeed.
- 3:48SPEAKER_00: Uh I would not want to be the recipient of the two-page email.
- 3:53SPEAKER_00: So the case team took that away and they produced a second memo, and that second memo uh had a changed recommendation that there should be a named announcement.
- 4:06SPEAKER_00: The FCA notified CPA that it intended to announce the investigation, naming it, and it gave CPA 24 hours notice.
- 4:17SPEAKER_00: CPA promptly took steps to protect its legal rights, um, it applied for judicial review in relation to the FCA's decision.
- 4:28SPEAKER_00: Ultimately, I think, John, as you've already mentioned, the High Court rejected that judicial review uh claim, and that's what brings us here today.
- 4:38SPEAKER_00: Excellent.
- 4:39SPEAKER_01: So we've got to the stage where the claims protection agency is uh judicially reviewing that decision.
- 4:46SPEAKER_01: So, James, can you talk us through the judgment, what the court was assessing, the test it's applying, and why it reached the decision it did?
- 4:54SPEAKER_02: Yeah, thanks, John.
- 4:55SPEAKER_02: So um essentially the claimant um advanced two uh distinct grounds of challenge in this case.
- 5:02SPEAKER_02: And the first ground of challenge was um an allegation that there had been a misdirection of law or a misinterpretation more precisely of the FCA's enforcement guide.
- 5:13SPEAKER_02: Um and the second ground of challenge was that um, in the alternative, that the decision was uh was so un was unreasonable and therefore unlawful, either in terms of the outcome that had been reached or the process that had been followed.
- 5:27SPEAKER_02: Um and I think as Michael's alluded to, um, on both grounds, ultimately the uh the claim was unsuccessful.
- 5:34SPEAKER_02: And on just picking up the first ground, which is the uh misinterpretation of the guide point, this is kind of an important ground to consider because in when you're looking at a legality type ground such as this, it's the court who's the primary objective decision maker here, and the court can assess objectively whether it considers that the interpretation, um the interpretation was was correct.
- 5:56SPEAKER_02: Um, but ultimately um the court found that there hadn't been a material misdirection um of the guide, and that when it's uh when the uh reasons for the decision are sort of read as a whole, um you know there wasn't any uh any misinterpretation in the circumstances.
- 6:14SPEAKER_02: Um on the second ground, um, which is quite an interesting ground because um, and this is the reasonableness point, because in this in this circumstance, what you have is you have an expert regulator who's exercised effectively their expert evaluative judgment as to whether a decision as to what decision to take in the circumstances.
- 6:32SPEAKER_02: And there, unlike the first ground, the court takes a bit more of a hands-off, or typically takes a bit more of a hands-off approach and is a bit more deferential to the decision of the expert regulator.
- 6:42SPEAKER_02: And it's quite interesting in this case because um the judgment itself says um, although some of the reasoning in the decision this is can be said to be weak, um, it uh it's still found that this reasonableness ground of challenge failed um in all of the um in all of the circumstances because although the decision had flaws, it was effectively within the range of decisions open to a reasonable uh decision maker.
- 7:10SPEAKER_02: And in sort of in cut reaching that decision, and I think that's a point that we'll, I'm sure we'll come back to, I think it's fair to say that the court placed significant weight on what it saw as the key theme of the um decision in question, which was a key theme of communicating um a message to the customers of the um of the claimant, um which I think is all I wanted to say by way of brief summary of the grounds that are advanced and the tests that the court applied.
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: Thanks, James.
- 7:37SPEAKER_01: So the uh it's fair to understand that in circumstances where your ground is focusing on the reasonableness of the decision, it's going to be a difficult application to make in terms of, or if it turned out to be a difficult application, they lost on that on that ground that you're you're going on an uphill battle.
- 7:55SPEAKER_02: Yeah, I think I think that's a very fair characterisation when you're um looking at a reasonableness ground of challenge.
- 8:00SPEAKER_02: There can be circumstances where um claimants can seek to persuade the court that they should take a bit more of a hands-on approach and look at a bit more detail and more closely at the reasoning.
- 8:10SPEAKER_02: But in this situation, I think the court took what would be seen as kind of a conventional public law reasonableness um uh reasonableness approach, and in that circumstance did pay um, you know, uh significant deference, I think, to the decision of the expert regulator.
- 8:27SPEAKER_01: Thank you very much, James.
- 8:28SPEAKER_01: Uh uh perhaps now we can sort of pick up um a few points that come from the judgment and in particular are of interest from a regulatory perspective in circumstances where the FCA has applied its when you formulated exceptional circumstances test for naming the subject of an investigation.
- 8:51SPEAKER_01: And Michael, I I think the starting point is uh the interpretation of exceptional, and in particular, there seems to be an an agreement between the claimant here, so the claims of protection agency and the FCA about what um what is exceptional relative to what, you know.
- 9:13SPEAKER_01: And perhaps Michael, do you can talk us through what is said in the judgment in relation to that?
- 9:18SPEAKER_00: Yeah, no problem, John.
- 9:20SPEAKER_00: So I think just starting with teasing out what the arguments were made by the claimants around uh interpretation and where they said the SCA may have erred.
- 9:33SPEAKER_00: The first point they made was around uh an idea of cohort relative exceptionality.
- 9:40SPEAKER_00: Now, for those who were well versed in the consultation process that flowed uh last year and the year prior, um that was a concept that we became aware of from our engagement with the FCA.
- 9:57SPEAKER_00: The idea that their starting point when looking at exceptionality was to look at their portfolio of cases and consider whether the case before them, relative to that portfolio, was exceptional or not.
- 10:14SPEAKER_00: Well, here we get a little bit more detail or flesh on the bones on that on that sort of high-level um explanation we were given at that time.
- 10:25SPEAKER_00: So I guess the the essential point that the the court summarized uh is that exceptional in the exceptional circumstances test means exceptional relative to investigated situations and not exceptional relative to regulated situations.
- 10:42SPEAKER_00: So it's not enough that a situation is exceptional such as to warrant investigation.
- 10:50SPEAKER_00: You have to just look at the smaller cohort of investigated cases.
- 10:55SPEAKER_01: And and pausing there, that there's nothing objectionable about that, I think.
- 10:59SPEAKER_01: Otherwise you'd have a scenario where you open up any investigation, and of course that is exceptional relative to the regulatory universe, as it were, because there are only a few number of um investigations relative to all the other uh regulatory activity that the FCA will be doing with you know authorised firms.
- 11:22SPEAKER_01: So that seems fine, I'd have thought, from uh a matter of just objective interpretation.
- 11:28SPEAKER_00: I think I think that's right.
- 11:29SPEAKER_00: I think there are a couple of things that we've been thinking about which we've found uh a little bit challenging.
- 11:36SPEAKER_00: The first is that that concept doesn't deal with a scenario where you have misconduct that's widespread throughout the market, but it isn't necessarily being investigated.
- 11:51SPEAKER_00: And that in fact looks like it was the case here.
- 11:54SPEAKER_00: You had CMCs adopting very similar practices to CPA, but there just weren't any investigations into those CMCs.
- 12:04SPEAKER_00: This was the f as we understand it, the first investigation into a CMC.
- 12:08SPEAKER_00: Um, and and that reasoning came out uh in the first memo.
- 12:13SPEAKER_00: Um if your starting point is to just look at investigated cases, you kind of ignore or don't take into account the misconduct that's going on in the market more generally.
- 12:30SPEAKER_01: Yeah, I think that's I think that's fair, and I don't think what in my reading of the judgment is necessarily clearly spelt out, but I think if you follow a approach of saying look at this investigated scenario, is the circumstances factors about this investigation which are exceptional relative to other investigations that we're doing and crucially relevant to the desirability of naming the firm, which then brings in the other factors in their test.
- 13:07SPEAKER_01: So if you do that, then which I think you you do get from the judgment in terms of how they've assessed the memos that the FCA have produced it is a coherent test which is uh um relevant to the to the objective that the FCA is trying to achieve.
- 13:27SPEAKER_01: And as James has outlined in relation to the key theme, the FCA uh case team here were focusing on the number of impacted customers, it seems in particular the CMC has um had successful advertising, uh which um the FCA is investigating whether that advertising was misleading or not.
- 13:50SPEAKER_01: And therefore a large part of the key theme was that sort of consumer protection and the necess or it being desirable to name the firm to give the customers options that the FCA would say.
- 14:05SPEAKER_00: Yeah, I think I think that's right.
- 14:06SPEAKER_00: That's that clearly is what appears to have carried the day the significant number of customers, which we understand was in the millions, um, because as a result of uh a very widespread and successful advertising campaign is what made this CMC stand out as compared to its competitors, um, and that that element of exceptionality um was enough to justify um naming them in the in the announcement.
- 14:38SPEAKER_00: I guess in the right case, it might be that being able to point to the fact that misconduct is widespread in the market.
- 14:50SPEAKER_00: You know, it might be an argument that another claimant in another case might be able to point to and say, look, this is a reason why this is not exceptional, even if it wasn't able to carry the day for CPA in in this judicial review.
- 15:03SPEAKER_00: Yeah, indeed.
- 15:04SPEAKER_01: I I don't think it comes through the from the judgment, but one could foresee the claimant in this, you know, the CPA, um, arguing that would this give perhaps a false impression to customers that other CMCs are fine, they're okay.
- 15:20SPEAKER_01: We don't understand that to be we don't understand that from our own experience to be the case, or from what the the is said in the judgment in terms of the FCA's concerns about the market more generally.
- 15:32SPEAKER_01: Um so you could see that as an argument potentially to say, well, this would actually give perhaps potentially a false impression to customers.
- 15:40SPEAKER_00: I think the other point to call out um just about how the test is being interpreted and what we get from the judgment is the idea that when looking at whether to make a naming announcement, the FCA would need to compare that as against not only making no announcement, but also whether to make an anonymized announcement and whether those desirable aims can be achieved or equally achieved through making uh an anonymized announcement.
- 16:12SPEAKER_00: Um I think the criticism that was levied by the court at the FCA was because it didn't necessarily always make clear whether its rationale weighing in favour of making a named announcement was as compared to making no announcement or was as compared to making an anonymised announcement.
- 16:36SPEAKER_00: Um I think it noted that it hadn't structured its memo in a sequential or logical flow, and that uh that has compounded the reasons why some of the reasoning could be said to be weak.
- 16:50SPEAKER_00: Um, and that might be something that the FCA carries forward as a as a lesson to learn.
- 16:55SPEAKER_00: Yeah, that's interesting.
- 16:56SPEAKER_01: And James, is that the sort of thing that one would be looking at when you're considering a judicial review of a decision, you know, how they've structured their their judgment, their decision making.
- 17:05SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, it certainly would, John.
- 17:06SPEAKER_02: And and one of the points that I um I I think is quite um interesting to reflect on coming out of this case is that on one view, it's quite a from a sort of potential claimant perspective, is quite a depressing read because it's that it's the court taking a fairly hands-off um approach and deferential approach, the decision of a regulator, even accepting that there are weaknesses in the the reasoning and the and the and the the process, but still finding that the decision in the round was a was a lawful one.
- 17:35SPEAKER_02: But I do think that some of these um some of these concessions as to how the um uh concessions and findings as to how the how the approach should should work in terms of the guide, um, and also just how it interacts and sort of the relevance of other public law principles do mean that there are um I think the judgment does leave the door open for further claimants, whether um whether in this sector, and I know of particular interest to your listeners is is obviously the the FCA and and this particular sector, or indeed um when looking at regulatory decisions in other sectors where we've seen other regulators looking at um their policies and changing their policies around naming um the subjects of investigations at the outset.
- 18:14SPEAKER_02: And I do think that there are um there are hooks there and opportunities there for further claimants, such that you know this is just, you know, in light of this judgment, I think there are arguments that could um could be pursued in further cases, whether on the um sort of correctness and lawfulness of um of decision making or or at attempting again on the sort of reasonableness, rationality side, or on wider grounds that weren't even but weren't pursued in this case, things like procedural fairness or human rights arguments, which you might be able to run um in an appropriate case.
- 18:48SPEAKER_02: So it's a long way of saying I think I agree with you, John, if I remember the correct correct question correctly.
- 18:53SPEAKER_01: Well, look, do you know that one of the other things, and I think perhaps we'll finish on this, that comes from the the judgment is quite how quickly one has to move here.
- 19:02SPEAKER_01: The FCA gave um Claims Protection Agency twenty-four hours to respond, or twenty-four hours notice that they were going to be publicly announcing uh them in terms of their investigation.
- 19:18SPEAKER_01: Um and that is an issue that was discussed in the consultation that happened last year, and indeed I think the House of Lords were critical of the periods of time that the FCA were considering giving firms I think was it starting off with 24 hours, weren't they?
- 19:37SPEAKER_01: I think that or two days I can't remember, yeah.
- 19:40SPEAKER_01: And um and it got extended as they consulted to I think ten days when they were contemplating putting in their ten business days for uh uh the public interest framework.
- 19:52SPEAKER_01: It's obviously ultimately got ditched and no longer pursued, but it shows that in applying this new formulated test, they will or they potentially would give you very short notice.
- 20:03SPEAKER_01: But again, James shows you the flexibility, I think, of the ability of using judicial.
- 20:08SPEAKER_02: Yeah, yeah, it does.
- 20:09SPEAKER_02: I mean, it it it puts a it puts a uh potential claimant and those um put on notice of uh a naming announcement in relation to them, you know, to some pretty considerable work at short order if they are going to seriously look at challenging, um, challenging a decision.
- 20:25SPEAKER_02: Um but I think as you say, John, one of the things that this case shows is that um for uh you know judicial review and um is it is a is a is a suitable and available remedy in in this situation.
- 20:38SPEAKER_02: Yes, the claimant lost overall, but ultimately they were given very short notice of the naming announcement.
- 20:44SPEAKER_02: They managed to get papers into court very, very quickly to apply for judicial review of um this decision and along doing alongside doing that, seeking, as I understand it, um interim relief.
- 20:56SPEAKER_02: And then it was only a matter of a few short weeks before ultimately we get to a final hearing before a judge in the administrative court and a decision.
- 21:06SPEAKER_02: And in the meantime, the process was sufficiently flexible and dealt with um by the court in a manner which um gave adequate and adequate protection, as I understand it, to um to the confidentiality in this case, which was obviously key in circumstances where the whole case turned on, whether it was lawful or right or fair or otherwise, to name the subjects of the investigation.
- 21:28SPEAKER_02: So I think um from a from a claimant perspective, again, it's certainly not um it's not all bad news in this judgment.
- 21:34SPEAKER_02: I think it does really demonstrate the um the sort of power and the flexibility of the administrative court looking at a judicial review to deal with things really quickly and sensitive to the needs of the relevant of the parties in the particular case, um uh really quite impressively, actually, I think.
- 21:53SPEAKER_01: Well, thank you very much, James, and thank you, Michael.
- 21:57SPEAKER_01: Um it's been an interesting discussion in relation to this you know joint issue in terms of both financial services regulatory and also public law.
- 22:06SPEAKER_01: Uh, and it looks like, given the FCA's desire to be able to use its exceptional circumstances test, it may well be something that our our clients or firms will be interested in the future.
- 22:17SPEAKER_01: So thank you all.
- 22:18SPEAKER_01: Until next time.