Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Andrew Tate goes to therapy (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00Heyeserve listeners today's episode and the other two episodes this week. All three episodes
- 0:05this week are going to be audio versions of a bunch of videos that I
- 0:10posted on YouTube recently. I don't normally do this, but after recording the
- 0:14videos, I thought it'd be good to share with the audio podcast audience because
- 0:18I ended up talking a lot about clinical things. The videos are of me
- 0:22reacting to a therapy session with Andrew Tait. If you don't know who he
- 0:28is, consider yourself lucky. He's probably the most well known misogynist in the
- 0:33world, or at least in the English speaking world. He has millions and
- 0:37millions of followers around the world, mainly boys and young men. He has
- 0:42allegedly been a sex trafficker and other He's allegedly committed other kinds of crimes that
- 0:49he's currently dealing with in the justice system in Europe. And he Andrew Tate
- 0:57posted a video of him in a therapy session. The video is over two
- 1:03hours long. I think it's almost two and a half hours, and a
- 1:07bunch of people sent me the video wanting me to comment on the video,
- 1:10react to the video, and when I first sat down to watch this,
- 1:15so called therapy session. I figured it was just going to be yet another
- 1:18video of him being misogynistic in him selling his bullshit to young susceptible minds.
- 1:23But I soon realized that the therapy session was a good representation of therapy and
- 1:27really not only a good representation of what therapy should look like, but also
- 1:33a good representation of how to work with clients who specifically suffer from narcissistic personality
- 1:38disorder. So I condensed the eight videos I published on YouTube down to three
- 1:45audio episodes, which I'll be posting starting today and the other two later this
- 1:51week, and let me know what you think. And here we go.
- 1:53Hey Zerman listeners, a lot of you have been asking me to react to
- 1:57this video on YouTube in which Andrew Tate goes to therapy. It is on
- 2:00the YouTube channel called Cobra Conker, and I want to say as some caveats.
- 2:06Normally I don't do this, but I've actually watched this entire video already.
- 2:09It's over two hours long, and I just want to provide some caveats
- 2:13before I go into it. One is that I didn't know who the therapist
- 2:16was. Halfway through the video, he reveals himself to be potentially more of
- 2:21a misogynist than Andrew Tate is. But I didn't know that, and I
- 2:23was giving David the Therapist the benefit of the doubt. So I'm worried that
- 2:28as I'm watching and I'm giving David the benefit of the doubt, that people
- 2:30will be angry at me for not attacking David because you or other people will
- 2:36know that David the Therapist is a massive massagist. I didn't know. I
- 2:39didn't even know who he was. Eventually I kind of figure out who he
- 2:43was later as I'm watching, But I just want to say that. I
- 2:45also want to say that even though he is seemingly a massive misogynist and has
- 2:50probably a lot of problematic views that may or may not impact his work with
- 2:54his clients, I don't know. Even though that's true, I can still
- 2:58identify thaying in David's approach that are laudable, that are positive that our techniques
- 3:05or approaches that I can get behind. The Other thing I want to say
- 3:07upfront is that I did not think that this session would actually get anywhere because
- 3:14of what I know about Andrew Tate. I thought this would just be an
- 3:16opportunity for agitate to brag about himself, and he does spend a majority of
- 3:21the session doing that, but there are moments where some movement seemingly is happening,
- 3:27and I am saying that because it takes a while for it to get
- 3:31there, so you might have to watch a few of my reaction videos before
- 3:35we get there, but eventually it ends at the very end of the two
- 3:38and twelve minutes session, two hour, twelve minute session of what I would
- 3:43observe to be a very powerful moment and a good example of what a version
- 3:47of good therapy can look like. So it really does pay off and able
- 3:51to say and react to things in reaction to this video that I've never been
- 3:55able to talk about on this YouTube channel before because I've ever been provoked to
- 4:00that. I've never been given an example because therapy is very complicated and there's
- 4:05a lot of things that you can't really explain. But if we see an
- 4:09example and then I comment on it, you can, So I don't know.
- 4:12I found this to be a very interesting watch, so if you're interested,
- 4:16you can stick through my yamoring. So we're gonna go to me in
- 4:20the past because when I first started watching this video, I hadn't seen anything,
- 4:24So just keep that in mind. Let's get to it in reality through
- 4:27the conviction of your thoughts, your beliefs, and the words that you use.
- 4:31Why else would you adopt any kind of mindset unless it's designed specifically to
- 4:35make you competitive and make you win. You install the software in your mind
- 4:39right. So if I'm going to install software in my mind, so well,
- 4:43I've tried very hard to create it right because was it installed by your
- 4:46upbringing? Wasn't installed by your mother and your father? And the first thing
- 4:50I should say is that is this an actual therapy session as it is advertised,
- 4:56Because in a typical therapy session, there is a conversation about what the
- 5:01client wants from therapy. I think there's a belief among the lay public that
- 5:08therapy is something that you just sort of sit down and the therapist does something
- 5:13to the client. But that is not good therapy. Good therapy is when
- 5:17a client sits down and presents something I would like to work on this,
- 5:21I have a problem with this, I am struggling with this, and then
- 5:27the therapist talks with the client about how they're going to help them with that,
- 5:32what sort of things are going to do to reach that goal, and
- 5:35without that then it's just a conversation. And I don't even know who this
- 5:40individual is. From context, it seems like maybe this individual is an actual
- 5:45clinician, but I don't know. Ready to break the internet for end?
- 5:47How are we going to break the internet? He said, you wanted this
- 5:49to be impactful's what would that look like to you? That's a really good
- 5:54question. I think a lot of people are. Oh. I just looked
- 5:58up the guy's name, David Sutcliffe, an actor, a Canadian actor,
- 6:01but with that beard, I didn't recognize him. So why did David Sutcliffe
- 6:09quit acting? Oh? He quit acting to become a therapist. Okay,
- 6:14that's you don't usually see that happen every day. Does it make you nervous
- 6:17that there may be things that you don't know about yourself that I'm going to
- 6:21try to reveal to you. I know everything about myself. You know you
- 6:26know everything about yourself. I believe that I have an intimate grasp of all
- 6:30the things about myself which matter. Which now it's possible I don't know Andrew
- 6:33Tate well enough obviously to know about that claim that he knows himself. It
- 6:42sort of to know what that means exactly. But I will say that that
- 6:46is potentially lacking in self awareness to say. I will say from experience,
- 6:53when I hear that from people, particularly when they say in that way,
- 6:57I usually will conclude later that they in fact did not know themselves very well.
- 7:00And we just have to think about why people say certain things. It's
- 7:05very helpful as a therapist to think about, you know, what people are
- 7:10saying between the lines, the meta content in that it's probable, given what
- 7:15I know about anditate that when he says I know everything there is about me,
- 7:19he's not just making a statement verbatim about that information. He is saying
- 7:26back off. He's saying there's nothing you're going to get from me, and
- 7:30anything you're going to try to dig at will be fruitless because I don't have
- 7:35a traumatic side, I don't have a weak side. I don't have some
- 7:39deep dark secret that I'm trying to hide or something, and I'm in control.
- 7:44That's probably another meta content bit of information he's trying to get across,
- 7:47Like if I were to say there is no possible way that I know everything
- 7:51about my personality, it's just a ridiculous comment or statement, I've done a
- 7:57lot of work, but I probably have a lot more to learn, and
- 8:01I will probably never learn. And I have a bias. I have a
- 8:05point of view, So even if I did, quote unquote learn, I
- 8:09will filter it through the way that I see the world for better or for
- 8:11worse. And I am not in control completely of my psychology, of my
- 8:18behavior, of my personality, of my defenses, of my biases. I
- 8:24will overreact. I will get upset when I shouldn't be. I will be
- 8:28hurt when I shouldn't be. I will be overly hurt when I shouldn't be.
- 8:31I will stuff my emotions. I will judge others. These are things
- 8:37that aren't good that I have a hard time dealing with. When I look
- 8:41at them, you know that's normal, that's human. But by saying that
- 8:46it to some will come across like I'm not in full control over my faculties
- 8:50that I'm weak. I think he tries to come across like he's in full
- 8:54control so that he can give a vibe that people should follow him because he
- 8:58has all figured out another thing to think about. I guess more down to
- 9:03earth with clients. When I hear this sort of thing, it usually indicates
- 9:07that they know, they absolutely know that there are dark corners to their personality,
- 9:13but they're so ashamed of it that they cannot bear to have others know
- 9:18of those corners existence. And they might even be shutting themselves off themselves to
- 9:24that information because of how ashamed they are. So that would be my initial
- 9:28hypothesis if I had a client in the first session say such a thing for
- 9:33me to compete. Right, So, there may be things I don't know,
- 9:35but I'm not sure if I particularly need them, so I'm not that
- 9:39interested. Right, what's useful is more important than what's true. Absolutely right,
- 9:43And you've developed a framework of thinking about yourself and thinking about reality that's
- 9:48been incredibly effective for you. Completely. What's useful is more You nailed it.
- 9:52What's useful is more important than what's true. This is an old argument
- 9:56of mine, but I think we discussed it in the last podcast, and
- 9:58I'll say it again when I say I don't believe in depression, nobody convinced
- 10:01me to can convince me to believe in depression. That's not a matter of
- 10:05discussing whether depression is real or not. That's a matter of me accepting that
- 10:09my mental model for going through life is more effective if I don't believe I
- 10:13can become a depressed person. From my understanding and my memory, he was
- 10:18detained in Europe by the authorities due to allegations of something related to sex trafficking.
- 10:26Women were coming forward saying that he had coerced them, forced them into
- 10:31sex work, and had abused them as well. I think there were a
- 10:35number of different alleged victims. Anyway, I think he's talking a little bit
- 10:39about that. I think what he's saying, which is fine, is that
- 10:43if I allow myself to go down a certain road of what he calls depression,
- 10:48then that will be bad for me. So I just have to not
- 10:54believe in depression. I have to keep going. I have to keep myself
- 10:58motivated. I have to not get down. I have to not go down
- 11:01those roads of thinking because it'll be bad for me, It'll be bad for
- 11:07my business. And that's the way I live my life. That's how I
- 11:09get myself through the day I've been through. I think what he's kind of
- 11:13referring to indirectly is he's been through some bad times lately for himself. Now.
- 11:18I think a lot of people, the majority of people would say,
- 11:22well, you know, you mess with the bull, you get the horns.
- 11:26You know, fuck around and find out. I guess is another phrase
- 11:30that people would say, meaning that you commit crimes and you go to prison.
- 11:35Right. You know the statement that he says of I don't believe in
- 11:37depression. If you just heard that, you would say, well, that's
- 11:41stupid, because it's a construct that we have been using in the field of
- 11:46psychology and psychiatry for decades, if not to over a century, and it's
- 11:50a well researched phenomenon among humans. Now, you know, it's a squishy
- 11:54concept. It's not like a diagnosis like cancer or something where you can actually
- 12:00open up the body and find the cancer cells and look at the cancer cells
- 12:03under a microscope and identify them and differentiate those cancer cells from other cells in
- 12:07the body. There's nothing like that in psychiatry and psychology. But it is
- 12:13a very distinct syndrome, condition, disorder that is quite noticeable and definable.
- 12:20I don't believe in depression, so I can't be depressed, so that allows
- 12:22me to be more effective. It's not a matter of sit and the or
- 12:26going well, maybe it's true, maybe it isn't I don't believe in it.
- 12:28Yeah, And then the way he says it is ridiculous that somehow people
- 12:33who are depressed are allowing themselves to be depressed, and if they just cho
- 12:39chose to not be depressed, then they wouldn't. That's ridiculous And it's his
- 12:43whole persona. That's what he's trying to sell, and that's what his misogynistic
- 12:50males are looking for. Young impressionable males who are adrift in our society and
- 12:54don't know where to land find him and find him to be an exaggeration of
- 13:01what they have absorbed. The reason why he's popular is because as our society
- 13:07in the West, you know, the United States, Canada in other parts
- 13:11of the world, are shifting away from toxic masculine ideas and ideologies. You
- 13:18all have a transition zone, if you will, where you have a lot
- 13:22of boys and men who have already been indoctrinated into the masculine ideals for better
- 13:28force. You know, there are good things about masculinity, for sure,
- 13:31that I adhere to, and there are negative things, what they call toxic
- 13:35things about masculinity that we're trying to evaluate and discard. But not everyone has
- 13:41a mentor or a role model or a place to talk about that. So
- 13:45you have all these men and boys who have been fully indoctrinated into toxic masculine
- 13:52ideas, and then all of a sudden, overnight, seemingly they're being attacked
- 13:56and told that, and they're also missing staining it to mean that all of
- 14:01masculinity is wrong, which is not the case. It's just a section of
- 14:05percentage, probably a small percentage. I mean, the entire discourse around masculinity
- 14:11is important to evaluate, but for me, there's only certain things that are
- 14:18discardable and should be discarded and aren't harmful. They're just harmful notions that we
- 14:22are given, like men can't have emotions. That's toxic masculine. That's a
- 14:26toxic masculine idea which is inhuman and harmful to men and everyone around them.
- 14:33So for these boys and men, they've already been brainwashed and conditioned, and
- 14:39they they've already started orienting their lives in that direction. Then all of a
- 14:45sudden, they're said, they're told that they're horrible, and and they have
- 14:48nowhere to look. So Andrew Tate and other people like him emerge because these
- 14:54men and boys need someone to save them. And the things that he says
- 15:00are exaggerations of toxic masculine ideals, such as I'm in total control of myself
- 15:07and I just have to use my mind and the strength of my brain.
- 15:13The strength of my willpower is so strong that I can overcome any mental issue,
- 15:20even depression, which is a very destructive thing to say to people and
- 15:26illogical, unscientific and ridiculous. Now, if he wants to say, there
- 15:31are times when I find myself going down a certain pattern of behavior and thinking
- 15:37that I have found leads to bad things for me that I call depression,
- 15:41I doubt he actually suffered from, actually, because if he actually had depression,
- 15:45he wouldn't be talking this way. But I don't know who knows.
- 15:48And you know, if he himself said, look, if I start going
- 15:50down sort of world, and you know, people, I've treated people with
- 15:52major depression, and some people will have that solution, not everyone. They
- 15:58will have a solution of I just have. Like Lady Gaga talked about this
- 16:03at an interview I think with Oprah. She said that she suffers fer depression
- 16:07or some sort of mood issue. What she said was that in the morning
- 16:10she just gets up. She wants to just stay in bed, she wants
- 16:12to just avoid and shut down, but she knows that if she does that,
- 16:17it'll just cascade. So she just takes one st Okay, get up,
- 16:19take a shower, Okay, eat something, walk the dog. You
- 16:22know, it can be hard work. For non depressed people, it doesn't
- 16:26feel as arduous, but for depressed people it can feel very arduous. And
- 16:30so some people will cope with that by saying I'm not going to allow myself
- 16:34to become depressed. I'm going to not give in to the depression. It
- 16:38doesn't take away the depression, but it is a component in some individuals with
- 16:44mood disorders in their solution to the problem. So if he said something like
- 16:48that, that would be great. But what he's saying is essentially everyone who
- 16:52is depressed does not have my strength of mind, which is quite a brag.
- 16:59Oh, I can't you shape your own reality through the conviction of your
- 17:03thoughts, your beliefs, and the words that you use. Why else would
- 17:07you adopt any kind of mindset unless it's designed specifically to make you competitive and
- 17:11make you win. You install the software in your mind right, So if
- 17:15I'm going to install software in my mind. So everything's about competition and winning,
- 17:19which is also a part of the toxic masculine ideology. Now, I
- 17:25like to compete and I like to win as well, if I'm playing cards,
- 17:30or when I was a kid, when I played sports, or if
- 17:33I'm trying to get views on YouTube for example. You know, it's a
- 17:37bit of a I wouldn't say competition, but you know I'm trying to succeed,
- 17:41so that there's nothing wrong with that, right, But the way that
- 17:45he talks about it that it's the sole reason for living is to compete,
- 17:51meaning I will beat others. You know, it's one thing to succeed,
- 17:55it's another thing to compete. Compete means you're competing against you are winning over
- 18:00other people are losing. You're winning and everyone else is losing. Well,
- 18:03I've tried very hard to create it right, because wasn't installed by your upbringing,
- 18:08wasn't installed by your mother and your father in some way before you were
- 18:14conscious, while you were just developing child like, something got programmed into your
- 18:18psyche that has to have an impact on you. I will say that I'm
- 18:22looking up his name again, David Sutcliffe. I think was yeah, I
- 18:25will say that, you know, we don't know what's going on in his
- 18:27mind. He might even come across like he likes Andrew Tate. But it's
- 18:33also and maybe he does, meaning that he believes in Andrew Tate's message.
- 18:37Who knows, but given what I've seen so far, it is also possible
- 18:41that David Sutcliffe, if you were to talk with him behind the scenes,
- 18:45like if you were a friend of his, he might say something like,
- 18:48oh, yeah, Andrew Tait is an awful, awful person. But when
- 18:52I'm being a therapist or I'm in that role, then I have a much
- 18:56different mindset and vibe because for me as a therapist, that happens not so
- 19:03often anymore because I you know, in the last I don't know ten fifteen
- 19:07years, the sort of clients that I've had in my practice, I haven't
- 19:11really ran into this, but before that, there are many instances where I
- 19:15would be working with a client and had you know, if I were free
- 19:19to evaluate them as like a friend or someone I would want to hang out
- 19:23with, or someone I wouldn't mind dating one of my family members or something,
- 19:30then I would have a lot of judgmental or critical or cautionary things to
- 19:36say about this individual. But for us therapists, it's important for us to
- 19:40build rapport and for us to have a connection for them to trust us and
- 19:44be saved with it. If we're going the people that are the most abrasive
- 19:48to therapists are typically very abrasive to everyone around them, And the people who
- 19:52are very abrasive to everyone around them, including therapists, need the most therapy.
- 19:57And if they're going to stay in therapy, then they have to feel
- 20:02safe with us. They have to kind of like us. They have to
- 20:04feel like we're on their side. So when I talk with individuals who otherwise
- 20:10I might try to distance myself from, I lean in and I enter their
- 20:15world. And those things can't necessarily be known because you were at such a
- 20:18young age. Absolutely, we're all programmed to some degree. I agree with
- 20:22you on this so far. I don't think anybody can escape programming. Whether
- 20:26it's society, whether it's a television show, whether it's the people around you,
- 20:29peer pressure, whether it's a religion. We're all programmed to some degree.
- 20:32That's absolutely not really true. What I have done, and what I
- 20:34think most people do not do, is heavily analyze why I hold the beliefs
- 20:37I hold, why they help me I don't if I don't hold the belief
- 20:42personally, or if I didn't learn it from personal experience. I know where
- 20:45it came from who tried to teach me that, whether their intentions for me
- 20:49were good or bad. So he's just doubling down in that idea that he
- 20:53is in full control and he's smarter or better, has better willpower or a
- 21:00system or something. But like I was saying earlier, it's possible, but
- 21:04not likely. It's more likely that this is him either wanting to sell his
- 21:12product. You know, he comes across to me like a salesperson constantly.
- 21:17I think he's in a constant state of selling something. And he does sell
- 21:22a lot of things, classes and other kinds of things, right, So
- 21:26I think he is savvy in that way. And also it's possible that he's
- 21:32trying to convince himself and everyone around him that he lacks any weakness or inferiority
- 21:37as he sees it, because he believes himself to be extremely inferior and extremely
- 21:44flawed, and he's in this constant defensive treadmill running trying to get forward in
- 21:51life, even though he's getting nowhere trying to run away from that notion that
- 21:56he developed when he was younger. For some reason, I've tried very hard
- 21:59to have my mindset rigidly analyzed and make sure that it's put together in a
- 22:04way which benefits me completely and absolutely. And I do not believe in things
- 22:07that take away power from me. I refuse to do that. I would
- 22:11rather say that they are not real. And people will sit here and argue
- 22:15to the end of time that they are real, but they're not real in
- 22:18my world, and I live inside of my mind. So even if you
- 22:21throw me in a Romanian dungeon, the idea that I become a depressed person
- 22:25is not a framework that my mind works within. So I can't become depressed.
- 22:27I can feel a little bit sad, sure, I can feel depressed,
- 22:30but I can't be depressed. I will say that as a therapist,
- 22:34I have had clients like him who, when I'm doing it right, eventually
- 22:41they will assume that I am mostly on board with their way of thinking because
- 22:47I haven't refuted it, I haven't argued against it, I haven't agreed with
- 22:52it overtly, but I have investigated, and I've reflected, and I've tried
- 22:56to pick out things that I can compliment if you will. Well, when
- 23:00that starts to happen, I know that I'm establishing rappoor with a client,
- 23:03I will tell myself that, okay, you know, eventually I'm going to
- 23:07start to test the waters regarding how sensitive they are to criticism or how intolerant
- 23:15they are to exploring the possibility that they don't have it all figured out.
- 23:18Because for people who present this way, you know, behind the closed doors,
- 23:22he might not be anything like this. I don't know, but people
- 23:26who present like this in therapy have typically they have a very, very huge
- 23:32sensitivity to criticism and any implications that they don't have it all figured out,
- 23:38because that's that's their foundation of safety. The only way that they feel safe
- 23:44in the world is if everyone else understands and they themselves have deluted themselves,
- 23:48you know, they've deluted everyone and themselves that they have it all figured out.
- 23:52If they can do that and there's a constant need for a supply around
- 23:55that, then they can kind of relax. They're not fully ever relaxed,
- 23:59because of their traumas that are always chasing them. But they can kind of
- 24:03relax any implication, meaning that if someone close to them, a therapist,
- 24:07were to think, you know, there's a question mark there, I don't
- 24:11know if you have it all figured out, that opens this, you know,
- 24:14if the door is a jar. It's sort of like in those comedy
- 24:17movies where they shove all the clutter in the house into a closet and then
- 24:22someone comes along and opens the door, Ajar, and all the stuff just
- 24:25comes pouring out. That's how it feels to them. If someone opens the
- 24:29door Ajar and says I don't know if you have it all figured out,
- 24:32they're terrified and convinced that all of their flaws and inferiority aspects will just come
- 24:38flooding in. And sometimes they do, and they will decompensate and they will
- 24:44suffer greatly. But anyway, so he's talking about going to prison, and
- 24:48he said he did get sad sometimes, and so that's a little bit in
- 24:52the direction of what some might call weakness. It's not weak to be sad.
- 24:57It's human to be sad. It's like saying it's weak to be thirsty
- 25:00or something. It's just an evolved feeling that we have and it's an indication
- 25:06of you know, if you're in prison, you might feel unfairly treated,
- 25:11or might feel extremely limited in your freedom and uncertain about the future, pessimistic
- 25:18about the future, and then you get sad, which is going to allow
- 25:22me to be a fearsome competitor in all realms of human endeavor. Have there
- 25:26been some of your beliefs or convictions that have been challenged through the experiences that
- 25:30you've had, particularly the last well recently, well, people challenge me often,
- 25:36and what a lot of people don't understand is that, Yeah, so
- 25:40David Sutcliffe was asking, I believe what he was asking was, have any
- 25:45of your beliefs that you had prior to all the things that have happened to
- 25:48you, has reality challenged those such that you've changed your beliefs or have you
- 25:55challenged your own beliefs at all? That's what David is asking. I think
- 25:59that's a kind of a good question to ask, given where Andrew Tate was
- 26:03headed. And then Andrew Tate and answers it in the way that he did,
- 26:07which is, well, yeah, people are trying to challenge my beliefs,
- 26:11and this is how that they're all wrong. Isn't that interesting that David
- 26:15asked a question about just Andrew Tate, Like, forget everyone else, just
- 26:19think about yourself. When have you and maybe David will follow it up with
- 26:23that, But has there in a mint of time when you changed your belief
- 26:26based on what was happening to you? And that's kind of like the paradox
- 26:32where people will say, you know, can God make a rock so big
- 26:36that he can't even pick it up? Either answer says that God is not
- 26:41omnipotent, right, And when you ask someone and I have no idea what
- 26:45Andrew Tate's real personality is, but his public persona is the one. It's
- 26:48pretty consistent, and you know what his public persona is such that if you
- 26:55ask him that question, have you ever had a belief that you found to
- 26:59be wrong and you changed it? Then that's in a similar vein not exactly
- 27:03the same as that God with the rock thing, because if he you know,
- 27:08on one hand, it's like, well, yeah, I have full
- 27:11control over myself, so I'm going to change my beliefs, you know,
- 27:14I'm that strong. But on the other side, at some point he had
- 27:18to have been wrong, so there's no way out of that. Question.
- 27:21There's no answer that question that will have his public persona upheld in which he's
- 27:29perfect and he's never been wrong. So he at the very least, you
- 27:36know, possibly subconsciously but maybe consciously, just interprets the question in this different
- 27:41way of like, well, yeah, people you know. And also for
- 27:44people with this public persona or I just say, with this presentation, either
- 27:48publicly or privately, they are very outwardly focused. They're very very focused on
- 27:53how other people see them. It's it's really an obsession because they're in this
- 28:00constant state of trying to prove themselves because of what they went through when they
- 28:03were going up. I will never adopt the thinking of somebody who is sad,
- 28:06and I will never adopt the thinking of somebody who is less competitive than
- 28:08I am or less successful than I am. If someone comes along, goes
- 28:11Andrew, you are wrong. The way you see the world is wrong.
- 28:15But they are suffering from an affliction. Why would I adopt a single one?
- 28:18And it's also possible again it's hard for me not to see this through
- 28:22my therapist lens. If I asked that question to an individual who was presenting
- 28:26this way and they answered this way, I would wonder if they're actually saying
- 28:32something to me, which often will be the case clients like this, especially
- 28:36if they're volunteering for therapy. They don't want to get into a fight with
- 28:41me. That's not what they came to therapy for. So when they have
- 28:47what they perceive to be an attack, and people like this can absolutely perceive
- 28:51it as an attack. That question that David asked, which is did you
- 28:53ever belief that you had to change? It can be very threatening because they
- 28:57kind of know what that's inpating, and they also suspect that it's a question
- 29:03that reveals a bigger idea in the therapist's mind, that is skepticism of the
- 29:08client's presentation and way of thinking, and so it's very threatening to them,
- 29:14and so some of them will respond in the way that Andrew Tate did by
- 29:18saying, people are always trying to tell me that I'm wrong. But what
- 29:21the client is really saying is you're telling me that I'm wrong, which isn't
- 29:25what David was saying. But because of the traumas and the schemas and the
- 29:29lens and the reactivity, that's how it's felt. And then the client will
- 29:34triangulate talk about outside people, but they're really talking to the therapist io of
- 29:44what they say. So it's kind of funny when I talk about depression the
- 29:47number of people who defend depression. Depressions ruined my life. It's super real,
- 29:52and my loss my wife and my life is over and I want to
- 29:53kill myself. It's real. Like, surely you should like my worldview if
- 29:59depressions don't tear parable and has destroyed your entire existence, right, you should
- 30:02be listening. I'm sure this is a straw man that he is constructing the
- 30:07way he mockingly role plays people that are saying that depression is real, and
- 30:11then his response is just so well, it's deplorable too. What it sounds
- 30:21like is someone reached out to him and said, well, I'm really depressed,
- 30:25and your notion that somehow that you can just overcome depression by sheer will
- 30:30power is not working for me or is hurting my feelings because it basically you're
- 30:36saying I'm weak or something, And so they're seemingly trying to give avance entritudie.
- 30:40No, No, depression is real. Believe me. I've been through
- 30:42some really bad experiences and now I have a hard time getting up in the
- 30:48morning, and I feel no motivation, and I don't take pleasure in anything
- 30:52anymore. And I need medication that kind of helps sometimes, and I go
- 30:56to therapy and it kind of helps sometimes, But then another thing will happen
- 31:00to me, and you know, I can't sleep at night, or I
- 31:03sleep too much, or I'm gaining weight, or I can't eat or you
- 31:06know, it's a it's a real thing. Obviously, I don't have to
- 31:10tell you that. But for Andrew Tate to create this straw man of someone
- 31:14that's just like stubbornly weak or something, and then he says, well,
- 31:19surely, wouldn't you want my perspective because my way is better. Just don't
- 31:26be depressed. Yeah, to me tell you it's not real. But instead
- 31:32they're defending it and sticking up for it, which I find very interesting.
- 31:36So that's the first thing in regards to whether I have had any of my
- 31:40convictions challenged. It's kind of amazing. Maybe it's just a semantics trick,
- 31:44and maybe it's that simple. Maybe it's as simple as saying, I feel
- 31:48a little bit depressed today, but I am not a depressed person, and
- 31:51I cannot become depressive, I'm not good. So actually, what he's talking
- 31:53about is a well known and established technique in treating people with very different issues,
- 32:00including depression. You can call it cognitive therapy. You can call it
- 32:02narrative therapy. That exact phrase will be used in therapy. I've used it
- 32:07sometimes or proposed it. You know, they will say I experience depression,
- 32:12but I am not a depressed person. And what they mean by that is
- 32:15I'm not going to let this become my identity, because if I let it
- 32:17become my identity, then I've truly given up, or I'm truly lost,
- 32:22or everything will be filtered through that identity. I'm experiencing depression every day for
- 32:29the past three months, but I refuse to believe that I am a depressed
- 32:32person. Or it can be medical too. Someone can say I experience chronic
- 32:38pain, but I refuse to be a chronic pain person. I'm not going
- 32:44to be labeled as that. I'm not going to think of myself as that
- 32:47I experience chronic pain and it's awful. Another tangent to this is to externalize.
- 32:53Various different therapies use this technique of saying I am me and the depression
- 33:00is over here, it's happening at me. And I might even give it
- 33:02a name like mister poopy Pants or the Demon. You know, I'm just
- 33:07thinking of names that clients have used, or the dark Sphere or something.
- 33:14And it helps to say that because for some people, when they're depressed,
- 33:17they start to think of it as being a part of who they are.
- 33:21It becomes infused in their personality. And when for some not everyone, but
- 33:27when they do that, then it can be very hard to dislodge it,
- 33:31even when you know, for some people when they actually start to recover from
- 33:36depression, you know, say that they've been depressed for five years, fifteen
- 33:39years, and they actually go to therapy, they go on medication, they
- 33:43start to emerge. They might, for example, they get invited to something
- 33:46and as soon as they get the invitation, they're like, I don't go
- 33:50to that because they still identify as a depressed person, even though if they
- 33:54thought about it, they actually want to go to the thing they're being invited
- 33:59to, but they're operating from the identity of a depressed person. I suspect
- 34:05for Andrew Tate, if he truly has never been depressed, that there have
- 34:07been times when he has felt demoralized and pessimistic and worried about the future,
- 34:15or maybe even wanting to give up, wanting to I just can't. I
- 34:20just can't do it. I can't try anymore. I don't want to fight
- 34:22anymore. I just have to I just want to sit here. And then
- 34:27he finds that if he says no, I'm not going to give up,
- 34:30I'm going to I'm going to continue to fight for him, he's saying that's
- 34:35depression, that's not I don't know, but if that is the case,
- 34:37that's not depression, that's just demoralization, that's lack of well burnt out,
- 34:43that kind of thing. And you know, I think that that would be
- 34:46fine if that's now. You know, the asterist to all this is that
- 34:52if the allegations are even somewhat on the mark, then it sounds funny to
- 34:58say that it's okay. I'll just say it's so okay for an individual,
- 35:00independent of the situation that they're in, to engage in that way of thinking.
- 35:05If they're trying to get out of demoralization, have depression, maybe it's
- 35:08just a semantics trip. And by saying that alone, I understand that it's
- 35:12a temporary state of mind which I can alter and I can affect. And
- 35:15I've never struggled with long term depression or long term negative thoughts because I don't
- 35:20believe in that mental model. So I've never struggled from long term depressed.
- 35:23I've never suffered from short term depression because I was raised very well and biologically,
- 35:31I'm not prone to that. People in my family aren't prone to that.
- 35:36We're prone to anxiety. I've never had clinical I've never been close to
- 35:42being clinically depressed. But it's not because I have this magical willpower of some
- 35:45sort. It's genetics, it's upbringing its attachment. So he's attributing it to
- 35:52his willpower or strength or something. And I think he's one, at the
- 35:58very least, trying to sell his product because if he says this, then
- 36:00he can get people to pay for things and he can make more money.
- 36:05But I also wonder if he needs to believe this because he needs to feel
- 36:10like he is superior and special believe in that. I don't think it's possible,
- 36:15so it just doesn't happen. You said you experienced depression, some form
- 36:19of depression or depression depressive feelings in sadness in prison? What were the thoughts
- 36:23that were coming up? What? So, this is a question that I
- 36:28might ask too. In this situation, everything depends on what Andrew Tate,
- 36:31if he were to talk with me or someone like him, what they wanted
- 36:35from me. You know, you might wonder, well, why would someone
- 36:38like Andrew Tate even come to therapy? Well, I'll tell you from memory
- 36:44and also just from research that people who present like Andrew Tate there. They
- 36:49might come across like they have everything figured out, and they might consciously believe
- 36:52that they have everything figured out, But the underlying traumas and their defenses and
- 36:57the way they treat other people result often in them having a very hard time
- 37:02getting their needs met, specifically their needs met regarding dependency, interdependency and mutual
- 37:07dependency and love and attachment and neediness. They deny their neediness very firmly and
- 37:15are very upset if you even imply that they have needs around this, that
- 37:22they have normal human emotions and attachment needs, And so they will go their
- 37:27whole life without getting those needs met, and they will become symptomatic in some
- 37:30way. They might become depressed. They might use a lot of substances.
- 37:35They might feel empty on the inside. They might feel like their life is
- 37:38meaningless. They might notice that they're getting into a lot of fights with their
- 37:43spouse, or that they find they are quick to rage in ways that they
- 37:50can't control, and so they might get fired from a job, they might
- 37:53go through a divorce, and suddenly, even though they know they have everything
- 37:59figured out, they also suspect that something's going on, so they end up
- 38:02in therapy. Another presentation is that they kind of know that something's going on
- 38:08with them, but they don't really know what it is, and they can't
- 38:12really admit that there's anything wrong with them, but they do want to explore
- 38:15things. They have enough flexibility within their personality to say, I would like
- 38:22to explore my childhood or the way that I think, or philosophies that I
- 38:28should be adhering to. And they might even seek out a therapist that they
- 38:32perceive as having a lot of intelligence. For a lot of people like this,
- 38:37it's incredibly important that they find someone that they believe to be at their
- 38:40level intellectually wise, and so they might seek out a therapist, and you
- 38:46know, when they come to my office, the beginning of therapy can feel
- 38:50very without foundation because I don't know. I keep asking them, like what
- 38:53they want, and they keep saying exploration, and I'm like, okay,
- 38:57what do you want to explore? And then they might explore certain things,
- 39:00but at the end of every session it feels like it's not because there are
- 39:04people that want to explore things. But the real issue is with these folks
- 39:07is they're not actually wanting to explore things. They keep running into a barrier.
- 39:12They have some part of their motivation and their personality it's saying I need
- 39:15help, but another part of them saying no, no, no. So
- 39:19they do this limbo zone in therapy where they're kind of exploring but not really
- 39:22And so once I detect that, then I do a lot of various things
- 39:27based on what's being presented, and I'll test the waters. I'm trying to
- 39:30connect with this part of them, and I'm trying to soothe this part of
- 39:35them. I'm like, hey, it's you know, you don't need that.
- 39:36It's okay, the barrier's fine, but you know this part is a
- 39:39good part. You know, let's let it over the barrier. Sometimes that's
- 39:44the visual I guess I have in my mind right now. But there's other
- 39:46presentations too. But at any rate, he is now asking Davis, now
- 39:50asking, so you identify in prison that you were sad, depressed, something
- 39:55was happening, what was going on there? So this will be very interesting
- 39:59to see how Andrew Tate responds, because if he has it in him,
- 40:02and he also trusts David and he is willing to share with the entire world
- 40:07on the Internet, then he might say something like, well, yeah,
- 40:13it was a pretty dark moment for me, but I you know. But
- 40:15then, but at the very least he would admit that he does have human
- 40:19emotion. But there's another possibility that if this because if I were in David's
- 40:25shoes, I wouldn't ask this question at this point because I would worry that
- 40:30I would step on a landmine. And the risk here is that Andrew Tate
- 40:35could well one just walk out. That'll happen sometimes. But the other is
- 40:40that he'll say, well, you know, I said depression, but you
- 40:44know everything. You know. It's astonishing how denial works for people. And
- 40:50when you're really concentrating on a client and you see them within the same sentence
- 40:55or paragraph completely contradict themselves, you see that transition from you know, saying
- 41:01something to denying it and and I, you know, I don't judge it.
- 41:06I do it too, We all do it. There's a reason for
- 41:08that. But there's a possibility that he'll just go intoplete complete now, although
- 41:13he's already led the way. So let's see it. Let's see what Andrew
- 41:15Tate does here. What was happening, Well, there's a lot of uncertainty,
- 41:19which is the first thing, which it has to be scary. It
- 41:21is scary. And then David very adeptly identifies with the emotion for therapists and
- 41:29really for parents, for teachers, just friends. This is a very good
- 41:34thing to keep in mind that when people first present, you know, I'll
- 41:37be talking to other therapists who obviously have a lot of emotional intelligence, and
- 41:43even those folks will frame things intellectually, they will intellectualize as a defense.
- 41:49So what happened was fear, was the terrifying feeling that Andrew Tate was going
- 41:54through because of the uncertainty. The uncertainty was happening of will I be in
- 42:00prison forever? Will everything fall apart from me? Will I have no more
- 42:05fans? You know, Yeah, it's terrifying. You could say it's justified
- 42:07that he has that terror, but whatever, he has that terrifying feeling.
- 42:10But he intellectualizes that as he recalls it and says there was a lot of
- 42:14uncertainty the therapist again, friend, listener, parent, teacher. It can
- 42:20help if you think that it's safe enough to do this, to say,
- 42:23wow, that must have been terrifying. And the fact that Andrew Tate responded
- 42:28well. One, the fact that Andrew Tate even presented something that David could
- 42:31respond means that Andrew Tate is flexible enough, healthy enough, if you will,
- 42:38and trust David enough to say such a thing. And maybe he learned
- 42:43something in prison that he needed to talk about this more so, I don't
- 42:46know who knows, but he says uncertainty. David says that must have been
- 42:51terrified, and he says it in an empathetic way, and then Andrew says,
- 42:54yes, it was terrifying. That's when you know therapy is working,
- 43:00or a conversation is working. When as David intuits very quickly and might have
- 43:06even been kind of setting up or trying to get to this place. I
- 43:10wouldn't be surprised if David didn't have a plan. But was acting intuitively,
- 43:15but had kind of a general direction that he wanted to go. That's typical
- 43:19because it's the thing that happens with therapy. Novice therapists. They tend to
- 43:23make a lot of plans because they're really nervous about providing therapy, and so
- 43:30you know, the night before they'll be like, taking, Okay, I
- 43:31want to do this, I want to get here, I want to hear.
- 43:34Ninety nine point nine nine percent of the time, those plans are completely
- 43:37thrown out the window because you cannot predict what will happen in a session,
- 43:42even with clients that are fairly predictable anyway. So David, you know,
- 43:46asked that question and then Andrew's like the quickness, right, you're past someone's
- 43:52defenses. And the fact that Andrew Tate, you know, eye contact.
- 43:55That's another kind of thing to watch is that when when does you Tate look
- 44:00at his eyes as opposed to not. For people who present like this,
- 44:04and I don't know Andrew Tate's personality, but people who present like this typically
- 44:07have a background an upbringing in which they were harmed and are neglected fairly significantly,
- 44:14and early in life, at the age of twelve, months old,
- 44:16they learned it was better not to have eye contact because to have eye contact
- 44:22meant that you were going to get hurt or rejected, and so it's just
- 44:24better to turn away and to not be noticed or to just focus on something
- 44:30else. And so when they're exploring and having conversation, they will tend to
- 44:35do this. If you ever noticed, you know, it's not something that's
- 44:38always the eye contact is kind of complicated. Some people just need to think,
- 44:43and so they will not look at your face because it's easier for them
- 44:45to concentrate if they're sort of just looking into the void. And there's a
- 44:51lot of pseudo science around eye movements. It's all nonsense. Science has debunked
- 44:55it a thousand times over. But eye contact is something that will show patterns
- 45:00and does have indications of something potentially anyway. But he locks in on David,
- 45:07like, let's rewatch that depressive feelings in sadness in prison. What were
- 45:10the thoughts that were coming up? What was happening. Well, there's a
- 45:13lot of uncertainty, which is the first thing, which it has to be
- 45:15scary. It is scary. It's scary. And also so if I had
- 45:20a supervising a trainee in my university or someone I was supervising who showed me
- 45:23a clip like this, I would really highlight how well they nailed that.
- 45:29They set up the question not manipulatively, but they intuited to ask, you
- 45:32know, like what was it like there? And also the delivery that David
- 45:37has, he is natural. He doesn't come across like he's trying to get
- 45:40him right. It comes across like he's a human being, Like he's asking
- 45:45from his own heart, not from his head. So he's asking that question.
- 45:49Andrew Tate responds and then immediately David says it must have been in the
- 45:52natural way that he responds off it must have been terrifying. You know,
- 45:58I could role play a role botic version of that, like that must have
- 46:01been terrified. So with my trainees and myself when I was first becoming a
- 46:08therapist, you're often terrified of what it is to be a therapist, and
- 46:13so you just want a prescription. It's like, tell me what to do,
- 46:15and you end up absorbing these listening techniques and then you try to follow
- 46:22those rules. But when you're thinking about them too much, they don't come
- 46:25from your soul, from your heart, from your humanness, and other people
- 46:30will be put off by that, obviously, so you have to get so
- 46:34used to those techniques such that they just naturally fly out of you, emerging
- 46:39from your humanists, which it did seemingly for David, and I think Andrew
- 46:43Tate responded to that in that way. I'm totally in control of your world,
- 46:47of your life, and that's almost like an imperative for you, and
- 46:51that gives you power, and all of a sudden you're thrust into a situation
- 46:54where you're essentially helpless. Well you just nailed it, You completely nailed because
- 47:00I was exactly about to say, it's the uncertainty that I struggle with the
- 47:04most because in my life I'm in charge of everything. I know exactly how
- 47:07everything works, and I'm the boss and I get to control absolutely everything.
- 47:09And this is the first time in a long time I'm in a scenario where
- 47:12I have no power whatsoever, no influence. Basically, I don't know what's
- 47:15going to happen. Nobody else knows what's going to happen. So that's interesting.
- 47:20And I'm guessing that David is picking up on this that Andrew Tate is.
- 47:24I don't know if he knows he's revealing this, but he's essentially revealing
- 47:28that he has a complex or a need for the defense that involves him constantly
- 47:34being in control and or believing that he's in control. None of us are
- 47:38in control of wide swaths of our lives. For people that go through sudden
- 47:45medical changes will attest to that. And we tend to walk around thinking,
- 47:50well, as long as I eat right and exercise right and take care of
- 47:52about everything, you'll be fine. And then all of a sudden boom,
- 47:55something happens regardless of you taking care of yourself, and then you realize,
- 48:00oh, I guess I don't have full control over my lives. And so
- 48:04that notion that he believes that he's in constant control of everything is absurd,
- 48:09and we all benefit from recognizing that we don't have full control over things,
- 48:15and ex essentially we really have to accept it. We have to fully embrace
- 48:21the reality that we don't have control over some very fundamental things like life itself.
- 48:28We all die. We don't have control over that. We don't have
- 48:30control over time and aging and the economy and our spouses, let alone our
- 48:37own behavior and psychologist. So the notion that he's in constant control of everything
- 48:43in his life all the time. You know, it just illuminates some need
- 48:46I'm contrasting that with you know, the fact that he says he's in constant
- 48:51control is in such contrast with reality. It points to that he needs to
- 48:55believe and will do a lot of things to give him evidence that he and
- 49:00control, and of course that points potentially to trauma, that he was traumatized.
- 49:05When people go through trauma early or really throughout one's life, but particularly
- 49:08when it's chronic over time, as a child, whether you consciously identify with
- 49:13this or not, you will feel very much like you have no control over
- 49:15things, particularly if the chaos and the abuse and the mistreatment had to do
- 49:21with things like your parents moving from town to town, or your parents with
- 49:27substance. Abuse can also cause children, even though the child isn't being abused
- 49:31directly, they feel very much out of control, like they wish they had
- 49:36control. And then once they get older and they have more power of their
- 49:39lives, one road of defensive structure is to be obsessive about control such that
- 49:46you will not have to risk going back to the way things were when you
- 49:52were young. The irony is that when individuals do this, they tend to
- 49:57in a way, recreate what happened when they were young, inadvertently, because
- 50:01when you're a two year old child, five year old child, what you're
- 50:06wanting is security and love and attuonement and safety and certainty, or at least
- 50:12a lack of undo uncertainty. And so when you are denied that and there's
- 50:17chaos and abuse and his treatment, and you're like, Okay, if I
- 50:22only had control, then I would be able to get that attunement and love
- 50:25and safety, and then they just focus on the control. Then they grow
- 50:30up and they say, okay, I'm doing the control thing, and they
- 50:32will push out all relationships and any flexibility because in order to be in a
- 50:38relationship, you have to accept that you don't have control over much. With
- 50:43my wife, I have zero control over her and her personality. I don't
- 50:49even have control over myself, for crying out loud, how could I possibly
- 50:52have control over her? And accepting that and working within that reality and having
- 50:58humility around that and allowing other people to run the show when they want to
- 51:04or when they need to is a part of a relationship and that's how things
- 51:08go. And so when someone dedicates themselves obsessively to control. You could imagine
- 51:15that they would deny themselves any kind of relationships. So they're actually recreating the
- 51:21past, and that they're very alone in my worldview. In my world,
- 51:29I'm the hero, right, I'm the head of the klan, not just
- 51:30my family, but of a law of people. A lot of people rely
- 51:34on me, lots of women rely on me, children rely on me,
- 51:37et cetera. So everyone comes to me every time there's a problem. So
- 51:39they continue to do that while I'm in a jail cell, expecting me to
- 51:42have some kind of answer, and I'm like, well, I don't have
- 51:44an answer this time. Every other time I had an answer, but this
- 51:46time is a bit unique. How did that feel? You don't have the
- 51:50answers? So, yeah, it's good good therapist, good instinct, And
- 51:53it takes a skilled therapist to let a lot of those things go by.
- 52:00The things that Andrew Tate says. You know, I'm not in my therapist
- 52:02mode right now. I'm YouTuber mode, I suppose. So when I'm listening
- 52:07to Andrew Tate talk, you know, they're just a couple of lines,
- 52:12and you know, if you just said there was uncertainty. I didn't know
- 52:15what was going on, and I was letting a lot of people down.
- 52:17Then it wouldn't irk me. But the way he frames it is I had
- 52:21all these women that depend on me and all these children that depend on me,
- 52:24and people are coming to me for answers, and I said, hey,
- 52:28circumstances are different. Now, you know. It's a weird way to
- 52:30frame all that. It's an indication of the way he sees the world.
- 52:35There's always an opposition, there's always someone outside of him that is being annoying,
- 52:38right, and so to look past all of that, just to just
- 52:44let that go past you as a therapist, and to try to highlight the
- 52:49content that Andrew Tate is presenting that is more human and might head down a
- 52:54road of perhaps helpfulness to Andrew Tate. I think that's what David is trying
- 53:00to do. That what'rer on? The time I had an answer, but
- 53:00this time is a bit unique. How did that feel? You don't have
- 53:04the answers, you can't help? Yeah, I mean it was frustrating.
- 53:07It's very frustrating, and it's the uncertainty that would bother to me. I
- 53:10don't think I felt sad very often, but I certainly felt extremely frustrated.
- 53:15I would sit there and think, there has to be a way out of
- 53:20this room. This is interesting. He is being more vulnerable than I've ever
- 53:23seen. And you know, I've probably seen zero point zero one percent of
- 53:28the content that he has, probably even less than that on the internet.
- 53:30You know, I barely watched any of his material. So maybe he's like
- 53:35this often. But the stuff that I've seen, he does not even come
- 53:39close to this kind of humanness right now. It's not as human as I
- 53:46would wish for him, so that he would live a happier life. And
- 53:50I don't know, but I suspect a happier life that would not harm other
- 53:54people. I don't know if he's harming others, but there's a lot of
- 53:58evidence that he might be. So he has a long way to go to
- 54:00get there. But this is in that direction. I wake up and I
- 54:04go I want more money. If I can get pissed off enough about it,
- 54:07I can do thirty six hour workdays. Right. So there's nothing wrong
- 54:09with being angry in my world as long as you are putting it in the
- 54:13correct direction. It's uncontrolled anger, I think is a problem, right anger
- 54:16can be used as a fuel, and it's necessary, and from my framework,
- 54:21anger sometimes is a mask for pain. I'd agree with that, so
- 54:25did you. So I just figured out where David Sutcliffe I know him from.
- 54:30He is Chris on Gilmore Girls. He's Rory's dad. The beard just
- 54:37makes them look so different. But if I just don't look at the beard,
- 54:39everything above the beard, that's Chris from Gilmore Girls. So this is
- 54:45weird. I've watched Gilmore Girls three times, I believe, all the way
- 54:51through. At first, I didn't like it because I thought they'd talked too
- 54:53fast, and I also thought that lore Li's parenting was problematic. But over
- 54:59time I fell in love with the show, and I wonder if I wonder
- 55:05if it's time to watch again, although there's so many shows I want to
- 55:07watch again, like The Office and Parks and rec what I was saying.
- 55:12He is saying that what's here can be used as a fuel, and it's
- 55:16necessary, and from my frame, anger sometimes is a mask for pain.
- 55:22Right, So he's either using emotion folks therapy or some other framework of therapy,
- 55:27or his own as he puts it, that will put forth that anger
- 55:30can often be a secondary emotion or a response to being hurt or being afraid,
- 55:37And that is something that I find to be a very useful framework.
- 55:40Sometimes it's hard to fit every experience of anger into this framework, but often
- 55:46it is useful to see this way, and it does resonate with people,
- 55:51and it resonates with me. And I think what David is trying to get
- 55:52at is you were angry that you were incarcerated because you were no longer in
- 55:58control and saying that you were frustrated and you were angry. Is it possible
- 56:02that there was some other emotion that was that preceded that anger, like being
- 56:07hurt or being afraid. Can you admit that to yourself? And I hope
- 56:13that people understand that therapy is not about digging up emotions or making people vulnerable
- 56:20just to make people vulnerable. It's designed to help people. It depends on
- 56:23the context, depends on the way it's done. Generally speaking, when you
- 56:25see this kind of interaction, the therapist is doing this kind of against the
- 56:31defa. It's sort of like a therapist. So if I was in David's
- 56:35shoes and I was treating someone like Andrew Tate, I would kind of see
- 56:38Andrew Tate as two different people, or two different modes within him. One
- 56:42is the true Andrew, someone who is human and able to have all the
- 56:46normal human emotions, and once to have those emotions and once to express them,
- 56:52once to have them received, once to have them taken care of,
- 56:55also want some self compassion around those emotions. I would see that. Then
- 57:00I would see another part of Andrew, of him being defensive about it,
- 57:04saying and everyone has these modes, even very emotionally intelligent people will when they
- 57:10narrativize their life, they will have a much easier time identifying frustration and anger
- 57:16and irritability than they will expressing or even acknowledging to themselves that they were afraid
- 57:22or they were hurt. So what I'd be thinking if I were in David
- 57:25chooses, Okay, I'm getting the defense, but how do I get to
- 57:30the real Edittate? And so when I get there and that part of him
- 57:34is allowed to express himself when he feels safe, then I will reward that,
- 57:39so to speak, with a corrective experience of making him feel hurt and
- 57:43understood and not judged and safe and cared about. And then the defensive part
- 57:49of him that is always saying no, I'm just I'm just angry, or
- 57:52I don't have emotions, that defense won't be needed as much and the ego
- 57:57won't utilize it as much, so that the real human and on the inside
- 58:00is able to you know, we have needs around that when we have an
- 58:02emotion, it's an indication typically of a need that is being perturbed or satisfied,
- 58:08you know, because emotions can be joy and other kinds of positive emotions.
- 58:14So when we are hurt and we are afraid, we have you know,
- 58:19something's happening to us, and it's very common that we want to express
- 58:23them to ourselves to have it be acknowledged and also have it be reacted to
- 58:29like we I'm fairly certain and there's no way to prove this or to experiment
- 58:34on humans in this way to find out, but there's a lot of evidence
- 58:37pointing to the very strong possibility that we evolved emotions like sadness because it benefited
- 58:44us. It benefited us in terms of procreation and survivability, and that when,
- 58:49for example, when we are left alone, you know, imagine two
- 58:53hundred thousand years ago and we're with our fifty members of our extended family and
- 59:00and tribe, and we are traveling around looking for food or shelter or something,
- 59:06and we're five years old or fifty years old, and we wander off
- 59:10and we get left behind, and then we get hurt. We're hurt because
- 59:15we thought that people cared about us. We also get afraid because we might
- 59:19be attacked. There were predators, like the sort of cat kingdom, the
- 59:23feline kingdom, would regularly eat us. As humans, we weren't at the
- 59:29top of the food chain back then, and so we evolved to have that
- 59:34immediate feeling of fear and also of hurt of like, hey, I thought
- 59:37people cared enough about me to tell me that they were leaving or to watch
- 59:40over me. And then one you're afraid, so you start looking around and
- 59:45oh my god. And so you are motivated to solve that fear by running
- 59:51and finding your people and say you do. But then that fear of hurt
- 59:54of your feelings art also kicks in, so that it motivates you to cry
- 1:00:00or to say something of like hey, you guys, hurt my feelings,
- 1:00:02and then that alerts other people like, oh, next time, let's make
- 1:00:07sure that we tell Kirk that we're leaving, and we don't leave them behind
- 1:00:10because I have compassion. You know that. It's that whole emotion, behavior
- 1:00:16perception matrix, if you will. And then that led to that Kirk two
- 1:00:22hundred thousand years ago, living longer to be able to procreate and to propagate
- 1:00:27one's genes. So we have these needs, and when those needs are being
- 1:00:31frustrated, like we're being told by society that we can't have sadness or fear,
- 1:00:37then we just stuff it and we don't do anything about our emotions.
- 1:00:40We have things that are happening to us that cause fear and cause hurt,
- 1:00:44and we're just like, well, I'm a bad person. I'm ashamed of
- 1:00:47it. No one wants to listen to me. So I'm just going to
- 1:00:50keep it down. You know, I'm going to be I'm gonna have a
- 1:00:52strong mind, I'm of willpower. I'm going to distract myself with alcohol or
- 1:00:55weed and you know, I'm just gonna and all the while one's needs aren't
- 1:01:00being met. But we evolved to do that, and when we are able
- 1:01:04to do it, we can relax. And there's a function to it.
- 1:01:07I mean, forget two hundred thousand years ago, for just if you look
- 1:01:09at today when someone doesn't invite you to a party, or when or even
- 1:01:15just more simple, you're at the mall and your friends just wander off and
- 1:01:20they don't tell you that they're wandering off. You get sad and you go,
- 1:01:22hey, I felt like you kind of ditched me. Oh, I'm
- 1:01:24sorry. It keeps us bonded, It keeps us in our relationships. It
- 1:01:29alerts people that you care about the relationship or something. You know. There's
- 1:01:31a lot of function to that. And so when therapists are asking clients for
- 1:01:37this information of trying to soothe the defensive part of them, the defense and
- 1:01:44create safety for the humanness to come out. It's not just digging for emotion
- 1:01:49because it's like, ah, I got Andrew Tate to be vulnerable. It's
- 1:01:52actually a function of trying to help someone to realize that they can be human,
- 1:01:59and that they are human, and that there are options. You know,
- 1:02:02the hope would be for someone like Andrew Tate is the next time I
- 1:02:07have an emotion, maybe I'll actually acknowledge it and put aside my defensiveness and
- 1:02:12maybe even reach out to people in a way that is meeting my needs.
- 1:02:15I'd agree with that, So did you experience pain in there? I know
- 1:02:22that's a pain is a you know, a kind of an abstract word,
- 1:02:25but was it painful? So David asked another zinger, did you feel pain?
- 1:02:34And then Andrew Tate goes hm, which I would suspect if I were
- 1:02:39in David's shoes, that this is going too vulnerable or we've gone we've gone
- 1:02:45for too long in vulnerability. And then David follows it up with another version
- 1:02:51of that, trying to soften it a little bit, because I think he
- 1:02:53noticed that because previously, when David would ask a question that was getting at
- 1:02:59the vulnerable Eduitate would go like, yeah, and that's when you know you're
- 1:03:01in the flow. But now and Tate is going hmmm. Then that usually
- 1:03:07indicates to a therapist that oh, I've threatened something. We were in the
- 1:03:10flow and now now he's doing this. It's also possible that agitate just has
- 1:03:15to think about it. But let's see what he says, like, I
- 1:03:16want to know about your pain. Yeah, it's strange because I'm being as
- 1:03:22honest as possible. It's strange because I had this instilled sense of duty where
- 1:03:28even though I'm in a jail cell, and I can't leave, and even
- 1:03:30though I'm cripplingly bored, I don't feel like I had time to feel pain,
- 1:03:36or I didn't feel like I had time to be a victimized you had
- 1:03:37nothing but time. No, I didn't have time because everyone outside still relied
- 1:03:44on me. So when I would get on the phone, people say,
- 1:03:49is that avoidance? Though I don't know, you keep busy. If David
- 1:03:52were my trainee or he hired me to consult about this session, I would
- 1:03:59ask to David what was going on with him in this moment, because he's
- 1:04:02kind of peppering Andrew, you know, who cares just a YouTube video.
- 1:04:08But if this was an actual therapy session, I would worry that David is
- 1:04:12actually losing Andrew at this point because you know, the pain question was met
- 1:04:15with him Andrew saying I didn't have time to feel pain, And David's contention
- 1:04:21is you must have been feeling pain, because it's just I'm guessing David is
- 1:04:27thinking it would be impossible for you not to feel some version of pain in
- 1:04:31my help. If David were to specify what he means by pain, like
- 1:04:35self disappointment or hurt from the attacks, or something like that. But the
- 1:04:43way that Andrew is responding, it's a different mode than we saw earlier.
- 1:04:47It's also possible that the way that Andrew sees the word pain, he actually
- 1:04:53didn't feel pain. So it's also possible that Andrew's trying to appease by answering
- 1:04:59it kind of instead of just saying no, I didn't feel pain. Although
- 1:05:02you know, it's possible that David has it all figured out and he knows
- 1:05:05like he needs this to happen in the conversation for it to go in the
- 1:05:11direction that he hopes it will go. Do you avoid your feelings by keeping
- 1:05:14busy being on the computer all the time. All the things I had to
- 1:05:16do still had to be done. Just because they threw me in a cell,
- 1:05:20it just made it more difficult, which means I have less time than
- 1:05:24ever because the difficulty has been increased. And when I would get on the
- 1:05:26phone, we wouldn't discuss how I'm feeling. I'd be worried about how everyone
- 1:05:30else is. They'd like, how are you? Yeah, I'm in jail,
- 1:05:31what's going on with this? Are you okay? Are you? So
- 1:05:34it's very consistent with the persona that he presents that self denial of his humanness,
- 1:05:42and what that'll do to someone is the needs and emotions will pile up
- 1:05:46and pile up and pile up and express themselves in very problematic ways. If
- 1:05:51the allegations about Andrew Tate are even halfway through, I have very little sympathy
- 1:05:56for him as an individual. But I will say I've treated a lot of
- 1:05:59people who present like this, who did not commit crimes that he allegedly committed,
- 1:06:03that I had tremendous compassion for it, because even though they present this
- 1:06:09way as very pompous and they brag a lot and have it all figured out,
- 1:06:13that at their core. The thing that I tell people is that underneath
- 1:06:17the defensive structure of someone with narcissism is a borderline person. You know,
- 1:06:24if you're familiar, people with borderline percent I sort of on the surface,
- 1:06:28can be very vulnerable and their emotions are on their They wear their heart and
- 1:06:32their sleeve, They announce their emotions. They have a lot of pain and
- 1:06:40fear and hurt, and they will let you know about it if you're close
- 1:06:44enough to them. And for people with a narcissistic defensive structure, underneath is
- 1:06:48all of that, but they just have a way of masking it to themselves
- 1:06:51and others, and almost you could see it as people with narcisism are worse
- 1:06:57off than people with borderline because at least people with borderline express it sometimes,
- 1:07:02which will provoke at least sometimes attunement from other people or care or compassion,
- 1:07:08and maybe from themselves at the very least, they'll look at themselves and their
- 1:07:11needs and they'll be like, my needs aren't being met or I have these
- 1:07:14emotions. For people with narcisism that never happens unless they have a complete meltdown,
- 1:07:19which does happen sometimes. I'm not diagnosing them, of course, I'm
- 1:07:23just talking about my clinical experience as possible as persona has nothing to do with
- 1:07:27a real personality. But I use this as a jumping off point for people
- 1:07:30to think about their own lives for themselves. Some of you might also be
- 1:07:32in the narcissistic spectrum and might benefit from realizing that you two also have a
- 1:07:39lot of pain and hurt on the inside. That in fact, that is
- 1:07:42the primary corrective experience and awareness for people who who are on the narcissistic spectrum.
- 1:07:47For these individuals, the primary therapeutic drive that I have is vulnerability,
- 1:07:53vulnerability, vulnerability, and attunement when they are vulnerable, meaning they are vulnerable
- 1:07:58with someone who is a too boned and cares, and to the point where
- 1:08:01with my clients who are on the narcissistic spectrum, at some point in every
- 1:08:06session I or they will mention this. You know, I know that I'm
- 1:08:12sort of in a later phase of therapy with someone like this when they come
- 1:08:15into therapy and they say something like, oh, Kurk, you'd be so
- 1:08:18proud of me. So yesterday I noticed some bad things were happening for me.
- 1:08:24So I sat down and thought about my vulnerable side, and I even
- 1:08:30indicated it over a text to my wife that she hurt my feelings and I
- 1:08:36did that. I said that I was sad, I was hurt. You'd
- 1:08:41be so proud of me, you know, because for years I've been telling
- 1:08:44them, trying to convince them that the road to wellness for them is through
- 1:08:48their own vulnerability. By being vulnerable with people that they can trust, it'll
- 1:08:55solve their emotional problems and their relational problems because when you are vulnerable, it,
- 1:09:01you know, lets other people in and it explains a lot of things.
- 1:09:04You know, if for you know, a typical story would be someone
- 1:09:09on a narcisistic spectrum. They get triggered and they start to criticize and lecture
- 1:09:14their spouse. To say, it's a husband, so he will start to
- 1:09:18criticize his wife and lecture her and say you're so emotional and you're illogical,
- 1:09:27and you know it's always about you, you know, just kind of those
- 1:09:30kinds of attacks. And then the next day he, through therapy, has
- 1:09:34learned okay. They start to have these bullet points that they because it doesn't
- 1:09:40naturally occur to them, It barely naturally occurs to anybody, but particularly them.
- 1:09:44So they wake up the next morning and say, okay, I got
- 1:09:45a fight last night, and I know through years of therapy that the road
- 1:09:48to wellness is vulnerability, and so what was happening? You know, in
- 1:09:53my head, this obsession about how my wife is wrong. That's all that
- 1:09:58I can think of, that's all that's in brain. But if I want
- 1:10:00to save my marriage and myself, I have to assume that I am not
- 1:10:06being vulnerable, I'm not expressing it, and that there's there's some sort of
- 1:10:11hurt and some sort of fear that's going on? What is that? And
- 1:10:14then he might say, oh, well, she triggered me earlier in the
- 1:10:18night because she was late from work or something, or she undermined me with
- 1:10:26parenting, or I wanted to go on this vacation with her and she said
- 1:10:30that she didn't really have interest in going to that location or something, and
- 1:10:34then that triggered me because I was hurt, but I didn't know it's hurt,
- 1:10:38so I went on the attack and do it. Okay, next morning
- 1:10:41they're like, okay, that's what happened for me, and then they will
- 1:10:45tell their wife. And as you know, there's baby steps, right,
- 1:10:49they don't they're not completely vulnerable, but you know, they test water.
- 1:10:53So you know, he texts his wife, you know you, I'm sorry
- 1:10:57about last night and my feelings were hurt when you said you didn't want to
- 1:11:01go to that location for vacation or something. And from the wife's side of
- 1:11:06things, it's very easy to narrativize the whole thing of great Just because I
- 1:11:13didn't want to go to can Kun with my husband, I got three hours
- 1:11:17of anger and lecture and criticism because he's a psychopath and a sociopath who has
- 1:11:24no empathy and no compassion. And the reason why I don't want to go
- 1:11:27to can Kuon is because I was traumatized there before. You know, some
- 1:11:32real reason as to why, you know, she said what she said.
- 1:11:36And so you know, for the wife, there's this narrative of just like,
- 1:11:40I don't matter. He is so self centered and just mean for no
- 1:11:45reason. That's the narrati because that's the way it looks, right. But
- 1:11:46to hear from him to say I was triggered and I was hurt, and
- 1:11:50of course what she deserves is to not be treated that way. But if
- 1:11:55she were to be treated that way, for him to sit down and say,
- 1:11:57I'm so sorry, I have these issues. I was harmed when I
- 1:12:00was a kid, and I was completely wrong. I should never have criticized
- 1:12:03you know every time that I've done that, you know, it's a defense.
- 1:12:08It's all my fault. That's what she deserves. But you say,
- 1:12:11she gets a little bit of that, and it will solve a lot of
- 1:12:15things because he's like, oh, okay, that's different. I was narrativizing
- 1:12:18it as he's a sociopath, But now what he's telling me is that he
- 1:12:21has vulnerability that I can kind of relate to. He solves it by being
- 1:12:25critical and lecturing me, which is terrible. Now, she might still decide
- 1:12:29to leave, By the way, I'm not saying you're supposed to stay in
- 1:12:30a situation like that, but it solves his need to express his emotion and
- 1:12:35have it be heard and rewarded at least by me as a therapist, and
- 1:12:40will resolve the conflict much faster. So, you know, the road to
- 1:12:43wellness is vulnerability, and it's really true for all of us, but particularly
- 1:12:45for people in the narcissistic spectrum and the avoidant attachment spectrum. All right,
- 1:12:50well, it's a journ there, and everyone out there, please take care
- 1:12:54of yourself because you deserve it, You really really do. In