Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / Managing the Employee Who Says I Need More Direction
Transcript
- Lucas: So, Luna, we've talked about the employee who says 'I need more context,' 'I need more autonomy,' 'I need a decision' — but there's one phrase I hear from managers all the time that we haven't dug into yet. Luna: Which one is that? Lucas: 'I need more direction.' It sounds reasonable, almost humble — but it can become a daily loop that drains you and stunts their growth. The employee wants you to tell them exactly what to do, step by step, and if you give in, you're not building their judgment, you're just becoming their GPS. Luna: Right, and I bet it's not always about laziness. Sometimes it's a confidence thing, or they're worried about making a mistake. Lucas: Exactly. So in this episode, we're going to unpack what's actually going on when someone keeps asking for direction, and give you a framework to diagnose the root cause. Because the fix is different depending on what's driving it. Luna: Let's start with a concrete example. Have you got one in mind? Lucas: Yeah, I was talking to a manager at a mid-sized SaaS company in Austin last month. She had a senior analyst — smart, experienced — but every task came back with questions like 'How detailed do you want this?' and 'Should I include the competitor analysis?' It wasn't a new hire; this person had been there two years. Luna: Two years and still asking that? That sounds less like a need for direction and more like something else. Lucas: That's exactly the point. When the need for direction persists beyond the onboarding phase, it's rarely about missing instructions. It's usually one of three things: a skill gap, a psychological safety issue, or a misalignment on what 'direction' actually means in your team. Luna: Okay, let's break those down. What does a skill gap look like? Lucas: A skill gap is when they genuinely don't know how to do something. Maybe they've never built a forecast model, so they ask you for the steps because they're afraid to show they don't know. The clue is that they ask the same type of question repeatedly, even after you've explained it once or twice. Luna: So it's not about direction, it's about competence. And the fix is different — you might need to provide specific training, not just more instructions. Lucas: Right. Then there's psychological safety. This is when they're actually capable, but they're terrified of making a wrong call. So they keep asking for direction to shift the responsibility onto you. Studies on psychological safety, going back to Amy Edmondson's work at Harvard, show that teams with higher safety take more risks and admit mistakes — but if your team doesn't have that, they'll default to asking the boss everything. Luna: That makes sense. And the third one — misalignment on what direction means? Lucas: That's the trickiest. Sometimes the employee has a different mental model of how decisions should be made. You think you're giving them latitude, but they interpret 'here's the goal' as 'here's a suggestion.' They're waiting for a directive, not a mission. So the phrase 'I need more direction' might actually mean 'I need you to clarify what level of autonomy I have on this.' Luna: Okay, so how do you diagnose which one it is without doing a therapy session in a one-on-one? Lucas: You ask one powerful question. Next time they say 'I need more direction,' respond with: 'What specifically is unclear? Is it the goal, the approach, or the constraints?' That forces them to pinpoint the gap. If they can't answer, that's a signal it's more of a comfort issue than a clarity issue. Luna: That's a good one. Let's say they say 'the approach' — what do you do then? Lucas: Then you can shift into coaching mode. You don't give them the answer. You ask, 'What approaches have you considered?' or 'If you had to pick one, which would you choose and why?' You're building their decision-making muscle, not just solving the immediate problem. Luna: And if it turns out it's a psychological safety thing, how do you address that? Lucas: You have to lower the stakes explicitly. Say something like, 'I'm not going to fire you for a wrong call — I'll support you, and we'll learn from it together.' But you have to actually mean it and behave that way. If they make a mistake and you get upset, you've just reinforced the need for direction. Luna: That's fair. And what about the skill gap? Do you just send them to a training course? Lucas: Sometimes, but often it's simpler. You can pair them with a peer who's strong in that area, or you can walk through it once together and then let them do the next one on their own. The key is to be transparent: 'I notice you keep asking about this, so let's make sure you have the skills.' Luna: That directness probably feels uncomfortable for a lot of managers, though. Lucas: It does, but it's actually a kindness. If you keep giving directions, you're masking the real issue. The employee stays stuck, and you burn out. And here's a quick honest thing — we're lucky that a small group of listeners chips in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that literally funds us making this many episodes. No ads, listener funded. Luna: Yeah, it's a nice model. It keeps us independent, and we don't have to cram in sponsor reads. So anyway, back to the skill gap — what are some signs you might be dealing with that rather than disengagement? Lucas: A good sign is that they're engaged in other areas — they take initiative on things they're comfortable with. So the skill gap shows up only in specific tasks, not across the board. If they're asking for direction on everything, that's more likely a safety or alignment issue. Luna: So you'd look for patterns. Like, they only ask about budget stuff, but they're confident with data analysis. Lucas: Exactly. Now, let's talk about the more systemic fix. The best managers I know set clear expectations about autonomy levels upfront. You can use a simple scale: level one is 'do exactly what I say,' level two is 'recommend an action, I'll approve,' level three is 'make the decision, tell me what you did.' You can literally write this down and use it in your one-on-ones. Luna: That's a nice concrete tool. How do you introduce it without making it sound like you're micromanaging? Lucas: Frame it as a way to give them more freedom, not less. 'I want to make sure I'm not over-specifying, so let's agree on what level of autonomy you want on this project.' That actually empowers them — they get to choose how much direction they need. Luna: It's like a contract for decision-making. That's a good way to put it. Lucas: And it's especially helpful for first-time managers who might default to giving too much or too little direction. This scale gives them a language to calibrate. Luna: Let's talk about the conversation you might have with the employee who keeps asking. What's a good script? Lucas: I like to open with curiosity: 'I've noticed you often ask for my input on decisions where you have the expertise. What's that about?' That's non-accusatory and invites them to share. Then, depending on the answer, you can move to a specific fix. Luna: And if they say 'I just want to make sure I'm doing it right'? Lucas: Then you can say, 'It sounds like you're looking for assurance more than direction. I trust your judgment — go with your best call, and we'll review the outcome.' That's the psychological safety connection again. Luna: I think the biggest takeaway is that 'I need more direction' is often a symptom, not the problem itself. Lucas: Exactly. Your job as a manager is to diagnose the root cause, not just hand out instructions like a vending machine. And once you do, you're not only solving their issue — you're building a more capable team. Luna: So, if you're dealing with this, start with that one question: 'What specifically is unclear?' And then listen carefully to what they say — and what they don't say. Lucas: And if you're not sure, ask a peer or your own manager for a sanity check. Sometimes our blind spots are the hardest to see. Good luck out there.