Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Sex, Porn, Therapy Discharge, and Ethics
Transcript
- 0:00So, Bob, I have a couple emails here about sex. Oh,
- 0:04so let's read them and answer what you say. I say, howdy,
- 0:07stranger, it's been a minute. Middle tier patron Jocelyn. She says,
- 0:12because of my trauma history, I frequently experience sexual feelings when I feel safe,
- 0:19or, as Kirk described it in past episodes, I have feelings of
- 0:23sexual attraction that naturally flow from finally accessing feelings of safety and trust with somebody.
- 0:29Yeah, right on. I think that this sexual transference, as we
- 0:33might call it, can have a serious upside personally. The safety sexy vibes
- 0:40clue me into something about the situation of feeling safe, which because of past
- 0:45trauma, I'm not always easily able to detect. Maybe other people know feelings
- 0:51of safety through other cues, but this seems to be how my body responds
- 0:56to safety. My sexual transference can have up in anywhere, in any time.
- 1:02It can happen with men and women of all shapes and sizes, and
- 1:06doesn't actually conform to my usual sexual sexual preferences or orientation. Bob, what
- 1:11do you think? Just chiming in? I think this is lovely, a
- 1:15beautifully non self judgmental description and awareness of this thing that happens to you,
- 1:21and a fearlessness about it. It's fantastic. Yeah, going on here.
- 1:26Reasonly, I felt sexual attraction to my personal trainer, who was not generally
- 1:32my type, but because she was reliably on time for our appointments and that
- 1:38she waited for me, I felt safe sexualness. Usually I let these feelings
- 1:44play out in my mind and body, and they go away on their own
- 1:47after some time. I'm extra mindful whenever this comes up for me at the
- 1:52workplace, but other than that, I just take out these sexual feelings on
- 1:56my spouse or on my toys. Everybody wins in this context. Lol.
- 2:02So if anyone is out there struggling with the shame around these feelings as I
- 2:07once did, it's possible that one day you will heal enough to befriend them.
- 2:13End of email, Jocelyn. That's lovely, no question, just putting
- 2:16it out there. That's so cool. Thank you. Another patron wrote in
- 2:22an Anonymous Patron, she says it came out last week. My boyfriend has
- 2:27been cheating on me, and so he gave me permission to go through his
- 2:31devices. Bob's monologue about cheating and devices I played my boyfriend this monologue,
- 2:39which prompted him, my boyfriend to give me permission to go through his devices.
- 2:46So thank you, Bob, You're welcome. I'm so pleased. What
- 2:49was your monologue? Oh, I went on a rant like give up your
- 2:53fucking device, your fucking privacy, blah blah blah blah. Yeah, I
- 2:55know. I'm glad. It helped feel funny to think that the monologue,
- 3:02the rant was used as a data point in an argument for gaining access to
- 3:08your spouse's devices. It might on another day, but today it feels awesome
- 3:15going on the themes in his porn history. So she went through his devices,
- 3:21the themes in his porn history spanning over a year. The themes matched
- 3:25the two people he was cheating with. Their specific body type is very opposite
- 3:30of mine. So that's interesting, Bob, what do you think? I
- 3:35think that he might be shame based and confused or conflicted inside about his eerotic
- 3:42self, and that there's a potential here for a lovely great deal of intimacy
- 3:49between them as they if they decide to work it through together. I mean,
- 3:54you know, our bodies are our bodies, and we didn't even choose
- 3:58what we're attracted to, so I would to learn more. Yeah, well,
- 4:02why do you say shame based because he's hiding it, huh, and
- 4:10he's hiding his porn news. I presume I think that's I think that's what
- 4:14I got. Well. In the longer version of her email, she said
- 4:16that her and her boyfriend had had a don't ask, don't tell policy about
- 4:20it, but she was totally fine with him looking at porn oh and masturbating,
- 4:27and thought it was fine for each of them to have a section of
- 4:31their sexuality to be private and by themselves. Great, So he was not
- 4:35necessarily actively hiding it. Do you know what I mean? I do,
- 4:40thank you. That's an important clarification. Could be that he was open to
- 4:44disclosing it if if it came up. But it's notable that these two women,
- 4:50and in her longer email, which she didn't want me to read,
- 4:54she went into specifics as to what exactly she's referring to. She's trying to
- 4:59not be too disclosing. But the body type is a category of porn that
- 5:06is particular, and it's the extreme opposite of her body type. I don't
- 5:13know the percentage, not that it matters too much. But if you pulled
- 5:17one hundred people, I would say that a small percentage, not a super
- 5:21small, but like a small percentage of people would be into this sort of
- 5:25thing. So it's notable. And the two people that he cheated with were
- 5:30also of this body type. So any thoughts on that that's what turns them
- 5:35on? Yeah, yeah, okay, Hey, I did want to go
- 5:40backwards a half step. They actually have an over agreement about porn and masturbation.
- 5:48Most couples don't. It's fantastic. Yeah, at the very least beginning
- 5:55to develop an agreement. Yeah, a conversation of understanding. And sometimes it
- 6:01doesn't have to be super overt. It can be something like, hey,
- 6:06you know, you look at porn right and you master by sometimes and the
- 6:11other person like sheepishly. You might say yeah, and that's kind of and
- 6:15yeah, me too. And that's that's the extent. That's a lovely agreement,
- 6:19right. It's not an agreement contractually, it's not, but it signals
- 6:25a lot of things of acceptance and acknowledgment, and it circumscribes something about who
- 6:30we are as a couple. It's fantastic. I love it now. I
- 6:33do think that optimally, there are overt conversations, not only just to clear
- 6:40things up in case of misunderstanding and hurt feelings, but I think there's a
- 6:45lot of glory in that intimacy. Oh what a great way to put it
- 6:48with a partner, you know, the achievement of that safety in that space,
- 6:55and just humanity, you know. The way I think about it,
- 6:59it's like, whatever fears we might have on my deathbed, am I going
- 7:02to be glad that I gave into those fears my entire life? Am going
- 7:06to my death bet? I might gonna be like, oh boy, I'm
- 7:10sure glad I avoided stretching my wings in that way, because I just really,
- 7:15I'm just so happy with myself that I avoided facing that fear and giving
- 7:20into the Victorian and puritanical notions of my society. What a wonderful thing.
- 7:28I get it. But there's so much benefit when two people enter it,
- 7:32you know, But it requires two people going on with the email. I
- 7:35don't hold moralistic judgments about porn and have been careful not to shame him for
- 7:41using porn, But for some reason I don't want him watching this type of
- 7:45porn anymore as a condition of us trying to repair from the cheating. Is
- 7:49this reasonable? I previously was fine with this porn use, but now it's
- 7:55different. Do you have any thoughts on or guidance on this issue? End
- 7:58of email? I appreciate both Anonymous Patroon and Joscelyn ending their email with end
- 8:03of email. They literally wrote that into their email. What's good about that?
- 8:07Because that's what I always say at the end of the email, because
- 8:09I you know, like on TV, there will be a visual representation of
- 8:16the email and you will see when the host switches from quoting to spouting.
- 8:22On the podcast, we don't have that luxury. So I'm often saying things
- 8:28like chiming in here or getting back to the email or end of email because
- 8:33I want people to know I'm reading something, not spouting. It's a signal.
- 8:37Yeah, so well done, sophisticated emailing. Is it reasonable for her
- 8:43to require or ask or semi demand that our partner not watch this particular kind
- 8:52of porn? Let me ask you, is it reasonable to laugh at a
- 8:56joke? Or do you just laugh? Laugh? Right? What she's just
- 9:01telling us and what she's discovering is that right now, I don't know about
- 9:05tomorrow or next week, next year, maybe to be the same, but
- 9:07nonetheless, right now, that feels threatening. And I like that she's plain
- 9:13about it, at least with her self and hopefully playing with her partner.
- 9:18And maybe they get to discover how the looking at that porn is related to
- 9:22the injury, you know, the betrayal if they heal the betrayal. Who
- 9:28knows where those stand, but they are in each other's care. And I
- 9:35don't think we have a right to be vindictive assholes, but we do have
- 9:41an obligation to ourselves and our partner to be honest about where our pain is
- 9:46and what our need is, and in this case, give them a shot
- 9:52at helping her heal. So is it reasonable? Yeah, of course it
- 9:58is. And I know it's reasonable because she's telling us this is how she
- 10:01feels. She doesn't sound like an asshole, right she is questioned, she's
- 10:07looking into it, she's trying to be self aware, she's coming at it
- 10:11from a lot of different angles. Yeah, and it doesn't seem like a
- 10:16knee jerk reaction that do we consider the possibility that her partner is lucky like
- 10:22this is this is a lovely partner being very earnest about an injury. Yeah,
- 10:26it's that guy's lucky, right, it's a small demand. Yeah,
- 10:31it's not. It's not a huge request. So one way to look at
- 10:35it, anonymous patron, is that when it comes to the initial stages of
- 10:41infidelity repair, there will be perhaps some quote unquote unfair demands from the victim.
- 10:50I don't know if we'd say it's unfair, but they might be unfair
- 10:54if they were forever. But in the initial stages, like, for exat
- 11:00s ample, gaining access to your partner's phone, I think a lot of
- 11:03people would say, well, that doesn't seem fair forever, right, how
- 11:09long do you give access, especially if one person wants some privacy. You
- 11:13know, you are wanting to have private conversations with your mom just about things
- 11:20unrelated to your marriage or something, or you want to be able to browse
- 11:24porn and not be observed in your history you know by your spouse. Of
- 11:31course Google's watching everything. But but you're entitled to wanting those boundaries for sure.
- 11:41But in the initial stages, if you screw up and you cheat,
- 11:46then concessions have to be made in the temporary to gain trust back, so
- 11:50that those kinds of boundaries can be allowed or can be given without the victim
- 11:58feeling a persistent feeling of fear of what's he doing, what's she doing?
- 12:03So to demand this or ask for this is one of those things. In
- 12:09all likelihood, if repair actually happens, then in all likelihood, at some
- 12:16point you'll be totally fine with him looking at whatever porn you want, because
- 12:20you'll feel solid in your security with him and trust with him. The other
- 12:26question, though, that has to do with the repair, I think,
- 12:31which is maybe the porn question is a symptom of this larger issue of does
- 12:39he love you? And is he attracted to you? Because that's a normal
- 12:43question, a normal series of questions to come up in your state, and
- 12:48to find this information. It raises these questions because you think, well,
- 12:52he's lied to me a lot before, because cheating requires an infinite number of
- 12:58lives. Oh it does, especially I omission, especially I mean particularly if
- 13:03it's ongoing in terms of like, they cheated and then a number of months
- 13:09went by, they didn't tell you. But the question of well, I
- 13:13don't know what he's telling me is truth or is deceptive? So when I
- 13:20find this information, is this evidence that he actually isn't attracted to me and
- 13:24we're not really made for each other. Because if that's true, whether he
- 13:28knows it or not, whether he's ready to admit that or not, that
- 13:31means that our relationship is doomed. No matter how much repair we do,
- 13:35he's going to cheat on me again because he's oriented towards a different sort of
- 13:41person than I am. Right, and that's a question that has to be
- 13:46explored thoroughly. I don't know that it's inevitable that he'll cheat again, but
- 13:50there'll be this thing in their relationship, like one where there's you know,
- 13:54some kind of unaddressed longing or pain or doubt in the power of in this
- 14:00case her about you know, are we a match? Right? Yeah,
- 14:03But it'll be there whether it gets acted on or not, It'll just be
- 14:09there. Right. So those are all things to do in couple therapy,
- 14:13yeah, because without that, it's going to be really hard to navigate these
- 14:18waters. And if I think if I take sort of a ten thousand foot
- 14:24view on your email, is that the phrase can you use that all the
- 14:28time? That's is it always ten thousand? Yeah? I don't know why?
- 14:31Yeah, Okay, well good, I'm glad, I because I'm bad
- 14:33with idioms as so everyone knows. But the ten thousand foot view that I
- 14:39have is it seems like you, anonymous patron, might do good to yourself
- 14:45by valuing your own needs to in this state having been cheated on for your
- 14:52question. And maybe it's just one of a thousand questions you have. But
- 14:56if your question is focused on I don't want to impinge on his right or
- 15:00something instead of how am I going to you know, regain trust and love
- 15:07and security? And so I just if you're not focusing on that, I
- 15:11recommend that you do, of course, because avoiding it won't make it better,
- 15:16you know what I mean. But repair is absolutely possible, particularly given
- 15:22what Bob is saying that you're you're not an asshole. That'll help. But
- 15:28think a break, we get back more emails. What do you say,
- 15:30Hey, we're doing good. We're back from the break. So this emails
- 15:37from patron Al from Boston. Al, You don't you don't hear very?
- 15:41My dad's name is Al. Raised teacher is called Al. My dad's name
- 15:46is Alan, but he goes by alb I like Al. Is he an
- 15:52older fella? No, he's my age we're older fellas. Oh then yes,
- 15:58No, he's my age here. I mean, I doubt there's a
- 16:03lot of kindergartener's name Al yeah, you would be so cool. Yeah,
- 16:08he says. I've been seeing my therapist via telehealth services for two years.
- 16:15During my last session, my therapist informed me she would be leaving the provider
- 16:19in three weeks time, and we made plans to discuss my options during my
- 16:23next session. So just jenmy in here reading the rest of the email earlier.
- 16:27I think what he's saying is that he goes to a therapist at an
- 16:32agency of some sort. Oh okay, and that the agency is he's she
- 16:37the therapist. She's leaving that agency, right, and so he had to
- 16:42transition and terminate and couldn't follow her for whatever reason anyway, in preparation for
- 16:48this life change. So again, two years of therapy in preparation for this
- 16:55life change. I recently watched your video titled saying Goodbye to your Therapist.
- 17:00I really liked the concept of getting closure, specifically with the opportunity to say
- 17:06goodbye, so thank you for that. Unfortunately, the next week's appointment came
- 17:11and I was informed that the therapist was already gone whooa. I have no
- 17:15idea why this occurred. I wasn't given any information other than my account being
- 17:19handed off to another therapist. This blindsided me, and I feel most unfortunate
- 17:26to have been robbed of the opportunity to get closure. My message to everybody,
- 17:30tell your therapist how grateful you are for the work you've done together,
- 17:34and don't wait to say goodbye to do so, which is nice. But
- 17:40what I would say is al from Boston that this is pretty rare that a
- 17:45therapist would end up terminating either at their own behest or at the behest of
- 17:52someone else. It's pretty rare that this would happen. Plus, there's nothing
- 17:56barring the therapist from contacting you after they leave the agency by well, unless
- 18:03they don't have access to the portal, but on their way out. I
- 18:06don't know. It sounds weird, right. It's not that hard to find
- 18:10people right right right on Instagram or Facebook or something, and presumably the therapists
- 18:15would on their way out, But I don't know. You know, I
- 18:18could see a scenario where all the records are on the company portal and the
- 18:23therapist is just shoved out the door. I mean that happened to me at
- 18:27my first job. Oh, I was fired from my first job, my
- 18:33first internship as a therapist. And I've been over this before, and I
- 18:37write about it pretty extensively in my book on Supervision, great book. Thanks
- 18:41you helped. And I was I'm twenty five, twenty six, and i
- 18:48don't know what I'm doing and I'm just learning. I was fired after eight
- 18:52weeks, and I'm pretty sure that after three it was decided that they were
- 18:57going to fire me. And nothing happened during those first initial weeks that anyone
- 19:03would say is grounds to fire and intern I was green. I knew I
- 19:07was green. I ran into him years later and he said that the whole
- 19:11agency was going through a lot of chaos and I was just part of the
- 19:15collateral damage, is the way that I would put it. I guess.
- 19:19So what happened was in the final supervision meeting as he is handing me this
- 19:25letter that has all these allegations against me, which are we're all unfounded.
- 19:30Oh my god, how awful. I've been over this before. We'll just
- 19:34give you one idea, like the one that really stuck out to me was
- 19:37that, well there were two. One was that I was making coworkers feel
- 19:41uncomfortable. And it was a large agency and they all knew each other,
- 19:45and I'm shy. Yeah, I'm a reserved person, and I just wanted
- 19:52to not get in other people's way, and I wanted to be a good
- 19:56therapist. I was terrified, and so I was just being But again,
- 20:00we're talking about the first five weeks of being an intern. Oh my god.
- 20:04I had so much newness and an agency that has a very tight knit
- 20:10group of people that know each other in and out of work. And I
- 20:15wasn't being aggressively shy, you know what I mean. I was responding when
- 20:19people addressed me, but I just wasn't initiating conversation or speaking very much.
- 20:25But anyway, so I was told that. The other thing I was told
- 20:29was that I had an unethical approach to treating people with addiction, because my
- 20:33supervisor asked me what I would do with someone that was in the throes of
- 20:38some addiction. It's not such bullshit, no, And I said, well,
- 20:44I've been told that we're supposed to terminate with them and tell them to
- 20:47get treatment, because it's hard to treat someone that is in the throes of
- 20:51an addiction. But I've also heard that there are other points of view,
- 20:55but I don't know because I'm three weeks into being a therapist and so a
- 21:00pop quiz. So I literally remember asking my supervisor, well, what do
- 21:07you think? And I remember him not giving anything, and I remember thinking
- 21:11that's weird. But he's the supervisor, so I should just take this for
- 21:18what it is as a normal representation of supervision. And I was getting this
- 21:23constant sense of a threat with him, to the point where I would have
- 21:26to meditate for like a half an hour before supervision. Imagine that. Imagine
- 21:32having to do relaxation exercises before a supervision is supposed to That's why, you
- 21:38know, So I start the book on supervision on this anecdote because I want
- 21:45to contrast the rest of the book with my experience, which is supervision is
- 21:49supposed to be one of the deepest, most caring, most guiding, most
- 21:56mentoring relationship you would ever have in your life in any content text, and
- 22:00for someone to be this not only just not a mentor but an antagonist.
- 22:07Yeah. But anyway, so in this meeting, they're telling me, He's
- 22:11telling me all these things, and I'm like, Okay, well I guess
- 22:14I'm fired, right He's like yeah, And I'm like, well, I
- 22:15don't know what I said, but I said, well, so I'll have
- 22:18to terminate with my clients because I knew enough to know that I needed to
- 22:22say goodbye. And he said, no, you have to leave right now.
- 22:26Oh right, at this very second. You have to dick. So
- 22:30and this is before electronic records, so that you know, unless I had
- 22:33access to the paper fire right, you're gonna run into the foul room and
- 22:37Collie and remembering all this is it makes my hand sweating. Oh he's such
- 22:40a jerk. But he's like, no, you have to leave right now.
- 22:42And I'm like, so I said, I said, wait, I
- 22:47have clients next, I have a client in five minutes. Are you telling
- 22:51me that I can't say goodbye to even that client. He's like, no,
- 22:53you have to leave the building right now. Oh God. And I'm
- 22:56like, what a dick? Why? Like why can't I say it?
- 23:00But it's like, that's just that's just what's gonna happen, Like why God?
- 23:06And that really tells you something, right that, Like, because even
- 23:10if I was this horrific, unethical, harmful therapist at the very least you
- 23:15would as a supervisor. Myself as a supervisor, would offer up that I
- 23:21would be there for those goodbye sessions, even if they were just five minutes
- 23:25long, right, because the harm that can happen to a client, a
- 23:30client to just have a therapist about just abandon them. Yeah, So when
- 23:37Al talks about having a therapist that just disappeared like this, it it just
- 23:42makes me wonder what happened. It's also possible the therapist might have just decided
- 23:48to leave, but that doesn't sound likely given the way that she was talking
- 23:52about let's you know, for three weeks. It's also possible that she literally
- 23:56died. She could have or gotten sick. What's so fucking annoying, though,
- 24:00Al from Boston, is that the agency apparently has told you nothing,
- 24:06nothing, which is just it's unnecessary. It's like going out of your way
- 24:11to be an asshole. Someone committed an ethical violation is a thing, either
- 24:15the therapist and or the agency. It's just an inexcusable. There has to
- 24:21be some some effort to ethical termination. It's it's in all of our ethical
- 24:29roads termination. It's not common sense, it's it does not define common sense
- 24:33to just be decent people are. Yeah, it's upsetting, very frustrating.
- 24:41So yeah, if you want to al you could google your therapist to find
- 24:48ways of contacting. Maybe they're somewhere else, but if you're generally in recovery
- 24:56from this, you know, maybe it's best to just can you continue to
- 25:00move on? But I'm sorry that happened to you. Sety two. Up
- 25:04at your patron Liz, she says, I work as a therapist, and
- 25:10my professor, who is a licensed Marriage of Family therapist, my professor from
- 25:14grad school many years ago, whom I adored, agreed to work with my
- 25:18sibling individually. So up at your patron Liz, who is a lovely person.
- 25:23I know her. Oh, she is a therapist and has a professor
- 25:29who was an LMFT from the past, been years ago, and she really
- 25:33connected with this professor And it sounds like she asked him to work with her
- 25:38sibling and he said yeah, and so he did. Later he agreed to
- 25:45see me and my husband for couple therapy. Then he agreed to see me
- 25:49individually. And I think she's also saying her husband individually and that he saw
- 25:56my parents once as well, because it sounds like maybe the parents came in
- 26:02for the couple therapy or the individuals, but mainly it's it sounds like that
- 26:07the professor was the siblings therapist and her therapist, and so thoughts on this
- 26:15bump too many hats. What do you mean? I mean, if they're
- 26:18the only therapist on the planet, then okay, fine, but it would
- 26:22be very hard to be There's a potential of it would be hard to be
- 26:26the therapist my client needs me to be when they have relationships with my other
- 26:30clients. So I would avoid it. It isn't like guaranteed it's going to
- 26:37cause troubles, you know, But since there are many other therapists in the
- 26:41world that are good and decent and probably connected to both of these folks,
- 26:45it just makes sense to me to keep it cleaner, to just not do
- 26:48that and just you know, find find somebody else. Yeah, it is
- 26:53a matter of risk. Is it guaranteed to harm? No, But it
- 27:00raises risks that are avoidable because, as you say, there are plenty of
- 27:03fish in the sea that are just as good. However, it is hard
- 27:08to find a good therapist. What if you're professor a former professor at that
- 27:15is one of those therapists. That's just one of those special people that just
- 27:19really connect and are able to help people. You know. Well, I
- 27:23think I know my way around how to be a therapist too, but I
- 27:26probably wouldn't take No, I wouldn't. I wouldn't. I would not be
- 27:32willing to take the risk. No. No, neither would I think it's
- 27:33okay to be asked. Yeah, clients and students can certainly ask, but
- 27:40it's up to the clinician to evaluate it. Yeah. No, for me,
- 27:44I was asked, but would never agree to this for that reason of
- 27:49there's other therapists out there, and also I want to practice what I preach
- 27:56as a professor and supervisor. I was pretty adamant about certain boundaries being upheld
- 28:03and not indulging oneself because that It's one of the reasons I would take a
- 28:11client who was a student is to be self indulgent because I want to work
- 28:17with them. I don't want to have them go to someone else. I
- 28:21want to be connected to this person. I want to please this person,
- 28:25you know, And that's not a reason to overlook one's concerns about harmed client
- 28:32and the harm that can happen is that if like just specifically with Liz's situation.
- 28:38So if we just take it step by step, that she goes to
- 28:41him and says, I want you to see my sibling. And so now
- 28:47that the professor former professor, I'm assuming that this happened after graduation. This
- 28:52that's just my read of it too. Let's go with that. That's not
- 28:56a huge leap there because the sibling doesn't know the professor, and the relationship
- 29:03between Liz and her former professor might be not ongoing, right, It wouldn't
- 29:08be normal for because Liz didn't say that the professor was her supervisor or boss
- 29:15or anything. So you know, if you and I think about professors that
- 29:19we had in the past, those are basically akin to a stranger at this
- 29:26point, at this point in terms of when we would run into them and
- 29:30any sort of ven diagramming about our lives, you know. But there is
- 29:33you know, a bit of a risk there. But I would say many
- 29:37professors who are concerned and buttoned up about ethical codes would absolutely consider seeing one
- 29:45of their former students siblings in the therapy if it seemed that the professor therapist
- 29:52was suited to that siblings deeds. You know what I mean, I could
- 29:56imagine Colleen seeing like say Ned Farley, right, yeah, yeah, great,
- 30:00yeah yeah. In fact, a lot of my close people in my
- 30:04life family members have seen people that I know really well, professors, colleagues
- 30:11of brain you. I've probably sent you people that I don't know if I
- 30:15can think off the top of my head. I wouldn't say on that podcast
- 30:18if I did, but I've I've referred very close people to me to colleagues
- 30:23of mine because I don't want to mess around when I'm referring therapists to someone
- 30:30who's close to me, you know, as someone close to me comes to
- 30:33me and says, do you have any referrals for this issue? For myself,
- 30:37I'm not going to just give them like five random people that I kind
- 30:41of know. I'm going to give them someone that I'm like, this person's
- 30:45good, you know you, and like a couple other people on my shortlist,
- 30:48you know. So yeah, that's pretty normal. Having said that,
- 30:53it's not universal because it depends on their relationships. So I actually, and
- 30:59I've talked to this before. I had a friend who I saw weekly who
- 31:04she had referred her sister to me, and the sister called me independently of
- 31:10my friend and said I want to make an appointment, and I failed to
- 31:15ask her how she heard about me, And so I had a whole session
- 31:19with her, and at the end of the session, she mentioned that her
- 31:23sister was my friend and I didn't know it until then. This is why
- 31:26it's important that therapist asks that you know that therapist will ask how did you
- 31:32find out about me? Because if it's a situation like this, then it's
- 31:37different. Because I determined that I couldn't work with her, and I felt
- 31:40bad about it, of course, but I said, I see your sister
- 31:45all the time socially, so you know there's too many risks here. Either
- 31:49you would have to divorce your sister or I would have to divorce your sister.
- 31:55One of us has to divorce your sister, and that's that's not okay
- 31:57to either one of us or your sister. Yeah. So, and there's
- 32:01no imperative reason as to why you're working with me. I get that you
- 32:07would reach out to your sister, that your sister would refer me, but
- 32:09I wish I would have asked. I should have asked right up front and
- 32:14not wasted your time. And I didn't charge her for this. This was
- 32:17like twenty five years ago, so so it's not universal. It just depends.
- 32:22But then we go on to the next one. Liz is saying that
- 32:25she went to him it sounds like and says, can you treat me and
- 32:30my husband? Well, now we're looking at a different situation. Again,
- 32:34if it's pretty distant as a former professor, it's not. It's not as
- 32:39long as it there's a firm boundary around that. How many times would they
- 32:45run into each other socially, like at a professional event. Maybe never.
- 32:49I don't know what kind of problem dually would that cause. Yeah, now
- 32:54you also have the different the dual relationship of well, I'm now treating my
- 33:00client's sister who also happens to be my former student. Is that going to
- 33:06mess things up? Because I might have heard a lot of things from my
- 33:10first client about my former student that might influence me in my approach. You
- 33:17know, say the sister and the husband had an antagonistic relationship, Well,
- 33:22the husband feel safe with me, and you know, just a lot of
- 33:27questions. But in and of itself not a problem inherently like automatically going to
- 33:32be a problem. It might be a problem. It could be a problem.
- 33:35Yeah, but I don't know. So when I first heard it,
- 33:38I was thinking, similar to you of just like, yeah, too many
- 33:42hats right, But it just depends on a thing. It really depends on
- 33:45that relationship the professor had with Liz, because as family therapists, we're used
- 33:52to this kind of muddy water. Otherwise we wouldn't be family therapists because even
- 34:00the bread and butter of family therapy or a couple therapy, you have a
- 34:04lot of people in the room and a lot of different vectors of alliances or
- 34:08of misunderstandings or something, and we're able to handle that anxiety and it's not
- 34:15a problem. So it just it depends, is what I'm thinking. But
- 34:22anyway, so going on here, I emailed him to ask why there was
- 34:27never an informed consent or an intake paperwork process at all. So it sounds
- 34:34like there was no paperwork, no disclosure, no informed consent. So I
- 34:39informed him as to why there was never an informed consent or intake paperwork.
- 34:44Here is his reply, So this is his email back. It makes sense
- 34:47to me that you would wonder about this. I usually provide it to clients,
- 34:52but I'm thinking there have been times when I have neglected to do so.
- 34:57The reason I don't need a questionnaire or other intake paperwork is because the
- 35:01therapeutic clients is important to me, and I am able to explore with people
- 35:06what I need to know based on their presentation. I'm happy to send you
- 35:09a PDS and my informed consent end of his email to her PDS. I'm
- 35:17trying to think, what disclosure statement persons professional disclosure statement? Yeah, that's
- 35:22it. So just I just want to read this again. It makes sense
- 35:27to me that you would wonder I usually provide it to clients. Okay,
- 35:30okay, And then he says, but I'm thinking there may have been times
- 35:35when I neglected to do so. So just chiming in here, I'm thinking,
- 35:37how do you neglect that? It's such an automatic thing, right,
- 35:42It's like neglecting, I don't know, to unzip your fly before you go
- 35:46to the bathroom, like like it's it's such an automatic thing, you know
- 35:51what I mean? Oh, I've been there, Like I don't need to
- 35:55remember to do my intake paperwork the beginning because it's so habitual. So for
- 36:01someone to say, you know, I think there might have been time,
- 36:05like if you had said to me, I think there might have been times
- 36:07when I might have not done the informed consent at the beginning of treatment.
- 36:13I would say, how would you possibly have that thought that that that's very
- 36:19alarming that someone thin I thought, maybe there have been times? How do
- 36:22you forget that? Do you know what I mean? It's like, I
- 36:25think there might have been times when I left my children at school and forgot
- 36:29to pick them up. I'm not sure about that. You know, that's
- 36:30not something that you would hear a parent, a responsible parent, It's not
- 36:35something you would hear a responsible therapist say I think there were times when I
- 36:38forgot my intake paperwork. What so, then he goes on the reason I
- 36:43don't need a questionnaire or other intake paperwork, So right there, it's not
- 36:47necessarily a questionnaire. Informed consent is very different from an assessment form. Oh
- 36:52yeah, So the reason I don't need a questionnaire or other intake paperwork is
- 36:57because the therapeutic alliance is important to me and I'm able to explore with people
- 37:00what I need to know based on their presentation these little apples and oranges.
- 37:05Yeah, okay, great. I think what he's saying is that he doesn't
- 37:08want the paperwork to interfere with the development of the therapeutic alliance or the relationship.
- 37:14Have you ever had that concern, Well, yeah, it's a bit
- 37:17of a concern because if you spend the first forty five minutes of the first
- 37:22session going line by line over your disclosure statement, then it can alienate a
- 37:28client and make him feel like, hey, I drove all the way here,
- 37:30Yeah I don't really know you. I'm dying to talk about five different
- 37:35things and just spent the whole time going over these dry legallyes kind of things.
- 37:40So there's a balance there. Yeah, balance and assessment is similar if
- 37:45the client's like, oh my god, last week and then you as a
- 37:49therapist, well, hold on, I have a lot of questions about your
- 37:51childhood or something, you know, And again, it's not going to cause
- 37:55the relationship to bond necessarily. So that's about not being rigid, not being
- 38:04you know, like, yeah, I don't think I have ever spent forty
- 38:06five minutes with anybody on a disclosure statement. I wouldn't want to do that.
- 38:09Usually it's ten. But if they came in and they were in crisis,
- 38:13I would skip it and I would bookmark it for the next time or
- 38:16when the dust settled. But I wouldn't skip it entirely. Yeah, there's
- 38:22no reason why you couldn't revisit it, especially in the second session. Yeah.
- 38:27Now, I do not recommend anybody skip the at least extremely brief process
- 38:32of explaining confidentiality and the bare essentials of disclosures and signatures that need to occur.
- 38:43So, regardless of the pressuring nature of a client's need to talk about
- 38:47something, there's no justification for just breezing past and form consent. You know,
- 38:53all you got to do is say, Okay, I really want to
- 38:57get and I don't want to get bogged down on the paper. I need
- 39:00you to consent to treatment before we begin treatment, which means that you're consenting
- 39:05that you understand this. You understand that you understand this, and so by
- 39:08signing this, you're agreeing to at least that later we can talk about all
- 39:14the other stuff that's on here. But I need you to sign this.
- 39:16Do you consent to treatment? Yes, Okay, you need to sign There
- 39:20is no reason. That took me what twenty seconds, So there's no reason
- 39:23why you can't do that. Plus a lot of people send the intake forms
- 39:29to the client before they come into the first session. That's what I do.
- 39:31Yeah, and now it's all emails. So it's very easy, right,
- 39:35Yeah, Like I imagine that a lot of people because when you go
- 39:40to like, like I just recently switched eye doctors, and they have a
- 39:45portal, they have their own medical portal, and there's all these informed consent
- 39:51forms that you have to sign online before you can even make an appointment.
- 39:54It's not hard to do, no anyway. So so that's what he said,
- 40:01and that's a concern. So we see two examples of floppy floppy,
- 40:09floppy ethical practices. Now does that mean harm is occurring, No, it
- 40:15just means risk of harm, especially to his practice. It's a wide open
- 40:22door for a lawsuit because if anything were to recur, then he has no
- 40:29leg to stand on. Like if a client were to be upset that he
- 40:34made a report to CPS, he would have no leg to stand on because
- 40:37he didn't inform the client that that was a possibility. So it's really not
- 40:43good for anybody, including it going on. He gave me the documents immediately,
- 40:47but I feel confused and yet I don't know what the ethics say and
- 40:52I've been listening to your podcast since twenty sixteen. I welcome your thoughts.
- 40:57End of email. Yeah, Patron Liz has been around a long time.
- 41:01She's an OG listener OG. So the ethics are that, as we discussed
- 41:08already, and if reported to the state licensing board, then he would have
- 41:15a talking to by the licensing board for sure. Would he lose his license?
- 41:21I don't think so, but he would be informed that he needs to
- 41:24button this up. And he probably sent to school. Yeah, and he
- 41:29probably would. Now I want to talk about I don't know if I told
- 41:36you, but another one of my colleagues from Antioch died and got hit by
- 41:42a card. Yeah you did, yeah, Jerry, Jerry, Yeah,
- 41:45yeah, I read about him. Where did I read about him in the
- 41:49Antioch publication? Maybe? Maybe? Yeah? I don't get that. I
- 41:52don't get the Antioch. But why don't I get the Antioch publication? Is
- 41:55there a newsletter? It's a little book. I think it comes quarter.
- 42:00Does it coming the mail? Yeah? In the physical meal? Yeah?
- 42:02Wow? Yeah, I don't get it. Yeah, Colleen read about him?
- 42:06Huh. Yeah, how do you know they still print out a pamphlet
- 42:10and sent it in the mail. Yeah, and it's not any Oeattle specific,
- 42:15it's the entire you know. Huh. Well, So he died a
- 42:21few months ago, hit by a car as he was crossing a road in
- 42:25Bellingham, late at night, nine o'clock, not at a crosswalk. So
- 42:30there's all these questions as to like, why was he trying to cross He
- 42:35was going to a store. He had parked his car and gone to the
- 42:37store. He parallel parked and then walked across the street. And it's a
- 42:42kind of a blind corner, and so you're thinking, was he unaware of
- 42:49the risk? Did the car come around the corner too fast? She did
- 42:53stay the person in the car, that's good, you know, called on
- 42:58anyway, poor guy. Yeah, So I will say that at his memorial,
- 43:05particularly the second one, which was open to a lot of other therapists
- 43:10and professors and clients. Actually, and pretty much I don't know. I
- 43:15would say eighty ninety percent of the people who talked about him brought up stories
- 43:21of his unethical behavior. So Jerry was loved by people. I cannot tell
- 43:29you how much he was loved by people. He was loved by colleagues,
- 43:32by students, by clients. Students particularly loved him. He was just he
- 43:38was always smiling, but he was also very real and confrontational and a really
- 43:46aggressive but soft way. It was weird. He was a short, slight,
- 43:54very you know, older guy. When he died, he was in
- 43:59his a easy and he was very soft and very kind, and he saw
- 44:07people very effectively and would remember things about people. And he was a total
- 44:14workaholic. I mean the guy as a program director myself as his boss.
- 44:19There were times when we would run into crises where we couldn't have We didn't
- 44:22have a professor to teach a class, and I always knew I could ask
- 44:24him and he would pick up the slack. He would teach literally twice the
- 44:30amount of classes that was required of him. He would get paid for it,
- 44:34but not a lot. You know, you don't get rich being a
- 44:37professor. Yeah, And he would meet with students off hours to help them.
- 44:43You know. It was just just a very lovely, helpful, warm,
- 44:47humorous, approachable, safe person. But the other part of it that
- 44:53I would lament as his boss was that he played fast and loose with boundaries
- 45:01and ethical codes. And now that he's gone and the licensing issue is no
- 45:08longer in question, and the fact that everyone at this memorial, clients,
- 45:15colleagues, bosses, would stand up and say all the lovely things about Jerry,
- 45:20but then would say, and you know, he did this one thing,
- 45:23and there were so many things, And of course I knew about a
- 45:28lot of the things because he was actually disciplined by Antiochet at some point because
- 45:31of his boundary problems. He would play real really fast and loose with it.
- 45:37And I'm wondering if upper TOI, your patron, Liz her professor is
- 45:44sort of like this where he is this very effective human helper and part of
- 45:52that that mindset of I am not because you know, for me, I'll
- 45:58say that when a student comes to me past or present student, and they're
- 46:05struggling with something, or I notice something that they're going through, I don't
- 46:09put my all into them the way I would if it was my mom or
- 46:14you or something. I have a little bit of a professional barrier there.
- 46:19I don't completely dive in. Now. I might be very helpful, and
- 46:22the student might find me to be very helpful. Yeah cool, But I'm
- 46:27not like completely open and free to act the way that I want to,
- 46:31you know what I mean. And that barrier is helpful when I need to
- 46:37evaluate whether or not a boundary is being crossed and whether a risk is being
- 46:44taken. Whereas I think people like Jerry and like up at your patron Lizz's
- 46:49professor, they might have an approach of like look. In order for me
- 46:52to really help people deeply, I have to let go of these boundaries.
- 46:58I don't know if that makes any sense. By I've seen that presentation enough
- 47:01times and have been very intimate with the Jerry presentation to know that he was
- 47:07so helpful to people. He could turn to you in the middle of a
- 47:12meeting at Antioch and affect you for months with just a small interaction, you
- 47:17know what I mean. He and I never had that relationship because we were
- 47:21more peers, you know what I mean. But anyway I saw him do
- 47:24that, and I at the same time would say, but Jerry's doing all
- 47:30these things about and Jerry would teach ethics. So on one hand, I
- 47:40think, yes, we need to be professional. Risks need to be accounted
- 47:45for, clients need to be protected. There are reasons why we have these
- 47:51professional standards and ethical codes, and some of these people are just such an
- 47:59overall good for the universe. That whatever kind of corners they cut, it's
- 48:06not a reason to completely shut them down. Now as I say that,
- 48:10you think, well, can't they be helpful and also just provide informed consent
- 48:15at the beginning of therapy? Doesn't seem like it gets in the way.
- 48:20I mean, do you know anyone like this? Do I know anyone like
- 48:22this? Let me think for a sec. We didn't really have a professor
- 48:27I know at Antioch when we were there, No that was like this.
- 48:32But I feel like this was more of a thing in the nineties when we
- 48:36first started out. I feel like we would have heard about this more than
- 48:38I think. It's like a cultural shift, like he comes from a different
- 48:43era. I do. I do, because things are much more rigorous now
- 48:46than they were. Yeah, yeah, And Jerry would lament that often.
- 48:52He would often talk about how things have become too professional, and I agree
- 48:59with that same time. On the one hand, there are little things you
- 49:02can do as a therapist that will help protect the client, you know,
- 49:07if you're truly concerned about the client. So the informed consent thing, I
- 49:12don't get why Liz's therapist wouldn't have And folks, it's just like, what's
- 49:15wrong with you, but the loose boundaries regarding sibling and couple therapy and that
- 49:21kind of thing, which again in marriage of family therapy wouldn't necessarily be seen
- 49:24as loose boundaries. Certainly some marriage of family therapists would, but not all
- 49:30of them. Well, he's an LMFT too. I mean, this is
- 49:32his training and background, so who knows, maybe he've used that in a
- 49:36very systemic way, right, so you know, Okay, fine, does
- 49:44Liz have a complain about him? She didn't say she doesn't have any question.
- 49:50She just laid it all out. Well, she just wants our thoughts.
- 49:53I wouldn't do it. If it were me, I wouldn't do it.
- 49:58I because of the and i'm you know, in this direction anyways risk
- 50:01averse. I wouldn't do it. But it doesn't necessarily mean that it is
- 50:07harmful. But I can't see the point to it. But I come from
- 50:12this era, so you know, maybe that person comes from you know,
- 50:15a bygone era and has a different mindset. Probably does. Yeah. Yeah.
- 50:23The other thing I'll say is I can't guarantee that Jerry didn't harm people.
- 50:30No, because I wasn't aware of every interaction that he had, right
- 50:37of course not. And I could see someone having been harmed by Jerry having
- 50:40a really hard time coming forward because of the overall love that was constantly being
- 50:47expressed about him. You know, it's just a it's a possibility, and
- 50:52it would be a quiet tragedy. Yeah, yeah, because because mitigating risk
- 51:00doesn't mean that you ace out the potential to harm. It's just, in
- 51:04my opinion, a good idea. Yeah. But even But but what I'm
- 51:08saying is, like with Jerry, he in my view, was taking a
- 51:13lot of risks, yeah, and could have resulted in harm as a direct
- 51:16result of that taking risk. You know, do you think any of that
- 51:21ego like I think I think some of it was for him, yeah,
- 51:23yeah, but I also think he genuinely just cared about human beings. He
- 51:30puts so much effort into helping everyone around him. I mean, there were
- 51:36so many because him and I were very close because in my program at for
- 51:42a good number of years, it was just him and me and Paul,
- 51:45you know, Paul David I do. So Paul was our boss and he
- 51:47had two employees basically, and it was me and Jerry, and we were
- 51:52in charge of you know, one hundred and fifty students. I didn't know
- 51:55that. Yeah. Wow, Yeah. Now the MFT program is like what
- 52:00fifteen full time professors or thirteen or something. Do they still have a lot
- 52:04of adjunct people. Additionally, they have a lot of it, but the
- 52:07ratio is far lower. You know, in the past it was a lot
- 52:12of adjuncts. But for us full time professors, it was up to us
- 52:15to do everything, to advise, to interview, to change policy, to
- 52:23interact with other systems, to market. That was kind of my job and
- 52:30Paul's job was to keep our jobs afloat by making sure that we had a
- 52:34steady stream of new students. And we didn't have a marketing department back then,
- 52:38and occasionally we would have a marketing department, but it was pretty ineffectual.
- 52:44It was completely up to us to make everyone know that we existed and
- 52:49to drag because you know, marriage of family therapy is always going to be
- 52:52the underdog to counseling because people know about counseling. Not everyone knows about marriage
- 52:57of family therapy. So we were all had a deficit. We were constantly
- 53:01competing with counseling because you know, our right across the hallway was the counseling
- 53:06program, and so we had to oftentimes pull students away from counseling. We
- 53:12managed to always be about half and half. Yeah that's what I remember,
- 53:16right, which was appreciated by everyone, and even the counseling side was happy
- 53:22to have that, you know. Anyway, So do they still call it
- 53:27MFT as opposed to a couple family therapy? They've always called it a couple
- 53:30of family therapy, but the widespread term in our field is marriage of family
- 53:37therapy, and the licenses marriage of family therapy and technically the degrees in marriage
- 53:42of family theory. So yeah, it's the couple of family therapy program,
- 53:45right, but you get a marriage of Family Therapy diploma. So because in
- 53:51order for the diploma to be more readily accepted by the community and by the
- 53:55licensing board, it has to conform to that language system. But it's so
- 53:59fucking stupid. We don't understand that not every couple is married, like everyone
- 54:04understands what couple of family therapists? You know what I mean? Yeah,
- 54:07and we but there's a further movement that's been a foot for I don't know,
- 54:10fifteen twenty years that seems to be gaining traction lately is to get away
- 54:15from the term marriage of family therapy and refer to us as relational therapists or
- 54:19relationship therapists. I don't like that. I think it's it's for the general
- 54:24public that they won't know what the hell that means. Yeah, I mean
- 54:28it's rough either way because marriage of family therapists see a lot of individuals.
- 54:32In fact, anecdotally, myself and all the other marriage family therapists around me,
- 54:37half or more of our clients are individuals. Right, So we were
- 54:42not called marriage of family and individual therapists. We're just called marriage of family
- 54:45therapists mft mmfith right, olympics. So if it's funny because you know,
- 54:52my background's in counseling, you know, as I do is aple couples.
- 54:55Yeah, so it's it's a pro either way, relational at least, especially
- 55:02if it was advertised better, which I don't think would ever happened, then
- 55:09it would It would be nice if the public had this term of oh,
- 55:14you sounds like you should go to a relational relations and then they know to
- 55:19come to us, because not only would we assess whether or not everyone should
- 55:23should come into the office, but even if it was just an individual,
- 55:28we would have the expertise to help them with their relationships. You know now
- 55:32counselors can help people with relationships. So I don't know. Yeah, but
- 55:37I have to tell you, before I got training, I would not have
- 55:39done a good job with that. Even in my thinking, which is individually
- 55:45oriented, misses the boat with attachment and seeing a person in their greater context.
- 55:51That was not part of my training. Yeah, and a really gully
- 55:55and important thing to learn, like a like a like a like a sense.
- 56:00Yeah, wow, central thing. You're a too convert. Don't tell
- 56:04you? I take it, raak in one word email after that. What
- 56:07he's saying? Right, all right? Back from the break anonymous middle tier
- 56:15patron. She says, Dear Kirk and Bob, is a wrong Is this
- 56:19a wrong reason? Is this a wrong reason to want to become a therapist?
- 56:23Oh? I have a concept that psychology is the root of everything via
- 56:28the relationships we create, which creates systems like family, government, and society,
- 56:32et cetera, And that by pursuing this career as a therapist, I
- 56:36will finally have a grasp at humanity in general. I want to be able
- 56:42to read and pick up people's behaviors and deconstruct what they are saying underneath.
- 56:46I also want to learn how to communicate in a way that people will understand
- 56:50and will know why. I want to know why they act the way that
- 56:52they do. Am I being too idealistic? Is all of the above possible?
- 56:57Bob? What do you think? I think this is love. It's
- 57:00a great reason to be a therapist. I just spent the weekend taking this
- 57:05training called psycho Biological Approach to Couple Therapy, and much of what was talked
- 57:09about from a theoretical point of view is akin to what this person wrote in
- 57:15and said about people as individuals in systems, and also that it's all created,
- 57:22you know, like we create like relationships or abstracts. They don't actually
- 57:24exist except that we say they do so, and they clearly are coming from
- 57:30it from a humanistic, humane kind of point of view, where they're interested
- 57:36in well being, in welfare and not like you know, treating zoo animals
- 57:39like or being a marketer or yeah yeah, yeah, right right, right,
- 57:43So yes, I think this would be a great reason to be a
- 57:46therapist. Yeah. Well, but specifically what she's saying I think is she
- 57:51wants to understand people in her personal life. No fucking yeah, why not?
- 57:54Yeah? Yeah, absolutely, I think that it's fine. I think
- 57:58if you pose this question people in the public, and maybe people in our
- 58:01field, they would pooh poo it on some level, because I don't know,
- 58:07it's it to some people might sound manipulative or something or that, or
- 58:12unrealistic, but it's not unrealistic and it's not necessarily manipulative. No, No,
- 58:16I don't think that either. Me personally, I am very very happy
- 58:21that I enter this field and have striven to learn, striven strived to learn
- 58:27about all the stuff, and it has helped my personal life. I mean,
- 58:31just one thing that it did immediately was I was halfway through psychopathology with
- 58:37Ned Farley. Were you in that class with me? I don't think I
- 58:39was in that class with Did you have psychopatology with Ned? That does not
- 58:44ring a bell. Ned is still a friend of mine at Antioch, by
- 58:46the way, he's a relationship What's wrong with You? He's in he's in
- 58:52the PhD program now. But anyway, he talked about panic disorder because that
- 58:58was the chapter we going over, and I suffered from panic disorder and learning
- 59:05about panic disorder completely. I would say took away the problem ninety eight percent,
- 59:10like just basically overnight. That's fantastic. After I understood what panic disorder
- 59:15was, I didn't know that was even a thing. Would Yeah, this
- 59:20is before the Internet or anything, so I didn't know. And I remember
- 59:23reading this line and they might even be in the DSM of that the individual
- 59:30will feel as though there's this impending doom, but they won't necessarily be able
- 59:36to identify what the danger is exactly. That is very insightful. Yeah,
- 59:39and not every panic disorder will benefit this way, but from any it will.
- 59:45And it was for me. And when I read that, I was
- 59:46like, what, Oh my god, that's exactly and I wouldn't even have
- 59:50been able to articulate it, you know anyway. So that's just one thing
- 59:53among thousands of things that I've benefited from learning about all this stuff, and
- 1:00:00it's a huge benefit. The question, though, anonymous military patron, is
- 1:00:02do you actually want to do the work, because it's wonderful to know this
- 1:00:07stuff and have it available to you in your personal life and your relationships,
- 1:00:10and just to get a grasp on like why do people and systems work this
- 1:00:15way, it's another thing to be sitting down for forty hours a week and
- 1:00:19actually doing therapy work. And I've seen a fair amount. It's a new
- 1:00:24phenomenon over the last ten years of increasing general awareness and interest in psychology,
- 1:00:31which is great, but I see an increasingly greater number of prospective students and
- 1:00:39students who will enter my program who after a year or two, will discover
- 1:00:45I don't think I was ever really wanting to do clinical work. I was
- 1:00:49just really interested in psychology. That doesn't mean it's a waste of time,
- 1:00:52not at all, but it very well might be a waste of time and
- 1:00:57money. So you just have to ask yourself. In addition to this,
- 1:01:01and maybe more fundamentally to your motivation, do you, anonymous militarier patron,
- 1:01:07have a deep calling to help people, to get into the thick of it,
- 1:01:14to get your hands dirty and sit down for seven hours a day with
- 1:01:20seven different clients and get into things that are chronically difficult for these people that
- 1:01:29will not change very quickly, if at all, in the time that you
- 1:01:32work with them. Do you have a desire to problem solve or to help,
- 1:01:38or to provide corrective experiences, or to validate or to delve into to
- 1:01:45listen. Is this something that you have a calling for? Is this something
- 1:01:50that is a gravitational force on your life? Otherwise I don't recommend pursuing the
- 1:01:57career. You can certainly go to school and get a graduate degree non clinical.
- 1:02:01In fact that my university we offer non clinical masters. They do.
- 1:02:06Yeah, you can take all the classes. It just at least last I
- 1:02:09was in charge of this policy. It was this way that you could take
- 1:02:14all the classes and you just wouldn't do an internship. Oh and you'd have
- 1:02:19what we called a non clinical master's degree, so that it wasn't set up
- 1:02:23for licensure because there was no practicum, but you did have a you did
- 1:02:29graduate with masters, and you'd have to replace the missing credits in the internship
- 1:02:35with other electives, which you know, a lot of people really enjoyed.
- 1:02:38You know, you can move on to a PhD from there, or just
- 1:02:44use the degree for understanding something so it can help you in another field,
- 1:02:52like in environmentalism or politics or a medical doctor or something. Yeah, yeah,
- 1:02:59all right. You know the thing about the thing that keeps going through
- 1:03:01my head is that scene from the Matrix, you know where Neo walks in
- 1:03:05and the little kid is bending spoons, and the kid says to him,
- 1:03:07don't try to spend the spoon. That's impossible. Instead, only try to
- 1:03:12realize the truth. And Neo goes, what truth? There is no spoon
- 1:03:16and it is only yourself that bends. I think if this person wants to
- 1:03:22pursue their training, I'd like them to be open to the fact that they'll
- 1:03:27be the one doing the bending, not other people around them. What do
- 1:03:32you mean by that? I mean that my training made me humble and continues
- 1:03:40to and should because understanding is a pathway towards empathy, not the side of
- 1:03:57ooh, I'm going to be able to figure other people out. I'm going
- 1:04:00to be able to figure out for myself and adjust to other people better.
- 1:04:04Yes. Yeah, And as a result, I hope and I think this
- 1:04:09is true, be in a position to be more helpful, not less,
- 1:04:12right. Yeah. Do you think about that in session with clients as you're
- 1:04:17trying to get your client to do something? On my best days? Yeah,
- 1:04:21yeah, yeah, I was thinking about this yesterday whenever. I don't
- 1:04:28remember all the context in which it came up, but the ways in which
- 1:04:31I find myself going after one person in a relationship which never works might be
- 1:04:39understandable that I get hooked but never works, and it generally represents a failure
- 1:04:45and empathy, like I am not getting in their shoes and I'm not seeing
- 1:04:49things as they really are. I've got my axe to grind. Yeah,
- 1:04:56hey, it's fine, you know, like I mean, what am I
- 1:04:58going to do? I am me and whatever. My my body has these
- 1:05:00responses or whatever. But it would be irresponsible to not challenge that, because
- 1:05:06the last thing anybody needs and they come to therapy is to get a tug
- 1:05:09war with the damn therapist. Yeah. So it reminds me that there was
- 1:05:15a comment on YouTube. I'm watching this show called couple therapy. Actually it's
- 1:05:18called couples therapy, which annoys me? Comment what annoys me too? It
- 1:05:24does annoy you too? Oh yeah, yeah, yeah right, because you
- 1:05:26and I come from a time when it was called couple therapy. It sounds
- 1:05:29a little weird the first one hundred times Jesus you say it, and then
- 1:05:32for a while, are you an individual's therapist, a family's there? Are
- 1:05:35you a family therapist? Are you a feat stoctor? Are you a teeth
- 1:05:43Doctor. Anyway, So I'm watching this show and it's a series that's for
- 1:05:49members only on YouTube, and one of the members so you know, members
- 1:05:54have to pay to become a member of the YouTube channel, you patrons,
- 1:06:00and then you have YouTube members. Oh, a similar kind of thing.
- 1:06:02And this show is called Couple Therapy and it's on show Top. Oh wait,
- 1:06:06is this the lady in New York who does couple therapy? Yeah?
- 1:06:10Oh yeah. A couple of my clients have told me about it. Is
- 1:06:13it? Did you know? Yeah? I think it is. I'm glad
- 1:06:18it exists. So I'm supremely glad it exists given the terrible depiction of therapy
- 1:06:24in the media. Ah. But for myself, I'm just watching. You
- 1:06:30know, this is what I do for a living, right, not only
- 1:06:33do it, but I supervise. And it's not particularly interesting to me.
- 1:06:39But it is interesting because it provides me a chance, gives me a chance
- 1:06:43to talk about things for the YouTube people that I don't get a chance to
- 1:06:47talk about with like reality TV. And apparently a lot of people will say
- 1:06:53that they like it when I react to it, because it helps them to
- 1:06:58understand their own therapy that they been in because they might be confused as to
- 1:07:03why their therapists did this or did that, and just hearing a therapist talk
- 1:07:08about the decisions that we make or the considerations helps them to just feel safer,
- 1:07:15I think, and maybe able to return to therapy after having a bad
- 1:07:18experience or something. Anyway, so I'm watching this one couple that everyone wanted
- 1:07:24me to watch, and the guy cheated on his wife, and in the
- 1:07:27beginning of therapy, he's extremely flippant about the whole thing, and it's pretty
- 1:07:32annoying the way he talks about it. He just is like, Hey,
- 1:07:36I was in a different town. What's the big deal? That kind of
- 1:07:39stuff, like yeah, And so I'm you know, I'm reacting, but
- 1:07:45I'm also providing a landscape in which we can explore why he would be this
- 1:07:50way. People don't necessarily wake up in the morning. Some people do,
- 1:07:56but most people don't and say I'm going to ruin other people's lives through my
- 1:07:59deception and gaslighting or something. Oh that was not his intention. Well it
- 1:08:02could be, but there are psychopaths. Okay, yes, yes, that's
- 1:08:06a rare case. But it's rare. And so I'm exploring I'm trying to
- 1:08:12figure out. But to be clear, I was pretty you know, if
- 1:08:15he were a client of mine, I would not be saying the thing or
- 1:08:19even thinking the things that I think as I'm reacting, and I'm pretty harsh
- 1:08:24against him, I'm not like railing Well, you're not a therapist, then
- 1:08:27you don't have to maintain a therapeutic alliance, and so it gives you a
- 1:08:30little more license to be frank. Yeah, my guess is you're not pathologizing
- 1:08:34him like some kind of douchebag. No, but I would say something like,
- 1:08:39oh, like I'd watch a clip and then I'd pause and I'd say,
- 1:08:42oh my god, that's fucking ridiculous. Why would you say that?
- 1:08:45Yeah, pretty judgmental stuff really. But one of the comments from one of
- 1:08:50the members, so these are people that are apparently people that might know the
- 1:08:55channel well enough anyway, me well enough, said something like it's incredible the
- 1:09:00amount of coddling that you give men, or something like that you give meneh,
- 1:09:05Wow, who do you think? Well, I get this from people
- 1:09:12because a lot of the viewers are women, heterosexual assists, women who have
- 1:09:17been harmed by men, and I do have a bias that I'm sure presents
- 1:09:23itself. I don't know which direction it goes, though, because I could
- 1:09:26see myself actually being meaner to men because I'm a man, and I also
- 1:09:33have absorbed the gender associations of our society. And if I were to pick
- 1:09:41a social a gender socialization that I'm less fond of, I would say the
- 1:09:45male socialization is more problematic in our society. So I don't know, but
- 1:09:51I imagine there are times when I might be able to relate to men better,
- 1:09:57and it might show in my leniency or something. I mean, I
- 1:10:00could see that being true for sure. You know, I'm a cisheat dude.
- 1:10:05I've been harmed by women so in these romantic ways, so that's probably
- 1:10:13gonna crop up now. And then do they give constructive feedback or did they
- 1:10:15just no, that's all they said? So I replied, I said,
- 1:10:19thanks for the feedback. Do you have a specific example, because I didn't
- 1:10:24want to rewatch the whole episode just to figure out what they're referring to.
- 1:10:28Right now, a lot of members were very kindly defending me and being very
- 1:10:34appropriate. You know, they weren't blasting this individual good. They were saying,
- 1:10:40huh, I've been watching doctor Kirk. For years, I've never thought
- 1:10:44this, what do you what are you referring to? Exactly? So there
- 1:10:47was that, but I just am bringing this up because why am I bringing
- 1:10:53this up? Because let's see, you were talking about Oh, you were
- 1:10:59talking about going after one person. This does not work. Yeah, And
- 1:11:04I felt it necessary to bring this up. I think because I my thin
- 1:11:11skin is thin, but I feel like it's getting better, but I'm still
- 1:11:15a little thin. And when I read this comment, it stuck in my
- 1:11:17craw. It was really great to see people, you know, defend me,
- 1:11:23as one way of putting it, but also they weren't blasting the person,
- 1:11:26you know, they were just like, huh, that's not my experience.
- 1:11:29Those are the kinds of defending comments that I appreciate. It's just like,
- 1:11:33huh, well that's your experience, that's not really mine. Curious as
- 1:11:36to what's going on, right, you know, we could talk about this
- 1:11:41or huh, I'll think about or whatever, you know, just instead of
- 1:11:45the typical Twitter sphere where it's just you know, these exaggeratory ad hominins sort
- 1:11:49of a troll anti troll kind of Yeah, right right, I guess good
- 1:11:55point. It's like you got the trolls, if we might use a broad
- 1:11:58definition of troll, and then the anti troll response can be just as toxic
- 1:12:02and weird, and so, yeah, I agree with you, that's that's
- 1:12:06lovely. But anyway, so when I watch this show, at times,
- 1:12:11I am kind of going after him, but I also, knowing what I
- 1:12:16know, tried desperately to hold on to the perspective that there's a reasonable reason
- 1:12:24for this unreasonable behavior. For those who are watching me watch this series.
- 1:12:30It takes me a while to get through this couple because it really touches on
- 1:12:33a lot of things. So you'll just have to keep tuning in as a
- 1:12:36YouTube member to see how that all plays out. Oh, there's the benefit
- 1:12:41of a lots of your wisdom. Huh No, in terms of for the
- 1:12:45client, because I'm watching him in therapy and things. Progress is the point.
- 1:12:51Oh right, right, right, got it? Yeah, yeah,
- 1:12:55so let's adjourn there, Bob, Sure, thanks for joining me. Yeah,
- 1:12:58it's been a while, right, Well, it's been a while for
- 1:13:00you and me. Yeah, but it hasn't necessarily been a while for the
- 1:13:02listeners, because there probably was an episode of yours published last week. But
- 1:13:10for you and me, it's been. It's been like I don't know,
- 1:13:13maybe like five or six weeks since we recorded right December, I think,
- 1:13:17yeah, I had plumbing troubles. Yeah, but that December recording will be
- 1:13:23published in February. Seriously, yeah, and this episode will probably air in
- 1:13:27February. Wow, And so people understand it's a couple of days before February
- 1:13:30right now. You know. What's funny is like I get a note every
- 1:13:35day about what your new content is, and so when it's one of you
- 1:13:40and me, I'll look at it and sometimes I'll listen to it and I
- 1:13:43can't remember saying anything. I can't Colleen's like, how is pack? I
- 1:13:47don't even I'll go home today and she'd be like, how was it?
- 1:13:49What did you talk about? I'm like listener emails, Yeah, but I
- 1:13:54don't remember. Yeah. You know, like You're gonna have to listen to
- 1:13:58it, babe, because I don't know what the hell you talked about.
- 1:14:00Yeah. I will do a deep dive and rerun it. I'll, you
- 1:14:04know, because Stacey will rerun those episodes and I will see the title of
- 1:14:10the episode that's published and I'll not remember a single Like there are so many
- 1:14:16times when someone will be like, I'm trying to find your deep dive on
- 1:14:19you know, this topic. I'll and I'll say, I don't think we
- 1:14:21did a deep dive on it, and then I google it and it turns
- 1:14:26out we did. And I'm thinking, what seventeen hours on that I can't
- 1:14:30remember? The thing that I tell myself because it's a very similar feeling to
- 1:14:33being a therapist. I remember, we've talked about this before the first maybe
- 1:14:40five, six, seven years of being a therapist. If you had asked
- 1:14:43me about any client, I would have remembered enough, if not a lot,
- 1:14:48about those people, the way they looked their issues. Da da dah.
- 1:14:54There was this point though, where it wasn't a It wasn't like a
- 1:14:58graduate you because you would think, Okay, I have three hundred slots for
- 1:15:02clients, and if I have five new clients, then five of the old
- 1:15:08ones. The memory has to be dumped. That would that's akin to a
- 1:15:13hard drive, right, But we're not hard drives. And I think the
- 1:15:15way that memory works is that there comes a point where that you just keep
- 1:15:21shoving memories in because you can't delete memories, right, And once the memories
- 1:15:28get to a certain density, you lose all specificity around any individual memory.
- 1:15:35And so there was a point where I remember thinking this is weird. I
- 1:15:40mean, last year, if you would have asked me about clients, I
- 1:15:43would have remembered every single one. Now I can barely remember clients I saw
- 1:15:46two weeks ago. What is happening? And with podcasting, if you had
- 1:15:51asked me after five hundred episodes about any one episode, I would have been
- 1:15:58able to tell you. But in point the memory became so densely packed that
- 1:16:03I can't remember any particular episode at all. How many have you done?
- 1:16:11Well, if you count all the videos, yeah, it's like four or
- 1:16:14five thousand. Wow, So you know, but in terms of audio it's
- 1:16:18but I haven't looked at I think it's I think it's like fifteen hundred or
- 1:16:23something. Let me look, it is seventeen thirty one. Wow. I
- 1:16:28was off those are published because then you get some that are you know,
- 1:16:31pre published. Uh, well, I've taken a fair amount down. So
- 1:16:39oh, but we've recorded seventeen well in terms of today anyway, at the
- 1:16:45time of this recording, we've recorded seven over seventeen hundred episodes. It's amazing
- 1:16:49for the audio podcast. Yeah, when you get the high score. Yeah.
- 1:16:55So sometimes I listen to the reruns to reacquaint myself with what the fuck
- 1:16:59was I don't even remember anything that was a good one, or I wouldn't
- 1:17:03say it that way. Oh god, yeah, yeah, there are many
- 1:17:06times I cringe. All right, Well that is for that. Oh,
- 1:17:13Bob, I have a lot of gifts for you. Oh so this is
- 1:17:15from Femma. She takes pictures of actual astronomy objects. Oh and she printed
- 1:17:21this is I believe a globular cluster that you're looking at. Oh, thank
- 1:17:26you, Fema. Oh that's so cool. I'm going to hang out in
- 1:17:29the back. That's a great little I did it says for Bob because he
- 1:17:31is a star. Thank you, Femma. And picture of a star which
- 1:17:35you can see the dark spots of the sun. There's a longer note in
- 1:17:41the back, but you don't have to read it, but you can if
- 1:17:43you want to, might as well read it. Yeah, Bob, you're
- 1:17:45such a warm and kind person, and you sound like an amazing therapist.
- 1:17:49Thank you. Out of all the therapists co hosts, I resonate with you
- 1:17:53the most. I found your voice so comforting. It's like you soothed my
- 1:17:57soul. When you talk, you are warm like the son. So this
- 1:18:00this picture is for you, Fema. Thank you Fema. That's really it's
- 1:18:04really lovely. Thank you. And for the record, she sent astronomy pictures
- 1:18:10for all the co hosts, but she sent two for you. Wow,
- 1:18:14here's a little card from someone else. Thank you, Caitlin. I will
- 1:18:18read this after we're done recording. Yeah, so that's nice. If you
- 1:18:25want to send Bob things, physical things, you can send it to the
- 1:18:30address that is on the website. I believe it's on the homepage of our
- 1:18:34website. I also got you and Colleen some merch some shirts. Oh she's
- 1:18:41been asking. She's oh, thank you, thank you, you say everybody
- 1:18:47loves Bob. Yeah, send one to my mom. So once for you,
- 1:18:53once for Colling, and then I got you a psychology and Seattle shirt
- 1:18:56for you were calling. Oh. Thanks. You know Colleen rearranged Mike.
- 1:19:01Oh yeah, that's nice. Colleen rearranged my closet. And there's a pile
- 1:19:05for podcast shirts. Oh yeah, there's blank, blank T shirts, graphic
- 1:19:11t shirts, white t shirts, long sleeved shirts, and psychology in Seattle.
- 1:19:15How many psychologies sell shirts? Do you have five? Six? Oh?
- 1:19:18Really? Yeah? Now now like eight? I guess I have to
- 1:19:23share these, but you know, everyone loves Bob. You got to have
- 1:19:27one of those. And I can't wait to see Colleen wear that. I'll
- 1:19:30be heading it home a little later. Maybe. Well what I can't wait
- 1:19:33to see is you wearing it. I don't know, dude, you have
- 1:19:39to yeah, okay, And you are the master of the silly T shirt.
- 1:19:44Oh god, you've worn some really silly T shirts. I feel like
- 1:19:47your silly T shirt game has been lost to history. You got to bring
- 1:19:50that back, Maneah. No, I actually wear mostly blank T shirts nowadays.
- 1:19:55Yeah yeah, yeah, he never wore blank T shirts in the past.
- 1:19:59Now they all or something. You had your own silly T shirt business.
- 1:20:03Yeah, you printed, you silk screened, physically your own patented joke
- 1:20:10shirts back when that wasn't really a thing. No, that was fun,
- 1:20:14that was a great learn How many shirts did you remember you sold them on
- 1:20:16Capitol Hill Shirt? Well, they they sold them on like sort of like
- 1:20:20consignment, like if they sold one then I'd get a cut, And they
- 1:20:25didn't sell I don't know. I mean one or two maybe, but I
- 1:20:28don't actually remember ever getting any money for them. Do you still have like
- 1:20:32boxes of No, I don't know where they went, like chucked them.
- 1:20:36Yeah, I didn't even have one of my for myself. Oh yeah,
- 1:20:41that's just kind of fun funny because they were they were fun. I could
- 1:20:44get them printed again. Yeah, but that was cool, like learning how
- 1:20:46to silk screen. Like that's the lost art I think, or at least
- 1:20:48for you know, because you get those iron on transfer things. Yeah,
- 1:20:53it was such a punk I mean, you weren't doing it in the punk
- 1:20:56direction, but for me in the late eighties early nineties, it was such
- 1:21:00a punk tradition because you would not find shirts of your things that you actually
- 1:21:08liked, you know, like if you had a band that you liked but
- 1:21:12wasn't very popular, you couldn't find a shirt. So there was this underground
- 1:21:15movement to make your own, you know, the zine culture. Do you
- 1:21:19remember this? The magazine or zine and all these I don't know if it's
- 1:21:28the right word, but sort of punk artists would go to the seven to
- 1:21:31eleven xerox machine and print out, you know, so you would hand draw
- 1:21:40all these zines, right and then maybe type out maybe, but collage and
- 1:21:45then you would go to the Xerox machine at the seven eleven and pay a
- 1:21:49certain amount of money and run off a bunch of these zines. And then
- 1:21:53there was this way of just folding the whole thing in half and stapling it
- 1:21:57and it was a little booklet and you would pass these things out. You
- 1:22:00know. It just before the Internet, so it was the only way that
- 1:22:03you could share anything. And I felt so adult or mainstream because you were
- 1:22:10publishing something, you had a physical copy, you were in league with actual
- 1:22:16publishers, but you were just by this Xerox machine at the seven eleven.
- 1:22:20Is so when you were making those T shirts, it felt that way to
- 1:22:25me. It's this underground movement, like not appealing to the corporate world aside,
- 1:22:31I'm just gonna make my own fucking shirts. Yeah, I'm gonna make
- 1:22:34my own jokes and I'm gonna sell them. Yeah. That was fun.
- 1:22:39So oh and I have one more gift for you. It is your own
- 1:22:42cup my cup. Oh good. So you left that cup probably five months
- 1:22:47ago, and I washed it and then Stacy put it in the cupboard and
- 1:22:54it just got lost and then I recently found it. Actually I found it
- 1:22:58like six weeks ago, but we haven't podcasts. Yeah, it's been a
- 1:23:01minute, right, So I've been like waiting to give it back. Thank
- 1:23:04you. You always come here with a Starbucks plastic cup filled with a latte
- 1:23:11or something. Yeah, usually Yeah, And I wondered, since I hadn't
- 1:23:15seen you come with a latte if you were waiting to get your cup back.
- 1:23:19Don't you even know you forgot it? I mean I knew the day
- 1:23:21I forgot it. I knew I forgot it, but then I forgot I
- 1:23:25forgot Yeah, you forgot it? Yeah I did. Yeah. How's it
- 1:23:28feel to have back? Oh? It's like it's like my baby, did
- 1:23:31you? Did you get another one? No? I've been drinking hot lot
- 1:23:34taste, this sort of ice one's hot lot taste through the winter. So
- 1:23:39oh yeah, oh it's a it's a summer thing that guy. Yeah yeah,
- 1:23:42yeah, but but it's getting warm out. How many ounces is that?
- 1:23:45Like a like a twenty twenty ounce? No, no, just twenty
- 1:23:47twenty ounce. It's double wall so it's sleaeding, but it's twenty ounces and
- 1:23:53yeah a vintie as they say, yeah, that's the end of episode.
- 1:23:58See, yeah, everyone take care of because you deserve it,