Latest / The History of Austria: Empire, Collapse, and Reinvention — Fexingo History / The Habsburgs and the Spanish Inquisition: Family Ties and Religious Terror
Transcript
- Lucas: We've spent a lot of time talking about the Habsburgs as Holy Roman Emperors — their wars in Italy, their struggles with the Ottomans, their endless family politics. But there's a Habsburg story that often gets told as purely Spanish, when really it's deeply intertwined with the dynasty's own ambitions. Luna: You're talking about the Spanish Inquisition. Lucas: Exactly. The Inquisition was founded in 1478 by the Catholic Monarchs, Isabella and Ferdinand. But when their grandson Charles V inherited both the Habsburg lands and Spain, the Inquisition became a tool of imperial policy. And it's not just about burning heretics — it's about how the Habsburgs used religious uniformity to hold their sprawling, multilingual empire together. Lucas: The Inquisition actually existed in various forms before the Habsburgs. There were medieval inquisitions in France and elsewhere. But the Spanish version was unique: it was a state institution, directly under the crown, not the pope. The monarch appointed the Grand Inquisitor. By the time Charles V took over, it was already a powerful instrument. Luna: So Charles V didn't start it, but he definitely used it. Lucas: He did. Charles saw the Inquisition as a way to enforce Catholic orthodoxy in a kingdom that had large populations of converted Jews — conversos — and Muslims — moriscos. Many of these conversions were forced or pragmatic, and there was constant suspicion of backsliding. The Inquisition was supposed to root out insincere converts. But it quickly expanded to include anyone accused of heresy, blasphemy, or even bigamy. Lucas: And Charles extended the Inquisition beyond Spain. When he became King of Sicily and Naples, he introduced it there too. In the Netherlands, he issued harsh edicts against Protestants, which laid the groundwork for what would become the Dutch Revolt. The Inquisition was a Habsburg export. Luna: I've heard about the 'Blood Council' in the Netherlands. Was that connected? Luna: And that's what sparked the Dutch Revolt. Lucas: Partly. The combination of religious persecution and heavy taxation — Alba introduced a 10% sales tax, the 'alcabala' — pushed the Dutch nobility and commoners into open rebellion. The Inquisition became a symbol of Habsburg tyranny. The rebels, the geuzen, used anti-Inquisition propaganda to rally support. Lucas: But let's go back to the auto-da-fé, the 'act of faith' — the public ceremony where sentences were pronounced. These were huge spectacles. In Madrid or Seville, thousands would gather in the main square. The condemned wore yellow penitential robes called sanbenitos. They were paraded through the streets. Then the sentences were read: some were acquitted, some did penance, and the worst were handed over to secular authorities to be burned. Luna: Burned at the stake. Lucas: Yes. But it's important to note that the Church didn't execute — it 'relaxed' the prisoner to the secular arm, which carried out the execution. Over the centuries, estimates of total burnings range from a few thousand to tens of thousands. The latest scholarship suggests about 1,500 to 2,000 executions in Spain between 1550 and 1800. That's still horrific, but less than the Black Legend would have you believe. Luna: The Black Legend — the idea that Spain was uniquely cruel and fanatical. Lucas: Right. And the Habsburgs were central to that. Protestant propagandists painted Philip II as a bloodthirsty monster. The Inquisition provided endless material: the torture, the secrecy, the burnings. But other countries had their own religious persecutions. England under Mary I burned about 300 Protestants. France had the St. Bartholomew's Day Massacre. The difference is that the Spanish Inquisition was a permanent institution, not a sporadic outburst. Lucas: For the Habsburgs, the Inquisition was also a way to control their diverse territories. Spain itself was a union of kingdoms with different laws. The Inquisition was one of the few institutions that operated uniformly across Castile, Aragon, and later Portugal. It gave the crown a direct line into local communities. Luna: So it was a tool of centralization. Lucas: Exactly. The same impulse that drove Charles V to create a unified legal code or Philip II to build the Escorial also drove the Inquisition. It was about creating a uniform Catholic state. But in the long run, it backfired. The persecution of conversos and moriscos drove away skilled populations. The moriscos were expelled in 1609, which devastated agriculture in Valencia and Aragon. And the repression in the Netherlands lost the Habsburgs their most prosperous provinces. Luna: It's interesting — the Habsburgs were so focused on religious unity that they undermined their own power. Lucas: Absolutely. Charles V spent his life fighting for a unified Christendom against the Ottomans and Protestants. But the Inquisition alienated the very people who could have helped him: the converso bankers, the morisco farmers, the Dutch merchants. By the time of Philip IV, Spain was in decline, and the Inquisition was still active but increasingly anachronistic. Lucas: One more thing: the Inquisition also censored books. It maintained an Index of Prohibited Books. That meant that Enlightenment ideas arrived late in Spain. The Habsburgs effectively put Spain in an intellectual straitjacket. When the dynasty ended in 1700 with the death of the last Spanish Habsburg, Charles II, the Inquisition lived on — it wasn't abolished until 1834. Luna: Wow. So the Inquisition outlasted the Habsburgs by over a century. Lucas: It did. And that's a good reminder that institutions can take on a life of their own. But the Habsburgs shaped it profoundly. They turned a medieval papal tool into a modern state bureaucracy. And in doing so, they made the Inquisition synonymous with their own brand of Catholic imperialism. Luna: This has really changed how I think about the Inquisition. It's not just about Spain — it's about the whole Habsburg project. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're interested in learning more, I'd recommend Henry Kamen's 'The Spanish Inquisition: A Historical Revision' — it's a balanced look at the evidence. But for now, let's take a quick break to mention something that keeps these conversations going. Luna: If you've been enjoying this series on Austria and the Habsburgs, it's because people like you help make it possible. Lucas: Yeah, we don't run ads, and we want to keep it that way. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Luna: Every little bit helps us keep digging into these stories. Lucas: Alright, back to the Inquisition. Let's talk about one of its most notorious figures: Tomas de Torquemada. He was the first Grand Inquisitor under Isabella and Ferdinand, and he's become the face of the Inquisition's cruelty. But he was actually a Dominican friar who had a reputation for personal austerity. He never burned anyone himself — he wasn't the executioner. But he oversaw the system. Luna: Did he really burn thousands? Lucas: The numbers are debated. Some earlier estimates claimed 2,000 burnings under Torquemada, but modern historians think it was more like a few hundred. Still, his name became synonymous with terror. And he was a favorite of the Habsburgs: Charles V's grandmother, Isabella, appointed him. So the Habsburg connection is there from the start. Lucas: Torquemada also helped establish the Inquisition's procedures: secret accusations, no right to know your accuser, torture to extract confessions. These procedures were later used by the Habsburgs in the Netherlands and elsewhere. So in a way, Torquemada's Inquisition was the model for Habsburg religious policy across Europe. Luna: So the Inquisition wasn't just a Spanish thing — it was a Habsburg method. Lucas: Exactly. And that's what makes it such an important part of Austrian history. The Habsburgs who ruled Austria were the same family. They might not have had an Inquisition in Vienna, but they used similar tactics: censorship, a secret police, and a state church. The Counter-Reformation in Austria was led by the Jesuits, who were just as zealous as the Spanish inquisitors, if less bloody. Lucas: So when we think about the Habsburgs, we have to include the Inquisition in our mental picture. It's not just the Spanish branch — it's a family policy. And it shaped the history of Europe for centuries. Luna: I'll never look at a Habsburg portrait the same way again.