Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / From Boom to Burden: Is Commerce Media a Growth Driver or a Brand Tax?
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. Amy, welcome to the podcast.
- 0:15Welcome. Welcome to Signal and Noise.
- 0:17Glad to have you. Oh, thank you for having me.
- 0:19I'm excited to chat with you guys today.
- 0:21So for the audience, I just want to give a little background to
- 0:25let you introduce yourself in your own words.
- 0:27But you've been recognized as one of the leading executives
- 0:29driving the rise of commerce media.
- 0:32You rose through the ranks at Universal McCann, which I think
- 0:35is now called umm, worldwide, right, a flagship.
- 0:38It's a flagship agency of IPG media brands, right, correct.
- 0:41And now you're the global, I'm going to use that word global in
- 0:44there, global chief commerce officer.
- 0:46That is a mouthful. It's a mouthful which which
- 0:49sounds like it sounds like a big role.
- 0:51And you and I met at Beat Retreat Berkshires just just a
- 0:54couple of months ago when I started the Icebreaker, which
- 0:57was kind of funny. I I I hope you found it funny.
- 0:59I said, what about the notion that some people think retail
- 1:02media is a hoax? So we'll talk about the topic.
- 1:07We don't. I don't really believe that.
- 1:08It was just a way that I could say, hey, Amy, let's get into a
- 1:11conversation. We had a great conversation at
- 1:13the table. But I want you to just introduce
- 1:15to the audience. Did I prove you wrong?
- 1:17Yeah, you. I think you did prove me wrong.
- 1:19Yeah, I think you did. I was like, there's a, you know,
- 1:21I've got a lot to learn. And so I'm like, we've got to
- 1:23talk about this on the podcast. So for the audience, I'd love
- 1:27you to sort of introduce yourself.
- 1:29What brought you to your role? What got you involved in
- 1:31shopper, retail, commerce, media?
- 1:36Yeah. Tell us a little bit about
- 1:37yourself. Yeah.
- 1:38So hey, everyone listening, it's Amy Owen.
- 1:41I actually, it's kind of funny, I've been in the role for or in
- 1:45the the space for about 20 years.
- 1:48You could say that I kind of just stepped into it and didn't
- 1:51really realize what I was getting into.
- 1:54I went to Syracuse University and we were talking about that a
- 1:56little bit earlier because Brett has a child right now at
- 2:00Syracuse. But go Orange.
- 2:03Go Syracuse play playing Colgate tonight.
- 2:07They start tailgating like 4 hours in advance.
- 2:09Yeah, exactly. Great time of my life.
- 2:13But anyway, so I majored in marketing and I went to a career
- 2:17fair and they were interviewing from a lot of different
- 2:21companies and I figured, hey, I'm going to meet with all the
- 2:23different companies that have marketing in their title because
- 2:26I thought it was a marketing company.
- 2:27And so the first interview that I remember having was with News
- 2:30America Marketing, which I ended up actually taking the job in
- 2:34the big city. So I grew up on Long Island,
- 2:37always wanted to have like that corner office in the city, like,
- 2:39because like Sex in the City was like my, my dream show.
- 2:42And like, I always wanted to like, you know, commute to the
- 2:44city and have that, have that gig.
- 2:46And so I, I took that job right off of the, the college
- 2:51interview and it ended up being a third party company who sells
- 2:56retail media. And so for those that are
- 2:59listening, retail media in their world is like coupon machine
- 3:03shelf talks at the grocery store.
- 3:05Any sort of like floor graphics that you're walking through like
- 3:08the aisle. They actually still to sell that
- 3:09today. But that's how I actually got
- 3:11into it because I was selling that to a lot of CPG's out there
- 3:15trying to actually say that, you know, you're closing a sale at
- 3:18shelf and you need to remind you're given consumer,
- 3:21especially when you're buying something where you have, you
- 3:24know, 5 different options in your brain at all times to
- 3:27really, you know, trigger that at point of sale, which was
- 3:30brick and mortar at the time. And I was doing that for a few
- 3:34years and really started to learn the landscape of what
- 3:37retail media was. And so like a little fun fact
- 3:39for you is that retail media actually started in 1972 with
- 3:42this company. So it's been around for decades
- 3:45and some people think it, you know, started in the 2000s or
- 3:47started with Amazon. No, it actually started with
- 3:49Sam's Club and it actually started with News America
- 3:53actually selling these in store products that you could buy on,
- 3:56on a client's behalf or at that point I was selling, I went over
- 4:00to the agency side. I was part of WPP.
- 4:05They created a retail Media Group, which I service a lot of
- 4:08CPGS and basically I took all the information that I learned
- 4:11on the sales side, flipped up to the buy side and I was
- 4:13negotiating now with News America and actually supporting
- 4:17a lot of my clients in the buys of Instore Media.
- 4:22I was there for a little bit and then IPG, which I currently came
- 4:28knocking on my door and I've been here ever since.
- 4:32I started within the IPG walls about 12 years ago.
- 4:36My anniversary is coming up. Actually it's Columbus Day or
- 4:39Patriots Day or you know, the, the rebranding of that.
- 4:43But ultimately from starting, I was a strategic hire.
- 4:48No one knew what retail media was.
- 4:50I was a team of 1 and we really kind of used to just say like,
- 4:54Hey, we do this thing called retail media buying on your
- 4:58behalf. We could do it for you.
- 5:00And we started growing. And so now, you know, Fast
- 5:04forward 12 years later, you know, consumer behaviors have
- 5:06changed and we've evolved. So we've never really sat still.
- 5:10We actually do a lot of, you know, digital buying,
- 5:12understanding of retail media networks, etc.
- 5:14Like, you know, through the, the evolution of what we're calling
- 5:17commerce and retail media, we have a global team.
- 5:21We have about, you know, like 400 plus clients globally.
- 5:25We have about 1000 people on the team and we support, you know,
- 5:28what we're doing from a retail media buying consulting practice
- 5:34on behalf of our clients. And so I've, I've been treated
- 5:37very well here. As you mentioned, I started in
- 5:40the Universal McCann or UMM umbrella and I was doing so well
- 5:45and servicing those clients that they moved me into the middle of
- 5:48media brands. And now I service all of our
- 5:50clients across our umbrella. And so it's not just media
- 5:54brands clients, it could be IPG clients or any honestly type of
- 5:57clients that are looking for support in this area.
- 6:01So a little bit about me, I'll stop rambling, but that's kind
- 6:04of how I, how I grew up in, in the space.
- 6:06And I have to tell you, I love and I've been treated really
- 6:08well. So here I am, still in it.
- 6:12From a team of 1 to a team of 1000, it's pretty impressive.
- 6:16Yeah, You've been doing this for a long time.
- 6:18That's that's, you know, 12 years.
- 6:19I mean, like, no one knew what retail media was 12 years ago,
- 6:21that's for sure. Yeah.
- 6:23It was so funny. Definitely a nascent thing.
- 6:25Yeah. Everything's coming back full
- 6:28circle. So like we were talking about in
- 6:31store media when I first started my career and all of a sudden
- 6:34there's like articles and things like that coming out saying in
- 6:37store media is the new best thing.
- 6:39And I'm like, oh man, it's back. Like it's it used to not be
- 6:41sexy. Yeah, the merger of digital out
- 6:43of home, right with like in store.
- 6:46Yep. It's funny, yeah.
- 6:47It's all coming full. Start in in caps are back.
- 6:50They are, yeah. Totally.
- 6:51Now they're digital screens in the store, but.
- 6:54They never went away. They were just never sexy.
- 6:57And what I mean by that is that they were never topic of
- 7:00conversation and you always had the sales of the and the like
- 7:04the marketing team or like the shopper marketing team back then
- 7:07always investing in it to drive the sale or to you get a
- 7:10secondary replacement. But now it's like, oh, if you
- 7:13say the word end cap someones like tell me more like what do
- 7:16you mean? How do you actually get?
- 7:17So funny. How do you retailers actually
- 7:20became a little bit more attuned to, you know, what consumer hate
- 7:25behaviors are doing? I think COVID really like flips
- 7:28everyone on their heads in the sense of people weren't going to
- 7:30the store anymore. Hey man, they were spraying
- 7:32their groceries with Windex like when they were getting them
- 7:35delivered until like Instagram. I remember the yeah, shopping
- 7:38with gloves on, right? And it was crazy, correct?
- 7:40Yeah. Having a table that was split
- 7:42into two sides. Exactly.
- 7:45So clean and dirty slit, yeah. Yeah.
- 7:48So I mean, like, it was like the best three years, the worst
- 7:51three years, because like, it actually put retail, media and
- 7:54commerce on the map, right? Because people were never really
- 7:57thinking about it as a tactic in the media world.
- 8:01So now all of a sudden, like you can't have a conversation
- 8:03without retail, media or commerce being part of your
- 8:06focal conversation with any client right right now.
- 8:10Yeah, well, those are crazy times.
- 8:11A lot changed. I remember, you know, digital,
- 8:13like, you know, most companies I work with their teams doubled.
- 8:16I mean, the amount of hiring and churn it was, it was certainly
- 8:19wild. I'm sure for retail media,
- 8:20that's when it just went meteoric and just went crazy.
- 8:23And then I mean, I guess Speaking of it going meteoric, I
- 8:25mean, it's just you look at like the pace of change and like the
- 8:29areas of growth, commerce or retail media has been like the
- 8:32fastest growing part of, of media right in the ad industry
- 8:36for the last few years. I mean that Brett, we were
- 8:38pulling some stats, right? It's 100 billion US spend
- 8:43projected by 2028, the 17% kegger, which is crazy.
- 8:47It's like easily outpacing other channels.
- 8:49And you know, more and more brands are flocking to do this.
- 8:51You know, you look at how fast Amazon ads has grown and
- 8:55Walmart's having getting crazy growth.
- 8:58You know, it's all over, right? I mean, it's like you combining
- 9:01authenticated like really rich purchase data with the closed
- 9:04loop reporting, right and close the attribution it really gives,
- 9:07you know, my opinion, CMO is a great way to prove out if we're
- 9:10the age of outcomes. I mean, what's there's nothing
- 9:12more outcome oriented than retail or commerce media, right?
- 9:15But at the same time, there's kind of been a like a backlash,
- 9:19right? And you know, Brett, you were
- 9:20mentioning us and we were chatting earlier, right, about
- 9:22how is this just a, it's just just a brand tax, right?
- 9:26Is this, is this a toll? Like, do these, do these ads
- 9:28work? I mean, I've done incrementality
- 9:29tests. I I know they work, but you
- 9:31know, there are a lot, there are some, I think some valid
- 9:33questions about, you know, should brands be investing in
- 9:36this that, you know, doesn't matter?
- 9:37I mean, so you come and I've also heard complaints about
- 9:41limited transparency, fragmented reporting that we've had this
- 9:44because of the successes explosion of new retail media or
- 9:47commerce media networks is over 200, right?
- 9:49It's it's just a crazy number and Academy, how do you even
- 9:52deal with that? If you retail, where do you
- 9:53spend your money, right, knowing that Amazon and Walmart make up
- 9:56the majority of it, But still there's a there's a ton of them.
- 9:59There's a lot of fragmentation. So just a big question we're
- 10:02really looking to talk about today.
- 10:03Amy, besides just getting your background and understanding
- 10:07what you're seeing is, is this really the new growth engine of
- 10:11modern advertising or is it kind of a rebranded trade spend?
- 10:14I mean, you, you've, it's been around a long time, right?
- 10:17I mean, like it's a huge revenue stream for these, for these big
- 10:21retailers. Will this continue to help us
- 10:25cut through the signal and noise?
- 10:27Great to have you on here and excited to dig in.
- 10:30Yeah, I mean, listen, everything that you just said, you're not
- 10:33wrong. Like we, I actually, it's kind
- 10:36of funny. I I was talking to someone and I
- 10:38and I mentioned it a bunch and Brett, I might have even said it
- 10:42to you during our debate, but I feel like we're in our middle
- 10:46school. Year.
- 10:46Was it national debate? Yeah, well, like we were
- 10:49debating at first. Well, he came at me and he and
- 10:51he said, you know, retail media, Is that a hoax?
- 10:54I got to defend my territory, but.
- 10:58Yeah. And it was sort of like I was
- 10:59representing sort of the standard media buys and and then
- 11:02I had a whole table of sort of commerce and retail media people
- 11:04and we just Rep. It was like, it was like a
- 11:06debate. We represented both sides of the
- 11:08story. Amy he's he's known for this.
- 11:10I mean, what you're probably learning now like this is this
- 11:12he it's a sign of affection. I.
- 11:15Mean I didn't do defense to it. I was just like, oh, I like this
- 11:17conversation here we go. But but like I I was saying.
- 11:21Like we're. In our middle school phase
- 11:23almost where it's like there's some retail media aspects that
- 11:27I'll be honest, it's been seeing like we we need to figure it
- 11:30out, right? So like I can't tell you how
- 11:32many times we talked about measurement increment,
- 11:34incrementality. What does that mean?
- 11:36Is it really just tree spend? So like there are things that we
- 11:39as an industry don't know yet and then there are things that
- 11:42are really working. And so you hit the nail on the
- 11:45head when you said it's the merge of the specific first
- 11:48party data and the tech. And we didn't have that back in
- 11:51the day. Like there were two actually
- 11:53retail media networks, and I'm going to call them retail media
- 11:55networks, even though they're more aggregators.
- 11:56But it was Myra Grocer and grocery shopping network way
- 11:59back in the day. And we used to look at click and
- 12:02click through rates and, and look at like consumer behavior.
- 12:04And people used to go on those websites and actually make us
- 12:07grocery list and print it out and then go to the store.
- 12:10So there was no connection with the data and the behavior online
- 12:14to what someone was doing in a store.
- 12:16Now we can connect all of that. So yes, it is to me and it can
- 12:21potentially tap into tree, but it's so much more because now
- 12:24it's functioning in the media space as well.
- 12:27So depending on what client you talk to, and we had this to be
- 12:29internally earlier this week, the conversation is different.
- 12:34So if your client is set up differently and the organization
- 12:36is different, they actually might talk about commerce in a
- 12:40completely different way. If they are really like shopper
- 12:43LED or sales LED and they are living and dying by the sales
- 12:47numbers. Then there are different types
- 12:49of clients that are, you know, like let's do the big things,
- 12:52but flashy, shiny, let's do marketing, but we still have to
- 12:55drive a sale. Let's connect what we're doing,
- 12:57I'll say like the air game and ground game and how do we
- 12:59connect that football terminology and really drive
- 13:03through what we're doing in store.
- 13:05And so there's a lot of different ways that people are
- 13:07actually experimenting with retail media and commerce media,
- 13:10which is a good thing because I think at the end of the day, you
- 13:13are getting the better data and you are getting the technology
- 13:17that are now supporting each other that we didn't have in the
- 13:19past at all. Like it was very segregated and,
- 13:22and it was very slow and it was all manual.
- 13:24And PS, some of it still is manual.
- 13:26So we're growing up. And that's why I said like where
- 13:28I started, you know, like my little rant saying like we're
- 13:30middle, middle schoolers, like we're just trying to figure out
- 13:32where we land. And it's going to be interesting
- 13:35because the efficiency play is really understanding the
- 13:38landscape as a tool. And it will be interesting for
- 13:41me to see like in five years from now what it looks like and
- 13:43how actually has it evolved and who's now working with who and
- 13:47what, what has technology done for us and what is the consumer
- 13:50doing with, with a lot of these ecosystems?
- 13:52So, so, so exciting. I'm I'm getting on my high
- 13:55horse. Retailer, commerce, media, like
- 13:57how do you like, do you prefer terms?
- 14:02Is there a difference? I'd love it if you could explain
- 14:03to people because I think these terms get thrown around a lot.
- 14:05A lot of people might not even know the difference.
- 14:07Like what is? Because there's a lot of
- 14:08different media networks out there.
- 14:10Like banks, like Chase has one, right?
- 14:12United has Kinetic, right? I mean, what's the difference?
- 14:14I mean, is there a difference and how do you define it?
- 14:19Yeah. So from my standpoint, commerce
- 14:22media is an umbrella term, right?
- 14:24So it encompasses a little bit of everything.
- 14:27Retail media specifically is with retailers and or a company
- 14:32that is actually selling a physical product.
- 14:34So someone who's selling something on their site that
- 14:37actually wants to drive a sale or in their store, right?
- 14:40So online or in store. And so that's kind of where it
- 14:42started. So like I think Walmart, you
- 14:43think HEB, you think Ali, not Ali bad, but that's a bad
- 14:48example. When you think of like Makatar
- 14:50Libre, you think of anything that actually has a physical
- 14:54footprint, with the exception of Amazon, right?
- 14:57Because Amazon is that digital footprint, right?
- 14:59So like you have all of these retail media networks, then you
- 15:02have what's called like the commerce media networks, which
- 15:04you just described, where it's like the United's of the world.
- 15:08It's with, you know, like Chase, like you said.
- 15:12And so they're actually taking their first party data and
- 15:15driving an action instead of potentially A transaction.
- 15:19So the action is bookings, right?
- 15:22If you're looking at United, you want someone to be a loyalist,
- 15:24you want someone to actually really be ingrained in the given
- 15:28brand. You see a lot of that happening
- 15:30now, Chase, you want people to actually be investing in, you
- 15:35know, either like loans or opening up a bank account and
- 15:38and things of that nature. So they're, they're driving in
- 15:41action versus being tied and uniquely tied to a physical
- 15:45product. And then there's almost like 1/3
- 15:47option where it's like the aggregators that are that are
- 15:50now popping up. And so Instacart to me is an
- 15:52aggregator. The Trade Desk was becoming more
- 15:55of an aggregator in the sense of the, you could look at more than
- 15:58just one of those networks and either drive an act or a sale of
- 16:03a given product. So it's interesting in the sense
- 16:05that like I mentioned earlier, like it evolves over time.
- 16:08And so we have seen the evolution.
- 16:11I think it's important for us to say like, even from like our
- 16:14agency to keep up with the trends.
- 16:16And I we say we can never be wrong because there's something
- 16:17new every day, but we should take that new piece of
- 16:19information and integrate it into what we're offering or just
- 16:22figure out what's happening. So then we have the latest and
- 16:25greatest for our clients instead of just saying, hey, we buy, you
- 16:27know, retail media and that's kind of a thing.
- 16:31Yeah. And the way that I've tell me,
- 16:32tell me, yeah, tell me if this is the right way to interpret it
- 16:36just in terms of how kind of the machinations of of how ads are
- 16:40placed and leveraged across retail media as well as commerce
- 16:44media. And I think of of retail media
- 16:46as sort of a hybridization of both the on site digital
- 16:50advertising, right, Obviously the in store digital advertising
- 16:53as well. But anything that's happening,
- 16:55whether they're sponsored products, sponsored brands,
- 16:58videos, on site display, category specific ads, that's
- 17:02happening within that ecosystem, Amazon ads or Walmart Connect.
- 17:06And then there's the off site, which is sort of an audience
- 17:08extension play where you're using that deterministic data to
- 17:12find people elsewhere. So that is that a good way to
- 17:14think about retail media. Now commerce media to me in, in
- 17:18the aggregators, I think really most of it is in fact, I think
- 17:23all of it really is offsite because they don't have either
- 17:26the digital. I mean, United does have a
- 17:28digital commerce sort of platform or a platform where
- 17:30they're where they're, they're. Selling tickets and they're
- 17:33selling, you know, different things.
- 17:34Yeah, but it sounds like most of that data is being used for
- 17:37offsite programmatic and targeting across channels
- 17:41outside of their own ecosystems because they're not retailers by
- 17:45definition. Is that a good way to think
- 17:47about it? I would say yes.
- 17:50And because they do have on site properties, so it's it's more so
- 17:56just taking their data. And to your point, like maybe
- 17:59the bigger game is to drive people to their websites, but
- 18:02they're also reaching people to make sure that they're driving
- 18:05loyalty with their given brand, right.
- 18:07So I go back to United where it's like you're sitting in
- 18:10front of a screen. You want someone to take another
- 18:13trip with your airline or you want them to enter sweepstakes
- 18:15to win something with a partner. So that drives you back and then
- 18:19you're making more money coincidentally.
- 18:21And so that's why it's still a commerce media network because
- 18:23there's still something at play I can't think of besides like
- 18:28working with like the Trade Desk.
- 18:29And that's why I put it into an aggregation and where it's just
- 18:32off site, there's always an on site element and there's always
- 18:35an off site element. But to your point, whether they
- 18:39we invest in one or the other is dependent on what we're trying
- 18:42to do. But then we'll also see like
- 18:44clients say like in like the banking space where like they
- 18:47are like we want to run with Walmart and we want to be on
- 18:49site and we're non endemic because we know people that chop
- 18:52at Walmart use our card. So there's things like that
- 18:54where we're also trying to work through.
- 18:57Yeah, yeah, non endemic has just a huge increase those last
- 19:00couple of years. I know Amazon ads was focusing
- 19:03heavily on that for a couple of years ago.
- 19:05Has been, there's been. I think they've seen a lot of
- 19:07success in my understanding, right?
- 19:10Yeah, yeah. I mean it's.
- 19:11Yeah, and you think? Go ahead.
- 19:15Sorry, Oh no, no. And you, you would think that
- 19:16that somebody like a, a United would do a lot of partnership
- 19:19deals, right, with leveraging their data to sell or, or, or or
- 19:24to have other brands target those United buyers, you know,
- 19:29Sheridan or Marriott, right, because they know destinations
- 19:32and purchases that are happening at the point of sale with
- 19:35United, right. I'm.
- 19:36I'm giggling at you because I had a panel and it was over a
- 19:38year ago and I was the moderator and I had three different types
- 19:43in one in each category at a retail media, at a commerce
- 19:46media and an aggregator on the stage.
- 19:47And I said, why won't you guys all work together and make
- 19:50something called, I called it like a super network or whatever
- 19:53it was. I don't remember what I called
- 19:54it on the stage, but it makes sense because they're non
- 19:57compete. And to your point, like as a
- 20:00consumer, like the consumer's not going to say, oh wait, I
- 20:03need to go buy this from my retail media network over here,
- 20:06but then I need to go work with the commerce network here.
- 20:09And the reality is like, as I sit in the buying seat, it's
- 20:12hard because what am I going to do?
- 20:14200 different buys and each of the different ecosystems, but
- 20:17it's one person that might be shopping in four different
- 20:20places for four different things.
- 20:22So it's it's interesting to me and I've always pushed, why
- 20:26can't they all work with each other as long as they're non
- 20:28compete? I haven't seen it happen yet,
- 20:31but you're starting to see like someone like an Instacart allow
- 20:35their ads to be on other sites. And then you actually just see
- 20:38it was in the trades recently that Amazon is working with
- 20:41Netflix. So it's a little bit incestuous
- 20:44and it's starting to happen, but it's not there yet.
- 20:46And that's why I'm excited to see like what the future would
- 20:48hold because you are going to see some sort of consolidation.
- 20:51And I think that's the best bet where everyone wins, where you
- 20:54still have your network, but you're also working with through
- 20:56the networks that are not actually, you know, stealing
- 20:59your share, but actually amplifying your share.
- 21:01So it's, it's, it's interesting, but I'm glad that you said that
- 21:04because I've been trying to push that and I was like, if anyone
- 21:06wants to try it, please come my way.
- 21:07I have clients that are are asking for that as well.
- 21:10Well, I think people kind of see it as a 0 sum game, right?
- 21:12Like like Trade desk stock tanked when Amazon added, you
- 21:16know, third party adds third party supply, they added
- 21:19Netflix, right? And then like Trade desk stock
- 21:21went down because I guess the thought is that people, more
- 21:24people are going to go do their buys just with Amazon DSP,
- 21:26right? Or I guess you can kind of look
- 21:29at Criteo's an aggregator, right?
- 21:30They have a couple 100 retail retail media networks, right?
- 21:33I think I think that they did give access to it kind of like
- 21:35ADSP. So yeah, yeah.
- 21:38So it's interesting. I think in Expedia, I think
- 21:40they're they're they're kind of becoming a trying to become a
- 21:42travel like aggregator of commerce media for travel is my
- 21:45understanding, right. So yeah, I think it's, I think
- 21:49you. Say 0 sum game too, because
- 21:51that's always a debate that we have.
- 21:52Because one would think that if you take what you're doing and
- 21:57I'll call it like standard media world where you're not using
- 22:00retailer data and then you apply retailer data, first party
- 22:04retailer data, that you would have greater efficiencies.
- 22:07But we make our job a lot more complicated than it is.
- 22:10And sometimes you see it and sometimes you don't.
- 22:12So in my mind, it shouldn't be a 0 sum game, but sometimes it is
- 22:17because when you have people that are actually buying retail
- 22:20media, they actually treated as performance media and then
- 22:23they're not actually considering what you're getting on the other
- 22:26side. So for example, we look at what
- 22:28we call return on retail relationship.
- 22:30So it's not just the ROI of a media program.
- 22:33It's like what are you actually getting from the retailer and
- 22:35how are you building that relationship, whether it be like
- 22:37beta testing or a secondary display or the end caps coming
- 22:40up again in conversation like the end cap.
- 22:42So it's like, how do you actually utilize media to unlock
- 22:46a holistic game? And then maybe your media tanks,
- 22:51but then you got, you know, $2,000,000 more in an order from
- 22:54a given store that actually is successful in a way.
- 22:58And so had so by looking at it as just a media play, yes, we
- 23:01need to be better at it, but you should be looking at it in all
- 23:04sorts of different directions. And it shouldn't be 11
- 23:07perspective. It should be holistic of many.
- 23:10So like so 0 sum game to me when I'm talking about it I take the
- 23:15side of that it isn't a 0 sum game because you should be using
- 23:19it as leverage to get something else to better your profits year
- 23:23over year with a given retailer. Yeah, and I and I think thinking
- 23:26about it holistically is critical.
- 23:27And I know Pepsi did use some retail media and since I was
- 23:30reading to measure incrementality and Halo effects
- 23:32across categories. And they were really trying to
- 23:35see, you know, bottle bottom funnel, sort of trade trade
- 23:40bottom funnel results versus the Halo effect of sort of brand
- 23:43awareness building, which which you've, you've talked a lot
- 23:47about. And it's the difference between
- 23:48sort of brand building and performance marketing and how
- 23:51honestly you have to holistically think about these
- 23:53things as interconnected, right, in terms of driving consumer
- 23:56outcomes, right? And, and banks are, are well
- 24:00known. And Brian and I've talked about
- 24:01this in a couple of episodes. Financial services is well known
- 24:04as is just driving all of their spin 7080%.
- 24:07We saw this at New Star towards direct mail because it was, it
- 24:11was so trackable, even though there's a lot of waste just
- 24:16built into the process. They know that if they, they
- 24:18acquire a customer, that customer is going to have a
- 24:21lifetime value of X. But they would ignore the spin
- 24:24on the top of the funnel. And we came back, came to them
- 24:27at New Start with sort of an MMM and MTA analysis.
- 24:31And this was Bank of America, it was JP Morgan Chase.
- 24:34That said, if you're combining these things and you're actually
- 24:36shifting more to the upper funnel and having a more
- 24:38holistic balance strategy versus just focusing on the direct
- 24:42response bottom of the funnel stuff, you're going to drive
- 24:44better ROI. And we can prove it through like
- 24:47a decade of of your data. So it sounds like like retail
- 24:51media sort of going through some of those same sort of challenges
- 24:55where brands are like maybe this isn't just a down funnel direct
- 24:59response channel. Yeah.
- 25:02So it's, it's, it's the same notion from a media perspective.
- 25:06If you are reaching and targeting the same audience over
- 25:09and over again, you're not going to grow, right.
- 25:13If you are just telling someone to go add something to your cart
- 25:16over and over again, no one's going to get any new news.
- 25:19No one's going to get the detailed information they want.
- 25:21So I always say that commerce is the glue that ties brand of
- 25:24performance together and it needs to be integrated into your
- 25:28total plan, right? And it's driven by media
- 25:32behaviors. So like I know right now that in
- 25:35my households we buy on Amazon and we use voice sometimes.
- 25:41And if you're not advertising in certain areas, I will never see
- 25:45the message. There are people that are buying
- 25:48from a screen, not like their actual like cell phone, but like
- 25:51an actual TV screen. If you do not actually play
- 25:55there from an awareness play and also have the option to buy,
- 25:58you're going to lose people because people are are trying to
- 26:01shift like their behaviors there.
- 26:04So it's getting more complicated for a brand because you used to
- 26:06just say let's do ATV by it's awareness and then you have a
- 26:09shelf signage in the store and people will go to the one store
- 26:12and it was kind of like 1 pathway.
- 26:14Now there are many different pathways that people are taking
- 26:16and you're not really seeing any incrementality.
- 26:18So you have to make sure that you are balancing out what
- 26:21you're doing for an awareness play and also performance
- 26:23because you don't want to talk to the same person over and over
- 26:25again. You're never going to see the
- 26:26growth you'll sustain like the what they call it, like the
- 26:29leaky bucket, like you'll see a lot of that and like you'll make
- 26:32sure like your numbers are hitting year over year.
- 26:34But until you start reaching either another audience or in a
- 26:37different facet or a different way, like you're not going to
- 26:39see that substantial growth. So I'm a very big advocate of
- 26:43retail. Media should be included in
- 26:44everything that we do. We actually have a shirts that
- 26:47say make everything shoppable everywhere all the time for your
- 26:50given audience. And so like, it's one of those
- 26:52things where it's like, just make sure that the options to
- 26:54buy is there and that the content and creative and the
- 26:58inventory that you buy is is right, right for your audience.
- 27:02Because if it's not, then you're missing out on all the different
- 27:05aspects of what you could be doing to trigger a sale.
- 27:09So yeah. Like it's interesting you say
- 27:11that. I mean, I think that you look
- 27:11at, yeah, you're sorry. So you look at you look at like
- 27:15full funnel, right, Retail media.
- 27:16I love the point you just made. And I think that's kind of way
- 27:18you look at what Amazon like Prime Video, for example.
- 27:21I mean, I think when they when they launched that they
- 27:23practically sold out of inventory.
- 27:24There's such a demand for it, right?
- 27:25So being able to tie an ID to really top of funnel brand
- 27:30awareness, which I like a lot of CTV is right.
- 27:32And then driving it down into more like search and display and
- 27:36sponsored, sponsored brands and all the very kind of lower
- 27:39funnel that you can add activity that you can actually and then.
- 27:46Track to, track to. Purchases, right or connect to
- 27:48purchases. It's it's super powerful, right?
- 27:51So I can see the why. Like for example, I mentioned it
- 27:55before Amazon's trying to trying to get more third party supply,
- 27:58including more CTV inventory right within its DSP.
- 28:01So it can have that complete picture and it can offer brands
- 28:03what you're describing. We can offer them a full funnel
- 28:06in one place to buy everything, right?
- 28:08I think it's, it's very compelling, right?
- 28:11Yeah, I mean. It yeah, it will go.
- 28:14Ahead. So go ahead, go ahead.
- 28:15Sorry. Yeah.
- 28:17And Amy, is that it's, it's interesting because I, I wonder
- 28:21how much of that is real? And how do you, and how much of
- 28:24that is, is sort of the, the promise of connecting sort of
- 28:29deterministic point of sale, you know, sort of authenticated data
- 28:34that's coming from some sort of commerce event to media
- 28:38exposure, right? To, to, you know, back to that
- 28:41incrementality conversation. I mean, how, how real is that
- 28:44today? And how much further do we have
- 28:46to go to sort of live up to the promise, I think is my question.
- 28:49I think it's real. I think we have to do a better
- 28:51job of actually selling it in and testing it, because what
- 28:55will happen is that when you're looking at these retail
- 28:59ecosystems now, so it's not just like a retailer like Apple has a
- 29:03ecosystem, Samsung has an ecosystem.
- 29:06Like everyone is ready to come up with ecosystems.
- 29:08They all measure and look at things differently.
- 29:10So how do you know which one, which one actually worked?
- 29:13So I think we just have to get better on our definitions and
- 29:16how do we standardize, if anything, of how we're looking
- 29:19at everything across the board to say this actually worked,
- 29:22this actually drove X, but it's all there.
- 29:26Like I've seen it, I've seen the, you know, like the
- 29:28measurements, I've seen the methodologies.
- 29:30We've had clients that are testing it, but there are other
- 29:34clients that are hesitant to do so, maybe not because they don't
- 29:37like the idea, but because their organization isn't set up to
- 29:40actually function in that manner.
- 29:42So like they're very segregated. Maybe, you know, sales doesn't
- 29:45talk to the brand team, that doesn't really talk to the media
- 29:48team. So before you get everyone on
- 29:49the same page, it's kind of like like a, you know, a colossal
- 29:53effort essentially. So it's, it's also understanding
- 29:56how the workflow is going to work at a given, a given agency
- 30:02or even like a given client. And so I would say that it's
- 30:06there, it's just there's a lot of complexity.
- 30:09And like I said earlier, I think we get in our way a bunch to
- 30:13really just try to figure out like what's how things could
- 30:16work, how we can drive sales. How do we make things
- 30:18efficiency? How do we, you know, have the
- 30:20efficiency play? And like our whole mantra this
- 30:22year is how do we simplify things for us, for our clients?
- 30:26And maybe it's like the bringing up the topic.
- 30:28I know you can't have a podcast probably without mentioning AI,
- 30:30but like AI has done a good number for us to like understand
- 30:34how well things are performing when you look at pure sales or
- 30:37you know, like you standardized measurement.
- 30:39And it's not just looking at retail, it's looking at the
- 30:42entirety of the package. So it's there.
- 30:46There's just a lot we don't have enough time to talk.
- 30:48Yeah. And with all of the networks
- 30:50over, there's 200 plus networks, you've got two big players, the
- 30:53Amazons of the Walmart's that have about 80% share there.
- 30:57There's a lot of grading your own homework, right?
- 30:59If you're a retail media network that kind of is behaving like a
- 31:02walled garden to a certain degree, how do you coach your
- 31:04clients to, to, it's really a data unification exercise.
- 31:08Like you've got to start with getting actual access to the
- 31:12PATH data or whatever exposure engagement and, and, and
- 31:16purchase data, getting that into one unified analytics cloud,
- 31:21right? And then performing holistic
- 31:24MMM, MTA, et cetera, on that unified data set.
- 31:27Is that a huge lift? Because I've seen that in real
- 31:30life, just coming from an MMM, an MTA company at Nustar, and it
- 31:35was extremely difficult. The larger the business came was
- 31:38the more difficult it became because you had so many, to your
- 31:42point, so many brands, so many teams, multiple data warehouses,
- 31:47not a lot. So half of our job was literally
- 31:50data unification, normalization, and then you can start to derive
- 31:54insights that are actually predictive, maybe prescriptive,
- 31:57etcetera. Yeah, that's one of one of the
- 32:01steps that you need to take. I would say the step that you
- 32:04have to take first is what's what are you trying to get at?
- 32:07What's your goal as a company and like the CMO is supposed to
- 32:10like set with their, with your public like a board, the board
- 32:14or like if you're private with like the CEO, like what are you
- 32:17trying to accomplish for the year?
- 32:19And then that should ladder down to, OK, well, if we need to
- 32:23accomplish X, then we need to make sure that all of our data
- 32:26is segregated. We need to make sure we're
- 32:27having these measurements so then we can ladder it back up.
- 32:30I think that's almost hard because we're in a state right
- 32:34now where like we talked to like CEOCMOS and they're trying to do
- 32:37one piece and then you get to, you know, like the head of
- 32:40media, the head of sales and they're trying to maybe
- 32:42potentially do something slightly different, but it's a
- 32:46different track that you would take.
- 32:48And then you get to the day-to-day people and they're
- 32:49like, well, I'm just doing this. And yes, it can all ladder back,
- 32:52but I think we're just complicating it because like
- 32:54some people are just not singing from the same song sheet, which
- 32:58is just a byproduct of how our organizations grew.
- 33:00So like, no one's doing it. I'll call it wrong.
- 33:02It's just how history has set up a lot of these, I'll call them
- 33:06like mid to like large side companies and smaller companies
- 33:09figured out more quickly because there's one person that's doing
- 33:1280 things versus 80 people doing one thing within like the given
- 33:16line. So that's the part where we're
- 33:18having conversations and there's a lot of aha moments of where
- 33:21the PA LS are set up or like what, what I guess teams that
- 33:25need to be involved in in certain instances.
- 33:28And then once you figure that out, then it's like this is what
- 33:31we have to do to get there. And to your point, yes, 100%
- 33:35like data is like the next step. And that could take like
- 33:38anywhere from like 12 to like 30-6 months of like actually
- 33:41combing your data like it's and it's a very big lengthy process.
- 33:47And So what you're starting to see is a lot of like CM OS and
- 33:49CE OS are creating five year plans because the first year is
- 33:52literally organizing yourself and to get where you need to be.
- 33:56Yeah, maybe AI can speed that up a little bit hopefully in the
- 33:58future. But I mean, looking at like
- 34:00retailer, commerce, media, I can understand why it's attractive,
- 34:03right? I mean, it's growing quickly and
- 34:05but it's also the margins are crazy, right?
- 34:07Like, you know, the key, compare that to groceries where the
- 34:09margins might only be a few points.
- 34:11I mean, I think the margins and some of the advertising products
- 34:14are like 8090%, right? I just you, so it's, it's
- 34:17attractive, it's growing quickly.
- 34:19Like Walmart connect grew 31% last year, while Walmart, the
- 34:22rest of Walmart grew only 4.8%, right?
- 34:25I think I read that Amazon ads contributes as much bottom line
- 34:28like net revenue as AWS, even though AWS is significantly
- 34:31bigger, right? So it's, it's, it's attractive.
- 34:34I can see why everyone's getting into it.
- 34:36That's why there are hundreds of retail and commerce meeting
- 34:38networks. Like are there too many?
- 34:39I mean, like when is enough enough?
- 34:41Or is there not, is there not enough?
- 34:43Will there be consolidation? What do you think?
- 34:46Yeah. I think honestly, it has to go
- 34:48get to what is, what are you trying to do as a company and
- 34:52then what retailers or what networks will help you get
- 34:55there. So there's a usually annually we
- 34:58do some sort of like discovery exercise and we try to
- 35:02categorize how we're investing into retailer networks.
- 35:05And some, some networks become tier one and some come Tier 2
- 35:09and some become tier 3. And that changes every year just
- 35:12depending on what you're trying to do.
- 35:13And maybe it's, you're trying to grow distribution.
- 35:15So it changes, you know, more than just every year.
- 35:17Maybe it's bi annually or maybe even every quarter.
- 35:21But yes, there are a lot. And if you peanut butter
- 35:23yourself like you're going to get stuck because you're not
- 35:26going to know how how to see how everything is performing.
- 35:30But there is a need for all of the networks to exist because
- 35:34every category is different and every product is different and
- 35:37every client is going after maybe a slightly different
- 35:40audience. So there are needs for all these
- 35:42networks, but there's going to be some that are needed more
- 35:46than others. But as we mentioned earlier, I
- 35:48think there's going to be some sort of like condensed
- 35:51condensation or peace and where they all work together and
- 35:56that's also OK too. And so that's why I think the
- 35:58aggregators are really key to our success because like you
- 36:01mentioned, like a Crideo or like a literary desk, you could hit
- 36:04or even Instacart, you could hit multiple retailers and drive
- 36:08your strategy across all of those retailers.
- 36:10And then even like turn out like our return on retail
- 36:13relationship. So I think that's interesting as
- 36:15well. It's just a matter of like what
- 36:17you're trying again, what you're trying to prove.
- 36:19And then I mean, sometimes we get briefs and it says we want
- 36:22to drive sales. I'm like, OK, that doesn't help
- 36:23me because I can't ladder up. So like what you're trying to do
- 36:28and then? No kidding, right?
- 36:29Who isn't? Well, why Walmart?
- 36:31Yeah. So it's like, why Walmart?
- 36:32Why are you actually doing retail media networks?
- 36:34And sometimes when you actually sit there and have a
- 36:36conversation like, why are you, do you want to invest in retail
- 36:38media networks? Like half the time they're like,
- 36:40I don't know, it's shiny. And we're like, or I've been
- 36:43told we. On the flip side, I've had
- 36:45conversations with retailers where they're like, I was told
- 36:49to make a network and I'm like, well, why are you making a
- 36:50network? What's in it for you?
- 36:53Do you have the data that you have a data play that you maybe
- 36:56should work with the Trade Desk or do you have a lot of people
- 36:59on your site that you think you can make a profit off of?
- 37:02When you say Amazon and Walmart and they're all making a lot of
- 37:05money. They're they're only making so
- 37:07much money on the the buying aspect of the buy.
- 37:10What's actually happening is that in the past you were
- 37:13dropping off a pallet off of a store.
- 37:15So like Walmart and products were being sold and you'd say,
- 37:18Hey, Walmart, call me, let me know what sell through was.
- 37:21Now what they're doing is they're, they're saying you're
- 37:23digital. So you have to set up your
- 37:25content on your, on your PDP page or your shelf page.
- 37:28Understand the understand what creatives you want, make sure
- 37:31you know the assortment, make sure that you have the ratings
- 37:34and reviews. And by the way, we have all
- 37:36these tools that you can invest in to help you do all of that.
- 37:38So the cost of actually setting up everything online in the user
- 37:42journey is so significant that all of these retailers are
- 37:46making even more money because they're offering all of these
- 37:49tools and, and, and all this help to set up what would have
- 37:53in the past just been someone dropping off a pallet at a
- 37:56store. So that's where all the dollars
- 37:58are coming from. Like when Walmart's making a lot
- 38:00of money and when, when, when Amazon's making money, don't get
- 38:02me wrong, they're making billions of dollars on media,
- 38:05but the growth is all in how can we actually have like Amazon
- 38:08calls it like a plus content. So how do we actually have the
- 38:11right content? Well, you invest in certain
- 38:13packages or you invest in certain areas.
- 38:16We could help you get the best. So you show up in like, you
- 38:19know, like the first one or two searches.
- 38:22And so that's that actually to me is even more interesting
- 38:24because people again, are buying probably not more quantity wise,
- 38:30but in so many different ways that you have to be there.
- 38:32And if you're not there, you're going to lose that sale.
- 38:36Interesting you mentioned data. So there's been this big push
- 38:38the last couple years. I've noticed this from a lot of
- 38:41the big retail media networks, right, to give us your first
- 38:43party data upload it. I mean, not all of them have the
- 38:48data right. And if they do it might not be
- 38:50in great shape, but it's been a big push for that.
- 38:51It's been a big push for you know, happier conversion API.
- 38:55Why do you why do you think this is and is it is it working?
- 38:59Yeah, I feel like it's, I don't, I like, I don't know if it's
- 39:07working. I just feel like there's a lot
- 39:10of restrictions and there's a lot of guidelines and I think a
- 39:16lot of clients are scared to invest in, a lot of retailers
- 39:20are scared to share. So I think there's just got to
- 39:24be that one mover who starts doing it all and then everyone
- 39:27will follow. But until we actually see that,
- 39:31I feel like it's going to be hard and it's enough that we
- 39:35just necessarily can't crack. And there's always that uphill
- 39:37battle because you have to have people sign off on everything
- 39:40from both sides. Then is it legal?
- 39:42Is it legal in the state? So there's a lot that we have to
- 39:44invest in. But ultimately, like, yes, like
- 39:48I feel like that should be where we should go because it would
- 39:52help everyone's lives. And I think again, like from a
- 39:54media buyer standpoint, it would help my life be a lot easier.
- 39:58Yeah, I mean, I don't see for suppression, it's easy, you know
- 40:00what I mean? Upload your first party data if
- 40:01you like. Let's say you're not you maybe
- 40:03groceries you don't want to suppress.
- 40:04But if you're selling, you know, selling bank accounts or
- 40:06something, you're not endemic. You probably want to not market
- 40:08to pay, pay for impressions to the same people, right.
- 40:12So I I can see that. But yeah, it's not easy.
- 40:14I mean, convincing brands, convincing legal departments or
- 40:16privacy departments and you know, you should upload this
- 40:19especially to, you know, if you're a retailer to Walmart, to
- 40:23Walmart or Amazon that that could be, that could be a tough
- 40:25lift. But isn't, isn't this a, doesn't
- 40:29this a lot of this happen that the promise of of clean rooms,
- 40:31right in sort of a native cloud environment where you can do
- 40:34second party data sharing privately, right where where
- 40:38retailer can share data with publisher in a anonymized, semi
- 40:42anonymized, pseudonymized, whatever you want to call it
- 40:45fashion within a clean room type of environment within let's say
- 40:49snowflake or data bricks. I mean, isn't that but how you
- 40:53do this? Isn't that the promise, right?
- 40:55To be able to share this data without actually giving up the
- 40:57golden goose, so to speak. So yes, but then to your point
- 41:02earlier, you have to have your data in order in your house,
- 41:06right? So what, what are you sharing?
- 41:09What are you allowed to share? What do you want to share?
- 41:12How do you want to share it? What are the implications,
- 41:15What's the cost? So like we've had a lot of
- 41:17conversations with a lot of retailers.
- 41:19We did like one test like back in the day, like maybe like 7 or
- 41:228 years ago. And it was like the best thing
- 41:24we ever did because we took two types of data.
- 41:27We took a client's data and a retailer data and overlaid it
- 41:29and then applied it to a media plan.
- 41:31And it was awesome. And it was like the best
- 41:33performing campaign. But we took, yeah.
- 41:35Because you're you're de duplicating.
- 41:37You could, yeah. You can create real cool
- 41:39segmentation schemes you can build.
- 41:40Look alike models like you can create seed audiences yeah, I
- 41:43mean, but it's it's yeah, it's it works.
- 41:45I think it's crazy though, but most brands today like, yeah,
- 41:48the clean rooms are made for that.
- 41:49But I, I've seen, I've talked to so many branch like, oh, we
- 41:52just, we just upload our data to DV360 or the trade desk just
- 41:57right to the DSP just for suppression.
- 42:00So they're and, you know, obviously uploaded to DSP,
- 42:02they're saying we'll only keep what's matched and we won't you
- 42:05know, it, it'll be it'll, it'll be hashing.
- 42:07They'll tell you that, right? I mean, but so like a lot of
- 42:10retailers are doing it, but they're not doing it through
- 42:12clean rooms. I find that really interesting
- 42:13and I I think that maybe mistrust of it or just not
- 42:17knowing really what it is, but I don't think adoption is where we
- 42:21expected it will be a few years ago, I'll be honest.
- 42:23No, I feel like there's more of a, I'll call it like a more AI
- 42:28play than anything right now versus like talking about clean
- 42:31rooms. Like clean rooms was like a blip
- 42:32on the radar screen and we and like people talk about it,
- 42:36right. So.
- 42:36It was big at Cannes like 4 years ago, five years ago.
- 42:39Yeah, I was just at IB and there were some people there talking
- 42:42about clean rooms, but like, it's just, I don't wanna say
- 42:45it's easier said than done. I think that there's not enough
- 42:47people that know about it and know the process of it to
- 42:49actually make it work. That's gonna be my.
- 42:52Statement. Yeah, yeah, it's funny.
- 42:55I just read an article this morning on James.
- 42:57Herman, you start involving data, it's just people get
- 43:00brands get really sensitive. Yeah, I was saying I think we
- 43:04got a little delay, but I think yes, I would just read an
- 43:06article on attic shows. I don't know if you guys saw it
- 43:07this morning that said, and it was kind of a racy click baity
- 43:10kind of title. It said retail media is starting
- 43:13to come to grips with the fact that we know nothing at all.
- 43:17So I thought, well, I got to read this.
- 43:18What does James Herscher have to say?
- 43:21And I guess he was reporting from the IAB Connected Commerce
- 43:24event in New York City. I don't know if you heard about
- 43:26this, Amy. And it was interesting because
- 43:28he, because a lot of what you're talking about how data
- 43:31unification and data normalization and organizational
- 43:35change within organizations that are very complex.
- 43:38It we're sort of the the building blocks are there, the
- 43:41tech stacks are there, but they're but but we're not as an
- 43:45industry quite we're sort of we're like middle schoolers.
- 43:48You said we're like advanced adolescents and we're not quite
- 43:51where the promise of this technology could potentially
- 43:54bring us. Yeah.
- 43:56And that impacts things downstream, like proving ad
- 43:58impact right. Yep, Yep.
- 44:01And I love that you bought a full circle because it's one of
- 44:03those things where the targeting has gotten so much better and
- 44:08the targeting plus technology has gotten so much better.
- 44:11And the opportunity is from a measurement standpoint, whether
- 44:14or not it's measured in its own ecosystem is another story.
- 44:18Have gotten better, but like we're still trying to figure out
- 44:21other places and spaces of how to actually move the ball
- 44:24forward and actually make things a little bit more efficient.
- 44:27And so I would just say like, I think the clean print, clean
- 44:30room, like there should be like clean room one O 1 and people
- 44:33should really understand like what it means, what can it
- 44:35yields? And then you need retailers to
- 44:38actually be pushing that on their behalf.
- 44:40I don't like I've heard a few retailers talk about it.
- 44:42A few of them do testing, but like it's not widely used.
- 44:46So I think that's the other part too, where it has to really be
- 44:50implied that it's already in use and like who actually wants to
- 44:53test it? So then we actually have case
- 44:55studies for it. Yeah, I know we're getting close
- 44:59to the end of time here, but I, I, you mentioned incrementality
- 45:01earlier. I mean, I just think that's such
- 45:03an important one. It's been, I mean, that was kind
- 45:05of like the measurement word of the year, like maybe in the last
- 45:08year. But I mean, I think retail media
- 45:10really comes down to that. Like can you prove it
- 45:13incrementality? Are these are these ads people
- 45:15should be paying for or are people going to buy it, buy the
- 45:17products anyway? Thoughts on it?
- 45:20Yeah, it does exist. You have to make sure that have
- 45:24you have the right strategy and that's why we have a lot of
- 45:26commerce strategy team members that understands like what you
- 45:31should be doing for reaching a given audience and how you're
- 45:34actually placing your ads. So I would say there's a right
- 45:37way to do it. There may be a not so right way
- 45:39to do it, meaning that you might be reaching the same people and
- 45:43not really having that group. So it's kind of the conversation
- 45:45we were having a little bit earlier where like commerce is
- 45:48that glue between brand and performance and how are you
- 45:51wanting to grow and what does that entail?
- 45:54And that is all dictated hopefully from the CMO down or
- 45:57from the sales up. But everyone is on the same
- 45:59page. So then they are all beating to
- 46:01the same jump to get to the right spot.
- 46:02So yes, I definitely, definitely think it exists, but it also,
- 46:05how do you actually utilize it? And like, are you just looking
- 46:08at incrementality in a given retailer?
- 46:10Because that's great. But like, what does that mean
- 46:13for everything else? You have to look at it
- 46:14agnostically to see like, yeah, really going to drive your
- 46:17business at the bottom, at a bottom line.
- 46:20Yeah. And have you seen it, Is there a
- 46:21general mistrust and sort of like ROI and row as metrics,
- 46:25which oftentimes can be, you know, averaged aggregate
- 46:28metrics, right, They can be gained a bit, right.
- 46:31Hey, we've driven, I've seen on the B to CCN side, I've seen a
- 46:34row as metrics that are just ridiculous.
- 46:36But you actually don't see them down funnel in the actual
- 46:38purchases or or in retail media. They could reflect things like
- 46:42brand name search, which means somebody's already predisposed.
- 46:47They have the propensity to buy that anyway.
- 46:49So it's not incremental. It's not incremental lift,
- 46:51right? It seems like that's the crux of
- 46:53the situation there Is that is that what your clients, what
- 46:55you're helping your clients figure out?
- 46:57I. Think so, but it all comes down
- 46:59to the whole like we need a dictionary for methodology as
- 47:02well. Because what happens is, I mean,
- 47:05like Walgart, Walmart, Target, like Amazon and like, you know,
- 47:08like all the top in the US, like they were all doing the same
- 47:14thing in the sense of they were all selling media, but they're
- 47:17all looking at it differently from a methodology standpoint.
- 47:20And then the other thing too is like, how are you setting it up?
- 47:22Because you might have, you know, 5 products being sold on
- 47:25Target, but you have 20 items being sold on Amazon.
- 47:29And it's not apples to apples. It's like we say, it's apples to
- 47:32oranges. So it's like, what's the common
- 47:33denominator and what do you look at?
- 47:35And so you have to actually look at the sales growth or the
- 47:37bottom line sales growth in order to actually move
- 47:39everything forward. Yeah.
- 47:45So, yeah, So looking three to five years out because we are
- 47:48running on time here. What's your, what's your
- 47:50prediction? I mean, you've, you've seen,
- 47:51you've been since the nascent brick and mortar days of what
- 47:55they called retail media back in the day to, to now what is a far
- 47:59bigger media play? It's a far different animal than
- 48:03it was, you know, and there's a lot more folks involved, right
- 48:07on the commerce media side. What is your what are your
- 48:09predictions for how this is going to look in the next three
- 48:11to five years? Yeah.
- 48:13I would say that the new model should eat the old model in the
- 48:17sense of there's a lot of AI, there's a lot of agentic
- 48:20solutions, there's a lot of efficiencies that are in our
- 48:23space that haven't been in our space for a while.
- 48:26So I would see more flexibility and allow us to be more agile
- 48:30when it comes to planning and buying and really working with
- 48:34retail media. And then the other part is we're
- 48:37going to see a simplification and maybe some of that
- 48:39consolidation, but it all is derived by media behaviors and
- 48:44how people are engaging with media.
- 48:46And so I can't just say put my finger on like podcasts are
- 48:50gonna be the next best thing or shopping carts with screens are
- 48:54gonna be the next best thing. It's just a matter of how people
- 48:57are actually going to engage and how the brands are really
- 49:01wanting to reach. So I would just say that there's
- 49:03going to be a lot more technology that's going to be
- 49:05involved. And then there's going to be
- 49:07some winners and some people that aren't going to win as
- 49:10much. And So what does that do for a
- 49:13company? And so how does that, how does
- 49:14that really handle it? And I'm excited to see where it
- 49:16Nets out. Well, thanks, Amy.
- 49:20Thanks for joining Signal and Noise.
- 49:21It was great having you. Yeah, thank you so much for
- 49:24having me. This was awesome.