Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Therapy Recording Sessions - "Anna", part 3/6
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to the Curious Mind podcast, and especially to the
- 0:04third part. In my therapy recording
- 0:07sessions. I discussed with my client Anna
- 0:11her family situation, her feeling of belonging, the
- 0:16question of home, and especially the question of how to reconnect
- 0:21with her family. This is the third part of six,
- 0:27which means that. Now we have the second session.
- 0:33In the previous session, Anna already started to reflect on
- 0:38her family situation, and in this spot she deepens her
- 0:43reflections and particular her relationship to her siblings,
- 0:49how she would like to approach them, the different needs that
- 0:53she has and how she perceives her place in the family dynamic.
- 1:00The purpose of this series is to introduce the audience to what
- 1:06therapeutic conversations can look like.
- 1:09In particular, because of this specific case, I take a more
- 1:13systemic approach which is very much based on the reflections on
- 1:18relationship, in particular family relationships in this
- 1:23case, and to have the personal needs.
- 1:28Has one element that feeds into the reflections on how the
- 1:33relationship should be framed. OK, so welcome to our second
- 1:38session. Last time for the first session,
- 1:43we started to reflect on some aspects of your background, some
- 1:47aspects of your feelings and attitudes towards the West, that
- 1:52it's not a clean cut home for you.
- 1:56As it probably was when you were younger and maybe as a
- 2:02consequence of our conversation, you had some thoughts that are
- 2:06interesting for you MM. HM yeah, yeah.
- 2:13It sat with me for a few days, the last cuz like I said, I was
- 2:18not used to talking to someone in such an open way.
- 2:23And revealing things that I don't normally talk about.
- 2:29So yeah, it was just making me think a little more about my
- 2:34family and ways that I can try to communicate to them to to
- 2:41have what I thought of this yesterday to have like a digital
- 2:45family because or virtual family, we have to like change
- 2:50the. The the way we have
- 2:53relationships with families when we don't live together, you
- 2:57know, and we're doing everything online.
- 2:59Like yesterday I I sent a message to my sister like hey,
- 3:03why don't you send me more pictures of you guys because
- 3:06that that would make me feel like, connected a bit more.
- 3:11So she said she would because that's something that she she
- 3:13didn't really think about before.
- 3:15But I'm like it would be really fun to see pics because they
- 3:18don't post pictures. I'm like, so I feel really you
- 3:21know. Cut off, so things like that.
- 3:26How many years are you apart? You're in your system.
- 3:29Six years? You mean like in age?
- 3:32Yeah. Yeah, in age, yes.
- 3:33In age 4 years or four years apart.
- 3:36I haven't seen her in six years. Yeah, Okay, four years.
- 3:40So that's an age difference where you didn't have the same
- 3:45friend group, I guess, right? No, not.
- 3:50Yeah, not really. But we were still, like,
- 3:54together. We even shared a room at
- 3:56Sometimes, You know, Too. Yeah.
- 4:00And she, she has children. I have a child.
- 4:03So, like, we can connect a little more.
- 4:07Then you have a brother. Is that correct?
- 4:09Yeah, I have a brother and he and I are a little over a year
- 4:13apart. So we we grew up a little more
- 4:17like, you know, following each other.
- 4:20In school and stuff. Yes.
- 4:22And you described last time that in terms of the whole family and
- 4:28maybe towards your parents, you were kind of, you felt like an
- 4:31outsider. At least you were the eldest
- 4:34siblings. So I guess you had more
- 4:36responsibilities or different responsibilities than the others
- 4:40and that then something in your image broke when you were 21 and
- 4:47pregnant and married. And then eventually moved away.
- 4:51Before that, how is the SO that is towards the the parents
- 4:57mostly. How did you perceive yourself in
- 4:59regards to your siblings? What's the last, less often
- 5:03artificial or wrong image of you?
- 5:06Could you be more natural with them?
- 5:10Yeah. I think that generally we grew
- 5:13up close. We had a normal sibling.
- 5:19Relationship like one day I hate you, next day I love you.
- 5:23It was like, you know, just normal stuff.
- 5:26I have positive connections with them from my childhood and
- 5:30especially because we all moved together.
- 5:33So it's like a bonding experience.
- 5:35So like my sister and I bonded even more when we moved and we
- 5:38had to share a room at one point in in a family member's house
- 5:42and it was just very stressful. So she and I like bonded
- 5:46together during that. And I never, like, I don't have,
- 5:52we've never had bad words or jealousy issues or anything like
- 5:57that. I always supported them.
- 6:00They would tell me secrets and I never reveal it.
- 6:03It was always very like positive.
- 6:05And I think that moving away kind of hurt them because they
- 6:11didn't have, you know, that other person in the family to
- 6:16kind of go to and to like. Bond over all these other crazy
- 6:20family members and situations, right?
- 6:23So. Even though I know examples
- 6:25where people move away and then make it a point to maintain a
- 6:29close relationship by calling often.
- 6:31So it might not be kind of the most intuitive thing to do, but
- 6:37it is possible and I guess it depends more on how to set it up
- 6:41and how the others feel about that as well if it was one of
- 6:46your wishes. Right.
- 6:48Yeah, I I really, I I tried reaching out, especially to my
- 6:52brother, you know, with messages, but he doesn't really.
- 6:56He's just not an online person. And my sister is so busy that
- 7:01it's just easy for them to just say no, I'm not going on online
- 7:06or on Skype or, you know, I don't have time, you know, And I
- 7:11get that to some degree, but sometimes I'm like, you know,
- 7:14would it be nice to have a conversation?
- 7:16Yeah. So that is also in regards to
- 7:19video calls also. That's.
- 7:21Too abstract for them. Yeah, yeah, sometimes, yeah.
- 7:28And that's hard, cuz it's like I'll make the effort.
- 7:32I'm busy and stuff, so it's really hard to empathize with
- 7:36them on that. Then my brother doesn't have any
- 7:39children. With my sister, at least she has
- 7:40children and she's really, really busy.
- 7:43I kind of accept that a bit and she'll message me from time to
- 7:48time, but my brother? Absolutely not.
- 7:50It's like, cut off, yeah. As far as you know, how are they
- 7:56involved in the family narrative about you?
- 7:59So there's a certain image that your parents might have, and
- 8:03maybe there's a difference between them as well, but do you
- 8:07have any idea in how much your siblings?
- 8:10Kind of share this attitude, for example, of she moved away.
- 8:14It's her responsibility to call and to make efforts, Yeah.
- 8:18Do they stay away from that? Are they more free from those
- 8:22kind of images and ideas? About that, I don't know.
- 8:28Honestly, I don't know. Maybe because we never had.
- 8:34Falling out. Maybe this is one of those
- 8:37situations where having an argument is healthy, You know,
- 8:42because it's like they they're just so cool and laid back to
- 8:46the point where you don't even know, like, well, how do you
- 8:49feel about this? Like, obviously you're
- 8:52exhibiting signs of not being happy with this situation, but
- 8:57it's not coming out even as, like, how dare you like, what's
- 9:01wrong with you? And then talking about it and
- 9:05then hopefully just like, you know, moving on from it.
- 9:07But there's not even that. There's like, it's just, it's so
- 9:13like around like uneventful, you know?
- 9:17Yes, And this is ambivalent, right?
- 9:19Because at least I wouldn't know exactly how to interpret that.
- 9:22Is that OK? So I'm I'm kind of meaningless
- 9:26to your life, Is that what it means or you're just busy?
- 9:30Or you wish that I take initiative.
- 9:32What does it mean? So silence as such does not tell
- 9:35much. Right.
- 9:37No. And not in this situation, cuz
- 9:38then my imagination runs wild and I'm thinking they think
- 9:43this, this, this, and maybe I'm just imprinting something that's
- 9:47not there and we just never had the.
- 9:51That level of openness with each other because like we've always
- 9:54talked about family members like Can you believe what mom said or
- 9:58you know, and we bonded in that way like siblings should.
- 10:01But we never had arguments with each other.
- 10:05Yeah. And maybe that should like like
- 10:08we had ohh you know, you touched my toy kind of thing.
- 10:11But nothing serious. No major drama.
- 10:16And maybe sometimes that's needed so that they understand
- 10:20like. Yeah, I'm not sure about the
- 10:23drama, but is there a theme maybe of avoidance between you?
- 10:26Or maybe it's is it a family thing?
- 10:29I. Think it's a family thing?
- 10:31We don't. We don't really embrace
- 10:38emotional problems. Both my parents come from
- 10:40families of alcoholism and so they were used to.
- 10:47Pushing aside and hiding things now with my family, like my
- 10:51parents thankfully were not. You know that they were very
- 10:55conscious of being good to their kids.
- 10:59But by doing so, it's like anytime we talk about emotional
- 11:03things, it's very uncomfortable for everybody.
- 11:07Yes, which brings me to I think a leading question in this
- 11:12topic, which is so. We talked about how you wish to
- 11:17reestablish a more close connection, right, In one way or
- 11:21another. And the question that I have is
- 11:26as who do you want to reestablish that connection?
- 11:30And there is no simple answer to that.
- 11:32And just to give you an idea of what I mean, there is a spectrum
- 11:35to that. One of the end of the spectrum
- 11:37is OK. Let me reintroduce myself to my
- 11:40parents and my siblings, just as they Remember Me before I left.
- 11:45Because then I can connect to the image of me and then they
- 11:49will have kind of less problems to understand who I am and this
- 11:54will give me the best guarantee that they will be willing to
- 11:59have a closer connection with me again.
- 12:01The other end of the spectrum is no, I changed and I don't want
- 12:05to put on a mask just in order to please them so that there may
- 12:09be maybe please. Want to have contact with me
- 12:12again. If I want closer contact I want
- 12:14to have it just as who I am right now, without compromising
- 12:19and without trying to please them so that there is, you know,
- 12:23a higher probability for an outcome.
- 12:25So I make it conditional if that.
- 12:28If this kind of condition is not met then I rather not have the
- 12:32contact with all. So these I think are the two
- 12:34extremes there and it would be interesting to reflect with you.
- 12:40Where I don't expect at all that you have already answered for
- 12:43that. I think it's a process to come
- 12:44to a point, to a position of comfort there, but to start this
- 12:48conversation of where do you think you would like as who do
- 12:54you think you would like to start to reestablish the
- 12:58connection. Well, definitely with my brother
- 13:02and sister. I want them to see me as who I
- 13:06am and. And kind of and and want to
- 13:10learn something about me in in my my life and and ask questions
- 13:16and you know just I live in a foreign country and they they
- 13:20rarely ask me anything about the country I'm living in and this
- 13:25is crazy for me because I would you know if they moved to
- 13:30another country I would be so interested and and wanna hear so
- 13:34many things but it's like. They don't ask anything.
- 13:40Else so then how does it look to contact them as you are right
- 13:47now? No.
- 13:49Do you think they're generic? Not appealing maybe to them.
- 13:54What do you think? No, I think it's just so
- 13:56generic. It's just like they wanna hear,
- 14:00of course, things with my son as a mom.
- 14:04They see me for sure, like I'm mom, right?
- 14:07Which is great like I that that is one role I play.
- 14:11But other things like it it, yeah, they just simply don't
- 14:17dive into it. They don't really know things
- 14:21that I've seen my friends here, you know sometimes and this is
- 14:25so wild. But I've made friends here that
- 14:28I feel closer with like as brother or sister like
- 14:33relationship than my own real brother and sister.
- 14:37Yes. That's wild where I Yeah.
- 14:43I feel like, my God, you're like a brother to me.
- 14:46Or like a sister in a stronger way than my own brother and
- 14:50sister. They know more about me.
- 14:52Okay. So this is the important element
- 14:54there. They know more about me, which
- 14:56is specifics of you, your interests, your goals, your.
- 15:01Doubts. Something like this that we
- 15:03often share with friends? Maybe more than with some family
- 15:06members. Yeah.
- 15:08So what is the kind of what is the connection?
- 15:11What's the depth of a connection with your siblings if it's not
- 15:15the particulars, the specifics that they know about you?
- 15:20Yeah, yeah. There's really nothing else.
- 15:24Is there no other? Level.
- 15:26Knowledge about each other to a connection.
- 15:28Yeah. I think at this point, yes, I
- 15:36tried, Especially when I lived there.
- 15:39I really tried to go on lunch dates with my brother and just
- 15:46ask him about his work and ask him about his stuff, but it was
- 15:52never reciprocated so. It was, I guess then it makes it
- 15:57easy for me to then stop trying cuz it's just you're not feeling
- 16:02it from their side. So it's like, well to that end.
- 16:08So this happens when we offer something and we don't see the
- 16:12same interests in return, yeah? I think that they had to deal
- 16:17with stuff just like I did growing up and everyone deals in
- 16:21their own way. And they come out of it in a
- 16:24different way, look at like same family, three different
- 16:27individuals, but each responding in a different way to to our our
- 16:33life. And I think for them it's like
- 16:39my sister, she's just completely involved with her own personal
- 16:43family, like her children, which is fine, but to the point where
- 16:47she has no life outside of her family.
- 16:50Like, there's nothing. She doesn't have hobbies.
- 16:53There's nothing. It's just family stuff.
- 16:56And then my brother, it's just work.
- 16:58He's just so involved with work in his world, job wise.
- 17:03And then family is just like to the side.
- 17:06So I have two hands of the extreme, Yes, extreme I.
- 17:12Understand that at the same time, my experience tells me
- 17:15that everyone wants connection and everyone wants.
- 17:19Love if that is possible, and I I it would surprise me if they
- 17:26were any different in that respect.
- 17:29So I wonder then when you connect with them, can you
- 17:35connect to this need that they have?
- 17:40Or is there some reason that you are not the person for them to
- 17:45satisfy this need of closeness? Trust?
- 17:49All of these things that we eventually we hope for, right?
- 17:52Because all of us, we have to play the roles and you know, as
- 17:57a school parent, as a workers, all of these things.
- 18:00And then we'd like to have those safe havens of connections and
- 18:05people where we can drop all these, we just exchange kindness
- 18:10and not to have those performance requirements put on
- 18:16us. So yeah, I guess my question is,
- 18:23do you, Can you imagine that you can be that person for them?
- 18:31I don't know cuz I mean, I know that I would want to, but I
- 18:37don't know if they want to, if it's more comfortable for them
- 18:45to just not. Have to think about me too much.
- 18:49It's easier for them. But for me, I would love to
- 18:53like, I love the idea of family and I want my son to feel like
- 18:59oh I have an uncle and aunt in America and his cousins to be
- 19:04closer and you know just it's just so wild that I.
- 19:14I was kind of excluded from their lives and how easy it was
- 19:18for them, at least from my perspective, how easy it was for
- 19:21them to just kind of do that. Yes.
- 19:24And that's hurtful. Yes, yes, and there is
- 19:29something. There's an apparent easiness and
- 19:32I don't think it's clear yet if it was really easy or if it's an
- 19:37expression of the way to deal with conflicts.
- 19:41In your family of origin, which is not.
- 19:43To look at it or not, to deal with it or not to express it,
- 19:47maybe to feel it, but not. To yeah.
- 19:49So there is a possibility then how to find out because you had
- 19:54a strategy in the past, it sounds like you had the strategy
- 19:57of casual connection and kind of to be nice about it.
- 20:02This is what it sounds like to me and that kind of slipped away
- 20:08somehow was not. Taken up it was not.
- 20:11Yeah. By them.
- 20:13So I think it makes sense to maybe start a new strategy in
- 20:19order to see what kind of needs they have regarding you.
- 20:26True. Yeah.
- 20:29And that's hard to do when you're in another country, cuz
- 20:32it's like, whoa. Yes.
- 20:34They, they don't like going online.
- 20:37They don't really read messages and stuff.
- 20:39Well, that that cuts off a lot of the a lot of the ways that I
- 20:43can communicate to you. So that's hard.
- 20:47You know, I used to be the one that would, like, stir up humor
- 20:53and jokes and we'd make fun and have a good laugh about about
- 20:58life. Yeah, especially our family.
- 21:00That was how we dealt with things through humor.
- 21:06And I don't know if we can maintain that energy online.
- 21:11Can you imagine, I wonder, speaking about the role that you
- 21:15had, Can you imagine to communicate to them and be
- 21:19writing or Skype eventually to tell them, look, I need you
- 21:23guys. Yeah.
- 21:25So not to have kind of a casual, hey, let's connect a bit more,
- 21:29let's exchange pictures because it would be nice.
- 21:33But more to make clear, look this.
- 21:36I need family and you are my family and I need you.
- 21:42Would that be very contrary to the role that you have had in
- 21:45the past? Yeah, yeah.
- 21:50First off, it would be showing me in a point of vulnerability
- 21:55as their older sister that I never really gave them.
- 22:01Because they were. I was always the one that had to
- 22:04help with their stuff. You know, there were moments
- 22:09that of course they did help me, but overall I was always like
- 22:15the leader. In some ways.
- 22:18It's normal for the first born that's, you know, the role that
- 22:21they play. And and now I'd be coming to
- 22:24them like, hey guys, you know, can you help me?
- 22:27Can you in I? That's my problem, that I've
- 22:31never asked that. Maybe I should, you know,
- 22:34because it doesn't matter when you're an adult now, who's first
- 22:38born, who's second, whatever. Like we're all adults now and
- 22:43the playing field should be even at this point.
- 22:47They have life experiences that I don't have and they can share
- 22:50with me. Yes.
- 22:52So theoretically I agree. But there is just this thing
- 22:56that we have developed habits. And especially in family
- 22:59dynamics and habits that are not very conscious.
- 23:03So whereas if they got to meet, you know, a new friend that is
- 23:08four years or two years older, they would not hesitate to be as
- 23:12they are and to see it as an, you know, symmetrical equivalent
- 23:16relationship. There might be this deep rooted
- 23:19experience of seeing you differently because they have
- 23:23this experience of you being in a particular role.
- 23:27In the past, you were the responsible one.
- 23:30You helped the parents out, you were there to listen and as you
- 23:34say now, you showed no vulnerability.
- 23:40Yeah. But it's possible that they
- 23:42would just never come to the idea that maybe we should treat
- 23:45her as A and reach out. Maybe she needs something.
- 23:50How does she feel abroad? Doesn't she miss the family?
- 23:55Maybe she's just too. Proud or unaware to say which
- 24:00thoughts that would come to us when we deal with friends, but
- 24:03maybe not with the older sibling.
- 24:06Maybe, yeah. I never thought of that.
- 24:10Even when I was going through the breakdown of my marriage and
- 24:13stuff, they never contacted me to see Nikay.
- 24:17Do you need to have a talk or anything?
- 24:22Yes, so. Then yeah, well you expressed
- 24:28enough that this is this was disappointing I'm sure have that
- 24:36did that surface once in a while this disappointment or is this
- 24:41the avoidance of conflict that you have that kind of your
- 24:46unconscious didn't let it come up too.
- 24:47Much. Yeah.
- 24:49Yeah, I probably never did my part in telling them.
- 24:54Hey, like, why didn't you? Why didn't you ask me how I was
- 24:59feeling? I also feel stuff.
- 25:05Yeah, I never did when I lived there.
- 25:10I tried to hang out with them and whatnot, but we never got
- 25:16into deep conversation about my. Situation and the breakdown of
- 25:20my marriage and cultural depression.
- 25:23These are things they couldn't relate with me, so I didn't talk
- 25:27about it. Yes, Let me ask a question to
- 25:35the opposite end of the spectrum.
- 25:38Why do you want any close connection with them?
- 25:41Just because you're siblings? Just because you're nominally a
- 25:45family? Yeah, I don't.
- 25:52I think that, you know, because I think of our childhood and we
- 25:57did have fun times. There was something special that
- 26:02that happened and I just think, wow, wouldn't it be great if if
- 26:10we could carry that into adulthood?
- 26:12Mmhmm, yeah. You're getting emotional now.
- 26:16Can you tell me why? I don't know.
- 26:36I'm not used to talking about that.
- 26:41Yeah, there is what is apparent. Is the loss that is there now
- 26:52that there was a time when you felt connected and then
- 26:56something which is seemingly trivial just to move location
- 27:02would have had the effect of just stopping that of cutting
- 27:07that off? Right.
- 27:10I feel like if I was more connected with my brother and
- 27:15sister then. I have a future in the family,
- 27:22right? Because if it's just mom and
- 27:24dad, it's to be realistic, one day they're gonna be gone,
- 27:31right? And then what?
- 27:34Yes, yes.
- 27:45And going back to the idea of family, yes, please go ahead.
- 27:49So I would like to strengthen it now while we still have our
- 27:54youth and all these interesting things happening in our lives
- 27:59and we can still share. It would be fun.
- 28:05Well, and there is more than fun, right?
- 28:08I mean, it shows you are very involved now emotionally with
- 28:12this topic. And yeah, I just want to
- 28:14highlight. What it is more because it is
- 28:17more than fun. It's not just OK, I want to have
- 28:19someone to exchange pictures with.
- 28:21That is not what is the deeper rooted need that you have?
- 28:26Can you point your finger at it more kind of clearly of what the
- 28:31particular need you have for connecting with them in contrast
- 28:37to connecting with other people that you just feel nice with and
- 28:42you want to be friends with. Yeah, that's the difference
- 28:44there. I don't know.
- 28:46Maybe I'm idealistic. Maybe.
- 28:50I think, well, because we shared this wonderful childhood and
- 28:54even through the bad times, we were still like, you know,
- 28:58fairly close that we can continue it.
- 29:02And maybe they can come here one day and visit me and how much
- 29:07fun that would be. And I can teach them things
- 29:10about this culture that I live in.
- 29:13And and show them things that they they've never experienced
- 29:18because they're just so like in a bubble.
- 29:22I would say like they're just they don't really experience
- 29:25very much and it breaks my heart because they just, they just
- 29:30live like this routine life and I don't want that for them.
- 29:35I want them to be like, Oh my God, I can go here and check out
- 29:38this or try this new food or something because I.
- 29:43That's the type of person I am, right?
- 29:45And yeah, I think it's really hard for them to connect with
- 29:49with me because I'm like, why not?
- 29:52Let's I, you know, I eat sushi. Like I had to teach my sister to
- 29:56like sushi, you know? And it was fun.
- 30:00Like, it was nice having those sushi dates and stuff.
- 30:03But, you know, if I'm not there, they don't do that stuff, yes.
- 30:10OK, I would like to take those those different bits apart
- 30:13because what you said now is the argument of I want to what I
- 30:18hear is I want to continue to be the Big Sisters for them.
- 30:22I want to continue to open their minds to have new experiences
- 30:27and so on. So this particular need is I
- 30:31want to be there for them and I want to be maybe also regarded
- 30:36and acknowledged as the elder sister who.
- 30:40Makes these things happen. Who opens the mind?
- 30:43It gives new impulses, and so on.
- 30:47So that is one. But then on the other hand, I'll
- 30:50also see the need that you where you need them, where you would
- 30:58like to get something for them, where.
- 30:59Where you're in the weak position, where you would like
- 31:03them to show you something to give you something.
- 31:08And I'm not saying it's either. Either or the many different
- 31:12needs that I mean family is notorious for that that we
- 31:16couple many many different and often contradictory needs and
- 31:19one package and maybe this is kind of the the madness aspect
- 31:22of family that they're so entangled.
- 31:25You know those different needs. But what I what I sense you know
- 31:31in talking to you is that you need them.
- 31:36This is more. That is the more intense part
- 31:40that I feel. So this was the first part of
- 31:45the second session. Please come back at the next
- 31:48episode to continue to follow Anna's development in her
- 31:53question of family reconnection.